Was Pliny Italian or provincial In one paragraph it is stated that Pliny was provincial namely the paragraph that says This connection and the friendship between the younger Pliny and Tacitus led many scholars to the conclusion that the two families were of similar class means and background equestrians of significant wealth and from provincial families while in the one next to the above it is stated that the statement in Pliny Book 9 Letter 23 led many scholars to the conclusion that one of them is Italian and the other is provincial and scince Pliny was from Italy some believe that Tcitus is provincial I just wonder how can we be sure that Pliny is Italian while there is a possibility that he is provincial as stated in the preceding paragraph