Contribution of 3D genome topological domains to genetic risk of cancers
Authors: Jablonski Kim Philipp , Carron Leopold , Mozziconacci Julien , Forné Thierry , Hütt Marc-Thorsten , Lesne Annick 
Published: July 2021

Genome-wide association studies have identified statistical associations between various diseases, including cancers, and a large number of single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). However, they provide no direct explanation of the mechanisms underlying the association. Based on the recent discovery that changes in 3-dimensional genome organization may have functional consequences on gene regulation favoring diseases, we investigated systematically the genome-wide distribution of disease-associated SNPs with respect to a specific feature of 3D genome organization: topologically-associating domains (TADs) and their borders.

For each of 449 diseases, we tested whether the associated SNPs are present in TAD borders more often than observed by chance, where chance (i.e. the null model in statistical terms) corresponds to the same number of pointwise loci drawn at random either in the entire genome, or in the entire set of disease-associated SNPs listed in the GWAS catalog. Our analysis shows that a fraction of diseases display such a preferential location of their risk loci. Moreover, cancers are relatively more frequent among these diseases, and this predominance is generally enhanced when considering only intergenic SNPs. The structure of SNP-based diseasome networks confirms that TAD border enrichment in risk loci differ between cancers and non-cancer diseases. Different TAD border enrichments are observed in embryonic stem cells and differentiated cells, which agrees with an evolution along embryogenesis of the 3D genome organization into topological domains.

Our results suggest that, for certain diseases, part of the genetic risk lies in a local genetic variation affecting the genome partitioning in topologically-insulated domains. Investigating this possible contribution to genetic risk is particularly relevant in cancers. This study thus opens a way of interpreting genome-wide association studies, by distinguishing two types of disease-associated SNPs: one with a direct effect on an individual gene, the other acting in interplay with 3D genome organization.

Author summary

Genome-wide association studies comparing patients and healthy subjects have evidenced correlations between diseases and the presence of pointwise genetic variations known as single-nucleotide polymorphisms (SNPs). We exploit and extend this statistical analysis by investigating the location of risk loci, i.e. disease-associated SNPs, with respect to the 3D organization of the genome into spatially-insulated domains, the topologically-associating domains (TADs).

We show that for certain diseases, mostly cancers, their associated risk loci are preferentially located in the borders of these topological domains. The predominance of cancers among these diseases is confirmed and even enhanced when considering only intergenic SNPs. A different enrichment behavior is observed in embryonic stem cells and derived cell lines at an early developmental stage, presumably due to the not fully mature TAD structure in these cells.

Overall, our results show that genome variations in specific TAD borders may increase the risk of developing certain diseases, especially cancers. Our work underlines the importance of considering the genetic risk loci within their 3D genomic context, and suggests a role of 3D genome partitioning into topological domains in the genetic risk which differs between cancers and non-cancer diseases.