For over a year we had the one sentence that was prefaced A small minority of scholars it seems like the use of the word scholar is disputed in this context Also it seems like one side of the dispute wants to completely remove any qualifier which states the position is only a minority view while the other side wants to go into more detail about it I think both of those issues can and should be worked out here in talk and that while there is disagreement there is little sense in edit warring TJ s changes which made the section longer were completely unsourced How can I verify that the view used to be more popular How can I verify that academics rarely consider it while it is more common among popular writers Similarly I d ask those who want to remove both A small minority and TJ s extra sentences to explain why it s a good idea to remove the POV weight qualifying information talk