Environmentally-mediated selection parallels population divergence across a chimpanzee subspecies contact zone
Authors: Mitchell Matthew W. , Alexander Walker , Mitchell Dana V. , Freedman Adam H. , Dordel Janina , Harrigan Ryan J. , Sacan Ahmet , Kentatchime Fabrice , Featherstone Bryan S. , Abwe Ekwoge E. , Sesink Clee Paul R. , Abwe Abwe E. , Locatelli Sabrina , Morgan Bethan J. , Fosso Bernard , Fotso Roger , Tishkoff Sarah A. , Eichler Evan E. , Anthony Nicola M. , Smith Thomas B. , Gonder Mary Katherine 
Published: July 2024

Species evolve from populations with ancestor-descendant relationships in a bifurcating process shaped by geography, gene flow, genetic drift, and natural selection leading to local adaptation to prevailing environmental and ecological conditions. Building on this foundational understanding, we explored local adaptation in chimpanzees (Pan troglodytes) at a key geographical intersection in Cameroon where the two main chimpanzee phylogenetic lineages converge. The Nigeria-Cameroon chimpanzee (P. t. ellioti) and central chimpanzee (P. t. troglodytes) last shared a common ancestor about 500 thousand years ago, with occasional gene flow between them. The evolutionary processes driving their prolonged separation are not fully understood, but neutral evolutionary mechanisms alone cannot account for the observed divergence pattern. Cameroon is often referred to as ‘Africa in miniature’ because the Gulf of Guinea Forest, Congo Basin Forest, and savanna converge there, forming an ecotone. Thus, this contact zone between subspecies in Cameroon provides a unique natural laboratory that enabled us to investigate how environmental variation and natural selection shape divergence in chimpanzees. We developed a genome-wide panel of single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs) in 112 wild chimpanzees sampled in multiple habitats across this contact zone. We augmented SNP discovery by sequencing eight new chimpanzee genomes from Cameroon and analyzing them with previously published chimpanzee genomes. We found thatP. t. elliotiandP. t. troglodytesdiverged from one another around 478,000 years ago and occasionally exchange migrants. We identified 1,690 unique SNPs across 905 genes associated with 31 environmental variables that describe the habitat. These genes are involved in essential biological processes, including immune response, neurological development, behavior, and dietary adaptations. This study highlights the importance of understanding the geographical context of natural selection, paving the way for future studies to interpret evidence for genetic variation with phenotypic traits and deepening our understanding of how populations diverge in response to environmental pressures.

Author Summary

We investigated how local adaptation contributes to shaping the diversification of chimpanzee subspecies at the geographical convergence point for the two major branches of the chimpanzee phylogenetic tree. We analyzed genome-wide SNP genotypes of 112 chimpanzees sampled from natural communities located in this understudied area. We used tiered methods that identified 905 genes subject to selection, each associated with one or more of 31 environmental predictors describing the habitat. We found strong signals of selection in immune response genes that separateP. t. troglodytesfromP. t. ellioti, highlighting the important role of different pathogen histories in their evolution. We also found evidence of selection in genes associated with neurological development, behavior, and diet, that separate both the subspecies and populations ofP. t. elliotithat occupy different niches. These findings suggest that ecological and cultural factors may also contribute to shaping the diversification of chimpanzees across the contact zone.