Gentlemen the problem with all this is that none of it answers the question I asked which I repeat here for clarity Is there any one discussion closed by an impartial admin where consensus was that any such D D creature should be automatically and permanently redirected rather than being independently discussed All that s been given is a bunch of examples which per WP OTHERSTUFF are not normative Likewise lumping a bunch of dissimilar creatures together at one AfD and getting one result is not normative for other non nominated creatures