Effects of Liming on an Acid—Sensitive Southern Appalachian Stream
Authors: Eggleton Michael A. , Morgan Eric L. , Pennington Wendell L. 
Published: April 2006

AbstractLaurel Branch (Tennessee, U.S.A.), an acid‐sensitive stream in the southern Appalachian Mountains, was limed as a part of the Acid Precipitation Mitigation Program funded by the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service. Objectives were (1) to evaluate the effectiveness of stream liming by means of a hydropowered doser design, and (2) to monitor stream response(s) to increased pH and alkalinity. Precipitation in the region was documented to be acidic, with a mean pH of 4.54 in 1987. Preliming evaluations conducted from 1986 through 1988 depicted Laurel Branch as soft (hardness less than 5 mg/L CaCO3, pH 6.2–6.6), dilute (ionic strength less than 400 μeq/L), and lightly buffered (alkalinity less than 100 μeq/L). Because of the apparent relationship between flow and water chemistry, Laurel Branch was considered susceptible to episodic acidification caused by storms. In June 1989, a hydro–powered limestone doser was installed to treat the lower 3 km of the stream. Approximately 8.2 tonnes of crushed limestone were added during an 18–month treatment phase that concluded in December 1990. Technical and design problems with the doser reduced efficiency and limited the scale of liming through much of the first 6 months of operation. Design modifications and equipment upgrades in late 1989 corrected most of the problems and improved doser performance in 1990. No substantial chemical or biological changes were detected within the treated reach of Laurel Branch as a result of liming. Time–series statistical analyses showed small but significant changes in total alkalinity (10 μeq/L average increase) and dissolved calcium at all limed sites. pH (as hydrogen ion) increased 0.16 and 0.13 units at two limed sites that were 1 km and 2 km below the doser, respectively. At the lowermost limed site 3 km below the doser, a significant decrease in pH was detected which was probably flow‐related. Mean length of age–0 (juvenile) and age‐1 rainbow trout increased marginally during liming, suggesting improved fish growth, but increases were not significant. Densities of an acid‐sensitive macrobenthic taxon (Baetis spp.) increased during liming, whereas densities of an acid‐tolerant taxon (Leuctra spp.) remained unchanged. In general, observed biological changes were considered minimal; they were judged unrelated to liming but rather of seasonal and/or spatial origin. The regional drought of 1987 and 1988 was considered a confounding factor. With most of the baseline data collected during these years, vastly differing hydrology in 1989 and 1990 (“wet” years regionally) became problematic and may have distorted some responses and masked others. It is also possible that biological responses may have been delayed because of the small magnitude of chemical changes, particularly pH and alkalinity. A calcium mass budget estimated that up to 62% of the calcium added was accounted for in chemistry data from limed sites, with increases most visible in the spring and summer of 1990. Results indicated that, although the Laurel Branch watershed does receive acidic precipitation, current biological communities show high levels of integrity and little apparent degradation related to acidification. If watershed buffering capabilities are depleted from continued acidic deposition, however, stream biota may be at risk in the future.