Most of the comments on that AfD were votes not counterpoints Further how can you say that the article doesn t mandate deletion when they clearly never addressed the points of NOR and V My greatest concern about the article is the associations with living biographies In all of that debate they have not verified a single notable alumni member This was the reason I originally nominated the article as they had associated themselves with Justice Rothstein of Canada I can only imagine the kind of revert warring that is going to take place on that article when I continue to remove all of the uncited associations I hope this isn t the beginning of a movement to include every student club in wikipedia As for your remarks about the closing afd despite the fact that I feel I did not have an opportunity to respond to the remarks posted I will let it go as I see your point about perception of points considered