Final Analysis of the Randomized Phase II/III Study of Standard R-CHOP Versus CHOP Combined with Dose-Dense Weekly Rituximab for DLBCL: JCOG0601
Authors: Ohmachi Ken , Kinoshita Tomohiro , Maruyama Dai , Ogawa Gakuto , Sano Yusuke , Yamauchi Nobuhiko , Fukuhara Noriko , Uchida Toshiki , Yamamoto Kazuhito , Miyazaki Kana , Tsukamoto Norifumi , Iida Shinsuke , Yoshida Isao , Suzuki Yasuhiro , Masaki Yasufumi , Murayama Tohru , Yakushijin Yoshihiro , Suehiro Youko , Nosaka Kisato , Dobashi Nobuaki , Kuroda Junya , Munakata Wataru , Ando Kiyoshi , Ishizawa Kenichi , Ogura Michinori , Yoshino Tadashi , Hotta Tomomitsu , Tsukasaki Kunihiro , Tobinai Kensei , Nagai Hirokazu 
Published: December 2023

Background: Despite several attempts of randomized phase III trial to overcome R-CHOP in overall survival (OS), R-CHOP has been continued to be a standard of care in previously untreated DLBCL. We conducted a randomized phase II/III study (JCOG0601, jRCTs031180139) that investigated the efficacy of dose-dense weekly rituximab combined with standard CHOP regimen (RW-CHOP) during the early treatment period for previously untreated DLBCL and published the results (Ohmachi K, et al. Blood Adv. 2021). Here in, we report the long-term efficacy and safety of the JCOG 0601 trial after 8 years follow-up from the end of accrual.
Methods: Patients aged 20-79 years with previously untreated CD20-positive DLBCL (stage I-IV, performance status 0-2) were randomized to standard R-CHOP (CHOP-21 with eight doses of rituximab, once every 3 weeks) or RW-CHOP (CHOP-21 with eight doses of weekly rituximab). The primary endpoint of phase III part was progression-free survival (PFS). Required sample size was 422 patients, an accrual period of 7 years, and a follow-up period of 3 years with the primary analysis. An additional follow-up period was added to assess long-term outcomes, for a total of 8 years of follow-up.
Results: Between December 2007 and December 2014, 422 patients were enrolled, but primary analysis was performed on 421 patients after one patient withdrew consent: 213 in the R-CHOP arm and 208 in the RW-CHOP arm. The baseline characteristics were as follows (R-CHOP arm vs. RW-CHOP arm): median age, 61 vs. 62 years; male sex, 54.5% vs. 55.8%; Ann Arbor stage I/II/III/IV, 14.6/32.9/26.8/25.8% vs. 16.3/42.8/20.2/20.7%; and International Prognostic Index score ≤2, 77.0% vs. 87.5%. At a primary analysis, there was no significant difference in PFS between the arms. At the time of final analysis with a median follow-up of 9.6 years (range: 0.3-14.9) among all patients, meaningful differences were not found in PFS and OS as well as the primary analysist (hazard ratio [HR] in PFS of RW-CHOP against R-CHOP, 0.94; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.67 to 1.32, one-sided log-rank, P = 0.36 and HR in OS, 0.94; 95% CI, 0.63 to 1.41). Median PFS and OS were not estimable in both arms. Estimated 10 years PFS and OS of all patients was 66.9% (95% CI, 62.1 to 71.3) and 78.0% (95% CI, 73.6 to 81.7). After the first relapse or refractoriness, 126 patients received post-protocol salvage therapy: 66 in the R-CHOP arm and 60 in the RW-CHOP arm. In each arm, 3 patients received high-dose chemotherapy followed by autologous stem cell transplantation. One patient in the R-CHOP arm proceeded to allogeneic stem cell transplantation from a sibling donor. Ann Arbor stage I to II disease tended to have more favor prognosis than Ann Arbor stage III to IV disease, and no sustained relapse was observed in either stage. Of the 401 patients who underwent central pathological review, 125 were diagnosed with germinal center B-cell-like (GCB) type and 216 with non-GCB type by immunohistochemistry analysis. There was no remarkable difference in PFS between the arms for GCB type and non-GCB type. Death occurred in 95 patients: 56 from DLBCL, 2 from treatment-related cardiac toxicity, 9 from treatment-related mortality caused by salvage treatment, 14 from secondary malignancies, and 11 from other diseases or reasons. There were 34 secondary malignancies in 31 patients (14.6%) in the R-CHOP arm, and 39 cases in 35 patients (16.8%) in the RW-CHOP arm. The most common secondary malignancies were lung cancer (2.6%), colon cancer (1.9%), prostate cancer (1.7%) and gastric cancer (1.9%). Three cases of acute myeloid leukemia (0.7%) and three of myelodysplastic syndromes (0.7%) were observed. The median age of patients who developed secondary malignancy was 72 years (range: 49-84) at the onset. The median time from study enrollment to the onset of secondary malignancy was 4.5 (range: 0.1-13.1) years and the incidence was time dependent. There were no unexpected adverse events, including late opportunistic infections.
Conclusion: This final-follow up data demonstrated again no superiority of RW-CHOP in PFS and OS. Standard R-CHOP remains a standard of care for untreated DLBCL.