EXPERIMENTS ON THE CONTROL OF WART DISEASE OF POTATOES BY SOIL TREATMENT WITH PARTICULAR REFERENCE TO THE USE OF SULPHUR
Authors: ROACH W. A. , GLYNNE MARY D. , BRIERLEY WM. B. , CROWTHER E. M. 
Published: February 2008

As susceptible varieties of potato are still widely cultivated and sporadic outbreaks of Wart Disease are a serious menace, it is imperative to find a method whereby the winter sporangia of Synchytrium endobioticum in contaminated soil may be killed. Previous studies and the unusual difficulties presented by the problem are discussed. Results of experiments extending over four years are recorded.

During 1920–2 pot experiments were carried out to test various chemicals alone and in conjunction with steam. Steaming the soil proved effective. but offered little hope of being economically possible as a field treatment. The amount of disease was reduced by sulphur. calcium and potassium polysulphides. formaldehyde, dichlorcrrsol. chlordinitro‐benzene and nitrobenzene. Satisfactory infection was not obtained in pot experiments; this method was therefore abandoned in favour of field experiments.

The incorporation of chemicals with the soil in the field was carried out with the Simar Rotary Tiller, great care being taken to ensure very thorough and even distribution. Results suggest that the efficiency of the treatment depends on this thoroughness of incorporation. During 1922 a selection of the chemicals tried in 1921 and others were tested. From these sulphur was selected in 1923 for more extensive study as being the most hopeful, because of its efficiency and cheapness.

In 1924, a year of very heavy disease, it was proved at Ormskirk that when the dose of ground sulphur was increased through 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 10 cwts. per acre the degree of infection was reduced in direct ratio from 73 per cent., the value for untreated soil, to 8 per cent. for an application of 10 cwts. per acre. Doses greater than the latter did not completely eradicate the disease; but there are reasons for thinking that the small amount of disease in certain of the plots was due to recontamination of those plots later in the season. When the results are represented in graphical form the straight line of nearest fit to the experimental values cuts the horizontal axis at a point representing 11.2 cwts. per acre of sulphur; and, in the absence of recontamination, this quantity of sulphur should be slightly more than the minimum necessary to free the Ormskirli soil of disease.

On the heavy clay soil at Hatfield it was found necessary to use much heavier applications of sulphur (about 40 cwts. per acre) to ensure absolutely clean plots.

Gasworks spent oxides, tried as an alternative source of sulphur, proved rather less effective than ground sulphur when equal quantities of sulphur were applied in each case. The result was probably due to the unsatisfactory state of division of our sample of spent oxides.

Sulphur inoculated with Thiobacillus thiooxydans showed no increased efficiency over uninoculated sulphur on Ormskirk soils and appeared less effective than the latter on the Hatfield clay.

The elimination of Wart Disease in the field by sulphur and sulphur compounds is not a simple function of the final soil reaction and it would appear that some sulphur product other than sulphuric acid is the active fungicidal agent.

The sulphur treatment will be put to a large scale critical test in 1925–6; but the results to date seem to show that a feasible method of eradication of Wart Disease from contaminated land has been found.

We wish to express our gratitude to the Piccard Pictet Company for the loan of a 4 h.p. Simar Rotary Tiller and for their assistance on sundry occasions in the working of the machine: to Messrs Chance and Hunt of Birmingham for the donation of much of the sulphur used in our work; to Messrs Carbolimo for a donation of ground limestone; to the National Institute of Agricultural Botany, Cambridge for the use of land at Ormskirk; to His Grace the Marquis of Salisbury for the use of land at Hatfield. Finally we would thank Mr H. B. Bryan and his assistant Miss Whitehead of the Potato Testing Station at Ormskirk; without their expert knowledge, which was freely placed at our disposal, and without their friendly forethought and generous help on innumerable occasions during 1920–4 it would have been impossible for us to carry on our work.