Well said Bonusballs There s a clear distinction between this article and the deleted ones which has been noted since the opening of the last discussion Wikipedia policy is negotiable because Wikipedia does not have firm rules it s how the single provider lists went from being acceptable to being deleted following consensus reached during discussions However we haven t reached a consensus that NOTDIR applies in this instance for nearly a month One of the points from the AfDs was that the provider could in theory remove any of the channels it wished to after contracts expire etc something which isn t uncommon in America but rare in the UK because of regulation therefore the provider would control the content of the article That isn t the case in a list of all channels as the channel could continue elsewhere within the market Frequency of edits updates isn t mentioned in NOTDIR and is rubbished as reason to delete under WP UPTODATE Movement between numbers is not particularly common there s nothing in the Future events section for example again because of regulation so update frequency isn t really increased and that argument has already been debunked Ignoring that some all of the reintroduced providers can be received and viewed without a TV subscription the DTT in the UK list contains subscription and pay per view channels so the argument that information which could potentially be useful primarily to subscribers isn t encyclopaedic doesn t work either along with the existence of thousands of articles on products services and businesses There seems to be no questions raised over whether the availability of a channel should be listed within the channel s own article either usually in the infobox or attempts to remove them which is inconsistent with the idea that there is a broad consensus to remove such content from Wikipedia While usefulness wasn t mentioned once here Since Wikipedical has left DTT availability in my opinion NOTDIR becomes irrelevant anyway as we re discussing additions of the same type of content which is available elsewhere within Wikipedia within the list rather than the list itself which would lean more to WP NOTE specifically WP NNC and WP LISTCOMPANY