When browsing WP REFUND I noticed the case of the guy whose user talk got deleted and now he can t get it restored since he can t prove his identity Per your looking into his request on October 12 Though this is perhaps not an earthshaking issue I do notice that WP CSD U1 says specifically that user talk pages may not be deleted under that criterion Do you think you could justify bring back on simple procedural grounds since the U1 was not correct It needs an MfD according to what is currently written down in the policy A glance at the deleted talk page shows nothing that would cause concern