Incivility aside the point that they were basically attacking Wikipedia on is a well documented and admitted point that the nature of the beast introduces the possibility of inaccuracies And the example they gave was a ignorance on their behalf All we needed to do was point out that incivility is inappropriate that their criticism is well known and not disputed and that their example was false Their entire post would be moot from that point on Any carrying on after that would then be pure trolling and dealt with appropriately But getting into a blanking war just supports their preconception that this is that conservative fork where detractors are suppressed