I tried to do it in private that s how I saw the talk pages and still in part do And it wasn t even totally out in the open until she drew attention to it If she d brought it up with me I would have been more than glad to talk to her as I intended And OwenX while you didn t directly mention personal attacks you said this it was not an isolated case of incivility you have in fact been warned prior to that by which I thought you meant personal attacks Since you just stated it wasn t a reference to personal attacks though I will be glad to talk about what ever edit was a case of incivility for which I haven t shown remorse