My objections again The rapings lootings desecrations inflicted on the civil population by the invading troops have to be properly mentioned not necessarily with those words Pfainuk s text they were frustrated when after three days of violent disorder almost the entire population of the town left citing their loyalty to Philip V the Bourbon claimant does not comply with this requirement The exodus of almost all Gibraltarians to San Roque and nearby areas is notable and relevant to Gibraltarians in History and thus must be mentioned Pfainuk s text does not mention this episode at all My proposal That s it