Reaper Eternal if you have the time take a look at just these two comments by Nishidani as well as his talk page were who by the way was called upon by Hijiri 88 to help attack CurtisNaito several times are these condesending and insulting comments acceptable How is what I said any worse Whatever no one need take my word for anything I know the topics fairly thoroughly through primary and secondary sources in Japanese and Western languages I try however to avoid the topic area because of the need to WP AGF and all I can see is puerile bickering and dumb ignorant edits based on an inability to see good sources and evaluate reliable evidence I see only POV passions googling for evidence to support them and above all the tolerance on the page of sheer bad edits or nonsense that anyone with the slightest BA competence in Japanese studies would find laughable I m thinking of CurtisNaito in this regard There are massive corrections to be made but as Ubikwit says one simply doesn t have the time at least for now except to note that the litigants who do edit those pages can t see the obvious citing outdated sources like Fenellosa et al from a century back etc I gave details a year ago why none of them are reliable and suggested how to fix the sourcing almost nothing done and my edits are invariably to replace bad edits by giving several good sources which however anyone could do if they had the foggiest idea of what Japanese scholarship knows If there is competent area specialists available to review these messes by all means get a third opinion from her them Nishidani talk Well I also know this topic very thoroughly Sigh I ve had to correct virtually every edit I ve seen you make or revert every revert True you eventually accept nearly all of these improvements after persisting on the talk page in justifying the trash you added but had you known the material you wouldn t have dumped in the trash in the first place I can document this at great length but suffice it to read the relevant talk pages and examine each time you ve been reverted by a knowledgeable editor Nishidani talk 202 71 190 26