Academic Achievement in Children With Asthma
Condition: Asthma
MeSH terms: Asthma
Study type: Observational [Patient Registry]

Summary: 
      Background: Asthma is the most common chronic disease of childhood with a prevalence that is
      1.6 times greater in African American children than in Non-Hispanic White children.1
      Nationally, 700,000 children are seen for asthma in Emergency Departments every year, 1% of
      which are seen at Children's National Health System in Washington, District of Columbia.
      School performance and school attendance has not been well studied in urban children with
      asthma, especially at the middle school level.

      Objective: Our purpose is to test the hypothesis that middle school children with asthma have
      worse school performance than middle school children without asthma in Washington DC and
      Prince George's county schools.

      Methods: The investigators will conduct a cross-sectional observational study of
      middle-school (grades 6-8 in the 2013-2014 school year) aged children with and without asthma
      recruited from the Emergency Departments and the IMPACT DC asthma clinic at CN. The
      investigators will collect demographic information, asthma severity information (for cases),
      and request that parents mail report cards and standardized test scores directly to the
      investigators. The investigators will use multivariable linear and logistic regression to
      determine if the presence of asthma is associated with school performance.
    

Detailed description: 
      Academic Achievement in Children with Asthma

      Research Plan A. Background and Specific Aims Asthma is the most common chronic disease of
      childhood with a prevalence that is 1.6 times greater in African American children than in
      Non-Hispanic White children. Nationally, 700,000 children are seen for asthma in Emergency
      Departments (ED) every year, 1% of which are seen at Children's National (CN) Medical Center
      in Washington, District of Columbia (DC). The asthma prevalence rate among African American
      children and teens in Washington, District of Columbia is 20% higher than the national rate
      and overall emergency department utilization rates for asthma are 4.3 times the national
      rate. In 2007, approximately 10.5 million school days were lost due to asthma.

      Asthma severity may impact academic performance due to increased absenteeism. A study of
      Canadian school children showed that children with the most severe asthma had the lowest math
      and reading scores.4 Tsakiris also showed that children with asthma on inhaled
      corticosteroids had better academic achievement than children with asthma not on long-term
      controller therapy, suggesting that poor control is associated with worse school
      performance.5 However, academic performance is dependent on many other factors, such as
      socio-economic status of the local district and resources available. Availability of skilled
      nursing differs between schools, impacting children with asthma; Hillemeier's study of
      children with asthma in Pennsylvania schools showed that less than half of secondary schools
      had adequate school nurse coverage, and that this reduced services provided to children with
      asthma.6 Children whose asthma is not managed at school may be absent more often. Parental
      education also plays a part in a child's school performance. Tsakiris et al, showed that in
      Greece, lower parental education level was independently associated with poor school
      performance in children with asthma.5

      Early adolescence (ages 10-13) is identified as a time of great transition with both
      developmental and biologic changes; in this time period male children with asthma generally
      improve and female with asthma develop worsening asthma, likely due to hormone effects. It
      has been shown that programs to reduce asthma symptoms in both younger children (elementary
      school) and older children (high school) do not work well in early adolescent children
      (middle school).7

      In addition, despite the National Asthma Education Prevention Program (NAEPP, 2007)
      guidelines that encourage the assessment of the quality of life (QOL) in children, there has
      been minimal research on QOL in children with asthma.

      Given the scarcity of information on the association between pediatric asthma and academic
      achievement, school attendance, and the QOL, and the need to establish baselines within
      individual communities, we have designed a study to examine the association between asthma in
      school-age (grades 3 through 8, inclusive) children and academic achievement, school
      attendance, and the QOL. Our overall hypothesis is that children with asthma will have worse
      school performance compared to children without asthma.

      Specific Aim 1: To determine the association between asthma and school performance by
      comparing unweighted grade point averages (GPA) in middle school aged children with and
      without asthma. We will enroll 200 children in grades 3-8 with asthma (cases) from the
      ED/IMPACT DC and compare them with a group of 200 children in grades 3-8 without asthma
      (controls) recruited from the ED. Report cards will be collected between August 2014 and
      December 1, 2014 or until 200 cases and 200 controls have been recruited, and GPAs will be
      compared. We expect children with asthma will have lower GPAs .

      B.

      Significance:

      School achievement in middle school students with asthma is not well understood; this study
      will be pivotal in identifying if middle school students with asthma in the Washington DC are
      are performing more poorly than their non-asthmatic counterparts.

      C. Preliminary studies We have not previously studied academic success in children with
      asthma.

      D. Research Design and Methods

      We are proposing a cross-sectional case-control observational study of school-age (grades
      3-8) children to compare academic achievement and school attendance between children with and
      without asthma. 200 children with asthma (cases) will be recruited from the IMPACT DC clinic
      and/or ED and 200 children without asthma (controls) will be recruited from the ED.

      Inclusion criteria for cases include asthma diagnosed by a clinician for greater than 1 year
      with a history of exacerbation requiring systemic corticosteroids within the past 2 years.
      Controls will have no history of asthma. All children, cases and controls, must (1) be in
      grade level 3-8 in the 2013-2014 school year, attend public school in Washington, DC (DCPS),
      and reside in their school district;(2) be accompanied by their parent or legal guardian.
      Exclusion criteria for cases and controls will be (1) presence of a chronic medical condition
      other than asthma; (2) triage category 1 or 2 in the emergency department; and (3) a family
      that does not speak English or Spanish

      Demographic Data for Cases and Controls Demographic information will be obtained by a
      structured interview; the questionnaire (Appendix A) will be used on both cases and controls:
      the parent/caregiver will be asked about the child's age, gender, race/ethnicity, insurance
      type. health care utilization, medications usage, highest level of education of the parent/
      caregiver, income of the household, and parental report of school services. Cases will
      complete an additional 11 questions to determine asthma severity to determine NAEPP score and
      the Asthma Control Test (ACT) score (Appendix F and G).

      We will utilize the child's electronic medical record (Cerner for ED charts and
      eClinicalWorks for the IMPACT DC charts) to determine insurance type and health care
      utilization.

      Reporting of Academic Achievement and School Attendance At the time of recruitment, families
      will be given a self-addressed, stamped envelope to send the child's 2013 first term (if
      available), standardized test score report (if available), and final report card to the
      research team. All report cards/score reports will be returned to the family via US Mail with
      a $25 gift card as incentive for sending in their report card. Academic achievement,
      standardized test scores, and school attendance will be recorded from the report cards. All
      report cards in the DCPS system use the same grading scale.. Both systems record attendance
      on the report cards and there are 180 school days in a year in both systems.

      Reporting of the Quality of Life using the Peds QL (Quality of Life) 4.0 Form QOL will be
      measured using the validated PedsQL 4.0 for children, teens, and parents (Appendices B, C, D,
      and E). The PedsQL 4.0 has four scales with 23 questions which ascertain physical
      functioning, emotional functioning, social functioning, and school functioning. A 5-point
      Likert scale is used in the child self-report and for the parent proxy reports. Items are
      reverse scored and linearly transformed to a 0 to 100 scale (0=100, 1=75, 2=50, 3=25, and
      4=0), so higher scores indicate better QOL.

      E. Statistical analysis Descriptive statistics will be used to analyze demographic variables
      (rates, proportions, means, medians, ranges). Univariate comparisons will be performed using
      appropriate categorical or continuous statistical analyses. Multivariate testing will be
      performed using logistic and/or liner regression where appropriate.

      Sample Size: The study will be powered on the proportion of patients in each group with a
      grade point average >3.0. The overall proportion of DC public middle school students in the
      2012-2013 school year with a GPA >3.0 was approximately 35%. Assuming that this figure is
      similar for children without asthma (controls), we will need 70 cases and 70 controls to have
      80% power detect a 20% absolute difference in the proportion of children with asthma (cases)
      with a grade point average >3.0 (alpha = 0.05, two-sided).

      We have chosen to include 200 children in each group, as we expect that less than 50% of all
      included patients will return their final year report cards via the self-addressed, stamped
      envelope.
    

Intervention name(s): Survey
Intervention type(s): Other
Intervention description(s): We will be administering surveys about health, quality of life, and asking for final report cards for the 2013-2014 school year for each group.
Observational model: Case-Control
Time perspective: Prospective
Sampling method: Non-Probability Sample
Study population: 
        We are proposing a cross-sectional case-control observational study of middle school
        (grades 6-8) children to compare academic achievement and school attendance between
        children with and without asthma. 200 children with asthma (cases) will be recruited from
        the IMPACT DC clinic and/or ED and 200 children without asthma (controls) will be recruited
        from the ED.
      
Keywords: asthma; academics; GPA; attendance