Predicting the strength of urban-rural clines in a Mendelian polymorphism along a latitudinal gradient
Authors: Santangelo James S. , Thompson Ken A. , Cohan Beata , Syed Jibran , Ness Rob W. , Johnson Marc T. J. 
Published: May 2019

Cities are emerging as models for addressing the fundamental question of whether populations evolve in parallel to similar environments. Here, we examine the environmental factors that drive parallel evolutionary urban-rural clines in a Mendelian trait — the cyanogenic antiherbivore defense of white clover (Trifolium repens). We sampled over 700 urban and rural clover populations across 16 cities along a latitudinal transect in eastern North America. In each population, we quantified the frequency of genotypes that produce hydrogen cyanide (HCN), and in a subset of the cities we estimated the frequency of the alleles at the two genes (CYP79D15andLi) that epistatically interact to produce HCN. We then tested the hypothesis that winter environmental conditions cause the evolution of clines in HCN by comparing the strength of clines among cities located along a gradient of winter temperatures and frost exposure. Overall, half of the cities exhibited urban-rural clines in the frequency of HCN, whereby urban populations evolved lower HCN frequencies. The weakest clines in HCN occurred in cities with the lowest temperatures but greatest snowfall, supporting the hypothesis that snow buffers plants against winter frost and constrains the formation of clines. By contrast, the strongest clines occurred in the warmest cities where snow and frost are rare, suggesting that alternative selective agents are maintaining clines in warmer cities. Additionally, some clines were driven by evolution at onlyCYP79D15, consistent with stronger and more consistent selection on this locus than onLi. Together, our results demonstrate that both the agents and targets of selection vary across cities and highlight urban environments as large-scale models for disentangling the causes of parallel evolution in nature.

Impact Summary

Understanding whether independent populations evolve in the same way (i.e., in parallel) when subject to similar environments remains an important problem in evolutionary biology. Urban environments are a model for addressing the extent of parallel evolution in nature due to their convergent environments (e.g. heat islands, pollution, fragmentation), such that two distant cities are often more similar to one another than either is to nearby nonurban habitats. In this paper, we used white clover (Trifolium repens) as a model to study the drivers of parallel evolution in response to urbanization. We collected >11,000 plants from urban and rural habitats across 16 cities in eastern North America to examine how cities influence the evolution of a Mendelian polymorphism for an antiherbivore defense trait – hydrogen cyanide (HCN). This trait had previously been shown to exhibit adaptive evolution to winter temperature gradients at continental scales. Here we tested the hypothesis that winter environmental conditions cause changes in the frequency of HCN between urban and rural habitats. We found that half of all cities had lower frequency of HCN producing genotypes relative to rural habitats, demonstrating that cities drive parallel losses of HCN in eastern North America. We then used environmental data to understand why cities vary in the extent to which they drive reduction in HCN frequencies. The warmest cities showed the greatest reductions in HCN frequencies in urban habitats, while colder, snowier cities showed little change in HCN between urban and rural habitats. This suggests that snow weakens the strength of natural selection against HCN in cities. However, it additionally suggests alternative ecological or evolutionary mechanisms drive the strong differences in HCN between urban and rural habitats in the warmest cities. Overall, our work highlights urban environments as powerful, large-scale models for disentangling the causes of parallel and non-parallel evolution in nature.