The Sun.
London, England, 1860-05-09 00:00:00

PARLIAMENTARY DIVISION'.

HOUSE OF COMMONS.—MAY 8.
PAPER DUTY REPEAL BILL.
- Order read, for resuming Adjourned Debate on Question
(24th April), " That the Bill be now read the third time :"
—Question again proposed :—Debate resumed :—Amend-
ment proposed, to leave out from the word "That" to the
end of the question, in order to add the words "the present
state of the finances of the country renders it undesirable
to proceed further with the repeal of the Excise duty on
paper," instead thereof :—Question put, " That the words
proposed to be left out stand part of the question :"—The
house divided :--The tellers reported the number as ayes
219, noes 209:—Notice taken that Mr. Ingram, one of filo
members for Boston, had been in the division lobby with the
noes, and having passed the division clerks, had avoided
being counted by the tellers : Whereupon Mr Speaker
directed the honourable member for Boston to come to the
table ; and Mr. Ingram being come to the table, stated that
he bad gone into the lobby with the noes by mistake :—Mr.
Speaker accordingly directed his vote to be added to the
noes, and declared the numbers to be, ayes 219, noes 210.

AYES - 219.
Acton, Sir J. Forster, Charles Ogilvy, Sir J.
Adam, W. P. Fortescue, Hon. D. Pacimore, R.
Agar-Ellis, Hon. L. Fortescue, C. S. Paget, Lord A.
Alcock, T. Freeland, 11. W. Paget, Lord C. E.
Andover, Lord Garnett, W. J. Paget, C.
Angerstein, W. Gavin, Major Palmerston, Visct.
Antrobus, E. Gibson, T. M. Paxton, Sir J.
Atherton, W. Gifford, Earl of Pease, H.
Ay",m, A. S. Gilpin, C. Peel, F.
Bagwell, J. Gladstone, W. E. Pilkinglon, James
Baines, E. Glyn, G. G. Pollard UrquhartW
Baring, Thos. Gco. Goldsmid, Sir F. Pousonby, A.
Baxter, W. E. Gordon, C. W. Pryse, Capt. E. L.
Bazley, Thomas Gower, F. L. Pritchard, John
Beale, Samuel Graham, Sir J. R. G. Proby, Lord. G. L.
Beamish, F. B. Greenall, G. Puller, C. W.
Berkeley, F. Greene, Capt. J. Raynham, Viscount
Bothell, Sir R. Greenwood, J. Redmond, J. E.
Black, Adam Gregson, S. Ricardo, 0.
Blake, J. A. Grey, Rt. Hn. Sir G. Richardson, J.
Blencowe, J. G. Gurney, John H. Ridley, G.
Bouverie, E. P. Hadfield, Geo. Robartes, T. J. A.
Bouverie, P. P. Hankey, Thomson Robertson, D. -
Briscoe, J. I. Harcourt, G. G. V. Rothschild BaronX
Browne, Lord J. T. Hardcastle, Jos. A. Rothschild,Baron L.
Buchanan, W. -Hartington,Marquia Roupell, W.
Buller, J. W. Hayter, Sir Wm. Russell, Lord J.
Buller, Sir A. Headlam, Thos. E. Russell, Hastings
Buxton, C. Henley, Lord Russell, A. J. E.
• Byng Hon. G. H. C. Herbert, S. Russell, F. W.
Caird, James . Hervey, Lord A Russell, Sir Wm.
Calcutt, F. Hodgsen, K. D. St. Aubyn, J.
Caithorpe, F. H. Howard, Hon. C. Salomong,Akierman
Cardwell, Rt. kin. E. Ingham, R. Salt, Titus
Carnegie, Hon. C. Jervoise, Sir J. Scholefle,d, W.
Castlerosse, Viet. Johnstone, Sir J. Scott, Sir W.
CavenCish, Hon. W. Kershaw, J. Seymour, Sir M.
Childers, H. C. E. Ring, Hon. L. Seymour, H. D.
Clay, James - Kinglake, Seri. J. Seymour, Digby
Clifford, IL M. Kingscote, Lt.-Col. Shelley, Sir J. V.
Clinton, Lord R. Laing, S. Sheridan, R. B.
Clive, George Langton, H. G. Sheridan, H. B.
Cogan, W. H. Lawson, W. Smith, J. B.
Collier, R. I'. Leatham, E. Smith, Augustus
Coningham, Wm. Lennox, Lord H. G. smollett, P.
Cowper, Hon. W.F. Lewis, Sir G.C., Bt. Stacpoole, W.
Craufurd, E. H. J Lindsay, W. S. Stafford, Marquis of
Crook, Joseph Locke, Jos. Staniland, M.
Cross, R. A. Locke, John Stansfeld. J.
Crosgley, Frank Lockhart, A. E. Stuart, Col.
Dalglish, Robert Lowe, Rt. Hon. R. Sykes, Col. W. H.
Davey, R. Lysley, W. Thompson, H. S.
Davie, Sir H. R. F. M'Cann, J. Tollemache, Hon.P,
Deasy, Rickard M'Cormick, W. Turner, J. A.
Denman, G. Mackinnon, W.A.in. Verney, Sir Harry
Dent, John Dent McMahon, P. Villiers, Rt. Hon. tf.
Dillwyn, Lewis L. Maguire, J. F. Waldron, L.
Douglas, Sir C. Mamwaring, T. Walter, John
Duff; M. E. Marjoribanks, D. C. Warner, Edward
Duff, Major. Marshall, W. Watkins, J. L. V.
Duke, Sir James Martin, P. W. Wemyss, J.
Dunne, M. Martin, J. Westhead, B.
Ennis, John Massey, W. N. Whalley, G. H.
Esmonde, John Merry, James Whitbread, S.
Evans, T. W. Miller, William Wickham, H. W.
Ewart, William Mitchell, T. A. Williams, W.
Ewart, J. C. Moncreiff, J. Wood, Rt Hn. Sir C.
, Ewing H. E. C. Monson, W. J. Woods, Henry
Fenwick, Henry Morris, D. , Worsley, Lord
Ferguson, R. Noble, J. Wrightson, W. B.
Feraioy, Lord North, F. Wyvill, M.
Fitzwilliam, C. W. O'Brien, P. TELLERS.
Foley, J. H. O'Connell, D. Brand, H. B.
Foley, Hon. H. W. O'Conoi Don, The Dunbar, Sir Wm.