Subgroup analysis demonstrated similar trends , with higher freedom from AF in the surgical ablation group for paroxysmal AF patients .
The incidence of pacemaker implantation was higher , while no difference in stroke or cardiac tamponade was demonstrated for the surgical versus catheter ablation groups .
Current evidence suggests that epicardial ablative strategies are associated with higher freedom from AF , higher pacemaker implantation rates and comparable neurological complications and cardiac tamponade incidence to catheter ablative treatment .
BACKGROUND Atrial fibrillation ( AF ) is an increasingly prevalent condition in the ageing population , with significantly associated morbidity and mortality .
Surgical and catheter ablative strategies both aim to reduce mortality and morbidity through freedom from AF .
This review consoli date s all currently available comparative data to evaluate these two interventions .
Comparison of catheter ablation and surgical ablation in patients with long-standing persistent atrial fibrillation and rheumatic heart disease: a four-year follow-up study.
BACKGROUND In our previous prospect i ve and r and omized study , we have demonstrated that the concomitant surgical ablation using saline-irrigated cooled tip radiofrequency ablation ( SICTRA ) system is more effective than subsequent circumferential pulmonary vein isolation ( CPVI ) combined with substrate modification in treating patients with long-st and ing persistent atrial fibrillation ( LS-AF ) and rheumatic heart disease ( RHD ) undergoing cardiac surgery during middle-term follow-up . Whether this strategy also decreases longer-term arrhythmia recurrence is unknown . This study describes the 4-year efficacy of SICTRA for these patients . Furthermore , we seek to compare the electrophysiological characteristics for recurrent atrial tachyarrhythmia ( ATa ) at the session of catheter ablation between two groups . METHODS Long-term follow-up was performed in 95 patients who underwent the catheter ablation strategy ( n=47 , Group A ) or SICTRA ( n=48 , Group B ) combined with valvular surgery for symptomatic LS-AF patients with RHD . RESULTS After one procedure , Group B had a significantly higher freedom from ATa compared with Group A ( 29/48 vs 15/47 , P=0.005 ) after a mean follow-up of 54 months ( range 48 to 63 months ) . Catheter-based mapping and ablation of recurrent ATa showed larger amounts of macro-reentrant atrial tachycardias ( ATs ) in Group B and higher incidence of pulmonary vein ( PV ) recovery in Group A. After multiple catheter ablations for recurrent ATa , sinus rhythm ( SR ) could be maintained equally between two groups . CONCLUSIONS Single procedure success seems to be higher with SICTRA but repeated catheter ablation potentially results in comparable outcomes in treating patients with LS-AF and RHD during long-term follow-up . More macro-reentrant ATs and more PV recoveries are identified to be responsible for ATa in SICTRA and catheter ablation group , respectively
Subgroup analysis demonstrated similar trends , with higher freedom from AF in the surgical ablation group for paroxysmal AF patients .
The incidence of pacemaker implantation was higher , while no difference in stroke or cardiac tamponade was demonstrated for the surgical versus catheter ablation groups .
Current evidence suggests that epicardial ablative strategies are associated with higher freedom from AF , higher pacemaker implantation rates and comparable neurological complications and cardiac tamponade incidence to catheter ablative treatment .
BACKGROUND Atrial fibrillation ( AF ) is an increasingly prevalent condition in the ageing population , with significantly associated morbidity and mortality .
Surgical and catheter ablative strategies both aim to reduce mortality and morbidity through freedom from AF .
This review consoli date s all currently available comparative data to evaluate these two interventions .