The impact of single gene testing (SGT) on subsequent comprehensive genomic profiling (CGP) success in community oncology practice for advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC): Results from a prospective observational reference laboratory testing program.
Authors: Nesline Mary K , DePietro Paul , Cooper Maureen , Zhang Shengle , Howarth Sarah , Wallen Zachary D , Biorn Michael D , Strickland Kyle C , Previs Rebecca A. , Ko Heidi Chwan , Sausen Mark , Jackson Jennifer B , Saini Kamal S. , Wise Scott , Jensen Taylor J. , Pabla Sarabjot , Conroy Jeffrey M. , Reddy Prasanth , Severson Eric A , Ramkissoon Shakti 
Published: June 2023

6506

Background: CGP concurrently tests tumor tissue for guideline-recommended predictive biomarkers for optimal therapy selection and identification of clinical trials in NSCLC patients. A common practice in the community oncology setting is to first order SGT, then consider CGP when SGT results are negative or after treatment failure. Given the limited tissue available and the scope of alterations not tested by SGT, we sought to characterize the effects of prior SGT on subsequent CGP testing success, and therapeutic opportunities identified by CGP beyond SGT for NSCLC patients in the community setting. Methods: Reference laboratory information systems were used to prospectively contact clinicians across 80 community practices who ordered at least 1 SGT for guideline-recommended genomic variants in NSCLC. CGP was offered for their patients prior to SGT or upon receipt of negative SGT results. SGT included individual assays for BRAF, EGFR, KRAS, MET exon 14 skipping mutations; ALK, RET, and ROS1 rearrangements; and PD-L1 IHC . CGP included DNA-seq for mutations, copy number variants in 523 genes including guideline-recommended genomic variants, MSI, and tumor mutational burden; RNA-seq for rearrangements/fusions/splice variants; and PD-L1 IHC. Results: Among a total of 580 NSCLC patients with CGP ordered (May 2021-December 2022), 168 (29%) had ≥1 SGT ordered prior to CGP (median=5). No patients had all SGT performed, with untested cases ranging from 10% for ALK to 90% for MET exon 14. The same FFPE tissue block was used for CGP in 150/168 (89%) of cases with prior negative SGT. Compared to CGP-only cases, CGP for cases with prior negative SGT was canceled twice as often at tissue review (16% vs 7%; p=.001), had higher DNA extraction failures (13% vs 8%; p=.09), and lower DNA sequencing success (70% vs 83%, p<.001). CGP detected guideline-recommended variants in 51% of all cases. Among prior negative SGT cases, frequencies were higher in genes where SGT was performed less often and is less sensitive than CGP RNA-seq ( RET fusions , MET exon 14 skipping). CGP also identified guideline-recommended variants in genes with no SGT offered during the study period ( ERBB2 mutations , NTRK2/3 fusions), as well as variants with emerging evidence for FDA expedited program-designated clinical trial therapies in 28% of patients, including NRG1 fusions and BRAF non-V600E , KEAP1, KRAS non-G12C, NFE2L2, STK11, and TP53 Y220C mutations. Conclusions: Prior negative SGT doubled subsequent CGP test cancellations for NSCLC due to tissue insufficiency and increased CGP DNA extraction failures. SGT practice in the community oncology setting does not meet practice guideline recommendations and negatively impacts the potential benefit of subsequent CGP for NSCLC patients.