Comparison with Private and Public Clonotypes Reveals That, While CLL Type Stereotyped BCR Are Produced in 90% of Healthy Subjects from 18 to 78 Years, They Are Not Accumulated and Are Mostly Found in Immature and Naïve B-Cells
Authors: Dupont Marine , Derouault Paco , Pascal Virginie , Rivière Charlotte , Ganne Benjamin , Boulin Mélanie , Perron Sophie , Chauzeix Jasmine , Gachard Nathalie , Feuillard Jean , Rizzo David 
Published: November 2021

Introduction:

One third of Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia (CLL) patients harbor stereotyped B-Cell receptor (BCR). This is in contrast with the 1012 potential different BCRs that can be produced by the immune system. Some stereotyped BCR are also highly associated with prognosis. For example, the stereotyped subset #2 identifies aggressive CLLs with frequent SF3B1 and ATM alterations. This underlies an important role of BCR selection for emergence of CLL clones.

Aim and methods:

We raised the question of the existence and quantification of B-cells with stereotyped BCR of the CLL-type in a series of 69 healthy subjects (HS) from 18 to 78 years old, without any past of hematological history nor any detectable monotypic B-cells by flow cytometry.

HS were divided in age three groups, adults (18 - 55 years, n= 31), senior-1 (55 - 65 years, n = 14) and senior-2 (&gt; 65 years, n = 24).

The variable region of the immunoglobulin heavy chain gene (IGHV) was amplified from genomic DNA of purified B-cells sequenced on an Illumina MiSeq and annotated with the online IMGT HighV-Quest tool.

Clonotypes were defined as IGHV genes with the same rearranged V and J segment and with the same CDR3 amino acid sequence with one mismatch tolerance, and if a minimal threshold read number was reached (ranging 5 to 15 according to the DNA input and sequencing depth).Public clonotypes were those shared in between at least 4 (5%) HS.

Detection of the 19 major stereotyped CLL's BCRs was performed with an in house R script. And was confirmed with the ARResT/AssignSubsets online tool (V Bistry et al, Bioinformatics, 2015).

Exploration of the IGHV repertoire of the different B-cell subpopulations was done from public data (Mitsunaga, Mol Cell Proteomics, 2020).

Results:

To be independent of the number of reads and to compare HS to each other, clonotypic frequencies were ranked in 150 increasing intervals. In each case, the mean rank of clonotypic frequency ranged 3 to 7 with an SD in between 2 and 6 and was independent of the age category. A Z-score was calculated for each clonotype. Less than 1% of private clonotypes had a Z-score&gt;1.96, while 10% to 30% of public clonotypes had a significant Z-score&gt;1.96 (figure 1). This indicates that public clonotypes are often accumulated when compared to their private counterpart.

A stereotyped CLL's BCR was found in 90% HS all stereotypes together. Subsets #2 and #5 were found in more than 50% of cases (figure 2). Frequencies of subsets #3, #59, #7C, #202, #14, #64B, decreased from 23% to 6% cases. Subsets #1, #4, #6, #8, #12, #16, #99 and #201 were never found.

Frequencies of stereotyped BCRs ranged 5.2x10 -5 to 1.2x10 -4, being similar in the different HS age categories. Ranks of stereotyped BCR frequencies were almost always below the mean rank of private clonotypes, that indicates a very low abundance (figure 3). Junction analyses suggest that B-cells with stereotyped BCRs were polyclonal since they were very likely to derive from different B-cell precursors. Exploring the longitudinal repertoires of Mitsunaga and Snyder(Mol Cell Proteomics 2020), showed that stereotyped BCRs were almost restricted to immature and naïve B-cells and were fugace while public clonotypes were recurrently and frequently found in memory B-cells and could be stable over time for many of them.

Conclusion:

B-cells with stereotyped CLL BCRs were easily detected in healthy people whatever their age category. Remarkably, subsets #2 and #5 that are associated with aggressive CLL were found in more than 50% healthy donors at any age. Comparison with private and public clonotypic repertoire reveals that abundance of stereotyped BCR was almost always very low and was restricted to immature and naïve B-cells.

Therefore, B-cells with stereotyped BCRs are produced throughout life in almost everybody. But these B-cells do not accumulate and do not seem to undergo to B-cell maturation.

This suggests that stereotyped BCRs are not intrinsically prone to transformation and that clonal selection of CLL cells would involve additional events such as antigenic encounter or oncogenic alterations.

Figure 1 Figure 1.

Disclosures

No relevant conflicts of interest to declare.