P-086 Consequences of elevated levels of DNA fragmentation and its influence on pregnancy – A multicentric cohort analysis
Authors: Shah N , Murdia N , Murdia K , Chandra V , Talwar D , Mistari W , Bhoi N 
Published: July 2024

Study question

Does an abnormal DNA Fragmentation Index impact the clinical outcomes of patients undergoing IVF treatment?

Summary answer

Statistical differences were seen in biochemical, implantation, clinical, and ongoing pregnancy rate in sperms with high and low DFI scores with autologous and donated oocytes.

What is known already

Sperm chromatin integrity is associated with embryo development and clinical outcomes of an IVF cycle. DNA Fragmentation Index (DFI) is a diagnostic tool for the detection of spermatozoa with damaged chromosomes in the ejaculate. DNA fragmentation is a significant cause of day 3 embryo arrest and the development of poor-quality embryos. The interventions associated with elevated levels of DFI are ICSI, lifestyle changes and antioxidant therapies. However, the published data regarding the potential of embryo development with high DFI is limited to the sample size thus, encouraging a need for more research in this area.

Study design, size, duration

The study is population-based and included 768 male patients who underwent DFI score detection across 44 centers at Indira IVF Hospital Private Limited from January 2023 to September 2023. The abstinence period for all the patients was recorded during the DFI detection. After the DFI assessment patients were classified into normal DFI score ( &lt; =15%) (n = 203) and abnormal DFI score (&gt;15%) (n = 565).

Participants/materials, setting, methods

The retrospective cohort analysis was performed on our databank on the male patients regardless of their age (21-50), ethnicity, and medical history. DFI was calculated using a Sperm Chromatin Dispersion assay. Patients were categorized into two groups: Normal DFI ( &lt; =15%) and Abnormal DFI (&gt;15%). The characteristics of population along with clinical outcomes were evaluated after transferring embryos fertilized with normal DFI sperm and abnormal DFI sperm. The data was analyzed and estimated by SPSS software.

Main results and the role of chance

Our analyses discovered that embryos fertilized with sperms of normal DFI score have significantly enhanced the likelihood of implantation compared with embryos fertilized with sperms of abnormal DFI (50.27% v/s 44.40%; p = 0.047). Simultaneously, early pregnancy was evaluated by determining the values of beta-HCG in blood, also known as biochemical pregnancy rate (BPR). The embryos fertilized with sperms of normal DFI score significantly enhanced the BPR compared with embryos fertilised with sperms of abnormal DFI (67% v/s 59.1%; p = 0.048). Clinical Pregnancy Rate (CPR) defined as presence of a heartbeat of gestational sac observed during the 6-week scan. Furthermore, it was evaluated that the CPR showed a significant enhancement in embryos fertilized with sperms of normal DFI score in comparison with embryos fertilized with sperms of abnormal DFI (65.5% v/s 57.9%; p = 0.034). However, it was noticed that male DFI score had no impact on the miscarriage rate of embryos inseminated with normal DFI score and abnormal DFI score (7.52% v/s 7.34%; p = 0.687). Moreover, the pregnancy was tracked, and it was revealed that embryos inseminated with sperms of normal DFI score significantly enhanced the ongoing pregnancy till 12 weeks compared with embryos inseminated with sperms of abnormal DFI score (60.6% v/s 53.6%; p = 0.039).

Limitations, reasons for caution

Embryos are known to have a self-correct mechanism to correct the presence of mosaicism in the embryos. Hence, the oocyte quality also affects the outcomes of the IVF cycle. Therefore, using a high grade of the oocyte for the patients with abnormal DFI score can be useful.

Wider implications of the findings

Our data suggest that abnormal DFI have an impact on the clinical outcomes of an IVF cycle. Therefore, examining the levels of DNA Fragmentation is utmost imperative for a successful pregnancy.

Trial registration number

not applicable