Cluster randomized trial to evaluate the impact of team training on surgical outcomes
Authors: Duclos A , Peix J L , Piriou V , Occelli P , Denis A , Bourdy S , Carty M J , Gawande A A , Debouck F , Vacca C , Lifante J C , Colin C , Aegerter P , Aouifi A , Arickx D , Aubart F , Baudrin D , Berry W R , Beuvry C , Bonnet F , Bouveret L , Cabarrot P , Cames E , Carty M J , Caton J , Chenitz M-C , Clergues F , Colin C , Coudray J-M , Damiens M , Dauzac C , Debono B , Debouck F , De Germay B , Deleforterie A-C , Denis A , Desrousseaux J-F , Didelot M-P , Doat B , Domingo-Saidji N Y , Duclos A , Durieux P , Fessy M , Hardy P , Cariven P , Fontas N , Ganansia P , Gawande A A , Giraud F , Gostiaux G , Habi S , Haga S , Houlgatte A , Jaffe M , Jourdan J , Kaczmarek N , Lamblin S , Level C , Liaras E , Lifante J-C , Lipsitz S R , Majchrzak C , Malavaud B , Serres T Mariaux , Martin X , Martinet C , Maupetit B , Michel P , Movondo A , Naamani B , Nacry R , Occelli P , Olousouzian S , Papin P , Paquet J-C , Parfaite A , Pattou F , Paugam C , Pavy E , Peix J-L , Petit H , Pierre S , Piriou V , Poupon Bourdy S , Pradere B , Quesne M , Radola Y , Raould A , Rongieras F , Rouquette I , Sanders V , Sanz F , Sens F , Surmont S , Sicre C , Tabur D , Targosz P , Thery D , Toppan N , Usandizaga G , Vacca C , Verheyde I , Zadegan F 
Published: September 2016

Background

The application of safety principles from the aviation industry to the operating room has offered hope in reducing surgical complications. This study aimed to assess the impact on major surgical complications of adding an aviation-based team training programme after checklist implementation.

Methods

A prospective parallel-group cluster trial was undertaken between September 2011 and March 2013. Operating room teams from 31 hospitals were assigned randomly to participate in a team training programme focused on major concepts of crew resource management and checklist utilization. The primary outcome measure was the occurrence of any major adverse event, including death, during the hospital stay within the first 30 days after surgery. Using a difference-in-difference approach, the ratio of the odds ratios (ROR) was estimated to compare changes in surgical outcomes between intervention and control hospitals.

Results

Some 22 779 patients were enrolled, including 5934 before and 16 845 after team training implementation. The risk of major adverse events fell from 8·8 to 5·5 per cent in 16 intervention hospitals (adjusted odds ratio 0·57, 95 per cent c.i. 0·48 to 0·68; P &lt; 0·001) and from 7·9 to 5·4 per cent in 15 control hospitals (odds ratio 0·64, 0·50 to 0·81; P &lt; 0·001), resulting in the absence of difference between arms (ROR 0·90, 95 per cent c.i. 0·67 to 1·21; P = 0·474). Outcome trends revealed significant improvements among ten institutions, equally distributed across intervention and control hospitals.

Conclusion

Surgical outcomes improved substantially, with no difference between trial arms. Successful implementation of an aviation-based team training programme appears to require modification and adaptation of its principles in the context of the the surgical milieu. Registration number: NCT01384474 (http://www.clinicaltrials.gov).