closing of Wikipedia Articles for deletion Robey Reed Can you please explain to me why you closed this AfD as no consensus when they only keep vote was the article s creator and four named editors voted to delete it I understand ignoring the IPs but 4 1 with no one except the article s creator voting to keep the article seems like a consensus to me Using that reasoning there are a number of martial arts articles being discussed at AfD created by the same editor that would be kept simply because he keeps making the same points repeatedly even though no one else agrees with him