Legal pluralism in contemporary societies: Dynamics of interaction between islamic law and secular civil law
Authors: Husain Sahin , Ayoub Nasir Purkon , Hassmann Mukhammadolim 
Published: May 2024

Legal pluralism refers to the simultaneous existence of different legal systems in a single community. This presents intricate challenges and opportunities for governance, justice, and social cohesion in many socio-cultural settings. This study examines the interplay between Islamic law (Sharia) and secular civil law in modern nations, specifically aiming to comprehend the intricacies, conflicts, and consequences of legal pluralism. This study does a thorough literature analysis to analyze existing scholarship on legal pluralism. It synthesizes important findings and perspectives from many geographical places that have significant Muslim populations. The review emphasizes the complex and diverse nature of legal pluralism, which involves the coexistence, competition, and accommodation of various legal traditions. Furthermore, it recognizes the difficulties that arise from conflicts between Islamic law and secular civil law, such as differences in rights and safeguards, tensions based on religion and cultural differences, and obstacles to efficient government and societal unity. Moreover, the review examines the wider consequences of legal pluralism on academic research, policy-making, and practical implementation. It proposes potential areas for future research to enhance our comprehension of the dynamics of legal pluralism and to guide efforts in fostering inclusivity, fairness, and appreciation for diversity within legal systems. This research adds to the continuous efforts of building inclusive and equitable legal systems that defend human rights, develop social cohesion, and promote justice for all individuals by recognizing the diversity of legal traditions and viewpoints within modern cultures.

Research Highlights:

Complex Dynamics of Legal Pluralism: The research elucidates the multifaceted nature of legal pluralism, examining the coexistence, competition, and accommodation between Islamic law and secular civil law in diverse socio-cultural contexts. By synthesizing existing scholarship, the study provides a comprehensive understanding of the complexities and tensions inherent in legal pluralism dynamics.
Challenges and Implications: The study identifies key challenges arising from conflicts between Islamic law and secular civil law, including disparities in rights and protections, tensions along religious and cultural lines, and impediments to effective governance and social cohesion. These insights shed light on the broader implications of legal pluralism for governance, justice, and social cohesion within contemporary societies.
Policy and Practice Recommendations: By exploring the broader implications of legal pluralism for scholarship, policy, and practice, the research offers valuable recommendations for promoting inclusivity, equity, and respect for diversity within legal frameworks. These recommendations inform strategies for addressing challenges and fostering inclusive legal systems that uphold human rights and equality for all individuals.