Super Mario RPG lists You asked why List of locations in Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars was redirected to Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars in Talk Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars I have restored the list of locations and we are discussing it on its talk page Could you please take a look If you have time please also look at List of characters in Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars and Smithy Gang Thanks Currently Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars has two lists pertaining to it List of characters in Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars and List of locations in Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars User TTN decided it would be best to merge the lists into the main article and split Smithy Gang into those articles I recently merged Smithy Gang into the list of chatacters by removing the non notable characters and I have asserted that a cameo section in the list of characters is valid per Wikipedia Trivia sections and Wikipedia Handling trivia that uses Alex Trebek Cameos as a good example I have suggested that we rename the articles per Wikipedia Requested moves Requesting potentially controversial moves to something along the lines of Characters of Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars and World of Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars or Mushroom Kingdom Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars just like Characters of Final Fantasy VIII and World of Final Fantasy VI or Gaia Final Fantasy VII I believe if these articles are to evolve beyond a non notable list they should be renamed For example List of Final Fantasy VII locations was merged into Gaia Final Fantasy VII because a World article is notable but a simple list of locations is not That is why there are other secions of the article to make it a World article It simply has not been renamed yet TTN believes the citations in the development and reception sections of the list of locations books and magazines are trivial sources When I added that the 3D perspective of the game is reminicent of Equinox to the main article TTN removed it since my souce was the opinions of the Nintendo Power player s guide writers Although it was actually Nintendo Power magazine I do believe a magazine is a reliable source and I gave a page from Next Generation Magazine which also said the same thing In addition I was surprized that TTN said that it was from the players guide since he claims to own the players guide for the game He has not verified this since I asked him for citations in May Could you look in the back of the Player s Guide and tell me what types of Magic I forgot what they call it in the game well anyways what types of Special Attack or whatever it is actually could you find out what it s called there are I remember some vaguely when I owned the guide like Fire Jump Electricity etc Could you provide a citation like the page number with a quote in context TTN replied that he was going to get to it User talk TTN Archive 5 List of locations in Super Mario RPG Legend of the Seven Stars TTN claims the player s guide is at the bottom of a box that s behind at least five others in a cramped space Seeing that TTN did not recognize that the page was not from the player s guide when I provided a scan of the page in question from Nintendo Power shocked me However I have continued to assume good faith by not questioning TTN s honesty Per Wikipedia Consensus Consensus can change I have offered five different reasonable temporary compromises that might integrate my idea with TTN s Go over the list of characters so we can delete non notable characters Rename the articles by following the steps at Wikipedia Requested moves Requesting potentially controversial moves Cut down the geography section list of locations by cutting it into the regional maps the adventures use when traveling from one to another I can get pictures and write the fair use rationals and someone can cut down the text that has no citation and does not allude to other media Write the concept and creation and reception sections for the list of characters Write the concept and creation section for the main article TTN rejected my compromise because it still keeps the articles I agreed I would consider a redirect but Wikipedia Article size does not allow tha