Lawrence Schembri: Dual vision for the Canadian payments system
Remarks by Mr Lawrence Schembri, Deputy Governor of the Bank of Canada, to the
Canadian Payments Association, Charlottetown, Prince Edward Island, 27 June 2014.
* * *
Introduction
Thank you. It is a privilege and pleasure to be here with you today at this important
conference.
As many of you know, the Bank of Canada has a strong interest in the evolution of our
payments system that goes well beyond our role as purveyor of the simplest form of payment
- cash. This interest stems not only from our oversight responsibility for systemically
important payment systems under the Payment Clearing and Settlement Act, but also from
the important role these systems play in the transmission of monetary policy. Indeed, working
with you and other stakeholders to improve payments falls squarely within our mandate to
promote the economic and financial welfare of Canada.
Today, I want to share with you a dual vision for Canada's payments system and its
oversight. While I won't claim that all of the elements of this vision are original, I hope that by
articulating it, we can begin a much-needed dialogue on how to improve our payments
system and move it into the 21st century.
Canada's payments system is undergoing rapid and fundamental change. The bulk of it is
driven by the combined forces of technological innovation and the desire of consumers to
realize the benefits, most notably the convenience, of new technologies.
But is all of this rapid change going in the right direction? Is it sufficiently coordinated? Is it
safe? Is it sound? Are users' interests well protected?
These are important questions. And addressing them represents the important challenges
we all face.
We must respond - in a coherent and far-sighted manner. Payment systems matter to
Canadians. Every year, we make approximately 24 billion payments, worth more than
$44 trillion. These payments not only affect our daily lives, but they also have a profound
impact on the effectiveness of our financial system in promoting economic activity, both here
in Canada and externally.
To coordinate our response and ensure that we are progressing in the right direction, we
need a dual vision for Canada's payments system and its oversight, one that promotes
efficiency-enhancing innovation while managing the risks associated with the adoption of
new technologies.
My address today will contain three important elements:
First, a vision for our payments system - one that meets the evolving needs of consumers
and businesses and thereby supports productivity growth and improving living standards.
Second, a vision for the oversight of the payments system - one that helps to ensure its
safety and soundness, its efficiency and its security.
And third, a coordinated approach for achieving this dual vision - one that calls on the
payments industry and regulatory agencies to work together to attain this collective goal.
A vision for the payments system
In considering a vision for the payments system, let's take a holistic perspective.1 The
oftenused distinction between retail payment systems, which involve many end-users and smaller
transactions, and wholesale or interbank payment systems, may not be appropriate when
considering a vision for the future. Instead, a more comprehensive view reflects a future in
which technological change will allow retail and wholesale systems to offer similar services
and thereby compete more directly for a share of the same payments pie.
My vision for the payments system draws from work that has already been done in Canada
and in other jurisdictions to map out a desirable path for the future evolution of payments.
We are not alone in wanting to move toward an innovative, safe and secure payments
system that evolves to meet the needs of consumers and businesses. This vision maintains
the best characteristics of our legacy system, while allowing for the advantages that
innovations promise.
Such a payments system has six essential attributes:2
(i) high speed - end-to-end processing in near real time;
(ii) low cost - efficient and convenient;
(iii) open access and ubiquitous usage;
(iv) improved cross-border functionality;
(v) safe, sound and reliable; and
(vi) secure - to protect the private information of users.
I will consider the first four attributes now and leave the last two for the discussion of the
vision for oversight.3
Comparing Canada's existing payments system to this vision, it is clear there are many
gaps.4 In particular, in this era of instant communication, Canadians expect to be able to
send and receive payments faster, at any time, and at low cost, without having to know the
recipients' banking information.
Some progress has been made, however.
The wider use of digital payments technology has increased speed, lowered costs and
broadened access to the payments market. For example, between 2008 and 2011, the
number of credit and debit card payments rose by 23 per cent and 17 per cent respectively.5
1
An example of an all-encompassing definition of a payments system is: a set of "arrangements that allow
consumers, businesses and other organizations to transfer value from one party to another. It includes the
institutions, instruments and services that facilitate the transfer of value between parties in a transaction." See
Task Force for the Payments System Review, Going Digital: Transitioning to Digital Payments, Chapter 1
(n.d.): 8.
2
These attributes are discussed in: Task Force for the Payments System Review, "The Way We Pay:
Transforming the Canadian Payments System" (July 2011); Canadian Payments Association, "CPA Payments
Strategy: Vision 2020" (February 2010); The Federal Reserve Banks, "Payment System Improvement - Public
Consultation Paper" (September 2013); Reserve Bank of Australia, "Strategic Review of Innovation in the
Payments System: Conclusions" (June 2012).
3
The use of global payment message standards will help to ensure the necessary information content to
facilitate achievement of the first four attributes.
4
See, for example, Task Force for the Payments System Review, "The Way We Pay: Transforming the
Canadian Payments System" (July 2011).
5
Canadian Payments Association, "Examining Canadian Payment Methods and Trends" (October 2012).
Electronic funds transfers continue to replace cheques for bill payments and payroll
transactions.6
Although there are fewer users, electronic person-to-person and e-wallet transactions have
grown at the impressive rate of about 40 per cent annually over the same period.7 And then
there are the new kids on the block - digital currencies - which, while more limited in market
penetration, have the potential to be game-changers by achieving low-cost, faster,
end-toend payments.
These innovations meet the important attributes of speed, convenience, lower costs and
efficiency, but fall short when it comes to ubiquity. New payment systems will only realize
their full potential when they attain the universal participation that legacy systems enjoy.
Despite many advances, the expression "the cheque is in the mail" is still a reality for many
Canadian businesses. The recent Task Force for the Payments System Review highlighted
that our businesses are still among the most cheque-reliant of the major economies.8 What is
needed is an electronic invoice and payment system to facilitate the end-to-end automated
processing of business-to-business payments.9
We also need to improve significantly cross-border payments. An analysis by the Canadian
Payments Association (CPA) revealed that international payment needs are not currently
being met.10 Compared with domestic payments, cross-border payments involve higher
transaction costs and longer processing times associated with converting from one national
payment system to another.
To achieve these four important characteristics, our core national payment clearing and
settlement systems should be upgraded. The Automated Clearing Settlement System
(ACSS) was implemented in the early 1980s, and is showing its age. Access is limited,
settlement occurs the next day and end-to-end processing of payments is slow. The Large
Value Transfer System (LVTS) was implemented in 1999. It, too, could benefit from
technological enhancements to clear and settle both retail and wholesale payments more
efficiently.
A vision for oversight
To complement this vision for the payments system, we also need a new, more
comprehensive vision for its oversight. The arrival of new players in the retail payments
market calls for a fundamental overhaul of the Canadian oversight framework. As new
systems compete with existing core systems, important public policy issues emerge.
The goal is to create a level playing field for all systems, taking into account that some pose
more risk than others. We achieve this through a holistic oversight approach that
encompasses three broad types of payment systems:
(i) systemically important systems;
(ii) prominent payment systems; and
(iii) other national retail payment systems.
Such an approach will reinforce the efforts of the payments industry to achieve three
important public policy objectives:11
(i) safety and soundness;
(ii) efficiency; and
(iii) meeting users' needs and protecting their interests.12
Like vital public utilities such as power and water, core national payment systems must be
both safe and sound to ensure continuous operations. They must be designed and operated
to ensure that risk is effectively managed, using international standards,13 and providing open
risk-based access and ubiquitous coverage. Core systems need to be efficient to remain
competitive by keeping costs low. These key attributes will help to ensure that the critical
mass of participation required to realize economies of scale and maximize social benefits will
be achieved.
The Bank of Canada is working with the Department of Finance to develop a new
comprehensive framework for the oversight of payment systems that articulates this vision. It
needs to be flexible, forward looking, and risk-based to meet public policy objectives, even as
payment systems evolve and new trends emerge.
The challenge is to find the balance between ensuring safety and promoting efficiency. The
oversight framework must instill confidence in the payments system and foster innovation
and competition to meet user needs, support economic growth and promote financial
stability. New players that are not currently subject to the same comprehensive regulatory
oversight as traditional incumbents must be brought into the framework.
In this vision, the Bank of Canada may play a larger role by overseeing prominent payment
systems, in addition to those that are systemically important.14 Through this expanded role,
within the new oversight framework, we would be able to help maintain a safe and efficient
payment infrastructure, even as the market responds to emerging trends and end-user
needs.
What would this potential change in the Bank's role mean for the CPA? Initial analysis
indicates that the CPA's ACSS exhibits characteristics of a prominent payment system and
therefore could be subject to Bank of Canada oversight.15
The vision for the other national retail payment systems is that they, too, would be subject to
oversight that is proportional to risks. While newer retail systems are not systemically
important or prominent, end-user protection is of particular importance. For instance, most
collect information about users, which has commercial value. Safeguards should be in place
to protect this information.
11
See the Canadian Payments Act (S.C. 1996, c. 6, Sch.), available at laws.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/p-
4.4/index.html.
12
Users' interests can be defined broadly to include service level expectations, convenience, ease of use, price,
safety, transparency of terms of use, privacy and effective redress mechanisms.
13
International standards for the oversight of systemically important payments systems are defined by the
CPSS-IOSCO "Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures" (Committee on Payment and Settlement
Systems and Technical Committee of the International Organization of Securities Commissions, April 2012).
14
Prominent payment systems do not pose systemic risk but a disruption or failure could cause, on a national
scale, significant disruption to the ability of consumers and businesses to make payments or a general loss of
confidence in the overall payments system.
15
The Bank of Canada could apply standards to prominent payments systems, based on the CPSS-IOSCO
"Principles for Financial Market Infrastructures" (CPSS-IOSCO, April 2012). These standards would be
adjusted so that they reflect the different nature and magnitude of the risks posed by prominent payments
systems.
Achieving the dual vision: private-public collaboration
Now that I have sketched out the dual vision for the payments system in Canada and for its
oversight, the next question is: How do we achieve it?
A simple one-word answer would be: Together!
In this context, "together" can have two meanings, but to be successful in moving toward this
dual vision, both are important.
Consumers, the payments industry and regulatory agencies all have an important stake in a
well-functioning state-of-the-art payments system. All should be consulted. Finding the right
solutions and the right balance will require collaboration from all those who have a role in
reaching our vision. I trust you agree that forums such as this conference, FinPay,16 and the
CPA's Stakeholder Advisory Council should be leveraged for this purpose.
In addition, public sector proposals for changing the regulatory and oversight landscape will
go through a public consultation process that will allow constructive input from all
stakeholders.
Conferring together is important. So, too, is acting together. If the payments industry can
adopt the same standards at approximately the same time, we can maximize the benefits
accruing from the positive network effects associated with widely used standardized
transactions.
Achieving this will require three additional "c" words beyond consultation: namely,
coordination, collaboration and co-operation.
Clearly, the CPA and the public agencies are well placed to help coordinate and encourage
collaboration and co-operation by industry.
The CPA and its members can take the lead by embracing new technology to upgrade core
clearing and settlement services to enhance efficiency and safety.
The CPA has taken bold - and welcome - steps in this direction by promoting the adoption
of the ISO 20022 standards and launching the Next Generation Clearing and Settlement
System project.
Using a common standard forms the foundation for any well-designed payment system.
Standards such as ISO 20022 facilitate straight-through processing, enhanced
business-tobusiness payments, interoperability, and faster funds transfers for end-users, both
domestically and across borders.17
Adopting a common standard will also reduce the barriers that prevent new players from
using core systems for clearing and settlement.
To be truly successful and to benefit all Canadians, co-operation on the implementation of
standards is essential. Giving consumers and businesses what they need and what they
want is no easy task, but it is an inescapable one. Those who do not innovate will be left
behind in today's globally competitive world.
Conclusion
Let me wrap up.
Looking ahead, we all want to embrace technological change to improve the payments
system in Canada and promote the economic and financial welfare of Canadians. For this
purpose, we need a complementary dual vision to guide the changes in both the payments
system and its oversight. Innovation is driving a rapid evolution - one that requires planning
as pointed out more than 10 years ago by my former colleague, James Dingle. He wrote a
short book about the history of the CPA titled, Planning an Evolution.18 If we were to write a
similar book covering the next 20 challenging, but promising, years in the life of the CPA, we
might want to modify the title somewhat to Planning a Revolution.
When it comes to monetary policy, the Bank is committed to achieving our 2 per cent inflation
target - the best contribution that monetary policy can make to keeping the Canadian
economy on a sustainable growth path. In recent months, we have said that economic
growth needs to become more balanced and broadly based, with more growth coming
through exports and related business investment.
Let me connect this with the vision for the payments system that I've described today: One of
the ways we can promote trade-driven growth is to work with our trading partners to reduce
substantially the costs of cross-border payments. And, of course, a well-functioning
payments system is a crucial element of an efficient financial system, which is, in turn, a key
ingredient of sustained economic growth.
As industry and the public sector work together to improve our payments system, we will
count on the CPA to continue to play a key role. At this pivotal point in time, we have a
oncein-a-generation opportunity to shape the future of Canada's payments system. And we
should act on it.
We look forward to continued dialogue and collaboration as our shared vision becomes
reality.
Thank you very much.