A novel radiological classification of midbrain pilocytic astrocytomas and its implication for surgical management: a single-institution experience of 57 cases
Authors: Pan Changcun , Li Tian , Zhang Mingxin , Wang Yujin , Xiao Xiong , Zhang Peng , Zuo Pengcheng , Wang Yi , Xiao Dan , Wu Zhen , Zhang Junting , Zhang Liwei 
Published: December 2023

OBJECTIVE

Surgery for midbrain pilocytic astrocytoma (PA) remains a formidable challenge. To facilitate decision-making and achieve a better outcome in the management of patients with midbrain PA, the authors have proposed a novel radiological classification of midbrain PAs with long-term follow-up.

METHODS

Fifty-seven midbrain PA patients who underwent surgery at Beijing Tiantan Hospital, Capital Medical University, from January 2008 to June 2021, were reviewed. Based on tumor location and the topological anatomical change identified on MRI, midbrain PAs were categorized into four types: crural (12/57, 21.1%), tegmental (25/57, 43.9%), aqueductal (5/57, 8.8%), and tectal (15/57, 26.3%) PAs. The relevant clinical, radiological, and pathological data; surgical procedures and results; and long-term outcomes were collected and analyzed.

RESULTS

The 1-, 3-, and 5-year survival rates reached 98%, 96%, and 96%, respectively, with gross-total resection achieved in 66.7% of cases, followed by near-total resection in 17.5% cases. The clinical and radiological features, selection of surgical approaches, and long-term postoperative deficits were distinct among each type. Crural PAs were associated with younger age (median 9 years, IQR 5.0–12.8 years); the largest tumor volume (median 31.9 cm3, IQR 17.2–42.6 cm3); the lowest preoperative Karnofsky Performance Scale (KPS) score (median 65, IQR 50–70); the most frequent preoperative motor deficit (91.7%); a mixed solid-cystic component (75%); occupation of the crural cistern; elevation and rotation of the thalamus (medial and/or lateral); displacement of the anterior third ventricle, uncus, and anterior commissure; the most diverse surgical approaches; more frequent use of multimodality image–guided surgery (58.3%); and the most remarkable improvement in KPS score at long-term follow-up. Tegmental PAs were associated with adolescents and young adults (median age 21 years, IQR 8–33 years); tumor volume (median 13.9 cm3, IQR 9.5–20.5 cm3); a good preoperative KPS score (median 80, IQR 70–80); a mixed solid-cystic component (72%); occupation of the ambient cistern and cerebellomesencephalic fissure; a close relationship with the dorsal pons, superior cerebellar peduncle, and posterior inferior third ventricle; and a higher probability of permanent postoperative sensory deficits (40%). Aqueductal and tectal PAs were associated with small tumor volume (median 9.14 cm3, IQR 5.1–17.4 cm3 and median 11.84 cm3, IQR 5.7–18.3 cm3, respectively), a higher percentage of hydrocephalus (80% and 86.7%, respectively), and a straightforward selection of limited surgical approaches.

CONCLUSIONS

A novel and comprehensive radiological classification of midbrain PAs was established, which will serve as a valuable tool in patient management and promote uniform communication and comparison across different studies and publications.