Omni-channel services in the banking industry_Qualitative multi-method research.pdf
Creators: name: Reis, João
Publisher: name: figshare
Year: 2024
Subjects: classificationCode: 401404
subject: Industrial engineering

description: The 64th article of the regulation of studies of the University of Aveiro considers the possibility of presenting an alternative to the doctoral thesis. This modality emphasizes that “if the thesis is replaced by a set of scientific papers already published, they will have to form a coherent and relevant set for the scientific area of the doctorate (…)”. In this context, this thesis is based on 8 scientific publications, some already published, and some accepted for publication, which include: oral communications in international conferences, articles in scientific journals, and book chapters. The interest in the subject is coined with the growing development of the omni-channel strategy in the service industry where the banks have been pioneers. The objective is to contribute to the characterization and understanding of the implications of different strategies and configurations of the service channel strategies for the management of operations and, consequently, for service quality and customer satisfaction. The thesis is divided into six chapters. It begins with two systematic reviews of the literature: to analyze research opportunities and to disseminate research paths for multi-channel services. From here on, the methodological options are explained and so are the existing relationship between industrial engineering and the social sciences. The empirical phase starts at this point as well as the analysis of the omni-channel services in the lens of technology-based business networks and complaint management. The literature review suggested, that, to date, the existing studies were predominantly formulated from a marketing perspective, the studies focused on process management and service operations are less represented. In this context, the work developed offers some contributions to the management of multiple-channel service operations, to identify, characterize and consolidate different multiple-channel strategies, and discuss principles for the alignment between multiple-channel front-office strategies and operational levels of the organization. A qualitative multi-method methodology (i.e., systematic review and case study) using different methods and sources was adopted for data collection (e.g., interviews) as well for its analysis. The work also illustrated how the multimethod strategy offers multiple research possibilities that lead to reliable results for studies in the field of engineering. This strategy is generally balanced and integrates theoretical and empirical studies, which give greater emphasis to the dimensions of development, triangulation and complementarity. The empirical evidence analyzed in this thesis suggests that service delivery through multiple channels raises new organizational synergies and creates new operational challenges, by allowing the configuration of new service systems that offer customers the integration of different service and channels from different providers in a unique experience. The omni-channel service operations are now based on technology-based business networks, as companies are changing the way they compete with each other. Companies are adopting processes and channels so they can collaborate in heterogeneous networks. These business networks generally combine more than one channel and service, which creates a multi-brand experience, clearly going beyond the typical omni-channel experience. In this perspective, the heterogeneous network of companies is an experience that involves the combination of a triad of different elements of channel-service-organization. What is implicit is that, although still unexplored, technology-based business networks are revolutionizing the service industry. Nevertheless, the move to omni-channel and business network strategies is far from linear. Although undesirable, the omnichannel service failures are inevitable, thus complaint management has always been considered an essential tool for managers. As a result, this work also includes an approach to service failures and recovery in an omnichannel context, as well as the weaknesses in the service delivery concerning new technology-based networks, in the context of financial services. The study suggested that clients are generally unaware of the recovery attributes of each channel and are often forced to seek help from the frontline employees, particularly when the recovery from the virtual channels is not in agreement with the expectations. Customers are not willing to interact with a large number of channels which would lead to a high number of interactions. Alternatively, customers are willing to wait for a personalized recovery when they realize that a specific failure may require a high level of decision-making. This tolerance occurs when customers realize that a company is making all the necessary efforts over the service recovery, in order to ensure that the failure will not be repeated again. The results revealed the importance of recovering permanent solutions and operations management, in order to allow effective recovery processes in the context of omni-channel and business network services. With regard to technology-based business networks, we found four types of weaknesses: a) barriers to channel migration strategies; b) barriers to automated service delivery; c) barriers to employee-technology service integration; d) barriers to operations standardization in network contexts. Managers should be aware of the weaknesses of technology-based business networks because their (in)activity can affect either positively or negatively network brand image. Solving Tb2N weaknesses allows organizations to be more synchronized and competitive. The results presented in this thesis reveal that the multiple-channel strategies are far from being overcome. This area of study requires permanent attention from the academic community in order to understand its evolution, the emergence of new strategies and to advance its knowledge base. Finally, we encourage the development of future research that allows the conduction of empirical studies within technology-based business networks, focusing not only on collecting data from one company but from the entire network.