Joachim Nagel: Inflation tide after peak - what next?
Speech by Dr Joachim Nagel, President of the Deutsche Bundesbank, at the Central
Bank of Cyprus, Nicosia, 28 November 2023.
* * *
Check against delivery
1 Introduction
Ladies and gentlemen,
Thank you very much for inviting me to Cyprus. It's a pleasure to be here, to discuss
various economic issues and to share my views with you.
Nicosia is the easternmost capital city in both the European Union and the euro area.
As I learned during my flight, we are now more than two full degrees longitude east of
the Great Pyramid of Giza. Some people may think Cyprus is pretty much at the edge
of Europe. I don't think so. Cyprus is at the heart of Europe, and is home to some of
Europe's oldest and deepest roots.
Well-known ancient legends say the goddess Aphrodite went ashore in Paphos in
Cyprus. And according to the ancient Greek poet Moschus, it is thanks to a prophecy by
1
Aphrodite why our continent was given the name of the Phoenician princess Europe.
An image of this mythical princess Europe is looking at us from every euro banknote.
But it is not all about myths. The factual ancient history of Cyprus is very rich as well.
And again, this is reflected in our single currency: The Cypriot euro coins display the
Idol of Pomos. This prehistoric sculpture dates back to around 3,000 BC - and is hence
older than the Great Pyramid in Giza.
In my opinion, it is important for us Europeans to be aware of our common historic and
cultural heritage. The euro reminds us of this heritage. Or in the words of European
Central Bank President Christine Lagarde: These banknotes are part of our economy,
2
our identity and our culture."
Now allow me to leave the realm of ancient history and myths and touch upon the
challenges of the modern era. And naturally, as a central banker, I am most concerned
about the issue of price stability. In my speech, I will express my views on the current
inflation dynamics in the euro area and the latest ECB's monetary policy decisions.
However, before I do this, let me shortly elaborate on the economic outlook in the euro
area.
2 Economic outlook
We are currently observing a period of pronounced weakness in the euro area
economy. In the year to date, euro area real GDP has increased only slightly so far, and
it is not expected to make much progress in the fourth quarter, either. For one thing,
tighter monetary policy is curbing economic activity. Weak private consumption, which
has been weighed down by high inflation, and weak external demand are additional
dampening factors. The weakness is increasingly affecting the service sector.
According to the ECB's September economic projection, real GDP in the euro area will
grow by 0.7% this year. This is a downward revision of 0.2 percentage point compared
to the summer forecast. However, the euro area will probably not slide into a recession.
Indeed, economic growth is expected to strengthen in the course of 2024. First, driven
by strong wage increases and falling inflation rates, private consumption is set to
recover. And second, export activity are expected to gain more momentum. The ECB
staff projects real GDP in the euro area to expand at a rate of 1% next year and of 1.5%
in 2025.
In Germany, sluggish foreign demand for goods, but also high energy prices have
weighed heavily on the industrial sector. The Bundesbank expects the German
economy to contract this year. In contrast, the Cypriot economy benefited from buoyant
domestic demand. According to the recent CBC forecast, real GDP in Cyprus will
expand by 2.4% this year.3
3 Current inflation tide -
Inflation rates are expected to decrease over the next two years. This is encouraging.
Nevertheless, inflation has remained too high for too long. It is thus too early to declare
victory over inflation. Monetary policy has to stay the course. But let's start with a look
back where we came from.
Following a prolonged period of consistently low inflation, the euro area experienced a
swift surge in inflation throughout 2021. In July 2021, inflation surpassed our
mediumterm target, reaching 2.2%. By the end of 2021, inflation had climbed to 5%.
Nevertheless, at that point, economic forecasts were still suggesting a rapid decline.
The disruptions in supply chains and changes in demand composition were expected to
be short-lived. And hence the inflation increase was held to be temporary, stemming
from specific circumstances tied to the COVID-19 pandemic, and thus expected to soon
dissipate. That turned out to be wrong. After Russia had started its war of aggression
against Ukraine, energy and food prices skyrocketed. That drove inflation rates up
further. There was a substantial risk of high inflation becoming entrenched.
4 - and monetary policy response
So it was absolutely clear that monetary policy would have to act decisively. First, even
before starting to raise rates, we stopped purchasing additional assets in accordance
with the Governing Council's forward guidance. After we had ended net asset
purchases in July 2022, we raised our key interest rates by 50 basis points, thereby
bringing the era of negative interest rates to a halt in just one move. This was followed
by a further nine consecutive increases. In the meantime, we have raised interest rates
by a combined 450 basis points. This represents the largest and steepest rise ever in
the history of the European monetary union.
Additionally, our balance sheet has started to shrink. Over the past twelve months, the
volume of our balance sheet has decreased by 1,700 billion euros, which corresponds
to one-fifth. So far, the decline has mainly been driven by the expiration of the third
series of targeted longer-term refinancing operations (TLTRO III). Moreover, we have
phased out the reinvestment of maturing assets under the Asset Purchase Programme.
Now, the stock of APP assets is shrinking by roughly 25 billion euros each month.
Nevertheless, it is clear to me that the large balance sheet will have to shrink further
significantly.
It goes without saying that setting interest rates is and remains our most important tool
with which to combat high inflation. In this regard, we on the Governing Council
currently consider them to be at levels that will make a substantial contribution to
inflation returning to target in a timely manner. But these levels need to be maintained
for a sufficiently long period.
Moreover, that does not necessarily mean that the current hike cycle is now over. Of
course, it could be that, if the inflation outlook worsened, we might have to raise rates
again. The opposite case - inflation returning much faster to 2% - seems much less
probable to me. Therefore, it would be premature to lower interest rates soon or to
speculate about such steps. After all, it is not just the level of interest rates that matters
for the stance, but also expectations about the future path of interest rates. The main
effect of the policy tightening on inflation is yet to unfold.
While headline inflation has fallen significantly over the last months, we cannot take it
for granted that this decline will continue. The disinflationary effects of fallen energy
prices have dissipated and we are still a considerable distance away from our target
level. And we expect a bumpy road ahead, with ups and downs in inflation over the
near future.
In October, the inflation rate was slightly below 3% for the first time since July 2021. But
we will see a return of numbers with a three before the decimal point. This is largely the
result of a base effect. For example, in December 2022, the German government paid
the regular gas bills of households, which resulted in a very sharp decline of the price
level. Meanwhile, indicators of underlying inflation such as the core rate, which strips
out volatile energy and food prices, show that inflation dynamics continue to be strong.
In October, core inflation stood at 4.2%.
A timely return of inflation to 2% will be important for keeping inflation expectations in
check. If we failed, medium-to-long-term inflation expectations could lose their firm
anchoring at levels consistent with price stability. If that happened, we would expect an
impact on price-setting or wage-setting behaviour. Ultimately, this would require an
even stronger monetary policy response.
Of course, we take note of concerns that the current monetary policy stance might be
too restrictive for the economy. Some argue that lower interest rates would enable us to
increase economic growth without jeopardising price stability. But I fail to be convinced
by that reasoning. First of all, I am confident that we can avoid a "hard landing". The
tight labour market, low corporate and household debt levels and brisk investment
activity suggest that the conditions for a "soft landing" are in place. And secondly, it
could do more harm to the economy if we were to loosen too early and then have to
tighten again and even more strongly. Seen from a risk management approach, I would
prefer to err on the side of caution and ensure a timely return to price stability.
At our next Governing Council meeting in December, new staff projections will provide
important information for our decision-making. Our future decisions will continue to be
based on three pillars: our assessment of the medium-term inflation outlook in light of
the incoming data, the dynamics of underlying inflation, and our assessment regarding
the strength of the monetary policy transmission. As regards the transmission, I do not
see an overtightening. The transmission across financial markets is currently working
well. And the transmission to the real economy and to inflation is making progress.
5 Concluding remarks
Ladies and gentlemen,
The main effects of the Eurosystem's policy tightening on inflation are yet to unfold.
They are still needed - as underlying price pressures are still strong. Hence, we must
stay on course. It is my conviction that we must not loosen policy until we are certain of
returning to price stability on a lasting basis.
Thank you very much.
1
Kuhlmann, P. (2004), Moschos' Europa zwischen Artifizialität und Klassizismus: Der
Mythos als verkehrte Welt. Rheinisches Museum für Philologie, 147, S. 276-293.
2
Lagarde, C., Welcome address by Christine Lagarde, President of the ECB, on
signing the euro banknotes, 27 November 2019
3
Herodotou, C., Governor's Welcome Address at the 1st Central Bank of Cyprus
Annual Conference "The Role of Monetary Policy in Tackling Inflationary Pressures",
speech delivered on 4 October 2023.