About the closing of this move request As noted in the template above the closing guidelines are set out at Wikipedia Requested moves Closing instructions In a discussion with on my talk page today I misinformed him her that a no consensus result here necessarily results in the title staying the same The Determining consensus section of those guidelines actually says among other important things However sometimes a requested move is filed in response to a recent move from a long existing name that can not be undone without administrative help Therefore if the closer feels that no consensus has been reached they may move the article back to the most recent stable name If the most recent stable name is itself a matter of dispute closers are expected to use their own judgment in determining the proper destination Since this article was named History of pottery in the Southern Levant from 22 June 2006 until it was first changed to the current title on 21 October 2011 that provision would seem to clearly apply I would also note in passing that in light of the serious issues and controversy concerning this issue the Non admin closure section of those guidelines would appear to not allow a non admin closure to this discussion I continue to express no opinion as to what the best or proper closure of this listing would be Regards TALK