One-year outcome of transcatheter repair of tricuspid regurgitation: comparison edge-to-edge repair versus anuloplasty
Authors: Ozturk C , Vogelhuber J , Sugiura A , Reckers D , Nickenig G , Weber M 
Published: November 2020

Tricuspid regurgitation (TR) is found to be associated with increased mortality, morbidity, and impaired quality of life. The interventional tricuspid valve repair techniques are being increasingly performed. We aimed to compare the mid-term outcomes of both methods (Clipping and Banding) in our patient cohort. F

We retrospectively included 60 patients who underwent between January 2016 to March 2018 the transcatheter tricuspid valve edge-to-edge repair or annuloplasty in our center. Follow up (FU) examinations were done 12.6±7.6 months. Comprehensive transthoracic echocardiography inclusively 3D acquisitions were performed before and at FU in all patients. The 3D data were used for strain analysis of left and right ventricles and atriums through a dedicated automated offline program (TomTec).

We retrospectively included 60 patients (75±6.1 years, 40% female) with symptomatic (65% ascites, 95% edema, 100% NYHA&gt;II, 75% liver congestion) severe TR (TR&gt;II, 90% functional) at surgical high risk (EuroSCORE II: 5.2±3.2%). Forty patients underwent transcatheter TV edge-to-edge repair (TTVR, MitraClip, PASCAL), and twenty patients were treated by interventional annuloplasty (Cardioband).

At baseline, the patients underwent edge-to-edge (E2E) repair showed more comorbidities with higher EuroScore II and more decreased functional capacity. Echocardiographical, patients who underwent annuloplasty, presented a more significant coaptation gap with more impaired RV function and more dilated right atrium. In contrast, the E2E group showed to have higher right ventricular systolic pressure. Left ventricular dimensions and functions were comparable between the groups.

Left atrial volume and right atrial pressure were found to be statistically significantly reduced in both groups at FU. RV and RA fractional area change were found to be relevantly improved solely after interventional annuloplasty at FU. Left ventricular end-diastolic pressure significantly increased in the E2E group with relevant reduction of outflow/inflow ratio. Moreover, interventional annuloplasty, as expected, reduces SL diameter more significantly.

Patients showed lower symptoms and better functional capacity 12 months after interventional E2E therapy. Of note, improvement in walking distance was found to be significantly higher in patients who underwent annuloplasty. However, patients were hospitalized significantly more frequently after interventional annuloplasty.

In conclusion, both interventional techniques are safe, feasible, and effective for treatment of tricuspid regurgitation in patients at surgical high risk. Interventional annuloplasty significantly impacts on RV function and geometry, and reduces SL diameter significantly. Patients were found to have decreased symptoms, better functional capacity, as well as fewer rehospitalization 12 months after interventional E2E therapy, although they showed more comorbidities at baseline compared to interventional annuloplasty.

Funding Acknowledgement

Type of funding source: None