You don t understand WP G5 Pages created by banned or blocked users in violation of their ban or block and which have no substantial edits by others It doesn t matter that Melborn the editor who created the article hasn t been blocked yet There is clear evidence he is Ryan kirkpatrick A administrator The Bushranger most usually would have CSD the article as a Giant Duck then started the Sockpuppet investigation afterwards to confirm this was another one of Ryan s socks With sockpuppets an administrator doesn t have to confirm before deleting in obvious cases Just look at this one case I m going to note this talk we re having on The Bushranger s talk page so he can explain G5 better to you You could put the G5 tag back on it if you want and let an administrator decide the matter That s up to you Cheers