Bariatric surgery appears efficacious compared to st and ard care in reducing BMI .
Weight losses are greatest with diversionary procedures , intermediate with diversionary/restrictive procedures , and lowest with those that are purely restrictive .
Compared with Roux-en-Y gastric bypass , adjustable gastric b and ing has lower weight loss efficacy , but also leads to fewer serious adverse effects
Laparoscopic Adjustable Gastric Banding versus Open Vertical Banded Gastroplasty: A Prospective Randomized Trial
Background : Laparoscopic adjustable gastric b and ing ( LAGB ) and open vertical b and ed gastroplasty ( VBG ) are treatment modalities for morbid obesity . However , few prospect i ve r and omized clinical trials ( RCT ) have been performed to compare both operations . Methods : 100 patients ( 50 per group ) were included in the study . Postoperative outcomes included hospital length of stay ( LOS ) , complications , percent excess weight loss ( % EWL ) , BMI and reduction in total comorbidities . Follow-up in all patients was 2 years . Results : LOS was significantly shorter in the LAGB group . 3 LAGB were converted to open ( 1 to gastric bypass ) . Directly after VBG , 3 patients needed relaparotomies due to leakage , of which one ( 2 % ) died . After 2 years , 100 % follow-up was achieved . BMI and % EWL were significantly decreased in both groups but significantly more in the VBG group compared to the LAGB group ( 31.0 kg/m2 and 70.1 % vs 34.6 and 54.9 % respectively ) . Co-morbidities significantly decreased in both groups in time . 2 years after LAGB , 20 patients needed reoperation for pouch dilation/slippage ( n=12 ) , b and leakage ( n=2 ) , b and erosion ( n=2 ) and access-port problems ( n=4 ) . In the VBG group , 18 patients needed revisional surgery due to staple-line disruption ( n=15 ) , narrow outlet ( n=2 ) or insufficient weight loss ( n=1 ) . Furthermore , 8 VBG patients developed an incisional hernia . Conclusion : This RCT demonstrates that , despite the initial better weight loss in the  VBG group , based on complication rates and clinical outcome , LAGB is preferred . It had a shorter LOS and less postoperative morbidity
Bariatric surgery appears efficacious compared to st and ard care in reducing BMI .
Weight losses are greatest with diversionary procedures , intermediate with diversionary/restrictive procedures , and lowest with those that are purely restrictive .
Compared with Roux-en-Y gastric bypass , adjustable gastric b and ing has lower weight loss efficacy , but also leads to fewer serious adverse effects