List of manga artists I see no reason why List of manga artists should be deleted as numerous similar lists exist and seem to be maintained for example List of American comics creators or List of science fiction authors There are many articles tagged as being in the scope of Wikipedia WikiProject Index that are equally broad or broader While I don t know if those articles generally have support on Wikipedia or not if you think articles of that sort do not belong on Wikipedia then it would probably be best to start a discussion on that sort of article in general For the List of manga artists article I do however think it should be limited to manga creators with Wikipedia articles which seems to be what is done for other similar lists