Role of apoptosis and autophagy in ovarian follicle pool decline in children and women diagnosed with benign or malignant extra-ovarian conditions
Authors: Cacciottola L , Camboni A , Cernogoraz A , Donnez J , Dolmans M M 
Published: November 2022

Abstract

STUDY QUESTION
Which biological mechanisms are responsible for physiological ovarian reserve decline owing to aging, or pathological follicle depletion triggered by inflammation or a pro-oxidant environment throughout a woman’s lifetime?

SUMMARY ANSWER
Ovarian follicle pool size is modulated by both apoptosis and autophagy, the first responsible for its physiological decline over time and increasing in the event of prior chemotherapy in children, and the latter playing a major role in physiological ovarian follicle pool diminution before puberty.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY
Among the different pathways of controlled cell death, apoptosis and autophagy are implicated in follicle loss. Apoptosis participates in eliminating damaged follicles, such as those impaired by chemotherapy (CHT), but its involvement in physiological age-related follicle decline is less well understood. Autophagy has proved crucial in follicle quiescence maintenance in murine models, but its contribution to human follicle pool modulation is still unclear.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION
This retrospective study included 84 patients with benign or malignant extra-ovarian conditions aged between 1 and 35 years, with ovarian tissue stored for histological analyses at the time of cryopreservation (between 2012 and 2021) at a tertiary care center.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS
Ovarian fragments were used for the following analyses: hematoxylin and eosin staining for follicle count and classification; cleaved caspase-3 immunostaining to identify follicle apoptosis; and microtubule-associated proteins 1A/1B light chain 3B immunolabeling to detect follicle autophagy. Transmission electron microscopy was also carried out to investigate ultrastructural features of oocytes and granulosa cells. All analyses stratified patients by age, menarchal status (premenarchal = 32; postmenarchal = 52), potentially gonadotoxic CHT before cryopreservation (n = 14), presence of endometriosis and use of hormonal treatment.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE
Premenarchal patients had a larger follicle pool in terms of total follicle density [mean, range 4979.98 (342.2–21789) versus 918.8 (26.18–3983), P &lt; 0.001], but higher rates of morphologically abnormal [8.52 (0–25.37)% versus 3.54 (0–17.5)%, P &lt; 0.001] and atretic [15.8 (0‒31.85)% versus 10.6 (0–33.33)%, P &lt; 0.01] follicles than postmenarchal subjects. Apoptosis rates did not change with increasing age [27.94 (0–93.2)% in prepubertal subjects and 29.5 (0–100)% in postpubertal subjects], but autophagic follicles were around 10 times more common in premenarchal than postmenarchal subjects [10.21 (0–62.3)% versus 1.34 (0–25)%, P &lt; 0.001], playing a crucial role in age-related follicle decline and elimination of ‘abnormal’ follicles, that are rarely seen after menarche. The impact of diagnosis and previous CHT varied according to age. In premenarchal patients with previous CHT, significantly more apoptotic [40.22 (0–100)% versus 26.79 (0–87)%, P &lt; 0.05] and fewer abnormal [3.84 (0–10–76)% versus 9.83 (0–25.37)%, P &lt; 0.01] follicles were detected than in subjects with no CHT prior to ovarian tissue cryopreservation, suggesting a direct effect on follicle elimination, especially of those with abnormalities. In postmenarchal subjects with previous CHT, quiescent follicle rates were lower than in patients with no CHT before tissue freezing [71.57 (0–100)% versus 85.89 (50–100)%, P &lt; 0.05], suggesting accelerated follicle activation and growth. Moreover, increased autophagic activity was observed in the event of a cancer diagnosis compared to benign conditions after puberty [26.27 (0–100)% versus 9.48 (0–29.41)%, respectively, P &lt; 0.05].

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION
The impact of specific CHT protocols could not be investigated since the group of patients with previous CHT was highly heterogeneous.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS
This study yields a deeper understanding of regulation of the follicle pool decline, showing for the first time that both apoptosis and autophagy pathways are involved in physiological follicle depletion, the latter being crucial before puberty. Moreover, our data showed a different response to non-physiological damage according to age, with higher apoptosis rates only in premenarchal subjects with previous CHT, confirming that this pathway is activated by drugs known to induce DNA damage in oocytes, such as alkylating agents, but not by cancer itself.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)
This study was supported by grants from the Fonds National de la Recherche Scientifique de Belgique (F.R.S.-FNRS/FRIA FC29657 awarded to L.C., CDR J.0063.20 and grant 5/4/150/5 awarded to M.M.D.), grants from the Fondation contre le Cancer (grant 2018-042 awarded to A.Ca.), the Fondazione Comunitaria del Varesotto and Provincia di Varese (‘Amalia Griffini’ Fellowship in Gynecology and Obstetrics awarded to A.Ce.), Fonds Spéciaux de Recherche, Fondation St Luc and donations from the Ferrero family. The authors have no competing interests to declare.

TRIAL REGISTRAION NUMBER
N/A.