Dispute s Note to NSBR TSSR SSBA AND ISSDC contributors Please advise if you concur or disagree with my summaries below From everything I have read it would appear as evidenced throughout this talk page AND the article edit page contributors representing the NSBR TSSR SSBA and ISSDC registries clubs have agreed compromised concurred regarding the following 1 They have agreed compromised to the inclusion of ALL currently established registries clubs affiliated with the Shiloh Shepherd dog including the ISSR SSDCA as an acknowledged Shiloh Shepherd registry club in the article 2 They have agreed compromised that the article contain an acknowledgement that Ms Barber initiated this breed and originated the standard for the breed 3 They concur that the article content must contain verifiable documentation not based on original research and stated only from a neutral point of view in agreement with Wikipedia s stated requirements for content criteria 4 They have agreed compromised in order to resolve this dispute and prevent potential for unverifiable dependent biased inclusions comparisons contrasts by any registry club including their own to refrain from including any registry club specific information and promotion in the article other than to cite the existence and names of each and to simply include ALL registry s club s homepage website links at the bottom of the article which will allow Wikipedia readers the opportunity to gain access should they choose to each of the various registries clubs individual purported documentation research and points of view 5 They concur that the article should NOT contain original publication of original thought propaganda advocacy self promotion and advertising in agreement with Wikipedia s stated requirements for Wikipedia What Wikipedia is Not 6 They have agreed compromised in order to resolve this dispute and prevent inclusion of these disallowed contents by any registry club including their own to refrain from including any registry club specific information and promotion in the article other than to cite the existence and names of each and to simply include ALL registry s club s homepage website links at the bottom of the article which will allow Wikipedia readers the opportunity to gain access should they choose to each of the various registries clubs individual thoughts propaganda advocacy self promotion and advertising 7 In order to resolve this dispute and prevent bias regarding the article s descriptive contents concerning Health they have agreed compromised to refrain from including any statements citing reviewing or comparing contrasting ISSR NSBR TSSR SSBA SSDCA or ISSDC health practices policies and they propose the Health section of the article contain only a statement listing those health issues acknowledged by ALL registries clubs gastrointestinal problems gastric torsion bloat bacterial overgrowth syndrome and skeletal or bone disorders such as hip dysplasia panosteitis and osteochondritis a recommendation by ALL registries clubs that testing be conducted and a statement that these reports clearly show that as giant breeds go the Shiloh is arguably a healthy example 8 They have agreed compromised that regarding Size Coat Color and Temperament there appears to be very limited dispute re the standards contained therein and that the section should remain free of any statements citing reviewing promoting any individual registry club and comparing contrasting one registry club with another These compromises and requested article inclusions exclusions meet Wikipedia s policies procedures for content criteria in that they embrace the following 1 Neutral WP NPOV in that the article would be representing all views fairly and without bias In FACT there are no requests from the NSBR TSSR SSBA and ISSDC registries clubs for the inclusion of any comparisons contrasts negative or otherwise between any of the registries clubs including the ISSR SSDCA nor have they requested that any clubs other than their own be exluded from inclusion in the article In FACT there has only been the request that ALL registries clubs affiliated with the Shiloh Shepherd dog be simply noted with appropriate website links included at the bottom of the art