Efficacy Study on Symptomatic Control of Patient With Knee Osteoarthritis Between 14% of Plai (Plaivana®) to Placebo Gels
Condition: Knee Osteoarthritis
MeSH terms: Osteoarthritis; Osteoarthritis, Knee
Study type: Interventional
Phase: Phase 3

Summary: 
      To determine whether plai cream is effective in treating mild to moderate degrees of
      osteoarthritis of the knee in the elderly patient compared with placebo cream.
    

Detailed description: 
      Osteoarthritis is the most common of the arthritides, affecting at least 20 million
      Americans, a number that is expected to double over the next two decades. currently available
      medical therapies primarily address the treatment of joint pain in patients with
      osteoarthritis.Analgesics as well as traditional and cyclooxygenase-2-selective nonsteriodal
      anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) have suboptimal effectiveness,and there is some question
      about their safety, especially in the light of recent reports of increased cardiovascular
      risk.

      Plai (Zingiber cassumunar Roxb.) belongs to family of Ginger. Plai essential cream also has
      an activity on scavenging H2O2 generated by ultrasound exposure. The dilutions of 1:2,000 and
      1:1,000 (v:v) of plai cream presented H2O2 scavenging activity by reducing emissions of
      DCFH-fluorescence within U937 cells, compared with the cell control. Plai essential cream
      inhibited nitric oxide (NO) production in the macrophage cell line (J774), compared with
      untreated cells. However, high concentrations of plai cream (1:1 and 1:10), were toxic to
      U937 and J744 cell lines. Moreover, plai cream at dilutions of 1:1,000 and 1:2,000,
      significantly inhibited COX II activity in treated cells compared to the untreated cells.
      Three major compounds of plai essential cream were sabinene, terpinen-4-ol and
      (E)-1-(3,4-dimethyoxyphenyl) butadiene respectively.There have been many studies on the
      efficacy of Plai as an analgesic and anti-inflammatory when applied directly to the affected
      area. The majority of these studies have been carried out in Thailand as this is where the
      plant originates from and it is used extensively in Thai massage and herbal medicine. The
      anti-inflammatory activity of a compound found in Plai extracts was assessed and compared
      with aspirin, and two other lesser known anti-inflammatory drugs. The results obtained showed
      that the anti-inflammatory effect of the compound (compound D) mainly occurred in the acute
      phase of inflammation.Moreover, the anti-inflammatory affect of plai oil was twice as potent
      as Diclofenac. The Plai cream was shown to reduce swelling and pain significantly in athletic
      ankle sprain in the first 2-3 days of the treatment.

      These findings suggest that topical plai cream is a safe and potentially useful drug for the
      treatment of painful OA of the joints, however, there has been no efficacious study on the
      plai cream namely Plaivana® for relieving symptoms in patient with OA knee joint before,
      therefore, this study is proposed.

      Subject selection and withdrawal criteria Number of subjects A sufficient number of subjects
      with OA of the knee will be screened in order to randomize at least 100 subjects (100 pairs)
      The study should provide 92 subjects (92 pairs) evaluable subjects, assuming that 10% of
      subjects will withdraw before having one the last assessment in the primary outcome variable.

      Objectives Primary To evaluate the pain control using VAS of Plai cream 14 gm/100 (Plaivana®)
      compared with placebo cream in patient with OA knee.

      Secondary

        -  To evaluate the WOMAC score of patients in the Plaivana® compared with the placebo
           groups.

        -  To compare the amount of acetaminophen tablet taking in both groups.

        -  To compare the side effect of Plaivana® with the placebo. Investigational plane Study
           Design This will be the phase III randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled
           cross-over trial of 12 weeks duration. This study is designed to evaluate the efficacy
           of Plaivana® to placebo, in adults with OA of the knee. Randomization will be stratified
           by Kellgren-Lawrence (KL) grading (grade 2 and 3) using X-ray standing MTP technique. A
           total of 100 subjects (100 pairs of subjects) are planned for enrollment in this study.
           This study will be conducted over approximately 12 weeks.

      Patients and Methods Patients and study design This was the phase III randomized,
      double-blind, placebo-controlled cross-over trial of 12 weeks duration designed to evaluate
      the efficacy of Plaivana® to placebo, in adult with OA of the knee. A total of 100 subjects
      (100 pairs of subjects) are planned for enrollment in this study. This was an 8 weeks period
      of study treatment-control periods (4 weeks for treatment, two weeks for wash-out and 4 weeks
      for placebo periods). The study was conducted in accordance with the Declaration of Helsinki,
      was approved by Khon Kaen University Ethics Committee for Human Research and informed consent
      was obtained from all patients.

      Study medication The essential plai cream has anti-inflammatory and antimicrobial effects
      (Wasuwat1989, Giwanon 2000, Pithayanukul 2007, and Tripathi 2008). Active chemicals of plai
      cream are composed of sabinene, alpha and gamma tepinenes, terpinen 4-ol and
      (E)-1-(3,4-dimethoxyphenyl butadiene (DMPBD). The DMPBD has a property of anti-inflammatory
      activity(Ozaki 1991, Jeenapongsa 2003). Plavina® 40 mg in 100 gm (contains DMPBD of …%). This
      product was supplied in lacquered aluminum collapsible tube containing 100 gram cream
      packing.

      Treatment Assignment and dosing Subjects will be assigned to study treatment in accordance
      with the randomization schedule. Randomization will be stratified by KL grade (grade 2 or 3).
      At the Baseline/Randomization Visit, each subject will be randomly assigned to either
      Plaivana® or placebo creams. Plaivana® or placebo creams were applied three times around the
      index knee. The 2 inches in length of cream was topically applied to the skin around the
      index knee joint, then rubbing the cream until it dry. After applying the cream, patients
      should wash their hands and do not touch their eyes.

      Blinding This is a double-blind study. All study drugs will be blinded to the investigators
      and subjects. The study and placebo creams were prepared in the same lacquered aluminum
      collapsible tube containing 100 gram cream packing.

      Product Accountability In accordance with the standard requirements, the investigator must
      document the amount of investigational cream product dispensed and /or administered to study
      returned to the investigator. Product accountability records must be maintained throughout
      the course of the study.

      Treatment Compliance A drug-dispensing log will be maintained by the investigator. Subjects
      will be instructed at the baseline visit to record the dates on which they applied the cream
      from each lacquered aluminum collapsible tube and to bring the tube with them on study visit
      days. Subject compliance will be assessed based on the weight of returning tube, which will
      be collected and recorded in the Data Record Form. Subject will be asked to complete a diary
      card to capture daily applying doses of the cream.

      Concomitant Medications and Non-drug therapies Subject was asked to complete a diary card to
      capture daily applying doses of the cream. Subject was asked to complete a diary to capture
      takes and changes in concomitant therapy during the study, including pain medication or
      nutritional supplements for OA related pain. Subjects were permitted to take acetaminophen
      (500 mg) three times or two tablets for pain every 4-6 hours. Other topical analgesics, NSAID
      and COX-2 inhibitors are prohibiting. All concomitant medications or nutritional supplement
      taken during the study were also recorded.

      During wash-out period Subjects were permitted to take only acetaminophen for OA pain for 7
      days. Subjects maintained written diaries to record dosing of medications and nutritional
      supplements for OA-associated pain.

      STUDY ASSESSMENT AND PROCEDURES Subjects will be expected to attend the clinic a minimum of 6
      times over period of approximately 12 weeks. The study consists of 7 phases: screen,
      treatment, follow-up, washout, screening, treatment, and follow-up.

      The study investigation will discuss with each subject in detail of the study objectives, its
      requirement and its restrictions.

      The screening 1st visit will include a formal review of the complete medical history, all
      concurrent medications, concomitant diseases, medication taken within the last month and all
      medications of interested in the exclusion criteria, and other eligibility requirement for
      the study including contraindication for plai cream.

      Eligible subject will further be determined by exclusion criteria such as severe pain defined
      as above 80 mm on the 100 mm VAS scale for pain, as identified by subject response to WOMAC
      pain subscale.

      If OA present in both knees the investigator will identify which knee will be X-ray for the
      study entry, with preference for the knee with more severe pain (<80 mm on WOMAC pain sub
      scale) A radiograph of the index knee will be obtained using the MTP technique to evaluate
      JSW and KL grade. The minimum JSW must be at least 1.5 mm in the medial compartment and at
      least 2.5 mm in the corresponding lateral compartment with KL grade of 2 or 3.

      At the screening 1st visit, subject should be instructed to withhold OA medication for pain
      for 7 days for all NSAIDs or 24 hours for acetaminophen immediately prior to the baseline
      visit.

      At the 2nd visit subject will be randomized following stratification by KL grade. This visit,
      the following procedures will be completed:

        -  VAS

        -  WOMAC Subject will be received their first study or placebo cream, acetaminophen 500 mg
           for 40 tablets and daily record their symptoms.

      Efficacy Assessments Primary endpoint VAS: The primary endpoint is the change from baseline
      in VAS. This endpoint will be measured at visit 2-13 (week 1-12) Secondary endpoint WOMAC
      Score The WOMAC score is a tri-dimensional, disease-specific, self-administered health status
      measure, probing clinically important, subject-relevant symptoms in the area of pain. The
      subject will answer WOMAC question on pain subscale, using the Linkert scale 0-100 at
      screening 1st visit to determine eligibility for inclusion in the study. The subject will
      complete the entire WOMAC questionnaire during visit 2-13 (week 1-12) Safety Assessments
      Adverse events The investigator will be responsible for detecting, documenting and reporting
      events that meet the definition of adverse events. Definition of an adverse event is any
      unfavorable or unintended sign (including a clinically significant abnormal laboratory
      finding, for example; skin rash, swelling), symptom, or disease temporally associated with
      the use of a medicinal product, whether or not considered as an adverse event.Any adverse
      event should be documented on the patient chart and reported on the Adverse Event Form.

      Dropouts Reason for dropout The patients may drop-out of the study if they decide to do so,
      at any time and irrespective of the reason, or this may be the investigator decision. All
      dropouts must be documented and the investigator must give the reason.

      Data Analysis and statistical considerations Sample size determination The primary endpoint
      was the change from baseline in visual analog scale (VAS).The secondary endpoint was the
      Western Ontario McMaster score (WOMAC). These endpoints were measured every week for 9 weeks
      (4 weeks for each treatment periods and one week for washout period). This study is
      determined to demonstrate that Plaivana® is able to reduce the pain (VAS), functional score
      and stiffness score when compared to placebo cream. It is expected that Plaivana® will reduce
      the VAS by 1.23 (which considers Minimal Clinical Improvement Important, MCII) and SD was
      4.39. The significant level is 95% or alpha at 5% of two-sided test and power for detecting
      different is 80% or beta at 20%. Therefore, the sample size of 103 pairs of patient is
      needed. Adding 5% dropout rate, we would need approximately 108 pairs of patient (108
      patients) to be randomized to each treatment group in the study.

      N pairs = ½(1+1/λ)[(Z1-α/2+Z1-β)2/D2pair +( Z2 1-α/2)/2] Λ= number of controls:case = 1 D=
      Effect size =VAS difference/SDof VAS The VAS difference which minimal clinical improvement
      important was 1.23 and SDof VAS = 4.39, therefore the sample size was 103 pairs Hypothesis
      testing The null hypothesis to be tested is that the VAS in Plaivana® group is not different
      from the placebo group.

      Analysis population The primary analysis will be based on patients on intent-to-treat (ITT)
      population, which will include all patients with baseline results of VAS, WOMAC score.

      Statistic methods The mean different of VAS in Plaivana® and placebo be analyzed by Z test,
      95% CI of the mean different of VAS. The confident interval of the mean of VAS in each
      treatment group will be calculated. Other baseline factors such as WOMAC, Stiffness score and
      acetaminophen used will be analyses by ANOVA, student T test and Mc Nemar 's Chi-square. All
      statistical analyses were performed by using STATA Statistical Software: Release 10th.
      (StataCorp. 2007. Stata Statistical Software: Release 10th. College Station, TX: SataCorp.)
      Data Management The data collection will be done by research assistance using the DATA RECORD
      FORM SHEATH. Clinical data management will perform in according with the Good Clinical
      Practice Guidelines.

      Ethics The trial will be considered in accordance with: The Declaration of Helsinki adopted
      by the World Medical Assembly in June 1964, amended at Tokyo in October 1975, at Venice in
      October 1983 at Hong Kong in September 1989 and at Somerset West in October 1996.

      Before a subject included in the trial, the aims and methods of the trial are explained to
      the subject. The subject givens his/her consent in writing on an information and informed
      consent form. The investigator will submit the documents required by the regulations
      according to the Ethics Committee of Khon Kaen University and will obtain their opinion in
      writing. Subjects cannot be included until the approval of the Ethics Committee has been
      received.

      Quality control-Quality assurance The investigator in charge of the study ensures the
      efficient organization and good quality of the study, notably he is responsible for protocol
      compliance, data collection and Good Clinical Practice in general. Data collection will be
      monitored throughout the study by the monitors after quality control by the investigator.
    

Intervention name(s): Plavina cream
Intervention type(s): Drug
Intervention description(s): The essential plai cream has anti-inflammatory and antimicrobial effects (Wasuwat1989, Giwanon 2000, Pithayanukul 2007, and Tripathi 2008). Active chemicals of plai cream are composed of sabinene, alpha and gamma tepinenes, terpinen 4-ol and (E)-1-(3,4-dimethoxyphenyl butadiene (DMPBD). The DMPBD has a property of anti-inflammatory activity(Ozaki 1991, Jeenapongsa 2003). Plavina® 40 mg in 100 gm (contains DMPBD of …%). This product was supplied in lacquered aluminum collapsible tube containing 100 gram cream packing.
Allocation: Randomized
Intervention model: Crossover Assignment
Masking: Double (Participant, Investigator)
Primary purpose: Treatment
Keywords: Plai; Efficacy; OA knee; The efficacy study of Plai cream for OA knee