Sand Deposition Inside a Horizontal Well-A Simulation Approach
Authors: Doan Q.T. , Doan L.T. , Ali S.M. Farouq , Oguztoreli M. 
Published: March 2010

Horizontal wells have been shown to be successful in improving oil recovery for marginal heavy oil reservoirs in Saskatchewan and Alberta. One commonly encountered problem in recovery operations for these poorly consolidated reservoirs is the production of sand and fines into the horizontal wellbore, where they settle and accumulate. This paper reports the numerical modeling of gravitational deposition of sand in a horizontal well in such heavy oil reservoirs.

The numerical model described in this work examines the transport process mechanistically, based on the conservation equations for the fluid phase (heavy oil) and the solid phase (sand particles). The interaction between these phases is described by empirical correlations. The equations are solved numerically to determine the concentration of sand particles and oil, and their respective pressure and velocity distributions inside the horizontal well.

According to the simulation results, oil viscosity and particle size play important roles in the transport process, including controlling the gravitational settling tendency of solid particles inside the horizontal wellbore. The results provide insight into the roles different mechanisms affect the transport of sand particles; as such, they provide guidelines for production operations involving horizontal wells in poorly consolidated and unconsolidated reservoirs.

Introduction

The use of horizontal wells, in Saskatchewan and Alberta heavy oil reservoirs underlain with bottom-water, has been found to improve primary recovery performance prior to water coning-recovering up to 15%, in some cases, of the initial oil in place, compared with only 5% for a vertical well(1). Horizontal wells have also been successfully used for increasing steamflood recovery(2,3). Due to the unconsolidated or poorly consolidated nature of these reservoirs, solid (sand and fines) production is quite prevalent. The produced solids lead to several production problems, including sand filling up the wellbore, preventing the operation of downhole pumps and surface equipment, etc.(4) In horizontal well cases, sand production potentially poses a serious problem, as the sand could settle and accumulate inside the horizontal wellbore. This settlement and accumulation of sand particles could give rise to reduced cross-sectional areas of the wellbore open to flow. The study reported in this paper examines, using numerical simulation, the gravitational deposition of sand particles inside a horizontal wellbore.

A brief survey of the relevant literature is given in the following. Solid-liquid multiphase flows are usually very complex, due to the large number of variables involved in the transport processes, and typically poorly understood interaction between the variables. There have been many experimental investigations of these (and other) flow processes, particularly focused on the deposition of the solid particles. Many of the earliest investigations of solid liquid flows focused on the settling tendency of solid particles. Richardson and Zaki(5) experimentally determined that the falling velocity of a suspension relative to a horizontal plane was equal to the upward velocity of the fluid required to maintain a suspension at the same concentration. For different flow regimes (i.e., Reynolds numbers), separate correlations were developed (from experimental data) for the exponent which corresponds to the slope of log-log plot straight lines between suspension falling velocities and suspension porosities.