Cost and cost-effectiveness analysis of near point-of-care GeneXpert testing for STIs in South Africa: leveraging current capacity to address high prevalence ofChlamydia trachomatis,Neisseria gonorrhoeaeandTrichomonas vaginalis
Authors: Lekodeba Nkgomeleng , Snyman Katherine , Nichols Brooke E , Jamieson Lise 
Published: December 2024

Background

Globally, four curable sexually transmitted infections (STIs) are responsible for over 1-million new infections daily with potential severe complications, predominantly in low- and middle-income countries. South Africa, with high prevalence rates faces significant challenges and the current syndromic management has limitations such as untreated asymptomatic infections and antibiotic misuse. However, diagnostic tools like GeneXpert for STIs may offer potential improvements. We evaluated costs and cost-effectiveness of reallocating GeneXpert capacity for STI testing in South Africa.

Methods

We developed a Microsoft Excel-based static decision analytical model using previously collected data. Over a one-year time horizon, the model compared the costs and outcomes of syndromic management (base case) with nine scenarios using near point-of-care GeneXpert testing forNeisseria gonorrhoeae(NG),Chlamydia trachomatis(CT), andTrichomonas vaginalis(TV) in various target groups, including symptomatic individuals, antenatal care (ANC) attendees, and HIV testers. Outcomes included number of cases treated, cases correctly treated, and reductions in excess antibiotic use and cost-effectiveness analysis as expressed in incremental cost-effectiveness ratios (ICERs) per additional case correctly treated. Univariate deterministic sensitivity analysis assessed parameter uncertainty, and costs were reported in 2024 USD.

Results

Total costs, cost per person treated and cost per person correctly treated were lowest in the base case scenario and higher in the near-POC GeneXpert testing scenarios. In the base case, the cost per person treated and correctly treated was $21 and $29 and between $113 and $728 across all GeneXpert testing scenarios. Implementing GeneXpert syndromic testing would cost the healthcare system up to $207 million (+752%), while opportunistic GeneXpert testing scenarios raised costs up to $1.7 billion (+6921%) and targeted or combined GeneXpert testing scenarios cost the healthcare system up to $941 million (+3759%). Of nine scenarios analysed, three were on the cost-effectiveness frontier, resulting in increased total health system costs but higher numbers of cases correctly treated. The ICER (cost per case correctly treated) ranged $429 from $914, with costs increasing up to $1.7 billion (+7094%) and correct diagnoses improving by up to 265%. Sensitivity analysis identified staff cost as the most influential input cost parameter for cost per case correctly treated under the base case scenario.

Conclusions

Our study highlights the potential of reallocating excess GeneXpert capacity for STI testing to enhance diagnostic accuracy and improve health outcomes in South Africa. Prioritizing symptomatic individuals and high-risk groups, such as antenatal care attendees, can reduce unnecessary antibiotic use, addressing antimicrobial resistance challenges. These findings support the need for targeted and context-specific strategies to optimize the clinical and economic benefits of GeneXpert deployment for STI management.