Mathematical modeling suggests heterogeneous replication ofMycobacterium tuberculosisin rabbits
Authors: Ganusov Vitaly V. , Kolloli Afsal , Subbian Selvakumar 
Published: February 2024

Tuberculosis (TB), the disease caused byMycobacterium tuberculosis(Mtb), remains a major health problem with 10.6 million cases of the disease and 1.6 million deaths in 2021. It is well understood that pulmonary TB is due to Mtb growth in the lung but quantitative estimates of rates of Mtb replication and death in lungs of patients or animals such as monkeys or rabbits remain largely unknown. We performed experiments with rabbits infected with a novel, virulent clinical Mtb isolate of the Beijing lineage, HN878, carrying an unstable plasmid pBP10. In our in vitro experiments we found that pBP10 is more stable in HN878 strain than in a more commonly used laboratory-adapted Mtb strain H37Rv (the segregation coefficient beings= 0.10 in HN878 vs.s= 0.18 in H37Rv). Interestingly, the kinetics of plasmid-bearing bacteria in lungs of Mtb-infected rabbits did not follow an expected monotonic decline; the percent of plasmid-bearing cells increased between 28 and 56 days post-infection and remained stable between 84 and 112 days post-infection despite a large increase in bacterial numbers in the lung at late time points. Mathematical modeling suggested that such a non-monotonic change in the percent of plasmid-bearing cells can be explained if the lung Mtb population consists of several (at least 2) sub-populations with different replication/death kinetics: one major population expanding early and being controlled/eliminated, while another, a smaller population expanding at later times causing a counterintuitive increase in the percent of plasmid-bearing cells. Importantly, a model with one kinetically homogeneous Mtb population could not explain the data including when the model was run stochastically. Given that in rabbits HN878 strain forms well circumscribed granulomas, our results suggest independent bacterial dynamics in subsets of such granulomas. Our model predictions can be tested in future experiments in which HN878-pBP10 dynamics in individual granulomas is followed over time. Taken together, our new data and mathematical modeling-based analyses illustrate differences in Mtb dynamics in mice and rabbits confirming a perhaps somewhat obvious observation that “rabbits are not mice”.

Author Summary

How quickly Mycobacterium tuberculosis (Mtb) replicates and dies in lungs of infected individuals is likely to determine the outcome of the infection – either control/clearance of the bacteria by the host immune response or progression to active disease, tuberculosis (TB). And yet, only a few studies, primarily in mice, rigorously estimated the rates of Mtb replication and death during an in vivo infection. We infected rabbits with a novel clinical isolate of Mtb carrying an unstable, “replication clock” plasmid and followed the dynamics of bacteria over time. Interestingly, previous methods developed to estimate Mtb replication and death rates using similar data for Mtb infection of mice failed to describe our novel data on Mtb dynamics in rabbits; we showed that heterogeneous dynamics of Mtb in semi-independent subpopulations in lungs of Mtb-infected rabbits may be one explanation of this failure of the method. Our results highlight potential differences in Mtb dynamics in different mammalian hosts and suggest ways to evaluate heterogeneity of Mtb replication and death rates in vivo.