Effect of macular pigment optical density on Yellow‐Blue and Red‐Green colour discrimination
Authors: Rodriguez‐Carmona Marisa , Barbur John L. 
Published: January 2024

The macular pigment (MP) absorbs preferentially short‐wavelength light and its narrow spectral absorption curve overlaps mostly the spectral responsivity function of S‐cones, although the M‐ and L‐cones are also affected. The MP is restricted to the centre ~14° disc region of the retina with a peak optical density (OD) at the centre in the range 0 to 1 log units. Although the macular pigment optical density (MPOD) decreases rapidly with increasing eccentricity, carotenoid supplementation studies reveal a large uptake of lutein and zeaxanthin, particularly in the parafoveal region and covering the centre ~6° to 8° of the fovea (doi: 10.1111/j.1475‐1313.2006.00386.x).

Since the MP contributes to the reduced excitation of S‐cones, it is of interest to examine the effects MP may have on colour vision, particularly when ‘blue‐blocking’ lenses are also involved. We studied the relationship between MPOD and red/green (RG) and yellow/blue (YB) colour thresholds by measuring the spatial distribution of the MP in normal trichromats using the Macular Assessment Profile (MAP) test (doi: 10.1111/j.1475‐1313.2010.00748.x) and the corresponding RG and YB colour thresholds using the CAD test (doi:10.1093/bmb/ldx007).

The results show negligible correlation between peak MPOD and YB thresholds and a small, but significant negative correlation with RG thresholds. This observation is of interest since increased MPOD values result in lower RG thresholds. The same experiment was also carried out in subjects with significantly larger amounts of MP following 3 months of supplementation with carotenoids. When averaged over the centre disc region of 2.5° and then over a parafoveal annulus between 2.5° and 4°, the corresponding, mean MP densities show only negligible correlations with RG and YB colour thresholds. To explain these findings, we calculated the expected cone‐contrasts for S‐, M‐ and L‐cones for chromatic displacements defined by the threshold ellipse. The results show that MP absorption of short‐wavelength light has a negligible effect on S‐cone contrast over the whole range of displacement directions associated with the colour threshold ellipse. Repeated calculations with simulated MPOD values up to 1 log unit, produced the same result. More recently, we modelled the effects ‘blue‐blocking’ lenses and pre‐receptor filters in the eye to explore changes to the orientation and the size of the colour threshold ellipse. The model predicts well the measured RG and YB thresholds and confirms the absence of significant threshold changes for MPOD values in the range 0 to 1 log unit. The model does, however, predict systematic changes in the orientation of the major axis (i.e., the tritan axis) and MPOD. These observations are of interest since the orientation of the major axis of the best‐fit ellipse appears to decrease monotonically from ~75° to 55°, as MPOD increases from very small values up to a peak OD of 1 log unit. More work is needed to investigate how YB and RG chromatic sensitivity is affected by combined absorption of short‐wavelength light by MPOD, the lens of the eye and ‘blue‐blocking’ spectacle lenses.