Determining the Composition and Structure of a High-Performing SEI Layer for Lithium-Mediated Nitrogen Reduction to Ammonia
Authors: Niemann Valerie Anne , Doucet Mathieu , Wang Hanyu , Deissler Niklas Henrik , Benedek Peter , Mygind Jon Bjarke Valbaek , Lee Sang-Won , Tarpeh William Abraham , Chorkendorff Ib , Nielander Adam C. , Jaramillo Thomas F. 
Published: February 2024

The industrial synthesis of ammonia (NH3) via the Haber-Bosch process has enabled mass production of fertilizer and the human population growth to 8 billion.1 NH3 also shows promise as a long-term, energy-dense fuel amenable to widespread distribution.2 However, the Haber-Bosch process operates at high temperatures and pressures in centralized facilities and accounts for 1.3% of global carbon emissions.1,2 To ensure a food-secure future and realize NH3 as a truly carbon-free fuel, we must develop an NH3 synthesis alternative that operates at ambient conditions and can be driven by renewables.
One of the most promising NH3 synthesis method under mild conditions is the electrochemical, Li-mediated process (Li-NRR). In this process, Li is electrodeposited from solution and reacted with N2 to form Li3N. A proton shuttle, e.g., ethanol, protonates Li3N to form NH3.3 The electrodeposited Li forms a solid-electrolyte interphase (SEI) layer that controls N2, Li+, and H+ transport and is key to system performance. The use of fluorinated Li salts, e.g., LiBF4, have recently advanced Li-NRR system performance. Improved selectivity has been attributed to changes in the SEI layer, but evaluating SEI structure and composition remains a significant challenge.3 Neutron-based characterization methods, complementary to X-ray methods, offer unique benefits to study SEI layers containing light elements such as Li- and H; for example, an element’s neutron scattering cross section does not depend on its atomic number.4 In this work, we studied the formation of the SEI layer in-situ before and after applying -0.3 mA/cm2 in galvanostatic experiments (chronopotentiometry, CP) on a copper (Cu) working electrode. We utilized a combination of deuterated and non-deuterated solvents and proton donors to distinguish their contributions to the SEI. We found that the SEI forms two layers: a compact, lithium rich layer, and a diffuse layer with carbonaceous species (Figure 1).4 We also identified the presence of boron in the layers, indicated by neutron absorption. Finally, we observed more proton-rich species in experiments containing the non-deuterated H+ donor, corroborating previous studies that indicate that Li-ethoxide may be a major component of the diffuse SEI (Figure 1b-c).5 Compared to LiClO4-based electrolytes, the structure of these LiBF4-derived layers is consistent even after repeated current cycling, indicating a more stable SEI structure and suggesting a relationship between SEI stability and increased Li-NRR performance.
References

Nørskov, J. et al. DOE Roundtable Report (2016).

Chang, F. et al. Advanced Materials
33, 2005721 (2021).

Li, S. et al.
Joule
6, 2083–2101 (2022).

Blair, S.J., Doucet, M. et al.
ACS Energy Lett., 7, 6, 1939-1946 (2022).

Steinburg, K. et al. Nature Energy, 8, 138-148 (2023).

Figure 1: (a) reflectivity curve before and after 4 mins constant applied current at -0.3 mA/cm2 (chronopoteniometry, CP) to plate Li using 1 M LiBF4 with 1 vol% ethanol, (b) resulting scattering length density (SLD) profile, and (c) schematic of layers indicated in SLD profile

Figure 1