UTC I m reverting back You can not claim that western sources are weak and liars Zora provided several sources supporting what is written So did I The best you can do is add any opposing sources to the text Not delete anything Your post obviously demonstartes you are Sunni and a supporter of Umar But you are not the only person who knows Arabic here There is specific mention of Arab cruelty against mawali in Al Allamah Baqir al Majlisi Bihar al anwar vol 9 chap 124 Shaykh Abbas al Qummi Safinat al Bihar under wall c f al Kay al Khutat by al Maqrizi e g See that not a single person in Iran speaks Arabic and whosoever is found speaking Arabic kill him Ibn an Naqqash Fatwa concerning the condition of the dhimmis vol 18 pp 513 514 trans Belin Journal Asiatique Vol 18 1851 and Vol 19 1852 in B Ye or The Dhimmi Jews and Christians Under Islam pp 184 185 Abd al Rahman al Bazzaz Islam and Arab Nationalism Arab Nationalism An Anthology ed S G Haim pp 176 177 23 10 13 July 2005