The Sun.
London, England, 1853-06-21 00:00:00

PARLIAMENTARY DIVISION.

HOUSE OF COMMONS.-JuNx 20.

( From the Votes and Proceedings of the House of
Commons. )
SUCCESSION DUTY BILL.

Clause 21 (In estimating the annual value of lands used
for agricultural purposes, houses, buildings, tithes, teinds,
rent-charges, and other property yielding or capable of
yielding income not of a fluctuating character, an allow-
ance shall be made of all necessary outgoings ; but there
shall be included in such estimate, in the case of a succes-
sor not restricted from cutting the timber thereon, the
computed annual value of such timber, not being timber
planted or left standing for the shelter or ornament of a
mansion house, and valued therewith :—Amendment pro-
posed, to leave out from the word "outgoings," to the end
of the clause :—Question put, " That the words but there
shall be included, &c.' stand part of the clause :"—The
Committee divided—Ayes, 150; Noes, 153.

MINORITY—AYES, 150.
A'Court, C. Fox, W. J. Mure, Col.
Alcock, Thomas Gardner, Richard Norreys, Lord
Anderson, Sir James Gladstone, William O'Brien, Patrick
Barnes, T. Gladstone, Captain Oliveira, Benjamin
Bass, M. T. Glyn, George Carr Osborne, Ralph
Beaumont, W. B. Goderlch, Viscount Paget Lord George
Bell, J. Goodman, Sir G. Palmer, R.
Berkeley, Adm. Graham, Sir James Palmerston, Via.
Bethell, Richard Greene, J. Pechell, Sir G.
Bonham-Carter, John Grenfell, C. Pellatt, A
Boyle, Col. Hadfield, George Philippe, J. H.
Brand, H. Hall, Sir Benjamin l'hillimore, R.
Brockman, E. D. Basile, Alexander Phinn, T.
Brotherton, J. Butte, Archibald Pilkington, James
Bruce," 11. A. Headlam, T. E. Pinney, W.
Butler, Charles Herbert, Sidney Robartes, T. J. A.
Bymr, G. H. Charles Hervey, Lord Alfred Russell, LordJ.
Cardwell, lion. E. Hindley, Charles Russell, F. C.
Challis, Alderman Hogg, Sir James W. Russell, F. W.
Chambers, T. Hughes, W. B. &obeli, Captain
Christy, S. Butt, William Seymour, W. 0
Clay. Sir W. Ingham, R. Shafto, R. D.
Cobden, Richard Johnstone, James Shelburne, Earl
Cockburn, Sir A. Johnstone. Sir J. Shelley, Sir J. V.
Collier, Robert P. Keating, Robert Sheridan. It. B.
Cowan, Charles Keogh, William Smith, R. V
Cowper, W. F. Kinnaird, A. 1. Smollett, A.
1 Craufurd, E. 11. J. Kiik, William Stuart, Lord D.
Crook, J. Labouchere, 11. Swift, R.
Crossley, F. Laing, S. Tancred,:ll. W.
Crowder, Richard B. Langston, J. M. Thicknease, R. A.
Dalrymple, Vise. Langton, 11. G. Thompson, G.
Dasliwood, Sir G. Layard, A. 11. Villiers, Rt. lime.
Davie, Sir H. Locke, J. Vivian, J. H.
Denison, E. Lowe, R. Walmsloy, Si r J.
Duncan, George Luce, T. Warner, E.
Dunlop, A. Mackie, J.
Wickham, H. Whitbread,
Samuel
Ellice, E. Macgregor, John
Elliot, John Marshall, W.
Emlyn, Viscount Massey, W. Wilkinson, W. A.
Esmonde. John Masterman, John Wilcox, B.
Evans, William Matheson, Sir I. Williams, W.
Ewart, William Mauls, Colonel Wilson, J.
Fagan, W. Miall, E. Wise, A.
Fergus, J. Milligan, R. Wortley, Jas. Stead
Ferguson, Col. Mills, T. Wrightson, W.
Fitzgerald, W. R. S. Milner, W. M. E. Wyvill, M.
Forster, Charles Monck, Lord Young, Sir John
Forster, J. Moncrieff, J. TELLERS.
Fertescue. Chichester Monsen, William Hayter, W. G.
Fox, R. Morriso D. Berkeley, Grenville.
MAJORITY—NOES, Is.
Acland, Sir T. Farrer, James Neeld, John
Adderley, C. Fellowes, Edward Newark, Viscount
Aglionby, it. A. Filmer, Sir Edmund Newelegate, C.
Alexander, J. Floyer. John Oakes, J. H. P.
Archdall, Captain M. Forbes, W. Packenham, E.
Arkvir right, G. Forster, Sir (leo. Pakington, Sir John
Aspinall, J. T. Franklyn, G. W. calmer, Robert
Bailey, Sir J. Frewen, C. H. Parker, R. T.
Baird, James Graham, Lord M. W. Percy, J.
Ball, Edward Granby, Marquis Pigott. F.
Bankes, G. Greaves, Edward Pollard-Urquhart, W.
Baring, T. Greene, T. Portman, W.
Barrow, Wm. 11. Grogan, E. Powlett, Lord W.
Bateson, T. Gwyn, bowel Prime, R.
Bennet, Philip Hanmer, Sir J. Ramaden, Sir J.
Bentinck, Lord 11. Hawkins, William Robertson, P. F.
Dentinck, G. P. Hayes, Sir E. Rushout, Captain
Berkeley, Craven F. Heneage, G. F. Sanders, G.
Blair, Colonel Henley, J. W. Sawle, C. B. G.
Booth, Sir R. Herbert, 11. A. Seymer, 11. K.
Bowyer, George Hilciyard, R. Seymour, Lord
Bramston. T. W, Hume, W. F. Sibthorp, Colonel
Browne, V. Irton, Samuel Smijth, Sir W.
Bruce, C. L. C. Joliiffe, Sir W. G.H. Smith, W. M
Buller, Sir J. Jones, Captain Smyth, R. J.
Bunbury, W. Kendall, N. Somerset, Captain
Burrell, Sir C. M. Ker, D. S. Spooner, Richard
Burroughes, Henry N. King, James King Stafford, A.
Butt, Gco. Medd Kingscote, R. N. F. Stafford, Marquis
Butt, I. Knlghtley, Rainald Stirling,:W.
Calrns,ll.M`Calmont Knox, Colonel Strickland, Sir G.
Campbell, Sir A. Knox, W. S. Start. 11.9.
Carnac, Sir J. Rivett Laflan, R. M. 'Talbot, C.
Cayley, E. S. Lockhart, A. E. Tudway, R. C.
Chelsea, Viscount Lockhart, W. Tyler, Sir G.
Christopher, R. A. Lovable, Lord Vance, J.
Clive, R. H. Lowden, P. Van sittart, George H
Clive. R. Lowther, Colonel Villiers, Francis
Codrington, Sir Wm. Lowther, Captain Vivian. J. Ennis
Colville, C. R. Macartney, G. Vyvyan, Sir R.
Conolly, T. Manus, Richard Waddington, H.
Davison, R. March, Earl of Walcot, Adm.
Dent, J. Maxwell, James P. Wall, Charles Baring
Hering, Sir E. Michell, W. Walsh, Sir J. B.
Dod. J. W. Montgomery, Sir G. West, Frederick R.
Drummond, Henry Moo -e, Ross S. Whitmore, Henry
Duff, G. Mostya, E. M. Wyndham, W.
buncombe, W. E. Mullings, J. R. Wynn, Herbert W.
Dunne, Col. Mundy William York, E. T.
East, Sir J. B. Murrough, J. P. TZLLF.IB.
Egerton. E. Naas, Lord Troltope, Sir J.
Farnham, E. Basil Napier, J. Taylor, Col.