Indications for different types of brittle failure due to active coal mining using waveform similarities of induced seismic events
Authors: Wehling-Benatelli S. , Becker D. , Bischoff M. , Friederich W. , Meier T. 
Published: May 2013

Abstract. Longwall mining activity in the Ruhr-coal mining district leads to mining-induced seismicity. For detailed studies seismicity of a single longwall panel beneath the town of Hamm-Herringen in the eastern Ruhr area was monitored between June 2006 and July 2007 with a dense temporary array of 15 seismic stations. More than 7000 seismic events with magnitudes between −1.7 &amp;leq; ML &amp;leq; 2.0 were detected and localized in this period. Most of the events occurred in the vicinity of the moving longwall face. In order to find possible differences in the brittle failure types of these events an association of the events to distinct clusters based on their waveform characteristics is performed. This task is carried out using a new clustering algorithm utilizing a network similarity matrix which is created by combining all available 3-component single station similarity matrices. The resultant network matrix is then sorted with respect to the similarity of its rows leading to a sorted matrix immediately indicating the clustering of the event catalogue. Finally, clusters of similar events are extracted by visual inspection. This approach results in the identification of several large clusters which are distinct with respect to their spatial and temporal characteristics as well as their frequency magnitude distributions. Comparable clusters are also found with a conventional single linkage approach, however, the new routine seems to be able to associate more events to specific clusters without merging the clusters. The nine largest observed clusters can be tentatively divided into three different groups that indicate different types of brittle failure. The first group consists of the two largest clusters which constitute more than half of all recorded events. Results of a relative relocation using cross correlation data suggest that these events are confined to the extent of the mined out longwall and cluster close to the edges of the active longwall at the depth of active mining. These events occur in lockstep with the longwall advance and exhibit a high b-value of the Gutenberg-Richter relation of about 1.5–2.5 and consist of small magnitude events. Thus, these events represent the immediate energy release adjacent to the mined out area. The second group consists of clusters locating either slightly above or below the depth of active mining occurring at the current position of the longwall face within the confines of the longwall. They consist of generally stronger events and do not follow a Gutenberg-Richter relation. This activity might be linked to the failure of more competent layers above and below the mined out seam resulting in larger events. Finally, one cluster represents seismic activity with a rather low b-value below 1 and events located partly towards the north of the longwall which are delayed with respect to the advance of the longwall face. These events are interpreted brittle failure on pre-existing tectonic structures reactivated by the mining activity.