Observational Cohort Study of Distribution of Ventilation in Pediatrics Requiring Mechanical Ventilation by Electrical Impedance Tomography
Condition: Respiratory Failure; Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome; Acute Lung Injury
MeSH terms: Respiratory Distress Syndrome; Respiratory Distress Syndrome, Newborn; Respiratory Insufficiency; Acute Lung Injury; Lung Injury
Study type: Observational

Summary: 
      Respiratory disorders are the leading cause of respiratory failure in children. Thousands of
      children are admitted to a pediatric intensive care unit each year and placed on mechanical
      ventilators. Despite over 40 years since the first pediatric-specific ventilator was
      designed, there has been no specific cardiopulmonary directed therapy that has proven
      superior. While mechanical ventilation is generally lifesaving, it can be associated with
      adverse events. There is evidence building to suggest that adopting a lung protective
      ventilation strategy by the avoidance of lung over-distension and collapse reduces death.
      Therefore, timely discovery of these two lung conditions is extremely important in order to
      mitigate the effects associated with positive pressure mechanical ventilation. The
      investigators research team has extensive research experience with a non-invasive and
      radiation free medical device called electrical impendence tomography (EIT). EIT is intended
      to generate regional information of changes in ventilation. Meaning it can detect this
      collapse and overdistension. This additional source of information could help fine tune the
      mechanical ventilator. A baseline of understanding of how often this occurs in the patients
      the investigators serve is required. Therefore the investigators propose an EIT observation
      study in their pediatric ICU patient population.
    

Detailed description: 
      A. Specific Aims/Objectives Specific Aim 1: To determine regional compliance and distribution
      of ventilation in a cohort of children requiring mechanical ventilation. Hypothesis -
      Abnormal distribution of ventilation will be discovered in all patients.

      Specific Aim 2: To determine changes in regional distribution of ventilation over the course
      of mechanical ventilation therapy. Hypothesis - Distribution of regional ventilation will
      change significantly as the patient's lung function improves and as they progress towards
      liberation from mechanical ventilation.

      Specific Aim 3: To compare previously developed EIT guided ventilation algorithms by BCH
      research team with medical team decisions regarding mechanical ventilation. Hypothesis - EIT
      guided ventilation algorithms will identify changes to minimize atelectasis and
      overdistension sooner than clinical team decisions.

      B. Background and Significance Clinical decisions regarding the mechanical ventilator rely
      heavily on clinical judgment typically based on intermittent and subjective assessments of
      relevant physiologic parameters which only reflect global lung function and without
      consideration for regional distribution of ventilation. Until recently there has not been a
      way to determine regional distribution of ventilation without exposing a patient to radiation
      in the form of a chest radiograph (CXR) or computer aided tomography (CT). CT and CXR provide
      regionally specific information but only as a snapshot in time. Determining how different
      regions of the lung respond to therapeutic interventions over time is challenging. However,
      our research team has extensive research experience with a non-invasive and radiation free
      medical imaging technology called electrical impendence tomography (EIT). EIT provides
      regional information of changes in ventilation. This additional source of information could
      help optimize mechanical ventilation by providing bedside clinicians with continuous decision
      support as the EIT data may be utilized to alert when regional collapse or over-distension is
      detected. However, there is little data describing changes in distribution of ventilation
      over time or as the patient's condition changes.

      Electrical Impedance Tomography (EIT) Barber and Brown introduced electrical impedance
      tomography to the medical community in the early 1980s. From there a wide spectrum of
      applications in medicine ranging from gastric emptying, brain function, breast imaging, to
      lung function have been explored. It is our belief that the most valuable benefit of EIT is
      in the monitoring of regional lung function in critically ill patients. Early EIT devices
      fell susceptible to poor sensitivity and signal interference in the clinical setting. After
      years and a renewed interest from a few commercial companies interested in ventilation
      technology, many of these shortcomings have been resolved. As with any new modality, EIT and
      its clinical utility and application need to be methodically explored; therefore we propose
      this IRB protocol to take us a step closer on this journey to develop a clinically useful
      tool9.

      Electrical impedance tomography capitalizes on changes in electrical impendence between
      air-filled versus tissue or fluid-filled spaces in order to characterize and quantify
      regional distribution of lung volume at the bedside. This technology has been validated in
      animal10 and human11, 12 studies. The technology utilizes a series of 16 electrodes placed
      across the patient's chest. As small currents, which are undetectable to the subject, are
      passed between the electrodes, impedance is measured between and amongst the series. Through
      a complex interrogation and manipulation of these impedance values, a two-dimensional image
      is formed, and has been shown to correlate with clinical and radiographic changes in
      patients.11 The ability to estimate lung volume and regional distribution of gas
      non-invasively and in real time may give us insight as to what mode of ventilation or setting
      is more effective in optimizing positive pressure ventilation.

      We have chosen to partner with Draeger Medical (Lubeck, Germany) through a CTA to explore the
      use of their commercially available product in Europe (not FDA cleared), through European
      Directive 93/42/EEC (medical devices) and meets the EN ISO 9001 and EN ISO 13485
      requirements. Boston Children's Hospital has extensive experience with their prototype system
      that led to the final product named PulmoVista 500. The PulmoVista 500 uses 16 electrodes to
      measure the voltages utilized for image reconstruction. Mathematical simulations based on
      this electrode arrangement demonstrate a spatial resolution of 15% of the thoracic diameter;
      however the resolution decreases to 20% towards the center of the body. While CT scanners
      typically provide images consisting of 512 x 512 or higher pixels, EIT images from the
      PulmoVista 500 only consist of 32 x 32 pixels, which are 256 times less pixels when compared
      to CT images9. However, our team intends to use EIT at the bedside and within the ICU
      environment to guide ventilation therapy in the future rather than be a high-resolution
      diagnostic tool such as CT or MRI. Our intent is not to replace CT or MRI imaging of the
      lung, but develop a bedside tool to guide ventilation in the future that can be applied
      continuously and with very few risks. The characterization of a cohort of critically ill
      mechanically ventilated children, as proposed in this protocol represents an important step
      towards clinical utility of EIT.

      C. Preliminary Studies Current strategies to provide lung protective ventilation rely on
      avoiding conditions associated with lung injury. There is growing interest in development of
      individualized mechanical ventilation treatment plans. The use of EIT has been demonstrated
      to be an accurate method of monitoring regional lung volume changes in animals and humans.10,
      13, 14 While radiological and EIT images both provide information about the regional
      distribution of air in the lungs the image characteristics provided by these modalities are
      quite different. Radiological images of the lung provide information on the air content and
      reflect, depending on the moment the images were taken, the endinspiratory, the
      end-expiratory status or a lung condition somewhere in between. EIT images reflect the lung
      function, not the lung itself, which means EIT displays ventilated lung regions rather than
      morphological or anatomical structures of the lung.9 Nonetheless, the regional information
      contained in EIT and CT images is closely related to each other when pathological conditions
      such as pleural effusion or atelectasis lead to non-aerated and non-ventilated lung regions.
      While CT images display lungs regions with trapped air (e.g. pneumothorax) in black because
      of the large air content, EIT also displays those regions in black because they are not
      ventilated.15, 16 Conversely a CT image may indicate a region of consolidated lung tissue in
      a white color because of the high fluid content, while this region might be displayed in the
      EIT image in black or dark blue color, if this region is not or only partially ventilated.17
      EIT has been proven in animal models and human case reports to be accurate determinant of
      pneumothoraces.15, 18, 19 More recently, EIT-derived parameters have been used to
      differentiate atelectatic, overdistened, and adequately recruited lung in different lung
      regions by a number of investigators.10, 20-28 Despite the ability of EIT to monitor regional
      lung behavior, the use of EIT derived indices has not been shown to improve outcomes in
      animals or humans with acute lung injury until last year when Drs. Wolf, Arnold and
      colleagues developed an EIT guided mechanical ventilation strategy that demonstrated promise
      in an animal model.29 Through this translational model they were able to demonstrate that EIT
      guided ventilation was superior to a national and standardized ventilation protocol called
      Acute Respiratory Distress Syndrome Network (ARDSNet) Ventilator Protocol.30-33 The goal of
      this study is to survey regional distribution in pediatric patients who require mechanical
      ventilation therapy.

      D. Design and Methods (1) Study Design In a prospective observational trial we will
      objectively measure regional compliance and distribution of ventilation by EIT in patients
      who require mechanical ventilation.

      (3) Description of Study Treatments or Exposures/Predictors Following attending approval and
      informed consent, patients who meet inclusion criteria and none of the exclusion criteria
      will (1) transition to the exact same setting on the FDA approved Draeger V500 ventilator.
      (2) A clinical assessment by the responsible respiratory therapist and nurse will be
      conducted to ensure the transitioned settings are appropriate and according to the standard
      of practice. (3) The PulmoVista 500 EIT device will be set-up and safety checked according to
      provided training and operating manual. (4) The provided electrode system will be placed
      around the patient's chest as in figure 2. (5) The EIT system will be connected to the
      electrodes array and the V500 ventilator. (6) Once signal quality is determined to be
      appropriate, a recording will be performed and saved securely. (7) The EIT belt and device
      will be removed and returned to storage and the V500 ventilator will remain on the patient
      for the ventilator course. The initial set-up and monitoring time commitment is approximately
      1 hour. (8) Repeat recordings will be performed each morning for the first 5 days, then every
      other day if > 5 days of mechanical ventilation is required and within 2 hours following
      major interventions such as prone positioning, increasing or decrease of PEEP or MAP of 2
      cmH2O or more, recruitment maneuvers, intubation (if on non-invasive ventilation), and prior
      to and following extubation. Follow-up monitoring events will be approximately 30 minutes. No
      set-up or monitoring session will be done without the approval of the bedside nurse and
      respiratory therapist.

      Treatment exposures modification

      Transition of the patient to the Draeger V500 Ventilator will not occur in the following
      situations:

        1. Patients who are deemed too unstable by the research in collaboration with the medical
           team to transition to the V500, yet are stable enough to apply the EIT belt will be
           studied without the Draeger V500 ventilator. Manual recording of the ventilator settings
           and measurements will be conducted instead.

        2. Patients enrolled who are receiving non-invasive ventilation. (5) Data Collection
           Methods, Assessments, Interventions and Schedule (what assessments performed, how often)
           Data will be collected from several sources. Initial evaluation will be performed within
           48 hours of initiation of mechanical ventilation. Vital signs, latest blood gas, CXR
           report, ventilator settings, pulmonary mechanic and EIT images will be recorded. Vital
           signs will be gathered from T3. Blood gas will be captured from Powerchart. Pulmonary
           mechanics and EIT images will be obtained from the PulmoVista 500 system. The PulmoVista
           will obtain the ventilator settings and pulmonary mechanics via a connection to the
           Draeger V500 ventilator. A manual flowsheet (paper) of findings will be recorded and
           compared to the electronic files. Once verified, the manual flowsheet will be properly
           disposed.

      The Pulmovista 500 system trends not only regional distribution of ventilation, but
      clinically useful and currently recorded information such as dynamic compliance, resistance,
      and ventilator settings. While the research team will not guide ventilation at this time from
      EIT images/data, the trending data summarized daily maybe useful. Parents will not be
      excluded from see the images if they desire. However, no data will be shared unless requested
      by the team. EIT images or data will not be used for routine clinical care or interventions,
      unless there is safety concern in which the team will be immediately notified and asked to
      clinically assess. Please see Risk/Benefit section of the online CHeRP protocol.

      (6) Study Timeline (as applicable)

        1. Initial set-up and recording will conducted as soon as possible following initiation of
           mechanical ventilation. Total set-up and recording is anticipated to take 1 hour.

        2. Routine subsequent recordings will be conducted every morning for the first 5 days of
           mechanical ventilation; then every other day until liberation.

        3. Interventional recordings will be conducted within 2 hours following changes of 2 cmH2O
           or more in PEEP or MAP, prone positioning, intubation, extubation, or modes of
           ventilation (inclusive of ECMO or HFV).

      E. Adverse Event Criteria and Reporting Procedures The following complications will be
      monitored for during the imagining process which include study timelines 1-3 above and major
      complications will be immediately reported to the IRB. Minor events include: skin irritation
      that continues for > than 1 hour after the belt is removed, increase in respiratory rate by >
      20%, temporal hypoventilation determined by an increase in ETCO2 by 10 mmHg, temporal
      increase in FIO2 of > 0.3, and temporal hypoxia determined by an desaturation (<88%) for
      greater than 1 minute. Minor events that occur more than 3 times will be reported to the IRB
      with a plan of action of how to avoid.

      Major events that will halt the study and be immediately reported to the IRB are:

        -  Desaturation < 80% (continuously monitored by pulse oximetry) for longer than 1 minute.

        -  Bradycardia < 60 BPM

        -  Decrease in lung compliance determined to be associated with the belt. All adverse
           events will be reviewed by the entire research team weekly and a detailed case report
           will be developed. If major or minor events occurring more than 3 times, the study will
           not continue until the research team and IRB feel as though it is safe to continue.

      F. Data Management Methods Upon entry, each patient will be assigned a number unique and
      unlinked from their medical record for the purpose of patient tracking. This number will be
      entered into a privately owned BCH, password protected research database (RedCap) accessible
      only by BCH study personnel.

      A spreadsheet will be kept at the bedside during the data collection periods for each data
      point to be entered manually. This spreadsheet will be destroyed once the electric and manual
      data have been verified.

      G. Quality Control Method Quality of the transfer of data will be ensured by a second
      investigator, who will confirm the manual and electronic data. RedCap and SPSS software will
      be used to help analyze the data and ensuring data integrity by establishing alerts for
      non-filled fields as well as unexpected or possibly misentered results.

      H. Data Analysis Plan EIT data: The lung imaging system is the Dräger PulmoVista 500 (Dräger
      Medical, Lübeck, Germany). Sixteen coplanar electrodes will be placed equidistantly around
      the thorax at the level of the parasternal sixth intercostal space. The reference electrode
      will be placed on the right side of the abdomen near the waistline. Electrodes #1 and #16 are
      symmetrically placed to the left and the right of the sternum, respectively, so that
      electrodes #8 and #9 straddled the spinal column. This configuration leads to transverse
      images in the radiological convention, caudal to cranial, similar to a cat scan. Lung image
      reconstruction will be done according to the Graz consensus for electrical impedance
      tomography (GREIT)34 using the Electrical Impedance and Diffuse Optical Reconstruction
      Software.35 Each subjects' data will be filtered and images will be reconstructed using the
      aforementioned open source software platform. Each reconstructed lung image will then be
      segmented in to regions of interest and changes in impedance for each region will be
      transcribed. The procedure will be repeated for each of the individual subjects EIT
      recordings. Furthermore, we will employ, in an observational manner only, an algorithm which
      was developed by the current research group in order to identify when changes in lung
      mechanics are likely to reflect overdistention or collapse of lung.20 These discrete points,
      and the mechanical ventilator settings upon which they were collected will be transcribed and
      compared to the standard of care per unit practice. Impedance changes indicate how open or
      closed the lung is. This approach has been previously described in detail by our research
      group.20 I. Statistical Power and Sample Considerations Age Categories

      1- < 6 months 6 months - < 1 year 1-7 years 8-14 years > 14 years This is a pilot
      observational study of mechanically ventilated children within our pediatric ICUs. We have
      proposed a target of 50 patients within two years. We anticipate a 10% dropout rate. Our goal
      would be to obtain 5-7 patients for each age category below. Since our experience and the
      preliminary data within this field is in severe lung injury and the fact that we wish to
      explore a heterogeneous mechanically ventilated patients, we have not been able to accurately
      determine a sample size and have therefore determined this to be a pilot study. Preference
      will be given to low volume lung disease patients such as but not limited to ARDS, CDH,
      hypoxic respiratory failure, patients transferred for possible ECMO, and asthmatics.

      J. Study Organization Single institution pilot study.
    

Observational model: Cohort
Time perspective: Prospective
Sampling method: Non-Probability Sample
Study population: 
        In a prospective observational trial we will objectively measure regional distribution of
        ventilation by EIT in patients who require mechanical ventilation.
      
Keywords: Pediatrics; ARDS; ARF; ALI; Respiratory; Mechanical ventilation; Ventilation; Noninvasive monitoring; electrical impedance tomography; EIT