Document ID: EPA-HQ-OW-2002-0033-0107
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2003-04-14T04:00Z

Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
3
45
6789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
N
Summary:
Preferred
Option
and
Option
2/
6/
10
7
%
discount
rate
Preferred
option
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Total
Hours
High
29,254
36,360
43,466
6,225
6,225
34,241
34,241
34,241
6,225
6,225
34,241
34,241
34,241
Medium
8,658
10,768
12,879
2,780
2,780
9,372
9,372
9,372
2,780
2,780
9,372
9,372
9,372
Low
3,173
4,106
5,038
1,910
1,910
3,558
3,558
3,558
1,910
1,910
3,558
3,558
3,558
Total
Costs
High
$
1,081,831
$
1,344,609
$
1,607,388
$
230,212
$
230,212
$
1,266,244
$
1,266,244
$
1,266,244
$
230,212
$
230,212
$
1,266,244
$
1,266,244
$
1,266,244
Medium
$
320,171
$
398,209
$
476,248
$
102,791
$
102,791
$
346,563
$
346,563
$
346,563
$
102,791
$
102,791
$
346,563
$
346,563
$
346,563
Low
$
117,330
$
151,823
$
186,316
$
70,649
$
70,649
$
131,592
$
131,592
$
131,592
$
70,649
$
70,649
$
131,592
$
131,592
$
131,592
High
Medium
Low
NPV
$
8,310,860
$
2,483,585
$
1,047,744
Max
One
Year
Hours
43,466
12,879
5,038
Max
One
Year
Costs
$
1,607,388
$
476,248
$
186,316
Annualized
Cost
$
912,488
$
272,684
$
115,037
Option
2/
6/
10
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
Total
Hours
High
863,939
1,187,479
1,511,019
868,565
868,565
1,168,950
1,168,950
1,168,950
868,565
868,565
1,168,950
1,168,950
1,168,950
Medium
272,917
368,999
465,082
264,235
264,235
334,913
334,913
334,913
264,235
264,235
334,913
334,913
334,913
Low
109,027
151,496
193,965
121,404
121,404
139,073
139,073
139,073
121,404
121,404
139,073
139,073
139,073
Total
Costs
High
$
31,948,466
$
43,912,970
$
55,877,474
$
32,119,541
$
32,119,541
$
43,227,754
$
43,227,754
$
43,227,754
$
32,119,541
$
32,119,541
$
43,227,754
$
43,227,754
$
43,227,754
Medium
$
10,092,463
$
13,645,595
$
17,198,727
$
9,771,403
$
9,771,403
$
12,385,100
$
12,385,100
$
12,385,100
$
9,771,403
$
9,771,403
$
12,385,100
$
12,385,100
$
12,385,100
Low
$
4,031,823
$
5,602,326
$
7,172,829
$
4,489,511
$
4,489,511
$
5,142,936
$
5,142,936
$
5,142,936
$
4,489,511
$
4,489,511
$
5,142,936
$
5,142,936
$
5,142,936
High
Medium
Low
NPV
$
357,680,237
$
107,121,278
$
45,719,037
Max
One
Year
Hours
1,511,019
465,082
193,965
Max
One
Year
Costs
$
55,877,474
$
17,198,727
$
7,172,829
Annualized
Cost
$
39,271,367
$
11,761,340
$
5,019,704
February
14,
2003
1
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Summary
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
3
45
6789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
O
P
14
15
6,225
6,225
2,780
2,780
1,910
1,910
$
230,212
$
230,212
$
102,791
$
102,791
$
70,649
$
70,649
14
15
868,565
868,565
264,235
264,235
121,404
121,404
$
32,119,541
$
32,119,541
$
9,771,403
$
9,771,403
$
4,489,511
$
4,489,511
February
14,
2003
2
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Summary
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
23456789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
Preferred
Option
Scenario
Definition
Number
of
facilities
operating
post­
regulation
requiring
a
permit
4,944
Of
facilities
operating
post­
regulation:
existing
concentration­
based
629
existing
mass­
based
3,667
no
permit
in
baseline
648
concentration
based
to
be
converted
to
mass­
based
223
new
concentration­
based
432
new
mass­
based
216
Number
of
currently
permitted
facilities
closing
(
no
longer
requiring
a
permit)
143
Of
facilities
closing
due
to
the
rule:
existing
concentration­
based
12
existing
mass­
based
131
Incremental
Number
of
Facilities
by
Type
of
Permit
Required
and
Year*
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
Type
of
Permit
Required
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
new
concentration­
based
permit
144
144
144
new
mass­
based
permit
72
72
72
facility
closure
with
concentration­
based
permit
4
4
4
facility
closure
with
mass­
based
permit
44
44
44
conversion
of
conc­
based
to
mass­
based
permit
74
74
74
repermit
­
concen­
based:
post­
regulation**
135
135
135
0
0
279
279
279
0
0
279
repermit
­
mass­
based
:
post­
regulation**
1,222
1,222
1,222
0
0
1,369
1,369
1,369
0
0
1,369
repermit
­
concen­
based:
baseline***
128
128
128
128
128
128
128
128
128
128
128
repermit
­
mass­
based
:
baseline***
760
760
760
760
760
760
760
760
760
760
760
cumulative
incremental
number
of
facilities
operating
under
permits
(
new
­
closing)
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
*
assumes
no
incremental
effort
for
facilities
that
already
have
the
type
of
permit
required
by
the
rule,
other
than
repermitting
on
a
different
schedule.
**
facilities
with
existing
permits
excluding
facilities
that
close
due
to
the
rule,
plus
new
permits.
***
facilities
with
existing
permits
including
facilities
that
close
due
to
the
rule.

Incremental
Number
of
Facilities
by
Permitting
Activity
Required
and
Year
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
develop
and
issue
permit
­
concentration
based
144
144
144
develop
and
issue
permit
­
mass
based
72
72
72
develop
and
issue
permit
­
conc
based
converted
to
mass
based
74
74
74
provide
technical
guidance
­
concentation
based
144
144
144
provide
technical
guidance
­
mass
based
72
72
72
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
216
216
216
inspection
for
permit
development
216
216
216
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
sample
and
analyze
effluent
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
repermit
470
470
470
­
888
­
888
760
760
760
­
888
­
888
760
February
14,
2003
3
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
23456789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
N
O
P
Q
12
13
14
15
279
279
0
0
1,369
1,369
0
0
128
128
128
128
760
760
760
760
505
505
505
505
12
13
14
15
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
760
760
­
888
­
888
February
14,
2003
4
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
High
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
develop
and
issue
permit
8,862
8,862
8,862
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
2,477
2,477
2,477
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
230
230
230
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
2,592
2,592
2,592
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1,683
3,367
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
sample
and
analyze
effluent
2,357
4,713
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
589
1,178
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1,847
3,694
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
161
323
484
484
484
484
484
484
484
484
484
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
21
41
62
62
62
62
62
62
62
62
62
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
157
313
470
470
470
470
470
470
470
470
470
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
291
582
873
873
873
873
873
873
873
873
873
repermit
7,988
7,988
7,988
­
15,093
­
15,093
12,923
12,923
12,923
­
15,093
­
15,093
12,923
Total
hours
29,254
36,360
43,466
6,225
6,225
34,241
34,241
34,241
6,225
6,225
34,241
Total
cost
$
1,081,831
1,344,609
1,607,388
230,212
230,212
1,266,244
1,266,244
1,266,244
230,212
230,212
1,266,244
NPV
of
cost
$
8,310,860
Maximum
one­
year
hours
43,466
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
1,607,388
Annualized
over
15
years
$
912,488
Sampling
cost
$
87,150
$
174,299
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
NPV
of
sampling
cost
$
2,142,235
Annualized
sampling
cost
$
235,206
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Medium
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
develop
and
issue
permit
2,855
2,855
2,855
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
742
742
742
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
56
56
56
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
1,015
1,015
1,015
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
623
1,246
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
sample
and
analyze
effluent
505
1,010
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
648
1,296
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
54
108
161
161
161
161
161
161
161
161
161
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
6
12
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
19
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
44
87
131
131
131
131
131
131
131
131
131
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
62
125
187
187
187
187
187
187
187
187
187
repermit
1,879
1,879
1,879
­
3,551
­
3,551
3,041
3,041
3,041
­
3,551
­
3,551
3,041
Total
hours
8,658
10,768
12,879
2,780
2,780
9,372
9,372
9,372
2,780
2,780
9,372
Total
cost
$
320,171
398,209
476,248
102,791
102,791
346,563
346,563
346,563
102,791
102,791
346,563
NPV
of
cost
$
2,483,585
Maximum
one­
year
hours
12,879
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
476,248
Annualized
over
15
years
$
272,684
Sampling
cost
$
18,675
$
37,350
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
NPV
of
sampling
cost
$
459,050
Annualized
sampling
cost
$
50,401
February
14,
2003
5
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
N
O
P
Q
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
5,050
5,050
5,050
5,050
7,070
7,070
7,070
7,070
1,768
1,768
1,768
1,768
5,541
5,541
5,541
5,541
484
484
484
484
62
62
62
62
470
470
470
470
873
873
873
873
12,923
12,923
­
15,093
­
15,093
34,241
34,241
6,225
6,225
1,266,244
1,266,244
230,212
230,212
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
$
261,449
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,869
1,515
1,515
1,515
1,515
505
505
505
505
1,944
1,944
1,944
1,944
161
161
161
161
19
19
19
19
131
131
131
131
187
187
187
187
3,041
3,041
­
3,551
­
3,551
9,372
9,372
2,780
2,780
346,563
346,563
102,791
102,791
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
$
56,025
February
14,
2003
6
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
L
M
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Low
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
develop
and
issue
permit
969
969
969
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
288
288
288
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
16
16
16
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
497
497
497
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
303
606
909
909
909
909
909
909
909
909
909
sample
and
analyze
effluent
168
337
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
505
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
84
168
253
253
253
253
253
253
253
253
253
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
324
648
972
972
972
972
972
972
972
972
972
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
27
54
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
81
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
3
5
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
12
24
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
12
24
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
repermit
470
470
470
­
888
­
888
760
760
760
­
888
­
888
760
Total
hours
3,173
4,106
5,038
1,910
1,910
3,558
3,558
3,558
1,910
1,910
3,558
Total
cost
$
117,330
151,823
186,316
70,649
70,649
131,592
131,592
131,592
70,649
70,649
131,592
NPV
of
cost
$
1,047,744
Maximum
one­
year
hours
5,038
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
186,316
Annualized
over
15
years
$
115,037
February
14,
2003
7
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
N
O
P
Q
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
909
909
909
909
505
505
505
505
253
253
253
253
972
972
972
972
81
81
81
81
8
8
8
8
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
35
760
760
­
888
­
888
3,558
3,558
1,910
1,910
131,592
131,592
70,649
70,649
February
14,
2003
8
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Pref
Option
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
A
B
C
High
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Concentration
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
4,421
provide
technical
guidance
1,541
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
153
inspection
for
permit
development
1,728
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1,400
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1,960
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
490
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1,536
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
134
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
17
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
130
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
242
repermit
121
Total
hours
13,874
Total
cost
$
513,069
NPV
of
cost
$
6,185,399
Maximum
one­
year
hours
25,694
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
950,167
Annualized
over
15
years
$
679,124
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
72,481
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
1,781,661
Annualized
over
15
years
$
195,617
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
483,507
High
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
2,880
provide
technical
guidance
936
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
77
inspection
for
permit
development
864
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
283
sample
and
analyze
effluent
397
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
99
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
311
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
27
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
3
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
26
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
49
repermit
7,866
Total
hours
13,819
Total
cost
$
511,036
NPV
of
cost
$
1,824,192
Maximum
one­
year
hours
16,211
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
599,496
Annualized
over
15
years
$
200,286
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
14,669
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
360,574
Annualized
over
15
years
$
39,589
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
160,697
High
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Conc
to
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
1,561
February
14,
2003
9
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160
161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
A
B
C
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
0
sample
and
analyze
effluent
0
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
repermit
0
Total
hours
1,561
Total
cost
$
57,726
NPV
of
cost
$
301,270
Maximum
one­
year
hours
1,561
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
57,726
Annualized
over
15
years
$
33,078
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
Annualized
over
15
years
$
0
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
33,078
High
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Total
1
develop
and
issue
permit
8,862
provide
technical
guidance
2,477
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
230
inspection
for
permit
development
2,592
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1,683
sample
and
analyze
effluent
2,357
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
589
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1,847
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
161
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
21
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
157
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
291
repermit
7,988
Total
hours
29,254
Total
cost
$
1,081,831
NPV
of
cost
$
8,310,860
Maximum
one­
year
hours
43,466
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
1,607,388
Annualized
over
15
years
$
912,488
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
87,150
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
2,142,235
Annualized
over
15
years
$
235,206
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
677,282
Medium
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Concentration
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
1,397
provide
technical
guidance
475
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
37
February
14,
2003
10
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197
198
199
200
201
202
203
204
205
206
207
208
209
210
211
212
213
214
215
216
217
218
219
220
221
222
223
224
225
226
227
A
B
C
inspection
for
permit
development
677
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
518
sample
and
analyze
effluent
420
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
140
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
539
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
45
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
5
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
36
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
52
repermit
29
Total
hours
4,369
Total
cost
$
161,576
NPV
of
cost
$
1,858,575
Maximum
one­
year
hours
7,879
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
291,382
Annualized
over
15
years
$
204,062
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
15,532
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
381,785
Annualized
over
15
years
$
41,918
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
162,144
Medium
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
864
provide
technical
guidance
266
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
18
inspection
for
permit
development
338
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
105
sample
and
analyze
effluent
85
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
28
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
109
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
9
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
1
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
7
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
11
repermit
1,851
Total
hours
3,693
Total
cost
$
136,580
NPV
of
cost
$
531,994
Maximum
one­
year
hours
4,404
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
162,851
Annualized
over
15
years
$
58,410
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
3,143
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
77,266
Annualized
over
15
years
$
8,483
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
49,927
Medium
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Conc
to
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
595
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
0
sample
and
analyze
effluent
0
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0
February
14,
2003
11
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
228
229
230
231
232
233
234
235
236
237
238
239
240
241
242
243
244
245
246
247
248
249
250
251
252
253
254
255
256
257
258
259
260
261
262
263
264
265
266
267
268
269
270
271
272
273
274
275
276
277
278
279
280
281
282
283
284
285
A
B
C
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
repermit
0
Total
hours
595
Total
cost
$
21,991
NPV
of
cost
$
92,953
Maximum
one­
year
hours
595
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
21,991
Annualized
over
15
years
$
10,206
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
Annualized
over
15
years
$
0
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
10,206
Medium
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Total
1
develop
and
issue
permit
2,855
provide
technical
guidance
742
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
56
inspection
for
permit
development
1,015
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
623
sample
and
analyze
effluent
505
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
168
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
648
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
54
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
6
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
44
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
62
repermit
1,879
Total
hours
8,658
Total
cost
$
320,171
NPV
of
cost
$
2,483,585
Maximum
one­
year
hours
12,879
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
476,248
Annualized
over
15
years
$
272,684
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
18,675
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
459,050
Annualized
over
15
years
$
50,401
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
222,283
Low
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Concentration
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
533
provide
technical
guidance
144
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
11
inspection
for
permit
development
331
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
252
sample
and
analyze
effluent
140
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
70
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
270
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
22
February
14,
2003
12
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
286
287
288
289
290
291
292
293
294
295
296
297
298
299
300
301
302
303
304
305
306
307
308
309
310
311
312
313
314
315
316
317
318
319
320
321
322
323
324
325
326
327
328
329
330
331
332
333
334
335
336
337
338
339
340
341
342
343
A
B
C
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
2
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
10
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
10
repermit
7
Total
hours
1,801
Total
cost
$
66,619
NPV
of
cost
$
807,087
Maximum
one­
year
hours
3,353
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
123,994
Annualized
over
15
years
$
88,614
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
5,177
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
127,262
Annualized
over
15
years
$
13,973
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
74,641
Low
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
New
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
288
provide
technical
guidance
144
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
5
inspection
for
permit
development
166
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
51
sample
and
analyze
effluent
28
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
14
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
55
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
5
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
2
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
2
repermit
463
Total
hours
1,223
Total
cost
$
45,213
NPV
of
cost
$
217,419
Maximum
one­
year
hours
1,537
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
56,824
Annualized
over
15
years
$
23,871
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
1,048
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
25,755
Annualized
over
15
years
$
2,828
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
21,044
Low
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Conc
to
Mass
Based
1
develop
and
issue
permit
149
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
0
sample
and
analyze
effluent
0
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
repermit
0
February
14,
2003
13
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
344
345
346
347
348
349
350
351
352
353
354
355
356
357
358
359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
370
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
378
379
380
A
B
C
Total
hours
149
Total
cost
$
5,498
NPV
of
cost
$
23,238
Maximum
one­
year
hours
149
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
5,498
Annualized
over
15
years
$
2,551
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
0
Annualized
over
15
years
$
0
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
2,551
Low
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Total
1
develop
and
issue
permit
969
provide
technical
guidance
288
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
16
inspection
for
permit
development
497
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
303
sample
and
analyze
effluent
168
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
84
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
324
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
27
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
3
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
12
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
12
repermit
470
Total
hours
3,173
Total
cost
$
117,330
NPV
of
cost
$
1,047,744
Maximum
one­
year
hours
5,038
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
186,316
Annualized
over
15
years
$
115,037
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
6,225
NPV
of
Sampling
&
Analysis
Cost
$
153,017
Annualized
over
15
years
$
16,800
Annualized
Permitting
(
Net
of
Sampling
&
Analysis)
$
98,236
February
14,
2003
14
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Pref
Option­
by
Type
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
23456789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
Option
2/
6/
10
Scenario
Definition
Iron&
steel
Other
Total
Number
of
facilities
operating
post­
regulation
requiring
a
permit
53,009
99
52,909
53,008
Of
facilities
operating
post­
regulation:
existing
concentration­
based
25,232
20
25,212
25,232
existing
mass­
based
3,764
79
3,685
3,764
no
permit
in
baseline
24,013
0
24,013
24,013
concentration
based
to
be
converted
to
mass­
based
8,424
20
8,404
8,424
new
concentration­
based
16,009
0
16,009
16,009
new
mass­
based
8,004
0
8,004
8,004
Number
of
currently
permitted
facilities
closing
(
no
longer
requiring
a
permit)
1,020
6
1,014
1,020
Of
facilities
closing
due
to
the
rule:
existing
concentration­
based
889
0
889
889
existing
mass­
based
131
6
125
131
Incremental
Number
of
Facilities
by
Type
of
Permit
Required
and
Year*
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
Type
of
Permit
Required
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
new
concentration­
based
permit
5,336
5,336
5,336
new
mass­
based
permit
2,668
2,668
2,668
facility
closure
with
concentration­
based
permit
296
296
296
facility
closure
with
mass­
based
permit
44
44
44
conversion
of
conc­
based
to
mass­
based
permit
2,808
2,808
2,808
repermit
­
concen­
based:
post­
regulation**
5,603
5,603
5,603
0
0
10,939
10,939
10,939
0
repermit
­
mass­
based
:
post­
regulation**
1,255
1,255
1,255
0
0
6,731
6,731
6,731
0
repermit
­
concen­
based:
baseline***
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
repermit
­
mass­
based
:
baseline***
779
779
779
779
779
779
779
779
779
cumulative
incremental
number
of
facilities
operating
under
permits
(
new
­
closing)
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
*
assumes
no
incremental
effort
for
facilities
that
already
have
the
type
of
permit
required
by
the
rule,
other
than
repermitting
on
a
different
schedule.
**
facilities
with
existing
permits
excluding
facilities
that
close
due
to
the
rule,
plus
new
permits.
***
facilities
with
existing
permits
including
facilities
that
close
due
to
the
rule.

Incremental
Number
of
Facilities
by
Permitting
Activity
Required
and
Year
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
develop
and
issue
permit
­
concentration
based
5,336
5,336
5,336
develop
and
issue
permit
­
mass
based
2,668
2,668
2,668
develop
and
issue
permit
­
conc
based
converted
to
mass
based
2,808
2,808
2,808
provide
technical
guidance
­
concentation
based
5,336
5,336
5,336
provide
technical
guidance
­
mass
based
2,668
2,668
2,668
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
8,004
8,004
8,004
inspection
for
permit
development
8,004
8,004
8,004
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
sample
and
analyze
effluent
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
repermit
854
854
854
­
6,003
­
6,003
11,666
11,666
11,666
­
6,003
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
High
February
14,
2003
15
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
23456789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
L
M
N
O
P
Q
10
11
12
13
14
15
0
10,939
10,939
10,939
0
0
0
6,731
6,731
6,731
0
0
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
5,224
779
779
779
779
779
779
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
10
11
12
13
14
15
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
­
6,003
11,666
11,666
11,666
­
6,003
­
6,003
February
14,
2003
16
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
develop
and
issue
permit
329,514
329,514
329,514
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
91,783
91,783
91,783
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
8,529
8,529
8,529
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
96,052
96,052
96,052
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
76,643
153,287
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
sample
and
analyze
effluent
107,301
214,601
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
26,825
53,650
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
84,097
168,194
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
7,349
14,697
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
938
1,876
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
7,135
14,271
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
13,252
26,503
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
repermit
14,520
14,520
14,520
­
102,054
­
102,054
198,330
198,330
198,330
­
102,054
Total
hours
863,939
1,187,479
1,511,019
868,565
868,565
1,168,950
1,168,950
1,168,950
868,565
Total
cost
$
31,948,466
43,912,970
55,877,474
32,119,541
32,119,541
43,227,754
43,227,754
43,227,754
32,119,541
NPV
of
cost
$
357,680,237
Maximum
one­
year
hours
1,511,019
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
55,877,474
Annualized
over
15
years
$
39,271,367
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Medium
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
develop
and
issue
permit
106,243
106,243
106,243
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
27,482
27,482
27,482
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
2,073
2,073
2,073
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
37,620
37,620
37,620
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
28,358
56,716
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
sample
and
analyze
effluent
22,993
45,986
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
29,508
59,015
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
2,450
4,899
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
281
563
844
844
844
844
844
844
844
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1,985
3,970
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
2,843
5,687
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
repermit
3,417
3,417
3,417
­
24,013
­
24,013
46,666
46,666
46,666
­
24,013
Total
hours
272,917
368,999
465,082
264,235
264,235
334,913
334,913
334,913
264,235
Total
cost
$
10,092,463
13,645,595
17,198,727
9,771,403
9,771,403
12,385,100
12,385,100
12,385,100
9,771,403
NPV
of
cost
$
107,121,278
Maximum
one­
year
hours
465,082
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
17,198,727
Annualized
over
15
years
$
11,761,340
Permitting
Hours
by
Activity
and
Year
­
Low
February
14,
2003
17
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99
L
M
N
O
P
Q
10
11
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
229,930
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
321,902
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
80,476
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
252,291
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
22,046
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
2,814
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
21,406
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
39,755
­
102,054
198,330
198,330
198,330
­
102,054
­
102,054
868,565
1,168,950
1,168,950
1,168,950
868,565
868,565
32,119,541
43,227,754
43,227,754
43,227,754
32,119,541
32,119,541
10
11
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
85,074
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
68,979
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
88,523
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
7,349
844
844
844
844
844
844
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
5,955
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
8,530
­
24,013
46,666
46,666
46,666
­
24,013
­
24,013
264,235
334,913
334,913
334,913
264,235
264,235
9,771,403
12,385,100
12,385,100
12,385,100
9,771,403
9,771,403
February
14,
2003
18
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
H
I
J
K
Year
Relative
to
Promulgation
of
Rule
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
develop
and
issue
permit
36,032
36,032
36,032
0
0
0
0
0
0
provide
technical
guidance
10,672
10,672
10,672
0
0
0
0
0
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
589
589
589
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
permit
development
18,410
18,410
18,410
0
0
0
0
0
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
13,796
27,592
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
sample
and
analyze
effluent
7,664
15,329
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
3,832
7,664
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
14,754
29,508
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
1,225
2,450
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
125
250
375
375
375
375
375
375
375
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
537
1,073
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
537
1,073
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
repermit
854
854
854
­
6,003
­
6,003
11,666
11,666
11,666
­
6,003
Total
hours
109,027
151,496
193,965
121,404
121,404
139,073
139,073
139,073
121,404
Total
cost
$
4,031,823
5,602,326
7,172,829
4,489,511
4,489,511
5,142,936
5,142,936
5,142,936
4,489,511
NPV
of
cost
$
45,719,037
Maximum
one­
year
hours
193,965
Maximum
one­
year
costs
$
7,172,829
Annualized
over
15
years
$
5,019,704
Annualized
over
15
years
$
21,296
February
14,
2003
19
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
100
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
L
M
N
O
P
Q
10
11
12
13
14
15
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
41,387
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
22,993
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
11,497
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
44,262
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
3,674
375
375
375
375
375
375
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
1,610
­
6,003
11,666
11,666
11,666
­
6,003
­
6,003
121,404
139,073
139,073
139,073
121,404
121,404
4,489,511
5,142,936
5,142,936
5,142,936
4,489,511
4,489,511
February
14,
2003
20
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Results
­
Option
2­
6­
10
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
34
5678
9
10
11
12
A
B
C
D
Summary
of
Incremental
Costs
per
Facility
High
Medium
Low
Annualized
over
15
years
at
3
percent
New
concentration­
based
permit
$
1,890
$
556
$
236
New
mass­
based
permit
$
1,924
$
564
$
240
Upgrading
from
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
$
1,789
$
526
$
221
Annualized
over
15
years
at
7
percent
New
concentration­
based
permit
$
2,477
$
729
$
309
New
mass­
based
permit
$
2,522
$
740
$
314
Upgrading
from
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
$
2,345
$
690
$
289
February
14,
2003
21
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Unit
Cost
Summary
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
3
4
56789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
A
B
C
D
High
Estimate
of
Hours
and
Costs
per
Facility
Activity
Initial
Year
Annual
(
nonpermitting
year)
Repermit
Year
New
concentration­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
31
provide
technical
guidance
11
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
1
inspection
for
permit
development
12
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
10
10
10
sample
and
analyze
effluent
14
14
14
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
4
4
4
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
11
11
11
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
1
1
1
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1
1
1
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
2
2
2
repermit
17
Total
Hours
by
Year
97
42
59
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
3,575
$
1,561
$
2,190
New
mass­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
40
provide
technical
guidance
13
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
1
inspection
for
permit
development
12
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
10
10
10
sample
and
analyze
effluent
14
14
14
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
4
4
4
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
11
11
11
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
1
1
1
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1
1
1
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
2
2
2
repermit
17
Total
Hours
by
Year
108
42
59
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
4,004
$
1,561
$
2,190
Upgrading
from
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
develop
and
issue
permit
21
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
10
10
10
sample
and
analyze
effluent
14
14
14
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
4
4
4
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
11
11
11
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
1
1
1
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1
1
1
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
2
2
2
repermit
17
Total
Hours
by
Year
63
42
59
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
2,338
$
1,561
$
2,190
(
average
considering
frequency
of
activity
and
percent
of
facilities
requiring
activity)

February
14,
2003
22
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Unit
Costs
­
High
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
3
4
56789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
A
B
C
D
Medium
Estimate
of
Hours
and
Costs
per
Facility
Activity
Initial
Year
Annual
(
nonpermitting
year)
Repermit
Year
New
concentration­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
10
provide
technical
guidance
3
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
5
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
4
4
4
sample
and
analyze
effluent
3
3
3
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
4
4
4
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
4
Total
Hours
by
Year
30
13
17
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
1,128
$
464
$
612
New
mass­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
12
provide
technical
guidance
4
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
5
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
4
4
4
sample
and
analyze
effluent
3
3
3
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
4
4
4
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
4
Total
Hours
by
Year
33
13
17
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
1,227
$
464
$
612
Upgrading
from
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
develop
and
issue
permit
8
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
4
4
4
sample
and
analyze
effluent
3
3
3
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
4
4
4
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
4
Total
Hours
by
Year
21
13
17
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
759
$
464
$
612
(
average
considering
frequency
of
activity
and
percent
of
facilities
requiring
activity)

February
14,
2003
23
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Unit
Costs
­
Medium
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
2
3
4
56789
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
A
B
C
D
Low
Estimate
of
Hours
and
Costs
per
Facility
Activity
Initial
Year
Annual
(
nonpermitting
year)
Repermit
Year
New
concentration­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
4
provide
technical
guidance
1
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
2
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
2
2
2
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1
1
1
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
2
2
2
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
1
Total
Hours
by
Year
13
6
7
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
466
$
205
$
242
New
mass­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
4
provide
technical
guidance
2
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
2
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
2
2
2
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1
1
1
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
2
2
2
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
1
Total
Hours
by
Year
14
6
7
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
515
$
205
$
242
Upgrading
from
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
develop
and
issue
permit
2
provide
technical
guidance
0
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
0
inspection
for
permit
development
0
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
2
2
2
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1
1
1
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
1
1
1
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
2
2
2
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
0
0
0
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
0
0
0
repermit
1
Total
Hours
by
Year
8
6
7
Total
Dollars
by
Year
$
279
$
205
$
242
(
average
considering
frequency
of
activity
and
percent
of
facilities
requiring
activity)

February
14,
2003
24
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Unit
Costs
­
Low
Record
for
the
Final
Metal
Product
and
Machinery
Rule
1
23456
7
89
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
A
B
C
D
E
F
G
Inputs
&
Assumptions
Source:
estimates
of
hours
by
activity
and
average
hourly
rate
from
the
1996
MP&
M
POTW
Survey.
Discount
rate:
7%
Average
hourly
rate:
$
36.98
(
1999$)

Permitting
Activities
and
Assumptions
Activity
Low
Medium
High
%
Facil
x/
yr
Notes
New
concentration­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
3.7
9.7
30.7
100.0%
1
one­
time
provide
technical
guidance
1.0
3.3
10.7
100.0%
1
one­
time
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
2.3
8.0
33.3
3.2%
1
one­
time,
3.2%
of
facilities
inspection
for
permit
development
2.3
4.7
12.0
100.0%
1
one­
time
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1.8
3.7
10.0
100.0%
1
annual
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1.0
3.0
14.0
100.0%
1
annual
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0.5
1.0
3.5
100.0%
1
annual
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1.0
2.0
5.7
38.5%
5
5x/
year,
38.5%
of
facilities
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.5
1.0
3.0
16.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
94%
in
compliance
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.8
1.8
6.0
1.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
6%
not
in
compliance
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1.0
3.7
13.3
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
1.0
5.3
24.7
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
repermit
1.0
4.0
17.0
100.0%
1
every
five
years
New
mass­
based
permit
develop
and
issue
permit
4.0
12.0
40.0
100.0%
1
one­
time
provide
technical
guidance
2.0
3.7
13.0
100.0%
1
one­
time
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
2.3
8.0
33.3
3.2%
1
one­
time,
3.2%
of
facilities
inspection
for
permit
development
2.3
4.7
12.0
100.0%
1
one­
time
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1.8
3.7
10.0
100.0%
1
annual
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1.0
3.0
14.0
100.0%
1
annual
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0.5
1.0
3.5
100.0%
1
annual
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1.0
2.0
5.7
38.5%
5
5x/
year,
38.5%
of
facilities
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.5
1.0
3.0
16.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
94%
in
compliance
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.8
1.8
6.0
1.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
6%
not
in
compliance
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1.0
3.7
13.3
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
1.0
5.3
24.7
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
repermit
1.0
4.0
17.0
100.0%
1
every
five
years
Converting
concentration­
based
to
mass­
based
develop
and
issue
permit
2.0
8.0
21.0
100.0%
1
one­
time
provide
technical
guidance
conduct
public
or
evidentiary
hearings
inspection
for
permit
development
inspection
for
compliance
assessment
1.8
3.7
10.0
100.0%
1
annual
sample
and
analyze
effluent
1.0
3.0
14.0
100.0%
1
annual
review
&
record
self­
monitoring
reports
0.5
1.0
3.5
100.0%
1
annual
process
&
act
on
non­
compliance
reports
1.0
2.0
5.7
38.5%
5
5x/
year,
38.5%
of
facilities
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.5
1.0
3.0
16.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
94%
in
compliance
review
compliance
schedule
report
­
not
in
compliance
with
schedule
0.8
1.8
6.0
1.0%
2
2x/
yr,
17%
of
facilities
with
compliance
milestones,
of
which
6%
not
in
compliance
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
order)
1.0
3.7
13.3
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
minor
enforcement
action
(
e.
g.,
admin
fine)
1.0
5.3
24.7
7.0%
1
annual,
7%
of
facilities
repermit
1.0
4.0
17.0
100.0%
1
every
five
years
February
14,
2003
25
of
25
AD­
MP&
M7A­
numeric.
xls
­
Inputs
&
Assumptions