Independent and interactive effects of viral species on risk for lower respiratory tract illnesses in early life
Authors: Moore Camille M. , Secor Elizabeth A. , Fairbanks-Mahnke Ana , Everman Jamie L. , Elhawary Jennifer R. , Witonsky Jonathan I. , Pruesse Elmar , Chang Chih-Hao , Contreras Maria G. , Eng Celeste , Canales Keyshla , Rosado Tsunami , Hu Donglei , Huntsman Scott , Jackson Nathan D. , Li Yingchun , Lopez Natalie , Valentin Annette Medina , Medina Vivian , Montanez-Lopez Chris Angely , Morin Andrew , Nieves Natalie A. , Oh Sam S. , Otero Richeliz Alfonso , Colon Raymarie , Rodriguez Leysha , Sajuthi Satria P. , Salazar Sandra , Serrano Gonzalo , Morales Emily Vazquez , Vazquez Gabriela , Morales Nicole Vazquez , Williams Blake J. M. , Zhang Priscilla , Sheppard Dean , Rodriguez Santana Jose R. , Seibold Max A. 
Published: February 2025

Importance

All children experience upper respiratory tract illnesses (URI) caused by viral infections. However, some of these illnesses progress to the lower airways. Although studies have found infection with certain viral species are more likely to trigger lower respiratory illnesses (LRIs), a comprehensive analysis of viruses underlying early-life LRIs is lacking.

Objective

Determine the incidence of URIs, mild and severe LRIs (mLRI, sLRI) during the first 2 years of life and the association between viral respiratory pathogens and odds of LRIs versus URIs in Puerto Rican children, a population at high risk for respiratory disease.

Design, Setting, and Participants

Healthy mother-infant pairs were enrolled in the Puerto Rican Infant Metagenomic and Epidemiologic Study of Respiratory Outcomes birth cohort, in Caguas, Puerto Rico. Infants (n=2,061) were surveilled for respiratory illnesses during the first two years of life (March 2020 to April 2024). Nasal swabs from a subset of 1,363 illnesses from 774 participants were screened for 21 pathogens.

Exposures

Infection with respiratory pathogens.

Main Outcomes and Measures

URI, mLRI, and sLRI in the first two years of life.

Results

RSV infections occurred in 23% of sLRIs and were associated with dramatically increased odds of sLRI vs URI (OR=9.28; 95% CI, 5.43-15.85). Metapneumovirus, parainfluenza, and non-SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus infections also increased odds of sLRIs. SARS-CoV-2 was associated with lower risk of sLRIs vs. URIs (OR=0.33; 95% CI, 0.16-0.68). Though rhinovirus (43%) and bocavirus (16.1%) were commonly detected in sLRIs, neither was associated with increased sLRI risk. Infection with multiple viral species (i.e. co-infection) occurred in one-third of sLRIs and was associated with 2.92-fold greater odds of sLRI (95% CI, 2.05-4.16) compared to single viral species infections. Rhinovirus-bocavirus was the most common co-infection (32.4%), and interaction between these viral infections was associated with increased sLRI risk (OR=2.21; 95% CI, 1.20-4.09) relative to illnesses that were negative for rhinovirus and bocavirus.

Conclusions and Relevance

A diversity of viral pathogens drive early-life sLRIs. Some viral pathogens (e.g. RSV and metapneumovirus) have intrinsic propensity to cause sLRIs, whereas many sLRIs are caused by viruses whose lower airway pathogenicity is dependent on other factors, including co-infection.

Key Points

Question

How do common respiratory viruses differ in their prevalence and risk of causing severe lower respiratory illnesses (LRIs) during early childhood?

Findings

RSV, metapneumovirus, and parainfluenza are independent risk factors for early childhood severe LRIs. While rhinovirus and bocavirus infections alone do not increase the risk of severe LRIs, these two viruses significantly elevate risk when they occur as co-infections.

Meaning

Our findings highlight significant variability in viruses that drive severe early-life LRIs. Some viral species appear to inherently predispose individuals to lower airway disease, while for others, the development of disease likely depends on co-infections and/or host susceptibility.