I agree and the additions have made this a much more useful and potentially accurate article I m happy with that and again understand the Comyn version makes NO sense they were bitter enemies of the Clan Chattan there is no dispute there Also again show me somewhere that even shows David Dhu was a son of a Comyn because I don t see that anywhere it never happened Somebody just puts someone has a son named David and voila this David formed the Davidson s but another brother formed the Cummings This makes no sense at all If you did reach out to Clan Davidson that was a wise thing to do Who they say they descend from carries much more weight than others who might have an interest in slandering their name It sounds like there might be a jealous Macintosh or Macpherson or someone in recent history who decided to corrupt the origins I couldn t even speculate why unless it has something to do with titles or land Someone made a stupid comment about dna and how we are all mixed anyway excuse me we are talking Male Paternal YDNA which DOES NOT mix It mutates but it passes generation to generation Autosomal dna is a mix and true if you go back thousands of years the YDNA that makes up your total dna from back in the days of the Clans would be a tiny percent of your total genetic makeup However we are strictly talking YDNA here and it would be nice if the current chiefly line would consider testing and perhaps one of his sons will or a cousin we ll have to see To close I m sorry you respect Quintus he is a dip stick and he needs to keep his dirty little hands of the Clans because he isn t making them better he s ruining them He s butchered a few other Clans that I didn t even mention I think one is Clan Grant I think he s calling them Norman too that is a huge insult they are one of the founding Clans from Dalriada Pictland along with the MacGregors tell him to leave the clans alone and go back to Dungeons and Dragons or Final Fantasy Thanks again