Comparison of Heat Fractionation and Gel Electrophoresis Methods for the Quantitative Determination of Alkaline Phosphatase Isoenzymes
Authors: Balogun Kayode , Lee Megan , Doyle Kelly 
Published: October 2020

Abstract

Introduction
Alkaline phosphatase (ALP) is important in the diagnostic work-up for hepatobiliary and bone diseases. ALP isoenzymes are expressed in the bone, liver, kidney, placenta, and intestine, and vary in heat stability and electrophoretic mobility. Distinguishing the different ALP isoenzymes is clinically important for the diagnosis of pathologies associated with elevated ALP activity. Current modalities available to measure ALP isoenzymes utilize the heat stability, electrophoretic mobility, and immunochemical properties of the isoenzymes. The differences inherent in these methods allow for unique benefits of each method in identifying ALP isoenzymes. The objective of this study was to compare bone, liver, and placental ALP isoenzyme results determined by heat fractionation and gel electrophoresis and to characterize the heat-stable non-liver fraction (t1/2 &gt;11 min), reported by heat fractionation, using gel electrophoresis.

Methods
A total of 72 de-identified serum samples that span a wide range of known ALP isoenzyme concentrations and disease states were used to measure ALP using gel electrophoresis and heat fractionation. Heat fractionation was achieved by selective inactivation of the isoenzymes at 56 °C in 10, 15, and 20-minute intervals. Log-percent activity of the total and heat-inactivated fractions at each time point was plotted against time in minutes. The linear activity decay between 10 and 20 minutes determined the relative amount of liver isoenzyme activity and the slope of the line determined the half-lives of ALP isoenzymes. Electrophoresis was performed according to the manufacturer’s protocol using the Hydragel ISO-PAL gel to resolve ALP isoenzymes based on their electrophoretic mobility and interaction with lectin. ALP isoenzymes were quantified by densitometry.

Results
Our results show a significant correlation coefficient (r) of 0.98, Deming regression slope of 1.1, and bias of -1.2% for the liver isoenzyme (n=43). However, liver fractions are not distinguishable by heat fractionation when heat-stable isoforms are present. The bone fraction (n=43) showed a coefficient of correlation of 0.86, slope of 0.55, and bias of -31%. Although, with a small sample size (n=6), the placental isoenzyme showed a significant agreement between the two methods: r = 0.999, slope = 0.98, and a -3.5% bias. Of the non-liver fractions reported by heat fractionation (n=13, ALP &gt;100 U/L) eleven (85%) showed distinct qualitative bands in the intestinal lane on gel electrophoresis; however, quantitative values did not correlate between the two methods.

Conclusion
Our data support an agreement between the heat fractionation and gel electrophoresis methods for the quantitative determination of liver and placental alkaline phosphatase isoenzymes. Although there is an association between the two methods, the activity of the bone isoenzyme was underestimated by the gel electrophoresis method, likely due to saturation of the gel and densitometry scan because of elevated protein concentrations. The non-liver fractions were qualitatively identified as intestinal isoenzyme.