That s not what A1 says Please read WP A1 It says nothing about below stub class whatever that may mean WP Stub deals at length with what may be too much for stub class but so far as I can see it says nothing about what may be too little If you want to change the standard to include something about articles below stub class you should propose it at WP CSD I will grant you that A7 may have appropriate for this article but not A1 t c