Thank you BoogaLouie for writing a draft I am not sure where to look at this draft Is what is at the top of this thread been re drafted or does the new draft appear somewhere else Any draft should include all of Edward Said s responses to Commentary He is not around to defend himself but did leave a detailed legacy in response to Commentary s three attacks on him Fair play requires that Said s list of errors in the Commentary article are quite specific Commentary s attacks on him are quite specific The Israeli writer and the magazine that published these errors are responsible for the errors The writer researcher was both defiant and boastful about not checking in with Said to verify facts about Said s biography Where is the full text of the Commentary article Thanks