A mixed-methods model for healthcare system responsiveness to public health: insights from Iranian experts
Authors: Khanpoor Hooman , Alizadeh Ahad , Khosravizadeh Omid , Amerzadeh Mohammad , Rafiei Sima 
Published: February 2025

Background

Responsiveness is a critical dimension of public health, focussing on how health systems address the needs, preferences and expectations of the population. It plays a central role in improving and maintaining the population’s health by ensuring timely, equitable and patient-centred healthcare services.

Objective

In this study, we developed a mixed-methods model to assess healthcare system responsiveness from a public health perspective, integrating the insights of Iranian experts. The model identifies key factors such as intersectoral collaboration, health equity and community partnerships, which are essential for enhancing system responsiveness and ultimately improving health outcomes.

Method

In this study, conducted in 2024, we developed a mixed-methods model for assessing healthcare system responsiveness from a public health perspective, integrating the insights of Iranian experts. R software version 3.2.4 and the lavaan package were used for statistical analysis, considering the significance level of 0.05.

Results

On the basis of the literature review, the main components of health systems’ responsiveness in the public health domain were extracted. The qualitative content analysis induced three different themes that affect health, which included payment mechanism (two subcategories of budget and incentive system), social determinants of health (three subcategories of intersectoral collaboration, community partnership and equity in health) and quality (three subcategories of timely provision of healthcare services, need-based service delivery and continuity of care). Finally, using structural equation modelling (SEM), a system of variables with causal relationships was developed. We found a statistically significant direct effect on intersectoral collaboration, health equity, payment mechanisms, timely delivery of services and need-based service provision. The strongest association was found for the payment system (β = 1.023, P ≤ 0.05). Model fit indices showed adequate fit.

Conclusions

Our developed model underscores the need for a comprehensive approach to healthcare system responsiveness, particularly focussing on public health services as foundational strategies for achieving universal health coverage. The results of our study revealed that a well-structured payment system and incentive mechanisms are critical for motivating healthcare professionals to deliver high-quality, timely and need-based services, ensuring sustainability in care provision. Beyond financial incentives, our model highlights the importance of health equity, intersectoral collaboration and community partnerships, which were identified as key drivers of responsiveness in healthcare systems. The findings indicate that fostering these elements not only strengthens healthcare delivery, but also supports the adaptation of services to meet diverse population needs effectively. In addition, the study emphasizes the innovative role of intersectoral collaboration in enhancing primary healthcare, which requires commitment across healthcare and non-health sectors. Our model introduces the concept of integrating community participation and resource allocation strategies into the healthcare system, thereby enhancing responsiveness. These strategies are anticipated to improve key health outcomes, such as life expectancy and maternal and child health indicators, by establishing robust healthcare networks that are more attuned to the health needs of the population.