MRI compared to 123I-MIBG scan for detection of central nervous system relapse in neuroblastoma.
Authors: Stiefel Jessica , Kramer Kim , Haque Sofia , Basu Ellen M. , Kushner Brian H. , Pandit-Taskar Neeta , Katz Andrew , Cheung Nai-Kong V. , Modak Shakeel 
Published: June 2024

10040

Background: Neuroblastoma (NB) relapsing in the central nervous system (CNS), though uncommon, is historically incurable. However, a multimodality approach has improved long term survival (1). Timely detection of CNS relapse may reduce or prevent morbidity and mortality. In most centers, surveillance for NB includes whole-body MIBG scans but does not require dedicated anatomical brain imaging. At Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center (MSK), head MRI at regular intervals is standard. The objective of this retrospective study was to determine the optimal imaging modality for detecting CNS relapse in NB. Methods: After MSK IRB approval, records of patients with CNS NB seen at MSK from 2004-2023 were evaluated. In most cases, relapse was diagnosed at other institutions before referral to MSK. Analyzed data included symptoms and findings on brain CT/MRI and MIBG scans. Results: Of 206 patients with MIBG-avid CNS NB, 7 were excluded because they had CNS disease at diagnosis. For the remaining 199 patients, median time to CNS relapse from diagnosis was 18 months. 132 (66%) patients had CNS relapse at a median of 9.8 months after achieving complete remission. In 67 patients with prior systemic progression, median time to CNS relapse was 10.9 months from the last relapse. Relapse was isolated to CNS in 130/199 (65%) patients. 118 (59%) patients had neurological symptoms at time of CNS disease; 81(41%) were asymptomatic, relapse being detected on surveillance scans. Multiple (>1) parenchymal lesions were noted in 74 (37%), diffuse leptomeningeal disease without parenchymal involvement in 15 (7%) and solitary lesions in 110 (55%) patients. Median diameter of the largest lesion was 2.7 (range <0.5-6.8) cm. Anatomical imaging was performed with MRI (65%), CT (14%) or both (34%). Of those undergoing both scans, CNS relapse was missed on CT in 4/67 (6%) patients. 137 patients had MIBG scans before resection of CNS relapse. All sites of CNS disease noted on MRI/CT were positive by MIBG in 46 (33%) patients. However, MIBG scan was either totally or partly negative in 69 (50%) and 22 (16%) patients, respectively. Even for lesions ≥2cm in diameter, MIBG was completely negative in 27/57 (47%). MIBG positivity did not correlate with age, size >2cm, MYCN amplification or ALK mutation status (p>0.05 for each). Lesions <1cm and infratentorially located were more likely to be negative on MIBG scan (p<0.05). Lesions in symptomatic patients, dural lesions and hemorrhagic lesions were more likely to be positive on MIBG scan (p< 0.05). Conclusions: CNS relapse is isolated to the brain in most patients. MIBG scan has poor sensitivity for the detection of CNS NB, regardless of size or location. Although CT or MRI are both effective in detecting CNS relapse, the former can miss some lesions. We recommend brain MRI for surveillance of high-risk NB for ≥2 years after initial diagnosis or last systemic relapse. 1. J. Neurooncology 97:409, 2010.