Document ID: EPA-HQ-OAR-2003-0121-0004
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2003-08-22T04:00Z

Date:
May
5,
2003
Subject:
Revised
MACT
Floor,
Regulatory
Alternatives,
and
Nationwide
Impacts
for
Equipment
Leaks
at
Chemical
Manufacturing
Facilities
Miscellaneous
Organic
NESHAP
EPA
Project
No.
95/
08;
RTI
International
Project
No.
08550.001.011
From:
Brenda
Shine,
North
State
Engineering,
Inc.
Melissa
Icenhour,
RTI
International
David
Randall,
RTI
International
To:
MON
Project
Files
I.
Introduction
This
memorandum
describes
existing
and
new
source
MACT
floors
for
equipment
leaks,
regulatory
alternatives
above
the
floor
and
resulting
incremental
cost
effectiveness
of
going
beyond
the
floor.
This
analysis
was
conducted
in
response
to
comments
received
on
the
April
4,
2002
proposal.

II.
Discussion
A.
Summary
of
Comments
1.
Process­
Based
Approach.
The
commenters
argued
that
the
approach
for
setting
the
floor
on
a
facility
wide
basis,
as
documented
in
the
MACT
floor
memorandum
may
not
have
adequately
addressed
variations
in
level
of
control
of
LDAR
programs
within
facilities.
1
The
Section
114
information
survey
requested
some
specific
information
about
LDAR
programs,
but
did
not
prompt
respondents
to
specifically
identify
each
LDAR
program
corresponding
to
each
MON
process,
if
different
programs
were
in
use
for
separate
MON
processes
at
the
facility.
Upon
review
of
our
data,
we
noted
that
there
are
circumstances
where
different
processes
are
controlled
by
different
LDAR
programs.
Therefore,
we
reviewed
our
database
and
reanalyzed
our
data
on
a
process
basis.

2.
Corrections
to
the
Database.
Commenters
recommended
numerous
changes
to
the
database.
We
reviewed
suggested
changes
and
revised
database
entries
under
the
following
two
circumstances:
(
1)
when
the
process
is
subject
to
the
HON
so
that
only
the
batch
process
vent
emissions
are
subject
to
the
MON
and
(
2)
when
the
facility
contact
indicated
to
the
commenter
2
that
a
non­
HON
LDAR
program
or
no
program
is
implemented
for
a
MON
process.
The
following
specific
changes
were
made
to
the
database:

#
Six
processes
at
the
Dixie
Chemical
Company
plant
were
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
in
our
original
database;
these
have
been
changed
to
TX
28MID.

#
Three
processes
at
the
Exxon
Chemical
Americas,
Bayway
Chemical
Plant
were
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
in
our
original
database;
these
have
been
changed
to
NSPS
VV.

#
Five
processes
at
the
Lubrizol,
Deer
Park
Plant
were
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
in
our
original
database;
these
have
been
changed
to
TX
28
MID.

#
Six
processes
at
the
Lubrizol,
Bayport
Plant
were
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
in
our
original
database;
these
have
been
changed
to
TX
28
MID.

#
We
deleted
entries
for
two
processes
at
the
Velsicol
Chemical
Corporation
Plant
that
are
subject
to
the
HON.

#
We
deleted
entries
for
three
processes
at
the
Kalama
Chemical,
Inc.
plant
that
are
subject
to
the
HON.

#
Of
11
processes
at
the
Witco
Corp.,
Sistersville
Plant
that
were
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
in
our
original
database,
we
revised
9
to
no
LDAR
program
and
assigned
the
HON
LDAR
program
to
2
processes.
We
also
added
two
additional
processes
and
assigned
no
LDAR
program.

3.
Costs.
Commenters
argued
that
the
proposed
LDAR
requirements
are
not
costeffective
because
the
potential
environmental
benefits
are
much
lower
than
EPA
assumed
based
on
its
SOCMI
factors.
Commenters
submitted
leak
data
from
their
industry
to
support
their
arguments.
They
also
listed
several
basic,
and
expensive,
requirements
that
would
have
to
be
implemented
to
make
an
LDAR
program
effective,
such
as
identifying
subject
equipment,
creating
facility
drawings,
developing
and
populating
a
data
management
system,
conducting
physical
tagging
of
components,
developing
a
system
to
coordinate
with
O&
M
personnel,
assigning
personnel
to
coordinate
the
program,
and
training
personnel.
In
arguing
cost
effectiveness
of
Method
21­
based
monitoring,
commenters
also
suggested
that
our
cost
analysis
was
obscured
by
the
inclusions
of
cost
effective
elements(
design
standards
and
audible/
visual/
olfactory­
based
program)
with
the
Method
21
portion.

B.
Revisions
1.
Revised
MACT
Floor.
Prior
to
making
the
revisions
noted
above,
we
analyzed
our
database
on
a
process
basis
and
found
that
85
of
the
1,142
processes
(
7.4
percent)
in
our
database
were
reported
to
be
controlled
by
HON­
equivalent
LDAR
programs.
This
analysis
includes
all
processes
in
the
database;
we
did
not
attempt
to
identify
continuous
processes
versus
batch
processes
because
many
processes
include
both
continuous
and
batch
operations.
After
making
3
the
revisions,
51
of
1,139
processes
are
controlled
to
the
HON
LDAR,
or
4.5
percent
controlled.
Based
on
this
result,
we
could
not
justify
a
MACT
floor
at
the
HON
level
of
control.

The
NSPS
subpart
VV
LDAR
was
written
into
40
CFR
Part
63
as
subpart
TT
(
Control
Level
1),
and
the
CAR
LDAR
program
was
written
into
Part
63
as
subpart
UU
(
Control
Level
2).
Therefore,
all
Part
63
standards
can
cross
reference
either
subpart
TT
or
subpart
UU,
depending
on
the
program
desired.
For
MACT
standards
promulgated
after
the
promulgation
dates
of
subparts
TT
and
UU,
options
are
the
adoption
of
either
subpart
TT
or
subpart
UU,
and
not
subpart
H.
The
HON
subpart
H
program
is
an
older
LDAR
program
that
has
been
improved
on
in
subpart
UU
by
providing
more
flexibility
and
less
burden
while
achieving
similar
reductions.
The
differences
in
moving
from
subpart
H
to
subpart
TT
are
a
change
in
leak
definition
from
500
ppmv
to
10,000
ppmv
for
most
components,
and
no
Method
21
monitoring
for
connectors.
In
moving
from
subpart
H
to
subpart
UU,
an
allowance
is
provided
for
less
frequent
monitoring
based
on
leak
rates.

Therefore,
we
reviewed
the
data
to
determine
how
many
processes
were
controlled
to
a
level
equivalent
to
Subpart
TT.
For
this
analysis,
we
considered
LDAR
programs
such
as
TX28MID,
28M,
TX28RCT,
TX28VHP,
TX
Reg
5,
and
LA
non­
HON,
as
well
as
processes
implementing
40
CFR
60
Subpart
VV.
Only
LDAR
programs
designated
as
audible/
visual/
olfactory
(
e.
g.,
not
Method
21
monitoring)
were
not
considered
at
least
equivalent
to
subpart
TT.
We
found
that
236
of
the
1,139
processes,
or
21
percent
were
controlled
at
least
to
that
level.
Therefore,
we
set
the
floor
for
existing
sources
on
the
requirements
of
subpart
TT.
The
floor
for
new
sources
is
still
the
requirements
of
subpart
UU.

2.
Regulatory
Alternative
Above
the
Floor.
We
conducted
an
analysis
of
the
cost
effectiveness
of
two
regulatory
alternatives
that
are
more
stringent
than
the
MACT
floor.
The
first
regulatory
alternative
would
require
subpart
UU
LDAR
for
all
processes
with
at
least
one
continuous
operation
(
i.
e.,
those
processes
represented
by
the
continuous
model
process
in
the
previous
analysis).
The
second
regulatory
alternative
would
require
the
subpart
UU
LDAR
program
for
all
processes.
In
conducting
this
analysis,
we
revised
our
estimated
uncontrolled
emissions
for
our
model
processes
by
using
the
initial
leak
rates
submitted
by
the
industry
in
their
comments.
2
At
the
leak
definitions
of
500
ppmv
for
connectors
and
valves
and
1,000
ppmv
for
pumps,
we
calculated
leak
rates
of
0.35
percent
for
connectors,
6.47
percent
for
pumps,
and
1.66
percent
for
valves
from
the
data
submitted
by
the
industry.
We
also
compared
these
leak
rates
and
their
resulting
emission
rates
to
data
collected
in
the
development
of
the
Polymers
and
Resins
IV
standard
and
found
good
agreement.
The
Polymers
and
Resins
industry
leak
rates
were
0.61
percent
for
connectors,
8.71
percent
for
pumps,
and
1.4
to
1.8
percent
for
valves.
3
For
reductions
achieved
by
the
programs,
we
assumed
that
the
reduction
achieved
by
the
subpart
UU
program
would
be
equal
to
the
emission
estimated
at
the
performance
level
of
the
program.
We
assumed
that
the
subpart
TT
program
would
be
half
as
effective
as
subpart
UU
for
pumps,
valves,
and
connectors,
and
that
the
reductions
for
pressure
relief
valves,
open­
ended
lines,
and
sampling
connections
would
be
the
same
under
both
programs.
A
tabular
summary
of
our
emission
estimates
is
provided
in
Table
1.
The
resulting
model
plant
emission
estimates
are
provided
in
Table
2.
4
Table
1.
Resulting
Emission
Rates
and
Program
Efficiencies
for
CMA
Data
Component
Leak
Definition
(
ppmv)
Number
Monitored
Number
Leaking
Initial
Leak
Rate
Adjusted
leak
definition
(
ppmv)
Adjusted
Initial
Leak
Rate
Uncontrolled
Emission
Rate
kg/
hr/
sourcea
Average
Initial
Leak
Rate
Average
Uncontrolled
Emission
Rate
kg/
hr/
source
UU
Performance
Levelb
UU
Controlled
Emission
Rates
UU
Control
Eff
TT
Control
Effc
Connectors
500
144792
173
0.12%
500
0.12%
7.32E­
05
0.36%
1.86E­
04
0.25%
1.35E­
04
27.8%
13.8%

10000
19912
168
0.84%
2.11%
1.01E­
03
Pumpsd
500
121
0
0.00%
1000
0.00%
3.10E­
04
6.47%
7.56E­
03
3.04%
3.80E­
03
49.7%
24.9%

1000
683
13
1.90%
1.90%
2.55E­
03
2000
82
0
0.00%
0.19%
6.70E­
04
5000
374
39
10.43%
19.81%
2.23E­
02
10000
662
13
1.96%
5.59%
6.61E­
03
Valvesd
500
62299
312
0.50%
500
0.50%
2.62E­
04
1.66%
3.68E­
04
0.25%
1.45E­
04
60.8%
30.3%

5000
483
0
0.00%
0.18%
8.10E­
05
10000
21185
123
0.58%
5.08%
6.87E­
04
a
Uncontrolled
emission
rate
based
on
the
ALR
Equations
contained
in
Table
5­
4
of
EPA
Protocol
Document.

b
Performance
level
is
the
monitoring
frequency
assumed
to
equal
subsequent
leak
rate.
For
pumps,
the
initial
leak
rate
was
multiplied
by
the
ratio
of
8.04/
17.1,
per
method
described
by
Group
IV
Polymers
and
Resins
Docket
A­
92­
45
Item
No.
IXc­
B­
1,
p.
4.

c
Assumed
to
be
half
as
effective
as
subpart
UU.

d
Uncontrolled
emission
rate
based
on
components
assumed
to
be
in
light
liquid
service.
5
Table
2.
Model
Plant
Emission
Estimates
Component
Components
Continuous
Uncontrolled
Emission
Rate,

Mg/
yr
Controlled
Emission
Rate,
Mg/
yr
Reduction
Components
Batch
Uncontrolled
Emission
Rate,

Mg/
yr
Controlled
Emission
Rate,

Mg/
yr
Reduction
UU
TT
UU
TT
UU
TT
UU
TT
Valves­
g/
vb
44
0.14
0.06
0.10
60.8%
30.4%
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.0%
0.0%

Valves­
llb
526
1.70
0.67
1.18
60.8%
30.4%
61
0.20
0.07
0.14
63.5%
30.3%

Valves­
hla
133
0.27
0.27
0.27
0.0%
0.0%
68
0.14
0.14
0.14
0.0%
0.0%

Pumps­
llb
12
0.80
0.40
0.60
49.7%
24.9%
5
0.33
0.17
0.25
49.7%
24.9%

Pumps­
hla
8
0.60
0.60
0.60
0.0%
0.0%
5
0.38
0.38
0.38
0.0%
0.0%

Compressors
0
Agitatorsa
0
3
0.35
0.35
0.35
0.0%
0.0%

PRVs­
g/
va
1
0.91
0.00
0.00
100%
100%
0
0.00
0.00
0.00
0.0%
0.0%

Open­
ended
linesa
156
2.32
0.00
0.00
100%
100%
11
0.16
0.00
0.00
100.0%
100%

Flanges/
Connectors
(
total)
b
1,067
1.74
1.26
1.50
27.8%
13.8%
324
0.53
0.38
0.46
27.8%
13.8%

Flanges
g/
v
Flanges
ll
Flanges
hl
Sampling
Connectionsa
39
5.12
0.00
0.00
100%
100%
10
1.31
0
0
100.0%
100%

Total
1,986
13.61
3.25
4.25
76.1%
68.7%
3.40
1.49
1.71
56.2%
49.7%

a
Based
on
the
emission
factor
contained
in
the
Alpha
Gamma
1999
memo
entitled
"
Ranking
of
Equipment
Leak
Programs."

b
Based
on
the
emission
factor
calculated
from
the
ALR
equations
and
reported
leak
frequencies.

Emission
Reduction
from
UU,
Mg/
yr
Continuous
Model
Process
10.36
Batch
Model
Process
1.91
6
7
3.
Revisions
to
Cost
Analysis.
We
also
revised
our
cost
analysis
to
address
commenter
concerns.
Table
3
presents
a
summary
of
changes
to
the
cost
elements.
The
revised
analysis
assumes
that
a
facility
required
to
implement
an
LDAR
program
will
hire
a
subcontractor,
based
on
our
understanding
that
this
is
the
preferred
and
common
alternative
over
the
implementation
of
an
in­
house
program.
The
analysis
makes
use
of
revised
data
from
the
project
files
of
the
Polymers
and
Resins
IV
standard,
including
specific
petitioner
comments.
Detailed
costs
for
batch
and
continuous
model
processes
under
subparts
TT
and
UU
are
included
in
Attachment
1.
Attachments
2
through
4
present
the
Microsoft
Access
modules
that
were
used
to
estimate
the
impacts
under
the
MACT
floor
and
the
regulatory
alternatives.
Note
that
references
to
"
HON"
and
"
subpart
VV"
in
the
attachments
mean
subparts
UU
and
TT,
respectively,
for
the
purposes
of
this
analysis.

Table
3.
Revised
Cost
Elements
Cost
element
Previous
analysis
UU
TT
Comments
Initial
monitoring
$/
Comp
Pumps
$
4.65
$
17.70
$
17.70
The
$
17.70
is
based
on
comments
from
PET
producer
Eastman's
experiences,
which
indicated
significantly
greater
initial
costs
than
had
been
previously
assumed;
items
included
in
the
$
17.70
are
walkdown
and
field
verification,
creation
and
issuance
of
drawings,
creation
of
data
forms
and
tags,
hanging
of
tags,
population
of
software,
cost
of
tags,
and
the
initial
monitoring
costs.
The
original
the
$
4.65
was
based
on
$
2.15/
component
for
identification
and
documentation
of
components
and
$
2.50
for
initial
monitoring.
The
$
17.70
cost
was
assumed
to
apply
to
the
UU
and
TT
programs
for
all
components
requiring
M21
periodic
monitoring.
For
connectors
subject
to
TT,
and
initial
cost
of
$
1.13
was
assumed,
the
same
cost
as
applied
to
heavy
liquid
components
in
all
of
the
four
programs.
Valves
$
4.65
$
17.70
$
17.70
Flanges
$
4.65
$
17.70
$
1.13
Heavy
Liquid
$
1.13
$
1.13
$
1.13
Subsequent
Monitoring
$/
Comp
Pumps
$
6.75
$
2.50
$
2.50
No
monitoring
fee
for
components
which
do
not
require
periodic
monitoring.
Valves
$.
75
$
2.50
$
2.50
Flanges
$.
75
$
2.50
$
0
Heavy
Liquid
$
0
$
0
$
0
Table
3.
(
continued)
8
Cost
element
Previous
analysis
UU
TT
Comments
Method
21
Monitoring
Frequencies
(
events/
yr)
Pumps
12
12
12
Valves
4
.5
1
Assumes
skip
monitoring
Flanges
1
.125
0
Assumes
skip
monitoring
Heavy
Liquid
0
0
0
Monitoring
Device
rental
NA
$
1609.53
$
1609.53
Based
on
12­
1day
rentals
(
e.
g.,
monthly
rental
charge);
includes
calibration
and
miscellaneous;
Note
that
this
rental
is
in
addition
to
hiring
a
subcontractor
to
perform
monitoring.
The
original
analysis
assumed
the
cost
of
buying
an
instrument.

Data
Collection
system
NA
$
14,500.00
$
14,500.00
Based
on
P&
R
IV
petitioner's
estimate.
The
facility
must
purchase
software
even
if
monitoring
program
is
subcontracted
out.
The
original
analysis
did
not
include
this
cost,
but
included
a
cost
of
$
7,700
for
every
7,000
components.

Admin
Reports
NA
60
hours
@
$
36.95/
hr
300
hours
@
$
36.95/
hr
300
hours
@
$
36.95/
hr
Costs
for
UU
used
in
P&
R
IV,
petitioner's
estimate;
TT
program
costs
assumed
to
be
same
as
for
UU.

Planning
and
Training
NA
200
hours
@
36.95/
hr
340
hours
@
36.95/
hr
340
hours
@
36.95/
hr
Costs
for
UU
used
in
P&
R
IV
petitioner's
estimate;
TT
program
costs
assumed
to
be
same
as
for
UU.

III.
Results
of
Cost
Analysis
The
results
of
the
cost
analysis
are
presented
in
Table
4.
Attachment
5
presents
the
detailed
analysis
results.
9
Table
4.
Impacts
for
Existing
Sources
Emission
reduction,
Mg/
yr
Total
capital
investment,
$/
yr
Total
annual
cost,
$/
yr
Cost
effectiveness,
$/
Mg
Relative
to
Incremental
Previous
analysis
MACT
floor
13,800
14,100,000
9,320,000
675
N/
A
Current
analysis
MACT
Floor
 
batch
1,430
19,946,000
16,372,000
11,400
N/
A
 
continuous
1,180
9,466,000
3,760,000
3,180
N/
A
 
overall
2,615
29,412,000
20,131,000
7,700
N/
A
Reg
Alt
1
 
batch
1,430
19,946,000
16,372,000
11,400
0
 
continuous
1,360
11,295,000
3,845,000
2,830
470
 
overall
2,790
31,241,000
20,217,000
7,250
470
Reg
Alt
2
 
batch
1,650
25,193,000
17,945,000
10,900
7,200
 
continuous
1,360
11,295,000
3,845,000
2,830
0
 
overall
3,010
36,488,000
21,790,000
7,240
7,200
IV.
Conclusions
The
changes
have
reduced
the
anticipated
emission
reductions
at
the
MACT
floor
by
almost
an
order
of
magnitude
while
more
than
doubling
the
annual
costs.
The
revised
cost
of
the
MACT
floor
for
processes
represented
by
the
continuous
model
process
is
$
3,180/
Mg,
and
the
incremental
cost
of
the
first
regulatory
alternative
(
subpart
UU
for
processes
that
contain
continuous
processes)
is
$
470/
Mg,
both
of
which
are
reasonable.
The
MACT
floor
cost
and
incremental
cost
effectiveness
of
regulatory
alternative
2
(
subpart
UU
for
batch
processes),
however,
are
unreasonable.
Therefore,
we
recommend
using
regulatory
alternative
1
as
the
standard
for
equipment
leaks
at
existing
sources.

V.
References
1.
Memorandum
from
B.
Shine
and
D.
Randall,
MRI,
to
MON
Project
File.
July
31,
2000.
MACT
floor,
regulatory
alternatives,
and
nationwide
impacts
for
equipment
leaks
at
chemical
manufacturing
facilities.

2.
Letter
from
J.
Mayhew,
American
Chemistry
Council,
to
EPA
Docket
No.
A­
96­
04.
June
28,
2002.
Comments
on
Proposed
Miscellaneous
Organic
Chemical
Manufacturing
NESHAP.
Exhibit
J.

3.
Memorandum
from
K.
Barnett,
EPA:
ESD,
to
Group
IV
Polymers
and
Resins
Docket
A­
92­
45.
December
2000.
Final
Analysis
of
Equipment
Leak
Program
for
PET
Facilities
Subject
to
the
Group
IV
Polymers
and
Resins
NESHAP.
Table
7.
A­
1
ATTACHMENT
1
Spreadsheets
Used
to
Estimate
Costs
for
Subpart
TT
and
Subpart
UU
LDAR
Programs
for
the
Model
Batch
and
Continuous
Processes
A­
2
HON
Program
Model
Process
 
Batch
Type
of
Component
Number
of
Components
Initial
Monitoring
Fee
or
Unit
Cost
($/
comp)
Initial
LDAR
Costs
($/
yr)

(
Capital)
Initial
LDAR
Admin.
Costs
Frequency
of
Monitoring
(
times/
yr)
Subsequent
Monitoring
Fee
($/
comp)
or
Charge
(%)
Annual
Monitoring
Costs
($/
yr)
Annual
Maintenance
Costs
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
8
17.70
327.94
12
2.50
318.00
532.61
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
5
1.13
5.65
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
0
17.70
0.00
0.25
2.50
0.00
0.00
*
Light­
liquid
service
61
17.70
1108.55
0.25
2.50
38.13
0.10
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
68
1.13
76.84
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
17.70
0.00
0.125
2.50
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
325
17.70
5771.88
0.125
2.50
101.56
0.25
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
0
78.00
0.00
1
2.00
0.00
0.00
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0
3852.00
0.00
1
5.00
0.00
Open­
ended
Valves
11
102.00
1122.00
5.00
56.10
Sampling
Connections
10
409.00
4090.00
5.00
204.50
Compressor
Vent
6242.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
8
180.00
93.17
Monitoring
Device
0
6500.00
0.00
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
0
0.00
Data
Collection
System
0
1200.00
0.00
Number
of
Subcategories:
1
Administrative
and
Reports
300
36.95
Planning
and
Training
340
36.95
12563.00
TOTALS
12596.03
12563.00
457.69
793.56
Capital
Costs
w/
o
OVA
and
Train
12,596
Annualized
Capital
Costs
3,582
Annual
Expenses
14,018
Annual
Fixed
Costs
($/
yr)
15,296
Annual
Variable
Costs
($/
yr)
2,304
A­
3
HON
Program
Model
Process
 
Batch
(
continued)

Type
of
Component
Initial
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Initial
Number
of
Leaks
Subsequent
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Annual
Number
of
Leaks
Percent
Repaired
OnLine
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
OnLine
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Percent
Requiring
Further
Repair
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
Offline
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Admin.

Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Misc.
Charges
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
6.47
0.52
3.04
2.92
100
16.00
22.50
1050.62
0
80.00
22.50
0.00
420.25
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
1.70
0.00
0.25
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
4.00
22.50
0.00
*
Light­
liquid
service
1.70
1.04
0.25
0.04
75
0.17
22.50
0.11
25
4.00
22.50
0.86
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
0.36
0.00
0.25
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
0.36
1.17
0.25
0.10
75
0.17
22.50
0.29
25
2.00
22.50
1.14
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
0.00
0.00
0.00
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0.00
0.00
0.00
Open­
ended
Valves
0.00
0.00
44.88
Sampling
Connections
0.00
0.00
163.60
Compressor
Vent
0.00
0.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
Monitoring
Device
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
Data
Collection
System
0.00
Administrative
and
Reports
11085.00
Planning
and
Training
TOTALS
1051.02
2.00
11085.00
628.73
A­
4
Batch
SOCMI
Program
Type
of
Component
Number
of
Components
Initial
Monitoring
Fee
or
Unit
Cost
($/
comp)
Initial
LDAR
Costs
($/
yr)
(
Capital)
Initial
LDAR
Admin.
Costs
Frequency
of
Monitoring
(
times/
yr)
Subsequent
Monitoring
Fee
($/
comp)
or
Charge
(%)
Annual
Monitoring
Costs
($/
yr)
Annual
Maintenance
Costs
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
8
17.70
357.02
12
2.50
318.00
305.86
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
5
1.13
5.65
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
17.70
0.00
1
2.50
0.00
*
Light­
liquid
service
61
17.70
1146.73
1
2.50
152.50
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
68
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
0.00
0
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
325
1.13
438.12
0
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
78.00
0.00
1
2.00
0.00
0.00
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0
3852.00
0.00
1
5.00
0.00
Open­
ended
Valves
11
102.00
1122.00
5.00
56.10
Sampling
Connections
10
409.00
4090.00
5.00
204.50
Compressor
Vent
6242.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
8
180.00
107.71
Monitoring
Device
­
Buy
6500.00
0.00
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
0
Data
Collection
System
0
1200.00
0.00
Number
of
Monitoring
Systems:
12
Number
of
Subcategories:
1
Administrative
and
Reports
300
36.95
Planning
and
Training
340
36.95
12,563.00
Data
Entry
­
Initial
0
1.88
0.00
Data
Entry
­
Subsequent
0
0.75
0.00
TOTALS
7344.07
12,563.00
470.50
566.46
Capital
Costs
7,344
Annualized
Capital
Costs
2,838
Annual
Expenses
13,195
Annual
Fixed
Costs
($/
yr)
14,376
Annual
Variable
Costs
($/
yr)
1,657
A­
5
Batch
SOCMI
Program
(
continued)

Type
of
Component
Initial
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Initial
Number
of
Leaks
Subsequent
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Annual
Number
of
Leaks
Percent
Repaired
OnLine
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
OnLine
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Percent
Requiring
Further
Repair
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
Offline
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Admin.

Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Misc.
Charge
s
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
7.48
0.60
1.77
1.70
100
16.00
22.50
611.71
0
80.00
22.50
0.00
244.68
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
7.48
0.00
2.33
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
4.00
22.50
0.00
*
Light­
liquid
service
4.34
2.65
0.54
0.33
75
0.17
22.50
0.93
25
4.00
22.50
7.41
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
1.55
0.00
0.138
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
1.55
5.04
0.138
0.45
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
5.05
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
0.00
0.00
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0.00
0.00
Open­
ended
Valves
0.00
44.88
Sampling
Connections
0.00
163.60
Compressor
Vent
0.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
Monitoring
Device
­
Buy
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
Data
Collection
System
0.00
Administrative
and
Reports
11,085.00
Planning
and
Training
Data
Entry
­
Initial
Data
Entry
­
Subsequent
TOTALS
612.64
7.41
11,085.00
453.16
A­
6
Continuous
SOCMI
Program
Type
of
Component
Number
of
Components
Initial
Monitoring
Fee
or
Unit
Cost
($/
comp)
Initial
LDAR
Costs
($/
yr)
(
Capital)
Initial
LDAR
Admin.
Costs
Frequency
of
Monitoring
(
times/
yr)
Subsequent
Monitoring
Fee
($/
comp)
or
Charge
(%)
Annual
Monitoring
Costs
($/
yr)
Annual
Maintenance
Costs
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
12
17.70
535.54
12
2.50
477.00
458.78
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
8
1.13
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
44
17.70
116.33
1
2.50
110.00
*
Light­
liquid
service
526
17.70
972.47
1
2.50
1,315.00
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
133
1.13
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
1.13
0.00
1
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
1,067
1.13
1032.92
1
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
1
78.00
78.00
1
2.00
2.00
3.90
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
1
3852.00
3852.00
1
5.00
192.60
Open­
ended
Valves
156
102.00
15912.00
5.00
795.60
Sampling
Connections
39
409.00
15951.00
5.00
797.55
Compressor
Vent
6242.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
12
180.00
161.57
Monitoring
Device
­
Buy
6500.00
0.00
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
0
Data
Collection
System
0
1200.00
0.00
Number
of
Monitoring
Days:
12
Number
of
Subcategories:
1
Administrative
and
Reports
300
36.95
Planning
and
Training
340
36.95
12,563.00
Data
Entry
­
Initial
0
1.88
0.00
Data
Entry
­
Subsequent
0
0.75
0.00
TOTALS
48,838.11
12,563.00
1,904.00
2248.43
Capital
Costs
48,838
Annualized
Capital
Costs
8,735
Annual
Expenses
18,052
Annual
Fixed
Costs
($/
yr)
21,619
Annual
Variable
Costs
($/
yr)
5,168
A­
7
Continuous
SOCMI
Program
(
continued)

Type
of
Component
Initial
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Initial
Number
of
Leaks
Subsequent
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Annual
Number
of
Leaks
Percent
Repaired
OnLine
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
OnLine
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Percent
Requiring
Further
Repair
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
Offline
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Admin.

Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Misc.
Charges
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
7.48
0.90
1.77
2.55
100
16.00
22.50
917.57
0
80.00
22.50
0.00
367.03
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
7.48
3.29
2.33
1.03
75
0.17
22.50
2.89
25
4.00
22.50
23.07
*
Light­
liquid
service
4.34
22.83
0.54
2.84
75
0.17
22.50
8.00
25
4.00
22.50
63.91
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
1.55
0.00
0.138
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
1.55
16.54
0.138
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
0.00
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
0.00
3.12
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0.00
154.08
Open­
ended
Valves
0.00
636.48
Sampling
Connections
0.00
638.04
Compressor
Vent
0.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
Monitoring
Device
­
Buy
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
Data
Collection
System
0.00
Administrative
and
Reports
11,085
Planning
and
Training
Data
Entry
­
Initial
Data
Entry
­
Subsequent
TOTALS
928.46
86.98
11,085
1798.75
A­
8
HON
Program
Model
Process
 
Continuous
Type
of
Component
Number
of
Components
Initial
Monitoring
Fee
or
Unit
Cost
($/
comp)
Initial
LDAR
Costs
($/
yr)

(
Capital)
Initial
LDAR
Admin.
Costs
Frequency
of
Monitoring
(
times/
yr)
Subsequent
Monitoring
Fee
($/
comp)
or
Charge
(%)
Annual
Monitoring
Costs
($/
yr)
Annual
Maintenance
Costs
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
12
17.70
491.90
12
2.50
477.00
798.91
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
8
1.13
9.04
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
44
17.70
799.61
0.25
2.50
27.50
0.07
*
Light­
liquid
service
526
17.70
9558.95
0.25
2.50
328.75
0.82
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
133
1.13
150.29
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
17.70
0.00
0.13
2.50
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
1,067
17.70
18949.54
0.13
2.50
333.44
0.83
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
1
78.00
78.00
1
2.00
2.00
3.90
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
1
3852.00
3852.00
1
5.00
192.60
Open­
ended
Valves
156
102.00
15912.00
5.00
795.60
Sampling
Connections
39
409.00
15951.00
5.00
797.55
Compressor
Vent
6242.00
0.00
5.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
12
180.00
139.75
Monitoring
Device
0
6500.00
0.00
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
0
0.00
Data
Collection
System
0
1200.00
0.00
Number
of
Subcategories:
1
Administrative
and
Reports
300
36.95
Planning
and
Training
340
36.95
12563.00
TOTALS
65892.09
12563.00
1168.69
2590.29
Capital
Costs
w/
o
OVA
and
Train
65,892
Annualized
Capital
Costs
11,163
Annual
Expenses
18,570
Annual
Fixed
Costs
($/
yr)
24,384
Annual
Variable
Costs
($/
yr)
5,349
A­
9
HON
Program
Model
Process
 
Continuous
(
continued)

Type
of
Component
Initial
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Initial
Number
of
Leaks
Subsequent
Leak
Frequency
(%)
Annual
Number
of
Leaks
Percent
Repaired
OnLine
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
OnLine
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Percent
Requiring
Further
Repair
Repair
Time
(
hours)
Labor
Charge
($/
hr)
Annual
Offline
Leak
Repair
Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Admin.

Cost
($/
yr)
Annual
Misc.
Charges
($/
yr)

Pump
Seals
*
Light­
liquid
service
6.47
0.78
3.04
4.38
100
16.00
22.50
1575.94
0
80.00
22.50
0.00
630.37
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Valves
*
Gas/
vapor
service
1.70
0.75
0.25
0.03
75
0.17
22.50
0.08
25
4.00
22.50
0.62
2.97
*
Light­
liquid
service
1.70
8.94
0.25
0.33
75
0.17
22.50
0.93
25
4.00
22.50
7.40
35.51
*
Heavy­
liquid
service
Connectors
*
Flanges
­
gas/
vapor
0.36
0.00
0.25
0.00
75
0.17
22.50
0.00
25
2.00
22.50
0.00
0.00
*
Flanges
­
light
liquid
0.36
3.84
0.25
0.33
75
0.17
22.50
0.94
25
2.00
22.50
3.75
36.01
*
Flanges
­
heavy
liquid
Pressure
Relief
Devices
*
Disks
0.00
0.00
3.12
*
Disk
holders,
valves,
etc.
0.00
0.00
154.08
Open­
ended
Valves
0.00
0.00
636.48
Sampling
Connections
0.00
0.00
638.04
Compressor
Vent
0.00
0.00
0.00
Replacement
Pump
Seals
Monitoring
Device
0.00
Monitoring
Device
­
Rent
Data
Collection
System
0.00
Administrative
and
Reports
11085.00
Planning
and
Training
TOTALS
1577.88
11.77
11084.00
2136.58
A­
10
ATTACHMENT
2
Access
Module
Used
to
Calculate
Costs
MACT
Floor
A­
11
MACT
Floor
Access
Module
Option
Compare
Database
Option
Explicit
Public
Sub
LDARCost()
Dim
dbs
As
Database
Dim
rst
As
Recordset
Dim
Batch_
PP
As
Double
'
Count
of
batch
product
process
Dim
Cont_
PP
As
Double
'
count
of
continuous
product
process
Dim
Component
As
Double
'
number
of
components
installed
in
each
facility
Dim
OVA
As
Long
'
number
of
OVA
required
for
each
facility
Dim
OVACost
As
Long
'
cost
for
OVA
required
Const
VVContFC
As
Long
=
48838
'
continuous
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchFC
As
Long
=
7344
'
batch
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVTrain
As
Double
=
12563
'
planing
and
training
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContCC
As
Long
=
8735
'
continuous
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchCC
As
Long
=
2838
'
batch
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContAnnExp
As
Long
=
18052
'
continuous
annual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchAnnExp
As
Long
=
13195
'
batch
anual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVRC
As
Double
'
recovery
credit
for
SubpartVV
Dim
ProType
As
String
'
process
type
Dim
UnctrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
Uncontrolled
emissions
Dim
CtrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
controlled
emissions
Dim
TTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
Dim
TTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
Dim
RC
As
Long
'
total
recovery
credit
Dim
Recovery
As
Double
'
reduction
in
emission
after
applying
LDAR
Dim
LDAR
As
String
'
LDAR
program
Dim
MAC
As
Integer
'
MACT
Dim
HAPRed
As
Double
'
total
hap
reduction,
lb/
yr
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
hon
monitoring,
reporting
and
recordkeeping
Dim
OandM
As
Double
'
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
CAR
As
Double
'
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
VVOandM
As
Double
'
VV
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
VVMirror
As
Single
=
0
'
VV
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
VVCAR
As
Double
'
VV
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
RCVV
As
Double
'
vv
recovery
credit
Dim
MFID
As
String
'
master
facility
id
Dim
HONTCI
As
Double
'
total
capital
investment
for
HON
Dim
OVAANN
As
Double
'
Annualized
OVA
costs
Set
dbs
=
CurrentDb
A­
12
Set
rst
=
dbs.
OpenRecordset("
LDAR,
with
cost
data")

rst.
MoveFirst
Do
While
Not
rst.
EOF
ProType
=
rst![
ProcType]
UnctrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Uncontrolled
Emissions]
CtrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Controlled
Emissions]
Recovery
=
rst![
Reduction]
LDAR
=
rst![
LDAR
Program]
MAC
=
rst![
MACT]
Batch_
PP
=
rst![
BatchPP]
Cont_
PP
=
rst![
ContPP]
HAPRed
=
rst![
Total
HAP
Reduction
(
lb/
yr)]
MFID
=
rst![
Master
Facility
ID]

If
Batch_
PP
=
0
And
Cont_
PP
=
0
Then
OVACost
=
0
OVAANN
=
0
Else
OVACost
=
14500
OVAANN
=
OVACost
*
0.142
+
1610
'
1610
is
annual
rental
cost
End
If
'
0.142
is
the
capital
recovery
factor
for
the
data
collection
system
`
assuming
equipment
life
of
10
years
If
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
batch"
Then
VVRC
=
(
0.497
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
'
0.10
$/
lb
is
salvage
value
ElseIf
(
MAC
=
0
Or
MAC
=
2)
And
ProType
=
"
continuous"
Then
VVRC
=
(
0.688
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
Else
VVRC
=
0
End
If
If
(
MAC
=
0
Or
MAC
=
2)
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVContFC
+
OVACost)
*
Cont_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVContCC
+
VVContAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Cont_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVBatchFC
+
OVACost)
*
Batch_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVBatchCC
+
VVBatchAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Batch_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
Else
A­
13
VVTCI
=
0
VVTAC
=
0
RCVV
=
0
End
If
If
(
MAC
=
0
Or
MAC
=
2)
Then
TTCI
=
VVTCI
TTAC
=
VVTAC
End
If
rst.
Edit
If
HAPRed
=
0
Then
rst![
HON_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
HON_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
TCI]
=
0
rst![
TAC]
=
0
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
0
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
0
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0
rst![
RC
($)]
=
0
Else
rst![
TCI]
=
TTCI
rst![
TAC]
=
TTAC
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
TTAC
­
Mirror
­
(
0.1098
*
TTCI)
+
RC
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
Mirror
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0.1098
*
TTCI
rst![
RC
($)]
=
RC
End
If
rst.
Update
rst.
MoveNext
Loop
End
Sub
A­
14
ATTACHMENT
3
Access
Module
Used
to
Calculate
Costs
Regulatory
Alternative
No.
1
A­
15
Regulatory
Alternative
No.
1
Access
Module
Option
Compare
Database
Option
Explicit
Public
Sub
LDARCost()
Dim
dbs
As
Database
Dim
rst
As
Recordset
Dim
Batch_
PP
As
Double
'
Count
of
batch
product
process
Dim
Cont_
PP
As
Double
'
count
of
continuous
product
process
Dim
Component
As
Double
'
number
of
components
installed
in
each
facility
Dim
OVA
As
Long
'
number
of
OVA
required
for
each
facility
Dim
OVACost
As
Long
'
cost
for
OVA
required
Const
HONContFC
As
Double
=
65892
'
continuous
fixed
cost
for
HON
Const
HONBatchFC
As
Long
=
12596
'
batch
fixed
cost
for
HON
Const
HONTrain
As
Long
=
12563
'
planing
and
training
for
HON
Const
HONContCC
As
Long
=
11163
'
continuous
annualized
capital
cost
for
HON
Const
HONBatchCC
As
Long
=
3582
'
batch
annualized
capital
cost
for
HON
Const
HONContAnnExp
As
Long
=
18570
'
continuous
annual
expense
for
HON
Const
HONBatchAnnExp
As
Long
=
14018
'
total
capital
investment
for
HON
Dim
HONTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
for
HON
Dim
HONRC
As
Double
'
recovery
credit
for
HON
Const
VVContFC
As
Long
=
48838
'
continuous
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchFC
As
Long
=
7344
'
batch
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVTrain
As
Double
=
12563
'
planing
and
training
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContCC
As
Long
=
8735
'
continuous
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchCC
As
Long
=
2838
'
batch
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContAnnExp
As
Long
=
18052
'
continuous
annual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchAnnExp
As
Long
=
13195
'
batch
anual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVRC
As
Double
'
recovery
credit
for
SubpartVV
Dim
ProType
As
String
'
process
type
Dim
UnctrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
Uncontrolled
emissions
Dim
CtrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
controlled
emissions
Dim
TTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
Dim
TTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
Dim
RC
As
Long
'
total
recovery
credit
Dim
Recovery
As
Double
'
reduction
in
emission
after
applying
LDAR
Dim
LDAR
As
String
'
LDAR
program
Dim
MAC
As
Integer
'
MACT
Dim
HAPRed
As
Double
'
total
hap
reduction,
lb/
yr
Dim
HONOandM
As
Double
'
hon
operating
and
maintenance
cost
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
hon
monitoring,
reporting
and
recordkeeping
Dim
HONCAR
As
Double
'
hon
annualized
capital
recovery
Dim
RCHON
As
Double
'
hon
recovery
credit
A­
16
Dim
OandM
As
Double
'
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
CAR
As
Double
'
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
VVOandM
As
Double
'
VV
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
VVMirror
As
Single
=
0
'
VV
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
VVCAR
As
Double
'
VV
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
RCVV
As
Double
'
vv
recovery
credit
Dim
MFID
As
String
'
master
facility
id
Dim
HONTCI
As
Double
'
total
capital
investment
for
HON
Dim
OVAANN
As
Double
'
Annualized
OVA
costs
Set
dbs
=
CurrentDb
Set
rst
=
dbs.
OpenRecordset("
LDAR
Reg
Alt
3,
with
cost
data")

rst.
MoveFirst
Do
While
Not
rst.
EOF
ProType
=
rst![
ProcType]
UnctrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Uncontrolled
Emissions]
CtrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Controlled
Emissions]
Recovery
=
rst![
Reduction]
LDAR
=
rst![
LDAR
Program]
MAC
=
rst![
MACT]
Batch_
PP
=
rst![
BatchPP]
Cont_
PP
=
rst![
ContPP]
HAPRed
=
rst![
Total
HAP
Reduction
(
lb/
yr)]
MFID
=
rst![
Master
Facility
ID]

If
Batch_
PP
=
0
And
Cont_
PP
=
0
Then
OVACost
=
0
OVAANN
=
0
Else
OVACost
=
14500
OVAANN
=
OVACost
*
0.142
+
1610
'
1610
is
the
annual
rental
cost
End
If
'
0.142
is
the
capital
recovery
factor
for
'
the
data
collection
system
assuming
'
equipment
life
of
10
years
If
MAC
=
4
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
'
0.10
$/
lb
is
salvage
value
HONRC
=
(
0.81)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
HONRC
=
(
0.761
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
ElseIf
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
HONRC
=
0.562
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
ElseIf
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
A­
17
HONRC
=
0.761
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
End
If
If
(
MAC
=
2
Or
MAC
=
0)
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
HONTCI
=
HONTrain
+
(
OVACost
+
HONContFC)
*
Cont_
PP
HONTAC
=
((
HONContCC
+
HONContAnnExp
+
OVAANN))
*
Cont_
PP
­
HONRC
RCHON
=
HONRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
1
Then
HONTCI
=
0
HONTAC
=
0
RCHON
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
4
Then
VVRC
=
(
0.497
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
'
0.10
$/
lb
is
salvage
value
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
Then
VVRC
=
Recovery
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
Else
VVRC
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
4
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVBatchFC
+
OVACost)
*
Batch_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVBatchCC
+
VVBatchAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Batch_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVContFC
+
OVACost)
*
Cont_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVContCC
+
VVContAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Cont_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
Else
VVTCI
=
0
VVTAC
=
0
RCVV
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
continuous"
Then
TTCI
=
HONTCI
TTAC
=
HONTAC
ElseIf
MAC
=
4
Then
TTCI
=
VVTCI
A­
18
TTAC
=
VVTAC
RC
=
VVRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
batch"
Then
TTCI
=
VVTCI
TTAC
=
VVTAC
RC
=
RCHON
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
continuous"
Then
TTCI
=
HONTCI
­
VVTCI
TTAC
=
HONTAC
­
VVTAC
RC
=
RCHON
End
If
rst.
Edit
If
HAPRed
=
0
Then
rst![
HON_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
HON_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
TCI]
=
0
rst![
TAC]
=
0
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
0
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
0
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0
rst![
RC
($)]
=
0
Else
rst![
HON_
TCI]
=
HONTCI
rst![
HON_
TAC]
=
HONTAC
rst![
VV_
TCI]
=
VVTCI
rst![
VV_
TAC]
=
VVTAC
rst![
TCI]
=
TTCI
rst![
TAC]
=
TTAC
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
TTAC
­
Mirror
­
(
0.1098
*
TTCI)
+
RC
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
Mirror
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0.1098
*
TTCI
rst![
RC
($)]
=
RC
End
If
rst.
Update
rst.
MoveNext
Loop
End
Sub
A­
19
ATTACHMENT
4
Access
Module
Used
to
Calculate
Costs
Regulatory
Alternative
No.
2
A­
20
Regulatory
Alternative
No.
2
Access
Module
Attribute
VB_
Name
=
"
LDAR
RA
2
Cost
Calc"
Option
Compare
Database
Option
Explicit
Public
Sub
LDARCost()
Dim
dbs
As
Database
Dim
rst
As
Recordset
Dim
Batch_
PP
As
Double
'
Count
of
batch
product
process
Dim
Cont_
PP
As
Double
'
count
of
continuous
product
process
Dim
Component
As
Double
'
number
of
components
installed
in
each
facility
Dim
OVA
As
Long
'
number
of
OVA
required
for
each
facility
Dim
OVACost
As
Long
'
cost
for
OVA
required
Const
HONContFC
As
Double
=
65892
'
continuous
fixed
cost
for
HON
Const
HONBatchFC
As
Long
=
12596
'
batch
fixed
cost
for
HON
Const
HONTrain
As
Long
=
12563
'
planing
and
training
for
HON
Const
HONContCC
As
Long
=
11163
'
continuous
annualized
capital
cost
for
HON
Const
HONBatchCC
As
Long
=
3582
'
batch
annualized
capital
cost
for
HON
Const
HONContAnnExp
As
Long
=
18570
'
continuous
annual
expense
for
HON
Const
HONBatchAnnExp
As
Long
=
14018
'
total
capital
investment
for
HON
Dim
HONTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
for
HON
Dim
HONRC
As
Double
'
recovery
credit
for
HON
Const
VVContFC
As
Long
=
48838
'
continuous
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchFC
As
Long
=
7344
'
batch
fixed
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVTrain
As
Double
=
12563
'
planing
and
training
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContCC
As
Long
=
8735
'
continuous
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchCC
As
Long
=
2838
'
batch
annualized
capital
cost
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVContAnnExp
As
Long
=
18052
'
continuous
annual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Const
VVBatchAnnExp
As
Long
=
13195
'
batch
anual
expense
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
for
SubpartVV
Dim
VVRC
As
Double
'
recovery
credit
for
SubpartVV
Dim
ProType
As
String
'
process
type
Dim
UnctrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
Uncontrolled
emissions
Dim
CtrlEmis
As
Long
'
HAP
controlled
emissions
Dim
TTCI
As
Long
'
total
capital
investment
Dim
TTAC
As
Long
'
total
annual
cost
Dim
RC
As
Long
'
total
recovery
credit
Dim
Recovery
As
Double
'
reduction
in
emission
after
applying
LDAR
Dim
LDAR
As
String
'
LDAR
program
Dim
MAC
As
Integer
'
MACT
Dim
HAPRed
As
Double
'
total
hap
reduction,
lb/
yr
Dim
HONOandM
As
Double
'
hon
operating
and
maintenance
cost
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
hon
monitoring,
reporting
and
recordkeeping
Dim
HONCAR
As
Double
'
hon
annualized
capital
recovery
A­
21
Dim
RCHON
As
Double
'
hon
recovery
credit
Dim
OandM
As
Double
'
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
Mirror
As
Single
=
0
'
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
CAR
As
Double
'
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
VVOandM
As
Double
'
VV
operating
and
maintenance
cost
'
Const
VVMirror
As
Single
=
0
'
VV
monitoring,
recordkeeping
and
reporting
cost
Dim
VVCAR
As
Double
'
VV
annualized
capital
cost
Dim
RCVV
As
Double
'
vv
recovery
credit
Dim
MFID
As
String
'
master
facility
id
Dim
HONTCI
As
Double
'
total
capital
investment
for
HON
Dim
OVAANN
As
Double
'
Annualized
OVA
costs
Set
dbs
=
CurrentDb
Set
rst
=
dbs.
OpenRecordset("
LDAR
Reg
Alt,
with
cost
data")

rst.
MoveFirst
Do
While
Not
rst.
EOF
ProType
=
rst![
ProcType]
UnctrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Uncontrolled
Emissions]
CtrlEmis
=
rst![
LDAR
Controlled
Emissions]
Recovery
=
rst![
Reduction]
LDAR
=
rst![
LDAR
Program]
MAC
=
rst![
MACT]
Batch_
PP
=
rst![
BatchPP]
Cont_
PP
=
rst![
ContPP]
HAPRed
=
rst![
Total
HAP
Reduction
(
lb/
yr)]
MFID
=
rst![
Master
Facility
ID]

If
Batch_
PP
=
0
And
Cont_
PP
=
0
Then
OVACost
=
0
OVAANN
=
0
Else
OVACost
=
14500
OVAANN
=
OVACost
*
0.142
+
1610
'
1610
is
the
annual
rental
cost
End
If
'
0.142
is
the
capital
recovery
factor
for
'
the
data
collection
system
assuming
'
equipment
life
of
10
years
If
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
'
0.10
$/
lb
is
salvage
value
HONRC
=
(
0.562
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
HONRC
=
(
0.761
­
Recovery)
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
ElseIf
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
HONRC
=
0.562
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
A­
22
ElseIf
MAC
=
0
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
HONRC
=
0.761
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
End
If
If
(
MAC
=
2
Or
MAC
=
0)
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
HONTCI
=
HONTrain
+
(
OVACost
+
HONContFC)
*
Cont_
PP
HONTAC
=
((
HONContCC
+
HONContAnnExp
+
OVAANN))
*
Cont_
PP
­
HONRC
RCHON
=
HONRC
ElseIf
(
MAC
=
2
Or
MAC
=
0)
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
HONTCI
=
HONTrain
+
(
OVACost
+
HONBatchFC)
*
Batch_
PP
HONTAC
=
((
HONBatchCC
+
HONBatchAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Batch_
PP)
­
HONRC
RCHON
=
HONRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
1
Then
HONTCI
=
0
HONTAC
=
0
RCHON
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
2
Then
VVRC
=
Recovery
*
UnctrlEmis
*
0.1
'
0.10
$/
lb
is
salvage
value
Else
VVRC
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Continuous"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVContFC
+
OVACost)
*
Cont_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVContCC
+
VVContAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Cont_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
And
ProType
=
"
Batch"
Then
VVTCI
=
VVTrain
+
(
VVBatchFC
+
OVACost)
*
Batch_
PP
VVTAC
=
(
VVBatchCC
+
VVBatchAnnExp
+
OVAANN)
*
Batch_
PP
­
VVRC
RCVV
=
VVRC
Else
VVTCI
=
0
VVTAC
=
0
RCVV
=
0
End
If
If
MAC
=
0
Then
TTCI
=
HONTCI
TTAC
=
HONTAC
ElseIf
MAC
=
2
Then
TTCI
=
HONTCI
­
VVTCI
TTAC
=
HONTAC
­
VVTAC
RC
=
RCHON
A­
23
End
If
rst.
Edit
If
HAPRed
=
0
Then
rst![
HON_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
HON_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TCI]
=
0
rst![
VV_
TAC]
=
0
rst![
TCI]
=
0
rst![
TAC]
=
0
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
0
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
0
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0
rst![
RC
($)]
=
0
Else
rst![
HON_
TCI]
=
HONTCI
rst![
HON_
TAC]
=
HONTAC
rst![
VV_
TCI]
=
VVTCI
rst![
VV_
TAC]
=
VVTAC
rst![
TCI]
=
TTCI
rst![
TAC]
=
TTAC
rst![
O&
M
($)]
=
TTAC
­
Mirror
­
(
0.1098
*
TTCI)
+
RC
rst![
MRR
($)]
=
Mirror
rst![
ACR
($)]
=
0.1098
*
TTCI
rst![
RC
($)]
=
RC
End
If
rst.
Update
rst.
MoveNext
Loop
End
Sub
A­
24
ATTACHMENT
5
Emissions
and
Cost
Impacts
MACT
Floor
and
Regulatory
Alternatives
A­
25
Equipment
Leak
Control
Cost
­
MACT
Floor
(
new)

Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

1
M1
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
2
M10
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
3
M100
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
4
M101
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
5
M102
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
6
M103
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
7
M104
1
0
7500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
8
M105
7
0
52500
None
0
0
52,500
26,093
Batch
$
165,471
$
135,305
$
10,371
9
M106
8
0
60000
HON
0.562
1
26,280
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
10
M107
0
1
30000
HON
0.761
1
7,170
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
11
M107
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
12
M107
7
0
52500
TX28VHP
0.497
1
26,408
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
13
M108
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
14
M109
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
15
M11
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
16
M110
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
17
M111
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
18
M112
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
19
M113
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
20
M113
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
21
M114
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
22
M114
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
23
M115
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
24
M116
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
25
M116
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
26
M117
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
27
M118
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
28
M119
6
0
45000
AVO
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
1
A­
26
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

29
M12
5
0
37500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
18,863
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
30
M120
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
31
M121
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
32
M122
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
33
M123
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
34
M124
2
0
15000
AVO
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
35
M125
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
36
M125
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
37
M126
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
38
M126
1
0
7500
TXReg5
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
39
M127
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
40
M128
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
41
M129
127
0
952500
None
0
0
952,500
473,393
Batch
$
2,786,75
$
2,454,815
$
10,371
42
M13
3
0
22500
AVO
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
43
M130
163
0
1222500
None
0
0
1,222,500
607,583
Batch
$
3,573,13
$
3,150,668
$
10,371
44
M131
39
0
292500
None
0
0
292,500
145,373
Batch
$
864,479
$
753,841
$
10,371
45
M132
2
0
15000
AVO
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,659
$
10,371
46
M133
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
47
M134
26
0
195000
None
0
0
195,000
96,915
Batch
$
580,507
$
502,561
$
10,371
48
M135
0
0
0
HON
0.562
1
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
49
M136
6
0
45000
AVO
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
50
M137
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
51
M138
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
52
M141
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
53
M142
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
54
M142
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
55
M144
7
0
52500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
26,408
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
56
M145
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
57
M146
3
0
22500
TX28MID
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
58
M146
0
4
120000
TX28MID
0.688
1
37,440
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
2
A­
27
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

59
M147
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
60
M148
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
61
M149
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
62
M15
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
63
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
64
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
65
M150
3
0
22500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
66
M150
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
67
M151
2
0
15000
TX28M
0.02
0
14,700
7,155
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,688
$
10,814
68
M152
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
69
M153
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
70
M154
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
71
M155
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
72
M156
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
73
M157
13
0
97500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
49,043
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
74
M158
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
75
M16
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
76
M160
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
77
M17
52
0
390000
None
0
0
390,000
193,830
Batch
$
1,148,45
$
1,005,121
$
10,371
78
M18
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
79
M19
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
80
M2
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
81
M20
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
82
M21
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
83
M22
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
84
M22
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
85
M23
0
1
30000
LA
2122
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
86
M23
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
87
M23
0
2
60000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
1
18,720
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
88
M23
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
3
A­
28
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

89
M24
3
0
22500
AVO
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
90
M25
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
91
M25
43
0
322500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
162,218
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
92
M254
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
93
M255
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
94
M256
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
95
M258
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
96
M259
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
97
M26
19
0
142500
None
0
0
142,500
70,823
Batch
$
427,599
$
367,256
$
10,371
98
M260
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
99
M261
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
100
M262
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
101
M265
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
1
18,720
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
102
M269
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
103
M27
7
0
52500
None
0
0
52,500
26,093
Batch
$
165,471
$
135,305
$
10,371
104
M27
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
105
M270
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
106
M271
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
107
M277
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
82,560
Continuous
$
265,915
$
113,568
$
2,751
108
M279
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
109
M28
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
110
M280
0
3
90000
28M
0.24
2
68,400
40,320
Continuous
$
202,577
$
87,336
$
4,332
111
M281
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
112
M283
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
113
M284
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
13,440
Continuous
$
75,901
$
29,112
$
4,332
114
M285
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
115
M287
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
116
M289
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
117
M29
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
118
M293
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
1
18,720
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
4
A­
29
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

119
M297
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
120
M299
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
61,920
Continuous
$
202,577
$
85,176
$
2,751
121
M3
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
122
M30
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
123
M300
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
124
M301
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
125
M303
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
126
M306
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
127
M307
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
128
M308
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
129
M311
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
130
M314
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
82,560
Continuous
$
265,915
$
113,568
$
2,751
131
M315
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
1
18,720
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
132
M318
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
133
M32
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
134
M320
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
1
18,720
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
135
M322
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
136
M325
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
137
M326
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
138
M328
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
139
M33
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
140
M330
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
141
M334
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
142
M337
0
1
30000
29MID
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
143
M34
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
144
M342
0
1
30000
TX28MID
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
145
M343
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
13,440
Continuous
$
75,901
$
29,112
$
4,332
146
M347
0
1
30000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
1
9,360
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
147
M35
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
148
M350
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
13,440
Continuous
$
75,901
$
29,112
$
4,332
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
5
A­
30
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

149
M351
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
61,920
Continuous
$
202,577
$
85,176
$
2,751
150
M352
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
151
M358
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
41,280
Continuous
$
139,239
$
56,784
$
2,751
152
M359
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
20,640
Continuous
$
75,901
$
28,392
$
2,751
153
M36
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
154
M37
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
155
M38
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
156
M380
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
157
M39
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
158
M4
4
0
30000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
15,090
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
159
M40
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
160
M41
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
161
M42
36
0
270000
None
0
0
270,000
134,190
Batch
$
798,947
$
695,853
$
10,371
162
M43
12
0
90000
HON
0.562
1
39,420
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
163
M44
0
2
60000
28M
0.24
2
45,600
26,880
Continuous
$
139,239
$
58,224
$
4,332
164
M44
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
165
M45
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
166
M45
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
167
M46
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
168
M47
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
169
M48
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
170
M49
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
171
M49
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
172
M5
10
0
75000
None
0
0
75,000
37,275
Batch
$
231,003
$
193,292
$
10,371
173
M51
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
174
M52
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
175
M53
1
0
7500
TX28M
0.02
0
7,350
3,578
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,344
$
10,814
176
M54
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
177
M55
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
178
M56
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
6
A­
31
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

179
M58
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
180
M59
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
181
M6
0
0
0
None
0
0
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
182
M60
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
183
M61
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
184
M62
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
185
M62
2
0
15000
Subpart
V
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
186
M63
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
187
M64
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
188
M65
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
189
M66
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
190
M67
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
191
M68
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
192
M69
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
193
M7
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
194
M70
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
195
M71
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
196
M72
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
197
M73
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
198
M74
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
199
M75
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
200
M76
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
201
M77
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
202
M78
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
203
M79
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
204
M8
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
205
M80
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
206
M81
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
207
M82
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
208
M83
13
0
97500
None
0
0
97,500
48,458
Batch
$
296,535
$
251,280
$
10,371
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
7
A­
32
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

209
M84
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
210
M84
5
0
37500
TX28MID
0.497
1
18,863
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
211
M85
10
0
75000
HON
0.562
1
32,850
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
212
M86
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
213
M87
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
214
M88
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
215
M89
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
216
M9
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
217
M9
9
0
67500
None
0
0
67,500
33,548
Batch
$
209,159
$
173,963
$
10,371
218
M90
22
0
165000
None
0
0
165,000
82,005
Batch
$
493,131
$
425,244
$
10,371
219
M91
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
220
M92
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
221
M93
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
222
M94
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
223
M95
10
0
75000
None
0
0
75,000
37,275
Batch
$
231,003
$
193,292
$
10,371
224
M96
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
225
M97
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
226
M98
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
227
M99
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
Total
10,507,500
9,215,850
4,461,383
$
24,679,693
$
18,251,539
$
8,182
Batch
7,867,500
7,089,720
3,156,743
$
19,946,613
$
16,371,907
$
10,37
Continuous
2,640,000
2,126,130
1,304,640
$
4,733,080
$
1,879,632
$
2,881
Overall
Continuous
5,280,000
4,252,260
2,609,280
$
9,466,160
$
3,759,264
$
2,881
National
13,147,500
11,341,980
5,766,023
$
29,412,773
$
20,131,171
$
6,983
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
8
A­
33
Equipment
Leak
Control
Cost
­
Regulatory
Alternative
No.
1
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

1
M1
6
0
45000
None
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
2
M10
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
3
M100
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
4
M101
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
5
M102
6
0
45000
None
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
6
M103
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
7
M104
1
0
7500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
8
M105
7
0
52500
None
0
4
52,500
26,093
Batch
$
165,471
$
135,305
$
10,371
9
M106
8
0
60000
HON
0.562
1
26,280
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
10
M107
0
1
30000
HON
0.761
1
7,170
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
11
M107
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
12
M107
7
0
52500
TX28VHP
0.497
1
26,408
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
13
M108
11
0
82500
None
0
4
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
14
M109
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
15
M11
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
16
M110
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
17
M111
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
18
M112
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
19
M113
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
20
M113
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
21
M114
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
22
M114
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
23
M115
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
24
M116
4
0
30000
AVO
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
25
M116
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
26
M117
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
27
M118
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
28
M119
6
0
45000
AVO
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
1
A­
34
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

29
M12
5
0
37500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
18,863
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
30
M120
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
31
M121
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
32
M122
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
33
M123
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
34
M124
2
0
15000
AVO
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
35
M125
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
36
M125
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
37
M126
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
38
M126
1
0
7500
TXReg5
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
39
M127
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
40
M128
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
41
M129
127
0
952500
None
0
4
952,500
473,393
Batch
$
2,786,75
$
2,454,815
$
10,371
42
M13
3
0
22500
AVO
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
43
M130
163
0
1222500
None
0
4
1,222,500
607,583
Batch
$
3,573,13
$
3,150,668
$
10,371
44
M131
39
0
292500
None
0
4
292,500
145,373
Batch
$
864,479
$
753,841
$
10,371
45
M132
2
0
15000
AVO
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,659
$
10,371
46
M133
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
47
M134
26
0
195000
None
0
4
195,000
96,915
Batch
$
580,507
$
502,561
$
10,371
48
M135
0
0
0
HON
0.562
1
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
49
M136
6
0
45000
AVO
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
50
M137
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
51
M138
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
52
M141
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
53
M142
8
0
60000
None
0
4
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
54
M142
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
55
M144
7
0
52500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
26,408
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
56
M145
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
57
M146
3
0
22500
TX28MID
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
58
M146
0
4
120000
TX28MID
0.688
2
37,440
8,760
Continuous
$
68,216
$
19,164
$
4,375
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
2
A­
35
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

59
M147
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
60
M148
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
61
M149
11
0
82500
None
0
4
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
62
M15
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
63
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
64
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
65
M150
3
0
22500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
66
M150
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
67
M151
2
0
15000
TX28M
0.02
4
14,700
7,155
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,688
$
10,814
68
M152
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
69
M153
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
70
M154
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
71
M155
6
0
45000
None
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
72
M156
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
73
M157
13
0
97500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
49,043
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
74
M158
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
75
M16
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
76
M160
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
77
M17
52
0
390000
None
0
4
390,000
193,830
Batch
$
1,148,45
$
1,005,121
$
10,371
78
M18
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
79
M19
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
80
M2
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
81
M20
8
0
60000
None
0
4
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
82
M21
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
83
M22
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
84
M22
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
11,318
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
85
M23
0
1
30000
LA
2122
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
86
M23
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
87
M23
0
2
60000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
88
M23
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
3
A­
36
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

89
M24
3
0
22500
AVO
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
90
M25
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
91
M25
43
0
322500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
162,218
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
92
M254
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
93
M255
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
94
M256
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
95
M258
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
96
M259
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
97
M26
19
0
142500
None
0
4
142,500
70,823
Batch
$
427,599
$
367,256
$
10,371
98
M260
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
99
M261
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
100
M262
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
101
M265
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
102
M269
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
103
M27
7
0
52500
None
0
4
52,500
26,093
Batch
$
165,471
$
135,305
$
10,371
104
M27
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
105
M270
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
106
M271
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
107
M277
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
91,320
Continuous
$
334,131
$
124,476
$
2,726
108
M279
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
109
M28
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
110
M280
0
3
90000
28M
0.24
2
68,400
46,890
Continuous
$
51,162
$
6,309
$
269
111
M281
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
112
M283
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
113
M284
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
114
M285
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
115
M287
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
116
M289
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
117
M29
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
118
M293
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
4
A­
37
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

119
M297
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
120
M299
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
68,490
Continuous
$
253,739
$
93,357
$
2,726
121
M3
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
122
M30
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
123
M300
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
124
M301
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
125
M303
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
126
M306
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
127
M307
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
128
M308
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
129
M311
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
130
M314
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
91,320
Continuous
$
334,131
$
124,476
$
2,726
131
M315
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
132
M318
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
133
M32
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
134
M320
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
135
M322
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
136
M325
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
137
M326
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
138
M328
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
139
M33
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
140
M330
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
141
M334
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
142
M337
0
1
30000
29MID
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
143
M34
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
144
M342
0
1
30000
TX28MID
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
145
M343
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
146
M347
0
1
30000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
147
M35
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
148
M350
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
5
A­
38
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

149
M351
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
68,490
Continuous
$
253,739
$
93,357
$
2,726
150
M352
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
151
M358
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
152
M359
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
153
M36
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
154
M37
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
155
M38
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
156
M380
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
157
M39
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
158
M4
4
0
30000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
15,090
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
159
M40
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
160
M41
1
0
7500
AVO
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
161
M42
36
0
270000
None
0
4
270,000
134,190
Batch
$
798,947
$
695,853
$
10,371
162
M43
12
0
90000
HON
0.562
1
39,420
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
163
M44
0
2
60000
28M
0.24
2
45,600
31,260
Continuous
$
34,108
$
4,206
$
269
164
M44
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
165
M45
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
166
M45
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
167
M46
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
168
M47
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
169
M48
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
170
M49
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
171
M49
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
172
M5
10
0
75000
None
0
4
75,000
37,275
Batch
$
231,003
$
193,292
$
10,371
173
M51
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
174
M52
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
175
M53
1
0
7500
TX28M
0.02
4
7,350
3,578
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,344
$
10,814
176
M54
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
177
M55
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
178
M56
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
6
A­
39
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

179
M58
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
180
M59
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
181
M6
0
0
0
None
0
4
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
182
M60
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
183
M61
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
184
M62
11
0
82500
None
0
4
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
185
M62
2
0
15000
Subpart
V
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
186
M63
4
0
30000
AVO
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
187
M64
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
188
M65
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
189
M66
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
190
M67
6
0
45000
None
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,975
$
10,371
191
M68
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
192
M69
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
193
M7
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
194
M70
2
0
15000
None
0
4
15,000
7,455
Batch
$
56,251
$
38,658
$
10,371
195
M71
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
196
M72
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
197
M73
8
0
60000
None
0
4
60,000
29,820
Batch
$
187,315
$
154,634
$
10,371
198
M74
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
199
M75
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
200
M76
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
201
M77
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
202
M78
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
203
M79
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
7,545
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
204
M8
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
1
3,773
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
205
M80
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
206
M81
4
0
30000
AVO
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
207
M82
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
208
M83
13
0
97500
None
0
4
97,500
48,458
Batch
$
296,535
$
251,280
$
10,371
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
7
A­
40
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

209
M84
3
0
22500
None
0
4
22,500
11,183
Batch
$
78,095
$
57,988
$
10,371
210
M84
5
0
37500
TX28MID
0.497
1
18,863
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
211
M85
10
0
75000
HON
0.562
1
32,850
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
212
M86
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
1
22,635
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
213
M87
11
0
82500
None
0
4
82,500
41,003
Batch
$
252,847
$
212,622
$
10,371
214
M88
6
0
45000
None
0
4
45,000
22,365
Batch
$
143,627
$
115,976
$
10,371
215
M89
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
216
M9
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
217
M9
9
0
67500
None
0
4
67,500
33,548
Batch
$
209,159
$
173,963
$
10,371
218
M90
22
0
165000
None
0
4
165,000
82,005
Batch
$
493,131
$
425,244
$
10,371
219
M91
5
0
37500
None
0
4
37,500
18,638
Batch
$
121,783
$
96,646
$
10,371
220
M92
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
221
M93
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
222
M94
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
223
M95
10
0
75000
None
0
4
75,000
37,275
Batch
$
231,003
$
193,292
$
10,371
224
M96
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
225
M97
4
0
30000
None
0
4
30,000
14,910
Batch
$
99,939
$
77,317
$
10,371
226
M98
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
227
M99
1
0
7500
None
0
4
7,500
3,728
Batch
$
34,407
$
19,329
$
10,371
Total
10,507,500
9,215,850
4,651,913
$
25,593,872
$
18,294,244
$
7,865
Batch
7,867,500
7,089,720
3,156,743
$
19,946,613
$
16,371,907
$
10,37
Continuous
2,640,000
2,126,130
1,495,170
$
5,647,259
$
1,922,337
$
2,571
Overall
Continuous
5,280,000
4,252,260
2,990,340
$
11,294,518
$
3,844,674
$
2,571
National
13,147,500
11,341,980
6,147,083
$
31,241,131
$
20,216,581
$
6,578
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
8
A­
41
Equipment
Leak
Control
Cost
­
Regulatory
Alternative
2
(
new
module)

Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

1
M1
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
2
M10
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
3
M100
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
4
M101
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
5
M102
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
6
M103
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
7
M104
1
0
7500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
8
M105
7
0
52500
None
0
0
52,500
29,505
Batch
$
202,235
$
145,932
$
9,892
9
M106
8
0
60000
HON
0.562
1
26,280
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
10
M107
0
1
30000
HON
0.761
1
7,170
0
Continuous
$
0
$
0
$
0
11
M107
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
12
M107
7
0
52500
TX28VHP
0.497
2
26,408
3,413
Batch
$
36,764
$
13,237
$
7,758
13
M108
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
46,365
Batch
$
310,619
$
229,322
$
9,892
14
M109
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
15
M11
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
16
M110
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
17
M111
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
18
M112
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
19
M113
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
20
M113
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
21
M114
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
22
M114
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
23
M115
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
24
M116
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
25
M116
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
26
M117
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
27
M118
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
28
M119
6
0
45000
AVO
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
1
A­
42
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

29
M12
5
0
37500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
18,863
2,438
Batch
$
26,260
$
9,455
$
7,758
30
M120
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
31
M121
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
32
M122
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
33
M123
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
34
M124
2
0
15000
AVO
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
35
M125
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
36
M125
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
37
M126
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
38
M126
1
0
7500
TXReg5
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
39
M127
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
40
M128
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
41
M129
127
0
952500
None
0
0
952,500
535,305
Batch
$
3,453,75
$
2,647,632
$
9,892
42
M13
3
0
22500
AVO
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
43
M130
163
0
1222500
None
0
0
1,222,500
687,045
Batch
$
4,429,21
$
3,398,142
$
9,892
44
M131
39
0
292500
None
0
0
292,500
164,385
Batch
$
1,069,30
$
813,052
$
9,892
45
M132
2
0
15000
AVO
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
46
M133
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
47
M134
26
0
195000
None
0
0
195,000
109,590
Batch
$
717,059
$
542,035
$
9,892
48
M135
0
0
0
HON
0.562
1
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
49
M136
6
0
45000
AVO
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
50
M137
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
51
M138
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
52
M141
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
53
M142
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
33,720
Batch
$
229,331
$
166,780
$
9,892
54
M142
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
55
M144
7
0
52500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
26,408
3,413
Batch
$
36,764
$
13,237
$
7,758
56
M145
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
57
M146
3
0
22500
TX28MID
0.497
2
11,318
1,463
Batch
$
15,756
$
5,673
$
7,758
58
M146
0
4
120000
TX28MID
0.688
2
37,440
8,760
Continuous
$
68,216
$
19,164
$
4,375
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
2
A­
43
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

59
M147
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
11,318
1,463
Batch
$
15,756
$
5,673
$
7,758
60
M148
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
61
M149
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
46,365
Batch
$
310,619
$
229,322
$
9,892
62
M15
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
63
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
V
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
64
M15
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
65
M150
3
0
22500
LA
non­
HON
0.497
2
11,318
1,463
Batch
$
15,756
$
5,673
$
7,758
66
M150
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
67
M151
2
0
15000
TX28M
0.02
0
14,700
8,130
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
10,257
68
M152
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
22,635
2,925
Batch
$
31,512
$
11,346
$
7,758
69
M153
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
70
M154
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
71
M155
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
72
M156
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
73
M157
13
0
97500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
49,043
6,338
Batch
$
68,276
$
24,583
$
7,758
74
M158
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
75
M16
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
76
M160
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
77
M17
52
0
390000
None
0
0
390,000
219,180
Batch
$
1,421,55
$
1,084,070
$
9,892
78
M18
6
0
45000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
22,635
2,925
Batch
$
31,512
$
11,346
$
7,758
79
M19
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
80
M2
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
81
M20
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
33,720
Batch
$
229,331
$
166,780
$
9,892
82
M21
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
83
M22
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
84
M22
3
0
22500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
11,318
1,463
Batch
$
15,756
$
5,673
$
7,758
85
M23
0
1
30000
LA
2122
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
86
M23
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
87
M23
0
2
60000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
88
M23
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
3
A­
44
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

89
M24
3
0
22500
AVO
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
90
M25
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
91
M25
43
0
322500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
162,218
20,963
Batch
$
225,836
$
81,313
$
7,758
92
M254
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
93
M255
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
94
M256
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
95
M258
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
96
M259
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
97
M26
19
0
142500
None
0
0
142,500
80,085
Batch
$
527,387
$
396,102
$
9,892
98
M260
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
99
M261
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
100
M262
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
101
M265
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
102
M269
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
103
M27
7
0
52500
None
0
0
52,500
29,505
Batch
$
202,235
$
145,932
$
9,892
104
M27
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
105
M270
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
106
M271
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
107
M277
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
91,320
Continuous
$
334,131
$
124,476
$
2,726
108
M279
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
109
M28
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
110
M280
0
3
90000
28M
0.24
2
68,400
46,890
Continuous
$
51,162
$
6,309
$
269
111
M281
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
112
M283
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
113
M284
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
114
M285
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
115
M287
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
116
M289
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
117
M29
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
118
M293
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
4
A­
45
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

119
M297
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
120
M299
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
68,490
Continuous
$
253,739
$
93,357
$
2,726
121
M3
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
122
M30
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
123
M300
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
124
M301
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
125
M303
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
126
M306
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
127
M307
0
1
30000
TX28VHP
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
128
M308
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
129
M311
0
1
30000
TX28RCT
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
130
M314
0
4
120000
None
0
0
120,000
91,320
Continuous
$
334,131
$
124,476
$
2,726
131
M315
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
132
M318
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
133
M32
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
134
M320
0
2
60000
TX28MID
0.688
2
18,720
4,380
Continuous
$
34,108
$
9,582
$
4,375
135
M322
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
136
M325
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
137
M326
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
138
M328
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
139
M33
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
140
M330
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
141
M334
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
142
M337
0
1
30000
29MID
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
143
M34
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
144
M342
0
1
30000
TX28MID
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
145
M343
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
146
M347
0
1
30000
LA
non­
HON
0.688
2
9,360
2,190
Continuous
$
17,054
$
4,791
$
4,375
147
M35
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
148
M350
0
1
30000
28M
0.24
2
22,800
15,630
Continuous
$
17,054
$
2,103
$
269
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
5
A­
46
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

149
M351
0
3
90000
None
0
0
90,000
68,490
Continuous
$
253,739
$
93,357
$
2,726
150
M352
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
151
M358
0
2
60000
None
0
0
60,000
45,660
Continuous
$
173,347
$
62,238
$
2,726
152
M359
0
1
30000
None
0
0
30,000
22,830
Continuous
$
92,955
$
31,119
$
2,726
153
M36
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
154
M37
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
155
M38
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
156
M380
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
157
M39
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
158
M4
4
0
30000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
15,090
1,950
Batch
$
21,008
$
7,564
$
7,758
159
M40
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
160
M41
1
0
7500
AVO
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
161
M42
36
0
270000
None
0
0
270,000
151,740
Batch
$
988,019
$
750,510
$
9,892
162
M43
12
0
90000
HON
0.562
1
39,420
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
163
M44
0
2
60000
28M
0.24
2
45,600
31,260
Continuous
$
34,108
$
4,206
$
269
164
M44
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
2
22,635
2,925
Batch
$
31,512
$
11,346
$
7,758
165
M45
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
166
M45
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
167
M46
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
168
M47
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
169
M48
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
170
M49
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
171
M49
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
172
M5
10
0
75000
None
0
0
75,000
42,150
Batch
$
283,523
$
208,475
$
9,892
173
M51
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
174
M52
4
0
30000
HON
0.562
1
13,140
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
175
M53
1
0
7500
TX28M
0.02
0
7,350
4,065
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
10,257
176
M54
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
177
M55
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
178
M56
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
6
A­
47
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

179
M58
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
180
M59
1
0
7500
HON
0.562
1
3,285
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
181
M6
0
0
0
None
0
0
0
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
182
M60
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
183
M61
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
184
M62
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
46,365
Batch
$
310,619
$
229,322
$
9,892
185
M62
2
0
15000
Subpart
V
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
186
M63
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
187
M64
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
188
M65
2
0
15000
LA
non­
HON
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
189
M66
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
190
M67
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
191
M68
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
192
M69
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
193
M7
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
194
M70
2
0
15000
None
0
0
15,000
8,430
Batch
$
66,755
$
41,695
$
9,892
195
M71
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
196
M72
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
197
M73
8
0
60000
None
0
0
60,000
33,720
Batch
$
229,331
$
166,780
$
9,892
198
M74
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
199
M75
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
200
M76
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
201
M77
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
202
M78
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
203
M79
2
0
15000
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
7,545
975
Batch
$
10,504
$
3,782
$
7,758
204
M8
1
0
7500
Subpart
VV
0.497
2
3,773
488
Batch
$
5,252
$
1,891
$
7,758
205
M80
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
206
M81
4
0
30000
AVO
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
207
M82
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
208
M83
13
0
97500
None
0
0
97,500
54,795
Batch
$
364,811
$
271,018
$
9,892
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
7
A­
48
Uncontrolled
HAP
Baseline
HAP
HAP
Continuous
Emissions
LDAR
Emissions
Reduction
CE
Count
MFID
Batch
PP
PP
(
lb/
yr)
Program
Reduction
MACT
(
lb/
yr)
(
lb/
yr)
Type
TCI
TAC
($/
ton)

209
M84
3
0
22500
None
0
0
22,500
12,645
Batch
$
93,851
$
62,542
$
9,892
210
M84
5
0
37500
TX28MID
0.497
2
18,863
2,438
Batch
$
26,260
$
9,455
$
7,758
211
M85
10
0
75000
HON
0.562
1
32,850
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
212
M86
6
0
45000
TX28MID
0.497
2
22,635
2,925
Batch
$
31,512
$
11,346
$
7,758
213
M87
11
0
82500
None
0
0
82,500
46,365
Batch
$
310,619
$
229,322
$
9,892
214
M88
6
0
45000
None
0
0
45,000
25,290
Batch
$
175,139
$
125,085
$
9,892
215
M89
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
216
M9
2
0
15000
HON
0.562
1
6,570
0
Batch
$
0
$
0
$
0
217
M9
9
0
67500
None
0
0
67,500
37,935
Batch
$
256,427
$
187,628
$
9,892
218
M90
22
0
165000
None
0
0
165,000
92,730
Batch
$
608,675
$
458,645
$
9,892
219
M91
5
0
37500
None
0
0
37,500
21,075
Batch
$
148,043
$
104,238
$
9,892
220
M92
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,847
$
9,892
221
M93
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
222
M94
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
223
M95
10
0
75000
None
0
0
75,000
42,150
Batch
$
283,523
$
208,475
$
9,892
224
M96
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
225
M97
4
0
30000
None
0
0
30,000
16,860
Batch
$
120,947
$
83,390
$
9,892
226
M98
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
227
M99
1
0
7500
None
0
0
7,500
4,215
Batch
$
39,659
$
20,848
$
9,892
Total
10,507,500
9,215,850
5,138,925
$
30,840,620
$
19,867,610
$
7,732
Batch
7,867,500
7,089,720
3,643,755
$
25,193,361
$
17,945,273
$
9,850
Continuous
2,640,000
2,126,130
1,495,170
$
5,647,259
$
1,922,337
$
2,571
Overall
Continuous
5,280,000
4,252,260
2,990,340
$
11,294,518
$
3,844,674
$
2,571
National
13,147,500
11,341,980
6,634,095
$
36,487,879
$
21,789,947
$
6,569
Tuesday,
June
17,
2003
Page
8