Abstract 3602: Mechanisms of CAR T cell dysfunction and identification of transcription factors that drive the exhaustion phenotype
Authors: Aznar M. Angela , Good Charly R. , Kuramitsu Shunichiro , Samareh Parisa , Agarwal Sangya , Donahue Greg , Ishiyama Kenichi , Wellhausen Nils , Rennels Austin K. , Ma Yujie , Tian Lifeng , Guedan Sonia , Alexander Katherine A. , Zhang Zhen , Rommel Philipp C. , Singh Nathan , Glastad Karl M. , Richardson Max W. , Watanabe Keisuke , Tanyi Janos L. , O’Hara Mark H. , Ruella Marco , Lacey Simon F. , Moon Edmund K. , Schuster Stephen J. , Albelda Steven M. , Lanier Lewis L. , Young Regina M. , Berger Shelley L. , June Carl H. 
Published: June 2022

Chimeric antigen receptor (CAR) T cell immunotherapy is FDA approved for the treatment of a subset of B cell malignancies but has shown limited clinical success in solid tumor therapy. T cell exhaustion is an important factor involved in treatment failure, and can, in part, result from continuous stimulation of the CAR by tumor cells expressing the cognate antigen. To gain deeper understanding of CAR T cell exhaustion induced by chronic antigen exposure (CAE), we developed and validated a robust in vitro model, in which mesothelin-redirected CAR T cells (M5CAR) were continuously stimulated with mesothelin-expressing AsPC-1 pancreatic tumor cells such that tumor cells were never cleared, and we characterized these CAE CAR T cells by gene expression at population and single-cell levels, and by epigenetic analyses.

CAE M5CAR T cells recapitulate the hallmarks of T cell exhaustion, including reduced proliferation, down-modulation of surface CAR, decreased cytokine production, and reduced cytotoxicity. In addition, CAR T cells undergoing CAE have a transcriptional signature and an epigenetic landscape consistent with exhaustion. Further, transcriptomic analysis revealed that CAE M5CAR T cells undergo a transition from T cells to a post-thymic NK-like T cell phenotype. This plasticity was confirmed by TCR lineage tracing and was also detected in CD19 CAR T cells analyzed from post-infusion blood from DLBCL patients and in M5CAR T cells infiltrating relapsed tumors derived from a xenograft NSG/AsPC-1 mouse model. The dysfunctional signature and the NK phenotype were further detected in vivo by transcriptomic analysis in Ly95 TCR-specific TILs infiltrating NY-ESO-1 tumors. Among the genes included in the dysfunctional signature, the transcription factors SOX4 and ID3 were identified as potential regulators of dysfunction by differential gene expression and pathway analyses. To determine their role in the establishment of a dysfunctional phenotype, we generated ID3KO.M5 and SOX4KO.M5 CAR T cells using CRISPR technology in primary human lymphocytes. The cytotoxic potential of the M5 CAR T cell product generated was not modified by the genetic disruption of the transcription factors. However, when CAR T cells were challenged with chronic antigen stimulation, KO CAR T cells showed a significant reduction of the dysfunctional signature and the NK-like T cell gene expression. Importantly, CAE KO CAR T cells exhibit improved cytotoxicity as compared to Mock.M5CAR T cells.

In summary, we have developed a robust in vitro model that recapitulates the hallmarks of T cell exhaustion and that facilitated the identification of a gene signature defining CAR dysregulation, a T-to-NK-like-T cell transition as a novel feature of CAR T cell dysfunction and the transcription factors SOX4 and ID3 as key regulators of CAR T cell exhaustion.

Citation Format: M. Angela Aznar, Charly R. Good, Shunichiro Kuramitsu, Parisa Samareh, Sangya Agarwal, Greg Donahue, Kenichi Ishiyama, Nils Wellhausen, Austin K. Rennels, Yujie Ma, Lifeng Tian, Sonia Guedan, Katherine A. Alexander, Zhen Zhang, Philipp C. Rommel, Nathan Singh, Karl M. Glastad, Max W. Richardson, Keisuke Watanabe, Janos L. Tanyi, Mark H. O’Hara, Marco Ruella, Simon F. Lacey, Edmund K. Moon, Stephen J. Schuster, Steven M. Albelda, Lewis L. Lanier, Regina M. Young, Shelley L. Berger, Carl H. June. Mechanisms of CAR T cell dysfunction and identification of transcription factors that drive the exhaustion phenotype [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2022; 2022 Apr 8-13. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2022;82(12_Suppl):Abstract nr 3602.