A Scalable Service to Improve Health Care Quality Through Precision Audit and Feedback: Proposal for a Randomized Controlled Trial (Preprint)
Authors: Landis-Lewis Zach , Flynn Allen , Janda Allison , Shah Nirav 
Published: May 2022

BACKGROUND

Health care delivery organizations lack evidence-based strategies for using quality measurement data to improve performance. Audit and feedback (A&amp;F), the delivery of clinical performance summaries to providers, demonstrates the potential for large effects on clinical practice but is currently implemented as a blunt <i>one size fits most</i> intervention. Each provider in a care setting typically receives a performance summary of identical metrics in a common format despite the growing recognition that <i>precisionizing</i> interventions hold significant promise in improving their impact. A precision approach to A&amp;F prioritizes the display of information in a single metric that, for each recipient, carries the highest value for performance improvement, such as when the metric’s level drops below a peer benchmark or minimum standard for the first time, thereby revealing an actionable performance gap. Furthermore, precision A&amp;F uses an optimal message format (including framing and visual displays) based on what is known about the recipient and the intended gist meaning being communicated to improve message interpretation while reducing the cognitive processing burden. Well-established psychological principles, frameworks, and theories form a feedback intervention knowledge base to achieve precision A&amp;F. From an informatics perspective, precision A&amp;F requires a knowledge-based system that enables mass customization by representing knowledge configurable at the group and individual levels.

OBJECTIVE

This study aims to implement and evaluate a demonstration system for precision A&amp;F in anesthesia care and to assess the effect of precision feedback emails on care quality and outcomes in a national quality improvement consortium.

METHODS

We propose to achieve our aims by conducting 3 studies: a requirements analysis and preferences elicitation study using human-centered design and conjoint analysis methods, a software service development and implementation study, and a cluster randomized controlled trial of a precision A&amp;F service with a concurrent process evaluation. This study will be conducted with the Multicenter Perioperative Outcomes Group, a national anesthesia quality improvement consortium with &gt;60 member hospitals in &gt;20 US states. This study will extend the Multicenter Perioperative Outcomes Group quality improvement infrastructure by using existing data and performance measurement processes.

RESULTS

The proposal was funded in September 2021 with a 4-year timeline. Data collection for Aim 1 began in March 2022. We plan for a 24-month trial timeline, with the intervention period of the trial beginning in March 2024.

CONCLUSIONS

The proposed aims will collectively demonstrate a precision feedback service developed using an open-source technical infrastructure for computable knowledge management. By implementing and evaluating a demonstration system for precision feedback, we create the potential to observe the conditions under which feedback interventions are effective.

INTERNATIONAL REGISTERED REPORT

PRR1-10.2196/34990