Observation of $e^+e^-\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{b1,2}(1P)$ and search for $e^+e^-\to\phi\chi_{b1,2}(1P)$ at $\sqrt{s}=$10.96---11.05 GeV
Creators: name: Yin, J. H.
name: Yuan, C. Z.
name: Adachi, I.
name: Aihara, H.
name: Al Said, S.
name: Asner, D. M.
name: Aulchenko, V.
name: Aushev, T.
name: Ayad, R.
name: Babu, V.
name: Badhrees, I.
name: Bahinipati, S.
name: Bakich, A. M.
name: Bansal, V.
name: Behera, P.
name: Beleño, C.
name: Bhuyan, B.
name: Bilka, T.
name: Biswal, J.
name: Bobrov, A.
name: Bozek, A.
name: Bračko, M.
name: Browder, T. E.
name: Cao, L.
name: Červenkov, D.
name: Chang, P.
name: Chekelian, V.
name: Chen, A.
name: Cheon, B. G.
name: Chilikin, K.
name: Cho, K.
name: Choi, S.-K.
name: Choi, Y.
name: Choudhury, S.
name: Cinabro, D.
name: Cunliffe, S.
name: Dash, N.
name: Di Carlo, S.
name: Dingfelder, J.
name: Doležal, Z.
name: Dong, T. V.
name: Drásal, Z.
name: Eidelman, S.
name: Epifanov, D.
name: Fast, J. E.
name: Ferber, T.
name: Fulsom, B. G.
name: Garg, R.
name: Gaur, V.
name: Gabyshev, N.
name: Garmash, A.
name: Gelb, M.
name: Giri, A.
name: Goldenzweig, P.
name: Golob, B.
name: Haba, J.
name: Hayasaka, K.
name: Hayashii, H.
name: Hirose, S.
name: Hou, W.-S.
name: Iijima, T.
name: Inami, K.
name: Inguglia, G.
name: Ishikawa, A.
name: Itoh, R.
name: Iwasaki, M.
name: Iwasaki, Y.
name: Jacobs, W. W.
name: Jaegle, I.
name: Jeon, H. B.
name: Jia, S.
name: Jin, Y.
name: Joffe, D.
name: Joo, K. K.
name: Julius, T.
name: Kang, K. H.
name: Kawasaki, T.
name: Kiesling, C.
name: Kim, D. Y.
name: Kim, J. B.
name: Kim, K. T.
name: Kim, S. H.
name: Kinoshita, K.
name: Kodyš, P.
name: Korpar, S.
name: Kotchetkov, D.
name: Križan, P.
name: Kroeger, R.
name: Krokovny, P.
name: Kuhr, T.
name: Kulasiri, R.
name: Kwon, Y.-J.
name: Lange, J. S.
name: Lee, I. S.
name: Lee, S. C.
name: Li, L. K.
name: Li, Y. B.
name: Li Gioi, L.
name: Libby, J.
name: Liventsev, D.
name: Lubej, M.
name: Luo, T.
name: Masuda, M.
name: Matsuda, T.
name: Matvienko, D.
name: Merola, M.
name: Miyata, H.
name: Mizuk, R.
name: Mohanty, G. B.
name: Moon, H. K.
name: Mori, T.
name: Mussa, R.
name: Nakano, E.
name: Nanut, T.
name: Nath, K. J.
name: Natkaniec, Z.
name: Nayak, M.
name: Niiyama, M.
name: Nisar, N. K.
name: Nishida, S.
name: Nishimura, K.
name: Ogawa, K.
name: Ogawa, S.
name: Ono, H.
name: Pakhlov, P.
name: Pakhlova, G.
name: Pal, B.
name: Pardi, S.
name: Park, H.
name: Paul, S.
name: Pedlar, T. K.
name: Pestotnik, R.
name: Piilonen, L. E.
name: Popov, V.
name: Prencipe, E.
name: Rostomyan, A.
name: Russo, G.
name: Sahoo, D.
name: Sakai, Y.
name: Salehi, M.
name: Sandilya, S.
name: Santelj, L.
name: Sanuki, T.
name: Savinov, V.
name: Schneider, O.
name: Schnell, G.
name: Schwanda, C.
name: Seino, Y.
name: Senyo, K.
name: Seon, O.
name: Sevior, M. E.
name: Shen, C. P.
name: Shibata, T.-A.
name: Shiu, J.-G.
name: Shwartz, B.
name: Simon, F.
name: Sokolov, A.
name: Solovieva, E.
name: Starič, M.
name: Sumiyoshi, T.
name: Sutcliffe, W.
name: Takizawa, M.
name: Tamponi, U.
name: Tanida, K.
name: Tenchini, F.
name: Uchida, M.
name: Uglov, T.
name: Unno, Y.
name: Uno, S.
name: Urquijo, P.
name: Van Hulse, C.
name: Van Tonder, R.
name: Varner, G.
name: Vinokurova, A.
name: Vorobyev, V.
name: Wang, B.
name: Wang, C. H.
name: Wang, M.-Z.
name: Wang, P.
name: Wang, X. L.
name: Watanuki, S.
name: Widmann, E.
name: Won, E.
name: Yamamoto, H.
name: Ye, H.
name: Yusa, Y.
name: Zhang, Z. P.
name: Zhilich, V.
name: Zhukova, V.
name: Zhulanov, V.
Publisher: name: Deutsches Elektronen-Synchrotron, DESY, Hamburg
Year: 2018
Subjects: electron positron: annihilation
electron positron: colliding beams
error: statistical
Upsilon(10870): electroproduction
Upsilon(11020): electroproduction
chi mesons: electroproduction
Upsilon(11020): branching ratio: measured
energy dependence
BELLE
KEK-B
tree approximation
Born approximation
channel cross section: upper limit
experimental results
electron positron --&gt; chi mesons pi+ pi- pi0
Upsilon(11020) --&gt; pi+ pi- pi0 chi mesons
Upsilon(11020) --&gt; electron positron
electron positron --&gt; Phi(1020) chi mesons
10.96-11.02 GeV-cms

description: We report searches for the processes $e^+e^-\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{bJ}$ and $e^+e^-\to\phi\chi_{bJ}$ (J=1,2) in the vicinity of the $\Upsilon(11020)$ resonance using energy scan data collected by the Belle experiment at the KEKB collider. We observe $e^+e^-\to \pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{b1}$ and find evidence for $e^+e^-\to \omega\chi_{b2}$ processes for data with center-of-mass energies from 10.96 to 11.05~GeV for the first time. The statistical significance for $\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{b1}$ and $\omega\chi_{b2}$ are $6.1\sigma$ and $4.0\sigma$, respectively. We investigate energy dependence of the $e^+e^-\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{bJ}$ cross section and find that it is consistent with production of $\Upsilon(10860)$ and $\Upsilon(11020)$ resonances without significant non-resonant contribution. Assuming $e^+e^-\to \pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{bJ}$ proceeds via $\Upsilon(10860)$ and $\Upsilon(11020)$, the branching fraction $\mathcal{B}(\Upsilon(11020)\to\pi^+\pi^-\pi^0\chi_{bJ})=(8.6\pm4.1\pm6.1^{+4.5}_{-2.5})\times10^{-3}$ is measured for the first time, where the first error is statistical, the second is systematic, and the third from the branching fraction of $\Upsilon(11020)\to e^+e^-$. The signals for $e^+e^-\to \phi\chi_{bJ}$ are not significant, and the upper limits of the Born cross sections at the 90\% confidence level are $0.6$ and $1.0$~pb for $e^+e^-\to \phi\chi_{b1}$ and $\phi\chi_{b2}$, respectively, for center-of-mass energies from 10.96 to 11.05~GeV.