Insulator Elements in Erythrocyte Membrane Genes
Authors: Steiner Laurie A , Maksimova Yelena , Lin Jolinta , Owen Ashley Nicole , Schulz Vincent , Bodine David M. , Gallagher Patrick G. 
Published: October 2019

Abstract
Insulators are DNA sequences and associated binding proteins that establish and/or maintain the boundaries between euchromatin and heterochromatin. One type of insulator establishes chromatin domains to separate enhancers and promoters and prevent their interaction (enhancer-blocking insulators) whereas another type creates a barrier to protect against heterochromatin-mediated gene silencing (barrier insulators). In the well-characterized chicken beta-globin LCR 5′HS4 insulator, binding of CTCF mediates enhancer-blocking functions and USF proteins mediate barrier activity. Because varying transcripts of erythrocyte membrane protein genes are expressed in both erythroid and nonerythroid cells, we hypothesized that that insulator elements that bind USF and CTCF participate in their regulation. Advances in technology have permitted rapid identification of DNA sequences bound by transcription factors and other DNA-associated proteins on a genome-wide scale. Coupling chromatin immunoprecipitation to microarrays that contain genomic regions (ChIP-chip) is a high resolution technique available for mapping protein-DNA interactions in vivo. We used ChIP-chip to identify CTCF and USF factor binding sites with potential insulator function that regulate membrane protein gene expression in erythroid cells. ChIP was performed with K562 and HeLa cells using antibodies against CTCF, USF1, and USF2. DNA obtained from these IPs was hybridized to a custom NimbleGen high-density human genomic DNA microarray. Chip probes were ~50bp in length, Tm ≥76°C, tiled ~65bp apart. Regions of repetitive DNA excluded. The chip included 15 erythrocyte membrane protein genes, most encoding complex loci with multiple tissue-, cell-, and developmental stage-specific transcripts, including alpha spectrin, beta spectrin, ankyrin, spectrin, band 3, ƒnalpha adducin, beta adducin, gamma adducin, ICAM4, erythroid associated membrane protein, protein 4.1R, protein 4.2, dematin, beta actin, tropomodulin, and tropomyosin. Each gene plus 50 to 100kb of flanking DNA were included on the chip. Binding sites on the custom DNA array were identified using the Tamalpais peak calling algorithm using L1–L3 level of stringency (Genom Res16:595, 2006) or Tilescope using a signal cutoff of 0.9 (Genome Biol8:R81, 2007). In K562 chromatin, 117 sites of CTCF occupancy were identified. There were 49 sites in 5′ flanking DNA, 3 in promoters, 9 in coding sequence, 20 in introns, 1 in 3′ untranslated region, and 35 in 3′ flanking DNA. Sites of USF1 and USF2 occupancy were identified in 7/15 and 9/15 genes, respectively. 15 USF1 sites were identified; 10 in 5′ flanking DNA, 1 in a promoter (<500bp from transcription start site), and 4 in 3′ flanking DNA. 22 sites of USF2 occupancy were identified; 9 in 5′ flanking DNA, 1 in a promoter, 4 in introns, and 8 in 3′ flanking DNA. USF1 and USF2 frequently heterodimerize and 10 sites bound both USF1 and USF2. To validate ChIP-chip results, a site binding USF2 near the ankyrin gene erythroid promoter was further analyzed. This site was chosen because the USF2-associated sequence directs uniform, copy-number dependent expression of a linked reporter gene in transgenic mice, the erythroid ankyrin promoter is positioned between 2 alternate, nonerythroid ankyrin promoters, and DNaseI mapping revealed that this region is contained within an erythroid-specific chromatin domain. Quantitative ChIP confirmed USF2 occupancy, as well as USF1 occupancy, in this region. For functional analysis, we used a gene silencing/position-effect variegation (PEV) assay to determine whether this region possess barrier element function. Using a HS2-beta globin promoter-GFP cassette as negative control and a cHS4-HS2-beta globin promoter-GFP-cHS4 cassette as positive control, the ankyrin promoter region fragment (p<0.001) functioned as barrier elements in this PEV assay. These data demonstrate that there are numerous binding sites for insulator-associated DNA binding proteins in erythrocyte membrane protein genes and indicate that these elements likely play a significant role in the regulation of tissue-specific expression of many genes expressed in erythroid cells.