Widespread brain activity increases in frontal lobe seizures with impaired consciousness
Authors: Salardini Elaheh , Vaddiparti Aparna , Kumar Avisha , Martin Reese A. , Gebre Rahiwa Z. , Arencibia Christopher Andrew , Dhakar Monica B. , Grover Eric H. , Quraishi Imran H. , Sternberg Eliezer J. , George Ilena C. , Sivaraju Adithya , Bonito Jennifer , Zaveri Hitten P. , Gober Leah M. , Ahmed Shamma , Ghoshal Shivani , Wu Kun , Farooque Pue , Hirsch Lawrence J. , Damisah Eyiyemisi C. , Gerrard Jason L. , Spencer Dennis D. , Yoo Ji Yeoun , Young James J. , Friedman Daniel , Shum Jennifer , Blumenfeld Hal 
Published: September 2024

Impaired consciousness is a serious clinical manifestation of epilepsy with negative consequences on quality of life. Little work has investigated impaired consciousness in frontal lobe seizures, a common form of focal epilepsy. In temporal lobe seizures, previous studies showed widespread cortical slow waves associated with depressed subcortical arousal and impaired consciousness. However, in frontal lobe epilepsy, it is not known whether cortical slow waves are present, or whether a very different cortical activity pattern may be related to impaired consciousness.

We used intracranial EEG recordings of 65 frontal lobe seizures in 30 patients for quantitative analysis of ictal cortical activity and its relationship to impaired consciousness. Behavioral changes based on blinded review of seizure videos were used to classify focal aware, focal impaired awareness, and focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures. Changes in intracranial EEG power from preictal baseline were analyzed in different cortical regions and across frequency ranges in these three categories.

We found that frontal lobe focal aware seizures showed approximately 40% increases in intracranial EEG power localized to the frontal lobe of seizure onset across frequency ranges, with relatively smaller changes in other cortical regions. Frontal lobe focal impaired awareness seizures showed approximately 50% increases in intracranial EEG power, not significantly different from focal aware seizures in the frontal lobe of seizure onset (P= 1.038), but significantly greater than focal aware seizures in other broad cortical regions (P< 0.001). Importantly, the widespread cortical increases in EEG power observed in focal impaired awareness versus focal aware seizures were seen not just in the frequency range of slow waves, but were also observed across other frequencies including fast activity. However, the widespread cortical increases in focal impaired awareness seizures differed from focal to bilateral tonic-clonic seizures where intracranial EEG power increased to a much higher level by approximately 600%. The large power increases in focal to bilateral tonic-clonic were significantly greater than in focal impaired awareness seizures both in the frontal lobe of seizure onset and in other cortical regions (P< 0.001).

Our findings contrast with focal temporal lobe epilepsy, where impaired consciousness is associated with cortical slow waves. We can speculate that different focal seizure types produce impaired consciousness by impacting widespread cortical regions but through different physiological mechanisms. Insights gained by studying mechanisms of impaired consciousness may be the first step towards developing novel treatments to prevent this important negative consequence of epilepsy.