Joachim Nagel: Anchoring monetary stability in people's minds
Speech by Dr Joachim Nagel, President of the Deutsche Bundesbank, at the
conference marking the tenth anniversary of the Alliance for Monetary and Financial
Stability (Aktionskreis Stabiles Geld), Frankfurt am Main, 22 June 2023.
* * *
Check against delivery
1 Introduction
Ladies and gentlemen, honoured guests,
It is my pleasure to welcome you to this year's Bundesbank symposium on "Banking
supervision in dialogue" - I truly regret that I cannot be there in person to speak to you
today.
Our colleagues who are there, in particular Mr Walch and Ms Braun-Munzinger, will
represent us perfectly, however. Claudia Buch and I have been invited to the Federal
Cabinet this morning to advise the government on the Federal budget which will
subsequently be adopted by the Cabinet. Ms Buch, our Vice-President and also, since
April, the Executive Board member responsible for banking and financial supervision,
will also be delivering the first virtual keynote of the day in a moment. My special thanks
go to the President of BaFin, Mark Branson, who will be our second keynote speaker.
Ladies and gentlemen, on 8 October 2020, during the first year of the pandemic, "The
1
Economist" published a piece with the evocative title "The eternal zero". The sub-title
was even more compelling: The pandemic will leave a legacy of even lower interest
rates. Well, this eternity wasn't particularly long in the end. There is a certain irony in
the fact that it was precisely the economic consequences of the pandemic that proved
to be an important reason for the current interest rate reversal.
Exactly two years ago, the euro area inflation rate surpassed the 2% mark, after we had
even seen negative rates for a short while during the first year of the pandemic. This
would prove to be the beginning of a dramatic climb lasting over fifteen months, with
inflation reaching an interim peak in the double digits.
The Governing Council of the ECB had to respond, and it did so resolutely. The
reversal of monetary policy interest rates will certainly have an impact on the situation in
the banking sector - and already is having an impact, in fact. That is also an important
topic for this symposium - and will be addressed right after the two speeches this
morning. I would like to use my speech to set the framework for this by explaining our
monetary policy decisions and briefly discussing where our monetary policy might go
from here. That said, I wouldn't be able to fully put things in context without briefly
describing the current economic situation and inflation developments. Let me start there.
2 Economic developments
The energy crisis put a considerable strain on the German economy in the winter
halfyear. While it was possible to significantly mitigate the effects of the energy crisis last
year, the German economy was still in a "technical" recession around the turn of the
year. Technical recession is the term used when real gross domestic product declines
in two consecutive quarters.
In this setting, high inflation weighed on private consumption, in particular. From the
spring onwards, the German economy is likely to have returned to an expansionary,
albeit moderate, path, with the strong wage increases expected to have stabilised
consumption spending despite the high inflation.
However, according to the Bundesbank 's June projections, real gross domestic product
2
in Germany is set to contract by 0.3% on average in 2023. The weak start to the year
is still making itself felt here. For next year, our economic experts expect growth of
1.2%.
3 Inflation
Looking at prices, in particular, shows just how extraordinary economic developments
were last year. According to the national consumer price index, consumer prices in
Germany rose by an average of 6.9% in 2022 - the strongest increase since 1974. And
measured by the Harmonised Index of Consumer Prices (HICP), that figure was even
as high as 8.7%. In the euro area as a whole, the HICP increased by 8.4%, the highest
rate since the introduction of the euro.
To the general public, the current wave of inflation is mainly associated with Russia's
attack on Ukraine. The geopolitical conflict did, in fact, lead to a dramatic rise in energy
prices over a year ago. But inflation had already picked up earlier, in the second half of
2021.
What made that happen? Back then, the global economy was recovering unexpectedly
quickly from the slump caused by the pandemic. As a result, energy prices rose
sharply. Moreover, the pandemic led to excess demand for certain consumer goods.
Industry was no longer able to keep up with enough supply. The outcome was supply
bottlenecks in a number of sectors - partly also due to pandemic-related closures. This
further intensified the upward pressure on prices.
Energy prices have now come back down significantly. This means that inflation is
gradually cooling again. But it is too early to sound the all-clear, because inflation has
become more broad-based overall. Our June projections show the inflation rate in
Germany remaining high for the time being. The ECB's June projections for the euro
3
area tell a similar story. They indicate that HICP inflation in the euro area is likely to be
5.4% this year. Only in 2025 will it start to move back towards our target of 2%.
4 Current monetary policy
But price stability is not going to appear out of nowhere, as if by magic. It requires a
decisive monetary policy response. And that is precisely what we on the Governing
Council have delivered. Over the past 12 months, we have raised our key interest rates
by a total of 400 basis points. That is the largest and fastest run of interest rate hikes in
the history of the euro area. We have brought net asset purchases to an end. From the
start of this month, we have also completely discontinued reinvestments under the APP
programme.
5 Future interest rate developments
However, I do not believe we have reached the end of the tightening path yet. As things
stand, interest rates will need to rise further. Currently, though, it is impossible to tell
how high they will still need to go. Nor can we say how long they will remain high or
where they will go after that. That all depends on how on inflation develops, which is
highly uncertain. Given this uncertainty, we are not currently providing a precise
"interest rate outlook" or forward guidance in our monetary policy communication.
In my view, this high level of uncertainty applies to both the short and the long term. In
the short run, for example, wages could rise more sharply than expected. That would
prolong the wave of inflation via second-round effects. The high prices for energy,
commodities and other intermediate products could also be passed through to end
customers to a greater degree than current projections suggest.
Looking at the longer term, there are also a number of developments that could push up
inflation. Let me give you two examples. First, we are now seeing a geopolitical
transformation that is probably without precedent in this century. The Russian war of
aggression is a significant factor in this, and there are also other geopolitical tensions
and, overall, a risk of geopolitical fragmentation. Second, climate change and the
necessary decarbonisation of the economy will require far-reaching adjustments.
Macroeconomic developments are therefore highly uncertain. Here, we can learn from
history. The period of high inflation in the 1970s was also accompanied by geopolitical
turmoil and energy supply challenges. With hindsight, we can now see that unanchored
inflation expectations were a key reason why inflation remained so persistently high at
4
that time. Some important lessons from that period are: don't let inflation expectations
become unanchored, don't shy away from a strong monetary policy response and don't
ease up too soon.
However, geopolitical and thus also geo-economic fragmentation could also cause a
lasting increase in price pressures. For example, UK economist Charles Goodhart
suspects that globalisation - above all, China's integration into the global economy -
5
has been an important factor in the low inflation rates of recent decades. Economic
fragmentation could therefore increase price pressures over an extended period of time.
And a lasting increase in price pressures would also require a lasting tightening of
monetary policy.
Overall, however, empirical evidence for the impact of globalisation on inflation is mixed.
6
Above all, the extent of this effect is subject to dispute and difficult to distinguish from
other factors. For example, the subdued inflation dynamics since the early 1990s could
also have resulted from the increasing stability orientation of monetary policy in many
countries. That would, of course, be good news for us; price stability could then be
achieved with less effort. But I will not count on it. In these complex circumstances, I am
wary of declaring a new era of high interest rates.
6 Closing remarks
Ladies and gentlemen, it is only human to zone in on the latest news when assessing a
situation. It is easy to overemphasise the present. In behavioural economics, this effect
is called recency bias. I think a prime example of this is the Economist article I
mentioned at the beginning of my speech, which assumed there would be zero interest
rates forever.
One thing is clear: the era of zero interest rates is over for now. But the truth is also that
we don't know what the future holds or what circumstances we will face in a few years'
time. What we do know, however, is that monetary policy will do what is needed to
overcome high inflation. It is important for banks and other financial market players to
be prepared for this. Communication between central banks, supervisory authorities
and the banking sector is vital to avoid falling victim to recency bias and making costly
misjudgements.
I am confident that this gathering will make a very valuable contribution to this aim, and
I hope it will bring forth some fascinating discussions and insights.
Thank you for your attention.
1
The Economist, The eternal zero, 10 October 2020.
2
Deutsche Bundesbank , Arduous recovery amid high and only gradually easing
inflation - outlook for the German economy up to 2025, Monthly Report, June 2023.
3
European Central Bank, Eurosystem staff macroeconomic projections for the euro
area, June 2023.
4
Reis, R. (2021), Losing the Inflation Anchor, Brookings Papers on Economic Activity,
BPEA Conference Drafts.
5
Goodhart, C. and M. Pradhan (2020), The Great Demographic Reversal - Ageing
Societies, Waning Inequality, and an Inflation Revival, Palgrave.
6
European Central Bank (2021), The implications of globalisation for the ECB
monetary policy strategy, Occasional Paper No 263.