EVOLUTION OF THE GENUS CHRYSOCOCCYX
Authors: Marchant S. 
Published: April 2008

Modern geological ideas on ocean‐floor spreading are briefly reviewed. Pangea began to break up at the end of the Trias, but Africa, Antarctica and Australia remained together or close to each other till the end of the Cretaceous. The position of western New Guinea at the start of the Miocene could have been approximately where Arnhem Land is now, and at the start of the Pliocene somewhat north of the present‐day Aru Islands. Its size until the end of the Pliocene was much smaller than it is today.

Friedmann's proposal for the evolutionary spread of Chrysococcyx therefore demands that the whole process occurred since about the start of the Pliocene. There may not have been enough time in these seven million years for the evolutionary dispersal of a genus of parasitic cuckoos halfway round the world. His proposal also regards C. osculans as an awkward throw‐back, and leaves a gap between species in New Guinea and southeastern Asia that is not bridged by intermediates.

If a stock of cuckoos had been in Gondwanaland before it broke up, that stock could have given rise to the genus Cacomantis and the forerunners of C. osculans. The lineage of osculans would have quickly given rise to a lineage of glossy cuckoos that then divided into two branches. One could have penetrated Africa, south of where Madagascar then was, produced the species klaas, cupreus, caprius and flavigularis (an aberrant end‐product), and much later, after Madagascar had drifted south from India (having been separate from Africa since the Cretaceous), colonised Asia where maculatus and xanthorhynchus would have differentiated. The other line could have differentiated, perhaps more slowly, in Australia into basalts, lucidus, ruficollis and malayanut (minutillus). When Australia had drifted near enough to the Malay Archipelago and as New Guinea grew, ruficollis and minutillus could have moved forward to colonise the islands, where minutillus would have produced the many races oimalayanus and meyerii differentiated as an aberrant end‐product.

This proposal overcomes some of the objections to Friedmann's theory because it arranges events to accord better with geological developments and avoids the evolutionary discontinuities of his proposal. The migratory habits of the cuckoos, thought by Friedmann to be significant, are discounted as evidence for evolutionary history. The parasitic habits are re‐interpreted. Better data are presented for the parasitic behaviour of basalis and lucidus; they suggest that both species are sophisticated and probably host‐specific parasites. Jensen & Jensen (1969) have already given evidence that some African glossy cuckoos are highly host‐specific. There seems to be a trend of decreasing parasitic sophistication in Australian species, correlated with the possible age of the species. In Africa parasitism seems to be far in advance of that in Australia, probably because the opportunities for parasitism are far better in Africa. These trends and differences in parasitic behaviour are compatible with an evolutionary spread from Gondwanaland.

The crucial question is whether the stock of Cacomantis and Chrysococcyx could have existed before the break‐up of Gondwanaland, i.e. before the early Eocene. The present fossil record suggests that this is unlikely, but the paucity of fossils and the difficulties of palaeoclimates do not seem to be insuperable and it is suggested that a southern origin for these cuckoos should be considered seriously.