Document: 426 U.S. 317 96 S.Ct. 2086 48 L.Ed.2d 666 UNITED STATES, Petitioner,v.Colin F. MacCOLLOM. No. 74-1487. Argued March 29, 1976. Decided June 10, Syllabus Nearly two years after his conviction of a federal crime, from which he took no appeal, respondent, Pro se, filed complaint for declaratory and injunctive relief, in asserted that intended to seek vacation sentence pursuant 28 U.S.C. § 2255; was unable afford transcript; without one could not frame arguments effective review; transcript would show had been afforded assistance counsel; there insufficient evidence support the guilty verdict. The District Court, granting respondent leave proceed In forma pauperis, appointing counsel, holding hearing, denied relief. Court Appeals reversed, entitled order assist him preparing motion under 2255. court concluded 753(f), provides free indigent prisoners asserting claim 2255 if trial judge certifies is "not frivolous" "needed decide issue," does prohibit courts requiring Government supply an prisoner with Before files motion. By so ruling felt it unnecessary hold 753(f) unconstitutional. Held : judgment reversed. Pp. 320-329; (Rehnquist, J., opinion); pp. 329-330 (Blackmun, opinion). 511 F.2d 1116, Mr. Justice Rehnquist, joined by Chief Burger, Stewart, Powell, concluded: 1. Section violate Art. I, 9, cl. 2, constituting suspension writ habeas corpus. right necessary concomitant writ, operated until 1944 provision at all transcripts indigents. If Congress thus have limited directly "suspending" it, may do indirectly. 322-323. 2. Nor Due Process Clause Fifth Amendment respondent's "equal protection," since whom available chosen appeal conviction, remained on conditions set forth 753, adequate opportunity attack conviction. 323-328. (a) establish 753(f)' are "so arbitrary unreasonable . as require their invalidation," Douglas v. California, 372 353, 365, 83 814, 820, 9 811, 819 (Harlan, dissenting). 323-324. (b) Though those statutory place position somewhat less advantageous than person means, equal protection component Amendment's guarantee absolute equality, providing access procedures review indigent, who, like chose forgo direct its attendant transcript. 324-328. Blackmun fair present claims effectively this collateral proceeding, consider constitutional significance what might done time appealed 329-330. Frank H. Easterbrook, Washington, D. C., pro hac vice, special petitioner. John A. Strait, Tacoma, Wash., respondent. REHNQUIST announced opinion THE CHIEF JUSTICE, STEWART, POWELL join. 1 This case presents question whether restrictions imposed 753 availability aid petition relief consistent Constitution. Ninth Circuit, contrast every other has ruled issue, held such We reverse. 2 * Respondent convicted uttering forged currency violation 18 472 jury United States Western Washington. On 3, 1970, sentenced 10 years' imprisonment. He did appeal. later acting paper designated "Motion Transcript Forma Pauperis." returned advice first file before act request 3 then "complaint Declaratory Judgment Injunctive Relief" alleged "intends move 2255." transcript, verdict guilty. further be "unable review." elaborate upon grounds 4 treated pleading 2255, granted appointed hearing. After hearing dismissed failure state granted. appealed, divided panel 1116 (1974), "in preparation postconviction (s) Id., 1124. II 5 expressly addressed furnishing public expense pertinent part: 6 "Fees furnished criminal proceedings persons proceeding Criminal Act (18 3006A), or corpus allowed sue, defend, shall paid out moneys appropriated purposes. Fees brought section title permitted sue pauperis money purpose circuit suit frivolous needed issue presented " 7 statute issue." conclusion failed granted, implicitly decided these issues against 8 declare unconstitutional grant Rather, "does government imprisoned Such simply fill deficit statute." (Emphasis added.) F.2d, 1119-1120. novel approach construction. established rule expenditure funds proper only when authorized Congress, expended unless prohibited Congress. Reeside Walker, 11 How. 272, 291, 13 L.Ed. 693 (1851). particular contains authority authorize plaintiffs actions. fact "prohibit" circumstances little significance, most statutes speak terms funds. Where subject here, expenditures where condition met, clear implication authorized. Botany Worsted Mills States, 278 282, 289, 49 129, 131, 73 379 (1929); Passenger Corp. Passengers Assn., 414 453, 458, 94 690, 693, 38 646 (1974).1 It true, observes, statute, currently written, distinguishes between petitioners parties latter must make showing need nonfrivolousness obtain Thus while still true "remedy" "exactly commensurate previously ," Hill 368 424, 427, 82 468, 471, 417 (1962), pursue remedy now Congress.2 argues constitutes argument presupposes, Inter alia, Founders declared suspended. obviously case. See 58 Stat. 6, 9a (1940 ed., Supp. IV). year time, certainly authorization nonfrivolous cases shown. IfCongress follows possible objection due process-equal claim, we turn. III 12 technically thought discovered lacuna but reference "constitutional deficit" suggests view question. urges read violates both protection." any see Griffin Illinois, 351 12, 18, 76 585, 590, 100 891 (1956) (plurality opinion), collaterally final conviction.3 payment costs were pursued use furnish part. Having forgone right, existed force only, several successfully assert process thereby own ancillary benefit. obtaining 811 (1963) dissenting); rather they "comport procedure," id., 357, S.Ct., 816 (Court's 14 Although respect movants therefore requirements Amendment, undoubtedly means. But neither Equal Protection Fourteenth nor counterpart requirement embodied guarantees "absolute equality precisely advantages," San Antonio School Dist. Rodriguez, 411 1, 24, 93 1278, 1291, 36 16 (1973). context "an (one's) fairly ." Ross Moffitt, 600, 616, 2437, 2447, 41 341 (1974). 15 supra, State provide counsel right. declined extend discretionary second intermediate appellate Supreme North Carolina. think distinction holdings considerable resolving claim. proceedings. having instead some sought best stands different position. grants review, deny because inability pay required filing fee, Smith Bennett, 365 708, 81 895, 39 (1961). There impediment here; action. also confide defender decision defendant who attacks Lane Brown, 477, 768, 892 (1963). observed "confers officer outside judicial system power take hope all." 485, 773. 17 congressional governing actions infirmity. provisions made initially official very heart district plaintiff tried. finds "suit 753(f). formula devised satisfies components Amendment. unconditional choice affects well delayed duplicate offered instance, even though means purchase pursuit basic adequacy light avenues follow seeks widen. enough collateral-relief stage provided pd demonstrates frivolous, presented. 19 urged oral poor job representing defendant, urge prevent ineffective being raised conceivable facts exist, notwithstanding fidelity interest clients demonstrated repeatedly overwhelming majority members legal profession. Prove convince frivolous. Had here confronted merely conclusory allegation, factual allegations indicating denial Sixth together additional explicit assertion should 753(f).4 20 our naked allegation counsel. Since discussion desirability normally appear trial, aided refreshing recollection discussions. flesh aspect then, likely cured 21 area law opinions appeals weight, represent expositions law, expressions essentially practical questions confront far more do. exception presently unanimously significant.5 A reason expressed Judge Haynsworth Shoaf, 832 (CA4 1964), said court: 22 "The usual successful convictions arise occurrences courtroom events aware can recall memory refreshed reading (to claim) rarely, ever, become constitute ground attack." 835.6 23 conclude To otherwise favorable similarly situated some, unlimited, presumably evaluation much prescribed spent 24 "(T)he service benefit mean constitutionally required. duty arsenal privately retained continuing effort reverse assure State's process." U.S., 2447. 25 dgment Circuit Reversed. 26 27 BLACKMUN, concurring judgment. I am complete accord n. plurality opinion, Ante, 321-322, regarding STEVENS' dissent. Court's function rewrite reflect dissent appears me regarded sound policy administration justice system. 29 write separately, however, emphasize narrowness us ease resolution. answer lies, think, MacCollom Current fairly, taken. 30 For me, Constitution requires makes showing, degree particularity, crucial inquiry, analogous context, affords indigents within adversary system." 612, 31 Here, him. basis, grounded Some articulable facts, believing proceeding. Clearly, prove face. tool, matter how speculative value, devoid be, unlimited choose waste resources quest kind. 32 way open bounds One go further. join reversing Appeals. 33 BRENNAN, MARSHALL joins, dissenting. 34 my Brother add separate record disagreement plurality's Government's refusal indigency, laws secured Federal Government, concedes, through Buckley Valeo, 424 87, 670, 46 659 (1976); Weinberger Wiesenfeld, 420 636, 638, 95 1225, 1228, 43 514 (1975). 35 central aim entire (is that) people charged crime must, concerned, 'stand bar American court,' 17, (1956), "country dedicated affording privileges none law." 19, 591. "Our decisions decade differences instruments vindicate rights, based financial situation repugnant Constitution." Roberts LaVallee, 389 40, 42, 88 194, 196, (1967). Thus, Griffin, "(d)estitute defendants buy transcripts," 591, purposes principle review. (1961), invalidated fee applied invalidation earlier courts. Burns Ohio, 360 252, 79 1164, 1209 (1959). Later, 484, 773, (1963), "Smith applies 37 next Long Iowa, 385 192, 87 362, 290 (1966), stating "having post-conviction procedure, cannot consideration," 364. And Gardner 393 367, 89 580, 601 (1969), went today indigency plain departure progeny. particularly egregious, merits Substantiation virtually impossible Yet denigrates "naked allegation." 327. Essentially, therefore, making unsubstantiated transcript.1 bears emphasis where, matters not, cases, defense reviewed unfairness born discrimination denying offensive resulting procedural deficiencies accept "(r)espondent proceedings." 324. demands despite same nonindigent.2 "If (the Government) general allowing (collateral relief), lack exercise opportunity. (Government) keep word promise ear illegally break hope." 593 (Frankfurter, judgment). 40 reliance, 324, proposition "(i) n (equal protection) require(s) 'an claim(s) fairly' patently misplaced. quotation Ross, speaks overall process, validity defendant's restraint primary consideration. reject wholly fallacious diminishes importance nonindigent tolerable. That explicitly rejected unbroken line distinction, analysis, trials appeals. Any necessarily intolerable stakes constitutionality plainly inconsistent recognition given Fay Noia, 391, 399-403, 822, 827, 837 prisoners, "history aremedy identical scope corpus." Davis 333, 343, 2298, 2304, 109 42 Today's empties assurance six ago applying "have pointedly passage heightened weakened attempts (by Court) mitigate disparate treatment Williams 399 235, 241, 90 2018, 2022, 586 (1970). STEVENS, WHITE, join, 44 decisive whether, judging sufficiency motion, assume true. 45 obtained expense.1 lawyer representation requires, supported examination training allege basis conclusion. If, accurate, new trial. As points out, legitimate reasons specific enough. pleader able details ultimate adequate, almost statement claiming entitle short, automatic sense, survive fails 47 why affirmative face value determining asserts. First, interpreted standard administered. itself address judges "that appeal," legislative history silent question.2 reads impose movant burden putting forward "some allegations" 326, creates risk will discretion conferred haphazard principled basis. many rational ultimately succeed [ ordering transcript.3 Unquestionably routinely others not. Given uncertainty adopted plurality,4 indigent's depends the] happenstance assigned important depend fortuitous circumstance. evenhanded dependent either receives appeal,5 ability persuade counsel's actually unsound. least sufficient completeness permit determination frivolousness. Cf. Coppedge 369 438, 445-446, 917, 920, 21.6 Second, favor tend improve seems probable, automatically proceedings, good sense prosecutors adopt practice eliminate serious cause delay processing appeals.7 Even assuming increase monetary costs,8 into account associated saving judges' result elimination this. Nation's scarcest judges; spending few dollars9 disposition preliminary enable them devote extra adjudicating disputes merits, spent. Coppedge, 450-452, 923, 928 (STEWART, concurring); J. Frank, Law: Case Radical Reform 85-110 (1969). More importantly, routine minimize danger insignificant safely ignored rights lost ineptitude 50 recognize permissible plead resolved transcript.10 added virtue avoiding discussed Part opinion. Jin Fuey Moy, 241 394, 401, 658, 659, 60 1061. balance, affirm Circuit. Our STEVENS construe part "make .," Post, 338. construction violence intent clearly language section, Supra, 320. Did Direct motions suit. advances course plaintiffs, pursuing considerations yet commended themselves difference great wish overcome "nonfrivolous" barrier 1915. E. g., Kitchens Alderman, 376 262 (CA5 1967); Blair 340 741 (CA9 1965). corpus, course, contained Clause, usually independent performance lead movant's nonfrivolous. Ellis Maine, 448 1325 (CA1 1971); ex rel. Buford Henderson, 524 147 (CA2 1975); 1964); Herrera, 474 1049 1973); Hoover 416 431 (CA6 1969); Nunes Nelson, 467 1380 1972) (habeas corpus); Taylor 238 409 1956) (§ motion); Hines Baker, 422 1002 (CA10 1970). aspects thoroughly shortly 1965 amendment Blackmun, Allowance Pauperis Habeas Corpus Cases, F.R.D. 343 Respondent's insufficiency evidence. Two indicate suffices verbatim Mayer City Chicago, 404 189, 92 410, (1971); Draper 487, 774, 899 indicated prejudicial prosecutorial misconduct, 198, 416, substantiation Mayer, 195, 415, colorable transcript" it. Indeed, (1959), invalid indigents, petitioner already received stated: Illinois left for, holds, once chooses foreclose phase procedure poverty." 257, 1168. 753(f); §§ 3006A(a), (c), (d)(6). Pub.L. 89-167, 647, followed proposal Judicial Conference 1961. Report Proceedings 100-101 H.R.Rep.No.133, 89th Cong., 1st Sess. (1965); S.Rep.No.617, (1965), U.S.Code Cong. & Admin.News 1965, p. 2916; 111 Cong.Rec. 5000 (1905) (remarks Rep. Celler); 20828-20829. sources discuss standards need. Specifically, stronger certification prior requirement, turn, imports 1915(d). indication 356-357 1915 nowhere mentioned. movants, 1915(d) reasonably gifted lawyers daily copy sure exactly happened preceding day, bound blended judge's memory, inconceivable determine arguable merit Would regard pleadings object inadmissible evidence, argue jury, advise properly about conduct cross-examination key prosecution witnesses? just easily ineffectiveness difficult Rather evaluate permutations these, sensible promptly automatically? attorney notice supports Because 10-day period specified Fed.Rule App.Proc. 4(b), protect clients' Furthermore, case, represented although advised 'it interfere modify sentence.' Brief 3. described "almost" equivalent full significant. amended transcripts, 91-545, 84 1412, appellants (1964 V), but, 446, 921, appellant nonfrivolousness. give difference, valuable Craven noted Jones Superintendent, Virginia Farm, 460 150, 153 1972), rehearing denied, 465 1091, cert. 410 944, 1380, 611 (1973): "It again deciding often attributable getting transcript." allowance bail pending (a routine, incidentally, restudied), postpone incarceration delaying long possible, and, thus, motivation sooner necessary. approximately 75% Of rate increased steadily 46% Fiscal Year 1966 1973, remained. Annual Reports Director Administrative Office Courts, Tables B1, D4 (1966-1969, 1971-1975) (compare total commenced trial). taken high percentage experience teaches apt decrease, appreciable number doubt prepared already, minimal impact budget. significantly, doubtful parallel cost surely substantial substituting individually, reporter faced deadline. words "few dollars" advisedly subsidizing including fees expenses amounted 5% 9% lower recent years, turn 1/10 1% national Courts VI-3 (1975), IV-2 III-3 (1973), (1972); Budget Government: 1977, (1976). Hospital Bldg. Co. Rex Trustees, 425 738, 746-747, 1848, 1853-1854, 338, 345 Haines Kerner, 519, 520-521, 594, 595, 652; Conley Gibson, 355 41, 45-46, 78 99, 101, 80.

Category: 1