I think that interpreting the results of that AFD as a merge was quite reasonable whenever none of the sides d k or m gets a consensus supporting it it is up to the closing admin to make a judgment call I am not all that enthused about that list being in the main Bobby Fischer article it looks a bit cluttered with it there But if nobody has a better place to merge it I won t complain too much Perhaps I could write an article on the book by Edmar Mednis How to Beat Bobby Fischer and merge that list there