Hipocrite I doubt that one isolated incident is evidence of a long history of a pattern of incivility If there are other examples in recent history I d be happy to evaluate them But no it doesn t mean that if Pedro slips up 9 months from now he s going to be insta blocked for all eternity And as for being on the recall list Pedro asked me a long time ago if I d have any objections to being on the list and I said no That s about it As far as I am aware being on the list means that I have the option of petitioning Pedro to relinquish his admin privileges nothing more It doesn t mean I m obligated to stalk all of his edits and make sure he s behaving At this point I haven t seen any evidence that would convince me that he is no longer fit to be an admin Were the comments uncivil Of course they were Do they deserve a desysop or a block In my opinion unless there is clear evidence that this was more than just an isolated incident of a personal attack then no Everyone screws up from time to time We don t desysop block people because they had a bad day unless it can be shown that they ve been having a bunch of bad days recently and that it is disrupting people s ability to contribute to the encyclopedia Frankly and I know you will probably all see this as the cabal protecting itself I see this as a witch hunt against an admin that you don t particularly get along with If you have a real issue with Pedro and you have real evidence that this is a long term problem then please present evidence in the form of diffs and I will gladly evaluate it But I m not going to waste my time searching for it myself because my hunch is that this is not going anywhere spout