ilandi My comments were made are on the AFD listing but yes I should have made a more detailed comment My only excuse is that I ve been on Candidates for Speedy for the last three hours now and I m pretty worn out The creator of this article appears sincere about attempting to conform I don t think this will save him but it does earn him a few days grace I am a fairly ruthless deleter deletor sp in general but I try to give people the benefit of the doubt when they argue their case