Allie has 9 - 1 = <<9-1=8>>8 toys of the same value.
Without the value of the one $12 toy, all 8 other toys are worth in total 52 - 12 = $<<52-12=40>>40.
That would mean, that one of the other toys is worth 40 / 8 = $<<40/8=5>>5.
#### 5