Abstract P1-05-12: Clonal heterogeneity in breast cancer and its impact on clinical biomarkers
Authors: Barrett MT , Lenkiewicz E , Malasi S , Webster T , Wison Sayres MA , McCullough AE , Anderson KS , Pockaj BA 
Published: March 2017

Introduction: Clonal heterogeneity in cancer is associated with resistance to therapies and evolution of metastatic disease. Clinical management of breast cancer relies on the status of estrogen (ER), progesterone (PR), and Her2 receptors in diagnostic biopsies. Results for these biomarkers rely on IHC and FISH assays that incorporate staining intensity and percentage of positive cell numbers for each sample of interest. Heterogeneous results for one or more of these biomarkers suggest the presence of multiple tumor populations within a biopsy. However the impact of clonal heterogeneity on clinical biomarkers has not been rigorously evaluated.

Methods: We interrogated the clonal composition of 3 treatment-naïve surgically excised invasive ductal carcinomas. Patient #1 cancer, (pT2, pN0) was grade 3, ER+, PR+, and Her2-- with a germ line BRCA2Q49X mutation. Patient #2 cancer (pT2, pN0) was grade 3, ER+ PR- Her2+. Patient #3 was a locally advanced cancer with both axillary and supraclavicular lymph node (LN) involvement (pT2, pN3c, and was grade 3, ER+PR-Her2+ by core but found to be ER+PR-Her2- on the resection specimen. We applied DNA content flow cytometry to multiple (8-18) mapped biopsies in each case. Each sorted tumor population was interrogated with whole exome sequencing, and whole genome array comparative genomic hybridization (aCGH). Single cell analysis of aneuploid populations present in the primary tumor and lymph nodes in patient 3 was done to further assess clonal heterogeneity.

Results: Tumor from patient #1 had a single ploidy with stable copy number profiles including an interstitial 13q deletion that converted a germ line BRCA2Q49X mutation to homozygosity, and a clonal homozygous deletion in Numb in each of 4 tumor biopsies. Tumor from patient #2 had a dominant ploidy (3.2N) in each of 10 (A1-A10) primary tumor biopsies but with a second co-existing ploidy (3.6N) in one (A2) biopsy. A homozygous somatic BRCA2r3129x mutation was identified in all 10 biopsies and in both ploidies; however the genomes had heterogeneous aCGH profiles. In contrast, 12 primary biopsies from Patient #3 contained 6 distinct ploidies with highly aberrant but homogenous genomes, characterized by SARC amplification, homozygous deletion of ROBO1 and ROBO2, and clonal mutations in TP53, NF1, and PIK3CA. One of the ploidies, (5.8N) was present in an adjacent node and another (5.0N) in both the adjacent and distant nodes. Single cell analyses of the 5.0N and 5.8N populations revealed that allele frequencies of driver mutations were stable in the tumor and become homozygous in the LNs. There were no Her2 amplicons or mutations in biopsies analyzed in Patients #2 and #3 further contradicting the heterogeneous staining for ER, PR and Her2.

Conclusion: Tumor heterogeneity includes variations in ploidies, copy number aberrations, and allele frequencies. However even highly aberrant aneuploid genomes can be stable within multiple primary and lymph node sites. Rigorous interrogation of flow sorted tumor populations, in contrast to inferring heterogeneity in bulk samples, identifies driver aberrations in single biopsies, challenges heterogeneous results with clinical biomarkers, and distinguishes allelic heterozygosity from tumor heterogeneity in highly aberrant aneuploid tumor genomes.

Citation Format: Barrett MT, Lenkiewicz E, Malasi S, Webster T, Wison Sayres MA, McCullough AE, Anderson KS, Pockaj BA. Clonal heterogeneity in breast cancer and its impact on clinical biomarkers [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the 2016 San Antonio Breast Cancer Symposium; 2016 Dec 6-10; San Antonio, TX. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2017;77(4 Suppl):Abstract nr P1-05-12.