Case Study
Patient Demographic: Name: Jack and Diane Clinical Issues: Marital/partner communication problems Diagnostic Category: V-codes Provisional Diagnosis: Z63.0 Relationship Distress with Spouse Age: 35 Sex Assigned at Birth: Male Gender and Sexual Orientation: Male, Heterosexual Ethnicity: White Marital Status: Married Modality: Couples Therapy Location of Therapy : Community-based mental health facility  
Mental Status Exam: The clients are a couple in their mid-30s. The husband is tall and healthy. The wife is petite and well-groomed. As they enter, you make note that though they came in the same vehicle, they enter with no contact between them. They sit far away from one another and do not look at each other but maintain excellent eye contact with you. The husband's movements seem to be more agitated; the wife appears subdued. He speaks quickly and loudly and often fidgets in his chair, rarely sitting still; in contrast, her speech is low and soft, and she remains still and moves very little. They both seem guarded. They both identify their son's diagnosis of Autism Spectrum as being a significant strssor.
Presenting Problem: First session Your clients are in their mid-30s and present to the community agency where you are employed as both a licensed mental health therapist and a marriage and family therapist. You begin by introducing yourself and telling the couple about your professional experience and explain the types of therapies that you provide for couples. When asked why the couple made an appointment to meet with you, the husband takes the lead and tells you that he and his wife have been "serious problems" with their relationship for a few years. The husband shares that his wife does not trust him since his alcohol use "got out of control." Although he has been able to maintain sobriety for two years, he says that his wife is "paranoid" that he is using again and insists on knowing where he is "every minute of the day." He further reports that his wife is "too dependent" on him, and he feels "suffocated." He says, "I just can't keep doing this" and puts his head in his hands. You thank him for sharing his perspective of the problem and encourage the wife to share her thoughts about what is going on with their relationship. She tells you, "Truthfully? I'm scared to death that he's going to start drinking again and leave me alone with our children. I don't know what I would do if I lost him." She wipes a tear away from her face. After taking a deep breath, she says that when she tries to approach him to talk about how she feels, "he just gets mad and leaves the room."    Using open-ended questions, you ask about each person's expectations for the counseling process and inquire about past experiences in therapy that may inform the current situation. Both partners look at each other, then back at you and share that they would like to re-establish trust and respect in their marriage. This is their first time seeking counseling. You also invite them to share the story of how they first met each other, memories of their relationship prior to getting married, and how they felt when they became parents. The husband shares that they first met when they were teenagers and have been together ever since. He talks about how their relationship was full of passion, respect, and trust. Even during the difficult times, they felt like nothing could tear them apart. He also shares that when their son was diagnosed with Autism Spectrum Disorder, they felt like the world had come to a standstill, but they were determined to get him the best care possible. He pauses. The husband and wife look at each other before the wife speaks. She explains that after their son's diagnosis, her husband began to drink more heavily as a way of dealing with his own stress and anxiety. He denied it for a long time, but eventually admitted he needed help and sought treatment. Although she was relieved that he got help, she is still struggling to trust him again.  Fourth session Today, the couple arrives for their afternoon appointment ten minutes late. The wife appears to have been crying. Her husband smells like mouthwash, and his movements are slightly slower than normal. You ask if he has been drinking today. He states that he has not had any alcohol today, but his wife says, "That's not true!" and proceeds to tell you that she "caught" him holding a bottle of liquor in their garage this morning. The husband replies, "I didn't do anything wrong. This is just another example of you looking for problems where there are none. Why can't you believe me when I tell you that I'm not drinking?" She replies, "I really want to believe you, but you make it really hard to do that." He shakes his head and throws his hands up in the air in frustration. You ask the husband to step out of the room for a few minutes. He agrees and says, "Fine. You know where to find me." The wife shares that she feels like her husband is not taking the process seriously, and she questions whether or not counseling will work for them. You thank her for expressing her thoughts and explain that it is very common for couples to have doubts about therapy, especially when there has been a history of substance abuse. You discuss the potential treatment barriers and emphasize that it is important to have insight into these problems in order to create positive outcomes. The wife appears to understand and is reassured by your words.    You invite the husband back into the room and ask him to share his thoughts about the counseling process. He takes a deep breath and says that he still wants to make their marriage work, but he is afraid of failing. He admits that he does not know how to "make things right" and this makes him feel helpless. You explain to him that counseling can help them gain insight into their communication patterns, learn new ways to interact with each other, and develop healthier coping strategies. You also discuss a plan for handling escalations in future sessions. You explain to the couple that it is important to have a plan in place whenever they are feeling overwhelmed or angry. Next, you discuss conflict resolution skills, emphasizing the importance of communicating their feelings and needs in an honest, respectful, and non-judgmental way. You also stress the importance of each partner taking responsibility for their own actions. You encourage them to practice these strategies outside of the session in order to improve their communication and relationship.    After the session, you discover that the community-based mental health facility where you work will be closing in six months due to a lack of funding. You view this as a potential barrier that will inhibit mental health treatment access for many clients as this is the only mental health treatment facility in the city.  Sixth session The wife presents for today's session without her husband. She reports that two nights ago, he was taken to the emergency room for pain. He had been drinking, and test results at the hospital liver indicated that his liver functioning was impaired. He continues to deny that he is drinking, but she knows this is untrue as she has been finding half-full liquor containers hidden around the house. She starts to cry, "I don't know what I will do without him. I had to call a babysitter and get a cab to come here. I'm worried about how I'll pay for the mortgage if my husband can't work. We'll end up losing the house and our health insurance! I'm going to have to sell off everything to make ends meet!" You respond to her fears with empathy and understanding. You are respectful of the client's thoughts and feelings and seek to understand her experience. You also explore the cognitive error that your client has made and how this is affecting her emotions.    You continue the session by asking her what her most immediate concerns are at the moment and what she needs help with. She pauses for a moment and then starts to explain how she is feeling overwhelmed by the situation and feeling helpless in being able to help her husband. She expresses a lot of fear and anxiety about her family's financial security and the potential loss of the house and health insurance if her husband's drinking continues. She expresses a need for support and understanding and worries about how she will cope without her husband. She feels isolated and alone, stating, "I feel like my worst nightmare has come true. I've been worrying about my husband's drinking for a long time. I've heard horror stories about how addiction can ruin people's marriages, and I don't want that for us. I know it's hard for him, but it's hard for me, too." You offer her some resources that could help her with her financial situation and ask her to put together a list of a few people she feels she can talk to for emotional support.
Other Contexts:   The husband used to have severe issues with alcohol. He went to rehab three years ago and has maintained sobriety for two years. He continues to attend weekly meetings. As a result of his alcohol misuse, he has some medical issues with his liver, but they are not currently life-threatening as long as he continues to abstain from alcohol. The husband has worked hard to rebuild his relationships with his family and friends. He is actively trying to repair the damage that was done due to his alcohol misuse. He has been attending AA meetings and is focusing on rebuilding trust and communication. He has also been making an effort to be more present in his family life and to be a better husband and father.

Question: What would you say to demonstrate a nonjudgmental stance towards the wife?
(A): "It must be hard for you to watch your husband struggle with his addiction."
(B): "It sounds like you're making many assumptions about what could happen in the future."
(C): "It sounds like you're really struggling right now."
(D): "You mentioned that your husband's drinking issues have been present for a long time. You must be feeling really frustrated with him."

Correct Answer: "It sounds like you're really struggling right now."
Explanation: This response is affirming and shows the client that you are listening to her and understanding her pain. It also expresses sympathy and empathy without making any judgments. Therefore, the correct answer is (D)
Competency: counseling skills and interventions