Solid Oxide Cell Degradation Operated in Fuel Cell and Electrolysis Modes: A Comparative Study on Ni Agglomeration and LSCF Destabilization
Authors: Hubert Maxime , Laurencin Jérôme , Cloetens Peter , Mougin Julie , Ferreira Sanchez Dario , Pylypko Sergii , Morales Miguel , Morata Alex , Morel Bertrand , Montinaro Dario , Siebert Elisabeth , Lefebvre-Joud Florence 
Published: February 2020

Ceramic high-temperature fuel cells and electrolysers are efficient energy conversion systems for electrical power generation and hydrogen production. Their core components are constituted by a stack of electroactive Solid Oxide Cells (SOCs) in which the electrochemical reactions take place. Thanks to their flexibility, the same stack can be alternatively operated in both fuel cell and electrolysis modes. However, the insufficient durability of SOCs still constitutes a major limitation for the technology. The present study addresses this issue and aims to bring some new insights on the effect of the Solid Oxide Fuel Cell (SOFC) versus Solid Oxide Electrolysis Cell (SOEC) operating modes on degradation of a typical Ni-YSZ//YSZ//CGO//LSCF-CGO cell.

The electrochemical degradations are generally attributed to several underlying phenomena such as electrode microstructural evolution, material chemical decomposition or electroactive sites poisoning by contaminants. Among them, it is generally considered that Ni agglomeration in the Ni-YSZ cermet and Lanthanum Strontium Cobalt Ferrite (LSCF) material destabilization are two prevalent mechanisms involved in the cell performance deterioration. Therefore, these two mechanisms have been specifically investigated by a coupled approach of long-term testing in both SOFC and SOEC modes (1000 ≤ t (h) ≤9000) and post-test characterizations. The experimental results have then been analyzed in the frame of an in-house multi-scale model with the purpose to interpret them and to quantify the effect of material ageing on cell performances.

The extent of Ni agglomeration has been characterized by three-dimensional electrode reconstructions obtained by X-ray nano-holotomography at European Synchrotron Radiation Facility (ESRF) (on the new Nano-Imaging beamline ID16A-NI). The new set-up and protocol enable the reconstructions of valuable 3D volumes (Fig. 1) with a large field of view (~50 µm) along with a high spatial resolution (~50 nm). The electrode morphological properties, which have been measured on the 3D volumes, have revealed a substantial Ni coarsening over time at 850°C and 750°C, whereas no Ni depletion was detected at the electrolyte interface. The increase of the Ni particle size is found to induce a decrease in both (i) the density of Triple Phase Boundary (TPBs) lines and (ii) the interfacial surface area between Ni and gas. Moreover, it was found that the Ni/YSZ interfacial surface area does not evolve during the experiments. This statement indicates that the ceramic backbone in the cermet prevents a massive Ni agglomeration at the SOFC/SOEC operating temperature. The compilation of all experimental data have allowed fitting the parameters of a physically-based law for Ni coarsening that was introduced in the modelling framework. The simulations have revealed that Ni agglomeration explains around 20-25% of the electrochemical degradation at 850°C after 1000 hrs of operation. However, the electrode microstructural evolution is found not to be affected by the cell polarizations. Therefore, the mechanism cannot explain the higher degradation rates recorded in electrolysis mode compared to the fuel cell ones.

To explain the impact of the operating modes (SOFC or SOEC) on the degradation rates, several post-test analyses (i.e. Scanning Electron Microscopy, Transmission Electron Microscopy, X-ray µfluorescence and µdiffraction techniques) have been employed to investigate the phase reactivity in the region of the CGO barrier layer. The characterizations have revealed that Sr diffusion across the barrier layer and formation of SrZrO3 secondary phase occur mainly during electrolysis operation, whereas the process is very limited in fuel cell mode (Fig. 2). As a consequence, LSCF destabilization is found not to be involved in the degradation of cell performances during fuel cell operation while it could explain the highest degradation rates recorded in electrolysis mode. The post-test analyses have also revealed a diffusion and an accumulation of Co in the region of the barrier layer which is concomitant with the formation of SrZrO3. The formation of these Co-rich segregates in contact with SrZrO3 grains have been identified as cobalt-ferrite type compound. The in-house multi-scale model has been used to interpret the role of the cell operating mode on the LSCF destabilization mechanism. The cell polarization curves and the local quantities within the O2 electrode have been computed in both fuel cell and electrolysis modes. The simulations have shown that the electrolysis operation leads to a strong depletion of oxygen vacancies in the LSCF material. It has been proposed that the depletion in oxygen vacancies under electrolysis polarization could drive the Sr release from the structure, and in turn, could explain the experimental results. Based on this proposition, a possible mechanism for the LSCF destabilization and SrZrO3 formation has been detailed.

Figure 1