No improvement in mortality among critically ill patients with carbapenems as initial empirical therapy and more detection of multi-drug resistant pathogens associated with longer use: a post hoc analysis of a prospective cohort study
Authors: Ishii Junki , Nishikimi Mitsuaki , De Bus Liesbet , De Waele Jan , Takaba Akihiro , Kuriyama Akira , Kobayashi Atsuko , Tanaka Chie , Hashi Hideki , Hashimoto Hideki , Nashiki Hiroshi , Shibata Mami , Kanamoto Masafumi , Inoue Masashi , Hashimoto Satoru , Katayama Shinshu , Fujiwara Shinsuke , Kameda Shinya , Shindo Shunsuke , Komuro Tetsuya , Kawagishi Toshiomi , Kawano Yasumasa , Fujita Yoshihito , Kida Yoshiko , Hara Yuya , Yoshida Hideki , Fujitani Shigeki , Shime Nobuaki ,   on behalf of the DIANA study Japanese group
Published: June 2024

Whether empirical therapy with carbapenems positively affects the outcomes of critically ill patients with bacterial infections remains unclear. This study aimed to investigate whether the use of carbapenems as the initial antimicrobial administration reduces mortality and whether the duration of carbapenem use affects the detection of multidrug-resistant (MDR) pathogens. This was a post hoc analysis of data acquired from Japanese participating sites from a multicenter, prospective observational study [Determinants of Antimicrobial Use and De-escalation in Critical Care (DIANA study)]. A total of 268 adult patients with clinically suspected or confirmed bacterial infections from 31 Japanese intensive care units (ICUs) were analyzed. The patients were divided into two groups: patients who were administered carbapenems as initial antimicrobials (initial carbapenem group,
n
= 99) and those who were not administered carbapenems (initial non-carbapenem group,
n
= 169). The primary outcomes were mortality at day 28 and detection of MDR pathogens. Multivariate logistic regression analysis revealed that mortality at day 28 did not differ between the two groups [18 (18%) vs 27 (16%), respectively; odds ratio: 1.25 (95% confidence interval (CI): 0.59–2.65),
P
= 0.564]. The subdistribution hazard ratio for detecting MDR pathogens on day 28 per additional day of carbapenem use is 1.08 (95% CI: 1.05–1.13,
P
< 0.001 using the Fine-Gray model with death regarded as a competing event). In conclusion, in-hospital mortality was similar between the groups, and a longer duration of carbapenem use as the initial antimicrobial therapy resulted in a higher risk of detection of new MDR pathogens.

IMPORTANCE

We found no statistical difference in mortality with the empirical use of carbapenems as initial antimicrobial therapy among critically ill patients with bacterial infections. Our study revealed a lower proportion of inappropriate initial antimicrobial administrations than those reported in previous studies. This result suggests the importance of appropriate risk assessment for the involvement of multidrug-resistant (MDR) pathogens and the selection of suitable antibiotics based on risk. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to demonstrate that a longer duration of carbapenem use as initial therapy is associated with a higher risk of subsequent detection of MDR pathogens. This finding underscores the importance of efforts to minimize the duration of carbapenem use as initial antimicrobial therapy when it is necessary.