Clearly not carefully enough as 5 was not well sourced As well it did not have the widest support and furthermore could not be used as it violated wiki policy specifically WP LEAD and WP N I wasn t the only person to point that out as not only the mediator pointed that out but others as well including Agha Nader and myself it is worth noting that Agha Nader usually disagree rather vehemently on a wide range of topics That we found agreement on this is significant and should be telling you something Rather than expend your energies on a choice we can not use perhaps you could concentrate your efforts on finding a wiki allowable solution that everyone could live with If you are entirely unwilling to pursue such a course of action I suggest that you re submit the matter for mediation I suggested ArbCom as it is sometimes an effective court of last recourse They can certainly address an unwillingness to follow wiki policy in regards to policy on the part of editors