Understanding how visual information is represented in humans and machines
Authors:   , Dwivedi Kshitij 
Published: March 2023

In the human brain, the incoming light to the retina is transformed into meaningful representations that allow us to interact with the world. In a similar vein, the RGB pixel values are transformed by a deep neural network (DNN) into meaningful representations relevant to solving a computer vision task it was trained for. Therefore, in my research, I aim to reveal insights into the visual representations in the human visual cortex and DNNs solving vision tasks. In the previous decade, DNNs have emerged as the state-of-the-art models for predicting neural responses in the human and monkey visual cortex. Research has shown that training on a task related to a brain region’s function leads to better predictivity than a randomly initialized network. Based on this observation, we proposed that we can use DNNs trained on different computer vision tasks to identify functional mapping of the human visual cortex. To validate our proposed idea, we first investigate a brain region occipital place area (OPA) using DNNs trained on scene parsing task and scene classification task. From the previous investigations about OPA’s functions, we knew that it encodes navigational affordances that require spatial information about the scene. Therefore, we hypothesized that OPA’s representation should be closer to a scene parsing model than a scene classification model as the scene parsing task explicitly requires spatial information about the scene. Our results showed that scene parsing models had representation closer to OPA than scene classification models thus validating our approach. We then selected multiple DNNs performing a wide range of computer vision tasks ranging from low-level tasks such as edge detection, 3D tasks such as surface normals, and semantic tasks such as semantic segmentation. We compared the representations of these DNNs with all the regions in the visual cortex, thus revealing the functional representations of different regions of the visual cortex. Our results highly converged with previous investigations of these brain regions validating the feasibility of the proposed approach in finding functional representations of the human brain. Our results also provided new insights into underinvestigated brain regions that can serve as starting hypotheses and promote further investigation into those brain regions. We applied the same approach to find representational insights about the DNNs. A DNN usually consists of multiple layers with each layer performing a computation leading to the final layer that performs prediction for a given task. Training on different tasks could lead to very different representations. Therefore, we first investigate at which stage does the representation in DNNs trained on different tasks starts to differ. We further investigate if the DNNs trained on similar tasks lead to similar representations and on dissimilar tasks lead to more dissimilar representations. We selected the same set of DNNs used in the previous work that were trained on the Taskonomy dataset on a diverse range of 2D, 3D and semantic tasks. Then, given a DNN trained on a particular task, we compared the representation of multiple layers to corresponding layers in other DNNs. From this analysis, we aimed to reveal where in the network architecture task-specific representation is prominent. We found that task specificity increases as we go deeper into the DNN architecture and similar tasks start to cluster in groups. We found that the grouping we found using representational similarity was highly correlated with grouping based on transfer learning thus creating an interesting application of the approach to model selection in transfer learning. During previous works, several new measures were introduced to compare DNN representations. So, we identified the commonalities in different measures and unified different measures into a single framework referred to as duality diagram similarity. This work opens up new possibilities for similarity measures to understand DNN representations. While demonstrating a much higher correlation with transfer learning than previous state-of-the-art measures we extend it to understanding layer-wise representations of models trained on the Imagenet and Places dataset using different tasks and demonstrate its applicability to layer selection for transfer learning. In all the previous works, we used the task-specific DNN representations to understand the representations in the human visual cortex and other DNNs. We were able to interpret our findings in terms of computer vision tasks such as edge detection, semantic segmentation, depth estimation, etc. however we were not able to map the representations to human interpretable concepts. Therefore in our most recent work, we developed a new method that associates individual artificial neurons with human interpretable concepts. Overall, the works in this thesis revealed new insights into the representation of the visual cortex and DNNs...