Document ID: EPA-HQ-OW-2002-0014-1911
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2003-08-15T04:00Z

MEMORANDUM
Eastern
Research
Group,
Inc.
110
Hartwell
Avenue
Lexington,
MA
02421
Date:
July
29,
2003
To:
James
Covington,
EPA
From:
Cal
Franz,
ERG
Re:
MPP
Industry
Cost
Effectiveness
Analysis
for
Subcategories
E
through
I,
J,
and
L
ERG
projected
economic
impacts
on
the
Meat
and
Poultry
Products
(
MPP)
industry
based
on
costs
received
from
Tetra
Tech
on
June
27,
2003
and
loads
received
from
Tetra
Tech
on
July
3,
2003.
The
attached
tables
show
the
results
of
these
analyses.
All
results
are
presented
by
subcategory.

Aggregating
Facilities,
Compliance
Costs,
And
Pollutant
Loads
ERG
received
estimated
compliance
costs
and
loads
from
Tetra
Tech
for
17
screener
survey
and
2
detailed
survey
facilities.
Because
the
analysis
required
mixing
detailed
survey
and
screener
survey
data,
ERG
aggregated
the
two
detailed
facilities
and
three
screener
survey
facilities
into
two
 
dummy 
facilities.
For
computational
convenience,
the
remaining
14
screener
survey
facilities
were
aggregated
into
six
dummy
facilities.
This
aggregation
only
occurred
when
identical
model
facilities
were
assigned
to
screener
survey
facilities
with
identical
production
processes
and
size,
hence
no
information
was
lost
in
the
aggregation.

In
order
to
perform
the
screener
survey
aggregation,
ERG:

C
assigned
each
facility
to
a
North
American
Industrial
Classification
System
(
NAICS)
code
based
on
production
processes:
 
red
meat
further
processors
were
assigned
to
NAICS
311612:
Meat
Processed
from
Carcasses
 
poultry
further
processors
were
assigned
to
NAICS
311615:
Poultry
Processing
 
renderers
were
assigned
to
NAICS
311613:
Rendering
and
Meat
Byproduct
Processing
 
mixed
meat
further
processors
were
assigned
to
NAICS
311612:
Meat
Processed
from
Carcasses
C
estimated
screener
facility
revenues
by
multiplying
facility
production
(
data
provided
by
Tetra
Tech)
and
market
model
baseline
prices;

C
assigned
a
model
facility
from
the
appropriate
NAICS
code
to
each
screener
facility
by
matching
estimated
screener
survey
facility
revenues
with
model
facility
revenues
C
aggregated
all
screener
facilities
with
identical
model
facilities,
process
classes,
and
production
levels
(
e.
g.,
small
or
nonsmall)
into
a
single
 
dummy 
facility
with
a
weight
equal
to
the
sum
of
the
component
screener
survey
weights.

1
The
two
detailed
survey
facilities
were
aggregated
with
three
screener
survey
facilities
following
an
identical
process,
with
one
exception.
Because
screener
survey
and
detailed
survey
weights
are
not
additive,
a
dummy
facility
composed
of
both
screener
and
detailed
facilities
has
a
weight
equal
to
the
sum
of
the
screener
facilities 
weights.

Estimated
compliance
costs
for
the
dummy
facilities
were
calculated
as
a
weighted
average
of
the
constituent
screener
survey
facility
costs.
For
the
dummy
facilities
composed
of
both
detailed
and
screener
survey
facilities,
compliance
costs
were
calculated
as
a
simple
average
of
both
types
of
facility
costs
(
as
directed
by
Jade
Freeman
in
her
e­
mail
of
July
14,
2003).
Total
costs
are
thus
equal
to
each
dummy
facility s
costs
multiplied
by
its
facility
weight,
and
summed
over
all
facilities.

Pollutant
loads
were
aggregated
for
the
dummy
facilities
in
an
identical
manner.
Estimated
loads
for
the
dummy
facilities
were
calculated
as
a
weighted
average
of
the
constituent
screener
survey
facility
loads.
For
the
dummy
facilities
composed
of
both
detailed
and
screener
survey
facilities,
loads
were
calculated
as
a
simple
average
of
both
types
of
facility
loads.
Total
loads
are
equal
to
each
dummy
facility s
loads
multiplied
by
the
its
facility
weight,
and
summed
over
all
facilities.

Other
Methodological
Issues
C
A
6.6
percent
discount
rate
was
used
in
the
cost
annualization
and
closure
models;
this
is
a
weighted
average
of
the
discount
rate
data
provided
in
the
detailed
surveys.

C
ERG
assumed
dummy
facilities
would
receive
no
tax
shield
from
the
increased
compliance
costs;
pre­
and
post­
tax
costs
are
identical.

C
Eight
(
weighted)
mixed
meat
processors
that
produce
at
least
85
percent
red
meat
by
weight
were
assigned
to
subcategory
E
through
I.
An
additional
eight
(
weighted)
mixed
meat
processors
produce
approximately
30
percent
to
50
percent
red
meat;
for
the
purpose
of
this
analysis,
these
were
not
assigned
to
a
subcategory.

C
an
option
for
a
subcategory
is
considered
 
dominated 
if,
in
total,
facilities:
 
incur
costs
but
have
zero
removals,
 
incur
costs
that
are
higher
than
the
previous
option,
but
have
lower
removals,
or
 
incur
costs
that
are
higher
than
the
previous
option,
but
have
no
additional
removals.

2
Table
1
Total
Compliance
Costs
by
Subcategory
($
1999)

Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
One­
Time
Capital
O&
M
Non­
capital
Post­
tax
Pre­
tax
Option
Costs
Costs
Costs
Annualized
Annualized
Subcategory
E
through
I
Option
2
$
1,709,252
$
522,888
$
0
$
695,594
$
695,594
Option
2+
P
$
13,872,119
$
2,352,913
$
0
$
3,765,246
$
3,765,246
Option
2.5
$
5,994,820
$
895,634
$
14,234
$
1,508,119
$
1,508,119
Option
2.5+
P
$
14,470,579
$
2,702,189
$
14,234
$
4,175,518
$
4,175,518
Option
4
$
15,975,161
$
3,190,886
$
58,948
$
4,820,676
$
4,820,676
Subcategory
J
Option
2
$
0
$
316,615
$
0
$
314,829
$
314,829
Option
2+
P
$
5,815,456
$
4,277,000
$
0
$
4,850,516
$
4,850,516
Option
2.5
$
7,566,842
$
1,058,135
$
142,905
$
1,844,480
$
1,844,480
Option
2.5+
P
$
9,549,416
$
5,088,227
$
142,905
$
6,055,583
$
6,055,583
Option
4
$
12,043,433
$
5,995,835
$
190,541
$
7,219,272
$
7,219,272
Subcategory
L
Option
2
$
405,682
$
103,326
$
0
$
144,434
$
144,434
Option
2+
P
$
496,359
$
244,293
$
0
$
293,925
$
293,925
Option
2.5
$
405,682
$
126,490
$
0
$
167,468
$
167,468
Option
2.5+
P
$
496,359
$
267,458
$
0
$
316,959
$
316,959
Option
4
$
621,325
$
347,771
$
0
$
409,662
$
409,662
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Option
2
$
1,314,277
$
278,577
$
0
$
412,070
$
412,070
Option
2+
P
$
4,071,550
$
955,536
$
0
$
1,368,570
$
1,368,570
Option
2.5
$
2,803,202
$
563,890
$
60,959
$
855,053
$
855,053
Option
2.5+
P
$
5,560,170
$
1,240,849
$
60,959
$
1,811,520
$
1,811,520
Option
4
$
8,863,002
$
1,687,081
$
60,959
$
2,594,660
$
2,594,660
Table
2
Incremental
Cost­
Effectiveness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
Toxics
and
Nonconventionals
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Pounds
Cost
Cost
Pre­
tax
Pounds
Cost
Cost
Annualized
Equivalent
Effectiveness
Effectiveness
Annualized
Equivalent
Effectiveness
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
(
PE)
($
1999/
PE)
($
1981/
PE)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
(
PE)
($
1999/
PE)
($
1981/
PE)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0.0
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
29.7
$
23,422
$
13,665
$
695,594
29.7
$
23,422
$
13,665
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
29.7
$
126,784
$
73,970
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
29.7
$
50,782
$
29,628
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
29.7
$
140,599
$
82,030
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
39.2
$
123,046
$
71,789
$
4,125,082
9.5
$
435,147
$
253,877
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0.0
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
89.6
$
3,513
$
2,050
$
314,829
89.6
$
3,513
$
2,050
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
89.6
$
54,131
$
31,582
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
180.3
$
10,231
$
5,969
$
1,529,651
90.7
$
16,868
$
9,841
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
180.3
$
33,588
$
19,596
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
7,219,272
198.6
$
36,357
$
21,212
$
5,374,792
18.3
$
294,109
$
171,592
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0.0
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
10.3
$
13,967
$
8,149
$
144,434
10.3
$
13,967
$
8,149
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
10.3
$
28,422
$
16,582
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
10.3
$
16,194
$
9,448
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
10.3
$
30,650
$
17,882
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
12.6
$
32,605
$
19,023
$
265,228
2.2
$
119,308
$
69,608
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0.0
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
12.3
$
33,633
$
19,622
$
412,070
12.3
$
33,633
$
19,622
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
12.3
$
111,701
$
65,170
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
855,053
12.3
$
69,788
$
40,717
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
12.3
$
147,854
$
86,262
DOM
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
27.3
$
95,093
$
55,480
$
2,182,589
15.0
$
145,182
$
84,704
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
3
Incremental
Cost
Reasonableness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
BOD,
Total
Phosphorus,
&
Total
Nitrogen
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Cost
Pre­
tax
Cost
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
61,209
$
11
$
695,594
61,209
$
11
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
181,579
$
21
$
3,069,652
120,370
$
26
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
61,209
$
25
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
181,579
$
23
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
230,724
$
21
$
1,055,430
49,145
$
21
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
34,176
$
9.21
$
314,829
34,176
$
9.21
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
614,011
$
7.90
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
1,431,897
$
1.29
$
1,529,651
1,397,721
$
1.09
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
2,011,732
$
3.01
$
4,211,104
579,835
$
7.26
Option
4
$
7,219,272
2,195,245
$
3.29
$
1,163,688
183,513
$
6.34
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
17,688
$
23
$
409,662
17,688
$
23
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
15,150
$
27
$
412,070
15,150
$
27
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
61,836
$
22
$
956,499
46,686
$
20
Option
2.5
$
855,053
15,150
$
56
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
61,836
$
29
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
77,780
$
33
$
1,226,090
15,944
$
77
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
4
Incremental
Cost­
Effectiveness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
Conventional
Pollutants
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Cost
Pre­
tax
Cost
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
113,525
$
6
$
695,594
113,525
$
6
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
113,525
$
33
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
113,525
$
13
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
113,525
$
37
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
135,449
$
36
$
4,125,082
21,924
$
188
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
34,176
$
9
$
314,829
34,176
$
9
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
34,176
$
142
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
34,176
$
54
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
34,176
$
177
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
7,219,272
56,604
$
128
$
6,904,443
22,428
$
308
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
1,879
$
218
$
409,662
1,879
$
218
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
15,421
$
27
$
412,070
15,421
$
27
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
15,421
$
89
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
855,053
15,421
$
55
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
15,421
$
117
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
33,275
$
78
$
2,182,589
17,854
$
122
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
5
Incremental
Nutrient
Cost­
Effectiveness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
Total
Nutrients
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Cost
Pre­
tax
Cost
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
120,370
$
31
$
3,765,246
120,370
$
31
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
120,370
$
35
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
164,551
$
29
$
1,055,430
44,181
$
24
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
579,835
$
8.37
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
1,397,721
$
1.32
$
1,844,480
1,397,721
$
1.32
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
1,977,557
$
3.06
$
4,211,104
579,835
$
7.26
Option
4
$
7,219,272
2,158,511
$
3.34
$
1,163,688
180,955
$
6.43
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
17,247
$
24
$
409,662
17,247
$
24
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
46,686
$
29
$
1,368,570
46,686
$
29
Option
2.5
$
855,053
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
46,686
$
39
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
49,394
$
53
$
1,226,090
2,708
$
453
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
6
Incremental
Nutrient
Cost­
Effectiveness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
Total
Phosphorus
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Cost
Pre­
tax
Cost
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
120,370
$
31
$
3,765,246
120,370
$
31
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
120,370
$
35
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
149,610
$
32
$
1,055,430
29,240
$
36
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
579,835
$
8.37
$
4,850,516
579,835
$
8
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
579,835
$
10.44
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
7,219,272
611,984
$
11.80
$
2,368,755
32,149
$
74
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
2,721
$
151
$
409,662
2,721
$
151
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
46,686
$
29
$
1,368,570
46,686
$
29
Option
2.5
$
855,053
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
46,686
$
39
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
49,071
$
53
$
1,226,090
2,385
$
514
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
7
Incremental
Nutrient
Cost­
Effectiveness
of
Pollution
Control
Options:
Total
Nitrogen
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Average
Incremental
Pre­
tax
Cost
Pre­
tax
Cost
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Annualized
Pounds
Effectiveness
Option
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)
Costs
($
1999)
Removed
($
1999/
pound)

Subcategory
E
through
I
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
695,594
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
3,765,246
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,508,119
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
4,175,518
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
4,820,676
14,941
$
323
$
4,820,676
14,941
$
323
Subcategory
J
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
314,829
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
4,850,516
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
1,844,480
1,397,721
$
1.32
$
1,844,480
1,397,721
$
1.32
Option
2.5+
P
$
6,055,583
1,397,721
$
4.33
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
7,219,272
1,546,527
$
4.67
$
5,374,792
148,806
$
36.12
Subcategory
L
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
144,434
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
293,925
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
167,468
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
316,959
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
409,662
14,526
$
28
$
409,662
14,526
$
28
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Baseline
$
0
0
NA
NA
NA
NA
Option
2
$
412,070
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2+
P
$
1,368,570
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5
$
855,053
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
2.5+
P
$
1,811,520
0
Undefined
DOM
DOM
DOM
Option
4
$
2,594,660
324
$
8,019
$
2,594,660
324
$
8,019
DOM:
Option
is
dominated;
it
either
has
(
1)
higher
cost
than
following
option,
resulting
in
a
negative
incremental
CE,
or
(
2)
it
has
higher
cost
than
the
previous
option
but
no
additional
removals,
resulting
in
an
undefined
incremental
CE.
Table
8A
Pollutant
Removals
by
Option,
Subcategory
E
through
I
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Removals
(
Pounds
per
Year)
Toxic
Removals
(
Pounds
Equivalent
per
Year)

Weighting
Pollutant
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Factor
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Toxics
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
16,228
16,228
16,228
16,228
21,409
1.83E­
003
29.7
29.7
29.7
29.7
39.2
Barium
0
0
0
0
0
1.99E­
003
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Carbaryl
0
0
0
0
0
2.80E+
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Chromium
0
0
0
0
0
7.57E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Cis­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Copper
0
0
0
0
0
6.27E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Manganese
0
0
0
0
0
7.04E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Molybdenum
0
0
0
0
0
2.01E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nickel
0
0
0
0
0
1.09E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
0
6.20E­
005
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Titanium
0
0
0
0
0
2.93E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Trans­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Vanadium
0
0
0
0
0
6.22E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Zinc
0
0
0
0
0
4.67E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total
16,228
16,228
16,228
16,228
21,409
29.7
29.7
29.7
29.7
39.2
Pollutants
for
Cost
Reasonableness
Test
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
61,209
61,209
61,209
61,209
66,173
NA
Total
Phosphorus
0
120,370
0
120,370
149,610
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,941
NA
Total
61,209
181,579
61,209
181,579
230,724
Conventionals
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
61,209
61,209
61,209
61,209
66,173
NA
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
NA
Total
Suspended
Solids
52,317
52,317
52,317
52,317
69,276
NA
Total
113,525
113,525
113,525
113,525
135,449
Nutrients
Total
Phosphorus
0
120,370
0
120,370
149,610
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,941
NA
Total
0
120,370
0
120,370
164,551
Table
8B
Pollutant
Removals
by
Option,
Subcategory
J
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Removals
(
Pounds
per
Year)
Toxic
Removals
(
Pounds
Equivalent
per
Year)

Weighting
Pollutant
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Factor
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Toxics
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
48,965
48,965
48,965
48,965
56,388
1.83E­
003
89.6
89.6
89.6
89.6
103.2
Barium
0
0
0
0
0
1.99E­
003
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Carbaryl
0
0
0
0
0
2.80E+
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Chromium
0
0
0
0
0
7.57E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Cis­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Copper
0
0
0
0
0
6.27E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Manganese
0
0
0
0
0
7.04E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Molybdenum
0
0
0
0
0
2.01E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nickel
0
0
0
0
0
1.09E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
1,462,661
1,462,661
1,538,322
6.20E­
005
0.0
0.0
90.7
90.7
95.4
Titanium
0
0
0
0
0
2.93E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Trans­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Vanadium
0
0
0
0
0
6.22E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Zinc
0
0
0
0
0
4.67E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total
48,965
48,965
1,511,626
1,511,626
1,594,711
89.6
89.6
180.3
180.3
198.6
Pollutants
for
Cost
Reasonableness
Test
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
34,176
34,176
34,176
34,176
36,734
NA
Total
Phosphorus
0
579,835
0
579,835
611,984
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
1,397,721
1,397,721
1,546,527
NA
Total
34,176
614,011
1,431,897
2,011,732
2,195,245
Conventionals
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
34,176
34,176
34,176
34,176
36,734
NA
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
NA
Total
Suspended
Solids
0
0
0
0
19,871
NA
Total
34,176
34,176
34,176
34,176
56,604
Nutrients
Total
Phosphorus
0
579,835
0
579,835
611,984
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
1,397,721
1,397,721
1,546,527
NA
Total
0
579,835
1,397,721
1,977,557
2,158,511
Table
8C
Pollutant
Removals
by
Option,
Subcategory
L
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Removals
(
Pounds
per
Year)
Toxic
Removals
(
Pounds
Equivalent
per
Year)

Weighting
Pollutant
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Factor
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Toxics
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
5,651
5,651
5,651
5,651
6,694
1.83E­
003
10.3
10.3
10.3
10.3
12.2
Barium
0
0
0
0
0
1.99E­
003
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Carbaryl
0
0
0
0
0
2.80E+
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Chromium
0
0
0
0
0
7.57E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Cis­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Copper
0
0
0
0
0
6.27E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Manganese
0
0
0
0
0
7.04E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Molybdenum
0
0
0
0
0
2.01E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nickel
0
0
0
0
0
1.09E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
5,080
6.20E­
005
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.3
Titanium
0
0
0
0
0
2.93E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Trans­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Vanadium
0
0
0
0
0
6.22E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Zinc
0
0
0
0
0
4.67E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total
5,651
5,651
5,651
5,651
11,774
10.3
10.3
10.3
10.3
12.6
Pollutants
for
Cost
Reasonableness
Test
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
0
0
0
0
441
NA
Total
Phosphorus
0
0
0
0
2,721
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,526
NA
Total
0
0
0
0
17,688
Conventionals
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
0
0
0
0
441
NA
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
NA
Total
Suspended
Solids
0
0
0
0
1,438
NA
Total
0
0
0
0
1,879
Nutrients
Total
Phosphorus
0
0
0
0
2,721
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,526
NA
Total
0
0
0
0
17,247
Table
8D
Pollutant
Removals
by
Option,
Subcategory
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Removals
(
Pounds
per
Year)
Toxic
Removals
(
Pounds
Equivalent
per
Year)

Weighting
Pollutant
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Factor
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Toxics
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
6,695
6,695
6,695
6,695
14,910
1.83E­
003
12.3
12.3
12.3
12.3
27.3
Barium
0
0
0
0
0
1.99E­
003
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Carbaryl
0
0
0
0
0
2.80E+
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Chromium
0
0
0
0
0
7.57E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Cis­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Copper
0
0
0
0
0
6.27E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Manganese
0
0
0
0
0
7.04E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Molybdenum
0
0
0
0
0
2.01E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nickel
0
0
0
0
0
1.09E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
0
6.20E­
005
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Titanium
0
0
0
0
0
2.93E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Trans­
permethrin
0
0
0
0
0
4.54E+
000
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Vanadium
0
0
0
0
0
6.22E­
001
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Zinc
0
0
0
0
0
4.67E­
002
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
0.0
Total
6,695
6,695
6,695
6,695
14,910
12.3
12.3
12.3
12.3
27.3
Pollutants
for
Cost
Reasonableness
Test
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
15,150
15,150
15,150
15,150
28,385
NA
Total
Phosphorus
0
46,686
0
46,686
49,071
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
324
NA
Total
15,150
61,836
15,150
61,836
77,780
Conventionals
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
15,150
15,150
15,150
15,150
28,385
NA
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
NA
Total
Suspended
Solids
271
271
271
271
4,890
NA
Total
15,421
15,421
15,421
15,421
33,275
Nutrients
Total
Phosphorus
0
46,686
0
46,686
49,071
NA
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
324
NA
Total
0
46,686
0
46,686
49,394
Appendix:
Table
1
Removals
of
Specified
Pollutants
by
Option
Nondetailed
Survey
Facilities
Removals
(
Pounds
per
Year)

Pollutant
Option
2
Option
2+
P
Option
2.5
Option
2.5+
P
Option
4
Subcategory
E
through
I
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
61,209
61,209
61,209
61,209
66,173
Total
Suspended
Solids
52,317
52,317
52,317
52,317
69,276
Chemical
Oxygen
Demand
42,213
42,213
42,213
42,213
42,213
Carbonaceous
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
51,549
51,549
51,549
51,549
51,549
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
16,228
16,228
16,228
16,228
21,409
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,941
Total
Phosphorus
0
120,370
0
120,370
149,610
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
0
Total
Kjeldahl
Nitrogen
28,508
28,508
28,508
28,508
32,414
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
Subcategory
J
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
34,176
34,176
34,176
34,176
36,734
Total
Suspended
Solids
0
0
0
0
19,871
Chemical
Oxygen
Demand
0
0
0
0
0
Carbonaceous
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
28,570
28,570
28,570
28,570
28,570
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
48,965
48,965
48,965
48,965
56,388
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
1,397,721
1,397,721
1,546,527
Total
Phosphorus
0
579,835
0
579,835
611,984
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
1,462,661
1,462,661
1,538,322
Total
Kjeldahl
Nitrogen
51,819
51,819
51,819
51,819
54,788
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
Subcategory
L
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
0
0
0
0
441
Total
Suspended
Solids
0
0
0
0
1,438
Chemical
Oxygen
Demand
43,609
43,609
43,609
43,609
59,123
Carbonaceous
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
337
337
337
337
337
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
5,651
5,651
5,651
5,651
6,694
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
14,526
Total
Phosphorus
0
0
0
0
2,721
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
5,080
Total
Kjeldahl
Nitrogen
3,435
3,435
3,435
3,435
7,711
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0
Unassigned
Mixed
Processors
5­
Day
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
15,150
15,150
15,150
15,150
28,385
Total
Suspended
Solids
271
271
271
271
4,890
Chemical
Oxygen
Demand
0
0
0
0
0
Carbonaceous
Biochemical
Oxygen
Demand
45,288
45,288
45,288
45,288
45,288
Ammonia
as
Nitrogen
6,695
6,695
6,695
6,695
14,910
Total
Nitrogen
0
0
0
0
324
Total
Phosphorus
0
46,686
0
46,686
49,071
Nitrate/
Nitrite
0
0
0
0
0
Total
Kjeldahl
Nitrogen
1,708
1,708
1,708
1,708
14,889
Oil
&
Grease
(
HEM)
0
0
0
0
0