ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of 'beside a parking spot in an indoor garage', which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A car jack
B. A fire extinguisher
C. A supermarket checkout conveyor belt
D. A parking sign
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (beside a parking spot in an indoor garage) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the setting of 'beside a parking spot in an indoor garage' (e.g., concrete floor, marked parking lines, garage walls/ceiling, vehicles).

2. The image contains a 'supermarket checkout conveyor belt' and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale, perspective, and placement of the 'supermarket checkout conveyor belt' are plausible within the scene, and its color/lighting matches the overall tone and atmosphere of the indoor garage.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Do not name the item.)
Options:
A. It has a flat, rigid surface suitable for sliding objects.
B. It is made of a hard, durable plastic or metal material.
C. Its overall structure is visibly twisted, bent, and deformed like soft rubber, holding that shape.
D. It has a consistent width and parallel sides.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable characteristic selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, lighting, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from Round 2 output.

2. The 'supermarket checkout conveyor belt' is still present in the image and can be recognized as such.

3. The depicted 'supermarket checkout conveyor belt' clearly exhibits the characteristic of being 'visibly twisted, bent, and deformed like soft rubber, holding that shape'.

4. Apart from the applied 'twisted, bent, deformed' characteristic, other features of the 'supermarket checkout conveyor belt' (e.g., basic form, color, surface pattern) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2 output, not a completely new generation from scratch.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a 'doorway passage in a home utility room', which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A stack of cardboard boxes
B. A vacuum cleaner
C. A large commercial freezer
D. A broom and dustpan
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a doorway passage in a home utility room) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a doorway passage in a home utility room (e.g., cluttered space, household items, typical door frame).

2. The image contains a large commercial freezer and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale and perspective of the large commercial freezer are reasonable, and it fits the overall color palette and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of its appearance is unreasonable? (Do not name the item.)
Options:
A. It has a metallic exterior with sharp, clean edges.
B. It is made of a semi-transparent jelly-like material with rounded, slightly sagging edges.
C. Its surface is smooth white plastic with visible hinges.
D. It features a sturdy, opaque construction with a glossy finish.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The large commercial freezer is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The large commercial freezer in the image now has the feature of being 'made of a semi-transparent jelly-like material with rounded, slightly sagging edges', and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the applied unreasonable feature (semi-transparent jelly-like material, etc.), other characteristics of the large commercial freezer (e.g., its basic form, size, position) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of 'the floor of a balcony laundry drying area', which one of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A laundry basket
B. A potted plant
C. A restaurant round table
D. A pair of slippers
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (the floor of a balcony laundry drying area) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the floor of a balcony laundry drying area (e.g., showing elements like a clothesline, hanging laundry, balcony railings, floor tiles/boards).

2. The image contains a restaurant round table and it is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale and perspective of the restaurant round table are reasonable, and its appearance fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which one of the following descriptions about it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions are about its visual appearance such as color, material, shape, or structure, and do not reveal the item's name.)
Options:
A. It has a smooth, polished wooden surface.
B. Its entire surface is covered in a dense, scaly texture with a fish-scale-like sheen.
C. It is supported by a central pedestal base.
D. It has a perfectly circular top.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, and environmental state) remain unchanged and are consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The restaurant round table is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The restaurant round table in the image now has the feature 'its entire surface is covered in a dense, scaly texture with a fish-scale-like sheen', and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the applied scaly texture feature, all other characteristics of the restaurant round table (e.g., its basic shape, size, position) remain largely consistent with how it appeared in the image generated in Round 2.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: At the location 'beside the fence at the downstairs garbage disposal point', which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?

Options:
A. A trash bag
B. A recycling bin
C. A three-seater sofa
D. A pair of work gloves
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (beside the fence at a downstairs garbage disposal point) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the setting of 'beside the fence at a downstairs garbage disposal point' (e.g., showing a fence, garbage/recycling bins, a disposal area).

2. The image contains a 'three-seater sofa' that is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale and perspective of the 'three-seater sofa' are reasonable, and its appearance fits the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions refer to its visual appearance—color, material, shape, structure, etc.—and do not name the item.)

Options:
A. It has a fabric upholstery with a subtle pattern.
B. It is shaped like a perfect cube with sharp, straight edges and no cushioning or soft contours.
C. Its frame is made of stained wood with visible grain.
D. It has three distinct seat cushions.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, modify ONLY the 'unreasonable item' by applying the unreasonable feature selected in round 3. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain unchanged from the image generated in turn 2.

2. The 'three-seater sofa' is still present in the image and can be recognized as such.

3. The 'three-seater sofa' in the image now has the feature 'shaped like a perfect cube with sharp, straight edges and no cushioning or soft contours', and this change is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the modified 'cube shape with sharp edges', other characteristics of the 'three-seater sofa' (e.g., its relative position, basic color scheme) remain largely consistent with the image generated in turn 2.

5. The image is clearly a modified version of the scene generated in turn 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of 'beside the security guard booth at the entrance of a residential complex', which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. A security camera
B. A fire extinguisher
C. A potted plant
D. A boxing heavy bag
E. None of the above.
output: answer: D

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts the setting of 'beside the security guard booth at the entrance of a residential complex'.

2. The image contains a 'boxing heavy bag' that is clearly visible.

3. The scale, perspective, and overall appearance of the 'boxing heavy bag' are reasonable and consistent with the scene's overall color palette and atmosphere.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of its appearance is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It is made of a durable, dark-colored synthetic leather.
B. It is cylindrical in shape and hangs from a chain.
C. It is made of transparent crystal with distinct angular facets.
D. It has a textured surface for better grip.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in round 3 to that specific item in the image, keeping all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image from round 2 output.

2. The 'boxing heavy bag' is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The 'boxing heavy bag' in the image possesses the feature 'made of transparent crystal with distinct angular facets', and this is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the 'transparent crystal with angular facets' feature, other characteristics of the 'boxing heavy bag' remain largely consistent with its appearance in the round 2 image.

5. The image is clearly a modification of the scene picture generated in round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a waiting area at the entrance to an office building elevator, which of the following items would be the most unreasonable to find present?

Options:
A. A stack of magazines and newspapers.
B. A small potted plant.
C. A grand piano.
D. A wall-mounted directory board.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a waiting area at an office building elevator entrance) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a waiting area at an office building elevator entrance (e.g., showing elevator doors, a waiting area with seating, corporate decor).

2. The image contains a grand piano that is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The grand piano's scale and perspective are realistic and consistent with the scene, and its appearance fits the overall color palette and atmosphere of the office environment.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which one of the following descriptions about it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions refer to its visual appearance such as color, material, shape, or structure.)

Options:
A. It has a glossy, polished wooden finish.
B. Its overall outline has been transformed into a perfect cube with sharp, regular edges and corners.
C. It features a row of black and white keys.
D. It is supported by three sturdy legs.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply *only* the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain consistent with the image generated in Round 2.

2. The grand piano is still present in the image and remains recognizable as a piano.

3. The grand piano in the image now possesses the feature 'its overall outline is a perfect cube with sharp, regular edges and corners,' and this modification is clearly visible.

4. Apart from the modified cubic shape, the grand piano's other characteristics (e.g., color, material texture of the body, the presence of keys and legs) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

4. Apart from the modified cubic shape, the grand piano's other characteristics (e.g., color, material texture of the body, the presence of keys and legs) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the image generated in Round 2.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the setting of a family living room's coffee table area in front of the sofa, which one of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. Television remote control
B. Stack of magazines
C. Street lamp post
D. Coffee mug
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (a family living room's coffee table area in front of the sofa) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a family living room's coffee table area in front of a sofa.

2. The image contains a street lamp post and it is clearly visible.

The scale and perspective of the street lamp post are reasonable, fitting the overall color tone and atmosphere of the scene.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which one of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: Descriptions refer to its visual appearance such as color, material, shape, or structure, and do not reveal the item's name.)
Options:
A. Has a metallic, slightly rusted surface.
B. Is cylindrical and tall with a light fixture at the top.
C. Has a surface with a wood-grain texture and distinct growth rings, as if carved from a log.
D. Is painted a dark green or gray color.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: The overall scene details are consistent with the image generated in Round 2 (composition, background, and environmental state remain unchanged).

2. The street lamp post is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The street lamp post in the image clearly exhibits the feature: a surface with a wood-grain texture and distinct growth rings, as if carved from a log.

4. Apart from possessing this wood-like texture feature, the other characteristics of the street lamp post (e.g., its basic cylindrical shape, presence of a light fixture) remain largely consistent with its appearance in the Round 2 image.

The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of a bedroom walkway beside the bed, which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?
Options:
A. Nightstand
B. Floor lamp
C. Vending machine
D. Area rug
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round, and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into this scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a bedroom walkway beside a bed.

2. The image contains a vending machine that is clearly visible.

The scale and perspective of the vending machine are reasonable, fitting the overall color palette and atmosphere of the scene. The color palette and atmosphere should be consistent with a typical bedroom walkway.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions is unreasonable?
Options:
A. It has a metallic exterior with a glass front panel.
B. It is brightly lit with internal LED displays.
C. It is noticeably bent and sagging like soft rubber, with edges lacking rigidity.
D. It has a rectangular shape with product selection buttons.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable feature selected in Round 3 to that item in the image, keeping all other scene contents unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: The overall scene details are consistent with the image generated in Round 2 (composition, background, and environmental state unchanged).

2. The vending machine is still present in the image and can be recognized.

3. The vending machine in the image clearly exhibits the feature: noticeably bent and sagging like soft rubber, with edges lacking rigidity.

4. Apart from the unreasonable feature, other characteristics of the vending machine remain largely consistent with the image from Round 2.

The image is clearly a modification of the scene generated in Round 2, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / compound_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: text
input: In the context of 'beside the kitchen counter between the sink and the stove', which of the following items would be most unreasonably out of place?

Options:
A. A set of kitchen knives
B. A large suitcase
C. A cutting board
D. A mixing bowl
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 2
modality: image
input: Please generate the scene mentioned in the previous round (beside the kitchen counter between the sink and the stove) and naturally incorporate the 'unreasonable item' selected in Round 1 into the scene, making it clearly visible.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene clearly depicts a kitchen counter area positioned between a sink and a stove.

2. The image contains a large suitcase that is clearly visible within the scene.

3. The scale and perspective of the large suitcase are realistic, and its appearance fits the overall color palette and atmosphere of the kitchen setting.

turn: 3
modality: text
input: Regarding the 'unreasonable item' that was added to the scene in the second round, which of the following descriptions of it is unreasonable? (Note: The item's name is not revealed in the options.)

Options:
A. It has a hard, rigid exterior.
B. Its outer shell is made of transparent ice, giving it a crystalline, refractive appearance.
C. It features a retractable handle.
D. It has sturdy wheels at its base.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 4
modality: image
input: Based on the image from Round 2, apply only the unreasonable characteristic selected in Round 3 to that specific item in the image. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged. Please generate the modified image.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The overall scene details (composition, background, environmental state) remain identical to those in the reference image.

2. The large suitcase is still present in the image and is recognizable as such.

3. The large suitcase in the image now clearly exhibits the characteristic of having an 'outer shell made of transparent ice, giving it a crystalline, refractive appearance'.

4. Apart from the newly applied transparent-ice-shell feature, all other characteristics of the large suitcase (e.g., its basic shape, size, position) remain largely consistent with how it appeared in the Round 2 image.

4. Apart from the newly applied transparent-ice-shell feature, all other characteristics of the large suitcase (e.g., its basic shape, size, position) remain largely consistent with how it appeared in the reference image.