probiotic strain e. faecium cmgb16 ( isolated from infant faeces ) was cultivated in anaerobic conditions , in mrs broth . enteropathogenic e. coli o28 ( provided by national institute of research and development for microbiology and immunology cantacuzino , bucharest ) and b. cereus cmgb 102 ( microbial culture collection of faculty of biology , microbiology department , university of bucharest ) strains were grown in nutrient broth . e. faecium cmgb16 was co - cultivated in the presence of heat - inactivated cultures of e. coli o28 and b. cereus , for 24 hours in mrs broth ( man rogosa sharp ) , in anaerobic conditions , at 37c . the co - cultivation method was performed by inoculating 4 ml mrs broth with 40 l of fresh e. faecium cmgb16 culture corresponding to standard mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) and 400 l of heat - inactivated cultures of e. coli o28/b . cereus corresponding to standard mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) , before inactivation . the heat - inactivation was performed by autoclaving the bacterial cultures at 121c for 15 min . after co - cultivation , the nvc components ( sns and cellular fraction ) were separated by centrifugation ( 6,000 rpm , 10 min ) . the cellular sediment was adjusted to mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) density in pbs ( phosphate buffer saline ) and along with integral cultures ( ic ) was heat - inactivated for 15 min at 121c . heat - inactivated cellular suspensions obtained from the cellular sediments ( cs ) , the ic , and the sn were further used for the immunomodulatory activity assay . immunomodulatory properties of the obtained nvcs were tested on holoxenic mice ( balb / c mouse strain ) . each nvc was orally administered ( by using a gradate pipette ) in three doses of 0.2 ml / dose to three animals / sample , at 24 hours . blood samples were collected from the retinal artery , by the non - traumatizing retro - orbital puncture method in the inner corner of the eye . blood samples were collected after 7 , 14 , and 21 days from the first administration of the heat - inactivated probiotic fractions . the serum concentrations of il-12 and tnf- interleukins were assessed by elisa method , using mouse elisa kit thermo scientific ( pierce biotechnology , rockford , uas ) , following the manufacturers instructions . all experiments were performed in triplicates and absorbance was measured on apollo lb 911 elisa plate reader set at 450 and 550 nm . a standard curve was generated by plotting the average absorbance obtained for each standard concentration on the vertical ( y ) axis vs. the corresponding il 12/tnf- concentration ( pg / ml ) on the horizontal ( x ) axis . using the standard curve , the il-12/tnf- amount in each sample was determined by interpolating the absorbance values ( y - axis ) to il-12/tnf- concentration . in this way sensitivity of il 12 mouse elisa kit was < 12 pg / ml and the sensitivity of tnf- mouse elisa kit was < 9 pg / ml . probiotic strain e. faecium cmgb16 ( isolated from infant faeces ) was cultivated in anaerobic conditions , in mrs broth . enteropathogenic e. coli o28 ( provided by national institute of research and development for microbiology and immunology cantacuzino , bucharest ) and b. cereus cmgb 102 ( microbial culture collection of faculty of biology , microbiology department , university of bucharest ) strains were grown in nutrient broth . e. faecium cmgb16 was co - cultivated in the presence of heat - inactivated cultures of e. coli o28 and b. cereus , for 24 hours in mrs broth ( man rogosa sharp ) , in anaerobic conditions , at 37c . the co - cultivation method was performed by inoculating 4 ml mrs broth with 40 l of fresh e. faecium cmgb16 culture corresponding to standard mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) and 400 l of heat - inactivated cultures of e. coli o28/b . cereus corresponding to standard mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) , before inactivation . the heat - inactivation was performed by autoclaving the bacterial cultures at 121c for 15 min . after co - cultivation , the nvc components ( sns and cellular fraction ) were separated by centrifugation ( 6,000 rpm , 10 min ) . the cellular sediment was adjusted to mcfarland 1 ( 310 cfu / ml ) density in pbs ( phosphate buffer saline ) and along with integral cultures ( ic ) was heat - inactivated for 15 min at 121c . heat - inactivated cellular suspensions obtained from the cellular sediments ( cs ) , the ic , and the sn were further used for the immunomodulatory activity assay . immunomodulatory properties of the obtained nvcs were tested on holoxenic mice ( balb / c mouse strain ) . each nvc was orally administered ( by using a gradate pipette ) in three doses of 0.2 ml / dose to three animals / sample , at 24 hours . blood samples were collected from the retinal artery , by the non - traumatizing retro - orbital puncture method in the inner corner of the eye . blood samples were collected after 7 , 14 , and 21 days from the first administration of the heat - inactivated probiotic fractions . the serum concentrations of il-12 and tnf- interleukins were assessed by elisa method , using mouse elisa kit thermo scientific ( pierce biotechnology , rockford , uas ) , following the manufacturers instructions . all experiments were performed in triplicates and absorbance was measured on apollo lb 911 elisa plate reader set at 450 and 550 nm . a standard curve was generated by plotting the average absorbance obtained for each standard concentration on the vertical ( y ) axis vs. the corresponding il 12/tnf- concentration ( pg / ml ) on the horizontal ( x ) axis . using the standard curve , the il-12/tnf- amount in each sample was determined by interpolating the absorbance values ( y - axis ) to il-12/tnf- concentration . in this way , the absorbance results were converted in pg / ml concentrations . sensitivity of il 12 mouse elisa kit was < 12 pg / ml and the sensitivity of tnf- mouse elisa kit was < 9 pg / ml . the majority of scientific studies use the term probiotic according to the fao / who ( food and agriculture organization of the united nations / world health organization ) ( 32 ) definition , i.e. live microorganisms , which when administered in adequate amounts could confer a health benefit on the host . therefore , this definition requires that the probiotic must be viable , with many studies supporting this idea ( 3336 ) . however , there are some scientific findings supporting the positive effects of the probiotic nvcs on health due to the ability of human immune cells to recognize specific bacterial components and metabolic by - products , generating an immunomodulatory effect that involves malt activation ( 2 ) . in addition , these heat - killed probiotic cells also induced high levels of il-12 p70 in dendritic cells of mice and the switch to a t helper 1 ( th1 ) immune response . given the complexity of the phenomena induced by viable and non - viable probiotics , taverniti ( 38 ) has proposed the term  paraprobiotic defined as non - viable fractions of probiotic origin ( inactivated microbial cells or cell fractions ) , which have been demonstrated to positively affect human / animal health . the study of these paraprobiotics is justified by the opinion of some authors that probiotics could be involved in obesity / metabolic syndrome ( 39 ) ; simultaneously , the specific effects of probiotic components / culture fractions and targets are important to be known in order to define appropriate clinical applications ( similarly to the modern , subunitary vaccines or to immunomodulators ) . during this study we have used probiotic culture fractions stimulated with other inactivated bacterial cultures , to mimic the interspecies interactions established in the intestinal mucosa . in order to include both probiotic and stimulating bacterial culture components found in the final fractions , parabiotic , defined as nvc of microbial origin that exhibit beneficial effects on the health of the human or animal host organism . the serum samples collected after 7 , 14 , 21 days from the first administration of probiotic fractions were analyzed for il-12 and tnf- serum levels by elisa method . the obtained values represent the average of the determinations performed for each animal batch ( fig . graphic representation of il-12 concentration in the serum of holoxenic mice , collected after : i  7 days from the first oral administration of nvcs ; ii  14 days from the first oral administration of nvcs ; iii  21 days from the first oral administration of nvcs . ic , integral culture ; cs , cellular suspension ; sn , supernatant ; a , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc ; b , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc stimulated with e. coli o28c ; c , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc stimulated with b. cereus ; mc , media control  serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of mrs ; nc , negative control  serum collected from holoxenic mice control . the obtained results showed that the age of the animals significantly influenced the serum concentration of il-12 . the highest levels of il-12 were recorded at 7 days after the first administration of the ic and sn nvcs , especially those stimulated with b. cereus ( fig . 1 ) . at 14 and 21 days after the first oral administration of probiotic nvcs , the serum concentration of il-12 generally decreased . in exchange , after the oral administration of sn component stimulated with b. cereus and e. coli , the serum concentrations of il-12 were maintained higher in the samples collected after 21 days post - administration . these aspects suggest that b. cereus and e. coli strains stimulate the synthesis and accumulation in the probiotic cultures sn of bacterial molecules potentially involved in the activation of mucosal intestinal cells , such as macrophages or dendritic cells , to synthesize il-12 . however , it is to be noticed that the unstimulated fractions , particularly cs and sn , also induced high levels of il-12 , especially at 7 and 14 days after the first administration . il-12 is a cytokine required for the initiation of the immune response , constituting the connecting bridge between non - specific defense reactions ( it activates macrophages and nk cells ) and specific immune response . the production of immunomodulatory molecules by probiotic bacteria is thus influenced by the presence of other bacterial species , both gram - positive and gram - negative , which inhabit the gut ( autochthonous and allochthonous microbiota ) , by complex and incompletely understood cross - talk mechanisms . the induction of a late immunostimulatory response by these soluble molecules could suggest that they are resistant to digestive enzymes degradation , and could slowly and gradually diffuse in the submucosa , inducing the activation of malt . this effect was not evident after the administration of cs and ic from the unstimulated nvcs , supporting the hypothesis that the late immunomodulatory effect is due to small , heat - stable , soluble molecules . studies on peptide fractions ( with molecular weight between 2 and 10 da ) isolated from lactobacillus helveticus culture ( using hplc method ) showed their immunomodulatory effects after oral administration in holoxenic mice infected with e. coli o157:h7 ( 40 ) . cytokine profile of these mice revealed a stimulation of th2 lymphocyte - mediated response and an increase of the b cells number in the intestine ( lamina propria ) , and thus the concentration of secretory iga . the scientific researches states that probiotics ( either viable cells or cellular fragments with antigenic potential ) must interact with malt structures ( dendritic cells , m cells from the peyer patches ) to generate an immunostimulatory effect , the route of antigen internalization being essential for the initiation of an immune response in the gastrointestinal mucosa ( 11 , 28 , 41 ) . these observations may explain why the early stimulation of il-12 synthesis at 7 days after the first administration was induced mainly by the ic stimulated fraction , containing strong particulate antigens . being the dominant cytokine involved in the maturation of cd t cells , il-12 plays an important role in immunomodulation , its synthesis being an essential process in triggering early cytokine cascade activation as a response to adjuvants ( 42 ) . in the case of tnf synthesis , the obtained results were variable , no specific cytokine profile dependent on probiotic nvcs , stimulating species , or serum harvesting time being identified . however , at all three harvesting intervals , the highest levels of tnf were induced after the administration of the ic fractions stimulated with e. coli ( fig . , the most intensive stimulating effect was obtained for sn fraction stimulated with b. cereus , while the un - stimulated cs fraction induced the highest levels of tnf at 14 and 21 days after administration . graphic representation of tnf  concentration in the serum of holoxenic mice , collected after : i  7 days from the first oral administration of nvcs ; ii  14 days from the first oral administration of nvcs ; iii  21 days from the first oral administration of nvcs . ic , integral culture , cs , cellular suspension ; sn , supernatant ; a , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc ; b , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc stimulated with e. coli o28c ; c , serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of nvc stimulated with b. cereus ; mc , media control  serum collected from holoxenic mice after oral administration of mrs ; nc , negative control  serum collected from holoxenic mice control . this effect suggests again that the cellular fragments with strong antigenic properties could induce the activation of macrophage cells from the sub - endothelial compartment ( the main tnf producing cells ) . it has been shown that both crude extracts and purified lipoteichoic acids from l. casei and l. fermentum could significantly induce tnf secretion by mouse splenic mononuclear cells ( 16 ) . this suggests that purified lipoteichoic acids may be a better candidate for clinical use than whole bacteria since they do not contain other bacterial components which might cause side effects ( 2 ) . the induction of tnf- synthesis by probiotic bacteria , observed in many other studies ( 28 ) seems to be necessary in order to establish functional connections between intestinal epithelial cells and the immune cells ( b cells , dendritic cells , macrophages ) from the lamina propria . our results , similar to other scientific studies , demonstrate that inactivated soluble and cellular fractions of probiotic cultures , whose composition can be influenced by the stimulation with other microbial species , could induce immunomodulatory effects mediated by cytokines . further studies are required in order to identify the chemical nature of these so - called parabiotic fractions . the authors have no potential conflicts of interest with any companies / organizations whose products or services may be discussed in this article .
backgroundcompetition of probiotic bacteria with other species from the intestinal microbiota involves different mechanisms that occur regardless of probiotics viability . 
 the objective of this paper was to assess the cytokine serum levels in holoxenic mice after oral administration of non - viable components ( nvc ) of enterococcus faecium probiotic culture stimulated with heat - inactivated escherichia coli and bacillus cereus in comparison to nvc of unstimulated e. faecium probiotic culture.methodsprobiotic e. faecium cmgb 16 culture , grown in the presence of heat - inactivated cultures of e. coli and b. cereus cmgb 102 , was subsequently separated into supernatant ( sn ) and heat - inactivated cellular sediment ( cs ) fractions by centrifugation . 
 each nvc was orally administered to holoxenic mice ( balb c mouse strain ) , in three doses , given at 24 hours . 
 blood samples were collected from the retinal artery , at 7 , 14 , and 21 days after the first administration of the nvc . 
 the serum concentrations of il-12 and tumor necrosis factor - alpha ( tnf- ) interleukins were assessed by elisa method.resultsafter the oral administration of sn component obtained from the probiotic culture stimulated with heat - inactivated cultures of b. cereus cmgb 102 and e. coli o28 , the serum concentrations of il-12 were maintained higher in the samples collected at 7 and 14 days post - administration . 
 no specific tnf- profile could be established , depending on stimulated or non - stimulated probiotic culture , nvc fraction , or harvesting time.conclusionthe obtained results demonstrate that non - viable fractions of probiotic bacteria , stimulated by other bacterial species , could induce immunostimulatory effects mediated by cytokines and act , therefore , as immunological adjuvants .