Case Study
Patient Demographic: Client Age: 13 Sex Assigned at Birth: Male Gender: Transgender; Gender Nonconforming (TGNC) Ethnicity: Caucasian Counseling Setting: Child and Family Agency, School-Based Services Type of Counseling: Individual and Family Presenting Problem: Truancy; Gender Dysphoria Diagnosis: Gender Dysphoria, Provisional (F64.1); Social Exclusion or Rejection V62.4 (Z60.4)
Mental Status Exam: Mental Status Exam: The client is dressed in age-appropriate clothing. They wear eye makeup and chipped black fingernail polish, and they have bitten most fingernails down to the quick. The client’s mood is irritable, and they are quick to show anger toward their mother when misgendered. Their thoughts are coherent, and they deny audio/visual hallucinations. The client acknowledges feeling sad and hopeless but denies suicidal ideation. They attribute increased levels of anxiety at school to bullying, particularly with select peers. They explain that a select group of students threaten the client and call them offensive and derogatory names. Family History and History of th
Presenting Problem: You are a school-based mental health counselor in a public middle school. Your client is a 13-year-old Caucasian 7th grader who presents for the initial intake with their mother. The mother says that the client has had several unexcused absences from school because “he is confused about his gender.” The client adamantly denies being confused and explains that they self-identify as transgender. The client’s preferred pronouns are “they/them.” The client further states that they have had a strong desire to be a different gender since early childhood, and this desire and their distress have recently intensified. The mother reports that the client is chronically irritable, spends a lot of time alone, and has “basically shut everyone out.”The client reports experiencingbullying—both verbal and physical—in school “nearly every day.” In addition to the bullying, the client says that certain teachers refuse to allow them to use the bathroom aligned with their identified gender. To prevent this conflict, the client does not eat breakfast or lunch at school.
Other Contexts: Client Age/Gender: Sexuality: Both Heterosexual Ethnicity: Both Caucasian Relationship Status: Married Counseling Setting: Outpatient Behavioral Health Type of Counseling: Couples Counseling  Marital Discord Diagnoses:  You are a certified counselor providing couples therapy in an outpatient behavioral health setting. The wife serves as the primary client due to the complexity of her clinical and diagnostic presentation. She is a 34-year-old female seeking marital counseling with her 44-year-old husband of 18 months. The client explains that shortly after returning from the couple’s honeymoon, she began having chronic, debilitating migraines causing her to remain bedridden, sometimes for days on end. She reports that she no longer engages in activities that she once enjoyed and feels chronically tired and depressed. Despite being treated by several neurologists, her chronic migraines persist, and she is now on long-term leave from her job. The client’s husband is a chief financial officer for a large hospital system and works long hours. The couple has joint custody of the husband’s 12-year-old son from a previous marriage. The client thinks that there is an unfair amount of burden placed on her to parent her stepchild, which has caused conflict among the client, her husband, and the husband’s ex-wife. The husband admits to growing impatient with the chronic nature of his wife’s illness and says she is not the same person that she was when they met nearly 3 years ago.  The client and the husband are both well dressed. The client is wearing sunglasses and explains that her migraines cause her to be light sensitive. It is the middle of the husband’s workday, and he is dressed in a suit and tie. The client reports daytime sleepiness, which she attributes to her migraine medication. Her appetite is fair. She denies current suicidal or homicidal ideations. However, the client does report that she has previously had thoughts of not wanting to live. Her mood is depressed, and her affect is congruent with her mood. The client is tearful when discussing how her illness has affected the marriage and states that she receives little support from her husband. When the client begins to cry, the husband responds by sitting silently, crossing his arms, shaking his head, and looking around the room. The client states, “See! This is what I’m talking about! Whenever I need his support, he checks out.” Family History and History of  The client’s parents were never married. The client was placed in foster care at age 3 due to parental neglect. She remained in foster care until age 6, when the courts granted her paternal grandmother full custody. The client’s husband has two younger brothers and was raised by his biological mother and father. He describes his father as “hardworking” and his mother as a stay-at-home mom. Approximately 5 years ago, the husband was treated for alcohol use disorder. He states that he stopped drinking independently and “didn’t have to rely on a 12-step program to get sober.” The couple met when the husband was married, which contributed to a drawn-out and acrimonious divorce

Question: During the initial session, which of the following would you use to create a therapeutic alliance with the couple?
(A): Encourage the use of “I” statements and teach effective problem solving.
(B): Empathize with and validate the client’s physical and emotional pain.
(C): Explain your clinical approach to help define the treatment focus.
(D): Summarize the couple’s concerns and assess readiness for change.

Correct Answer: Summarize the couple’s concerns and assess readiness for change.
Explanation: Summarizing shared concerns and assessing readiness for change can help create a therapeutic alliance with the couple. During the initial stage of treatment, building a therapeutic alliance can be accomplished by assisting the couple in conceptualizing the presenting problem. This can be done by using core counseling techniques, including, but not limited to, summarization, empathy, attending, encouraging, genuineness, and congruence. In addition, counselors can use a motivational enhancement approach to determine a couple’s readiness for change. Assessing a couple’s readiness to change contributes to the therapeutic alliance by fostering hope. Explaining your clinical approach to define the treatment focus is not the best option because it does not elicit the couple’s input for what they need and hope to get out of therapy. Empathizing and validating the client’s pain addresses the client’s needs, but this does not address the couple’s needs. Further, this response may alienate the husband and potentially deprive him of the opportunity to later express this sentiment to his wife. Encouraging “I” statements and problem solving are helpful interventions, but this is not the best option for creating a collaborative therapeutic alliance. Therefore, the correct answer is (C)
Competency: counseling skills and interventions