The meta- analysis of the current evidence base showed that minimally invasive THA is associated with a significantly increased risk of transient lateral femoral cutaneous nerve palsy ( p = 0.006 ) with no significantly better outcome
Over the past decade , minimally invasive surgery has gained popularity as a means of optimising early postoperative rehabilitation and increasing patient satisfaction and cosmesis following  total hip arthroplasty ( THA ) .
However , this surgical exposure has also been associated with increased risk of iatrogenic nerve injury and implant mal-positioning due to limited visibility compared to conventionally larger surgical incisions .
The purpose of this meta- analysis was to compare the outcomes of these two surgical exposures .
Which is more invasive—mini versus standard incisions in total hip arthroplasty?
In this study , interleukin-6 ( IL-6 ) , C-reactive protein ( CRP ) , and haemoglobin levels were evaluated to compare the degree of surgical invasion between mini and st and ard incisions in total hip arthroplasty ( THA ) . Sixty-two patients admitted for primary cementless THA were enrolled in this r and omised study . The patients were allocated to have surgery through either a mini incision of < 10 cm or a st and ard incision of 15 cm . In each group , inflammatory responses were evaluated by IL-6 , CRP , and haemoglobin levels before operation and one day after operation . Significant differences were not found in IL-6 , CRP , and haemoglobin levels between both groups . At six months after surgery , there were no significant differences in postoperative Harris hip scores or radiographic evaluations between both groups . In conclusion , a 5.0 cm difference in the skin incision to the hip joint seemed to have no influence on the degree of surgical invasion during THA.RésuméAfin de mesurer l ’ importance de l’agression chirurgicale tissulaire dans les prothèses totales de hanche , incision st and ard , versus mini-invasifs , les niveaux d’Interleukin 6 ( IL-6 ) de protéine C-réactive ( CRP ) et d’hémoglobine doivent être appréciés . 62 patients devant bénéficier d’une prothèse totale de hanche primaire sans ciment ont été enrôlés dans cette étude r and omisée . Ces patients devaient bénéficier soit d’une mini-incision inférieure à 10 cm , soit d’une incision st and ard supérieure à 15 cm . Chaque groupe a été évalué avec ces différents facteurs biologiques avant l’intervention et un jour après intervention . Il n’a été trouvé aucune différence significative dans les deux groupes avec ces différents marqueurs Inteleukin , CRP et hémoglobine . Six mois après la chirurgie pas de différence significative non plus au niveau des scores de Harris ou au niveau de l’évaluation radiographique . En conclusion , la différence d’incision cutanée de 5 cm ne semble pas avoir d’influence sur l ’ importance des lésions des parties molles au cours d’une prothèse totale de hanche
The meta- analysis of the current evidence base showed that minimally invasive THA is associated with a significantly increased risk of transient lateral femoral cutaneous nerve palsy ( p = 0.006 ) with no significantly better outcome
Over the past decade , minimally invasive surgery has gained popularity as a means of optimising early postoperative rehabilitation and increasing patient satisfaction and cosmesis following  total hip arthroplasty ( THA ) .
However , this surgical exposure has also been associated with increased risk of iatrogenic nerve injury and implant mal-positioning due to limited visibility compared to conventionally larger surgical incisions .
The purpose of this meta- analysis was to compare the outcomes of these two surgical exposures .