TruSilver Mediation et al You can include the following statement as part of the mediation template if you wish I m not able to edit at the moment because jdchamp s admin shopping on WP AIV finally paid off While obviously I m happy to accept any attempt to produce a better US Mobile Phone Companies template I have concerns about the mediation proposal currently made on the subject My first concern is that mediation is supposed to be one of the tools used after discussion has failed on the relevant article s discussion page At this stage the only person who appears steadfastly unable to posit views other than attacks on editors and the fact he disagrees with them a discussion requires that you express your reasons why and address the reasons given by the people who have opposing views is jdchamp A better position at this point would be to ask jdchamp to participate fully in the discussion on the Talk page of the appropriate article I have contributed my views to that discussion page multiple times in the last two weeks and given my reasons for my beliefs I have done also said that I believe this is the most appropriate action at this stage to jdchamp and to TruSilver the admin jdchamp has involved in the dispute about what is going on there Unfortunately he has instead repeatedly posted the same comments over and over again to my talk page varying from false accusations of bad conduct from me to expressing a willingness to discuss the article yet for some reason not followed by actual action on his part Mediation only makes sense if the parties involved continue to have a dispute that s based upon a genuine difference of opinion after proper discussion While that different of opinion might exist at this point unless jdchamp actually expresses his differing opinion fully as in gives valid reasons and challenges the reasons his opponents give with legitimate arguments there has been no discussion and therefore going on to the next stage of dispute resolution seems premature My second concern and believe me I m not happy in saying this is that I have concerns about TruSilver as the mediator Please do not take anything I say about this as assuming bad faith I m absolutely sure TruSilver thinks what he s done is right but that said I don t trust his judgment on this issue based upon an on going harassment campaign leveled against me by jdchamp TruSilver has consistently misrepresented my actions while doing little to challenge jdchamp s on going campaign In particular TruSilver has accused me of using his talk page to continue my apparent argument with jdchamp This is untrue I have only ever posted once to TruSilver s talk page posting an apology for the fact he d been involved in the mess and expressing my concern about it After it became obvious that jdchamp was posting at the same time and challenging my comments about my personal state of mind I made the decision to not post there again TruSilver has accused me of refusing to discuss jdchamp s differences with me these differences concerning the Mobile Phone Companies template This is also manifestly untrue I have have been a full participant in the discussion on that page s Talk page even participating in a poll that I believe was posted prematurely arguing why I believe what I do and suggesting compromise solutions that might suit all parties I have removed jdchamp s vandalism of my page which in some cases involved posting claims that he was willing to discuss various issues but were neither posted in the correct place nor actual discussions of those issues TruSilver has also leveled unnecessary personal attacks on me accusing me of being dysfunctional and of disruptiveness edit warring and incivility With the possible exception of my pretty justified expression of frustration last night nothing I ve done of late fits the latter category and the nearest thing I ve done that comes to edit warring consists of removing spam that has been repeatedly added to my page by jdchamp The other comments are just plain insulting and wrong I ve suffered a sustained campaign of harassment against me for most of the last 15 days I asked for help and instead the admin who put his hand up has essentially acted as an enabler for the person harassing me Other than an ultimately unenforced threat to block jdchamp if he continued to spam WP AIV with inappropriate demands I be blocked nothing has been done to encourage jdchamp to tone down his behavior and as he showed last night with three warnings and multiple reverts on my Talk page his behavior remains as bad as ever While I m sure TruSilver has acted in what he believes is the most appropriate way given the facts immediately available to him I don t believe he h