Study on the causes of growth differences in three conifers after the rainy season in the Xiong’an New Area
Authors: Ran Xin , Qiao Shenqi , Zhang Yu , Gao Xiaokuan , Du Yuewei , Liu Bingxiang , Ma Changming , Mu Hongxiang 
Published: July 2023

Background

The implementation of the Millennium Forestry Plan was accompanied by growth discomfort exhibiting varying degrees of symptoms in some coniferous forests after the rainy season.

Hypothesis

High soil water content affects the underground root growth and distribution characteristics of conifers, and the above-ground parts show corresponding variability. To determine the factors contributing to the significant growth disparities among the three conifers in Xiong’an New Area after the rainy season, we conducted a study investigating the growth characteristics of conifers. This study involved analyzing the external morphology of the plants, assessing leaf pigment content, measuring the root morphological index and root vigor, as well as respiratory characteristics, to evaluate the growth attributes of their root systems in a high soil moisture environment.

Methods

In the “Millennium Forest” area of Xiong’an New Area, we selected three coniferous trees, Pinus tabuliformis, Pinus bungeana and Pinus armandii, and set up three standard sample plots for each conifer. The conifers were classified into 3 levels according to their growth performance (vigorous or suppressed), leaf condition (color change, wilting or not) and relevant grading criteria.

Results

(1) The growth of the three conifers displayed discernible differences in external morphology. Moreover, a decrease in growth condition corresponded to a reduction in crown size, ground diameter, diameter at breast height, leaf length, and new growths. (2) The root biomass, length, surface area, and root volume of conifers growing N class were significantly reduced than those of L class conifers. Conifers with a higher proportion of root systems in the 40-60 cm soil layer experienced more severe stress. (3) The significant decline in root respiration and vigor among all three conifer growth classes (M and N) suggested that the root system was undergoing anoxic stress, particularly at a soil depth of 40-60 cm where root respiration and vigor were notably reduced. (4) The persistent anoxic stress created by long-term exposure to high soil moisture content primarily impacted P. armandii to a greater extent than P. tabuliformis and P. bungeana. Additionally, the transporting and absorbing root ratios varied among conifers with differing growth conditions. The long-term high moisture environment also caused partial death of absorbing roots, which played a key role in the observed differences in growth. (5) As the soil depth increases, the soil water content increases accordingly. Plants with more root distribution in the deeper soil layers grow worse than those distributed in the top soil layers. Soil water content is related to aeration, root distribution, growth and growth of above-ground parts. The variability of root distribution and growth led to the differentiation of the growth of the above-ground part of the plant in terms of external morphology, which inhibited the overall plant growth. The results of the study provide a theoretical basis for the cultivation and management of three conifers in high soil moisture environments.