Precision Targeting of the Malignant Clone in Diffuse Large B Cell Lymphoma Using Chimeric Antigen Receptor T Cells Against the Clonotypic IGHV4-34 B Cell Receptor
Authors: Cohen Ivan J , Bochi-Layec Audrey C , Kim Ki Hyun , Jenks Scott , Ugwuanyi Ositadimma , Ghilardi Guido , Gabrielli Giulia , Harris Jaryse , Wang Li-Ping , Zhang Yunlin , Pajarillo Raymone , Vlachonikola Elisavet , Porazzi Patrizia , Sanz Ignacio , Ghia Paolo , Stamatopoulos Kostas , Schuster Stephen J , Ruella Marco 
Published: December 2023

Introduction: CD19-directed Chimeric Antigen Receptor T cell (CART19) immunotherapy has revolutionized the treatment of B cell lymphoma. However, most CART19-treated patients either fail to respond or show disease progression after an initial response. In fact, up to 30% of lymphoma relapses following CART19 show loss of CD19 expression. In addition, several patients who respond well to CART19 display complete loss or severe reduction of their normal B cell repertoire, leaving them exposed to recurrent infections, limited response to vaccines, and requiring prophylactic measures such as intravenous immunoglobulins.
A significant portion of mature B cell malignancies express B cell receptors (BCR) that use the same immunoglobulin heavy variable gene: IGHV4-34. In particular, ~30% of activated B cell (ABC) diffuse large B cell lymphomas (DLBCL), ~35% of primary central nervous system lymphomas, ~65% of vitreoretinal lymphomas, and ~35% of hairy cell leukemia variant express IGHV4-34. This suggests that the IGHV4-34 heavy chain is critical for driving the disease by delivering cell survival and proliferation signals, and multiple studies have shown that BCR signaling is required for ABC-DLBCL survival. However, while highly enriched in several types of B cell lymphomas, IGHV4-34 expressing B cells compose only ~5% of the normal B cell repertoire of healthy individuals.
Therefore, we hypothesized that anti-IGHV4-34 CAR T cells would be highly effective and safe against B cell malignancies, as they would: (i) efficiently recognize IGHV4-34+ lymphoma cells while sparing normal B cells; and (ii) target a tumor driver that is essential for lymphoma cell survival ( Fig 1A).
Methods and Results:We developed a novel CAR construct (CD8-41BB-CD3z) targeting the IGHV4-34+ BCR (CART4-34) using a single-chain variable fragment (scFv) derived from the 9G4 rat monoclonal antibody. We used tumor B cells that endogenously (HBL1) or exogenously (Jeko1, Bonna12, Mec1) express the IGHV4-34 BCR. Using cytotoxicity, cytokine secretion and proliferation assays in vitro we showed that CART4-34 specifically target all IGHV4-34+ tumor B cells tested while sparing IGHV4-34- tumor B cells and, most importantly, healthy B cells. However, while the initial CART4-34 showed strong cytotoxicity towards IGHV4-34+ cells in short-term in vitro assays, they were significantly inferior to CART19 in in vivo xenograft models.
We hypothesized that the poor performance of CART4-34 compared to CART19 was due to the unique challenge of targeting the membrane-distal portion of the BCR, 18 nm from the plasma membrane. In contrast, CART19 targets an epitope of CD19 located just 5 nm from the membrane ( Fig 1B). Therefore, to improve immune synapse (IS) formation, we designed new CAR constructs with smaller extracellular domains by replacing the original CD8 hinge (44 amino acids (aa)) with either: (i) a short version of the IgG4 hinge (12aa); or (ii) a G4S linker (5aa). We found that both CART4-34 (IgG4) and CART4-34 (G4S) exhibited significantly improved cytotoxicity towards IGHV4-34+ tumor cells in short-term and long-term in vitro assays in all IGHV4-34+ cell lines tested, while maintaining specificity. Importantly, in in vivo human xenograft models of IGHV4-34+ lymphoma (HBL1), CART4-34 with short hinges showed significantly improved tumor control comparable to, or better than, CART19 ( Fig 1B). We also found that while CART19-resistant lymphoma cells had complete loss of CD19 surface expression, CART4-34-resistant tumor cells retained high expression of IgM, suggesting a reduced likelihood of antigen-negative escape owing to the critical role of the BCR for lymphoma B cell survival.
Mechanistically, we found that while the original CART4-34 (CD8 hinge) formed IS with striking morphological differences compared to IS formed by CART19, the IS formed by CART4-34 with short hinges highly resembled those formed by CART19, providing a rationale for the improved anti-tumor potency of short-hinge CART4-34.
Conclusion:We implemented a novel paradigm for the treatment of B cell malignancies: the specific targeting of the malignant clone, while sparing the remainder of the healthy B cell repertoire. We designed and optimized a best-in-class anti-IGHV4-34 CAR T cell product with potent anti-tumor effects and minimal toxicity towards IGHV4-34-negative B cells. The activity of CART4-34 will be investigated in a Phase I clinical trial.