Thanks for your polite reply on my discussion page outlining the fact that since Irving has been convicted of holocaust denial this is how he should be described by Wikipedia Unfortunately this logic is inconsistent with other entries in Wikipedia Consider the case of Mike Tyson Using your logic he would be introduced as an American rapist and not as a boxer due to his conviction for rape Nelson Mandela would be introduced unacceptably as a terrorist There are many other examples as you will be aware I ask you simply to apply the same logic in this article as in other Wiki articles and list the individual according to his primary activity and not according to the name of a conviction Sorry for clinging to this issue but I use Wiki extensively and want to be sure that the admins hold to a neutral and consistent viewpoint