Hmmm I was actually writing a response as you sent yours Oh well For the record my response was this Resurrecting articles is frowned upon yes We might be able to get away with it if the article we resurrect is a substantial improvement on the last one however though of course we both know that there s no guarantee it would ultimately be accepted whatever we did there is an established bias towards deleting articles on individual matches Changing the name would be nice but I m not sure what we would change to the game didn t really have a name like the Ballet on Ice or any such and there are limited other ways of naming the article Making this subpage was a decent idea you just got unlucky in that it s something that has already been tried elsewhere and ultimately voted against Honestly I can say I ve never seen a subpage for an actual mainspace article so I have no idea how much people tend to chase these articles up or whether it might just glean a community wide shrugging of the shoulders Certainly there s been no AfD nomination yet which is a start I have to say I somewhat favour making it a standalone article or merging with the season article i e not keeping the subpage but I don t have strong feelings so I ll run with whatever works If it got categorised it would either be put into a category for something like Category Football matches I have no idea if that exists it was another example and Category FA Cup and then probably into a new category for City matches or comebacks or somesuch where it probably would be on its own That category would then have to be categorised so it wasn t just an orphan I don t know what the ethic is here for creating categories with only a single article in them but I suspect it s not encouraged so that idea might be rejected if whoever did it couldn t find more like minded articles to categorise into the same I don t think it being categorised would really affect anyone s opinion of the article though The one thing that might affect peoples judgement right now is that it will in its present form show up in categories as 2003 04 Manchester City F C season Spurs 3 4 City or however the subpage is actually named given the in the name Yes I d say it will currently be located in an overarching please categorise these pages category I don t know how long it would take for it to get sorted but it would probably be put somewhere generic Better to do it ourselves I guess Sorry my thoughts were a bit disjointed but I was answering the points as they came and well better English just didn t quite flow from my fingers as I typed Hopefully I addressed all your points I ll settle for just keeping the subpage if you want it though I think that page would be best served by being redone with as many citations as possible and expanded upon so we can argue a case for it being reincluded into society so to speak Having an article AfD ed isn t a permanent sign that that article should never exist it s merely a suggestion that it shouldn t exist in the state it s in Generally speaking most articles that get deleted will be kept the second time around if their quality and or level of detail is substantially improved As for the Charity Shield I always considered it a notable trophy Yes it s a single game but it requires winning a trophy to qualify in the first place ignoring those early years when some teams refused to play To this end I d consider it more of an accomplishment than winning the trophy which qualified you for it Similarly would you question the worthiness of the European Super Cup In fact because some teams initially didn t enter City were instrumental in making the Charity Shield the respected competition it is today by taking their place in the competition twice You could argue that of all the teams to have ever played in it we should be the ones most ardently defending it Talk