Antigenic characterization and pandemic risk assessment of North American H1 influenza A viruses circulating in swine
Authors: Venkatesh Divya , Anderson Tavis K. , Kimble J. Brian , Chang Jennifer , Lopes Sara , Souza Carine K. , Pekosz Andrew , Shaw-Saliba Kathryn , Rothman Richard E. , Chen Kuan-Fu , Lewis Nicola S. , Baker Amy L. Vincent 
Published: May 2022

The first pandemic of the 21st century was caused by an H1N1 influenza A virus (IAV) introduced from pigs into humans, highlighting the importance of swine as reservoirs for pandemic viruses. Two major lineages of swine H1 circulate in North America: the 1A classical swine lineage (including the 2009 pandemic H1N1) and 1B human seasonal-like lineage. Here, we investigated the evolution of these H1 IAV lineages in North American swine and their potential pandemic risk. We assessed the antigenic distance between the HA of representative swine H1 and human seasonal vaccine strains (1978-2015) in hemagglutination inhibition (HI) assays using a panel of monovalent anti-sera raised in pigs. Antigenic cross-reactivity varied by strain but was associated with genetic distance. Generally, swine 1A lineage viruses that seeded the 2009 H1 pandemic were antigenically most similar to H1 pandemic vaccine strains, with the exception of viruses in the genetic clade 1A.1.1.3 that had a two-amino acid deletion mutation near the receptor-binding site, dramatically reducing antibody recognition. The swine 1B lineage strains, which arose from previously circulating (pre-2009 pandemic) human seasonal viruses, were more antigenically similar to pre-2009 human seasonal H1 vaccine viruses than post-2009 strains. Human population immunity was measured by cross-reactivity in HI assays to representative swine H1 strains. There was a broad range of titers against each swine strain that was not associated with age, sex, or location. However, there was almost no cross-reactivity in human sera to the 1A.1.1.3 and 1B.2.1 genetic clades of swine viruses, and the 1A.1.1.3 and 1B.2.1 clades were also the most antigenically distant from all human vaccine strains. Our data demonstrate that antigenic distances of representative swine strains from human vaccine strains represent a rational assessment of swine IAV for zoonotic risk research and pandemic preparedness prioritization.

Importance

Human H1 influenza A viruses (IAV) spread to pigs in North America, resulting in sustained circulation of two major groups of H1 viruses in swine. We quantified the genetic diversity of H1 in swine and measured antigenic phenotypes. We demonstrated that swine H1 lineages were significantly different from human vaccine strains and this antigenic dissimilarity increased over time as the viruses evolved in swine. Pandemic preparedness vaccine strains for human vaccines also demonstrated a loss in similarity with contemporary swine strains. Human sera revealed a range of responses to swine IAV, including two groups of viruses with little to no immunity. Surveillance and risk assessment of IAV diversity in pig populations are essential to detect strains with reduced immunity in humans, providing critical information for pandemic preparedness.