X-ray Dark-Field Chest Imaging can Detect and Quantify Emphy-sema in COPD Patients
Authors: Willer Konstantin , Fingerle Alexander , Noichl Wolfgang , De Marco Fabio , Frank Manuela , Urban Theresa , Schick Rafael , Gustschin Alex , Gleich Bernhard , Herzen Julia , Koehler Thomas , Yaroshenko Andre , Pralow Thomas , Zimmermann Gregor , Renger Bernhard , Sauter Andreas , Pfeiffer Daniela , Makowski Marcus , Rummeny Ernst , Grenier Philippe , Pfeiffer Franz 
Published: January 2021

Background

Diseases of the respiratory system are leading global causes of chronic morbidity and mortality. While advanced medical imaging technologies of today deliver detailed diagnostic information, a low-dose, fast, and inexpensive option for early detection and/or follow-ups is still lacking. Here, we report on the first human application of a novel modality, namely X-ray dark-field chest imaging, which might fill this gap. Enabling the assessment of microstructural changes in lung parenchyma, this technique presents a more sensitive alternative to conventional chest X-rays, and yet requires only a fraction of the dose applied in computed tomography (CT).

Methods

For this first clinical evaluation, we have built a novel dark-field chest X-ray system, which is also capable of simultaneously acquiring a conventional thorax radiograph (7 seconds, 0·035 mSv effective dose). Representing a major medical condition, we selected chronic obstructive pulmonary disease as study subject to obtain a first impression of potential diagnostic benefits relevant to humans. For a collective of 77 patients with different disease stages, X-ray dark-field- and CT-images were acquired and visually assessed by 5 readers. In addition, pulmonary function tests were performed for every patient. The individual data sets were evaluated in a statistical work-up using correlation testing, rank-based analysis of variance, and pair-wise post-hoc comparison.

Findings

Compared to CT-based parameters (quantitative emphysema: ρ=–0·27, p=0·0893 and visual emphysema: ρ=–0·45, p=0·0028), the dark-field signal (ρ=0·62, p<0·0001) yields a stronger correlation with diffusion capacity in the evaluated collective. Emphysema assessment based on dark-field chest X-ray features yields consistent conclusions with findings from visual CT image interpretation and shows improved diagnostic performance in comparison to conventional clinical tests characterizing emphysema.

Interpretation

X-ray dark-field chest imaging allows the diagnosis of pulmonary emphysema as it provides relevant information representing the structural condition of lung parenchyma. Significant diagnostic benefits are also expected for other lung disorders.

Funding

European Research Council, Royal Philips, Karlsruhe Nano Micro Facility.

Research in context

Evidence before this study

With a rising number of examinations in the last decades, X-rays play an indispensable role in clinical routine. Contrast formation in medical X-ray imaging such as radiography, fluoroscopy, and computed tomography is based on attenuation, which generally benefits from large differences in atomic number and/or mass density between involved materials. If these conditions are not prevalent, or the resolution of the imaging system is not sufficient, diagnostic capabilities are limited. However, attenuation is not the only physical effect X-rays are subjected to when penetrating matter. Variations in an object’s electron density lead to refraction and coherent small-angle scattering of incident X-rays. Phase-sensitive imaging techniques can detect these wave-optical phenomena, yielding additional object information. The dark-field signal, being a function of small-angle scattering, can provide structural information on the micron scale, generally below the resolution limit of the imaging system. Due to their very stringent requirements to X-ray source coherence, these techniques were originally limited to large-scale synchrotron facilities. The proposal of a three-grating interferometer in 2006, however, enabled the use of low-brilliance sources for X-ray phase-contrast imaging and thereby paved the way into the clinics. Such an apparatus elegantly allows the simultaneous acquisition of the conventional attenuation, differential phase-contrast, and novel dark-field signals. In a compact table-top system suitable for investigating murine disease models, numerous studies on pulmonary disorders such as chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD), pulmonary fibrosis, pneumothorax, ventilator-associated lung injury, lung cancer, and pneumonia have been conducted and demonstrated a broad diagnostic value of the dark-field modality in particular. Adapting the system to enable imaging of the human body is a technical challenge due to limitations of the micrometer-fine, high aspect ratio grating structures in terms of fabricable size and performance at clinically relevant X-ray energies. The first evidences that these limitations are manageable were delivered in 2017 and 2018 by in-vivo porcine and human cadaver studies with an experimental prototype system.

Added value of this study

With this work we present the first X-ray dark-field chest images of human subjects in-vivo and demonstrate the method’s feasibility in a clinical surrounding. To enable this study, we have conceived, constructed, and commissioned a custom-built first demonstrator system suitable for patient use. This includes satisfying clinical demands regarding safety, usability, acquisition time, radiation dose, field of view, and image quality. This study marks the transition from investigating artificially induced disease models to evaluating the modality’s actual diagnostic performance in patients.

Implications of all available evidence

Our findings indicate that X-ray dark-field radiography provides image-type information of the lungs’ underlying microstructure in humans. In view of the strong link between alveolar structure and the functional condition of the lung, this capability is highly relevant for respiratory medicine and might help to establish a better understanding of pulmonary disorders. With regard to early detection of COPD, which is generally accompanied by structural impairments of the lung, this novel technique might support resolving the prevalent under-diagnosis reported in literature. With an effective dose significantly lower (about a factor of hundred) compared to thorax computed tomography, dark-field radiography could be used as broadly deployed screening tool.