Mario Draghi: Interview with Bild Zeitung
Interview with Mr Mario Draghi, President of the European Central Bank, in BILD Zeitung,
conducted by Messrs Kai Diekmann, Editor in Chief, Nikolaus Blome, Deputy Editor in
Chief, on 19 March 2012 and published on 23 March 2012.
* * *
Part I
BILD: President Draghi, when it was clear that you were to become head of the European
Central Bank, BILD made a photomontage of you wearing a Prussian spiked helmet and
called you a "true German". What did you think of that?
I really liked it. The Prussian element is a good symbol of the ECB's key task:
Mario Draghi:
to maintain price stability and to protect European savers.
BILD: For Germans, a central bank chief must take a strict line on inflation, be politically
independent and favour a strong euro. In that light, how German are you?
Draghi: These are indeed German virtues. But every central banker in the euro area should
have them.
The French President said that Europe should learn from the German model...
BILD:
Draghi: ...he's right. Long before him I said that Germany is a model. The old European
welfare state model is in fact dead, because it had to make debts far too often. The Germans
have re-invented it - with no excessive debts.
BILD: Do you have a message for the people of Germany?
Draghi: Keep it up!
BILD: The ever-present fear of devaluation, of inflation, is typically German. Can you
understand that?
Draghi: In the twentieth century the people of this country suffered terribly because of
inflation. It destroys wealth and makes planning impossible. What's more, it can really
destroy the fabric of a society.
BILD: Why then, as ECB President, are you allowing euro area inflation to currently stand at
2.7%, significantly more than the ECB's objective?
Draghi: Hold on. If you exclude the price of oil and recent tax increases by many
governments, the inflation rate has been stable for months at 1.5%. Should the inflation
outlook get worse, we will immediately take preventive steps. And look at the facts, they
speak for themselves. Since the founding of the ECB the yearly average inflation rate has
been better than in any comparable period prior to the euro.
BILD: In two moves, the ECB has put almost €1 trillion into circulation. That's inflationary,
surely?
The banks to which the ECB has lent the money have, by and large, not fed this into
Draghi:
the economic cycle but have used it to meet old liabilities. So the money in terms of inflation
has, so to speak, been neutralised. This action is not inflationary. And we will watch very
carefully if and how the money is fed into the economic cycle.
BILD: But the head of Germany's Bundesbank, Jens Weidmann, has issued a sharp warning
about this flood of money.
Draghi: I get on very well with Jens Weidmann both professionally and personally. Our
difference of opinion has been blown up.
Was he exaggerating?
BILD:
Draghi: He is a typical central banker, like all of us. We like to worry about things that
nobody else worries about. And of course there are risks and side effects if you use such a
strong drug, such as the almost €1 trillion of central bank money. It was right of Jens
Weidmann to point that out and I agree with him.
BILD: Is there a rift between north and south in the Governing Council?
Draghi: No, there is no divide between north and south. All members of the Governing
Council have taken to heart Germany's stability culture. The time of conflicts is over. But let
me also say that the situation in the autumn was really critical. It could have led to a
dangerous credit crunch at the banks and thus to bankruptcies; companies would have
suddenly been left sitting high and dry financially. We had to prevent that.
BILD: And the banks are doing nicely out of it, right?
Draghi: The ECB's money has got to the right places. In Germany alone, 460 banks
participated in the action, many more than usual. So it wasn't just the acutely suffering
banks, but also many others, many of them small. That particularly helps the small and
medium-sized companies that account for 70% of all jobs in Europe.
BILD: This all sounds very optimistic. Is the euro then a safe currency?
Yes, it is.
Draghi:
BILD: Is the crisis over?
Draghi: The worst is over, but there are also still risks. The situation is stabilising. The key
data for the euro area, such as inflation, the balances of payments and in particular budget
deficits, are better than in the United States, for example. Investors are regaining their trust
and the ECB has not had to provide support by buying government bonds for several weeks
now. It is now up to the governments. They must make the euro area crisis-proof in a
sustainable manner
BILD: If it were your birthday today, what would you want from the German government and
the Chancellor?
Draghi: Trust the ECB. Trust Europe.
Part II
BILD: There is no end to the crisis in Greece. Yet again, more than €100 billion of credit is to
be given to them. But isn't the country a bottomless pit?
Draghi: The Greeks have passed very many important reforms in parliament. If they also
implement these, the country has a chance to get itself out of the current downward spiral.
BILD: But the parties that reject the reforms will be the ones that win in the upcoming
elections.
Draghi: To overcome the crisis, Greece needs a stable political situation.
BILD: Why should taxpayers in Germany and other euro area countries be liable if it goes
wrong?
Draghi: The fact is that European taxpayers have taken on a lot for Greece. Their money
must be protected. This is also why the ECB did not take part in the debt relief - because the
cost would have been borne by taxpayers.
BILD: How much time does Greece have left?
Some reforms can take effect very quickly. For example, a tax reform and better
Draghi:
tax collection would spread the tax burden more fairly. That is a strong incentive to work
more - and this will get the economy quickly back on its feet.
BILD: Many experts now think that the only way for Greece to become competitive again is if
it leaves the euro area.
Draghi: As a matter of principle, the ECB does not give any thought to a country leaving the
euro area.
BILD: Nevertheless...
Draghi: Leaving the euro area and having the possibility to devalue their own currency would
not improve anything. It would not remove the need for reform. In fact, the consequences of
leaving the euro area would be high inflation and instability - and, for the foreseeable future,
nobody would lend Greece the money it needed.
BILD: Will the Greeks in any case have to give up their prosperity?
Draghi: Yes, they are renouncing exactly that as a result of wage cuts across all sectors. But
this is still easier to do inside the euro area rather than outside it.
BILD: Is there a limit to the support? Or will it just continue like this?
Draghi: I can't answer that. We will have to see how things develop in the country. Generally
speaking, the fact remains that if we want to protect taxpayers' money, the euro area cannot
be turned into a transfer union, where one or two countries provide the money, the rest
spend, and the whole thing is financed by joint Eurobonds. That cannot happen.
BILD: Many parties, also in Germany, are calling for that.
Draghi: A community must be founded on trust - trust that shared rules will be adhered to,
for example, with regard to budgetary discipline. That is why the new fiscal pact among euro
area states is the right thing and why Eurobonds would be premature.
BILD: Is the German Chancellor's stance winning through?
Draghi: Let me put it this way: without pressure from the markets and from the Germans,
much of the progress we have made in the various euro area countries would not have been
possible.
BILD: How often do you speak on the telephone with the Chancellor?
Draghi: Not very often. The ECB is very mindful of its independence. And the Chancellor
fully respects this.