CD38 Compared with ZAP-70 or Immmunoglobulin Mutation Status as Predictor of Disease Progression in Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia.
Authors: Rassenti Laura Z. , Neuberg Donna S. , Keating Michael J. , Gribben John G. , Flinn Ian W. , Rai Kanti R. , Byrd John C. , Kay Neil E. , Kipps Thomas J. 
Published: April 2020

We performed immunophenotypic and IgVH mutation analyses on the chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) cells of 307 patients for expression of CD38, ZAP-70, and IgVH mutation status to determine the relative strength of each in predicting the need for early treatment. For this we assessed the time from diagnosis to initial therapy for progressive and/or symptomatic disease. Patients confirmed to have remained untreated were censored for this endpoint. Expression of CD38 was defined as the proportion of CD38-stained CLL cells that had fluorescence intensity above a defined threshold. Similarly, cases were defined as ZAP-70+ when 20% or more of the ZAP-70-stained CLL cells had fluorescence intensity above a defined threshold, as described (NEJM351:893, 2004). CLL cells were classified as expressing mutated IgVH genes if they expressed IgVH with &lt;98% homology with a known germline IgVH gene. The median percentage of cells expressing CD38 in our cohort was 11.5% (range 0.1% to 99.5%). In patients with multiple samples, the CD38 expression level appeared constant over time, with a median S.D. of 0.8%. We defined patient samples that had CD38 expression levels at or below the median as having low expression. There was a significant association between low expression of CD38 and lack of ZAP-70 or expression of a mutated IgVH (p &lt; 0.0001 for each assessment by the Fisher exact test). Median level of CD38 among cases expressing mutated IgVH was 4.0%, compared to 27.4% among cases expressing unmutated IgVH (p &lt; 0.0001 by the Wilcoxon rank sum test). Median level of CD38 among ZAP-70 negative cases was 5.3%, compared to 27.2% among ZAP-70+ cases (p &lt; 0.0001 by the Wilcoxon rank sum test). Patients with low-level expression of CD38 had a median time to initiation of therapy of 8.2 years; whereas, patients with high-level expression of CD38 had a median time to initiation of therapy of 4.0 years (p&lt;0.0001). Although high-level expression of CD38 was associated with a shorter time from diagnosis to initiation of therapy (p &lt; 0.0001 in a Cox proportional hazards regression), the inclusion of IgVH mutation status (p &lt; 0.0001) or expression of ZAP-70 (p &lt; 0.0001) in these models reduced the contribution of CD38 status to a p-value of 0.051 (ZAP-70 model) or 0.052 (mutation status model). Although ZAP-70 expression and mutation status each contributed significantly to the hazard of initiating therapy in a Cox proportional hazards model, high-level expression of CD38 did not add significantly to the model that already addresses ZAP-70 and mutational status, p=0.425. As such, although knowledge of the CD38 expression level can be used as a predictor of the time from diagnosis to the initiation of therapy it provides only marginal value if either the IgVH mutational status or expression of ZAP-70 is known and no value if knowledge of both ZAP-70 expression and IgVH mutational status is available.