This systematic review indicates that lithium is more effective than placebo as a treatment for acute mania but increases the risk for somnolence and tremor .
Limited evidence suggests little or no difference between lithium and other mood stabilisers ( valproate , carbamazepine ) or antipsychotics ( risperidone , quetiapine , haloperidol ) .
Olanzapine may be an exception , as it is probably slightly more effective than lithium .
There is uncertain evidence that risperidone may also be more effective than lithium .
Lithium is probably more effective at treating acute mania than topiramate .
When compared to placebo , lithium was more likely to cause adverse events .
More , rigorously design ed , large-scale studies are needed to definitively conclude if lithium is superior to other interventions in treating acute mania
BACKGROUND Bipolar disorder is a common condition associated with high morbidity ; developing efficacious , safe treatments is therefore essential .
Lithium is an effective maintenance treatment for bipolar disorder .
It acts as mood stabiliser and reduces the risk of suicide .
However , evidence assessing the efficacy of lithium in the treatment of acute mania is less robust .
Current evidence -based guidelines cite multiple anti-dopaminergic and mood-stabilising agents as initial treatments : more definite evidence is needed to decide if lithium should be the first-line therapy .
OBJECTIVES 1 .
To assess the effects of lithium in comparison with placebo or other active treatment in alleviating the acute symptoms of a manic or mixed episode in people with bipolar disorder.2 .
To review the acceptability and tolerability of treatment with lithium in comparison with placebo or other active treatments in alleviating the acute symptoms of a manic or mixed episode in people with bipolar disorder .
A randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled efficacy and safety study of quetiapine or lithium as monotherapy for mania in bipolar disorder.
OBJECTIVE To evaluate the efficacy and tolerability of quetiapine monotherapy versus placebo for the treatment of mania associated with bipolar disorder . METHOD In an international , multicenter , double-blind , parallel-group , 12-week study , patients with a DSM-IV diagnosis of bipolar I disorder ( manic episode ) were r and omly assigned to treatment with quetiapine ( flexibly dosed up to 800 mg/day ) , placebo , or lithium . The primary efficacy measure was change from baseline in Young Mania Rating Scale ( YMRS ) score at day 21 . Data were gathered from April 2001 to May 2002 . RESULTS More patients in the quetiapine ( 72/107 ) and lithium ( 67/98 ) groups completed the study compared with the placebo group ( 35/97 ) . Improvement ( reduction ) in YMRS score was significantly greater for quetiapine than placebo at day 7 ( -8.03 vs. -4.89 ; p < .01 ) , and the difference between groups continued to increase over time to day 21 ( -14.6 vs. -6.7 ; p < .001 ) and to endpoint at day 84 ( -20.3 vs. -9.0 ; p < .001 ) . Significantly more quetiapine patients compared with placebo patients fulfilled YMRS response criteria at day 21 ( 53.3 % vs. 27.4 % ; p < .001 ) and at day 84 ( 72.0 % vs. 41.1 % ; p < .001 ) . Quetiapine was also superior to placebo in efficacy at day 21 and day 84 by all secondary measures . Lithium-treated patients improved significantly compared with placebo patients and similarly to quetiapine-treated patients on the primary efficacy measure . The most common adverse events for quetiapine were dry mouth , somnolence , and weight gain , while lithium was associated with tremor and insomnia . The quetiapine and placebo groups had similar , low levels of extrapyramidal symptom-related adverse events . CONCLUSIONS Quetiapine demonstrated superior efficacy to placebo in patients with bipolar mania and was well tolerated
This systematic review indicates that lithium is more effective than placebo as a treatment for acute mania but increases the risk for somnolence and tremor .
Limited evidence suggests little or no difference between lithium and other mood stabilisers ( valproate , carbamazepine ) or antipsychotics ( risperidone , quetiapine , haloperidol ) .
Olanzapine may be an exception , as it is probably slightly more effective than lithium .
There is uncertain evidence that risperidone may also be more effective than lithium .
Lithium is probably more effective at treating acute mania than topiramate .
When compared to placebo , lithium was more likely to cause adverse events .
More , rigorously design ed , large-scale studies are needed to definitively conclude if lithium is superior to other interventions in treating acute mania
BACKGROUND Bipolar disorder is a common condition associated with high morbidity ; developing efficacious , safe treatments is therefore essential .
Lithium is an effective maintenance treatment for bipolar disorder .
It acts as mood stabiliser and reduces the risk of suicide .
However , evidence assessing the efficacy of lithium in the treatment of acute mania is less robust .
Current evidence -based guidelines cite multiple anti-dopaminergic and mood-stabilising agents as initial treatments : more definite evidence is needed to decide if lithium should be the first-line therapy .
OBJECTIVES 1 .
To assess the effects of lithium in comparison with placebo or other active treatment in alleviating the acute symptoms of a manic or mixed episode in people with bipolar disorder.2 .
To review the acceptability and tolerability of treatment with lithium in comparison with placebo or other active treatments in alleviating the acute symptoms of a manic or mixed episode in people with bipolar disorder .