Contested deletion The following was copied from the deleted page Talk Misha Bryan Please use the proper venue for these discussions you are welcome to re open another review at WP DRV if you feel the prior decision missed some key points This page should not be speedily deleted because your reason here newzealander I do not understand why this article should be deleted The argument being used right now is that Misha Bryan is not successful enough in her own right outside of the X Factor But if you look at the Wikipedia Notability guidelines I would argue that she does sufficiently meet the guidelines for notability and should be granted her own page She has reliable third party sources on her albeit there is some cleanup to be done on the bare URL s She has significant coverage Preceding unsigned comment added by When the article was last deleted there was also a Deletion Review closed yesterday which endorsed the decision Thanks for this link But if I go to Wikipedia Notability music Criteria for musicians and ensembles the first reason for notability is Has been the subject of multiple non trivial published works appearing in sources that are reliable and are independent from the musician or ensemble itself Although I don t have the deleted page now to reference if I go to List of The X Factor finalists UK series 8 there are multiple references that are reliable sources Newspapers in London like the Metro and Daily Mail the website digitalspy com yahoo com musiceyz co uk a credible review of her mixtape which would mean she is noteworthy outside of X Factor Now on that same page there are a bunch of references to Misha B s twitter announcements which would be uncredible And if there were personal trivia items that would not be considered encyclopedic on the deleted page and other things to be cleaned up and deleted off the page then that s a whole other matter But if I go simply off of Wikipedia s own guidelines for musician notability there appears to be enough there to warrant her own page Also if you compare Misha Bryan to many of the finalists on this last season of American Idol then she qualifies just as much as they do for her own page Example Heejun Han 29 June 2012 UTC