I agree that the example is controversial and unsuitable That said it s about an ordinary person e g a Christian fundie such as do exist in the world this has nothing to do with what you deign to consider a serious theologian And by the way of course a serious theologian won t recognize that there is an obvious and ridiculously simple problem that discredits the scriptures after all if a person is inclined to recognize such a thing he would have realized that serious theologian is an oxymoron and then he wouldn t have become a theologian in the first place A scholar of religion perhaps but not a scholar of God which is what a theologian is supposed to be