Poster 373: Lower Extremity Injury Rates on Turf Versus Natural Grass Surfaces - An Analysis of Professional Football Athletes in the 2021 and 2022 Seasons
Authors: Venishetty Nikit , Xiao Angel , Ghant Ramesh , Reddy Rohit , Pandya Nirav , Feeley Brian 
Published: October 2024

Objectives: As the emphasis on player safety in the national football league (NFL) has increased in recent years, numerous risk factors for injury have been closely scrutinized for their roles in placing players at increased risk. One such factor, the use of artificial turf football fields, has become a controversial topic, with many current and former players stating that turf fields place players at higher risk for injury while alternative sources have suggested there is no significant injury rate between artificial and natural grass surfaces. The purpose of this study was to quantify the rate of lower extremity injuries occurring in NFL players on artificial turf compared to natural grass surfaces and to characterize the degree of time missed with injury and the proportion of injuries requiring surgery. We hypothesized that major lower extremity injuries requiring surgical intervention occurred on artificial turf surfaces at a higher rate than on natural grass. Methods: Lower extremity Injury data for the 2021 and 2022 NFL seasons were obtained using publicly available records from the internet. All reported lower extremity injuries during the regular and playoff seasons were analyzed. Upper extremity, head, and back injuries were excluded. Preseason data was also excluded. Data collected included player position and age, playing surface of the field on which, the injury occurred, injury type, weeks missed with injury, and whether the patient underwent season-ending or minor surgery. Statistical analysis was performed using R Software (Rlabs). Descriptive statistics were used to summarize data, including percentages and counts for categorical and ordinal data and means with interquartile ranges for continuous data. Incidences of injury on both grass and turf fields were calculated for the 2021 and 2022 seasons by taking a ratio of the number of injuries that occurred and the number of games played on respective fields. Additionally, injuries were stratified by subsequent number of games missed: 0 games missed, 1-2 games missed, >6 games missed. Multivariable logistic regression was performed to determine the influence of field type on the risk of major surgery. A p-value less than 0.05 was statistically significant. Results: In total there were 327 (44.12%) lower extremity injuries in 2021 and 391 (54.45%) lower extremity injuries in 2022, resulting in a total of 718 lower extremity injuries. A demographic summary of these injuries by position, age, field, and history of previous injury is displaced in Table 1. Combining the 2021/2022 seasons, the incidence rate of lower extremity injury on natural grass surfaces was 1.22 injuries/game while for turf surfaces, the incidence rate was 1.42 injuries/game (Table 2). Injury severity was stratified by weeks missed. Odds of a season-ending surgery were found to be significantly higher on turf surfaces compared to natural grass surfaces (OR 1.60, 95% CI 1.28-1.99, p<0.05), while additional variables, including weather, age, position, and week of injury occurrence and history of prior injury were not found to influence the odds of season-ending surgery. In total, there were 50 players injured on the grass who required lower extremity surgery and 83 players injured on turf who required lower extremity surgeries. The most common surgeries after a lower extremity on grass were ACL repair (17), Achilles repair (9), and ankle or syndesmosis ORIF (7). The most common surgeries after a lower extremity on turf were ACL repair (30), Achilles repair (12), patella ORIF, or patellar tendon repair (8) (Table 3). Conclusions: The debate about playing on artificial turf versus natural grass has persisted for several years; however, there is a discrepancy in data reported on these overall injury rates. Our study showed that NFL athletes were more likely to get injured on artificial surfaces and that turf dramatically increased the likelihood of suffering a serious injury requiring surgery. These findings support earlier research, highlighting the necessity of putting player safety first and reducing dangers on pitches with artificial turf. For players, coaches, and teams to make wise decisions about playing surfaces, the study offers useful information regarding playing safety. Overall, it indicates that there is a higher risk of lower extremity injuries on artificial grass in the NFL, confirming the continuing discussion about field safety.