Arindam Chaudhuri Hi This is regarding the lawsuit related content that you removed from this article I also had a look at your Talk Arindam Chaudhuri Edits and sources on the talk page I understand your point about not relying on primary sources for BLP articles However I have a couple of comments The passage that I added includes at least one source the New Yorker article that is definitely not a primary source I feel that this source alone justifies a mention of this case in the article Per WP BLPPRIMARY Where primary source material has been discussed by a reliable secondary source it may be acceptable to rely on it to augment the secondary source subject to the restrictions of this policy no original research and the other sourcing policies Also per WP PSTS we can use a primary source as long as we do not base articles and material entirely on it and as long as we re using it only to make straightforward descriptive statements Thus in conjugation with the secondary source mentioned above I feel the use of primary sources is justified Siddhartha Deb s book has actually been published now although maybe not in India Fortunately I have access to an academic library and should soon be able to borrow a copy myself At this point I m a bit confused on the status of biographical books whether they should be considered as primary or secondary sources I d like to hear your view on this I feel that this passage is an important component of the article and I do not see why it can not stay as long as it is properly sourced Cheers