A comparative study of the construction of road formation layers using labour-intensive versus traditional mechanistic methods on road 1264 in KZN
Authors:   , Mkhize Mongezi S. 
Published: September 2022

The urgent need to upgrade and construct roads in South Africa is one of the many critical utility provision challenges faced by the municipalities, consultants and departments involved in road construction. The biggest challenge that is faced by the government is to minimise unemployment and increase skills transfer through the training of inexperienced local communities on road construction. The road can be constructed using traditional mechanistic methods (TMM), commonly known as plant machines, which makes more use of plant machine than labour. On the other hand, the road can also be constructed using the labour-intensive construction (LIC) method which utilises more labour involvement during construction and minimal machine usage. The purpose of this research is to provide insight into the time and cost comparison between LIC and TMM of constructing road formation layers. Road D1264 in Bergville, KwaZulu-Natal will be used as a case study in the research to compare the difference between labour-intensive and traditional mechanistic construction of road formation layers, using cost and time to reach the same quality. This research aims to promote the use of LIC roadbed construction to be used more frequently in the road construction industry in South Africa. The Expanded Public Works Programme (EPWP) encourages road construction to be undertaken using labour- intensive methods to allow unemployed people to be given more job opportunities. Municipalities, consultants and departments involved with road construction will be assisted through this research in making informed decisions and selections thereafter of the most reliable road formation construction method in terms of time and cost. Available cost, time and quality data from the Road D1264 will be used to compare the construction of road formation layers using LIC versus TMM in KZN. The decision making process will lie in the hands of the municipalities and consultants based on the cost and time required to complete the project. Furthermore, a quantitative survey questionnaire was developed by the researcher. This questionnaire was aimed at the road construction technical experts in the Department of Transport, Department of Works, consultants and the roads departments of districts and local municipalities. The results of the survey questionnaires revealed that the road construction experts agree with the finding of this study that LIC is more expensive when compared to TMM. LIC is also more time-consuming than TMM. LIC and TMM produce the same quality. The survey questionnaire revealed that South Africa may be advancing over the years in the use of LIC methods; however, more education in the form of training, seminars and other methds of marketing must be undertaken, starting at the universities, municipal level, the Department of Transport, Department of Works, and consultants. The comparative research in this study using the available data from Road D1264 revealed that during the construction of the road formation layers, using LIC is more expensive when compared to TMM. LIC is also more time-consuming than TMM. LIC and TMM produce the same quality. But it cannot be ignored that LIC creates employment particularly for women, youth and the disabled within the community. LIC maximises the use of local materials and plant owners as suppliers of goods and services. LIC can be the country’s solution to unemployment and porvety.