Mathematical learning through actions on diagrams : reconstruction of learners' interpretations when acting on digital and analogue materials in primary school
Authors:   , Billion Lara Kristina 
Published: December 2023

In this thesis, the focus is on the actions of primary school children using digital and analogue materials in comparable mathematical situations. To emphasise actions on different materials in the mathematical learning process, a semiotic perspective according to C. S. Peirce (CP 1931-35) on mathematics learning is adopted. This theoretical research perspective highlights the activity itself on diagrams as a mathematical activity and brings actions to the forefront of interest. The actions on comparable digital and analogue diagrams are the basis for the reconstruction of mathematical interpretations of learners in 3rd and 4th grade. The research questions investigate to what extent possible differences between the reconstructed interpretations of the learners can be attributed to the different materials and what influence the material has on the mathematical relationships that the learners take into account in their actions to manipulate the diagram. For the reconstruction of the diagram interpretations based on the learners' actions on the material, a semiotic specification of Vogel's (2017) adaptation of Mayring's (2014) context analysis is used. This specification is based on Peirce's triadic theory of signs (Billion, 2023). The reconstructed interpretations of the analogue and digital diagrams are compared in a second step to identify possible differences and similarities. The results of the qualitative analyses show, among other things, that despite the different actions of the learners on the digital and analogue diagrams, it is possible to reconstruct the same diagram interpretations if the learners establish the same mathematical relationships between the parts of the diagrams in their actions. There are also passages in the analyses where the same diagram interpretations cannot be reconstructed based on the actions on the digital and analogue materials. If the digital material acts as a tool and automatically creates several relationships between the parts of the diagram triggered by an action, then the reconstruction of the learners' diagram interpretations based on the analysis of their actions is partially possible. If the tool automatically establishes relationships, these must then be interpreted by the learners using gestures and phonetic utterances to understand the newly created diagram. Thus, a tool changes how mathematical relationships are expressed, because learners no longer have to interpret the relationships before their actions to manipulate the diagram itself, but afterwards through gestures and phonetic utterances. Regarding diagrammatic reasoning according to Peirce (NEM IV), this means that with analogue material the focus is on the construction and manipulation of diagrams through rule-guided actions, whereas with digital material, which functions as a tool, there is more emphasis on observing the results of the manipulations on the diagram. At the end of the thesis, a recommendation for teachers on how to design mathematics lessons for primary school children using digital and analogue materials will be derived from the results. The literature cited in this summary can be found in the references of the presented thesis.