Document: 391 U.S. 392 88 S.Ct. 1725 20 L.Ed.2d 689 The PUYALLUP TRIBE, etc., Petitioner,v.DEPARTMENT OF GAME WASHINGTON et al. Nugent KAUTZ al., Petitioners, v. DEPARTMENT Nos. 247, 319. Argued March 25 and 26, 1968. Decided May 27, Rehearing Denied Oct. 14, See 89 64. Arthur R. Knodel Jack E. Tanner, Tacoma, Wash., for petitioners. Joseph L. Coniff, Jr., Mike Richard Johnston, Olympia, respondents. George S. Woodworth, Portland, Ore., State of Oregon, as amicus curiae. Mr. T. J. Jones III, Boise, Idaho, Idaho Fish Game Dept. Justice DOUGLAS delivered the opinion Court. 1 These cases present a question public importance which involves in first place construction Treaty Medicine Creek made with Puyallup Nisqually Indians 1854 (10 Stat. 1132) secondly constitutionality certain conservation measures adopted by Washington allegedly impinging on those treaty rights. 2 suits were brought respondents state court against declaratory relief an injunction. trial held exceptions not relevant to our problem Supreme Court affirmed part remanded further findings aspect problem. Department Tribe, 70 Wash.2d 245, 422 P.2d 754; Kautz, 275, 771. We granted petitions certiorari consolidated oral argument. 389 1013, 584, 19 659. 3 While created reservation these Indians, no extent rights, if any, is involved here.1 Our concerns fishing rights protected Article so far reads follows: 4 'The right taking fish, at all usual accustomed grounds stations, secured said common citizens Territory, erecting temporary houses purpose curing, together privilege hunting, gathering roots berries, pasturing their horses open unclaimed lands * *.' 5 fish pertain are salmon steelhead, anadromous that hatch fresh water River River. steelhead trout; four species—chinook, silver, chum, pink. They come from ocean, pass through salt Puget Sound, enter waters mouths rivers, go up rivers spawn. adult die after spawning, but necessarily steelhead. In time fry return ocean start cycle anew. 6 People species offshore.2 As respects within its territorial waters, specifies when may take place, areas fishing, gear be used.3 7 Fishing licenses prescribed.4 Steelhead taken only hook5 commercially. Salmon commercially nets type areas.6 Set or fixed appliances barred 'any waters' steelhead.7 So 'monofilament gill net webbing.'8 8 Nearly every river has preserve mouth;9 Commencement Bay mouth one preserves.10 9 use set upstream. own needs well, supplying markets large volume salmon. used concededly illegal laws regulations valid; it we now turn.11 10 'right places, with' Territory under Yakimas was United States Winans, 198 371, 662, 49 L.Ed. 1089. bordering Columbia places acquired private owners who license there sought exclude reason ownership. 'continuing' could destroyed change ownership land river. U.S., 381, S.Ct., 664. To construe giving 'no such they would have without treaty' (198 380, 664) 'an impotent outcome negotiations convention seemed promise more, give word Nation more.' Ibid. Seufert Bros. Co. States, 249 194, 39 203, 63 555, construed same provision liberally include 'accustomed places' even though shared other white men, rejecting strict, technical keeping justice case. 11 It spirit approach determining scope Puyallups obtained. 12 terms 'at places.' assume customary Treaty; also commercial aspects present. But manner done purpose, whether commercial, memtioned Treaty. quite diferent case had preserved 'usual accustomed' manner. silent mode modes guaranteed. Moreover, respective exclusive one. Rather, 'in Territory.' Certainly latter regulated. And see why regulated appropriate exercise police power State. may, course, qualified State, born States. Act June 2, 1924, 43 253, superseded § 201(b) Nationality 1940, U.S.C. 1401(a)(2). size take, restriction like interest conservation, provided regulation meets standards does discriminate Indians. 13 Tulee Washington, 315 681, 62 862, 86 1115, before us Yakima guaranteed citizens' Territory. 951. Tulee, member tribe, off Indian Reservation; convicted him failure obtain license. reversed, saying: 14 '(W)hile leaves impose equally others restrictions purely regulatory nature concerning outside necessary forecloses charging fee kind here.' Id., 684, 864. 15 words, 'right' conditioned 'the concervation fish,' being defined established treaty, reach power. 16 overriding expressed nondiscriminatory conserving resources, preserved. supra, forerunner case, said: 17 '(S)urely competency nation secure remnant great possessed 'taking Nor restrain unreasonably, all, right.' 384, 665. 18 Another Kennedy Becker, 241 556, 36 705, 60 1166, nonexclusive grant charged spearing contrary New York law, defense treaty. Court, sustaining judgments conviction, 'We do think proper conveyance regard attempt either reserve sovereign prerogative, divide inherent preservation make competent impossible. Rather clause fully satisfied considering hunting upon grantees, whom might extended, subject, nevertheless, regulation, privileged, inhered sovereignty over where exercised.' 563—564, 707—708. purse seines nets12 permitted purposes conditions prescribed State; well others. nets13 streams mounths An expert testified prohibition conservation: 21 milling delaying, especially times law early arrival run any number reasons, delay considerable. 22 'Once again available again. This main preserve, stock will completely taken. 23 'Then further, this point bay you very definitely funnelling effect. 24 entire funneled into smaller area vulnerable.' hook line allowed because 'milling near mouth,' 'feeding don't strike fishery small percentage matter how hard fish.' 26 Whether 'reasonable necessary' (70 Wash.2d, 261, P.2d, 764) measure14 left determination deeming injunction No. 247 too broad, findings.15 When argued here, much about pros cons issue. Since given authoritative answer question, leave unanswered add ultimate issue must cover equal protection implicit phrase with.' 27 Affirmed. should noted while II Treaty, VI President remove 'on remunerating them improvements expenses removal, consolidate friendly tribes bands.' gave authority alternatively lots assign individuals families willing permanent home. 1887 Congress passed General Allotment (24 388) authorizing division among individual 1893 Act, 633, commission allotments. April 28, 1904, 33 565, consent States' removal prior alienation found boundaries been transferred pursuant Acts Congress, exception two tracts cemetery members tribe; City Tacoma. Satiacum, 50 513, 314 400 (1957). light history extinguished reach. Cf. Seymour Superintendent Penitentiary, 368 351, 356—359, 82 424, 427, 429, 346. seems hold once old III guarantee. 262, 763, 764. There indeed specifically reserved except covered III. high seas governed agreed Canada, Japan, 9, 1952, U.S.T., Pt. I, p. T.I.A.S. 2786. sockeye pink salmon, Canada separate signed 1930, amended July 3, 1957. 1057, 3867. bars international Pacific. Wash.Rev.Code 75.12.220. Wash.Admin.Code §§ 220—16—010 220—48—060 (salmon); Wash. Game, Perm.Regs. 32—35 (1964), Temp.Reg. no. 273 (1968) (steelhead). Wash.Rev.Code. 75,28.010—75.28.380; 77.32.005 77.32.280. Perm.Reg. 34 (1964). 75.12.140 defines permissible reef fishing. Section 75.12.010, containing area, allows director fisheries permit stated gear. 220—32—010 220—32—030 (Columbia area); 220—36—010 220—36—020 (Grays Harbor 220—40—010 220—40—020 (Willapa 220—48—010 (Puget Sound area). Commercial banned. 75.12.160; 220—20—010. 75.12.060, 77.16.060. 75.12.280. appears monofilament (made plastic) less visible clear daylight than nylon web. 220—48—020. 220—48—020(10). Petitioners argue courts lacked jurisdiction entertain action tribe Governement (citing Fidelity & Guaranty Co., 309 506, 653, 84 894 Turner 248 354, 109, 291), viewing suit 'extinguish Tribal communal federal Treaty.' however, enjoin violations tribal reservation. such, analogous prosecution crimes committed lands, courts. See, e.g., DeMarrias South Dakota, 319 F.2d 845 (C.A.8th Cir. 1963); Buckman 139 Mont. 630, 366 346 (1961). With respect boundaries, 1153, 1162. 401(a) Title IV 1968 Civil Rights Pub.L. 90284, 78; 346; Celestine, 215 278, 30 93, 54 195. A seine encircles school lead weights down, boat operating each end net. runs rings bottom net, making possible close 220—16—010(15). mesh cannot back out heads get through. Gill drift 1,800 feet length. 220—16 010(8). Purse water. often anchored end, stretched cork line, down weights, drifting end. located above another short distance. hadn travels varies, depending running—chinook, 1/2 inches; sockeye, inches. nits width used. 220—16—010(19). Much emphasis placed Maison Confederated Tribes Umatilla Reservation, 169 (C.A.9th 1963), pertaining tendered opposition Oregon's regulate interests conservation. stations States.' 170. Appeals Oregon Indians' conditions: first, need limit second, particular imposed 'indispensable' accomplishment needed limitation.' 172. idea measure derived striking imposition fees indispensable effectiveness program.' 685, statement context meant more would, indeed, unusual tax 'federal sentence immediately following, 'acts charge exercising ancestors intended reserve.' Murdock Com. Pennsylvania, 105, 112, 870, 874, 87 1292. control suppress enjoyment.' 'regulation' (as opposed 'tax'), measured 'necessary legal propriety kinds therefore distinct constitutional standard Ferguson Skrupa, 372 726, 83 1028, 93; Williamson Lee Optical Okl., 348 483, 75 461, 99 563; Daniel Family Sec. Life Ins. 336 220, 69 550, 93 632; Olsen Nebraska, 313 236, 61 85 1305. 319, parties entered stipulation facts which, scope, unnecessary tailoring meet specific situation, 280, 774. did, remand instructions stipulated presently runs. grounds' (within meaning Treaty) encompassed tributaries downstream Reservation. defendants fished since 1960; '(i)f continue, defendants' virtually exterminate River'; 'it plaintiffs enforce activities grounds.'

Category: 1