Finite Element Modelling of Reinforced Concrete Beams with Corroded Shear Reinforcement
Creators: name: Bernard, Sebastien
Publisher: name: Université d'Ottawa / University of Ottawa
Year: 2013
Subjects: Corrosion
Reinforced Concrete
Shear Strength
Deterioration
Assessment

description: This thesis presents a finite element (FE) modelling approach investigating the effects of corroded shear reinforcement on the capacity and behaviour of shear critical reinforced concrete (RC) beams. Shear reinforcement was modelled using a “locally smeared” approach, wherein the shear reinforcement is smeared within a series of plane-stress concrete elements at the specific stirrup location. This was done with the objective of incorporating both the reduction in cross-sectional area due to corrosion and the corresponding expansion of corrosion products build up. Corrosion damage was incorporated through equivalent straining induced by the corrosion build up on the affected surrounding concrete where the concrete cover was treated as a thick-wall cylinder subjected to internal pressure. Strains were introduced in the FE model using fictitious smeared horizontal pre-stressing steel, with a compressive pre-straining level related to the degree of corrosion penetration of the reinforcement. The FE modelling approach was first validated against published test data of shear critical RC beams with and without stirrup corrosion. The proposed modelling approach successfully reproduces the load deformation response as well as the failure mode and cracking patterns of the published experimental tests. Upon validation of the FE model, the work was extended to a parametric analysis of important shear design variables, such as the shear span-to-depth ratio, beam width and stirrup spacing The FE analyses were carried out for three increasing levels of corrosion (low, moderate and high) applied to affected stirrups within the critical section of the beams and based on steel mass loss (10%, 30% and 50%, respectively). In general, the results show a reduction in load carrying capacity accompanied by a softening of the load-deformation curves with each increasing level of corrosion. In most of the cases, a reduction in deflection associated to peak loads was also observed for moderate and high levels of corrosion. The impact of the various parameters was studied with respect to strength and deformation, as well as crack angle and mid-height horizontal strain. This was done in an effort to compare FE values to those provided by the CSA A23.3 design equations. The CSA A23.3 shear design equations were compared against FE analysis data in terms of residual shear strength estimation and individual component contributions to shear resistance (i.e., concrete and steel). The comparisons revealed an over conservative estimation for both strength and concrete contributions and an overestimation of the steel contribution. This divergence was attributed to a transition in shear behaviour within the critical section. Based on the progression of the concrete compressive struts with increasing corrosion and predicted crack angle, it was found that stresses in affected sections are redistributed towards adjacent undamaged material. The shear resistance mechanism generally transitioned from typical beam behaviour towards an arching-dominated one. Finally, based on important findings from the literature and the work conducted within this research, important considerations for assessment practice are suggested.