A quesiton about material allowed on userpages here you said The userpage or userspace is not to be used to house a list of misdeeds of another user unless it is going to be used in dispute resolution such as RfC An aside before I ask my question I tried to provide dispute resolution in that incident but my involvement was based upon my assumption that Drolz was concerned about being blocked and wanted to assemble evidence should that occur Turns out my fears were right he was blocked but he wasn t amassing Vir quotes for that reason so I dropped out of the discussion I can understand why WP would want to discourage collections of misdeeds but I can also understand why prohibiting it might equally be a problem I haven t reached my own conclusions on what the policy should be Back to my question after pointing out that I am familiar with WP OSE do you think is compliant with or a violation of the policy statement you made I m not about to waste my time proposing it for MfD but I am interested in whether you can distinguish that page from the page of Drolz which you felt should be deleted T