Failed 25JUL12 I added the FailedGA template on 25 July 2012 Nominator The Devil s Advocate 1 did not address issues regarding compliance with GA criteria and MOS guidelines pointed out by reviewer 2 did not seek second opinion that he requested despite my mentioning that reviewer was not averse to such an action I recommend to the nominator to resolve the outstanding issues indicated above to copyedit and revise the article tighten its prose abide by MOS guidelines and then to renominate the article I will be glad to revise my assessment and support a nomination when and only when issues are addressed to the satisfaction of GA criteria and MOS compliance