The Temporal Evolution of Chromosome 1q Gain and Hyperdiploidy and Its Impact on Clinical Outcomes in Multiple Myeloma
Authors: Maura Francesco , Kaddoura Marcella , Poos Alexandra Maria , Cirrincione Anthony , Diamond Benjamin , Maclachlan Kylee H , Ziccheddu Bachisio , Mai Elias K. , Goldschmidt Hartmut , Weisel Katja , Fenk Roland , Morgan Gareth J. , Usmani Saad Z , Landgren Ola , Raab Marc S. , Weinhold Niels 
Published: December 2023

INTRODUCTION: Multiple myeloma (MM) evolution is shaped by the acquisition and selection of distinct genomic events over time. While various temporal patterns have been identified, the precise chronological order in which key clonal genomic defining events are acquired, and their specific impact on clinical outcomes remain to be fully elucidated.
METHODS: To decipher the genomic life history of MM and its impact on clinical outcomes, we interrogated the high coverage (80X) whole genome sequencing (WGS) of 378 MM patients. Overall, 319 and 59 WGS were generated from samples collected at diagnosis and at relapse, respectively. Newly diagnosed MM (NDMM) patients were treated upfront with proteosome inhibitors, lenalidomide, dexamethasone, +/- monoclonal antibodies. To estimate the relative and absolute temporal relationship among clonal events, we leveraged the molecular time approach, based on the corrected ratio between duplicated and non-duplicated single nucleotide variants (SNV).
RESULTS: Overall, 300/378 (79%) patients had at least one large chromosomal gain defined as &gt;1Mb with &gt;50 clonal SNV eligible for molecular time analysis, for a total of 1493 events tested. Consistent with recent findings, using clock-like mutational signatures SBS1-SBS5, we estimated that the first gain in MM is typically acquired around the second or third decade of life, with a median time lag of approximately 33 years between acquisition and diagnosis. In 158/178 (89%) of hyperdiploid (HRD) patients, all trisomies of odd-numbered chromosomes were acquired simultaneously. Among patients with canonical IGH translocations and HRD, the molecular time when trisomies were acquired was usually late compared to HRD without canonical IGH translocations (p&lt;0.0001). Next, we examined the temporal relationship between IGH canonical translocations and gains linked to the same IGH canonical translocation in 29 patients. We consistently observed that when IGH canonical translocations co-occurred with HRD (n=7), and/or 1q gain (n=8) in the same patient, the canonical IGH translocation was always found to be the initiating event, occurring earlier than the chromosomal gains.
Interestingly, in 104/178 (58.4%) HRD patients, the earliest multi-gain event was not always restricted to odd chromosomes, but in involved other non-HRD chromosomes such as: 6p (n=43) and 1q (n=32), demonstrating that gain 1q, which is assumed to occur at progression, can also be acquired very early in disease life history. A total of 92 and 21 patients with 1q gain and 1q amp (&gt;3 copies) were identified, respectively. In 14/21 (66%) with 1q amp, the first and second 1q extra copies were acquired in two distinct and independent time windows. Interestingly, patients with early 1q gain showed the same clinical outcomes as 1q amp, and inferior progression free survival outcomes compared to late 1q gain (p=0.01; Figure 1). In 18/21 1q amp the first 1q duplication was acquired early, suggesting that the adverse prognostic effect of 1q gain/amp in NDMM may be more dependent on the timing of its acquisition rather than the number of extra copies gained.
To investigate late temporal patterns and differentiate selection versus acquisition of large gains at relapse after autologous stem cell transplant (ASCT), we interrogated 25/59 (42%) RRMM patients exposed to melphalan with detectable SBS-MM1. To establish the temporal order of events, we employed the melphalan mutational signature, SBS-MM1, as a unique temporal barcode (Diamond et al. Blood 2023). Overall, we observed that 21% of all loss of heterozygosity (LOH) events and 15% of all gains were acquired after ASCT (i.e., SBS-MM1 mutations were only detectable in the pre-gain/duplicated SNV). Notably, among these events, 1q gain was acquired after ASCT in 3/4 patients, indicating that the acquisition of 1q gain can occur even after administration of first-line therapy.
CONCLUSIONS: In our study, we have uncovered distinct temporal patterns in the acquisition of early genomic drivers in MM. These patterns contribute to the reconstruction and better understanding of the life history of MM and may hold potential clinical and prognostic implications.