Unapologetic reviews Not a preference or POV issue I personally like this album just that the template s existence in general has been questioned by other reputed editors of album articles at Template talk Album ratings along with the favorable unfavorable entries so a comprimise would be keeping the ratings template with actual technical ratings scores Also Billboard is a trade magazine for the music industry and they usually rate albums higher than other professional critics Metacritic s profile of them As for the entry in the ratings template I usually use the ratio percentage of favorable unfavorable mixed reviews from either Metacritic or AnyDecentMusic and use that to model the template In short undue weight to a positive review and that it s not a score to begin with is why I removed it As of now there are five positive scores in the template while Metacritic shows 6 out of 15 being positive or 40 and 4 out of 10 so the ratings template right now is pretty generous believe it or not Sorry if this was a bit long