Thanks I have apologized to Dr Dec at the RD M as I have now realized that it was wrong to accuse him without sufficient evidence It also would have created unnecessary WikiDrama and been counterproductive should I have proceeded With regards to the comments I made I do agree that I could have been far more polite and it was possibly the haste with which I made the remark which caused problems However I did honestly believe that the OP intended to waste our times the reason I did not proceed to the talk page was because I thought it was too small a matter and only deserved a small remark In the future I shall take your advice to heart if I do respond to an OP at the reference desk for a similar reason I shall ensure that it is only done if absolutely necessary Mostly however I will ignore such posts and let others judge the content Thanks for making me see things in this manner T