Third opinion Hey So I ve looked over the conversation here and to be honest I don t have any problem with the URL category It doesn t really strike as spam since they all seem to fit the inclusion criteria The links might be more gracefully included than just the standard numbered link maybe have it say clearwiki com and have the link but it seems okay Similarly WP NOTLINK doesn t apply here since there is a lot more meaningful data attached to the entries in the list As a side note I think it would be most helpful to this article to either create articles for each of the entries on here or at least give some references as to why they re notable I personally don t see the Alexa criterion as making it notable and instead I d just fall on WP WEB as a way of determining notability say whaaat