The Statesman.
London, England, 1820-12-06 00:00:00

THF: STATESMAN.

-ILeistiurting T4eli.gistcr in rotoideration of his tr. it The Cote,' „Goitre—You aboall not state that, Mr
ile mud the tisk he ran of publishing. it. lite .I,_ Co!Armor any thing which you cannot pretest.
Mr. COBBETT—I could hart ',roved the
l main of whet
fentlant reposed is 111111A1/1 unbounded discretion as
to what articles he should insert, •t, or alter.— I have said, if Major Cartwright had been aeldneed.
Litametitnes he accordingly altered otE•nrive Words The Cutts Josilec—f Icave•nu aisli wisaterell to Ito
terropt or to restrain yon: but I am analog. to conduct
which were too strung, and toni: hal passagt a altogether. this cause Demoting to thin rules which prevail upon
In the libels in question he left out the words mitt- every other trial.
cosec/ and reptile, which acre rot unsparingly used • Mr. Cononyr, aslverting to what the Learned INotnarl
a, applied to Mr. Cleary. lie never declined to pub., bad %aid with revert to the Ilrestininster Eletoion, at
Haft altogether any number:: a hit li had been sent to int.:l:trill': Major
bynuts he aii„,,lrd hart been, be could have shewin
himself at liberty to du so. Since the libels appeared that clean- seas not the person entitled to complicit), ;ts
he had become acquainted with the plaintiff, but not lie was actually the to rzreasar in publishing a private
intimately. Ile had inserted a letter from Mr. Cleary, letter, iwiiroper!y oht.iier,l from II treaehrrons agent,
upon the subject of the libel, as a measure of justice fur the impose of scandaliaitio a particular candidate at
to Mr. Cleary, whom he considered as hat ing been that riqriiiiii, and involving. him (Mr. rehbett) in a
quitro.l with this eamlidate. If Major Cartwright had
ill-nerd. lie also inserted coniutuoicatious from Ha brew atlelored as a witness. he should also have citron
jor Cartwright. He had received the letter addressed that *hide the Major would no doubt li:eyeball the jois-
t° the Fdiosr of ne New 14,.k Mulling- Post. front tier to admit, that he hail Ownss and decidedly disap.
Mr. Cobbrtt, in a printed form. He bad general in- proved of three poiltieal club., to promote the establish-
atructions to insert the defendant's cot 1111 l unications, merit of which Cleary was titecially employed. lie dis-
hut did not rerbilect any particular instruction's as to approved of such chat... liremiae he eould• nut help re-
tling them as so ae nets. over vraieh the
the alleged lilwis. Ile could not recollect any rarti-
a"ernts of liiirernmeutm minyghtlittl s at any time cast heir nets.
ettlar writing of the defendant itiscrihed.in Hsi first .414 the tre,,indli„ter Election, alluded to in this "se, it
'toter from New York. Witness further deposed that worth! he ttoollreted, that Major Cartwright and Mr.
Mr. C"l'hett had never complained to him in writings limit a ere canclitlatea, as well as Sir Francis Burdett.—
or otherwise. of any alterations which he had thonirht Cleary was at the outset an advocate for the Major, hut
proper to make in the mane-tries t transmitted to him be afterwards joined the standard of the Baronet and the
from America. Romp. and to them he entlraviturcol with others to per-
Mulyneex, the Printer of the Re gister at the `wade Mr. Hunt to yield his pretensions; but faitn, Alr.
Hunt wonlel not re;igit. Thence a controversy more,
time the al'eged libels were published, deposed that and Mr. Hunt thought proper to read a letter of Cleary's,
• he received the manuscripts from Jackson, with an it, which the latter eNpreated his readiness ilk beeome
order for their insertion. Upon his cross-examination. . he hangman of the tinfortntottr Herby people, whoeotn.;
by Mr. Cobbett, this witness stetted that hr knew these posed one of the nests formed by "liiiaself, and over I
who, whit-1'01;1,er threw his net. Bat whatever were the I
papers to be the manuscript of Mr. Cobbett.
he had sent write. He tool seen Ur. 1.'., about three 1
mists
of this controeray, or the provocation
years ago, write an order upon 'Tipp, r anti Fry, the t VIII hr I leary, lie,v olio was :It the time in Amm .
rica, had no - concern whatever aids it, and it I
stationers for some paper, wax obviously unjust, as ajar). of limiest men most feel,
'fhe case for the plaintiff being closed, Mr. CORBETT I that he slionld stiffer for the talecontltict of others; yet
was called upon for his defence. Ile began by express- Cleary, sit!, the consent, or rather at the iustiitation
ing his assurance that many of the Learned Advocates; of the Rump Committee, thong lit popop.o to inflict this
about him mere competent to conduct his defence a its I suffering upon him. To-day as well as on other o..ea-
more ability and effect than he could, but there were shots, complaint was made to him for hat ing called the
reasons a bids determined him to nadertake that task letter alluded to a forgery, and it was urged by the
hitosAf, and among others, the selection of the Learned Learned Counsel, that hr had been pithy of charging
1
Gentleman below him as the advocate of his assailant. Mr. Cleary of tittering a forged note. Only a part of
The Learned Gentleman hall, upon this occasion, ibis letter was read at the Westminster hustings by
oloonalit proper to attribute to him great, nay, wonder. Cleary, and from that part he had no recollection of such
f II Wein., adding, that be was the more to be dreaded. a letter, and this confri not excite any surprise, when it
Su that these anailernil talents were ascribed to him Was remembered that the letter purported to hare been
obv•oas4 for the purpose of raising prejudice against written so far hark as ISIS. If the postscript as to Sir
him fur their applieation. espiCally as the Learned ' Jam:, Astley hail Kern published, that cireuass!ance
Ca it. had observed, t I at in his zeal to maintain his& ject, I might hare loonght it Li leis recollection, and if so, he
;Po was not very Permissions in his attacks upon character. t should have no h. si,ation in avowing it. But that
A t if h • wrre n ,t scrnpulons in his animadversions a letter written in a hurry, about teayears before
I
'event chatac•er, how came it that so few proceedings I it was atidtteeil at thr having., slowild have (oval e.I
hid been instituted against him ton such animadversions I his *moors, was nit a matter of surprise.. There
during the 2S years in which he had been a tolerably were, how, ver, foraerics or omiesiutts as well as
active and prominent public writer in England and of coin:Motion : awl it nag iatlieputable that the pub-
America' The fact was, indeed, that within that pe- I Heaths,' of a were extract of the letter alluded to did
rip I, excepting an action brosta,lst against him in Ame- i amount to the crime of forgery, for in a garbled state
ti-•a by Doctor Rosh, the father of the present American that letter wile not his. But haul his sun, whom the
Ambassador in this country, the present was the first . other aide load stoottioned as a minuses, b-en pia in the
ertion ever ttie.l against hint. After expatiating on this l box, this affair would herr been fully explained. How-
part, Mr. Cohhett proceeded to observe that the ever, as the rase appeared, the publication of this letter
Learned Gentleman had dwelt rather too notch in this was clearly a di•hononrable action., Mr. Admits had
it...dia.-a upon the mischief resulting front an attack up- I deposed, that he thonght tbe letter malt fur publication,
on priest, charaefet. For he was fully anxious as this but who that read the whale of tt could entertain such
Leaenetlllentlentan to deprecate any attack upon private • an itnprmision ! Mr. Kte • ti:pl not go so far as Mr.
character, arid in proof of that anxiety be could refer to . Atlanta, saving. th it he Cooled this letter only meant
his radii-Mimi; lint he would ask any candid man wile- for the consideration of the Comositter. The letter
tlter Mr. 'Mora. Cleary wile to he regarded as 'a private , cautioned that Committer against Mr. Hum, who was
chaet eta ? If the Learned Gentleman had adduced Major I as it stated, travelling about the eontory a its a certain
('artwright, who Was atimutoned as a witness, and who fee lode, a Ito was not his wife. Now, upon this point he
S. as e),ea In attendant, he (Mr. F.) could bare alien ii Guild not forltrar from expressing his atiorohation to a
o ha and what Mr. Cleary was ; but Major Cartwright certain event of the defence. lately art up is Col. French,
1 a not brought forward, although the Learned Counsel on a similar rliarge against him. That officer pleaded the
1 ad thought proper to describe Cleary as his friend atol ' affection and fidelity a hick he had Pipet-letter :for years,
',Proem alto'. What, Cleary the frientrand companion of ',from the female with a hoot he was acrueeel of associating,
A a.•or Cartorielit ! it might as well be said that a hug was land his plea ma he a due impression in his defence. Still
to.. bedfellow (a laugh in which tar LearuedJudgrjoined 'he woull not be imilerstootl to pleat, fur the tracociation
v it'. the Bar )Anyattack made by the Learned Urnt.npou l of Mr. Hunt with the female Minded to. lint he wunld
1.•••••cif, he ciptild readily forgive,hut he felt it impossible ask whether Sir F. Ennio% who had for some orrice
1
to 'arrive the altetnipt of the Learned lientleman to re. enjoyed the hospitality of Mr. Hunt, moiler the 011111 C
tree the venerable bfajor to a level with Cleary, by de- roof and in the company of this female, were entitled to
P•••;!+ic him as the Major'e companion. If the Major snake that 241'06:toots the aithject of public cert.:lre:.
himself hall been brought forward as a witness, hose ' But other rionne should have been silent upon this auto
ectaly mold this ralionniona attempt bare lawn repelled. feet as well AS Sir F. Minima Was it pos•ilble, inched,
The Alsj..r mild hare explained whit and what Cleary that any other persons than Wright, Jackson, Cleary,
was—he could have •lorn, that instead of being the Adams, and Mare, multi approve of the propagation of
ot, ontanenna, nnpaiil advocate for Reform ulnas the each cenanre? Conlil lion who rondesienrd the con.
1.-Art*ll Gentleman painted him--Cleary, who was a dnct of Alajocchi, Moonlit, and I hisptrila. aaprore of
art of prts•ecrretairr• was paid for all his services. smell a breach of confidence as that of which lie had, in
Ttpie Cleary was indeed a clerk to a errivener in flab- this instance, so ',inch right to romplain ? The Learned
I
lie.- in the first instance. and upon coning neer here, in- Conned had allearil that Ompteda bail broken open the
area I of employing himself as tine.stne the nature of his ' locks of the gtieett'e priva'r drawer; lint the Baron
rapacity in iwrepirto the top-rte. or picking tip bob-nails entilla no: by,. expected to fool Bergasni there. No. If
for bread, he most (atonal, become a politician. Well, Ompoola had broken the locks, and he could readily be.
so 4 did in the caparity of sorcoorerreuirc to a Cloth of I lies.. .in Hanoverian Minister willing to do any thing to
herormert in fhtkrotreet; St. Jaine•tee, a•lsere he (Mr. whirl, the devil Isittiarlf rould be ilisimAelf, lie must sup-
('.) saw this Cleary acting in thalcapacity ander a man I pose him to tin et. with a virts• isi 61111 the Prinerae's let.
or the name of Harie, who is as the S;ecretarprn-chef. ter.. lint if there harrtir.l to be a Writ:lit in her Royal
T;a're. too, (leery a-ac paid (so 164 sirs ire'', as Major llighnetet's rontillence, Omitted.' need nut have plated
V mwriolit well' knew. lint if the Major had been locks—for he might have olstaitool private letters tie the
b-ought forward he could hare told all. Ile. however, I same means that were rt.stoteil to in this easy by Illace, .
had never interfered ails the payment% of this Cleary AJams, aml Cleary. We hail also heard of Vitimicarti
for leis atteadatice upon Major Cartwright or any of Ilia I and i'illonel Browne, antl• with regard to them also he
en!. All that he knew of the man Weed, Iraq to ton- might say aotorthino, it' toe were not interrupted.
(ler him serrires as be dill a hen he drew 11l a potition i The .frone observed that .11r. robliett had gone far '
for him to the douse. of lards 'before hie departure for I enough for his purpose. !
esoteric-a. Air. Connery rt .ittoseil. olmrrying that these two rr-
Air. liatircnaat herr interposed, observing, that the %olives had seduced the rlerk of tht• Quern's law agent
el, fen.laist et as stating that whielt wax not in proof, and to give op sonar °flier confidential papers, and thus more
that hue Welt net at liberty to make any statement to I arenrairly imitated, if not formed, the example for
Is nieh he dill not mean to adthwe evidence. Placr, Adams and Cleary. 'Chaos the reprobation
Mr. Coatis:To ransarked, that the Learned Gentleman I which the Learned Connscl so profusely, but so
Ivapl soared litany things in his opening speed. which he , justly applied to the Milan i'murnission, militia be trans-
hod not litiP.Wpirgi to prove. - ! (erred to the ennspirary of era its he had reason to row.
The Jl.l.ia said, that it would not be resotlar to state : plain on the present ocratiion. Thr Learned Connael had
thine% to which it was sot meant to affilitcr ecitlener. I said that his client was an mach agitated be file altered
Alr. Crittuvr-r oberryed, than the 'Plaintiff wax de- hibels that they were but too likely to inteifere with Isla
scribed in his declaration. and in his AllTOCarr'S Spred'. I r.,tiabilities to become a prat-tic-al Barrister, to which
114 a gentleman ; and kr. was proceeding to *hew what object his present toadies were directed.—Now, ',mi. •
at." of g"atlemen he was, especially when travelling 1 drristo the scarcity of the Gentlemen of the Bar. ami
tbectugh /die country in a gig, as the hired missionary ! the iliflieulty of proeurino a Barrister tot love or mosey,
of the I bitupden Club, in order to extend theism/rogation. he most say that he shossid feel serionsir responsible if
The Inter JUSTICIL observed, that Cleary's complaint he had the misfortune to °eyeshot a deallietlen from that ,
against the defendant "cm* unt of the P'4lliriti°n° be- Learuml professiow of such an entitteet pm-sonar as Me.
fore the Court, and which he was rhargrei with erigi- 1 T. Cleary (a Leigh !). It was held to lira evince, even
uniting. :. 3.•:::. by poachers, to crush a bird ire the egg', bat how deeply
Nit. l'orarrr said. thatherikissi An action for AL arintioal must he be if lie happested is mash a lawyer
' kiges, and that hewn prooeseling twahew the plailiallf ! in Ake egg (lond laughter, in whack amossiet and the
iris not entitled tw aayilamaaars. esperiatly after his i Jiffy cordially participated). Hrsherahldra wally sorry
it to become Hie hangman a the people a to commit so:, a crime. alth,,,,gh tly'and an
. •. by, whose fate we lb a great wallow attrlhdtablelPo 1 greedy provoked by Mn. torary irlirrippr,wmi mpg
own conduct in promoting the egtahlislimeoc,a. haul, poialtaw several libels m
ow ,Atiot • win, Ills
11 Clubs. , ...
Came dusters—W. tamest enter iltto that. .-.
~....s. hot itewrica. in the rusrpollia of wide&
his faithful neva. Mr. Mink Wined . Aft
. COganen—elf )44Ps Varfwefahf Isla been PM „{list i.e did sot assist. OWN( Ibiae libels, whit&
1 thawitaasta's bort,' should have strewn that cifspy ititeMit printipala was addersmiss Ma_
,iwe.tartweirrdas
ye
par lei. thassuintry ft form theiso Atlas a a do gaidiroboa purported, by fifty. Major a. tersest.
322:11rwas paid for skit( M. '1 rettrewila4 all",_ 15:10146, iaslatals Masted that he hat4..finer or litolilial
A r0w:4141 I podeitm. lee. inkl FR* fitill,Pt Isille4.Mae (Mr. C.) with his `gaol die biapAawrisaa Gait
Was** setraatlial for Dot ptiolg "hat the bat, 410012OUIRISEI011 Ada Iso aardstath.lbassiliat
• e ,T . : ' ' : llierary,starrier 'wen hie return telliglasatalinwishishi
• aitial Op. rafilaratteh. alb* J.: ' leapt to fight a darts theratentng.hipiollitelme ili
tletaoza, is si vol
. 1 . 1 ~ • , , li. 1/ ,26 1 *e. • • .*
• II 04 0111" 44 .•
'el . • . t. 6
' ' ~ , 1 pf:pn-" .4441 , meniall iii.,! • . ... -.44V•50 Ri. 11.1./41111.1. "ail .6"
.4111111181 tir•ill 00'6" • t
• . . • ..•• :: • • • .

____.,„_.., - -.., -‘c. r
itewas44loo he relaxed to attend to the challenge, lint, 114 pnlslie life? Ani h.
s, all Ir. Cl
Feehl•ness wax airs. taken for mild• •
1 o •
,domplaceutt adding, that
. if.ileillo'elf were,
;too e1d.t.1.0. to be protected agaiest the ftrit as Willtantiste:
meet the c allenge, that challenger amigo meet ism;
Writ sop, si;erlione he professed a great regard. '
i
t aess ; lit ti,
*humid recollect that the fechlest animals acre
li
. MC itabinntin observed, that there would be no end
to this latitude if the defendant were allowed to proceed.
than an Coe meet
ma m
sdid .us—reptiles were attire usiscloirar.
il. -7
The Jr/MT:said, that if the defendant did not He begged the Jury to kt, at
to adduce evidence to these statements, they must be
whole trionsae:isits hone 41;*. ,from the lees lull„; to:7
stiaments of r obbin him and Isis fat.:ily oft;:
thrown out of the considera•ion of the Jury. 4end; that thr_y would giftlt wAde 1 '
Le i„,
Mr. Consery said that Cleary hail sent him two
little they pas . tl, ta.tngls int „.„,04 g
challenges, the first on the 24th of September, andrat •r
the second shortly afterwards, in which he stater', ' Work In Its.' 1.1 or sappy- to -his iripoa,, il:
211
that. lie (.t!r. Cobbett) had done him no 'harm, and b_m•:(le to the Learned tientlesuan or Ls rls..
yet hut a few ills elapsed when Cleary made an lie 'legged they would not 4.:ive their sauelbobliv
affidavit before his Lordship that he had suffered an lessest treachery every Leonia the begged t k
injury to a certain extent for ss".oieh he (Cobbett) was t Intik once %pious' the svi..tsesses before user rleriti„,.
held to bail. afterwards, no detist, Cory wan!! be glad to EN
tr:
Mr. listousonast again protested against the state- thrill For e‘''r•-(.11"'Ig1) -ii'' 6'4i:ell thew to ii,;,•
molts which Mr. Cobbett was making, observing that with reprolor'imi this alsmiimtible ays,em stfefri„.,
he understood Mr. Cobbett intended to produce no this spy system, .to 'hew the natured abloarnti.,.;
evidence. Englishmen at what was base, ::nd to let thei,a-..
-r:•
Mr. CURSETT maintained, that the interruptions of 'ion stump the itifaisoy of those who had bees tto !
the Learied Counsel were out justifiable. of such a breach of pi ivate coetioletice.
The Jenne. said, that it was his duty to tell the de- 31r. ilwousmasa said, the der•nditit: Its.' intre,lace.l
fendant that he was not at liberty to atate that which oath a variety of tonics, that he should is hekano
lie did not mean to prove. Lie bar, have ease. fed his right 4 f commenting spok
them, though he did s co: feel it necessary to 11, isi•
Mr. Conaarr 'observed, that he was not stating
any thing but that which was quite notorious. resting as they did on the .leleatil4tat's 4'..sCrti...l
The Jenne remarked then, that the notosiety pre. The Cist::v Jus.t.:.:.—.llr. Brougham, this'll*
eluded the necessity of the statement. y .str time.
After sunse. farther controversy— The Learned Judge, in sit/tondo% nn, observe!, 111,1
the lettersi4 in Twist son U.Sif It eaten in 1 44t4, sod publish.,
mine! ~
with, eet% tlaei tsalpyp
raootti
a:
ioorna
of purposel ede7ll, i c.hm:st.ould Imo
Mr. Connell' said, that he woods' put the cases to
whirls he had hypothetically alluded, for the consider-
ation of the jury, ,bleb the Judge admitted, as the :
w•rotteto when the defendant thought um svourallotly"
'Counsel for the plaintiff had put many ea, a hypotlie. Mr. Hunt, an I when he loorthcruthi Inure tivouraione:'
tieally. to abide lie hail not attempted to seldom. any 1 Mr. Hunt, this letter was hronght fnewrr 1 agsiest iii
evidenee. Air. Brougham, however, contending that • fur the purposes of an .declion. The oloservationsorow
defendant on this poiat were certainly we!ldeserriner,
he was entitled to comment upon even hypothetical
cases. But this position was not admitted by the • ennsideration, aml if he hail on the err/vino attar st,
telligence motioned himself to a complaint of that hied,
Court. he (the Chief Jestio•e) should have tlessuaht his '-
.r
Mr. Coesrrr proceeded, and, under the shelter of ranted in great latitude of observation, and crentrthui
'apposition, recited all the misconduct wish which he I ingnage. lint that wrs not Isis course. tie batch,,
charged Cleary, Wright ...d Jackson. He mentioned Cie plaintiff a tth lor‘ery, whirls was mot w strove) it
They hot therefore to consider-Forst, 16.
that he load released Wri:eht from a prison, fed and the tills-
titer the defendant had authorised the pub(' :ion slew
clothed him, and considering bins as a creature of Isis
libel, and if they do ttannisseil in the adirtisafße.tleilli,
own, communicated confidentially tor several years.
to consider what damages slsould be Rime, tablet fiats
He regarded him as grateful : although, finding him scrolled the nature of the chirp., (a tr.sve mad 5e,i,,,,,
soppie, he ought not to have trusted loins. In the course one certainly), and the proioabtlity of stems! iejsre, ;,4
of leis connection with loins, flowerer, he wrote no him well as the circumstance. of mitigation whirls had 'ern
probably 20U11 letters upou the most confidential mat- remarked upon by the defendant.
tt rs wish regard to lois family ausl bitsiness, and npon 'else Jury withdrew. sml were absent far nearly la
hour anti a
limit .thotit ei zli t o'clock Coq returnesssaa
tousling loim off whets he hail good reason to st:spect
te.lostv,erieusd. I eir rennet for the plaintiff Damages ilk
him. this man retained all those letters, instead of
eiting thew up ashes:Arne an honest man. To Jackson
he was introduces' by Lord Cochratoa. To him also
he gave that ronfidence which his unsuspecting nature
was but too liable to grant. Yet this wan, to whom
he never gave any offence, was found to use Isis own
Register fur the purpose of publishing attacks upon
Isis character, and to league wills Isis known enemies,
Cleary, Wright, Plate and Ashans, with a view to in-
jure him. Of alolynenx, who was also a member of
this conspiracy, he should only declare, .as he could
most solemnly, that he never signed the order to the'
stationers, to which that witness deposed. What then
was to he thought of the turpitude of this corps, or
what security could there be for any man ur Isis
family, if such h cads of confidence as that of which
Wright stood convicted could possibly be sanctioned ?
Bost he cared not a farthing about this man's exposure
of Isis private letters. Su indeed he bad always told
his cloildreto. Fur whatever foolish letters he might
have written, he klt confident that he had never writ-
ten any thing which could justify any one in saying
that IVilliato Cobb..tt was not an honest man. The
Learned Counsel had shown Isis wish to dwell upon
the letter read at Covent-Harden litts:ings, as a proof
in his eoneeptiop, that he (Mr. ('.) was not consistent
its his principles or opiniuus of mess ; but notwith-
standing this letter, written a hen lie knew nothing
of Mr. Hunt, except (runs common report, hr would
say that that gentleman possessed great merits, although
the Learned Counsel *hewed such a disposition to
abuse him. I
Mr. iittoento sat denies' that he load said a word '
about Mr. Ilunt ; he shout I indeed be ashamed to abuse
any IMIII in Mr. Hunt's aituatiou.

COL R!' OF .41,DRI1VEN.

A Court of Aldermen was held at the finildhel
yesterday. Immediately on the Cou:t's being falet,l.
Mr. Alderman Ilia it me to propose that a elatila
and loyal Address be presented to his Majesty by Iha
Court, express:ng their attachment to his royal persa
an I g,iverAnteet. He prefaced this maim by prs
nonueing a violent philippir against the press. whki
be denounced as mot abandoned. He felt it to
the duty of Ile it Court to express their thterinlaiArl
to protect the Crown and uphold the constituted asthe
rities. With this view he proposed the Address, which
i was then read.
' The Address being seconded, . I
Sir W. Doss% st.t.o observed, that there 'rarebit
expressions and omissions in the Address with
he could not br.ne his mind to accord.
Alderman Wi•oo detailed the press front the sal
nions observations east upon it.
A'd 'row n IlevusTa said, he was willing to apt
to a do Ifni and loyal adders', provided it was urea&
of their duty awl loyalty only. He condeniteed
wimle of the condnet of Ministers relative to her*,
jes:y the Queen; his wish nos fur such Ministetta
would reduee the artily and decrease the public rape*
turr, and such a s,t of Ministers he, fur uoe, ahuuWh
Ito see in pollee,
Mr. Alderman 11'M-11111.1N said be was as wink
to go np with a Loyal A aires4 to his Majesty as Or
Worthy Alderman who had just at down, or thefts

rimer of the present .I(ldress ; hat he text at a
know what it nits the linnourable Iln►er intro

how to unilerAtan.l the ariiiiients and alinainns
had made in support of his proposition.
other st,rr law+ to be imarted and enforcecl, or in eke
way was it lie sugge4ted to alter the temper intl dispesi•
Con of the public: Could he hope to edict teak s
pitrisose by indiscriminately °barging thn whole intie
penitent press of the rintitry with disloyalty lot OP
'Heating the caner of their injured and persecuted Qnses.
lir accusing tne whole people with disalicrtiim fur their
noble stand in defeare t, the laws and the colstitutios:
If these general charges again.t the people acre ss
true, they were gross and dangerous libels; and, es
the other hand, it it were true that the pe.iple were
generally distil-31 and disarmed as the Worthy
deem sit seems to lament, it IYJS 103 late to talk °fur
g the asvernment : if tl.e disallectioa was s,
general as had barn described the whole system ins
already ; and at least it was most unwise to tell
the people Ibis whieli was but adilin4 oil Mire.
Sir es, mous Uv writ* said he had always eappertoi
Ministers Lease* he approved th.ir taeasnrest ail he
trap how prepared to *mord with an address,
related to the porn of the Sovereign ; but a ANT
duty impelled hint to oppose the present addreen -111
I was of opinion that the voltam% of his liajellf.
I et .rs relative to the Queen was highly llnPegrer,
.outran to their ditty, end had tal',.; the stel:4 flor.
lion tbrnaglsont the whole conatre. I' tart, 110 whole
people, from one end or the country to another. we .911
'retest the preset* wen and their measure ; I II"
short of their roomy:11;0mill restore to the Kier
14eatts end ufreetious of hit sulijacts. Aa evid/rvit
This Ent he would mug readily *free tat alba bo"".•_,,
the Court gait sip Welt bowllPOw—.
; dere+ itself frost t
it big %wen retineedbri—CilWrulles
hilt sod fitinnotoniklifire4opn. • ;
Alderman lbscroonta thought it right t at an noblresssf
taus kind should he solslpted itt thus uto 414,41' re f
it was finite ithoelkfftrit i tee ' niudi, pit, god
elan y ellreitssis a prates:dons "'mom IMPIfT d!!'
11,tople 11;•-- paid • + iberi.4/ Iv°

'I. lie JUDOR said, that he did not hear the Learned
fientlenian mention Mr. !hut.
Mr. CeillttETT admitted, that Mr. Hoot was not named,
hot it was impossible to mistake the Learned lien:lefusa's
allusion, or the inferences which he swished to have
drawn. —Ailverti iig to the learned flentleman's allusion
to his *opposed versatility of opinion, he admitted, dist
lie hail chanced, het it was generally from gem' to bet-
ter, or at least from bail to trooil the Learned
Itentleman's chopping about was finite of a different de-
scription, as appeared from his renunciation of his
wri't'e pledge in favour of Itailiral lieforni, which he
had lodged in the bands of that faithful gentleman. Mr.
I'. Place, who thought proper to rive It to .the pithiie.
This was a rnaspir.ery a, fool as any they hail heard of
lately, although not so inquirtant as to the parties again. t
wh t wa., directed. Now as to the question of
Illigt•S; till• illsiffilletler, • 111 311ilarilf of such a mut as
the plaintiff asking fur damages, was neiparalleled.
The plaintiff had begun the attack ; lie had peered forth
pamphlet after pamphlet against him Vie defendant), to
!s which hr ail made, by the by, no rep
Mr. Intocitti %It —I insist make the sameobsierrstion as
I have made before. If Mr. l'obbett has any evidence
to prove tin'', I have no objection to his arguing
upon it.
The enter ./vsytez observed, the defendant should
tonna,. himself to what hail been proved, or to what hr
intended to prove.
Mr. ronerrr proceeded. The plaintiff had taken him
to the Judge's riosniliers. His intastion of otavilp,

Patirshin Wetinefolavihisoifice
nal as nitiorioas, at least to mt. Pletnent's eliureli in this
Strand. Yet, knowing all this, Cleary had gm,. to a
Jnrige to swear ihw be appreftended dint. Ire should 4141
the country. Was ever act so nialisiona or haw t It
was theft Tread the nest dar.ahnosigh all the•ortprer.
doe newspapers, that Cohbett was arrested for debt by
Clesry.
The Calm Jr:suss—This is not stated in evideare.
Mr, llitocan43ll—Mr. Cleary made the alma! Admit
Sr Jaht.
Mr. La..
circumstances
it

ire wet. • anu proves:4mo' ININUIIIf
Mr. CORS t 7 T. t sat friA Pleilieltiled.a.tol paid tp *was wifai4/0111;
_Pun tbear: nc•Fl WC°
rr mas.ta nee* of tits root t *pips, gal fpgA. in -4016sidi-To ~hi est lowyrnersoF7
lk dia. in (*cf. Pt +OW ; 14 WS orldishallAil,olll . isdhsliespoitstillirre;
e"ntri Partki,4 "UPS ll4lo.sighge•
slake Paraoo's ygert, ATATA, rawtl/2406.40.1itil‘nmalL 111101.
4"1.4"61 !r• 10.ftl ItMg ' 4:448,04.4kikit°41.°
7 Ant,
P.Jw , • 1„. •"
, . . • id . &
pins M taftel leiti.Sad. am p« -.9,4 ih.tl w J Olio mai ildb