Comparison of Mental Health Symptoms Prior to and During COVID-19 among Patients with Systemic Sclerosis from Four Countries: A Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network (SPIN) Cohort Study
Authors: Thombs Brett D. , Kwakkenbos Linda , Henry Richard S. , Carrier Marie-Eve , Patten Scott , Harb Sami , Bourgeault Angelica , Tao Lydia , Bartlett Susan J. , Mouthon Luc , Varga John , Benedetti Andrea ,   for the SPIN Patient Advisors,   SPIN Investigators
Published: June 2020

Background

No studies have reported comparisons of mental health symptoms prior to and during COVID-19 in vulnerable populations. Objectives were to compare anxiety and depression symptoms among people with a pre-existing medical condition, the autoimmune disease systemic sclerosis (SSc; scleroderma), including continuous change scores, proportion with change ≥ 1 minimal clinically important difference (MCID), and factors associated with changes, including country.

Methods

Pre-COVID-19 Scleroderma Patient-centered Intervention Network Cohort data were linked to COVID-19 data collected April 9 to April 27, 2020. Anxiety symptoms were assessed with the PROMIS Anxiety 4a v1.0 scale (MCID = 4 points) and depression symptoms with the Patient Health Questionnaire-8 (MCID = 3 points). Multiple linear and logistic regression were used to assess factors associated with continuous change and change ≥ 1 MCID.

Findings

Among 435 participants (Canada = 98; France = 159; United Kingdom = 50; United States = 128), mean anxiety symptoms increased 4.9 points (95% confidence interval [CI] 4.0 to 5.7). Depression symptom change was negligible (0.3 points; 95% CI −0.7 to 0.2). Compared to France, adjusted scores from the United States and United Kingdom were 3.8 points (95% CI 1.7 to 5.9) and 2.9 points higher (95% CI 0.0 to 5.7); scores for Canada were not significantly different. Odds of increasing by ≥ 1 MCID were twice as high for the United Kingdom (2.0, 95% CI 1.0 to 4.2) and United States (1.9, 95% CI 1.1 to 3.2). Participants who used mental health services pre-COVID had adjusted increases 3.7 points (95% CI 1.7 to 5.7) less than other participants.

Interpretation

Anxiety symptoms, but not depression symptoms, increased dramatically during COVID-19 among people with a pre-existing medical condition. Increase was larger in the United Kingdom and United States than in Canada and France but substantially less for people with pre-COVID-19 mental health treatment.

RESEARCH IN CONTEXT

Evidence before this study

We referred to a living systematic review that is evaluating mental health changes from pre-COVID-19 to COVID-19 by searching 7 databases, including 2 Chinese language databases, plus preprint servers, with daily updates (https://www.depressd.ca/covid-19-mental-health). As of June 13, 2020, only 5 studies had compared mental health symptoms prior to and during COVID-19. In 4 studies of university students, there were small increases in depression or general mental health symptoms but minimal or no increases in anxiety symptoms. A general population study from the United Kingdom reported a small increase in general mental health symptoms but did not differentiate between types of symptoms. No studies have reported changes from pre-COVID-19 among people vulnerable due to pre-existing medical conditions. No studies have compared mental health changes between countries, despite major differences in pandemic responses.

Added value of this study

We evaluated changes in anxiety and depression symptoms among 435 participants with the autoimmune condition systemic sclerosis and compared results from Canada, France, the United Kingdom, and the United States. To our knowledge, this is the first study to compare mental health symptoms prior to and during COVID-19 in any vulnerable population. These are the first data to document the substantial degree to which anxiety symptoms have increased and the minimal changes in depression symptoms among vulnerable individuals. It is also the first study to examine the association of symptom changes with country of residence and to identify that people receiving pre-COVID-19 mental health services may be more resilient and experience less substantial symptom increases than others.

Implications of all the available evidence

Although this was an observational study, it provided evidence that vulnerable people with a pre-existing medical condition have experienced substantially increased anxiety symptoms and that these increases appear to be associated with where people live and, possibly, different experiences of the COVID-19 pandemic across countries. By comparing with evidence from university samples, which found that depression symptoms were more prominent, these data underline the need for accessible interventions tailored to specific needs of different populations. They also suggest that mental health treatments may help people to develop skills or create resilience, which may reduce vulnerability to major stressors such as COVID-19.