Effect of SGLT2 Inhibitors on Stroke and Atrial Fibrillation in Diabetic Kidney Disease
Authors: Zhou Zien , Jardine Meg J. , Li Qiang , Neuen Brendon L. , Cannon Christopher P. , de Zeeuw Dick , Edwards Robert , Levin Adeera , Mahaffey Kenneth W. , Perkovic Vlado , Neal Bruce , Lindley Richard I. , Ahuad Guerrero Rodolfo Andres , Aizenberg Diego , Albisu Juan Pablo , Alvarisqueta Andres , Bartolacci Ines , Berli Mario Alberto , Bordonava Anselmo , Calella Pedro , Cantero Maria Cecilia , Cartasegna Luis Rodolfo , Cercos Esteban , Coloma Gabriela Cecilia , Colombo Hugo , Commendatore Victor , Cuadrado Jesus , Cuneo Carlos Alberto , Cusumano Ana Maria , Douthat Walter Guillermo , Dran Ricardo Dario , Farias Eduardo , Fernandez Maria Florencia , Finkelstein Hernan , Fragale Guillermo , Fretes Jose Osvaldo , Garcia Nestor Horacio , Gastaldi Anibal , Gelersztein Elizabeth , Glenny Jorge Archibaldo , Gonzalez Joaquin Pablo , del Carmen Gonzalez Colaso Patricia , Goycoa Claudia , Greloni Gustavo Cristian , Guinsburg Adrian , Hermida Sonia , Juncos Luis Isaias , Klyver Maria Isabel , Kraft Florencia , Krynski Fernando , Lanchiotti Paulina Virginia , Leon de la Fuente Ricardo Alfonso , Marchetta Nora , Mele Pablo , Nicolai Silvia , Novoa Pablo Antonio , Orio Silvia Ines , Otreras Fabian , Oviedo Alejandra , Raffaele Pablo , Resk Jorge Hector , Rista Lucas , Rodriguez Papini Nelson , Sala Jorgelina , Santos Juan Carlos , Schiavi Lilia Beatriz , Sessa Horacio , Smith Casabella Tomas , Ulla Maria Rosa , Valdez Maria , Vallejos Augusto , Villarino Adriana , Visco Virginia Esther , Wassermann Alfredo , Zaidman Cesar Javier , Cheung Ngai Wah , Droste Carolyn , Fraser Ian , Johnson David , Mah Peak Mann , Nicholls Kathy , Packham David , Proietto Joseph , Roberts Anthony , Roger Simon , Tsang Venessa , Abrão Raduan Roberto , Alves da Costa Fernando Augusto , Amodeo Celso , Andreotti Turatti Luiz Alberto , Bregman Rachel , Camelo Sanches Fernanda Cristina , Canani Luis Henrique , Chacra Antônio Roberto , Cunha Borges João Lindolfo , Cunha Vêncio Sérgio Alberto , da Silva Franco Roberto Jorge , d’Avila Domingos , de Souza Portes Evandro , de Souza Pedro , Deboni Luciane Mônica , Fraige Filho Fadlo , Geloneze Neto Bruno , Gomes Marcus , Keiko Kohara Suely , Keitel Elizete , Kerr Saraiva Jose Francisco , Kurtz Lisboa Hugo Roberto , Loss de Carvalho Contieri Fabiana , Milagres Rosângela , Montenegro Junior Renan , Moreira de Brito Claudia , Nasser Hissa Miguel , Nazario Sabbag Ângela Regina , Noronha Irene , Panarotto Daniel , Pecoits Filho Roberto , Pereira Márcio Antônio , Saporito Wladmir , Scafuto Scotton Antonio , Schuch Tiago , Simões de Almeida Roberto , Slompo Ramos Cássio , Soares Felício João , Thomé Fernando , Tibes Hachmann Jean Carlo , Yamada Sérgio , Yoiti Hayashida Cesar , Zanata Petry Tarissa Beatrice , Zanella Maria Teresa , Andreeva Viktoria , Angelova Angelina , Dimitrov Stefan , Genadieva Veselka , Genova-Hristova Gabriela , Hristozov Kiril , Kamenov Zdravko , Koundurdjiev Atanas , Lozanov Lachezar , Margaritov Viktor , Nonchev Boyan , Rangelov Rangel , Shinkov Alexander , Temelkova Margarita , Velichkova Ekaterina , Yakov Andrian , Aggarwal Naresh , Aronson Ronnie , Bajaj Harpreet , Cherney David , Chouinard Guy , Conway James , Cournoyer Serge , DaRoza Gerald , De Serres Sacha , Dubé François , Goldenberg Ronald , Gupta Anil , Gupta Milan , Henein Sam , Khandwala Hasnain , Leiter Lawrence , Madore François , McMahon Alan , Muirhead Norman , Pichette Vincent , Rabasa-Lhoret Remi , Steele Andrew , Tangri Navdeep , Torshizi Ali , Woo Vincent , Zalunardo Nadia , Fernández Montenegro María Alicia , Godoy Jorquera Juan Gonzalo , Medina Fariña Marcelo , Saavedra Gajardo Victor , Vejar Margarita , Chen Nan , Chen Qinkai , Gan Shenglian , Kong Yaozhong , Li Detian , Li Wenge , Li Xuemei , Lin Hongli , Liu Jian , Lu Weiping , Mao Hong , Ren Yan , Song Weihong , Sun Jiao , Sun Lin , Tu Ping , Wang Guixia , Yang Jinkui , Yin Aiping , Yu Xueqing , Zhao Minghui , Zheng Hongguang , Accini Mendoza Jose Luis , Arcos Edgar , Avendano Jorge , Diaz Ruiz Jorge Ernesto Andres , Garcia Ortiz Luis Hernando , Gonzalez Alexander , Hernandez Triana Eric , Higuera Juan Diego , Malaver Natalia , Molina de Salazar Dora Inés , Rosero Ricardo , Terront Lozano Monica Alexandra , Valderrama Cometa Luis , Valenzuela Alex , Vargas Alonso Ruben Dario , Villegas Ivan , Yupanqui Hernan , Bartaskova Dagmar , Barton Petr , Belobradkova Jana , Dohnalova Lenka , Drasnar Tomas , Ferkl Richard , Halciakova Katarina , Klokocnikova Vera , Kovar Richard , Lastuvka Jiri , Lukac Martin , Pesickova Satu , Peterka Karel , Pumprla Jiri , Rychlik Ivan , Saudek Frantisek , Tesar Vladimir , Valis Martin , Weiner Pavel , Zemek Stanislav , Alamartine Eric , Borot Sophie , Cariou Bertrand , Dussol Bertrand , Fauvel Jean-Pierre , Gourdy Pierre , Klein Alexandre , Le Meur Yannick , Penfornis Alfred , Roussel Ronan , Saulnier Pierre-Jean , Thervet Eric , Zaoui Philippe , Burst Volker , Faghih Markus , Faulmann Grit , Haller Hermann , Jerwan-Keim Reinhold , Maxeiner Stephan , Paschen Björn , Plassmann Georg , Rose Ludger , Gonzalez Orellana Ronaldo Arturo , Haase Franklin Paul , Moreira Diaz Juan Pablo , Ramirez Roca Luis Alberto , Sánchez Arenales Jose Antonio , Sanchez Polo José Vicente , Turcios Juarez Erick , Csecsei Gyongyi , Csiky Botond , Danos Peter , Deak Laszlo , Dudas Mihaly , Harcsa Eleonora , Keltai Katalin , Keresztesi Sandor , Kiss Krisztian , Konyves Laszlo , Major Lajos , Mileder Margit , Molnar Marta , Mucsi Janos , Oroszlan Tamas , Ory Ivan , Paragh Gyorgy , Peterfai Eva , Petro Gizella , Revesz Katalin , Takacs Robert , Vangel Sandor , Vasas Szilard , Zsom Marianna , Oomman Abraham , Raju Sree Bhushan , Dewan Deepak , Fernando M. Edwin , Gopalakrishnan Natarajan , Gracious Noble , Alva Hansraj , Jain Dinesh , Keshavamurthy C. B. , Khullar Dinesh , Sahay Manisha , Peringat Jayameena , Prasad Narayan , Rao K. Satyanarayana , Reddy Sreedhar , Melemadathil Sreelatha , Sudhakar Bhimavarapu , Vyasam Ramesh Chandra , Bonadonna Riccardo , Castellino Pietro , Ceriello Antonio , Chiovato Luca , De Cosmo Salvatore , De Nicola Luca , Derosa Giuseppe , Di Carlo Alberto , Di Cianni Graziano , Frascà Giovanni , Fuiano Giorgio , Gambaro Giovanni , Garibotto Giacomo , Giorda Carlo , Malberti Fabio , Mandreoli Marcora , Mannucci Edoardo , Orsi Emanuela , Piatti Piermarco , Santoro Domenico , Sasso Ferdinando Carlo , Serviddio Gaetano , Stella Andrea , Trevisan Roberto , Veronelli Anna Maria , Zanoli Luca , Akiyama Hitoshi , Aoki Hiromi , Asano Akimichi , Iitsuka Tadashi , Kajiyama Shizuo , Kashine Susumu , Kawada Toshio , Kodera Takamoto , Kono Hiroshi , Koyama Kazunori , Kumeda Yasuro , Miyauchi Shozo , Mizuyama Kazuyuki , Niiya Tetsuji , Oishi Hiroko , Ota Satoshi , Sakakibara Terue , Takai Masahiko , Tomonaga Osamu , Tsujimoto Mitsuru , Wada Takashi , Wakasugi Masakiyo , Wakida Yasushi , Watanabe Takayuki , Yamada Masayo , Yanagida Kazuhiro , Yanase Toshihiko , Yumita Wataru , Gaupsiene Egle , Kozloviene Dalia , Navickas Antanas , Urbanaviciene Egle , Abdul Ghani Rohana , Abdul Kadir Khalid , Ali Norsiah , Che Yusof Mohd Daud , Gan Chye Lee , Ismail Mastura , Kong Wei Yen , Lam Swee Win , Lee Li Yuan , Lim Soo Kun , Loh Chek Loong , Manocha Anita Bhajan , Ng Kee Sing , Nik Ahmad Nik Nur Fatnoon , Ratnasingam Vanassa , Shudim Saiful Shahrizal Bin , Vengadasalam Paranthaman , Abraira Munoz Luis David , Alpizar Salazar Melchor , Baas Cruz Juan , Burgos Soto Mario , Chevaile Ramos Jose , Chew Wong Alfredo , Correa Rotter Jose Ricardo , Diaz Escalante Tonatiu , Enriquez Sosa Favio Edmundo , Flores Lozano Fernando , Flota Cervera Luis Fernando , Frenk Baron Paul , Garcia Ballesteros Cecilia , Gomez Rangel Jose David , Herrera Jimenez Luis Enrique , Irizar Santana Sergio Saul , Jimenez Flores Fernando , Laviada Molina Hugo , Luna Ceballos Rosa Isela , Martin del Campo Blanco Belia , Morales Franco Guadalupe , Moreno Loza Oscar Tarsicio , Mustieles Rocha Cynthia , Obrador Vera Gregorio , Orozco Castellanos Ricardo , Peralta Calcaneo Juan , Reyes Rosano Miguel Angel , Rodriguez Pattzi Hiromi , Rosas Guzman Juan , Rucker Joerg Isabel Erika , Saavedra Sanchez Sandra Berenice , Sanchez Mijangos Jose Hector , Serrano Sanson Pablo , Tamayo y Orozco Juan Alfredo , Tellez Chavez Eloisa , Valdes Cepeda Alejandro , Venegas Carrillo Luis , Villagordoa Mesa Juan , Zamarripa Escobedo Rolando , Baker John , Noonan Paul , Scott Russell , Walker Robert , Watson Edward , Williams Michael , Young Simon , Abejuela Zaynab , Agra Jeimeen , Aquitania Grace , Caringal Clodoaido , Comia Rhea Severina , Delos Santos Lalaine , Gomez Olivert , Jimeno Cecilia , Santos Florence , Tan Gerry , Tolentino Marsha , Yao Christy , Yap Yvette Ethel , Ygpuara Ma. Dovie Lallaine , Bijata-Bronisz Renata , Hotlos Lucyna , Januszewicz Andrzej , Kaczmarek Barbara , Kaminska Anna , Lazuka Lech , Madej Andrzej , Mazur Stanislaw , Mlodawska-Choluj Dorota , Nowicki Michal , Orlowska-Kowalik Grazyna , Popenda Grazyna , Rewerska Barbara , Sowinski Dariusz , Angelescu Liliana Monica , Anghel Veronica , Avram Rodica-Ioana , Busegeanu Mihaela-Magdalena , Cif Adriana , Cosma Dana , Crisan Carmen , Demian Luiza Despina , Ferariu Ioana Emilia , Halmagyi Ildiko , Hancu Nicolae , Munteanu Mircea , Negru Doru , Onaca Adriana Gabriela , Petrica Ligia , Popa Amorin Remus , Ranetti Aurelian-Emil , Serafinceanu Cristian , Toarba Cristina , Agafyina Alina , Barbarash Olga , Barysheva Olga , Chizhov Daniil , Dobronravov Vladimir , Dreval Alexander , Glinkina Irina , Grineva Elena , Khirmanov Vladimir , Kolmakova Elena , Koroleva Tatiana , Kvitkova Liudmila , Marasaev Viacheslav , Mkrtumyan Ashot , Morugova Tatiana , Nagibovich Galina , Nagibovich Oleg , Nedogoda Sergei , Osipova Irina , Raskina Tatiana , Samoylova Yulia , Sazonova Olga , Shamkhalova Minara , Shutemova Elena , Shwartz Yuriy , Uriasyev Oleg , Vorobyev Sergey , Zateyshchikova Anna , Zateyshshikov Dmitry , Zykova Tatyana , Antic Slobodan , Djordjevic Miodrag , Kendereski Aleksandra , Lalic Katarina , Lalic Nebojsa , Popovic-Radinovic Vesna , Babikova Jana , Benusova Olga , Buganova Ingrid , Culak Jan , Dzupina Andrej , Dzuponova Jana , Fulop Peter , Ilavska Adriana , Martinka Emil , Ochodnicka Zuzana , Pella Daniel , Smatanova Iveta , Ahmed Fayzal , Badat Aysha , Breedt Johannes , Distiller Lawrence , Govender Vimladhevi , Govender Ravendran , Joshi Mukesh , Jurgens Jaco , Latiff Gulam , Lombard Landman , Mookadam Mohamed , Ngcakani Nomangesi , Nortje Hendrik , Oosthuizen Helena , Pillay-Ramaya Larisha , Prozesky Hans , Reddy Jeevren , Rheeder Paul , Seeber Mary , Chae Dong-Wan , Cho Young Min , Jeong In-Kyung , Kim Sin Gon , Kim Yeong Hoon , Kwon Hyuk-Sang , Kwon Min Jeong , Lee Byung-Wan , Lee JungEun , Lee Moon-Kyu , Nam Moon-Suk , Oh Kook-Hwan , Park Cheol-Young , Park Sun-Hee , Yoon Kun Ho , Alvarez Garcia Pere , Asmarats Mercadal Luis , Barrios Clara , Cereto Castro Fernando , Cigarran Guldris Secundino , Dominguez Lopez Marta , Egido de los Rios Jesus , Fernandez Fresnedo Gema , Galan Serrano Antonio , Garcia Isabel , Gonzalez Martinez Francisco Javier , Jodar Gimeno Jose Esteban , Lopez Mendoza Manuel , Malek Marin Tamara , Morales Portillo Cristobal , Munar Vila Maria Antonia , Muñoz Torres Manuel , Nieto Iglesias Javier , Pantoja Perez Jonay , Perez Vera Merce , Portoles Perez Jose Mª , Quesada Simón María Angustias , Simo Canonge Rafael , Soto Gonzalez Alfonso , Terns Riera Manel , Tinahones Madueno Francisco Jose , Velo Plaza Mercedes , Chang Chwen-Tzuei , Chuang Lee-Ming , Hsia Te-Lin , Hsieh Chang-Hsun , Hwang Shang-Jyh , Lin Chih-Ching , Lu Yung-Chuan , Sheu Wayne H-H , Barna Olga , Bilyk Svitlana D. , Botsyurko Volodymyr , Dudar Iryna , Fushtey Ivan , Godlevska Olga , Golovchenko Oleksandr , Gyrina Olga , Kazmirchuk Anatoliy , Kolesnyk Mykola , Komisarenko Iuliia , Korzh Oleksii , Kravchun Nonna , Legun Oleg , Mankovskyy Borys , Martynyuk Liliya , Mostovoy Yuriy , Pashkovska Nataliia , Pererva Larysa , Pertseva Tetyana , Samoylov Oleksandr , Smirnov Ivan , Svyshchenko Yevgeniya , Tomashkevych Halyna , Topchii Ivan , Tryshchuk Nadiya , Tseluyko Vira , Vizir Vadym , Vlasenko Maryna , Zlova Tetiana , Zub Liliia , Abusnana Salah , Railey Mohamed , Abouglila Kamal , Ainsworth Paul , Ali Zishan , Arutchelvam Vijayaraman , Barnard Maria , Bellary Srikanth , Davies Emyr , Davies Mark , Davies Simon , Dawson Alison , El Kossi Mohsen , English Patrick , Fraser Donald , Gnudi Luigi , Gunstone Anthony , Hall Timothy , Hanif Wasim , Jackson Alan , Johnson Andrew , Joseph Franklin , Krishnan Singhan , Kumwenda Mick , MacDougall Iain , Nixon Paul , O’Hare Joseph , Philip Sam , Ramtoola Shenaz , Saxena Manish , Sennik Davesh , Simon Godwin , Singh Baldev , Stephens Jeffrey , Strzelecka Anna , Symonds Rehan , Turner Wayne , Wahba Mona , Wakeling John , Wheeler David , Winocour Peter , Abdallah Joseph , Abdullah Raied , Abramowitz Matthew , Acosta Idalia , Aiello Joseph , Akright Laura , Akyea-Djamson Ayim , Alappan Rajendran , Alicic Radica , Al-Karadsheh Amer , Allison Dale Crawford , Arauz-Pacheco Carlos , Arfeen Shahabul , Arif Ahmed , Arvind Moogali , Atray Naveen , Awad Ahmed , Bakris George , Barnhill Peggy , Barranco Elizabeth , Barrera Carlos , Beacom Matthew , Behara Venkata , Belo Diogo , Bentley-Lewis Rhonda , Berenguer Ramon , Bermudez Lidia , Bernardo Marializa , Biscoveanu Mihaela , Bowman-Stroud Cynthia , Brandon Donald , Brusco Osvaldo , Busch Robert , Canaan Yamil , Chilito Alicia , Christensen Tom , Christiano Cynthia , Christofides Elena , Chuateco Caroucel , Cohen Kenneth , Cohen Robert , Cohen-Stein Debbie , Cook Charles , Coyne Daniel , Daboul Nizar , Darwish Riad , Daswani Adarsh , Deck Kenneth , Desouza Cyrus , Dev Devasmita , Dhillon Monika , Dua Sohan , Eder Frank , Elosegui Ana Maria , El-Shahawy Mohamed , Ervin John , Esquenazi Alberto , Evans John , Fishbane Steven , Frias Juan , Galindo-Ramos Eugenia , Galphin Claude , Ghazi Adline , Gonzalez Enrique , Gorson David , Gowda Anupama , Greco Barbara , Grubb Stephen , Gulati Rakesh , Hammoud Jamal , Handelsman Stuart , Hartman Israel , Hershon Kenneth , Hiser Daniel , Hon George , Jacob Radu , Jaime Maria , Jamal Aamir , Kaupke Charles , Keightley Gerald , Kern Elizabeth , Khanna Rakhi , Khitan Zeid , Kim Sun , Kopyt Nelson , Kovesdy Csaba , Krishna Gopal , Kropp Jeffrey (Jay) , Kumar Amrendra , Kumar Jayant , Kumar Neil , Kusnir Jorge , Lane Wendy , Lawrence Mary , Lehrner Lawrence , Lentz John , Levinson Dennis , Lewis Derek , Liss Kenneth , Maddux Andreas , Maheshwari Hiralal , Mandayam Sreedhar , Marar Isam , Mehta Bhasker , Middleton John , Mordujovich Jorge , Moreda Ramon , Moustafa Moustafa , Mujica Trenche Samuel , Narayanan Mohanram , Narvarte Javier , Nassar Tareq , Newman George , Nichol Brian , Nicol Philip , Nisnisan Josier , Nossuli A. Kaldun , Obialo Chamberlain , Olelewe Sarah , Oliver Michael , O’Shaughnessy Andrew , Padron John , Pankhaniya Rohit , Parker Reginald , Patel Devesh , Patel Gnyandev , Patel Nina , Pavon Humberto , Perez Armando , Perez Carlos , Perlman Alan , Pettis Karlton , Pharr Walter , Phillips Andrea , Purighalla Raman , Quesada-Suarez Luis , Ranjan Rajiv , Rastogi Sanjeev , Reddy Jakkidi , Rendell Marc , Rich Lisa , Robinson Michael , Rodriguez Hector , Rosas Sylvia , Saba Fadi , Sankaram Rallabhandi , Sarin Ravi , Schreiman Robert , Scott David , Sekkarie Mohamed , Sensenbrenner John , Shakeel Muhammad , Shanik Michael , Shaw Sylvia , Smith Stephen , Solomon Richard , Sprague Amy , Spry Leslie , Suchinda Pusadee , Sultan Senan , Surampudi Prasanth , Sussman Sherry , Tan Anjanette , Terrelonge Antonio , Thompson Michael , Trespalacios Fernando , Trippe Bruce , Trueba Pilar , Twahirwa Marcel , Updegrove John , Van Buren Peter , Vannorsdall Mark , Varghese Freemu , Velasquez-Mieyer Pedro , Ventrapragada Sailaja , Vukotic Goga , Wadud Khurram , Warren Mark , Watson Henry , Watts Ronald , Weiner Daniel , Welker James , Welsh Jean , Williams Shelley , Zaniewski-Singh Michelle 
Published: April 2021

Background and Purpose:

Chronic kidney disease with reduced estimated glomerular filtration rate or elevated albuminuria increases risk for ischemic and hemorrhagic stroke. This study assessed the effects of sodium glucose cotransporter 2 inhibitors (SGLT2i) on stroke and atrial fibrillation/flutter (AF/AFL) from CREDENCE (Canagliflozin and Renal Events in Diabetes With Established Nephropathy Clinical Evaluation) and a meta-analysis of large cardiovascular outcome trials (CVOTs) of SGLT2i in type 2 diabetes mellitus.

Methods:

CREDENCE randomized 4401 participants with type 2 diabetes mellitus and chronic kidney disease to canagliflozin or placebo. Post hoc, we estimated effects on fatal or nonfatal stroke, stroke subtypes, and intermediate markers of stroke risk including AF/AFL. Stroke and AF/AFL data from 3 other completed large CVOTs and CREDENCE were pooled using random-effects meta-analysis.

Results:

In CREDENCE, 142 participants experienced a stroke during follow-up (10.9/1000 patient-years with canagliflozin, 14.2/1000 patient-years with placebo; hazard ratio [HR], 0.77 [95% CI, 0.55–1.08]). Effects by stroke subtypes were: ischemic (HR, 0.88 [95% CI, 0.61–1.28]; n=111), hemorrhagic (HR, 0.50 [95% CI, 0.19–1.32]; n=18), and undetermined (HR, 0.54 [95% CI, 0.20–1.46]; n=17). There was no clear effect on AF/AFL (HR, 0.76 [95% CI, 0.53–1.10]; n=115). The overall effects in the 4 CVOTs combined were: total stroke (HR
pooled
, 0.96 [95% CI, 0.82–1.12]), ischemic stroke (HR
pooled
, 1.01 [95% CI, 0.89–1.14]), hemorrhagic stroke (HR
pooled
, 0.50 [95% CI, 0.30–0.83]), undetermined stroke (HR
pooled
, 0.86 [95% CI, 0.49–1.51]), and AF/AFL (HR
pooled
, 0.81 [95% CI, 0.71–0.93]). There was evidence that SGLT2i effects on total stroke varied by baseline estimated glomerular filtration rate (
P
=0.01), with protection in the lowest estimated glomerular filtration rate (<45 mL/min/1.73 m
2
]) subgroup (HR
pooled
, 0.50 [95% CI, 0.31–0.79]).

Conclusions:

Although we found no clear effect of SGLT2i on total stroke in CREDENCE or across trials combined, there was some evidence of benefit in preventing hemorrhagic stroke and AF/AFL, as well as total stroke for those with lowest estimated glomerular filtration rate. Future research should focus on confirming these data and exploring potential mechanisms.

Registration:

URL:
https://www.clinicaltrials.gov
; Unique identifier: NCT02065791.