GFA Good faith analysis I think Minor4th attacked because that s pretty much the standard operating procedure Since Wikipedia culture stupidly frowns on people letting off steam by yelling You asshole I loved that page and you ruined it You re an idiot and I want to kill you we instead invent silly ways to make up circumlocutions of personal attacks and read into every comment made Malicious is a provocative adjective indeed but it s emotive illustrating how Minor4th felt about the redirect Welcome to Wikipedia By the way Lar I m not sure what the point is in telling people that their input lacks a certain amount of helpfulness You seem to do that a lot and it strikes me as a bit POTty Have you had much luck with that technique in the past Because if not it can look to the party you re criticizing like you re lording it over them like some sort of parental figure Just FYI