deletion of redirects per Wikipedia Naming conventions schools The issue has gotten contentious for one redirect in particular for Uni High There s been an Rfd for days nowand I ve said that I d be fine with keeping it but only if there was a particular reason to We are forming guideslines etc and while a look at the ones in place helped form them I ll definitely admit that I could have overlooked stuff But the current discussion has been going round and round and the person who wants the redirect kept is arguing two things it seems One is that keeping the redirect will prevent article duplication And the other is that it will help people find the article In my point of view both of these arguments make no sense as the article in question was moved from name of school plus paramater to name of school plus different parameter There are half a dozen different paramaters that could be used easily so the idea that people are going to naturally gravitate towards the one that did happen to exist and want to create an article there or search that way doesn t make sense If the person really thinks that that s a problem then they should have created other redirects from the other possible namespaces for the article If you could take a look at the discussionI d appreciate it I may be missing something we may want to change the guidelines per different things that have been raised notability of the city was raised which we don t outright address because I didn t think we would need to but we probably should Alsoit occured to me that there s no WP shortcut for the guideline which I assume would belong at WP NC SCH We should create the shortcut no talk 20 46 May 18 2007