If asking someone honestly if they were trolling is a personal attack which it isn t then accusing someone of making a personal attack when they didn t should be one too So WP NPA right back at ya and let me add an equally valid charge of libel Anyway I don t see how labeling Moore as leftist liberal etc reduces his contributions and I use the term loosely Being labeled a liberal leftist should only be a slur to people who think liberals are idiots smirking grin Regardless I would be delighted to hear a consensus on the matter as well