Document: 398 U.S. 144 90 S.Ct. 1598 26 L.Ed.2d 142 Sandra ADICKES, Petitioner,v.S. H. KRESS & COMPANY. No. 79. Argued Nov. 12, 1969. Decided June 1, 1970. [Syllabus from pages 144-146 intentionally omitted] Eleanor Jackson Piel, New York City, for petitioner. Sanford M. Litvack, respondent. Mr. Justice HARLAN delivered the opinion of Court. 1 Petitioner, Adickes, a white school teacher York, brought this suit in United States District Court Southern against respondent S. Kress Co. ('Kress') to recover damages under 42 U.S.C. § 19831 an alleged violation her constitutional rights Equal Protection Clause Fourteenth Amendment. The arises out Kress' refusal serve lunch Miss Adickes at its restaurant facilities Hattiesburg, Mississippi, store on August 14, 1964, and Adickes' subsequent arrest upon departure by Hattiesburg police charge vagrancy. At time both arrest, was with six young people, all Negroes, who were students Mississippi 'Freedom School' where she teaching that summer. Unlike offered service, not arrested. 2 Petitioner's complaint had two counts,2 each bottomed 1983, alleging deprived right Amendment be discriminated basis race. first count charged been refused service because 'Caucasian company Negroes.' Petitioner sought, inter alia, prove pursuant 'custom community segregate races public eating places.' However, pretrial decision, 252 F.Supp. 140 (1966), ruled court, would have there specific * refusing whites Negroes' custom 'enforced State' Mississippi's criminal trespass statute.3 Because petitioner unable trial other instances person having while directed verdict favor A divided panel Appeals affirmed ground, also holding 1983 'requires discriminatory or usage proved exist locale discrimination took place, State generally,' petitioner's 'proof points deficient,' 409 F.2d 121, 124 (1968). 3 second complaint, product conspiracy between police, dismissed before motion summary judgment. 'failed allege any facts which might inferred.' F.Supp., 144. This determination unanimously Appeals, F.2d, 126—127. 4 seeking review here, claims erred directing substantive count, granting judgment count. Last Term we granted certiorari, 394 1011, 89 1635, 23 38 (1969), now reverse remand further proceedings counts. 5 As explained Part I, failed show absence disputed material fact, think With respect reasons II, will made claim equal protection if proves state-enforced requiring racial segregation restaurants. We courts below (1) assuming only proof relevant showing related statute; (2) defining as practice throughout persons Negroes rather than simply 6 Briefly stated, following allegations: While serving volunteer Negro children went Public Library about noon 1964. librarian allow use library, asked them leave. they did leave, called chief told library closed, ordered From proceeded respondent's wished eat lunch. According after group sat down eat, policeman came into 'and observed (Miss Adickes) students.' waitress then booth sitting, orders students, but 'in goes left store. When reached sidewalk outside store, 'the Officer Law previously entered (the) store' arrested groundless vagrancy custody. 7 On these underlying conspired 'to deprive (her) enjoy treatment place accommodation'; cause 'on false vagrancy.' 8 A. CONSPIRACIES BETWEEN PUBLIC OFFICIALS AND PRIVATE PERSONS GOVERNING PRINCIPLES 9 terms make plain elements are necessary recovery. First, plaintiff must defendant has him secured 'Constitution laws' States. Second, 'under color statute, ordinance, regulation, custom, usage, Territory.' element requires acted law.'4 10 noted earlier read counts based race rights.5 Few principles law more firmly stitched our fabric proposition discriminate his companions, way act compel encourage segregation.6 Although is lawsuit private party, one officials, cases clear entitled relief can employee, course employment, somehow understanding deny Negroes. 11 involvement state official such plainly provides action essential direct rights, whether actions officially authorized, lawful; Monroe v. Pape, 365 167, 81 473, 492 (1961); see Classic, 313 299, 326, 61 1031, 1043, 85 L.Ed. 1368 (1941); Screws States, 325 91, 107—111, 65 1038—1040, 1495 (1945); Williams 341 97, 99—100, 71 576, 578—579, 95 774 (1951). Moreover, party involved conspiracy, even though State, liable 1983. 'Private persons, jointly engaged officials prohibited action, acting color' purposes statute. To does require accused officer State. It enough he willful participant joint activity agents,' Price, 383 787, 794, 86 1152, 1157 (1966).7 B. SUMMARY JUDGMENT 12 proceed consider In motion, stated 'no evidence affidavits papers 'reasonably-minded person' draw inference conspiracy,' 144, aff'd, Our own scrutiny factual allegations well found depositions presented Court, however, convinces us improper carry burden genuine issue fact. Before explaining why so, it useful arguments, parties concerning judgment, reasoning below. 13 moving argued 'uncontested facts' established no existed employee police. support assertion, pointed statements deposition manager (Mr. Powell) (a) communicated police,8 (b) had, prearranged tacit signal,9 food counter supervisor fearful riot customers angered seeing 'mixed group' blacks together.10 relied police,11 arresting officers,12 effect Powell requested Finally, knowledge communication member relying circumstantial contention arrangement 14 opposing dispute allegation statement deposition,13 unsworn employee,14 her, subsequently her. although agreement sequence events created substantial possibility trial, especially given fact noncircumstantial could come adverse witnesses. Further, submitted affidavit specifically disputing manager's assertion situation 'explosive,' thus creating what motives ordering service. 15 record, error grant lodged viewed light most favorable party.15 Respondent here failure foreclose awaiting some served. 16 true Powell, manager, claimed seen prior signal Baggett, counter. But submit Baggett,16 Freeman,17 actually either whom find particularly noteworthy officers there; that, disapproval thereby influencing decision 17 Given unexplained gaps materials respondent, conclude fulfill initial demonstrating critical aspect case—that If present, open jury, followed, infer circumstances 'meeting minds' should '(o)n inferences drawn contained (the party's) motion,' Diebold, Inc., 369 654, 655, 82 993, 994, (1962), reversal. 18 Pointing Rule 56(e), amended 1963,18 argues incumbent forward properly asserting presence rely avoid notes regard none met requirements 56(e).19 19 argument withstand scrutiny, commentary background 1963 amendment conclusively intended modify 56(c) initially fact.20 Advisory Committee note states changes designed 'affect ordinary standards applicable judgment.' And, comment like respondent's, '(w)here evidentiary matter establish issue, denied presented.'21 meet establishing required suitable affidavits.22 20 by, example, submitting policemen denying their question, 56(e) done contrary complaint. avoided conceding someone saw 56(f) impractical do so. Even defeat submission preferable counsel followed. commentator said: 21 'It always perilous neither proffer countering nor file affidavit. And peril rightly continues (after 56(e)). Yet principles; discharge No defense insufficient required.' J.Moore, Federal Practice 56.22(2), pp. 2824—2825 (2d ed. 1966). II 22 There remains discussed Amendment.23 CUSTOM OR USAGE confronted 'custom' force law, whether, dissent, required. never explicitly decided interpret statute amorphous backdrop. 24 What existence Ku Klux Klan Act April 20, 1871, Stat. 13. Chairman House Select drafted legislation described24 modeled Civil Rights 1866—a provision language forbade certain acts custom,' 27. Cases, 109 3, 16, 18, 25, 27 835 (1883), said 1866 statute: 'This clearly corrective character, counteract furnish redress laws proceedings, customs sanction wrongful specified.' (Emphasis added.) exhaustive examination legislative history Act, majority dissenting opinions25 Jones Alfred Mayer Co., 392 409, 88 2186, 1189 (1968), concluded limited 'deprivations perpetrated law."26 25 Quite apart Court's construction identical of' 1871 lineal ancestor indicates question encompass conduct supported action. That limitation supporters opponents Act. reporting Committee's recommendations House, Representative Shellabarger, carefully confined giving civil wrongs citizenship abridge rights.'27 Senator Edmunds, Senate Judiciary, supporter bill, provision: 'The section I believe nobody objects to, Constitution when assailed merely carrying since become part Constitution.'28 Thus, leader those favoring bill expressly deprivations law. Congress limit scope taken contrasting sections same hand, comparatively little debate over eventually enacted form introduced House.29 Its stands sharp contrast Act.30 For Act,31 aimed conspiracies law' requirement, great storm controversy, thought conduct. Thurman, leaders opposition objecting grounds, admitted constitutionality32 characterized 'refer(ring) deprivation usage' common law.'33 insisted vociferously congressional power penalize individuals violate law.34 comparative lack controversy context heated provisions, suggests minor exceptions, proponents understood 28 addition history, exists unbroken line decisions, extending back many years, declared predicate 1983,35 counterpart, 242.36 possible exception exceedingly opaque district court opinion,37 every lower aware considered reflects longstanding social habits, generally people locality.38 itself direction 'custom, 'of State,' living state. sum, background, virtue persistent practices officials. 29 included usages within definition widespread areas post-bellum South. Garifield '(E)ven just face, yet, systematic maladministration them, neglect enforce portion them.'39 authorized written so permanent settled constitute 30 interpretation recognizes may, imposing sanctions withholding benefits, transform predilections compulsory rules behavior less pronouncements. authority needed truism, Nashville, C. St. L.R. Browning, 310 362, 60 968, 84 1254 (1940), held statutory suggested different note, 'law' Tennessee railroads utilities taxed full cash value. Frankfurter wrote seems equally apt here: 31 narrow conception jurisprudence confine notion 'laws' books, disregard gloss life it. Settled clause write empty formalism Constitution. Deeply embedded traditional ways policy, complains, often tougher truer dead words text.' Id., 369, S.Ct., 972. 32 closely analogous case mayor Orleans, interpreted Lombard Louisiana, 373 267, 83 1122, 338 (1963), proprietors articulating Cf. Garner 368 157, 176—185, 248, 258—263, 207 (Douglas, J., concurring) Wright Georgia, 284, 1240, 349 (1963); Baldwin Morgan, 287 750, 754 (C.A.5th Cir. 1961). STATE ACTION—14TH AMENDMENT VIOLATION 33 guaranteed Since 'action inhibited may fairly States,' Shelley Kraemer, 334 13, 68 836, 842, 92 1161 (1948), decide, case, 'state action' issue: Is sufficient shows compelling restaurants? 34 analyzing problem, polar propositions, easily identified resolved. prohibits discriminating forbid backdrop compulsion involvement, personal affairs expression predilections. supra, '(t)hat erects shield conduct, however wrongful.' U.S., 842. 35 point extremes State's becomes Amendment, far refuse race, beyond invalid enjoined enforcement. Nor through convictions discriminate, prosecutions patrons who, being honor request leave premises.40 36 slightly one. owner offends implicit decisions sit-in responsible compelled act. Peterson City Greenville, 244, 1119, 1121 (1963): 'When commanded particular result, saved determine result significant extent' 'become involved' it.' much opinions conclusion offend Fifth Circuit '(t)he very posting maintaining separate (waiting room) (railroad) Terminal state.' say: 'As above distinction. medium others so.' 755—756 (emphasis added). principle governs here. 37 makes difference racially law—in Without deciding satisfy requirement abridgement right, segregating THREE ADDITIONAL POINTS remand, appropriate three additional points. 39 suggest exclusive means available enforcement used purpose. disagree assumption enforced statute.41 Any too restrictive, give variety ways, least examples record thing, able subjected purpose harassing punishing attempting black people.42 Alternatively, shown tolerate violence threats toward violated restaurants.43 40 wrong ruling Judge Waterman dissent below, possibly 'long unvarying' habit 'mixed' simple reason 'it 1964 became Afro-Americans opportunity served 'white' restaurants' all, 128. Like Waterman, narrowly, inquiry episode still prevailing places. Such course, perforce kind challenged case. 41 Third, Hattiesburg—a political subdivision State—was insufficient. error. whose source town ordinance state-wide application, lacks application. summary, places incident question; motivated 1983.44 43 foregoing new 44 reversed, remanded consistent opinion. 45 ordered. 46 MARSHALL 47 BLACK, concurring 48 petitioner, violations employees She another together judge and, presentation allegation. Both rested conclusions issues jury trial. allowing present court's correct—it my permitted claims. 49 Summary judgments pleadings, depositions, answers interrogatories, admissions file, affidavits, any, *.' Fed.Rule Civ.Proc. 56(c). stating '(w)e colored, going them.' friends soon stepped federally protected rights. filed concluding basic finding conspiracy. 50 nonexistence essentially judge, decide. impeaching store's witnesses appealing disbelieve affidavits. confront, cross-examine impeach fundamental sought preserved Seventh trials cases. advantages live witnesses, possibilities considering human factors, eliminated substituting sterile bareness subject cross-examination credibility weight testimony appraised. Trial substitute long hallmark 'even handed justice." Poller Columbia Broadcasting System, 464, 486, 491, 458 (1962). 51 surveyed He thereupon away conclusion. testified follows: 52 'Q. Did you occasion know against? Yes. 53 How recall? moment. 54 Will describe us? turned church, integrated church Hattiesburg. me. rabbi beaten 55 rabbi? drug group. don't remember name 56 studied observed, your conversations there, towards Negroes? 57 conclusion? persons—it evidence, weakened cross-examination, sufficient, think, let go secure constitutionally jury. See Galloway 319 372, 396, 63 1077, 1090, 87 1458 (1943) (Black, dissenting). 58 pass validity views, concurred proper term. Assuming correct valid, warrant entire accordance instructions framed reflect views. 59 concur reversing remanding DOUGLAS, part. seriously emasculated today's ruling. Custom, said, law'; 'law,' opinion, Hamiltonian sense.1 62 actionable means, according 'must officials.' is, borrow phrase Harlan, 'too artificial.' re 26, 32, (dissenting opinion). Section protects 'rights' 'secured 'right' exemption account race—an stems Thirteenth myriad Congress. concerned 'any State.' obviously prejudices few; dominant communal sentiment. 64 include predominant attitude backed indirect inscribed books. Thus 207, involving discrimination, municipal structure Louisiana revealed mosaic laws. 179—181, 259—261 (concurring 66 numerous continue regime races. legislature passed resolution condemning Brown Board Education 347 483, 74 686, 98 873, 294, 75 753, 99 1083, 'unconstitutional' infringements States' Miss. Laws (1956), c. 466, Concurrent Resolution 125. program perpetuate segregated Sovereignty Commission, Miss.Code Ann. 9028—31 et seq. Governor chairman duty perform things deemed protect sovereignty encroachment thereon Government 9028 35. 4065.3 (1956) executive branch government prohibit lawful, peaceful, causing mixing integration schools, parks, waiting rooms, amusement, recreation assembly state, federal government. *' Every word deed officer, agent, connected schools sovereign Mississippi.' 4065.4 (Supp.1968). unlawful student attend high level attended students. 6220.5. Separate junior college districts whites. 6475—14 (1952). Ellisville School feebleminded provide maintenance 6766. Insane Hospital keep separate, id., 6883, South Charity Hospital. 6927. entrances maintained hospitals patients. 6973. responsibility number nurses patients, supervision supervisors. 6974. convicts worked together. 7913 (1956). County sheriffs maintain rooms jails. 4259. taxicab drivers passengers 3499. Railroad depots cities 3,000 inhabitants 'closets' 7848. crime overthrow 2056(7). 67 similar Garner. restaurants, deeply entrenched 'at powerful law.' 181, 260 opinion); cf. Robinson Florida, 378 153, 156, 1693, 1695, 771. III pervasive. includes unwritten commitment, stronger ordinances, statutes, regulations, men arrange lives. Bronislaw Malinowski, famed anthropologist, speaking 'cake custom' Melanesian 'safeguarding life, property personality' said:2 69 'There religious rules, fear, superstitious rational, enforces tribal punishment visits breach, stigma moral blame. forces binding shall lay bare definable, described concept, real less. concatenation obligations, arranged chains mutual services, take periods covering wide aspects interest activity. added conspicuous ceremonial manner legal obligations discharged. binds appeal vanity self-regard, love self-enhancement display. due natural mental trend self-interest, ambition vanity, set play special mechanism obligatory framed.' 70 concept universal elsewhere. apparent problem sole aim search sense 'law.' restricted certainly grammar. 'Of' meanings, thing whence anything originates, comes, acquired sought.' Oxford English Dictionary (definition III). geographical area entity originates found. 72 philosophy Black Codes prescribed them. judges, early desegregation decrees, felt ostracism community, local purported penalties judges doing acts. Forty years ago Washington, D.C., sun northwest Chevy Chase Circle arrested, 'crime' bus home caddying plush golf environs. sanctioning arrest. Nation's Capital. Harry Golden3 recently wrote: 73 'Southerners drew crossing They doomed themselves lifetime guarding line, fearing breached. Southerner forever watch intrudes life.' 'custom?' Title derived 'Ku Act' 'under-color-of' provisions turn, 1866, meaning therefore for, states, mean 242, descendant Act.4 Ante, 152 n. 7. 76 targets 1866. upheld 1189, provided remedy specified discrimination. any' bent nullification racist laws,' 429, 2198, restricting strictly action; ban partly respects actions, sense, 'custom.' 77 Of cover purely discussion grips covered quite 'color (or) regulation'—in words, sense. Instead, divide groups—those constituting 'private action'—with coverage former. reach violations,' realm mere predilection prejudice. despite suggestion contrary, term shorthand reference relevance custom.'5 78 2, adopted. Co.: 79 'Surely rationally badges incidents slavery, translate effective legislation.' 440, 2203. 80 Privileges Immunities Clause, Due Process protective individual 'state' guarantees various restricted. laws.' 1983's 492. 'color' alone, ingredients satisfied.6 adoption expanded vis-a -vis ingredient remedial Neither successor, conditioned need complicity. Guest, 745, 761, 774, 782 6, 1170, 1180, 1186, 1191, 239, enables punish interferences 'whether implicated.' 782, 1191. (18 241) proscribed impair 'secured' agreed order qualify involve By development, maintenance, participation. including Amendment; rightfully protection, whoever instigator offender. repeat, 'one whereby exercised vested Amendment.' 171, 475. powers stem source. McCulloch Maryland, Wheat. 316, 421, 579; Veazie Bank Fenno, Wall. 533, 548—549, 482; Edye Robertson, 112 580, 595—596, 247, 252—253, 798; Gettysburg Electric R. 160 668, 683, 427, 430, 576. rights' unmistakably cover, reach, protect, enabling range rid slavery. derives turn action.'7 face realities leads regressive announced today. stopped niggardly construing legislation. kept up construed amplitude lingering tolerance BRENNAN, contends statute' involved, independent elements: first, laws'; second, Mississippi. Whether suing element—the laws'—depends nature asserted. 1982 completely independently S.Ct laws, unelaborated Reese, 214, 249—252, 563 (1876) (Hunt, dissenting), uses 'State' original several ways. historical categories inaction wholly see, e.g., Bell 226, 286—316, 1814, 1847—1864, 822 (1964) (Goldberg, concurring); Harris, Quest Equality 24—56 (1960); J. tenBroek, Under 201—239 (1965). applies significantly (1948); Burton Wilmington Parking Authority, 715, 721—722, 856, 859—860, (1961). element—action State—depends analysis text, policy infra. These inquiries different, suffice other. protection. Therefore, cases, asserts respects. she, person, accompanied friends. treats join.1 contends, alternatively, encouraged statutes. turn. state-action doctrine profound denials treatment, color, singularly grave shares organ society look promotion liberty, justice, fair setting worthy norms goals Therefore something uniquely amiss government, authoritative oracle values, involves Accordingly, condemned subtle whatever taken. See, supra; Evans Newton, 382 296, (1966); Hunter Erickson, 393 385, 557, 616 (1969). represent vigilant fidelity lend sordid business Among nearly resemble S.ct. 323 petitioners convicted Carolina. Greenville imposed restaurants establishments, ordinance. excluded solely Amendment: 91 it, removed sphere choice. 'Consequently cannot stand, assuming, ordinance.' 1121. 93 convictions, neutral present. cite logical starting judicial denial occurred restaurant. tainted convictions. Reitman Mulkey, 387 380, 1627, 1633, 830 (1967), (was) influenced establishes commands class regardless command. intimation echoes Harlan's motivates discriminate. 251 253. squarely rejected Peterson, resurrect now. 94 rationale extended (1963). Prior arrests superintendent Orleans publicly demonstrations undesirable fully enforced. statements, unlike evidencing system prevalent institutions petitioners' directed. command restaurateurs restaurateur integrate services without violating restaurateur's factor. alone regree violative actual Lombard, therefore, advances propositions. nondiscriminatory promulgation. Guinn 238 347, 364—365, 926, 931, 1340 (1915); Gomillion Lightfoot, 364 339, 125, 110 (1960). privately chosen accommodation, renders unconstitutional discriminator 771 (1964). arising time, Florida regulation lavatory toilet sex. itself; demonstrators regulation. Nevertheless, reversed ground sufficiently commented: 96 'While regulations directly colored together, embody putting burdens serves races, bound discourage together.' 1695. 97 segregation, enforcing Lombard. imposition amounting discouragement integration. happened facilities; burden—for tax sufficed render Again, depend step small Indeed, hold discouraging encouraging expressed non-discriminatory taints seeks bring about. precedents statutes manifest supporting facilities, relies principally 2046.5 which, 'authorizes' 'empowers' owners hotels, accommodation amusement whomsoever choose.2 unfettered discretion management, reason. explicit maintained, falls broad informed, essence, call incorporated 2046.5. extent authorizes empowers muster 726—727, 862—863 (Stewart, concurring). 100 'persons reception entertainment offensive major Stewart position 'construed enactment authorizing classification exclusively color.' 862. Justices Frankfurter, Whittaker, dealt length statute,3 construed. adopted insufficiently final issue. 101 considerably broader Burton. apparently authoritatively courts, reason, Were conceivable doubt authorize, 'discriminatory color,' dispelled consideration enacted. 102 isolation, examined 'immediate objective,' 'ultimate effect' 'historical conditions existing enactment." 373, 1630; supra. Through 1950's 1960's 'steel-hard, inflexible, undeviating segregation.' Jackson, 318 (C.A. 5th 1963) (Wisdom, J.). Silver, Mississippi: Closed Society originally 1956 wake Education, 873 (1954); 1083 (1955). contemporaneously resolutions Brown,4 transportation facilities,5 committing continued adherence Together resolutions, indexed Session 'Segregation' 'Races.'7 1956, '(t)o *.'8 Subsequent passage 2046.5, breach peace, vagrancy, 2046.59 employed weapons combat attempts desegregate accommodation. .e.g., Dilworth Riner, 343 226 1965).10 103 Illustrative practical gave rise litigation. shortly unsuccessfully dismissal charges removal utter baselessness engaged' attempted receive city Achtenberg 468, 474—475 1968).11 104 constituted response 'they parts single plan. plan unlawful.' Swift 196 375, 276, 279, 518 (1905) (Holmes, integral scheme foster elsewhere, furthered affording elected difficult conceive authorization express previously. Mulkey Reitman, Cal. 2d 529, 544, Cal.Rptr. 881, 413 P.2d 825, 835—836 (1967). 105 innkeeper, analogy restaurateur, whomever selecting customers. 131—133. 296—300, 1852—1855, L.2d presumed apply Western Union Telegraph Goodman, 166 146 So. 128 (1933), concludes 'drastically changed enacting 2046.5.12 132. Further view preamble 'confer(s) sell Miss.Laws 257. formulation alter 106 clear, innkeepers restaurateurs, ever widely matters. Reconstruction times amusement. 1873, LXIII. applied Donnell 661 (1873). quickly fell desuetude.13 'changed' 1956. clarified behind authorize 107 remaining nexus efforts otherwise, encourage, otherwise facet constitutes illegal pertinent occur. supra.14 1633 commission conforms manifestation ambit discriminates conformity heard say prohibitions 108 entitled, 'An Provisions Purposes.'15 popularly known Act,' was, absolutely outrages committed extensively 172—183, 476—482 engendered activities Klan, evil. 183, 482. Mosley, 383, 388, 904, 906, 1355 (1915), Holmes, commented Enforcement 1870, 141, amended, 241, 1983: 'Just important application statute) general away. (W)e past affect citizens reasonably affords.' 111 Stirred wholesale breakdown South, carried completion creation comprehensive remedies—civil, criminal, military16—for interference. undertook remedies interference exercise enjoyment (now 1983) surviving 1985(3)) conspiratorial person's 1986) cast net liability providing ability reasonable diligence prevent fails bolstered 27, re-enacted amounts 141 interfere right.17 113 until recently, virtual Key unduly keeping purposes.18 629, 601, 290 invalidated analogue 1985(3), except perhaps extreme remote circumstances. Essential recognition reaches Franks, 120 678, 656, 766 (1887). (Rev.Stat. 5519) repealed 1909. 1154. Collins Hardyman, 651, 937, 1253 (1951), influence 1985(3). 1985(3) exactly (except provided) sustain constitutionality. limiting necessarily 1986, keyed 1985. 114 241 fared better. indicated, deals among 'rights arise relationship Government.' Williams, 70, 77, 581, 585, 758 (1951) (opinion Ex parte Yarbrough, 152, 274 (1884); Waddell, 76, 35, 673 Logan 263, 617, 429 (1892); Quarles, 158 532, 959, 1080 (1895). 'arising from' Cruikshank, 542, 588 (1876). relation four members placed considerable reliance otherwise. 77—78, 584—585. Hodges 203 (1906). 115 principal protecting nonetheless constitutional. 'willfully,' 'a intent definite rule 103, 1036, (1945). 242 nonofficial 116 narrowed restrictive 117 239 267 resolving Williams. Guest conjunction officials,19 unnecessary put doubt, 761—762, 1180—1181 Clark, joined Fortas, JJ.), 774—786, 1186—1193 Brennan, Warren, C.J., Douglas, Katzenbach 384 641, 1717, 828 118 'By draftsmen Congress, Necessary Proper Art. 8, cl. 18. Correctly viewed, positive determining 650 1723. 119 Carolina Katzenbach, 301, 803, 769. (1966).20 Harris overruled. 782—783, 1190—1192 Consequently, longer warped unwarranted concern 170—171, 475—476; 205—206, 493—494 121 grounds. Code dining facilities. 122 capacity official, precisely misuse alone,21 shown, view, 123 authorizing, encouraging, narrower action.' kinds remedy. understand how helpful 'color,' authority,' law,' office,' title,' 'colorable,' 'appearance, semblance, simulacrum,' reality. Black, 331—332 (rev.4th 1968). appears covers Myers Anderson, 368, 932, 1349 Nixon Herndon, 273 536, 446, 759 (1927); Lane Wilson, 307 268, 872, 1281 (1939), 111, 1040. latter situations appearance taking. abuse palpable victim observer exceeding authority, transparent. Catlette 132 902 (C.A.4th 1943). overtly violates he, consciously gives aid, comfort, incentive, Griffin 130, 1770, (1964); Flemming Elec. Gas 224 752 1955), dismissed, 351 901, 692, 1439 (1956); body prescribing, legitimating, effectuating, vice wherever draws irrelevant contention, presents difficulty. few 1983;22 litigated briefly summed Territory' incorporating akin Clause. loose vague usage.' held, intimated, formula summarizing 242; referred authority.' 454, 2211. 'discriminations legitimated deserve 'custom." 457, 2212. 193, 487 (Harlan, ('abuses recurrent amount usage"). summarize parallel §§ 1983.23 occurs debates version enacted, enumeration of,'24 handy readily explained. More importantly, considered, comprehensive, summation century repeated, 'In expounding guided sentence sentence, whole object policy.' Boisdore Heirs, How. 113, 122, 1009 (1849) (Taney, C.J.,); Mastro Plastics Corp. NLRB, 350 270, 285, 349, 359, 309 Richards 11, 592, (1962); Dandridge 397 471, 517, 1153, 1173, 491 (1970) (Marshall, 125 guidance Much lengthy truth KKK constitutionality wisdom Little attention precise wording sustained usage.'25 analyze achieve 1871. Only relating 126 recall originated depredations army. Cong. Globe, 42d Cong., 1st Sess., 339 (remarks Rep. Kelley, bill). recognized 'operating 436, 2201, employing methods coerce forgo theoretically strong paralyze operations Coburn, noted: 127 'Such, then, character outrages—numerous, month year year, States; citizens; palliated excused justified men. Not outbreaks sometimes appearing districts, mob band regulators commit crimes defy mark attribute systematic, persistent, well-defined organization, fixed purpose, regular development condition work day year. be, things; slow; piled another, week week, 129 'Such occurrences pre-concerted thousands fettered, witnsesses silenced, impotent, annulled, free, persecuted citizen looks vain redress. extends counties places, rule, exception.' 42nd 458—459. 130 App. 172 Sen. Pool, supporter); 653 Osborn, 155—160 Sherman, supporter). mischief derived, concerted 'private' unwilling cope with. 131 Schurz, moderate opponent behalf President personally investigated disorders with: evil southern baffled pro-slavery tendency diseased sentiment vents violent acts, winks permits overawed terrorizing timid corrupting jury-box, overawing witness-stand, obstructing functions justice.' 687. 133 (later President) Garfield, supporter, focused evils remedy: 134 '(T)he unequal, 153. 135 task device instigated terror, numbers, means. 136 Houses careful itself, problems presented, isolated amounted right. 578—579 Trumbull, opponent); 514 Poland, conferee); 153 Garfield); Perry, supporter).26 Where, injury genuinely prejudice, authorities failing countenancing affirmatively fulfilling obligation afford wrong, resulting intrusion unjustified. 137 Near debate, Garfield observed: 138 'I believe, Speaker, last trenchant heart yet guarded preserve intact autonomy machinery governments, organizations 808. 139 'trenchant' measured, remedies, currently codified 1985, 1986. achieve, narrowly concert say, 'Every *'; '(A)ny Every) Similarly, broadly sections, debates, reaching 'major' effects warranted category invasions Where participate assumes graver have, conflict 238, 511 agreements aggravated dangers society, Rabinowich, 78, 88, 682, 684, 1211 Pinkerton 328 640, 644, 1182, 1489 (1946); Krulewitch 336 448—449, 716, 720—721, 790 (1949) (Jackson, Note, Developments Law—Criminal Conspiracy, Harv.L.Rev. 920, 923—924 (1959), exemplified protection.27 third where, overt habitual conventions regarded prescribing consent, unofficial sanctions—in short, usages. customary, definition, enduring, response. 143 '(e)very subjects, causes subjected, jurisdiction thereof privileges, immunities *.'28 excerpts quoted wanted remedy, violence, potentially virulent customary reflection attitudes people. 'diseased sentiment' reflected multifarious former status inferiority. 'down organization' deal manifestations Respect 'embodied intrenched daily habits American Kelley). legislate popular sentiments, types could, customary. 145 'We leaves origins dictate, accord sweep language.' 801, 1160. imposes obstacle identified. 'subject' '(cause him) deprivation' invaded Fourth Amendments. Certainly 'deprivation' 'extinguishment,' policeman, whole, extinguish sits. Panhandle Oil ex rel. Knox, 277 218, 223, 451, 453, 857 dissenting).29 extinguished itself. meant 1983—and 242—would nullity. 'violation,' 'denial,' 'infringement.' 420—421, 2193—2194; 39th 605 242). illustrates, discussing already indicated of.' 211—212. well. usually law—a practice, commonly sanctions. Strother Lucas, Pet. 410, 437, 445—446, 1137 (1838); Arredondo, 691, 713—714, 547 (1832). Adams Otterback, 539, 545, 805 (1854); Merchants' Bank, 604, 1008 (1871); 423, 2194.30 generate impose recognized. Mercer Hacket, 83, 95, 548 (1864); W. Blackstone, Commentaries *64; Cardozo, Nature Judicial 58—64 (1921).31 147 'State during refer Texas White, 700, 227 (1869),32 Constitution: 148 describes united relations, inhabiting temporarily permanently country; denotes country territorial region, inhabited community; unfrequently live; represents combined idea territory, 149 senses primary community. territory dwelling, permanently, organized looser 150 undoubtedly republican established. 151 frequently expresses noticed, Constitution, free citizens, occupying defined boundaries, sanctioned constitution, consent governed.' debate. Perry). understood, strained tortured—indeed, perfectly natural—to 'statute, agree too, 1983; subdivision. sanctions, belief prescribes large regards conduct.33 eschews attempt rational purposes. Instead basically sets First cases; casual rest significance erroneous theory altogether. hardly relevant, controlling, 213—214 22. consists quotations purporting explain reliable guide interpretation. demonstrable consensus debaters highly misleading select arguably pronounce authoritative. remarks Shellabarger Edmunds consist matters draftsmanship, varying 154 dwells relative Edmunds' complacement prediction, opposed, opposed vigorously. Johnston commented, Vermont (Senator Edmunds) objection bill. section, slight unconstitutional.' 215. McHenry 'outrage,' 'flagrant infraction' 429. Edward Rice bringing 'lambs slaughter'; dragging homes, neighbors, vicinage grievances courts.' 395. 216—217 San. Thurman). 155 adequately characterize proposed, enclave 'murder, manslaughter, mayhem, robbery, assault battery, perjury, subornation obstruction process resistance duty, arson, larceny.' 68—69 Shellabarger). Extreme attacked sections. Moderate objected ousted successfully meeting 366 Arthur, opponent). criticized praised voted 807, 156 intrinsic merits, 'for acceptable 'force meant, law—that normative force, meaning. takes acquire 'by supports reading relies, ante, refers 'permanent well-settled' practices, 'systematic laws), enforce' Garfield's Mere converted 333—334 Hoar, 375 Lowe, 725, 861; 902, 907 1943); Lynch 189 476 1951); Henkin, Kraemer: Notes Revised Opinion, U.Pa.L.Rev. 473 189. 26. Recognition theory—and fortiori bill's supporters, radical assert plenary affairs, ibid.—only confirmation 157 remanded, views prevail merits. invoking arsenal Standards governing developed Tenney Brandhove, 367, 783, 1019 (1951); Pierson Ray, 386 547, 1213, 288 (1967); Basista Weir, 340 74, 85—87 (C.A.3d 1965); Sullivan Hunting Park, 396 229, 238—240, 400, 405—406, (1969); I. Case Borak, 377 426, 433—434, 1555, 1560 1561, 423 justice duty-bound enrich looking wherein sit. 1988. resort adequate 159 strict prohibitions; 187—192, 484—487; 553—555, 1217—1218. torts, tort doctrines bearing liability. Whirl Kern, 407 781 1969). torts questions defenses relief, inadequate infallible particular, central stamp out. recovery, vagaries governed uniform standards. appropriateness depends degree culpability defendant. voluntary compensation damages, violation. compensatory allocation loss, innocent deliberately faithful loss discriminator, unaware Proof motive 183—187, 481—484; indeed, (1927), complaints $5,000 recoveries election plaintiffs voting ineligible vote. declaratory injunctive damages. Hot Shoppes, U.S.App.D.C. 358, 370, 293 835, 847 (1961) (Bazelon, 161 punitive 'willfully' 87—88; Tracy Robbins, F.R.D. 108, (D.C.S.C.1966). Territory,' reckless McCormick, Handbook Damages (1935). proprietor 2000a 2000h—6, damages.34 factfinder recklessness assessing award 162 inequitable defendant, knowingly recklessly fear lose not. unacceptable. watered actively oppose others. Cooper Aaron, 358 1401, (1958). compliance devoid merit determined virtually cost, violations. 41st 804 Poland). befitting purposes, threat withdrawal patronage largely better prospect persuade Rev.Stat. 1979, provides: Territory, injured equity, proceeding redress.' amend liquidated 1875, 335. certiorari petition, ruling, revive overruling raised 1875 Appeals. Second contentions. ordinarily Lawn 355 362—363, 311, 324—325, 321, (1958); Husty 282 694, 701—702, 240, 241—242, 629 (1931); Duignan 195, 200, 566, 568, 996 (1927). decline owners, managers, establishments choose 184, 187, 482, 484, 793, 1156, 1157, (1966). alleges 'deprived privilege association (she) Code, 1983.' (App. 4.) alleges, 'conspired accommodation.' might, generously, Accommodations 243, seemingly concedes, 201 2000a. doubtful, recovery 207(b) injunction 206 'exclusive title.' intend Cong.Rec. 9767 (remark floor 'is 1983'); 7384, 7405. Johnson, 390 563, 1231, 203(b) prosecution (another 'outsiders,' accommodations, notwithstanding 'exclusive' 207(b). doubtful Johnson 201, indeed contend. 203, stated: exclusive-remedy inserted 202 injunction.' 567, 1234. event, nothing title 'shall preclude inconsistent pursuing vindication right.' precludes one's evident 'inconsistent' E.g., Barrows 346 249, 1586 (1953). Price 185, 483 (majority opinion), 212, 497 J.); deposition, knowing Hugh Herring, talked occasions Adickes. 123—126). Ralph Hillman, didn't 'Maybe day.' inside 136, (3) (4) 155. signal, nod head. supervisor, 'told shook head no. But, sign, ahead anybody.' 135. Baggett 'there lot Hattiesburg' 'with mixed group.' 131. 'On day, o'clock, estimate pretty—was pretty full, front aisles, girls, woman north door, next 'And really me group, dressed alike. on, looked blue denim skirt. best were—they almost identical, coming look, booths. there. one, 'And, immediately there—I this, seconds door sit down, but, began mill around started close candy counter, sour faces, joking, corny, on. frightened mob. did. mobs before. Korea riots 1954 1955. are. got front, see-through windows. backs You street. window, standing in, across street even, jewelry bad yelled 'Let's get them,' before, mind riot, employees, hurt themselves. knew break there.' 133—134. part: 'Mr. statement. (But Powell's supra.) way.' 107.) Sergeant Boone Hillman language: contacted date John Jr., representative Genesco, Company, connection aforesaid streets consulted G. T. Manager Company date. consult anyone arrest.' 110, 112.) answered: 'My in.' 75.) identify 'Carolyn.' Carolyn Moncure, 'about five minutes' '(H)e facing passed, end booth, stood smiled, out.' 302.) corroborated Dianne Carolyn's sister, awhile' 'walked store.' 291.) During discovery, Irene Sullivan, check-out girl. Patrolman '(s)hortly 12:00 noon,' traded 'hello greeting' walked 'out vision.' on: 'A minutes later northerly composed woman. onto car pulled alley alongside escorted car.' 178.) 176 V. Moore, 56.15(3) supplemental brief copy contact question. Apart unsworn, court. Manifestly, disposition depose Baggett. resisted convincing 'managing agent,' 'was managerial decisions.' contain Freeman 'did ask else occurred.' 177.) statement, 56(e): pleading, response, forth respond, appropriate, him.' hearsay; unsworn. specifies sufficient. 56(e). overturn primarily Third Circuit, create asserted well-pleaded Frederick Hart Recordgraph Corp., 169 580 Kolton Halpern, 590 Note (e) 56. Ibid. National Ariz. Cities Service, 391 253, 1575, 569 misapplied shift rejecting 'Essentially (petitioner) producing showed susceptible 289, 1593. 'not susceptible' argue 2. noted, applications (1964), code restated 'allowing (restaurateurs) wished,' 126, operated inappropriate posture decide Whatever 44, infra, determinations Cong.Globe, (statement 424—426, 2195—2196 454—473, 2210—2220 2196. arguing predecessor 1982) governmental 'Indeed, immunity interference, all. fines prison protected' exempt imposed. Hence language, (that) criminally punishable 2.' 2195. cited violations' 'governmental interference.' 425, 2195 33. 68. 568 added), 171. 475; (Rep. Perry) (§ injuries authority'). Compare 568; 153—154 Garfield). Throughout 'moderates' proposals role parties. (Sen. author Act); Poland); conspiracies, 1985(3): refutes recognizes. period, comparable unmistakable terms,' citing quoting 663—664, 943. intimating correctness Collins, dissenters 'said terms' necessary. 216. 217; 268 Sloss). 218. 554, 1217, Smith Allwright, 321 649, 757, 987 (1944). 109, 1039; 326—329, 1043 1044. Gannon Action, 303 1240 (D.C.E.D.Mo.1969), hand 'Section defendants (sic) Missouri (of) undisturbed worship dictates consciences' Louis cathedral, disrupted freedom assembly, speech, worship, property, 1983,' 1245. Vand.L.Rev. 413, 419—420 (1970). Howard Johnson's, 1963); 363, 840 ('As join unanimous that—'The prohibition Amendment," Johnson's Restaurant, 845, 848 1959)), U.S.App.D.C., 367—368, 844—845 dissenting); Slack Atlantic White Tower 181 124, 127—128, (D.C.Md.), aff'd 284 746 1960). post, 219, 230, infers affirmative broad, however. All maladministration' of, 'just face.' Official neglecting books enact 1122 Shuttlesworth Birmingham, 262, 1130, 335 statute,' workers prosecuted charges, retaliation engaged, buttresses undisputed (i.e., 'attempts accommodations Library, nationally store') arrested.' 474 dissented removable Georgia Rachel, 780, 1783, 925 'vagrancy baseless unsophisticated subterfuge,' 10, immune 7, There, 'To *,' 1157. core 'participant intimate shown. 370—371, 847—848 briefed explored instance remand. juncture hand. Federalist, 15: sanction; or, penalty disobedience. annexed disobedience, pretend will, advice recommendation. penalty, inflicted ways: agency ministers military force; COERCION magistracy, arms.' Crime Custom Savage 66—67 Book Guide, Boston Sunday Herald Traveler, February 22, 1970, p. offense inhabitant Territory act.' form, 1368, 1495, 'Whoever, willfully subjects punishments, pains, penalties, alien, fined $1,000 imprisoned both.' reads: context, misleading. distinguished law" interprets exclude sans realistic addressing 'custom,' using distinguish limited, out, "white' Brother BLACK outlined restrictive. custom. abundant particular. conceded, past. concerned.' concerns 178—179, 259—260 page 'second (of law." reads '1. firm corporation business, trade profession whatsoever including, motels, tourist lodging houses, room counters, barber shops, beauty parlors, theatres, picture shows, parks swimming pools, stores merchandise sale, hereby empowered desires with, wait owner, desire serve. '2. desires, display sign posted notice management reserves person,' prerequisite exercising conferred '3. enters premises thereof, therefrom refuses do, guilty conviction therefor hundred dollars ($500.00) jail (6) months, fine imprisonment. ground. cc. 258—260 Miss.Code. 7787.5, 2351.5, 2351-7). 254 4065.3). Inaugural Address James P. Coleman, Journal 59, 65—68 (enacted 1962). session Legislature produced dealing separation heading index General volume cross-reference 'Races.' 257, chapters February, March, April, heading: Chapter (maximum ten-year incestuous interracial marriage); 253 2049—01 2049—08) (act fomenting agitation litigation'); 4065.3) ('entire branch' lawful assembly'); 255 8666) (standards admitting foreign lawyers Mississippi); (5) 256 2090.5) disturbance peace business'); 258 7787.5) railroad companies, companies carriers, owning, operating leasing depots, stations terminals traveling intrastate travel'); (7) 259 2351.5) carriers hire (8) 2351.7) travel occupy marked persons; entering persons'); (9) 261 profane, vulgar, indecent, offensive, slanderous telephone'); (10) (separate children) (see 6220.5 (unlawful schools)); (11) (repeal education laws); (12) 9028—48) (creation commission); (13) 466 (Senate 'condemning protesting' Education). enactments thereafter repealed, policies. 2339 (punishment 'printing, publishing circulating urging presenting acceptance information, arguments suggestions equality intermarriage negroes'). Other purport taxicabs servants) (Miss.Code 3499); 6882, 6883); (Miss.Const., 207). 1954, 2056. omitted 1968 reenactment 2056 2087.5, 2087.7, 2089.5 1960); 2087.9 1964). Bailey v Patterson, Cir.1963). 6—7 Cir.1963), terminals, sophisticated circumventing eschew 'segregation' conventional instruments euphemistically termed 'separation." Lewis Greyhound 199 210 (D.C.M.D.Ala.1961); 595, 609—622 (D.C.S.D.Miss.1961) (Rives, vacated 31, 549, 512 661, 680—681 (1873): 'Among past, quasi wayfarer traveler demand inn-keeper; carrier accept goods transportation, Soo, admission amusements, admission, instance, refusal, lay, unless (state rights) control.' 1873 Miss.Rev. 2731, 2732 (1871), forbade, railroads, stage coaches, steamboats. None appear 1880 codifications 1888 'all races' therewith pro tanto. 1888, Also McCabe Atchison, Topeka Santa Fe 235 151, 69, (1914); Abney, 435, 457—458, 628, 639—640, 634 (Brennan, 302—312, 495, provided: 'That subject, shall, notwithstanding, redress; circuit appeal, error, ninth eighteen sixty-six, vindication'; cases.' presently 1874 Statutes 1979. id.; Revision Statutes, Draft 947 (1872). jurisdictional 1343. assume linguistic differences immaterial. 212—213, 497—498, 492, 422—423, 2194—2195, inadequate, 333. Comment, Intervention Suppression Domestic Violence: Constitutionality, Statutory Power, Policy, 1966 Duke L.J. 415. Numerous 28; 4, 5, 15, 19, 1870 seq.; Feb. 28, 433, 437. (1894); 1088, 1153 (1909), unconstitutional. (ss unconstitutional); Bowman, 190 127, 979 (1903) unconstitutional). Gressman, Unhappy History Legislation, Mich.L.Rev. 1323 indictment Cox, Foreword: Constitutional Adjudication Promotion Human Rights, aside passing 246, 515—516; 216, 25. received thorough inter- pretations. 363—364, 840—841 (D.C.E.D.Mo.1969). Shoppes requirement; doubts Those Supra, 208 210. 845 1959), 1963), sub nom. Lewis, 342 727 1965) (en banc), 1983—deprivation right—and usage. constructions 1960), reports defendant's 126. codified, begins: differs example: precedes 'statute' 'or follows 'statute qualified 'secured,' whereas protected'; added); limited. precursor inclusion memtioned substantive. 483; 212 213, inconclusive. interpretations suggested. Blair, 209; Sloss, reject Shellabarger); Edmunds); 697—698 Edmunds). Representa- tive managers weight; Kerr, opponent, predicted flood litigation property. 50. 'refers useage' 217. 515—516 Thurman's unclear. referring approved ancient itself.' Louisville Nashville Reverman, 243 Ky. 702, 707, S.W.2d 558, 560 (1932). **68—74. Thurman taking fourth position: persons. Thurman); 215 Johnston, McHenry, 395 Rice, conferee). speeches 219-220. compatible preceding positions: remove authority. 416 Biggs, Maynard, patterned enlightening comments 1680 (veto message Johnson); 1120 Loan, manager); 1778 1785 Stewart, 475, 500, 1758 manager). Similar appeared Freedmen's Bureau debated addition, 209. though, indication Hendricks, 29, 44—50 1985 binding. 206—210. 1986 fits share perpetration wrongs. answer 17, cannot, can, extinguishing violate, infringe, fail infringe when, circumstances, 27; Clyatt 197 726 (1905); Alabama, 219 145, 191 (1911). also, run 774—784, 1186—1192 occur correlative 2194 30, consequence belonging (N)egroes previous slavery involuntary servitude 209, 318. vetoed 'right purchase (property)' 'refused denied' prejudice' 'Of 'abrogation armed ordinance." enforced.' overruled unrelated Morgan 476, 496, 588, 1044 (1885). Thereafter, approvingly McPherson Blacker, 869 (1892). superficially odd violator. interested violations, vary another. others, depending policies dictated sound considerations

Category: 1