and one from me Greetings from Wales you are correct Early life rem ungrammatical comma the adjective cramped is attributed to the noun phrase living conditions hence living is not an adjective but an attributive noun Yes you are correct I shall blame my error on having just returned from a two weeks holiday and the lateness of the hour My father who was a commissioned officer in the British Army was in Norway for the latter part of World War II and always spoke fondly of your country With kind regards Thanks for the heads up Cyfarchion Diolch yn fawr Eisfbnore