The Sun.
London, England, 1853-05-31 00:00:00

PARLIAMENTARY DIVISIONS.

HOUSE OF COMMONS.—MAT 30.
( From the Votes and Proceedings of the House of

Commons.) -
INCOME TAX.

Clause 31 (tenants of lands who are called upon to pay
arrears due from former occupiers may deduct the
amount from their rent) :—Amendment proposed, at the
end of the clause to add the following proviso :—" Pro-
vided nevertheless, that nothing in this act shall be con-
strued to compel any occupier, being a tenant for the
time being, to pay the arrears of income tax due by any
former tenant or occupier of the same lands, tenements,
or hereditaments, or to deduct and retain from his land-
lord out of any subsequent payment of rent such arrears,
unless the landlord shall have received his rent for the
period for which the arrear is due." Question put,
. " That the proviso be there added." The committee
divided ; ayes 69, noes 145.
MINORITY—AYES, 69.
Arbuthnot, Gen. Farnham, E. Basil Michell, W.
Bonne, H. Ferrer. James Montgomery ,11. L.
Ball, Edward Fitzgerald, W. R. S. Morgan, Octavius
Barmy, IVm. 11. Forbes, William Muntz, G. F.
Bateson, T. Forster, Sir Geo. Naas. Lord
Bentinck, Geo. P. Frewen, C. H. Neeld, John
Blair, Colonel Galway, Viscount Palmer, R.
Blandford, Marquis George, John Smith, W. M
Brady, J. Grogan, E. Stafford, A.
Brainston, T. ‘r. Hamilton, Geo. A. Stanhope. James B.
Bruce, Cumin ing Harcourt, Col. Taylor, Col.
Buck, Lewis W. Herbert, H. A. Thompson, A Id.
Butt, G. Si. Herbert, Sir Thomas Tollemache, J.
Child, Smith Jolliffe, Sir,W. G. H. Trollope, Sir J.
Chohnondeley, Ld. 11. Jones, Capt. Tyler, Sir George
Christopher, R. Adam Kelly, Sir F. Vauslttart, G. H.
Christy, Samuel Kendall,!N. Vyse, Capt.
Coles, H. Beaumont Knox, W. S. Walcott, Adm.
Coote, Sir C. H Langton, W. G. Wynne, W.
Davies, D. Laslett, W.
Duncombe, Tin, A. Lockhart, W.
Duncombe. W. E. Lovaine, Lord
Dundee, G. Macartney, G.
Dunne, Col. Mathis, It. Spooner, Richard
Egerton, W. :deux, Sir Henry Freshfleld, J. W.

TELLERS.

MAJORITY-NOES, 145.

A'Conrt, C. Freestun, Colonel 3iurrough, J. P.
Anson, General French, Fitzstephen O'Connell, Maurice
Ball, John. Gladstone, William O'Flaherty, Anthony
Baring, H. B. Glyn, George Carr Otway, A. J.
Baring, Sir F. Goderich, Viscount Palmerston, 'Viscount
Beckett, William Goodman, Sir George Patten, J.
Bell, James Grace, 0. Peto, S.
Beribow, John Graham, Sir J. Phillimore, J.
Berkeley. C. L . Greene, J. Phillimore, I:. J.
Bothell, Richard Gregson, Samuel Pils ington, J.
P.lackett, J. F. B. Grenfell. C. Pollard-Urquhart. W.
Bland, L. Grey, Sir G. Ponsonby, Hon. A.
Benham-Carter, John Grosvenor, Lord R. Ricardo, 0.
Boyle, Colonel Grosvenor. Earl Rice, E.
Bright, John - Pladfleld, George Robartes, T. J. A.
Br otherton, Joseph Hall, Sir Benjamin Russell. Lord J.
Brown, William Harmer, Sir J. Russell,Y. C.
Bruce, H. A. thistle, Archibald Russell, F. W.
Butler, Charles S. Heard, J. I. Sadleir, J.
Cardwell, Hon. E. Herbert, Sidney Sawle, C. B. G.
Chaplin, W. J. Hervey, Lord Alfred Shelburne, Earl of
Charteris, F. Heywood, James Shelley, Sir J. V.
Chcetham, John Hindley, Charles Sheridan. R. B.
Cobden, Richard Howard, W. G. Smith. J.
Cocks, Thomas S. Hughes, W. B. Smith, Rt. lin. R.
Collier, Robert P. Hutchins, E. Smollett, A.
Cowan, Charles Hutt, William Stafford, Marquis
Cowper, W. Keogh, William Strutt, E.
Craufurd, E. H. J. Kershaw, JameB Stuart, H.
Crook, J, Kinnaird, ♦. F. Thicknesse, R. A.
Crossley, F. Kirk, William Thompson, George
Crowder, R. Lacon, Sir E. Thoniely, T.
Dalrymple, Vise. Langton, H. G. Towneley, C.
Davie, Sir H. Lemon, Sir C. Traill, G.
Denison, J. E. Lewis, Sir T. Vane, Lord H.
Dont, J. Lowe, Robert Vernon, G.
Divert, E. Mackinnon, W. A. Vivian, J. H.
Duncan, George Macgregor, James . Walmsley, Sir J.
Dunlop, A. 3.l`Targart Sir J. Whalley, G.
Elliot, J. E. l'llarjorrbanks, D. Whitbread, Samuel
Esmonde, J. Mar tin, John Wickham, H. W.
Euston, Earl Massey, W. Wilkinson, W. A.
Evans, W. Milligan, H. Wilson, James
E wart, William Milner, W. M. E. Wyndham, W.
Fergus, John Moffatt, G. Young, Sir John
Ferguson, Col. Molesworth. Sir W.
Ferguson. Joseph Moncreiff, James
Fitzroy, Henry Monsell, William
Fertescue. Chichester Morris, D. Hayter, Hon. W.
Fox, W. J. Mostyn, E. M. Mulgrave, Earl

TZLLZAS.

•
Clause 33 (deduction to be allowed under Schedule,(A) for
the expenses of making and repairing sea Nitlli'and em-
bankments):—Amendment proposed, at the end of the
clause to add the following words :—" And in like manner
an allowance and deduction shall be made for the amount
of all parochial rates, taxes, or assessments charged on
any lands, tenements, hereditaments, and heritages iu
Scotland, which by statute or custom are payable by the
landlord or owrfer thereof." Question put, " That those
words be there added." The committee divided ; ayes
42, noes 101.

MINORITY—AYES, 42.
Arbwithnott, General George, John Morgan, C. Rodney
Barrow, W. H. Gordon, Admiral Mullings, J. R.
Blair, Colonel Greaves, Edward Naas, Lord •
Burke, Sir T. Greene, J. Pollard-Urquhart, W .
Butt, I. Grogan, E. Sthollett, A.
Campbell, Sir A. Hamilton, G. A. Spooner, R.
Carnac, Sir J. R. Jones, Captain Swirling, W.
Cowan, Charles Kendall, Nicholas Taylor, Colonel
Crautlird, E. 21 acartney, G. Traill, 0.
Dalrymple, via. M'Slahon, P. Vansittart, Georg H.
Dundas, G. M'Tagg art, Sir J.
Dunne, Col. Maguire, J.
Ferguson, Sir Robert Malins, Richard
Forbes, W. Meagher, Thom&
Forster, Sir G. Montgomery, H.
Freen, C. IL Bailey, 11. j
w Montgomery, Sir 0,
Lockh
art, W.

TELLIRD.

- - -
MAJORITY—NOES, 101.
Acland, Sir T. Gladstone, William Phillimore, u.
A'Court, C. Goodman, Sir G. Phinn, T.
Baines, M. T. Graham, Sir James Pigott, F.
Ball, John Grosvenor. Earl
Ponsonby, .Berkeley, Craven L. Hadfield, Gem': e Price, Sir It
Hn L.G. J .
Bethell, Richard Balmer, Sir John
Ramsden,
Blackett, J. F. Hastie, Archibald Rice, E. Sir J.
Bland, L. Heard, J,
Russell,
Bonham-Carter, J. Herbert, Sidney Rus:.ell, `V rd
F. W .
Boyle, Col. Hervey, Lord
Alfred Sadleir, J.
Brockman, E. D. Hey a orth, li. Sawle, C. B. G.
Rrotherton, J. • Johnstone, Sir J. Scobelt, Capt.
Brown, W. Keogh, William Smith, John Benj.
Butler, Charles Kiiinaird, A. F. Strickland, Sir G.
Cardweil, E. Kirk, William Strut,, Rt. lion. E.
Cavendish, C. Langston, .1. H. Thicknesse, It. A.
Cavendish, George Lemon, Sir C. Thompson, 0.
Charteris, F. Lewis, Sir T. F. Thornely, T.
Cheetham, john Lowe, R. Wernon.G. E. H.
V Illters, Bt. liit. C.
Cobden Richard Mackie. J.
r• • , J. H.
CollierAtobert P. Macgregor, James N ivial , •..
Walmaley, Sir J.
Coots, Sir Chas. H. II iall, E.
Cowper, W. F. Milligan, Robert
Crook, J. Mills T.
Crossley, Frank alitdieli, T.
• trinanson, V.
Davie, sir li, Moffatt, G.
W ' {Whams,
William
Moleaworth, Sir W.
,iiraw,i, j.
Duncan, G.
sir C.
Monerier, J. Wo•xl, '
Dunlop, A.
Slt J
Mtn rough, J. F. miwg, J.
Egerton, Edward . . mauiCO Y
0 Cannes), _ _ red
Eamonde, John Lord Ahr
pap et. Ferguson, Joseph Palmerston, VI&
Fitzgerald, J. 1).
Fatte J. 111%vVjileilaiktIbli)ear3.,:ia', t.1(11,;Se:, 11.
Crook,
W.
I Fox, W. J.
ri
Fitzroy,Fttzge.a 1Rd.0.W..g.
rrheielliimr.ore, J.

TZLLE7III.

Ilayter, W. G.
Mulgraxa, Earl