P-025 Mitochondrial activity in sperm is associated to blastocyst development: a double-donation study
Authors: Ribas-Maynou J , Novo S , Rovira S , Antich M , Yeste M 
Published: July 2024

Study question

Do oxidative parameters in sperm affect oocyte fertilization or blastocyst development in double-donation ICSI cycles?

Summary answer

While intracellular oxidative stress in sperm does not suppose an impact on fertilization or embryo development, mitochondrial activity is related to increased blastocyst development rates

What is known already

Reactive oxygen species(ROS) are molecules causing a detrimental effect on sperm quality and function, especially when they are imbalanced with respect to the sperm and seminal plasma antioxidant capacity. Previous research have extensively demonstrated that sperm affected by oxidative stress(OS) show reduced fertilizing capacity, and lead to embryos with impaired development after conventional IVF. The role of OS in sperm in the case of ICSI is, however, controversial because many factors may cause a bias. Not only could this explain the inconsistent results reported thus far, but would also support the need of testing healthy donor gametes to reduce variability.

Study design, size, duration

This research was devised in the context of a collaboration between a sperm bank and a public university, and was set as a blinded, retrospective study that included samples from 45 sperm donors used in a total of 55 oocyte donation cycles. Intracellular levels of total ROS and of superoxides (O2•-), oxidative stress and mitochondrial activity (MA) were evaluated in frozen-thawed sperm donor samples, and related to the embryo outcomes obtained from the same samples.

Participants/materials, setting, methods

Samples from selected sperm donors were used to fertilize oocytes through ICSI in oocyte donation programs, and fertilization and blastocyst rates were recorded. Sperm viability and intracellular levels of total ROS and superoxides were determined through a combined assay (2’,7’-Dichlorofluorescin diacetate/Hydroethidine/Sytox Red); oxidative stress and sperm viability were assessed through co-staining with CellRox Far Red and propidium iodide (PI); and MA (mitochondrial membrane potential) and sperm viability were evaluated after staining with DiOC6(3) and PI.

Main results and the role of chance

The average and standard deviation for fertilization and blastocyst rates were 76.8%±17.3% and 67.5%±22.8%, respectively. Taking the viable sperm population into account, percentages of sperm with high ROS and low O2•- were 17.6%±15.9%, those with high ROS and high O2•- were 0.5%±0.4%, percentages of sperm with low ROS and low O2•- were 25.9%±9.2%, and those with low ROS and high O2•- were 54.5%±21.1%. The evaluation of oxidative stress with CellRox revealed that the percentage of viable sperm with high OS was 63.1%±16.5%. Neither intracellular levels of ROS and superoxides, nor oxidative stress in viable sperm were found to be correlated to fertilization or blastocyst rates (P&gt;0.05). In spite of this, the percentage of viable sperm with high MA, which was 20.7%±10.5%, was observed to be positively correlated to blastocyst rates (Rs=0.276; P=0.04). While sperm mitochondria do not participate in further embryo development, a greater mitochondrial activity in post-thawed donor sperm could indicate a healthier sperm function. Mitochondrial activity could, therefore, be used as a predictive biomarker for embryo development.

Limitations, reasons for caution

The sample size is the main limitation of this study, despite the efforts made to include a high number of sperm donors.

Wider implications of the findings

Results obtained in the present study show that ICSI evades the detrimental effects of sperm oxidative stress on fertilization and embryo development. Yet, sperm mitochondrial activity could be used as a biomarker to test the ability of a sperm donor to generate healthy embryos that develop up to blastocyst stage.

Trial registration number

Not applicable