So when is an AfD secret I m confused you claim that everything is done in secret yet the issues with your article are being dealt with in an open transparent consensus building manner You use an AfD process as the sole basis for calling someone both rude and unfair which in itself just smacks of lacking good faith Seriously Don t be a dick Pick what you want here you want an AfD one minute from Orderinchaos and the next minute you re complaining when someone does You can t have it both ways I don t have to ask to open an AfD nor should I have to The AfD is an open discussion which allows for the building of community consensus and the decision on what happens is up to the community If you have a valid and supportable argument on why the article should be kept take it up there And again Don t be a dick