The Sun.
London, England, 1830-10-30 00:00:00

*feet health, that-winld produce such a wound as
and I doubt much whether any of the sti-
lt/Wolf %entente common use would produce
umtriffectiNt.-the same extensive mischief. I mean by
ihat to Welt& the constitutional effects and the local in-
'jury. I regard the sickness and vomiting to have been as
'ninth the effect of what had been done as the mortifica-
tion. Had the stimulating liniment not been applied to
the baek there would have been no sickness and vomiting.
' By Mr. Baron GARROW...I think the application of a
liaiment that could produce such an effect applied to the
'back of a lady like Miss Cashin, in perfect health, was
calculated to bring on serious constitutional derangement
and danger ;. and it has fallen to my lot to see another
ease very similar to Miss Cashin's. There is great differ-
ent* in the constitution of individuals, and I don't mean to
say such application would produce the sure effect on all.
By Mr. Justice PA MC E..-1 have not known the applica-
tion of strong stimulants to produce counter. irritation.
Where there was only apprehended consumption; I knew
nothing of Miss Cashin before this ; the spot of black in
the Miami was as large as the palm of my hand when
I saw the wound first; if the stomach would have
t4rn it, wine properly administered would not
have Men' improper to have given to the pa-
tient with the state of bark that I saw. I did
tot attend the examinations of the body after death.
The appearances I saw on the back were quite sufficient
to cause death. I can pay nothing about the cause of
the appearances, except what I was told by those whom 1
saw in the house.
Mr. Alexander Thomson sworn, and examined by Mr.
Au.tv-4 am a bachelor of medicine. I have been at
the Loos. of Mrs. Boddie. I saw the body of the deceased
,there. I was there on the Sunday morning after the
leeth. 'examined the wound that was on her back. I
uncut in what Mr. Brodie has said as to his opinion of
the state of the, body. I went afterwards to the vault and
/317 the body. The body that I saw in the vault was the
same which I had seen at Mrs. 'toddies.
Mr. Thorne, King morn and examined by Mr. Pim.-
stn--I attended the examination of the body after it had
'heearburied. I observed the state of the back. There
Mat I piece'of disorganised skin, which we call an mar,
lad which Mr. Brodie has just called a slough. It was
A4/Ittit the sin of the crown of a hat. The parts imme-
-1„%441/ be.nreth the skin were gorged with serum. The hold-
-% 0 a Not ironist abo tquarter of an inch from the akin
for aco • u
Aline would produce such an esear. By
411:_iwieeri Mealratllead portion of organised skin. I ex-
"nu.'" htillbedY With many others, with a view to dis-
'l"*
-e—tr 6r" there was any latent disease, but we
",, 11 Id discover none, nor any seeds whatever of latent
l'lurmuselee and the whole of the body were in a
bsaithy slate.
Jamee.-Johnstone, M.D., sworn and examined by Mr.
•At.t.te--.1 was present at the examination of the body in
Yults and- it was healthy in every respect. There
"""0A avideice if disease whatever. The brain and
spinal narrow-were healthy in every respect—indeed no
seeds of disease were traceable is any part beyond what
•Pree"l4ll d tee, nethe.wound.
John.. Hogg sworn, and examined by Mr. Putt-
L're'„7"',l attended the•examination in the vault. The wound
thy Dick had an appearance as if it bad been produced
14,17.,:r..._g11nf0wden.. I can conceive no state in a healthy
the application of anything that could produce
marrow could be of aervice. The sheath of the spinal
tilecolotared opposite the external wound.
The Inferenceas
I draw from that ix, that there must have
Venn&
hut vent greet constitutional disturbance produced by the

ktigr.srusticePAßKS..4 stated before the coroner that
is Was difficult for me to assign the cause of death, but I
had not then heard Dr. Thomson's first examination of the
.144,2sletoiletl. I said that such violence done to the ner-
'""*Ystelns (particularly in a young and delicate lady)
the local injury must have produced, was sufficient to
tense death,
Goodeve sworn and examined by Mr. ALLEY—He
tttesdd the examination at the vault, and corroborated
the former evidence as to the appearances of the body. He
!mold not have produced such a wound on the person of
Patient.
..?`lite Dyke sworn and examined by Mr. Pnir.tres—l
Mine servant of the prisoner. I have been so for the
six months. I remember Miss Cashin, who
Whitt of the prisoner's. Both the Misses
Srashin attended. On the Sd of August I rubbed
tense liquid on the back of Miss Catherine Cashin by the
s;loner's order; that was the first day on which I rubbed
, Ftshia• I never rubbed her hut that one time. I
-• not know what that liquid was composed of.
Cross.exemined by Mr. GUENEY—The prisoner had a
rat many patients, many of them were persons of rank.
-..Laa eMPlO,Yeti to rota the ladies. I used to take the lathdy
-..rubbed *but 4, screen, and separate her from e
!at y the ilium. The rubbing was done for the purpose
Producing a ore or discharge.. She came day by day,
wise she bad
,!peen rUbbsel, to be. drewed. I washed
bpd it with a :lotion when. she so came. I r_ e e
rubbed
asr With the Paine lotion with which I rubbed
litmus, and I washed her with the same lotion
bit l[ washed other persons with. This did not produce
,sitrtster discharge from the back of Miss Cashin than it
e'd kern the bodies of others to whom the liquid was ap-
Plied, I dressed it every day. The wound did not put
.444410 re angry appearance than other wounds did. I
rime! the lotion out of the same bottle that I
taarrd it out of for others. On one day, when
Cashin was there, the Marchioness of Orinoild
Mae there with her daughter Lady Harriet Butler ; I
Labhd Lady Harriet Butler with the same lotion. Miss
4Y lSod Miss Roxborongh were also present, and were
rniTh". The washing of the wound round was not to
letrica.,,a sore. The wound was dressed with a cabbage
uirs. Cashin; the mother, used generally to come
With Mite CAllhio-
-1241 'ziunined by Mr. Pniu.tes—There were not two
.bee used,
only one. The same lotion I used to wash
le bust. with wss the. seine lotion that used to produce
the sore.
k
e mother and sister were in the room when
I robbed Miss Cashin. When I had done rubbing pa-
tients, I kept the bottle to rub others with ; when it was
,„ItaPtY I returned it to my master fur him to put
,:at toore into it. On the 14th of August the
i;4441 was not bigger than the palm of my
tat!, and not larger than was on other ladies. It was
atuer red in appearance.
asY Mr. 'notice P./ALIEN—The lotion produced no sore,
1:21 when I rubbed it. I rubbed with a sponge. I
eseo ladies wash their hands with the lotion.
'ma sicced the case for the prosecution.
DEFENCE.
...The Counsel for the defence submitted that there was
ease to go to the Jury with, and that it ought now to
a. 'lr. Justice PARKE said that he and his learned brother
eate.. in opinion on the question.
ohrs,ro Baron GARROW at considerable length stated his
Vtiw,'l. His opinion was, that the point arising
Cese ought to he decided, and that at once,
j„ ill the Judges of the land. He had, however,
si.?i
Inllsetion to his Learned Brother taking the opinion
Juy upon the facts of the ease, but if the Jury
,i,411t1 beg against the prisoner, thst judgment should be
"It,veci until the opir,ion of the Judges was taken.
Justice Isaitxx celled on the prisoner for his defence.
10.1 hilt prisoner handed in a written paper to the clerk,
71 IVES NA It denied that he bad any intention butVi
benefitting Miss Cashin, and that her death
,11; an event which no skill could have prevented,
If 0“!,144 might have happened had she been in the hands
I.7ZtMost eminent practitioner. The Marchioness of Or-
theMarquis of Sligo, Lord Morpeth, and a vast
01' urt at t people of rank, were on the Bench and in the
_his time.
sm„„
llotvtOn, of Manchester, proved that he
shout the prisoner, who had Attended him for
Ut eight months,
-feattnent and skill, and he was quite satisfied with his
sarmi„, Wilding,
„,
an I'4 Shropshire, had two or three
"
ago been under the prisoner's care for about ten
Aa d satisfied with his skill and attention.
~,;:"? P4p had been under his care for three weeks, and
s";,peett satisfied with hie treatment.
st'rterli eto the prisoner of
Dfm"4
bo, at yellow' times re-
-44 had "'"er
f"isaisi't4nce
to her children.. She
d
three under his care.
was in April but, an 4
the The first time she visited
ra Auengus visits went through July
Was perfectly satisfied with the prisoner's
t. was
Mill,h thefirst .rlis, before she took thwite others fl
to hchild for about two
dit im.
Ottley
ri had resorted to the prisoner for le-
S Lit►
June e. Had seen him fur three months, beg irin-
tokttirl last, and was perfectly satisfied with his treat-
iss
last onelve had been under his care since
of 1144, fila decideilli favourable opinion
!Itll.and
„lirrfieittiet,2lei.ctithael Ingestrie had consulted the rimer—
y. rev for three weeks, and wasp perfectly
14 The ls shill and attention.
414,74:in1u1s of Sligo had consulted the prisoner as
8104„ al adviser, and been under his care for four
\Vas perfectly satisfied with his conduct.
‘.7l„pt
as
Ottley had attended the prisoner for two months,
satisfied with his skill and attention. Was the
Herter 'al
(htl been eY, who had be already examined.
mutter had been
under the prisoners care for thirteen

weeks before she (witness) went to him, and she went to
him with the entire approbation of her mother.
Miss Catherine Webb had been under his care for four
months, and was perfectly satisfied with his conduct.
[Numerous other witnesses were ready to be called when
we left to go to press.]

SPORTING INTELLIGENCE.

NOTTINGHAM MEETING.

WEDNESDAY, OCT. 27.--(CoNcLunzn.)—The County
Members' Kite of 60 soys., for three-yr-olds. fleas,
one mile and a quarter.
Mr. Houldsworth's Crescent 1 4 1
Lord Scarborough's br. f. by Swims 4 1 2
Mr. W. Scott's Laura
Mr. Martin's Miss Foote
THURSDAY.—The Chesterfield Stakes of 25 guineas each.

Two miles and a half.
Lord Chesterfield named Independence...walked over
His Majesty's Plate of 100 guineas, for all ages. Heats,
four miles.
Mr. Sadler's Jocko, aged
Mr. Jackson's Hazard, 4 yrs 2 2
Mr. Townsend's Anti-Catholic, 4 yrs 3 3
The Noblemen and Gentlemen's Plate of 50 soya. fur all
ages. Heats, two miles and a half.
Mr. Houldsworth's Vanish, 5 yrs
Mr. Charlton's Kalmia. 4 yrs 4 2
Mr. Dowbiggin's Marlborough, 3 )Ts
Mr. Johnson's Jupiter 2 4
A Sweepstakes of 10 soya. each, with 20 added, for all
ages. Once round and a distance.
Colonel Yates's Versatility, 4 yrs 1
Mr. Houldsworth's Gilbert, 3 yrs
Mr. Thistlewood's Bottle Imp, 4 yrs

HUNTING INTELLIGENCE.
APPOINTMENTS FOR TUE ENSUING WEEK.

The Warwickshire Hounds meet on Monday, at Upton;
Tuesday, at Wolford Wood ; Thursday, at Chesterton
Wood; and Saturday, at Tamborough—at half-past ten.
The Brighton Harriers meet on Monday, near Patch= ;
Wednesday, near the Race Course; and Friday, near the
Dyke—at half-past ten.
The BrooksPe Harriers meet on Mondays, at Newmarket
Hill; Wednesdays, at Asheombe, (the alternate Wednes-
day at the Kennel, Ilford) ; and Friday, at Telseombe
Tye—at half .past ten.
Sir John Gerard's Hounds meet on Monday, at Bos-
worth; Tuesday, at Wharton Village; Thursday, at Croft
Hill; and Saturday, at Lindley---at eleven.
Mr. Lester's Harriers meet on Monday, at Corte Mills ;
Wednesday, at Parkstone ; and Saturday, at Major-Gen.
Le Mesurier's Cottage.

The Cambridgeshire 'Unlade meet on Monday, at Eltisley
Green; and Friday, at Poten Wood—at half-past ten.
The Puckeridge Hounds meet on Monday, at the Angel,
Hadham • Wednesday, at Hunsdon Mill; and Saturday,
at Cumbelow—at half-past ten.
Sir Richard Sutton's Hounds meet on Monday, at Pia-
kerton Long Wood ; Tuesday, at Thorney-hall ; Thurs.
day, at Stapleford Moer ; and Saturday, at Wickenby
Village—at eleven.
Lord Yarborough's Fox Hounds meet on Monday, at
Kingerby; Wednesday, at Burnham; Friday, at Audleby ;
and Saturday, at Grainshy House—at eleven.
Mr. Foljambe's Hounds meet on Monday, at Matterfey
Bridge; Wednesday, at Cantley ; and Friday, at Barlbro'
Mall—at half-past ten.
The South Wold Subscription Hounds meet on Tues-
day, at the Tower on the Moor ; Thursday, at Hundleby ;
and Saturday, at Greenfield Wood—at half-past ten.
The East Kent Fox Hounds meet on Monday, at Wing-
ham ; and Thursday, at Ashley—at nine.
The Shropshire Hounds meet on Tuesday, at Shawbury
Village ; Thursday, at Queen's Head ; at Pithian's Gate
—at half-past ten.
Mr. Wicksted's Fox Hounds meet on Tuesday, at the
Walkerton. Lodge, Doddington ; and Friday, at Heleigh
Castle—at half-past ten.
The Albrington Hounds meet on Tuesday, at Chilling-
ton ; Thursday, at High Oun; and Saturday, at Patahull
—at half-past ten.
The Badsworth Fox Hounds meet on Tuesday, at Don-
caster Bar ; Thursday, at Owston ; Friday, at Badsworth;
and Saturday, at South Hiendley—at half-past ten.
The Worcestershire Fox Hounds meet on Tuesday, at
Grafton Mill ; Thursday, at Worcester Perry Wood; and
Saturday at Croome Perry Wood—at half-past ten.
The Surrey Stag Hounds meet on Monday, at the Lock's
Bottom; and Thursday, at Leatherhead—at half-past ten.

H. Jolliffe, Esq.'s Fox Hounds meet on Wednesday,
at Chipetead Church; and Saturday, at the Hermitage—
at eleven.

Mr. Moynell's Hounds meet on Monday, at the. Spread
Eagle, on the Burton-road ; Tuesday, at Kedleston ;
Thursday, at Morley; and Saturday, at Langley Common
—at balf•past ten.