an entirely rational ass placed exactly in the middle between two stacks of hay of equal size and quality will starve since it can not make any rational decision How is it that the rational ass can not just make a random choice for the sake of breaking the deadlock There is nothing subjective about making a random choice the implication is that the ass needs a preference in order to choose That is a fallacy What do you expect from a guy who claimed that all matter was made up of just 5 elements