Clinical, Cytogenetic and Immunophenotypic Spectra of Post-Transplant Relapse Following Allogeneic Hematopoietic Stem Cell Transplantation for Myelodysplastic Syndrome
Authors: Herrity Elizabeth Kathryn , Alfaro Tommy , Pinto Pereira Mariana , Novitzky-Basso Igor , Lam Wilson , Pasic Ivan , Michelis Fotios , Law Arjun D. , Viswabandya Auro , Smith Adam , Tierens Anne Maria , Gerbitz Armin , Kumar Rajat , Mattsson Jonas , Kim Dennis D. H. 
Published: December 2023

Introduction

Allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation (HCT) is a curative therapy used to treat myelodysplastic syndrome (MDS). Relapse post-HCT confers poor outcomes and subsequent therapy is not standardized. Like acute myeloid leukemia (AML), several mechanisms are known to be involved in post-HCT relapse including clonal evolution in favor of chemotherapy-resistant clones and tumor immune escape. Systemic reviews are scarce in the MDS post-HCT relapse population. Accordingly, the present study aimed to investigate clinical, cytogenetic, and immunophenotypic (IP) spectra for MDS post-HCT relapse patients (pts), along with subsequent therapies, and clinical outcomes following post-HCT relapse.

Patients and methods

A retrospective study was conducted and found that 231 MDS pts received HCT between April 2010 and September 2022 at the Princess Margaret Cancer Centre (PMCC). The primary endpoint was overall survival (OS) following post-HCT relapse. Secondary endpoints explored time to relapse (TTR), relapse presentation (i.e., MDS or AML), clonal evolution (i.e., changes in cytogenetics or IP profiles), and therapeutic strategies delivered after relapse.

Results

Of the 231 MDS pts treated with HCT, 52 (23%) relapsed in a median of 4.5 months (range 0.9-59.8 months). Twenty-five (48%) pts relapsed with MDS (i.e., blast &lt;20%), while 27 (52%) relapsed with AML (i.e., blast ≥20%) in the marrow. Fifteen (65%) pts showed cytogenetic changes at the time of post-HCT relapse. Eleven (48%) of which presented with more aggressive findings (i.e., additional structural abnormalities and monosomal karyotype). Ten of 17 (59%) pts presented with changes in their IP profile at post-HCT relapse, 7 (70%) of which relapsed with AML. Combined these findings give evidence of clonal evolution in favor of more aggressive malignant clones that are often responsible for post-HCT relapse. Treatment with hypomethylating agents (HMA) alone or in combination after post-HCT relapse increased OS to 5.6 months in comparison to those not receiving HMA of whom OS was 1.4 months (p=0.0003).

Stratified by disease presentation cytogenetic clonal evolution was seen in 6/12 (50%) of the post-HCT MDS relapses, and 9/11 (82%) of the post-HCT AML relapses. Cytogenetic abnormalities at diagnosis and post-HCT relapse, respectively included in descending order: structural abnormalities (n=14/23, 61%; n=20/23, 87%), complex karyotype (n=12/23, 52%; 17/23, 74%), -5/del(5q) (n=11/23, 48%; n=10/23, 43%), -7/del(7q) (n=8/23, 35%; n=11/23, 48%), monosomy karyotype (n=8/23, 35%; n=11/23, 48%), -17 (n=3/23, 13%; n=5/23, 22%), der(5)/t(5;17) (n=2/23, 9%; n=5/23, 22%), -20 (n=2/23, 9%; n=3/23, 13%), and inv(3) (n=1/23, 4%, n=2/23, 9%).

Seventeen pts had paired IP profiles available both prior to HCT and at post-HCT relapse, of which 10 (59%) had profile changes of at least 1 antigen. Seven of 10 (70%) pts that relapsed with AML post-HCT had IP expression changes, compared to 3/7 (42.9%) pts that relapsed with MDS post-HCT. Summarized IP findings include reduced expression of CD7 (n=2/6, 33%), altered expression of CD34 (n=3/15, 20%), altered expression of CD117 (n=3/14, 21%), and reduced expression of HLA DR (n=4/15, 27%). The presence of IP expression changes at post-HCT relapse suggests evidence of clonal evolution or immune escape as the mechanism behind the relapsed disease.

Overall survival duration was 3.97 months; the 12-month OS rate was 20.0% (10.0-32.5%). Post-HCT relapse treatments included hypomethylating agents (HMA; n=13/46, 28%), HMA with donor lymphocyte infusion (DLI; n= 7/46, 15%), HMA with Venetoclax (VEN; n=7/46, 15%), chemotherapy (n=9/46, 19%), best supportive care (8/46, 17%) and second HCT (n=2/46, 4%). Patients that received HMA with or without DLI or VEN had a longer survival duration of 5.6 months (95% CI [3.4-13.2 months]) compared to those not receiving HMA 1.4 months (95% CI [0.6-0.39 months, p=0.0003]). The 12-month survival rate was also significantly in favor of pts that received HMA following post-HCT relapse (35.3% [95% CI 17.2-54.0%] vs 4.3% [95% CI 0.3-18.0%]).

Conclusion

Patients with MDS undergoing HCT may relapse with either MDS or AML. The relapsed disease often shows evidence of clonal evolution in its immunophenotype and/or cytogenetic profile toward a more aggressive disease. Approaches to post-HCT relapse remain heterogenous but HMA is beneficial.