You re being negative and unhelpful I did not the thumbs down on my talk page before you got around to the article itself the draft itself is automatically a Wikipedia Talk page due to the nature of the WP Articles for Creation format But instead you prefer to leap to the conclusion that I did not read your article despite it being clearly on a Talk page for admin reasons like all AFC articles Secondly I did not say that NYT isn t notable so that s a specious allegation You have overall not provided reliable coverage since you ve provided only one single source You allege that So a mass panic in two NYC borough s is not notable enough then Really well that s true per Wikipedia Notability events Duration of coverage Notable events usually receive coverage beyond a relatively short news cycle As very clearly stated in my comments if this 1939 event is important than people since 1939 will at least have occasionally mentioned it It is incumbent on you as the submitter to find evidence that it has ever been discussed since I don t appreciate your allegations that I have failed to WP AGF I have followed AFC procedure treated you politely given explicitly clear indications of what should be fixed and I have not deleted blanked salted your draft but have simply Declined it If you think I m somehow a minority opinion by all means visit WP AFC Help Desk and ask for a different reviewer to take a look I don t appreciate your abusive language like pathetic and it s quite inappropriate of you to take something as incredibly minor as a temporary decline and the vast majority of article drafts get several declines and improvements before being published it s not some binary amazing terrible judgment for eternity And it is quite overblown to feel slighted by a rejection and instantly leap to railing against the gods accusing other people of being pathetic and lambasting the Wikipedia project which you were evidently quite interested in contributing to prior to receiving even the slightest constructive criticism If you are unable to accept positive suggestions and feedback you will most likely not enjoy editing Wikipedia you must be able to tolerate developing consensus and working in a collaborative environment