ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a school cafeteria serving line aisle, which of the following items would be most unreasonable to find there?
Options:
A. Tray
B. Treadmill
C. Napkin dispenser
D. Food warmer
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate a scene of the location mentioned in the previous round (a school cafeteria serving line aisle) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a school cafeteria serving line aisle (e.g., showing a counter, food trays, people in line).

2. The image contains a treadmill and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The treadmill's scale and perspective are reasonable, and its appearance fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the cafeteria setting.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions about it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions refer to its visual appearance like color, material, shape, or structure.)
Options:
A. It has a textured, non-slip rubberized walking surface.
B. It is made of polished black metal that reflects the surroundings with mirror-like clarity.
C. It features a simple, rectangular frame with handrails on the sides.
D. It has a digital control panel and display screen.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, modify only the 'unreasonable item' by applying the specific unreasonable feature selected in Round 3. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from Round 2 output.

2. The treadmill is still present in the image and can be recognized as the same object.

3. The treadmill in the image now clearly exhibits the feature: 'made of polished black metal that reflects the surroundings with mirror-like clarity'.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature (the black mirror-metal surface), the treadmill's other characteristics (basic shape, size, presence of handrails/console) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature (the black mirror-metal surface), the treadmill's other characteristics (basic shape, size, presence of handrails/console) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 output image.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a lobby in front of a movie theater ticket counter, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A popcorn machine
B. A movie poster stand
C. A large aquarium fish tank
D. A row of waiting chairs
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a lobby in front of a movie theater ticket counter) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a lobby in front of a movie theater ticket counter.

2. The image contains a large aquarium fish tank that is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the large aquarium fish tank are reasonable and fit the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions refer to its visual appearance such as color, material, shape, or structure.)
Options:
A. Has a smooth, transparent glass surface
B. Contains water and decorative aquatic plants
C. Appears to have a rough, rocky texture with irregular, stone-like edges
D. Features internal lighting to illuminate the water
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain consistent with the image generated in turn 2.

2. The large aquarium fish tank is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The large aquarium fish tank in the image clearly exhibits the feature: 'appears to have a rough, rocky texture with irregular, stone-like edges'.

4. Apart from the applied 'rough, rocky texture with irregular edges', other characteristics of the large aquarium fish tank remain largely consistent with its appearance in the round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in turn 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a hotel front desk check-in counter, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A luggage cart
B. A computer monitor
C. A bouncy castle
D. A stack of registration forms
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a hotel front desk check-in counter) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a hotel front desk check-in counter (e.g., counter, computer, key card holders, staff).

2. The image contains a bouncy castle and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The bouncy castle's scale and perspective are reasonable, and it fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a soft, inflatable, and bouncy surface.
B. It is made of a hard, transparent glass material with sharp edges, allowing you to see its hollow interior.
C. It is brightly colored, typically in primary colors like red, blue, and yellow.
D. It has a simple, geometric shape, often resembling a castle or house.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) are consistent with the image generated in turn 2.

2. The bouncy castle still exists in the image and is recognizable.

3. The bouncy castle in the image now has the feature: 'made of a hard, transparent glass material with sharp edges, allowing you to see its hollow interior,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature, the bouncy castle's other characteristics (e.g., its basic shape, position in the scene) remain largely consistent with the image generated in turn 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in turn 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a narrow hallway corner in a residential building, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?

Options:
A. A stack of cardboard moving boxes
B. A fire extinguisher mounted on the wall
C. A double-door refrigerator
D. A doormat and a pair of shoes
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a narrow hallway corner in a residential building) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 (the double-door refrigerator) into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a narrow hallway corner in a residential building (e.g., tight space, walls, doors, lighting).

2. The image contains a double-door refrigerator and it is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the double-door refrigerator are reasonable, and its appearance fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of its appearance is unreasonable?

Options:
A. It has a smooth, glossy metallic surface.
B. Its exterior is covered in a distinct long-pile plush texture, appearing fluffy like a blanket.
C. It features a rectangular shape with two vertical doors.
D. It has a standard household plug and power cord.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) are consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The double-door refrigerator is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The double-door refrigerator in the image now has the feature 'exterior covered in a distinct long-pile plush texture, appearing fluffy like a blanket,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'fluffy plush texture' feature, other characteristics of the double-door refrigerator (e.g., basic shape, size, position) remain largely consistent with the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene picture generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a bus aisle, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A backpack
B. A shopping bag
C. A double bed
D. A folded stroller
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a bus aisle) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a bus aisle.

2. The image contains a double bed and it is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the double bed are reasonable and fit the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions is unreasonable? (Do not reveal the item's name.)
Options:
A. It has a soft, fabric surface.
B. It is rectangular in shape.
C. Its surface is segmented, hard, and reflective like metal armor.
D. It has a wooden frame.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details are consistent with the image generated in round 2 (composition, background, and environmental state remain unchanged).

2. The double bed is still present in the image and can be identified.

3. The double bed in the image clearly exhibits the feature 'surface is segmented, hard, and reflective like metal armor'.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature, the other characteristics of the double bed remain largely consistent with the image from round 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of the space between the back seat and the door of a taxi, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?

Options:
A. A small umbrella
B. A forgotten water bottle
C. A folded newspaper
D. A grandfather clock
E. None of the above.
output: answer: D

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (the space between the back seat and the door of a taxi) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the space between the back seat and the door of a taxi.

2. The image contains a grandfather clock that is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the grandfather clock are reasonable and fit the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene. (The scene's color tone and atmosphere are defined by the initial generation requirement to depict the space between the back seat and the door of a taxi.)

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: The item's name is not revealed in the options.)

Options:
A. It has a polished wooden exterior.
B. It is made of transparent crystal with distinct faceted edges.
C. It features Roman numeral markings.
D. It has a pendulum hanging inside.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable characteristic selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain unchanged and are consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The grandfather clock is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The grandfather clock in the image possesses the characteristic of being 'made of transparent crystal with distinct faceted edges,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'transparent crystal with faceted edges' feature, the other characteristics of the grandfather clock remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of an aisle in front of a small supermarket's beverage cooler, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. Shopping cart
B. Product price tag
C. Boxing ring
D. Stack of soda crates
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (an aisle in front of a small supermarket's beverage cooler) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts an aisle in front of a small supermarket's beverage cooler.

2. The image contains a clearly visible boxing ring.

3. The boxing ring's scale and perspective are reasonable, fitting the scene's overall color palette and atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions is unreasonable for it?
Options:
A. Has a flat, elevated platform surface.
B. Is constructed from soft, draped fabric that lacks a rigid frame.
C. Features vertical posts at each corner.
D. Is surrounded by ropes on all sides.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain consistent with the image generated in round 2.

2. The boxing ring is still present in the image and can be identified.

3. The boxing ring in the image clearly exhibits the feature: being made of soft, draped fabric that lacks a rigid frame.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature (being made of soft, draped fabric that lacks a rigid frame), the other characteristics of the boxing ring (e.g., its scale, perspective, color, and placement within the scene) remain largely consistent with its depiction in the image generated in round 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the setting of a narrow passageway in front of a night market stall, which one of the following items would be the most illogical and out of place?

Options:
A. A portable folding table
B. A stack of cardboard boxes
C. An ATM machine
D. A vendor's pushcart
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a narrow passageway in front of a night market stall) and naturally incorporate the 'illogical item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a narrow passageway in front of a night market stall, with appropriate elements like stalls, crowds, and lighting.

2. The image contains an ATM machine that is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The ATM machine's scale and perspective are realistic and consistent with the scene's overall color palette and atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'illogical item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which one of the following descriptions of its appearance is illogical?

Options:
A. Made of brushed stainless steel with a digital keypad.
B. Constructed from solid, opaque plastic with sharp, defined edges.
C. Composed of semi-transparent jelly-like material with rounded, slightly flowing edges.
D. Has a matte finish and is rectangular in shape with a card slot.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the illogical feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from Round 2.

2. The ATM machine is still present in the image and can be recognized as such.

3. The ATM machine in the image clearly exhibits the feature of being 'composed of semi-transparent jelly-like material with rounded, slightly flowing edges'.

4. Apart from the applied 'semi-transparent jelly-like' feature, other characteristics of the ATM machine (like its basic shape, size, and position) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a subway station turnstile area, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A backpack
B. A water bottle
C. A bathroom jacuzzi
D. A transit card
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a subway station turnstile area) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a subway station turnstile area.

2. The image contains a bathroom jacuzzi and it is clearly visible.

3. The scale, perspective, and overall color tone of the bathroom jacuzzi are consistent with the scene's atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of its appearance is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a smooth, white ceramic surface.
B. It is made of opaque, matte plastic.
C. It has a deep green metallic sheen, shining like polished copper.
D. It has a rectangular shape with rounded corners.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) match those in the Round 2 output image.

2. The bathroom jacuzzi is still present in the image and can be identified.

3. The bathroom jacuzzi in the image clearly exhibits the feature 'deep green metallic sheen, shining like polished copper'.

4. Apart from the applied 'deep green metallic sheen' feature, the other characteristics of the bathroom jacuzzi remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in the Round 2 output image, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of an open-plan office walkway in a skyscraper, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A stack of printer paper
B. A rolling office chair
C. A potted desk plant
D. A go-kart
E. None of the above.
output: answer: D

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (an open-plan office walkway in a skyscraper) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts an open-plan office walkway in a skyscraper (e.g., cubicles, desks, people working, overhead lighting).

2. The image contains a go-kart that is clearly visible within the office environment.

3. The go-kart's scale and perspective are reasonable relative to the office elements, and its coloring/lighting fits the overall scene's tone and atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Do not name the item.)
Options:
A. Has a sleek, aerodynamic body made of fiberglass or carbon fiber.
B. Is equipped with four rubber tires and a small steering wheel.
C. Has a low-profile chassis and a small seat for one person.
D. Has an exterior covered in obvious long plush fur, soft and fluffy like a sweater.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: D

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) match the output image from Round 2.

2. The go-kart is still present in the image and can be recognized as such.

3. The go-kart in the image now has the feature 'exterior covered in obvious long plush fur, soft and fluffy like a sweater,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the new plush fur exterior, the go-kart's other features (shape, size, position, wheels, etc.) remain largely consistent with the Round 2 image.

4. Apart from the new plush fur exterior, the go-kart's other features (shape, size, position, wheels, etc.) remain largely consistent with the go-kart as depicted in the output image from Round 2.