Normative growth modeling of brain morphology reveals neuroanatomical heterogeneity and biological subtypes in children with ADHD
Authors: Bu Xuan , Zhao Yilu , Zheng Xiangyu , Fu Zhao , Zhang Kangfuxi , Sun Xiaoyi , Cui Zaixu , Xia Mingrui , Ma Leilei , Liu Ningyu , Lu Jing , Zhao Gai , Ding Yuyin , Deng Yao , Wang Jiali , Chen Rui , Zhang Haibo , Men Weiwei , Wang Yanpei , Gao Jiahong , Tan Shuping , Sun Li , Qin Shaozheng , Tao Sha , Wang Yufeng , Dong Qi , Cao Qingjiu , Yang Li , He Yong 
Published: March 2024

Background

Neuroimaging studies suggest substantial individual heterogeneity in brain phenotypes in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). However, how these individual-level brain phenotypes contribute to the identification of ADHD biotypes and whether these biotypes have different treatment outcomes and neurobiological underpinnings remain largely unknown.

Methods

We collected multisite, high-quality structural magnetic resonance imaging data from 1,006 children aged 6-14 years, including 351 children with ADHD and 655 typically developing children. Normative growth models of cortical thickness were established for 219 regions in the typically developing children. Individual-level deviations from these normal references were quantified and clustered to identify ADHD biotypes. We validated the replicability and generalizability of the ADHD biotypes using two independent datasets and evaluated the associations of the biotypes with symptomatic, cognitive, and gene expression profiles, as well as follow-up treatment outcomes.

Findings

No more than 10% of children with ADHD had extreme deviations in cortical thickness in a single region, suggesting high heterogeneity among individuals with ADHD. On the basis of the brain deviation maps, we discovered two robust ADHD biotypes, an infra-normal subtype with cortical thinning associated with ADHD symptoms and a supranormal subtype with cortical thickening associated with cognition. Patients with the infra-normal subtype responded better to methylphenidate than to atomoxetine, although both subtypes showed treatment efficacy. Brain deviations in the infra-normal subtype were explained by the expression levels of genes enriched in presynaptic and axonal development and polygenic risk of ADHD.

Interpretation

We identified anatomically distinct, clinically valuable, and biologically informed ADHD subtypes, providing insight into the neurobiological basis of clinical heterogeneity and facilitating a personalized medication strategy for ADHD patients.

Panel: Research in context

Evidence before this study

Substantial individual heterogeneity in brain phenotypes in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) motivates the need to discover homogeneous biotypes. We searched PubMed for research articles on ADHD biotypes using brain MRI published before December 1, 2023, using the search terms ((attention deficit hyperactivity disorder [Title/Abstract]) OR (ADHD [Title/Abstract])) AND ((subtypes [Title/Abstract]) OR (subgroups [Title/Abstract]) OR (subtyping [Title/Abstract])) AND ((MRI [Title/Abstract]) OR (neuroimaging [Title/Abstract]) OR (brain [Title/Abstract])) without language restrictions. Of the eight included studies, two identified ADHD biotypes using structural morphology, four used functional activity, and two used multimodal features. However, none of these studies considered the developmental effect of the brain phenotypes, examined treatment response, or investigated the genetic correlates of the biotypes.

Added value of this study

This study is the first to use individualized brain measures extracted from normative models to investigate ADHD biotypes in a large sample of more than 1,000 children. We identified two reproducible ADHD biotypes, characterized by distinct symptomatic, cognitive, and gene expression profiles, as well as differential treatment responses. This study advances our understanding of the neurobiological basis underlying the clinical heterogeneity of ADHD and highlights the critical need to discover ADHD biotypes using an unbiased and individualized approach.

Implications of all the available evidence

This study revealed remarkable neuroanatomical heterogeneity in ADHD patients and identified anatomically distinct, clinically valuable, and biologically informed ADHD biotypes. Our findings have potential value for the investigation of data-driven biotypes to evaluate treatment efficacy and facilitate personalized treatment. We also highlight the need for future studies to move beyond the understanding of ADHD solely based on the “average patient” perspective.