Random X-Chromosome Inactivation in Adult Hemophilia B Carriers Does Not Attenuate Bleeding Risk
Authors: Cygan Peter H. , Eyster M. Elaine , Carrel Laura 
Published: December 2023

Introduction: The X-linked bleeding disorder Hemophilia B (HB) results from deficiency in coagulation Factor IX (FIX). In contrast to Hemophilia A, genotype-phenotype correlations in HB males are complex, as some F9 variants in males are associated with low plasma FIX activity (FIX:C) but milder than expected bleeding phenotypes. At least 75% of FIX is extravascular and not adequately measured from plasma. Hemostasis is likely influenced by this extravascular FIX which is bound reversibly to type IV collagen in the subendothelial basement membrane. We predict that genotype-phenotype correlations in female carriers of F9 mutations may have additional complexity as the mutant FIX can competitively interfere with wild type (WT) FIX for extravascular binding sites.
F9 expression in female HB carriers is influenced by X-chromosome inactivation (XCI), a process that silences one X in XX females. XCI results in cells that randomly inactivate either the X carrying the mutant or wild type F9, although skewed XCI (&gt;80:20) is found in ~25% of the general population. XCI skewing in HB carriers can lead to preferential expression of the X carrying the F9 mutation, which in turn influences plasma and extravascular levels of FIX and bleeding tendency. How frequently XCI is skewed in HB carriers, and the role of XCI in modulating FIX levels and bleeding phenotypes, remains poorly understood. We sought to determine whether XCI skewing may further differentiate bleeding risk in HB carriers.
Methods: Subjects were enrolled in a prospective, observational cross-sectional study with informed consent. Both the Condensed MCMDM-1 bleeding assessment tool (BAT) and Pictorial Blood-loss Assessment Chart (PBAC) were completed at the time of the visit. F9 mutation analysis confirmed carrier status. FIX:C and FIX antigen ELISA assays were performed on all subjects. XCI skewing was assessed using established assays at the Androgen Receptor (AR) and Fragile X Mental Retardation (FMR1) loci.
Results: A total of 15 subjects (11 adults) were confirmed F9 mutation carriers; six missense mutations and one frameshift mutation were identified. Abnormal bleeding is frequent in adult HB carriers, with 5/11 (45%) having BAT scores &gt;4. Heavy menstrual bleeding (HMB) is particularly frequent, with all adult HB carriers reporting PBAC &gt; 100, and 8/11 with BAT HMB subcategory score &gt;1. FIX assessment by activity (mean 56% ± 28) and antigen (mean 0.55 IU/mL ± 0.2) assays are highly correlated (r 2= 0.83, p &lt; 0.0001). Notably, only two adult HB carriers with significant bleeding have FIX levels &lt; 50%, while two HB carriers with FIX levels &lt; 50% have BAT scores &lt; 4, indicating that neither FIX:C nor FIX antigen levels adequately predict bleeding risk in all HB carriers. Indeed, for all 11 adult HB carriers, no significant differences in either FIX:C or FIX antigen were observed between those with BAT scores ≥ 4 and &lt; 4.
We asked if XCI explained FIX levels or bleeding phenotypes. Nearly half (5/11) of the adult carriers have moderately skewed XCI (&gt; 70:30); only one is extremely XCI skewed (&gt; 80:20), and of the individuals with skewed XCI, 3/5 have BAT scores ≥ 4. Although random XCI is proposed to attenuate HB carrier bleeding phenotype, 2/6 HB carriers with random XCI also have BAT scores ≥ 4. XCI weakly correlated with FIX antigen (n = 15; r 2= 0.27, p &lt; 0.05) but not FIX:C. When assessing this relationship for only the individuals with F9 c.1025C&gt;T (n = 6), there was significant correlation with FIX:C (R 2= 0.73, p &lt; 0.05) but not with FIX antigen or bleeding phenotype. The lack of correlation between XCI and FIX antigen in individuals with an identical F9 mutation argues for additional influences on intravascular, and likely extravascular, FIX levels and will require further investigation.
Conclusions: Bleeding tendency in HB carriers is not rare and does not correlate with plasma FIX:C or FIX antigen. Random XCI is not fully protective against abnormal bleeding. Future studies are needed to better understand bleeding phenotypes in HB carriers that consider XCI, F9 mutation type and influences on circulating levels of WT and mutant FIX.