Document ID: EPA-HQ-OAR-2011-0817-0111
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2012-07-18T04:00Z

Part 70 Permit Number PRIVATE  

47-065-3070

This Permit Shall Remain in Full Force and Effect

 From May 15, 2004 Through May 14, 2009

Issued to:

 

SIGNAL MOUNTAIN CEMENT COMPANY

1201 SUCK CREEK ROAD

CHATTANOOGA, TENNESSEE  37405

Designated Representative:

Shan Rolin

TELEPHONE: 886-0803

Responsible Official:

(Agreed to By)

___________________________________

  George Garcia

Vice-President of Manufacturing

 

       

An Application For Renewal Must Be Submitted to the Director of

 the Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau

No Later Than November 14, 2008

CHATTANOOGA-HAMILTON COUNTY

AIR POLLUTION CONTROL BUREAU

Development Resource Center

1250 Market Street, Suite 3020

Chattanooga, Tennessee 37402-2713

(423) 668-2567

___________________________________                                     
       

Robert H. Colby

Director

Prepared by: Douglas L. Erwin

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Subject   											Page 

Emission Unit Summary	2

Conditions of General Applicability to

All Part 70 Sources	3

Conditions Applicable to the Entire Facility	14

Emission Unit Special Conditions	18

 

Permit Shield	27

The emissions units regulated by this permit are the following:  

Permit Emission Unit	Description

10	Precalciner/Kiln

11	Raw Material Handling and Preparation

12	Clinker Handling and Storage

13	Fuel Handling and Storage

14	Product Finishing and Handling

15	Finish Materials Storage and Handling

Conditions of General Applicability

This permittee, Signal Mountain Cement Company is subject to each of the
conditions expressed below and is required to comply with them
throughout the term of the permit, and by accepting this permit and
operating under it Signal Mountain Cement Company agrees to comply with
all terms, provisions, limitations and requirements herein.  

ALL SECTIONS OF THE CHATTANOOGA AIR POLLUTION CONTROL ORDINANCE CITED IN
THIS PERMIT ARE INCORPORATED HEREIN BY REFERENCE.  Section numbers
referred to in this permit which are not otherwise identified refer to
sections in the Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance.  

Definitions.  Unless specifically defined within an air pollution
control ordinance provision referenced elsewhere in this permit, the
definitions in §4-2 and §4-53 shall apply.  §4-2; §4-53

Severability.  If any provision, part of a provision, sentence, clause
or phrase in this permit is for any reason declared to be
unconstitutional or otherwise invalid by any court of competent
jurisdiction, such decision shall not affect the validity of any other
portion of this permit, and only such invalid portion shall be elided. 
§4-57(a)(5)

Compliance.

The permittee must comply with all conditions of the Part 70 permit. 
Noncompliance with any permit provision constitutes a violation of
either the Chattanooga City Code, Part II, Chapter 4, known as "The
Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance"; the Tennessee Air Quality
Act, T.C.A. 68-201-101 et. seq.; and/or the federal Clean Air Act, as
amended, Title 42 United States Code §7401 et. seq. and is grounds for
joint and several enforcement action; for permit termination, revocation
or modification; or for denial of a permit renewal application. 
Enforcement by the Board or Bureau Director shall be conducted in
accordance with the provisions of §4-4, §4-7, §4-14, §4-15, §4-17,
§4-18, §4-20, §4-61, §4-62, §4-63, §4-64, and §4-65, as
appropriate to the circumstances.  §4-57(a)(6)(I)

It shall not be a defense for a permittee in an enforcement action that
it would have been necessary to halt or reduce the permitted activity in
order to maintain compliance with the conditions of this permit. 
§4-57(a)(6)(ii)

This permit may be modified, revoked, reopened and reissued, or
terminated for cause.  The filing of a request by the permittee for a
permit modification, revocation and reissuance, or termination; or the
filing of a notification of planned changes or anticipated noncompliance
does not stay any condition in this permit.  §4-57(a)(6)(iii)

3.4	Annual compliance certifications shall be submitted on or before
April 30 of each year throughout the term of this permit.  Separate
compliance certifications shall be submitted to:

		Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau

		Development Resource Center

		1250 Market Street, Suite 3020

		Chattanooga, TN  37402-4443

	and to:

		U.S. EPA Region 4

		Air Enforcement Section

		Sam Nunn Atlanta Federal Center

		61 Forsyth Street SW

		Atlanta, GA 30303-8960 

	Each such compliance certification shall include the following
information (provided that the identification of applicable information
may cross-reference the permit or previous reports as applicable):

3.4.1	Identification of each term or condition of the permit that is the
basis of 	the certification;

3.4.2	Compliance status;

3.4.3	Whether compliance was continuous or intermittent;

3.4.4	The method(s) used for determining the compliance status of the
source, 	currently and over the reporting period consistent with
§4-57(a)(3);

3.4.5	Where any specific test method requires quality assurance audit
samples 	and the audit result does not validate the source's sample
within the 	specified parameters, the source must retest the stack test
until such time 	as the audit result does validate the sample within the
specified 	parameters; except that the Bureau Director may waive
retesting if the 	source's stack test sample is in compliance with this
permit even if not 	validated within the specified quality assurance
parameters.  §4-3(d)

3.4.6	Such other facts as the Board or Bureau Director may require to
determine 	the compliance status of the Part 70 source; and 
§4-57(c)(5)(iii)(E)

3.4.7	Such additional requirements as may be required for enhanced
monitoring 	compliance certification under Title 42 U.S.C. § 7414(a)(3)
and §7661c(b) 	of the Clean Air Act.  §4-57(c)(5); §4-3(d)

3.5	The methods set forth in §4-3 shall be applicable for determining
compliance with 	all terms, provisions, limitations and requirements
contained in this permit, except 	where otherwise specifically provided
in this permit.

Property Rights.  This permit does not convey any property rights of any
sort or any exclusive privilege.  This permit is not assignable except
as provided in §4-58 (d)(l)(iv).  §4-57(a)(6)(iv)

Information to be Furnished.  The permittee shall furnish to the Bureau
Director, within a reasonable period of time, any information that the
Board or the Bureau Director may request in writing to determine whether
cause exists for modifying, revoking, or terminating the permit or to
determine compliance with the permit.  Upon request, the permittee shall
also furnish to the Board or the Bureau Director copies of records
required to be kept by the permit.  For information claimed to be
confidential, the permittee may furnish such records directly to the
Administrator of the U. S. Environmental Protection Agency along with a
claim of confidentiality.  Eligibility for confidential treatment shall
be determined by the Board pursuant to the provisions of §4-19 of the
Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance for information submitted
directly to the Bureau Director.  An independent determination regarding
confidentiality would be made by the Administrator of the U.S.
Environmental Protection Agency for information submitted directly to
the Administrator.  §4-57(a)(6)(v) 

Fees.  The permittee shall pay fees to the Bureau Director consistent
with the fee provisions set forth in §4-60 of the Chattanooga Air
Pollution Control Ordinance.

  	§4-57(a)(7) 

Changes Provided for by Permit.  No permit revision shall be required
under any economic incentives, marketable permits, emissions trading or
similar program or process which is included in the Chattanooga City
Code, Part II, Chapter 4, Article III for changes that are provided for
in this permit pursuant to such program or process.  §4-57(a)(8) 

Reasonably Anticipated Operating Scenarios. Contemporaneously with
making a change from one operating scenario to another, the permittee
must record in a log at the Part 70 source premises a record of the
scenarios under which it is operating.  §4-57(a)(9)

Acid Precipitation Requirements.  Where an applicable requirement of the
Clean Air Act is more stringent than an applicable requirement of
regulations promulgated under Title IV of the Clean Air Act and
incorporated by reference at §4-52(d), both provisions are herein
incorporated into this permit by reference and shall be legally
enforceable.  This source does not lawfully hold any allowance under
Title IV of the Clean Air Act.  §4-57(a)(1)(ii)

Federal Enforceability.  All terms and conditions in this Part 70
permit, including any provisions designed to limit the potential to emit
of this Part 70 source, are enforceable by the Administrator of the U.S.
EPA and by citizens under the Clean Air Act except as noted in this Item
10:

Rule 12	Odors					(Local Only)

Rule 14	Nuisances				(Local Only)

Any terms and conditions included in the permit that are not required
under the Clean Air Act or under any of its applicable requirements are
specifically designated in this permit as not being federally
enforceable under the Clean Air Act.  §4-57(b)(1) and (2)  

Inspection of Permitted Source(s).  Upon presentation of identification
and in the performance of their duties, the permittee shall allow the
Bureau Director and other employees of the Chattanooga-Hamilton County
Air Pollution Control Bureau to perform the following:

Enter upon the permittee's premises or buildings where a Part 70 source
is located or emissions-related activity is conducted, or where records
must be kept under the conditions of the permit;

Have access to and copy, at reasonable times, any records that must be
kept under the conditions of the permit;

Inspect at reasonable times any facilities, equipment (including
monitoring and air pollution control equipment), practices, or
operations regulated or required under the permit; and

Sample or monitor substances or parameters, and collect and preserve
evidence for the purpose of assuring compliance with the permit or
applicable requirements thereunder at reasonable times and for taking
such other actions as are appropriate under the law in accordance with
Item 3.1 of Conditions of General Applicability of this permit.

For the purposes of Items 11.2, 11.3, and 11.4 of these Conditions of
General Applicability, "reasonable times" shall be considered to be
customary business hours, unless reasonable cause exists to suspect
noncompliance with  the Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance or
any "applicable requirement," as defined in §4-53, or with any permit
issued thereunder, and the Bureau Director specifically authorizes a
designee to inspect a facility at any other time.

In the alternative, the Bureau Director, other employees of the
Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau, or any other
law enforcement officer may obtain a search warrant to obtain, collect
and preserve evidence.  §4-16; §4-57(c)(2)

Record Retention Requirements.

All required monitoring data and related support information shall be
retained by the permittee for five (5) years after the date of the
monitoring sample, measurement, report or application.  Support
information includes all calibration and maintenance records, all
original strip-chart recordings for continuous monitoring
instrumentation, copies of all reports, and logs required by the permit.
 §4-57(a)(3)(ii)(B)

Reporting of Deviations.  The permittee shall promptly report all
emissions limitations exceedances and all other deviations from permit
requirements (including those attributable to malfunctions), the
probable cause of such exceedances or deviations, and any corrective
actions or preventive measures taken.  "Promptly report" shall mean an
initial telephone report to the Bureau Director within twenty-four (24)
hours after the onset of the exceedance or other deviation, followed up
by a written report submitted to the Bureau Director within seven (7)
days after the onset of the exceedance or other deviation.  Any excess
emissions or other deviation that creates an imminent hazard requiring
immediate action to protect health or safety must be reported by
telephone immediately to the Bureau Director, to the appropriate local
emergency response agency, to the appropriate national response agency,
and to the Tennessee Emergency Management Agency. 

		§4-12 and §4-57(a)(3)(iii)(B)

Emergency Provision.  

Definition.  An emergency is any situation arising from sudden and
reasonably unforeseeable events beyond the control of the permittee,
including acts of God, which situation requires immediate corrective
action to restore normal operation, and that causes the permittee to
exceed a technology-based emission limitation under the permit, due to
unavoidable increases in emissions attributable to the emergency.  An
emergency shall not include noncompliance to the extent caused by
improperly designed equipment, lack of preventative maintenance,
careless or improper operation, or operator error.  §4-57(g)

An emergency constitutes an affirmative defense to an action brought for
noncompliance with such technology-based emission limitations if the
conditions of Item 13 of these Conditions of General Applicability are
met, unless an ambient air violation occurs as a result of the
emergency.  The affirmative defense of emergency shall be demonstrated
through properly signed, contemporaneous operating logs, or other
relevant evidence which establishes that:  

An emergency occurred and that the permittee can identify the cause(s)
of the emergency; and

The permitted facility was at the time being properly operated; and

During the period of the emergency the permittee took all reasonable
steps to minimize levels of emissions that exceeded the emission
standards, or other requirements in the permit; and

The permittee submitted telephone notice of the emergency to the Bureau
Director within one (1) working day of the time when emission
limitations were exceeded due to the emergency, and the permittee
submitted a follow up written report to the Bureau within seven (7) 
days after the onset of the exceedance.  This notice must contain a
description of the emergency, any steps taken to mitigate emissions, and
corrective actions taken.  §4-57(g)

In any enforcement proceeding, the permittee seeking to establish the
occurrence of an emergency has the burden of proof.  §4-12; 4-57(g) 

The permittee must employ all reasonable measures to keep emissions to a
minimum during start-ups, shutdowns, operation, and emergencies.  These
measures may include installation and use of alternate control systems,
changes in operating methods or procedures, cessation of operation until
the process equipment or air pollution control equipment is repaired,
maintaining sufficient spare parts, use of overtime labor, use of
outside consultants and contractors, and other appropriate means. 
Exceedances of limitations on emissions that are caused by poor
maintenance, careless operation, or any other preventable upset
condition or preventable equipment breakdown shall not be considered
emergencies, and shall be considered in violation of the emission
standard exceeded.  §4-12

A log of any operation or failure to operate, start-up, or shutdown
resulting in air pollutant emissions in excess of any applicable
requirement must be kept at the Part 70 source.  This log must record at
least the following:

Stack, air pollution control equipment, or emission point involved;

Time excess emissions, start-up, or shutdown began or when excess
emissions were first discovered by the source;

Type of exceedance qualifying as a malfunction, or reason for shutdown;

Time start-up or shutdown was complete or time the air pollutant source
returned to normal operation after an emissions exceedance;

Documentation that the source was or was not, at the time of the onset
of the exceedance, being properly operated;

Documentation of any preventative maintenance of the air pollution
control equipment or process equipment or processes that had been
completed prior to the emissions exceedance, start-up, or shutdown;

The steps taken by the source during the period of the emissions
exceedance, start-up, or shutdown to minimize levels of emissions that
exceeded the applicable requirements; and

The magnitude and identity of the excess emissions, expressed in pounds
per hour and the units of the applicable emission limitation, and the
operating data and calculations used in determining the magnitude of the
excess emissions.  §4-12

The information required by Items 13.5.1 and 13.5.2 of these Conditions
of General Applicability must be entered into the log by the end of the
shift during which the exceedance or other deviation began.  All
required information shall be entered in the log no later than 24 hours
after the exceedance or other deviation has ceased or has been
corrected.  Any later discovered corrections may be added in the log as
footnotes with the reason given for the change.  There shall be no
erasures, obliterations, modifications, or revisions of the log entry
except by single line-through and identification of corrections.  §4-12

If the Bureau Director or the Administrator of the Chattanooga-Hamilton
County Health Department finds that a condition of air pollution exists
or is likely to exist, and that it creates any emergency requiring
immediate action to protect human health or safety, the mayor with the
concurrence of the Bureau Director or the Administrator of the
Chattanooga-Hamilton County Health Department shall order persons
causing or contributing to the air pollution to reduce or discontinue
immediately the emission of air pollutants.  Upon issuance of any such
order, the Bureau Director shall fix a place and time, not later than
twenty-four (24) hours thereafter, for a hearing to be held before the
Board.  Not more than twenty-four (24) hours after commencement of such
hearing, and without adjournment thereafter, the Board shall affirm,
modify, or recommend to the mayor that the order be affirmed, modified
or set aside.  §4-20 

Certification.  Any application form, report, or compliance
certification submitted pursuant to this permit shall contain a
certification, as defined in §4-53, by a responsible official, as
defined in §4-53, of truth, accuracy, and completeness.  Any
certification required by this permit shall state that based on
information and belief formed after reasonable inquiry, the statements
and information in the document are true, accurate, and complete. 
§4-56(d)

Modifications.

Administrative amendments to this permit shall be requested and may be
granted in accordance with §4-58(d), and only for the reasons set forth
therein.  The permittee is required to submit an application for an
administrative amendment within sixty (60) days after a change of the
name of the permittee is registered with the Tennessee Secretary of
State.   

Minor permit modifications to this permit shall be requested and may be
granted in accordance with §4-58(e)(1) and (2).

Significant permit modifications to this permit shall be requested and
may be granted in accordance with §4-58(e)(3). 

Operational flexibility allows changes within this permitted source
without requiring a permit revision, if the changes are not
modifications under Title I of the Clean Air Act and the changes do not
exceed the emissions allowable under this permit (whether expressed
herein as a rate of emissions or in terms of total emissions), provided
that:

The permittee provides the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the
Bureau Director with written notification at least 7 days in advance of
the proposed changes; and

For each such change, said written notification shall include a brief
description of the change within the permitted source, the date on which
the change will occur, any change in emissions, and any permit term or
condition that is no longer applicable as a result of the change.

The permit shield described in §4-57(f) shall not apply to any change
made pursuant to operational flexibility.  §4-58(i)

Installation permit application and issuance requirements in §4-8(a) of
the Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance will apply to this
permittee and emissions units located at this Part 70 source if
modifications to or new construction of a Part 70 source are subject to
the following:

§ 4-41, Rule 18 (PSD);

§ 4-41, Rule 25.3 (VOC rule for new or modified sources);

§ 4-41, Rule 23 (Reasonable and proper controls for process gaseous
emissions);

Any standard or other requirement pursuant to regulations promulgated
under Title 42 U.S.C. §7411 in Title 40 Code of Federal Regulations
Part 60; or

Case-by-case determinations made pursuant to Title 42 U.S.C. §7412(g)
and (j) as set forth at §4-53 "Applicable requirement" (4); or

Case-by-case determinations made pursuant to 4-41, Rule 27 (Particulate
Matter Controls for New Sources and New Modifications after August 29,
1995).  §4-50

Off-Permit Changes.

An off-permit change is one that:

Is not addressed or prohibited by the permit;

Is not a modification under Title I of the Clean Air Act;

Is not subject to any requirements under Title IV of the Clean Air Act;

Meets all applicable requirements, as described in this permit; and

Does not violate, or cause or contribute to a violation of, any existing
permit term or condition.

A contemporaneous notification shall be submitted to the Bureau Director
and to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency except for changes that
qualify as insignificant under Sections 4-56(c)(11) and (c)(12).

The permittee shall keep a record describing off-permit changes made at
the Part 70 source that result in emissions of a regulated air pollutant
subject to an applicable requirement, but not otherwise regulated under
the permit, and the emissions resulting from those off-permit changes.

The permit shield described in §4-57(f) of the Chattanooga Air
Pollution Control Ordinance shall not apply to any change made pursuant
to off-permit changes.§4-58(j)

Permit Reopening.  This permit shall be reopened and revised under any
of the following circumstances, as set forth in §4-58(f)(1).

Additional applicable requirements become applicable by amendment of the
Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance to this source and the
remaining permit term is 3 or more years.  Such reopening shall be
completed not later than 18 months after promulgation of the applicable
requirement.  No such reopening is required if the effective date of the
requirement is later than the date on which the permit is due to expire.

Additional requirements (including excess emissions requirements) become
applicable to an affected source as defined in §4-53.  Upon approval by
the Administrator and amendment of the local air pollution control
ordinance, excess emissions offset plans shall be incorporated into the
permit.

The Board or Bureau Director or the Administrator determines that this
permit contains a material mistake or that inaccurate statements were
made in establishing the emissions standards or other terms or
conditions of the permit.

The Board or Bureau Director or the Administrator determines that the
permit must be revised or revoked to assure compliance with the
applicable requirements.

Proceedings to reopen and issue a revised permit shall follow the same
procedures as apply to initial permit issuance, described in §4-58, and
shall affect only those parts of the permit for which cause to reopen
exists.  Such reopening shall be made as expeditiously as practicable,
but only after notice of such intent is provided to this permittee by
the Bureau Director at least 30 days in advance of the date that permit
is to be reopened.  A shorter time period may be provided in the case of
an emergency.  §4-58(f).

This permittee is also subject to reopening for cause by EPA, as
described in §4-58(g).  

§4-58(g).

Rules Applicable to All Permittee Activities.  The following conditions
apply to all activities of this permittee, including insignificant
activities:

Nitrogen Oxides.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rules 2.4, 2.5
and 2.7, regarding emissions of nitrogen oxides.

Visible Emissions.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 3,
limiting the opacity of visible emissions to twenty (20) percent for an
aggregate of five (5) minutes in any one-hour period or twenty (20)
minutes in any twenty-four hour period.  The permittee shall also comply
with §4-41, Rule 9, regarding visible emissions from internal
combustion engines.  In addition, the permittee shall comply with
§4-41, Rule 11 limiting opacity from transport and material handling in
open air to twenty- (20) percent opacity for three (3) minutes in any
consecutive sixty-minute period or twenty (20) minutes in a twenty-four
hour period.  §4-41, Rule 3, Rule 9 and Rule 11. §4-3(c)(9).

Certain Fuels.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 4,
regarding importation, sale, transportation, use or consumption of fuels
and sulfur content.	

Prohibition of Hand-Fired Fuel-Burning Equipment.  The permittee shall
comply with §4-41, Rule 5, regarding hand-fired fuel-burning equipment.

Open Burning.  The permittee is prohibited from conducting open burning
except in accordance with §4-41, Rule 6.

Other Fuel-Burning Equipment.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41,
Rule 8, regarding other fuel-burning equipment.

Process Emissions.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 10,
regarding process emissions.

Odors in Ambient Air.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 12,
regarding emission of objectionable odors.  (Local Rule).

Sulfur Oxides.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 13,
regarding emissions of sulfur oxides.  

Nuisance.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 14, concerning
discharges from any source of air contaminants or other material which
shall cause a nuisance.

(Local Rule)

Hazardous Air Pollutants.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule
16.1 through 16.4 regarding emission standards for hazardous air
pollutants other than asbestos.

Asbestos Demolition or Renovation.  The permittee shall comply with
§4-41, Rule 17, when conducting any demolition or renovation activities
at the permitted source.

Stack Heights.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 22,
regarding good engineering practices for stack heights.

Particulate Matter Controls for New Sources and New Modifications After
August 30, 1995.  The permittee shall comply with §4-41, Rule 27
regarding particulate matter controls for any new source or modification
for which installation commences after August 30, 1995.  

Stratospheric Ozone and Climate Protection.  The permittee is subject to
the standards for recycling and emissions reduction promulgated at Title
40 Code of Federal Regulations Part 82, Subpart F, including the use of
certified technicians only.

Dismantled Equipment.  The permittee shall report to the Bureau Director
within thirty (30) days after the permanent discontinuance or
dismantlement of any equipment or activity covered by this permit.

§4-11(a)

Monitoring.  All monitoring and related reporting shall be conducted in
compliance with §4-57(a)(3)(ii)(A) and (B).

Applicable Requirements.  In addition to the Conditions of General
Applicability, Conditions Applicable to the Entire Facility, and
Emission Unit Special Conditions in this permit, "applicable
requirements" as defined in §4-53 shall apply.

 

Basis of Permit.  This permit is being issued based on the statements
made and the information provided in the Part 70 permit application
submitted under oath by this source.

CONDITIONS APPLICABLE TO THE ENTIRE FACILITY

  

1.0	Federal Standards

 

	Permittee is subject to Section 4-41, Rule 15.1 (Title 40 CFR Part 60
Subparts F	and Y, beginning at §60.60 and §60.250 respectively) of the
Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance. 

	Permittee is subject to Title 40 CFR Part 63 Subpart LLL – National
Emission Standards for Hazardous Air Pollutants From the Portland Cement
Manufacturing Industry, 64 FR 31925-31960 (June 14, 1999).  (The
permittee has demonstrated by stack sampling their status as an area
source under this rule and is therefore excluded from select parts of
the rule as listed in Table 1 of §63.1342.) This standard includes, but
is not limited to, the following requirements:  

1.1	Applicable emission and operating limits as cited in §63.1342
through §63.1344 and summarized in Table 1 of the rule, including:

1.1.1	8.7x10-11 grains TEQ (see §63.1341 Definitions) per dscf
corrected to seven percent oxygen; or 1.7x10-10 grains TEQ per dscf
corrected to seven percent oxygen, when the average of the performance
test run average temperatures at the inlet to the PM control device is
204(C (400(F) or less, in accordance with §63.1343(b)(3);

1.1.2	Process gas temperature limits for kilns and in-line kiln/raw
mills shall be followed in accordance with §63.1344 and shall be
established by recording these parameters during periodic testing
(baghouse #5 inlet temperature with and without the raw mill operating
as recorded during the most recent stack test that demonstrated
compliance with the above standards);

   

1.2	Periodic testing for dioxins and furans (D/F; see §63.1341
Definitions) pursuant to §63.1349(d).     

1.3	Monitoring requirements as specified in §63.1350, which include the
following:

1.3.1	Maintenance of an operations and maintenance plan conforming 	with
§63.1350(a). 

1.3.2	Gas temperature as a D/F emissions surrogate in accordance with
§63.1350(f), which describes installation, calibration, maintenance,
and operating requirements for monitoring the temperature of various gas
streams in kilns and in-line kiln/raw mills.  The time interval for
verifying calibration of thermocouples and other temperature sensors is
no less frequently than once every three months in accordance with
§63.1350(f)(6) 

1.3.3	Inspection of the components of the combustion system of in-line
kiln/raw mill system at least once per year in accordance with
§63.1350(i).

1.4	Reporting and record-keeping requirements in addition to those cited
in condition 12.2 of the Conditions of General Applicability (reporting
of deviations including malfunctions) shall be met in accordance with
§63.1354 and §63.1355, respectively.

	§4-3, §4-41, Rules 15 (Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subparts F and Y) and 16
(Title 40 CFR Part 63 Subpart LLL)

 

	Permittee is subject to Title 40 CFR Part 64 Compliance Assurance
Monitoring (CAM) for select pollutant specific emission units (PSEU)
pursuant to the rule requirements and as listed in the source's CAM
plan.  The compliance requirements under conditions 1.5, 1.6 and 2.0
provide the monitoring parameters and ranges representing compliance for
those PSEU's subject to CAM.	  

	

	1.5	Baghouse Monitoring (CAM): Permittee shall operate each CAM PSEU
baghouse 		within its specified differential pressure (dP) range except
during start-up 				following bag 	change-out when bag fabric is not
loaded and therefore indicating 			low dP. The following Table I lists
the specified baghouse dP, which are from 			manufacturer's
recommendations and/or performance history. 

Table I     Baghouse dP

Baghouse #	Range (inches of water)

2	2-6 

3	2-6 

5	*

6	2-6 

13	2-6 

14	2-6

15	2-6

16	1-7

29	2-6

30	2-6

* Baghouse 5 is not subject to a dP requirement due to the COM
requirement under §60.63(b) of Subpart F and the recognition of this
feature at §64.3(d) of the CAM rule.

	 

1.6	Permittee shall measure and record the operating dP of each baghouse
at least once per month. If the baghouse is operating outside the
specified range, corrective action shall be taken to bring the dP within
range as soon as possible and the occurrence shall be reported as a
deviation. If the baghouse is believed to be operating effectively, but
outside the specified dP range (for example at start-up following bag
change-out or where the baghouse emissions influent is extremely low) a
written note shall be logged explaining why and the occurrence shall be
reported as a deviation. Baghouse maintenance records shall include
date, personnel initials, and corrective action taken, when applicable.

§4-41, Rule 16.5(c) and Rule 16.6 (40 CFR §64.3(b)(4)(iii)), §4-57

2.0	Qualitative Visible Emissions

 

	The following requirement applies to all emissions units, except those
covered by a 	continuous opacity monitor.

Daily qualitative visible emissions (VE) observations shall be conducted
and documented.  If emissions exceeding 10% opacity are observed, the
source shall perform a certified visible opacity reading using EPA
Reference Method 9, 	Title 40 CFR Part 60, Appendix A (July 1, 1996) and
in accordance with Section 4-3 of the Chattanooga Air Pollution Control
Ordinance (the Ordinance) at the emission point(s) in question.  If the
applicable opacity limitation has been exceeded, then certified readings
shall be conducted and documented on a daily basis until corrective
action has eliminated the excess visible emissions. This information
shall be recorded daily in a log.  Logging shall include, at a minimum,
the date and result of the observation, action(s) taken, if any,
including results of visible emissions readings as well as corrective
action, and the initials of the observer.  

§4-41, Rule 16.5(c) and Rule 16.6 (40 CFR §64.3(a)(1), §4-57

3.0	Semiannual Compliance Monitoring Reports

	

In addition to the conditions of general applicability and any other
requirements cited in this permit, semiannual compliance monitoring
reports are required.  The initial report is due no later than 30 days
after the end of the 6-month period following original permit issuance. 
Subsequent reports are due no later than 30 days after each subsequent
six-month period.  The following shall be included in the compliance
report:

 

3.1	A written summary of operating upsets in the most recent 6-month
period including malfunctions and exceedances to any emissions or
opacity standard in this permit.  This summary shall include the time
and duration of each such incident (excluding start-ups and shutdowns),
the reason(s), and corrective action taken; 		

3.2	A written summary of periodic maintenance to equipment and/or
instrumentation that demonstrates compliance with any requirement of
this permit including, but not limited to, those actions ensuring the
reliability of the back-end kiln oxygen monitoring instrumentation.

	§4-57(a)(3)(ii)

4.0	Visible Emissions (haul roads)

Haul road traffic that results in visible emissions is subject to the
visible emission limits listed in Condition 18 of the Conditions of
General Applicability of this permit (20% opacity).  Visible opacity
from haul roads shall be determined by Tennessee Visible Emission
Evaluation (TVEE) Method 1, Visible Emissions Evaluation Instruction
Manual, August 1988, as amended in 1995, issued by the Tennessee
Department of Health and Environment Division of Air Pollution Control.
Compliance with this limit shall be achieved by, but not limited to, wet
suppression, operational changes/limitations, and/or those techniques
listed in the Fugitive Dust Plan.  §4-41, Rule 11.2

5.0	Replacement of Equipment

The addition of air pollution control equipment to achieve additional
emissions reductions and/or the replacement of air pollution control
equipment with air pollution control equipment of equal or greater
control efficiency for each pollutant controlled by the original
equipment are changes that qualify as operational flexibility with the
following exception: Air pollution control technology required by any
regulation promulgated pursuant to Section 112 of the Clean Air Act
codified at Title 40 CFR Part 63, including control measures employed to
demonstrate early reductions of hazardous air pollutants, is not
eligible for replacement under operational flexibility.  Operational
flexibility changes are subject to the notification requirements of
Paragraph 15.4. in the conditions of General Applicability. 

6.0	Insignificant Activities

The following insignificant activities were certified in the
permittee’s Part 70 application to be in compliance with
§4-56(c)(12):

	

	6.1	Emergency Generator  		   

	6.2  	Storage Drums	 	 

	6.3   	Gasoline Welders  

	 §4-57(c)(12)

EMISSIONS UNIT SPECIAL CONDITIONS

Emission Unit 10  Precalciner/Kiln

 

1.0	Emissions of CO from the precalciner/kiln (EP2000) shall not exceed
2.77 pounds per ton of clinker or 248 lb/hr (if determined by stack
testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs), not to exceed 1,085
tons/yr.  This limitation is Best Available Control Technology (BACT)
based on the emissions determinations and the BACT analysis submitted by
the source in accordance with Section 4-41, Rule 18 (Prevention of
Significant Air Quality Deterioration, or PSD) of the Ordinance and in
accordance with the PSD Final Determination.  Compliance with this
limitation shall be accomplished by adherence to kiln and precalciner
oxygen level requirements.

	§4-41, Rule 18 (PSD)

2.0	Emissions of NOx from the precalciner/kiln (EU3030 and EP2000) shall
not exceed 1500 ppm and based on the Director’s Final Determination
under the PSD Rule, 1,763 tons/yr (for test sampling purposes, 403 lb/hr
when averaged over any three consecutive 1-hour periods).  These limits
shall be met by adherence with the following: 

2.1	Backend kiln oxygen (O2) shall be measured and recorded at 1-minute
intervals as a predictive indicator of NOx emissions, except during
periods of maintenance and calibration which are required to sustain the
integrity of the O2 instrumentation and are part of the source’s
Inspection and Calibration Procedures; 

2.2	Backend kiln O2 shall not exceed 4.5% (dry volume basis) when
averaged over any three consecutive 1-hour periods;

2.3	The kiln exit oxygen analyzer shall be maintained in accordance with
the source’s Inspection and Calibration Procedures, which shall, at a
minimum, contain those items included in the procedure submitted to the
Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau (Bureau) on 22
March 2002.  Revisions to their procedures will be submitted to the
Bureau Director within 14 days of adoption.

	§4-41, Rule 18 (PSD)

3.0	Emissions of PM from the precalciner/kiln (EP2000) shall not exceed
13.8 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour
test runs). Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by venting
the exhaust through baghouse 5; by operating this baghouse at all times
that material is being processed; and by maintenance of the baghouse in
accordance with the source’s Baghouse Operating and Maintenance Plan. 
This limitation and these requirements are BACT as determined by the
Director, the Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Bureau
(the Bureau) in accordance with Section 4-41, Rule 27 of the Ordinance. 

	Source Request consistent with §4-41, Rule 15 (Title 40 CFR Part 60
Subpart F) ,Rule 18, Rule 27 

4.0	Visible emissions shall not exceed 20% opacity as determined by a
continuous opacity monitoring system (COMS) operated and maintained in
accordance with Title 40 CFR §60.63(b).  §4-41, Rule 15 (Title 40 CFR
Part 60 Subpart F)

5.0	Emissions of SO2 from the precalciner/kiln (EP2000) shall not exceed
500 ppm and, based on the Bureau Director’s Final Determination under
PSD Rule 18, 89.5 lb/hr.   

	§4-41, Rule 13.1, Rule 18

 

6.0	The permittee shall be required to obtain written approval from the
Bureau Director prior to changing the type of raw materials and/or fuels
to be used in the cement kiln or precalciner, other than those which are
considered to be traditional materials and fuels in the manufacture of
cement clinker.  Traditional raw materials mean calcium carbonate,
aluminum, silica, iron, and water; and fuels consisting of petroleum
coke, coal, tires, and #2 fuel oil.

	§4-41, Rule 13.1, Rule 18 

 

7.0	Emissions of VOCs from the precalciner/kiln (EP2000) shall not
exceed 10.7 lb/hr.  Compliance with this limitation shall be
accomplished by adherence to kiln and precalciner oxygen level
requirements.

	§4-41, Rule 18, Rule 25.3

Emission Unit 11  Raw Material Handling and Preparation

1.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP1000 (Baghouse 1) shall not
exceed 0.543 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with these limitations shall be achieved
by operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed
and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

2.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP1010 (Baghouse 2) shall not
exceed 0.634 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs). Compliance with these limitations shall be achieved
by operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed
and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

3.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP1020 (Baghouse 3) shall not
exceed 0.943 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with these limitations shall be achieved
by operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed
and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

4.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP3000 (Baghouse 6) shall not
exceed 0.509 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

5.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP3010 (Baghouse 7) shall not
exceed 0.136 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan. 

6.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust points EP3020 and EP7160 combined
(Baghouses 8 and 48)  shall not exceed 0.203 lb/hr (if determined by
stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs).  Compliance with
this limitation shall be achieved by operating the baghouse at all times
that material is being processed and by maintenance of the baghouse in
accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance plan.  

7.0	Raw material handling and preparation emission points are subject to
Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F, which includes the following:

	7.1	Visible emissions shall not exhibit 10% opacity or greater,
averaged over any 6-minute period in accordance with §60.62(c);

	7.2	Record-keeping and reporting requirements as described in §60.65.

§4-41, Rule 18, Rule 27, Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F

Emission Unit 12  Clinker Handling and Storage

 

1.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP3060 (Baghouse 12) shall not
exceed 0.185 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

2.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP3070 (baghouse 13) shall not
exceed 0.618 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan. 

3.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP5000 (baghouse 14) shall not
exceed 0.742 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

4.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP5010 (baghouse 15) shall not
exceed 0.464 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

5.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP6000 (baghouse 19) shall not
exceed 0.069 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse at all times that material is being processed and
by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

6.0	Emissions of PM from each of exhaust points EP6010, EP6020, EP6030
and EP6040 (baghouses 20-23) shall not exceed 0.096 lb/hr (if determined
by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs).  Compliance
with this limitation shall be achieved by operating the respective
baghouses at all times that material is being processed and by
maintenance of the baghouses in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.

7.0	Emissions of PM from each of exhaust points EP6050 (baghouse 24) and
EP7150 (baghouse 47) shall not exceed 0.103 lb/hr (if determined by
stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs).  Compliance with
this limitation shall be achieved by operating each baghouse at all
times that material is being processed and by maintenance of the
baghouses in accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance
plan.

8.0	Clinker Handling and Storage emission units are subject to Title 40
CFR Part 60 Subpart F, which includes the following:

	8.1	Visible emissions shall not exhibit 10% opacity or greater,
averaged over any 6-minute period, in accordance with §60.62(c);

	8.2	Record-keeping and reporting requirements as described in §60.65.

 §4-41, Rule 18, Rule 27, Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F

Emission Unit 13  Fuel Handling and Storage

 

1.0	Particulate matter (PM) emissions from fossil fuel grinding at
exhaust point EP4000 (baghouse 4) shall not exceed 0.643 lb/hr (if
determined by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs). 
Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by operating the
baghouse at all times that material is being processed and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.

2.0	Particulate matter (PM) emissions from fossil fuel grinding at
exhaust point EP4010 (baghouse 16) shall not exceed 2.27 lb/hr (if
determined by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test runs). 
Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by operating the
baghouse at all times that material is being processed and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.

3.0	PM emissions from exhaust points EP4020 (baghouse 17) and EP4030
(baghouse 18) shall not exceed 0.013 lb/hr at each of these emission
points (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test
runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by operating
the respective baghouses at all times that material is being processed
and by maintenance of the baghouses in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan. 

	

4.0	The fuel handling and storage system is subject to Title 40 CFR Part
60 Subpart Y, which includes the following:

	4.1	PM emissions at each subject emission unit shall not exceed 0.070
g/dscm (0.031 gr/dscf) in accordance with §60.252;

  

	4.2	Visible emissions shall not exhibit 20% opacity or greater,
averaged over any 6-minute period, in accordance with §60.252(a)(2) and
(c);

	4.3	Monitoring requirements as described in §60.253

5.0	The fuel handling and storage system is subject to §4-48(d) of the
Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance, Title 40 CFR Part 64 -
Compliance Assurance Monitoring (CAM). 

 §4-41, Rule 15 (40 CFR Part 60 Subpart Y), Rule 18, Rule 27, §4-48 (
Title 40 CFR Part 64)

	 



Emission Unit 14  Product Finishing and Handling

1.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP6060 (baghouse 25) shall not
exceed 2.305 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
venting the finish mill and separator exhaust through baghouse 25, which
shall be operating at all times when material is being processed and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.

2.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP6070 (baghouse 26) shall not
exceed 6.964 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs).  Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
venting the finish mill and separator exhaust through baghouse 26, which
shall be operating at all times when material is being processed and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.

§4-41, Rule 18, Rule 27

3.0	Product finishing and handling emission points EP6060 and EP6070 are
subject to Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F, which includes, but may not
be limited to, the following:

	3.1	Visible emissions shall not exhibit 10% opacity or greater,
averaged over any 6-minute period, in accordance with §60.62(c);

	3.2	Record-keeping and reporting requirements as described in §60.65.

§4-41, Rule 15 (Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F)

4.0	Emissions of PM from each of exhaust points EP6100 and EP6110
(baghouse 29 and 30) shall not exceed 0.020 gr/dscf.  Compliance with
this limitation shall be achieved by venting each system exhaust through
a Fuller Dracco #52 Multibag baghouse; by operating the respective
baghouse during ball mill operations and by maintenance of the baghouse
in accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance plan.

§4-41, Rule 26.14(2)

Emission Unit 15  Finish Materials Storage and Handling

1.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7000 (baghouse 32) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 1, 2, and 3 through a Fuller Norblo baghouse
and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.  

 

2.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7010 (baghouse 33) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 4, 5, and 6 through a Fuller Norblo baghouse
and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s
operations and maintenance plan.  

	 

3.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7020 (baghouse 34) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 7, 8, and 9 through a Fuller baghouse and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.	  	 

	

4.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7030 (baghouse 35) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 10, 11, and 12 through an ICA baghouse and by
maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations
and maintenance plan.

	 	 

5.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7040 (baghouse 36) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 13 and 14 through a Fuller Model 2-MB-32
baghouse and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the
source’s operations and maintenance plan. 	 

6.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7050 (baghouse 37) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silo 15 and bulk truck loadout (EU7050 and EU7150)
through a Fuller Model 2-MB-32 baghouse and by maintenance of the
baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance
plan.

	 

7.0	Emissions of PM from exhaust point EP7060 (baghouse 38) shall not
exceed 0.020 gr/dscf. Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved
by venting storage silos 16 and 17 through a Fuller Model 2-MB-32
baghouse and by maintenance of the baghouse in accordance with the
source’s operations and maintenance plan.

§4-41, Rule 26.14

River Storage and Transport

8.0	Emissions of PM from the river cement silo (baghouse 27) shall not
exceed 0.757 lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three
1-hour test runs). Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by
operating the baghouse during silo loading and by maintenance of the
baghouse in accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance
plan.

9.0	Emissions of PM from the barge (baghouse 28) shall not exceed 1.422
lb/hr (if determined by stack testing, averaged over three 1-hour test
runs). Compliance with this limitation shall be achieved by operating
the baghouse during system operation and by maintenance of the baghouse
in accordance with the source’s operations and maintenance plan.

§4-41, Rule 27, Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F

   

10.0	Finish materials storage and handling emissions points EP6080,
EP6090 and EP7120 are subject to Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F, which
includes the following: 

	10.1	Visible emissions shall not exhibit 10% opacity or greater,
averaged over any 6-minute period, in accordance with §60.62(c);

	10.2	Record-keeping and reporting requirements as described in §60.65.

 §4-41, Rule 15 (Title 40 CFR Part 60 Subpart F), Rule 18, Rule 26.14

11.0	Emissions of PM from loadout operations, conveyance for loadout,
and packing 	operations (baghouses 39-43) shall not exceed 0.020
gr/dscf. Compliance with this 	limitation shall be achieved by operating
each baghouse during respective system 	operation and by maintenance of
the baghouses in accordance with the source’s 	operations and
maintenance plan. 

	§4-41, Rule 26.14(2)

PERMIT SHIELD

At the request of the responsible official who signed and certified to
the Part 70 permit application, compliance with the conditions of this
permit shall be deemed compliance with any "applicable requirements", as
defined in §4-53 of the Chattanooga Air Pollution Control Ordinance, as
of the date of permit issuance that (1) are included and specifically
identified in this permit, or (2) have been determined in writing in
this permit not to be applicable to this permittee as specifically
identified.  This permit shield does not alter or affect the following:

(a)	The provisions of Title 42 U.S.C. §7603 (emergency orders),
including the authority of the Administrator or of the
Chattanooga-Hamilton County Air Pollution Control Board or Bureau
Director thereunder;

(b)	The liability of a permittee of a source for any violation of
applicable requirements prior to or at the time of permit issuance;

(c)	The applicable requirements of the acid rain program promulgated
under Title IV of the Clean Air Act consistent with Title 42 U.S.C.
7651g.(a);

(d)	The ability of EPA to obtain information from a source pursuant to
Title 42 U.S.C. §7414, or of the Board or Bureau Director to obtain
information from a source pursuant to the Chattanooga Air Pollution
Control Ordinance or any other provision of local, state or federal law;
and §4-57(f)

(e)	The right of any person to damages or other relief on account of
injury to persons or property and to maintain any action or other
appropriate proceeding therefor; nor does it abridge, limit, impair,
create, enlarge or otherwise affect substantively or procedurally this
right. 

	§4-5(1)

 

 

Signal Mountain Cement Company, L.P	 Page  page \* arabic 15  of 27

2004 Part 70 Permit