Document: 491 U.S. 701 109 S.Ct. 2702 105 L.Ed.2d 598 Norman JETT, Petitioner,v.DALLAS INDEPENDENT SCHOOL DISTRICT. DALLAS DISTRICT, Petitioner v. JETT. Nos. 87-2084, 88-214. Argued March 28, 1989. Decided June 22, Syllabus Jett, a white male, was employed by respondent Dallas Independent School District (DISD) as teacher, athletic director, and head football coach at predominantly black high school. After repeated clashes with the school's Principal Todd, man, over school policies Jett's handling of program, Todd recommended that Jett be relieved his duties director coach. The DISD's Superintendent Wright affirmed Todd's recommendation reassigned to teaching position in another school, where he had no coaching duties. Alleging, inter alia, racially motivated, DISD, acting through Wright, discriminated against him on basis race violation 42 U.S.C. §§ 1981 1983 Equal Protection Clause, brought this action Court, which upheld jury verdict favor all counts. Court Appeals reversed part remanded, finding, among other things, Court's instructions liability under § were deficient, since (1) they did not make clear that, Monell New York City Dept. Social Services, 436 658, 98 2018, 56 611, such could predicated actions or only if those officials been delegated policymaking authority acted pursuant well settled custom represented official policy; (2) even considered policymaker for purposes transfer personnel, made finding decision either improperly motivated consciously indifferent improper motivations Todd. also rejected conclusion respondeat superior theory, noting held Congress intend municipalities subject vicarious federal constitutional statutory violations their employees, declaring impose certain wrongs based apparently would contravene congressional intent behind 1983. Held: judgment is part, cases are remanded. 798 F.2d 748 (CA5 1986), 837 1244 1988), Justice O'CONNOR delivered opinion respect Parts I, III, IV, concluding that: 1 1. A municipality may liabl its employees' theory. express "action law" provided "deprivation . rights secured Constitution laws" provides exclusive damages remedy guaranteed when claim pressed state actor. Cf., e.g., Brown GSA, 425 820, 96 1961, 48 402, holding 717 Title VII Civil Rights Act 1964 constitutes racial discrimination employment despite possibility an implied 1981, invoked general principle precisely drawn, detailed statute pre-empts more remedies. Monell, supra, specifically cannot liable while Courts post-Monell decisions have unanimously contention, analogous petitioner's argument here, theory available aBivens-type directly from Fourteenth Amendment. Given recognition Amendment largely intended embody expand protections 1981's predecessor actors, declines invitation imply broader than declaration rights. Creation allow 1983's carefully crafted remedial scheme circumvented artful pleading. Nor can standard 1988, since, although does authorize district courts civil look common law remedies withdraws where, inconsistent law; i.e., See Moor County Alameda, 411 693, 706, 710, n. 27, 93 1785, 1794, 1796, 36 596. Thus, prevail petitioner must show "right contracts" caused policy within meaning ofMonell subsequent cases. Pp. 731-736. 2 2. These remanded determine whether, light principles enunciated clarified Pembaur Cincinnati, 475 469, 106 1292, 89 452, St. Louis Praprotnik, 485 112, 108 915, 99 107, possessed final Texas area employee transfers, so whether new trial required responsibility determination. Although correctly ruled constituted manifest error, case tried before Praprotnik decided, issued Praprotnik. 736-738. 3 O'CONNOR, joined THE CHIEF JUSTICE, WHITE, KENNEDY, concluded Part II text legislative history both 1866 1871, precursors respectively, demonstrate provide independent local governmental entities; rather, explicit provisions control context actors. 711-731. 4 (a) Act, originally enacted implement Thirteenth Amendment, demonstrates neither nor created any original jurisdiction support Act's penal section—the provision explicitly directed officials—was designed punish committing itself. Two passage Act—the submission States ratification, upon, widely viewed "constitutionalizing," protections, reenactment substance Enforcement 1870, statute—further evidence relationship between statute. 713-722. 5 (b) 1871 expressly enforce establish unlike portion exposed newly deprivation rights; expanded providing prosecution actions; (3) now modeled amend enhance parallel same violations. contention already actors unpersuasive. Moreover, fact Sherman amendment Act—which proposed imposition municipal governments injuries mob violence enjoyment exercise rights—demonstrates awareness of, desire comply with, then-reigning doctrine "dual sovereignty," indicated power assign duty instrumentalities making them others. background, silently form historically untenable. Furthermore, addition, 1874, phrase "and what indicates guarantees contained enforced remedy. 722-731. 6 SCALIA question properly decided solely rudimentary construction specific—here, 1983, precludes precise category offense issue—governs general—here, 1981—and permits, statutes dealing similar subjects should interpreted harmoniously. P. 738-739. 7 J., announced I REHNQUIST, C.J., SCALIA, JJ., joined; WHITE joined, except insofar relies history; II, joined. filed concurring judgment, post, p. 738. BRENNAN, dissenting opinion, MARSHALL, BLACKMUN, STEVENS, 739STEVENS, 753. 8 Frank Gilstrap, Arlington, Tex., Jett. 9 Leonard J. Schwartz, Dallas, Dist. 10 KENNEDY join. 11 questions us these cause entities, superior. 12 * South Oak Cliff High (South Oak) until reassignment DISD hired 1957, assigned assistant 1962, promoted 1970. During lengthy tenure Oak, composition changed black. In 1975, Dr. Fredrick black, principal Oak. clashed repeatedly policies, particular program. conflicts came following November 19, 1982, game Plano School. objected comparison team professional teams match, entered officials' locker room after lost told two never work game. statements, reported newspaper, effect majority players meet National Collegiate Athletic Association academic requirements collegiate athletes. 13 On 15, informed recommend 17, sent letter John Kincaide, athletics recommending removed poor leadership planning skills comportment subsequently met Santillo, personnel who suggested schools because remaining shattered. then Linus superintendent DISD. At meeting, believed criticisms performance unfounded animus wished replace difficulties might preclude but assured him. 14 25, remain officially remove felt compelled follow principal. Soon Santillo effective August 4, teacher Business Magnet School, include Petitioner's attendance poor, May 5, Sant llo wrote indicating being placed "unassigned budget" temporary security department. Upon receiving Santillo's letter, lawsuit Northern Texas. offered freshman track Jefferson accept assignment, formal resignation 15 personal capacities, alleging due process, First equal protection process alleged constitutionally protected property interest deprived without law. allegation removal taken retaliation statements press regarding sports program His causes positions white, responsible discriminatory diminution status. claimed product harassment thus amounted constructive discharge. claims jury, found awarded $650,000 $150,000 jointly severally, $50,000 punitive capacity. 16 motion notwithstanding verdict, defendants argued there showing sustained district. App. Pet. Cert. No. 46A. argument, Board Trustees unreviewable reassign saw fit. Id., 47A. event, court cognizable "liability permitted one 1981." Ibid. set aside award unsupported evidence, excessive ordered remittitur $200,000, otherwise denied defendants' motions n.o.v. jury's respects. 62A-63A. has reached settlement longer party action. 82A-84A. 17 appeal, Fifth Circuit (1986). Initially, "in intangible, noneconomic benefits assignment coach." 754. Since received teacher's coach's salary reassignment, change deprive entitlement Due Process Clause. constructively discharged insufficient sustain loss offer less r humiliating unpleasant reasonable resign. 754-756. While "very close," sufficient conclude transferred impermissible animus. noted replaced coach, overtones tension game, explanation unsatisfactory rating questionable supported testimony spoke laudatory terms. 756-757. substantial concerning standing athletes remarks addressed matters public concern, admitted consideration 18 turned district's deficient First, instruction policy. Second, Wright's 759-760. 19 1981. 611 (1978), employees. reasoned "[t]o section 1983." F.2d, 762. 20 published second rejecting suggestion rehearing en banc panel gave further entities unavailable (1988). our rested " 'creation raised problems' associated framers 1247, quoting U.S., S.Ct., 2037. 21 Because Appeals' bodies Appeals, see, Springer Seaman, 821 871, 880-881 (C.A.1, 1987); Frankfort Electric W ter Plant Bd., 752 189, 194, (C.A.6, 1985) (dictum), we granted petition certiorari 87-2084. 488 940, 363, 102 353 We cross-petition 88-214, ibid., clarify application Pra- protnik, 107 (1988) (plurality opinion), 452 (1986) potential 22 note stage proceedings substantive scope reach injury suffered here. Patterson McLean Credit Union, 164, 176-177, 2363, 2372, 132 (1989). Instead, limitations applicable obtained violated contested below ground injury, assume cases, deciding, reassignment. Canton Harris, 489 378, 388-389, 8, 1197, 1204, 103 412 (1989); United Leon, 468 897, 905, 104 3405, 3411, 82 677 (1984). Rule 21.1(a). 23 amended, 24 "All persons shall right every State Territory contracts, sue, parties, give full benefit laws enjoyed citizens, like punishment, pains, penalties, taxes, licenses, exactions kind, other." 25 essence, argues 39th create others enumerated concedes itself completely silent score, see Brief 26, contends nonetheless Act. adopt prevailing approach effectuate remedy, concludes place 1866, it 42d Congress, passed present day narrow sweeping five years earlier. "repeals implication favored," id., (citations omitted), unaffected constraints Monell. alternative, 1988 invites craft looking principles, again point rule 27-29. To examine contentions, consider respectively. 26 BRENNAN's dissent errs sserting strayed upon certiorari. 739-740. asks decide "[w]hether job resulted 'policy custom' order recover i. answering question, lower looked refused differentiate "between sections liability." 1247. brief merits took issue militated creation pp. 14-16; 14-25. "private Sections 1982 do arise language statutes," "look fashion single rule," 28-29 (footnote omitted). think obvious fairly included 27 Equally implausible somehow unwittingly answered past. 741. Most cited involved private conduct, quite obviously propriety judicial address BRENNAN Takahashi Fish Game Comm'n, 334 410, 68 1138, 92 L.Ed. 1478 (1948), Hurd Hodge, 24, 847, 1187 inapposite. 745. mandamus court, understandably nothing say about injunctive relief, latter apply Columbia time case. Carter, 409 418, 602, 34 613 (1973). A. 28 December 18, 1865, Secretary certified ratified become Constitution. Less three weeks later, Senator Lyman Trumbull, Chairman Senate Judiciary Committee, introduced S. 61, 1866. Cong. Globe, Cong., 1st Sess., 129 (1866). bill eight introduced, first relevant inquiry Section 1, provided: 29 "That immunities inhabitants account race, color, previous condition slavery; regard slavery involuntary servitude, punishment crime whereof duly convicted, inherit, purchase, lease, sell, hold, convey real property, person none other, law, statute, ordinanc , regulation, contrary notwithstanding." 474. 30 January 29, Trumbull floor describe 61 colleagues. "the will amount unless machinery carry into effect." 475. alluded 31 color ordinance, subject, subjected, inhabitant act, different penalties having 32 reason prescribed persons, deemed guilty misdemeanor, and, conviction, punished fine exceeding $1,000, imprisonment year, both, discretion court." 33 Senate: "This valuable far protecting freedmen concerned." This criminal freedman felt, retrospect somewhat naively, "it necessary go late slaveholding State, most prominent ones hope break up whole business." described third bill, which, later enacted, pertinent part: 35 States, respective districts, have, exclusively several cognizance crimes offenses committed also, concurrently circuit causes, criminal, affecting tribunals locality act; suit prosecution, commenced person, whatsoever defendant proper manner 'Act relating habeas corpus regulating cases,' approved three, eighteen hundred sixty acts amendatory thereof." Stat. 27. "giving customs." Much debate House terms "civil immunities" sentence Senate. remained throughout Senate's stricken shortly body bill. 37 Discussion focused constitutionality subjecting officers effectuating laws. Opponents consistently referred fines levied judges enforcement conflict 475, 499, 500 (Sen. Cowan); Davis); 1121 (Rep. Rogers); 1154 Eldridge). They intimated understood political subdivisions States. 38 Debate court. Howard, opponent, engaged criticism introduction Trumbull. As numerous examples perception operation. All for. 479 ("All Federal courts"); Davis) ("Section suits come purview courts"). February 2, vote House. 606-607. 39 Representative Wilson Iowa, Of said: 40 "Mr. Speaker, safely affirm declares equality citizens merely affirms existing It object rights, protect belong citizen." 1117. 41 Senate, immediately provision, main mechanism "In accomplish end, fortify declaratory portions sanctions render effective." 1118. discussion debates surrounding response Bingham's proposal send back Committee "to strike out parts said proceedings, lieu thereof injured denial courts, double costs emergency, damages." 1266, 1291. Bingham opposed strictly grounds exceeded Government. "sustaining relation Government States," Bingham, along Republicans, doubted interfere reserved powers define 1292. realized objections applied modification "less oppressive, therefore objectionable." 43 responded Republican colleague's proposal. pointed difference saying citizen enactments rights." 1295. however effectiveness He stated: 44 proposes humblest ample cost Government, whose [Bingham] recognizes involved, says despoiled instead Gove nment, own way pay bills attendant thereon. highest obligation owes return allegiance exacted secure Under gentleman receive few dollars damages, fortunate solvent wrongdoer. called protection. asked enforcing Dollars weighed life, liberty property." 45 thereafter defeated 113 37. 1296. carried House, adding ninth appeal Supreme arising 13661367. concurred amendments record vote, 1413-1416, President. 46 days, President Johnson vetoed returned objections. President's Trumbull's responses thereto, particularly illuminating. declared counteract legislation, "by imposing legislators pass laws." 1680. section, vest affected. 47 statements. charge result legislators, replied: "Who punished? Is Are men bill? Not all. If 'under law,' entitled, punished. Who? who, some communities prevails inflicted blacks meted whites offense. Does propose community prevails? Or custom, deprives right? perversion assert anything else." 1758. 49 proceeding. "So reference given against. Now, necessarily against, discriminating him, Legislature him; validity comes States; presumed judge hold valid direct conflict, rise tested, 1759. 50 went indicate "[i]f [of discrimination] confer clause amendment." days April 6, overrode veto 15. 1809. 9, message read floor. 1857-1860. promptly 122 41, 1861, became 51 Several points emerge adoption nowhere Jones Alfred H. Mayer Co., 392 409, 414, 13, 88 2186, 2189, 1189 (1968) (noting "[t]hat couched method enforcement"); Sullivan Little Hunting Park, Inc., 396 229, 238, 90 400, 405, 386 (1969); Cannon University Chicago, 441 677, 690, 12, 1946, 1954, 60 560 (1979); 728, 1947 (WHITE, dissenting). Allen McCurry, 449 90, 99, 14, 101 411, 417, 66 308 (1980) (§ embodied "post-judgment state-court threatened"); Georgia Rachel, 384 780, 788-789, 86 1783, 1788-1789, 925 (1966); Strauder West Virginia, 100 303, 311-312, 664 (1880). Finally, officials, was, words, "person act," prevails." 1758 52 events bear just months joint resolution sending ratification. past, "constituted initial blueprint Amendment." General Building Contractors Assn., Inc. Pennsylvania, 458 375, 389, 3141, 3149, 73 835 (1982). Many Members "constitutionalizing" expanding laying rest doubts shared sides aisle measure. See, 2465 (1866) Thayer) ("As understand it, incorporating lately law"); 2498 Broomall); 2459 Stevens); 2461 Finck); 2467 Boyer). 32, 851 ("[A]s reveal, primary many members supporting incorporate guaranties organic land") 53 41st reenacted 1870. 144. 1870 earlier entire reenacted. Cases, 3, 16-17 (1883). recognized Runyon McCrary, 427 160, 168-169, 2586, 2593-2594, 415 (1976); 190, 2604 (STEVENS, concurring); Contractors, 383-386. B 54 What "An Enforce Provisions For Purposes," 20, ch. 13. immediate impetus widespread perpetrated loyal groups Ku Klux Klan. 23, Grant Klan's reign terror Southern "render[ed] life insecure," correct evils [was] beyond authorities." 42nd 244 (1871). special committee consisting distinguished each formed Grant's call drafted known problem 55 Unlike activities full: usage privileges, shall, notwithstanding, equity, proceeding redress; prosecuted review act April, sixty-six, entitled 'An furnish means vindication'; nature cases." 57 Three face ordained "person" "be law." expose Newport Fact Concerts, 453 247, 259, 2748, 2755, 69 616 (1981). Will Michigan Police, 58, 66, 2304, 2309, (1989) ("[A] purpose enactment forum claims"); accord, Mitchum Foster, 407 225, 239, 2151, 2160, 705 (1972). Third, seen opponents proponents amending enhancing Chapman Houston Welfare Organization, 600, 610-611, 1905, 1912, 508 (1979) [1871] generated least concern; added imposed Act"); Monroe Pape, 365 167, 185, 81 473, 483, 492 (1961); Mitchum, 2160. 58 Even cursory glance makes clear. introducing Shellabarger, served 59 "The model 'civil act.' That identically for, must, former slavery." Shellabarger "on facts" Obviously Shellabarger's colleagues altogether view Member, supplement echoed 461 Coburn); 312-313 Burchard). operated understanding. 429 McHenry) ("The act"); Arthur). Both working expansion jurisdiction. Supporters continually failure freedman, remedying situation interposing 376 Lowe) arisen resort agencies execution. Hence throws open doors impaired"). railed grounds. vests individual State; belongs tribunals"); Kerr); 365-366 Authur); 373 Archer). 62 tenor. Edmunds, terms: 63 believe nobody objects to, defining assailed carrying Constitution." 568, quoted 171, S.C ., 64 Again Senators creating accommodate incompatible supposition 653 (1871) Osborn) ("I true lies chiefly courts. proven themselves competent legislate But done so"); 216 Thurman) ("Its it—a conferred grant, yet it"); 501 Frelinghuysen). 65 aspect rejection amendment, governments. thoroughly canvassed broadest outlines need traced Immediately prior seventh 663 form, corporations per se, rendered riotously tumultuously assembled together." conference committee. draft county, city, parish compensation damnified offense." 755. Judgments run corporation, enforceable "lien moneys treasury parish, Opposition vehement, ran across lines, extending Republicans voted Reconstruction including 758 Trumbull); 798-799 Farnsworth). 67 regarded theretofore untested Blair put it: proposition amendment—and confine myself House—is entirely new. precedent country. asserted attempted assert, know, authority. Union lay obligations please municipalities, creations alone." 795 Blair), partially 673-674, 2026-27. Trumbull) (referring version "asserting exercised, rate"). 70 strong adverse reaction continued references complete novelty difficult entertain important opposition. large number 674-679, 2027-30. Farnsworth officer." 799 lent arguments opponents, Collector Day, Wall. 113, (1871); Kentucky Dennison, How. (1861), Prigg 539, 1060 (1842). Day amendment. 673-683, 30, 2027-32, 30. Prigg, perhaps famous oft line Story "insist states bound national government." Pet., 616. objection driving force eventual 676, 2028. 71 established occurred inconceivable adopted "creation problems keep peace" existence background "compell[ed] [under 1] tort." 691, 2036. 72 Dennison books clearly aware use 1294 Wilson). There however, Prigg's complementary rendering vicariously Just affected interpretation silence score militates imputing Cf. Tenney Brandhove, 341 367, 376, 783, 788, 95 1019 (1951). "of ' Revised Statutes words Rev.Stat. 1979. time, jurisdictional grant split provisions, 563(12), granting redress deprivations 629(16), old 1911, abolished Code's definition 629(16) narrower "providing rights" language. 1343(3), counterpart Chapman, 608, 1911. 74 commentary information addition revisers' work, 1872, marginal notes appeared completed themselves, clues Congress' adopting change. states: "Suits States." cross cites 563(12) followed bracketed citations 1979, 1977, 95, 111 (1874). 1872 contains notation 629(16): 75 "It intention provide, [the 1871], mentioned actually supersede indefinite act. Constitution, authorized here intended, safer add act." Revision Drafted Commissioners Appointed Purpose 362 (1872). 76 past ambiguities scope, 617, 1915-16 omitted) (Section "served ensure extended individuals afforded 668, 1942 judgment). Maine Thiboutot, 448 7, 2502, 2505, 555 ("There insertion 'and laws.' hand, legislation ambit statute") (some internal quotations III 77 recounted above indi ates controlling "state action" scheme. "had little choice aggrieved prohibition, existed statute." Cannon, 1974 dissenting) (emphasis added; footnote manifestly whatever limits remedies, long exercised Railroad Passenger Corporation Assn. Passengers, 414 453, 458, 94 646 (1974) ("A frequently stated coverage subsume remedies"); Fleischmann Corp. Maier Brewing 714, 720, 87 1404, 1408, (1967); 718-724, 1968-1972 78 "compels standard." 79 [chapter 18], vindication, conformity suitable effect; adapted object, modified constitution wherein held, govern disposition cause. ." Far plain supports 596 (1973), here: "[Section 1988] instances 'is States.' Railway Express Agency, 421 454, 465, 1716, 1722, 295 (1975). Moor, "Congress intend, matter employees." liability, thought "suitable effect" anything, direction principles. 80 Our units finds 402 (1976). Brown, dealt interaction VII, 1964, 2000e-16, proscribe administrative promotion occasions, occasion complaint agency race. agency's Director investigation promotional 717(c) bring decision. Forty-two dismissed Brown's untimely 717(c), affirmed, allegations employment. began analysis simply failed 717's constellation antidiscrimination 825, 1964. 1972, strictures employment, availability 828, 1965. "seems 1972 exclusive, pre-emptive discrimination." 828-829, 1966. bolstered invoking "a remedies." 834, 1968. definitively spoken very precurser enacting first, only, historical revision 1874 embodies federalism concerns underpinnings Congresses. careful balance drawn autonomy fiscal integrity vindication upset artifice 83 entity Bivens-type Tarpley Greene, 221 U.S.App.D.C. 227, 237, 684 11, (1982) (Edwards, J.) ("Because elected super appellant options Bivens [v. Six Unknown Fed. Narcotics Agents, 403 388, 91 1999, 619 (1971) ]. find good logic sound legal view; decline invitation"); Owen Independence, 589 335, 337 (CA8 1978); Thomas Shipka, 818 496 (CA6 Ellis Blum, 643 68, 85 (CA2 1981); Cale Covington, 586 311, 317 (CA4 Molina Richardson, 578 846 (CA9), cert. denied, 439 1048, 724, 707 (1978). applies laws," Thus district, IV 84 Clause instruction: "A (such District), and/or (including principals), personnel. District) wrongful unconstitutional personnel." 31. agree error. seems assumption policymakers actor refer determining rightly represent Last Term (1988), clarification tools employ plurality reaffirmed teachings "whether 'final authority' 123, 924 original), Pembaur, 1300 opinion). sta e identification unit resolved submitted jury. Reviewing materials, positive 'custom usage' law," 124, 924, identify speak issue. Once identified, affirmatively command occur, 661, 2020, acquiescence longstanding practice "standard operating procedure" entity. 485-487, 1301-1302 J, concurring). fault recognizing October 1984, guide it. Similarly, Pursuant urges Respondent 6-8. concede transfers unreviewable. 30-32. resolve us. expertise interpreting greater own, better extent holds remand outlined above. ordered. judgment. join history. mode excluded closely related (42 1983) deals violate specific governs general, whom STEVENS join, dissenting. familiar last Terms' (1976), overruled, (1989), today's short astonishing. led hard 1981—the prompted initiative, reargument, 1419, 879 (1988)—was today is, fact, creates conduct. strange, indeed, simultaneously conduct (Patterson) (these cases)—and hence raise landmark affords not, hints consideration, ante, 711 ("In 1981"), issue, Court.1 six produced opinions, once furnished able respond reply Court. often relied below, ordinarily below. Heckler Campbell, 468, 1952, 1958, (1983); Washington Yakima Indian Nation, 463, 476, 740, 749, 740 Hankerson North Carolina, 432 233, 240, 97 2339, 2344, 306 (1977); Massachusetts Mutual Life Ins. Co. Ludwig, 426 479, 2158, 784 Dandridge Williams, 397 471, 1153, 1156, (1970). unfair basis; unwise. important; one-sided briefing, views rash. unnecessary. appears (though pellucid) government answer dispose contentions. choosing decide, well, furnishes government, mistakes avoided impetuous course. violating terms, superior, dissent. (1866 Act), permits approaches though us, recounting methodical detail introduction, debate, passage, veto, story anyone passing acquaintance reviewed course deciding—and reaffirming to—the deems novel today. (1968); Tillman Wheaton-Haven Recreation 410 431, 432, 1090, 1091, (1973); (1975); McDonald Santa Fe Trail Transportation 273, 2574, 493 Delaware College Ricks, 250, 498, 431 (1980); (1982); Saint Francis Al-Khazraji, 481 604, 2022, 582 (1987); Shaare Tefila Congregation Cobb, 615, 2019, 594 Goodman Lukens Steel 482 656, 2617, 572 An essential (now 1982) prohibits, relatively moment passed. period thereafter, routinely setting forth specifying incurred statute's Marbury Madison, Cranch 137, 162-163, (1803); Kendall 524, 624, 1181 (1838); Pollard Bailey, 520, 527, (1874); Hayes Central R. 228, 369, 374, (1884); De Lima Bidwell, 182 743, 745, 1041 (1901); & N.O.R. Clerks, 281 548, 569, 570, 427, 433, 1034 (1930); Bell Hood, 327 678, 684, 773, 777, 939 (1946); J.I. Case Borak, 377 426, 1555, 1560, 423 (1964). classic statement Pacific Rigsby, 241 33, 39-40, 482, 484, 874 (1916), observed: disregard results damage class especial default implied, according fit comfortably Rigsby framework. small consequence, therefore, Act.2 Indeed, legislators' worry too much, little. explained "[t]here importance abstract truths [contained Amendment] effect, availing benefits." 474 added). Thayer Pennsylvania theme: "When abolish suppose offering mere paper guarantee." engages attention guaranty reality great practical force. prevent measu dead page country." 1151. circumstances, unreasonable inferring intent. Yet suggesting serve 715-721, exactly draw. intent, squarely occurring "under persons. Dismissing explained: "[Section] meant prohibit law' criminally punishable 2." 2196.3 distinguish Jones, argue officials. today, questioned sue giving vaguest hint lawsuits brought. (1948); (1948). dissenters Hodge arguing 2209. heeded cases: Metrocare Metropolitan Area Transit Auth., 220 104, 679 922 Seamen, 871 (CA1 Mahone Waddle, 564 1018 (CA3 1977), 438 904, 3122, 1147 (1978); Dist., rehearing, (19 8) (case below); Water Board, 189 1985); Milwaukee, 746 1205 (CA7 1984); Taylor 1193 Greenwood Ross, 778 Sethy Alameda 545 1157 (CA9 1976) (en banc). Perhaps how odd infer erased previously explains: 'state action' 'had statute.' Ante, 731-732, 1973, original; passed, suggests implicitly However, generally disfavor repeals implication, Morton Mancari, 417 535, 549-550, 2474, 2482-2483, 290 (1974); Posadas Bank, 296 497, 503, 349, 352, 351 (1936); Henderson's Tobacco, 652, 656-658, 235 (1871), hostile allegedly repealing rules out. regard, highly significant; herein construed repeal repugnant thereto." 15.4 fails reasons well. Its scheme" 1981."5 731. rely, attempts do, 'when remedies.' Ibid., (1974). inference sets used tells 110 suggestion, moreover, "finds in" audacious. 733. 1983—which, example, specifies exhaustion requirement, limitation, defenses, limitations—can hardly compared 829-832, 1966-1968. Preiser Rodriguez, 489, 1827, 1836, emphasized "general" refusing prisoners challenge prison's withholding good-time credits rather 2254. thorough statutes; intimations contrary. Middlesex Sewerage Authority Sea Clammers 19-21, 2615, 2625-2627, 435 According complaining circumvent 735-736. am unconvinced something vague inconclusive "federalism R Congresses," 734, unable Monell's limitation begins tell restriction exists covering range comprehend, case, why worried construing delicts elsewhere goes lengths suggest vicarious. 718-720. 112 distinguishing impression actionable choice" sued claim, depends deciding includes action, turn Clammers, analyzed Pollution Control 13-19, 2622-2626, one. departs attributes fluctuates depending during (1961), "persons" plurality, confirms Columbia. 713. view, alters endorse bizarre conception 114 remains recovery 115 vain contemplates institutions municipalities) evidences assumed. absolute significant: contracts citizens." Certainly wording refutes 116 contrast, forbids "subjec[t], caus[e] subjected" telling contain causation. "plainly imposes policy, 'causes' another's A's tort B's 'caused' attach causation absent." 692, absence 117 acknowledged "subjects, nevertheless inconsistency, be. surprise stresses, 719-720, envisioned extraordinary. liability. 118 cast doubt heavy reliance dramatic 1246-1247. 726-729, curious, frequent reminder 'the hazardous one.' Consumer Product Safety Comm'n GTE Sylvania, 447 102, 117, 2051, 2060, 766 (1980), Price, 361 304, 313, 326, 331, (1960). kind conventional 119 reveals encompassed 727-729. recognize, circumstances describes "provided offense.' 727, Cong.Globe, 755 threat forced others, Story's Pennsylvani 616, (1842), cancellation contract itself, matter. assuming 42d, 120 121 No unprecedented 723-726. wrought withdraw afforded. not. 123 My agreement buttressed expressed 2627, (1981) (opinion part), Oklahoma Tuttle, 471 808, 2427, 2441, 791 (1985) (dissenting twice opening brief, 712, presents question. Neither passages refers, remotely anticipated, let alone raised, advanced merits. 1970's, announcing four-part test: "First, plaintiff 'one enacted'—that plaintiff? indication implicit, deny one? consistent underlying And finally, traditionally relegated basically concern inappropriate law?" Cort Ash, 422 78, 2080, 2088, (1975) 39, 484. sense, test 1975 actual take interpretive time. 698-699, 1958-1959, Merrill Lynch, Pierce, Fenner Smith, Curran, 456 353, 375-378, 1825, 1837-1839, Welch Highways Public Transportation, 483 496, 2941, 2958, 389 (1987) (SCALIA, concurring) (advising passed). interpret Cort. Application fashioned Cort, lead (those contracts) created; indicators action; purposes; Reconstruction-era curtail emphasis ignores modern-day descendant penalty 242, Classic, 313 299, 327, 10, 1031, 1043, 1368 (1941), Code separate facts strongly placing much weight plurality's assertion 721, similarly unavailing. easily suits, much. 704-705, 1793, (1973) hear, 1"). confuses (state federal) exists. amici impliedly repealed sole International Management et al. Amici Curiae 18-19. Their exist premise, observe, 1960's doing so, ignore approving relevance date escapes me; faced 1860's. "[i]n "rested post-date uriae 19. 412, (1968), (1969), 1343(4) understand, shows jurisdiction, inferred appear recognize hear "left task courts." 17. imagine enforcement" mind, seeks. bright spot reaffirmation (1980).

Category: 1