Document ID: EPA-HQ-OAR-2002-0076-0411
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2005-06-13T04:00Z

New
BART
+
CAIR
New
BART+
CAIR+
CAMR
Difference
SO2
SO2
SO2
State
Name
Alabama
255
260
5
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
167
167
0
Georgia
259
241
­
18
Illinois
244
245
1
Indiana
383
377
­
6
Iowa
164
163
­
1
Kentucky
282
264
­
18
Louisiana
62
62
0
Maryland
24
43
19
Michigan
392
394
2
Minnesota
85
85
0
Mississippi
86
86
0
Missouri
269
266
­
2
New
York
52
49
­
4
North
Carolina
145
125
­
21
Ohio
239
272
32
Pennsylvania
150
141
­
9
South
Carolina
142
106
­
36
Tennessee
163
191
28
Texas
362
373
11
Virginia
118
95
­
23
West
Virginia
119
111
­
8
Wisconsin
151
151
0
Grand
Total
4,314
4,267
­
47
New
BART
+
CAIR
New
BART+
CAIR+
CAMR
Difference
NOx
NOx
NOx
State
Name
Alabama
49
49
0
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
61
61
0
Georgia
67
67
0
Illinois
66
66
0
Indiana
86
82
­
4
Iowa
44
52
8
Kentucky
78
77
­
1
Louisiana
30
32
3
Maryland
14
14
0
Michigan
88
94
5
Minnesota
40
40
1
Mississippi
12
8
­
4
Missouri
62
70
8
New
York
37
24
­
13
North
Carolina
51
51
0
Ohio
86
93
7
Pennsylvania
80
74
­
5
South
Carolina
36
37
0
Tennessee
27
27
0
Texas
161
159
­
2
Virginia
40
40
1
West
Virginia
44
40
­
5
Wisconsin
39
41
2
Grand
Total
1,299
1,299
0
New
BART
New
BART
+
CAIR
Difference
NOx
NOx
NOx
State
Name
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Alabama
107
49
­
58
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
133
61
­
71
Georgia
94
67
­
27
Illinois
89
66
­
23
Indiana
182
86
­
96
Iowa
71
44
­
27
Kentucky
110
78
­
33
Louisiana
40
30
­
10
Maryland
24
14
­
10
Michigan
95
88
­
6
Minnesota
57
40
­
17
Mississippi
31
12
­
19
Missouri
72
62
­
10
New
York
47
37
­
9
North
Carolina
56
51
­
5
Ohio
178
86
­
92
Pennsylvania
149
80
­
70
South
Carolina
38
36
­
1
Tennessee
76
27
­
48
Texas
179
161
­
19
Virginia
61
40
­
21
West
Virginia
85
44
­
41
Wisconsin
65
39
­
26
Grand
Total
2,041
1,299
­
742
Old
BART
Old
BART
+
CAIR
Difference
NOx
NOx
NOx
State
Name
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Alabama
111
49
­
62
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
120
61
­
59
Georgia
77
66
­
11
Illinois
86
65
­
21
Indiana
166
84
­
82
Iowa
51
39
­
12
Kentucky
91
64
­
27
Louisiana
38
30
­
8
Maryland
24
12
­
12
Michigan
85
85
0
Minnesota
50
37
­
13
Mississippi
19
12
­
7
Missouri
66
58
­
8
New
York
44
34
­
10
North
Carolina
56
49
­
7
Ohio
169
80
­
89
Pennsylvania
123
77
­
46
South
Carolina
34
36
2
Tennessee
83
27
­
56
Texas
181
160
­
21
Virginia
61
38
­
23
West
Virginia
90
44
­
46
Wisconsin
47
32
­
15
Grand
Total
1872
1239
­
633
Summary
of
Differences
Between
Old
analysis
and
New
Analysis
for
NOx
Difference
Between
New
BART
Difference
Between
Old
BART
State
Name
and
New
CAIR
+
BART
and
Old
CAIR
+
BART
Alabama
­
58
­
62
District
of
Columbia
0
0
Florida
­
71
­
59
Georgia
­
27
­
11
Illinois
­
23
­
21
Indiana
­
96
­
82
Iowa
­
27
­
12
Kentucky
­
33
­
27
Louisiana
­
10
­
8
Maryland
­
10
­
12
Michigan
­
6
0
Minnesota
­
17
­
13
Mississippi
­
19
­
7
Missouri
­
10
­
8
New
York
­
9
­
10
North
Carolina
­
5
­
7
Ohio
­
92
­
89
Pennsylvania
­
70
­
46
South
Carolina
­
1
2
Tennessee
­
48
­
56
Texas
­
19
­
21
Virginia
­
21
­
23
West
Virginia
­
41
­
46
Wisconsin
­
26
­
15
Grand
Total
­
742
­
633
CAIR
+
BART
gets
the
same
or
more
reductions
than
BART
for
all
States
in
the
New
Analysis
Overall,
CARI
+
BART
gets
more
NOx
reductions
in
the
New
Analysis
New
BART
New
BART
+
CAIR
Difference
SO2
SO2
SO2
State
Name
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Alabama
227
255
29
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
228
167
­
61
Georgia
273
259
­
15
Illinois
333
244
­
89
Indiana
1,140
383
­
757
Iowa
193
164
­
29
Kentucky
519
282
­
237
Louisiana
36
62
26
Maryland
80
24
­
56
Michigan
251
392
141
Minnesota
152
85
­
67
Mississippi
29
86
57
Missouri
249
269
20
New
York
140
52
­
88
North
Carolina
101
145
44
Ohio
1,113
239
­
874
Pennsylvania
343
150
­
193
South
Carolina
160
142
­
18
Tennessee
580
163
­
417
Texas
279
362
83
Virginia
205
118
­
87
West
Virginia
394
119
­
275
Wisconsin
105
151
46
Grand
Total
7,131
4,314
­
2,816
Old
BART
Old
BART
+
CAIR
Difference
SO2
SO2
SO2
State
Name
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Thousand
tons
Alabama
272
255
­
17
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
Florida
159
167
8
Georgia
205
249
44
Illinois
280
239
­
41
Indiana
1128
353
­
775
Iowa
96
125
29
Kentucky
307
271
­
36
Louisiana
31
62
31
Maryland
84
24
­
60
Michigan
219
385
166
Minnesota
114
72
­
42
Mississippi
25
86
61
Missouri
184
245
61
New
York
131
41
­
90
North
Carolina
91
139
48
Ohio
1100
202
­
898
Pennsylvania
372
133
­
239
South
Carolina
120
106
­
14
Tennessee
566
161
­
405
Texas
257
352
95
Virginia
217
116
­
101
West
Virginia
402
116
­
286
Wisconsin
58
132
74
Grand
Total
6418
4031
­
2387
Summary
of
Differences
Between
Old
analysis
and
New
Analysis
for
SO2
Difference
Between
New
BART
Difference
Between
Old
BART
State
Name
and
New
CAIR
+
BART
and
Old
CAIR
+
BART
Alabama
29
­
17
District
of
Columbia
0
0
Florida
­
61
8
Georgia
­
15
44
Illinois
­
89
­
41
Indiana
­
757
­
775
Iowa
­
29
29
Kentucky
­
237
­
36
Louisiana
26
31
Maryland
­
56
­
60
Michigan
141
166
Minnesota
­
67
­
42
Mississippi
57
61
Missouri
20
61
New
York
­
88
­
90
North
Carolina
44
48
Ohio
­
874
­
898
Pennsylvania
­
193
­
239
South
Carolina
­
18
­
14
Tennessee
­
417
­
405
Texas
83
95
Virginia
­
87
­
101
West
Virginia
­
275
­
286
Wisconsin
46
74
Grand
Total
­
2,816
­
2387
Overall,
CAIR+
BART
gets
more
SO2
reductions
than
BART
in
the
new
analysis
than
in
the
old
analsyis
In
15
States,
CAIR
+
BART
gets
the
same
or
greater
reductions
than
BART
in
the
new
analysis
In
7
States
where
CAIR
+
BART
does
not
get
greater
reductions
than
BART,
the
difference
in
the
new
analsysis
is
less
than
the
difference
in
the
old
analysis
Alabama
is
the
only
State
in
which
CAIR
+
BART
achieved
less
reductions
than
BART
in
both
analysis
and
the
difference
between
CAIR
+
BART
and
BART
is
greater
in
the
new
aanlysis
than
the
old
analysis
2015
Emissions
Dec
04
BART
Dec
04
BART
New
BART
New
BART
Dec
04
CAIR
+
BART
Dec
04
CAIR
+
BART
AR,
DE,
NJ
included
forfor
PM
AR,
DE,
NJ
included
for
PM
State
Name
Total
SO2
(
MTons)
Total
NOx
(
MTons)
Total
SO2
(
MTons)
Total
NOx
(
MTons)
Total
SO2
(
MTons)
Total
NOx
(
MTons)

Alabama
272
111
227
107
255
49
District
of
Columbia
0
0
0
0
0
0
Florida
159
120
228
133
167
61
Georgia
205
77
273
94
249
66
Illinois
280
86
333
89
239
65
Indiana
1128
166
1,140
182
353
84
Iowa
96
51
193
71
125
39
Kentucky
307
91
519
110
271
64
Louisiana
31
38
36
40
62
30
Maryland
84
24
80
24
24
12
Michigan
219
85
251
95
385
85
Minnesota
114
50
152
57
72
37
Mississippi
25
19
29
31
86
12
Missouri
184
66
249
72
245
58
New
York
131
44
140
47
41
34
North
Carolina
91
56
101
56
139
49
Ohio
1100
169
1,113
178
202
80
Pennsylvania
372
123
343
149
133
77
South
Carolina
120
34
160
38
106
36
Tennessee
566
83
580
76
161
27
Texas
257
181
279
179
352
160
Virginia
217
61
205
61
116
38
West
Virginia
402
90
394
85
116
44
Wisconsin
58
47
105
65
132
32
Grand
Total
6418
1872
7131
2041
4031
1239
New
CAIR
+
BART
New
CAIR
+
BART
New
CAIR
+
BART
+
Hg
New
CAIR
+
BART
+
Hg
Total
SO2
(
MTons)
Total
NOx
(
MTons)
Total
SO2
(
MTons)
Total
NOx
(
MTons)

255
49
260
49
0
0
0
0
167
61
167
61
259
67
241
67
244
66
245
66
383
86
377
82
164
44
163
52
282
78
264
77
62
30
62
32
24
14
43
14
392
88
394
94
85
40
85
40
86
12
86
8
269
62
266
70
52
37
49
24
145
51
125
51
239
86
272
93
150
80
141
74
142
36
106
37
163
27
191
27
362
161
373
159
118
40
95
40
119
44
111
40
151
39
151
41
4314
1299
4267
1299