Head-to-head comparison of pulsed field ablation, very high power-short duration, cryoballoon and conventional radiofrequency ablation by LGE-MRI-based ablation lesion assessment
Authors: Regany-Closa M , Pomes J , Invers-Rubio E , Prat S , Garre P , Guichard J B , Guasch E , Tolosana J M , Porta-Sanchez A , Arbelo E , Brugada J , Roca-Luque I , Mont L , Althoff T F 
Published: May 2024

Background

Novel concepts for pulmonary vein isolation (PVI) like pulsed field ablation (PFA) or high power-short duration ablation (HPSD) promise favourable profiles of safety and efficacy. However, clinical comparisons of ablation lesion quality are lacking.

Purpose

To systematically investigate lesion characteristics of novel ablation concepts, we performed a prospective head-to-head comparison between PFA, HPSD, conventional RF and latest generation cryoballoon ablation using late gadolinium enhancement (LGE)-MRI-based ablation lesion assessment.

Methods

This study included patients that underwent first-time PVI-only atrial fibrillation ablation - either by ablation index-guided RF ablation, cryoballoon ablation (Arctic Front Advance Pro), HPSD ablation (QDOT micro catheter, QMODE+, 90W, 4s) or PFA (Farapulse PFA system). All patients received an LGE-MRI 3 months post-ablation. LGE was quantified based on the signal intensity ratio of each voxel relative to the blood pool, applying a previously validated threshold of &gt;1.2 to define LGE indicative of ablation-induced scarring using a dedicated software. LGE discontinuations of &gt;3 mm were considered as gaps, and complete lesions were defined as LGE covering &gt;90% of the peri-antral circumference of ipsilateral pulmonary vein (PV) pairs.

Results

Post-ablation LGE-MRIs from 120 patients were analysed (40 RF, 40 cryoballoon, 20 PFA, 20 HPSD).

The proportion of complete PV-encircling LGE lesions was significantly higher with conventional RF than with cryoballoon ablation (50% vs. 34%; p=0.023). Importantly, HPSD ablation resulted in even more complete lesions than conventional RF (68%, p=0.004), whereas the proportion of complete LGE lesions was lowest with PFA (21%). Accordingly, the total number of gaps was lower with HPSD ablation (1.9 gaps/patient) compared to the other ablation concepts (conventional RF 2.7, cryoballoon 3.2, PFA 3.4 gaps/patient; p=0.034).

As expected, large-area ablation with the cryoballoon (13.8 mm) and PFA (12.8 mm) single-shot devices resulted in the widest lesions. Of note, HPSD lesions were significantly wider than conventional RF lesions (11.1 mm vs. 8.9 mm; p=0.004).

Conclusions

HPSD ablation resulted in the most continuous lesions, translating in the lowest number of gaps. Of note, HPSD lesions were also significantly wider than conventional RF lesions, thus corroborating the concept of a shallower HPSD lesion geometry from experimental studies.

Interestingly, conventional RF showed a higher proportion of complete PV-encircling lesions than cryoballoon ablation.

While PFA lesions cover relatively large areas, comparable to cryoballoon ablation, lesions are more inhomogeneous. However, it remains to be determined, to what extent LGE discontinuities in PFA lesions indicate ineffective ablation or only reflect a different kind of remodeling compared to thermal ablation, which may be less detectable by LGE-MRI.