Document ID: EPA-R08-OAR-2016-0585-0003
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2017-12-04T05:00Z

Technical Support Document for Utah's Subpart 4 PM2.5 SIP Submittals of the Provo; Salt Lake; and Logan, UT-ID Nonattainment Areas
           Public Comment Period from November 1 to December 1, 2014
 
1) Inventory, General
     1.a) Overview
     1.b) Inventory Preparation Plan
     1.c)  Multi-State Nonattainment Area Considerations
 
2)  Episodic Inventories
     2.a)  General
          2.a.i)  Overview
          2.a.ii)  Summary Tables
               2.a.ii.A)  Episode Summary:  SMOKE Output - All Categories Tons/Episode Day
                    2.a.ii.A.I)         Episode 1: 1/11/007-1/20/2007 (10 days)
                    2.a.ii.A.II)        Episode 2:  2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                    2.a.ii.A.III)       Episode 3:  12/8/2009 - 1/20/2012 (44 days)
 
               2.a.ii.B)  Summary by Non-Attainment Area -- All Categories Tons/avg Episode Day
                    2.a.ii.B.I)          Episode 1:  1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                    2.a.ii.B.II)        Episode 2:  2/14/2008 - 2/18/2008 (5 days)
                    2.a.ii.B.III)       Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
               2.a.ii.C)  SMOKE Profiles
                    2.a.ii.C.I)          States/County Area in Modeling Domain
                    2.a.ii.C.II)         County Populations in Modeling Domain
                    2.a.ii.C.III)        Profile Codes
 
     2.b)  Point Sources
          2.b.i)  Overview
          2.b.ii)  Summary Tables
               2.b.ii.A)  Point Emissions Summary by Non-Attainment Area: SMOKE
                                         Output  -  Tons/Average Episode Day"
                    2.b.ii.A.I)         Episode 1:  1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                    2.b.ii.A.II)        Episode 2:  2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                    2.b.ii.A.III)      Episode 3:  12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
               2.b.ii.B)  Point Source Summary by Company -- Non-attainment Area:  SMOKE
                                  Output -- Tons/Average Episode Day"
                    2.b.ii.B.I)         Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                    2.b.ii.B.II)        Episode 2:  2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                    2.b.ii.B.III)       Episode 3:  12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
          2.b.iii)  Point Source Inventory Development Details (pre-SMOKE processing)
               2.b.iii.A)  2008 point source actual annual emissions
               2.b.iii.B)  Table of sources that stayed unchanged according to questionnaire responses
               2.b.iii.C)  Table of sources that changed according to questionnaire responses  -  by episode
               2.b.iii.D)  Table of sources that reported breakdown/excess emissions according to
                                  questionnaire responses by episode"
               2.b.iii.E)  Appendix 1: Employment Data and Methods
                    2.b.iii.E.I)       Development of Projection Data and Episode Inventories
                    2.b.iii.E.II)      Employment Projection Data
 
               2.b.iii.F)  Appendix 2:  Questionnaire Letters and Data
                    2.b.iii.F.I)        First Form Questionnaire Letter
                    2.b.iii.F.II)       Second Form Questionnaire Letter
                    2.b.iii.F.III)      Episode Breakdown And Excess Emissions
                    2.b.iii.F.IV)      Episode Production Calculations
 
     2.c)  Area Sources
          2.c.i)  Overview
          2.c.ii)  Summary Tables
               2.c.ii.A)  Area/Nonpoint Sources by NA: SMOKE Output-Tons/Average Episode Day
                    2.c.ii.A.I)         Episode 1:  1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                    2.c.ii.A.II)        Episode 2: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                    2.c.ii.A.III)        Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
               2.c.ii.B)  Area/Nonpoint Sources by Sector: SMOKE Output-Tons/Average Episode Day
                    2.c.ii.B.I)          Area/Nonpoint Sources by Sector:  SMOKE Output-Summary of All Pollutants
                         2.c.ii.B.I.1)     Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                         2.c.ii.B.I.2)     Episode 2: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                         2.c.ii.B.I.3)     Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
                    2.c.ii.B.II)         Area/Nonpoint Sources by Non-Attainment Area  -  Sector
                        2.c.ii.B.II.1)     Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                        2.c.ii.B.II.2)     Episode 2: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                        2.c.ii.B.II.3)     Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
                  2.c.ii.B.III)         Area/Nonpoint Sources by NA  -  County  -  Sector  -  With Temporal
                                                 Profile Codes by SCC"
                        2.c.ii.B.III.1)    Episode 1:  1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                        2.c.ii.B.III.2)    Episode 2: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
                        2.c.ii.B.III.3)    Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
                  2.c.ii.B.IV)         Area/Nonpoint Sources by Non-Attainment Area  -  by Pollutant  -  Sector
                        2.c.ii.B.IV.1)    Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
                             PM2.5
                             NOX
                             VOC
                             NH3
                             S02
                             CO
 
                       2.c.ii.B.IV.2)    Episode 2:  2/14/2008 -- 2/18/2008 (5 days)
                             PM2.5
                             NOX
                             VOC
                             NH3
                             S02
                             CO
 
                       2.c.ii.B.IV.3)    Episode 3:  12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
                             PM2.5
                             NOX
                             VOC
                             NH3
                             S02
                             CO
 
               2.c.ii.C)  SMOKE Distribution/Apportionment Tables    
                    2.c.ii.C.I)      States/County Area in Modeling Domain
                    2.c.ii.C.II)     County Populations in Modeling Domain
                    2.c.ii.C.III)    Temporal Profile Code
 
          2.c.iii)  Estimation Methods
               2.c.iii.A)  Area Activity Data Sources
               2.c.iii.B)  Sources
 
          2.c.iv)   2007  -  2010 Episode Years
               2.c.iv.A)   Annual Emissions Summary Tables
               2.c.iv.B)   Area Source Categories
 
 
     2.d)  Non-Road Mobile Sources
          2.d.i)  Non-Road Sources by NA:  SMOKE Output -- Tons/Average Episode Day
               2.d.i.A)      Episode 1:  1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
               2.d.i.B)       Episode 2: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
               2.d.i.C)       Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
          2.d.ii)  Non-Road Sources by Sector:  SMOKE Output -- Tons/Average Episode Day
               2.d.ii.A)      Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
               2.d.ii.B)      Episode: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
               2.d.ii.C)      Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
          2.d.iii)  Non-Road Sources:  PM2.5 Emissions Inventories for PM2.5 SIP Base Years
 
     2.e)  On-Road Mobile Sources
          2.e.i)  On-Road Sources -- Episode Summary:  SMOKE output -- Episode Tons/Average Day
               2.e.i.A)      Episode 1: 1/11/2007  -  1/20/2007 (10 days)
               2.e.i.B)      Episode: 2/14/2008  -  2/18/2008 (5 days)
               2.e.i.C)      Episode 3: 12/8/2009  -  1/20/2010 (44 days)
 
          2.e.ii)  On-Road Mobile Source SIP Inventory -- EPAMOVES2010a Overview
 
          2.e.iii)  On-Road Sources:  PM2.5 Emissions Inventories for PM2.5 SIP Base Years
 
3)  Baseline and Projected Inventories
     3.a)  General
          3.a.i)  Overview
          3.a.ii)  Post SMOKE Summary Tables: 2010, 2015
 
     3.b)  Point Sources
          3.b.i)  Baseline Overview and Methods
               3.b.i.A)  Table 1:  2008 Pre SMOKE Point Source Data Tables
               3.b.i.B)  Table 2:  2010 Pre SMOKE Point Source Baseline Data Table
 
          3.b.ii)  Projections Overview and Methods
               3.b.ii.A)  Table 1:  2008 True-Up Adjusted Pre SMOKE Point Source Data Table
               3.b.ii.B)  Table 2:  Source Reporting Site Specific Growth Factors and Data
               3.b.ii.C)  Table 3: Projected Annual Emissions (Condensables and RACT Included) for 2015
 
          3.b.iii)  Post SMOKE Point Source Summary Tables:  2010, 2015
 
          3.b.iv)  Appendix 1 - Employment by Area and Industry
 
      3.c)  Area Sources
          3.c.i)  Overview:  Baseline and Projection Inventories
          3.c.ii)  Post SMOKE Area Source Summary Tables:  2010, 2015
          3.c.iii)  Estimation Methods
               3.c.iii.A)  Activity Data and Sources
               3.c.iii.B)  Sources
         
           3.c.iv)  Baseline & Projected Years Tables
               3.c.iv.A)  Emissions Summary Tables
               3.c.iv.B)  Categories Tables
 
     3.d)  Non-Road Mobile Sources
          3.d.i)  Overview and Emissions Inventories  --  Baseline and Projected Years
          3.d.ii)  Post SMOKE Non-Road Summary Tables:  2010, 2015
          
     3.e)  On-Road Mobile Sources
          3.e.i)  Overview
          3.e.ii)  Post SMOKE On-Road Summary Tables:  2010, 2015
          3.e.iii)  On-Road Mobile Sources:  PM2.5 Emissions Inventories for PM2.5 SIP
 
4)  Air Quality Modeling
     4.a)  Meteorological Modeling
     4.b)  SMOKE
     4.c)  CMAQ Modeling
     4.d)  MATS
     4.e)  Weight of Evidence
 
5)  Control Strategies
     5.a) Background and Overview
     5.b)  Area Sources
         5.b.i)  Area Source Control Strategies:  Background and Table
                        R307-302.  Residential Fireplaces and Solid Fuel Burning Devices
                        R307-303.  Commercial Cooking
                       R307-307.  Road Salting and Sanding
                       R307-309.  Fugitive Emissions and Fugitive Dust
                       R307-312.  Aggregate Processing Operations
                       R307-335.  Degreasing and Solvent Cleaning Operations
                       R307-342.  Adhesives and Sealants
                      R307-343.  Emission Standards for Wood Furniture Manufacturing Operations
                      R307-344.  Paper, Film and Foil Surface Coatings
                      R307-345.  Fabric and Vinyl Coatings
                      R307-346.  Metal Furniture Surface Coatings
                      R307-347.  Large Appliance Surface Coatings
                      R307-348.  Magnet Wire Coatings
                      R307-349.  Flat Wood Panel Coatings
                      R307-350.  Miscellaneous Metal Parts and Products Coatings
                     R307-351.  Graphic Arts
                     R307-352.  Metal Container, Closure, and Coil Coatings
                     R307-353.  Plastic Parts Coatings
                     R307-354.  Automotive Refinishing Coatings
                     R307-355.  Control of Emissions from Aerospace Manufacture and Rework Facilities
                     R307-356.  Appliance Pilot Light
                     R307-357.  Consumer Products
                     R307-361.  Architectural Coatings
         5.b.ii.A)  RACT Analysis for 2014 Area Source Rule Amendments
         5.b.ii.B)  Final Area Source Rules for 2014 Amendments
      5.b.iii)  Area Source Ammonia Reasonable Available Control Technology (RACT)
    
    5.c)  Point Sources
     5.c.i)     Overview
     5.c.ii)     RACT SUMMARY TABLE
     5.c.iii)   RACT/RACM Evaluation Reports
A-General refinery requirements
B-Big West OIl Refinery
C-Chevron Salt Lake refinery
D-Holly refinery
E-Tesoro salt lake city refinery
F-Kennecott Utah Copper LLC Smelter, Refinery & Map
G-Kennecott Utah Copper LLC-Power Plant
H-Kennecott Utah Copper LLC-BCM
I-Nucor Steel
J-Vulcraft and Nucor Building Systems
K-Proctor and Gamble Paper Products Company
L-Great Salt Lake Minerals
M-ATK Launch Systems Inc
N-Hill Air Force Base
O-Wasatch Integrated Waste Management District
P-Bountiful City Light and Power  -  Power Plant
Q-Pacificorp energy  -  Gadsby Power Plant
R-Constellation Energy Resources Generation II, LLC
S-University of Utah
T-hexcel corporation
U-central valley water reclamation facility
V-Olympia Sales Company
W-Chemical Lime Company  -  Lhoist North America
X-Payson City Power
Y-Provo City Power  -  Power Plant
Z-Pacificorp  -  Lake Side Power Plant
ZA-Springville City Corporation  -  Whitehead Power Plant
ZB-Brigham Young University
ZC-Geneva Nitrogen LLC
ZD-PacifiC states cast iron pipe company
           
     5.d)  Non-Road Mobile Sources
     5.e)  On-Road Mobile Sources
         5.e.i)  RACM Analysis for the Logan, UT-ID Nonattainment Area

6)  Contingency Measure Effectiveness

7)  CD of Inventory Data Files
     PM 2.5 MOVES files
     MATS Input Files
 
8)  CD of Point Source Projection and Inventory Data Files
      Point Source Emissions Inventories
      Point Source True-up, Projections and RACT