Abstract 5671: Alignment of TMB measured on clinical samples: Phase IIB of the Friends of Cancer Research TMB Harmonization Project
Authors: MERINO Diana M. , Yee Laura M. , McShane Lisa M. , Williams P. Mickey , Vilimas Tomas , Patidar Rajesh , Barrett J. Carl , Chen Shu-Jen , Cheng Jen-Hao , Conroy Jeffrey M. , Cyanam Dinesh , Eyring Kenneth R. , Fabrizio David A. , Funari Vincent , Garcia Elizabeth P. , Glenn Sean T. , Gocke Christopher D. , Gupta Vikas , Haley Lisa M. , Hellmann Matthew D. , Keefer Laurel , Keeler Lauryn R. , Kennedy Brett , Lazar Alexander J. , MacConaill Laura E. , Meier Kristen L. , Papin Arnaud , Rizvi Naiyer A. , Sokol Ethan , Stafford Phillip , Thompson John F. , Tom Warren , Weigman Victor J. , Xie Mingchao , Zhao Chen , Stewart Mark D. , Allen Jeff 
Published: September 2020

Abstract
Introduction:
Tumor mutational burden (TMB) is the number of somatic mutations per megabase in a tumor's genome and has shown promise as a predictive biomarker of response to immune checkpoint inhibitors across several cancers. TMB is typically measured by whole exome sequencing (WES TMB) or by targeted next-generation sequencing gene panels (panel TMB). As more assays are developed to estimate TMB, harmonization is emerging as an unmet need and is a key goal of the Friends of Cancer Research (Friends) TMB Harmonization Project. Phase I of the Harmonization Project demonstrated correlation between panel TMB and WES TMB using TCGA data and defined theoretical sources of variability across panels. In phase IIA, sustainable TMB reference standard materials generated from human derived cell lines were used to characterize variability in TMB measurements across panels and assessed for utility in TMB alignment. Phase IIB aims to characterize variability in TMB measurements in clinical samples and to establish best practices for estimating and aligning TMB in order to improve consistency across panels.
Methods:
Fifteen laboratories (16 targeted gene panels) at different stages of development participated in phase IIB. Thirty formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded (FFPE) samples with &gt;30% tumor content were acquired; tumor DNA was isolated by a single reference lab. TMB values were calculated for DNA extracted from lung (N=10), bladder (N=10), and gastric tumors (N=10) using WES and a uniform bioinformatics pipeline agreed upon by all Consortium members. DNA samples were also sent to all laboratories, and each used their own sequencing and bioinformatics pipelines to estimate TMB from the genes represented in their respective panels. For each tumor sample, a median across panel TMB estimates was calculated; individual panel TMB estimates were translated to fold-changes relative to the sample median to quantify variability. Association between WES TMB (reference) and panel TMB will be assessed by regression analysis; dependence of association on cancer type was investigated.
Results:
A subset of tumor samples (9 bladder, 7 lung, and 5 gastric) was analyzed using 11 panels at the time of abstract submission. Median panel TMB values ranged 0.60 - 40.26 across samples, with median of median values of 5.35. Fold-change from sample-level medians ranged 0x - 6.67x. Assessment of these clinical samples by WES and all 16 gene panels, as well as regression analysis results, are forthcoming.
Conclusions:
The Friends TMB Harmonization Project has made substantial progress in characterization of TMB measurement variability and association between WES TMB and panel TMB. These are important steps toward alignment of TMB estimates generated by different gene panels which may improve the interpretation of findings within clinical development programs and ultimately enhance the usefulness of this predictive biomarker in clinical decision making.
Citation Format: Diana M. MERINO, Laura M. Yee, Lisa M. McShane, P. Mickey Williams, Tomas Vilimas, Rajesh Patidar, J. Carl Barrett, Shu-Jen Chen, Jen-Hao Cheng, Jeffrey M. Conroy, Dinesh Cyanam, Kenneth R. Eyring, David A. Fabrizio, Vincent Funari, Elizabeth P. Garcia, Sean T. Glenn, Christopher D. Gocke, Vikas Gupta, Lisa M. Haley, Matthew D. Hellmann, Laurel Keefer, Lauryn R. Keeler, Brett Kennedy, Alexander J. Lazar, Laura E. MacConaill, Kristen L. Meier, Arnaud Papin, Naiyer A. Rizvi, Ethan Sokol, Phillip Stafford, John F. Thompson, Warren Tom, Victor J. Weigman, Mingchao Xie, Chen Zhao, Mark D. Stewart, Jeff Allen. Alignment of TMB measured on clinical samples: Phase IIB of the Friends of Cancer Research TMB Harmonization Project [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the American Association for Cancer Research 2020; 2020 Apr 27-28 and Jun 22-24. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(16 Suppl):Abstract nr 5671.