In response But Boattini 2013 did and he equally found R1b1c to be only M18 2 4 82 smaples The images you have are not representing the specified subclades tested or they were not tested as also by R1b1a2 M269 Some bloggers and forum users Mr Rocca have more details from the Fraccalacci et al 2014 study and deceiphered for example R1b U152 frequency Try to find these specific tables