Peyton Sawyer She was brought on to the series as Peyton Sawyer not as Peyton Sawyer Scott Nor has she been known as Peyton Sawyer for as long or even close to as long as Haley James has been known as Haley James Scott That is why she Peyton should be listed as Peyton Sawyer Look at WP Common names for an example of how Wikipedia views names a character has been known by for the longest The one exception where it is not that off to list her as Peyton Sawyer Scott would be in the Lucas Scott character box where she is listed as his wife