Prevalence of language and pre‐literacy difficulties in an Australian cohort of 5‐year‐old children experiencing adversity
Authors: Smith Jodie , Levickis Penny , Neilson Roslyn , Mensah Fiona , Goldfeld Sharon , Bryson Hannah 
Published: March 2021

Background

Early reading success is predicated on language and pre‐literacy skills. Children who are behind their peers in language and pre‐literacy development before formal schooling are less likely to be proficient beginner readers, and difficulties may persist throughout primary school and beyond. We know children experiencing adversity are at greater risk of early language and pre‐literacy difficulties; we do not know the prevalence of these difficulties in an Australian adversity context.

Aims

To investigate the prevalence and co‐occurrence of language and pre‐literacy difficulties in a cohort of Australian 5‐year‐old children experiencing social adversity.

Methods & Procedures

Data were drawn from a large Australian community‐based trial of nurse home visiting (right@home), which aimed to support women experiencing social adversity from pregnancy until their child turned 2 years of age. Social adversity was determined by two of more risk factors: young pregnancy, not living with another adult, no support, poorer health, current smoker, long‐term illness, anxious mood, not finishing high school, no household income and no previous employment. Children whose mothers were enrolled in the control group (receiving usual maternal and child healthcare) were included in the current study (n = 359). Language and pre‐literacy skills were measured at age 5 using the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamental Preschool—Second Edition (CELF‐P2) and the School Entry Alphabetic and Phonological Awareness Readiness Test (SEAPART). Language difficulties were defined as ≥ 1.25 standard deviations (SD) below the Australian normative mean on CELF‐P2 Core Language scores. Pre‐literacy difficulties were defined as children scoring in the Beginner (versus Developing or Competent) criterion‐referenced level on the SEAPART First Sound Identification and/or Alphabet Letter Identification subtests. Co‐occurrence of language and pre‐literacy difficulties was also determined.

Outcomes & Results

At the 5‐year follow‐up, 201/359 (56%) children were assessed (mean age = 5.1 years, SD = 0.1). Mean Core Language score for this cohort (91.8, SD = 15.9) was 0.54 SD below the normative mean (100, SD = 15). The proportion of children presenting with language difficulties was 24.9%. Regarding pre‐literacy skills, 43.8% of children were ‘Beginner’ for identifying first sounds and 58.6% for identifying alphabet letters/sounds. There was also considerable overlap whereby 76.7% of children with language difficulties also exhibited pre‐literacy difficulties.

Conclusions & Implications

This is the first empirical Australian‐based study highlighting the high prevalence and co‐occurrence of language and pre‐literacy difficulties in preschool children experiencing social adversity. Clinicians should be aware of co‐morbid language and pre‐literacy difficulties in disadvantaged populations and consider both areas during assessment and intervention planning.

What this paper adds

What is already known on the subject

The prevalence of language and literacy difficulties is substantially higher in cohorts experiencing social adversity when compared with more advantaged families. There is some evidence that adversity also contributes to pre‐literacy difficulties, but less is known here.

What this paper adds to existing knowledge

This study presents new prevalence data showing high rates of language and pre‐literacy difficulties for 5‐year‐old children experiencing adversity within an Australian context. It is the first to explore these skills in a large cohort of pre‐schoolers recruited from community settings in Australia.

What are the potential or actual clinical implications of this work?

In this cohort experiencing adversity, most children who presented with language difficulties likewise exhibited pre‐literacy difficulties. This concordance reflects how early oral language and pre‐literacy skills develop together. Clinicians should assess both skills in preschool populations—especially those working with children experiencing adversity—to ensure all children have strong foundations to become proficient beginner readers.