SMALL‐SUBUNIT RIBOSOMAL DNA SEQUENCE ANALYSES AND A RECONSTRUCTION OF THE INFERRED PHYLOGENY AMONG SYMBIOTIC DINOFLAGELLATES (PYRROPHYTA)1
Authors: McNally Kenneth L. , Govind Nadathur S. , Thomé Patricia E. , Trench Robert K. 
Published: October 2004

The small‐subunit ribosomal RNA genes (SSU rDNA) from the four symbiotic dinoflagellates, Symbiodinium corculorum Trench isolated from the bivalve mollusc Corculum cardissa (from Belau, Western Caroline Is.), S. meandrinae Trench, from the scleractinian coral Meandrina meandrites (from famaica, W.I.), Gloeodinium viscum Banaszak et al. from the hydrocoral Millepora dichotoma (from the Gulf of Aqaba), and Amphidinium belauense Trench from the acoel flatworm Haplodiscus sp. (from Belau) have been amplified by the polymerase chain reaction, cloned, and sequenced. Following alignment of these complete sequences to homologous sequences from six other dinoflagellates, eight api‐complexans, six ciliates, six chromophytes and oomycetes, three ascomycetes, two rhodophytes, two chlorophytes, and two myxomycetes (with Physarum polycephalum as the outgroup), phylogenetic reconstruction was conducted using Fitch and Margoliash distance, DNA maximum likelihood, and Wagner parsimony methods, with bootstrap resampling. All methods generated trees with similar topologies. The inferred “across Kingdom” phylogeny reemphasizes previous reports that show that the dinoflagellates, the apicomplexans, and the ciliates share a common ancestry and that the dinoflagellates are distantly related to the chromophyte‐oömycete lineage. The evidence supports the concept of a polyphyletic origin of dinoflagellate‐invertebrate symbioses, as symbiotic dinoflagellates represent seven genera in at least four orders. The three symbiotic species, S. corculorum, S. meandrinae, and S. pilosum, consistent with their morphological and biochemical similarities, cluster most closely. Symbiodinium pulchrorum Trench, the symbiontfrom the Hawaiian sea anemone Aiptasia pulchella, is more distantly related to them. Gloeodinium viscum is not closely related to the Symbiodinium species. Amphidinium carterae (free‐living) and A. belauense (symbiotic) also appear to be distantly related to Symbiodinium. Some symbionts (e.g. S. corculorum, S. pilosum) from distant geographic locations (the Indo‐Pacific and Caribbean, respectively) were found to be very closely related, whereas S. pulchrorum and S. corculorum from the Pacific were found to be distantly related. Analyses of 10 additional symbiotic and nonsymbiotic dinoflagellates, using partial SSU rDNA sequences to generate a tentative dinoflagellate phylogeny, indicate that members of the genus Symbiodinium cluster with most of the other (free‐living) dinoflagellates in the genus Gymnodinium. The genus Amphidinium, as represented by A. carterae and A. belauense, appear to be distantly related to the other members of the Gymnodiniaceae. This analysis, combined with morphological and biochemical data, indicates that the symbionts S. pulchrorum (from Aiptasia pulchella) and S. bermudense Trench (from Aiptasia tagetes) from the Indo‐Pacific and Caribbean, respectively, are very closely related but are not identical.