Again you re taking stuff out of context Marx was certainly opposed to the Jewish religion because he was opposed to all religion But beyond this I think this is a ridiculous argument As to Finkelstein and Chomsky I think it s arguable that they are anti semites but again one should have pretty solid backing to make such a claim I m fairly certain we havan t reached that level with Marx BTW my Irish sounding name does hide the fact that I m Jewish 02 53 30 Mar 2004 UTC