I have no idea which version is correct but we should not be edit warring over the issue I suggest that everyone takes a step back reads WP NPOV and notes that we should reflect all valid opinions If there is an inability to gain consensus regarding the reliability of source s then the correct course to take is to refer the specific source s and the specific statements to the Reliable Sources Noticeboard This thing is a Featured Article and any resolution really does have to be done carefully not disruptively