Well he s been a rather contributory editor Sure his religious convictions seemed to get the best of him but I honesty had the impression that his heart was in the right spot You ve got to realize that there are editors who go around smearing Islam everyday on Wikipedia I see this myself For someone who holds Islam as his deen that must be very challenging to have to contend with particularly as there is not a whole lot of Muslim editors on Wikipedia Grenavitar described this smear group as an anti Muslim brigade and I ll tell you what he was 100 right on When I sense such an ant Muslimness in an editor I try to distance myself from them I haven t gotten that impression from you but I can see how a Muslim person might