Dude read the last line I have even bolded it three times The list s should contain all characters races places etc from the work of fiction with links to those that have their own articles Capisce now It seems to me that you have totally ignored previous consesus and guidelines set before you decided to place all the characters in the same page You have also ignored other examples native to Wikipedia and other examples from outside sources The fact is that your only argument against this format is fear of fancruft and fear my friend is not a valid argument