First Tarsometatarsal Instability Corrects Itself After Triple Arthrodesis in Progressive Collapsing Foot Deformity
Authors: Jeng Clifford L. , Motsay Morgan , Rowe Kenneth , Manchester Maggie K. , Cotton Michael , Campbell John T. 
Published: April 2024

Introduction/Purpose: Triple arthrodesis is commonly used to correct severe or rigid progressive collapsing foot deformity (PCFD). In many cases of PCFD, patients have associated first tarsometatarsal instability demonstrated by plantar gapping or dorsal subluxation on the lateral weight-bearing radiographs. During flatfoot reconstruction this is usually addressed with a first tarsometatarsal fusion to realign the joint and to restore the medial column height. However in the setting of triple arthrodesis it has not been well established if it is necessary to add a first tarsometatarsal fusion to the procedure in order to adequately correct the overall deformity. This study retrospectively examined pre- and post-operative radiographs of patients that had first tarsometatarsal instability as a component of their PCFD and who were managed by triple arthrodesis alone. Methods: All triple arthrodesis cases were searched for a single surgeon between 2013 and 2021. Inclusion criteria were patients who had a diagnosis of PCFD and had an isolated triple arthrodesis without first tarsometatarsal joint fusion. Pre-operative radiographs were then examined for the presence of first tarsometatarsal joint instability on the lateral weight-bearing view only. This was demonstrated by either plantar gapping or first metatarsal dorsal subluxation at the tarsometatarsal joint. Those patients who were a minimum of 21 months post-op were called to obtain current radiographs. Measurement of the sagittal first metatarsal-medial cuneiform angle as well as a the first metatarsal lift as described by King and Toolan (FAI 2004) was performed. Results: Twenty patients satisfied the inclusion criteria and were included in the study. Of these patients, five had no correction of their first tarsometatarsal joint instability postoperatively and were considered failures. The remaining fifteen patients demonstrated early correction of their first tarsometatarsal joint instability and were called back for longer term follow-up radiographs. Average follow-up was 4.8 years (range 1.8 - 9.4 years). The sagittal first metatarsal-medial cuneiform angle (plantar gapping) improved significantly from 3.8 degrees to 1.0 degrees (p=0.00002). The first metatarsal lift (dorsal subluxation) corrected from 4.0 mm to 1.5 mm (p=0.000001). Only one patient showed radiographic evidence of arthritis in the first tarsometatarsal joint at final follow-up. Conclusion: First tarsometatarsal joint fusion to correct medial column instability is well established in flatfoot reconstruction cases. However less is known about whether this is required when performing a triple arthrodesis for PCFD. In this study, 75% of patients had their first tarsometatarsal joint instability correct itself after isolated triple arthrodesis and maintained this correction at 4.8 year follow-up. In many cases of PCFD with medial column instability, triple arthrodesis alone may be adequate to restore overall alignment thereby avoiding the additional operative time and risk for complication associated with a first tarsometatarsal joint fusion. First tarsometatarsal joint instability correction following isolated triple arthrodesis. Pre-operative radiographs demonstrate plantar gapping and dorsal subluxation at the first tarsometatarsal joint consistent with medial column instability. At 2.8 year post-operative follow up after isolated triple arthrodesis, radiographs show maintained correction of the instability.