Document ID: EPA-HQ-OW-2005-0037-0226
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2006-06-30T04:00Z

This
spreadsheet
estimates
the
industry
cost
of
dairy
Option
6,
which
includes
anaerobic
diges
Step
Spreadsheet
1
FarmWare
Runs
Model
farms
were
run
in
FarmWare
v
2.0
to
establish
anerobic
diges
Farm
Type
Head
Location
Flush
850
Tulare
County,
CA
Flush
1500
Tulare
County,
CA
Flush
2500
Tulare
County,
CA
Scrape
850
Tulare
County,
CA
Scrape
1500
Tulare
County,
CA
Scrape
2500
Tulare
County,
CA
2
NASS
Farm
Data
FarmWare
weighted
avgs
3
Option
2
and
6
costs
Description
The
weighting
factors
used
in
the
calculation
are
derived
from
USDA
The
cost
estimates
from
FarmWare
were
used
to
represent
the
entire
Next,
ERG
must
estimate
the
Option
6
cost
to
the
entire
industry.
An
other
requirements
of
Option
6
are
the
same
as
the
requirements
inc
to
Option
6
costs
because
Option
2
costs
for
Large
dairies
do
not
inc
Model
farms
were
selected
for
the
FarmWare
runs:

Model
farms
were
going
to
also
be
estimated
for
Marathon
County,
W
different
results
from
Tulare
County,
CA.
estion
and
Option
2
costs.

estion
costs
DA
NASS
data
tire
Large
CAFO
size
category
by
calculating
the
Anaerobic
digestion
is
only
a
portion
of
Option
6;
the
included
in
Option
2.
Option
2
costs
can
be
simply
added
include
lagoon
costs
(
pg
6­
17
in
Cost
Methodology).
,
Wisconsin;
however,
FarmWare
runs
produced
no
Flush
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Barn
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
850
255
255
12988.75
42500
746,585
9,683
74,659
50,910
1500
450
450
22738.75
75000
1,204,852
17,084
120,485
87,780
2500
750
750
37738.75
125000
1,896,021
28,476
189,602
144,178
Scrape
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
850
255
255
504.375
323,495
13,802
32,350
53,072
1500
450
450
707.5
485,435
24,358
48,544
89,939
2500
750
750
1020
728,269
40,593
72,827
146,657
23,749
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
564,202
501,119
78,979
935,832
874,153
120,485
1,496,685
1,448,053
189,602
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
122,935
46,958
36,670
186,985
81,655
48,544
280,340
135,022
72,827
Consulting
Fee
4320
The
number
of
farms
by
farm
size
were
obtained
from
the
USDA
NASS
QuickStats
database
http://
www.
nass.
usda.
gov/
QuickStats
Only
the
US
total
number
of
operations
is
available
for
farms
with
greater
than
700
head:
Head
Number
of
Farms
500­
999
1700
farms
1000­
1999
770
farms
2000+
325
farms
To
esimate
the
number
of
farms
in
the
Large
CAFO
category,
ERG
needs
to
estimate
the
number
of
farms
with
g
The
size
category
with
500­
999
head
was
divided
into
a
category
with
700­
999
by
multiplying
the
total
number
of
The
resulting
size
categories
are:
Head
Number
of
Farms
Percent
of
Farms
Representative
Model
Farm
Size
700­
999
1020
farms
48%
850
1000­
1999
770
farms
36%
1500
2000+
325
farms
15%
2500
total
2115
farms
100%

Year
State
StFips
CommoditCommoditTotal
Total(
UNIT)
1­
29
Head
1­
29
Head(
2001
Alabama
1
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
250
Number
2001
Alaska
2
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
30
Number
2001
Arizona
4
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
250
Number
120
Number
2001
Arkansas
5
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
700
Number
2001
California
6
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
2500
Number
300
Number
2001
Colorado
8
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
800
Number
580
Number
2001
Connecticut
9
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
310
Number
2001
Delaware
10
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
110
Number
2001
Florida
12
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
510
Number
290
Number
2001
Georgia
13
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
720
Number
320
Number
2001
Hawaii
15
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
30
Number
2001
Idaho
16
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1000
Number
230
Number
2001
Illinois
17
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1900
Number
480
Number
2001
Indiana
18
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
2900
Number
1500
Number
2001
Iowa
19
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
3500
Number
820
Number
2001
Kansas
20
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1200
Number
2001
Kentucky
21
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
2900
Number
1300
Number
2001
Louisiana
22
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
610
Number
2001
Maine
23
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
600
Number
2001
Maryland
24
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
950
Number
170
Number
2001
Massachusetts
25
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
350
Number
2001
Michigan
26
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
3300
Number
1050
Number
2001
Minnesota
27
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
7800
Number
1100
Number
2001
Mississippi
28
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
480
Number
2001
Missouri
29
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
3700
Number
1600
Number
2001
Montana
30
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
650
Number
2001
Nebraska
31
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1100
Number
2001
Nevada
32
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
150
Number
2001
New
Hampshire
33
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
260
Number
2001
New
Jersey
34
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
230
Number
2001
New
Mexico
35
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
500
Number
335
Number
2001
New
York
36
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
7300
Number
1300
Number
2001
North
Carolina
37
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
900
Number
460
Number
2001
North
Dakota
38
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
850
Number
2001
Ohio
39
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
5200
Number
2400
Number
2001
Oklahoma
40
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1700
Number
1050
Number
2001
Oregon
41
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
820
Number
400
Number
2001
Pennsylvania
42
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
10300
Number
1800
Number
2001
Rhode
Island
44
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
30
Number
2001
South
Carolina
45
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
240
Number
2001
South
Dakota
46
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1400
Number
500
Number
2001
Tennessee
47
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1500
Number
630
Number
2001
Texas
48
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
2100
Number
950
Number
2001
Utah
49
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
760
Number
270
Number
2001
Vermont
50
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1600
Number
190
Number
2001
Virginia
51
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1500
Number
490
Number
2001
Washington
53
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
1000
Number
335
Number
2001
West
Virginia
54
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
600
Number
2001
Wisconsin
55
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
19100
Number
3150
Number
2001
Wyoming
56
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
270
Number
2001
Other
States
98
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
4200
Number
2001
United
States
99
Milk
Cows
&
40999199
97460
Number
28320
Number
h
greater
than
700
head.
of
farms
in
the
category
by
3/
5.

30­
49
Head30­
49
Head50­
99
Head50­
99
Head100­
199
He100­
199
He200­
499
He200­
499
He500+
Head
10
Number
10
Number
20
Number
90
70
Number
80
Number
250
Number
700
Number
1100
10
Number
30
Number
55
Number
75
Number
50
5
Number
20
Number
35
Number
60
Number
100
20
Number
90
Number
170
Number
90
Number
30
80
Number
210
Number
150
Number
150
Number
180
360
Number
700
Number
280
Number
70
Number
10
470
Number
570
Number
280
Number
55
Number
25
890
Number
1200
Number
480
Number
95
Number
15
520
Number
760
Number
270
Number
45
Number
5
150
Number
360
Number
210
Number
50
Number
10
550
Number
800
Number
620
Number
215
Number
65
2700
Number
3000
Number
700
Number
250
Number
50
700
Number
850
Number
500
Number
45
Number
5
5
Number
5
Number
15
Number
140
1300
Number
2800
Number
1300
Number
470
Number
130
40
Number
150
Number
160
Number
75
Number
15
860
Number
1250
Number
550
Number
120
Number
20
120
Number
260
Number
210
Number
50
Number
10
30
Number
80
Number
170
Number
100
Number
40
3700
Number
3600
Number
910
Number
260
Number
30
270
Number
400
Number
170
Number
45
Number
15
140
Number
390
Number
250
Number
80
Number
10
100
Number
240
Number
320
Number
320
Number
170
35
Number
140
Number
170
Number
110
Number
35
310
Number
675
Number
280
Number
120
Number
25
140
Number
420
Number
340
Number
100
Number
10
40
Number
115
Number
160
Number
210
Number
140
5300
Number
7800
Number
2000
Number
680
Number
170
1000
Number
2000
Number
1250
Number
500
Number
100
19910
Number
29005
Number
12255
Number
5175
Number
2795
500+
Head500­
999
Head
500­
999
Head(
UNIT)
1000­
1999
Head
1000­
1999
Head(
UNIT)
2000+
Head
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
Number
1700
Number
770
Number
325
2000+
Head(
UNIT)
Number
Flush
From
FarmWare
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Barn
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
1450
435
435
20,342
67,009
1,090,052
15,265
30,340
Scrape
From
FarmWare
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
1450
435
435
658
444,651
21,762
Annualized
Costs
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
10%)
O&
M
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Flush
1,090,052
4320
109,005
113,325
78,665
842,789
Scrape
444,651
4320
44,465
48,785
80,875
170,441
Using
Estimate
from
Cost
Model
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
Volume
(
gallons)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
109,005
78,665
842,789
782,438
5,852,636
111,089
Using
Estimate
from
Cost
Model
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
Volume
(
gallons)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
44,465
80,875
170,441
73,122
546,955
46,549
Year1
Year2
Year3
Year4
Year5
Year6
1,068,049
34,660
34,660
34,660
34,660
34,660
388,169
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
32,424
­
34,326
Year7
Year8
Year9
Year10
Year11
NPV
Annual
34,660
34,660
34,660
34,660
22,002
$
2,033,298.43
$
271,154
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
­
32,090
$
384,899.03
$
51,329
Animal
Type
Operation
LMH
GW
Link
NM
Basis
Region
Category
#
Facilities
Size_
ID
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
1
16.2975
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
2
42.2025
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
3
16.5
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
1
16.2975
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
2
42.2025
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
3
16.5
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
1
32.8123
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
2
84.9677
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
3
33.22
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
1
4.6774
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
2
15.6026
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
3
5.72
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
1
4.6851
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
2
13.2549
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
3
5.06
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
1
23.856
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
2
86.904
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
3
31.24
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
1
23.856
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
2
86.904
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
3
31.24
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
1
47.88
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
2
174.42
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
3
62.7
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
1
3.3473
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
2
9.9127
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
3
3.74
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
1
3.3473
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
2
9.9127
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
3
3.74
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
1
6.6946
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
2
19.8254
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
3
7.48
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
1
5.4325
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
2
14.0675
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
3
5.5
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
1
5.4325
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
2
14.0675
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
3
5.5
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
1
10.865
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
2
28.135
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
3
11
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
1
4.6774
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
2
15.6026
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
3
5.72
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
1
4.8888
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
2
13.8312
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
3
5.28
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
1
7.896
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
2
28.764
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
3
10.34
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
1
7.896
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
2
28.764
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
3
10.34
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
1
16.128
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
2
58.752
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
3
21.12
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
1
1.1814
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
2
3.4986
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
3
1.32
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
1
1.1814
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
2
3.4986
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
3
1.32
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
1
2.1659
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
2
6.4141
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
3
2.42
Large1
Head
Farm
Size
Cropland
Fert
Sav
Man
Off
Permit
Fix
Permit
O&
M
Permit
3yr
Permit
5yr
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
Option
Pretax_
ann
Option
2
Total
Costs
Annual
Digestion
Cost
TOTAL
OPTION
6
COSTS
2
21,209
$
345,650.53
4,419,138.59
$
$
4,764,789
2
61,412
$
2,591,749.21
11,443,392.96
$
$
14,035,142
2
64,159
$
1,058,628.35
4,474,047.36
$
$
5,532,676
2
9,848
$
160,495.95
4,419,138.59
$
$
4,579,635
2
50,375
$
2,125,967.77
11,443,392.96
$
$
13,569,361
2
53,300
$
879,449.88
4,474,047.36
$
$
5,353,497
2
19,090
$
626,400.16
8,897,199.02
$
$
9,523,599
2
59,457
$
5,051,916.89
23,039,364.48
$
$
28,091,281
2
62,292
$
2,069,351.98
9,007,748.68
$
$
11,077,101
2
25,178
$
58,883.22
634,148.75
$
$
693,032
2
144,392
$
1,126,447.20
2,115,356.64
$
$
3,241,804
2
205,843
$
588,711.54
775,501.52
$
$
1,364,213
2
14,071
$
32,907.45
634,148.75
$
$
667,056
2
133,548
$
1,041,848.66
2,115,356.64
$
$
3,157,205
2
195,095
$
557,972.65
775,501.52
$
$
1,333,474
2
23,200
$
108,514.80
1,268,297.50
$
$
1,376,812
2
142,545
$
2,224,071.97
4,230,713.27
$
$
6,454,785
2
204,044
$
1,167,132.02
1,551,003.04
$
$
2,718,135
2
26,005
$
63,565.77
662,809.79
$
$
726,376
2
36,187
$
250,252.85
1,875,195.26
$
$
2,125,448
2
50,968
$
134,556.82
715,847.58
$
$
850,404
2
14,550
$
35,566.27
662,809.79
$
$
698,376
2
25,080
$
173,440.68
1,875,195.26
$
$
2,048,636
2
40,084
$
105,821.02
715,847.58
$
$
821,669
2
23,853
$
111,752.91
1,270,385.43
$
$
1,382,138
2
34,208
$
453,424.16
3,594,124.25
$
$
4,047,548
2
49,102
$
248,453.86
1,372,041.19
$
$
1,620,495
2
27,041
$
645,092.74
6,468,659.17
$
$
7,113,752
2
191,041
$
16,602,226.00
23,564,401.44
$
$
40,166,627
2
113,861
$
3,557,019.51
8,470,863.25
$
$
12,027,883
2
15,821
$
377,418.79
6,468,659.17
$
$
6,846,078
2
180,078
$
15,649,526.00
23,564,401.44
$
$
39,213,927
2
103,001
$
3,217,746.61
8,470,863.25
$
$
11,688,610
2
24,993
$
1,196,669.82
12,982,872.28
$
$
14,179,542
2
189,121
$
32,986,542.65
47,294,749.38
$
$
80,281,292
2
111,994
$
7,022,031.25
17,001,380.47
$
$
24,023,412
2
15,755
$
52,737.78
907,635.07
$
$
960,373
2
146,086
$
1,448,104.34
2,687,872.08
$
$
4,135,976
2
100,076
$
374,283.99
1,014,117.40
$
$
1,388,401
2
4,583
$
15,339.04
907,635.07
$
$
922,974
2
135,167
$
1,339,865.52
2,687,872.08
$
$
4,027,738
2
89,191
$
333,574.93
1,014,117.40
$
$
1,347,692
2
13,743
$
92,006.10
1,815,270.14
$
$
1,907,276
2
144,201
$
2,858,836.56
5,375,744.16
$
$
8,234,581
2
98,209
$
734,603.26
2,028,234.80
$
$
2,762,838
2
12,737
$
69,195.71
1,473,046.20
$
$
1,542,242
2
10,318
$
145,150.43
3,814,464.32
$
$
3,959,615
2
5,566
$
30,610.26
1,491,349.12
$
$
1,521,959
2
10,167
$
55,230.65
1,473,046.20
$
$
1,528,277
2
7,921
$
111,421.77
3,814,464.32
$
$
3,925,886
2
4,771
$
26,239.00
1,491,349.12
$
$
1,517,588
2
11,592
$
125,950.57
2,946,092.39
$
$
3,072,043
2
9,259
$
260,496.58
7,628,928.64
$
$
7,889,425
2
5,309
$
58,394.58
2,982,698.24
$
$
3,041,093
2
18,333
$
42,875.16
634,148.75
$
$
677,024
2
13,300
$
103,754.93
2,115,356.64
$
$
2,219,112
2
52,896
$
151,282.91
775,501.52
$
$
926,784
2
15,300
$
35,781.53
634,148.75
$
$
669,930
2
10,353
$
80,765.61
2,115,356.64
$
$
2,196,122
2
52,214
$
149,331.17
775,501.52
$
$
924,833
2
17,057
$
79,781.45
1,268,297.50
$
$
1,348,079
2
12,074
$
188,381.70
4,230,713.27
$
$
4,419,095
2
52,708
$
301,489.37
1,551,003.04
$
$
1,852,492
2
19,408
$
47,440.53
662,809.79
$
$
710,250
2
15,457
$
106,897.19
1,875,195.26
$
$
1,982,092
2
5,811
$
15,340.41
715,847.58
$
$
731,188
2
15,067
$
36,828.78
662,809.79
$
$
699,639
2
10,689
$
73,918.44
1,875,195.26
$
$
1,949,114
2
4,991
$
13,177.34
715,847.58
$
$
729,025
2
17,547
$
85,783.95
1,325,619.57
$
$
1,411,404
2
13,423
$
185,662.78
3,750,390.52
$
$
3,936,053
2
5,554
$
29,324.36
1,431,695.15
$
$
1,461,020
2
19,063
$
150,519.88
2,141,035.08
$
$
2,291,555
2
13,198
$
379,623.46
7,799,484.98
$
$
8,179,108
2
23,177
$
239,653.68
2,803,736.43
$
$
3,043,390
2
16,238
$
128,216.39
2,141,035.08
$
$
2,269,251
2
10,185
$
292,949.68
7,799,484.98
$
$
8,092,435
2
22,383
$
231,435.72
2,803,736.43
$
$
3,035,172
2
17,791
$
286,931.04
4,373,178.03
$
$
4,660,109
2
11,832
$
695,156.18
15,930,862.95
$
$
16,626,019
2
22,920
$
484,060.45
5,726,780.79
$
$
6,210,841
2
8,529
$
10,076.00
320,341.79
$
$
330,418
2
18,761
$
65,636.80
948,660.73
$
$
1,014,298
2
21,237
$
28,032.47
357,923.79
$
$
385,956
2
6,199
$
7,323.32
320,341.79
$
$
327,665
2
17,097
$
59,815.94
948,660.73
$
$
1,008,477
2
20,417
$
26,951.02
357,923.79
$
$
384,875
2
7,516
$
16,279.99
587,293.28
$
$
603,573
2
18,081
$
115,975.11
1,739,211.35
$
$
1,855,186
2
20,980
$
50,771.30
656,193.61
$
$
706,965
$
117,776,475.10
­
$
$
510,950,339
Flush
From
FarmWare
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Barn
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
1450
435
435
20,342
67,009
1,090,052
15,265
109,005
Scrape
From
FarmWare
Dairy
Calf
Heifer
Parlor
Water
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
FW)
1450
435
435
658
444,651
21,762
Annualized
Costs
Capital
Cost
O&
M
(
10%)
O&
M
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Flush
1,090,052
4320
109,005
113,325
0
842,789
Scrape
444,651
4320
44,465
48,785
0
170,441
Using
Estimate
from
Cost
Model
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
Volume
(
gallons)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
109,005
0
842,789
782,438
5,852,636
111,089
Using
Estimate
from
Cost
Model
O&
M
(
10%)
Energy
Benefit
Digester
Cost
Volume
(
ft^
3)
Volume
(
gallons)
O&
M
plus
consulting
fee
44,465
0
170,441
73,122
546,955
46,549
Year1
Year2
Year3
Year4
Year5
Year6
1,146,714
113,325
113,325
113,325
113,325
113,325
469,044
48,785
48,785
48,785
48,785
48,785
111,089
46,549
Year7
Year8
Year9
Year10
Year11
NPV
Annual
113,325
113,325
113,325
113,325
­
56,663
$
2,590,178.28
$
345,418
48,785
48,785
48,785
48,785
48,785
$
769,545.31
$
102,624
Animal
Type
Operation
LMH
GW
Link
NM
Basis
Region
Category
#
Facilities
Size_
ID
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
1
16.2975
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
2
42.2025
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
CE
3
16.5
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
1
16.2975
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
2
42.2025
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
CE
3
16.5
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
1
32.8123
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
2
84.9677
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
CE
3
33.22
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
1
4.6774
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
2
15.6026
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MA
3
5.72
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
1
4.6851
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
2
13.2549
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
MW
3
5.06
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
1
23.856
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
2
86.904
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
PA
3
31.24
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
1
23.856
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
2
86.904
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
PA
3
31.24
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
1
47.88
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
2
174.42
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
PA
3
62.7
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
1
3.3473
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
2
9.9127
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
H
N
P
SO
3
3.74
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
1
3.3473
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
2
9.9127
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
L
N
P
SO
3
3.74
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
1
6.6946
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
2
19.8254
Large1
Dairy
Flush
0
M
N
P
SO
3
7.48
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
1
5.4325
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
2
14.0675
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
CE
3
5.5
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
1
5.4325
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
2
14.0675
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
CE
3
5.5
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
1
10.865
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
2
28.135
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
CE
3
11
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
1
2.3387
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
2
7.8013
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MA
3
2.86
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
1
4.6774
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
2
15.6026
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MA
3
5.72
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
1
2.4444
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
2
6.9156
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
MW
3
2.64
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
1
4.8888
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
2
13.8312
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
MW
3
5.28
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
1
7.896
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
2
28.764
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
PA
3
10.34
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
1
7.896
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
2
28.764
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
PA
3
10.34
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
1
16.128
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
2
58.752
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
PA
3
21.12
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
1
1.1814
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
2
3.4986
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
H
N
P
SO
3
1.32
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
1
1.1814
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
2
3.4986
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
L
N
P
SO
3
1.32
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
1
2.1659
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
2
6.4141
Large1
Dairy
Hose
0
M
N
P
SO
3
2.42
Large1
Head
Farm
Size
Cropland
Fert
Sav
Man
Off
Permit
Fix
Permit
O&
M
Permit
3yr
Permit
5yr
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1167
­
5717
0
180
0
130
180
1430
249
­
3735
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1382
­
10718
0
180
0
130
180
1430
213
­
4414
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
1403
­
9909
0
180
0
130
180
1430
322
­
6628
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
841
­
12522
0
180
0
130
180
1430
128
­
4902
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
1430
544
­
1815
0
180
0
130
180
1430
17
­
60
0
180
0
130
180
1430
0
0
0
180
0
130
180
Option
Pretax_
ann
Option
2
Total
Costs
Annual
Digestion
Cost
TOTAL
OPTION
6
COSTS
2
21,209
$
345,650.53
$
5,629,452
$
5,975,103
2
61,412
$
2,591,749.21
$
14,577,510
$
17,169,259
2
64,159
$
1,058,628.35
$
5,699,400
$
6,758,028
2
9,848
$
160,495.95
$
5,629,452
$
5,789,948
2
50,375
$
2,125,967.77
$
14,577,510
$
16,703,478
2
53,300
$
879,449.88
$
5,699,400
$
6,578,849
2
19,090
$
626,400.16
$
11,333,964
$
11,960,364
2
59,457
$
5,051,916.89
$
29,349,386
$
34,401,303
2
62,292
$
2,069,351.98
$
11,474,791
$
13,544,143
2
25,178
$
58,883.22
$
807,829
$
866,713
2
144,392
$
1,126,447.20
$
2,694,711
$
3,821,158
2
205,843
$
588,711.54
$
987,896
$
1,576,607
2
14,071
$
32,907.45
$
807,829
$
840,737
2
133,548
$
1,041,848.66
$
2,694,711
$
3,736,559
2
195,095
$
557,972.65
$
987,896
$
1,545,869
2
23,200
$
108,514.80
$
1,615,659
$
1,724,174
2
142,545
$
2,224,071.97
$
5,389,421
$
7,613,493
2
204,044
$
1,167,132.02
$
1,975,792
$
3,142,924
2
26,005
$
63,565.77
$
844,340
$
907,906
2
36,187
$
250,252.85
$
2,388,774
$
2,639,027
2
50,968
$
134,556.82
$
911,904
$
1,046,461
2
14,550
$
35,566.27
$
844,340
$
879,906
2
25,080
$
173,440.68
$
2,388,774
$
2,562,214
2
40,084
$
105,821.02
$
911,904
$
1,017,725
2
23,853
$
111,752.91
$
1,618,319
$
1,730,072
2
34,208
$
453,424.16
$
4,578,483
$
5,031,907
2
49,102
$
248,453.86
$
1,747,816
$
1,996,270
2
27,041
$
645,092.74
$
8,240,296
$
8,885,389
2
191,041
$
16,602,226.00
$
30,018,221
$
46,620,447
2
113,861
$
3,557,019.51
$
10,790,864
$
14,347,883
2
15,821
$
377,418.79
$
8,240,296
$
8,617,715
2
180,078
$
15,649,526.00
$
30,018,221
$
45,667,747
2
103,001
$
3,217,746.61
$
10,790,864
$
14,008,610
2
24,993
$
1,196,669.82
$
16,538,622
$
17,735,292
2
189,121
$
32,986,542.65
$
60,247,837
$
93,234,380
2
111,994
$
7,022,031.25
$
21,657,719
$
28,679,750
2
15,755
$
52,737.78
$
1,156,218
$
1,208,956
2
146,086
$
1,448,104.34
$
3,424,027
$
4,872,131
2
100,076
$
374,283.99
$
1,291,864
$
1,666,148
2
4,583
$
15,339.04
$
1,156,218
$
1,171,557
2
135,167
$
1,339,865.52
$
3,424,027
$
4,763,892
2
89,191
$
333,574.93
$
1,291,864
$
1,625,439
2
13,743
$
92,006.10
$
2,312,436
$
2,404,442
2
144,201
$
2,858,836.56
$
6,848,053
$
9,706,890
2
98,209
$
734,603.26
$
2,583,728
$
3,318,331
2
12,737
$
69,195.71
$
1,876,484
$
1,945,680
2
10,318
$
145,150.43
$
4,859,170
$
5,004,320
2
5,566
$
30,610.26
$
1,899,800
$
1,930,410
2
10,167
$
55,230.65
$
1,876,484
$
1,931,715
2
7,921
$
111,421.77
$
4,859,170
$
4,970,592
2
4,771
$
26,239.00
$
1,899,800
$
1,926,039
2
11,592
$
125,950.57
$
3,752,968
$
3,878,919
2
9,259
$
260,496.58
$
9,718,340
$
9,978,836
2
5,309
$
58,394.58
$
3,799,600
$
3,857,994
2
18,333
$
42,875.16
$
807,829
$
850,705
2
13,300
$
103,754.93
$
2,694,711
$
2,798,466
2
52,896
$
151,282.91
$
987,896
$
1,139,179
2
15,300
$
35,781.53
$
807,829
$
843,611
2
10,353
$
80,765.61
$
2,694,711
$
2,775,476
2
52,214
$
149,331.17
$
987,896
$
1,137,227
2
17,057
$
79,781.45
$
1,615,659
$
1,695,440
2
12,074
$
188,381.70
$
5,389,421
$
5,577,803
2
52,708
$
301,489.37
$
1,975,792
$
2,277,281
2
19,408
$
47,440.53
$
844,340
$
891,781
2
15,457
$
106,897.19
$
2,388,774
$
2,495,671
2
5,811
$
15,340.41
$
911,904
$
927,244
2
15,067
$
36,828.78
$
844,340
$
881,169
2
10,689
$
73,918.44
$
2,388,774
$
2,462,692
2
4,991
$
13,177.34
$
911,904
$
925,081
2
17,547
$
85,783.95
$
1,688,680
$
1,774,464
2
13,423
$
185,662.78
$
4,777,548
$
4,963,210
2
5,554
$
29,324.36
$
1,823,808
$
1,853,132
2
19,063
$
150,519.88
$
2,727,422
$
2,877,942
2
13,198
$
379,623.46
$
9,935,608
$
10,315,232
2
23,177
$
239,653.68
$
3,571,624
$
3,811,278
2
16,238
$
128,216.39
$
2,727,422
$
2,855,638
2
10,185
$
292,949.68
$
9,935,608
$
10,228,558
2
22,383
$
231,435.72
$
3,571,624
$
3,803,060
2
17,791
$
286,931.04
$
5,570,904
$
5,857,835
2
11,832
$
695,156.18
$
20,294,008
$
20,989,164
2
22,920
$
484,060.45
$
7,295,232
$
7,779,292
2
8,529
$
10,076.00
$
408,077
$
418,153
2
18,761
$
65,636.80
$
1,208,480
$
1,274,117
2
21,237
$
28,032.47
$
455,952
$
483,984
2
6,199
$
7,323.32
$
408,077
$
415,400
2
17,097
$
59,815.94
$
1,208,480
$
1,268,296
2
20,417
$
26,951.02
$
455,952
$
482,903
2
7,516
$
16,279.99
$
748,141
$
764,421
2
18,081
$
115,975.11
$
2,215,547
$
2,331,522
2
20,980
$
50,771.30
$
835,912
$
886,683
$
117,776,475.10
$
0
$
618,632,812