Abstract 2239: Analysis of nucleosomal DNA as an extraction control for plasma-based circulating tumor DNA assays
Authors: Syeda Mahrukh M. , Karlin-Neumann George , Osman Iman , Polsky David 
Published: August 2019

Purpose: Challenges to accurate quantitative measurements of circulating tumor DNA (ctDNA) include variable contamination with large DNA fragments released during mononuclear cell lysis, and potential variability in extraction efficiency. We investigated optimal procedures for plasma processing and the potential utility of a DNA spike-in as a process control for extraction efficiency.

Methods: Initial experiments analyzed the potential benefits of different centrifugation protocols (1600 x g vs. 1600 x g followed by 16000 x g) for plasma separation by analyzing the size distribution of extracted DNA using a BioAnalyzer. In subsequent experiments we used droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) to compare differences in extraction efficiency between nucleosomal DNA (nDNA) and genomic DNA (gDNA) spiked into healthy donor plasma and extracted using the QIAamp DSP Circulating NA Kit (Qiagen). To evaluate the properties of the purification columns with respect to the yield of different DNA sizes, we compared the plasma results to experiments extracting purified nDNA and gDNA spiked into PBS instead of plasma. We investigated the potential competitive effect of large DNA on the extraction efficiency of small DNA by mixing nDNA with commercially available human gDNA in different concentrations. To assess if nDNA, when spiked into patient plasma, would track with endogenous ctDNA, we spiked a pool of plasma from patients with BRAFV600E mutations with known quantities of nDNA purified from NRASQ61K mutant cells (CHP212). The spiked plasma pool was divided and extracted using multiple separate columns. Copies/ml and mutant fraction were determined by ddPCR assays for BRAFV600E and NRASQ61K. Coefficients of variation were also calculated.

Results: Comparison of different centrifugation speeds for plasma processing before and after freeze-thaw indicated that a 2nd high-speed centrifugation (16000 x g), either before or after a freeze-thaw cycle, minimizes large DNA in plasma samples prior to ctDNA extraction. In initial spike-in experiments extraction efficiency for nDNA was 87.7% compared to 42% for gDNA. We obtained similar results when purifying the nDNA and gDNA from PBS instead of plasma. We observed greater variability in nDNA extraction efficiency when increasing amounts of gDNA were added as a contaminant. Finally, we found that the slight, paralell variations in extraction yields of externally spiked NRASQ61K mutant nDNA and endogenous BRAFV600E ctDNA in 7/9 replicate extractions. The overall coefficients of variation (total copies/mL) for 9 extractions for BRAFV600E and NRASQ61K were 3.9 and 4.2 respectively.

Conclusion: A second centrifugation step helps reduce potential contamination of ctDNA with large DNA, and may improve the recovery of ctDNA from plasma samples. Nucleosomal DNA can potentially be used as a process control for extracting ctDNA from plasma samples.

Citation Format: Mahrukh M. Syeda, George Karlin-Neumann, Iman Osman, David Polsky. Analysis of nucleosomal DNA as an extraction control for plasma-based circulating tumor DNA assays [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 2239.