1998 99 who won Most sources all the sources I can find actually say LeClair Yet Karpovtsev did have a better plus minus 38 compared to LeClair 36 The only reason I can think of that LeClair would be given the award over Karpovtsev is Karpovtsev only played in 58 games with the Rangers and Maple Leafs Is there a minimum number of games a player must play in order to win the award