11 August 2006 UTC I certainly do not have a problem with this user CORRECTING birth date years to reflect the truth provided some kind of proof is given in the form of a link to an authoritative web site or other source The evidence indicates however that the changes made by this user were in fact arbitrary additions or subtractions of a year or two or ten It may be that the user inadvertently hit on a correct year purely by accidental coincidence particularly if there are source information sites that have alternate years of birth posted as well But there are other cases in the contributions list where the user made a change to a false year and then changed it back to the correct year either to confuse the anti vandalism patrollers or to make the latest edit look like a true and legitimate one Either way I think it would be good practice for us all to provide a reference link and edit summary any time such a change is made In the case of celebrities with two or more possible birth years then we should post all of them with an explanation and again reference sources for proof Thanks 18 41