Geographic heterogeneity impacts drug resistance predictions inMycobacterium tuberculosis
Authors: Gan Guo Liang , Nguyen Matthew H. , Willie Elijah , Rezaie Mohammad H. , Lee Brian , Chauve Cedric , Libbrecht Maxwell , Chindelevitch Leonid 
Published: September 2020

AbstractThe efficacy of antibiotic drug treatments in tuberculosis (TB) is significantly threatened by the development of drug resistance. There is a need for a robust diagnostic system that can accurately predict drug resistance in patients. In recent years, researchers have been taking advantage of whole-genome sequencing (WGS) data to infer antibiotic resistance. In this work we investigate the power of machine learning tools in inferring drug resistance from WGS data on three distinct datasets differing in their geographical diversity.We analyzed data from the Relational Sequencing TB Data Platform, which comprises global isolates from 32 different countries, the PATRIC database, containing isolates contributed by researchers around the world, and isolates collected by the British Columbia Centre for Disease Control in Canada. We predicted drug resistance to the first-line drugs: isoniazid, rifampicin, ethambutol, pyrazinamide, and streptomycin. We focused on the genes which previous evidence suggests are involved in drug resistance in TB.We called single-nucleotide polymorphisms using the Snippy pipeline, then applied different machine learning models. Following best practices, we chose the best parameters for each model via cross-validation on the training set and evaluated the performance via the sensitivity-specificity tradeoffs on the testing set.To the best of our knowledge, our study is the first to predict antibiotic resistance in TB across multiple datasets. We obtained a performance comparable to that seen in previous studies, but observed that performance may be negatively affected when training on one dataset and testing on another, suggesting the importance of geographical heterogeneity in drug resistance predictions. In addition, we investigated the importance of each gene within each model, and recapitulated some previously known biology of drug resistance. This study paves the way for further investigations, with the ultimate goal of creating an accurate, interpretable and globally generalizable model for predicting drug resistance in TB.Author summaryDrug resistance in pathogenic bacteria such asMycobacterium tuberculosiscan be predicted by an application of machine learning models to next-generation sequencing data. The received wisdom is that following standard protocols for training commonly used machine learning models should produce accurate drug resistance predictions.In this paper, we propose an important caveat to this idea. Specifically, we show that considering geographical diversity is critical for making accurate predictions, and that different geographic regions may have disparate drug resistance mechanisms that are predominant. By comparing the results within and across a regional dataset and two international datasets, we show that model performance may vary dramatically between settings.In addition, we propose a new method for extracting the most important variants responsible for predicting resistance to each first-line drug, and show that it is to recapitulate a large amount of what is known about the biology of drug resistance inMycobacterium tuberculosis.