Document: 404 U.S. 116 92 S.Ct. 360 30 L.Ed.2d 312 NATIONAL LABOR RELATIONS BOARD, Petitioner,v.PLASTERERS' LOCAL UNION NO. 79, OPERATIVE PLASTERERS' & CEMENT MASONS' INTERNATIONAL ASS'N, AFL-CIO, et al. TEXAS STATE TILE TERRAZZO CO., Inc., al., Petitioners, v. Nos. 70—63, 70—65. Argued Oct. 13, 1971. Decided Dec. 6, Syllabus Two unions, the Plasterers and Tile Setters, in accordance with procedures binding them to arbitrate, submitted a board their jurisdictional dispute over work be done for contractor. The awarded Plasterers. When contractor Setters refused abide by arbitration board's decision, Plasterers, force reassignment of work, picketed that as well another employing members Setters. Neither was subject agreement. Charges were thereupon filed against allegedly violating § 8(b)(4)(D) National Labor Relations Act, hearing resolve held under 10(k), which directs Board (NLRB) 'hear determine out (the alleged) unfair labor practice (has) arisen' unless 'the parties such dispute' agree upon settlement. NLRB, after weighing decision 'and all (other) relevant factors,' award, 8(b)(4) (D) complaint they found have violated provision. Both contractors, had collective-bargaining agreements (but not Plasterers) been union perform operation involved dispute, contended it far more efficient use tile setters than plasterers. Court Appeals on review set aside NLRB's order, holding is employer but rival unions are 10(k) applies. Held: employers here, both substantial financial stakes outcome proceeding, 'parties within meaning provision NLRB empowered this case where competing employers, agreed voluntary method adjustment. Highway Truckdrivers, Local 107 (Safeway Stores, Inc.), 134 N.L.R.B. 1320, distinguished. Pp. 123—137. 142 U.S.App.D.C. 146, 440 F.2d 174, reversed. Norton J. Come, Washington, D.C., Bd. Wayne S. Bishop, Texas State Terrazzo Co., Inc. others. Donald Capuano, respondents. Laurence Gold, American Federation Congress Industrial Organizations, amicus curiae. Mr. Justice WHITE delivered opinion Court. 1 charge amended, provision1 banning so-called disputes, must (the) shall arisen, * adjust or adjustment dispute.2 issue here whether an employer, 'party' 'dispute' purposes 10(k). two involved, settlement, dismiss proceedings proceed being afforded chance participate? 2 Co. (Texas State) Martini (Martini) contractors Houston, Texas, engaged business installing terrazzo. Tile, Marble Union No. 20 (Tile Setters) characteristically used laying also described contract applying 'a coat coats mortar, prepared proper tolerance receive floors, walls ceiling regardless mortar wet dry at time applied it.'3 3 This arose when Plasterers' Operative Cement Masons' International Association (Plasterers), job sites claiming Setters.4 nor regularly employed workers represented union. 4 Before picketing began, claim disputed Joint Settlement Jurisdictional Disputes (Joint Board), body established Building Trades Department, certain groups.5 Setters' locals bound decisions because international AFL-CIO's Department. decisions, however. covered agreement August 1917, between Plasterers.6 acquiesce change assignment, began formed basis charges. jobsite employees, tile, although Board. 5 Southwestern Construction general hired State, charges Regional Director noticed consolidated dispute.7 Southwestern, Martini, participated hearing. A panel noted admitted procedures, deemed lack controlling weight,8 'after taking into account balancing factors' Setters.9 indicate would Board's issued them, committed assign them.10 In making rejected contention even though provisions precluded subsequent 6 On petition cross t enforce Board, divided order Board.11 It that: 'It (or other employee groups) who contesting employees entitled seek question.'12 concluded may make determination opposing settle differences through arbitration. petitioned certiorari, we granted petitions.13 II 7 Section makes organization strike threaten coerce person require particular one group rather another, refusing honor representation its face, section appear cover any challenge assignment prohibited means employed. Radio Television Broadcast Engineers Union, 1212, 364 573, 576, 81 330, 332, 302 (1961) (hereinafter CBS). As charging intervening party, normally party section.14 8(b)(4)(D), however, read light interlocked. CBS, supra, S.Ct., 332. there reasonable cause believe has committed, issuance withheld until satisfied. That determine' alleged arose; required decide acceptable, Board-developed standards, underlying Whether will sustained dismissed thus dependent proceeding. allows fully participate proceeding party. If prefers whom he assigned his right later relief union's conditioned ability convince original valid criteria 8 jobsites giving rise disagreement lay final plaster coat. three-cornered one. made demands cases, employers' refusal accede inevitably inextricably triangular intended resolve. 9 some cases no stake how settled interested only prompt Other shown cause, neutral economic interests result different terms conditions employment, new bargain with, higher wages costs, lower efficiency quality work. construction industry, particular, frequently calculate bids very narrow margins, small cost likely extremely important.15 present contracts specifically covering issue; neither regularly. determined best vigorously less costly same craft last plaster, putting bonding coat, consistent industry did.16 companies claimed costs substantially increased if award went without lose 30%—40% plastering contractors.17 obvious, therefore, 10 phrase given commonsense corresponding actual here. Cf. United Automobile, Aerospace Agricultural Implement Workers America, AFL—CIO, 283 Scofield, 382 205, 220, 86 373, 382, 15 272 (1965). does expressly impliedly deny status since section's adoption 1947, accorded settle.18 11 Its reasoning, find unpersuasive, should insist participation. But standing alone, binds No cease-and-desist either results from proceeding; impact felt practical determines prevail proceedings. persists conduct despite it, issues guilty ordered cease desist. hand, wins comply, employer's evaporates dismissed.19 legally observe 8(b) (4)(D) protection may, did shut down job. intense pressure, practically, conform decision. design Act; provided way implement 12 We do legislative history requires conclusion. rely various statements sections, particularly remarks Senator Morse, referring disputes controversies unions,20 passage House Conference Report directing practices 8(b)(4)(D).'21 Nothing these documents indicates affirmative intent exclude participating usual focus debates ways protecting havoc strikes.22 follow condemning economically deleterious effects inter-union strife say affect radical way. non-neutral nothing negatives standing;23 dispute,' terminology ordinarily include these.24 13 cautioned '(i)t treacherous Congressional silence alone rule law.' Girouard States, 328 61, 69, 66 826, 90 L.Ed. 1084 (1946); Boys Markets, Retail Clerks 770, 398 235, 241, 1583, 1587, 26 199 (1970). clear protect public detrimental 'indefensible'25 strikes. therefore myopic transform procedure meant device could injure them. absence 'unmistakable directive,' construe legislation aimed class fashion run counter goals clearly effectuate. FTC Fred Meyer 390 341, 349, 88 904, 908, 19 1222 (1968). conclude, sections enacted partisan those neutral. 14 mandates Until case, striking pursuant certification contract. taken too view task broader, inclusive respect entitlement, other. course opinion, referred 10(k)'s having 'no except groups employer.' U.S., 579, 334. Again, quarrel designed before us decides question. CBS able equal skill, expense, efficiency. recognized there, 'as most instances' 'so little interest seems perfectly willing (union) just let him alone.' Ibid. (emphasis added.) doubt, intention deciding now us. considered absent private agreement, abort insisted so encourage avoid arbitration, whereas sufficient foreclose action pressure become part settlement mechanisms productive sound much swifter 16 difficulties argument several. First all, arbitrate terminate proceedings, assurance always open participation, meaningful participate, factors properly considered.26 17 Second, regarding dispensable reminiscent position case. There, sought justify function failure awards generating privately. passed Senate, directed alternative deleted Conference, amended bill Senate strenuous objections Morse others.27 By amendment, expressed preference compared compelled policy respected. 581—582, 335—336, 302. Although approved expansive role enforcement settlements predicated voluntarily themselves mechanism bargaining table. Carey Westinghouse Electric Corp., 375 261, 84 401, 404, 320 (1964) Clerk's 238, 1585, acceded terminal step grievance procedure. concession instant case; contemplates bar decline powers coerced accept compulsory declined adopt policy. 18 There remains matter Safeway announced 196228 followed since.29 Under rule, effectively renounces claim, aborted legitimate securing urged prevents situation, cannot understand doctrine, disclaims terminate, 'parties' statute, ground that, words brief power, hear merits definition, exist claims *.'30 Concededly, third assignments, differenced declines conflict §§ eliminate disappears. comparative determining tasks. refuses Similarly, applicability premised conflicting job; futile replaces disclaiming reject disfavored resumes picketing. disclaimer ends about becomes academic; not, can prevent recognizing insures come Further, applies longer faces demonstrates, apply unimplemented consider applicable continue loses work.31 These de facto real, deserve resolution achieved. 579—580, 334—335. extend arbitrate; inter- equivalent effective unions. ignores rule. fails recognize problem arising local continues parent body. difference 'settlement' agreed-upon long barred enjoying theoretical resolution. simple reason live unresolved fact existed. 21 Our conclusion evinces hostility wholly federal contexts, challenged poses arbitrable jurisdiction will, policy, defer arbitral LMRA. See 29 U.S.C. 160(a); 272, 409; Strong, 393 357, 360—361, 89 541, 544—545, 546 (1969); Acme 385 432, 438, 87 565, 569, 495 (1967). statutorily situations, often defers arbitrator practice. Spielberg Mfg. 112 1080 (1955); Harvester 138 923 (1962), enforced sub nom. Ramsey 327 784 (CA7 1964). again, deference context us, LMRA settlement; ignore override arbitrate. 22 Reversed. 61 Stat. 136, 141 seq. provides agents '(i) engage in, induce individual commerce affecting employment use, manufacture, process, transport, otherwise, handle goods, articles, materials, commodities services; (ii) threaten, coerce, restrain commerce, object thereof is— '(D) forcing requiring trade, craft, class, failing representative performing work.' 158(b)(4). provides: 'Whenever charged paragraph 158(b) title, unless, ten days notice filed, submit satisfactory evidence adjusted, methods of, dispute. Upon compliance dismissed.' 160(k). App. 20. grew developed mid-1950's. R. 111, 123, 135. 1948 Associated General Contractors America several specialty contractors' associations. consists number representatives chairman. An signing stipulation agreeing Art. III, 7, Bldg. Constr. Dept., Plan Settling Nationally Locally Member AFL—CIO's Department formally virtue contained constitutions. Procedural Rules Regulations generally K. Strand, Construction: Causes, 89—104 (1961). November 9, 1966, 'any day tile.' 316. give up undercoat applied, gave picket line January 24, 1967; March 15, 1967, clarification stating smooth laid dry-set 341. employer-subcontractor, intervened 22. among parties, area practice, relative skills operation, past weight 'ambiguous nature,' 22), concluded: 'Tile least skilled performance plasterers, satisfied Moreover, assignments explicit wit Employers, inconsistent *.' 23. reported 167 185 (1967) 172 70, 72 adverse prove violation issue. findings conclusions res judicata determination. Typographical 125 759, 761 (1959). put stage, often, stipulate record Finally, exercise need occurred, while itself preponderance 8(b)(4)(D). n. 174 Id., 152, F.2d, 180. worksite nevertheless 401 973, 91 1195, 28 322 (1971). C.F.R. 102.8, 102.9, 102.109 (1971); 219—221, 382—383, Comment, Employer Necessary Party Voluntary Work Assignment NLRA, 38 U.Chi.L.Rev. 389, 400 96—97, 130—132, 141. 95, 129, 145—148. See, e.g., Lodge 68 Int'l Assn. Machinists (Moore Drydock Co.), 1108, 1113—1114, 1126—1128 (1949); 231, Hod Carriers (Middle States Telephone 598, 604 (1950); Brotherhood Carpenters, 581 (Ora Collard), 98 346, 348—349 (1952); Journeymen Apprentices Plumbing Pipefitting Industry Canada, 108 186, 197 (1954); Bay Counties District Council 115 1757, 1766—1767 (1956); 173, Wood, Wire, Metal Lathers' (Newark Essex Plastering 121 1094, 1103—1104 (1958); Operating (Schwerman Pa., 139 1426, 1429 (1962); Carpenters Denver (J. O. Veteto Son), 146 1242, 1245 (1964); Electrical Workers, (McCloskey 147 1498, 1501—1503 (Twin City 152 1609, 1611, 1615 (1965); Engineers, 49 (Egan-McKay Contractors, 164 672, 673 reasserted Appeals' Lathers 104 (Blaine Petty 186 70 now, courts appeals uniformly upheld position; see, New Orleans 368 755, 763 (CA 1966); 825, 326 213, 216 1964); 450, A.F.L.-C.I.O. Elliott, 256 630, 636 1958). 264, 405, (1964), citing Wire (Acoustical Assn.), 119 1345, 1347 (1958). dismissal language 'compliance (Board's) decision' but, rather, 'employer Apparently, construes disregarding Brief 23 16, 21. regulations provide 'if regional director irrespective complied determination.' 36 Fed.Reg. 9133 93 Cong.Rec. 1845, 1824 (remarks Sen. Morse). H.R.Conf.Rep. 510 H.R. 3020, 80th Cong., 1st Sess., 57 (1947). A1222—A1223 Cong. Landis); 3424 Hartley); 3227—3228 Lucas); 4860 4862 Aiken); A2251—A2253 Ball). extended unorganized employees. bill, broadened Committee conflicts organized 584, 337, what apparently participation explicitly considered, Taft indicated proceeding: 'Mr. Morreale (General Counsel, Hodcarriers, Building, Common Laborers America) I think (compulsory antagonistic unions) itself, combination matters, affected interested, labor. joint management 'The Chairman (Sen, Taft) objection address arbitrating question.' Hearings 55 Public Welfare pt. 3, p. 1467 version explanation Conference. 27, infra. 24 construing ruled 'without probative value, contradictory, ambiguous,' permitted control customary words. Dickerson, 310 554, 562, 60 1034, 1038, 1356 (1940). Gemsco, Walling, 324 244, 260, 65 605, 614, 921 (1945). previously occasion term broad realistic definition. Lewis 357 10, 78 1029, 1103 (1958), Counsel subpoena. obtained subpoenas duces tecum ad testificandum issued; complaint, moved revoke 11(1) Act member thereof, application forthwith subpoenas. *' define 'party,' emphasized 'major one' 1032. 'indispensable prosecution case' relegating lesser 'overlook critical performs Act.' 1033. description equally (1965), somewhat similar analysis substantive judicial stage successful 'charged' 'charging' intervene ensuing action. Excluding common-law 'all persons materially suit ought court 'do complete justice." Vetterlein Barnes, 124 U.S.169, 170—171, 441, 442, 31 (1888). Story Livingston, Pet. 359, 375, 200 (1839). 25 President Truman, 1947 Message, 136. stated guidelines resolving disputes: certifications company arbitrators, boards, AFL-CIO related business. list exclusive, illustration. Every act judgment based common sense experience precedent.' Machinists, 1743 A. Jones 135 1402, 1410—1411 (1962). solely interpretation 1917 1924 interpreting 53, 69—70, 73—76. At were: 'Decisions forth Green Book Department's book precedents), Unions attested trade prevailing locality.' 1(a), 1970 addition 1(f), 'Because efficiency, good essential well-being consumer settling disputes.' 27 6452—6453; 6519 Pepper). 1320 Bridge 678 (W. Aldrich 145 943 Carpet, Linoleum Soft Layers, 1905 (Butcher Sweeney 143 251 (1963); (Acoustics Specialities, 598 Brie limited 'to situations involving (was) (of union) involved.' 251, 255—256 (1963) original). Joiners (A.F.L.-C.I.O.) 1849 C. Montag Sons, 335 216, 221 Las Vegas, 525 (Charles Dorfman), 173 1339 presently representing question, Mine (Turman 136 1068 ignored disclaimers questioned representative's authority disclaim Millwrights' 1113 (Brogdex 157 996, 1002 (1966). 1291, Longshoremen's (Pocahontas Steamship 676 enforced, (CA3 1966), cert. denied, 386 1033, 1482, 595 (1967); Bricklayers' 2, 278, 282 supra

Category: 6