I reject your assertion that any PROD which does not result in deletion is automatically inappropriate Let s keep going with your November example Of the eleven PROD s that didn t result in deletion six were BLPPROD s in which in your argument about the necessity of debate is not applicable and one was an honest mistake in which I accidentally PROD ed that I had no intention PROD ing a mistake that I corrected myself That leaves four articles in which you might argue that I misjudged controversy If you take issue to that systematically you ll quickly find that you ll have a problem with entire WP FOOTY You accuse me of not assuming good faith in my first response and I ll admit there is a grain of truth to that but I d ask that you hold yourself to the same standard If my deprod rate seems unusually high try and figure out why that might be rather than basing an accusation of inappropriate behaviour on unfiltered numbers Where did I not assume WP FAITH I simply expressed concern about the non delete rate and asked a polite question without passing any judgement I couldn t figure out why your deprod rate is so high and still don t understand November doesn t seem to be an outlier That s why I asked Some should be AFDs and some seem to be arguably notable I haven t had time to dig into many or look earlier than November though that was most recent month I thought it was fair to look at given that December prods might not yet be deleted Fair enough I haven t thought about BLPPRODs