The Sun.
London, England, 1842-04-12 00:00:00

PARLIAMENTARY I

IVISION.

(From the Votes and Procecdzngs of the
MONDAY, APRIL

used Commons.)

INC ( iME 7 AX,

ate on Question [Bth
-undersigned persons
Nietropolis, against
.tion again proposed:
,0 House divided .-
221.

Order read for resuming adjourned Deb
Apr;l]. " That the Petition [,,f the there•
engaged in Profet•sions end radeS in 0;
the Income Taal be brought up t"—Quc
—Debate resumed i—Question put t-'-T"
Ferguson, o.onel
l'errand, W. B.
Fielden, J.
Fitzwiliam, G. W
Forester, Hon. G.
French, F.
0 Ibsen, T. M

Agilonby, H.. k.
Ainsworth, Peter
Aldan., William
Archbold, lt.
lial: wing C. Barry
Ba»neirnan, A.
Bar lay, David
Paring, -F. T.
l':artiard, E. G.
Bell, John
Berkeley, Captain
Berkeley, FL F.
Bernal, Captain
Blackstone, W. S.
lildke, Sir Valentine
Biewitt, Ileginald
Blunt, Sir C.
Borth, Irk, Peter
Bowes, J.
13owring, Dr.
Brock lehurA, .1.
Brodie, W. B.
Bretherton, J.
Browne, W.
Bryan, George
Bull, ley, Sir R. B. W.
Burroughes, N. N.
Busteilo, W.
Butter, Hon. P.
Byng, George -
Cave, 11. U.
CavendiSti, Hon. C.
Cayley, F. S.
Chapman, Benjamin
Childers, sAr.
Clay, S r W.
Clayton, It. R.
Clements, Lord
Cobe en, ttichard
Colebrooke, Sir T. E.
Collins, W.
ColvCle, C
Cower, Hon W.
Craig, V. Gibson
Crawford, W. S.
J;urrie, Itaikes
Curteis, tl B
Dalawny, Lord
Dalrymple, Captain.
Dawson, lion. T. V.
Denison, John Evely n
I) omistonn, J.
lick, Uuintin
Dick.nson. F. IT.
D'lsraeli, Benjamin
'lvett, L.
Duff, James
Duke, Sir James
Duncan, Lord
I)uncan, George
Dundas, C. NV. D.
Dundas, F.
Dundas, Hon. J. C.
Du Pre, George
This l hope, Sir John
Ebrington, Viscount
Egerton, Uri! Fran.
Elhee, It,. Hon. E.
Ellice, E.
Ellis, Wynn
Elphinstune, Howard
Lt wail, It..
Evans, V‘illiam
Ewart, W.

Philips, G. R.:
Phillpotts, John 1,
tiger 1). R.
Pinney, W.
Plumridge, Captain
Ponsonby, C. F. A.
Ponsonby, llon.Jolin
Powell, Caleb
Power, Jam',
Prothcroe, E.
Pulstord, It Bert
Ramsbottorn,
Rawdon, J. U.
Rennie, George
Ricardo, John Lewis
Itos,ell, Loin John
Russell, Lord E.
ttoch.eru d, A.
Seim!Meld, J.
Scott, Rcbe t
Scropt, (4. P.
.Sheil, R. L.
Sibthorp, Colonel
Smith, Lenjamin
Smith, J. A.
Sombre, -, 0 ,Dyee
:turners, J. .I'
Som2rville, Sir W.
Stanloy, VV
:Mansfield, W. It
St.fr.to,, W. H.
Staiit:ten, Sir 0.
St wart, M.
Strickland, Sir,G,_
Strutt; Edwa'd
Stuart, Lord J.
Stuart, W. Vi tiers
'Pancred, H. W.
Thornely, Thomfts
• Ilemaclle, F. J.
Tolls:maclie, John
Town, ley, John
Trouhridge, Sir T.
'Purnell, Henry
Turner, E •
Vane, Lord Harry
Villiers, Charles P.
Villiers, Frederick
Vivian, C. C.
Vivian, J. H.
Vii ian lion. Cai.tain
Wakley, Thomas
Walker, R.
Wall, B.
Wa!iace, R.
Ward, H. G.
Wason, Rigby
Waist', John r,
Westeara, H. It.
White, Luke
White, S.
Williams, Wm.
Wilshere, W.
Winnington, Sir '1
Wodehouse, Edmond
Wow, Benjamin
Wood, (3, W.
Wortley, Lord
Wortley, J. 'tuart
Wrightson, W
Yorke, H. itedhead

Gill. ThorriaS •
fiord- n, ly)rd F.
Gore, Robert
Granger, T. C.
Grattan, H.
ito, sit G. •
Grosvemr, Lord R.
Guest, .1.
Hall, Sir B.
Ilanmer, 41r John
Hlntly, Jehri
Harris. John Q
flastie, A.
Hatton, Capt.:An V.
Hayter, W. G.
Heathcoat, John
S r R.
Hill, Lord Mamas
1-I,Onouse, Sir .1.C.,
Howard. C. W. G. •
Howaid, J. K.
Howard, Lord
Howard, E. G.
Howard, P. H.
Howard, 11.
rivw,:.K Lord
Hutt, W.
James, W.
John: tone, Alex.
Labouehere, H.
Lainlnon, it.
Langston, J. 1-1.
Lecgton, W.
Leader, J. T.
Lemon, Sir C.
Listowel, Earl of .
Loch, James
Macaulay, T. B
M`Taggart, .101111
Marnii, Lord
Mainwaring, 'l'
Mangles, B. tr,
Warners, Lord J
Marjoribank,, S.
Alarshall, %V.
Martin. John
Henry
Mitcnell, T. A.
Morris, David
Morison, W lliarn
Morison, James
Mostyn, Hon. E. M. -
Murphy, F. S.
Napier, Sir Charles
Noricys, Sir D.
O'Brien, C.
0' i:rien, I.
O'Brien, W. Smith
O'Connell. D.
O'Connell, J.
Ogle, S. C. H.
Pag:, Frederick
Paget, Lord Alfred
Palmer, R.
Palmer, G.
Palmerston, Viscou n
Parker, John
Pendarves, E. W.

TELLERS.
Duncombe, T. S.
Hawes, B.

Aciand, 'l'. 1).
A'Court, Captain
Acker's, Janles
Acton, Colonel
Adare, Lord
Adderley, C. B.
.-i dual, Viscount
Allis, John Peter
A ntrobus, Edmund
Archdall, General
Arkwrig:.t, George
Ashley, Lord
Ashley, Hon H. A.
Astdll,' Wllham
Bagot, Hon. W.
Barley, J.
Bailey, Joseph, jun.
Colonel
H. J.
Baird, W:11 am
Balfour, J. 31.
Baring, W. B.
Barrington, Lord
Baskerville, T. IS. M.
Beckett, William
1;0.1,
Bentinck, Lord G
Ber. afoul, Major
Bernard, Viscount
Blackburn, John 1.
Buldero,Henry G.
kiotfwld, bcriah
Bradshaw, James .
Broa.,ley, Henry
Broadwood, H.
lkooke, Sir A. B.
ISrowurigg, J. S.
Bruc Lord E.
Brui c, C. L. •.
Bruen, Colonel
Buck,
.Lewis W.
Buckley, Edmund
Buller, 'Sir J. B. Y.
Burdett, Sir E.
Burred, Sir C. M.
Campbell, A.
1.1-lapin:ill, Aaron
Viscount"
Chet weile, john
Clerk, Sir G.
It. H,
Cochrane, A.
Cot oruc, W P.idley
Collett, W. Bickford
Cooto, Sir C. H.
Corry, H. L.
Lcurtenay, Viscount
Up; s, J.
I)user, lion. Dawson
Darby, ;_ieorgt
Dawilay, Hon. W.
D.idd, George
Dough s, Sii Howard
Douglas, Sir C. E.
3.•1). S.
Drummond, H. H.
Dugdale, W. S.
Duncombe, A.
Egerton, .T.
Ege ton, Sir P. G.
Lon.
Escott, Bichkam
Estronit, T. 6. B.
Farnham, E. B.
Feilden, W.

JOlll T V—NOES,
Fellowes, Edward
Filiner, Sir E •
Fitzroy, Captain
Fitzroy, Ho-. H. •
Follett, Sir W. W.
I'aibes, %%a:lam
Forester, lion. G.
Fuller, A. E.
Gaskell, J. M.
Gladstone, W. E.
Gorden, Hon. W.
Gore, Montague
Core, W. H. 0.
Goring, H. D. •
Goulburn, H.
G,aliam, Sir J.
Granhy, Marquis
Grant, Sir A. C.
Greena 1, Peter
Greehe, T.
Grimseitch. T.
Grimston, Lord
Grogan,
hale, It. B.
Haltord, H.
Hamilton, C J. B.
W. J. '
Harcourt, G. G.
Hardinge, Sir H.
Haw kos,
Hayes, Sir E.
ileatbcote, it V.
Ilenea;;c, a W. •
Ilcivey,a. W.
liepiairn, Sir T. B.
ilerbe.t, Hon. S.
1-I.llshorough, Earl o
• Ilnide, J. H. •
Hodgson, :IL
-Hodgson, F.
Hogg,. J. W.
Holmes, W. A'Court
Eopc, Charle-,
Herlihy, John .
Houldsworth' T.
ingestre, Lord
Irving, John
James, Sir Walter
Jer y Ear'.
_Jocelyn, Vneount
Johnson., W. G.
Johnstone, Sir John
Johnstone, Hope
Jones, 'J.'
Knatchbull, Sir E.
Knight, Henry Gaily
Knight, F Winn
Law, Hon. C. E.
Lawson, AlldiCw
Lei:ester, Earl of
',Mild 1:11. T.
Lincoln, Earl of
Lindsay, 11.
Lockhart, William
Low.ner, J. H.
I..wther, Colonel
Lyali, Ge,rge
Lygoii, General
Mackenzie, homas
Mackenzie, W. F.
Mackinnon,. W. A.-
M &Goan hv, F. A.
Manners, Lord C.
Alartyn, C. Cecil
Martin, G. It.

Master, T W. C.
Mas erman, John
Meynell, H.
Miles, P. W. S.
Milnes, 11. M. •
Bltxdaunt, Sir J.
Morgan, Octavius
Mundy,.E. Miller
Murray, C. R. S..
Neeld, John
Needle, Ralph
Newry, Viscount
Nichol', .1,
Surreys, Lord
No trilind. t.ord
O'Brie , A. Stafford
Ossulston, Lord
Owen, Sir J.
Packe. C. W.
Patten., John Wilson
Peel, Sir- R
Peel, Jonathan
Pemberton, T.
Pigot, Sir R. •
Planta, J.
Pluniptre, J. P.
Polhill, F.
P0111,.t ton, Viscount
Pollock, Sir
I owell, Colonel
Piaed, W. I.
Price. Richard
Pi logic?, A.
Rashleigh, William
Heade, W. M.
Reid, Sir J. 11. -
'lepton, George J.
la. /Janis, Richard
lU:re, Sir George
Round, C. G.
Russell, J. D. W.
Ryder, G. D.
Sativierson, R.
Situdon, Lord
Scarlett, Hon. R.
Sheppard. "I nomas
Shirley, E. P.
south, :fuel
Sorrier lord G.
Somerton, Viscount
Sotheron, T. H.
Stanley, Lord
Stuart, H.
Stint, H. C.
Sutton, Henry M.
Taylor, J. A.
'reorient, J. E.
Trench, Sir Frederick
Trevor, Hon. G. R.
Trollope, Sir John
Irotter, John
Vere, Sir C. 13.
Verrwr, W.
Vernon, Granville
NValsh, Sir J.
Wilbraham, it. 13.
Williams, T. P.
Wmod, Colonel
Wood, Colonel 'l'.
Wyndham, C,,lonel
Wynn, Sir W. W.
Young, John

Fr:ma:We. ;!.ir 'l'.
Baring, H. B.

CORONER'S INQUEST.

Yesterday forenoon a long inquiry, adjourned from Thurs-
day list, was resumed before Mr. Wakley, M.P., and a most
respectable Jury, at the infirmary of St. Marylebone k-
house, New-load, on the body of William Chapman, aged 47,
formerly a linendraper in an extensive way of business at
Pentonville, who was alleged to have died in consequence of
improper treatment at the hands of the police.
Mary Hill said, the deceased was her brother. He formerly
was a linendraper in a large way of business at Pentonville,
but had become reduced in circumstances, and lately lived in
Oxford-buildings, Oxford-street, and had been wholly main-
tained by herself and husband for some time, being from his
birth affected with paralysis of the left arm and the whole of
the left side. On Saturday week last she met him in Caven-
dish-square. and gave him some money for his support, and
was to meet him in the evening to give him some more. He
was a perfectly sober man, and she had never known him to be
intoxicated in her life, At II o'clock •on the same night she
heard he was in the station-house at Marylebone-lane, and she
went there to see him. The po!ice were very rough to her,
and would scarcely give her anv information about deceased,
only that "he was drunk," They would not permit her to go
to the cell to see him; but after great entreaties brought him
up to her. On bringing him up he was quite insensible, and
she at once told the police that he was not drunk, but very ill.
They would not believe her, hot- persisted in his being drunk,
and said that was what he was charged with. She gat him
bail or, the charge of drunkenness ; but no having sufficient
money to pay ter a cab to take him home, she was persuaded
to let him stay there all night, and gave money to a man named
Robinson to get. him some breakfast in the morning, and the
police said he would be seen to. They said they had found
hint drunk in Ge..'s-court, at tour that afternoon, sitting on a
step. On going next morning to the station-house, She found
he hail just been removed to Marylebone workhouse, where she
afterwards saw him. She was positive he was not iss.oxicated
when she saw him at the station-house.

~..,..
Dr. R. I3oyd, resident physician and surgeon of Marylehone
Infirmary, was then sworn. -He said deceased was brought
thereabout eleven o'clock on Sunday morning in a perfect state
of paralysis dual convulsions, on a stretcher, and he was in
tried that he had been al night in the station-house. Every
effort was used to produ e reaction, but the deceased stied at
four o'clock the next mornit.g. He had since, bv the Coroner's
order, made a post morteni xamination 01 the bo-dy. He ,ound
~_xtens:ve disease rit the brain of long standing on the right
side. One half of the right hemisphere was perfectly. ab-
sorbed, and tie space supplied by fluid. The left brain weighed
eighteen ounces and a half, and the right my nine oastices and
a quarter. He did riot think that the deceased's life could have
been saved, or his death accelerated, by any treatment he had
received at the hands of the police. A man with the brain in
such a state as that of the deceased might like all the appear-
ances of a ,:runken man, and be found in a state of stupor.
The CORONER said it vis.s a mest abotnimble practice, when
there were surgeons so easy cf access, for the police to loCk
up people presumed to be intoxicated without taking medical
opinton thereon, and it was throwing on the police themselves a
.degiee of responsibility which they ought not to be permitted
to bear.
Inspector Tedrnan said that he could produce witnesses who
saw the deceased it,ipgering as if intoxicated before he was
found by the policeman.
• The CORONER. said, that only showed the extreme diffi-
culty in deciding on such cases, and the absolute necessity of
calling in medical aid. Another point, and which was of equal
importance, was the system of placing a man who was drunk
in a cell,. without any place upon which his head could rest
above the level of his body. The result of this was, that
frequently the determination of Mood to the head would
cause'svessel to give way. and produce apoplexy. The floors
of the stations ouget to be built on inclines, or there ought to
be'inclined seats, with straps to keep drunken persons in an
upright position.
The Jury concurred in the views of the Coroner, and re-
turned a verdict of " Natural death," with a recommendation
that the treatment of persons found by the police in the, streets
in a state of stupor should be brought under the consideration
of the Police Commissioners, and their attenticn also directed
to the other suggestions thrown out.
Inspector Tedtnan said, he would lose no time in forwarding
the recommendations of the Coroner and Jury to the Cora-
missivners. •

ANOTHER COAL-PIT ACCIDENT.—On Thursday
morning last, one of the most alarming coal-pit accidents oc-
curred at a pit in °rehire, that has happened for a number of
years in this district, though not attended with immediate loss
of life. It appears that on the morning in question the miners
descended the pit as usual, about twenty in number, and re-
sumed their labour for a short time, when the fire-damp ex-
ploded With nuot alarming fury,
-10., A great number of the poor
unfortunate workmen are severely burnt, and some, it is pain-
ful to relate, are in a very perilous state. The names of the
sufferers we have been able to ascertain are John Grey, a..d
two persons of the names of Alai sh, brother and sister, who
reside in Chapel-late. We are informed that five or six others,
who re,iiie at Pemberton, are also very severely burnt.--
Bolton- Free Pro's.
At the ebb of the tide each day since the first dis-
covery of 'coil-1i opposite Lambeth Palace, men, women,
and
ehildrt n have been hard at work in sitting the mud, but with-
out much success. On Saturday, however, a lad found two
groat pieces, of the reign of Henry VIII., in ari excelle9t state
of pre servaton ; and three others of •Edward VI., were found
by a man named Jones.
A short time ago a carabineer, stationed at Clam-
bery, the capital of Savoy, having an animosity against one of hie
officers, fired at, but missed him. Another officer, hearing !h
report, came to inqiiire the cause, when the carabineeftli-12earvirneg
reloaded his piece, and, believing it was the first od
1;m
in-
turning to arrest him, discharged it again, and
stantly, The ma-, tn-
, a=eralrtinarti.a.), asi
• by
&timed to • •••• f:, .:.:• 0,7
h's „ a
tho W idol,
.• .•,_ • • ••.
children of the officer whose lite he Shad inveitintarily taken.