Well have a look at this photo especially what the grabber is doing with his hands it s very plausible and highly likely that there were scratches I use grabber guardedly since a person who by force of arms takes and carries away is a robber at least here under the common law so a more accurate description would be attempted robber As for your argument about idiocy that s like saying rape victims are at fault by wearing skimpy dresses What s wrong is wrong is wrong and using violence against an innocent civilian to promote a political agenda is wrong and you can not justify it by the tenuously connected actions of another Talk