Measurement of activity of developmental signal transduction pathways to quantify stem cell pluripotency and phenotypically characterize differentiated cells
Authors: Wesseling-Rozendaal Yvonne , Holtzer Laurent , Verhaegh Wim , van de Stolpe Anja 
Published: April 2021

Stem cell research is emerging both as a scientifically and clinically relevant area. One of the current challenges in stem cell research and regenerative medicine is assessment of the pluripotency state of induced pluripotent stem (iPS) cells. Once a stem cell differentiation process is initiated the challenge is how to assess the state of differentiation, and the purity of the differentiated cell population. Stem cell potency and differentiation states are determined by tightly coordinated activity of developmental signaling pathways, such as the Notch, Hedgehog, TGFβ, Wnt, PI3K, MAPK-AP1, and NFκB pathways. Source of the stem cells and culture protocols may influence stem cell phenotype, with potential consequences for pluripotency and in general for experimental reproducibility. Human pluripotent embryonic (hES) and iPS stem cell lines under different culture conditions, organ derived multipotent stem cells, and differentiated cell types, were phenotyped with respect to functional activity of developmental signaling pathways.

Methods

We previously reported on the development and validation of a novel assay platform for quantitative measurement of activity of multiple signal transduction pathways (STP) simultaneously in a single sample, based on interpreting a preselected set of target mRNA expression levels. Assays were used to calculate Notch, Hedgehog, TGFβ, Wnt, PI3K, MAPK-AP1, and NFκB signal transduction pathway activity scores for individual cell samples, using publicly available Affymetrix expression microarray data.

Results

Culture conditions (e.g. mouse versus human feeder) influenced pluripotent stem cell pathway activity profiles. hES and iPS stem cell lines cultured in the same lab under similar conditions showed minimal variation in pathway activity profile despite different genetic backgrounds, while across different labs larger variations were measured, even for the same stem cell line. Pathway activity scores for PI3K, MAPK, Hedgehog, Notch, TGFβ, and NFκB pathways rapidly decreased upon pluripotent stem cell differentiation, while increasing for the Wnt pathway. Further differentiation to intestinal progenitor cells resulted in higher PI3K, Wnt and Notch pathway activity. In multipotent intestinal crypt stem cells obtained from intestinal mucosa samples, similar Notch and even higher Wnt pathway activity were measured, which disappeared upon differentiation to mucosal cells.

Conclusion

Results support the validity of using these STP assays for quantitative phenotyping of stem cells and differentiated derivatives, and enabled definition of a pluripotency profile with high PI3K, MAPK, Hedgehog, TGFβ, Notch, and NFκB, and low Wnt pathway activity scores.

Measurement of combined signaling pathway activity scores is expected to improve experimental reproducibility and standardization of pluripotent and multipotent stem cell culture and differentiation. It enables controlled manipulation of signaling pathway activity using pathway targeting compounds. An envisioned additional utility may lie in quality control for regenerative medicine purposes.