GA Review This review is transcluded from Talk Goldfish GA1 The edit link for this section can be used to add comments to the review Reviewer I am quick failing this article because large swaths of text are completely uncited plus there s a citation needed tag This is unacceptable for a Good Article nomination and should have been dealt with prior to nomination Other issues ref 6 is a non functional link refs 7 8 have no page number the article states The optimum temperature for goldfish is around 25 C 77 F which is sourced to citation 9 however the source does not say this the citations to web sites are not properly cited and are little more than bare links some of the web sources look very dubious filled with ads and unrelated randomness check 10 for example the prose in some sections is unencyclopedic and needs work