The Liverpool Standard and General Commercial Advertiser.
Liverpool, Merseyside, England, 1851-11-18 00:00:00

LIVERPOOL DOCKS

--.-..
LOANS. OF MONEY.
THE COMMITTEE of the LIVERPOOL DOCKS
do HEREBY GIVE NTIC tat are to
lirtiftteesive LOANS of MONE'Y on tte sE ecurh itythe yof the_Bondswillinz of the
tees of the Liverp ,
00l Docks, the rate of Four Pounds
r Centum per Annum Int or periods of either Three,
let or Seven Years. nterest payable here or in London.
..._nlil offers to ressed to GEORGE WITHERS, lbsq•,
44tasurerto th iverpool Docks, Dock-office, Liverpool.
By order,
DANIEL MASON, Secretary.
~,.oe, Liverpool, March, 1850.

berA \•O4

TO PIPELAYERS.
/TE TOWN COUNCIL of the BOROUGH of
v , LIVERPOOL are desirous to receive TENDERS for
ric
,Z_ING about 14 miles of 36 inch PIPES, being part of the
7-tn Pine of the Liverpool Corporation Waterworks.
in" Pies of the Specification may be obt 'nedd Drawings
enected, at the Engineer's Office, rks, Hotliam-street,
bge•rP°ol, On and after WED - AY, the 12th day of Novem •
instant.
Tend
"err° erls must be ' erect at the Town-clerk's office, in Li-
t/walk on or e WEDNESDAY, the 26th day of November

WILLIAM SHUTTLEWORTH, Town-clerk
T 00,14
Liverpool, November, 1851.

tibltrattons.

34"
Published, by J. Cntincu mt., London, and may be had of
all Booksellers,
TREATISE ON THE PON-ENTION AND
petillE OF SPINAL CUR RES AND DEFORMI-
bens. OF THE CH EST. e result of many years' expe-
re Bc, Mrs. Y, Renshaw- l
street.
Intended or Mothers and Principals of Schools.

USEFUL HOUSEHOLD WORKS,
[OFFICES, 69, FLEET-STREET, LONDON;]
Published by HOU LSTON mid STONEMAN,

THE 6. PATER NOSTER. ROW.
FAMILY 'FRIE ND, an established Magazine,
Arieetrisbed upon the First and Fifteenth of Every Month,
%eau Twopence Thirty-two pages, beautifully printed, an
Y covered.
Thesew
following is a type of the opinion formed of THE FA
Ilew FRIEND. and expressed by upwards of three hundred
widea?spers:—.. We know of no Miscellany m more deserving
nof
tics spread circulation than 7'he Family Friend. It is e ph -
t msome-
-4114,p/foul Magazine for a FAMILY. Its pa"lfesN'cle, for-
tOtte r all ; there is no member of th e,, i . a
Gentp. and no class of Society o ooked. It is SELF
etnan'a Itfaoavine a Lady' agazine. a servant's 1114mt-
tirl▪ °4t44
Working Ma' n's lend. It is a Mother's Magazine,
-kragazitie. an Child's Companion. It is, as its
71,4c.2rFectly declar , a ' Magazine of Domestic Ec2eorri y,
teceii talonlent, I ruction, and Practical Science.' W h. have
liot ved it into-tur home circle with great pleasure, for it is
slanro.Y a Family Visitor but really a Family FRIEND. We
4 r L describe its conteilts, they are an omnium gatherum i
~,...eyeertory of things pleasant and profitable. of things. gay oPfl
iTiocv,., selected with remarkably good taste,. and edited wattle
iewheßerulthaecthaabd judgment. It is a work capitally adapted
IVY fireside of home, and to aid the development
.i.,?e'al affection."—Brarlford Observer.
in vie Work may he had complete, up to the end of June, 1851,
t' These
Volumes, price 2s. 6d. each,beautifully hound.
MIA ..Mese Volumes contain the Celebrated PRIZE ENIGMAS
am' Ineir Solutions, respecting which extraordinary Competition
al rrontred. The Editor announces his intention of offerinz,
tbe,-,‘ ristmas next, a Prize of ONE HUNDRED GUINEAS. for
'lLLiit,t Solution of an ENIGMA to be competed for anotherilta..„,-`" ; FIFTY GUINEAS for ,he Solution of
tyit''''s,.o, to be competed for by LADIES; and TWENTY-FIVE
v 11)1,4F.AS for an ENIGMA to be competed forbyJUVENILES
Ll_ oth sexes. Further particulars will be given in the Num-
..,r.B of TE. FRIEND.
111,..1e FOURTH VOLUME contains a Quadruple Index to the
Hundred
Pour Volumes, embodying about Three Thousand ive
brundred References to matters of every day usefulness. 'fhe
",p,ork forms a most perfect Encyclopmdia of Domestic Economy.
are fair reader. of THE FAMILY PRIEND will find the fol-
ic:10! Ell Nat Designs in FANCY NEEDLEWORK, in the
-"log Numbers of the Work
b„_. VOL. I. CheeseCloth—`Cheese'
Round Tpoyley
Anitted L '
Crochet ace } N`" ' ' Stilton'
,-.'-'mt Cffs— Sofa 1,„ 3 VOL. 111.
Ir;blvering
Sof e Cover—Lamp Mat. No. 4 Octagon Chair Cover..
er aor Carriage Pillow 1,„ Round D'Oyley Knit- }No. 21
„L?_chet Edge I ' ted Purse
s'iivolvtitus Mat for Baby's Boot
p,f Plower 'Vase }No. 6An Open-worked Knit- }No.
e1'.:.11, de BruxellsCollar ted Sock
134abrki" Bag
wo,,!_ll.lcanitted Sock } ''". ' Knttet Mitten
7.00111 n Pattern Knitted
B'Y
nitted Collar a la N°• ' Hyacinth Glass Mat
LaGr,re,eque Knitted Toilet Cover
..
ZY 8 and Gentle- VOL. IV.
suTan's Nightcaps .. N, ~ D'OyfeyfoLSpiritStand
verb Table Cover in ' Knitted Pattern for N 0.31
LaPatchwork
winter
Polka
No.lo Lady's Netted Cap 1
Cap, Neck Tie, Screen fora Flower Pot No. 40
.alld Under Sleeves.. No. 11 and Saucer
Child'
Patterns
l'aild's Polka No. 12 Tulip-shaped Mat for a No. 42
Bread Cloth
11. Toilette Bottle
„ „ 'Musnud for a Sofa
it,usic Stool Couverette I 'Cy' " Patchwork Designs
Nei' for a Cruet Net for the Hair, with}
„..Stand . }No. 16 Gold Border No. 44
Cheese Cloth
Mat for Hyacinth Glass 1 Nr,, i. Knitted Toilette Cu-
ToiletteCushion,' Pins' I ""' " shion or Ottoman, ). No. 46
Flower Vase Mat Sexagon Shape
Point Lace Collar in 1 No. 20 Netted Mitten .. . .
Crochet A Cover fora Footstool}
Palm Lenf Edging or Sofa Pillow No. 46
Fish Serviette—' Fish.' ) No' 22 A Blind Tassel Cover
Each Design is illustrated by a WOOD ENGRAVING, so that
Crochet Workers may see the Pattern before commencing it.—
The Numbers may be had separately, Price Twopence each ;
but purchasers are recommerded to obtain the VOLUMES,
which are filled with practical matters of every-day use. Price
Is. 6d. each.

THE CHEAPEST ORIGINAL AND COPYRIGHT MUSIC

IN TH

WORLD,

THE FAMILY FRIEND, Vols. 11. and 11L. contain numerous
Original and Copyright Musical Productions by Celebrated
Composers. These may be had collectively, bound in the
Volumes, price 2s. 6d. each, or separately in the Numbers,

p e ch
rice 2d..i. IN voL.-.
THERE'S A POWERCONTAINED CAN CONQUER 'THE SWORD.
Song and Chorus by ALEXANDER Las, Esq. (No. 13.)
THE FAMILY POLKA. By MARIE SCOTT. One of the most
attractive and lively of the new over-done Polka Music. (In
No. 14.1
OH I SACRED ARE A MOTHER'S TEARS.—Composed by
_G. LINDLEY, Esq. (In No. 15.)
HYMN—THE SEASONS.—By ALEXANDER LEE, Esq. Words
by Bishop HEBER. (In No. 17.)
THE BROKEN-HEARTED.—By J. F. DucmAN, Esq. Sung
by HERR MENG'S. (In No. 19.)
THE SECRET.—By J. F. DUGGAN, Esq. Snug by Miss JULIA

ST. No. 21.)
THE LANGUAGE OF THOSE EYES.— Composed by ALEX.
LEE, Esq. Sung by Mrs. ALEXANDER LEE, late Mrs. Way-
lett. (In No. 23.)
CONTAINED IN VOL. 111.
PAYAWAY.—COM_posed by J. F. DUGGAN, Esq. Written by
MrB. MARIA L. CHILD. (In No. 25.)
THE FAMILY WALTZ.—By Miss Pimp. This Waltz has
been greatly admired. It is a suitable companton to" The
_lPamily Polka." (In No. 27.)
44-1...VE IN THE REIGN OF THE ROSES.—Composed by
HERB MENGIS. On No. 29.)
I WOULDN'T, WOULD YOU ?"—Composed by ALEXAN-
DER LEE, Esq. (In No. 31.)
'IIY, MOTHER'S GRAVE.—Composed by J. F. DUGGAN, Esq
(In No. 33.)
BLEEP, GENTLE BABY l'
3.5.)
one of these Musical Compositions can be obtained from any
other source. To secure any particular piece, it is only neces-
IlarY to order the number containing it, price 2d.; but Pur-
chasers are recommended to obtain the Volumes, and thus
Cure the whole SERIES of FAMILY MUSIC, in an elegant
term, and at a trifling cost.
A limited number of Advertisements are inserted in The Fa-
Thily Friend. Terms—First Fifty Words, 6s. 6d., and ls. IN
every Ten Words after. Average Circulation, 80.000.
It,* Persons wishing to judge of tne contents of the First Four
Volumes of The Friend, may receive the QUADRUPLE INDEX.
gratis, by applying (post paid) to the Office, 69, Fleet-street,
London.

'—Composed by WEBER. (I■

THIIFAMILY TUTOR AND SCHOOL COMPANION 1
commenced on the Ist of January, 1651, and appears on the
Ist and 15th of each Month, in Parts price 2d. each, uniform
with " The Family Friend."
The FAMILY TUTOR, as its name implies, is a Work of a
highly instructive character, and realises, as far as can be ac-
complished in print, the-advantages of a PRIVATE TUTOR to
every reader—a Tutor whose teachings are lively, kind, and
comprehensible, making the acquirement of knowledge a
PLEASURE, not a TASK.

THE FIRST VOLUME CONTAINS

A Complete English Grammar, Improved and Simplified—
Familiar Lectures on Chemistry—Tales of History and of
Travel—Zoology—The Physical History of Mankind—The
Physiology of Health and Disease—Celestial and Terrestrial
Phenomena of the Months—Mathematical, Geometrical,
thmetical, ana other l'roblems—Elocutionary Exercises—
The-Tutor and his Pupils," being Answers to Education,/
Questions:
. and a Varied Miscellany.
,First Volume of the Family Tutor is sots ready, Els

"'"--
pant Bound, price 2s. 6d.
~,rat TUTOR'S ENGLISH GRAMMAR, contained in the
Xl7 and Volume, is illustrated by Wood Engravings, by which a
and difficult study is rendered singularly interesting.
A s
ire Jew select Advertisements of Educational Institutions, Sze.
c received in the TUTOR. Terms as in the FRIEND.

TIT*
tin PARLOUR MAGAZINE of the Literature of all Na.
M-011: is printed in the Crystal Palace ! Price 2d. Weekly ;
thly parts sd. or 10d. ; Volumes 58.
t,_l! Is the only Work devoted specially to the translation if
t'rnlversal Literature. and will be found rich in intellectual
"tures.
.. . / •

.....ments are inserted in the v.
*gathers and tbs Monthly Parts. Terms as is rum FAMILY

Price Is., crown eve, cloth boards,
FAx. ,Lit,
siiitinLY PASTIME, OR, HOMES MADE HAPPY; con-
Con,,Lof entirely Original Anagrams, Enigmas, Charades,
to -"unions, Fireside Games, Practical Pnzzles, &c. &c.,
4473ber With their Solutions ; for which PRIZES TO THR
Itdit.liwr OF FIFTY GUINEAS have been awarded by the
'r of THE FAMILY FRIEND.
tb, twards of Three Hundred Competitors have centrihnted
of tirls of Entertaining Literature from which the contents
~__ork hare been selected.
tfil—erelhe above Works may be obtained of Booksellers every.
Est here any difficulty occurs, they may be rrceived.by
the 'ect from the Office, by remitting Sixpence in addition
poserice of each Volume.
DlN:Pike Orders for Advertisemes street, London be made
e to Join, BRNNErr, 6g, Fleet .
odon:
..ouLrrom and STOWSSMAN, and all Booksellers.

URSTJANT to a decree of the High Court of
toe Ch
e cred't
aeerY, made in a cause Higgin son against Higgiirisonn,
het, ors of JOHN HIGGINSON, formetly of
_Eevceeatosed,
(whotfverpool, in the county of Lancaste erchant, d
or fold
sb on or about the 21st day o ember, 11134,).are. on
and
/v.. tlie 31st day of Jan . 1852, tocome m
Of tylvz their BElrrs before ' eau William Senior, Es q_., Dire
me Masters of the said urt, at his Chambers, in South-
._.theegPtlildings. Ch ery-lane London ; or in default
Ntl ""el will be remptorily'excluded the benefit el the
ttree. .

IN CHANCERY-INJUNCTION,

MILNER V. HARRISON

AN application was made on Thursday, the 25th
September, be his Honour Vice-chancellor Sir
George Turner, at Bath, on behalf of Mr. William Milner, as
Executor of the late Thomas Milner, the Patentee of an Inven-
tion of " Imrovements in Boxes, Safes, or other Depositories
for the Protection of Papers or other materia a from Fire," for
an injunction to restrain the defendant, John Germsn Harri-
son, of Liverpool, his agents, servants, &c., from making,
using, putting in practice, or vending, or procuring to he
made, &c., during the remainder of the term mentioned in the
Letters Patent granted to Mr. Thomas Milner, any Boxes,
Safes, or other depositories made in such or the like manner,
or on the same or the like principle as the said Thomas Mil-
ner's Invention, or in anywise counterfeiting, imitating, or
resembling the said Invention.
Mr. Webster appeared for the plaintiff. and Mr. Shebbeare
for the defendant, and affidavits in support of and in oppositiou
to the motion were read. Milner's invention consisted in the
use of substances, distributed in an absorbent material in
spaces between the outer and inner casings of the Box, which
substances, when exposed to heat, evolved steam or moisture,
the combined effect of the moisture and the material, kept
humid, protecting the Safes, enclosing papers, &c., from fire.
The defendant sold Safes and Boxes, which he represented
to be made under a Patent granted to Messrs. Tan», of Lon-
don, but which the plaintiff contended were substantially
made according to Milner's Invention, and were an infringe-
ment on his Patent. An actirin had been brought by the
plaintiff against the defendant for the infringement, and tried
in June last, before Lord 9iiief Justice Campbell and a special
jury, and a verdict found for the plaintiff, the defendant's
counsel tendering aB. of Exceptions to the direction of the
learned judge on th onstruction of Mr. Milner's specification.
Notwithstanding is verdict, the defendant Harrison had
cowbird to se he Boxes and Safes complained of, and the
affidavits file y the plaintiff proved the recent sale by defe
dant of a Sa e, which scientific witnesses stated was substan-
tially the same as those proved on the trial, and found to he an
infringement. This was verified by Doctor Musprat whose
analysis accompanied his affidavit. The affidavit of Mr. John
Tann stated that he believed this Safe had been made by hint
and his partners, and he alleged that it was made according to
their specification
His HONOUR stated the principle on which the Court inter-
fered in cases of this kind, and observed that Tann's specifi-
cation appeared to contemplate only a dry non-conductor to
stop the heat, whereas Milner's created a further obstruction
to the fire, by producing at the period when the fire began to
act on the box an effusion of steam, wl.ich pervaded the non-
conducting material with moisture, and thereby protected the
Safe and its contents. His Honour adverted to the long enjoy-
ment of the Patent which was granted in 1840, the result of the
trial at law, arrd the clear opinion in the plaintiff's favour
expressed by the Lord Chief Justice, and in which his Honour
concurred, stating that he considered Milner's was a Patent
claiming every mode by which the liquid. &c., might be em
ployed to moisten the absorbent material ; and he concluded
by granting the injunction in the terms of the motion.

PRESERVATION OF BOOKS, DEEDS, &c.,
" FROM FIRE.__

COURT OF QUEEN'S -BENCH, JUNE 23RD, 1851, BEromt

LORD CAMPBELL AND A SPEC' NI. JURY.
MILNER v. HARRISON.
(The latter selling Tann's Safes and Boxes, and advertising
himself as sole proprietor of Tann': Patent Safes, Chests, .5.c.)
The-above trial was instituted for the purpose of vindicating
the exclusive right, on the part of the Plaintiff, of applying
liquids, or materials evolving moisture on the application of
heat, together with ether absorbent materials, within the
chambers of Boxes, Safes, or Depositories, calculated to per-
vade the chambers and contents of the sa'es with moisture
and steam, when heated by fire, thereby preserving the papers
from ignition. Mr. Crowder, Q.C., Mr. M. Chambers. Q.C.,
and Mr. Webster, appeared for the Plaintiff; and Sir F. The-
siger, Mr. Knowles, Q.C., and Mr. Hindmarsh, for the Defen-
dant. After the case had been stated by Mr. Crowder evidence
was given by Mr. Grant mha, of Liverpool, Civil Engineer and
Surveyor •f Steamers to the Board of Trade ; Mr. Samuel
Woods. jun., of London, formerly of Liverpool ; Mr. J. W.
Pitcher, of Liverpool; Mr. Alderman Bennett, Ironfounder, of
Liverpool; Dr. Sheridan Muspratt, Professor of Chymistry,
Liverpool; Mr. John Smith, President of the Guardia.
Society, Liverpool ; Mr. B. Woodcroft, Professor of Machinery
at the University College, London ; and by Mr. John Owens,
one of the foremen of Milner's Works for the last twenty years,
on the utility, originality, &c., of Milner's Safes—of which
upwards of 25,000 are now in use—and also of the infringe-
ment of Milner's Patent by the Defendant, who was proved
have used the very materials in the Safes and Boxes he had
tested and sold, which he had seen used by the Plaintiff's firm,
when in their service as Shopinan, from 1846 to 1849. This
was followed by Sir F. Thesiger's reply for the Defendant, who
called several witnesses, hut whose testimony. on cross-exami-
nation, completely established the Plaintiff's case. Mr.
Crowder finally addressed the Jury on the facts, and
Lord CAMPBELL then summed up. This, Le said, was an
action for the infringement of a patent granted on the 26th of
August, 1840, for certain alleged improvements in boxes for
the protection of papers from fire. The defet.dant set up
several defences, which he would not take exactly in their
proper order. Ist. He said that there was no proper specifica-
tion of this patent. 2dly. That Milner, the patentee, was not
the inventor ; also, that it was not a new invention, that it was
not a useful invention; and that, at all events, the defendant
had not infringed the patent. Ile had taken the evidence very
fully, and if the jury thought it would assist them he would
read it ever. _ _

The Jury intimated that they did not think it necessary.
Lord CAMPBELL then said, he should shortly direct their
attention to the several questions they were to determine, for
they were all for their determination. With regard to the in-
fringement. he would repeat the direction he had before given
them. Here was the specification, and although he thought
this issue was hardly disputed, they must consider whether as
ordinary workman, of ordinary skill, looking at it, could make
one of the boxes it described. The witnesses had said that an
ordinary workman, in their judgment. would be able to do so.
The next issue was with regard to the novelty of the invea-
Hon. The third and fourth were so much alike that they might
be taken as part of the same question.
It lay on the plaintiff to show that this was a new invention,
and if he gave prima facie evidence that it was so, the defen-
dant would have to show that it was not. Now there was cer-
tainly strong evidence on the part of the plaintiff to show that
it was new. It was for them to say whether it was properly as
invention for the protection of papers against fire. The papers
were locked in an iron box, having cases enclosed, leaving
chambers between t e two cases, and the object was to have
some substance that would give out a moisture upon the appli-
cation of the heat, and the steam thus produced was to be in-
closed in the box and moisten the papers so that they might be
preserved from the effects of fire. There had been several wit-
nesses of respectability on both sides, although several of those
called for the defendant had only recently turned their atten-
tion to this subject. Several witnesses for the plaintiff said
that, although there had been an addition to the old safe which
consisted merely of a single iron box, a mode having been in-
troduced of having an enter box, the great object was to in-
troduce some non-conducting substance, so that the operation
of heat might be retarded as much as possible; but that there
was nothing until Mr. Milner's patent to moisten the papers
by the operation of steam.
On the part of the defendant, he chiefly relied on Marr's and
Chubb's patents, and it would be for them to say whether those
patents were not confined to introducing non-conductors.
The object of both was to save papers from destruction, but the
mode and operation was the question in disnute. He had bees
puzzled to know the difference between the two patents of Marr
and Chubb, and he afterwards found from ono of the witnesses
that there was no distinction between them. They both bad
non-conductors in the inner case, but neither seemed to have
had the slightest contemplation of any liquid, as their object
was rather to have substances as dry as possible, but had no
notion of a liquid which was to be condensed into steam to
moisten the papers in the inner case. They had heard the
evidence, and it would be for them to say whether they were
satisfied that the invention which Mr. Milner set out in kis
specification was known before the date of his patent. If they
thought it was, they would find that issue for the defendant;
and if they thought it was not,they would find it for the plaintiff.
The third and fourth issues were substantially the same, being
that Mr. Milner was not the inventor, and the invention was
not new. If Mr. Milner was the inventor, the invention was
new; and if he was not the inventor, it was not new. Then
came the issue of whether it was useful, and he must say he
had been astonished to find such strong evidence of its usefsd-
newt. Up to this hour he had no idea that there were any
human means of so effectually preserving papers from the
action of fire. It appeared that, by means of the condensation
of steam, the papers enclosed in the inner box were rendered
moist. It was a comfort for one to know that there was an in-
vention, by which valuable documents might be rendered secure,
notwithstanding the terrible calamity of fire breaking out in a
house. Although the defendant had thought fit to say it was
not useful, he was really at a loss to say what evidence there
was to raise any doubt as to its utility; but the question was
for them alone. Now came the direction he should give them
in point of law, and in this they must be guided by what he said.
He thought there might be an infringement, although the de-
fendant did not use vessels, pipes, or tubes for containing the
liquid. All the rest he left to them ; but he only said that it
was not indispensably necessary that the defendant should use
pipes, tubes, or artificial vessels, but they were to consider
whether the evidence was sufficient to convince them that the
defendant had infringed the patent. They would bear in mind
that respectable professors from King's College, anti other
seminaries of learning, had been called for the defendant, and
they would consider whether they disproved the infringement.
Tann's patent could only be evidence on the ground of infringe-
ment, for it was not taken out until nearly four years after
Milner's; but if, as it won

boxes, he could not say that tbey were not to look to Tann's
specification, if they came to the conclusion that the boxes made
by Tann were the same as those Milner described in his specifi-
cation. They were to look on all the evidence on either side
bearing on these issues ; and if they thought that, although the
boxes that the defendant sold did not contain any pipes, tubes,
or artificial vessels for containing the liquid, they contained
alum and other substances from which moisture was to be ex-
tracted by heat; if they thought they were substantially the
7 same as Milner's, they would find that issue for the nl."

and if they thought th-ey were not the same as Milner% for the
defendant, They were at liberty to find that issue for the
plaintiff, although the defendant did not use eni
or artificial vessels. If they thought the proces
tinily the same as that mentioned in the plaintiff's apes
they would find that issue for the plaintiff. They m
mind that the plaintiff said, "I claim as my inventio,..
troduction or application of the combined effect in chambered
boxes, or depositories of the moisture and material kept humid
in the space surrounding the innermost box, and its contents,
nnv way being confined to the material or liquid

y pipes, tube

rile," must bear in
',n the in-

employed, or the manner in Wblol It may oe Ulistriutneu uz-
arranged, in order to produce t.he desired effect of protecting
!name. nsnara Ar other

boxes-, safes, or other depositories eniClUnte crat.,
NS CI
vs Tl;"es—e
materials, from fire." It ITIIS on
. t
fondant
that tallye
havehad dtinrfereitnegdedth etmh e
patent,
oa fl law,oug h thath e didt e
not
t-
make use of tubes, or pipes, or artificial vessele. Withthi
exception, he left it for them to say if the defendant had t
in-
fringed the pateat ; if they found that it was so, damages no
being in dispute, the cam of forty shillings would be sufficient:
but they were to consider, themselves, which way they would
find their verdict.
The Jury, after a short deliberation, said they found their
verdict 'pc* all the issues for the plaintif.
VIRDICT FOR TMR PLAINTIFF.
Upon this verdict, establishing the validity of Milner's Pa-
tents, so fully confirmed by his Honour the Vice-Chanceller's
decision, farther proceedings in Chancery are bejug adopted
aoinit all parties k'elliaq, 1414ing, or Mini Ono Nrel or
Boxed: