If articles supporting Islam aren t permitted those devoted to criticizing it shouldn t be either If an article can represent both views Views On Islam maybe that d be something If the generic Islam Islam related articles do represent a positive image of Islam then they re not NPOV and need to be corrected The tone was supposed to be neutral By the way I don t see the Islam article listing every positive comment or opinion ever voiced regarding Islam the way this article documents so many negative ones No I m fairly convinced this article shouldn t be here at all Because of the title only negative views regarding Islam can be documented followed perhaps by responses to those criticisms Pope John Paul II s positive words on Islam or Muhammad wouldn t fit here nor would those of anyone else Muslim or Non Muslim who ve ever expressed a positive view of Islam that wasn t a response to criticism That makes this article POV biased at its core I don t particularly know Amin or Merzbow and I ll assume good faith until I know them better I do know several of the players who frequent pages dealing with Islam or Muslims and I know their intentions are malevolent Articles such as these serve as a platform for their Islam bashing My suggestion perhaps it can be renamed such all views can be accomodated