history: I stole from my parents as a kid and got caught. I felt so bad afterwards.  I stole from my parents and they caught me. I felt so bad as they yell at me.  I would feel guilty too if I was in your shoes.  Did you feel bad because you stole or bad because you got caught?
current: I felt bad because I stole. I didn't even need the money I stole. 
next: Then why did you do it?