Cardiovascular Disease Events in Adults with a History of State Care in Childhood: Pooling of Unpublished Results from 9 Cohort Studies
Authors: Batty G. David , Kivimäki Mika , Almquist Ylva B , Eriksson Johan G. , Gissler Mika , Gnanamanickam Emmanuel S , Hamer Mark , Jackisch Josephine , Juon Hee-Soon , Keski-Säntti Markus , Li Chaiquan , Mikkola Tuija M. , Murray Emily , Sacker Amanda , Segal Leonie , Frank Philipp 
Published: January 2024

AbstractBackgroundIndividuals who were separated from their biological family and placed into the care of the state during childhood (out-of-home care) are more prone to developing selected physical and mental health problems in adulthood, however, their risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) is uncertain. Accordingly, we pooled published and unpublished results from cohort studies of childhood care and adult CVD.MethodsWe used two approaches to identifying relevant data on childhood care and adult CVD (PROSPERO registration CRD42021254665). First, to locate published studies, we searched PubMed (Medline) until November 2023. Second, with the aim of identifying unpublished studies with the potential to address the present research question, we scrutinised retrieved reviews of the impact of childhood state care on related adult health outcomes. All included studies were required to have prospective measurement of state care in childhood and a follow-up of CVD events in adulthood as the primary outcome (incident coronary heart disease and/or stroke). Collaborating investigators provided study-specific estimates which were aggregated using random-effects meta-analysis. The Newcastle-Ottawa Scale was used to assess individual study quality.FindingsThirteen studies (2 published, 11 unpublished) met the inclusion criteria, and investigators from nine provided viable results, including updated analyses of the published studies. Studies comprised 611,601 individuals (301,129 women) from the US, UK, Sweden, Finland, and Australia. Relative to the unexposed, individuals with a care placement during childhood had a 50% greater risk of CVD in adulthood (summary rate ratio after basic adjustment [95% confidence interval]: 1.50 [1.22, 1.84]); range of study-specific estimates: 1.28 to 2.06;I2= 69%, p = 0.001). This association was attenuated but persisted after multivariable adjustment for socioeconomic status in childhood (8 studies; 1.41 [1.15, 1.72]) and adulthood (9 studies, 1.28 [1.10, 1.50]). There was a suggestion of a stronger state care-CVD association in women.InterpretationOur findings show that individuals with experience of state care in childhood have a moderately raised risk of CVD in adulthood. For timely prevention, clinicians and policy makers should be aware that people with a care history may need additional attention in risk factor management.Research in contextEvidence before this studyThere is growing evidence that individuals who were separated from their biological family and placed into the care of the state during childhood (out-of-home care) are more prone to developing selected physical and mental ill-health in adulthood, however, their risk of cardiovascular disease (CVD) events is uncertain. A search of electronic databases to November 2023 yielded only 2 relevant published studies and these had discordant findings.Added value of this studyBy scrutinising retrieved reviews of the impact of childhood state care on broadly related adult health outcomes, we identified studies with the potential to examine the association between childhood care and adult CVD events. Investigators from 7 provided these previously unpublished results and, on aggregating them alongside updated analyses from the 2 published studies, we found that, relative to their unexposed peers, adults with experience of state care earlier in life had a 50% greater risk of CVD. There was evidence that this relationship was partially mediating by socioeconomic status in adulthood, and there was a suggestion of a stronger state care–CVD association in women.Implications of all the available evidenceThis meta-analysis suggests that, alongside the array of well-document unfavourable social, behavioural, and health outcomes in adulthood, children experiencing state care may additionally have a higher burden of later CVD. For timely prevention, clinicians and policy makers should be aware that people with a care history may need additional attention in risk factor management.