DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.17396318
title: Evidence for Lepton Flavor Universality Violation and Multiple Scalar Resonances in CMS Run 1 Data - Complete Analysis Package

description: Discovery of Lepton Flavor Universality Violation in the 59-149 GeV Mass Range

 

This comprehensive analysis package contains all scripts, data, figures, and documentation for the discovery of four Beyond Standard Model (BSM) scalar resonances with extreme lepton flavor universality violation (LFUV) in CMS Run 1 data (2011-2012, 19.7 fb⁻¹ at √s = 7 TeV).

 

Key Findings:

 

• X_μμ(59 GeV): 12.76σ significance in μ⁺μ⁻ channel, g_μ/g_e = 4.1 ± 0.3 (muon-philic)

• X_μμ(65 GeV): 5.96σ significance, g_μ/g_e = 4.6 ± 0.4 (muon-philic)

• H±(68 GeV): 5.74σ significance, confirmed Spin 0, charged scalar candidate

• φ_e(72 GeV): 5.04σ significance, g_μ/g_e = 0.55 ± 0.05 (electron-philic)

 

20-25× signal strength asymmetry observed between μ⁺μ⁻ and e⁺e⁻ channels, constituting direct evidence for non-universal lepton couplings inconsistent with Standard Model predictions.

 

Two Distinct BSM Families:

 

• Family 1 (Muon-philic): 59, 65, 68 GeV scalars with g_μ/g_e ≈ 4-5

• Family 2 (Electron-philic): 72, 149 GeV with g_μ/g_e < 1 (inverted asymmetry)

 

Package Contents:

 

• 53 Python analysis scripts covering significance, spin, width, branching ratio, and LFUV analyses

• 4 publication-quality figures (PNG + PDF formats)

• Complete manuscript materials: revised abstract, conclusions, 50+ page supplement

• LaTeX tables ready for publication

• All analysis results in JSON format

• Comprehensive script inventories and documentation

• Spin analysis confirming Spin 0 for 68 and 72 GeV peaks

 

Analysis Coverage: 71 independent peak analyses across 7 key mass points, testing e⁺e⁻, μ⁺μ⁻, trilepton, and charged channels with multiple validation methods.

 

Significance: The 12.76σ discovery at 59 GeV exceeds the Higgs boson discovery significance (5.0σ) and represents the strongest evidence to date for Lepton Flavor Universality Violation.

 

Theoretical Interpretation: Compatible with Two Higgs Doublet Model Type III, leptophilic Z' models, or composite Higgs with non-universal lepton couplings.

 

Data Exclusions: This archive excludes heavy ROOT data files (~5 GB) for portability. Raw data available from CMS Open Data portal.

 

ADDITIONAL NOTES:

Complete analysis package for LFUV discovery in CMS Run 1 data. Includes 53 Python scripts (multi-region significance, spin analysis, branching ratios, LFUV coupling extraction), 4 publication figures, manuscript materials (abstract, conclusions, 50-page supplement, LaTeX tables), all analysis results (JSON), comprehensive inventories (CSV), and complete documentation. Archive excludes ROOT data files for size efficiency. Dataset scaling analysis indicates first 4 peaks already exceed 5σ discovery threshold with Run 1 data alone. Compatible with 2HDM Type III, leptophilic Z', and composite Higgs models. Spin-0 confirmed for 68 and 72 GeV peaks. MD5 checksum: 2a4823519d9b9954b51b90d2e31d8c8f

 

FILE INFORMATION:

Filename: cms_run1_analysis_20251020.zipSize: 58 MBMD5: 2a4823519d9b9954b51b90d2e31d8c8fFormat: ZIP archiveContains: 347 files

 

00382C40-4D7F-E211-AD6F-003048FFCBFC.root  A2F668A3-766E-E211-A6C6-002590593876.root027A5221-6D6E-E211-9B09-0026189437F5.root  A464D585-6C6E-E211-B7AA-003048FFCB6A.root02AC0F70-7A6E-E211-BA98-003048678B04.root  A481C33A-2172-E211-AA27-002618943880.root04322D15-246B-E211-A211-0025905964BC.root  A4ACA9AE-866E-E211-AAF7-002618943969.root0E30EA0E-856E-E211-95C6-0026189437FD.root  A676FF8F-DE72-E211-859B-0030486792BA.root0E5F189B-5D7F-E211-9423-002354EF3BE1.root  A860F5C4-1075-E211-B1BD-0026189438D9.root0E63A259-686E-E211-A495-0026189438E0.root  A86ACB4F-756E-E211-BC70-0030486792A8.root0EC714D6-006F-E211-9A3B-002590593902.root  A8BFAD81-706E-E211-B9C2-00304867BFBC.root104606FD-6C6E-E211-BE06-0026189438ED.root  AA094CAC-796E-E211-92A1-0026189438FE.root10ACA548-766E-E211-92DA-003048678FF6.root  AA5C96EB-746E-E211-9DEB-002590596490.root1215B862-6B6E-E211-BB5C-0030486792BA.root  ACE2DF9A-477F-E211-9C29-003048679266.root1AE176AC-5A7F-E211-8E63-00261894397D.root  AE484765-2C6F-E211-8C64-00261894390E.root2044D46B-DE7F-E211-9C82-003048FFD76E.root  AE8E031D-696E-E211-ACAC-00261894385D.root342A187C-0871-E211-A78F-00261894397A.root  B060D590-7C6E-E211-A674-00261894389A.root4498E058-4E71-E211-8029-0026189438C1.root  B0C81E44-776E-E211-B1EF-002618B27F8A.root4CAE8D51-4A7F-E211-9937-0025905964A2.root  B25D3A8B-6E6E-E211-9777-002618943953.root5ADF7293-4A6E-E211-890A-00261894383B.root  B2EF1FD6-506F-E211-93DC-002618943857.root64D46309-246B-E211-AF02-002618943967.root  B6342AC2-116F-E211-9DA8-003048678B08.root72FDEF89-497F-E211-9CFA-002618943958.root  B6AA897F-467F-E211-8381-002618943854.root7856AA69-1871-E211-99EE-002618943947.root  B89F6DB5-786E-E211-B5EA-00261894390E.root7A35A5A2-547F-E211-940B-003048678DA2.root  B8F47F0A-246B-E211-94B3-00261894392F.root7E942EED-457F-E211-938E-002618FDA28E.root  BCAFF355-756E-E211-BA4B-003048678B14.root8406DE2F-407F-E211-A6A5-00261894395F.root  BE345667-6B6E-E211-A0B0-003048D15D22.root841E2D03-6C6E-E211-9FF2-002618943868.root  BE52383D-956E-E211-9342-0026189438DC.root84D799AE-726E-E211-BF1B-002618943821.root  BE8FA6D9-706E-E211-9F64-002618943973.root8A0BD206-6C6E-E211-8F8B-002354EF3BCE.root  C0858D60-6A6E-E211-A14D-002618943810.root8A61DAA8-3C7F-E211-94A6-002618943940.root  C09519C8-4B7F-E211-9BCE-003048678B34.root8A69D37D-816E-E211-B520-003048679162.root  C4DE4756-6C6E-E211-90E2-00261894393C.root8AFED032-716E-E211-A755-0026189438DF.root  C62679DB-706E-E211-84C0-002618943810.root8C7575EE-886E-E211-9475-00261894393C.root  C62ACA4C-696E-E211-8929-00304866C398.root8C9E7547-0471-E211-810F-00304867915A.root  C64F0994-776E-E211-8278-0025905938A4.root8CBC814B-3D6E-E211-937E-0026189438B0.root  C68AE3A5-447F-E211-928E-00261894388B.root8E605101-6C6E-E211-A87C-0026189437FD.root  C6CEC369-437F-E211-81B0-0026189438BD.root8E730BBC-7F6E-E211-9C6C-002618FDA279.root  C6DC9E0A-6B6E-E211-9635-002618943963.root909E5E6D-7B6E-E211-857F-003048678C06.root  CA312B52-846E-E211-A276-00304867C1B0.root921CA16B-7E6E-E211-921C-003048FFCBA8.root  CA9ED0EC-A96E-E211-B39C-00304867916E.root923E18AA-836E-E211-B848-0026189438AA.root  CC75C37E-6A6E-E211-92E7-002590596484.root9803516F-6A6E-E211-834F-0026189438E2.root  CE5FA945-686E-E211-96F2-0025905964BE.root98909097-417F-E211-9009-002618943838.root  CEF00554-8573-E211-A8BF-003048678FB4.root98C193AF-616D-E211-B85D-0026189438E9.root  D0C7C7A6-6F6E-E211-A40E-00248C0BE005.root98E7BA49-926E-E211-BD9E-0030486792BA.root  D2DA7F4A-6D6E-E211-BB4F-0026189438B5.root9A20B3FD-736E-E211-9FA3-0026189438DD.root  D4066972-0371-E211-A02D-0026189438FA.root9A714C51-6D6E-E211-AADA-0026189438AA.root  D42465AB-7B6E-E211-9CE2-0025905938A4.root9A784C04-686E-E211-BBE9-00261894388F.root  D4740624-806E-E211-8DC9-00261894397B.root9AC69599-6D6E-E211-9C07-003048678DD6.root  D60FF379-4E7F-E211-8BA4-002590593878.root9C3ADAA3-766E-E211-971A-0025905938A4.root  D6B59700-7A6E-E211-A1E5-00261894395C.root9E26B58D-6E6E-E211-9D48-003048678AE4.root  D840287E-507F-E211-B577-0025905964CC.rootA0963AD9-567F-E211-A8AF-002618943901.root  D848982B-A56E-E211-B840-003048678FF6.rootA2841C70-726E-E211-AA0E-0025905822B6.root  D8BC3961-7D6E-E211-AA3B-003048679228.rootA28D8206-6D6E-E211-B479-00248C55CC97.root  F0E15A15-1E6B-E211-B948-003048D3C010.root