TH1980 mentioned that he did a spot check back during the good article review and I know he has access to almost all of the sources If users interpret the sources in different ways then those can be discussed on a case by case basis However there have been plenty of experienced users who have already done spot checks and found no outstanding problems In this thread though it s hard to see what point there is in discussing anything other than the topic of the thread The discussion will become too convoluted to follow I did propose mediation as an alternative to request for comment but currently I have not heard any reason why request for comment is not the best manner to resolve the issue of how to structure the article