Sabine Mauderer: Turning ambition into action - the importance of
transition plans for the green transition
Speech by Dr Sabine Mauderer, Member of the Executive Board of the Deutsche
Bundesbank, at the UN Climate Change Conference COP 27, German Pavilion, Sharm
el-Sheikh, 9 November 2022.
* * *
1 Introduction
Ladies and gentlemen,
We have come a long way since the "Earth Summit" in Rio de Janeiro 30 years ago.
And yet, to limit global warming to 1.5 degrees, we will have to step up climate action
and scale up climate finance. Driving forward the green transition will require substantial
public-sector and private-sector engagement and financing.
Let me briefly touch upon three aspects:
1. transition plans
2. scenario analyses and stress tests
3. the role of central banks and supervisors.
2 Transition plans
Financial market actors play a key role in scaling up climate finance. To make informed
investment decisions, they need reliable, comparable and forward-looking data. Solid
and credible transition plans that lay out how financial institutions and corporates plan
to achieve their climate ambitions give investors a better idea if a company or a project
is worth investing in.
The United Kingdom has been a pioneer when it comes to transition plans. As from
next year, companies listed in the UK must put forward transition plans. In the EU,
mandatory disclosure of transition plans could become part of the upcoming Corporate
Sustainability Reporting Directive. However, there are lots of moving parts with regard
to transition plans.
Open questions include:
What types of risks should be addressed, for example, physical or transition
climate risks? Should the risks related to the loss of biodiversity also be
considered?
Which corporates should have to publish transition plans? Big corporates, all
listed companies or only certain industries?
Last but not least: Who will check these transition plans, and against which
standards?
3 Scenario analayses
While much about transition plans is still up in the air, more experience is available with
regard to scenario analyses. Scenario analyses can be a valuable strategic planning
tool for companies because they can simulate the outcomes of different sets of factors.
This feature can make scenario analyses an important part of transition plans. They
allow the resilience of transition plans to be assessed under a variety of scenarios.
Scenario analyses are also a valuable source of information for central banks and
supervisors and can feed into stress testing exercises. This enables central banks and
supervisors to gauge the risk exposure of individual institutions as well as of the
financial system and the economy as a whole. This summer, ECB Banking Supervision
ran a climate stress test that showed that many banks still have their work cut out for
them when it comes to managing climate risks.
4 NGFS climate scenarios
That stress test was based on a set of scenarios developed by the Network for
Greening the Financial System (NGFS). The NGFS is a network of more than 120
central banks and supervisors that aims to support sustainable transformation.
The NGFS scenarios help quantify the economic impacts of different emission and
policy pathways. The most recent update considered physical risks for the first time and
took an improved look at regional and sectoral factors. The NGFS is continuing to
upgrade the scenarios and their practical usability - also with a view to transition plans.
The NGFS is working out how transition plans relate to supervisors' roles and mandates
and how they could become part of the supervisory toolkit.
5 Conclusion
Many aspects of transition plans are still up for discussion. The same is true for the role
of supervisors when it comes to checking these plans. Events like this are good
opportunities to consider such fundamental questions. So let us discuss ways forward
and find common ground internationally. The goal is clear: to define ambitions and to
turn these ambitions into actions.