Doc this is just the religion thing rearing it s ugly head Clearly you do not believe Laura to be a true jew and have made some comments about Judaism this is a touchy area as I know too well my ex girlfriends family were Jewish with Orthodox Jew cousins family reunions were tense and I can immediately see why your original indelicate comments stating your personal opinion might have caused upset to some such as this new editor Their response was clearly wrong but it did not strike me as the typical trolling rant you see from socks or POV editors They were just upset by what you said and responded with a little too much emotion Scot had the right approach just shouldn t have killed the talk page comment outright IMO I meant no offence in restoring the comment and doing saying what I did my thinking was that supporting the new editor was the right thing to do because you and scot as established editors will understand the light flak whereas they might see it as yet another person against them I believe in the benefit of the doubt till the absolute end a failing perhaps I hope I caused no offence BTW I believe new accounts are confirmed after a number of edits