The residency of BMO s CFO is not analogous with the Gardner situation There were a number of criticisms over the years of the fact that a Toronto City Councillor and then chair of the Toronto Police Services Board didn t live in the city whose bylaws he was voting on and police force he was governing No criticisms of the BMO s CFO s residency that I am aware of and of course the Bank of Montreal has not actually been based in Montreal for decades and has not limited its operations to Montreal for centuries whilst the Toronto Police and Toronto City council are not only based in Toronto but are confined to the city s limits What would be analogous would be say a federal politician who didn t live in Canada or an Ontario cabinet minister who doesn t live in the province