Disputing Job Guarantee Section Chartalists don t guarantee a job They merely argue that the role of government in cases of underutilization is to provide the necessary demand to resolve that situation since otherwise you have unused capacity and net economic loss It s quite a jump to take that and conclude the government hires everyone who isn t employed in fact it often means the government becomes the customer of a lot of businesses If you are in a state of underutilization that represents an economic loss and it s due to a demand problem it means you must have some net fiscal expansion from some source in order to drive utilization If the private sector is attempting to build assets run a surplus and you have an external deficit the only mathematical means of accomplishing this is public deficit that is the government is either hiring people or buying from the private sector So the section I ve marked for expert review needs to recognize that Chartalists prescribe that government deals with unemployment not by guaranteeing a job but by hiring more and or spending i e buying more from the private sector Things could easily and likely would weigh more towards the second option posting on behalf of one Filburt