Hi David may I ask did you post this at Jossi s request Are you someone who s ever edited the Rawat articles I think I recall a David at some point Was that you In any event while I agree with the general point that editors shouldn t be hunted down etc is that really a fair way to characterize my asking an editor if he s ever been a paid publicist for the article s subject Do you think that s an irrelevant question especially in light of Jimbo Wales saying just the other day that ideally articles shouldn t be edited by interested parties but that it was hard to know who was who given the ease with which people can be anonymous Besides Jossi s not anonymous is he Sorry but I find this confusing Wales says Wikipedia s a free speech forum Jossi says it isn t It s all too subtle for me I m afraid