I had seen this in a longer version presumably before semi blanking While I think disrupting the discussion or changing the proposal in non constructive ways is childish I also did not see much that I thought was worthwhile in the earlier framework either It looked like even more layers of formalism on top of all the WP policies procedures and rules that already exist For example while it sounds nice for editors not to be subject to ex post facto rules there are already many contradictions in the existing rules and I doubt anyone has read them all anyway More common sense and less proceduralism is better IMO