I broadly agree although when you say Allmusic is widely considered to be a perfectly reliable and notable critical commentary resource on Wikipedia And that s that I would counter that any wikipedia policy and practice will have been arrived at by a process of consensus and reaching a group opinion on the basis of considering various facts and ideas not just And that s that So I should go and do some reading on the various policy pages and find out how the current position was arrived at As it seems a bit dubious to me For example are Allmusic staff on salaries If not then why are they writers rather than bloggers