The Effects of Endurance Training on Lipedema
Condition: Lipedema
MeSH terms: Lipedema
Study type: Interventional

Summary: 
      Lipedema is a fat disorder causing accumulation of subcutaneous adipose tissue particularly
      in arms and legs, and predominantly affects women. Lipedema likely contributes to an array of
      other pathologies, including obesity, inflammatory bowel disease, and neurological disorders.
      Lipedema tissue is often very painful and can severely impair mobility. The condition can
      also increase the incidence of depression, anxiety, or eating disorders.

      There seems to be a general impression that lipedema tissue is difficult to reduce by diet,
      exercise, or bariatric surgery. However, only a few studies have actually explored the
      effects of exercise training on lipedema. Despite the lack of knowledge, the existing
      guidelines for lipidemia treatment promote a healthy lifestyle with individually adjusted
      weight control measures, including physical activity. In general, exercise is known to have
      an important effect on adipose tissue. Excess adipose tissue causes macrophage infiltration
      into the adipose tissue leading to continuous low systemic inflammation. This would suggest
      that there is a systemic inflammatory response in lipedema patients. Increasing IL-6 levels
      with exercise can decrease the level of proinflammatory TNFalpha synthesized from adipocytes
      and therefore lead to an anti-inflammatory effect by increasing IL-10 and IL-1ra levels. IL-6
      also stimulates fat oxidation by increasing lipolysis. For these reasons, adding an
      appropriate exercise program to standard treatment might provide additional benefits for
      lipedema patients. The investigators aim to determine the therapeutic potential of
      high-intensity interval training (HIIT) on pain, quality of life, body composition,
      cardiorespiratory fitness and circulating biomarkers in women with lipedema.
    

Detailed description: 
      Methods

      Subjects 30 women diagnosed with lipedema age 18-65 will be randomized to (1:1) to 8 weeks of
      exercise training og a control group. Exclusion criteria includes ongoing eating disorders
      and/or orthopedic limitations for exercise training. A compliance with the training program
      of 80% will also be set as a criterion for completing the study. Participants will be
      recruited via social media, via physiotherapists, via posters at GPs and via a user
      representative from the Norwegian Lymphedema and Lipedema Association (NLLF). The master's
      students will obtain informed consent cf. GCP and the Health Research Act. The potential
      participants will have at least one week to consider their participation. If a research
      participant should be injured on the basis of something the investigators ask them to do,
      NTNU will have the insurance responsibility. The investigators will collect data on the type
      and stage of lipedema, when the participant was diagnosed. The investigators will also
      collect data on which clinical aids they are using and how often, e.g., compressions aids.

      Intervention - Training protocol The women will be randomized (1:1) to 8 weeks of supervised
      high-intensity interval training (HIIT) that is 4×4 min intervals at 85-95% of maximal heart
      rate (HRmax) with 3-minute active breaks (~60 % HRmax) in between intervals, twice a week) on
      treadmills at the NextMove core facility at NTNU or to a control group. All participants will
      be provided with a pulse watch to keep after the study is completed. In addition, the
      participants will perform exercise once a week on their own following the correct exercise
      intensity. Pool training will be recommended based on potential benefits from compression.
      Body composition, blood pressure, VO2max (maximal oxygen uptake), questionnaire data and
      blood samples will be measured/collected before and after the exercise intervention. The
      participants will write a diary for their physical activity using standardized templates from
      the NextMove core facility.

      Maximal oxygen uptake (VO2max) VO2max will be measured during uphill treadmill walking or
      running (Woodway PPS 55 Med, Munich, Germany), using ergospirometry (Jaeger, Oxycon pro,
      Hoechberg, Germany / Meta Max II, Cortex, Leipzig, Germany) as described earlier.11 A warm-up
      period for 10 min (~60% of HRmax) will precede the test. A levelling off of oxygen uptake
      (VO2) despite increased work load and respiratory exchange ratio ≥1.05 will be used as
      criteria for VO2max. HR will be measured continuously during the test (Polar, Polar Electro,
      Kempele, Finland), to define HRmax.

      Anthropometric measurements Body weight, body mass index and waist-to-hip ratio will be
      measured. Body composition will be measured using InBody. For measurement of body
      composition, the investigators will use an instrument called Inbody 720 (Body Analysis AS).
      Inbody 720 provides weight, muscle mass, fat percentage, metabolism and mineral status
      non-invasively by sending weak electrical signals through the body. The whole test lasts just
      a few minutes. Before the analysis the participants should be fasten at least two hours and
      should avoid strenuous exercise. The standard procedures at NextMove will be used to measure
      the weight and height of participants. The height will be measured without shoes or head
      wear, this must be done with equal weight on both legs. The distance between the legs shall
      be a foot. The heels should be in the ground at full stretch their legs. The height is
      measured with one decimal. The weight is measured without heavy clothes and shoes, while the
      participants are standing still. It will be drawn 0.5 kg for the remaining clothes. The
      weight is measured with one decimal. The participants must stand upright for measuring of
      waist and hip circumference and a regular exhaust measuring the circumference one cm over the
      navel. The waist circumference is measured with no decimals.

      Blood pressure Blood pressure will be measured while the patient is sitting down and have
      been resting for at least five minutes in a quiet room. It will be measured by a trained
      person, with a handheld sphygmomanometer (Tycos, 5098-02CB, USA). Blood pressure will be
      measured at the same time of the day for each individual at pre- and post test. The first
      reading will be discarded and the mean of the next three consecutive readings with a
      coefficient of variation below 15% will be used in the study, with additional readings if
      required. The sleeve should be placed at heart level and customized with the size of the
      participants arm.

      Pain and fatigue registration Visual analog scale (VAS), measured by means of a 0-100 mm, for
      pain will be used to collect data on pain. VAS has been used in the social and behavioral
      sciences to measure a variety of subjective phenomena. A VAS is a straight line, whose end
      anchors indicate the extreme boundaries of the sensation, feeling, or responses to be
      measured. For example a VAS to measure pain can be labeled "no pain" on one end and "pain as
      bad as it could possibly be" on the other end. Subjects respond to the VAS by placing a mark
      through the line at a position which best represents their current perception of a given
      phenomenon between the labeled extremes. Although a VAS may be horizontal or vertical and of
      any length deemed appropriate, its most common form is a 100 mm horizontal line. The VAS is
      scored by measuring the distance, usually in millimeters, from one end of the scale to the
      subject's mark on the line. In the present study, a score from 1-100 was used for measuring
      self reported total pain and fatigue. LYMQOL (Lymphoedema Quality of Life) BEN and Brief Pain
      Inventory will be applied.

      Quality of life questionnaires Short Form Health Survey-36 (SF-36) will be used to track
      potential changes in quality of life. The SF-36 consists of eight scaled scores, which are
      the weighted sums of the questions in their section. Each scale is directly transformed into
      a 0-100 scale on the assumption that each question carries equal weight. The eight sections
      are; vitality, physical functioning, bodily pain, general health perceptions, physical role
      functioning, emotional role functioning, social role functioning, and mental health.

      Standard blood analyses Blood collection and blood analyses will be performed using standard
      local procedures for the general biomarkers in clinical use and will be performed in all
      participants at the pre- and post-test. Three 3ml EDTA-tubes and one 3ml Li-heparin-tube will
      be collected and sent to clinical-chemical analyses at St.Olav's hospital. Parameters to be
      analyzed includes e.g. glucose, HbA1C, triglycerides, HDL-cholesterol, total cholesterol,
      serum ferritin and hs-CRP. An additional two tubes of blood (serum and EDTA) will be
      collected for later explorative biomarker assays. These blood samples will be centrifuged and
      aliquoted before freezing and storing in the LipidEx-biobank. A test from the standard
      laboratory that is without normal range may indicate a need for following up by a doctor,
      will be reported back to the participant as soon as possible, thus they will be asked to
      contact their general practitioner. The participants must fast at least three-hours before
      blood sampling. The time of last meal time for participants will be recorded on the patient
      form.

      ELISA for lipedema biomarkers The ELISA technique can detect an amount of a given protein,
      antibody, or antigen in a sample. Explorative biomarkers outside clinical use will be assayd
      by ELISA methods established at the local laboratories at the Department of Circulation and
      Medical imaging. Potential biomarkers include TNFalpha, interleukines as well as PF4/CXCL4.

      NMR Lipidomics/metabolomics/inflammatomics To explore the beneficial effects of HIIT on blood
      profile in these individuals, NMR (nuclear magnetic resonance) technology will be applied to
      determine if changes occur on the 1) lipoprotein subfractions that cannot be detected by
      measuring standard lipids, 2) changes occur in the metabolome and 3) changes occur in the
      inflammatory status. Lipidomics is a recently developed research area that apply different
      techniques to perform large-scale analyses of circulating lipids. NMR lipidomics utilizes
      differences in lipoprotein composition, size and density to extract information on
      lipoprotein subclasses. Several studies have demonstrated an association between lipoprotein
      subfractions and future cardiovascular health. This suggest that more refined analyses of
      lipoprotein subfractions may lead to further improvements in monitoring cardiovascular
      health. Lipidomics technology has developed rapidly over the past decade, to the point where
      clinical application now is possible.

      Statistical power This is a pilot study, as there is very limited knowledge on exercise as
      treatment for lipedema. That is, no variables are available for power calculations. The
      investigators have chosen to set the number to 15 in each group to be able to account for up
      to 20% drop-outs. With the limited time available during a Master's project, this is a
      realistic target.

      Data protection Patient information will be stored and handled in conformity with Norwegian
      laws and regulations.
    

Intervention name(s): Exercise training
Intervention type(s): Behavioral
Intervention description(s): 8 weeks of supervised high-intensity interval training (HIIT).
Allocation: Randomized
Intervention model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: None (Open Label)
Primary purpose: Treatment