Immunogenicity and safety of fractional doses of yellow fever vaccines: a randomized, double-blind, non-inferiority trial
Authors: Juan-Giner Aitana , Kimathi Derick , Grantz Kyra H. , Hamaluba Mainga M. , Kazooba Patrick , Njuguna Patricia , Fall Gamou , Dia Moussa , Bob Ndeye S. , Monath Thomas P. , Barrett Alan D. , Hombach Joachim , Mulogo Edgar M. , Ampeire Immaculate , Karanja Henry K. , Nyehangane Dan , Mwanga-Amumpaire Juliet , Cummings Derek A.T. , Bejon Philip , Warimwe George M. , Grais Rebecca F. 
Published: August 2020

AbstractBackgroundYellow fever vaccine stocks have been insufficient to cover exceptional demands for outbreak response. Fractional dosing evidence is limited to the 17DD substrain vaccine. We assessed the immunogenicity and safety of one-fifth fractional dose compared to standard dose of each of the four WHO-prequalified yellow fever vaccines produced from three substrains.MethodsWe conducted a randomized, double-blind, non-inferiority trial in Mbarara, Uganda and Kilifi, Kenya. 960 participants aged 18-59 years without previous yellow fever vaccination or infection were recruited from communities and randomized to receive one of four vaccines and to standard or fractional dosage. Vaccine was administered subcutaneously by unblinded nurse. Other study personnel and participants were blinded to vaccine allocation. Primary immunogenicity outcome, seroconversion, was measured in the per-protocol population; safety outcomes included all vaccinated participants. We defined non-inferiority as no more than 10% decrease in seroconversion in fractional compared to standard dose arms 28 days post-vaccination. Seroconversion was defined as ≥4-fold rise in neutralizing antibody titers measured by 50% plaque reduction neutralization test (PRNT50).ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02991495, following participants.FindingsBetween 6th November 2017 and 21st February 2018, 960 participants, total sample goal, were randomized. The primary per-protocol analysis includes 899 participants, with 110 to 117 participants per arm. The absolute difference in seroconversion between fractional and standard doses by vaccine was 1.71% (95%CI: −2.60, 5.28), −0.90% (95%CI: −4.24, 3.13), 1.82% (95%CI: −2.75, 5.39), 0.0% (95%CI: −3.32, 3.29). Fractional doses from all four vaccines met the non-inferiority criterion. There were no safety concerns.InterpretationThese results support fractional dosing of all WHO-prequalified yellow fever vaccines for the general adult population for outbreak response in situations of vaccine shortage.FundingThe study was funded by Médecins Sans Frontières Foundation, Wellcome Trust (grant no. 092654) and the UK Department for International Development. Vaccines were donated in kind.Research in contextEvidence before this studyIn July 2016, following major yellow fever (YF) outbreaks in two countries, WHO published a secretariat information paper including a review of studies assessing the immunogenicity of fractional doses of YF vaccines and recommended consideration of fractional doses to manage a vaccine shortage. Following this, fractional doses of YF vaccine produced by Bio-Manguinhos/Fiocruz (17DD substrain) were given to approximately 7.5 million non-pregnant adults and children ≥ 2 years of age in Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo. The evidence base to support this action was limited to a single vaccine substrain and to a specific context. To broaden and simplify recommendations, WHO called for additional research to be conducted. We designed a trial to assess non-inferiority in seroconversion of fractional (one-fifth dose) versus standard dose for each of the four WHO-prequalified YF vaccines at 28 days post-vaccination in an adult population in Kenya and Uganda. We selected vaccine batches as close as possible to each manufacturer’s minimum release specification.Added value of this studyThis is the first randomized controlled trial assessing all four WHO-prequalified YF vaccines, providing information on the immunogenicity and safety of fractional doses of the different vaccine substrains at 10 days, 28 days and one year post-vaccination. The results show that, at 28 days post-vaccination, most participants had high levels of neutralizing antibodies and that seroconversion rates in the fractional dose arms were non-inferior to standard dose for each of the four vaccines. Seroconversion rates and neutralizing antibodies remained high up to one year post-vaccination for both fractional and standard doses for all vaccines. These results are aligned with previous studies using the 17DD substrain vaccine but extend the evidence to randomized comparisons of all four vaccines and to a sub-Saharan Africa context. To our knowledge, this is the first trial assessing immunogenicity of fractional doses at 10 days post-vaccination.Implications of all the available evidenceOur study supports the use of one-fifth fractional doses of all four WHO-prequalified yellow fever vaccines for the general adult population and fills a critical knowledge gap to support WHO policy on the use of fractional dosing of yellow fever vaccine for outbreak response. The immunogenicity and safety of fractional dosing in children and specific populations, such as those living with HIV, is yet to be determined. Long-term studies are warranted to confirm the duration of protection.