Three factual observations 1 The Patchett AfD was logged here 2 Her page clearly states that she s from Western Australia and that she s listed in the category for People from Perth Western Australia 3 Dan has a long history of editing pages about WA Obviously I can t say for certain how Dan came to edit the page and I have no idea at all if he would recognise the name and follow through after seeing it in the log nor if he even saw the log but I can say that there are other possibilities than the one LibStar suggests Unless LibStar has other evidence that isn t posted here I don t really see how he or she can be so confident that Dan is in the wrong Now for the record before I m accused of something I ll note that I ve been editing some of the same pages as Dan since 2007 I took a look at his contributions page to see if he d been up to anything interesting recently and came across this