I suggest you take the time and look up each of the books on the list before you lay judgement upon them If you believe any one of them is innapropriate go ahead and point it out I have personally read many of the books on the list and I doubt that you will find a more thorough list of secondary literature on the subject of this size anywhere else A should add that I used the WorldCat search engine which as you might know searches the library catalogs of many of the worlds libraries Again the criteria for inclusion to the collection of essays section were 1 recently published after 2000 2 collections of essays 3 books that are available in over 50 libraries around the world As for the prominent law scholars section I personally searched out all the books written by law scholars from the most eminent universities in the english speaking world yale harvard nyu uc berkeley stanford u chicago columbia oxford cambridge and then chose those books having to do with liberalism The same goes for the philosophy section The PHD dissertations and the articles were not as deliberately chosen as the above mentioned lists I am disposed to having them removed if only for the sake of conciseness