Abstract P4-20-07: Research biopsies in oncology-patient willingness, perceptions, understanding, and experience: An integrative review
Authors: Abraham E , Spring L , D'Alleva J , Malvarosa G , Tripp E , Post K , Bardia A , Habin K 
Published: March 2017

Research Biopsies in Oncology – Patient Willingness, Perceptions, Understanding, and Experience: An Integrative Review.

Background

Tumors are classified into subsets based on molecular alterations to select personalized therapies, and research biopsies are essential to advance personalized medicine. However, research biopsies can be associated with complications, results might not directly benefit the patient particularly on-treatment biopsies obtained for evaluation of pharmacodynamics effect, and mandatory requirement can impact patient enrollment in clinical trials. Understanding patient perceptions and experiences surrounding research biopsies may highlight areas for improvement and could expand participation in clinical trials.

Objectives

The purpose of this integrative review explores and summarizes the current literature on oncology patient perceptions, willingness and experience of research biopsies evaluates data to determine potential implications for practice improvement, patient experience, and clinical trial participation.

Methods

Articles from January 2010-February 2016 were retrieved via a systematic search restricted to English of MEDLINE/Ovid. Search terms included breast cancer, cancer, research, biopsy, perceptions and attitudes. Inclusion criteria were studies that included patients with cancer and had information on patient willingness, perceptions, understanding, attitudes, and/or experience around research biopsies. Abstracts were independently reviewed for inclusion by two authors. For each selected manuscript, the following information was abstracted: primary author, sample and setting, results, conclusion, and assessment of strength of evidence level and quality using John Hopkins Nursing Evidence Based Practice (JHNEBP) Rating Scales.

Results

The search resulted in 175 unique studies. 17 abstracts were selected for full manuscript review. From these, 8 were excluded for not meeting inclusion criteria. The 9 selected studies ranged in sample size from 10-362 and all articles were rated IIIA-B evidence level. The majority of studies (66.7%) focused on breast cancer patients. Studies exploring patient willingness to undergo research biopsies (N=8) revealed variability in patient willingness to undergo research biopsies and identified research biopsies identified as a potential barrier to clinical trial participation. Studies exploring patient understanding of the risks and benefits of research biopsies (N=3) revealed overall poor understanding among patients. One study explored anxiety surrounding the research biopsy procedure, suggesting significant anticipatory anxiety is a significant concern. Issues surrounding informed consent were raised in several studies.

Conclusions

Research biopsies can be associated with significant anxiety, potentially impact enrollment in clinical trials, and consequently there is a need for development of strategies to improve patient experience and education. While a separate consent for research biopsies may be onerous, tailored educational materials, focus groups, as well as development of alternate strategies such as liquid biopsies, are essential to ensuring advancement in cancer care and outcomes.

Key Words: cancer, research, biopsy, perceptions, attitudes.

Citation Format: Abraham E, Spring L, D'Alleva J, Malvarosa G, Tripp E, Post K, Bardia A, Habin K. Research biopsies in oncology-patient willingness, perceptions, understanding, and experience: An integrative review [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2016 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2016 Dec 6-10; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2017;77(4 Suppl):Abstract nr P4-20-07.