ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of Tikal Temple I in Guatemala, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of Tikal Temple I, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, erosion, and signs of historical decay.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this building's ruins?
Options:
A. It features a central dome and four minarets, typical of Ottoman architecture.
B. It is a stepped pyramid with a temple on top, characteristic of Classic Maya architecture.
C. It is constructed with large, precisely cut stone blocks without mortar, like Inca structures.
D. It has a colonnaded facade and triangular pediment, typical of ancient Greek temples.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this monument, depicting it in its complete, glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing parts of the building are filled in, and its structure is restored to completeness.

2. The surface materials of the building appear new, with no signs of weathering.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the civilization and era of the monument (Classic Maya).

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Classic Maya civilization and era, specifically as a stepped pyramid with a temple on top, as identified in Turn 2.

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image (depicting the unrestored ruins of Tikal Temple I).
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Temple of the Warriors at Chichen Itza, Mexico, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of the Temple of the Warriors at Chichen Itza, with its distinctive features (e.g., stepped pyramid form, columns) recognizable.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, such as missing sections, crumbling stonework, overgrown vegetation, and visible weathering to convey a sense of age and decay.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this building's ruins?

Options:
A. It features a classical Greek pediment and Doric columns.
B. It is a multi-story pagoda with upturned eaves, typical of East Asian architecture.
C. Its core structure is a stepped pyramid (Mesoamerican pyramid) with a temple on top and rows of carved columns depicting warriors.
D. It is a Gothic cathedral with flying buttresses and pointed arches.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this ancient site. Generate it in its complete, glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural parts (e.g., the full temple structure atop the pyramid, intact staircases, complete columns) are restored, making the structure whole.

2. The building's surfaces (stonework, carvings) appear new, clean, and sharp, with no signs of erosion, cracks, or plant overgrowth.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Maya civilization of the Terminal Classic period (e.g., the form of the stepped pyramid, warrior column motifs, Mesoamerican decorative elements).

The image background (e.g., sky, surrounding vegetation/terrain), camera perspective, lighting angle, and any non-architectural elements match the Turn 1 output image closely.

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 1 output image. Core elements from the ruin (like the base layout, specific column positions) should be recognizable as the foundation that has been digitally 'repaired' or painted over, not a completely redrawn scene from scratch.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Sacsayhuamán stone fortress in Peru, conveying a sense of historical decay and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of Sacsayhuamán, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, weathering, and other signs of historical erosion.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features a series of concentric circular walls.
B. It is constructed using large, irregularly shaped stones fitted together without mortar.
C. It is primarily built from red sandstone blocks with intricate carvings.
D. Its design includes tall, pointed arches and flying buttresses.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, modify it to restore the site. Please generate the fortress in its original, complete, and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections are filled in, and the overall structure is restored to completeness.

2. The building surfaces appear new, with no signs of weathering or aging.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Inca civilization and period to which Sacsayhuamán belongs.

The image background, camera perspective, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image (the ruins of Sacsayhuamán).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 input image (the ruins of Sacsayhuamán), not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the ancient city of Memphis in Egypt, conveying a sense of historical decay and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the ancient city of Memphis, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The image conveys a clear sense of damage, weathering, and the passage of time through visible cracks, missing sections, and eroded surfaces.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. Characterized by pointed arches, ribbed vaults, and flying buttresses.
B. Known for its use of massive stone blocks, monumental scale, and simple geometric forms.
C. Features intricate wooden latticework, upturned eaves, and a pagoda-style layout.
D. Defined by its use of concrete, arches, and domes for large public spaces.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, please modify it to restore the monument, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections from the Turn 1 image have been filled in, restoring the structure to a complete form.

2. The building's surface materials appear new and pristine, with no signs of weathering or erosion.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the ancient Egyptian civilization and era, specifically reflecting the 'massive stone blocks, monumental scale, and simple geometric forms' as identified in Turn 2's correct option (B).

The image background, camera angle, and non-essential elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins), not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current ruins of the Temple of Apollo in Pompeii, depicting the scene as it exists today—unrestored, with a sense of historical wear and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Temple of Apollo in Pompeii, with distinct architectural features.

2. The image conveys a strong sense of damage, weathering, and historical erosion.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features a central dome and minarets, typical of Islamic architecture.
B. It is constructed with a post-and-lintel system and columns, characteristic of ancient Roman architecture.
C. It has a stepped pyramid structure with a flat top, common in Mesoamerican cultures.
D. It uses flying buttresses and pointed arches, distinctive of Gothic architecture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, please modify it to restore this ancient site. Generate how it would have looked in its complete, glorious state when it was first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural parts are filled in, and the structure appears fully restored.

2. The building's surface materials look new, without signs of weathering or aging.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the civilization and era of the original site, specifically using the post-and-lintel system and columns characteristic of ancient Roman architecture as identified in Turn 2.

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 output image, not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored state of the ruins of the Bamiyan Buddha Caves in Afghanistan, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of the Bamiyan Buddha Caves, with distinct features.

2. The image clearly depicts significant damage, weathering, and historical deterioration.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?

Options:
A. It features a classical Greek colonnade and pediment.
B. It is a monolithic structure carved directly into a sandstone cliff face.
C. It is primarily constructed from fired bricks and features intricate Gothic arches.
D. It is a wooden post-and-beam structure built on a stone platform.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore the monument, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing parts of the structure are filled in, restoring its complete form.

2. The surface material of the structure appears new, without signs of weathering.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Gandharan Buddhist civilization and era of the original monument, as implied by the correct option (B) in Turn 2 which describes it as 'a monolithic structure carved directly into a sandstone cliff face'.

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the reference image from Turn 1 output.

The image is clearly identifiable as a modified version of the Turn 1 output image, not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of Ta Prohm temple in Angkor, Cambodia, capturing a sense of historical decay and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of Ta Prohm temple, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, weathering, and other signs of historical passage of time.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this temple ruin?
Options:
A. It is a classic example of Gothic architecture with pointed arches and flying buttresses.
B. Its primary structure is a massive stone pyramid built as a royal tomb.
C. It is a Buddhist temple complex known for its fusion of laterite and sandstone construction, and the iconic strangler fig trees growing over its ruins.
D. It features a large central dome and four minarets, characteristic of Islamic mosque architecture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this temple to its original, complete, and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections of the temple are reconstructed, restoring its complete structure.

2. The surface materials of the building appear new, without any signs of weathering or aging.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Khmer Empire civilization and era to which Ta Prohm belongs, as described in Turn 2's correct option C: 'Buddhist temple complex known for its fusion of laterite and sandstone construction'.

The image background, camera perspective, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image (the image of the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly identifiable as a modification of the Turn 1 output image (the generated image of the unrestored ruins), not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of Machu Picchu in Peru, conveying a sense of historical wear, damage, and the passage of time.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of Machu Picchu, with its distinctive features (e.g., terraces, stone structures) being prominent.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, decay, and weathering, such as crumbling walls, overgrown vegetation, and worn stone surfaces, to evoke a sense of historical erosion.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features large, precisely cut polygonal stones fitted together without mortar, a hallmark of Inca construction.
B. It is characterized by tall, pointed Gothic arches and flying buttresses.
C. Its primary structure is a massive, stepped pyramid built for ceremonial purposes.
D. It utilizes a post-and-lintel system with fluted Doric columns.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore the site, depicting Machu Picchu in its original, complete, and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections (e.g., walls, roofs, terraces) from the Turn 1 image are reconstructed, resulting in a complete and intact structure.

2. The building surfaces (stonework) appear new, clean, and polished, with no signs of weathering, moss, or cracks.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with Inca civilization, maintaining features like polygonal stonework, terraces, and trapezoidal doorways.

The image background, camera perspective/angle, lighting, and any non-architectural elements (e.g., distant mountains, sky) are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins), evident through shared compositional elements and structure, rather than being a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of Stonehenge in the UK, conveying a sense of historical wear, damage, and the passage of time.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of Stonehenge, with its characteristic features (e.g., large standing stones, lintels, circular arrangement) being prominent.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, weathering (e.g., cracks, erosion, missing stones), and historical decay, evoking a sense of age and ruin.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this monument?
Options:
A. It was constructed using a post-and-lintel (trilithon) system of massive sarsen stones.
B. Its primary structure was a series of interconnected, vaulted stone arches.
C. It was built primarily from fired clay bricks arranged in complex geometric patterns.
D. Its design features intricate carved reliefs depicting mythological scenes on all standing stones.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore the monument, depicting Stonehenge in its complete, newly-built, and glorious state when it was first constructed.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural parts (e.g., fallen or absent stones, lintels) from the Turn 1 image are restored, resulting in a complete and intact circular structure.

2. The surface material of the stones appears new, smooth, and without signs of weathering, erosion, or damage.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Neolithic/Bronze Age period of Stonehenge, featuring the characteristic megalithic post-and-lintel construction.

The image background, camera perspective/angle, lighting, and any non-architectural elements (e.g., sky, ground, distant landscape) are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 input image (e.g., same base composition, with ruins digitally repaired/added), not a completely redrawn or unrelated scene.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Hall of One Hundred Columns at Persepolis, Iran, conveying a sense of historical wear, damage, and the passage of time.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Hall of One Hundred Columns at Persepolis, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The image clearly depicts significant damage, weathering, and historical decay, such as broken columns, eroded surfaces, and missing architectural elements.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of the Hall of One Hundred Columns at Persepolis?
Options:
A. It was constructed primarily from marble and featured intricate Corinthian capitals.
B. It was a hypostyle hall with a flat roof supported by numerous stone columns, characteristic of Achaemenid Persian palatial architecture.
C. It featured a large central dome and pointed arches, typical of later Islamic architecture in the region.
D. It was built using large, interlocking stone blocks without mortar, similar to Inca construction techniques.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, modify it to restore the Hall of One Hundred Columns at Persepolis to its original, complete, and magnificent state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. All missing architectural parts (e.g., broken columns, collapsed sections) from the Turn 1 reference image are reconstructed and the structure appears whole.

2. The building's surfaces (e.g., stone, reliefs) appear pristine, polished, and free of weathering, erosion, or damage.

3. The restored architectural style (e.g., column design, capital motifs, overall proportions) remains consistent with Achaemenid Persian palatial architecture of the 5th century BCE.

The image background, camera perspective/angle, lighting, and any non-architectural elements (e.g., sky, ground, distant landscape) are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (the image of the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 1 output image (the image of the unrestored ruins), not a completely new illustration. This can be shown through identical compositional elements where the ruins were, now filled in with restored parts.
Domain: Damage_Repair / rust_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Generate a rusty iron chain, with its surface heavily covered in rust.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly an iron chain.

2. The surface of the item shows clear signs of oxidation and rust (e.g., reddish-brown iron rust), with a rough texture.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To remove the rust from the surface of the item in the image, what is the most suitable physical or chemical treatment method?
Options:
A. Painting over it
B. Acid pickling or abrasive blasting
C. Soaking in water
D. Applying oil only
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, generate what the item looks like after being treated with the method described in Turn 2, with the rust removed and restored.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The rust on the item's surface has been removed, and the surface appears clean.

2. The item exhibits the natural luster of its original material (e.g., metallic shine).

The image background, item outline, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the output image from Turn 1, showing it is a modification of that image. The item must remain a chain, consistent with the 'rusty iron chain' described in Turn 1.

turn: 4
modality: text
input: Observe the modified image from the previous turn. What is the most likely use for this item?
Options:
A. Jewelry
B. Securing or lifting heavy objects
C. Cooking utensil
D. Decorative wall art
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 5
modality: image
input: Based on the determined use of the item from the previous turn and the rust-free image generated in Turn 3, generate the item in a realistic usage scenario, with a natural and appropriate background and scene elements.
output: evaluation_points: The appearance of the item in the image (shape, color, texture/material) remains consistent with the output image from Turn 3. The item must be a chain, consistent with the 'rusty iron chain' described in Turn 1.

2. The item is being used in a typical and correct manner, with actions and states that reasonably reflect its purpose.

3. The image background and scene elements are appropriate and match the usage scenario of an iron chain.

turn: 6
modality: text
input: Observing the usage scenario of the item in the previous image, will this use accelerate the rusting of the item?
Options:
A. Yes
B. No
C. Cannot be determined.
output: answer: <DYNAMIC>