CO2e Life-Cycle Assessment: Twin Comparison of Battery–Electric and Diesel Heavy-Duty Tractor Units with Real-World Data
Authors: Piepenbrink Hannes , Flämig Heike , Menger Alexander 
Published: February 2025

In 2023, the EU set the target to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions by 55% until 2030 compared to 1990. The European Transport Policy sees battery–electric vehicles as a key technology to decarbonize the transport sector, so governments support the adoption through dedicated funding programs. Battery–electric trucks hold great potential to decarbonize the transport sector, especially for high-impact, heavy-duty trucks. Theoretical life-cycle assessments (LCA) predict a lower CO2e emission impact from battery–electric trucks compared to conventional diesel trucks. Yet, one concern repeatedly mentioned by potential users is the doubt about the ecological advantage of battery–electric vehicles. This is rooted in the problem of a much higher CO2e impact of the lithium-ion batteries production process. As heavy-duty trucks have a much larger battery, the hypothec in the construction phase of the vehicle is significantly higher, which must be regained during the use phase. Although theoretical assessments exist, CO2e evaluations using real-world application data are almost nonexistent, as the technology is at the very start of the adoption curve. Exemplary is the fact that there were only 72 registered battery–electric heavy-duty tractor trucks throughout the whole of Germany at the start of 2023. This paper aims to deliver one of the first real-world quantifications using operational data for the actual reduction impact of battery–electric heavy-duty trucks compared to diesel trucks. This study uses the methodology of the life-cycle assessment approach according to ISO 14040/14044 to gain a systematic and holistic technology comparison. For this LCA, the system boundaries are considered from cradle to cradle. This includes the production of raw materials and energy, the manufacturing of the trucks, the use phase, and the recycling afterward. The research objects of this study are battery–electric and diesel Volvo FM trucks, which have been in use by the German freight company Nord-Spedition GmbH since May 2023. The GREET® database is used to assess the emission impact of the material production and manufacturing process. The Volvo tractor trucks resemble a critical case, as the vehicles have a battery size of 540 kWh—around 11 times larger than a usual passenger car. The operation data is directly provided by the logistics company to observe fuel/electricity consumption. Other factors are assessed through company interviews as well as a wide literature research. Finally, a large question mark concerning total emissions lies in the cradle-to-cradle capabilities of large-scale lithium-ion batteries and the electricity grid mix. Different scenarios are being considered to assess potential disposal or recycling paths as well as different electricity grid developments and their impact on the overall balance. The findings estimate the total emissions reduction potential to range between 34% and 69%, varying with assumptions on the electricity grid transition and recycling opportunities. This study displays one of the first successful early-stage integrations of battery–electric heavy-duty trucks into the daily operation of a freight company and can be used to showcase the ecological advantage of the technology.