Evaluation of a novel clinical pharmacy tool in identifying and categorising drug-related problems in hospitalised patients: The MA2VER2ICK Tool Study
Authors: O’Donovan C , Henman M , McManamly C , Seoighe A , Deasy E 
Published: April 2024

Introduction

Literature searching has revealed a lack of high-quality research outlining the use of tools or checklists in hospitalised patients. Additionally, few tools identified relate directly to clinical pharmacy practice. The tools identified focus on specific disciplines (e.g. critical care) or specific tasks (e.g. handover).

The MA2VER2ICK Tool is a novel clinical pharmacy tool which has recently undergone review and adaptation.[1] The tool is unique as it is comprehensive and applicable to all hospitalised patients, regardless of clinical discipline. The intended purpose of the tool is to assist clinical pharmacists in comprehensive pharmaceutical care planning.

Aim

Demonstrate the utility of the MA2VER2ICK tool in pharmaceutical care planning, by outlining the type and frequency of drug-related problems occurring in hospitalised patients.

Methods

A prospective, observational, cross-sectional study was conducted in a 560-bed acute university teaching hospital.

Clinical pharmacists adopted the tool in their daily practice, in a mixed medical-surgical inpatient population, over four weeks. All drug-related problems identified were recorded and assigned to the applicable category within the tool, by the clinical pharmacist. Additionally, all drug-related problems were retrospectively assigned to applicable categories of the Pharmaceutical Care Network Europe Classification for Drug Related Problems Version 9.1,[2] for comparison, by two independent researchers.

Results

All identified drug-related problems identified were successfully categorised using the MA2VER2ICK Tool. In total, 753 drug-related problems were identified in 180 patients over four weeks, with 233 patient-pharmacist encounters occurring. The mean age of patients was 68.9±16 years, while 51.7% (93/180) were female and 48.3% (87/180) were male. The mean number of drug-related problems identified per patient was 4.2±3.6. The highest number of drug-related problems experienced by an individual was 20, while 17 patients experienced no drug-related problem.

The majority of drug-related problems identified using the tool related to medication reconciliation (52.7%; 397/753), followed by prescription endorsement and administration (17.3%; 130/753) and pharmacotherapy optimisation (9.3%; 70/753).

In comparison with the MA2VER2ICK Tool, the Pharmaceutical Care Network Europe classification system has a much larger range of categories for assigning drug-related problems. Despite this, a proportion of identified drug-related problems 1.6% (12/753) could not be categorised using this tool, while there were also several categories within the tool 43.2% (19/44) whereby no drug-related problems were assigned.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates that the MA2VER2ICK Tool is a robust clinical pharmacy tool, that is effective and practical in assisting clinical pharmacists with the identification of drug-related problems and thus is a useful guide to facilitate pharmaceutical care planning at the patient’s bedside. This is in comparison with the Pharmaceutical Care Network Europe classification system, which has less utility as a clinical pharmacy tool, but is better placed as a research instrument.

Despite demonstrating the usefulness of the MA2VER2ICK Tool in identifying drug-related problems, the clinical significance of those identified was not assessed during this study. However, data collection occurred in real time, facilitating the identification of actual and potential problems, thus reducing the likelihood of underestimating the incidence rate.

References

1. O’Donovan C, Henman M, McManamly C et al. A mixed-methods review and adaptation of a novel clinical pharmacy tool: The MA2VER2ICK Tool Study. 2024. International Journal of Pharmacy Practice. 2024;32(S1):i45.

2. PCNE Classification for Drug-Related Problems V9.1: Pharmaceutical Care Network Europe; 2020 [cited 06 December 2023]. Available from: https://www.pcne.org/upload/files/417_PCNE_classification_V9-1_final.pdf