Some new issues and information I went on a bit of an editing spree and while the list is in somewhat better shape there are some lingering issues I wasn t able to update the post member counts on all of the forums as some did not clearly display it and at least one forum was inaccessible members only access Some of the forums that do not display a post count will still provide post counts for each subforum I wrote some JavaScript to parse this for College Confidential and Wrong Planet but I didn t have the time to modify it to work with any of the others those two had formatted the post counts in a way that made regex matching much easier Anyone wishing to update the post counts on those two in the future can just reuse the JavaScript I left it inside a comment above both entries I also manually resorted the list from highest to lowest BPDFamily com had a massive drop in post count from 12 550 839 to 2 946 601 I m not sure why this happened but the most likely possibility is that someone accidentally added a one at the front of the previous number and nobody ever caught the error I added several major sites from the Curse network While the ones I added do not have individual Wikipedia articles they are all mentioned on the Curse Inc Wiki page I linked to They should easily qualify for inclusion based on the number of posts users but may not perfectly meet the inclusion criteria I excluded the Bukkit 2 3 m 408k and GW2 Guru 2 1 m 74k forums because they were much lower volume forums and weren t really as significant but was that actually justified There are some forums that might qualify but weren t added Nexopia certainly qualifies but I can t easily get a post count and it s targeted at Canada instead of the US despite being English HackForums is massive 46 m posts 2 7 m members but it s shady and there is no Wikipedia article it got deleted in 2010 due to a lack of notability so I m not adding it although I believe that the situation has changed significantly since 2010 and it would now be considered notable enough to justify a Wiki article and inclusion in this list It s not clear why d2jsp conceptart org Honda Tech etc are not considered worthy of inclusion based solely on requiring the article but I m not going to challenge that directly Anyways here s the summary 1 How should we handle updating the post counts on forums that no longer clearly display the current counts While scripts may work for some forums it is a bit impractical for others 2 Does anyone have an alternate explanation for the BPDFamily com drop It s probably not important and just from an error when inputting the first value but I want to make sure I didn t miss something major with a such a large ten million drop in the number of posts 3 Does anyone have any thoughts on the eligibility of the major Curse network sites that I added Or on if my disqualification of the Bukkit and GW2 Guru forums was justified despite the sites technically meeting the criteria for inclusion 4 Can someone else take a look at adding Nexopia and perhaps HackForums 5 A very large number of these forums only have an article to link to because of sponsorship by a notable parent organization While the parent organization may be perfectly notable that does not always mean that the forum they run is actually really that notable How many of these forums would actually justify their own Wikipedia page I m concerned that this makes notability a very poorly defined concept and this list mostly worthless Many of the clearly notable forums meaning standalone forums with their own Wikipedia page have relatively sparse Wikipedia pages in the first place There isn t much to write about with most forums even extremely active ones I m being nitpicky but I feel that the whole criteria for this list is a bit questionable and that significance notability would be better established by activity using metrics such as post member thresholds Anyways