The Use of Chlorhexidine Gel Following EDTA Root Surface Etching as an Adjunctive to Open Flap Debridement in Treating Intra-Bony Defects
Condition: Periodontal Bone Loss
MeSH terms: Alveolar Bone Loss
Study type: Interventional

Summary: 
      SUMMARY Chronic periodontitis is regarded as an inflammatory disease that affects the
      supporting tissues of teeth which could lead to bone destruction. According to the pattern of
      bone destruction, vertical infrabony defect could occur. Several biomaterials have been used
      to treat infrabony defects including bone grafts, membranes, anti-microbials, growth factor &
      Enamel matrix proteins. CHX gel which has been widely used in the treatment of infra-bony
      defects.

      Chemical treatment of root surfaces of teeth have been used as an adjunct with mechanical
      instrumentation. Among these chemical agents is EDTA which was found to be able to remove the
      smear layer and expose the collagen fibers on the root surface which would make the root
      surface biocompatible favoring fibroblast attachment and increase substantivity of CHX gel.
      However, studies have found that there was no clinical significance of EDTA with
      chlorhexidine gel .

      Recent studies revealed that signiﬁcant improvements could be obtained for deep intrabony
      defects after EDTA root surface etching and CHX gel application after non-surgical therapy
      compared to control non etched treated sites. This could be attributed to the associated
      prolonged and higher values of CHX levels for the CHX-EDTA-treated group. However, the main
      target of that work is to quantify levels of CHX during the early stages of healing to
      determine if such clinical improvement could be attributed to prolonged and increased CHX
      levels after EDTA root surface preconditioning.

      The aim of this study was to evaluate clinically the use of Chlorhexidine gel following root
      surface EDTA after open flap debridement in treating Intra-bony defects and to study the
      effect of EDTA bone etching on Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 (BMP-2) in gingival crevicular
      fluid.
    

Detailed description: 
      SUBJECTS AND METHODS A total of 20 patients were selected from the outpatient clinic of Oral
      Medicine, Periodontology and Oral Diagnosis department, Faculty of Dentistry, Ain Shams
      University. The proposal reviewed by the research ethics committee, Faculty of Dentistry,
      Ain-shams University.

      Patients fulfilling the inclusion criteria were randomly divided into one of two groups using
      a randomizing program (Randomization.com):

      Group 1:

      This group included 10 patients with localized periodontitis stage 2 or 3, grade A infra-bony
      defect sites (Caton, 2018) that had undergone proper curettage ensuring complete removal of
      all granulation tissue present within the defect by sub-mechanical debridement then open flap
      debridement only.

      Group 2:

      This group included 10 patients with localized periodontitis stage 2 or 3, grade A infra-bony
      defect sites (Caton, 2018) that had undergone proper curettage ensuring complete removal of
      all granulation tissue present within the defect by sub-mechanical debridement then open flap
      debridement before treating root and bony walls of the pocket surfaces by application of 24%
      EDTA etching and washing with saline, then application of 2% chlorhexidine gel on root
      surface.

      Inclusion criteria:

        1. Age from 32 to 60 years old.

        2. Females and males.

        3. Healthy adult patients.

        4. Selected patient with a single site of defect:

      Two walled defect or three walled infra-bony defect. The bone defect should be at least 3 mm
      in depth from the crest of the alveolar bone to the base of the defect.

      Pocket depth of more than or equal to 5 mm. Clinical attachment loss equal or more than 3mm.

      Exclusion criteria:

        1. Smokers.

        2. Breast feeding and pregnant females.

        3. Vulnerable group of patients (handicapped and prisoners).

        4. Patients who have received any periodontal therapy or antibiotics in the last 6 months.

      The study protocol explained in details to all patients. Then a signed informed consent
      obtained from the patients. The data obtained from patients as well as the results of the
      follow up will be kept confidential.

      Measurements and indices:

      Clinical Assessment were done using Universal Dental Williams Michigan Probe.

      The following clinical parameters were measured in every patient before the surgery and after
      3 months of the surgery:

      Initial therapy by full mouth supra and sub-gingival mechanical debridement using ultrasonic
      scaler and hand instruments have been done on all patients. The patients were given
      instructions for self-performed plaque control measures with soft dental brush and
      interdental cleaning using dental floss or interdental brush to achieve good oral hygiene.
      All groups were subjected to the previous procedure. All groups received open flap
      debridement after one month of scaling and root planning.

      Open flap debridement initiated by giving infiltration local anesthesia (Articaine
      Hydrochloride 4% and Epinephrine 1:100,000) to the affected area. Then a reverse bevel
      incision and full thickness flaps were elevated. This helped to gain access for deep scaling,
      root planning and removal of granulation tissues and tissue tags and irrigation into the
      pockets.

      Baseline samples from the gingival crevicular fluid were collected from all selected sites
      using filter paper inserted into the deepest part of each periodontal pocket and left in situ
      for 30 seconds for assessment of BMP-2 concentrations.

      In both groups, the area of selected pocket were completely dried using oil free air syringe,
      and then the site was isolated with cotton rolls to prevent contamination from saliva.

      The local drug delivery gel (24% of EDTA gel on root and bone surface and then application of
      2% of chlorhexidine gel on root surface) were placed for group 2 in the periodontal pockets
      using a dedicated syringe until the gel flowed out from the gingival margin for 1 minute.
      Filter paper were inserted into the orifice of the pocket for 1 minute. This was done in the
      day of surgery then after 3 days, 7 days, 14 days and 21 days after the local drug delivery
      to measure the gel release profile. (Ahmed Y. Gamal and Jason M. Mailhot, 2007).

      The flaps were replaced as close as possible to their original position and sutured by
      polypropylene (4-0) suture with interrupted interproximal sutures to achieve as complete
      coverage of the inter-dental areas as possible.

      - Poste-operative care: All patients received amoxicillin antibiotic three times per day.
      Patients were also prescribed 0.12% chlorhexidine digluconate mouthwash (Hexitol antiseptic
      mouthwash, Arab Drug Company, Egypt) to be used twice per day for one week and were
      instructed to avoid brushing at the site of surgery for the first ten days. Sutures were
      removed after 1 week and then application of perio- pack for another 1 week and follow up
      after 3 months.

      6) Biochemical assessment: i. EDTA and Chlorhexidine gel release profile: The collected
      samples were labeled and carried in a dark container until High Performance Liquid
      Chromatography (HPLC) evaluation.

      ii. Concentration of BMP-2: In both groups, assessment was done at baseline and one month
      after local drug delivery.

      BMP-2 concentrations were determined using a commercial human BMP-2 ELISA Kit. Measurements
      were performed according to the manufacturer's instructions.

      Measurement of BMP-2 in GCF by ELISA:

      GCF was extracted from the filter paper after addition of 100ul of PBS (pH 7) and
      centrifugation at 5000xg. The supernatant was used for measurement of the BMP-2. The kit was
      provided by Chongqing Biospes Co., Ltd, China (Catalog No.: BEK1014)
    

Intervention name(s): CHX gel 2 % + 24% EDTA
Intervention type(s): Procedure
Intervention description(s): The local drug delivery gel (24% of EDTA gel on root and bone surface and then application of 2% of chlorhexidine gel on root surface) were placed for group 2 in the periodontal pockets Filter paper were inserted into the orifice of the pocket for 1 minute. This was done in the day of surgery then after 3 days, 7 days, 14 days and 21 days after the local drug delivery to measure the gel release profile.
Allocation: Randomized
Intervention model: Parallel Assignment
Intervention model description: chlorhexidine gel, Biological drug
Masking: Double (Participant, Outcomes Assessor)
Primary purpose: Treatment