Unraveling the potential of cold-water carbonates as geochemical archives for paleoceanographic reconstructions
Authors:   , Schleinkofer Nicolai 
Published: August 2022

Geochemical investigations on biogenic carbonates are commonly conducted to reconstruct the environmental conditions of the past. However, different carbonate producers incorporate elements to varying degrees, due to biological vital effects. Detecting and quantifying these effects is crucial to produce reliable reconstructions. These paleoreconstructions are of great importance to evaluate the consequences of our recent climate change and identify control mechanisms on the distribution of endangered species such as Desmophyllum pertusum. In chapter three we tested Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca and Na/Ca ratios on this species, among other coldwater scleractinians, to test if they provide reliable proxy information. The results reveal no apparent control of Mg/Ca or Sr/Ca ratios through seawater temperature, salinity or pH. Na/Ca ratios appear to be partly controlled by the seawater temperature, which is also true for other aragonitic organisms such as warm-water corals and the bivalve Mytilus edulis. However, a large variability complicates possible reconstructions by means of Na/Ca. In addition, we explore different models to explain the apparent temperature effect on Na/Ca ratios based on temperature sensitive Na and Ca pumping enzymes. The bivalve Acesta excavata is commonly found in cold-water coral reefs among the North Atlantic, together with D. pertusum. Multiple linear regression analysis, presented in chapter four, indicates that up to 79% of the elemental variability in Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca and Na/Ca is explainable with temperature and salinity as independent predictor variables. Vital effects, for instance growth rate effects, are evident and make paleoreconstructions not feasible. Furthermore, organic material embedded in the shell, as well as possible stress effects can drastically change the elemental composition. Removal of these organic matrices from bulk samples for LA-ICP-MS (laser ablation inductively coupled mass spectrometer) measurements by means of oxidative cleaning is not possible, but Na/Ca ratios decrease after this cleaning. This is presumably an effect of leaching and not caused by the removal of organic matrices. Interesting biogeochemical relations were found in the parasitic foraminifera H. sarcophaga. We report Mg/Ca, Sr/Ca, Na/Ca and Mn/Ca ratios measured in H. sarcophaga from two different host species (A. excavata and D. pertusum) in chapter five. Sr/Ca ratios are significantly higher in foraminifera that lived on D. pertusum. This could indicate that dissolved host material is utilized in shell calcification of H. sarcophaga, given the naturally higher strontium concentration in the aragonite of D. pertusum. Mn/Ca ratios are highest in foraminifera that lived on A. excavata but did not fully penetrate the host’s shell. Most likely, this represents a juvenile stadium of the foraminifera during which it feeds on the organic periostracum of the bivalve, which is enriched in Mn and Fe. The isotopic compositions are similarly affected, both δ18O and δ13C values are significantly lower in foraminifera that lived 23on D. pertusum compared to specimen that lived on A. excavata. Again, this might represent the uptake of dissolved host material or different pH regimes in the calcifying fluid of the hosts (bivalve < 8, coral > 8) that control the extent of hydration/hydroxylation reactions. Temperature reconstructions are possible using stable oxygen isotopes on this foraminifera species; however, the results are only reliable if the foraminifera lived on A. excavata. Samples of H. sarcophaga from D. pertusum would lead to overestimations of the seawater temperature due to the lower δ18O values. Apart from biological vital effects, storage and preservation methods can significantly change the geochemical composition of different marine biogenic carbonates. In chapter six this is presented on the example of ethanol preservation, a common technique to allow extended storage of biogenic samples. The investigation reveals a significant decrease of Mg/Ca and Na/Ca ratios even after only 45 days storage in ultrapure ethanol. Sr/Ca ratios on the other hand are not influenced. Besides temperature, salinity and pH further environmental parameters are important such as nutrient availability, especially for the distribution of cold-water corals. In chapter seven we extend the investigations on A. excavata by including the elemental ratios Ba/Ca, Mn/Ca and P/Ca. We expected P/Ca to be helpful in the otherwise difficult process of dentifying growth increments. Based on our observations we had to refute this theory. P/Ca ratios are not systematically enriched in the vicinity of growth lines. Instead, we found a regular sequence of peaks of Ba/Ca, P/Ca and Mn/Ca. This sequence as well as the peaks in general are potentially caused by equential blooms of different algae, diatoms and other planktonic organisms ...