Good point how does the title relate to the meaning of apartheid This was discussed somewhat in the centralized Talk and the synthesis There are two meanings of apartheid 1st The official self described policy of South Africa 2nd Similar or analogous policies in other places The title Israeli apartheid uses the 2nd meaning This seems to favor the anti Israel side In the suggestion that started this thread Comparisons between Israel and apartheid era South Africa the word apartheid has the 1st meaning This arguably favors the pro Israel side But Israel and apartheid Gee one of the interesting things about Israel and apartheid is that the noun apartheid is not modified either by Israeli or SA So here the meaning of apartheid is ambiguous If you don t mind my asking a follow up question Andyvphil don t you think that ambiguity might add to the appeal of such a title Talk