This particular issue of Homeopathy is written by a number of scientists from different backgrounds including a sceptic and several who are not connected with the homeopathic community It gives a good overview of current thoughts concerning the memory of water phenomena Leaving it out would certainly be ill advised if WP wishes to present an encyclopedia One must also consider the difficulties involved in publishing in this area in other journals the fact that it is a peer reviewed journal and the particular articles it contains It is certainly not a fringe publication for this area of science