Elimination Order Bret s Call out Order ContestantsEpisodes123456789101112 1AshleyAshleyBrittanyaKelseyAshleyJennyTayaAshleyAshleyMindyTayaMindyTaya 2BeverlyBeverlyTayaNatashaNatashaKamiMindyBeverlyJamieJamieJamieTayaMindy 3BrittaneyBrittanyaNatashaFarrahFarrahJamieKamiBrittanyaMindyTayaMindyJamie 4BrittanyaConstandinaFarrahAshleyKelseyAshleyBeverlyFarrahBrittanyaBeverlyBeverly 5ConstandinaFarrahAshleyTayaTayaMindyJamieJamieBeverlyAshley 6FarrahKelseyKelseyBrittanyaBrittanyaTayaAshleyMindyTayaBrittanya 7GiaMariaBeverlyMariaMindyBeverlyFarrahTayaFarrah 8HeatherMeganMindyMindyBeverlyKelseyKelseyKelsey 9KelseyMelissaMariaMarciaMarciaFarrahBrittanyaKami10MarciaMindyBrittaneyBeverlyMariaBrittanyaJenny11MarcyNatashaMarciaBrittaneyNatasha12MariaSamanthaMelissaMelissa13MeganTayaConstandina14MelissaMarciaMegan15MindyBrittaneySamantha16NatashaGia17NikkiHeather18SamanthaMarcy19StephanieNikki20TayaStephanie21Jamie22Jenny23Gaydino The contestant won the competition The contestant won a solo date with Bret The contestant won a group date with Bret The contestant was eliminated The contestant was going to receive a pass but was eliminated The contestant voluntarily withdrew from the competition The contestant won a date with Bret but was eliminated The contestant won a date with Bret but was eliminated before the elimination ceremony began The contestant was added by Bret in Episode 5