Structural basis for breadth development in a HIV-1 neutralizing antibody
Authors: Henderson Rory , Zhou Ye , Stalls Victoria , Wiehe Kevin , Saunders Kevin O. , Wagh Kshitij , Anasti Kara , Barr Maggie , Parks Robert , Alam S. Munir , Korber Bette , Haynes Barton F. , Bartesaghi Alberto , Acharya Priyamvada 
Published: September 2022

Antibody affinity maturation enables adaptive immune responses to a wide range of pathogens. In some individuals broadly neutralizing antibodies develop to recognize rapidly mutating pathogens with extensive sequence diversity. Vaccine design for pathogens such as HIV-1 and influenza have therefore focused on recapitulating the natural affinity maturation process. Here, we determined structures of antibodies in complex with HIV-1 Envelope for all observed members and ancestral states of a broadly neutralizing HIV-1 antibody clonal B cell lineage. These structures track the development of neutralization breadth from the unmutated common ancestor and define affinity maturation at high spatial resolution. By elucidating contacts mediated by key mutations at different stages of antibody development we have identified sites on the epitope-paratope interface that are the focus of affinity optimization. Thus, our results identify bottlenecks on the path to natural affinity maturation and reveal solutions for these that will inform immunogen design aimed at eliciting a broadly neutralizing immune response by vaccination.

Somatic hypermutation drives affinity maturation of germline-encoded antibodies leading to the development of their pathogen neutralization function1. Rational vaccine design efforts that aim to recapitulate affinity maturation rely on information from antibodies elicited and matured during natural infection. High-throughput next generation sequencing and methods for tracing antibody development have allowed close monitoring of the antibody maturation process. Since maturation involves both affinity-enhancing and affinity-independent diversification, the precise effect of each observed mutation, their role in enhancing affinity to antigens, and the order in which the mutations accumulated are often unclear. These gaps in knowledge most acutely hinder efforts directed at difficult targets such as pan-HIV, pan-Influenza, and pan-Coronavirus vaccines. In HIV-1 infection, antibody maturation over several years is required to achieve neutralization breadth. Here, we determined structures of antibodies in complex with HIV-1 Envelope trimers for all observed members and ancestral states of a broadly neutralizing HIV-1 antibody clone to examine affinity maturation as neutralization breadth developed from the unmutated common ancestor. Structural determination of epitope-paratope interfaces revealed details of the contacts evolving over a timescale of several years. Structures along different branches of the clonal lineage elucidated differences in the branch that led to broad neutralization versus off-track paths that culminated in sub-optimal neutralization breadth. We further determined structures of the evolving Envelope revealing details of the virus-antibody co-evolution through visualization of how the virus constructs barriers to evade antibody-mediated neutralization and the mechanisms by which the developing antibody clone circumvents these barriers. Together, our structures provide a detailed time-resolved imagery of the affinity maturation process through atomic level descriptions of virus-antibody co-evolution leading to broad HIV neutralization. While the findings from our studies have direct relevance to HIV-1, the principles of affinity optimization and breadth development elucidated in our study should have broad relevance to other pathogens.