seeing all this I ve lately been checking NPP more often myself and like you concentrating on those NPPatrollers who seem to need some suggestions At this point I d support a userright Long ago I made a suggestion about having editors sign up for particular time slots Not that they could follow 2 3 a minute but that they d take responsibility for a particular time day say an hour Do you think we could get 168 experienced people Hooking to some of the above do you think we could make at least an informal requirement for admin candidates to take such a slot for a month or so I m also trying to write up what I use in my head a a NPP red flag checklist As you may recall I did not support AC and for the first time yet I actually support the WMF when they overrode us but that does not mean I m not concerned about thisfor several years I ve been concentrating on what gets deleted shouldn t be but the number in the other direction seems considerably larger My main concern is retention of new editors and both directions are equally important for that