talk page visitor Can t resist butting in here if only to agree with what you re both saying about FAC By the way MOS HOWEVERPUNC may be too prescriptive in insisting on a semicolon Here is Theodore M Bernstein in The Careful Writer Incidentally if your elementary school teacher told you never to begin a sentence with however forget it The governing consideration should always be simply this Which ideas are to be contrasted May Mrs Phillips of P S 10 rest in peace All his examples use periods I ll spare you my rant about Wikipedia dialects