I have from the outset I think I was the first to note it suggested 98 is open to WP OR challenges You don t need to convince me on this that there is a legitimate problem there I personally think this is all provisory work I know of scholarly analyses now underway which will be peer reviewed precisely on these questions and available in some months I prefer what scholars tell me months afterwards than what newspapers say in the heat of events In the meantime we have our problem But I think your objection to Thrylos s graph somewhat forced Very many sources agree that June to November 4 marked an almost total shut down of rocketing from Gaza To insist on the whole lull period has an advantage for the rockets at the end once added make blur one s recognition of the demonstrated fact that even if it is OR between June and Nov 4 rocket attacks underwent a 95 reduction Perhaps I am not a good wiki editor But for an historian who would do what Thrylos did this point warrants mention and clarity