ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a pen cap being placed onto the tip of a pen.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a pen cap.

2. The image contains the tip of a pen.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of capping, with the pen cap placed over the outer end of the pen tip.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round (capping the pen), what is the most fundamental spatial relationship that should be maintained between the pen cap and the pen tip?

Options:
A. The cap is placed inside the tip.
B. The cap is placed over the outer end of the tip.
C. The cap is placed beside the tip.
D. The cap is placed underneath the tip.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the pen cap with a small paper cup while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that existed between the original two objects. Keep all other elements and the background unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in Round 1.

2. The pen tip remains in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position completely unchanged.

3. The pen cap has been completely removed, with no trace of it remaining.

4. A small paper cup is clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The small paper cup is placed over the outer end of the pen tip, maintaining the 'placed over the outer end' relationship.

5. The small paper cup is placed over the outer end of the pen tip, maintaining the 'placed over the outer end' relationship as described in the correct option (B) from Round 2.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene showing a cork being placed into the mouth of a bottle.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a cork.

2. The image contains the mouth/neck of a bottle.

3. The image clearly shows the action of the cork being inserted into the bottle's mouth, with the cork fitting snugly into and sealing the opening.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first round, which of the following relationships should the cork and the bottle's mouth maintain?

Options:
A. The cork is placed next to the bottle.
B. The cork is inserted into and seals the bottle's opening.
C. The cork is placed on top of the bottle.
D. The cork is placed inside the bottle but does not touch the opening.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the cork with an eraser while keeping the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The bottle's mouth is still present in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position unchanged.

3. The cork has been completely removed, with no trace left.

4. A new eraser is clearly visible in the image.

5. The eraser maintains the same spatial relationship with the bottle's mouth as the cork did (i.e., inserted into and sealing the opening).

6. The image is clearly a modification of the scene from round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: At the counter of a quiet coffee shop, which of the following items would be most out of place?
Options:
A. A laptop
B. A coffee mug
C. A canoe
D. A pastry display case
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (the counter of a quiet coffee shop) and naturally incorporate the 'out-of-place item' selected in round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the counter area of a quiet coffee shop.

2. The image contains a canoe and it is clearly visible.

3. The canoe's scale and perspective are reasonable, fitting the scene's overall color palette and atmosphere. The scene's overall color palette and atmosphere should be consistent with a typical quiet coffee shop counter.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'out-of-place item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It is made of solid wood.
B. It has a long, narrow, boat-like shape.
C. It is made entirely of transparent glass, allowing a clear view of its hollow interior.
D. It is painted in a natural wood color.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain unchanged and are consistent with the image generated in round 2.

2. The canoe is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The canoe in the image possesses the feature 'made entirely of transparent glass, allowing a clear view of its hollow interior' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'transparent glass' feature, the canoe's other characteristics (like its basic shape and position) remain largely consistent with the image generated in round 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene picture generated in round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the setting of a clothing store fitting room hallway in a mall, which of the following items would be most out of place?
Options:
A. A clothing rack with hangers
B. A full-length mirror
C. An outdoor barbecue grill
D. A shopping cart
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a clothing store fitting room hallway in a mall) and naturally incorporate the 'out-of-place item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a clothing store fitting room hallway in a mall (e.g., hallway with fitting room doors, mirrors, clothing racks).

2. The image contains an outdoor barbecue grill and it is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the outdoor barbecue grill are reasonable and fit the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'out-of-place item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions is unreasonable for it?
Options:
A. Made of solid, heavy-duty cast iron with a matte black finish.
B. Constructed from shiny, pure pink plastic with a highly smooth surface and no metallic texture.
C. Has a rectangular shape with a wire cooking grate on top.
D. Features a cylindrical propane tank attached to one side.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image, keeping all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) are consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The outdoor barbecue grill still exists in the image and can be recognized.

3. The outdoor barbecue grill in the image possesses the feature 'made of shiny, pure pink plastic with a highly smooth surface and no metallic texture,' and this feature is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'shiny, pure pink plastic' feature, other characteristics of the outdoor barbecue grill (e.g., shape, size, position, other visual details) remain largely consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene picture generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a rest area next to a badminton court in a sports stadium, which one of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?

Options:
A. A water cooler
B. A bench
C. A cement utility pole
D. A sports bag
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a rest area next to a badminton court in a sports stadium) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a rest area adjacent to a badminton court within a sports stadium.

2. The image contains a cement utility pole that is clearly visible.

3. The scale, perspective, and placement of the cement utility pole are realistic and consistent with the overall tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which one of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: The item's name is not revealed in the options.)

Options:
A. It has a rough, gray, concrete-like surface texture.
B. It is a tall, cylindrical, vertical structure.
C. Its overall appearance is a smooth, glossy white ceramic glaze, shiny like porcelain.
D. It is a solid, sturdy object anchored to the ground.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from round 2.

2. The cement utility pole is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The cement utility pole in the image now has the feature 'overall appearance is a smooth, glossy white ceramic glaze, shiny like porcelain,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from possessing the new 'glossy white ceramic glaze' feature, all other characteristics of the cement utility pole (e.g., its basic shape, structure, placement) remain largely consistent with how it appeared in the round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in round 2, not a completely new generating.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the setting of a small flower shop's indoor display area, which of the following items would be most unreasonable to find present?
Options:
A. Watering can
B. Electric scooter
C. Flower vase
D. Pair of gardening shears
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a small flower shop's indoor display area) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a small flower shop's indoor display area (e.g., shelves with potted plants, bouquets, floral arrangements).

2. The image contains an electric scooter that is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The electric scooter's scale and perspective are reasonable, and its appearance fits the overall color palette and atmosphere of the flower shop setting.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions about it is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a metallic frame and handlebars.
B. It is inflated like a pool toy, with a rounded, puffy shape and no hard structural edges.
C. Its wheels are made of rubber with a tread pattern.
D. It has a digital display screen on the handlebars.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable characteristic selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from Round 2.

2. The electric scooter is still present in the image and can be recognized as such.

3. The electric scooter in the image clearly exhibits the characteristic of being 'inflated like a pool toy, with a rounded, puffy shape and no hard structural edges'.

4. Apart from the newly applied 'inflated' characteristic, other features of the electric scooter (e.g., its basic form, position in the scene) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a bookstore checkout line queueing area, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A stack of bestseller books
B. A shopping basket
C. A heavy punching bag (sandbag)
D. A promotional poster stand
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a bookstore checkout line queueing area) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a bookstore checkout line queueing area (e.g., people waiting, cash register, bookshelves in background).

2. The image contains a heavy punching bag (sandbag) and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale, perspective, and color of the punching bag are consistent with the overall scene's lighting and atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of its appearance is unreasonable? (Do not reveal the item's name.)
Options:
A. It has a cylindrical shape and a rough, canvas-like texture.
B. Its surface is covered in dense, overlapping scales that shimmer like fish scales.
C. It is predominantly dark in color, such as black or dark blue.
D. It is suspended from a chain or rope.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, modify only the 'unreasonable item' by applying the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain identical to the Round 2 output image.

2. The punching bag (sandbag) is still present in the image and can be recognized as the same object.

3. The punching bag now clearly exhibits the feature: its surface is covered in dense, overlapping scales that shimmer like fish scales.

4. Apart from the new scaly texture, other characteristics of the punching bag (shape, size, color tone, suspension) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

4. Apart from the new scaly texture, other characteristics of the punching bag (shape, size, color tone, suspension) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 output image.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of the floor area next to a barber's chair in a barbershop, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. Hair clippers
B. Barber's cape
C. A large bookcase
D. A broom
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (the floor area next to a barber's chair in a barbershop) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the floor area next to a barber's chair in a barbershop.

2. The image contains a large bookcase and it is clearly visible.

3. The scale and perspective of the large bookcase are reasonable, and it fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions about it is unreasonable? (Do not name the item.)
Options:
A. It is made of solid wood with a dark finish.
B. It has multiple shelves for storage.
C. It is made of transparent plastic, allowing its internal structure to be clearly seen through.
D. It is a tall, rectangular piece of furniture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The large bookcase is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The large bookcase in the image now has the feature of being made of transparent plastic, allowing its internal structure to be clearly seen, and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the transparent plastic material, other features of the large bookcase (e.g., its basic shape, size, number of shelves) remain largely consistent with how it appeared in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the setting of a public restroom sink area, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A roll of paper towels
B. A liquid soap dispenser
C. An outdoor traffic sign
D. A hand dryer
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a public restroom sink area) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a public restroom sink area.

2. The image contains an outdoor traffic sign and it is clearly visible.

The scale and perspective of the outdoor traffic sign are reasonable, fitting the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a reflective, smooth metal surface.
B. It is made of a hard, rigid plastic.
C. Its overall surface has a felt-like texture with slightly fluffy edges.
D. It features bold, high-contrast lettering.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain unchanged and are consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The outdoor traffic sign still exists in the image and can be recognized.

3. The outdoor traffic sign in the picture possesses the feature 'overall surface has a felt-like texture with slightly fluffy edges,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'felt-like texture with fluffy edges,' other characteristics of the outdoor traffic sign remain largely consistent with the image from Round 2.

The image is clearly a modification of the scene picture generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: At the entrance to the spectator stands of an outdoor basketball court, which of the following items would be most out of place?
Options:
A. A water cooler
B. A scoreboard
C. A large wardrobe
D. A first-aid kit
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (the entrance to the spectator stands of an outdoor basketball court) and naturally incorporate the 'out-of-place item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the entrance to the spectator stands of an outdoor basketball court.

2. The image contains a large wardrobe that is clearly visible.

The scale and perspective of the large wardrobe are reasonable, and it fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene. (Note: The color tone and atmosphere should be consistent with a typical outdoor basketball court entrance scene.)

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'out-of-place item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a rectangular, boxy shape with flat sides.
B. It is made of painted wood or composite board.
C. Its overall outline is a perfect sphere with a uniformly smooth surface.
D. It likely has doors or drawers for storage.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain unchanged from the output image of Round 2.

2. The large wardrobe is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The large wardrobe in the image possesses the feature 'overall outline is a perfect sphere with a uniformly smooth surface,' and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'perfect spherical shape with a smooth surface,' other characteristics of the large wardrobe remain largely consistent with the image from Round 2.

Apart from the 'perfect spherical shape with a smooth surface,' other characteristics of the large wardrobe (such as its color, texture, and any non-spherical structural details like potential door/drawer indications) remain largely consistent with the large wardrobe in the output image of Round 2.