Document: 355 U.S. 18 78 S.Ct. 2 L.Ed.2d 1 See 900, 258. Jay Lee GIBSON, Petitioner, v.Guy A. THOMPSON, Trustee, New Orleans, Texas & Mexico Railway Company. No. 142. Rehearing Denied Dec. 9, 1957. Messrs. Doerner, Rhinehart Stuart, Tulsa, Okl., Fred Parks, Houston, Tex., for petitioner. Woodul, Arterbury Wren, Walter F. respondent. PER CURIAM. The petition certiorari is granted, and the judgment of Supreme Court reversed case remanded. We hold that proofs justified with reason jury's conclusion employer negligence played a part in producing petitioner's injury. Rogers v. Missouri Pacific R. Co., 352 500, 77 443, 493; Webb Illinois Central 512, 451, 503; Ferguson Moore-McCormack Lines, Inc., 521, 457, 511; Shaw Atlantic Coast Line 353 920, 680, 718; Futrelle 682, Deen Gulf, C. S.F. Ry. 925, 715, 721; Thomson 926, 698, 722; Arnold Panhandle 360, 840, L.Ed. 889; Ringhiser Chesapeake O. 354 901, 1093, 1268; McBride Toledo Terminal 517, 1398, 1534. For reasons set forth his opinion 524, 459, 493, Mr. Justice FRANKFURTER view writ improvidently granted. Memorandum HARLAN, whom BURTON WHITTAKER join. elaborated by at last Term, 511, I think should have been denied. However, continue view, expressed 559, 478, once has granted such cases, we disbelievers, consistent Court's procedure, consider them on merits. Further, much as disagree, 562—564, 478 481, reasoning philosophy case, which strips historical role judge jury trial all meaningful significance, feel presently bound to bow it. Applying present am forced concur judgments reversal Nos. 142 350.

Category: 7