The Sun.
London, England, 1853-05-27 00:00:00

MINORITY-AYES, 172.

Adair, 11. Fitzroy, Henry Mullings J. Randolph
Aglionby, 11. A. Foley, J. H. Muntz, G. F.
Alcock, Thomas Forster, Charles Murphy, F. S.
Anderson, Sir James Forster, J. Mu: rough, J. P.
Bailey, C. . Fortescue, C. Norreys, Lord
Baines, ?el T. Fox. W. S. Oliveira, B.
Ball, Edward Gat dner, R. Osborne, Ralph
Barnes, T. (leach, Charles Paget, Lord George
Bass, M. T. Gibson, Thomas H. Peelle'', Sir G.
Beaumont, W. B. Glyn, George Carr Pellatt, A
Bell, James Goderich, Viscount Phillimore, J.
Berkeley, H.' Goodman, Sir George Phimi, T.
Berkeley, Craven F. Gower, F. L. Pigott P.
Bethel', Richard Greene, J. Pas ington, J.
Biddulph, R. M. Gregeon, Samuel Potter, R.
Biggs, William Grenfell, C. Price, W. P.
Blackett, J. F. B. Grey, Sir G. Ramsden, Sir J.
Bland, L. Grosvenor, Lord R. Ricardo, 0.
Bonham-Carter, JoLn Medfield, George. Robartes, T. J. A.
Bouverie, E. Hall, Sir lienjainin Russell, F. C.
Bower, G. Ilanmer, Sir J. Sadleir, J.
Boyle, Colonel Hustle, Alexander Scholetleld, W.
Brady, John Hustle. Archibald Seobell, Captain
Brand, H. Headlam, T. E. Scully, F.
Bright, John Heywood, James Seymour, H. D.
Brocklehuret, John Hey a orth, L. Seymour, W. D.
Broiherton, Joseph 'Lindley, Charles . Shelley, Sir J. V.
Brown, William Howard, W. G. Sheridan, R. B.
Bulkeley, Sir It. B. Hume, Joseph Srnii:h, J.
Butler, Charles Hutchins, E. Smith, M. Tucker
Ilyng, G. H. Charles Hutt, William Smith, Rt. Hn. R.
Cavendish, C. C. Keating, H. S. Strickland, Sir G.
Chambers, Montagu Kennedy, T. Strutt, E.
Chambers, Thomas Keogh, William Stuart, Lord D.
Chaplin, W. J. Kershaw, James Sullivan, M.
Cheetham, John King, P. J. Swift, R
Clifford, H. Kinnaird, A. F. Talbot, C. R. M.
Cobbett, J. Morgan Langston, J. H. Tancred, Henry Wm.
Cobden, Richard Langton, 11. G. Thicknesse, it. A.
Coffin, W. Laslett, W. Thompson, George
Collier, Robert P. Layard, A. H. Tbornely, T.
Craufurd, E. H. J. Lee, W. Towneley, C.
Crossley, F. Lowe, R. Vivian, J. 11.
Currie, Raikes Lucas, F. Vivian, Henry H.
Dashwood, Sir G. H. }Mann, James Wall, Charles Baring
Divett, Edward Macgregor, John Walmsley, Sir J.
Duffy, C. G. Maguire, J. F. Warner, Edward
Duke, Sir J. Martin, John Whalley, G.
Duncan' G. Massey,, IV. N. Wilkinson, W. A.
Duncombe, T. Meagher, Thomas Wilcox, B.
Dunlop, A. lii fall, Edward Winnington, Sir T. Ii
Ellice, Rt. lion. E. Milligan, Robert Wise, A.
Ellice. E. Mills, T. Wyvill, H.
Estnonde, J. Mi ner, W. M. E.
Ewart, William Mitchell, T. A.
Fergus, John Moffatt, G.
Ferguson, Joseph Molesworth, Sir W. Clay, Sir William
Fitzgerald, J. i). Morris, D. Peto, S.
Fitzgerald, Sir J. Mostylt, E. H.

MAJORITY—NOES, 220.
A eland, Sir T. Gooch,:Sir, E. Noel, lion. G.
A'Court, C. Graham, Slr James North, Colonel
Adderley, C. Graham, Lord M. W. Oakes, J. H. P.
A rchdall, Captain Granby, lila, quis Ossulston, Lord
Arkwright, G. Greaves, Ea V 4 ard Pak et, Lord Alfred
Atherton, Win. Greenali, Gilbert raking ton, Sir John
tinge, W. Greene, T. Palmer, lt.
Bankes, G. . Grogan, E. , Palmerston, Viscount
Baring, Sir F. Grosvenor, Earl Parker, R. T.
Baring, T Guernsey, Lord Peel, Sir lt.
Harrington, Viscount Gwyn, Rowel Peel Frederick
Barrow, Wm. 11. Ila:e, Robert B. Peel, Colonel
Bennet, Philip Daisy, T. Pennant, Col.
Bentinck, Geo. P. Hamilton, Geo. A. Percy, J. W illiam
Blair, Colonel Ihnbury, Hon. C. Philipps, J. 11.
Boldero, Colonel Ha' court, G. G. 1 hillimore, K.
Booker, Thos. Wm. Harcourt, Col. Portal, Melville
Booth, Sir R. Hardline, Charles S. Portman, Ilit. W.
Bramston, T. W. Hayes, Sir E. Pritchard, J.
Brockman, E. D. Ileathcoate, Sir G. Itepton, G.
Brooke, Sir A. lleathcote, Gilbert H. Robertson, P. F.
Bruce, Lord E. lieneage, G. H. W. Bolt, P.
Bruce, 11. A. lleneage, G. F. Rumbold, C. E.
Buck, Lewis W. Herbert, Sidney Russell, LordJ.
Huller, Sir J. Y. Hervey, Lord Alfred Russell. F. W.
Burghley, Lord Ilildyard, Robert C. S a Ild ars, ti..
Burroughes, Henry N Hotham, Lord Sawle, C. B. G.
Butt, I. Hughes, W. B. Seaham, Lord.
Cairns, 11. M'Calmoat Hume, W. F. Seymer, 11. K.
Campbell, Sir Arch. Ingham, Robert Seymour, Lord
Cardwell, lion. E. Inglis, Sir R. H. Suatith, Sir W.
Cavendish, George Jerilyn, Earl Smollett, A.
Cayley, E. S. Johnstone, Sir J. Somerset,Captain
Cisarteris, F. Jolilife, Sir W. G. H. Sotheron, T. U.
Chelsea, Viscount Jones, Captain Spooner, Richard
Chohnondeley, Ld. H. Jones, D. Stafford, A.
Christopher, R. Adam Kelly, Sir F. Stafford, Marquis
Clive, It. 11. Kendall, N. Stanhope, J. U.
Clive, R. Kinescote, R. N. F. Stanley, Lord
Cobbold, J. Chevalier Kirk, William Stephenson, Robert:
Cocks, Thomas S. Knatchbull, Wm. F. Stirling, W.
Coles, 11. Beaumont Kieghtley, Rainald Stuart 11.
Colville, C. R. Laeon, Sir E. Taylor, Colonel
Coote, Sir C. H Laffan, it. M. Thes (ger, Sir N'.
Corry, Henry Lowry Langton, W. G. Tollemache, John
Cowper, W. Lawley, F. C. Trollops, Sir J.
Davies, D. A. S. Lennox, Lord H. G. Turner, C.
Denison, E. Lewisham, Ld Tyler, Sir G.
Dent, J. Liddell, 11. G. Vance, J.
Dering, Sir E. Lindsay, Colonel Vane, Lor! A.
Disraeli, B. Lockhart, W. Vansittart, G. IT.
Duckworth, Sir J. Long, W. Vivian, J. Ennis
East, Sir J. Lovalne, Lord Vyvyan, Sir It.
Egerton. Sir Philip Lowther, Colonel Waddington, IT.
Egerton, W. Lytton, Sir E. G. Walcot, Adm.
Egerton, E. Macarteney, G. 'Walpole, S. H.
Elliot, J. E. Mackie, J. Walter, John
Euston, Earl Macgregor, James West, Frederick R.
Farnham, E. Basil Maddock, Sir 11. Whatman, J.
Furor, James Manners, Lord G. Whitbread, Samuel
Fellowes, Edward Manners, Lord J. Whitmore, H.
Ferguson. Sir Robert Masterman, John Wickham, 11. W.
Fitzgerald, W. R. S. Maxwell, lion J. P. Wigratn. L. T.
Fioyer, John Meux, Sir Henry Wood, Sir C.
Fol ett, B. Spencer Riles, W. Woodd, B.
Forester, Col. Michell, W. Wortley, Jas. Stuart
Forster, Sir G. Moncreiff, James Wrightson, Sir Win.
Frewen, C. H. Montgomery, Sir G. Wyndham, General
Gallwey, Sir W. P. Moody. C. A. 'Wynne, W.
Galway, Viscount I
Moreau' C. It. Yorke, Eliot T.
George, John Mundy William You6g, Sir T.
Gladstone, William Fans, lord .
TELLIES/I.
Gladstone, Captain Newark, Viscount Hayter, Hon. W.
Goddard, Aaabront L. Newdegate, C. Berkeley, Grenville

HIGIE WATER AT LONDON BRIDGE.
THIS DAY —Morning 51 min. after 4 Evening 18 min.aft. 5
To-Moultow—Morning 43 min. after 5 I Evening 10 min.aft. 6

the Sublime Porte may have been by the andacil
of the Court of St. Petersbargh, it has all along
placed an implicit reliance in the justice, and in thes
honour, and in the resolution of the allied Cone
of St. James's and the Tuileries. Notwithstanding
the military forces collected. together on the 11115:
sian frontiers—notwithstanding, in fact, the 11151:,.1;
time armament assembled on the waters of
tilf
Black Sea—the Divan has ever felt confident °,
securing effectual assistance in the hour of
(bilge;
through the simultaneous appearance of the Frencv
and English Fleets at the mouth of the Pill
danelles. That confidence, we rest assured, s(ce
never, on the arrival of a lamentable crisis, P7O,
to have been in any manner misplaced. Tur.nii
has a guarantee of this at once in the honour ao,
in the interest of the French and English
vemments.

-- ---- le
The House of Commons was so fully ee. of
with the interesting and important question 4
Church Rates last night that no time
to dispose of the Income Tax Bill. That aill'isny
therefore, remains for this evening, when we
..ot,
pose it will finally be disposed of. There i' not,
however, much hope for those who have been
fering under the iniquitous system that prec_.,o
for eleven years. Not a single person lias e'.,,
(1131"
given notice of bringing forward an anlen oi
for the purpose of obtaining a more equitably $7
impartial assessment, or even the slightes 0
• of '
proximation to justice by the recognition
3000
reiaa:.oect,
distinction, however trifling, between Peri3l,4le•
and precarious income. One Honourableu:oo,
man, the representative of an Irish COO'
tuency, while evincing a creditable 3/1 el
to improve the details of the ineas.llre'o
points exclusively relating to the sister •Ina
has given notice of motion, that " the og, tio
1)0
to persons whose respective incomes arele:dol
1501. a year, shall be continued in respect ',OO
duties chargeable under schedules D and .7 'te
also "in respect of any duties chargeibeej t!
any income, stipend, or emolument, reeeif f as!
Clergyman, Minister, or Religious Teacher °oii'
denomination, from or in right of any eles,
cal benefice, preferment, or in respect of ntseber,
pation as such Minister or Religious Te3,itiou,
We thank Mr. BUTT for this excellent proPe' Ije
It is true that it affords but an infinitesiteee3F
gree of relief ; that it does not in any deg XO4
nefit the numerous sufferers with incases,i
bg'
ing from 1501. to 3001. per annum ; 0
would keep the collector from the do° 0
those whose positions are, of all others'to
most difficult to maintain ; it would prece,l),
impost from touching on the domains of '3oit,
from including in its operation men will' over
varying from 21. to Si. per week, or tlle,d
toiled and under-paid ministers of the
lo veett
whose scanty remuneration is totally ad
Beet?
to maintain the position which an educated tV
men should assume, or to the exercise °fa $$J
Christian charities befitting his sacred calliV
which the sick and the destitute are seclisold'i
to consider almost as a right ; for it is 3fe pet?'
able fact, that it-is not to the rich and P3131t
pluralist —the wealthy incumbent --tlit,:t,
afflicted turn with almost a certainty of 35°' 1
but to those who must curtail their es°,AP
forts—we had almost said necessariesooo
who must purchase by their own privy' ootf
expensive luxury of doing good. Blit'tll
especially do we thank the Honourable Gen; of
for the universality of his proposition-ti'"
no exclusive privilege intended ; no sec
favour to one at the expense of his brother.of
Burr's amendment comprehends the Ministe,l4
Religious Teachers of every denomination) 'ooo'
the Roman Catholic as the Protestant, tl/440!
senter as the State Churchman. This
should be ; and most sincerely do we hope Iff
will insure the success of the amendment: poi!
could anticipate any degree of independenv",,, bv,
part of those who at one time refused wie
themselves to the chariot wheels, or red 10
;
o
their own convictions at the behest, •0 f
Minister, we should have no denbAeciei
the result. As it is, we await the 'i
patiently. If it should be in se&fe?,
with justice and expediency, we shall i f
for the sake of those who have esalf
undue responsibility. If, on the other /0-1
Chancellor of the Exchequer should ~,'
triumph—if "might should once .more, !ti,,,
over right "—we shall comfort ourselves 1(11
consideration, that the more atrocious the r,f,Vl
the sooner we may anticipate its overtbreileilie
when the " iniquity " is thoroughlynnLl
and the full extent of the burden WV:
dured, the pressure from without will,,j
irresistible, and the law must be resu'ooe;
materially improved, even long before °ld°
years' lease, to which the obedient Legis'iet°'
about to affix its seal, shall have expired. thwes-li/ji
circumstances, and whatever may be theari, r,f
the proceedings, we willingly render to olotii, ,
the approbation to which he has enitebief
titled himself for his judicious and ego"'
position.
0
Mr. BLACKETT, too, merits thanks torte 01
r IT
1:Y
positions, by which due allowances are vte' f:
for the bad debts, and losses by bankfTii,"
solvency, or the acceptance of coroPesiorr'
which every trader is liable, and all° iP°oc l v
derate allowance for the wear and teilr,g-e 01
nery employed in any manufacture.
_," to eri
gladly have seen the allowance eaten de' 06
kind of trade or professional expenditureit Fief
viously recognised ; but, even as it is'no g', 1
if sanctioned, remove some very sel:s{,e,3
antes, and materially improve the 5,71. 1 elji?
would, however, be letting in "the s°ooloo3
the wedge," and would lead to an erre'lliiibitiii
that any regard to justice would be lir, vit il'
the assessment—a precedent wiliell .01 l'''tP
STONE will unquestionably resist wl,l ",of
powers. Well, nous verrons, time will teejo of ,YOl4
manufacturers of the West Riding, them osy
chester, will think of no allowance begedsfool
bad debts or depreciated machinery.
and i"
perhaps arrive when Messrs. Cosnrs eto 01
foro 113 ii
will rejoin the ranks of the Fiscal Be dOf v
an ' 0,1
which they have so recently secededProde it,
veteran JOSEPH HUME, head the 0.„05t ,g, cite
industrious classes against the 'Of
ti,
and iniquitous instance on recor that f,
legislation." At present, all those OF
for the friends of the people/ forositiol,lof;
recognise the justice of the Pr°ll ad'ie tid
every new law should tend to the
gOod pr i
of " the many," that " the greates' the 0
greatest number is a sacred princiPi:oo/4
never be lost sight of by eurEfla;euri.aiit:iicaah:::_st
enter their earnest protest against sairedrieg,d f
based on injustice, and (as we have t dis iiii/i
exhibiting in all its parts a
the commonest principles of
almost as demoralising and impolitiseter 0:1% I
just and inexpedient," and to lb ,001* 0 fr.
alike the agitation which its tp eli,
Fo
certain speedily to excite. t littief Y
sent Parliament we have ha- oo- to I
bide „ro 0
tation of relief. But we
of the 10°01ii
Whatever may be the result ~.ssolot,o
a
11.1 1
Reform Bill, there must be 0 orii,
year. Every Honourable Gentle Oso' i"ii
have to render a strict account °le ard Peer)
if seeking a renewal of confidenc '
ottersi.Peti,
lens Pep„
day of reckoni,2-2ff„...
on the Income Tax will not be forgoollc, i
______---- ilo,ry
Each gel' ;
When a Chancellor of the oil .ili
Mg, lie
11l
weathered the east winds of oat
00
holiday-making
dparye.t.mtyakisunrge
toefullpiiesrßauddhgeerti4 rhasepn`/0,10,11fti4
the sweets of Whitsuntide an
what clOg- ()O.')
spirit of obstructiveness begins
* g ace Sill the
what with the near approachnf:;;ecirf, °I)01:;54011,1
Members get afraid of being wich 0 i
no one likes, by delaying t°() ,;0 ofn 0501 ti
to delay les of 004
of Cabinet measures,
Already Mr. DISRAKLI gives S, to 01 t, pe
and we fear that we are destine,' vodge joy
bitter as well as the sweet been destine,'
nooliljjifi
vr ise or 1,
Mr. GLADSTONE'S SCIICIDOS ' 0 rer r
~., -stoissPself ccai
Mr. DISRAELI'S before ~ari ~;g ai,
• where P-- OAP y
would surely have left him .00 ,0050 c,
logic has left him in arginnent; olio e,'" 0,, V
ing to the old proverb, to, P''
between two stools. Aee°rdill4' TAY
from rateable property
roust be, Ol t?
v,...lreadl '