Document ID: EPA-HQ-OAR-2005-0029-0331
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2006-08-07T04:00Z

Jaime
Pagan/
RTP/
USEPA/
US
06/
29/
2006
08:
09
AM
To
Margaret
Reidy/
DC/
USEPA/
US@
EPA
cc
Subject
FW:
Proposal
Margaret,
the
email
below
shows
that
the
information
in
question
is
not
confidential.
Perhaps
we
can
add
this
email
to
the
docket
to
clarify
this.

Thanks,
Jaime
­­­­­
Forwarded
by
Jaime
Pagan/
RTP/
USEPA/
US
on
06/
29/
2006
08:
06AM
­­­­­

To:
Jaime
Pagan/
RTP/
USEPA/
US@
EPA
From:
Brad
Nelson
<
bnelson@
alpha­
gamma.
com>
Date:
06/
29/
2006
08:
00AM
cc:
Jennifer
Snyder
<
jsnyder@
alpha­
gamma.
com>
Subject:
FW:
Proposal
Jaime,

Here
is
the
release
for
both
of
the
SCR
price
quotations
that
was
obtained
from
Johnson
Matthey.

Brad
­­­­­
Original
Message­­­­­
From:
Jeremy
Harris
[
mailto:
harrisje@
jmusa.
com]
Sent:
Friday,
April
07,
2006
4:
16
PM
To:
Brad
Nelson
Cc:
Steve
Clark
Subject:
RE:
Proposal
Brad,

You
can
forward
a
copy
of
the
proposal
that
I
provided
you
to
the
EPA.
This
e­
mail
will
serve
as
your
release
to
forward
the
information
to
them.

Best
regards,
Jeremy
Harris
for
Johnson
Matthey
Phone:
610­
971­
3110
Cell:
610­
636­
8318
Fax:
610­
971­
3116
>>>
Brad
Nelson
<
bnelson@
alpha­
gamma.
com>
4/
7/
2006
4:
04
PM
>>>
Jeremy,

We
would
like
to
use
the
SCR
cost
information
that
you
provided
for
the
Wartsila
engines
(
Warstila
12V46,
Wartsila
12V32)
in
an
EPA
control
cost
analysis
for
engines
with
a
displacement
>
30
l/
cyl.
Based
on
the
SCR
cost
information
that
we
received,
we
found
that
SCR
is
a
cost
effective
control
technology
for
the
reduction
of
NOx,
and
the
emission
standard
developed
for
the
compression
ignition
engine
NSPS
is
based
on
the
use
of
SCR.
The
cost
proposals
that
you
sent
to
me
are
marked
as
"
CONFIDENTIAL"
and
EPA
has
asked
me
if
you
can
provide
non­
confidential
cost
estimates
for
SCR
for
these
Wartsila
engines.

Thank
you
very
much
for
your
time
and
effort
in
putting
this
analysis
together.

Brad
Nelson
­­­­­
Original
Message­­­­­
From:
Jeremy
Harris
[
mailto:
harrisje@
jmusa.
com]
Sent:
Thursday,
January
05,
2006
11:
32
AM
To:
bnelson@
alpha­
gamma.
com
Subject:
Proposal
Brad,

Attached
is
our
proposal
for
an
SCR
System
for
your
5.3MW
Wartsila
engine.
Our
total
price
for
the
SCR
equipment
is
$
178,500,
which
does
not
include
installation.
I
would
estimate
the
cost
to
install
the
equipment
at
$
125,000,
but
this
cost
will
depend
on
the
equipment
layout,
piping
runs,
accessibility,
etc.
The
only
operating
cost
for
the
equipment
is
the
cost
of
purchasing
the
reagent,
which
is
a
32.5%
urea
solution.
The
cost
of
the
urea
solution
is
about
$
1.70­$
2.00
per
gallon
depending
on
the
plants
proximity
to
a
dealer.
This
engine
will
require
33.4
gallons
per
hour
of
urea.

Please
let
me
know
if
I
can
be
of
any
further
assistance.

I
will
forward
the
quotation
for
the
11.7MW
engine
as
soon
as
I
am
finished.

Best
regards,
Jeremy
Harris
for
Johnson
Matthey
Phone:
610­
971­
3110
Cell:
610­
636­
8318
Fax:
610­
971­
3116