This won t by itself be more o a precedent than the 1000 or so this year claiming similar incompatibilities between the twoI ve argued both ways from time to time for the contradiction can be used to get any desired result If anything it shows we need flexible rules for after all the real point is suitable for an encyclopedia such as WP if WPedians disagree on what that isas WPedians do in very basic ways there is no way we can juggle fixed rules to gloss over the differences Current idea 2 RSs only as the default in case there is no decision on other grounds Personally I d add keep if its in the de WP except perhaps for purely German figures I trust them more than en WP not to include if not appropriate and why should we try to decide everything in every separate WP