Document ID: EPA-HQ-OW-2005-0037-0100
Agency: epa
Document Type: Supporting & Related Material
Title: 
Posted Date: 2006-06-30T04:00Z

DCTM_
ARP.
xls
Manure
Type
Operation
Type
Region
Capital
Cost
($
per
Head)
Annual
Cost
($
per
Head)
Pit
Grower­
Feeder
Mid­
Atlantic
41.3
­
6.31
Pit
Grower­
Feeder
Midwest
42.1
­
5.77
Pit
Farrow­
Feeder
Mid­
Atlantic
39.09
­
2.08
Pit
Farrow­
Feeder
Midwest
39.37
­
2.42
Liquid
Grower­
Feeder
Mid­
Atlantic
38.73
­
6.18
Liquid
Grower­
Feeder
Midwest
39.45
­
5.57
Liquid
Farrow­
Feeder
Mid­
Atlantic
33.81
­
1.97
Liquid
Farrow­
Feeder
Midwest
34.79
­
2.13
Evaporative
Pond
Grower­
Feeder
Central
37.62
­
5.55
Evaporative
Pond
Farrow­
Feeder
Central
33.81
­
2.13
DCTM_
ARP.
xls
Capital
Cost
no
generator
($
per
Head)
18.8
19.6
16.59
16.87
16.23
16.95
11.31
12.29
15.12
11.31
High
Quality
Cover
Material
Operation
Type
Region
Size
Primary
LagoLagoon
Cover
Generator
Building
Engineering
Flush
GF
MA
2,500
12,022
31,568
35,450
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
2,664
12,618
32,904
36,800
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
4,134
17,562
43,592
48,825
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
4,424
18,524
45,613
51,200
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
4,581
19,117
46,851
52,475
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
6,390
25,215
59,316
67,275
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
7,838
30,193
69,228
79,150
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
12,374
45,233
98,306
116,225
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
13,713
49,606
106,592
127,175
25,000
Flush
GF
MA
14,929
53,897
114,555
137,150
25,000
ManureOperation
Type
Region
Size
Primary
LagoLagoon
Cover
Generator
Building
Engineering
Pit
GF
MA
2500
12,022
31,568
35,650
25,000
5000
20546
49813
56325
25,000
Pit
GF
MW
2500
20546
49813
35050
25,000
5000
37439
83370
55125
25,000
Pit
FF
MA
2570
10227
27459
31150
25,000
5145
16815
42012
47350
25,000
Pit
FF
MW
2570
16815
42012
30725
25,000
5145
30193
69228
46475
25,000
Liquid
GF
MA
2500
12,022
31,568
35,450
25,000
5000
20546
49813
55900
25,000
Liquid
GF
MW
2500
20546
49813
35000
25,000
5000
37439
83371
55025
25,000
Liquid
FF
MA
2570
10227
27459
30975
25,000
5145
16815
42012
47025
25,000
Liquid
FF
MW
2570
16815
42012
30675
25,000
5145
30193
69228
46400
25,000
EvaporaGF
CE
2500
13079
33927
35050
25,000
5000
22477
53772
55100
25,000
EvaporaFF
CE
2570
11028
29312
30675
25,000
5145
18329
45204
46400
25,000
Total
Cost
Annual
on
farm
ePropane
Saving
Total
Benefit
Annual
Operating
costs
Total
Cost
($
per
head)
120,267
12,862
3,535
16,397
3,472
48.11
123,713
13,654
3,769
17,423
3,701
46.44
152,753
20,663
5,846
26,509
5,741
36.95
158,379
22,038
6,258
28,296
6,144
35.80
161,640
22,787
6,480
29,267
6,364
35.28
196,671
31,338
9,037
40,375
8,875
30.78
224,775
38,171
11,086
49,257
10,887
28.68
310,027
59,527
17,493
77,020
17,180
25.05
334,817
65,827
19,384
85,211
19,037
24.42
358,157
71,556
21,107
92,663
20,729
23.99
33.55
Total
Cost
Annual
on
farm
ePropane
Saving
Total
Benefit
Annual
Operating
costs
Total
Cost
($
per
head)
104,240
12,955
3,580
16,535
3,515
41.70
151,684
24910
7161
32,071
7033
130,409
11371
3061
14,432
3009
200,934
22108
6122
28,230
6018
93,836
7070
1053
8,123
2749
131,177
12219
2106
14,325
5503
114,552
6824
1053
7,877
2357
170,896
12105
2106
14,211
4719
104,040
12,862
3,535
16,397
3,472
41.62
151,259
24770
7072
31,842
6945
130,359
11344
3051
14,395
2999
200,835
22059
6101
28,160
5998
93,661
7063
1053
8,116
2712
130,852
12218
2106
14,324
5434
114,502
6816
1053
7,869
2348
170,821
12098
2106
14,204
4704
107,056
11285
3028
14,313
2977
156,349
21941
6052
27,993
5951
96,015
6778
1053
7,831
2327
134,933
12057
2106
14,163
4659
Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
(
5.17)
(
5.15)
(
5.02)
(
5.01)
(
5.00)
(
4.93)
(
4.90)
(
4.84)
(
4.83)
(
4.82)
(
4.97)

Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
(
5.21)

(
5.17)
ManureOperation
Type
Region
Size
Primary
LagoLagoon
Cover
Generator
Building
Engineering
Pit
GF
MA
2500
30,000
31,568
46,150
25,000
5000
50,000
49813
66,825
25,000
Pit
GF
MW
2500
30,000
49813
45,550
25,000
5000
50,000
83370
65,625
25,000
Pit
FF
MA
2570
30,000
27459
41,650
40,000
5145
50,000
42012
57,850
40,000
Pit
FF
MW
2570
30,000
42012
41,225
40,000
5145
50,000
69228
56,975
40,000
Liquid
GF
MA
2500
12,022
31,568
45,950
25,000
5000
20,546
49813
66,400
25,000
Liquid
GF
MW
2500
20,546
49813
45,500
25,000
5000
37,439
83371
65,525
25,000
Liquid
FF
MA
2570
10,227
27459
41,475
40,000
5145
16,815
42012
57,525
40,000
Liquid
FF
MW
2570
16,815
42012
41,175
40,000
5145
30,193
69228
56,900
40,000
EvaporaGF
CE
2500
13079
33927
45,550
25,000
5000
22477
53772
65,600
25,000
EvaporaFF
CE
2570
11028
29312
41,175
40,000
5145
18329
45204
56,900
40,000
ManureOperation
Type
Region
Total
Cost
($
Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
Pit
GF
MA
47.99
(
3.46)
Pit
GF
MW
55.10
(
2.86)
Pit
FF
MA
47.79
(
0.30)
Pit
FF
MW
53.36
(
0.39)
Liquid
GF
MA
41.04
(
4.77)
Liquid
GF
MW
51.77
(
4.20)
Liquid
FF
MA
40.30
(
1.62)
Liquid
FF
MW
48.63
(
1.71)
EvaporaGF
CE
40.20
(
4.17)
EvaporaFF
CE
39.23
(
1.70)
Total
Cost
Annual
on
farm
ePropane
Saving
Total
Benefit
Annual
Operating
costs
Total
Cost
($
per
head)
139,354
12,955
3,580
16,535
9,015
55.74
201,220
24910
7161
32,071
12,533
40.24
157,881
11371
3061
14,432
8,509
63.15
235,195
22108
6122
28,230
11,518
47.04
146,064
7070
1053
8,123
8,249
56.83
199,355
12219
2106
14,325
11,003
38.75
160,899
6824
1053
7,877
7,857
62.61
227,013
12105
2106
14,211
10,219
44.12
120,267
12,862
3,535
16,397
4,472
48.11
169,847
24770
7072
31,842
7,945
33.97
147,902
11344
3051
14,395
3,999
59.16
221,902
22059
6101
28,160
6,998
44.38
125,119
7063
1053
8,116
3,712
48.68
164,170
12218
2106
14,324
6,434
31.91
147,002
6816
1053
7,869
3,348
57.20
206,137
12098
2106
14,204
5,704
40.07
117,556
11285
3028
14,313
3,977
47.02
166,849
21941
6052
27,993
6,951
33.37
121,515
6778
1053
7,831
3,327
47.28
160,433
12057
2106
14,163
5,659
31.18
Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
(
3.01)
(
3.91)
(
2.37)
(
3.34)
0.05
(
0.65)
(
0.01)
(
0.78)
(
4.77)
(
4.78)
(
4.16)
(
4.23)
(
1.71)
(
1.53)
(
1.76)
(
1.65)
(
4.13)
(
4.21)
(
1.75)
(
1.65)
ManureOperation
Type
Region
Size
Primary
LagoLagoon
Cover
Generator
Building
Engineering
Pit
GF
MA
2500
30,000
31,568
25,000
5000
50,000
49813
25,000
Pit
GF
MW
2500
30,000
49813
25,000
5000
50,000
83370
25,000
Pit
FF
MA
2570
30,000
27459
40,000
5145
50,000
42012
40,000
Pit
FF
MW
2570
30,000
42012
40,000
5145
50,000
69228
40,000
Liquid
GF
MA
2500
12,022
31,568
25,000
5000
20,546
49813
25,000
Liquid
GF
MW
2500
20,546
49813
25,000
5000
37,439
83371
25,000
Liquid
FF
MA
2570
10,227
27459
40,000
5145
16,815
42012
40,000
Liquid
FF
MW
2570
16,815
42012
40,000
5145
30,193
69228
40,000
EvaporaGF
CE
2500
13079
33927
25,000
5000
22477
53772
25,000
EvaporaFF
CE
2570
11028
29312
40,000
5145
18329
45204
40,000
ManureOperation
Type
Region
Total
Cost
($
Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
Pit
GF
MA
31.28
2.76
Pit
GF
MW
38.64
2.55
Pit
FF
MA
33.38
2.38
Pit
FF
MW
39.13
2.23
Liquid
GF
MA
24.42
1.39
Liquid
GF
MW
35.34
1.20
Liquid
FF
MA
25.95
1.06
Liquid
FF
MW
34.42
0.91
EvaporaGF
CE
24.53
1.19
EvaporaFF
CE
25.69
0.91
Total
Cost
Annual
on
farm
ePropane
Saving
Total
Benefit
Annual
Operating
costs
Total
Cost
($
per
head)
90,896
­
8,015
36.36
131,054
­
11,533
26.21
110,054
­
7,509
44.02
166,289
­
10,518
33.26
102,332
­
7,249
39.82
138,613
­
10,003
26.94
117,613
­
6,857
45.76
167,189
­
9,219
32.50
72,020
­
3,472
28.81
100,127
­
6,945
20.03
100,127
­
2,999
40.05
153,101
­
5,998
30.62
81,570
­
2,712
31.74
103,768
­
5,434
20.17
103,768
­
2,348
40.38
146,392
­
4,704
28.45
72,006
­
2,977
28.80
101,249
­
5,951
20.25
80,340
­
2,327
31.26
103,533
­
4,659
20.12
Annual
Cost
($
per
head)
3.21
2.31
3.00
2.10
2.82
1.94
2.67
1.79
1.39
1.39
1.20
1.20
1.06
1.06
0.91
0.91
1.19
1.19
0.91
0.91