Two regimens , each represented by one large trial , which showed limited evidence of efficacy in reducing the incidence of hip or other appendicular skeleton fractures were : 1 ) Oral Vitamin D when accompanied by calcium supplementation .
2 ) 1,25 dihydroxy Vitamin D ( calcitriol ) .
This appeared more effective than calcium in a direct comparison .
Hypercalcaemia and gastro-intestinal symptoms , reported in less than 5 % of participants , were slightly more common when Vitamin D analogues were taken .
However , the risk of death was marginally less .
REVIEW ER 'S CONCLUSIONS Uncertainty remains about the efficacy of regimens which include Vitamin D or its analogues in fracture prevention .
Particularly if co-supplementation of calcium is required , significant cost differences are likely to exist between regimens .
BACKGROUND Due to their known effects on bone metabolism , Vitamin D and related compounds have been proposed for the prevention of osteoporosis and fractures .
OBJECTIVES To determine the effects of supplementation with Vitamin D or a Vitamin D analogue in the prevention of fractures of the axial and appendicular skeleton in elderly men or women with involutional or post-menopausal osteoporosis .
Calcitriol treatment is not effective in postmenopausal osteoporosis.
STUDY OBJECTIVE To determine if calcitriol is an effective treatment in postmenopausal osteoporosis . DESIGN Double-blind , r and omized clinical trial of 2 years ' duration . SETTING University medical center with patients recruited by media announcements . PATIENTS Eighty-six postmenopausal women with vertebral compression fractures . INTERVENTIONS Patients were treated with calcitriol or placebo . Mean dose was 0.43 micrograms/d . Dietary calcium was 1000 mg/d ( 24.9 mmol/d ) . The medication dose and dietary calcium were adjusted for hypercalciuria or hypercalcemia . MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS No significant differences between placebo and control groups were seen in the percent change in total body calcium ( 0.4 % + /- 1.0 compared with 0.0 % + /- 0.9 ) , single photon absorptiometry ( -0.5 % + /- 1.2 compared with -3.1 % + /- 0.9 ) or dual photon absorptiometry ( 0.0 % + /- 1.7 compared with -1.0 % + /- 2.2 ) . New fractures were seen in 16 % of the placebo group and 26 % of the calcitriol groups , so the difference in percent fractures was 10 % ( 95 % CI , -5.7 % to 25.7 % ) . Bone biopsies did not show changes in either group . The calcitriol group had significantly higher serum and urine calcium values , but renal function was not worse than in the placebo group . CONCLUSIONS Calcitriol is not an effective treatment for established postmenopausal osteoporosis
Two regimens , each represented by one large trial , which showed limited evidence of efficacy in reducing the incidence of hip or other appendicular skeleton fractures were : 1 ) Oral Vitamin D when accompanied by calcium supplementation .
2 ) 1,25 dihydroxy Vitamin D ( calcitriol ) .
This appeared more effective than calcium in a direct comparison .
Hypercalcaemia and gastro-intestinal symptoms , reported in less than 5 % of participants , were slightly more common when Vitamin D analogues were taken .
However , the risk of death was marginally less .
REVIEW ER 'S CONCLUSIONS Uncertainty remains about the efficacy of regimens which include Vitamin D or its analogues in fracture prevention .
Particularly if co-supplementation of calcium is required , significant cost differences are likely to exist between regimens .
BACKGROUND Due to their known effects on bone metabolism , Vitamin D and related compounds have been proposed for the prevention of osteoporosis and fractures .
OBJECTIVES To determine the effects of supplementation with Vitamin D or a Vitamin D analogue in the prevention of fractures of the axial and appendicular skeleton in elderly men or women with involutional or post-menopausal osteoporosis .