Inappropriate tone Once again has left a note on my talk page about leaving the project in disgust this time because one or two editors have been putting Template Inappropriate tone at the top of his work on Scotland in the Late Middle Ages John MacDonald II Lord of the Isles and Union of the Crowns The template frankly seems to be an unspecific demand that articles should be boring with the implication that interesting writers should go away It refers to Wikipedia Guide to writing better articles but the only hint that gives about tone is in a reference to News style which doesn t seem to demand such a thing I feel that the template should ideally be deleted or at the least modified so that it appears on the talk page rather than the article page and requires the editor adding it to say what the specific complaint is and preferably try editing to improve the article rather than just adding a useless template to categorise it as Category Wikipedia articles needing style editing Which itself seems to be an exercise in listing work needed rather than getting on with it Your comments and assistance would be appreciated