COMPREHENSIVE EXPERT STUDY OF A CONSTRUCTION INDUSTRY FACILITY TO DETERMINE THE CONSTRUCTION READINESS OF A CONSTRUCTION FACILITY AND DETERMINE THE VOLUME AND COST OF THE WORK ACTUALLY PERFORMED
Authors:   Atyrau university of oil and gas named after Safi Utebayev, Arstanaliev Yesengeldy Uteshevich , Zhanturin Zhomart Kairzhanovich ,   Atyrau university of oil and gas named after Safi Utebayev, Abishev Murat Nikolaevich ,   Atyrau university of oil and gas named after Safi Utebayev, Tazhieva Gulmira Baltasovna ,   Atyrau university of oil and gas named after Safi Utebayev, Mukambetkalieva Raushan Yerlanovna ,   Atyrau university of oil and gas named after Safi Utebayev, Vasilevskaya Svetlana Petrovna ,   Orenburg state university, Solopova Valentina Aleksandrovna ,   Orenburg state university, Sagitov Ramil Fargatovich ,   Scientific research design institute "Industrial and civil engineering" LLC
Published: January 2025

This comprehensive expert survey of the facility was compiled based on the results of a construction and technical examination to determine the construction readiness of the construction facility and to determine the volumes and costs of the work actually performed.
The purpose of the work was to establish:
- the degree of construction readiness of the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of signing the Acceptance Certificates from the Contractor to the Subcontractor (June 20, 22 and 27, 2023), based on the terms of the Agreements (design and estimate documentation), building codes and the requirements of federal legislation in the field of industrial construction;
- is it possible for the Subcontractor to commence and perform work under the Agreements at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of signing the Acceptance Certificates from the Contractor to the Subcontractor (June 20, 22 and 27, 2023) taking into account their actual degree of readiness for the specified period of time, based on the terms of the Agreements (design and estimate documentation), building codes and requirements of federal legislation in the field of industrial construction;
- the degree of construction readiness of the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of the expert visual and instrumental inspection with the participation of a representative of the Contractor and the Subcontractor, based on the terms of the Agreements (design and estimate documentation), building codes and requirements of federal legislation in the field of industrial construction;
- is it possible for the Subcontractor to commence and carry out work under the Contracts at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of the expert visual and instrumental inspection with the participation of a representative of the Contractor and the Subcontractor, based on the terms of the Contracts (design and estimate documentation), building codes and the requirements of federal legislation in the field of industrial construction; - the volume and cost of work actually performed by ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC under the contracts concluded between ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC and SibER JSC - No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1480 dated June 19, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1481 dated June 22, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1491 dated June 20, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1526 dated June 19, 2023 and No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1528 dated June 19, 2023; - the volume and cost of additional works actually performed by ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 for the preparation of construction sites not included in the subject of the contracts concluded between ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC and SibER JSC - No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1480 dated June 19, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1481 dated June 22, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1491 dated June 20, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1526 dated June 19, 2023 and No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1528 dated June 19, 2023.
As a result of the work performed, the following conclusions were made:
- the degree of construction readiness of construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of signing the Acceptance Certificates from the Contractor to the Subcontractor (June 20, 22 and 27, 2023) based on the terms of the Agreements (design and estimate documentation), building codes and requirements of the Federal Legislation in the field of industrial construction (RF Government Resolution of April 22, 2019 No. 480), according to the experts' visit to the research site and the visual instrumental examination, analysis of photo and video documentation, design estimates and other documents submitted for examination:
- section No. 1 - the degree of construction readiness is - 0%;
- section No. 2 - the degree of construction readiness is - 0.14%;
- section No. 3 - the degree of construction readiness is - 9.35%;
- section No. 4 - the degree of construction readiness is - 0%.;
- commencement and performance of works by the Subcontractor under the Contracts at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 within the framework of contracts No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1480 dated 19.06.2023, SIBERSIBEM-23/1481 dated 22.06.2023, SIBERSIBEM-23/1491 dated 20.06.2023, SIBERSIBEM-23/1526 dated 19.06.2023, SIBERSIBEM-23/1528 dated 19.06.2023 determined by clause 4.6.1 — "Proceed to perform the work after receiving the work permit issued by the Contractor, in accordance with clause 4.4.5 of the agreement." Before starting the work, the Contractor was obliged to complete the entire list of preparatory work (clause 4.6 of SP 48.13330.2019). The acceptance certificates of the sites from the Contractor to the Subcontractor (June 20, 22 and 27, 2023) are only a formal permit for the commencement and performance of work under contracts at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 located at the address: 630032, Novosibirsk, Stantsionnaya, 4, although in fact the construction sites did not have the proper construction readiness, which is confirmed by the studies of this examination on issues No. 3 and No. 4, that is, the commencement and performance of work is possible only if the Contractor fulfills the conditions listed in clause 4.6 of SP 48.13330.2019; - at the time of the experts' visit from Architecture LLC to conduct an expert visual and instrumental inspection with the participation of a representative of the Contractor and the Subcontractor, the degree of construction readiness of the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 located at the address: 630032, Novosibirsk, Stantsionnaya, 4, was determined based on the terms of the Agreements (design and estimate documentation), building codes and requirements of the Federal Legislation in the field of industrial construction (RF Government Resolution of April 22, 2019 No. 480), and it was:
- section No. 1 - the degree of construction readiness is - 9.13%;
- section No. 2 - the degree of construction readiness is - 0.14%;
- section No. 3 - the degree of construction readiness is - 10.52%;
- section No. 4 - the degree of construction readiness is - 0%;
- the commencement and performance of works by the Subcontractor under the Agreements at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 at the time of the expert visual and instrumental inspection with the participation of a representative of the Contractor and the Subcontractor is possible upon completion of the entire list of preparatory works at the construction sites (clause 4.6 of SP 48.13330.2019). Based on the expert visual and instrumental inspection, the construction readiness of the sites for sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 was determined (answers to questions No. 1 and No. 3), these percentage ratios do not allow construction and other work to be carried out on sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4, which was recorded and confirmed by the topographic method (expert geodetic survey), as a result, visual inspection reports were drawn up at the construction site (for the purpose of detecting objective circumstances that impede the work) for sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4; - the volume and cost of works actually performed by ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC under the contracts concluded between ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC and SibER JSC - No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1480 dated June 19, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1481 dated June 22, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1491 dated June 20, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1526 dated June 19, 2023 and No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1528 dated June 19, 2023 are determined and formed in tables 05-08, the cost is: 2,411,426.95 rubles (including VAT 20%);
- the volume and cost of additional works actually performed by ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC at the construction sites of sections No. 1, No. 2, No. 3 and No. 4 at the construction sites: Novosibirsk CHPP-2, Novosibirsk CHPP-3 for the preparation of construction sites not included in the subject of the contracts concluded between ROSTROYGAZPROM LLC and SibER JSC - No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1480 dated June 19, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1481 dated June 22, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1491 dated June 20, 2023, No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1526 dated June 19, 2023 and No. SIBERSIBEM-23/1528 dated June 19, 2023 are defined and formed in tables 09-11, the cost is: 2,277,932.89 rubles (including VAT 20%).