D3.1: Pilot Operational Characterization and Global Challenges
Creators: name: GIROA SOCIEDAD ANONIMA
name: AZIENDA ELETTRICA DI MASSAGNO (AEM) SA
name: Findhorn Innovation Research & Education, CIC
name: MUNICIPALITY OF ALBA IULIA
name: SCUOLA UNIVERSITARIA PROFESSIONALE DELLA SVIZZERA ITALIANA
name: GRID SINGULARITY GMBH
name: SOFTWARE IMAGINATION & VISION SRL
Publisher: name: Zenodo
Year: 2024

description: Positive Energy Districts (PEDs) play an increasingly important role in the European context contributing to achieving climate goals, establishing energy security, advancing economic progress, fostering innovation and cutting-edge technology and promoting citizen and community engagement. 

The implementation of PEDs across Europe plays a critical role in the continent's strategy to achieve a sustainable and resilient future. This deliverable has two main objectives: 1) to analyse the readiness of the EU and EEA, and in particular of four pilot locations: Scotland, Switzerland, Spain and Romania, for implementation of PEDs. 2) to evaluate the technical and operational aspects of the project pilots by analysing their energy system topology, market and pricing mechanisms, equipment specifications, and overall ICT/IOT infrastructure. 

The deliverable evaluates community engagement, including the potential of local energy sharing/trading, from a business and regulatory perspective. Regulatory sandboxes and regulation exemptions (good practices) are also explored at EU level. The aim is to identify operational challenges and enable synergies with the grid systems. Policy makers and regulators need to be aware of and have clarity about effective transition towards PEDs. Lack of awareness among users creates hurdles, which need to be addressed by educating them about potential benefits. This lack of awareness also negatively influences wider social acceptance of the PED concept. 

A thorough analysis of the legislative framework within the EU regarding PEDs, covering various aspects such as energy sector roles, consumption patterns, poverty alleviation, collective generation, smart metering, demand-side management, building performance standards, and electric vehicle infrastructure is presented. The challenges associated with the formation and development of PEDs are discussed, encompassing legal, economic, social, and technical dimensions. Emphasis is placed on the importance of community-led energy initiatives within PEDs to ensure their success and sustainability. 

The second part of the deliverable aims to evaluate the technical and operational aspects of the project pilots, namely Lugaritz Matia Community, in San Sebastian Spain; the Park Ecovillage Findhorn, in Moray Scotland; Arena Innovation Community, in Capriasca Switzerland; and Alba Iulia in, Transylvania Romania. It      provides a detailed overview of their system topology, market and pricing mechanisms, equipment specifications, and the overall ICT/IOT infrastructure. The objective is to categorise the energy systems of pilots, including both renewable and conventional resources, with a particular focus on local RES exploitation and waste heat recovery opportunities. By providing a description of the socio-economic profile of each PED the ability to impact energy demand based on human behaviour change, as well as by participation in local energy trading is elucidated. 

Through the overview and analysis of these four pilots the deliverable shines a light on the diversity of PEDs and their potential to be developed in a variety of contexts and countries. It provides an evidence base for the flexibility of the concept and pliancy of its application to support the development and optimization and scaling of energy communities across Europe.