This is not going to a be a fruitful line of reasoning No one is arguing that it doesn t make any sense or that it is ungrammatical English to use the word intact to describe an uncircumcised penis What is being argued is that the term intact has a negative connotation when used in contrast with the term circumcised and the connotation is inherently biased and POV therefore the term must be avoided to maintain neutrality It s a loaded word