Anterior transpetrosal approach and the tumor removal rate, postoperative neurological changes, and complications: experience in 274 cases over 33 years
Authors: Tomio Ryosuke , Horiguchi Takashi , Shibao Shunsuke , Tamura Ryota , Yoshida Kazunari , Kawase Takeshi 
Published: January 2024

OBJECTIVE

The authors report on the anterior transpetrosal approach (ATPA) and the results of surgeries performed over a 33-year period for petroclival tumors, including meningioma, trigeminal schwannoma, chordoma, and epidermoid tumor. They analyze early postoperative neurological changes, surgical complications, and trends over the decades.

METHODS

A retrospective analysis of 274 surgical cases that had undergone the ATPA from January 1984 to March 2017 was conducted. Data were collected from charts, clinical summaries, operative records, and operative videos. The analyzed parameters included patient diagnosis, tumor size, disease location, operation date, tumor removal rate, pre- and postoperative neurological symptoms (consciousness level, motor and sensory deficits of the limbs, sensory aphasia, and cranial nerve III–VIII injuries), surgical deaths, and radiologically recognized brain injuries after the operation (contusion, infarction, hemorrhage).

RESULTS

Gross-total resection (GTR) was achieved in 53.5% of the 243 tumors with available data. The GTR rate for meningiomas (148 cases) was 54.1%. Trigeminal schwannomas had a high GTR rate of 87.1%, whereas chordomas had a low GTR rate of 14.3%.

The rate of early neurological deterioration immediately after the ATPA, referred to as "early neurological change," was as follows: consciousness disturbance in 1.9% of cases (5 cases), improvement of hemiparesis in 45.0% of cases but deterioration in 8.1% of cases, sensory aphasia in 2.3% of cases due to temporal lobe injury, improvement of cerebellar symptoms in 39.3% of cases with rare deterioration (1.9% of cases), worsening of preoperative diplopia in 49.4% of patients and rarely improving, improvement of trigeminal symptoms in 19.1% of cases (mostly trigeminal neuralgia) among the 43.7% of patients who had them preoperatively, and deterioration of facial hypesthesia and/or paresthesia in 27.4% of cases.

Early neurological deterioration was monitored in 183 patients for 6 months to determine the surgical complications of ATPA. Consciousness disturbance recovered in half of the cases but persisted in 3 (1.5%). Hemiparesis fully recovered in 63.2% of cases, resulting in a complication rate of 3.0%. The most frequent complication was diplopia (36.4%), with a complete remission rate of 26.4%. The second most frequent complication was facial hypesthesia (24.0%), with a recovery rate of 16.1%. Facial nerve palsy improved in 63.0% of cases and had a complication rate of 4.9%. Cerebellar symptoms showed complete recovery in all cases.

CONCLUSIONS

The ATPA allows the removal of petroclival tumors extending into Meckel’s cave and the middle fossa, making it preferred for dumbbell trigeminal schwannomas and meningiomas. However, the ATPA’s aggressive tumor removal can risk a lower recovery of cranial nerve IV–VI deficits. For benign meningiomas, initial observation with regular follow-up is recommended. Surgery is appropriate for high-growth cases aiming for total removal, accompanied by a thorough explanation of the risks. If the risks are not accepted, subtotal removal can be considered, and radiosurgery is suggested for residual tumor.