Changes in tree-ring wood density of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.), silver fir (Abies alba Mill.), and Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) H. Karst.) in European mountain forests between 1901 and 2016
Authors: Torresan Chiara , Hilmers Torben , Avdagić Admir , Di Giuseppe Edmondo , Klopčič Matija , Lévesque Mathieu , Motte Florian , Uhl Enno , Zlatanov Tzvetan , Pretzsch Hans 
Published: December 2024

Key message

We found a significant increase in the latewood density of European beech, and a decrease in the latewood and mean wood density of silver fir and Norway spruce in European mountain forests over the period 1901–2016. In the past century, drought did not directly influence the wood density trend of the three studied species. However, for both fir and spruce, drought indirectly affected the mean wood density via changes in the latewood to earlywood ratio, i.e., in the case of extreme drought, trees with high values of latewood to earlywood ratio experienced a slight attenuation in the declining trend of their mean wood density.

Context

Century-long wood density measurements can provide novel information on tree response to climate change and the carbon sequestration potential of forest ecosystems. Still, the knowledge about long-term changes in wood density of European beech (Fagus sylvatica L.), silver fir (Abies alba Mill.), and Norway spruce (Picea abies (L.) H.Karst.) in European mountain forests needs to be further explored.

Aims

We assessed long-term changes in tree-ring mean wood density, earlywood density, and latewood density in trees of the three species between 1901 and 2016. We investigated the influence of endogenous factors (i.e., tree-ring width, current tree diameter, and latewood to earlywood ratio) and drought events on wood density.

Methods

In total, 150 tree cores were sampled from mountain forests in Bulgaria, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Slovenia, Switzerland, and Germany. The mean, early, and latewood density of these samples were measured with the LIGNOSTATION™ system. To address our research aims, we applied a linear mixed-effect modelling approach using the data from 101 correctly cross-dated cores that spanned the entire period of analysis.

Results

In the absence of drought, the latewood density of European beech increased by 7.1%, the late and mean wood density of silver fir decreased by 16.8% and 11.0%, respectively, and the late and mean wood density of Norway spruce decreased by 16.1% and 7.2%, respectively, between 1901–2016. In the past century, drought influenced the trends of wood density through an effect mediated by changes in the latewood to earlywood ratio. Specifically, in cases of extreme drought, silver fir and Norway spruce trees with a latewood to earlywood ratio value 50% higher than the median experience a slight attenuation in the declining trend of their mean wood density, making the negative impact of drought marginally less severe.

Conclusions

Our findings have significant implications for the accuracy of carbon stock assessments, national greenhouse gas inventories, and the utilization of wood from the three species. Given the fact that changes in wood density follow species-specific patterns and the expectation of more frequent drought events in Europe, in the future, it is essential to build further tree-ring density time series for other species and sites to improve our understanding of how climate change alters wood density and carbon sequestration of forest ecosystems.