Assessing the Contribution of Self-Monitoring Through a Commercial Weight Loss App: Mediation and Predictive Modeling Study (Preprint)
Authors: Farage Gregory , Simmons Courtney , Kocak Mehmet , Klesges Robert C , Talcott G Wayne , Richey Phyllis , Hare Marion , Johnson Karen C , Sen Saunak , Krukowski Rebecca 
Published: July 2021

BACKGROUND

Electronic self-monitoring technology has the potential to provide unique insights into important behaviors for inducing weight loss.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to investigate the effects of electronic self-monitoring behavior (using the commercial <i>Lose It!</i> app) and weight loss interventions (with differing amounts of counselor feedback and support) on 4- and 12-month weight loss.

METHODS

In this secondary analysis of the Fit Blue study, we compared the results of two interventions of a randomized controlled trial. Counselor-initiated participants received consistent support from the interventionists, and self-paced participants received assistance upon request. The participants (N=191), who were active duty military personnel, were encouraged to self-monitor their diet and exercise with the Lose It! app or website. We examined the associations between intervention assignment and self-monitoring behaviors. We conducted a mediation analysis of the intervention assignment for weight loss through multiple mediators—app use (calculated from the first principal component [PC] of electronically collected variables), number of weigh-ins, and 4-month weight change. We used linear regression to predict weight loss at 4 and 12 months, and the accuracy was measured using cross-validation.

RESULTS

On average, the counselor-initiated–treatment participants used the app more frequently than the self-paced–treatment participants. The first PC represented app use frequencies, the second represented calories recorded, and the third represented reported exercise frequency and exercise caloric expenditure. We found that 4-month weight loss was partially mediated through app use (ie, the first PC; 60.3%) and the number of weigh-ins (55.8%). However, the 12-month weight loss was almost fully mediated by 4-month weight loss (94.8%). Linear regression using app data from the first 8 weeks, the number of self–weigh-ins at 8 weeks, and baseline data explained approximately 30% of the variance in 4-month weight loss. App use frequency (first PC; <i>P</i>=.001), self-monitored caloric intake (second PC; <i>P</i>=.001), and the frequency of self-weighing at 8 weeks (<i>P</i>=.008) were important predictors of 4-month weight loss. Predictions for 12-month weight with the same variables produced an <i>R</i><sup>2</sup> value of 5%; only the number of self–weigh-ins was a significant predictor of 12-month weight loss. The <i>R</i><sup>2</sup> value using 4-month weight loss as a predictor was 31%. Self-reported exercise did not contribute to either model (4 months: <i>P</i>=.77; 12 months: <i>P</i>=.15).

CONCLUSIONS

We found that app use and daily reported caloric intake had a substantial impact on weight loss prediction at 4 months. Our analysis did not find evidence of an association between participant self-monitoring exercise information and weight loss. As 12-month weight loss was completely mediated by 4-month weight loss, intervention targets should focus on promoting early and frequent dietary intake self-monitoring and self-weighing to promote early weight loss, which leads to long-term success.

CLINICALTRIAL

ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02063178; https://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT02063178