Evaluation of root zone soil moisture products over the Huai River basin
Authors: Liu En , Zhu Yonghua , Calvet Jean-Christophe , Lü Haishen , Bonan Bertrand , Zheng Jingyao , Gou Qiqi , Wang Xiaoyi , Ding Zhenzhou , Xu Haiting , Pan Ying , Chen Tingxing 
Published: June 2024

Abstract. Root zone soil moisture (RZSM) is critical for water resource management, drought monitoring and sub-seasonal flood climate prediction. While RZSM is not directly observable from space, several RZSM products are available and widely used at global and continental scales. This study conducts a comprehensive and quantitative evaluation of eight RZSM products using observations from 58 in situ soil moisture stations over the Huai River basin (HRB) in China. Attention is drawn to the potential factors that contribute to the uncertainties of model-based RZSM, including the errors in atmospheric forcing, vegetation parameterizations, soil properties and spatial scale mismatch. The results show that the Global Land Data Assimilation System Catchment Land Surface Model (GLDAS_CLSM) outperforms the other RZSM products with the highest correlation coefficient (R= 0.69) and the lowest unbiased root mean square error (ubRMSE = 0.018 m3 m−3), while SMOS Level 4 (L4) RZSM shows the worst performance among eight RZSM products. The RZSM products based on land surface models generally perform better in the wet season than in the dry season due to the enhanced ability to capture of the temporal dynamics of in situ observations in the wet season and the inertia of remaining high soil moisture values even in the dry season, while the SMOS L4 RZSM product, derived from SMOS L3 surface moisture (SSM) combined with an exponential filter method, performs better in the dry season due to the attenuated ground microwave radiation signal caused by the increased water vapour absorption and scattering in the wet season. The underestimated SMOS L3 SSM triggers the underestimation of RZSM in SMOS L4. The overestimated RZSM products based on land surface models could be associated with the overestimated precipitation amounts and frequency, the underestimated air temperature, and the underestimated ratio of transpiration to the total terrestrial evapotranspiration. In addition, the biased soil properties and flawed vegetation parameterizations affect the hydrothermal transport processes represented in different land surface models (LSMs) and lead to inaccurate soil moisture simulation. The scale mismatch between point and footprint also introduces representative errors. The comparison of frequency of normalized soil moisture between RZSM products and in situ observations indicates that the LSMs should focus on reducing the frequency of wet soil moisture, increasing the frequency of dry soil moisture and the ability to capture the frequency peak of soil moisture. The study provides some insights into how to improve the ability of land surface models to simulate the land surface states and fluxes by taking into account the issues mentioned above. Finally, these results can be extrapolated to other regions located in similar climate zones, as they share similar precipitation patterns that dominate the terrestrial water cycle.