ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a straw being inserted into the hole of a cup lid.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a straw.

2. The image contains a cup lid with a hole.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the straw passing through the hole in the cup lid.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first image, what is the most fundamental spatial relationship that should be maintained between the straw and the cup lid hole?

Options:
A. One object is placed on top of the other.
B. One object passes through an opening in the other.
C. One object is placed next to the other.
D. One object is placed inside the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you generated in the first round, replace the straw with a pencil while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The cup lid with its hole is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) remaining unchanged.

3. The straw has been completely removed, with no parts of it remaining.

4. A pencil is now clearly visible in the image.

5. The pencil maintains the same spatial relationship with the cup lid hole as the straw did (i.e., it passes through the hole).

6. The image is clearly a modified version of the scene from round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a key being hung onto a keyring.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a key.

2. The image contains a keyring.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of hanging, with the key passing through the circular opening of the keyring.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (hanging), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the key and the keyring?

Options:
A. One object is placed on top of the other.
B. One object passes through an opening in the other.
C. One object is attached to the side of the other.
D. One object is placed inside a closed container formed by the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the key with a fork while keeping the original relative relationship between the two objects. All other elements in the scene should remain unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene's environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The keyring is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged compared to the image generated in round 1.

3. The key has been completely removed, with no parts of it remaining.

4. A fork is now clearly visible in the image.

5. The fork maintains the same relative relationship with the keyring as the key did: it is shown passing through the keyring's circular opening.

6. The image is clearly a modification of the scene from the image generated in round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a shoelace being threaded through a shoe's eyelet.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a shoelace.

2. The image contains a shoe's eyelet.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of threading, with the shoelace passing through the hole of the eyelet.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round (threading), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the shoelace and the shoe's eyelet?

Options:
A. One object is placed on top of the other.
B. One object is wrapped around the other.
C. One object passes through a hole or opening in the other.
D. One object is attached to the side of the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you generated in the first round, replace the shoelace with a headphone cable while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in Round 1.

The shoe's eyelet remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged.

3. The shoelace is completely removed, with no remnants left behind.

4. A headphone cable is newly present in the image and is clearly visible.

5. The headphone cable maintains the same 'passing through a hole' spatial relationship with the shoe's eyelet as the shoelace did.

The headphone cable maintains the same 'passing through a hole' spatial relationship with the shoe's eyelet as the shoelace did in the image generated in Round 1.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a thread being passed through the eye of a needle.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image must contain a thread.

2. The image must contain the eye of a needle.

3. The image must clearly depict the action of passing the thread through the needle's eye, with the thread satisfying the relationship of 'passing through the hole of the needle eye'.

4. The overall scene should be realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (passing the thread through the needle's eye), which of the following relationships should the thread and the needle's eye maintain?

A. The thread is wrapped around the needle.
B. The thread passes through a hole in the needle's eye.
C. The thread is placed next to the needle.
D. The thread is tied to the needle.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the thread with a thin piece of wire while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene's environment, background, and details must be consistent with the image generated in round 1.

The needle's eye must remain in the image, with all its details (shape, color, texture, position) unchanged from the image generated in round 1.

3. The thread must be completely removed from the image, with no trace left behind.

4. A thin piece of wire must be clearly visible in the image.

5. The thin piece of wire must maintain the same spatial relationship with the needle's eye as the original thread did (i.e., passing through the hole of the needle's eye).

The image must clearly appear to be a modified version of the scene from the image generated in round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a binder clip clamping the edge of a sheet of paper.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a binder clip.

2. The image contains a sheet of paper.

3. The image clearly shows the action of clamping, with the binder clip positioned on the edge of the paper, satisfying the relationship 'A clamps the edge of B'.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first round, which of the following relationships should be maintained between the binder clip and the sheet of paper?
Options:
A. A is placed on top of B.
B. A encloses B completely.
C. A clamps the edge of B.
D. A is placed next to B.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you drew in the first round, replace the binder clip with a nutcracker while maintaining the original relative relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The sheet of paper remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged compared to the image generated in round 1.

3. The binder clip is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A nutcracker is clearly visible and added to the scene.

5. The nutcracker maintains the same relative relationship with the paper as the binder clip did (i.e., clamping its edge).

5. The nutcracker maintains the same relative relationship with the paper as the binder clip did in the image generated in round 1 (i.e., clamping its edge).
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene showing a clip pinching the opening of a snack bag.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a clip.

2. The image contains the opening of a snack bag.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of pinching, with the clip applying pressure to the edge of the bag opening.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (pinching the bag opening), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the clip and the bag opening?

Options:
A. The clip is placed next to the bag opening.
B. The clip applies pressure to the edge of the bag opening.
C. The clip is inside the bag opening.
D. The clip is hanging from the bag opening.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the clip with a stapler while keeping the original spatial relationship between the two objects. All other elements in the scene should remain unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene's environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The snack bag opening is still present in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position unchanged from the image generated in round 1.

3. The clip has been completely removed from the image, with no remaining parts.

4. A stapler is now clearly visible in the image.

5. The stapler maintains the same spatial relationship with the bag opening as the clip did (applying pressure to its edge).

5. The stapler maintains the same spatial relationship with the bag opening as the clip did in the image generated in round 1 (applying pressure to its edge).
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene showing a cup lid being placed on the rim of a cup.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a cup lid.

2. The image contains the rim of a cup.

3. The image clearly depicts the action/state of placing the lid on the rim, with the lid covering the cup's opening.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action/state from the first round, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the cup lid and the cup rim?
Options:
A. One object is placed inside the other.
B. One object is placed next to the other.
C. One object covers the opening of the other.
D. One object is suspended above the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the cup lid with a plate while maintaining the original relative relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The cup rim is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged from the image generated in round 1.

3. The cup lid has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A plate is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The plate maintains the same relative relationship with the cup rim as the original lid did (i.e., covering its opening).

5. The plate maintains the same relative relationship with the cup rim as the original lid did in the image generated in round 1 (i.e., covering its opening).
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a lid being placed on the opening of a box.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a box lid.

2. The image contains a box opening.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of placing the lid on the box opening, with the lid covering the opening.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round (placing the lid on the box), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the lid and the box opening?

Options:
A. The lid is inside the box opening.
B. The lid is adjacent to the side of the box.
C. The lid covers the box opening.
D. The lid is underneath the box opening.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the box lid with a cutting board while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

The box opening remains in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position completely unchanged.

3. The box lid has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A cutting board is clearly visible and added to the scene.

5. The cutting board maintains the 'covering the opening' spatial relationship with the box opening, just as the lid did.

The cutting board maintains the 'covering the opening' spatial relationship with the box opening, just as the lid did in the image generated in round 1.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the action of sealing a bowl's opening with plastic wrap.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains plastic wrap.

2. The image contains a bowl's opening/rim.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of sealing, with the plastic wrap adhering to and covering the bowl's opening.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action of sealing from the first round, what is the most essential relationship that should be maintained between the plastic wrap and the bowl's opening?

Options:
A. The plastic wrap is placed loosely beside the bowl.
B. The plastic wrap is crumpled up inside the bowl.
C. The plastic wrap adheres to and covers the bowl's opening.
D. The plastic wrap is stretched over the bowl but not touching the rim.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you drew in the first round, replace the plastic wrap with a paper towel while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

The bowl's opening is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged.

3. The plastic wrap is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A paper towel is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The paper towel maintains the same spatial relationship with the bowl's opening as the plastic wrap did (adhering to and covering the opening).

The paper towel maintains the same spatial relationship with the bowl's opening as the plastic wrap did in the image generated in round 1 (adhering to and covering the opening).
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting someone applying tape to a piece of paper (tape, paper).
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a roll of tape.

2. The image contains a piece of paper.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of applying, with the tape satisfying the relationship of being adhered to the surface of the paper.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with reasonable scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the tape and the paper?
Options:
A. One object is inside the other.
B. One object is adhered to the surface of the other.
C. One object is supporting the other from below.
D. One object is wrapped around the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the tape with a piece of chewing gum while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene's environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The piece of paper remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, texture, position) unchanged from the image generated in round 1.

3. The tape is completely removed, with no remnants left behind.

4. A piece of chewing gum is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The chewing gum maintains the same 'adhered to the surface of' relationship with the paper that the tape had.

6. The image is clearly a modification of the scene from the image generated in round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a card being inserted into a card sleeve.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a card.

2. The image contains a card sleeve.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the card satisfying the relationship of being inserted into the opening of the card sleeve.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first round, which of the following relationships should be maintained between the card and the card sleeve?

Options:
A. The card is placed on top of the card sleeve.
B. The card is inserted into the opening of the card sleeve.
C. The card is wrapped around the card sleeve.
D. The card is attached to the side of the card sleeve.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the card with a slice of toast while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The card sleeve remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, texture, position) unchanged.

3. The card is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A slice of toast is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The slice of toast maintains the same spatial relationship (inserted into the opening) with the card sleeve as the original card did.

5. The slice of toast maintains the same spatial relationship (inserted into the opening) with the card sleeve as the original card did in the image generated in round 1.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a person applying a bandage to their finger.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a bandage.

2. The image contains a finger.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of applying the bandage, with the bandage adhering to the surface of the finger.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with reasonable scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the bandage and the finger?

Options:
A. The bandage is wrapped around the finger.
B. The bandage is adhered to the surface of the finger.
C. The bandage is placed inside the finger.
D. The bandage is suspended above the finger.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the bandage with a roll of clear adhesive tape. Keep the original spatial relationship between the two objects unchanged, and leave all other elements in the scene the same.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The finger is still present in the image, with its shape, color, texture, and position all unchanged.

3. The bandage has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A roll of clear adhesive tape is now clearly visible in the image.

5. The roll of adhesive tape maintains the same 'adhered to the surface' spatial relationship with the finger as the original bandage did in the image generated in round 1.

6. The image is clearly a modification of the scene from the image generated in round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a person putting a glove onto their hand.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a glove.

2. The image contains a hand.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of putting on a glove, with the glove being placed over the exterior of the hand.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (putting on a glove), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the glove and the hand?

Options:
A. The glove is inside the hand.
B. The glove is adjacent to the hand.
C. The glove encloses the hand.
D. The glove is underneath the hand.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the glove with a plastic bag while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene's environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in turn 1.

The hand remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, texture, position) unchanged from the image generated in turn 1.

3. The glove has been completely removed, with no parts of it remaining.

4. A plastic bag is clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The plastic bag maintains the same 'enclosing the exterior' spatial relationship with the hand that the glove had.

The plastic bag maintains the same 'enclosing the exterior' spatial relationship with the hand that the glove had in the image generated in turn 1.