Lobectomy vs Total Thyroidectomy With Ipsilateral Lateral Neck Dissection for N1b Intermediate-Risk Papillary Thyroid Carcinoma
Authors: Saito Yoshiyuki , Matsuzu Kenichi , Abdelhamid Ahmed Amr H. , Inoue Kosuke , Shibuya Hiroshi , Matsui Ai , Kuga Yoko , Ono Reiko , Yoshioka Kana , Masaki Chie , Akaishi Junko , Hames Kiyomi Y. , Okamura Ritsuko , Tomoda Chisato , Suzuki Akifumi , Kitagawa Wataru , Nagahama Mitsuji , Sugino Kiminori , Takami Hiroshi , Randolph Gregory W. , Ito Koichi 
Published: November 2024

Importance

The management of papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), particularly in cases with clinically apparent lateral neck lymph node metastasis (cN1b), remains an area of debate. The surgical options for PTC, including total thyroidectomy and lobectomy, have distinct impacts on patients’ outcomes and quality of life.

Objective

To compare survival and recurrence outcomes between patients who underwent a lobectomy plus ipsilateral lateral neck dissection (LND) and those who underwent a total thyroidectomy plus ipsilateral LND for intermediate-risk cN1b PTC with both primary tumors and lymph node metastases in the ipsilateral neck region.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This retrospective cohort study was conducted at Ito Hospital, Tokyo, Japan. Patients who underwent surgery for PTC between January 2005 and December 2012 were included, and those with high-risk PTCs and concurrent other thyroid cancers were excluded. Data were analyzed from April to August 2024.

Exposures

Lobectomy plus LND vs total thyroidectomy plus LND.

Main Outcomes and Measures

An inverse probability of treatment weighting (IPTW)–adjusted Kaplan-Meier analysis and a Cox proportional hazards regression analysis were performed to compare the patients’ overall survival, recurrence-free survival (RFS), and modified RFS (which considered the potential need for a future contralateral lobectomy).

Results

Of 401 included patients, 317 (79.1%) were female, and the median (IQR) age was 47 (36-59) years. A total of 157 patients underwent lobectomy plus ipsilateral LND and 244 underwent total thyroidectomy plus ipsilateral LND. The median (IQR) follow-up time was 13.0 (11.2-15.0) years. The IPTW-adjusted overall survival rates at 5, 10, and 15 years were 98.0% (95% CI, 93.9-99.3), 97.5% (95% CI, 93.2-99.1), and 96.8% (95% CI, 92.2-98.7), respectively, for the lobectomy group vs 99.4% (95% CI, 97.0-99.9), 97.4% (95% CI, 94.4-98.8), and 96.9% (95% CI, 93.3-98.5), respectively, for the total thyroidectomy group (hazard ratio [HR], 1.10; 95% CI, 0.35-3.47). The IPTW-adjusted RFS rates at 5, 10, and 15 years were 93.8% (95% CI, 88.5-96.7), 88.4% (95% CI, 82.0-92.6), and 84.1% (95% CI, 76.8-89.3), respectively, for the lobectomy group vs 95.4% (95% CI, 91.8-97.4), 92.9% (95% CI, 88.8-95.5), and 87.8% (95% CI, 80.8-92.4), respectively, for the total thyroidectomy group (HR, 1.41; 95% CI, 0.79-2.54). The IPTW-adjusted modified RFS rates at 5, 10, and 15 years were 96.7% (95% CI, 92.2-98.6), 93.8% (95% CI, 88.5-96.7), and 88.9% (95% CI, 82.4-93.1), respectively, for the lobectomy group vs 95.4% (95% CI, 91.8-97.4), 92.9% (95% CI, 88.8-95.5), and 87.8% (95% CI, 80.8-92.4), respectively, for the total thyroidectomy group (HR, 0.93; 95% CI, 0.49-1.76).

Conclusions and Relevance

In this study, for these selected intermediate-risk cN1b PTC cases, total thyroidectomy and lobectomy provided comparable outcomes in terms of prognosis and recurrence. These data may help inform future guideline revisions and support joint decision-making between patients and their clinicians.