Star.
London, England, 1804-11-30 00:00:00

never received any value for it. ?it then comment-
ed at great length, and much ability, upon the letter.
.which was completely contradidory of all the fails
fworn to by the witnefs Lyons.
Mr. Aaron, a Jew attorney, of Pertfmourh, fwore,
t' at he had feveral communicatioas with Lyons nit
the fubjeft of this bill, who laid, he bad feveral bills
of the Defendant, who owed him nothing ; and that
be had various hills from the Defendant for the pur-
pole of difconnt ; he laid, be had two bills, oat of
which was the one in queftion, gives him by his af.
fignees, upon which he intended to arreft Mr. Coar-

incr.
Mr. Palmer, the Plaintiff's attorney, proved he had
had this bill in his poffellion upwards of a year.
Lord Ea.t.c w unarm m, in fumming up the evidence,
obferved to the Jury, that the whole of the faas of
Plaintiff's cite bad been proved by the witnefs Ly-
ons, of whore teffinsony they were the bet! judges.
If they did not think this witnefs deferring of credit,
the cafe was (tripped of any evidence ; and, accord
ding to the tenor of the letter, offering himfelf a wil-
ling witnefs at either fide, he did not well fee bow
they could believe him.
His Lordthip was interrupted by one of the Jury-
men, who told him the Jury were perkaly fasisfied,
as they did not believe one word the witnefs had

(Worn.
A rerclia was. therefore, found for the defendant.

CQURT OF COMMON PLEAS. NOVEMBER st

A bi Taw adios was brought by the Plaintiff, a
common informer, to recover two penalties of Sol.
each, with cogs—the one again(! the Printer and the
other &saint% The Publither of a Sunday newfpaper
called The Difpateh, for publifbinz a certain adver
tifement, announcing a hone race-Tor a left wager
than Sol. contrary to the datute of George 11. which
wads, that no race (ball be advertifed %therein the
parties ran for left than Sol.: and a motion was made
by Mr. Serjeant Damao for leave to compound, in
the fird cafe, for sol. penalty and 401. cods s and in
the fecond for *of. penalty and aol. cods.
Serjeant BAST, on the part of the Defendant, af•
(clued, and leave was given by the Court.
Nomura 39.0-000 nos O. NOLOITIRS.
This was an anion for a nuifance, brought by the
Plaintiff, who kept a cook's Chop in Idlandrd-ftreet,
Mancheder-fquate, againit the Defendant, a tallow-
' chavidler and tallow-welter, who lived nest dour
'to

him.
Serjeant Barr, in a very able wanner, Rated the
care of the Plaintiff, and called Owen Edwards, who
depnfed, that he lodged in the hook of the Plaintiff,
between January and Amril laß—and that he per-
ceived a very difagrerable fmell, twice a week ; that
he was often awoke out of his Reep, by a natty fmell,
which was fo bad, that he was obliged to get up and*
open the window, which fometimes relieved him ; but
often, when the wind blew from a particular point,
it only made it worfe, and obliged hint to that it
down again ; that it produced ficknefs in the Romach
and retching; and his .wife was affected with it, as
bid, if not worfe than himfelf ; and that when he
got up in. the morning, after one of the melting
nights, the houfe was full of fmoke or Ileam, which
had a very diffgreeable Nell, and that altogether
the houfe was very unplea(ant.
Martin Odber levore he lodged in the bow& of the
Plaintiff, about fix years and a half, and that the
Bench was not near fo bad when he Sett went there,
as it had been lately. He often buck a light in his
room, when he was awoke, but could not fee the
length of his arm haute him on account of the Ream.
and that he had often fisiike to the Defendant about
it, who jeered him, and laid it was very wholefome.
William Coverdel had been in the habit of going
to the Plaintiff's houfe to get his dinner, and had
beta more than once obliged to rife from his meal,
and go out on account of the linen. He bad feen
other perfons Jo the fame, it made them all Co deadly
lick, and that the Plaintiff had uot now fo many cuf
comers as he had when he first tiequented his thop.
Sarah Edwards, fervant to the Plaintiff, laid, the
frnell was pall bearing, twice a week ; and that the
!tad often teen her miltrets obliged to go into the
fields with her children, for the pttrpote of taking
Ere& air.
Some of the people of the neighbourhood were
then called, who proved, that they were greatly an•
noted by the Defendant's worldly p.
William Kitchen, a botcher, who lived opposite
to the Plaintiff laid, that before the Plaintiff came
into the neighbourhood, the landlord of the Defen-
dant had conic about to all, the neighbours, and ob-
tained leave from them that the Defendant might
carry on the fulfillers of a tallnw•chandler, but that
he should not melt tallow for his own tife, or for the
pnrpofe of telling. lie laid he now fold his fat to
the Defendant, lie having come to him and asked
him for it. The Witnets then ;liked him, how he
could have ore for his fat, when he had engaged not
to melt it ? to which the Defendant anfwercd, that he
would have his complement at any rate, mad might
as well have it Irom him as any one elfe—in confe-
deration of which he fold him his fat for the future.
Richard Rayner heard the Defendant Cay, he had,
made every thing As aarceable as he could.
Scrirant Snrrasao Haled the Defendant's cafe.
Joh Bates was called, who depotcd, he lived with
the Defendant, about liven years ago, and remained
about a year ; he then left him, and returned to him
about font years ago, and remained with him about
the fame time. The barna* had not increafed t when
he was there lad, he had often got the kitchen Ruff
front the Plaintiff tiv the purpofe of melting, and the'
fmell from it was much vim IC than from tat. They
melted fat twice a week, but did not melt kitchen
more than once in lie weeks.
Some other witnelfes were called, who (wire, that
the Defendant had no increale of Wane's. and that
he took much more care to oblige his neighbours
than any chandler they knew.
William Dove, a bricklayer, made nitrations in
the Defendant's preludes, for the purpofe of allowing
his men more rpom to work—that he had done every
thing by the Defendant's dirations, for the putpute
of preventing the fmell from annoying his neigh•
bouts; and that he bad a meeting about a month
ago, with three cr four chandlers, for the pairpofe of
itliking out tome way of carrying off the linen, but
nothing more could be done.
The Chandlers wises had met the left witnefs at the
Defendant's honfe were tailed, who (wore, every
thing that colds! be done was done, foe the purpcte