A Study of MVA85A, in Asymptomatic Volunteers Infected With TB, HIV or Both
Condition: HIV Infections; TB
MeSH terms: HIV Infections
Study type: Interventional
Phase: Phase 1

Summary: 
      This study is designed to evaluate the safety of MVA85A in asymptomatic volunteers in South
      Africa who are infected with M.tb, HIV or both. A single vaccination with MVA85A, when
      administered at a dose of 5 x 107pfu intradermally, is safe and highly immunogenic in
      mycobacterially naïve individuals, BCG vaccinated individuals and M.tb latently infected
      individuals. We will use the same vaccination regime in this study. Participants will be
      defined as being infected with M.tb.if they have a positive Elispot response to ESAT6 or
      CFP10. Participants will be defined as being infected with HIV.if they have a positive HIV
      rapid test (Determine®, Abbott Laboratories) followed by a positive HIV ELISA result.
      Participants will be identified from the general population living in Worcester, Western
      Cape, South Africa
    

Detailed description: 
      Prime-boost immunization strategies Heterologous prime-boost immunization strategies involve
      giving two different vaccines, each encoding the same antigen, several weeks apart. Using a
      DNA prime-recombinant modified vaccinia virus Ankara (MVA) boost induces higher levels of
      antigen specific CD4+ and CD8+ T cells than using homologous boosting with the same vector in
      a number of different disease models (Schneider, 1998; McShane, 2001). Given the protective
      efficacy of BCG in childhood, ideally BCG would be the priming immunization in such a
      prime-boost strategy. In order to do this, we have focused on antigen 85A as a candidate
      antigen. Antigen 85A is highly conserved amongst all mycobacterial species and is present in
      all strains of BCG. Antigen 85A is a major secreted antigen from M. tuberculosis which forms
      part of the antigen 85 complex (A, B and C). This complex constitutes a major portion of the
      secreted proteins of both M.tb and BCG. It is involved in fibronectin binding within the cell
      wall and has mycolyltransferase activity. Antigen 85A is immunodominant in murine and human
      studies and is protective in small animals (Huygen, 1996).

      Recombinant modified vaccinia virus Ankara (rMVA). Many viruses have been investigated as
      potential recombinant vaccines. The successful worldwide eradication of smallpox via
      vaccination with live vaccinia virus highlighted vaccinia as a candidate for recombinant use.
      The recognition in recent years that non- replicating strains of poxvirus such as MVA and
      avipox vectors can be more immunogenic than traditional replicating vaccinia strains has
      enhanced the attractiveness of this approach. MVA (modified vaccinia virus Ankara) is a
      strain of vaccinia virus which has been passaged more than 570 times though avian cells, is
      replication incompetent in human cell lines and has a good safety record. It has been
      administered to more than 120,000 vaccinees as part of the smallpox eradication programme,
      with no adverse effects, despite the deliberate vaccination of high risk groups (Stickl,
      1974; Mahnel, 1994). This safety in man is consistent with the avirulence of MVA in animal
      models. MVA has six major genomic deletions compared to the parental genome severely
      compromising its ability to replicate in mammalian cells (Meher, 1991). No replication has
      been documented in non- transformed mammalian cells. Viral replication is blocked late during
      infection of cells but importantly viral and recombinant protein synthesis is unimpaired even
      during this abortive infection. The viral genome has been proven to be stable through a large
      series of passages in chicken embryo fibroblasts. Replication-deficient recombinant MVA has
      been seen as an exceptionally safe viral vector. When tested in animal model studies
      recombinant MVA's have been shown to be avirulent, yet protectively immunogenic as vaccines
      against viral diseases and cancer. Recent studies in severely immunosuppressed macaques have
      supported the view that MVA should be safe in immunocompromised humans (Akira, 2001;
      Stittelaar, 2001).

      Safety of rMVAs in immunosuppression. There is now considerable preclinical and clinical data
      demonstrating the safety and immunogenicity of MVA as a viral vector in immunosuppression and
      HIV infection. Recombinant MVAs expressing HIV antigens have been administered to
      immunosuppressed macaques with no serious adverse events (Stittelaar et al, 2001). In
      addition, the safety of recombinant MVAs expressing HIV antigens and epitopes have now been
      evaluated in several Phase I clinical trials of HIV-infected subjects, both on and off
      antiretroviral therapy, with no serious adverse events (Cosma et al, 2003; Harrer et al
      2005).

      Preclinical data supporting this BCG prime-MVA85A boost strategy In BALB/c mice, using BCG as
      the priming immunization and then boosting with MVA85A induces higher levels of both antigen
      specific IFN-γ secreting CD4+ and CD8+ T cells and significantly greater levels of protection
      against aerosol challenge than after BCG alone (Goonetilleke et al, 2003). This regime has
      now been further evaluated in the more sensitive guinea pig aerosol challenge model with very
      encouraging results. Guinea pigs vaccinated with BCG and boosted with MVA85A, and then
      further boosted with a second recombinant viral vector expressing antigen 85A, fowlpox-85A
      (FP85A) showed significantly greater protection against challenge than guinea pigs vaccinated
      with BCG alone (Williams et al, 2005). This regime is also immunogenic in rhesus macaques,
      and protective (Verrek, personal communication).

      Clinical data to date with MVA85A UK studies Over the last 3 years HM has established a
      clinical trial programme to evaluate the safety and immunogenicity of this BCG prime-MVA85A
      boost vaccination strategy in a series of Phase I studies. MVA85A was the first candidate TB
      vaccine to enter clinical trials anywhere in the world in September 2002, and is currently
      the only one in clinical trials in Africa. The design of these Phase I studies with MVA85A
      allowed for sequential vaccination of volunteer groups with a step-wise increase in
      mycobacterial exposure, to minimize the possibility of a Koch reaction. Trials were also
      conducted sequentially in the UK and The Gambia, as there is a greater degree of exposure to
      both environmental mycobacteria and M.tb in The Gambia. A Koch reaction describes the
      development of immunopathology in a person or animal with tuberculosis, when an exaggerated
      immune response to M.tb is stimulated. It was described in patients with TB disease when Koch
      performed his original studies employing mycobacteria as a type of therapeutic vaccination.
      It has now been demonstrated in the mouse model of therapeutic vaccination27. Available
      animal data suggest that these reactions do not occur in mice latently infected with M.tb,
      suggesting that such reactions may correlate with high bacterial load and that the Koch
      phenomenon may not pose a problem for vaccination of asymptomatic albeit latently infected
      humans25.

      In the UK, 14 mycobacterially and BCG naïve, asymptomatic volunteers were recruited. and
      vaccinated twice with 5 x 107pfu MVA85A, administered intradermally at 3 week intervals. In
      these studies, MVA85A was found to be safe and well tolerated. All subjects experienced some
      local side-effects (redness, itching etc) which lasted for 3-7 days after vaccination.
      Approximately one third of subjects experienced some transient systemic symptoms (myalgia,
      headache) for the first 12-24 hours after vaccination. All local and systemic side-effects
      spontaneously resolved. There were no serious or severe adverse events in any of these
      studies.

      The main immunological outcome used in these ongoing clinical trials is the ex-vivo
      interferon-gamma (IFN-γ) Elispot assay, which was used to assess specific T cell responses to
      tuberculin PPD, purified antigen 85 complex and pools of overlapping 15mer peptides spanning
      the length of antigen 85A. A single vaccination with MVA85A induced remarkably high levels of
      specific effector T cell responses 1 week after vaccination (mean IFN-γ Elispot response to
      PPD was 460 spots per million PBMC).

      Next, the safety of MVA85A in volunteers previously vaccinated with BCG was demonstrated in
      17 volunteers. The safety profile of MVA85A in these 17 volunteers was the same as in the BCG
      naïve group. These 17 volunteers showed even higher peak levels of antigen specific T cells
      (mean response to PPD was 917 spots per million PBMC) 1 week post-vaccination than those
      immunized with MVA85A alone. Perhaps more importantly for the induction of T cell memory,
      volunteers who were previously BCG vaccinated maintained significantly higher levels of
      antigen specific T cells after MVA85A for up to 24 weeks after vaccination, when compared to
      those volunteers vaccinated with either BCG or MVA85A alone (McShane et al, 2004).

      The next trial to be conducted in the UK looked at the boosting efficacy of MVA85A when
      administered one month after BCG vaccination. 10 healthy, BCG naïve volunteers were
      vaccinated with BCG and one month later were boosted with MVA85A. Comparable safety and
      boosting efficacy was seen to the previous trial where the interval between BCG and MVA85A
      was 0.5-37 years.

      The current ongoing study in the UK is designed to assess the safety and immunogenicity of
      MVA85A in asymptomatic volunteers who are latently infected with M.tb. Latent infection with
      M.tb describes a state where an individual is presumed to have a very low level persistent
      bacterial infection with no clinical or radiological evidence of disease, and yet has a
      detectable immune response against M.tb. Latent infection in this study is defined using
      specific diagnostic tests based on antigens that are absent from BCG and most environmental
      mycobacteria such as ESAT 6 and CFP 10, allowing an accurate diagnosis of latent M.tb
      infection to be made. Subjects for this study were recruited from TB contact clinics and
      vaccinated with a single dose of MVA85A. Follow-up involved detailed radiological and
      clinical assessment of the safety of this vaccine in this group. To date, 11 subjects have
      been vaccinated with MVA85A in this study and the safety and immunogenicity profile of MVA85A
      is identical to that seen in previous studies. Importantly there has been no clinical,
      radiological or immunological evidence of a Koch reaction. The Elispot responses to PPD, ESAT
      6, CFP10, antigen 85A and other mycobacterial antigens are being monitored for 12 months
      following vaccination.

      Gambian studies Following the success of the trials with MVA85A in the UK, a collaboration
      with the MRC unit in The Gambia was initiated. MVA85A was first evaluated in Phase I clinical
      trials in BCG naïve subjects (n = 11) and subsequently in BCG primed subjects (n=10). In
      these studies the safety and immunogenicity profile is comparable to that seen in the UK
      studies. In both the UK and The Gambian studies, MVA85A induces 5-10 fold higher immune
      responses than any other recombinant MVA in clinical trials. The most likely explanation for
      this is that the volunteers have some weak pre-existing anti-mycobacterial immunity induced
      by exposure to environmental mycobacteria, and this is being boosted by vaccination with
      MVA85A. When MVA85A is administered to BCG naïve subjects in the Gambia, the magnitude and
      kinetics of response resemble the BCG primed group in the UK, a finding that is likely to
      represent a greater degree of environmental priming in tropical climates.

      South African studies A Phase II study of the safety and immunogenicity of MVA85A in healthy,
      M.tb uninfected and HIV uninfected adults in Cape Town commenced in August 2005. The studies
      with MVA85A at this site have begun in adults, as a safety requirement despite the fact that
      we already have safety and immunogenicity data in adults from both the UK and the Gambian
      studies. The population in South Africa is very different from the UK and Gambian populations
      in terms of both host genetics and mycobacterial exposure. There is considerably more M.tb
      exposure in South Africa than in the Gambia and the exposure to environmental mycobacterial
      is believed to be lower in South Africa than the Gambia. The BCG literature demonstrates wide
      variation in efficacy across geographical areas and it was important to confirm our findings
      in adults in Cape Town before proceeding to a study in adolescents. We aim to vaccinate 24
      adults in total. These studies commenced in August 2005, and to date, 14 volunteers have been
      vaccinated. Encouragingly, the safety and immunogenicity results so far are comparable with
      the previous studies in the UK and the Gambia.
    

Intervention name(s): MVA 85A
Intervention type(s): Biological
Intervention description(s): Modified vaccinia Ankara virus expressing antigen 85A from M. tuberculosis. Dose is 5x10^7
Other intervention name(s): TB Vaccine; modified vaccinia virus Ankara
Intervention MeSH terms: Vaccines
Allocation: Non-Randomized
Intervention model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: None (Open Label)
Primary purpose: Prevention
Keywords: HIV; MVA85A; TB; Tuberculosis; Human Immunodeficiency Virus; Safety; Immunogenicity; Efficacy; Treatment Naive