The Dorset County Express and Agricultural Gazette.
Dorchester, Dorset, England, 1872-10-08 00:00:00

. ,

Mr. Waterman : May I te allowed to present •
mo.rlsign..l by all the inhabit inti of the immediate
nri4l.bonrho el, I hese one in my pocket, and hare
be requeete,l by them to present It.
Mr. triorer : That would not be on the formal gnaw
, thin but on the genera' merits.
• Tim Clerk uf too PO4OO suggested next yea.
IMr. Moyer • It the proper time to prseent It would
he when an application was mods before the magistrates
to_rrnew lb' lie ume.

Mr. Tan; ;;41d—all the laudoweere were favourable
t 0.0,0

_
Mr. Fl Ryer told Mr. Watprman that U he had ap-
itua-r1 1.. for., th- Ileetud4 juatioqs he would new have
bml a leers ; but as be did not ha meet &aide
.ilat
Lle.:nee ea:Armed.
. _ _ _

Railway- iits."11:;;;:• Broadsocy. —Mr. Weston, of Def.
chest r, inApported tho confirmation of • hccena to Mr.
Jecob ito:ers, for the Ithilway Station Inn, Ilroatthey.
Th." we.. no .Prealtion. and it was cringed.
Tcruainie Boid, Portiand.—Mr. Reward supported
tho confirmation of the transfer of the Hoene) of the
Quarrymen'. Arnie, Mr. J. R. White, Southrell, Port-
.
1.0.1. t. the Terminue iiotol. Mr. 8. Smith, Chignon,
Portlen.i. Mr. Symln'is opco-ad.
Mr llowafil at the outtet
objected to Mr. Symonds
appearing &Railed the Application. The 50th section of
the hot of Perlia•nent sothoriaed the removal of
Hoene,. from one part of • district to another, on the
easclatrat.o being aauefied of certain thing., and then
it 00110 heforn them formally for oonfirrnstion The
Act drew • distinction in the procedure betwron transfers
.inknew hoer. a.

Mr. For r inquired if " removal " there was new
Oita...loge for tranafor.
Mr. Howard aasiantiel, and Mooted notice to the 37th
cud 43rd seetions, which, a. he argued, restricted
appeals before the mailman:: committee to "flew"
lie•mus ; sad, referring Sr. the interpretation clause,
showed, of ultras, that a removal did not umo within
that term. No addition wee toad° to the number of
licensed bourse bye removal, and he urged that it was
the intention of the lrgfolature to give the confirming
authority pewsr over lbo inereseing of license., while
it left to the local linen sing justices control over the
trionferenoe of !league. •within their jurisdiction.
Mr. Syinonda in repij, quoted from motion 50 to th•
effect that no order of i he jostle°o shall be valid unless
coofirmod by the oonfamiug authority. Lie did not
onderstivid that the oufirming authority was to be •
more registry olioe for the 000 rt below. lie appre-
hended they sat a. • court of appeal—at all events as a
court of • secerior claw, and it rested with them to
review the derisiom of the °mid below in all Instaaaas,
It appeared to him, whether the i iOOOllB4l were new or
removed. A Irani/or was a personal matter from Mr.
A. to Mr. B. • but a removal, Irons No. 27 to No. 36
was a very different matter. The present ease was not
a transfer, nor did it urna within his friend's ingenious
argument about the removal of a Boone* front one Pert
of a district to another because it did not bureau the
total number of public-bouts. Mr. rename, in his
book on the clot, said that every alteration was an
appeal to their dineretion, and in that form was • new
license to all intoot• and purpose.. Reappeared before
the liormaing committee to optima the grant on Its
merits, and be now attended to oppose it before thesis;
and he submitted Mr. Howard must go through all the
forms as in an original application.
The Clark of the Puto. said that by the 50th section
the confirming authority had power by implication to
go into the merita of removals as of new licensee.
Mr. Royer said the cloud were noanimoutly of
opinion they would hear the cue.
Mr. Howard then stated that *police Lion and justified
It on the ground of the increase of holues In the neigh.
beerhooi of the railway station and the visitors to the
island, while Southwell had declined owing to the dell-
o,a of the stone trade, and the removal was saaetionsd
by some of the oldest magistrates in the diatrlot--gen.
Heinen who had bileo on the Bench 14 or 15 years, and
were well acquainted with the wante of the neighbour.
hood. 11.3 would prove that the house had superior
acoommodatlou, far beyond the necessity of the case,
arid then ho would leave the matter unfirieutly in their
hand.. Hu called the applicant, Samuel Smith.
Mr. Symonds asked that the notices might be proved.
He apprehended the ease was analagons to an order for
removal.

Kr. Howard urged that the notice. were proved
before the harming judos' am a preliminary form, end
therefore need not be gone into now; but (het the pro-
doetloo of the grant of a lioense from, the lioenathg
oommittee wee sufficient.

Mr. Flojer said the court were of opinkon the notions
must be tooewt

Mr. T. H. (Nooker proved the exhibition of the
notioes on the church door and premises on Sundays,
4th and 11th ausn.t. Cruse examiesd : The 'tattoos
were all sieved by the ap,•licant before they were
posted. Smith did riot sign one of them in that °oar%
on the 24th Ausnet.

Mr. A. 0. If te,vlLe proved notions were sent to the
occupier and ownvr of the Quarryman's Arms, on nod
August.
Mr. Symonds said by the subsection of ees. 50 notice
of intended applioation of removal was to be given in
the same manner sit for • new Ilene., and a oopy nerved
persunslly or by reglat.re, Liter on the owner and
occupier of the promises unless he be the applicant.
The Act savi notions were to to given (see. 40) in the
manner directed by sea. 7 of r • Wine and ileurbonise
Act, 1869 and the Asi. amending the. same. Sec. 7, of
the Let, 180, requirLd the notices' to be given not MOTO
than 2$ or lees than 1-1 days beftros the day of applica-
tion; but in this case unly two cir.ys' notios was given;
therefore he submitted they were. Lot ilium In time.
Mr. Howard replied Oat at the end of the 40th
section there was • note the: met the objection—
Provided, that notwithetanlins- anything in tide Ao.
contained, the notion; for any licensing meetin4 held"
between the :lath a August act the end of September
1872, shall be given as if Lois Act bad toot passed*
The Ant had not punted at tilt. dine throe nstiou were
g I yen, and under 31 anti 35 W.ctorot, it was not requi-
site to sive notice to the owni r or oecupier.
Mr. ?foyer said he understood the nodose objected
to were those given ou the 22nd Angust—th• Act be-
cause law on the 10th.

Mr. Llo ward reposted the note to the 40th section,
and said giving notice to tho °coupler and owner was
mere surplusage. Thoy could not have given 14 days'
notice, for there was not Mom
7h. Bench decide! Utu notions to owner an.l occupier
were not riquired at AIL
Tbe applicant, Mr. S. Boonh, then spoke to the
accommodation the bona° arrdod. He was cross-
ermined as to the numbers of hotels and beerhouaos tu
Chesil and In the island, Mr. Symonds ahowmg that
there are 22 :transit houaa and 21 beerhousss.

_
Mr. Gundry ~id he shoule. like t, know wild was
the meaning of all this oppos'Aion. Objections of this
kind ought to be very much d'azooraged, when Coe7 had
been gme into before the lioenaing justiom who were
acquainted with the district.
Mr. Symonds said the homes was opposed because
there ts no necessity for allf extension ef licenswi in the
district.

The applicact : I should like to koow who you appear
for.

Mr. Symonds: Never you mini; when the magi*.
trate' ask me I'll tell them.
Mr. J. Turd, of the firm of Eldiidge. P. me and Co.,
said the premiss. cost upwards of £l,iloo, and the
&indicant was • very respectable m.o. Bre ry year over
2.0.00 e people travelled on eh, Purtlsud rs alway. He
produced the consent of the owner and oecu pier of the
Quarryman's Arnie to the tramfer.
Mr. Symonds : Was aayoonsiderstion give it to Mn.
Prows* hr her uonseai?

Mr. ;rd : I -d—o -think that is matenal now. The
same qaestion was asked boron, the Um:oft g justices,
and Mr. Williams dmided it oould not be sat ed.

Mr. ?tor: Wit only sit to decide too to tad merits
of thee....

Symonds said if Mr. Mud objected to answer
that was quite enough for him, but he put ;tie question
because he should make tome remarks upon it.
Mr. Flom said be we. not bound to answer.
Mr. Symonds then &Dressed the court in opposition
to the 000firtuation of Use grant of the Wean. He
I had no doubt that in sanctiooinr; • removal, m well as
in granting • now License, for toe,' were subeentially
I at hu,epiy
ihoc. wouldhat
.71 11%. e h
heyeldehtild"shbacif; b.yaaterhtlibal
ars
en
em
othaw theb,
that jaewl rurthlt:Ndoterethe .aeam.r.t.agApallcuol*.blico ari;ieboia,
trof.Ch4s..isdpatuetili7t.lihoueri:wris
.3ren.dpial,rebidwdy
hottses in the bland of Portland. The 'number of
inhabitants was about 9,000, which included 1,500 son.
• viols who did not reqntre publio-housee, and,. regiment
of soldiers, about 700, who were suppliod by • eantems
so that there was • population of about '7,500 to be
served by 45 hones, or one to every 170 potpie. The
ltitrie nit egaiviihor
..enme
op aL power
wo f.sat sa a zit
roc
asew L°t. ea
toatohlethee rizmin if v.l 'de
want,t ahei ar
o. tollestonelgsb.hmdbourbe.oodThistouo.whir..h
wthus
oredgimor,vemilyargas.pwro-
posed i
lowellthweseCiwaricuin's •
village abs krdmista% l th
osi°ufreinweli' bees:,..everyot South-
tier
I'ublio-
house, sod •
the inhabitantsehpiritLousewsa of that place.revjuirtedforthe
a
now they had the leas under Mrs. Prowee,
ooming here, making use of his undertenant
, at Southall to get that very theme transferred toe
house at Chiewell where there are already five public-
. houses, and where, he and, the requirements of the
puha* did not call for any itier...me of limns's. There
was another strong fact. Mr. Tissrd had declined to
• my whether any ommideratiou w.s given to hire. Prows.,
for her consent—he did not Kees it, Mr. Tissrd had
the power to decline; but, as • magistrates' li ruse to
be bought and sold ?—for it came to 'Jim : • hoes., to
a pulse:virtue. wee of the nature of • property, and
; could nit be withheld alter °sing onus granted without
grave muse, therefore it. repraien:o i so inorrasing
value to property; and was it to b, that a person
, having • beerhoum in soother I. elghboarhood could
, buys license hod then COEDS to thn in and b. entitled
to ask for its removal to the house he had got to cover?
Ho WS, free to SALMON Hist POOlu co moderation issued
for the consent of Mrs Prows., in mgh Mr. 'Pisani
sheltered himself from animating under what ho did
nit deny was his privilrgo ; but it wai a trotileki.g
with a miljatrrina. liaelaSo weioti the law Jul nut
tolerate, and whloh be thought they would not sanction.
As to the decision of the liconnug justion• it was
expremy stated dist was not an unatumims .deolaion.
Turning to the alleged requiremeste it Uhisiwell be
mid for the last 20 years, ever dice the ste &elbows
fir
so olb::::::1"kddiasngotoo-uthtorb.uirs sta to
lking-horse
tte.Povi"fterletFhi
yew' were
I. 1 fricoirjr:uall ir
• d • ub
'nee"' ntohlwet
with
bisthuarot
bettnaPdP,liht"lotiteoh:ramoatineryanfirduliahin aymnahonoth4:ere had heard estimate the visitors at 1200 or LIOD a.day •
go:ng by the railway would
find that tee great mijorlty of t no 1111•01 ion were Pertiaod or Weymouth people no business. For
the visitors tiers were beeklei lb. existing public-
houses • number of refreshment houses, and no doubt some iif tho visitors were t, esti:Aden, b°•id",
ho bad hestd cmpl,.ints that at both Porth.nd sod
Weymouth many if tie visitors be. ught their own pro.
visions. So the prot-tic, that 11.1 not
sufficient account° lotion wait aoltat con& Tao To -minas
hull wise I,i, iionbt • newly-imilt I- cam, b., it id not
follow 014 Luc:klieg a maan out mosey to
building it should b. lionised. 'lb. gustation we. —Did
the public requirements cell foe an increase? liai also
pointed out that there was no stabl log acooreniodeatelk
and that when the needs of applicants family were MO
the home afforded very little room for trivet lire. '
Altogether he maintained a Calle Its this Ikenee to be ,
removed had not bow mad* out; sad, iasouolusloo, he I

quoted a ri•reark by Kr. Krlila, oa the Lice•laft.g
filll—" No B 1 of this desoliptlon waist t be perfeo:
it ; roinded maohincry by 111110') the Dealer of
houses might h.. brought within th. pu ri qu iremen te,
si, pr bORIO machinery by litakb bootee
.her lb, y fulled to OlCtill of labile requirementl
eeillil be reduced."
:n miser. r to the 13.n0h, Mr. Syconn Is said he appeared
for 'A.. lloblen, of the Victoria Witel (Kraal. J. A.
Dsvaui,h and
After a brief eonsultati,in Kr. Y. ,yor announced
thiq the rt.n.. sal would be ad:finned.
lir. lii run dt not ask for costs.

Its.aa DLopom.-11e. Arikuro.bh, of Orsugwrisad,
Wasebsw, has apple tress now is blossom in I.i. orchard
aux resat bearing.

ATHELLIAMPTON.
THANKSGIVING BEIVICIS for thu harvest wen held
hero on Sunday, wheu the church was decorated with
sheaves end devisee of grata bet off with horde' big, of
heath, (erne di.. Spelbal psalms, hymns, and lessons
wero used. Tbe offertory far the Church Mbsionary
Society amounted to £4.