(Invited) Understanding and Optimization of Versatile Molecular and Coordination Polymer-Based 3d Transition Metal Oxygen Evolution Reaction Catalysts
Authors: Zhao Yonggui , Adiyeri Saseendran Devi Prasad , Triana Carlos A. , Patzke Greta Ricarda 
Published: February 2024

The demanding multi-electron transfer process renders the oxygen evolution reaction (OER) a bottleneck for achieving efficient clean hydrogen generation via water electrolysis.[1] Over the past decades, two main categories of catalysts, namely, homogeneous molecular and heterogeneous catalysts, have been implemented for the OER. However, due to the sluggish reaction kinetics and the aggressive reaction media of the OER, the structural integrity of both homogeneous molecular and heterogeneous catalysts faces the dramatic challenges. This calls for a thorough understanding and close monitoring of OER catalysts under their operando reaction conditions.
Over the last years, we have been combining a variety of in situ/operando spectroscopy approaches with computational studies toward the comprehensive understanding of our designed catalysts at the atomic level. With this information in hand, we established a full identification of catalytically active species and sites for several systems, some of which are discussed here.
First, inspired by nature’s {Mn4CaOx} OER complexes, we recently reported on the design of a tetramer Cu-bipyridyl complex for the OER.[2] Structural characterizations demonstrated a new defect-cubane structure of our designed complex, [Cu4(pyalk)4(OAc)4](ClO4)(HNEt3). We found that this Cu-bipyridyl complex can further undergo structural transformations into two unique complexes under different solution conditions, namely Cu-dimer and Cu-monomers, as revealed by in situ UV-vis and ERP characterizations as well as electrospray ionization mass spectrometry. Specifically, the Cu-monomers can be only formed in presence of carbonate buffer (pH 10.5). Otherwise, the structural transformation into a Cu-dimer complex [Cu2(pyalk)2(OAc)2(H2O)] is dominant under solution conditions. Furthermore, electrochemical characterizations revealed an overpotential of 960 mV to reach a current density of 0.1 mA/cm2 of our designed Cu-dimer catalysts, which is comparable with significant Cu-based OER electrocatalysts. To gain in-depth insights into their conversion processes, postcatalytic characterizations of Cu-based molecular catalysts were carried out based on X-ray photoelectron/absorption (XAS/XPS) spectroscopy appraoches. The results showed that nanosized Cu-oxide-based species were formed in situ in Cu-based molecular catalysts after the OER. Our study highlights the crucial role of the structural integrity of molecular catalysts in solutions for their efficient design.
In parallel, we explored the structural transformations of heterogeneous electrocatalysts during the OER. As a typical example, we developed a cost-effective and high-performance NiFe-based coordination polymer (referred to as NiFe-CP) as OER electrocatalyst, which is being investigated as the best-known bimetallic combination for the OER.[3] A central element of our study is the monitoring of true catalytically active species. Results from spectroscopic characterizations revealed a kinetic restructuring of NiFe-CPs into NiFe (oxy)hydroxides during the OER. To further improve the OER activity, we introduced a facile NaBH4-assisted reduction strategy to prepare low-crystalline reduced NiFe-CP (denoted as R-NiFe-CP) OER electrocatalysts with rich structural deficiencies. These catalysts can maintain a very low overpotential of 225 mV at 10 mA/cm2 for over 120 h without any performance decline, outperforming many recent reported bimetallic OER electrocatalysts. As revealed by XAS characterizations and density functional theory (DFT) calculations, engineering of structural deficiencies not only tunes the local electronic structure but also optimizes the rate-determining step towards facilitated OH- adsorption. Noteworthy, the true OER active sites of R-NiFe-CPs originate from the in situ reconstructed Ni-O-Fe motifs. However, fundamental questions, as to (a) the role of engineered structural deficiencies in the generation of active species and (b) facilitating the formation of catalytically active dual oxygen-bridged moieties, need to be answered. Combination of time-resolved operando XAS monitoring and DFT calculations enables the tracking and understanding of the kinetic changes of active species and sites under the operando reaction conditions. We found that the OER of R-NiFe-CPs relies on the in situ formation of crucial high-valent NiIV-O-FeIVO moieties.[4] Furthermore, an anionic engineering strategy through heteroatom sulfur incorporation was carried out to obtain S-R-NiFe-CP showing faster OER kinetics. Importantly, engineered sulfur content promotes the generation of catalytically active S-NiIVO-FeIVO motifs prior to the OER. This offers a lower onset potential to trigger the OER of S-R-NiFe-CPs compared to sulfur-free R-NiFe-CPs. Moreover, our results also suggest a dual-site mechanism pathway of S-R-NiFe-CPs during the OER, in which the O-O bond formed atop the S-NiIVO-FeIVO moieties. Such an anionic modulation strategy for promoting the formation of catalytically active structural moieties and for optimizing the OER kinetics opens an avenue to optimize a wide range of heterogeneous catalysts for the OER.
[1] Zhao, Y. et al.
Chem. Rev.
2023
,
doi.org/10.1021/acs.chemrev.2c00515.
[2] Adiyeri Saseendran, D. P. et al.
Chem. Comm. 2023, In Revision.
[3] Zhao, Y. et al.
Adv. Energy Mater.
2020, 10, 2002228.
[4] Zhao, Y. et al.
ACS Nano
2022, 16, 15318-15327.