Reduced reciprocal inhibition during clinical tests of spasticity is associated with impaired reactive standing balance control in children with cerebral palsy
Authors: Willaert Jente , Ting Lena H. , Van Campenhout Anja , Desloovere Kaat , De Groote Friedl 
Published: November 2023

Background

Joint hyper-resistance is a common symptom in cerebral palsy (CP). It is assessed by rotating the joint of a relaxed patient. Joint rotations also occur when perturbing functional movements. Therefore, joint hyper-resistance might contribute to reactive balance impairments in CP.

Aim

To investigate relationships between altered muscle responses to isolated joint rotations and perturbations of standing balance in children with CP.

Methods & procedures

20 children with CP participated in the study. During an instrumented spasticity assessment, the ankle was rotated as fast as possible from maximal plantarflexion towards maximal dorsiflexion. Standing balance was perturbed by backward support-surface translations and toe-up support-surface rotations. Gastrocnemius, soleus, and tibialis anterior electromyography was measured. We quantified reduced reciprocal inhibition by plantarflexor-dorsiflexor co-activation and the neural response to stretch by average muscle activity. We evaluated the relation between muscle responses to ankle rotation and balance perturbations using linear mixed models.

Outcomes & results

Co-activation during isolated joint rotations and perturbations of standing balance was correlated across all levels. The neural response to stretch during isolated joint rotations and balance perturbations was not correlated.

Conclusions & implications

Reduced reciprocal inhibition during isolated joint rotations might be a predictor of altered reactive balance control strategies.

Highlights

Impaired reciprocal inhibition might underlie altered balance control in CP.

Co-activation during isolated joint rotations and balance responses is correlated.

Hyperreflexia is not correlated with increased response to perturbations of standing.

Reduced reciprocal inhibition has functional implications.

It might be valuable to clinically assess reduced reciprocal inhibition.

What this paper adds

It has been hard to relate alterations in muscle coordination during functional movements to alterations in the muscle’s response to isolated joint rotations as applied during (clinical) assessments of hyper-reflexia. Here, we performed a more comprehensive assessment of the altered muscle response to isolated joint rotations in children with cerebral palsy (CP) by not only considering muscle activity in response to stretch but also agonist-antagonist co-activation. Muscle co-activation in response to isolated joint rotations in relaxed patients has been attributed to reduced reciprocal inhibition in the spinal cord. We found that muscle co-activation during isolated joint rotations was correlated to muscle co-activation during perturbed standing, an important functional movement. Therefore, increased muscle co-activation during standing balance control might – at least partially – result from reduced reciprocal inhibition in the spinal cord. In contrast, we found very few relations between the mean muscle activity during isolated joint rotations and perturbed standing. This might be due to the sensitivity of the response to stretch to stretch velocity, posture, and baseline muscle activity, all of which largely differed between the two conditions. Our results indicate that clinical assessment of reduced reciprocal inhibition during isolated joint rotations might provide information about balance impairments.