When haloperidol and midazolam were compared with olanzapine , there was some evidence the combination was superior in terms of improvement , sedation and behaviour .
There were relatively little good data and most trials are too small to highlight differences in either positive or negative effects .
Adding a benzodiazepine to other drugs does not seem to confer clear advantage and has potential for adding unnecessary adverse effects .
Sole use of older antipsychotics unaccompanied by anticholinergic drugs seems difficult to justify .
BACKGROUND Acute psychotic illness , especially when associated with agitated or violent behaviour , can require urgent pharmacological tranquillisation or sedation .
In several countries , clinicians often use benzodiazepines ( either alone or in combination with antipsychotics ) for this outcome .
OBJECTIVES To estimate the effects of benzodiazepines , alone or in combination with antipsychotics , when compared with placebo or antipsychotics , alone or in combination with antihistamines , to control disturbed behaviour and reduce psychotic symptoms .
Efficacy of lorazepam and haloperidol for rapid tranquilization in a psychiatric emergency room setting
The efficacy of a benzodiazepine was compared with that of a neuroleptic for the rapid tranquilization of patients presenting at a psychiatric emergency room service . Thirty-seven highly agitated patients exhibiting psychotic symptoms were r and omly assigned to receive either 2 mg lorazepam or 5 mg haloperidol as needed every 30 min for 4 h. Administration route was either intramuscular injection or oral concentrate . Symptom ratings were conducted each hour using double-blind procedures . Both medications reduced symptom ratings on the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale and Global Clinical Impression of Overall Symptom Severity Scale . Global Clinical Impression scores for the two medication groups did not differ significantly either at baseline or at 4 h after entry into the study . However , Global Clinical Impression scores of patients in the lorazepam group were less severe at intermittent ratings . The groups did not differ on the Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale at any rating time . No differences were found either in the number of doses administered or in the administration route selected . Given the potential for severe extrapyramidal symptoms developing hours or days after a single dose of haloperidol , lorazepam may provide an excellent alternative for the rapid tranquilization of the acutely agitated psychotic patient in the emergency room setting
When haloperidol and midazolam were compared with olanzapine , there was some evidence the combination was superior in terms of improvement , sedation and behaviour .
There were relatively little good data and most trials are too small to highlight differences in either positive or negative effects .
Adding a benzodiazepine to other drugs does not seem to confer clear advantage and has potential for adding unnecessary adverse effects .
Sole use of older antipsychotics unaccompanied by anticholinergic drugs seems difficult to justify .
BACKGROUND Acute psychotic illness , especially when associated with agitated or violent behaviour , can require urgent pharmacological tranquillisation or sedation .
In several countries , clinicians often use benzodiazepines ( either alone or in combination with antipsychotics ) for this outcome .
OBJECTIVES To estimate the effects of benzodiazepines , alone or in combination with antipsychotics , when compared with placebo or antipsychotics , alone or in combination with antihistamines , to control disturbed behaviour and reduce psychotic symptoms .