Gibnews I agree with you that the geographical argument is a weak one in general I understand that you are an activist on the issue of gibraltar and i ill try not to offend you Your reference to Canarias is understandable However Morocco can not validly claim the canaries because there are 2 million canarians who are neither arabs nor muslims and who are spaniards wishing to remain part of the EU and of a democratic state Morocco has no relation whatsoever with the canaries at any level neither culturally nor historically If there was such a relation and morroco was a functioning democracy i would be the first to support a morrocan claim on the islands I understand for example and contrary to most spaniards morocco s claim on western sahara Firstly the saharaouis are very few and their independence would clearly have been the result of european colonialism of the maghreb and algerian expansionism in the region I understand how countries which have been subjected to the humiliation of colonialism feel their borders being decided by foreign powers and i believe that the polisario should take their people out of the horrendous conditions they live in in the camps of Tindouf and move back to their land Do nt forget the history of panama which was a farflung province of Colombia The US paid the local Firebrigade to declare independence so that they could control such a strategic region which they control to this day Have a good day