The Sun.
London, England, 1837-12-09 00:00:00

No. 11.

" Downing-street, Nov. 30, 1837.
" My Lord,—l have this morning had the honour of re-
ceiving your Lordship's letter, to which I hasten briefly. It
certainly was your Lordship to whom I alluded in the debate
on Monday night in the House of Lords ; indeed, I stated that
I adverted to a charge delivered by a Rev. Prelate to the
clergy of the diocese of Exeter, which could, of course, only
be understood to designate your Lordship. I did also affirm
that no one of the numerous and distinguished individuals
who had animadverted upon those expressions which I
had employed in moving the Irish Tithe Bill in the
year 1835 had read the whole of the paragraph, or had
given me the benefit of the modifications and qualifica-
tions with which I had guarded my propositions. This I
said and still say was unfair, but I deny that the charge of
unfairness either necessarily does or was intended upon the
present occasion to imply a charge of dishonesty. Persons

" It is possible that what I said may appear in the report
more bitter than it really was in the utterance. This is not
unfrequently the case, and vice versa. I did not previously
intend to have mentioned this subject, and was only led to do
so by Lord Rolen's reproducing in his speech those much-
cited phrases. All I said was, that when so much stress was
laid upon particular expressions, and such various conclusions
drawn from them, fairness required that the whole passage in
which they were employed should be quoted. I was perfectly
aware that your Lordship had left the House, and if I had in-
tended a charge of the serious nature which you seem to -aon-
►ider it, I should not have brought it forward in your Lord.
ship's absence. _

A I have the honour to remain, my Lord,
" Your Lordship's faithful and obedient servant,
" MELBOURNE.

" The Lord Bishop of Exeter."

PARLIAMENTARY DI VISIONS.

PENSIONS.

(From the Votes and Proceedings of the House of Commons.)
FRIDAY, DEC. 8.
. _

DIVISION ON THE CHANCELLON OF THE EXCHE-
QUER'S RESOLUION,
For a Select Committee on Pensions.
MAJORITY—AYES, 295.
Adam, Sir Charles Fergusson, R. C.
Aglionby, H. A. Fielden, J.
Ainsworth, Peter Finch, Francis
Alsager, Richard Fitzalan, Lord
Anson, Hon. Colonel Fitzroy, Lord C.'
Anson, Sir George Fleetwood, H.
Archbold, R. Fort, John
Attwood, T. French, F.
Bainbridge, E. T. Gibson, J.
Baines, E. Dillon, W.. 0.
Ball, N. Goddard, Ambrose
Bannerman, A. Gordon, R.
Baring, F. T. Goring, H. D.
Barnard, E. G. Grattan, J.
Barron' W. H. Grattan, Henry
Barry, G. S. Greenaway, Charles
Bearnish, F. B. Grey, Sir G.
Belfast, Lord Grote, U.
Bellew, R. M. Hall,—B.
Benett, John Bellybutton, Lord D
Bentirck, Lord W. Handley, H.
Berkeley, F. H. Harvey, D. W.
Berkeley, C. Hastie, A.
Bernal, R. Hawes, B.
Bewes, T. Hawkins, J. H.
Blackest, C. Hay, Sir A. L.
Blake, M. J. Hayter, G. W.
Blake, W. J.* Heatlicoat, J.
Blewitt, Reginald Heneage, E.
Blunt, Sir C. Hindlev, C.
Bowes, J. Hobhouse, Sir J. C.
Brabazon, Sir W. J. Hobhouse. T. B.
Bridgman, Hewitt Hodges, T. L.
Briscoe, J. Hollond, Robert
13rocklehurst, J. Horsman, Edward
Brodie, W. B. Hoskins, K.
Brotherton, J. Howard, F. J.
Browne, .D. Howard, P. H.
Brownrigg, J. S. Ifowick. Lord
Bryan, George Hume, Joseph
Buller, C. Humpnery, J.
Bulwer, E. L. Hurst, It. H.
Busfield, W. Hutton, It.
Callaghan, D. Jephson, C. D. 0.
Campbell, Sir John Jervis, Swynfen
Carnac, Sir J. It. Johnston, General
Carter, J. B. Kimaird, Hon. A. F.
Cavendish, Hon. C. Labouchere, H.
Cavendish, G. H. Lambton, H.
Cayley, E S. Langdale, Hon. C.
Chalmers, P. L-ader, J. T.
Chapman, M. L. Lefevre, C. S.
Chichester, J. P. Lemon, Sir C.
Clay, W. Lennox, Lord G.
Clayton, Sir W. Lennox, Lord A.
Clements, Lord Lev.son, Lerd
Clive, E. B. Loch, James
Codrington, Sir E. Lushington, Dr.
Collier, J. Lushington, C.
Collins, W. Lmch, A. H.
Colquhocn, S'r J. M'Leod, R.
Copeland, %V. Macnamzra, W.
Cowper, W. F. APTaggart, J.
Craig, W. Gibson Maher, John
Crawford, W. Mahony, P
Crompton, S. Marshall, W
Currie, Raikes Martin, .1
Curry, W. Monte, W. H.
Dalmeny, Lord Melgund, 1..0 d
Drishwood, G. H. IMildmay, P. St. J
Davies, Colonel Milti.n, Lore
Denison, W. J. MolemNorth, Sir W.
Dennistoun, J. Morpeth, Viscount
D'Eybcourt, C. T. Morris, David
Dick, Quinten Murray, J A.
Divett, B Muskett, G. A.
Duckworth, S. Nagle, Sir 11
Duff; James O'Brien, Corrielius
Duke, Sir James O'Brien, W. S.
Duncan, Lord O'Callaghan, H in. C
Duncombe, T. S. O'Coinen, D.
Dundas, W. D. O'Connell, J.
Dundas, F. O'Connell, M. J.
Dundas, J. C. O'Connell, Morgan
Dundas, J. D. O'Ferrali, More
Dunlop, J. Paget, Lord A.
Eadhope, John Paget, F.
Ebringtoa, Viscount Palmer, C. F.
Eliot. Hon J. E. Palmerston, Viscount
Ellice, Caidain Parker, J.
Ellice, Rt. Hon. B. Parnell, Sir H.
Ellice, E. Parrott, .1.
Erle, William Pattison, J.
Evans, Colonel Pease, Joseph
Evans, G. Pechell, Captain
Evans. W. B. Pendarves, E. W,
Fenton, John Philips, M.
1 ergusau, Sir llonale. Phillips, G.
Ferguson, Sir It A Philpotts, J
Ferguson, Robert

Pinney, W.
Plumptre, J. P..
Ponsonby, C.
Ponsonby, Hen. J.
Potter,
P.wer, James
Price, Sir
Protheroe, E.
Pryme, G.
Pryse, P.
Ramsbottosn; J.
Reddington, T. N.
Rice, Edward
Rice, T. S.
Rich, H.
Ilickford, W.
Roche, E. B.
Roche, W.
Roche, D.
Rolfe, Sir R. M.
Pumbold, C. E.
Rundle, J.
Russell, Lord John
Russell, Lord
Russell, Lord C. J. F.
Sal vi y, Colonel
balder , F. A.
Scl,oletleld, J
Scrope, G. P.
Seale, Colonel
Seymour, Lord
Sharpe, General.
Shell, R. L.
Sibthorp, Colonel
Sinclair, Sir G.
J Smith, J. A.
Smith, Hon. R. J..
Smith, Vernon
Somers, J. P.
Somerville, Sir W.
Standish. Charter
Stanley, 111..isi:ey
Stanley, W. 0.
Stansfield, W. R. C
Stewart, J.
Stuar , Lord James
Stuart, W. Vi liers
Straninvit-' .1 G.
Stricl.land, Sir G.
Struts, t.eward
Style, Sir T. C.
Furfey, Ea'l of
Talbot, C. It.
Tni!,ot, .T. 14,
Talfourd, I'. N.
laliereci, vs. W.
Thompson, NV.
'rhornson, P.
Thorneley, The nas
Tollemaehe. A. G.
Townley, R. G.
'1 r icy, H.
Troubridge, Sir T.
luffhell, H.
W.
Ve ey, H.
Vigors, N.
Villiers, Charles P.
Vivian, J. H.
Vivian, J. E.
Vivian, Sir R. R.
Waklev, Thomas
Walker ,R..=
Wallace, it,
Warburton, H.
\Va'd, H. G.
Westcnra, J. C.
NVlialley, Sir S.
White, Andrew
Wilbraham, G.
Wilde, T.
Williams, W.
Williams' W. A.
Wilmot, Sir E.
Wilshere, W.
NVitin i sigton, T.
Winningron, H.
\Vood, C.
Wood, Sir Matthew
Wood, G. W.
Worsiey, Lord
Woulte, Sergeant
Wrightson, W. B.
R'y se, Thorne
Yate,, J. A.
Young, G. F.

TELLERS.
Stan E. J.
Steuart, It.

Acland, Sir Thomas
Acland, T. D.
A'Court, Capt. E
A eare, Lord
Alexander, Lord
Alford, Viscount
Ashley, Loid
Att wood, Wolvcrly
Attwoo.i. N.
Bagge. W.
Bacot, Hon. W.
Baillie, Colonel H.

NORITY—NOES, 233.
\Forester, Hon. G. , Neeld, John
Gaikell, J. M. Nicholl, J.;
Gibson, T. Northland, Viscount
Gladstone, W. E. Ossulston, Lord
(ily ne, Sir S. it. ()wen, H. 0.
Goulburn, H. Packe, C. W.
Granby, Marquis Pakington J. S.
Grant, Colonel F. V‘ Palmer, R.
Greene, T. Pittner, G.
Grimsditch. I'. Parker, M. E. Ns.
Grimston, Viscount Parker, R. I'.
Grin-Jo-ono. E. It. Parker, T. A. W.
I talc, R. Blagdon Patten, Wilson
H dford, H. Peel, Sir It
Harcourt, G. S. - feel, Colonel J.
Harstinge, Sir il. Pemberton, Thomas
P-Teathcote Sir W. P'svce,•al C,ilon I
He,ir,iker, Lord Percev sl, Captain
Herries, J. C. • yr.r, Noir)
Hillsborough, Earl Po'hill, F.
Hinde, J. H. Pollen, Sir J W.
Hodgson, It. Pollock, Nir 1,.
Hogg, J. W. Powell, Colo lel
H Imes, W. A'Ccurt Po, erscourt, Lord
Holmes, W. Praed, W. M.
!tor, G. W. Pace, Richard
Hope, H. T. Pringle, A.
Ilotham, Lord Posey. Philip
I loulds wol th, T. Varrv,v, Lord
Houstoun, G. Reid, Sir John Rae
Hughes, W. B. It C ,ards, Richard
lngestrie, Lord Po 1-nton, Color.el
Inglis, Sir It. H. R )-e, Sir George
Irton, S. Round, C. G.
Irving, John Round, J.
Jackson, J. D. Rlishbrooke, Colonel
.I—nes, Sir Walter Rushout, Bowles
Jenkltret,R.l St. Pail, Horace
Jerinyn, Lord Sanderson, R.
) Johnstone, Hope Smdon, Lord
Jolifle, Sir W. Scarlett, Major J. Y.
Jones, T. Scariett, It. C.
Kemble, Henry Shaw. K
Kerrison, Sir E. Shepparcl,_T.
Kirk, P. shit ,ey, E. J.
Knatchbull, Sir b. Said), Abel
Knight, H. G. Smyth, Sir H.
Knightley, Sir C. Somerset, Lord G.
Lascelles, W. S. Stanley, E.
Law, lion. C K Stanley, Lord
Lefroy, lir. T. Stewart, John
Lewis, W. Stuart, H.
Liddell, H. T. Stmt, H. C.
Lincoln, Earl of Sugilen, Sir Edward
Litton, Edward Thornhill, George
Lockhart, N. M. Trench, Sir F.
Logan, H. Trevor, lion. G. R.
Lowtli r, Colonel Tyrrell. Sir J.
Lowther, J. H. Vere, Sir C. B.
Lucas, E. Verner, W.
Lygon, Hon. Gen. Villiers, Lotl
Mackenzie, Thomas Wall, C. B.
Mackenzie, W. F. Welby, G. Fade
Mackinnon, \V. A. Wilberforce, \V.
Maclean, D. Wilbraham, Hon. B.
Mahon, Lord Williams, Robert
Maidstone, Lord Williams, 'l'. P.
Manners, Lord C. Wodehoose, .1.:.
Martin, G. R. Wo, d, Colonel T.
Master, Colonel Wood, Captain
Maunsell, T. P. . Wyndham, \\.
Meynell, H. Wynn, C. W.
Miles, \V. Yorke, E T.
Miles, P. J. Young, John
Miller, W. H. Young, Sir W. L.
Milnes, Richard
Moneypenny, Capt.
Morgan, C. M. R.

Baker,' E.
Ba in;' Hon. F.
Parneby. John
Barn, Sir F.
Barrington, Viscount
Bateman, J.
Bell, 111.1
Bentmek, Lord G.
I3t hell, 8..
Placketone W. S.
Bhir, J.
flak mere, R
Blennerhassett, A.
Bo'ling, W.
Borthwick, P.
Bradshaw, James
Bramstou, 'P. W.
Broadley, H.
Proadwool, H.
Bruce, Lord E.
Bruges, \V 11. L.
Burr, Hit:fort!
Burrell, Sir C. M.
Calcraft, J. 11.
Campbell, Sir H. P.
Canning, Sir S.
Cantilupe, Lard
Castlereagh, Viscoun.
Chandos, Marquis of
Ch+plin, V.
Chapman, A.
Christopher, R. A.
Chute, W. L. W.
Clive., Viscount
Clive, R. H.
Codrington, C. NV.
ole, Lord
Compton. 11. C.
Conolly, Colonel
Corry, Right Han. H
Courtenay, T. P.
Cresswell, C.

Ilaitni3ple, Sir A.
Darter, Hon. G.
Darby, George
Darlington, Earl of
De Horsey, S. H.
Mgr_ eli, Benjaaiio
Douglass, Sir C.
Dowdeswell, W.
Dottiel I, T. D.
Thigdale, W. S.
East, J. Buller
Eastnor, Viscount
Eaton, Richard J.
Egerton, W.T.
Eliot, Lord
Ellis, J.
Estcourt, T. G. B.
Estcourt, T S. B
Farnham, E. B.
Fcilden, W.
Fe! 'owes, Edward
Fitzroy, Hon. H.
Fleming, Admiral
Foley, E. T.
Fo'lett, Sir W. NV.

TELLERS.
Baring, H. B.
Fremantle, Sir T.

THE MA