history: We adopted a new kitten after our beloved cat ran away. The day we brought our new cat home, our old cat showed up.  When I was a little girl_comma_ our cat ran away and was gone so long we didn't think he would come home so we adopted another kitten.  Thats sad_comma_ hopefully the new cat got to live a long and full life with you
current: Well, we had a funny twist. The same day we brought the new kitten home, or old cat showed up. We kind of thought maybe he was hanging out close to home and was mad that we replaced him.
next: Haha thats crazy, I hope they became best friends, I love cats.