Comparative breed studies of beef cattle. I. Changes in body weight
Authors: Tulloh NM 
Published: November 2004

A comparative growth study was made of Hereford, Aberdeen Angus, and beef Shorthorn cattle reared and kept together throughout their lives on irrigated perennial pastures at the Metropolitan Farm, Werribee, Vic. Records of body weight as a function of age were obtained on 404 Hereford, 172 Aberdeen Angus, and 127 Shorthorn cattle, representing cattle born in 1955, 1957, 1958, 1959, and 1960. At birth, male calves were significantly heavier than females, and Hereford calves were significantly heavier than Shorthorn and Aberdeen Angus calves, the birth weights of Shorthorn and Aberdeen Angus calves being similar. Up to the age of 5 years, the younger and lighter 2-year-old cows produced lighter calves than cows which were both older and heavier. At weaning age (9.5 months) steers were significantly heavier than heifers. Herefords were significantly heavier than Aberdeen Angus in two years out of three; and in one year out of three, Herefords were significantly heavier than Shorthorns. Shorthorns were significantly heavier than Aberdeen Angus in one year out of three. When the steers were finally weighed off grass at the mean age of either 20 months (1958, 1959, and 1960 cattle) or 25 months (1957 cattle), Herefords were significantly heavier than Aberdeen Angus in four successive years, and in one year out of four the Herefords were significantly heavier than Shorthorns. In three years out of four, Shorthorns were significantly heavier than Aberdeen Angus. Breed differences between the mean weights of breeding cows were not significant and, up to the age of 5 years, as breeding cows grew older they became heavier. Body weight growth curves indicated that the cattle experienced a severe check in growth during the winter months (June, July, August). At other times of the year, growth rates were satisfactory. Cattle born in some years grew better than cattle born in others. This was thought to be due partly to differences between years in the quality and quantity of pasture available, even though the pastures were irrigated. Average absolute and average relative growth rates were calculated for the 1957 and 1958 steers before and after weaning. Breed differences in absolute growth rates before weaning were not statistically significant, but after weaning, rates were significantly the highest for Herefords in both years. The breed differences in average relative growth rates were in the same direction as those for absolute growth rates. However, the pre-weaning relative growth rate of Shorthorns was significantly higher than those of the other breeds among the 1957 steers. When due allowance was made for the smaller size of Aberdeen Angus steers at birth and at weaning, the relative growth rates of this breed were less than those of the other breeds. Absolute and relative growth rates were higher for all breeds before weaning than afterwards. This was mainly a reflexion of low post-weaning growth rates during the winter months. Rank correlation coefficients between birth weight and weight at subsequent ages were low and variable in different breeds and in different seasons. However, coefficients calculated between subsequent ages, beginning at weaning age, were generally highly significant. The breed and sex differences presented in this paper have been compared with the limited data from the literature and, in general, the results are similar.