The crude oil spot and futures prices dynamics: cointegration, linear and nonlinear causality
Authors: Wong Wing-Keung , Lv Zhihui , Espinosa Christian , Vieito João Paulo 
Published: December 2024

Purpose

To the best of the authors’ knowledge, this study is the first to investigate the intricate relationship between crude oil spot and futures prices, focusing on both cointegration and market efficiency during the COVID-19 pandemic, and the beginning of the Russia–Ukraine conflict. Using daily West Texas Intermediate data from January 2020 to March 2024, like Cunado and Pérez de Gracia (2003), the authors use advanced statistical methods to identify structural breaks and assess cointegration levels. Linear and nonlinear Granger causality tests are used to reveal underlying dynamics.

Design/methodology/approach

This paper uses the Lagrange Multiplier test by Arai and Kurozumi (2007) to check for cointegration with various shifts in crude oil spot and futures markets. The two-step procedure by Kejriwal and Perron (2010) and Kejriwal et al. (2022) is then applied to assess partial parameter stability in cointegration models. Efficiency is examined using both bivariate and trivariate models based on non-arbitrage and expectations hypotheses. Finally, causality is analyzed with the vector error correction model for linear Granger causality, and the tests by Bai et al. (2018) and Diks and Panchenko (2006) for nonlinear causality.

Findings

The analysis reveals that futures prices generally lead spot prices through both linear and nonlinear causality during certain periods, while only linear causality is present in others. This inconsistency suggests fluctuating market efficiency and potential arbitrage opportunities. Structural breaks indicate that the equilibrium between spot and futures prices adjusts in response to significant events like the COVID-19 pandemic and the Russia–Ukraine war. The study identifies specific periods, particularly between January 2020 and March 2024, where both linear and nonlinear forecasting between futures and spot oil prices are effective, highlighting the dynamic nature of their relationship.

Research limitations/implications

Despite extensive efforts, pinpointing the exact break date for COVID-19 remains challenging due to limitations in the data set and methodology. Additionally, the analysis of the Russia–Ukraine conflict is still ongoing. These challenges highlight the complexity of addressing structural breaks linked to unprecedented events.

Practical implications

The findings offer valuable insights for both academia and industry practitioners. The study reveals potential arbitrage opportunities stemming from inconsistent market efficiency and fluctuating causality between futures and spot prices, allowing traders to optimize their trades and timing. It also enhances risk management by identifying when linear and nonlinear causality is most effective. Policymakers can use these insights to evaluate market stability, especially during major disruptions such as the COVID-19 pandemic and geopolitical conflicts, guiding regulatory decisions. Furthermore, the study highlights the importance for investors to adjust their strategies in response to structural breaks and evolving market conditions.

Social implications

This study’s social implications are diverse, extending beyond finance and academia. It influences economic stability by revealing inefficiencies and arbitrage opportunities in crude oil markets, aiding better resource allocation. Enhanced transparency benefits stakeholders, promoting fair market practices and consumer protection. Policymakers can refine regulations based on identified structural breaks, ensuring market stability. The study indirectly impacts environmental discussions by examining crude oil’s link to global energy consumption. Financially, it guides investment strategies, influencing resource distribution and the broader economy. Additionally, its educational contribution stimulates academic discourse, fostering growth in energy economics and financial market knowledge, shaping future research.

Originality/value

The originality and value of this paper lie in its comprehensive examination of the dynamic relationship between futures and spot oil prices, particularly through both linear and nonlinear causality across different periods. By identifying and analyzing periods of both linear and nonlinear causality, the study uncovers fluctuating market efficiency and potential arbitrage opportunities that are not typically addressed in conventional analyses. Additionally, the paper’s focus on the impact of significant global events, such as the COVID-19 pandemic and the Russia–Ukraine war, on the equilibrium between spot and futures prices offers a novel perspective on how structural breaks influence market dynamics. This nuanced understanding enhances both theoretical and practical knowledge, offering valuable insights for traders, investors and policymakers to navigate and respond to evolving market conditions.