The British Press; or, Morning Literary Advertiser.
London, England, 1822-03-12 00:00:00

7..1!

1-7 -7;." "

14V77-7- '

ri -

Mr. BANKER SW he was Me the Selig Mead p slang
With hi. is the expstataltes of its wait greeted atknossiedg-
meets to Ms Majesty fee the commuoitetiste whisk he had
been graciously pleated ite direst to be made to them— '
(Cheers)—bet with regard to sem perie of the arittemeut
w►irh they bad heard fres the Right Hon. Gentleman, he
was not folly prepared to agree le them, as they struck M.
at present. The stale-ofooperemmatiee etreelied to betrodeed
upon the present amounts 'of the salaries of the different
ofilces; .but when it was 4:coedited that many of those eel&
ries had been considerably increased within • few years, and
that they had been greatly augmented by the alteration of
the currency, he coed not thick it fair to leave those permits
is the full possession of such augmented incomes at a pe-
riod when the state of the coyote, was such as called loudly
on Parliareeot for a diminution of its burdens. He recol-
lected that many "cleaners bad, is the extravagance of the
times, been carried further Mee they ought to be, sad
now they ought to strike off the Increase which had
been made le the last len or Anse. years. He could
not approve altogether of the Axed scale, and of the
mode of allowing the superannuation...-. He thought the
period was too short in many instances, hi which persoes
were to become entitled to superenonation on their full
salaries. The scale which was to be adopted el •
larger degree of remuneration than eras in the oontemplstioa
of Mr. Primeval, sod those who aepported the Pension Bill.
It also extended the allowance fir superannuation to per-
sons whom be could not look epee es entitled to such a pro-
vision. The Solicitor of the Trtewerle fur jorliure--(Hears
bear!)—Upon w►at principle was it that a penes embat kiug
le the public service is • prerelease' capacity 'ethos ►e had
mentioned, claimed an indeateity against silage\ ateerie-
geodes as others is the saute profeasioo were liable to, led
to a provision against future casualties to which every other
pigeon was subject. He @hoed like to heves relent eel avg.
meetatione of salaries for • attain number of years past, mud
then to have a proportionate ',docile made fermi euchre part
of the *moue so reduced to he approprioted to tileformatios
of a seperannostion fund. He did imitator whether it was
the ititention of the Right Hun. Gentleman to call ott the
Committee to come to a decision on the plan which be had
submitted that evening ; if no, he feared he could not give it
his •vent soul be was better informed of the details. He
gave the Right Hen Gentleman full er-dit fur the spirit with
which he had entered Into the invest teatime of the 'object of
the reductions in the several branches of the civil service of the
country, and he thought be had effected • greet deal. No-
. thing gave him greater pl than the latter-part of the
Right Hon. Gentleman's speech; and he thought the House
ought to sek•oeledge with gratitude the very gracious man-
ner in which his Majesty had been pleased to make the
communication they had beard.—(Hear, hear.)
The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER said, he
thought the best course for the House to pursue was to pass
the present resolution, for the pernose of enabling him to
found a Bill thereon, which it would be has wish to render
as g Ily acceptable as possible.
Mr. M A RRYATT said, that one decided objectind which
be felt to the prl nciple of the superannuation scheme was, that
it made no difference between 'merit and demerit, activity
and indolence; but made the same provision for the argil-
gent end the diligent—the moot useful and the most stupid
clerk that ever west into an oilier. He doubted whether the

system were not so radically bad, a; to reader it preferable
to abolish it altogether than to make any attempt to amend
it. The Chancellor of the Exchequer had not, ►e contended,
made his statement so folly as be ought. He nbould have
given them an account of all the civil officers, with their an-
peranotiations, pensions, and retired allowances, and also the
increase of t►eir respective salaries for a number of yr an past.
The Hon. Member them recited in detail from returns before
the House the scale of the establishments of arveratof the
public uMcee, wit► the amounts of soperannuesiuns and
other allowances, end contended that the lamer were extra-
vagantly disproportieeed to the amoent soil necessities of
the service. Returning to t►e sew plan, he asked, what
did the clerks is the °Mere themselves sly us the subject?
They remonstrated most Messily against the scheme ; they
said, that an absolute puling gain of 180,0001. would be
made out of Ike hundred clerk. ; they told the Go-
vernment that they meld do better for themselves than
the Goveremeet by this plan proposed to do foe !Mai, by
laying out the amount proposed to be taken from them is
life insurances, or at composed interest. The *openwork-
lino plait would make a provision for the clerk himself
while he lived, bet it pot it out of, his pewev.to provide for
his wife sad family as he might by a prim.. application of
the ammo( thereby deducted frum 'his salary. On the
ground of moral principle, therefore, this plan was not to be
defended. The clerks farther stated, that the Ave per cent.
which was too much to take from them, would cost the
public VI per rent, by the increase and abuse in the grant-
; log of the superannuation,. He (Mr. NI.) believed that
the Act 60 Geo. 111. was carried much further !ban it was

Intended. The word soperennuatiou" carried its owe
meaning along with it. It was never Intended that any man
sh•teld have such an allowance antil he was by ielleatity rens
dered unable to discharge the duties of his office; hut
It was notorious to all the world that many young men
were to be found walking the streets of ibis tows la
health and indolence upon superannuated allowances.
It also frequently happened that persons who had been
wise led from one ogee, were afterwards, through
'merest. appointed to *these more lucrative, and often
retained the superannuation allowance of the Looser
office, while they were on She actual establietroneut
of another. The whole plan eppesred to him se defective,
se liable to abuse, and so utterly objectionable, tbsi he
thought the better course would be to leave the clerk, as
they themselves preyed, to the dictates of their owe prudence
sod the results of their own conduct, and even repeal the
Act of 60 George Ill.; sod that course be recommended
the Committee to adopt.
Mr. HUME perfectly concurred in what had fallen from
the Honourable Member who had just down, and in the
suggestion of the Hon. Member for Curfe Cast le( Mr. &likes),
not to pass this resolution that night. The evil of ibis plan
of a Axed scale of aisperammatiou wee perceptible in every
department. In the Cullom-house she charge ow the rupee
sun ostlers fund had increased In a few years from 15,0001.10

98,0001. l• the Navy Estimates there were two Chap-
loins to a certain chapel; one of them was removed to a
particular plate whore he still remnined—(Latighter)—and
afire two year. and a half of advice, was superaunnsted.—
If the House wished to reduce the immense charge which
the conetry already had to sustain on this head, be thought
it had better leave the individuals to provide for themeades
as they thought proper out of their salaries. Arid what,
after all the boasted exertions of the Right lion. Gentle-
man, was the mighty advantage which the country were to
reap from his I sof economy, and Ma extousive strum
is the public oaken ? Whet •tdsial be Hai amount of she if/-
firedog is. this reseal' year la the words of the Right
Honourable Gentleness) Aiseself it . would be 168,0001. Isle
Great Britain, and 81114/01. fur Ireland. Really lie could
slot cooratulate the.ilimse on such a saving. He could See
no comae fur thankfulutars,when they were told that out of
a charge of 857,0001. for the Civil List alone, it was eow-
ceded that 53,0001. was s suffkieut redaction. The lota
siding they were to look fur in a charge of 4,200,0001.
was tOO,OOO/. It. 1796, the charge fur the Treasury
establishment was 20,0001. The minimum to which it
could be reduced by the preseut plan was 41,0001;
its premed amount was 66,000 L, sad the proposed re
auction would make it 4110004 rid ultimately it was
to be brouolit doom to 42,0001. which was double its
amount iu 1796.—(The Chancellor of the Exchequer acid,
scrod the table, that the amount in 1796, was 30,0001., and
Mr. Rome then continued.)—The ultimate redactors+ con- '
' 'enfolded would leave the charge for the establishment at
42.000/., which was. then, 12,0001. more than la 1796.
He confessed himself fur use quite disappointed, and he
erred with dm Husioarablis clamber for Corfr Castle, that
they ought to suspend their vote till the whole of the details
were before them, so that May could ge folly into the sub.
ject. The Right Hun. Gentleman (the Chancellor of the
Exchequer) was an interested guardian of therahlie purse;
be would be rather disposed to favour the super lion of
air individual, in order that he might have the power of Ailing
up the ofiles; and it was better to put him out of the reach
Of this lealgitatiosi to transgress the rules of publieeconomy.
With respect to the obstreatioss of the Right Honourpro
Gestlema§ ea the male of the Civil List, he could not feel
tbiejest ice of the remark about the pMer mid diegrae• of di-
stillates iato tbs expeaditsre lathe Civil List. The •necer
skies or the Stoioreleind that they should examine onlast•iy

--- . -! ..

„-.-:

...

nery breath 6f Eakt public expeaditare, tea Alt Mt sad
ewe jetties should be dosieto all.
Mt. SWART WORTLEY thought the Ma. Mabee
'for Aberdeen mistaken is his statement cattier redeletian in
the Civil List mentioned by the Chtetellor Grille Iltrebenser.
With respect to what had fallen from the Hun. Member fur ;
Sandwich (Mr. Marryatt) cuocerning the slope tion I
fend, It appeared is bleats mien iamb Toutt irairtrePtliy
of their serious considelation, and be thought the Com- !
orifice had better weigh well whether it would be preferable ;
to continue that fund, or In leave the individuals to provide I
for themselves oat of an efficient salary. i
The Marquis of LONDONDERRY said, he was sure it
had never mitered the inteutiou of his Right Hon. Friend
that say Member agreeing to this resolution should pledge •
himself as to the vote which be should give*, any part of
the details of the plan which he had stated, before the de- 3
tails were fully gime into. Bat as it was necessary that i
a vote on the subject sboutd be come to in the C. .
mittre, without which it was not possible to obtain leave to !
bring in a Bill, be had therefore moved • Resolatimsp '
and he bad R Bill ready prepared, which he would bays print.
eat as loon ss possible, and it would he found to contain the ..
Wiest infotmation on the details of the plan, and the re-
turas from the public office. on which it was founded. it
was impossible without that fur the Hon. Member to loader.
stead the details of the plan of his Right Hon. Friend, end
he therefore hoped the Committee would allow the Reedy-
lion to pass, that the Bill might be brought in and printed,
and that time might be given to Gentlemen to examine the
plea, and see is what they disagreed Amu it. He did nut
mean to deny that the existing Act was open to abase; but
he thought • fair answer was given to the charge of abuse,
in its actual application, by the statement of his Right Hon.
. Friend, which 'hewed that there were 1,800 individuals now
on the supertanuation bets of the me and political de-
PUtlaenti• the average number of years of whose service was
between 29 sod 30 each and lb* average of whose ages Ores
65 years. That, IF thought, was sufficient evidence of ilie
absence of abuse in the general practice of the sups •
lion at present. The Hon. Member for Sandwich (Mr.
Merryitit) thought it better to do away with superaneuatio•
altogether, and to leave the individuals to exercise their own
discretion and judgment, according to moral Muesli, and to
provide fur their families according to the dictates of their
prudence. But suppose they there'd not so provide; sup-
pose a man, at a late period of lifka, after • service of fifty
years perhaps, become. a tad clerk, and it is desirable to
get him removed from the office, were they to turn him out
without any provision for himself ur family, or any mesas to
procure them a maintenance? General theories were not
good tbiup at any time ; but that was a theory on which
neither ibis ace any other country ever would att. For what
would be the euestquence ? They would not ettoove to
tuns out a person unprovided for, after fifty years servi
tilde, and be must be suffered to remain i• the office, to the
detriment of the public aevvice. The Honouruble Member
would allow ham to !geestion ilia correctness of the fact,
which seemed to hies attucic bisobeervation, that she at
were tilled with young men walking about doh.' nu
thing, and hying io- idleness on super hoe pensions;
fur his owe (Lord Losdonderry's) part, he had not
been fortunate enough to fall in wish them. He con-
fessed that the principle of an unlimited fend for su-
perannuations might be objectionable; but his Right Ho-
pourable Fries,' tutended to introduce a Watery check to '
that principle, sod to Ss • certain amount beyond which the
fund should nut go, whatever might be the number of twit-
cants entitled by length of service to their super !suns,
sod in the course of a few years the clerks themselves
would be an effectual check ini improper applications of
the food to persons sot It objects for superamiustiow
. The returns from which the Hos. Member had made hie
statement, t bat the charge on the public would amount so
o
lib per cent. contained not only the superannuation+ from
the Aim now existing, bet also the provisions for persona
removed from offices, which it had been thought proper to
abolish; so that his shitement of the operation of the Bill
was inflated by what butt no coaaesion with it, sad it
would be found on rumination, that the charge did
sot go beyond what it had heen stated as, 10 per emit.
With respect to the Gimes@ of the proposal, be Omaght he
might properly congratulate Ibis Right Hon. Friend a the
low tomer the H 0,,. Member fur Aberdeen. Never had be
heard the Honourable Member so flat in bier tone before—.
(Leugister).—he sever heard him speck in so small a hey
as he had done oa that oreasion—(Laugher)—and be
thought he bad a fair right, therefore, to poems, that the
Hos. Member had out been side to make out so strong a ease
as usual against his Right Hon., Friend. The Hen. Mem-
bee was mistaken in his spplicaties of the prewst saving of
200,0001. and ultimately of 400,1/001. to an expenditure of
4„000,000t. He apprehended be must have included in that
calculation his old grievauce of the expense of collection of the
Revenue. It only applied to 1,000,0001. oat of the 4.000,0001.
to which be alluded ; and the Hon. Member would hereafter
dud that the charge for collection had sot bees overlooked,
• but that a considerable reduction had bees effected in that
also. Bat when the Hos Member said that a saving of WM
per test. on an expenditure of 2,000,0001. fur the public
offices of the country wag disappointing to the 'specialities
of Perlis:teem, he must call ur the House to dilator such
• statement, beesise that was not the way to encourage
Moister, to pursue measures of eeittionty, but could (oily
induce them to receive 'egg. atoms dam stature wilb•pithy
and contempt, whew they found that the appetite of (bore she
put them forth only increased with the su.tenarsce it received.
The Noble Lord then proceeded to eulogise the paternal
Isolicitude of his Majesty for the welfare of she country, sad
referred to his giving up 50,0001. of the Civil List is 1817,
1 and 30,0001. on the pr. seat occasion to the exigencies of the
i State, and his anxiety to make still larger menaces, bad not
• his Ministers interpouid, iu order to secure the Crown from
1 future embarrassments in comic-yippee of those optimum'
aseiffefrtrieodn.., 36 the strongest and mast convincing proof
te I of the deep interest his Majesty always felt when his people
I Mr. H. G. BENNETT said, that after all that had been
! proved on the subject of 'artesian. on time mile of the House,
i sod allowed on the other, it was too much to call on the
Committee to agree by their vote to the principle of sorer-
' association. The Noble Lord bad said there was nu danger
of abuse, because the clerks in the offices would be • cheek
on improper applications of the fetid ; but be (Mr. Sennett)
should like to see what effect the representation uf a clerk
iwould have ou the bead of • departmeut,s'r on • Minister who
wished to cause a vacancy by • sopereennstion which be
I might 611 by the appointment of some friend ur dee...ides,.
3 if these Genii...tee could not contrive to save something fur
I the *option of themselves, their wires, and children, in old
age, they must pay the penalty which attaches to such im-
pudence in every swher coudition of human life ; but to say
, that the enisetry was to pay for their services, and the pc-
salty of their extravagance also was going, lee thought, a
st 1 ile too far. He thought that the proposed reducttos from
the junior clerks was too much, whilst that (tom the heads uf
departments, from the Lords of the T y, for example,
I was tun little; the reductions ought to graduate downwards,
1 from the higher to the lower. Jo the present wanton. uf
I the MAllittl, he considcred the salaries of those °deers es
shogeilwe too large.. The offic. a of the Lord Steward and
Lord Chamberlain Should be considered as offices uf honour,
and ought not to bare any salary at all attached. is
thought the House had begun mune wrong end, and whilst
I they were culling at the salaries of the poor clerks, they
olicauld also look to the enormous posh,. list. Tbe Noble
Lord said, that it was nut 'lithos the province, cud he
doubted *twitter it was in the power of the House of Cons-
: mons to diminish the Civil List, sod be bad quoted a
speech of the late Mr. Fox to the same effeet. He (Mr. Ben.
nett) denied that Mr. Fox had ever stated that. When Lord
North took the same bold hate of conduct which the Noble
Lord now took, Mr. Foe bell that it was the duty of the
House to inquire into the Civil LIM, and to a apnea* or di-
minish it if they thought right, and be distinctly put the
question of tight to Sir Fletcher Norton (the Chairman), who
coincided • is. opiniou with him. That this was Mr. Fox's
real opinion wee clear from the uniform tenor of all his
speeches; where the Noble Lord could hove picked up his
shreds and patches he was. at a. loss to know. He should
gave oo "Pintos as the proposed arrangement till the papers
which the Noble toed had promised were before the House.
Is the Incas time be recommended the Noble Lord to take
the odirice.of the Hoe. Member for Cork Castle,to look over
the *bole of lbe pensioultst, and apply the same pleaded,
iw.tleest wffiel be was now applying to the junior clerks.
gr IYM. DISKESPIGNY expressed his gratitude sad

~. "

...,r,~
.... ..

~-•

• .

-,----

jetesitnihey, +haslet's:lrd iLe. nalcointemionyliceal°tDeds binyittlX"llithetrHhoigneW:i!
able Coatrooms.
Mr. WA RRE wished to know if the Dish Civil Lietsas
to be modest the same regulations es the Esigledsl The me
ries of foreign Ambaimadors laid not hero dimmest, menli,o:
ed, bet he tbutight it was • subject worthy of ivlisidpleilos
ld
Irboalpi teyi :deli- seo
hia of" g evut
Parliament;
ele° rwlnia triinubp:ll:otc
ab observe
ets eieseviehe trill • eses
.1 cueww:oet the:theeladitiutnbles du: inievei eatadebTot,l!l mightu:eipsba6i et:ties ph
4.
d
ery
Lh
:lE:etslinblgalhililosehldtut4ll"dteociasio:l9l:oaseredisjed.wsel:rusli'fweb:sati"ltialteieptelatteditfiNbtederhempaguniehtnebliaiert:i,orienliusomirdisapeiddelittphisoiretatiecitiley,6:ill.
aio•re
7
&wady. 200,0001. wall; be believed, the exp. nee of mislieee
last year, which, at 10 per cent. gave 20.040/. la rep(, it
what fall from the Won. Member fur fihrewsbery, certaisi•
be might vole One the present resoistiori, without bring st
MI mnienltted. Os the ilecond reading*? the EII he might
VsSki principle, and in the Committee all The details.
WI NN thought the prinetple trf surer
a sound one. It was a common remark, that the faculties of
Men were impaired by age, 18811 before they is,re themselves
aware of it; if adopting the *.station of Goatee's Opp*.
site the delis, after 30 or 40 years service, being dismissed,
might apply to the House of Commons ; but If that wen
the regulatioe, every iodiriJral who was saperaimeated
would apply to the House, and state his capacity to perm*
all the duties of his office as well as ever. le Itstiitr depot,
mints this was observed, and In the instance of Lord Rasa.
field, he believed so man could doubt that be reunified Ave
years Chief Justice yf the King's Bench longer ;hag he
ought. Upon the whole, he thought that white the average
of soperannuatioo were 30 years of service and IS years of
age, nu great degree of mismanagement could be irapard.
No banker la that noose having a clerk, who ioe, 30
years of service was unable to maintain
It fitting to say to him, " You ought to have sande sof.
Actettey out of your salary to support you in yeareldige,
It was said that all public Ware's should look te that these
--even officers of the army and navy—bet inch Nene had
b-en the constitution—the Crown always bad been (benne.
btu of honour and resew', and if the principle Weft owe
established, that persons were to look to that Heale,there
would be an end of the Muairehy—(Hear, beer, Isear).-
aild the Goyerumeot would at out! le eome a Repine,
The House was certsiuiy competent to look to say careen.
lure of the Crown, and if they conaidere I the Civil List tims
large they might throw upon it the payment of other see.
vices, aid by that means reduce it. He perfectly ode,.
membered that, is 1802, Mr Fox did state in sabetsace shit
the Noble Lord had said. He (Mr. Wynn) was of venues
that nothing was more hope", r, or more treaded to dilatant'
the respect due to the Crown; thaw continual scrutinies ism
the Civil List; yet if it were to be admitted that
the price of provisions being at present Is., was as
argument for &minimum, then also, when they roe It
would serve as a reason for an asigmeetattoo; 'adenosine
delicate subject wuald be her continually upea, and .the
end the interest of the public would suffer. To mart pemo
larity, ao Administration might reduce the Civil List sow
low, when It would necessarily become encumbered with
debts, which, iu the result, would be more expeutire Asada
prevent mode.
Sir .1. 3. YORKE wished to know if any redraw ma
contemplated in the allo•ances to the Royal Family, shell
it should be remembered were intent off the Civil LW
't he Marquis of LONDONDERRY .aid, the season the
Royal Family were removed from the Civil Let was, that us
case of the demise of any one of them, the savieg seat
accrue to the ',shine •id not to the Civil List.
Mr. P. MOORE thought it right that the Hoare shield
be put in possession of the evidroce which bad bees pea.
lathed before the resuAll.otis were agreed to. He should
Uteri:fore move that the Chairman report progress sad ask
leave io sit again. He agreed .ilh the Right Huootralpit
Gentlemen (Mr. Wyss), that frequent optkocitsos to
Parliastent an the subject of the Ord L.t tiers tar
proper. If be had had V • hualor of mistime ho
Majesty, he certainly would rot have recommended my
eacreacbehent en tie Privy Purse. The seat feel*
pervaded the Committee wren fist to inquire tato the Free
pert; of his lite Majesty. The Prory Porte the held
• sacred; bet indepeodent of that the whole bf Omani Lit
had always beer Node/ the euperveroiou of Parliament,
and be never reeollected lie•roig any flints f.ll fruit 14r.
1 Fox to impugn that roincipk. This ems as atiesipt ter.
vent ioeritigatioo. His Hon. Friend ( Ur. 11 tne); *lee bade'
manfully looked auto the abuses in tor public aerostats, hut
been attempted to tiepin down by reverts mad ridrrele; bethe
(Mr. M) trusted that he would persevere. He (Mr. 11.)nd
attempted it, but he had nobody to back him; bet his Mo.
Friend bad •n oufailing Dieted in the public desires
calamity, which be was afraid .0411 J stand by btu.—(A!agg9
The Chairman then put 11,41 gametic/3 for refirrrilit
geese
Mr. GIPPIi said& few words, which were inaiefibtilie tb
galktry.
Sir 111. W. RIDLEY begged to rallied his Eloocisritle
Friend (Mr. P. Moore), that the reoulutioas did set go i.e
detail, and woe not to be coistdeied as runrlndiag any
gentleman from opposing valor the principle or detail at
future stages. He thought the pi enclitic of surraussooo
good when not carried to excess. H. should havesped
with his Honourable Frieed, the Member fur Covesalol.
instead of the silly Which Le bad Nest ioned, hi had said On
it was the opinion of the coyote, which would sopped*
Honourable Member for Aberdeen, there was s very le
tiers! tbsagh erroneous opinion abroad, that the
the Civil Lust was at the disposal of his Majesty, instead
the very limited son which r.ally was at his blajeray's ea-
; mated. With respect to the plan of the Right Hos. Ger
tlensaa, there were some high ufcus lo which pension mash
attach. Now he thought it would have been snore agrees*
to the principle Idd dues by the Oilier:ell., of the Es'
chequer if these ()Meer, had paid 20 per cent. Mandel
10 per eclat.
The CHANCELLOR of the EXCHEQUER add, dun
far as it was in the power of the Crown to male Ike arraar
meats they world take place from the bib of Jsasary be
The soperannu utiou election being dependent so ON I:
tits of Parliament, could out of course take place liii
was obtained.
su
perM r
sLICI
oßs,dl
though
shield
ad
• itubstedeurtteswtittualusle,d,
! a year sow, blirsuaretemonuu
.aittiiheurelaindela dh'hellveweovfeek:e dirl;en indcr,:ellnliat:aloit:fil:es:ebteoltitwEecihet:eht:4":::ba:ferns:ri..tlese2ol;alibilla:Fl::°:
▪ sod he alto uoilioetood that the other parties!!
torthwe was undergoing a very strict revision. A :It;
they had gone this appeared • very considerable fin_
and, as far as he could ju•lge, very ettisfscr;
could not but express his undivided vaii.firt:ou st
ofmusieatrou
. we
Some
a eot etmr
.11
ctr
tl
thee—G b.
u•ui
air t
ear
iwnoalu:ato
,J 1
et a5.1,..*n:.
might be
t
of
wowboeheusabtoiectethhiuwiibc.hateese:: reosfitrui:ar.nendi:ei
a'botai isswl though'2l
ebr :get:b most6itt.waricm satisfactory.aought
.leii:3
4Pon 'lb:11lee
en 6
tly
to
wbagesji
; :1474-
"
Wvote up.usliMedl,T.Hu. eixhepressunderdr.hliesndrei:
present.n
w precludedt uwcua4f:Aiof
CHANCELLOR
e merely dei
thought
_sae.
it nR Ayl
f.
preliminaryr t a ft t ern etand :hl:ea'.
EXCHEQUERP: r i LI!
cew11:"
Mr. P. MOORE waled the resolutions to be Pe.,
oritibmedserlowtopcs:comeembEata.re7twrabem
hereafter
itehretoevtioodein.rde.: t_ (I, be .
jeesnurtie.rdw.
hiiteouthmwmEtpetdelisasihereeedshidtsourmainsogktiptitienhe,aich.ei::.hweceopr.eleuar:obberat
beikeljeo
wereß
llu hl
:reel et.pCHilaltllre"Cl amendment
vELlos
aWf under
et°.
that
" °Ps t hiidbr• :sr le: (sew.
ila".ol.4oEt the.Qu(efU tEwweßii
rs;er:3 •
id,
"hemdiniduenoitleohosailidseerflteeomperd suerchata.rewas a soaking re

is Ow present cue.
After • few words from the Nardi of Loodondeoi,

` f .. ~