The Effect of Preoperative Suggestions on Perioperative Dreams and Dream Recalls
Condition: Dreamy State
Study type: Interventional

Summary: 
      Hypothesis: By employing suggestions before the induction of narcosis dreams may be evoked
      and their content may be directed.

      The main goal of suggestive techniques in the perioperative phase is to turn the content of
      dreams toward a favourable direction that is considered a pleasant event by the patient. So
      far little attention has been paid to the administration of perioperative psychological
      methods that may meet these requirements.

      Along these lines, in the present study we intended to assess whether dream recalls can be
      influenced by two different psychological methods administered in the preoperative setting
    

Detailed description: 
      The investigators were carried out up 2009 to 2011 at the Department of Oral and
      Maxillofacial Surgery of the Faculty of Dentistry, University of Debrecen, in a prospective
      randomized fashion.

      Adult patients were included, with whom verbal communication was possible. After a written
      informed consent, written agreement was obtained. Exclusion criteria were: mental
      retardation, tracheotomy, and inability to communicate. None of the participants needed to be
      excluded.

      Among others, the most important components of general anaesthesia is providing a sufficient
      level of hypnosis during the procedure, as well as reducing anxiety in the perioperative
      period. Perioperatively used hypnosis and suggestive techniques can be employed, in addition
      to local, or general anaesthesia as complementer techniques for anxiolysis, sedation,
      relaxation, pain alleviation, and amnesia.

      It has been proven that despite the use of depth of anesthesia monitors: in recent decades
      the occurrance of perioperative dreams cannot be avoided. 7-16 According to our present
      knowledge, dream formation during the anaesthetic procedure reflects a brief period of light
      level of hypnosis and dreams show a close relationship to external events in the
      perioperative period. Unpleasant perioperative dreams or dream recalls may lead to decreased
      patient satisfaction related to the surgical/anaesthesiological event and thus should be
      reduced.

      It seems that imagination guided by suggestions before anaesthesia induction can modify dream
      recalls after recovery. The main goal of suggestive techniques in the perioperative phase is
      to turn the content of dreams toward a favourable direction that is considered a pleasant
      event by the patient. So far little attention has been paid to the administration of
      perioperative psychological methods that may meet these requirements.

      Along these lines, in the present study we intended to assess whether dream recalls can be
      influenced by two different psychological methods administered in the preoperative setting.

      The investigators intended to answer the following study questions:

        1. What is the incidence of spontaneous dreams and recallable dreams while using different
           general anaesthesiological methods?

        2. What is the effect of perioperative suggestions and dreamfilm-formation training on the
           occurrence of dreams and recallable dreams in different general anaesthesiological
           techniques?

        3. What is influence of induction and maintance anaesthesia agents on the psychological
           methods?

        4. Finally the investigators intended to assess whether a relationship can be found between
           the content of the preoperatively administered suggestions and prepared dreamfilms as
           well as the postoperatively recalled dreams.

      Grouping of the patients

      Patients were randomly allocated into three groups according to the following aspects:

        1. In the control group spontaneous dreams of patients were assessed under conventionally
           managed anaesthesia without suggestions.

        2. In the suggestion group patients received suggestions evoking their images exclusively
           in the operating theatre at the time of narcosis induction. For this, patients were
           instructed to find out and fix a favourite place "where they want to travel" during
           anaesthesia.

        3. In the "dreamfilm group" the patients worked out a dreamfilm-plan using the favourite
           place technique one day prior to surgery. At the induction of narcosis, the series of
           images prepared by suggestions was evoked.

      In all three of the previously listed groups 3 further subgroups were formed based on the
      anaesthesiological technique used:

      Subgroup 1: anesthetic induction with etomidate (0,15-0,3 mg/kg), maintenance with
      sevoflurane (1 MAC(minimal alveolar concentration), low-flow technique), Subgroup 2:
      anesthetic induction with propofol (1,5-2,5 mg/kg), maintenance with sevoflurane (1 MAC,
      low-flow tchnique), Subgroup 3 (TIVA group): anesthetic induction with propofol (1,5-2,5
      mg/kg), maintenance with propofol (8-10 mg/kg/hour).

      Psychological methods used

      The "favourite place" technique" describes guided imagination of life events with the help of
      positive suggestions immediately before induction of anesthesia. In the operating theatre
      after the first measurements were made the patient was informed about what was going to
      happen, what sensation the induction agent would cause and was also told that the waking
      stimulus would be their name. We asked the patient not to pay attention to noises, only to
      what the anaesthetist said. The suggestion technique itself starts with a relaxation
      exercise, using suggestions promoting calm, deep breathing and muscle relaxation. In this
      pleasantly relaxed atmosphere positive suggestions help the patient to imagine their
      favourite place or activity where they feel calm, safe and happy. Acting as suggestions, our
      gestures, our actions, our touch and voice unwittingly evoke some effects in our patients.
      Suggestions help us in guiding the vivid imagination of our patients with an altered state of
      consciousness. The patient is not simply asked to remember an event, the aim is to produce a
      feeling that they are "virtually" there in their favourite place. Meanwhile the patient is
      involved in the imagination process in a dialogue form.

      "Dreamfilm method": Patients were met one day prior to surgery and asked to imagine and
      produce a film that they would like to "watch" during the anaesthesia. Thus, a "favourite
      place" is produced by the patients, featuring in the prepared dreamfilm that we evoke through
      suggestions at the time of the induction of narcosis.

      In both groups, the favourite place and the dreamfilm that was produced by the patient were
      recorded prior to anaesthesia by the physician for the sake of further analysis. All
      suggestions and anesthesias were performed by the same person (JGY), who is a certified and
      experienced anaesthetist and psychotherapist.

      Postanaesthetic management in the OR: After the patients were awakened, they were called by
      their names, and were informed where they were and that the operation had been finished.
      Thereafter they received amnesia-lifting suggestions, they were asked, before recovery of
      full consciousness, to retain their dreams and recall them so that later in the ward they
      could report them to the independent assistants. At this phase, all events related to the
      recovery period were recorded, including the patient's first reactions during the early
      recovery phase.

      Gathering data The patients were interviewed about their dreams and the postoperative
      questionnaires were filled by the department's assistants, 10 and 60 minutes after recovery,
      respectively. These were pretrained, independent (blind) staff personnel who were not aware
      of the grouping status of the patients. The postoperative questionnaire contained parameters
      of the patients ' general condition: blood pressure, pulse, complications, and communication.
      A pivotal part of this questionnaire were questions about the dream report. One section of
      the questionnaire concerned the assessment of the relationship between the anaesthetist and
      the patient (rapport) as well as of the team's work and the patient's anxiety level related
      to the procedure. (See Appendix)

      On the day of the study, the first author recorded the data of the questionnaires
      (preoperative and blinded-postoperative), the assessment of rapport by the anaesthetist (5:
      best mark, 1:

      worst mark) and the description of the association serving as "favourite place".

      Anaesthetic and monitoring techniques General anaesthesia as well as the suggestion
      techniques for patients in groups 2 and 3 were applied by a single physician (JGy). Midazolam
      (7,5- 15 mg) and atropin (0,5-1 mg) were administered per os one hour before anaesthetic
      induction as premedication in all patients. Induction and maintenance of anaesthesia was
      performed depending on the grouping status of the patients, as described above. In all three
      anaesthetic protocols, pain relief was achieved with fentanyl (0,02-0,05 mg/kg boluses),
      muscle relaxation with atracurium (0,5 mg/kg bolus, 0, 15mg/kg rep.), or with mivacurium (0,2
      mg/kg), depending on the length of surgery. Intratracheal intubation was performed in all
      cases, followed by a pressure controlled ventilation technique, using oxygen-air mixture,
      with Dräger Primus anaesthetic device. Monitoring was secured using an Dräger Infinity Kappa
      XLT monitor: as part of standard narcosis monitoring, non-invasive blood pressure, pulse
      oxymetry, capnography, ECG, and relaxometry were performed. Hypnotic depth was measured using
      a bispectral index monitor (BIS). Anaesthesia was managed to ensure that hypnotic depth
      measured by BIS was between 40 and 60 throughout the entire time elapsed between intubation
      and wound closure. Monitoring started at the time point before induction of anaesthesia and
      ended after total recovery of the patient, awake state of consciousness and return of
      adequate communication were reached. Postoperative analgesia: Tramadol (4x 1mg/kg) and
      metamizole (4x0,5-1 g) were used to reduce postoperative pain as was necessary for proper
      pain relief. Analgesia and anxiolysis measurements: The efficiency of analgesia was graded
      every hour by the patients based on the rating scale used in the Hungarian school assessments
      (5 being the best grade= no pain, 4= mild pain, 3= moderate pain, 2= strong pain, and 1=
      worst, intolerable pain).

      Statistical methods

      The statistical analysis was performed by SPSS 11.5 software. We used the following
      procedures and tests:

        -  χ²-test for independence of two variables, provided by the SPSS Crosstabs procedure. As
           is well known, it can be interpreted even as a test of homogeneity of distributions, and
           it was this purpose that it was used for.

        -  T-test for independent samples (we should have used the large samples version of the
           independent samples binomial test, however, the SPSS does not offer it, so we used the
           t-test instead, as these tests are asymptotically equivalent).

        -  One-sample binomial test. Dependent variables examined Patient report 10 and 60 minutes
           respectively after recovery about the appearance of a dream (yes/no).
    

Intervention name(s): control; suggestion; dreamfilm
Intervention type(s): Other; Other; Other
Intervention description(s): No psychological intervention; In the suggestion group patients received suggestions evoking their images of favourite place at the time of narcosis induction.; In the dreamfilm group patients worked out the dreamfilm plan using a favourite place technique one day prior to surgery. At the induction of anesthesia the series of images prepared by suggestions was evoked.
Allocation: Randomized
Intervention model: Parallel Assignment
Masking: Single (Investigator)
Keywords: anesthesia; modification of dreaming; suggestions