Pervasive Antagonistic Interactions Among Hybrid Incompatibility Loci
Authors: Guerrero Rafael F. , Muir Christopher D. , Josway Sarah , Moyle Leonie C. 
Published: December 2016

ABSTRACTSpecies barriers, expressed as hybrid inviability and sterility, are often due to epistatic interactions between divergent loci from two lineages. Theoretical models indicate that the strength, direction, and complexity of these genetic interactions can strongly affect the expression of interspecific reproductive isolation and the rates at which new species evolve. Nonetheless, empirical analyses have not quantified the frequency with which loci are involved in interactions affecting hybrid fitness, and whether these loci predominantly interact synergistically or antagonistically, or preferentially involve loci that have strong individual effects on hybrid fitness. We systematically examined the prevalence of interactions between pairs of short chromosomal regions from one species (Solanum habrochaites) co-introgressed into a heterospecific genetic background (Solanum lycopersicum). We used lines containing pairwise combinations of 15 chromosomal segments fromS. habrochaitescrossed into the background ofS. lycopersicum(i.e., 95 double introgression lines). We compared the strength of hybrid incompatibility (either pollen sterility or seed sterility) expressed in each double introgression line to the expected additive effect of its two component single introgressions. We found that: epistasis was common among co-introgressed regions; epistastic effects for hybrid dysfunction were overwhelmingly antagonistic (i.e., double hybrids were less unfit than expected from additive single introgression effects); and, epistasis was substantially more prevalent in pollen fertility compared to seed fertility phenotypes. Together, these results indicate that higher-order interactions frequently contribute to postzygotic sterility barriers in these species. This pervasive epistasis leads to the decoupling of the patterns of accumulation of isolation loci and isolation phenotypes, and is expected to attenuate the rate of accumulation of hybrid infertility among lineages over time (i.e., giving diminishing returns as more reproductive isolation loci accumulate). This decoupling effect might also explain observed differences between pollen and seed fertility in their fit to theoretical predictions of the accumulation of isolation loci, including the ‘snowball’ effect.AUTHOR SUMMARYA characteristic feature of new species is their inability to produce fertile or viable hybrids with other lineages. This post-zygotic reproductive isolation is caused by dysfunctional interactions between genes that have newly evolved changes in the diverging lineages. Whether these interactions occur between pairs of divergent alleles, or involve more complex networks of genes, can have strong effects on how rapidly reproductive isolation—and therefore new species—evolve. The complexity of these interactions, however, is poorly understood in empirical systems. We examined the fertility of hybrids that carried one or two chromosomal regions from a close relative, finding that hybrids with two of these heterospecific regions were frequently less sterile than would be expected from the joint fitness of hybrids that have the same regions singly. This ‘less-than-additive’ effect on hybrid sterility was widespread (observed in 20% of pairwise combinations), and especially pronounced for male sterility. We infer that genes contributing to male sterility form a more tightly connected network than previously thought, implying that reproductive isolation is evolving by incremental dysfunction of complex interactions rather than by independent pairwise incompatibilities. We use simulations to illustrate these expected patterns of accumulation of reproductive isolation when it involves highly interconnected gene networks.