Incorporating a Stepped Care Approach Into Internet-Based Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for Depression: Randomized Controlled Trial (Preprint)
Authors: Jagayat Jasleen Kaur , Kumar Anchan , Shao Yijia , Pannu Amrita , Patel Charmy , Shirazi Amirhossein , Omrani Mohsen , Alavi Nazanin 
Published: August 2023

BACKGROUND

Depression is a hidden burden, yet it is a leading cause of disability worldwide. Despite the adverse effects of depression, fewer than one-third of patients receive care. Internet-based cognitive behavioral therapy (i-CBT) is an effective treatment for depression, and combining i-CBT with supervised care could make the therapy scalable and effective. A stepped care model is a framework for beginning treatment with an effective and low-intensity intervention while adapting care based on the patient’s needs.

OBJECTIVE

This study investigated the efficacy of a stepped care i-CBT model for depression based on changes in self-reported depressive symptoms.

METHODS

In this single-blinded, randomized controlled trial, participants were allocated to either the i-CBT–only group (28/56, 50%) or the i-CBT with stepped care group (28/56, 50%). Both groups received a 13-week i-CBT program tailored for depression. The i-CBT program was provided through a secure, online mental health clinic called the Online Psychotherapy Tool. Participants read through the sessions and completed the assignments related to each session. Participants in the stepped care group received additional interventions from their care provider based on standard questionnaire scores (ie, Patient Health Questionnaire–9 [PHQ-9], Quick Inventory of Depressive Symptomatology [QIDS], and Quality of Life Enjoyment and Satisfaction Questionnaire–Short Form) and their assignment responses. From lowest to highest intensity, the additional interventions included SMS text messages, phone calls, video calls, or a video call with a psychiatrist.

RESULTS

For this study, 56 participants were recruited to complete an i-CBT program (n=28, 50%; mean age 37.9; SD 13.08 y; 7/28, 27% were men) or an i-CBT with stepped care program (n=28, 50%; mean age 40.6; SD 14.28 y; 11/28, 42% were men). The results of this study indicate that the i-CBT program was effective in significantly reducing depressive symptoms, as measured by the PHQ-9 (<i>F</i><sub>4,80</sub>=9.95; <i>P</i>&lt;.001) and QIDS (<i>F</i><sub>2,28</sub>=5.73; <i>P</i>=.008); however, there were no significant differences in the reduction of depressive symptoms between the 2 groups (PHQ-9: <i>F</i><sub>4,80</sub>=0.43; <i>P</i>=.78; QIDS: <i>F</i><sub>2,28</sub>=3.05; <i>P</i>=.06). The stepped care group was not significantly better in reducing depressive symptoms than the i-CBT group (PHQ-9, <i>P</i>=.79; QIDS, <i>P</i>=.06). Although there were no significant differences observed between the number of participants who completed the program between the groups (<i>χ</i><sup>2</sup><sub>1</sub>=2.6; <i>P</i>=.10), participants in the stepped care group, on average, participated in more sessions than those who prematurely terminated participation in the i-CBT group (<i>t</i><sub>55</sub>=−2; <i>P</i>=.03; 95% CI –4.83 to –0.002).

CONCLUSIONS

Implementing a stepped care approach in i-CBT is an effective treatment for depression, and the stepped care model can assist patients to complete more sessions in their treatment.

CLINICALTRIAL

Clinicaltrials.gov NCT04747873; https://clinicaltrials.gov/study/NCT04747873