DOI: 10.5061/dryad.zkh1893j9
title: Measuring the aggregated impact of research: Establishing criteria for coding Translational Science Benefits Model data

description: Introduction: A promising approach to assessing research impact draws on
 the Translational Science Benefits Model (TSBM), an evaluation model that
 tracks the applied benefits of research in four domains: Clinical and
 Medical; Community and Public Health; Economic; and Policy and
 Legislative. However, standardized methods to verify TSBM benefit data, to
 aid in aggregating impact data within quantitative summaries, do not
 currently exist. Methods: A panel of 11 topic experts participated in a
 modified Delphi process to establish content and face validity of a set of
 criteria for verifying qualitative TSBM data. Panelists were each
 affiliated with a Clinical Translational Science Award (CTSA) hub,
 including those at: Case Western Reserve University, Duke University
 School of Medicine, Medical University of South Carolina, University of
 Miami, University of Minnesota, University of New Mexico, and Washington
 University in St. Louis. Two survey rounds were completed by panelists,
 with a moderated discussion in between rounds to discuss criteria not
 reaching consensus to include.  Data: The dataset available
 contains data from 3 surveys. One survey collected screening information
 about panelist's experiences with collecting, analyzing, and
 reporting TSBM data. Another survey collected responses from the first
 round of the delphi panel, which contained proposed criteria on all 30
 TSBM benefits for panelists to respond if the criteria should be required.
 The last survey collected responses from the second round of the delphi
 panel, and was a condensed version of the survey with only the criteria on
 which the panelists had not previously reached consensus, as well as new
 criteria suggested by panelists in Round 1. 
description: # Measuring the Aggregated Impact of Research: Establishing Criteria for
 Coding Translational Science Benefits Model (TSBM) Data Dataset DOI:
 [10.5061/dryad.zkh1893j9](10.5061/dryad.zkh1893j9) ## Description of the
 data and file structure This data is from a Delphi panel used to establish
 the content and face validity of a set of criteria for verifying
 qualitative Translational Science Benefits Model (TSBM) data. A panel of
 11 topic experts participated in a modified Delphi process. Two survey
 rounds were completed by panelists, with a moderated discussion in between
 rounds to discuss criteria not reaching consensus. Criteria with panel
 consensus at or above 70% from the survey rounds were confirmed as
 validated. ### Files and variables #### File:
 DelphiPanelTSBMCriteria\_DATAfull6.16.2025.csv **Description:**  The
 dataset available contains data from 3 surveys. One survey collected
 screening information about panelist’s experiences with collecting,
 analyzing, and reporting TSBM data. Another survey collected responses
 from the first round of the Delphi panel, which contained proposed
 criteria on all 30 TSBM benefits for panelists to respond if the criteria
 should be required. The last survey collected responses from the second
 round of the Delphi panel, and was a condensed version of the survey with
 only the criteria on which the panelists had not previously reached
 consensus as well as new criteria suggested by panelists in Round 1. All
 Delphi panel participants consented to have their data published. This
 dataset contains 11 records; 2 participants did not respond in the second
 survey round. "Null" values in the dataset indicate non-response
 by the participant. Some text fields were optional in the surveys, and
 were intentionally left blank in the dataset due to participants not
 replying to optional fields. No data is missing for required fields. ####
 Variables: | Variable Name | Field Type | Required Field? | Field Label |
 Choices | | :--------------------------------------------- | :--------- |
 :------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | :------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | :------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ | | recordid | (text) | (required) | Record ID | | | overall\_tsbmexperience\_2023\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Overall, how much experience with TSBM do you have? | 0, None 1, A little - have reviewed material or resources about TSBM 2, Some - have begun to collect TSBM data or use the model 3, A lot - have collected TSBM data or used the model multiple times 4, Extensive - have collected TSBM data or used the model frequently | | qual\_collect\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Interview or other qualitative TSBM data collection | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | quant\_collect\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Survey or quantitative TSBM data collection | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | qual\_analysis\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Qualitative TSBM data analysis | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | quant\_analysis\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Quantitative TSBM data analysis | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | case\_study\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | TSBM case study or studies developed | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | quant\_report\_wu | (numeric) | (required) | Quantitative TSBM reporting and/or data visualization | 0, None 1, A little 2, Some 3, A lot 4, Extensive | | panel\_screener\_only\_complete | (text) | | Is the survey complete? | 0, not completed 2, complete | | diagnostic\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the diagnostic procedure is for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the purpose of the diagnostic procedure is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the diagnostic procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous diagnostic procedures | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diag\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | diag\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for diagnostic procedures? | | | diagnostic\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | investigative\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the purpose of the investigative procedure is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the investigative procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous investigative procedures | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | invest\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | invest\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for investigative procedures? | | | investigative\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | guidelines\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_name\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the name of the organization issuing the guidelines | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the guidelines are for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates a broad use of the guidelines | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the content of the guidelines are | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guide\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | guide\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for guidelines? | | | guidelines\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | therapy\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the therapeutic procedure is for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the purpose of the therapeutic procedure is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the therapeutic procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates it is new or has improved on previous therapeutic procedures | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | thera\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | thera\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for therapeutic procedures? | | | therapy\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | biologics\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the biological factors or products are for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the biological factors or products are and their medical purpose | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the biological factors or products are new | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biol\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | biol\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for biological factors or products? | | | biologics\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | biomedical\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomedical\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the biomedical technology is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomedical\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the biomedical technology is used | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomedical\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous biomedical technology | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomedical\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomedical\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biomed\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | biomed\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for biomedical technology? | | | biomedical\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | drugs\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the drug is used by | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the purpose of the drug is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the drug is new | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | drugs\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for drugs? | | | drugs\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | | equipment\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the equipment or supply is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the equipment or supply is used | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous equipment and supplies | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equip\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | equip\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for equipment and supplies? | | | equipment\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | software\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the software is available to others outside of the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the software technology is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the software technology is used | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous software technologies | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | softw\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | softw\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for software technologies? | | | software\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | additional\_comments | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Clinical and Medical benefits. | | | health\_services\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the services are provided for individuals in a community (ie. instead of provided population wide) | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the community health service is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | hlthsvs\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | hlthsvs\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for community health services? | | | health\_services\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | consumer\_software\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the software is broadly available to consumers | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the consumer software is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the consumer software is used | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how it is new or has improved on previous consumer software | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | con\_soft\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | con\_soft\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for consumer software? | | | consumer\_software\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | health\_ed\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the health education resources is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the health education resource is used | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | hlthed\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | hlthed\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for health education resources? | | | health\_ed\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | access\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who health care access is improved for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how health care access is improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | access\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for health care accessibility? | | | access\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | delivery\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the improvement in health care delivery is broad | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how health care delivery is improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | delivery\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for health care delivery? | | | delivery\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | quality\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | quality\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the quality of care was improved, and standards the quality of care is measured by (if applicable) | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | quality\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | quality\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | quality\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | quality\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for health care quality? | | | quality\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | prevention\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | prevention\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the disease prevention and reduction is community or population wide | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | prevention\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how disease prevention and reduction is improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | prevention\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | prevention\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | prevent\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | prevent\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for disease prevention and reduction? | | | prevention\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | qol\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | qol\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who life expectancy and quality of life is improved for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | qol\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how life expectancy or quality of life is improved, and what measure of life expectancy or quality of life is used (if applicable) | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | qol\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | qol\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | qol\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | qol\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for life expectancy and quality of life? | | | qol\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | ph\_practices\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the services are provided for whole communities or populations (instead of care provided for specific individuals) | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the public health service is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the public health service was organized or delivered | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_pract\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | ph\_pract\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for public health practices? | | | ph\_practices\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | additional\_comments2 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Community and Public Health benefits. | | | license\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | license\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who entered into the license agreement | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | license\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the license agreement is for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | license\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | license\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | license\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | license\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for license agreements? | | | license\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | commercial\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commercial\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the non-profit or commercial entity does | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commercial\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commercial\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commer\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | commer\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for non-profit or commercial entities? | | | commercial\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | patents\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | patents\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the patent was received for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | patents\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | patents\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | patents\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | patents\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for patents? | | | patents\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | cost\_effectiveness\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | cost\_effectiveness\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what changes/project activities were done for cost effectiveness | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | cost\_effectiveness\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how cost effectiveness is improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | cost\_effectiveness\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | cost\_effectiveness\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | costeffect\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | costeffect\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for cost effectiveness? | | | cost\_effectiveness\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | savings\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the cost savings are | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how cost savings are achieved/ improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | savings\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for cost savings? | | | savings\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | illness\_cost\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illness\_cost\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the reduction in societal and economic costs of illness are | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illness\_cost\_novel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how societal and economic costs of illness are improved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illness\_cost\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illness\_cost\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illcost\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | illcost\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for societal and financial cost of illness? | | | illness\_cost\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | additional\_comments3 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Economic benefits. | | | committee\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_name\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the name of the committee | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who joined the committee | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the committee does | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_how\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the committee member is involved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | committee\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for committee participation? | | | committee\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | expert\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | expert\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who gave the expert testimony/the name of the entity that testimony was given to | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | expert\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what content was presented in the expert testimony | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | expert\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | expert\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | expert\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | expert\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for expert testimony? | | | expert\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | reports\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the target audience of the document is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the purpose and topic of the document is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | reports\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for scientific research reports? | | | reports\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | legislation\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | legislation\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the legislative body is that passed it/the name of the legislation | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | legislation\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the content of the legislation is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | legislation\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | legislation\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | legis\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | legis\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for legislation? | | | legislation\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | policies\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the entity is that created the policy | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the content of the policy is | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | policies\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for policies? | | | policies\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | standards\_rel\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | is relevant to the TSBM definition | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_who\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the entity is that issued the standards | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_scope\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the standards are broadly used industry or occupation wide | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_what\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates what the content of the standards are | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_result\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit is tied to the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_realized\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the benefit has happened | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_sufficient\_valid1 | (numeric) | (required) | In your view, are there other criteria required for this benefit to be demonstrated? | 1, Yes 0, No | | standards\_othersufficient\_valid1 | (text) | (required) | What criteria do you also view as required for standards? | | | standards\_notes\_valid1 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit (optional): | | | additional\_comments4 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Policy and Legislative benefits. | | | benefits\_criteria\_survey\_round\_1\_complete | (numeric) | Is the survey complete? | 0, not completed | 2, complete | | diagnostic\_who\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the diagnostic procedure is for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_how\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the diagnostic procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | diagnostic\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the diagnostic procedure\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_diagnostic\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the diagnostic procedure? | | | diagnostic\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | investigative\_how\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the investigative procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | investigative\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the investigative procedure\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_investigative\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the investigative procedure? | | | investigative\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | guidelines\_scope\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates a broad use of the guidelines | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | guidelines\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the guidelines\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_guidelines\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the guidelines? | | | guidelines\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | therapy\_value | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the patient-reported value of therapy\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_who\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the therapeutic procedure is for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_how\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the therapeutic procedure is performed | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | therapy\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the therapeutic procedure\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_therapy\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the therapeutic procedure? | | | therapy\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | biologics\_who\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the biological factors or products are for | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | biologics\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing biological factors or products\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_biologics\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the biological factors or products? | | | biologics\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | biomedical\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing biomedical technology\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_biomedical\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the biomedical technology? | | | biomedical\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | drugs\_who\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who the drug is used by | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | drugs\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the drug\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_drugs\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the drug? | | | drugs\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | equipment\_scope | (numeric) | (required) | indicates broad access to or use of the equipment or supply\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | equipment\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the equipment or supply\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_equipment\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the equipment or supply? | | | equipment\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | software\_scope\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the software is available to others outside of the project | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | software\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the software technology\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_software\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the software technology? | | | software\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | additional\_comments\_v2 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Clinical and Medical benefits. | | | health\_services\_novel | (numeric) | (required) | indicates new or improved community health services\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_scope\_b | (numeric) | (required) | indicates broad access to or use of the community health services\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_services\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the community health service\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_health\_services\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the community health service? | | | health\_services\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | consumer\_software\_value | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the value of the software to the consumer\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | consumer\_software\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the consumer software\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_consumer\_software\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the consumer software? | | | consumer\_software\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | health\_ed\_who | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the intended users of the health education resource\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_scope | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how broadly disseminated or available the health education resource is\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | health\_ed\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the health education resource\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_health\_ed\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the health education resource? | | | health\_ed\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | access\_scope | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how broad the increase in health care access is\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | access\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of increased health care access\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_access\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of improved health care access? | | | access\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | delivery\_scope\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the improvement in health care delivery is broad | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | delivery\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of improved health care delivery\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_delivery\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of improved health care delivery? | | | delivery\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | quality\_scope | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how broad the improvement in health care quality is\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | quality\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of improved quality of care\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_quality\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of improved health care quality?&lt; | | | quality\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | prevention\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of disease prevention or reduction\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_prevention\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of disease prevention or reduction? | | | prevention\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | qol\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of improved life expectancy or quality of life\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_qol\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of improved life expectancy or quality of life? | | | qol\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | ph\_practices\_scope\_b | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how use of the public health practice is being spread\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | ph\_practices\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of organizing or delivering the public health service\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_ph\_practices\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the public health practice? | | | ph\_practices\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | additional\_comments2\_v2 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Community and Public Health benefits. | | | license\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the license agreement\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_license\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the license agreement? | | | license\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | commercial\_who | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the target population who receives services from the non-profit or commercial entity\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commercial\_name | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the name of the non-profit or commercial entity\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | commercial\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the non-profit or commercial entity\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_commercial\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the non-profit or commercial entity? | | | commercial\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | patents\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the patent\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_patents\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the patent? | | | patents\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | cost\_effectiveness\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of improved cost effectiveness\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_cost\_effectiveness\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of improved cost effectiveness? | | | cost\_effectiveness\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | savings\_who | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who experiences cost savings\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | savings\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of cost savings\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_savings\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of cost savings? | | | savings\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | illness\_cost\_who | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who experiences reduced societal and financial costs of illness\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | illness\_cost\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of reduced societal and financial costs of illness\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_illness\_cost\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of reduced societal and financial costs of illness? | | | illness\_cost\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | additional\_comments3\_v2 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Economic benefits. | | | committee\_policyaims | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the policy or legislative aims of the committee\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_who\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates who joined the committee | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_how\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the committee member is involved | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | committee\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of committee participation\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_committee\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the committee participation? | | | committee\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | expert\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the expert testimony\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_expert\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the expert testimony? | | | expert\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | reports\_name | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the name of the report\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_scope | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how broadly disseminated or available the report is\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | reports\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of developing the report\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_reports\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the report? | | | reports\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | legislation\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the legislation\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_legislation\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the legislation? | | | legislation\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | policies\_who\_b | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the target population who the policy change benefits\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_how | (numeric) | (required) | indicates how the policy is used to guide decision-making\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | policies\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the policies\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_policies\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the policies? | | | policies\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | standards\_who\_b | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the target population who the standards benefit\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_scope\_valid1\_v2 | (numeric) | (required) | indicates the standards are broadly used industry or occupation wide | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | standards\_evidence | (numeric) | (required) | includes documented evidence of the standards\* | 1, Yes, required 0, No, not required | | text\_standards\_evidence | (text) | | Optional: What type(s) of documentation could the investigator provide as evidence of the standards? | | | standards\_notes\_valid1\_v2 | (text) | | Please share any comments you have on the criteria for this benefit. | | | additional\_comments4\_v2 | (text) | | Use the space below if you have additional comments on the criteria for Policy and Legislative benefits. | | | benefits\_criteria\_survey\_round\_2\_complete | (numeric) | | Is the survey complete? | 0, not completed 2, complete | ## Code/software No software or script is required for this data.  ## Access information Other publicly accessible locations of the data: * Not applicable Data was derived from the following sources: * Not applicable ## Human subjects data Names, emails, and institution information was collected in the Screener Survey to determine who was eligible and available to participate in this project. Names, emails, and institutions have been removed from the dataset posted on Dryad. We received consent to publish the de-identified data in the public domain.