Peer Review Responding to the request for peer review I ve read this article In my opinion as a working physicist the introduction fails badly in not spelling out the reason why the hypothesis that fusion reactions explain the reported measurements of excess heat generations remains unaccepted as an explanation by most physicists According to our theoretical understanding of fusion release of excess heat should be accompanied by release of well determined quantities of energetic particles including fast neutrons and gamma rays None of the experiments reported to release excess heat have also released energetic particles in the quantities predicted In the absence of a convincing theoretical argument why the purported fusion reactions should not behave like all others that we have measured the clear conclusion is that something else most likely measurement error or poor experimental design yields the reported results As I see from the talk page that this article has been heavily discussed I ll ask for comments on a proposal to write the above content into the introduction before going ahead and doing so