Closing of Wikipedia Articles for deletion Ramona Trinidad Iglesias Jordan Hi RoySmith I was wondering if you could elaborate on your rationale a little for your closing of this AfD as keep given the large number of SPAs 6 of the 10 keep votes including one user that has been subsequently blocked as the sockpuppet of a topic banned editor and the contentious history of meatpuppetry and off wiki canvassing for longevity related articles While I obviously see no consensus to delete I do think that the AfD would have benefited from being relisted to gain broader community input or at least being closed as no consensus Thanks