to IP above clarification on Jat ethnicity To the IP above do not bold your text and put it at the top of the page If you believe that that is true find reliable sources that suggests that Why are Jats said to be a distinct ethnic group Are they not a Kshatriyan caste group My grandfather is a Jat but he s also Punjabi Jats see themselves as Kshatriya and Jat writers tend to write this I have read that they are considered Vaisya due to mostly farmers In Manu Smirti they are refered to as Sudra There is a lot of mystery around this Thanks Hello where did you find the reference of Jats in Manusmriti and also where did you find this vaisya theory Article structure I ve started to try to organise the many facts in this article into a better structure please feel free to improve on it Jamot I ve removed the phrase see article on Jamot from the Jat people in Pakistan sub section because the Jamot article does not mention Jats although it is catagorised as such If information is added to the Jamot article to make it obviously relevant to this article then I d be happy to resinstate the link BSP In the Jat people in India subsection I changed BSP to Bahujan Samaj Party if this is wrong please correct it but please don t revert to BSP without explaining what it stands for Thanks Hookah image To show common behaviour in a group is not the same as showing behaviour different from that of other groups Example Many different cultures play checkers But a very common rural tradition in some areas in the US is to play checkers An image of 2 men playing checkers might well be appropriate for many different areas of the world with possibly the only difference being their appearance clothing adornments whatever I don t see any objection to the image in the deleting edit summary although the statement that it is not specific to Jat people is certainly true There are Southern US Jazz musicians of many nations cultures origins social strata who use the hooka I support keeping the image I would suggest that any images should add to enhance or reinforce the reader s appreciation and understanding of the primary subject of the article The image in question is captioned A typical Jat chaupal in a village smoking a hubble bubble hooka but the article doesn t explain what a chaupal is so it doesn t enhance my understanding nor does it claim to show anything characteristicly Jat the article makes no mention of smoking Furthermore some 36 of the caption 4 words out of 11 is concerned with the smoking which appears to be undue weight for a subject to which the article gives no weight at all Furthermore the reader may reasonably be misled by this image to believe that this form of smoking plays a significant role in Jat culture I suggest that the image serves no useful purpose in the article and may well be counterproductive Makes sense to me 122 162 97 233 edits I reverted the edits by this user and neglected to make comments The reason why I did this was that Gujjar was changed to Ahir when the reference stated Gujjar Also the references added either were dead links or did not meet wiki standards i e wiki type pages themselves Jatt In punjabi JATT KI TE GHAT KI YAARI JATT DI TOOT DA MOSHA KADE NA WICHALEO TUT DI WE ARE VERY PROMISING PEOPLE WE SAY WE DO IT OR DIE WE BELIEVE IN THE SAYING EVERYTHING IS FAIR IN LOVE AND WAR Preceding unsigned