DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17429960
title: APT Knowledge Graph Dataset (Embedded Data)

description: This repository provides embedded representations of the APT knowledge graph dataset, as described in Zhou et al., 2025. To comply with confidentiality requirements, only processed embeddings are shared, enabling researchers to conduct threat analysis and modeling without accessing sensitive raw data.

Dataset Overview

The explicit relation dataset uses the APT knowledge graph with 10 entity types and 11 relationship types. Data statistics are presented in Table 1: Node Type Quantities and Table 2: Relationship Type Quantities.

For implicit relationships, particularly the (Indicator → Uses → TTPs) triples, the dataset includes:





10,127 Indicators: Malicious samples and analysis results, representing mutable "symptom"-level features in the "Pyramid of Pain" model.




293 TTPs: Attacker behaviors and strategies at the apex of the "Pyramid of Pain."




148,231 triples: Sourced from VirusTotal, providing a reliable benchmark for inferring Indicator-TTP relationships.



The embedded data in this repository preserves the structural and semantic properties of the original dataset while ensuring confidentiality.

Node Types

The nodes.csv file details the following node types:




Node Type ID
Node Type




1
Attacker


2
TTPs


3
Campaign


4
CourseOfAction


5
Identity


6
Indicator


7
Location


8
Malware


9
Tool


10
Vulnerability




Dataset Statistics

Table 1: Node Type Quantities




Node Type
Quantity




Attacker
149


TTPs
883


Campaign
76


CourseOfAction
57


Identity
305


Indicator
19,287


Location
250


Malware
1,174


Tool
268


Vulnerability
296,978


Total
319,427




Table 2: Relationship Type Quantities




Relationship Type
Quantity




Attributed to
95


Authored by
54


Downloads
53


Exploits
518


Impersonates
52


Indicates
26,969


Located at
582


Mitigates
1,608


Related to
23


Targets
1,141


Uses
15,996


Total
47,091




Why Embedded Data?

The original APT knowledge graph contains sensitive information unsuitable for public release. The provided embeddings retain essential structural and semantic properties, making them ideal for research tasks such as:





Inferring implicit Indicator-TTP relationships.




Mapping low-level attack traces to high-level behavioral patterns.




Enhancing threat detection and traceability.



Data Source and Rationale

The implicit (Indicator → Uses → TTPs) triples were sourced from VirusTotal for the following reasons:





The APT knowledge graph lacks explicit (Indicator, Uses, TTPs) triples.




Indicators represent mutable features at the base of the "Pyramid of Pain," while TTPs reflect high-level attacker behaviors. Inferring these relationships improves threat detection and traceability.




VirusTotal's public API provides reliable TTP information linked to Indicators, serving as a robust benchmark for validating inferred relationships.



Usage

The embedded data is suitable for research applications, including training machine learning models for cybersecurity threat analysis and evaluating knowledge graph completion methods. Refer to the provided data files and documentation for details on the embedding format and usage instructions.

Contact

For questions or additional information, please contact th