ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Great Zimbabwe stone walls, conveying a sense of historical weathering and decay.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of Great Zimbabwe, with its distinctive stone wall features.

2. The image conveys a clear sense of incompleteness, weathering, and historical erosion.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features a complex system of arches and domes typical of Islamic architecture.
B. It is characterized by massive, dry-stone walls built without mortar, forming enclosures and conical towers.
C. Its primary construction material is fired brick, arranged in intricate geometric patterns.
D. The structure is defined by its use of large, precisely cut stone blocks with metal clamps, similar to classical Greek temples.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, please modify it to restore the monument. Depict it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing architectural sections from the Turn 1 image are filled in, restoring the structure to a complete form.

2. The surface materials of the building appear new, with no signs of weathering or erosion.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the architectural style described in Turn 2's correct option B: 'massive, dry-stone walls built without mortar, forming enclosures and conical towers', which is characteristic of the Shona civilization and the era of Great Zimbabwe.

The image background, camera perspective, and non-essential elements are highly consistent with the input image from Turn 1.

The image is clearly identifiable as a modification of the input image from Turn 1, not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Gate of the Sun at Tiwanaku, Bolivia, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of the Gate of the Sun at Tiwanaku, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, erosion, and other signs of historical wear and tear.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It is a massive stone archway with intricate carvings of celestial beings and a central deity figure, typical of the Tiwanaku civilization.
B. It is a tall, slender obelisk covered in hieroglyphic inscriptions, characteristic of ancient Egyptian architecture.
C. It is a circular, open-air amphitheater built with concentric stone rings, resembling Roman construction.
D. It is a multi-tiered wooden pagoda with upturned eaves, a common style in East Asian temple architecture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this monument, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing or damaged parts of the structure have been reconstructed, restoring it to a complete form.

2. The surface materials of the structure appear new, with no signs of weathering or erosion.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Tiwanaku civilization and its historical period.

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the image generated in Turn 1 (the unrestored ruins of the Gate of the Sun at Tiwanaku).

The image is clearly recognizable as a modified version of the image generated in Turn 1 (the unrestored ruins of the Gate of the Sun at Tiwanaku), not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Copán Maya Site in Honduras, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Copán Maya Site, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, erosion, and signs of historical decay.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this building ruin?

Options:
A. Characterized by large, smooth-faced stone blocks and corbeled arches, typical of the Maya civilization.
B. Features intricate stone carvings, hieroglyphic stairways, and ceremonial ball courts, hallmarks of the Classic Maya period.
C. Built primarily from mudbrick and featuring pointed arches, characteristic of later Mesoamerican cultures.
D. Constructed with massive, unadorned stone slabs in a cyclopean style, common to earlier Olmec architecture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this ancient site. Generate it in its complete, glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections are filled in, and the structure is restored to completeness.

2. The building's surface materials appear new, with no signs of weathering or erosion.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Maya civilization and the Classic period.

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image (the ruins of the Copán Maya Site).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 input image, not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Mycenae Lion Gate in Greece, conveying a sense of historical wear, damage, and the passage of time.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of the Mycenae Lion Gate, with its distinctive features (e.g., the massive stone lintel and the relief of two lions) visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, weathering (e.g., cracks, erosion, missing stones), and historical decay, evoking a sense of age and ruin.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this building's ruins?
Options:
A. Features a true arch and extensive use of concrete, characteristic of Roman engineering.
B. Constructed using Cyclopean masonry with massive, irregular limestone blocks and a corbeled arch (relieving triangle) above the lintel.
C. Built with precisely cut marble blocks and decorated with intricate Ionic or Corinthian column capitals.
D. Characterized by its pointed arches, ribbed vaults, and flying buttresses, typical of Gothic cathedrals.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this monument, depicting it in its complete, newly-built, and glorious state when it was first constructed.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural parts (e.g., any missing stones in the walls, the gate structure) are filled in, and the overall structure appears whole and intact.

2. The surface materials of the building (e.g., the limestone blocks) look new, clean, and polished, with no signs of weathering, cracks, or erosion.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Mycenaean civilization/era (Late Bronze Age Greece), featuring Cyclopean masonry and the iconic lion relief, without anachronistic elements.

The image background, camera perspective/angle, lighting, and any non-architectural elements (e.g., sky, ground, distant landscape) are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image (the unrestored ruins of the Mycenae Lion Gate).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 input image (the unrestored ruins of the Mycenae Lion Gate), not a completely new, unrelated illustration from scratch.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current ruins of the Palace of Knossos on Crete, showing the site as it exists today in an unrestored state, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Palace of Knossos, with its distinctive features visible.

2. The image conveys a clear sense of damage, decay, and the passage of time through visible crumbling, missing sections, and weathering effects.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this building's ruins?
Options:
A. Characterized by massive stone trilithons and sarsen stones arranged in a circle.
B. Known for its extensive use of frescoes depicting bull-leaping scenes and complex multi-story layout with light wells.
C. Features a central nave, side aisles, and a large rose window on the western facade.
D. Built primarily from adobe bricks and features a series of stepped platforms forming a pyramid shape.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to reconstruct the Palace of Knossos, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections from the Turn 1 image are restored, making the structure appear whole and complete.

2. The building's surface materials appear new, without signs of weathering, erosion, or aging.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with Minoan civilization (Bronze Age Crete) characteristics.

The image background, camera/viewing angle, and non-essential elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (which depicted the ruins of the Palace of Knossos).

The image is clearly a modified version of the Turn 1 output image (which depicted the ruins of the Palace of Knossos), not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current state of the interior of the Roman Colosseum, showing the existing ruins and broken walls, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Roman Colosseum, with distinct architectural features.

2. The image conveys a clear sense of damage, weathering, and historical decay.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features a large central dome and four minarets.
B. It is constructed primarily from wood with intricate latticework.
C. It is an elliptical amphitheater built with travertine limestone, concrete, and tuff.
D. It has a stepped pyramid structure with a temple at the summit.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, modify it to restore the Colosseum to its original, complete, and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing architectural parts of the Colosseum are restored, and its structure appears complete.

2. The building's surface materials appear new, without signs of weathering or aging.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Roman civilization and era to which the Colosseum belongs, specifically as an elliptical amphitheater built with travertine limestone, concrete, and tuff (as confirmed by the correct answer in Turn 2).

The image background, camera perspective, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 input image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 input image, not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the Temple of Jupiter in Baalbek, Lebanon, conveying a sense of historical decay and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of the Temple of Jupiter in Baalbek, with its distinctive features (such as the massive stone blocks and remaining columns) prominently visible.

2. The image clearly conveys a sense of ruin, with visible signs of collapse, weathering, erosion, and other historical damage.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this building's ruins?
Options:
A. A structure characterized by pointed arches, ribbed vaults, and flying buttresses.
B. A structure built with massive, precisely cut stone blocks, featuring a colonnade of Corinthian columns and a monumental podium.
C. A structure made primarily of wood and paper, with curved roofs and intricate bracketing systems.
D. A structure built from adobe bricks, featuring stepped pyramids and intricate stone carvings of deities.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this ancient site, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing parts of the building (e.g., collapsed columns, walls, pediment) have been reconstructed, restoring the structure to its full, intended form.

2. The surface materials of the building (stone) appear new, polished, and intact, with no signs of weathering, cracks, or erosion.

3. The restored architectural style (Roman, with Corinthian columns and monumental scale) remains consistent with the historical and cultural context of the Temple of Jupiter in Baalbek.

The image background, camera angle/perspective, lighting, and any non-architectural elements (e.g., sky, ground) are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins), with the base ruins (e.g., the massive stone blocks and remaining columns) being recognizable but repaired, not a completely new, unrelated illustration.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of the ancient city walls of Troy in Turkey, conveying a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the ancient city walls of Troy, with distinctive features.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, erosion, and signs of historical wear and tear.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of these ruins?
Options:
A. Constructed primarily of large, precisely cut marble blocks with intricate Corinthian column capitals.
B. Built using a combination of large limestone blocks and smaller stones, featuring sloping defensive walls and projecting towers.
C. Characterized by massive, smooth-faced stone blocks assembled without mortar, forming a cyclopean structure.
D. Featuring a series of concentric circular walls made of timber and earthworks.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this ancient site, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The missing parts of the structure are filled in, restoring it to a complete form.

2. The surface materials of the structure appear new, with no signs of weathering.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the correct description of the ruins from Turn 2, which is 'Built using a combination of large limestone blocks and smaller stones, featuring sloping defensive walls and projecting towers.'

The image background, camera angle, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins).

The image is clearly recognizable as a modification of the Turn 1 output image (the unrestored ruins), not a completely new generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current, unrestored ruins of Hadrian's Villa in Italy, conveying a sense of historical weathering and decay.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of Hadrian's Villa, with its distinctive architectural features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant damage, weathering, and other signs of historical passage of time.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this ruin?
Options:
A. It features a series of interconnected domes and a central oculus, typical of Roman bath complexes.
B. Its design is characterized by pointed arches and flying buttresses, common in Gothic cathedrals.
C. The structure includes a hypostyle hall with massive columns and a flat roof, indicative of Ancient Egyptian temple architecture.
D. The complex showcases a blend of Roman architectural elements with influences from Greek and Egyptian styles, reflecting the eclectic tastes of Emperor Hadrian.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: D

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this ancient site, depicting it in its complete and glorious state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections of the building have been filled in, restoring its complete structure.

2. The surface materials of the building appear new, with no signs of weathering or aging.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the civilization and era to which Hadrian's Villa belongs (i.e., Roman Imperial architecture).

The image background, camera perspective, and unrelated elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image (which depicted the unrestored ruins of Hadrian's Villa).

The image is clearly identifiable as a modification of the Turn 1 output image (which depicted the unrestored ruins of Hadrian's Villa), not a completely new, unrelated generation.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current ruined state of the Abbey of Jumièges in France, depicting it as an unrestored ruin that conveys a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject in the image is clearly recognizable as the ruins of the Abbey of Jumièges, with its distinctive architectural features visible.

2. The scene clearly depicts significant structural damage, weathering, and historical decay, such as crumbling walls, missing roofs, and overgrown vegetation.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes the architectural style or structural features of this building's ruins?

Options:
A. It features a central dome and minarets, typical of Islamic architecture.
B. It has a symmetrical layout with a large central nave and twin western towers, characteristic of Romanesque architecture.
C. It includes flying buttresses and extensive stained glass windows, indicative of High Gothic style.
D. It is constructed primarily of wood with intricate carvings, common in traditional Japanese architecture.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Please modify the image from Turn 1 to restore this historical site. Generate it in its complete, magnificent state as it would have appeared when first built.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections (e.g., roofs, walls, towers) are reconstructed, restoring the building's complete structural form.

2. The building's surface materials appear new and pristine, with no signs of weathering, erosion, or discoloration.

The restored architectural style remains consistent with the Romanesque architecture described in Turn 2's correct option (symmetrical layout with a large central nave and twin western towers).

The image background, camera perspective, and non-architectural elements (e.g., sky, ground, vegetation placement) maintain high consistency with the Turn 1 output image.

The image is clearly identifiable as a modified version of the Turn 1 output image, not a completely new illustration from scratch.
Domain: Damage_Repair / relic_restoration

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate the current ruins of Urquhart Castle in Scotland, depicting the scene of the site as it exists today, unrepaired. The image should convey a sense of historical weathering and damage.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The main subject of the image is clearly identifiable as the ruins of Urquhart Castle, with its distinctive features (e.g., remaining tower, location on Loch Ness).

2. The image clearly depicts significant damage, decay, and weathering (e.g., crumbling walls, missing sections, overgrown vegetation) to convey a sense of historical passage and ruin.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: Which of the following options correctly describes a key architectural style or structural feature of this castle ruin?

Options:
A. It was originally built with a central keep surrounded by concentric curtain walls, typical of 13th-century Scottish castles.
B. Its primary structure featured a large, rectangular great hall with timber framing, common in early medieval Scottish architecture.
C. The castle's design was heavily influenced by Romanesque architecture, featuring rounded arches and thick, squat towers.
D. The fortress utilized a motte-and-bailey design with a wooden palisade, characteristic of early Norman fortifications in Scotland.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: A

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Turn 1, please modify it to restore the castle. Generate Urquhart Castle in its complete, newly-built, and glorious state as it would have appeared when first constructed.
output: evaluation_points: 1. Missing architectural sections (e.g., collapsed walls, the missing part of the Grant Tower) are reconstructed, restoring the castle's full and intended structure.

2. The building's surface materials (stonework) appear new, clean, and without signs of weathering, erosion, or vegetation overgrowth.

3. The restored architectural style remains consistent with the 13th-16th century Scottish castle architecture of Urquhart (e.g., stone construction, key features like the tower and curtain walls).

The image background (e.g., Loch Ness, surrounding landscape), camera/viewpoint angle, and any non-architectural elements are highly consistent with the Turn 1 output image.

The image is clearly a modification of the Turn 1 output image (e.g., the underlying ruin structure is recognizable, with parts added/repaired), not a completely new, unrelated illustration.