ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent glass is empty. A blue ballpoint pen is placed inside it, either upright or leaning against the side. Which of the following is the most accurate description of the required image?

Options:
A. A transparent, empty glass with a blue ballpoint pen clearly visible inside, leaning against the inner wall.
B. A transparent glass half-filled with water, showing a blue ballpoint pen that appears bent at the water's surface.
C. A transparent, empty glass with a broken or bent blue ballpoint pen inside.
D. A transparent glass with a blue ballpoint pen placed completely outside of it on the table.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a blue ballpoint pen, either standing upright or leaning against the inner wall.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple, clean background.

2. The blue ballpoint pen is clearly visible, straight in form with no bending or breaking.

3. The pen is placed reasonably inside the glass, leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the image from the previous turn, clear water is poured into the glass until it is about half full. Which of the following best describes the expected visual effect on the pen?

Options:
A. The pen remains perfectly straight and unchanged in appearance.
B. The pen appears broken or displaced at the air-water interface due to refraction, and the submerged part looks slightly thicker.
C. The water is opaque and completely obscures the submerged part of the pen.
D. The glass changes color and the pen disappears entirely.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Using the previous image as a reference, modify it by adding clear water until the glass is about half full. Show the visual appearance of the blue ballpoint pen now.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is about halfway up the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. The pen shows a clear visual 'break' or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the pen appears slightly thicker than the part above water (lens magnification effect).

The background, glass style, and the pen's original appearance (color/material) remain consistent with Turn 2 output image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 2 output image, not a completely new, unrelated generating.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent glass (empty) is generated. Inside the glass, a slender bamboo skewer is placed, either vertically or leaning against the side. Which of the following is the most accurate description of the key visual elements that should be present?

Options:
A. The glass is opaque and contains a liquid. The skewer is broken into two pieces.
B. The glass is transparent and empty. The skewer is clearly visible, straight, and placed inside the glass, leaning against its wall.
C. The glass is transparent and half-filled with water. The skewer appears bent at the water's surface.
D. The glass is frosted and empty. The skewer is curved and floating above the glass.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent glass (empty). Inside the glass, place a slender bamboo skewer, either vertically or leaning against the side.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a clean, simple background.

2. The slender bamboo skewer is clearly visible, appears straight with no bends or breaks.

3. The skewer is placed realistically inside the glass, leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the image from the previous turn, clear water is poured into the glass until it is about half full. What is the primary visual phenomenon that should now be observed regarding the bamboo skewer?

Options:
A. The skewer completely disappears underwater.
B. The skewer changes color to match the water.
C. The skewer appears bent or displaced at the air-water interface due to refraction.
D. The skewer remains perfectly straight and unaffected by the water.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, pour clear water into the glass until it is about half full. Generate the observed appearance of the bamboo skewer.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is approximately halfway up the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. The bamboo skewer shows a clear visual 'break' or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the skewer appears slightly thicker than the part above water due to the magnifying lens effect of the water and glass.

The background, glass style, and the skewer's original appearance (color/material) remain consistent with Turn 2 output image.

The image should clearly appear to be a modified version of the Turn 2 output image, not a completely new, unrelated generating.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a slender orange lollipop stick, either standing upright or leaning against the side.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple background.

2. The slender orange lollipop stick is clearly visible, straight in form, with no bending or breaking.

3. The stick is placed realistically inside the glass, leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, fill the glass with water to about half its capacity. Generate the observed appearance of the lollipop stick now.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is approximately halfway up the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. The stick shows a clear visual 'break' or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the stick appears slightly thicker than the part above water, due to the magnifying lens effect.

The background, glass style (transparent, empty), and the stick's original appearance (slender, orange) remain consistent with the Turn 1 output image.

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 1 output image (featuring the transparent empty glass and slender orange lollipop stick), not a completely new generation.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent, empty glass is shown. Inside the glass, a slender, solid object is placed, either upright or leaning against the side. What is the most likely identity of this object?
Options:
A. A wooden chopstick
B. A thin watercolor paintbrush
C. A metal straw
D. A plastic ruler
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a slender watercolor paintbrush, either standing upright or leaning against the inner wall.
output: evaluation_points: The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple, uncluttered background.

The slender watercolor paintbrush is clearly visible, with a straight form showing no bends or breaks.

The brush is placed realistically inside the glass, leaning against the inner wall or standing upright.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the previous image, the glass is now filled halfway with clear water. Observing the same slender object, what visual effect is expected at the air-water boundary?
Options:
A. The object appears completely straight and continuous.
B. The object appears broken or displaced at the water's surface due to refraction.
C. The object's color changes dramatically.
D. The object disappears underwater.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, fill the glass approximately halfway with clear water. Generate the observed appearance of the watercolor paintbrush now.
output: evaluation_points: The water level is about halfway up the glass, and the water is transparent.

The paintbrush shows a clear visual break or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

The submerged portion of the brush appears slightly thicker than the part above water, due to lens magnification.

The background, glass style, and the brush's original appearance (color/material) remain consistent with Turn 2 output image.

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 2 output image, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent glass is empty. A long, thin, solid object is placed inside it, either standing upright or leaning against the side. What is the most likely visual characteristic of the object in this initial setup?

Options:
A. The object appears broken or disjointed at a specific point.
B. The object's portion inside the glass looks noticeably thicker than the portion outside.
C. The object is clearly visible, straight, and shows no visual distortion.
D. The object is partially submerged in a liquid, causing a shift in its appearance.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a single white knitting needle. The needle should be positioned either vertically or leaning at an angle against the inner wall of the glass.
output: evaluation_points: The glass is transparent and completely empty, with a simple, uncluttered background.

The white knitting needle is clearly visible. Its form is perfectly straight, with no bends, curves, or breaks.

The needle's placement is physically plausible: it is inside the glass and is either standing upright or realistically leaning/slanted against the inner wall of the cup.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the image from the previous turn, clear water is now poured into the glass until it is about half full. What is the primary visual phenomenon expected to be observed in the new image?

Options:
A. The knitting needle disappears completely under the water.
B. The water causes the entire needle to appear uniformly thicker.
C. The needle shows a clear visual break or displacement at the air-water boundary due to refraction.
D. The water changes the color of the knitting needle from white to a different hue.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Using the previous image as a reference, modify it to show the glass now filled approximately halfway with clear water. Generate the resulting visual appearance of the white knitting needle.
output: evaluation_points: The water level fills about half of the glass. The water is transparent.

The knitting needle exhibits a distinct visual 'break' or misalignment at the air-water interface, demonstrating the refraction of light.

The portion of the needle underwater appears slightly thicker than the portion in air, due to the magnifying lens effect of the water and glass.

Consistency Check: The background, the style/shape of the glass, and the original properties of the needle (white color, straight form, material suggestion) remain identical to the image from Turn 2 output.

Consistency Check: The new image must be clearly identifiable as a modified version of the Turn 2 output image (e.g., same perspective, lighting, object position), not a completely redrawn or unrelated scene.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent, empty glass is generated. Inside the glass, a long, thin object is placed. What is the most likely object being depicted?

Options:
A. A silver fountain pen
B. A golden mechanical pencil
C. A wooden chopstick
D. A plastic straw
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a golden mechanical pencil, either standing upright or leaning against the side.
output: evaluation_points: The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple background.

The golden mechanical pencil is clearly visible, with a straight form showing no bends or breaks.

The pencil is placed realistically inside the glass, leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the previous image, water is poured into the glass until it is about half full. Which of the following optical effects should be clearly visible in the new generating?

Options:
A. The pencil appears completely straight and unbroken.
B. The pencil appears broken or displaced at the air-water boundary.
C. The submerged part of the pencil looks thinner than the part above water.
D. The water is opaque and colored.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, pour clear water into the glass until it is about half full. Generate the observed appearance of the golden mechanical pencil now.
output: evaluation_points: The water level is at approximately half the height of the glass, and the water is transparent.

The pencil shows a clear visual break or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

The submerged portion of the pencil appears slightly thicker than the part above water due to the magnifying lens effect.

The background, glass style, and the original appearance of the pencil (color/material) remain consistent with the Turn 2 output image.

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 2 output image, not a completely new generating.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A slender thermometer is placed inside an empty transparent glass. Which of the following best describes the thermometer's appearance?
Options:
A. The thermometer appears perfectly straight and continuous.
B. The thermometer appears broken at the midpoint.
C. The thermometer appears thicker at the top than at the bottom.
D. The thermometer appears to be floating above the bottom of the glass.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate an empty transparent glass with a slender thermometer placed vertically or leaning against the inside wall.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple background.

2. The slender thermometer is clearly visible, appearing straight without bends or breaks.

3. The thermometer is positioned realistically inside the glass, either upright or leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: The glass from the previous image is now filled halfway with water. How does the thermometer appear at the air-water interface?
Options:
A. The thermometer appears perfectly straight and continuous.
B. The thermometer appears broken or displaced at the water's surface.
C. The thermometer appears thinner below the water than above.
D. The water level appears above the top of the thermometer.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, fill the glass with water to about half its height and generate the observed appearance of the thermometer.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is approximately halfway up the glass, and the water appears transparent.

2. The thermometer shows a clear visual break or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the thermometer appears slightly thicker than the part above water (lens magnification effect).

The background, glass style, and thermometer's original appearance (color/material) remain consistent with Turn 2 output image.

The image should clearly appear to be a modified version of the Turn 2 output image, not a completely new generating.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent, empty glass is generated. Inside the glass, a long, slender metal file is placed, either vertically or leaning against the side. Which of the following is the most accurate description of the required image?

Options:
A. A transparent glass containing a long, slender metal file. The file is clearly visible, straight, and placed inside the glass, leaning against its inner wall.
B. A transparent glass containing a long, slender metal file. The file is clearly visible but appears bent or broken.
C. A transparent glass containing a long, slender metal file. The file is placed outside the glass.
D. A transparent glass containing a long, slender metal file. The file is submerged in a liquid inside the glass.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a long, slender metal file, either vertically or leaning against the inner wall.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple, clean background.

2. The long, slender metal file is clearly visible, appears straight without any bends or breaks.

3. The file is placed inside the glass in a plausible position (e.g., leaning against the inner wall or standing vertically).

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Based on the image from the previous turn, water is poured into the glass until it is about half full. Which of the following best describes the expected visual effect on the metal file?

Options:
A. The file appears completely unchanged from its original straight form.
B. The file appears broken or misaligned at the air-water interface due to refraction, and the submerged portion looks slightly thicker due to magnification.
C. The file disappears completely underwater.
D. The file changes color when submerged in water.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, modify it by adding clear water until the glass is about half full. Generate the observed appearance of the metal file now.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is at approximately half the height of the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. The metal file shows a clear visual 'break' or displacement at the air-water interface, illustrating the refraction effect.

3. The submerged portion of the file appears slightly thicker than the part above water, demonstrating the lens magnification effect.

The background, glass style, and the file's original appearance (color/material) remain consistent with the Turn 2 output image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 2 output image (e.g., water added, file appearance altered at interface) and not a completely redrawn, unrelated scene.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: text
input: A transparent glass is empty. Inside it, a long, thin, fluorescent glow stick is placed, either standing upright or leaning against the inner wall. Which of the following best describes the correct visual representation for this initial setup?

Options:
A. A transparent glass containing only a straight, intact, fluorescent glow stick.
B. A transparent glass containing a bent or broken fluorescent glow stick.
C. A transparent glass that is partially filled with water, with a glow stick inside.
D. An opaque mug containing a straight fluorescent glow stick.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Generate a transparent, empty glass. Inside the glass, place a long, thin, fluorescent glow stick, either standing vertically or leaning at an angle against the inner wall.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple, uncluttered background.

2. The long, thin, fluorescent glow stick is clearly visible, appearing straight and intact with no bends or breaks.

3. The glow stick is positioned plausibly inside the glass, such as leaning against the inner wall or standing upright.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Using the image from the previous turn as a reference, the glass is now filled about halfway with clear water. Considering the optical phenomenon of refraction, which of the following describes the expected visual change to the glow stick?

Options:
A. The glow stick appears completely unchanged from the previous image.
B. At the air-water boundary, the glow stick appears to have a clear visual 'break' or displacement.
C. The portion of the glow stick underwater appears significantly thinner than the portion in air.
D. The water is colored, and the glow stick's color has changed.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, add clear water to the glass until it is about half full. Generate the resulting view of the glow stick, accurately depicting the visual effects caused by refraction.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is at approximately half the height of the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. At the air-water interface, the glow stick shows a distinct visual 'break' or displacement, illustrating refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the glow stick appears slightly thicker than the part in air due to the magnifying lens effect of the water and glass.

The background, glass style, and the original appearance of the glow stick (its fluorescent color/material) remain consistent with the image from Turn 2 output.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 2 output image (e.g., water added, glow stick altered) and not a completely redrawn, unrelated scene.
Domain: Physics / refraction_single

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Generate an empty, transparent glass. Inside the glass, place a red and white plastic straw, either standing upright or leaning at an angle against the inner wall.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The glass is transparent and empty, with a simple, uncluttered background.

2. The red and white plastic straw is clearly visible, appearing straight and intact with no bends or breaks.

3. The straw is positioned realistically inside the glass, either vertically or leaning against the inner wall.

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Based on the previous image, fill the glass with water until it is approximately half full. Generate the straw as it would appear under these new conditions.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The water level is at about half the height of the glass, and the water is transparent.

2. The straw shows a clear visual 'break' or displacement at the air-water interface due to refraction.

3. The submerged portion of the straw appears slightly thicker than the part above water, simulating a lens magnification effect.

The background, glass style, and the straw's original appearance (color/material) are consistent with the Turn 1 output image. Specifically, the straw must retain its 'red and white plastic' colors and material appearance.

The image should be clearly recognizable as a modified version of the Turn 1 output image, not a completely new, unrelated generating.