Evidence for neutrino emission from the nearby active galaxy NGC 1068
Creators: name: IceCube Collaboration
name: Abbasi, R.
name: Ackermann, M.
name: Adams, J.
name: Aguilar, J. A.
name: Ahlers, M.
name: Ahrens, M.
name: Alameddine, J. M.
name: Alispach, C.
name: Alves, A. A.
name: Amin, N. M.
name: Andeen, K.
name: Anderson, T.
name: Anton, G.
name: Argüelles, C.
name: Ashida, Y.
name: Axani, S.
name: Bai, X.
name: V., A. Balagopal
name: Barbano, A.
name: Barwick, S. W.
name: Bastian, B.
name: Basu, V.
name: Baur, S.
name: Bay, R.
name: Beatty, J. J.
name: Becker, K. -H.
name: Tjus, J. Becker
name: Bellenghi, C.
name: BenZvi, S.
name: Berley, D.
name: Bernardini, E.
name: Besson, D. Z.
name: Binder, G.
name: Bindig, D.
name: Blaufuss, E.
name: Blot, S.
name: Boddenberg, M.
name: Bontempo, F.
name: Borowka, J.
name: Böser, S.
name: Botner, O.
name: Böttcher, J.
name: Bourbeau, E.
name: Bradascio, F.
name: Braun, J.
name: Brinson, B.
name: Bron, S.
name: Brostean-Kaiser, J.
name: Browne, S.
name: Burgman, A.
name: Burley, R. T.
name: Busse, R. S.
name: Campana, M. A.
name: Carnie-Bronca, E. G.
name: Chen, C.
name: Chen, Z.
name: Chirkin, D.
name: Choi, K.
name: Clark, B. A.
name: Clark, K.
name: Classen, L.
name: Coleman, A.
name: Collin, G. H.
name: Conrad, J. M.
name: Coppin, P.
name: Correa, P.
name: Cowen, D. F.
name: Cross, R.
name: Dappen, C.
name: Dave, P.
name: De Clercq, C.
name: DeLaunay, J. J.
name: López, D. Delgado
name: Dembinski, H.
name: Deoskar, K.
name: Desai, A.
name: Desiati, P.
name: de Vries, K. D.
name: de Wasseige, G.
name: de With, M.
name: DeYoung, T.
name: Diaz, A.
name: Díaz-Vélez, J. C.
name: Dittmer, M.
name: Dujmovic, H.
name: Dunkman, M.
name: DuVernois, M. A.
name: Dvorak, E.
name: Ehrhardt, T.
name: Eller, P.
name: Engel, R.
name: Erpenbeck, H.
name: Evans, J.
name: Evenson, P. A.
name: Fan, K. L.
name: Fazely, A. R.
name: Fedynitch, A.
name: Feigl, N.
name: Fiedlschuster, S.
name: Fienberg, A. T.
name: Filimonov, K.
name: Finley, C.
name: Fischer, L.
name: Fox, D.
name: Franckowiak, A.
name: Friedman, E.
name: Fritz, A.
name: Fürst, P.
name: Gaisser, T. K.
name: Gallagher, J.
name: Ganster, E.
name: Garcia, A.
name: Garrappa, S.
name: Gerhardt, L.
name: Ghadimi, A.
name: Glaser, C.
name: Glauch, T.
name: Glüsenkamp, T.
name: Goldschmidt, A.
name: Gonzalez, J. G.
name: Goswami, S.
name: Grant, D.
name: Grégoire, T.
name: Griswold, S.
name: Günther, C.
name: Gutjahr, P.
name: Haack, C.
name: Hallgren, A.
name: Halliday, R.
name: Halve, L.
name: Halzen, F.
name: Minh, M. Ha
name: Hanson, K.
name: Hardin, J.
name: Harnisch, A. A.
name: Haungs, A.
name: Hebecker, D.
name: Helbing, K.
name: Henningsen, F.
name: Hettinger, E. C.
name: Hickford, S.
name: Hignight, J.
name: Hill, C.
name: Hill, G. C.
name: Hoffman, K. D.
name: Hoffmann, R.
name: Hokanson-Fasig, B.
name: Hoshina, K.
name: Huang, F.
name: Huber, M.
name: Huber, T.
name: Hultqvist, K.
name: Hünnefeld, M.
name: Hussain, R.
name: Hymon, K.
name: In, S.
name: Iovine, N.
name: Ishihara, A.
name: Jansson, M.
name: Japaridze, G. S.
name: Jeong, M.
name: Jin, M.
name: Jones, B. J. P.
name: Kang, D.
name: Kang, W.
name: Kang, X.
name: Kappes, A.
name: Kappesser, D.
name: Kardum, L.
name: Karg, T.
name: Karl, M.
name: Karle, A.
name: Katz, U.
name: Kauer, M.
name: Kellermann, M.
name: Kelley, J. L.
name: Kheirandish, A.
name: Kin, K.
name: Kintscher, T.
name: Kiryluk, J.
name: Klein, S. R.
name: Koirala, R.
name: Kolanoski, H.
name: Kontrimas, T.
name: Köpke, L.
name: Kopper, C.
name: Kopper, S.
name: Koskinen, D. J.
name: Koundal, P.
name: Kovacevich, M.
name: Kowalski, M.
name: Kozynets, T.
name: Kun, E.
name: Kurahashi, N.
name: Lad, N.
name: Gualda, C. Lagunas
name: Lanfranchi, J. L.
name: Larson, M. J.
name: Lauber, F.
name: Lazar, J. P.
name: Lee, J. W.
name: Leonard, K.
name: Leszczyńska, A.
name: Li, Y.
name: Lincetto, M.
name: Liu, Q. R.
name: Liubarska, M.
name: Lohfink, E.
name: Mariscal, C. J. Lozano
name: Lu, L.
name: Lucarelli, F.
name: Ludwig, A.
name: Luszczak, W.
name: Lyu, Y.
name: Ma, W. Y.
name: Madsen, J.
name: Mahn, K. B. M.
name: Makino, Y.
name: Mancina, S.
name: Mariş, I. C.
name: Martinez-Soler, I.
name: Maruyama, R.
name: Mase, K.
name: McElroy, T.
name: McNally, F.
name: Mead, J. V.
name: Meagher, K.
name: Mechbal, S.
name: Medina, A.
name: Meier, M.
name: Meighen-Berger, S.
name: Micallef, J.
name: Mockler, D.
name: Montaruli, T.
name: Moore, R. W.
name: Morse, R.
name: Moulai, M.
name: Naab, R.
name: Nagai, R.
name: Nahnhauer, R.
name: Naumann, U.
name: Necker, J.
name: Nguyên, L. V.
name: Niederhausen, H.
name: Nisa, M. U.
name: Nowicki, S. C.
name: Nygren, D.
name: Pollmann, A. Obertacke
name: Oehler, M.
name: Oeyen, B.
name: Olivas, A.
name: O'Sullivan, E.
name: Pandya, H.
name: Pankova, D. V.
name: Park, N.
name: Parker, G. K.
name: Paudel, E. N.
name: Paul, L.
name: Heros, C. Pérez de los
name: Peters, L.
name: Peterson, J.
name: Philippen, S.
name: Pieper, S.
name: Pittermann, M.
name: Pizzuto, A.
name: Plum, M.
name: Popovych, Y.
name: Porcelli, A.
name: Rodriguez, M. Prado
name: Price, P. B.
name: Pries, B.
name: Przybylski, G. T.
name: Raab, C.
name: Rack-Helleis, J.
name: Raissi, A.
name: Rameez, M.
name: Rawlins, K.
name: Rea, I. C.
name: Rehman, A.
name: Reichherzer, P.
name: Reimann, R.
name: Renzi, G.
name: Resconi, E.
name: Reusch, S.
name: Rhode, W.
name: Richman, M.
name: Riedel, B.
name: Roberts, E. J.
name: Robertson, S.
name: Roellinghoff, G.
name: Rongen, M.
name: Rott, C.
name: Ruhe, T.
name: Ryckbosch, D.
name: Cantu, D. Rysewyk
name: Safa, I.
name: Saffer, J.
name: Herrera, S. E. Sanchez
name: Sandrock, A.
name: Sandroos, J.
name: Santander, M.
name: Sarkar, S.
name: Sarkar, S.
name: Satalecka, K.
name: Schaufel, M.
name: Schieler, H.
name: Schindler, S.
name: Schmidt, T.
name: Schneider, A.
name: Schneider, J.
name: Schröder, F. G.
name: Schumacher, L.
name: Schwefer, G.
name: Sclafani, S.
name: Seckel, D.
name: Seunarine, S.
name: Sharma, A.
name: Shefali, S.
name: Silva, M.
name: Skrzypek, B.
name: Smithers, B.
name: Snihur, R.
name: Soedingrekso, J.
name: Soldin, D.
name: Spannfellner, C.
name: Spiczak, G. M.
name: Spiering, C.
name: Stachurska, J.
name: Stamatikos, M.
name: Stanev, T.
name: Stein, R.
name: Stettner, J.
name: Steuer, A.
name: Stezelberger, T.
name: Stokstad, R.
name: Stürwald, T.
name: Stuttard, T.
name: Sullivan, G. W.
name: Taboada, I.
name: Ter-Antonyan, S.
name: Tilav, S.
name: Tischbein, F.
name: Tollefson, K.
name: Tönnis, C.
name: Toscano, S.
name: Tosi, D.
name: Trettin, A.
name: Tselengidou, M.
name: Tung, C. F.
name: Turcati, A.
name: Turcotte, R.
name: Turley, C. F.
name: Twagirayezu, J. P.
name: Ty, B.
name: Elorrieta, M. A. Unland
name: Valtonen-Mattila, N.
name: Vandenbroucke, J.
name: van Eijndhoven, N.
name: Vannerom, D.
name: van Santen, J.
name: Verpoest, S.
name: Walck, C.
name: Watson, T. B.
name: Weaver, C.
name: Weigel, P.
name: Weindl, A.
name: Weiss, M. J.
name: Weldert, J.
name: Wendt, C.
name: Werthebach, J.
name: Weyrauch, M.
name: Whitehorn, N.
name: Wiebusch, C. H.
name: Williams, D. R.
name: Wolf, M.
name: Woschnagg, K.
name: Wrede, G.
name: Wulff, J.
name: Xu, X. W.
name: Yanez, J. P.
name: Yoshida, S.
name: Yu, S.
name: Yuan, T.
name: Zhang, Z.
name: Zhelnin, P.
Publisher: name: arXiv
Year: 2022
Subjects: subject: High Energy Astrophysical Phenomena (astro-ph.HE)
subject: Astrophysics of Galaxies (astro-ph.GA)
subject: Instrumentation and Methods for Astrophysics (astro-ph.IM)
subject: High Energy Physics - Experiment (hep-ex)
subject: FOS: Physical sciences
subject: FOS: Physical sciences

description: We report three searches for high energy neutrino emission from astrophysical objects using data recorded with IceCube between 2011 and 2020. Improvements over previous work include new neutrino reconstruction and data calibration methods. In one search, the positions of 110 a priori selected gamma-ray sources were analyzed individually for a possible surplus of neutrinos over atmospheric and cosmic background expectations. We found an excess of $79_{-20}^{+22}$ neutrinos associated with the nearby active galaxy NGC 1068 at a significance of 4.2$\,σ$. The excess, which is spatially consistent with the direction of the strongest clustering of neutrinos in the Northern Sky, is interpreted as direct evidence of TeV neutrino emission from a nearby active galaxy. The inferred flux exceeds the potential TeV gamma-ray flux by at least one order of magnitude.
description: Minor adjustment to the pdf metadata. Paper content remains unchanged. For the published version of this article visit the Science web portal: https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.abg3395 , or the IceCube database (no subscription needed): https://icecube.wisc.edu/science/publications/