Abundance of C1q Expressing Macrophages Promotes Resistance to Modern Therapy
Authors: Stein Caleb K , Meermeier Erin W , Shotts Yuliza , Zhu Yuan Xiao , Shi Chang-Xin , Pfeffer Kirsten , Du Megan , Sharik Meaghen , Bergsagel Leif , Chesi Marta 
Published: December 2024

Overview: Despite advances in therapies targeting the tumor-intrinsic aspects of the disease, multiple myeloma (MM) remains functionally incurable. Given that new alternatives such as T cell redirected therapy and monoclonal antibodies engage ADCC and CDC by leveraging other elements of the immune system, we believe that deeper studies of the tumor microenvironment are warranted. In particular, we believe that certain macrophages are associated with tumor progression, serve as markers of future relapses, are immunosuppressive, and reduce the effectiveness of otherwise successful therapies.

Methods: We performed 5' scRNAseq analysis of 189,025 cells collected from spleen or bone marrow of 4 wild type, 14 de novo, and 40 tumor bearing Vk*MYC mice treated with vehicle or effective anti-MM therapies. Discoveries were cross-referenced against a set of 45,626 human bone marrow cells collected from 35 samples at different stages of disease and treatment. We experimentally recreated in vitro the cross-talk between MM cells and macrophages by co-culturing bone marrow derived macrophages (BMDM) with MM cells or their conditioned medium, and correlated changes in gene expression as well as the ability of polarized BMDM to inhibit CAR T mediated killing of MM cells in vitro.

Results: Gene expression analysis of murine in vivo C1q macrophages and in vitro polarized BMDM revealed a common signature identified in lipid-associated macrophages and Kupffer cell-like macrophages1 (high expression of Fabp5, ApoE, Cd63, C1qa/b/c, Cd163, Cd5l, Vcam1, Fcgr4, Folr2, Maf) which is associated with immunosuppression and disease progression. Ligand-receptor analysis via LIANA identified C1qb ligand in macrophages with C1qbp in tumor among the top interactions in both human and murine single cell analyses. C1qbp is a crucial element of cell adhesion and metastasis,2 and this link between tumor and macrophage can severely limit effective therapy: BMDM following stimulation/polarization with MM lines, but not naïve/unstimulated BMDM, strongly inhibit anti-BCMA CAR T in vitro cytotoxic activity. In total, a complement-related connection between tumor and macrophage is capable of directing an immunosuppressive, chemokine response that imparts resistance to therapy.

While effective therapies reduce tumor and C1q expressing macrophage populations,3 retention of C1q expressing cells may be associated with future relapses. Presence of a specific subset of C1Q expressing cells, even in very low numbers, in human samples following ASCT was associated with early relapse (6 of 8 good responding samples had zero C1Q+ cells while 12 of 16 poor responding samples had 1 or more C1Q+ cells-Fisher test p-value &lt; 0.05). In addition to high expression of C1QA/B/C, these cells are also highly upregulated in TYROBP (known to relate to macrophage polarization4 and found in a spatial transcriptomic analysis of cells at the periphery of MM and its environment5) as well as FCER1G (known to relate to macrophage infiltration6).

Conclusion: As advanced therapies manipulate elements of the immune microenvironment to impart effective treatment, the connection between tumor and macrophage should not be overlooked since macrophages likely help create an immunosuppressive niche that assists in disease growth and eventual revival.

1. Ma, R.-Y., Black, A. & Qian, B.-Z. Macrophage diversity in cancer revisited in the era of single-cell omics. Trends Immunol. 43, 546-563 (2022).

2. Wang, Y. et al. C1QBP suppresses cell adhesion and metastasis of renal carcinoma cells. Sci. Rep. 7, 999 (2017).

3. Stein, C. K., Meermeier, E., Welsh, S. J., Chesi, M. & Bergsagel, P. L. Key Subsets of Immune Cells in Bone Marrow Myeloid Compartment Indicate Degree of Tumor Infiltration and Avenues for Successful Immunotherapy in Multiple Myeloma. Blood 140, 7082-7083 (2022).

4. Liang, T. et al. TYROBP, TLR4 and ITGAM regulated macrophages polarization and immune checkpoints expression in osteosarcoma. Sci. Rep. 11, 19315 (2021).

5. Sudupe, L. et al. Spatial Transcriptomics Unveils Novel Potential Mechanisms of Disease in a MI cγ1 Multiple Myeloma in vivo Model. Blood 142, 4076 (2023).

6. Dong, K. et al. FCER1G positively relates to macrophage infiltration in clear cell renal cell carcinoma and contributes to unfavorable prognosis by regulating tumor immunity. BMC Cancer 22, 140 (2022).