Frontal NCAP performance and field injury over 40 years
Creators: name: Viano, David C.
Publisher: name: Taylor & Francis
Year: 2024
Subjects: subject: Biochemistry
subject: Neuroscience
subject: Physiology
subject: FOS: Biological sciences
subject: Pharmacology
subject: Biotechnology
subject: Chemical Sciences not elsewhere classified
subject: Sociology
subject: FOS: Sociology
subject: Immunology
subject: FOS: Clinical medicine
subject: Science Policy
subject: Mental Health

description: Vehicle and occupant responses in 35 mph NCAP tests were determined for small-midsize passenger cars grouped around model year (MY) 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010 and 2020. A baseline was established with 1980 vehicles not designed for NCAP. The results of four decades of vehicles designed for NCAP were compared to the baseline. The study also determined the risk for serious injury (MAIS 3 + F) by vehicle model year (MY) using 1989–2015 NASS and 2017–2020 CISS. It explored safety trends in frontal crashes over 50 MYs of vehicles. The 1980 baseline group was established with 10 1979–1983 MY passenger cars weighing &lt;1,500 kg. Four decades of vehicle crash tests from five manufacturers established trends in vehicle dynamics and dummy responses over four decades of vehicles designed for NCAP. Triaxial acceleration of the head and chest were reanalyzed for each test to have a consistent set of responses over five decades. The risk for serious injury (MAIS 3 + F) to the driver and front passenger was determined by vehicle MY using 1989–2015 NASS and 2017–2020 CISS with belted and unbelted drivers and right-front passengers. The data was sorted in four MY groups 1961–1989 MY, 1990–1999 MY, 2000–2009 MY and 2010 MY-2021 MY. The risk for MAIS 3 + F injury was determined with standard errors using weighted data. The 1980 NCAP tests brought about changes in vehicle structures and occupant restraints by 1990; however, HIC<sub>15</sub> and 3 ms chest acceleration have not changed much the past 20 years since the use of advanced airbags and seatbelts with pretensioner and load-limiters. For the driver, HIC<sub>15</sub> dropped 40 ± 19% from the 1980 to 1990 NCAP tests and dropped further to 76 ± 32% in 2020. The percentage drops after 1990 were not statistically significant. The driver 3 ms chest acceleration dropped 18 ± 5% from 1980 to 1990 and plateaued with 22 ± 6% in 2020. For the front passenger, HIC<sub>15</sub> dropped 68 ± 52% from the 1980 to 1990 NCAP tests and plateaued at 71 ± 49% in 2020. The passenger 3 ms chest acceleration dropped 13 ± 5% from 1980 to 1990 and has fluctuated with minimal change. Injury risks based on responses show the same initial drop in 1990 and have remained essentially constant. Nothing meaningful has changed in dummy responses in the past 20 years of NCAP testing. The field data found the belted driver MAIS 3 + F risk was 1.66 ± 0.37% in 1961–1989 MY vehicles and 1.39 ± 0.33% in 2010–2021 MY vehicles. For belted right-front passengers, the risk was 1.52 ± 0.39% in 1961–1989 MY vehicles and 1.42 ± 0.46% in 2010–2021 MY vehicles. The field data shows no meaningful change in injury risk in 50 MYs of vehicles. NCAP involves 35–40 mph delta-V, which represents a small fraction, 0.33%, of belted occupant exposure and only 8.6% of severe injury based on 1994–2015 NASS. The NCAP test lacks field relevance. Manufacturers are merely “tuning” the restraint systems for star ratings without meaningful changes in field injury risks the past 20 years. There are disbenefits of “tuning” safety for a single, high-severity crash when most of the severe injury occurs in lower severity crashes. NHTSA should reevaluate plans to change the dummy to Thor and add BrIC injury criteria to assess NCAP responses. These changes would cause manufacturers to further “tune” structures, restraints and interiors without meaningful effects in real-world crashes.