Case Study
Patient Demographic: Name: Carter Clinical Issues: Developmental processes/tasks/issues Diagnostic Category: Neurodevelopmental Disorders Provisional Diagnosis: F90.0 Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder, Predominately Inattentive Presentation; F81.2 Specific Learning Disorder with Impairment in Mathematics Age: 11 Sex Assigned at Birth: Male Gender and Sexual Orientation: Male, Not Assessed Ethnicity: White Marital Status: Not Applicable Modality: Individual Therapy Location of Therapy : School  
Mental Status Exam: The client is of average build. He is dressed in a neat and appropriate manner for school. He is reluctant to engage in the conversation but does not display any hostility or aggression. The client displays a flat affect with occasional brief moments of animation which appear to be fueled by fleeting interests. His mood appears to be somewhat dysphoric as he often responds with a shrug or a one-word answer. The client’s thought process is non-linear and circumstantial. He is able to answer questions in a straightforward manner once he understands the topic being discussed. The client’s speech is of normal rate and volume for his age but it does contain some articulation errors due to his speech disorder. His memory appears intact as he can recall details from previous conversations with ease.
Presenting Problem: First session You are a mental health therapist in a public school. The client, an 11-year-old male, and his parents arrive at your office for the intake appointment per a referral from the committee on special education. The parents express concerns with their son's ongoing lack of concentration, being easily distracted, requiring multiple prompts and redirection throughout his day, and not following multi-step processes. The mother states that he tends to "drift off and is fidgety." He has trouble sitting still and cannot focus on anything for more than a few minutes. According to the parents, this behavior is present at both school and at home. As you progress with the intake session, you ask the parents to describe their current goals and any treatment barriers they have experienced up to this point. They state that they would like their son to be more focused throughout the day and be better able to follow instructions. They also mention that so far their efforts in trying to help him have been unsuccessful and he is still struggling.    After gathering more insight into the client's home life, school performance, and developmental history from the parents, you turn your attention to the client. He has been looking around the room and has not been actively engaged in the conversation. When asked directly about his feelings about school, he shrugs and says, "It's okay." You ask him if there is anything that makes it hard for him to stay focused in class, and after a few seconds of reflection he admits that it is sometimes difficult because "there are too many things happening at the same time." He states that he cannot keep up with all of the activity going on around him and it is distracting. You inquire further as to what else may be contributing to his difficulty maintaining attention in school and he admits that sometimes he gets frustrated when tasks are too challenging for him. While he is answering your questions, he is looking at the small tabletop clock sitting on the corner of your desk.    Once you feel that you have an accurate understanding of the current presenting issues, you discuss next steps with the parents. You discuss meeting with the client for individual weekly sessions to help him develop effective coping skills, build self-esteem, and manage emotions associated with frustration, failure, and low self-worth. You also suggest collateral sessions with the parents to check in with them about their son's progress and discuss strategies they can use at home to help him. They agree to this arrangement and ask if there are any tools or techniques they can try between now and the next time they meet with you. You suggest they start by creating a daily routine that will provide a sense of predictability and help to reduce chaos, and having a set time for homework, meals, and bedtime. You also mention that stimulant medication is often prescribed for children with ADHD, which can help to improve focus and concentration. Lastly, you let the parents know there is some evidence that certain foods can trigger or worsen ADHD symptoms, such as sugary, processed, or artificial foods.
Other Contexts:  The client is currently a fifth grader participating in the general education curriculum. He has a disability classification with his school district as learning disabled. He receives consultant teacher services via classroom support aide for English Language Arts (ELA) and Math. In addition, he attends the resource room daily for added support. The client arrives to class prepared with necessary materials and homework assignments but requires prompts throughout his day to stay on track. He is conscientious about his grades and doing well academically but is easily distracted by environmental factors surrounding him. Three years ago, the client's triennial evaluation report indicated a classification of Speech Language Disorder. To date, staff suggests that the client's speech deficits manifesting as notably impaired speech do not seem to cause concern in social situations. Additional Characteristics: The client is a very pleasant, quiet, shy, reserved boy. He tends to lack confidence in his academic abilities, which seems to cause him stress. Small glimpses of the client's good sense of humor can often be seen in small group settings. 

Question: What, if any, ethical issue did you create by responding to the client's parents asking if there are any tools or techniques they could learn from you to work with their son?
(A): No ethical issue was violated by mentioning medication is prescribed for children with ADHD.
(B): A behavioral analyst should be responsible for scheduling and creating a daily routine for the client.
(C): Mentioning that medication is often prescribed for children with ADHD is not within your scope of practice as a therapist.
(D): A qualified dietician should be the only provider mentioning this treatment modality.

Correct Answer: No ethical issue was violated by mentioning medication is prescribed for children with ADHD.
Explanation: Giving the client's parents options does not create an ethical issue. If you indicated that their son should be on medication, that would be outside the bounds of your clinical practice. Therefore, the correct answer is (B)
Competency: professional practice and ethics