ccccEsion/IMUG-Bench huggingface dataset:
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting someone putting a hat on their head.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image must contain a hat.

2. The image must contain a head.

3. The image must clearly depict the action of putting a hat on a head, with the hat positioned on the outside of the head.

4. The overall scene should be realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (putting a hat on a head), what is the most fundamental spatial relationship that should be maintained between the two objects?

Options:
A. One object is placed inside the other.
B. One object is placed on top of the other.
C. One object is placed underneath the other.
D. One object is placed beside the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you generated in the first round, replace the hat with a small pot while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene's environment, background, and details must be consistent with the image generated in round 1.

The head must remain in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged.

3. The hat must be completely removed from the image, with no remaining parts.

4. A small pot must be clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The small pot must maintain the same 'placed on the outside of' spatial relationship with the head that the hat originally had.

The small pot must maintain the same 'placed on the outside of' spatial relationship with the head that the hat originally had in the image generated in round 1.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the action of putting a sock onto a foot.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a sock.

2. The image contains a foot.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of putting on a sock, with the sock being pulled over the foot, covering it.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (putting on a sock), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the sock and the foot?

Options:
A. The sock is placed underneath the foot.
B. The sock is wrapped around the foot.
C. The sock is placed beside the foot.
D. The sock is attached to the top of the foot.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the sock with a paper cup while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that originally existed between the sock and the foot. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The environmental state, background, and scene details are consistent with the image generated in turn 1.

2. The foot remains in the image, with its shape, color, texture, and position unchanged relative to the image generated in turn 1.

3. The sock is completely removed from the image, with no trace left behind.

4. A paper cup is clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The paper cup maintains the original spatial relationship of 'covering' the foot, as the sock did.

6. The image is clearly a modified version of the scene from the image generated in turn 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the action of putting a phone into its case.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a smartphone.

2. The image contains a phone case.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the phone fitting inside the case and being secured by its edges.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first image (putting the phone into its case), what is the most fundamental spatial relationship that must be maintained between the phone and the phone case?

Options:
A. The phone is placed on top of the phone case.
B. The phone is inserted inside the phone case and secured by its edges.
C. The phone case is attached to the side of the phone.
D. The phone and phone case are placed next to each other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you generated in the first image, replace the phone with a lunch box. Keep the exact same spatial relationship that originally existed between the two objects. All other elements in the scene should remain unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene's environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in turn 1.

2. The phone case is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged from the image generated in turn 1.

3. The phone has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A lunch box is now clearly visible in the image.

5. The lunch box maintains the same spatial relationship with the phone case as the phone did: it is inserted inside the case and secured by its edges.

5. The lunch box maintains the same spatial relationship with the phone case as the phone did in the image generated in turn 1: it is inserted inside the case and secured by its edges.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a pair of glasses being closed and placed inside its case.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image must contain a pair of glasses.

2. The image must contain a glasses case.

3. The image must clearly depict the action of placing the glasses into the case, with the glasses located inside the enclosed space of the case.

4. The overall scene should be realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (placing the glasses into the case), what is the most fundamental spatial relationship that should exist between the glasses and the case?

Options:
A. The glasses are placed on top of the case.
B. The glasses are located inside the enclosed space of the case.
C. The glasses are positioned beside the case.
D. The glasses are attached to the outside of the case.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the glasses with a plastic water cup while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that originally existed between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene's environment, background, and details must be consistent with the image generated in round 1.

The glasses case must remain in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged compared to the image generated in round 1.

3. The glasses must be completely removed from the image, with no remaining parts.

4. A plastic water cup must be clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The plastic water cup must maintain the same spatial relationship with the case as the glasses did: located inside the enclosed space of the case.

The image must clearly appear to be a modified version of the scene from the image generated in round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a coin being inserted into a coin slot.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a coin.

2. The image contains a coin slot.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the coin and coin slot satisfying the relationship where the coin passes through the narrow opening of the slot.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round (inserting a coin into a slot), which of the following relationships should be maintained between the coin and the coin slot?

Options:
A. The coin rests on top of the slot.
B. The coin passes through a narrow opening in the slot.
C. The coin is placed beside the slot.
D. The coin is magnetically attached to the slot.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you drew in the first round, replace the coin with a button while keeping the original spatial relationship between the two objects. All other elements in the scene should remain unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in turn 1.

2. The coin slot is still present in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged from the image generated in turn 1.

3. The coin has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A button is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The button maintains the same spatial relationship with the coin slot as the coin did (i.e., passing through the narrow opening).

5. The button maintains the same spatial relationship with the coin slot as the coin did in the image generated in turn 1 (i.e., passing through the narrow opening).
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the following: a piece of paper is being inserted into a document folder.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a piece of paper.

2. The image contains a document folder.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the paper entering the folder's opening and being mostly enveloped by the folder.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first image, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the piece of paper and the document folder?

Options:
A. The first object is placed on top of the second object.
B. The first object is placed beside the second object.
C. The first object enters an opening in the second object and is mostly enveloped by it.
D. The first object is completely inside and sealed within the second object.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the piece of paper with a towel while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements and the background unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in Round 1.

The document folder is still present in the image, with its shape, color, texture, and position unchanged.

3. The piece of paper is completely removed, with no trace of it remaining.

4. A towel is clearly visible and has been added to the scene.

5. The towel maintains the same spatial relationship with the document folder as the paper did: it enters the folder's opening and is mostly enveloped by it.

The towel maintains the same spatial relationship with the document folder as the paper did in the image generated in Round 1: it enters the folder's opening and is mostly enveloped by it.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the action of putting a photo into a picture frame.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a photograph.

2. The image contains a picture frame.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of putting a photo into a frame, with the photo's transparent surface flush against the frame's glass and secured in place by the frame's border.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action from the first round (putting a photo into a frame), what is the most essential spatial relationship that should be maintained between the photograph and the picture frame?

Options:
A. The photograph is placed behind the frame.
B. The photograph is placed on top of the frame.
C. The photograph is placed inside the frame, with its surface flush against the glass and secured by the border.
D. The photograph is placed beside the frame.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: C

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the photograph with a bag of potato chips while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that the original two objects had. Keep all other environmental elements and details unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The picture frame is still present in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position completely unchanged.

3. The photograph has been completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A bag of potato chips is newly present in the image and is clearly visible.

5. The bag of potato chips maintains the same spatial relationship with the picture frame as the photograph did: its surface is flush against the frame's glass and it is secured in place by the border.

5. The bag of potato chips maintains the same spatial relationship with the picture frame as the photograph did in the image generated in round 1: its surface is flush against the frame's glass and it is secured in place by the border.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a padlock being fastened onto a hasp staple.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a padlock.

2. The image contains a hasp staple.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of fastening, with the padlock's shackle passing through the ring opening of the hasp staple and being in a closed/locked state.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with appropriate scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round (fastening the padlock onto the hasp staple), what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the padlock and the hasp staple?

Options:
A. The padlock is placed on top of the hasp staple.
B. The padlock's shackle passes through the ring opening of the hasp staple and remains closed.
C. The padlock is attached to the side of the hasp staple.
D. The padlock is positioned next to the hasp staple.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the padlock with a binder clip while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that existed between the original two objects. Keep all other environmental elements and details unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and all other details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The hasp staple remains in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position completely unchanged.

3. The padlock is completely removed from the scene, with no remaining parts.

4. A binder clip is clearly visible and present in the image.

5. The binder clip maintains the same spatial relationship with the hasp staple as the padlock did: its metal arms pass through the ring opening of the hasp staple and are in a closed position.

5. The binder clip maintains the same spatial relationship with the hasp staple as the padlock did in the image generated in round 1: its metal arms pass through the ring opening of the hasp staple and are in a closed position.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene showing a USB flash drive being inserted into a USB port.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a USB flash drive.

2. The image contains a USB port.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of insertion, with the USB flash drive satisfying the relationship of being inserted into the opening of the USB port.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first round, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the USB flash drive and the USB port?
Options:
A. The USB flash drive is placed on top of the USB port.
B. The USB flash drive is inserted into the opening of the USB port.
C. The USB flash drive is connected to the USB port via a cable.
D. The USB flash drive is positioned next to the USB port.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in the first round, replace the USB flash drive with a lipstick while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The USB port remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, texture, position) unchanged.

3. The USB flash drive is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A lipstick is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The lipstick maintains the same spatial relationship with the USB port as the original USB flash drive did (i.e., inserted into its opening).

6. The image is clearly a modified version of the scene from round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene showing a zipper slider being aligned and inserted into a zipper box.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a zipper slider.

2. The image contains a zipper box.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of aligning and inserting, with the zipper slider positioned to fit into the slot of the zipper box.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action shown in the first image, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the zipper slider and the zipper box?

Options:
A. One object is placed on top of the other.
B. One object is inserted into a matching receptacle of the other.
C. The two objects are connected by a hinge or pivot point.
D. The two objects are magnetically attracted to each other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the zipper slider with a key while maintaining the exact same spatial relationship that originally existed between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in turn 1.

2. The zipper box remains in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position completely unchanged from the image generated in turn 1.

3. The zipper slider has been completely removed, with no residual parts visible.

4. A key is clearly visible and newly present in the image.

5. The key maintains the same 'aligned and inserted into the slot' spatial relationship with the zipper box that the zipper slider originally had.

6. The image is clearly a modified version of the scene from turn 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting the action of fastening a button into a buttonhole.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a button.

2. The image contains a buttonhole.

3. The image clearly depicts the action of fastening, with the button passing through the hole of the buttonhole and resting on the other side.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with proper scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action in the first round, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the button and the buttonhole?

Options:
A. One object is placed on top of the other.
B. One object passes through an opening in the other and remains on the opposite side.
C. One object is glued to the other.
D. One object is placed next to the other.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene you drew in the first round, replace the button with a coin while maintaining the original spatial relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements of the scene unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in round 1.

2. The buttonhole remains in the image, with its shape, color, material, and position unchanged.

3. The button is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A coin is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The coin maintains the same spatial relationship with the buttonhole as the button did (i.e., passing through the hole and resting on the other side).

6. The image is clearly a modification of the scene from round 1, not a completely new generation.
Domain: Counterintuitive_Reasoning / action_relation_mismatch

turn: 1
modality: image
input: Please generate a realistic scene depicting a keychain being hung on a hook.
output: evaluation_points: 1. The image contains a keychain.

2. The image contains a hook.

3. The image clearly depicts the action/state of hanging, with the keychain and hook satisfying the relationship where the keychain is hanging on and supported by the hook.

4. The overall scene is realistic and natural, with reasonable scale and perspective.

turn: 2
modality: text
input: To achieve the action/state from Round 1, what is the most fundamental relationship that should be maintained between the keychain and the hook?

Options:
A. The keychain is placed next to the hook.
B. The keychain is hanging on and supported by the hook.
C. The keychain is inside the hook.
D. The keychain is attached to the hook with adhesive.
E. None of the above.
output: answer: B

turn: 3
modality: image
input: Based on the scene image you generated in Round 1, replace the keychain with a banana while maintaining the original relative relationship between the two objects. Keep all other elements unchanged.
output: evaluation_points: The scene environment, background, and details are consistent with the image generated in Round 1.

The hook remains in the image, with all its details (shape, color, material, position) unchanged compared to the image generated in Round 1.

3. The keychain is completely removed, with no remaining parts.

4. A banana is newly added to the image and is clearly visible.

5. The banana maintains the same relative relationship with the hook as the keychain did (i.e., hanging on and supported by the hook).

The banana maintains the same relative relationship with the hook as the keychain did in the image generated in Round 1 (i.e., hanging on and supported by the hook).