Why is it a PA I would like you to explain to me how this is a personal attack It was left on s talk page not on s talk page and does not say Felonious Monk is a bastard or something The Australian Democrats have a saying Keep the bastards honest They are refering to the 2 main parties in Austalia the Labor and Liberal parties No one finds this offensive so if Felonious Monk finds what Sam said offensive then he is being overly sensitive Sam has told me that he was just trying to give Ungtss encouragement and was not trying to slander anyone I m not claiming Sam is a paragon of good but if he hasn t actually made a personal attack then don t try to claim he has And don t answer to this by dredging up every comment Sam has ever made I am asking about this particular comment and why it is thought to be a PA