Document ID: EPA-HQ-OAR-2005-0036-0134
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2006-03-30T05:00Z

September
30,
2004
Ms.
Vickie
Presnell
Project
Officer
Office
of
Air
Quality
Planning
and
Standards
Emissions,
Monitoring,
and
Analysis
Division
(
C304­
02)
U.
S.
Environmental
Protection
Agency
Research
Triangle
Park,
North
Carolina
27711
Dear
Ms.
Presnell:

EPA
Contract
No.
68­
D­
02­
061,
Work
Assignment
2­
05
Please
find
enclosed
a
copy
of
our
final
Task
7
technical
report
entitled
"
Final
Experimental
Designs
for
Ozone
Modeling"
This
report
serves
as
a
deliverable
under
the
subject
Work
Assignment.

If
you
have
any
questions,
please
call
me
at
614/
424­
6538
or
Doug
Mooney
at
614/
424­
7527.

Sincerely,

Basil
W.
Coutant,
Ph.
D.
Principal
Research
Scientist
Measurement
and
Data
Analysis
Sciences
DDM/
BWC:
llj
Enclosure
cc:
Otelia
Newsome
(
EPA
CO)
(
ltr
only)
Bryan
Hubbell
(
EPA
WAM)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
September
30,
2004
Final
Technical
Report
FINAL
EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGNS
FOR
OZONE
MODELING
Contract
No.
68­
D­
02­
061
Work
Assignment
2­
05,
Task
7
for
Vickie
Presnell,
Project
Officer
Bryan
Hubbell,
Work
Assignment
Manager
Emissions,
Monitoring,
and
Analysis
Division
Office
of
Air
Quality
Planning
and
Standards
U.
S.
ENVIRONMENTAL
PROTECTION
AGENCY
Research
Triangle
Park,
North
Carolina
27711
Prepared
by
Douglas
D.
Mooney,
Ofelia
Marin,
and
Basil
W.
Coutant
BATTELLE
505
King
Avenue
Columbus,
Ohio
43201­
2693
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
ii
DISCLAIMER
This
report
is
a
work
prepared
for
the
United
States
Environmental
Protection
Agency
by
Battelle
Memorial
Institute.
In
no
event
shall
either
the
United
States
Environmental
Protection
Agency
or
Battelle
Memorial
Institute
have
any
responsibility
or
liability
for
any
consequences
of
any
use,
misuse,
inability
to
use,
or
reliance
upon
the
information
contained
herein,
nor
does
either
warrant
or
otherwise
represent
in
any
way
the
accuracy,
adequacy,
efficacy,
or
applicability
of
the
contents
hereof.
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
iii
TABLE
OF
CONTENTS
Page
1.0
INTRODUCTION
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
2.0
DESIGNS
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
1
2.1
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
2
2.2
Design
2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4
2.3
Design
3
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
5
2.4
Global
Validation
Runs
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
6
2.5
Local
Validation
Runs
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
6
APPENDIX
A:
EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
1
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A­
1
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A­
8
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
A­
10
APPENDIX
B:
EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
2
Design
2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
B­
1
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
B­
3
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
B­
4
APPENDIX
C:
EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
3
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
C­
1
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
C­
13
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
C­
15
List
of
Table
and
Figures
Table
1.
Longitudes
and
Latitude
of
Local
Validation
Sites
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
7
Figure
1.
Histogram
of
Variable
X1
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
3
Figure
2.
Scatterplot
of
Variables
X1
versus
X2
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
4
Figure
3.
Location
of
Sites
for
Local
Policy
Validation
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
7
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
1
Final
Technical
Report
on
Final
Experimental
Designs
for
Ozone
Modeling
WA
2­
05,
Task
7
1.0
INTRODUCTION
This
report
contains
three
final
designs
based
on
feedback
to
the
document
"
Preliminary
Experimental
Designs
for
Ozone
Modeling."
Both
preliminary
and
final
designs
are
based
on
the
document
"
Definition
of
Response
Surface
`
Policy
Space'
for
8­
Hour
Ozone
Determinations"
provided
by
Bryan
Hubbell
and
subsequent
correspondence.

2.0
DESIGNS
Three
different
designs
were
presented
in
the
"
Preliminary
Experimental
Designs
for
Ozone
Modeling."
This
report
also
contains
three
designs
that
follow
the
design
specification
of
the
preliminary
designs
with
some
minor
variations.
Specifically,
all
designs
are
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
designs,
separate
global
validation
runs
were
created
with
their
own
Latin
Hypercube
design,
and
finally
additional
Latin
Hypercube
designs
for
local
validation
were
created
to
validate
how
well
the
global
model
predictions
estimate
local
policy
changes.
The
local
runs
are
to
have
an
associated
location
variable
(
indexed
by
lat/
lon)
in
addition
to
the
factors
present
for
other
runs.
EPA
will
determine
an
appropriate
neighborhood
of
sites
around
the
latitude/
longitude
coordinates.

The
particular
type
of
Latin
Hypercube
design
in
this
report
used
is
called
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
design.
It
is
a
Latin
Hypercube
design
with
constraints
to
maximize
the
minimum
distance
between
points
to
prevent
patterns
and
degenerate
designs
(
like
all
diagonal
points)
from
being
chosen
by
chance.
Latin
hypercube
designs
are
very
flexible
in
accommodating
restrictions
on
the
number
of
runs
(
as
opposed
to
factorial
designs,
for
example,
which
are
fairly
rigid).
While
ten
runs
per
variable
is
an
empirically
derived
rule
of
thumb,
good
designs
can
be
developed
with
fewer
points.
Since
discussions
with
EPA
indicated
that
it
would
be
advantageous
to
have
complete
designs
after
subsets
of
runs
have
been
completed,
the
final
designs
were
built
using
a
methodology
we
call
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
in
Stages.
These
designs
built
a
true
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
in
the
first
stage.
If
resources
were
tight
this
design
could
be
used
for
analysis
or
it
could
be
used
to
begin
analysis
while
other
runs
are
in
process.
The
second
stage
adds
additional
points
to
this
design
to
form
a
Latin
Hypercube
maximizing
the
minimum
distances
for
the
newly
added
points.
Technically,
this
is
not
a
true
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
design
since
the
points
from
the
first
stage
are
fixed,
but
it
is
still
an
effective
method
for
preventing
unintended
patterns
from
arising.
Similarly,
third
or
fourth
stages
can
be
added.
Again,
the
main
advantage
of
this
approach
is
it
allows
for
complete
designs
after
specified
numbers
of
runs
that
give
fall
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
2
back
options
if
resources
are
limited
or
stages
at
which
analyses
can
begin
while
further
data
are
collected.
Another
advantage
is
that
it
provides
a
natural
method
for
including
subdesigns
over
different
parameter
ranges,
such
as
in
the
specified
[
0.9,
1.0]
range.

The
next
three
subsections
describe
the
features
and
constraints
that
distinguish
the
designs
from
one
another.
The
last
two
subsections
describe
the
methodology
for
creating
the
global
and
local
validation
runs.
The
actual
designs
with
validation
runs
are
in
AppendicesA
through
C.

2.1
Design
1
Design
1
has
the
14
continuous
variables
that
the
design
specifications
document
indicated
as
primary
dimensions.
The
design
was
formulated
as
described
below:

14
Variables
 
140
Runs
°
1
baseline
run
°
139
runs
constructed
as
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
in
Stages.

Stage
1:
Construct
a
50
run,
(
14
vars
on
[
0,1.2])
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
design.

Stage
2:
Augment
the
50
run
(
14
vars
on
[
0,1.2])
design
by
adding
50
more
points
in
an
optimal
fashion
using
the
Maximin
design
criterion
while
remaining
within
the
class
of
Latin
Hypercube
designs.

Stage
3:
Augment
the
100
run
(
14
vars
on
[
0,1.2])
design
obtained
in
Stage
2
by
adding
29
(
in
[
0,1.2])
more
points
in
an
optimal
fashion
using
the
Maximin
design
criterion
while
remaining
within
the
class
of
Latin
Hypercube
design.

Stage
4:
Augment
the
129
run
(
14
vars
on
[
0,1.2])
design
obtained
in
Stage
3
by
adding
ten
more
points
(
in
[
0.9,1])
in
an
optimal
fashion
using
the
Maximin
design
criterion
while
remaining
within
the
class
of
Latin
Hypercube
design.

Combining
these
gives
an
experimental
design
with
140
runs
that
more
heavily
samples
the
range
between
0.9
and
1.0.
It
is
a
staged
design
so
that
complete
Latin
Hypercube
subdesigns
occur
after
50,
100,
and
129
runs
if
budgetary
constraints
require
scaling
back
the
design
or
it
desired
to
begin
analysis
before
all
runs
are
completed.

There
are
some
nice
features
of
the
design.
Figure
1
shows
a
histogram
of
Variable
1,
which
illustrates
the
uniform
coverage
of
the
design
space
with
over
sampling
in
the
0.9
to
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
3
0.012
0.180
0.348
0.516
0.684
0.852
1.020
1.188
X1
0.0
2.5
5.0
7.5
10.0
12.5
15.0
1.0
range.
Figure
2
shows
a
scatterplot
of
Variable
1
versus
Variable
2.
They
show
both
the
depth
and
uniformity
of
the
coverage.
Even
though
these
designs
do
not
hit
the
corners
as
a
factorial
design
would,
there
is
thorough
coverage
of
the
parameter
space
to
very
near
the
edges.
Other
pairs
of
variables
should
have
very
similar
scatterplots.

Figure
1.
Histogram
of
Variable
X1.
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
4
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
X1
0.0
0.2
0.4
0.6
0.8
1.0
1.2
X2
Figure
2.
Scatterplot
of
Variables
X1
versus
X2.

2.2
Design
2
This
design
reuses
the
same
design
for
both
attainment
and
non­
attainment
areas.
Effectively,
there
are
now
seven
parameters
so
half
the
number
of
runs
were
used,
but
still
ten
runs
per
variable.
The
design
now
consists
of
°
One
baseline
run,
°
A
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
of
70
runs
over
the
full
parameter
space,
and
°
An
augmentation
of
the
70
run
design
with
5
runs
over
the
0.9
to
1.0
parameter
space
to
achieve
a
Staged
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube.

Here,
the
use
of
the
staged
design
is
just
to
add
the
extra
points
in
the
restricted
policy
space.
Additional
validation
runs
were
designed
and
are
discussed
in
Sections
2.5
and
2.6
below.
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
5
2.3
Design
3
The
design
specification
document
indicated
four
secondary
variables
to
be
added
at
a
later
time.
While
runs
can
be
added
to
a
Latin
hypercube
design,
it
is
not
feasible
to
add
factors
or
parameters
after
the
fact.
If
these
variables
will
be
used
eventually,
it
makes
sense
to
include
them
now.
Hence,
the
third
design
repeats
the
design
process
of
Design
1,
but
for
18
variables
instead
of
14.
Specifically,
there
is
one
baseline
run,
a
169
run
Staged
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
is
constructed
on
the
full
range
and
augmented
with
a
final
stage
consisting
of
ten
runs
on
the
restricted
range
0.9
to
1.0.
EPA
requested
the
use
of
180
runs
in
this
design
(
increased
from
150
in
the
preliminary
design)
to
satisfy
the
"
10
runs
per
variable"
rule
of
thumb.

Specifically
the
design
consists
of
°
1
baseline
run
°
179
runs
constructed
as
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
in
Stages.

Stage
1:
50
points
with
all
18
variables
in[
0,1.2].

Stage
2:
50
points
with
all
18
variables
in[
0,1.2].

Stage
3:
50
points
with
all
18
variables
in
[
0,1.2].

Stage
4:
10
points
with
all
18
variables
in
[
0,1.2].

Stage
5:
9
points
with
all
18
variables
in
[
0,1.2].

Stage
6:
10
more
points
with
all
18
variables
in
[
0.9,1].

As
mentioned
in
the
introduction
to
Section
2,
Latin
Hypercube
designs
are
very
flexible
in
accommodating
restrictions
on
the
number
of
runs.
While
ten
runs
per
variable
is
an
empirically
derived
rule
of
thumb,
good
designs
can
be
developed
with
fewer
points.
While
ideally
180
runs
would
be
recommended
for
18
variables,
a
Latin
hypercube
with
150
runs
is
a
valid
design
that
should
give
good
results.
This
design
has
been
set
up
so
that
complete
Latin
Hypercube
(
distance
optimized)
designs
are
available
after
50,
100,
150,
160,
and
169
runs,
not
counting
the
extra
runs
in
the
restricted
space.
The
rationale
was
that
analysis
could
begin
as
soon
as
the
first
50
or
100
designs
have
been
run
(
though
it
is
not
advisable
to
stop
here),
and
if
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
6
resources
are
limited
a
good,
but
less
than
optimal
design,
is
possible
after
160,
170,
and
179
runs
(
counting
the
extra
10
runs).

2.4
Global
Validation
Runs
For
all
designs,
a
set
of
20
runs
was
created
for
purposes
of
global
model
evaluation.
The
runs
were
chosen
in
three
stages
in
such
a
way
that
after
any
stage
(
10,
15,
and
20
runs)
the
cumulative
design
is
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube.
In
particular,
the
stages
are
as
follows:

Stage
1:
Construct
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
of
10
runs
with
variables
in
[
0,1.2].

Stage
2:
Augment
the
design
from
Stage
1
with
5
more
points
with
variables
in
[
0,1.2]
in
an
optimal
fashion
using
the
Maximin
criterion
within
the
class
of
Latin
Hypercube
designs.

Stage
3:
Augment
the
design
from
Stage
2
with
5
points
with
variables
in
[
0,1.2]
in
an
optimal
fashion
using
the
Maximin
criterion
within
the
class
of
Latin
Hypercube
designs.

This
design
has
the
following
features.
It
is
a
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
so
the
validation
runs
provide
a
very
good
representative
set
of
points
from
the
policy
space.
A
validation
set
of
ten
runs
was
specified
by
the
EPA
and
the
first
stage
completely
satisfies
that
requirement
with
a
complete
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
design.
If
additional
resources
were
to
be
available,
either
now
or
at
a
later
date,
this
design
further
allows
for
complete
Staged
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
designs
to
be
exist
after
15
runs
and
20
runs.
Please
note
that
the
numbers
10,
15,
and
20
are
the
stages
of
the
design
and
stopping
after
a
different
number
of
runs,
say
12,
does
not
provide
a
Latin
Hypercube
design.

2.5
Local
Validation
Runs
In
addition
to
the
global
validation
runs,
20
local
validation
runs
are
provided
for
each
design.
These
runs
follow
the
staged
design
presented
in
Section
2.4
for
global
validation
runs.
They
differ,
however,
in
that
an
extra
variable
representing
location
was
added
to
the
design.
Thus,
the
designs
are
Staged
Maximin
Latin
Hypercube
designs
in
all
variables
including
location.
Five
locations
were
chosen
from
within
the
borders
of
the
United
States.
The
number
five
was
chosen
so
that
if
only
10
validation
runs
are
made,
each
site
would
have
two
data
points.
With
15
or
20
validations
runs,
each
site
has
three
or
four
data
points,
respectively.

The
locations
are
listed
in
the
design
using
the
codes
1
through
5.
These
codes
associated
with
latitudes
and
longitudes
are
in
Table
1.
If
there
are
subject
matter
specific
reasons
why
any
of
these
sites
may
be
problematic,
one
or
more
new
locations
could
be
readily
chosen
and
swapped
with
an
existing
location
without
changes
to
the
experimental
designs
presented
in
the
appendices.
The
locations
of
these
sites
are
displayed
in
Figure
3.
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
7
Location
Number
Longitude
Latitude
1
­
106.56278
35.107222
2
­
68.770278
44.798889
3
­
77.623889
36.486111
4
­
89.779722
43.327222
5
­
115.25361
36.107778
Table
1.
Longitudes
and
Latitude
of
Local
Validation
Sites.

It
is
expected
that
the
local
policy
changes
will
be
applied
to
a
region
about
one
of
these
sites.
EPA
will
decide
on
the
appropriate
regions.
Based
on
discussions
with
EPA,
it
is
assumed
that
several
additional
runs
will
be
added
from
sites
presumed
to
be
problematic.

Figure
3.
Location
of
Sites
for
Local
Policy
Validation.
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
APPENDIX
A:

EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
1
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
1
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
X11
X12
X13
X14
1
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
2
0.420
0.636
0.636
0.108
0.612
0.036
0.900
0.084
0.276
0.948
0.636
0.252
1.164
0.444
3
0.396
0.876
0.492
0.612
0.756
0.204
0.588
0.780
1.092
1.044
0.084
0.420
0.444
0.060
4
0.156
0.420
0.660
0.252
1.092
0.300
0.180
0.252
0.540
0.204
0.132
1.020
0.060
0.132
5
0.252
0.828
1.116
1.020
0.036
0.276
0.996
0.684
0.396
0.492
0.252
0.012
0.996
0.372
6
1.044
0.924
0.876
0.468
0.012
0.108
0.228
1.044
0.900
0.588
0.684
0.348
0.276
0.156
7
0.036
0.204
0.780
0.132
1.140
0.228
1.140
1.116
0.972
0.756
0.300
0.876
0.756
0.972
8
1.116
0.660
1.140
0.564
1.164
0.924
0.396
0.924
0.780
0.996
1.020
1.116
0.948
0.276
9
0.228
0.612
0.828
0.900
0.900
0.708
0.492
0.012
0.924
0.276
1.092
1.068
0.612
0.036
10
0.132
1.068
0.996
1.188
0.972
0.900
0.300
0.564
0.468
0.660
0.516
0.396
1.116
0.948
11
1.068
0.180
0.252
0.876
0.564
1.068
0.540
0.276
1.020
0.444
0.924
0.084
1.092
0.204
12
0.348
0.516
0.228
1.164
0.132
0.252
0.060
0.204
0.756
0.324
0.828
0.180
0.300
0.828
13
0.780
0.996
0.300
0.012
0.180
0.804
0.348
0.180
1.068
0.780
0.564
1.044
0.852
0.348
14
1.020
0.108
0.180
0.036
0.804
0.684
0.924
0.660
0.108
1.068
0.996
0.996
0.348
0.924
15
0.012
0.588
0.564
0.804
0.780
0.852
0.132
1.020
0.180
0.108
0.420
0.156
1.044
0.300
16
0.204
0.132
0.324
0.324
1.188
0.876
0.612
0.444
0.252
1.188
0.228
0.780
0.252
0.540
17
0.612
0.684
0.540
0.636
0.084
0.132
1.164
0.420
0.036
0.180
0.948
0.660
0.828
0.612
18
0.852
0.324
0.684
0.924
0.060
0.948
0.564
1.164
0.324
0.876
0.444
0.492
0.324
1.068
19
0.588
0.084
0.588
0.372
0.636
1.020
0.324
0.804
0.732
0.516
0.324
1.188
0.588
0.108
20
0.276
0.228
1.020
0.660
0.492
0.060
0.252
0.348
0.204
0.852
1.068
1.164
0.108
0.780
21
0.492
1.164
0.708
1.068
1.116
0.588
0.468
0.828
0.060
0.612
0.588
0.108
0.180
0.804
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
2
22
0.756
0.036
0.804
0.588
0.828
1.188
0.852
0.396
0.564
0.684
0.852
0.036
0.228
1.116
23
0.564
0.012
1.044
0.756
1.068
0.540
0.660
0.156
0.372
1.092
0.780
0.324
0.732
0.252
24
0.180
1.020
0.516
1.116
0.420
1.140
1.044
1.068
0.612
0.924
1.116
0.924
0.372
0.228
25
0.876
0.804
0.396
0.228
0.540
1.164
0.636
0.588
1.188
0.132
0.660
1.092
0.780
0.852
26
0.060
0.492
0.348
0.492
0.588
0.516
1.020
0.900
0.132
0.252
0.540
0.612
0.516
1.140
27
0.300
0.708
0.852
0.420
0.396
1.116
0.732
0.708
1.044
1.116
0.468
0.204
0.036
1.020
28
0.804
0.540
0.132
0.732
0.468
0.612
1.188
0.732
0.492
0.540
0.732
0.852
1.188
0.012
29
0.732
0.756
0.084
0.180
1.044
0.756
0.084
1.092
0.012
0.468
1.044
0.444
0.564
0.516
30
0.900
0.396
1.164
0.708
0.948
1.092
0.036
0.060
0.084
0.708
0.276
0.564
0.420
0.708
31
0.084
0.948
0.444
0.084
0.876
0.444
0.444
0.372
0.708
1.140
0.756
0.516
1.020
0.684
32
0.996
1.044
0.108
0.684
0.324
0.324
0.516
0.876
0.660
0.036
0.204
0.228
0.804
1.092
33
0.108
0.252
0.036
0.276
0.228
0.972
0.684
0.756
0.876
0.084
0.972
0.588
0.204
0.420
34
1.188
0.348
0.900
0.204
0.276
0.396
0.948
0.852
0.228
0.804
0.804
0.684
1.068
0.084
35
0.948
1.188
0.156
0.396
0.996
0.180
0.828
0.324
0.300
0.372
1.140
0.636
0.660
0.324
36
0.516
0.852
0.204
0.300
0.924
0.636
1.068
0.300
0.828
0.828
0.396
0.276
0.900
1.188
37
0.708
0.156
0.372
1.092
0.156
0.348
0.708
0.972
0.516
0.972
0.372
0.372
0.636
0.732
38
0.540
0.564
1.188
0.156
0.204
0.084
0.420
0.612
0.588
0.396
0.012
0.756
0.468
1.044
39
0.324
0.372
0.420
0.516
0.708
0.660
0.372
1.188
0.444
0.012
1.164
0.060
0.708
0.492
40
0.828
1.140
0.972
0.060
0.732
0.996
0.972
0.948
0.996
0.348
0.156
0.300
0.132
0.588
41
0.444
1.092
0.060
0.948
0.108
0.468
0.756
0.492
0.156
0.732
0.060
1.140
0.684
0.180
42
1.140
1.116
0.756
0.348
0.372
0.828
1.092
0.108
0.420
0.156
0.876
0.468
0.492
0.756
43
0.660
0.444
0.468
1.140
0.516
0.780
0.780
0.132
0.852
0.564
0.180
0.708
0.972
0.996
44
1.092
0.732
0.924
1.044
0.852
0.492
0.276
0.228
1.164
0.060
0.348
0.828
0.396
0.468
45
0.372
0.276
1.092
0.972
1.020
1.044
0.876
0.996
0.636
0.228
0.708
0.804
0.876
0.900
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
3
46
0.924
0.972
0.612
0.996
0.684
0.564
0.108
0.540
0.948
1.020
0.900
0.732
0.012
1.164
47
0.636
0.900
0.012
0.540
0.300
0.420
0.156
0.036
0.348
0.420
0.492
0.900
0.156
0.876
48
0.468
0.060
0.732
0.828
0.444
0.372
0.204
0.636
1.116
0.300
1.188
0.540
0.924
0.564
49
0.972
0.468
1.068
0.444
0.252
0.732
1.116
0.468
1.140
0.900
0.108
0.132
1.140
0.660
50
0.684
0.300
0.948
0.852
0.348
0.156
0.012
0.516
0.804
1.164
0.612
0.972
0.540
0.396
51
1.164
0.780
0.276
0.780
0.660
0.012
0.804
1.140
0.684
0.636
0.036
0.948
0.084
0.636
52
0.972
1.092
0.228
0.612
0.492
0.948
0.900
1.092
0.396
0.060
0.588
0.756
0.036
0.108
53
0.444
0.756
0.708
0.300
0.276
0.804
0.012
0.372
0.636
0.348
0.516
0.348
0.348
0.012
54
1.116
0.084
0.372
0.252
1.020
0.156
0.780
0.012
0.996
0.876
0.756
0.228
0.180
1.164
55
0.060
1.116
0.660
0.660
0.924
0.012
0.636
0.204
1.116
0.492
0.468
0.732
0.636
0.276
56
0.036
0.876
0.636
0.732
0.180
1.140
0.828
0.660
0.804
0.276
0.804
0.108
0.108
0.516
57
0.324
0.036
0.972
0.444
0.156
0.852
0.516
0.252
0.036
0.540
0.636
0.588
0.444
1.188
58
0.012
0.684
1.116
0.492
0.444
1.068
0.444
0.492
0.300
0.780
0.156
0.420
0.084
0.828
59
1.140
1.068
0.540
1.044
0.300
0.732
0.660
0.348
0.492
0.252
0.684
1.188
0.924
1.020
60
0.156
0.612
0.180
1.068
0.348
1.044
0.108
1.188
1.092
0.732
0.780
0.612
0.780
0.636
61
0.660
0.996
0.900
0.780
1.164
0.276
0.732
0.468
1.188
0.444
1.164
0.276
0.492
0.708
62
0.924
0.516
0.516
0.012
1.140
0.396
0.540
0.108
0.876
0.684
0.444
0.972
0.684
0.588
63
1.092
0.540
0.444
0.636
0.732
1.092
0.084
0.852
0.372
0.948
1.188
1.044
0.252
0.948
64
0.252
0.420
0.012
1.140
0.804
0.180
0.348
0.972
0.684
0.828
0.660
0.468
1.188
0.540
65
0.780
0.636
1.092
1.188
0.708
0.540
0.756
1.068
0.828
0.156
0.228
0.540
0.156
0.060
66
0.684
0.732
0.588
0.036
0.132
0.588
0.612
0.924
0.564
0.804
1.140
0.564
1.140
0.972
67
1.188
1.164
1.044
0.516
0.636
0.324
1.188
0.588
1.020
0.228
0.396
0.516
0.372
0.348
68
0.300
1.140
0.348
0.828
0.228
0.420
1.068
0.396
0.780
1.068
0.276
0.852
1.116
0.156
69
0.372
0.780
1.188
0.396
0.828
0.348
0.228
0.732
0.060
0.756
0.900
1.068
1.020
0.252
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
4
70
0.132
0.468
0.852
0.060
0.204
0.636
0.804
1.020
0.324
0.468
0.876
0.828
0.804
0.228
71
0.516
0.108
0.084
0.876
0.396
0.060
0.372
0.948
0.348
0.204
0.300
0.708
0.228
0.684
72
0.204
0.060
1.068
0.156
0.756
0.468
0.060
0.324
0.444
0.612
0.180
1.092
0.828
0.420
73
0.876
0.252
0.468
0.372
1.044
0.108
0.948
0.228
1.044
0.300
0.252
0.924
1.164
1.092
74
0.540
0.972
0.684
0.468
0.468
0.204
0.708
0.060
0.732
0.132
1.044
0.012
1.092
0.468
75
0.588
0.924
0.396
0.804
0.900
0.756
0.924
0.876
0.468
0.708
0.924
0.780
0.060
0.396
76
0.900
0.324
0.780
0.756
0.420
0.660
0.300
0.276
0.660
1.044
0.012
1.140
0.204
0.372
77
0.492
0.948
0.996
1.020
0.780
0.972
1.116
0.036
0.540
1.188
0.828
0.660
0.564
0.204
78
0.228
0.348
0.612
0.084
0.972
0.828
1.164
0.900
1.164
0.420
0.972
0.948
0.276
0.804
79
0.948
0.900
0.324
0.108
0.084
0.924
0.204
0.756
0.612
0.516
0.036
0.084
0.732
0.732
80
0.756
0.492
0.252
0.996
0.996
0.084
1.140
0.828
0.252
1.092
0.492
1.116
0.420
0.492
81
1.044
0.708
0.036
0.924
0.684
0.252
0.852
0.300
0.012
1.164
0.540
0.876
0.948
0.756
82
0.732
0.204
0.300
0.564
0.876
0.612
0.036
0.636
0.900
0.924
0.132
0.636
1.068
0.900
83
0.348
1.188
0.804
0.708
0.588
0.900
0.684
1.044
0.228
1.020
0.108
0.996
0.996
1.068
84
0.708
0.852
1.140
0.972
0.612
0.876
0.180
0.156
0.972
0.036
1.092
0.684
0.324
0.660
85
0.084
0.804
0.060
0.852
1.188
0.564
0.972
0.132
0.516
0.852
0.948
0.156
0.396
1.044
86
0.564
0.660
0.948
0.324
0.564
0.372
1.044
1.164
1.068
0.588
0.852
1.164
0.660
0.924
87
0.396
0.156
1.020
0.348
0.948
0.684
0.156
1.116
0.588
0.084
0.564
0.204
0.972
0.612
88
1.164
0.300
0.732
1.092
0.852
0.996
0.588
0.540
0.276
0.564
1.068
0.180
0.852
0.132
89
1.068
0.444
0.204
0.132
0.324
1.116
0.996
0.420
0.924
0.660
0.060
0.492
0.588
0.300
90
0.420
0.564
0.876
0.684
1.068
0.780
1.020
0.804
0.948
1.140
0.372
0.060
0.876
0.852
91
0.468
0.588
0.132
0.204
0.060
0.300
0.324
0.516
0.852
1.116
1.116
0.804
0.132
1.116
92
0.612
0.372
0.156
0.900
1.116
1.188
0.252
0.612
0.708
0.972
0.204
0.444
0.900
0.180
93
0.108
1.044
0.756
0.180
0.516
0.132
0.132
0.684
0.084
0.900
0.348
0.300
0.708
0.036
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
5
94
0.828
0.132
0.564
0.420
0.012
0.516
0.876
0.564
0.756
0.012
0.084
1.020
0.756
0.780
95
0.636
0.228
0.492
0.228
0.372
0.492
0.492
1.140
0.108
0.996
0.708
0.132
0.300
0.324
96
0.180
0.276
0.420
0.588
0.036
0.708
1.092
0.180
0.156
0.396
0.324
0.396
0.012
0.564
97
0.852
0.012
0.276
1.116
0.252
0.228
0.276
0.708
0.180
0.180
1.020
0.252
0.540
0.876
98
0.276
0.180
0.108
0.540
0.108
1.164
0.420
0.084
1.140
0.636
0.420
0.324
0.516
0.084
99
0.996
0.828
0.828
1.164
1.092
1.020
0.396
0.444
0.132
0.108
0.732
0.900
0.468
0.444
100
0.804
0.396
0.924
0.948
0.540
0.036
0.468
0.780
0.420
0.372
0.996
0.372
1.044
1.140
101
1.020
1.020
1.164
0.276
0.660
0.444
0.564
0.996
0.204
0.324
0.612
0.036
0.612
0.996
102
0.352
1.014
0.683
0.600
1.055
1.055
0.269
0.931
0.848
1.179
0.021
0.517
0.807
0.021
103
0.766
0.931
0.062
0.641
0.269
0.683
0.476
1.014
1.014
0.931
0.269
0.972
0.476
1.179
104
0.559
0.186
0.807
1.179
0.641
0.434
0.972
0.724
1.179
0.890
0.683
0.724
0.848
0.517
105
0.186
0.434
0.931
0.807
0.103
1.014
0.890
0.600
0.062
1.014
0.517
0.021
0.641
0.683
106
0.931
0.807
0.559
0.145
0.476
0.269
0.931
1.179
1.138
1.097
0.559
0.393
0.228
0.186
107
0.103
0.103
0.393
1.055
0.766
0.807
1.179
1.055
0.931
0.434
0.600
1.138
1.138
1.055
108
0.972
0.683
0.476
0.352
0.600
1.179
0.352
0.021
0.476
1.055
0.352
0.559
1.055
0.807
109
0.062
0.145
0.021
0.724
0.062
0.848
0.062
0.848
1.055
0.352
0.890
0.269
0.931
0.476
110
0.228
0.269
0.145
0.766
0.683
0.021
0.186
0.434
0.890
0.145
0.848
0.103
0.393
0.972
111
1.097
0.062
1.014
0.103
0.021
0.724
0.683
0.517
0.683
0.766
0.434
0.683
0.434
0.848
112
1.055
0.848
0.766
0.517
0.186
0.517
0.021
0.972
1.097
1.138
1.055
0.766
0.683
1.014
113
0.641
1.097
0.600
0.310
0.724
1.138
0.228
0.145
0.310
0.310
0.766
0.807
1.097
0.393
114
0.683
1.055
1.055
0.890
1.179
0.641
1.014
0.228
0.269
0.724
0.724
0.476
0.145
0.103
115
0.807
0.228
0.352
0.972
0.310
0.931
0.310
0.103
0.021
0.600
0.393
0.186
0.062
0.228
116
0.724
0.393
1.138
0.393
0.393
0.145
0.641
1.097
0.186
0.641
0.807
0.848
0.890
0.931
117
0.393
0.559
0.269
0.062
1.014
0.393
0.559
0.476
0.517
0.062
0.310
0.641
0.103
0.269
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

Run
No.
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)

Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)

Non­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
non­
attainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)

Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)

On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
6
118
0.434
0.310
0.103
0.228
0.807
1.097
0.724
0.186
0.393
0.269
1.138
0.890
0.724
0.641
119
0.310
1.179
0.434
0.021
1.097
0.476
0.145
0.559
0.641
0.848
0.931
0.931
0.559
0.062
120
0.269
0.517
0.641
0.848
0.848
0.972
0.807
0.269
0.103
0.021
0.186
0.352
0.600
0.890
121
0.145
1.138
1.179
0.559
0.559
0.766
0.848
0.766
0.724
0.807
1.097
0.228
0.269
0.310
122
1.138
0.972
0.186
0.186
0.228
0.600
0.517
0.807
0.145
0.186
0.476
1.055
0.972
0.724
123
0.021
0.352
0.228
0.434
0.517
0.559
1.055
0.062
0.559
0.476
0.228
1.097
0.352
0.600
124
0.600
0.766
0.890
1.097
0.434
0.890
1.138
0.310
0.766
0.228
0.062
0.310
0.186
1.138
125
0.476
0.476
1.097
1.138
0.352
0.103
0.600
0.393
0.972
0.517
1.014
1.014
0.021
0.434
126
0.890
0.890
0.972
0.476
0.890
0.310
0.766
0.352
0.228
0.972
0.972
0.145
0.766
0.559
127
1.179
0.641
0.517
0.931
0.972
0.228
0.103
0.641
0.352
0.559
0.103
0.062
0.517
1.097
128
1.014
0.021
0.724
1.014
0.931
0.352
0.393
1.138
0.807
0.393
0.145
0.600
1.179
0.766
129
0.848
0.600
0.848
0.269
0.145
0.062
1.097
0.890
0.600
0.683
1.179
0.434
1.014
0.352
130
0.517
0.724
0.310
0.683
1.138
0.186
0.434
0.683
0.434
0.103
0.641
1.179
0.310
0.145
131
0.995
0.975
0.995
0.965
0.945
0.945
0.955
0.945
0.905
0.975
0.925
0.965
0.915
0.985
132
0.915
0.945
0.915
0.905
0.975
0.915
0.965
0.965
0.965
0.935
0.915
0.905
0.935
0.915
133
0.945
0.995
0.975
0.955
0.965
0.985
0.905
0.975
0.925
0.905
0.935
0.975
0.955
0.925
134
0.905
0.965
0.905
0.985
0.925
0.955
0.915
0.935
0.995
0.915
0.955
0.985
0.945
0.955
135
0.965
0.925
0.925
0.925
0.955
0.995
0.995
0.925
0.955
0.945
0.965
0.995
0.905
0.995
136
0.975
0.905
0.935
0.995
0.915
0.905
0.945
0.955
0.935
0.925
0.985
0.955
0.975
0.935
137
0.925
0.915
0.955
0.975
0.985
0.975
0.975
0.905
0.915
0.965
0.995
0.915
0.965
0.965
138
0.985
0.955
0.965
0.915
0.995
0.925
0.925
0.985
0.945
0.955
0.945
0.945
0.995
0.975
139
0.955
0.935
0.945
0.945
0.935
0.965
0.935
0.915
0.985
0.985
0.905
0.935
0.985
0.905
140
0.935
0.985
0.985
0.935
0.905
0.935
0.985
0.995
0.975
0.995
0.975
0.925
0.925
0.945
Table
A­
1:
Design
1
(
Continued)

WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
7
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
8
Run
Number
1)
Nonroad
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Nonroad
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
1
0.780
0.660
0.060
0.900
0.300
0.540
0.660
2
0.180
0.780
0.660
0.060
0.660
0.060
0.780
3
0.300
0.060
0.900
0.780
0.180
0.180
0.420
4
0.660
0.300
0.780
0.300
0.420
0.300
1.140
5
1.140
0.180
0.300
0.660
0.060
1.020
1.020
6
1.020
0.900
0.180
0.420
0.780
0.420
0.300
7
0.060
1.020
1.140
0.540
1.140
0.900
0.540
8
0.420
0.420
0.420
1.140
0.900
0.780
0.900
9
0.540
1.140
1.020
1.020
0.540
0.660
0.060
10
0.900
0.540
0.540
0.180
1.020
1.140
0.180
11
0.360
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.120
1.080
0.120
12
0.840
0.120
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.360
0.360
13
1.080
0.600
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.600
0.840
14
0.120
0.840
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.600
15
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.840
1.080
16
0.840
0.840
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.600
1.080
17
1.080
0.600
0.840
0.360
0.600
0.840
0.360
18
0.120
0.120
1.080
0.600
0.840
1.080
0.600
19
0.360
1.080
0.120
0.840
0.360
0.360
0.840
20
0.600
0.360
0.600
1.080
1.080
0.120
0.120
Table
A­
2:
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
9
Run
Number
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)

Onroad
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)

Onroad
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
Onroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
Onroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
X8
X9
X10
X11
X12
X13
X14
1
0.420
0.060
0.540
1.020
0.660
0.060
0.060
2
0.180
1.020
0.300
0.660
0.540
1.140
0.420
3
0.660
0.660
1.020
0.180
0.420
0.180
1.140
4
1.140
0.420
0.780
1.140
1.140
0.900
0.540
5
0.900
1.140
0.420
0.540
0.780
0.540
0.660
6
0.780
0.180
0.060
0.300
0.060
1.020
1.020
7
0.540
0.780
0.660
0.420
1.020
0.780
0.300
8
0.060
0.300
0.900
0.060
0.180
0.660
0.180
9
1.020
0.900
0.180
0.900
0.300
0.420
0.780
10
0.300
0.540
1.140
0.780
0.900
0.300
0.900
11
1.080
0.120
0.360
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.120
12
0.360
1.080
0.600
0.840
1.080
0.600
0.360
13
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.360
0.360
1.080
0.840
14
0.840
0.360
1.080
1.080
0.120
0.360
0.600
15
0.600
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.120
1.080
16
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.120
0.360
0.840
0.360
17
0.120
0.840
0.360
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.600
18
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.120
0.120
0.840
19
1.080
0.360
1.080
0.840
0.840
0.600
1.080
20
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.360
1.080
1.080
0.120
Table
A­
2:
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
10
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
A­
11
Run
Number
1)
Nonroad
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Nonroad
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
11)
Onroad
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
Onroad
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
Onroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
Onroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Location
Number
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
X11
X12
X13
X14
X15
1
1.020
0.660
0.060
0.300
1.020
0.900
0.420
1.020
0.300
0.300
0.300
0.780
0.420
1.140
5
2
0.660
0.180
0.420
0.420
0.660
1.140
1.140
0.060
0.780
1.020
0.180
0.660
0.300
0.660
2
3
1.140
0.420
1.020
0.660
0.060
0.540
0.300
0.300
0.540
0.060
1.020
0.900
0.660
0.300
2
4
0.060
0.300
0.180
0.180
1.140
0.300
0.540
0.660
0.660
0.900
0.900
0.420
0.900
0.060
3
5
0.900
1.020
0.540
0.060
0.420
0.060
0.900
0.540
0.180
1.140
0.780
1.020
0.540
0.420
4
6
0.540
0.780
0.780
0.900
0.780
1.020
0.780
0.420
1.140
0.420
1.140
1.140
1.140
1.020
3
7
0.780
0.540
0.900
1.140
0.900
0.420
1.020
1.140
0.060
0.780
0.540
0.060
0.780
0.780
1
8
0.420
0.060
0.300
1.020
0.180
0.660
0.660
0.900
1.020
0.180
0.420
0.180
0.180
0.180
4
9
0.300
1.140
0.660
0.540
0.300
0.780
0.060
0.780
0.420
0.540
0.060
0.540
1.020
0.540
1
10
0.180
0.900
1.140
0.780
0.540
0.180
0.180
0.180
0.900
0.660
0.660
0.300
0.060
0.900
5
11
1.080
1.080
0.840
1.080
0.360
0.840
0.600
1.080
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.360
1.080
1.080
2
12
0.360
0.360
0.600
0.120
0.840
0.600
1.080
0.360
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.120
0.600
5
13
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.120
0.600
1.080
0.600
0.120
1
14
0.600
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.120
0.360
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.840
0.840
0.840
4
15
0.840
0.120
1.080
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.120
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.600
0.360
0.360
3
16
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.600
1.080
1.080
0.360
0.600
0.120
0.360
1.080
0.360
1.080
0.600
2
17
1.080
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.360
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.600
0.360
1.080
0.120
0.360
5
18
0.840
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.840
0.600
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.840
0.840
0.840
0.600
0.120
1
19
0.600
0.600
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.120
0.120
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.600
0.120
0.360
1.080
4
20
0.120
0.360
0.360
1.080
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.840
3
Table
A­
3.
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
1
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
APPENDIX
B:

EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
2
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
B­
1
Table
B­
1.
Design
2
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
2)
Area
VOC
control
3)
Non­
road
NOx
control
4)
EGU
NOx
control
5)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
6)
On­
road
VOC
control
7)
On­
road
NOx
control
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
1
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
2
0.146
0.986
0.934
1.054
1.071
0.780
0.111
3
0.917
0.557
0.746
0.557
0.060
0.814
1.157
4
0.197
0.831
0.591
0.849
0.026
1.106
0.231
5
1.054
1.140
1.054
0.369
0.094
0.111
0.420
6
1.123
1.054
0.060
0.643
1.106
0.591
0.454
7
0.849
0.094
0.626
1.037
0.643
0.094
0.969
8
0.591
1.089
0.557
0.197
0.986
1.003
0.917
9
0.746
0.334
0.763
0.111
1.089
1.089
0.883
10
0.111
0.694
0.403
0.094
0.077
0.609
1.003
11
0.060
1.071
0.814
0.780
0.626
0.334
0.557
12
0.471
0.797
0.454
0.591
0.386
0.009
0.866
13
1.089
0.883
0.694
0.077
0.934
0.437
0.026
14
1.140
0.111
0.506
0.746
0.163
1.123
0.643
15
0.780
0.814
0.317
0.386
1.157
0.523
1.123
16
1.191
0.454
0.214
0.454
0.609
0.746
0.849
17
0.506
0.471
0.797
0.986
0.917
1.191
1.054
18
0.643
0.746
0.900
0.677
0.231
0.077
0.266
19
0.814
0.420
0.866
0.883
0.403
1.020
0.009
20
0.540
0.866
0.009
0.540
0.574
0.163
0.146
21
0.609
0.163
0.386
0.009
0.763
0.763
0.729
22
0.660
0.643
1.020
0.266
0.849
1.140
0.814
23
0.043
0.506
0.643
0.420
0.197
0.917
0.094
24
0.866
0.711
1.089
0.471
1.020
0.300
0.369
25
0.386
1.003
0.420
0.351
0.471
1.071
1.191
26
0.369
0.540
1.037
0.763
1.191
0.660
0.951
27
0.986
0.043
0.266
0.249
0.420
0.317
0.180
28
0.317
0.609
1.174
0.146
0.129
0.969
0.163
29
0.454
1.106
0.300
0.489
0.249
0.677
0.043
30
0.437
0.626
0.677
0.917
1.054
0.180
0.506
31
0.951
0.917
1.140
0.814
1.140
0.214
0.746
32
0.129
1.157
0.711
0.609
0.523
1.157
0.317
33
0.626
0.369
0.180
0.729
0.506
0.506
0.077
34
0.900
1.174
0.523
0.900
0.780
0.574
0.129
35
0.797
0.489
0.969
0.626
0.009
0.351
0.711
36
0.694
1.020
0.146
1.174
0.146
0.283
1.020
37
0.574
0.677
0.077
0.866
0.300
0.386
1.174
38
0.231
0.283
0.489
0.214
1.174
0.369
0.437
39
0.351
0.026
0.729
1.157
0.266
0.557
0.609
40
0.094
0.386
0.540
0.317
0.317
0.146
0.763
41
0.180
0.591
0.129
0.403
0.746
0.043
0.626
42
0.523
1.191
0.917
0.163
0.437
0.626
0.660
43
1.174
0.849
0.831
0.231
0.283
0.866
0.986
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
B­
2
44
0.249
0.900
1.003
0.969
0.180
0.729
0.334
45
0.300
1.037
0.609
0.523
0.883
0.489
0.677
46
0.489
0.129
0.163
0.283
1.123
0.951
0.300
47
0.883
0.951
0.231
0.026
0.334
1.174
0.574
48
0.420
0.403
1.106
0.060
0.660
0.831
0.249
49
0.214
0.077
0.883
0.043
0.831
0.197
1.140
50
1.106
0.266
0.951
0.506
0.729
1.037
1.037
51
0.934
0.180
0.986
0.129
0.540
0.026
0.489
52
0.266
0.009
0.111
0.711
1.037
0.849
0.831
53
0.677
0.231
0.660
0.797
0.369
0.797
0.386
54
0.969
0.351
0.437
1.191
0.866
0.883
0.351
55
0.763
1.123
0.026
1.003
0.711
0.900
0.780
56
0.334
0.317
0.249
0.831
0.969
0.060
1.106
57
0.026
0.249
1.123
0.951
0.454
0.540
0.900
58
0.831
0.214
0.094
0.334
0.900
0.643
0.214
59
0.283
0.763
0.780
0.300
0.694
0.249
0.060
60
0.711
0.060
1.157
0.574
0.951
0.711
0.523
61
0.729
0.574
0.471
1.071
0.591
0.471
0.283
62
0.403
0.197
0.849
1.106
0.111
0.420
0.797
63
0.077
0.780
0.197
1.089
0.814
1.054
0.471
64
0.557
0.300
0.334
1.020
0.043
0.266
0.591
65
1.020
0.660
0.574
1.123
0.489
0.694
1.089
66
1.037
0.437
0.043
0.180
0.214
0.231
0.540
67
1.071
0.729
0.283
0.934
0.557
0.934
0.694
68
0.163
0.146
1.071
0.660
0.351
0.454
1.071
69
1.157
0.523
0.369
1.140
1.003
0.129
0.197
70
0.009
0.934
0.351
0.694
0.677
0.986
0.403
71
1.003
0.969
1.191
0.437
0.797
0.403
0.934
72
0.987
1.000
0.973
0.946
1.000
0.970
1.000
73
0.916
0.930
0.912
1.000
0.952
0.928
0.949
74
0.950
0.979
1.000
0.900
0.904
0.991
0.900
75
1.000
0.906
0.943
0.902
0.937
0.901
0.988
76
0.902
0.964
0.902
0.989
0.970
1.000
0.999
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
B­
3
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
2)
Area
VOC
control
3)
Non­
road
NOx
control
4)
EGU
NOx
control
5)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
6)
On­
road
VOC
control
7)
On­
road
NOx
control
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
1
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
2
0.146
0.986
0.934
1.054
1.071
0.780
0.111
3
0.917
0.557
0.746
0.557
0.060
0.814
1.157
4
0.197
0.831
0.591
0.849
0.026
1.106
0.231
5
1.054
1.140
1.054
0.369
0.094
0.111
0.420
6
1.123
1.054
0.060
0.643
1.106
0.591
0.454
7
0.849
0.094
0.626
1.037
0.643
0.094
0.969
8
0.591
1.089
0.557
0.197
0.986
1.003
0.917
9
0.746
0.334
0.763
0.111
1.089
1.089
0.883
10
0.111
0.694
0.403
0.094
0.077
0.609
1.003
11
0.060
1.071
0.814
0.780
0.626
0.334
0.557
12
0.471
0.797
0.454
0.591
0.386
0.009
0.866
13
1.089
0.883
0.694
0.077
0.934
0.437
0.026
14
1.140
0.111
0.506
0.746
0.163
1.123
0.643
15
0.780
0.814
0.317
0.386
1.157
0.523
1.123
16
1.191
0.454
0.214
0.454
0.609
0.746
0.849
17
0.506
0.471
0.797
0.986
0.917
1.191
1.054
18
0.643
0.746
0.900
0.677
0.231
0.077
0.266
19
0.814
0.420
0.866
0.883
0.403
1.020
0.009
20
0.540
0.866
0.009
0.540
0.574
0.163
0.146
Table
B­
2.
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
2
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
B­
4
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
2)
Area
VOC
control
3)
Non­
road
NOx
control
4)
EGU
NOx
control
5)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
6)
On­
road
VOC
control
7)
On­
road
NOx
control
8)
Location
Number
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
1
1.020
0.660
1.020
0.780
0.540
0.060
0.060
2
2
0.900
0.540
0.060
0.300
1.140
1.020
0.660
3
3
0.780
1.140
0.780
0.900
0.900
0.540
0.540
1
4
0.300
0.060
0.540
1.140
0.660
0.300
0.300
3
5
0.420
1.020
0.300
0.180
0.060
0.420
0.900
2
6
1.140
0.180
0.180
0.660
0.780
0.660
1.020
5
7
0.660
0.300
1.140
1.020
0.180
0.780
0.780
4
8
0.540
0.780
0.660
0.060
0.420
1.140
0.420
5
9
0.180
0.900
0.900
0.420
1.020
0.180
1.140
4
10
0.060
0.420
0.420
0.540
0.300
0.900
0.180
1
11
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.600
5
12
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.840
1
13
0.840
0.840
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.840
1.080
2
14
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.120
3
15
1.080
1.080
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.360
0.360
4
16
0.600
0.840
1.080
0.600
0.120
0.120
1.080
3
17
0.840
1.080
0.360
0.360
0.600
0.840
0.120
5
18
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.360
1
19
1.080
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.360
1.080
0.600
2
20
0.360
0.600
0.120
0.840
0.840
0.600
0.840
4
Table
B­
3.
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
2
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
APPENDIX
C:

EXPERIMENTAL
DESIGN
3
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
1
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
1
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
2
0.924
0.180
1.164
1.068
0.324
0.228
0.180
0.060
0.468
0.516
3
1.164
1.020
0.036
0.468
0.468
0.396
0.252
0.468
0.588
0.924
4
0.444
0.324
0.780
0.900
1.188
1.116
1.140
0.684
0.132
0.756
5
0.036
0.204
0.828
0.420
0.804
0.468
0.804
0.372
0.372
0.588
6
0.468
0.780
1.020
0.060
0.012
0.876
0.708
0.276
0.564
0.444
7
0.252
0.660
0.348
0.588
0.420
0.276
0.276
0.636
0.252
0.084
8
0.060
0.948
0.516
1.164
0.372
1.092
0.132
0.324
0.948
0.252
9
0.372
0.156
0.012
0.612
0.084
0.324
0.564
1.044
0.348
0.372
10
1.044
0.612
1.068
0.804
0.732
1.020
1.092
0.828
0.036
0.540
11
0.564
0.300
0.300
1.020
0.396
0.492
1.044
0.924
1.068
0.180
12
0.108
0.276
1.092
0.180
0.588
0.756
0.492
0.420
1.116
0.780
13
0.756
1.092
0.228
0.492
0.564
0.708
0.396
0.084
0.012
0.300
14
0.708
0.372
0.732
0.540
0.636
1.044
0.900
0.780
0.660
0.276
15
0.948
0.492
0.612
0.108
0.492
0.516
0.756
0.564
0.732
0.732
16
0.852
0.876
0.108
0.204
1.092
0.564
0.924
1.068
0.228
1.044
17
0.660
0.060
0.972
1.188
0.132
1.188
0.684
0.900
0.828
0.612
18
0.420
0.972
1.140
0.756
0.828
0.612
1.020
0.612
0.996
1.092
19
0.012
1.188
0.180
0.324
0.612
0.300
0.972
0.948
0.756
0.876
20
0.588
0.636
1.188
0.972
1.116
0.060
0.468
0.348
0.180
0.348
21
0.972
0.588
0.060
0.684
0.180
0.156
0.876
0.660
0.972
0.828
22
1.068
0.900
0.636
0.924
1.020
0.804
0.588
0.852
0.396
0.204
23
0.300
1.068
0.540
0.708
1.164
0.540
0.444
1.140
0.684
0.492
24
0.540
0.444
0.948
0.444
0.036
0.636
0.156
0.804
0.204
0.972
25
0.204
0.564
0.756
0.036
0.948
0.732
0.228
1.020
0.780
0.636
26
0.684
0.684
1.116
0.852
0.060
0.828
0.324
1.092
0.900
0.012
27
0.516
0.396
0.084
0.156
0.684
0.444
0.012
0.108
0.876
0.660
28
0.228
0.852
0.876
1.044
0.516
1.068
0.036
1.116
0.084
0.324
29
0.132
0.516
0.468
0.876
0.540
0.420
0.852
0.036
0.540
0.132
30
0.828
1.044
0.444
0.372
0.156
0.780
1.068
0.540
0.156
0.684
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
2
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
3
Run
Number
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
X11
X12
X13
X14
X15
X16
X17
X18
1
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
1.000
2
0.612
0.780
0.996
0.684
0.516
0.636
1.044
0.492
3
0.492
0.012
0.876
0.156
1.044
0.540
0.540
0.876
4
0.924
0.756
0.852
0.348
1.116
0.756
0.828
0.204
5
1.188
1.164
0.804
0.780
0.372
0.924
0.156
0.324
6
0.804
0.348
1.068
0.996
0.420
0.708
0.204
1.188
7
0.852
0.732
0.108
0.060
0.396
1.164
1.188
0.948
8
0.780
0.612
0.588
1.164
0.588
0.564
0.660
0.132
9
1.092
0.636
0.228
1.044
1.092
0.084
0.276
0.564
10
0.180
0.588
0.060
0.852
0.780
0.492
0.300
0.900
11
1.116
0.300
1.020
0.444
0.300
0.468
0.564
1.140
12
0.516
0.396
0.420
0.012
0.492
0.036
0.060
0.972
13
0.036
0.660
0.948
0.972
0.348
1.116
0.804
0.780
14
0.588
1.116
0.252
0.084
0.132
0.252
0.108
1.164
15
1.068
0.540
0.036
0.108
0.948
1.020
0.996
0.156
16
0.324
0.996
0.972
1.116
0.444
0.516
0.348
0.180
17
0.540
0.948
0.924
0.612
1.140
1.044
0.396
0.924
18
0.660
0.852
0.300
0.228
0.996
1.068
0.228
0.732
19
0.204
0.876
1.188
0.900
0.612
0.732
0.924
0.444
20
0.468
0.108
0.276
0.924
0.252
0.972
0.948
0.036
21
0.012
0.420
1.044
1.188
0.180
0.852
0.468
0.300
22
0.708
0.036
1.092
0.036
0.084
1.092
1.092
0.420
23
0.564
0.324
1.116
0.804
0.660
0.204
1.164
0.852
24
0.108
0.444
0.684
0.732
0.876
0.060
1.140
0.108
25
0.372
0.828
0.204
0.756
0.036
0.444
0.612
0.012
26
1.020
1.140
1.164
0.180
0.540
0.420
0.780
0.252
27
0.948
0.060
0.564
0.660
0.684
1.188
0.252
0.636
28
0.252
0.372
0.372
0.564
1.020
0.876
0.420
0.396
29
0.684
0.924
0.732
0.516
1.188
0.180
0.324
0.060
30
0.276
0.180
0.132
0.468
0.564
0.276
0.180
0.540
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
4
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
5
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
6
31
0.804
0.540
0.156
0.252
0.444
1.164
0.516
0.252
0.300
1.140
32
1.116
0.036
0.204
0.228
0.756
0.900
0.204
0.588
0.420
0.396
33
0.996
0.252
0.420
0.732
0.996
0.924
0.108
0.204
0.108
0.036
34
0.084
0.420
0.588
1.092
0.204
0.948
0.948
1.188
0.324
0.420
35
0.324
0.756
0.684
1.140
0.660
0.036
0.348
0.492
0.276
0.852
36
0.156
0.996
0.708
0.132
0.276
0.252
0.540
0.876
0.060
0.996
37
0.492
0.924
0.132
1.116
0.900
0.684
1.116
0.180
0.516
0.900
38
0.348
0.084
0.900
0.300
0.300
0.660
0.372
0.228
0.636
0.156
39
1.020
1.116
0.852
0.828
0.108
0.084
0.780
0.156
0.444
1.020
40
0.612
0.108
0.492
0.012
1.044
0.972
0.300
0.972
0.492
0.948
41
0.276
0.132
0.276
0.660
0.708
0.852
0.660
0.132
1.140
1.164
42
0.180
0.228
0.924
0.516
1.068
0.108
0.996
0.708
0.852
1.188
43
0.780
0.012
0.804
0.780
0.924
0.372
0.732
0.732
0.924
0.108
44
0.900
1.164
0.324
0.636
0.972
0.996
1.164
0.396
0.612
1.068
45
0.876
0.708
1.044
0.348
0.852
0.132
0.420
0.996
1.188
0.228
46
1.140
0.468
0.396
0.396
0.348
0.012
0.612
0.756
1.020
0.468
47
1.092
0.732
0.996
0.564
0.252
0.588
0.060
0.012
0.708
0.804
48
0.732
0.804
0.660
0.276
1.140
0.348
1.188
0.300
1.092
0.564
49
1.188
0.348
0.564
0.996
0.876
0.180
0.636
0.516
0.804
1.116
50
0.636
1.140
0.372
0.948
0.780
0.204
0.084
1.164
1.164
0.708
51
0.396
0.828
0.252
0.084
0.228
1.140
0.828
0.444
1.044
0.060
52
1.068
0.660
0.612
0.372
0.372
0.876
0.900
0.420
0.012
1.092
53
1.020
0.444
0.996
0.036
1.116
0.372
1.020
0.084
0.276
0.372
54
0.636
0.252
0.636
0.564
0.012
0.996
0.372
0.660
0.420
0.588
55
0.420
0.708
0.492
0.660
0.612
1.164
0.180
0.492
0.084
0.732
56
0.804
0.924
0.588
0.012
0.636
0.252
0.804
0.684
1.140
0.444
57
0.300
0.420
1.116
0.204
0.132
1.068
1.116
0.372
0.732
0.204
58
0.108
0.612
0.732
0.708
0.780
0.012
0.156
0.252
0.828
1.020
59
0.708
0.012
0.300
0.420
0.684
0.804
0.996
0.276
0.060
0.900
60
0.732
0.276
0.372
1.116
0.228
0.396
0.660
1.044
0.132
0.996
61
0.564
0.684
0.540
0.540
0.804
1.188
0.588
0.060
0.444
0.876
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
7
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
0.636
0.468
1.140
0.420
0.828
0.900
0.684
0.660
0.876
0.252
0.612
0.540
0.276
0.228
0.492
0.228
1.140
0.900
0.900
0.948
0.900
0.348
0.084
0.612
0.348
0.132
0.780
0.204
0.804
1.140
0.852
1.068
1.164
0.228
0.708
0.372
0.060
0.660
0.372
0.756
0.828
1.188
0.516
0.492
0.204
0.372
0.876
0.828
1.044
1.044
0.156
0.588
0.156
0.108
0.972
0.996
0.396
0.084
0.084
1.140
0.972
0.780
0.036
0.276
0.420
0.708
0.324
0.396
0.636
0.012
0.588
1.092
0.060
0.564
0.396
0.324
0.708
0.828
0.132
0.708
0.300
0.516
0.828
0.276
0.108
0.588
0.900
0.084
0.756
0.276
0.012
0.132
0.756
0.132
0.732
0.516
0.228
0.156
0.444
1.068
0.228
0.612
1.116
0.684
0.996
0.204
0.492
0.708
1.164
0.996
0.708
0.372
0.900
0.492
0.756
0.636
1.068
0.324
1.020
1.116
0.972
0.972
0.348
0.876
0.012
0.804
0.756
1.020
0.156
1.020
0.468
0.300
0.324
0.948
0.636
0.588
0.084
0.804
0.540
0.252
0.924
0.156
0.444
1.044
0.132
0.684
0.636
1.020
0.468
0.396
0.012
0.348
0.732
1.092
0.180
1.092
0.852
0.684
0.516
0.804
0.444
1.068
0.660
0.828
0.732
0.300
1.068
0.468
0.060
0.876
0.204
0.588
1.116
0.636
1.140
0.636
0.900
1.140
0.156
0.516
0.732
0.780
0.060
0.372
0.444
0.156
1.140
0.492
1.068
0.444
0.972
0.132
0.852
0.036
1.020
0.780
0.228
0.108
0.324
1.044
1.116
0.924
0.564
0.708
1.020
0.036
0.636
0.252
0.828
0.804
1.044
0.948
1.044
0.012
0.756
0.684
1.092
0.012
0.492
0.564
0.348
0.732
0.996
0.708
0.564
0.732
0.732
1.116
1.092
0.828
1.044
0.012
0.660
0.324
0.036
0.660
0.276
0.660
0.684
0.300
0.300
0.396
0.060
1.068
0.900
1.140
0.708
0.204
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
8
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
9
62
0.900
0.804
0.564
0.132
0.084
0.732
0.852
0.180
0.996
0.276
63
0.084
0.732
0.756
0.444
1.140
0.276
0.636
0.588
0.516
0.324
64
0.132
0.060
1.068
0.516
0.996
0.300
0.828
1.116
0.180
0.708
65
0.252
0.348
0.444
0.804
0.180
0.324
0.204
0.876
1.188
0.300
66
0.828
1.140
0.132
0.876
0.036
0.588
0.612
0.444
0.852
0.540
67
0.324
1.044
0.420
0.060
0.060
1.020
0.516
0.708
0.756
1.044
68
1.092
0.516
0.324
0.948
0.708
1.116
0.348
0.204
0.780
0.420
69
0.204
0.756
0.036
0.828
0.756
0.612
1.164
0.756
0.108
0.252
70
0.396
0.780
0.828
0.588
0.948
0.180
0.972
0.156
0.876
0.492
71
1.164
0.564
0.348
0.276
0.828
0.684
0.684
1.140
0.900
0.780
72
1.188
0.396
0.876
1.164
1.044
0.852
0.468
0.804
1.044
0.516
73
0.948
0.636
0.108
0.300
0.108
0.132
0.060
0.732
1.068
0.948
74
0.588
0.996
0.180
0.684
0.900
1.044
0.708
1.068
1.116
0.684
75
0.516
0.540
0.228
1.044
1.092
0.780
0.876
0.636
0.684
0.924
76
0.180
0.372
0.060
0.324
1.164
0.948
0.132
0.540
0.372
0.132
77
1.044
0.180
0.900
0.756
0.204
0.708
0.084
0.972
1.092
0.852
78
0.924
0.132
0.396
0.348
0.924
1.140
0.492
1.188
0.204
0.180
79
0.444
0.228
0.204
1.188
0.564
0.204
0.756
0.324
0.636
0.348
80
0.372
0.588
0.516
0.468
0.492
0.060
1.140
1.164
0.396
1.188
81
0.060
0.852
1.188
0.924
1.068
0.516
0.228
0.132
1.020
0.972
82
0.348
0.948
1.044
0.996
0.396
0.756
0.732
0.036
0.228
0.564
83
0.876
0.492
1.020
0.612
1.188
0.828
0.012
0.948
0.468
1.116
84
0.996
0.036
0.468
1.140
0.420
0.444
0.396
0.300
1.164
1.068
85
0.036
1.068
0.276
0.108
0.468
0.108
1.188
0.780
0.492
0.804
86
0.660
1.020
0.708
1.092
0.588
0.900
0.036
0.996
0.972
0.156
87
0.612
0.828
0.084
0.732
0.324
0.036
1.092
1.092
0.660
0.396
88
0.756
1.188
0.780
0.972
0.348
0.924
0.300
0.828
0.708
1.164
89
0.468
0.468
0.156
0.180
0.252
0.084
0.276
0.924
0.036
0.036
90
0.492
0.204
0.660
0.852
0.732
1.092
0.948
0.900
0.252
1.140
91
0.228
0.972
0.972
0.252
0.876
0.420
0.444
0.396
0.324
0.012
92
1.140
1.164
0.948
0.780
0.444
0.228
1.044
1.020
0.348
0.060
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
10
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
11
0.228
0.108
0.684
0.036
0.324
0.756
0.732
0.876
0.732
0.516
0.996
0.828
1.164
1.068
0.036
0.612
0.636
0.684
0.468
0.348
0.012
0.564
0.468
1.140
1.164
1.044
1.116
0.228
0.708
0.996
0.948
0.180
0.876
0.828
0.396
1.164
0.948
0.924
0.900
1.164
0.132
1.092
0.804
0.636
0.300
1.092
0.444
0.036
0.084
0.372
0.300
0.132
0.204
0.516
0.156
0.492
0.468
0.564
0.924
0.444
0.468
0.180
1.116
0.444
1.140
0.492
0.084
0.540
0.564
0.540
0.804
0.108
0.780
0.132
0.972
0.372
0.612
0.060
1.068
0.564
0.372
0.900
1.188
0.468
0.372
1.020
0.492
0.756
0.684
0.660
0.852
0.804
0.084
0.900
0.180
0.972
0.420
0.276
0.708
0.756
0.396
0.804
0.828
0.588
1.188
0.612
0.516
0.276
0.540
0.684
0.012
1.092
0.612
1.020
0.324
0.996
0.252
0.468
0.780
0.924
0.924
0.468
0.612
0.108
1.188
0.420
1.164
1.188
1.044
0.588
0.540
0.156
0.660
1.116
0.372
0.324
0.180
0.996
1.092
0.180
0.036
0.324
1.188
0.660
0.276
0.948
0.444
0.684
0.420
0.372
0.108
1.116
0.156
0.348
0.420
0.420
1.140
0.276
0.252
0.276
1.020
0.972
0.876
0.084
0.684
0.852
0.924
0.780
0.108
0.228
0.900
1.140
0.756
0.252
0.516
0.996
0.492
0.444
0.252
0.852
0.516
0.084
0.852
0.420
0.948
0.852
0.108
1.044
0.804
0.348
0.396
0.228
0.756
0.708
0.132
0.252
0.444
0.972
0.276
0.468
0.804
0.756
0.780
0.012
0.828
1.044
0.564
0.084
0.516
1.164
0.660
1.188
0.996
1.188
0.348
0.540
0.588
0.180
0.228
0.204
0.972
0.588
0.420
0.348
0.708
0.084
0.372
0.972
0.492
0.300
0.612
0.852
0.972
0.540
1.068
1.092
0.132
0.492
0.588
0.516
0.540
0.060
0.828
0.324
0.180
0.156
0.204
0.156
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
12
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
93
0.012
0.876
0.804
0.492
0.156
0.660
0.564
0.108
0.564
0.228
94
0.276
1.092
1.164
0.396
0.276
0.972
0.924
0.228
0.924
0.660
95
0.684
0.324
0.852
0.228
0.300
0.540
1.068
0.468
0.540
0.828
96
0.780
0.156
0.684
0.156
0.852
0.564
0.780
0.852
0.588
0.084
97
1.116
0.900
0.924
0.636
0.516
0.492
0.252
0.348
0.156
0.612
98
0.156
1.116
0.012
1.020
0.972
0.636
0.420
0.564
0.948
0.108
99
0.852
0.300
0.252
1.068
1.020
0.156
0.324
0.012
0.300
0.756
100
0.540
0.084
1.092
0.084
0.540
0.348
0.108
0.612
0.804
0.468
101
0.972
0.108
1.140
0.900
0.660
0.468
0.540
0.516
0.612
0.636
102
0.828
0.588
0.276
0.060
0.828
0.420
0.036
0.180
0.036
0.972
103
0.972
1.092
0.900
0.540
1.188
0.900
0.660
0.396
0.780
0.084
104
0.612
0.372
0.996
0.852
0.492
0.252
0.444
0.252
0.972
0.852
105
0.108
0.708
0.468
1.188
0.300
0.852
1.020
0.684
0.348
1.116
106
1.068
0.756
0.204
0.780
0.132
0.444
0.828
0.540
1.020
1.164
107
1.188
0.156
0.252
0.924
0.156
0.876
0.132
0.732
0.252
0.324
108
0.660
0.348
0.660
0.396
0.660
0.732
0.468
0.084
0.516
0.036
109
0.060
0.492
0.156
0.468
0.396
1.020
0.060
0.516
0.180
0.492
110
0.156
0.300
0.180
0.036
0.228
0.012
0.780
0.204
0.684
0.612
111
0.252
1.188
0.300
0.684
0.852
0.372
0.900
0.324
0.876
0.564
112
0.588
1.116
1.092
1.116
0.612
0.564
0.228
0.276
0.372
0.252
113
0.132
0.948
0.228
0.420
0.732
0.228
0.012
0.996
0.564
0.756
114
0.876
0.204
0.516
0.108
0.780
0.612
0.252
1.116
0.756
0.348
115
1.020
0.828
1.044
1.092
0.924
0.588
0.516
0.660
0.156
0.876
116
0.444
0.924
1.116
0.348
0.444
0.396
0.612
0.156
1.092
0.828
117
0.468
0.012
0.588
0.828
0.372
1.044
0.420
0.804
0.852
0.924
118
0.948
1.164
0.564
0.228
0.252
0.276
0.684
0.492
0.396
0.900
119
0.228
0.804
0.444
0.876
0.972
1.188
0.156
0.852
0.492
0.372
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
13
0.996
0.252
0.276
0.300
0.852
0.396
0.300
0.948
1.068
0.420
0.636
0.924
0.060
0.132
0.540
0.396
0.204
0.636
0.348
0.732
0.108
1.164
1.020
0.804
0.036
0.300
0.180
0.876
0.588
0.876
0.084
0.060
0.012
1.116
0.756
1.020
0.636
0.612
0.876
0.732
0.324
0.780
1.164
0.612
0.780
0.708
0.132
1.020
0.396
1.188
0.588
0.900
0.924
0.204
0.228
0.900
0.348
0.204
0.012
0.396
0.156
0.948
1.092
0.828
0.252
1.068
0.948
0.060
0.876
0.228
0.660
1.068
0.516
0.228
1.020
0.060
0.708
0.156
0.780
0.660
0.708
0.996
0.708
0.420
1.020
0.108
1.020
0.900
0.228
0.252
0.228
0.828
0.588
1.092
0.348
1.044
0.252
0.780
0.660
0.948
0.684
0.516
1.092
1.164
1.044
0.324
1.188
1.140
0.900
0.444
0.420
0.804
0.564
0.804
0.468
0.708
0.804
0.780
0.324
0.444
0.828
0.372
0.756
1.188
0.780
0.540
1.140
0.276
0.900
1.188
0.204
0.228
0.492
0.132
1.068
0.708
0.732
0.492
0.876
1.068
0.156
0.996
0.300
0.252
0.444
0.924
0.348
0.372
0.852
1.116
0.180
1.188
0.684
0.972
0.084
0.156
0.108
0.396
0.444
0.540
0.276
0.828
1.116
0.396
0.300
0.084
0.756
0.348
1.116
0.708
1.140
0.276
0.180
1.188
0.828
0.924
0.780
0.012
0.252
0.684
0.036
0.228
0.156
0.156
0.348
1.164
0.492
1.116
0.396
1.044
0.108
0.492
0.012
1.068
0.972
0.924
0.828
0.420
0.060
0.324
0.372
0.444
0.300
0.252
0.756
0.324
0.804
0.060
0.420
0.420
0.852
0.108
0.276
0.612
0.012
0.828
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
14
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
15
120
1.044
0.060
0.708
0.636
1.068
1.092
0.324
0.564
0.540
0.300
121
0.732
0.468
0.924
1.140
0.948
1.068
0.924
0.468
1.140
0.396
122
1.092
0.252
1.188
0.324
0.204
0.468
1.092
0.636
0.900
0.276
123
0.372
0.972
0.060
0.180
1.020
0.996
0.756
0.060
0.828
1.140
124
0.300
0.876
0.012
0.804
0.348
1.140
0.540
0.348
0.420
0.804
125
0.636
1.068
0.948
0.276
0.804
0.036
0.876
0.588
0.132
0.204
126
0.012
0.132
0.348
0.132
1.092
0.084
0.396
0.828
0.324
0.732
127
0.348
0.324
0.732
0.948
0.540
0.972
0.996
0.108
0.204
0.060
128
1.116
0.852
0.612
1.164
0.036
0.132
1.116
1.044
0.804
0.132
129
0.924
0.564
0.036
0.972
0.588
0.804
0.948
1.068
0.444
0.468
130
1.164
0.228
0.492
0.204
0.108
0.780
1.188
0.948
0.948
0.420
131
0.708
0.900
1.140
0.492
0.876
0.924
0.852
0.924
0.276
0.660
132
0.516
0.996
0.804
0.612
0.756
0.156
1.068
0.300
1.044
0.636
133
0.756
0.084
0.972
0.564
0.468
0.828
0.636
1.140
1.068
1.044
134
0.900
0.444
1.068
0.300
0.636
0.540
0.588
0.876
0.924
1.188
135
0.492
0.780
0.324
0.732
0.276
0.756
0.564
1.164
0.300
0.108
136
0.036
0.396
0.396
0.900
1.140
0.684
0.732
1.020
0.060
1.068
137
0.324
0.660
0.828
1.044
0.996
0.348
0.204
0.972
0.996
0.684
138
0.540
1.140
0.684
0.012
0.180
0.516
0.372
0.012
0.084
1.092
139
0.180
0.684
0.372
0.252
0.564
0.660
1.140
0.900
0.708
0.516
140
0.804
0.276
1.164
0.708
0.708
0.300
0.084
0.708
0.012
0.180
141
0.852
0.420
0.780
0.756
0.060
0.060
0.180
0.132
0.588
0.156
142
0.996
1.044
0.108
0.996
1.116
1.164
0.276
0.420
1.188
0.444
143
1.140
0.732
0.876
0.516
0.420
1.116
0.804
1.188
0.660
0.948
144
0.204
1.020
1.020
0.660
0.084
0.204
0.300
0.780
0.612
0.996
145
0.396
0.540
0.540
0.156
0.324
0.108
0.108
0.372
0.228
0.228
146
0.564
0.180
0.756
0.372
0.900
0.180
0.348
0.444
0.108
1.020
147
0.780
0.636
0.420
0.588
1.164
0.636
1.044
0.036
0.636
0.708
148
0.084
0.108
0.636
1.068
0.684
0.492
1.164
0.228
1.116
0.012
149
0.684
0.612
0.132
1.020
1.044
0.324
0.708
0.612
0.732
0.780
150
0.420
0.516
0.852
0.444
0.012
0.948
0.492
1.092
1.164
0.540
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
16
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
17
0.468
0.876
0.540
1.092
0.084
0.060
0.564
1.116
0.060
0.108
0.996
0.444
0.660
0.924
0.276
0.948
0.108
0.516
0.180
0.612
0.972
0.828
0.372
0.852
0.804
0.588
0.132
0.780
0.876
0.948
0.852
1.020
0.660
0.180
0.900
0.756
0.540
0.876
0.996
1.140
0.396
0.900
0.420
0.084
0.516
0.468
1.188
0.372
1.020
0.348
0.732
0.588
0.468
1.068
0.636
0.684
0.324
0.468
1.044
0.012
0.996
0.636
0.612
0.996
0.588
0.396
0.516
0.900
0.732
1.164
0.588
0.780
0.924
1.044
0.396
0.636
0.924
0.564
0.036
0.756
0.636
1.092
0.060
0.564
0.372
0.204
0.900
0.612
0.156
0.564
0.108
0.876
0.228
0.012
1.164
0.132
0.612
0.132
1.164
0.132
1.164
0.660
0.084
0.204
1.164
0.756
0.156
0.732
0.252
0.180
0.252
0.732
0.492
0.732
0.804
0.324
1.188
0.684
0.972
0.300
0.180
1.116
0.012
0.468
1.044
0.804
0.468
0.228
0.300
1.140
0.588
0.996
1.068
0.900
0.540
0.516
0.972
1.020
0.948
1.164
1.092
0.036
0.876
0.084
0.948
0.636
0.924
0.540
0.420
0.588
0.732
0.972
1.140
0.156
0.564
0.036
0.636
0.852
0.204
0.036
0.996
0.060
0.684
1.020
0.564
1.020
0.132
1.068
0.084
0.612
0.036
0.804
0.012
0.300
0.924
0.564
1.068
0.276
0.372
0.348
0.348
0.372
1.116
0.108
1.092
0.852
1.068
0.660
0.444
0.276
0.948
0.012
1.188
0.300
0.444
0.972
0.948
1.140
1.044
0.420
0.204
0.684
0.828
0.492
1.140
0.252
0.228
0.396
0.852
0.948
1.092
0.300
0.612
0.972
0.492
0.876
0.756
0.540
0.636
0.204
0.204
0.732
0.396
1.092
0.876
0.660
0.324
0.852
0.324
0.708
0.516
0.180
0.036
0.084
0.780
0.516
0.060
0.348
0.708
0.468
0.540
0.204
0.612
1.044
0.132
0.756
0.660
0.636
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
18
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
19
151
0.276
0.036
0.084
0.084
0.516
0.708
0.972
0.756
0.468
0.588
152
1.020
0.900
0.300
0.060
0.660
0.660
0.180
0.420
1.140
1.140
153
0.780
0.420
0.900
0.660
0.780
0.540
1.140
0.060
1.020
0.900
154
0.540
0.540
1.140
1.140
0.060
0.300
0.780
0.780
0.420
0.300
155
1.140
0.060
1.020
1.020
0.180
1.020
0.540
0.180
0.300
1.020
156
0.660
0.180
0.060
0.780
1.140
1.140
1.020
1.140
0.540
0.660
157
0.180
0.300
0.540
0.420
0.300
0.180
0.900
0.300
0.780
0.780
158
0.900
1.020
0.180
0.900
1.020
0.060
0.660
0.900
0.660
0.060
159
0.300
0.780
0.420
0.540
0.420
0.420
0.060
0.540
0.060
0.540
160
0.420
1.140
0.780
0.300
0.540
0.900
0.420
1.020
0.180
0.420
161
0.060
0.660
0.660
0.180
0.900
0.780
0.300
0.660
0.900
0.180
162
0.200
0.467
0.867
1.133
0.200
0.867
0.867
0.067
0.200
0.600
163
0.333
0.867
1.000
1.000
0.333
0.067
0.467
0.600
0.067
0.467
164
0.733
1.000
0.600
0.333
0.067
1.000
0.200
0.333
0.467
0.733
165
0.867
0.200
0.067
0.867
0.867
0.333
1.133
0.200
0.733
0.333
166
0.067
0.733
1.133
0.733
0.467
0.733
1.000
0.867
1.133
1.133
167
0.600
0.067
0.733
0.600
1.133
0.600
0.067
0.467
1.000
0.067
168
1.133
1.133
0.467
0.067
0.733
1.133
0.333
0.733
0.600
0.867
169
0.467
0.333
0.333
0.200
1.000
0.467
0.733
1.133
0.333
1.000
170
1.000
0.600
0.200
0.467
0.600
0.200
0.600
1.000
0.867
0.200
171
0.995
0.945
0.905
0.915
0.935
0.945
0.945
0.915
0.975
0.965
172
0.905
0.915
0.985
0.975
0.955
0.985
0.995
0.925
0.965
0.935
173
0.925
0.985
0.955
0.945
0.975
0.905
0.965
0.955
0.985
0.955
174
0.975
0.975
0.945
0.985
0.995
0.975
0.955
0.905
0.945
0.905
175
0.935
0.925
0.935
0.905
0.985
0.925
0.915
0.995
0.935
0.945
176
0.945
0.905
0.995
0.935
0.915
0.995
0.905
0.965
0.955
0.975
177
0.955
0.965
0.915
0.995
0.945
0.965
0.935
0.945
0.915
0.985
178
0.915
0.955
0.975
0.925
0.965
0.935
0.985
0.985
0.905
0.995
179
0.965
0.935
0.925
0.955
0.905
0.915
0.975
0.975
0.925
0.925
180
0.985
0.995
0.965
0.965
0.925
0.955
0.925
0.935
0.995
0.915
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
20
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
Table
C­
1.
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
21
0.132
0.036
0.276
0.180
1.116
0.492
0.684
0.588
0.180
1.020
0.660
0.540
0.540
1.140
0.420
0.060
0.540
1.140
0.540
0.060
0.060
0.540
0.300
1.140
1.140
0.420
1.020
0.300
0.780
0.780
1.020
0.540
0.300
0.540
0.300
0.780
1.020
0.300
1.140
0.780
1.020
0.660
0.060
0.420
0.420
0.660
0.660
0.420
0.900
0.180
0.180
0.180
0.180
0.900
0.900
1.020
0.780
0.780
0.900
1.020
0.300
0.420
0.180
0.660
0.420
0.060
1.140
0.900
1.140
0.060
0.060
0.300
0.060
0.300
0.420
0.660
0.900
1.020
0.780
0.180
0.660
0.900
0.780
1.140
0.660
0.180
0.540
0.900
0.200
0.200
1.133
1.000
0.333
0.333
0.333
0.867
0.600
0.467
0.200
0.067
0.200
0.200
1.000
0.200
0.733
1.133
0.467
0.333
1.000
0.867
0.067
0.067
1.000
0.333
0.600
0.867
1.133
0.600
1.133
0.733
0.867
1.000
0.067
0.600
0.067
0.067
0.200
0.467
1.133
0.600
0.867
0.467
0.867
1.133
0.600
0.333
0.333
0.733
1.000
0.200
0.600
0.467
0.467
0.600
0.067
0.867
0.333
1.133
0.467
0.733
0.733
1.133
0.467
0.067
0.733
0.733
0.733
1.000
0.867
1.000
0.985
0.955
0.955
0.915
0.945
0.945
0.985
0.995
0.945
0.945
0.965
0.975
0.905
0.915
0.905
0.905
0.955
0.925
0.905
0.925
0.985
0.925
0.975
0.935
0.925
0.965
0.985
0.905
0.955
0.905
0.955
0.945
0.975
0.985
0.925
0.965
0.965
0.985
0.915
0.915
0.965
0.905
0.975
0.995
0.975
0.965
0.925
0.955
0.935
0.915
0.945
0.945
0.995
0.995
0.965
0.925
0.915
0.995
0.995
0.935
0.935
0.955
0.935
0.975
0.995
0.935
0.915
0.985
0.925
0.935
0.945
0.985
0.905
0.975
0.935
0.955
0.915
0.975
0.995
0.965
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
22
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
1
1.020
0.180
0.780
0.180
0.180
1.020
0.780
0.900
1.140
0.420
2
1.140
0.660
0.300
0.780
0.300
0.780
1.140
1.140
0.540
0.180
3
0.300
0.420
0.540
0.900
1.020
0.180
0.660
0.300
0.420
0.300
4
0.060
0.300
0.660
0.660
0.780
0.540
1.020
0.780
0.300
0.780
5
0.180
0.780
0.060
0.060
0.660
0.300
0.300
1.020
0.060
0.060
6
0.780
0.060
0.420
0.540
0.060
0.420
0.180
0.180
0.780
1.020
7
0.660
0.900
0.180
0.420
1.140
1.140
0.420
0.060
0.660
0.540
8
0.900
0.540
0.900
0.300
0.420
0.060
0.540
0.540
1.020
0.900
9
0.420
1.140
1.140
1.020
0.540
0.900
0.900
0.420
0.180
1.140
10
0.540
1.020
1.020
1.140
0.900
0.660
0.060
0.660
0.900
0.660
11
0.600
0.600
0.840
1.080
1.080
1.080
0.600
1.080
0.360
1.080
12
1.080
1.080
0.600
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.360
0.120
0.840
0.360
13
0.120
0.840
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.840
14
0.840
0.120
0.120
0.360
0.840
0.360
1.080
0.360
0.120
0.120
15
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.120
0.840
1.080
0.600
16
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.840
17
0.840
0.840
1.080
0.840
0.120
1.080
0.120
0.600
1.080
0.360
18
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.840
0.600
0.360
0.360
0.600
0.120
19
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.120
0.360
0.120
1.080
0.840
0.120
1.080
20
1.080
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.600
0.360
0.840
0.120
0.360
0.600
Table
C­
2.
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
3
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
23
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
X11
X12
X13
X14
X15
X16
X17
X18
1.020
0.900
0.660
0.060
0.300
0.780
0.900
0.540
0.660
0.180
0.900
1.020
0.420
0.420
0.540
1.140
1.140
0.300
0.060
0.660
0.180
1.140
0.060
0.780
0.060
1.140
1.140
0.780
1.020
0.540
1.020
0.180
0.540
0.660
0.540
0.420
0.900
1.020
0.300
0.420
0.180
0.420
0.420
0.180
1.140
0.900
0.660
1.020
0.780
1.020
1.020
0.540
0.660
0.180
1.140
0.660
0.300
0.060
0.180
0.900
0.780
0.060
0.420
0.300
0.900
0.540
0.300
0.300
0.540
0.300
0.780
0.060
0.420
0.780
0.780
1.140
0.060
0.660
0.180
0.900
0.120
0.600
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.600
1.080
1.080
0.360
0.840
1.080
0.360
0.360
0.840
0.840
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.360
1.080
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.120
0.840
0.600
0.120
0.840
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.360
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.600
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.600
0.840
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.360
0.120
1.080
0.840
0.360
1.080
0.840
0.600
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.360
1.080
0.840
0.600
1.080
1.080
0.840
0.840
1.080
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.840
0.600
0.360
Table
C­
2.
Global
Validation
Runs
for
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
24
Run
Number
1)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
2)
Non­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
3)
Area
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
4)
Area
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
5)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
6)
Nonroad
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
7)
EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
nonattainment
areas
8)
EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
9)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
10)
Non­

EGU
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
X1
X2
X3
X4
X5
X6
X7
X8
X9
X10
1
0.780
0.300
0.540
0.060
0.780
0.780
0.420
0.300
0.060
0.180
2
0.300
0.780
0.180
0.540
0.060
0.180
0.540
0.900
1.020
0.060
3
0.060
0.180
0.300
0.420
1.020
0.540
0.060
1.020
0.660
0.420
4
0.420
1.140
0.780
0.180
1.140
0.060
0.180
0.420
0.180
0.900
5
0.180
0.660
0.420
0.900
0.300
1.140
0.900
0.180
0.780
1.140
6
0.900
0.900
0.060
0.300
0.900
1.020
0.780
0.780
0.300
1.020
7
1.140
0.060
0.660
1.140
0.660
0.300
0.300
0.060
0.900
0.540
8
0.660
0.540
0.900
0.780
0.540
0.420
0.660
1.140
1.140
0.780
9
0.540
1.020
1.140
1.020
0.420
0.660
1.140
0.660
0.540
0.300
10
1.020
0.420
1.020
0.660
0.180
0.900
1.020
0.540
0.420
0.660
11
0.120
0.120
0.840
1.080
0.600
1.080
0.840
0.360
0.600
1.080
12
0.600
1.080
0.120
0.840
0.840
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.360
0.600
13
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.600
1.080
0.600
1.080
0.600
1.080
0.120
14
1.080
0.840
1.080
0.360
0.360
0.840
0.120
0.120
0.120
0.360
15
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.120
0.120
0.120
0.360
0.840
0.840
0.840
16
0.120
0.360
1.080
0.360
1.080
0.840
0.840
0.840
1.080
0.840
17
0.600
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.360
18
1.080
1.080
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.120
0.600
0.360
0.600
0.600
19
0.840
0.120
0.360
0.120
0.840
0.360
1.080
1.080
0.840
0.120
20
0.360
0.600
0.840
0.840
0.600
0.600
0.120
0.600
0.360
1.080
Table
C­
3.
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
3
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
25
Run
Number
11)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
12)
On­
road
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
13)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
14)
On­
road
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
15)
Area
NOx
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
16)
Area
NOx
control
in
attainment
areas
17)
Non­

EGU
VOC
control
in
projected
residual
NA
areas
18)
Non­
EGU
VOC
control
in
attainment
areas
19)
Location
Number
X11
X12
X13
X14
X15
X16
X17
X18
X19
1
1.140
0.300
0.300
0.900
1.020
0.540
1.020
0.900
5
2
1.020
0.180
0.060
0.540
0.420
0.900
0.660
0.180
4
3
0.300
1.020
0.540
0.420
0.180
0.660
1.140
0.660
1
4
0.780
0.660
0.660
0.060
0.540
1.140
0.540
0.780
2
5
0.540
0.060
1.020
0.780
0.300
0.180
0.900
1.020
2
6
0.060
0.900
0.780
0.660
0.900
0.420
0.060
0.060
3
7
0.420
0.540
1.140
1.020
0.660
0.780
0.300
0.300
3
8
0.900
1.140
0.900
0.180
0.060
0.300
0.180
0.540
5
9
0.180
0.420
0.420
0.300
0.780
0.060
0.420
1.140
4
10
0.660
0.780
0.180
1.140
1.140
1.020
0.780
0.420
1
11
1.080
0.840
0.120
0.120
0.600
0.600
0.840
0.600
4
12
0.360
0.600
0.360
1.080
1.080
0.120
1.080
0.120
2
13
0.600
0.360
0.840
0.840
0.120
1.080
0.120
0.840
3
14
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.600
0.360
0.360
0.360
0.360
5
15
0.120
1.080
1.080
0.360
0.840
0.840
0.600
1.080
1
16
0.600
0.600
0.360
1.080
0.600
0.840
0.600
0.120
5
17
0.360
0.840
0.120
0.360
0.120
0.120
0.120
0.600
3
18
0.120
0.360
0.840
0.840
0.360
0.600
0.360
0.840
1
19
0.840
0.120
0.600
0.120
1.080
0.360
0.840
1.080
4
20
1.080
1.080
1.080
0.600
0.840
1.080
1.080
0.360
2
Table
C­
3.
Local
Validation
Runs
for
Design
3
(
Continued)
WA
2­
05
Final
Technical
Rept.­
Task
7
September
30,
2004
C­
26