The Dorset County Express and Agricultural Gazette.
Dorchester, Dorset, England, 1882-05-02 00:00:00

L'Cridt, —ANOTUEII
DISPUTZ.

I Stine e 11 K. Harris. —Hr. Trevanion WIG for lb.
plaintiff. Mr. Travers for the &fen ant.
Trevanion said his elient eas a Trinity house pilot,
owning hie own vested. The defend int subpart...A Imo to
give evidence in his behalf in an netin, whim e me short
time ego was heard bob,* his Honour—he had probably
no foesotten it—and which arose out of an el-ctionrer.ng
web/go in P.eds with refer no. to • display of party
colouts His client had to attend three days, and ho
believed 'het holding the position be did, tie was entiil.d
to more thin he had offered him for hi. toes of gm, The
liffth rubs of the new Comity Court's rules pn,vl ies that
where seamen wet, onnetssiarily demined on shore,
allowence ought to he mad, for their lois of drill". Tarn
aupp • ag his H 'Dour dit not think he mum under that
cstegory, he would mk Lien to allow him on extra sum
and tit the male for picifesilooal and other wlauSo. His
clime had Main obliged to stay at home, instead of betas
not in the C'iannel. He hal apoliel for payment to lb.
defend•nt, and hod been refused.
The Reigistr ir said 15s. hal been paid lot, CoJrt, at the
rats of 5.. per day.
lila : But .uprising the deendant was not
bou .d by law to pay anythtng at all, what then! If yod
h..* I oked at caws which have has. rec-ntly d,
you would see that the obligation t att.nl • court of
Jostle, ia • matte: solely between the court and the
witll.ll4. I, hOg•OVIff, moot stat. thee 1 have ,eon two
decleioss by COaal, C turt. Judge. which hors been decid d
diametricelly opt mite I should bk. to have the matter
mown fairly before MO. I know ',it ertll find mverat
vine tried before the superior cni,t.. in which it bap hem
held • witness could not recover, but latterly there bays
hem d Cerium the other way.
Mr. Trevaaion mild In Poole they had rather an Inevit-
able pilot lety for making new laws and explaining them
at their own expense. But he woull prefer not to do so
In thie ingiagc
Hie H ~our: But perhaps your client would like to go
down t•i pst.rlty 11. one who bd been instruniental In
explaistig tke law to the town of Poole amethter
Mr. Trevankio : I taint, sir, we wood rattier accept the
amount that MO t 0... paid int., Gaut
His Honour: 1 think you bed better, for to tell you the
truth my mind went with those whir decision* adverse
to 700.
Mr. Trailers mid he wished to correct one siisht mistake
on the mit of Yr. Temente'', and that was that his client,
Mr. Barrie, had not offered to pay anything previous ti
the tratamone being issued lb. fact was he had offered
10e.
jedgmeat wee then st,ft for the defendant, the amount
paid into Court being accepted by the plaintiff, but hi.
Homer declined t tallow costs.

nit warn a mlaioa on behalf of Kr. Y. W. Wheatley,
I an.. of UN estat. at Mr. IL It Deot, formerly landlord
ot tan Qualm's Rotel, Bonmunnouto, t 3 recover fron lir.
Stirring, LI P.. 01. and II•ruboll. broom.. damages lot
distraint caul certain goods erltinh ti tru.tee e.n•
landed l.oogd the bankrupt under the order and
d amide& clauem—kfr. Wheeler. barti•to.. lustre/AM by
Ik. Wade. el Bet meacetti. 619.4.54 1 i 'Wart ol•

motiosc—lfr. Treventos wea Ifer the defeadank—Mr.
Wheeler opened the ean In a speech over two hours
duration. end the dry and can le honour which time
learned Council throw Into his remarks create' comader-
able amuustrent. He inform. a ha Hon cur the 'intim
before I divided itself into live subint matters. Forst,
he claimed cm l lain furniture and .8, cm which were on tie
premien at the time of the bankruptcy. the date ..f which
wae 18 July, '8 . Secondly. be &eked his Honour to
adjudican ova the este on fr 'tut it .nsive juridic-
Hon which had been conferred up on him al Yint-Chancelor
under the 720-I netion. Thirdly. te ask-d lut damage
r..r this ow& wful detention. Ls tl. they asked hi.
Ron .ur to rescind an n.eetnan• none, Mr. Dont 4.141
4r. S yang, dated tn 4th of Anent., IMO. The tort, of
the con octet... Ou the 20tda June. Mgt Mr. Du' tort&
oat the Q teen'. H •tel, whict. i.e belier d ow el, std.
at • rental of MOW and he al.) Scot on th- Refreshment-
r tome, subjout to co additioial rental of CU, which, on
are tith Jun, 1879, W&I tn. rkad into a total rental of
£5OO. According to Mr. Sings affidavit. he bad at the
time pot-chased from a Mr. Short eno worth of fin altars.
Now, if that wsa &tr. Styring's in, nature. there was an
end of the case as to Mr. Styrian. but Mr. Sty ring put
brf TO thorn • view of the transaction more ingenious than
men I ; perhaps he might use outer word then
ineenhout, he might say smuts (Littetter.) He was
cure no one wolf olde -t 1, that—;ll- Trevanion 5.1 d he
d•d not; ho preferred the word &stool—sod he ventured
It ear that withal! his H moue. aapeneoce, when he read
ttie paragraph in the ottani misting 'oil he woold I. as
misled as trw himulf ma Ha would gather hour that
paragraph that on the morning of the 13th September
Mr. Styria( for the ire time knew that Mr.
Dot cull not complete that numbers Bat that
ou not to. for Mr. Deta had emit or • fort-
night prwrionly to that eft ct, and wrist he should
sh or would be that Mr Stymie pal this money for tha
furniture to: for him. it, aa h . tan th on to Where.
but for Dent. Oa the 131 of fiept.mber Mr. Dent wad
Mr. Stysin the sum of CM, beitevittit it ea, on account
of the anis. He undoubteda shifted an agreement on
that nation, but be I oked at it, end did no under
• mistake as to the facts. But haviav thia sentiment
Suring approwiated the .C2b for real. N.ter, they might
take it, as • in otur of hi.tooy, that hint went into tee
hotel in November. 1878, but, as ter as the oeenunt was
concerned, it was not ready until 'ossuary, 1879 There
was sonsthlog sold in the and tad's about • libol at
Cuic'iester, but he would rather wit go into estraueous
in otters. Dent left the Catches er Hotel for paints
[—urns. Dent at this lime got he burs, worn, and
spi it. from Mr. Scyromea brewery, colic mu an import-
ant f oct that at the time 8 yr.ng disc, erd of his brewer,
to b 1 . Pope and Wsluieeley, Dtot wee indebted It
him in tie cum of £3OO, and shortly .Iter he was indebt-d
to Maur& Pops and W• meal y to the amount o CMS 13.
lhe latter gentlemen naturally deoired, end he could not
blame them, to be paid, end the ult.:sae malt ween et • dint,.,, we. lints against Dent, but '(towards
Kenn P. pet and Walareslety did what be babes, d
perfectly lawful In this country—they changed their
minds, and were desirous toil,. him ample tim, to turn
round an I see the best he could do for himself and otters
in this new 'feature. Subs.qmpaly, however, on Jose
2818 a writ weal sited & Ped by Meterope and Waloatteley ;
i um to twining which D rat went track to Yr.
Sty, ,trots. and Mr. Styria( wtote back style( hs was very
much annoyed with the cornet ileum Pope and Aldridge
had taheu ; and that he bad written to Messrs. Aldridge
empenind hie solvents that they Ind brought an Gabe an
hi. n.me, &gamut Dent, for goods fold and delivered from
tie Poole Brewery. Teat letter ma i an at nun to show
D nt that Styr nd was his Iron I an I was dnirous of pro.
' hooting him: but there we& • manwiloas putunpt which
ead,"l rep cc Mr Trewsnion will have put to ellappekrance
, for yoo. ' On th • :o.h June Mr. Styrian erlow another
letter. .Latioa th ot the course be was taking, after due
°and erotict and . dein, ems tn• best that could he taken
under . xi Log c reumnences, and that he would set Dent
.n tie course of toat or the following day, and fully
, ornate!, his movements. Mr. Stertag's DeOVIIIIIeDte, how-
ever, seemed to hare been very pialtrim for he went
easy on a Ix tliclay, and on the 3rd of July Mr. Deal
received • letter nom Mr. F. H. Sawing, who mid
"Aceordine to your request, I have foewaded your letter
to Mr. Strand but I !ear he wiil not be able to eply by
robin. I u May say that caution se to the value of their
advice is eminents• neceseary. That ma. the unhappy
bliosurs. Pope and W&lmuley. The writer added Their
put actions have shown their only desire is to get what
Icy can for themselves. You may deltoid upon it your
lotereeta an not tceire, and that, if you an punnet to
44, excut aa Mr. Sty, leg advise", you tail .1 wan regret
it. I vent to say I fear they are not to to trusted."
(laughter.) Nene caul i complain of toenails candour of
that heiter. (L aughter ) Redid not think Mr. Styring bad
acquired the art I his (ether as • reedy writer ; there watt
mucht 'lea... 0.1 the 12th July, Kr.Suring, eon., again
appeared upon Vie WOOS, and been I hie eon or oitcs—it
was at 'u-bug sane—seemed to be of one min . Re then
erut • t Den "I hop• you will place no coodd ace in
muttons Pepe holdt out to you." Prior to this • writ had
torn inlet by Pope and Walmuley—on the 30th fitm—
ent Kr. S yr,ng followed •uit with • duties'. Kr.
String wrote that this was the best course he cud tatke
cod r the circumstances; bit that was only tempering
tos clod ti the acorn iamb. There was &homer letter to
which be rant attention. On the 18th July Mr. Styrian
wrote tell ng Pont that naiad conultal with Hr. Tr.vam-
-1,112 and Mr. Witt, and that the p .11.11ee co minion he had
&trivet at was ih it if he—Duet—desired or reutato in UM
hotel be must suds ovour to compromise with his creditors,
and that beleught not to demy louse,. He (Kr. Styring)
obenfore • firmed woo to wee Mr. fteventon, &ad, if he
th might proper, to in.truct htro It push him through ttp.
Co ift 1141 speedily as ponittle. Coins corns such mourn waa
taken au affair would We one • in at oomplicattl •LO,
and be (Kr. Sarum) .Id be put to • areat deal .ti
trouble, with no ittintate baulk to Mr. Doot. To
that lett-or It,. Dent rep.l d ; Your letter to band
, per In-se.nta, has enraged me. if lie connote are curled
.ut they will be suicidal It ounielf en •l guano's to me.
Tour. arm rerben, eomplie.tio or Notch your isins-re are
unaware of. It wili hemy duty to oonioaunma w promptly,
with those of my creditors who are likoly to soder most
oto the pr mottos. there !too owned ty tor iatantptcy,
lit',. f rOtoroooll le shown to us which me &tune after
working so heel, and losing our money and Imo is whieb
we brought wi h us to k-ep the hotel goins."—Mr.
Trevanion 'ad net was a prep:tide Wbeelcr
said he •as not one of ttone who pretended to regret
c .mplicatione. It asp. vier, no such thins the great
otter to which he beloonse I would cease t .xt.t. Kr.
p.m% who *as not &law yer,aud who own netther minion
oor astute, .aw the haunt cf that ram., and declined to
ect upon It. Mr. 8 yrins said the &mews •ro. for rent
alien', to the . :teat tot £8155 made up as follows —Rent
ot hotel, 1:900 ; rent of refrestatoeut ro one, £119; one
ymar's rent of the whole ttremteu, £500; aed rent
of furniture, &tinge, &.,C505, He sbootod libel. hoots
velvet law in the realm goy. Suring Us. ristit to diew•le
tor root n good• sm.& ebokeall•. Mr. Wheeler contended
that, in re.lity, thou. ted ha wita then twitted to clam
Ica LlB7 5.. it. was willing to .dmit tip re Woe no legal
tooter made, but it was a nuttier of act that Dent went
Ii ltle Curt a, and offered hin £575. Mr. Wheeler then
rig id fro.o the ssr.euserst enter. i into on that :3041 0,
c iwending tba . it Gush, to have no effect wbalseer, es—
t• us. • familiar phr ur—it was the result of c (orlon. By
agreement D :tot's g twis were to In, sun to St, ran et
a price to he wscertain-d by valuation. Mr. Curtis,
for ft,e purges of appralsement, •mued the (urea tire
at £575 15s. Id., and ih ot mauled certain arttclee
In a:toned in patina tp k flee of ths uotie • of
mot on. Under this uneaten: Kr. Curtis had to
vi ue the goods &nein, and be tiro n decaud from
tots o• lima' fl •on, who, must have b-en butiir arrived
▪ aod put £791 14. it ,or something like CS more. A
Mr. Waelht mu employed us the other nit., .n 1 he,
•Poto.eiiing the matter front a Dent point of view, put
lbw value a• £llB5 11.. 61. But .bat waa more uton sh-
ins. Mr. Kin. wuo wu the uhar.tor and umpire, .nd
whore 'amnion bad to b., exceptel, whether they liked it
or no, put the voolue at £l.2* en that was exclus v.Ol
the articles utentaoned is paragraph b. Mr. Styring was
nit pl-ue I With that Ilion and •io his Atli lava he called
it unjua. But that dtd not matter ; 'hey 'Sr. very often
the subject of uproot" dot:Woes. Coder septum Int Mr.
D.ta 'nook the hot-1, and betook himself to the refresh-
ment rooms, from ere•el he was afterwards fortildr
-Joetwd. Trell parties in that can had a very plmenat
trio In What:inter, end at Wiacnoter an &encasement
, was come to which ran lered it quite unnocesury any
t unbar proceedings should be taken. The connoting:.
•as thet from that time Dent ceased to hold the ro fresh
-
mutt ro dna though letters which were aubeequsntly
wr thin showed that It tram sdmdtsd then was • ba'ance
due to his trusts. from Staring. Me Wheeler concluded
by briefly recapitulains his arguments. Trevenion
intimated there teat no ease rir him to sourer. Kr.
Wheeler had bail before thous ire grounds, on which be
&eked for that moti n. He should a: present diver I all
the others, and take only the let, unless hi. II moor
thought it necessary be should deal with the others. The
only pouts, which Kr. Wheeler e toll p mobly rime be.
fore the Court mai on tbe order and o..p.sitt•ta c'ause, all
the others being outside • d within the purhou of the
common law oourn He should submit the% if his
Honour was of opinion there was • gee on which a
tuot,on could be man in reference to the order

and disposition casual. Ms H had no juruidictioe.
Aft 1. a omeid-reble ern ,unt or dbcisipon, bla liengur
'it'd he would reetweehudc.lob till the out court. but
be sarn-itty saisutegil the propriety o( the olive branch
an the meent,nte.—Mr. Trevanton laid if the other Pim
watild eithdraw the not 'es of moti-n they would iiettm
the amount that Mternuon aid piy the money, but
they were not going to do so wh 's there was this
motion.