Management of Labral Tears in the Hip: A Consensus Statement
Authors: Matache Bogdan A. , Belzile Étienne L. , Ayeni Olufemi R. , Garie Luc De , Degen Ryan M. , Goudie Richard , Heroux Martin , Klett Marie-Josee , Persson Erika , Wong Ivan ,   The AAC-CASEM Consensus Group, Al-Rawi Firas , Baylis Penny-Jane , Beaule Paul E. , Blanchet Richard , Buchko Jordan , Collin Pierre , Crookham Jason , Homayoon Bobby , Hurley Eoghan T. , Johnston Kelly , Khan Moin , Lambert Diane , Leblanc Claire , Lemmex Devin , Ling Patrick , Lodhia Parth , Longland Billy , Kyle Martin R. , McConkey Mark , McCormack Bob , Moroz Mickey , Nault Marie-Lyne , Outerbridge Ross , Peltz Julie , Pozgay Anita , Reid David , Shallow Scott , Shields Ryan , Tucker Allison , Urquhart Nathan , Woodmass Jarret 
Published: January 2025

Background:

Inconsistencies in the workup of labral tears in the hip have been shown to result in a delay in treatment and an increased cost to the medical system.

Purpose:

To establish consensus statements among Canadian nonoperative/operative sports medicine physicians via a modified Delphi process on the diagnosis, nonoperative and operative management, and rehabilitation and return to play (RTP) of those with labral tears in the hip.

Study Design:

A consensus statement.

Methods:

A total of 40 sports medicine physicians (50% orthopaedic surgeons) were selected for participation based on their level of expertise in the field. Experts were assigned to 1 of 4 balanced working groups defined by specific subtopics of interest. Consensus, strong consensus, and unanimous consensus were defined as achieving 80% to 89%, 90% to 99%, and 100% agreement with a proposed statement, respectively.

Results:

There was a unanimous consensus that several prognostic factors—including age, pain severity, dysplasia, and degenerative changes—should be taken into consideration with regard to the likelihood of surgical success. There was strong agreement that the cluster of symptoms of anterior groin pain, pain in hyperflexion, and sharp catching pain with rotation make a diagnosis of a labral tear more likely, that radiographs—including a minimum of a standing anteroposterior pelvis and 45° Dunn view—should be obtained in all patients presenting with a suspected labral tear, that a diagnostic injection should be performed if there is uncertainty that the pain is intra-articular in origin, and that a minimum of 6 months should elapse after surgical treatment before reinvestigation for persistent symptoms.

Conclusion:

Overall, 76% of statements reached a unanimous/strong consensus, thus indicating a high level of agreement between nonoperative sports medicine physicians and orthopaedic surgeons on the management of labral tears in the hip. The statements that achieved unanimous consensus included the timing of RTP after surgery, prognostic factors affecting surgical success, and the timing to begin sport-specific training after nonoperative management. There was no consensus on the use of orthobiologics for nonoperative management, indications for bilateral surgery, whether the postoperative range of motion and weightbearing restrictions should be employed, and whether postoperative hip brace usage is required.