Multiscale Characterization of Complex Binding Interactions of Cellulolytic Enzymes Highlights Limitations of Classical Approaches
Authors: Chundawat Shishir P. S. , Nemmaru Bhargava , Hackl Markus , Brady Sonia K. , Hilton Mark A. , Johnson Madeline M , Chang Sungrok , Lang Matthew J. , Huh Hyun , Lee Sang-Hyuk , Yarbrough John M. , López Cesar A. , Gnanakaran S. 
Published: May 2020

Cellulolytic microorganisms, likeTrichoderma reeseiorClostridium thermocellum, frequently have non-catalytic carbohydrate-binding modules (CBMs) associated with secreted or cell surface bound multidomain carbohydrate-active enzymes (CAZymes) like cellulases. Mostly type-A family CBMs are known to promote cellulose deconstruction by increasing the substrate-bound concentration of cognate cellulase catalytic domains. However, due to the interfacial nature of cellulose hydrolysis and the structural heterogeneity of cellulose, it has been challenging to fully understand the role of CBMs on cellulase activity using classical protein-ligand binding assays. Here, we report a single-molecule CAZyme assay for an industrially relevant processive cellulase Cel7A (fromT. reesei) to reveal how subtle CBM1 binding differences can drastically impact cellulase motility/velocity and commitment to initial processive motion for deconstruction of two well-studied crystalline cellulose allomorphs (namely cellulose I and III). We take a multifaceted approach to characterize the complex binding interactions of all major type-A family representative CBMs including CBM1, using an optical-tweezers based single-molecule CBM-cellulose bond ‘rupture’ assay to complement several classical bulk ensemble protein-ligand binding characterization methods. While our work provides a basis for the ‘cautious’ use of Langmuir-type adsorption models to characterize classical protein-ligand binding assay data, we highlight the critical limitations of using such overly simplistic models to gain a truly molecular-level understanding of interfacial protein binding interactions at heterogeneous solid-liquid interfaces. Finally, molecular dynamics simulations provided a theoretical basis for the complex binding behavior seen for CBM1 towards two distinct cellulose allomorphs reconciling experimental findings from multiscale analytical methods.

Significance Statement

Multimodal biomolecular binding interactions involving carbohydrate polymers (e.g., cellulose, starch, chitin, glycosaminoglycans) are fundamental molecular processes relevant to the recognition, biosynthesis, and degradation of all major terrestrial and aquatic biomass. Protein-carbohydrate binding interactions are also critical to industrial biotechnology operations such as enzymatically-catalyzed bioconversion of starch and lignocellulose into biochemicals like ethanol. However, despite the ubiquitous importance of such interfacial processes, we have a poor molecular-level understanding of protein-polysaccharide binding interactions. Here, we provide a comprehensive experimental and theoretical analysis of bulk ensemble versus single-molecule binding interactions of enzyme motors and associated non-catalytic binding domains with cellulosic polysaccharides to highlight the critical limitations of applying classical biochemical assay techniques alone to understanding protein adsorption or biological activity at solid-liquid interfaces.