I have read the article of Nikki R Keddie and Persianca Enclopendia a little bite Nikki R Keddie write in his article THE BIOGRAPHIES WHICH WHERE WRITED BY THE PEOPLE WHO KNOWED HIM VERY WELL ARE DESTROYED WITH POLITICAL INTENTIONS REASONS So the qeustion is who have done this Afghans British people Persians or someone else Answer Afghanistan Afghanistan would never do things like this Even if they wanted they are simply not able to do things like this and have also no reasons British people well British people want to destroy his image and have also the possibilities and the habit to do jobs like this as a British people knower Read this Persians Persians want to claim Jamaludin Afghan as a Persian personality and are able to do jobs like this Let it be clear his real biographies are destroyed and sometime later comes Persia with letters with Jamaludin Afghan would have writed and after a time comes his biographies of being from a Persian origins Well is it not a little bite strange don t do you think so Except from this the Persian people have allways try to claim Afghan history and the personalities of Afghans as their own To claim Jamaludin Afghan as a Persian they needed to have proves to have proves they needed to destroy the real proves like his Biographies and to prove what they are saying is right they needed to create prove So what is the true behind this letters IN PERSIANCA ENCLOPENDIA they write Government of India and Ma m a sources show that in Afghanistan he called himself the Sayyed R m Anatolian or Estanbol and claimed to be from Istanbul The government of India reporter noted that he was a stranger to Afghanistan and spoke Persian like an Iranian well he have never claimed himself as a Estanboli or if being from Istanbul this is what i call the propaganda of Persians if he is not our we will also don t late make it yours well in letters and article wite where writed about him in Afghanistan when he was in Afghanistan they write only Sayed Jamalludin Afghan nothing else And about he was a stranger to Afghanistan Well if he was a stranger to Afghanistan How could he write a book about the Afghan History I think it says enough And except from this i have found 2 books on internet on his biography Tofaan