Free or Bound? Thomeer and NMR Porosity Partitioning in Carbonate Reservoirs, Alta Discovery, Southwestern Barents Sea
Authors:   Lundin Energy Norway AS, Gianotten Ingrid P. , Rameil Niels ,   Lundin Energy Norway AS, Foyn Sven E. ,   Lundin Energy Norway AS, Kollien Terje ,   Lundin Energy Norway AS, Marre Julio R. ,   Miramar Julio Marre, Looyestijn Wim ,   PanTerra Geoconsultants B.V., Zhang Xiangmin ,   PanTerra Geoconsultants B.V., Hebing Albert ,   PanTerra Geoconsultants B.V.
Published: March 2021

The main etrophysical challenges in carbonate reservoirs are often to define meaningful rock types, then to establish robust permeability and saturation models for these rock types, as well as to develop a realistic estimation of irreducible water saturation (Swirr). Realistic Swirr estimation is important for predicting production behavior (expected development of water cut) and thus ultimately for planning the future development scheme of a discovery. In this study, we present the 2014 Alta discovery, located in the southwestern Barents Sea. More than 50% of the expected hydrocarbon resources reside within complex carbonate reservoirs of Permo-Carboniferous age that display highly variable rock properties. The initial screening revealed that primary rock textures and pore geometries were, for a large part, overprinted by diagenetic processes. Hence, better control on the reservoir’s diagenetic evolution will be needed to apply a full-scale rock typing workflow. In the meantime, it was decided to proceed with a simplified reservoir characterization approach based on the main stratigraphic building blocks. Sufficient core coverage allowed for using permeability measurements on core samples as direct input to a 3D reservoir model. A customized core analysis program, using whole-core samples, was designed to characterize the effect of large-scale vuggy pores. For modeling water saturation, a workflow based on the Thomeer hyperbola was developed that describes mercury injection capillary pressure (MICP) curves. The results adequately specify the saturation in all the stratigraphic building blocks. However, saturation uncertainty in the reservoir is high due to a highly variable cementation factor (m), unknown wettability, and the presence of residual oil below the current free-water level (FWL). The Alta structure has been and still is leaking gas, causing the FWL to rise over time. To address the otherwise underestimated volumes in the transition zone above the current FWL, a deeper pseudo-FWL was created and used as input to the saturation height function. Despite log-based water saturation (Archie) and core measurements (Dean-Stark) indicating more than 80% water saturation for less permeable reservoir rocks within the oil leg, production tests did not produce water at normal rates. This clearly demonstrated the need to distinguish “nonproductive” pore systems (with capillary-bound fluids; in this case, water) from pore systems contributing to production (“free” fluids). A large MICP data set confirmed that most reservoir rocks exhibit a mix of different pore types and pore-throat diameters. To model this accurately, porosity partitioning in nonproductive microporosity and movable porosity using the NMR logs was performed. Calibrating appropriate T2 cutoffs by matching core MICP to NMR logs in these heterogeneous rocks is seriously hampered by the large difference in sample size. Applying both MICP and NMR measurements to a subset of core plugs helped to resolve this challenge. Comparing the corresponding movable (“free”) porosity to total porosity revealed near-linear relationships for different reservoir rocks. For irreducible water saturation (Swirr), Swimmobile is calculated using the NMR-based movable porosity. Swimmobile is considered to be a close approximation of Swirr. The resulting full-field simulation showed a significantly improved match between model output and recorded well test data.