Optimisation of the timing of fertilisation assessment for oocytes cultured in standard incubation: lessons learnt from time-lapse imaging of 78 348 embryos
Authors: Barrie A , Smith R , Campbell A , Fishel S 
Published: September 2021

STUDY QUESTION

Using time-lapse data, can the current consensus for the timing of fertilisation assessment of oocytes, cultured in standard incubation, be optimised?

SUMMARY ANSWER

The optimum time to perform fertilisation assessment for oocytes cultured in standard incubation is 16.5 ± 0.5 h post-insemination (hpi), and the current consensus requires modification in order to minimise the chance of fertilisation being missed.

WHAT IS KNOWN ALREADY

Time-lapse incubation allows the embryologist to retrospectively review collated images of oocytes and embryos to capture important embryological observations that may otherwise be missed in standard incubation. According to expert consensus, the optimum time to perform the assessment of fertilisation is 17 ± 1 hpi.

STUDY DESIGN, SIZE, DURATION

A retrospective, multicentre analysis utilised data obtained from 54 746 ICSI-derived embryos and 23 602 IVF-derived embryos cultured in time-lapse incubation between January 2011 and November 2019.

PARTICIPANTS/MATERIALS, SETTING, METHODS

Using time-lapse imaging (TLI), the precise time of pronuclei appearance and disappearance was recorded, where applicable, and the number of oocytes with two pronuclei observable during 10 30-min intervals from 15 hpi to 20 hpi was determined.

MAIN RESULTS AND THE ROLE OF CHANCE

Between 15 and 17.5 hpi, the average number of oocytes exhibiting normal fertilisation, elicited as two pronuclei, was 98.19% with the highest proportion of oocytes having visible pronuclei at 16–16.5 hpi (98.32%). At 18–18.5 hpi, the number of visible pronuclei reduced to 95.53% and continued to fall to 87.02% at 19.5–20 hpi.

LIMITATIONS, REASONS FOR CAUTION

The authors’ expectation is that these findings are transferable to other settings, however it is possible that, with alternative culture media and incubation environments, calibration of this timing may be required. As data cannot readily be recorded for pronuclear appearance for IVF-derived embryos, it is not possible to determine the optimum time to perform the fertilisation assessment for IVF-derived embryos.

WIDER IMPLICATIONS OF THE FINDINGS

By fine-tuning the time at which fertilisation assessment takes place the accuracy of the assessment can be increased to maximise the number of fertilised oocytes identified, thereby increasing the number of usable embryos for the patient. Without TLI and following current consensus guidelines, over 11% (n = 3000) of oocytes would have been marked as unfertilised within this cohort. Further to this, depending on the time of a standard fertilisation assessment, up to 300 embryos which resulted in live births could have been categorised as unfertilised, as they presented no visible pronuclei at the conventional assessment time-point.

STUDY FUNDING/COMPETING INTEREST(S)

A.C. is a minor shareholder in CARE Fertility Limited. Validated algorithmic time-lapse embryo selection is offered to patients at CARE Fertility at an additional charge as an adjuvant treatment option.

TRIAL REGISTRATION NUMBER

N/A.