Articles for creation Miriam Battista Hi Arctic Kangaroo I m totally puzzled by the reasons you gave for rejecting this article Wikipedia talk Articles for creation Miriam Battista Miriam Battista is definitely worthy of notice that is significant interesting or unusual enough to deserve attention or to be recorded It s true that her moment of national fame was short but it was intense and she continued to be noticed in the press as an adult actress Also the fact that she received a news obit not paid for by the family in the New York Times should in itself attest to her notability since the obit was published so many years after her heyday For comparison please look at the article for Gladys Hulette I certainly think that Battista rises to at least the same level of notability As far as verifiable references are concerned I truly thought I had over referenced if anything There are references to Charles Donald Fox s book Famous Film Folk Photoplay Variety The New Yorker the New York Times the Internet Broadway Database and Internet Movie Database are these not considered reliable verifiable sources If the problem is that I used too many references to privately held materials I apologize for that but I thought that the information they included was interesting and enlightening I guess that raises a basic question for me would Wikipedia prefer that information from privately held materials be omitted even if it sheds light on the subject If the answer is Yes I m afraid that Wikipedia is missing out on a gold mine of material I had been considering trying to get in touch with Wikipedia editors who are working on WikiProject Biography as well as those involved in WikiProject Film before submitting this article for review but as a newbie I wasn t sure how to do that Now that the article has been rejected I would very much like to get feedback directly from anyone involved in those two projects as well as more feedback from you Perhaps you can show me how to connect with those projects Thanks in advance for any further light you can shed on your decision and for any help you can give me