Estimating Rare Disease Incidences With Large-scale Internet Search Data: Development and Evaluation of a Two-step Machine Learning Method (Preprint)
Authors: Li Jiayu , He Zhiyu , Zhang Min , Ma Weizhi , Jin Ye , Zhang Lei , Zhang Shuyang , Liu Yiqun , Ma Shaoping 
Published: April 2023

BACKGROUND

As rare diseases (RDs) receive increasing attention, obtaining accurate RD incidence estimates has become an essential concern in public health. Since RDs are difficult to diagnose, include diverse types, and have scarce cases, traditional epidemiological methods are costly in RD registries. With the development of the internet, users have become accustomed to searching for disease-related information through search engines before seeking medical treatment. Therefore, online search data provide a new source for estimating RD incidences.

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to estimate the incidences of multiple RDs in distinct regions of China with online search data.

METHODS

Our research scale included 15 RDs in China from 2016 to 2019. The online search data were obtained from Sogou, one of the top 3 commercial search engines in China. By matching to multilevel keywords related to 15 RDs during the 4 years, we retrieved keyword-matched RD-related queries. The queries used before and after the keyword-matched queries formed the basis of the RD-related search sessions. A two-step method was developed to estimate RD incidences with users’ intents conveyed by the sessions. In the first step, a combination of long short-term memory and multilayer perceptron algorithms was used to predict whether the intents of search sessions were RD-concerned, news-concerned, or others. The second step utilized a linear regression (LR) model to estimate the incidences of multiple RDs in distinct regions based on the RD- and news-concerned session numbers. For evaluation, the estimated incidences were compared with RD incidences collected from China’s national multicenter clinical database of RDs. The root mean square error (RMSE) and relative error rate (RER) were used as the evaluation metrics.

RESULTS

The RD-related online data included 2,749,257 queries and 1,769,986 sessions from 1,380,186 users from 2016 to 2019. The best LR model with sessions as the input estimated the RD incidences with an RMSE of 0.017 (95% CI 0.016-0.017) and an RER of 0.365 (95% CI 0.341-0.388). The best LR model with queries as input had an RMSE of 0.023 (95% CI 0.017-0.029) and an RER of 0.511 (95% CI 0.377-0.645). Compared with queries, using session intents achieved an error decrease of 28.57% in terms of the RER (<i>P</i>=.01). Analysis of different RDs and regions showed that session input was more suitable for estimating the incidences of most diseases (14 of 15 RDs). Moreover, examples focusing on two RDs showed that news-concerned session intents reflected news of an outbreak and helped correct the overestimation of incidences. Experiments on RD types further indicated that type had no significant influence on the RD estimation task.

CONCLUSIONS

This work sheds light on a novel method for rapid estimation of RD incidences in the internet era, and demonstrates that search session intents were especially helpful for the estimation. The proposed two-step estimation method could be a valuable supplement to the traditional registry for understanding RDs, planning policies, and allocating medical resources. The utilization of search sessions in disease detection and estimation could be transferred to infoveillance of large-scale epidemics or chronic diseases.