Esther Delisle Could you have a look at Esther Delisle I should warn you that you may pop a vessel I near did and I like Dr Delisle Anyway it seems to me like a highly propagandistic depiction of the controversy over her first book I don t think she would endorse it for a start I removed some POV but my knowledge of the dispute is limited In particular I ve never been able to find any follow up about the serious methodological criticisms that were made of her work apart from her own