Oppose The contents of this list are quite clear members must be Jewish and Nobel laureates How do we decide Same way as always whatever reliable sources say Similar lists including List of African American Medal of Honor recipients List of African American United States Cabinet Secretaries List of Asian American Medal of Honor recipients and even List of Jewish Medal of Honor recipients do not have such statements despite the fact that the definition of African American Asian American and Jew can at times be a bit fuzzy These are all Featured Lists indicating that they represent Wikipedia s best practices It s unclear why List of Jewish Nobel laureates would need something that similar Featured Lists do not talk