I suppose that User Scott Wilson has standing to raise this issue I am an American and write judicial biography articles but I wouldn t say that Judge Wilson is astonishingly noteworthy On the other hand I m not in a position to say much about the Scottish footballer There will probably be relatively few users in a position with knowledge of both to do the weighing As for the engineering company if this does become a disambiguation page I have no objection to mentioning it but I don t think it should be a factor in this decision unless and until the company has an article of its own Regards