Longer trastuzumab duration ( hera : 2 years vs. 1 year ) showed no improvement in dfs or os and a higher rate of cardiac events .
In the neoadjuvant setting ( neoaltto , GeparQuinto , Neosphere ) , trastuzumab alone or in combination with another anti-her2 agent ( lapatinib , pertuzumab ) was compared with either lapatinib or pertuzumab alone and showed superior or equivalent rates of pathologic complete response .
In the adjuvant setting , lapatinib alone or in combination with trastuzumab , compared with trastuzumab alone ( altto ) or with placebo ( teach ) , was not superior in dfs .
BACKGROUND This systematic review addresses the question " What is the optimal targeted therapy for female patients with early-stage human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (her2)-positive breast cancer ? "
Lapatinib versus trastuzumab in combination with neoadjuvant anthracycline-taxane-based chemotherapy (GeparQuinto, GBG 44): a randomised phase 3 trial.
BACKGROUND We compared the efficacy and safety of the addition of lapatinib versus trastuzumab to anthracycline-taxane-based neoadjuvant chemotherapy . METHODS In the GeparQuinto r and omised phase 3 trial , patients with untreated HER2-positive operable or locally advanced breast cancer were enrolled between Nov 7 , 2007 , and July 9 , 2010 . Patients were eligible if their tumours were classified as cT3/4a-d , or hormone receptor (HR)-negative , HR-positive with clinical ly node-positive and cT2 disease ( cT2 cN+ ) , or HR-positive and pathologically node-positive in the sentinel lymph node for those with cT1 disease ( cT1 pN(SLN+ ) ) . Patients were r and omly assigned in a 1:1 ratio to receive neoadjuvant treatment with four cycles of EC ( epirubicin [ 90 mg/m(2 ) intravenously ] plus cyclophosphamide [ 600 mg/m(2 ) intravenously ] , every 3 weeks ) , and four cycles of docetaxel ( 100 mg/m(2 ) intravenously every 3 weeks ) with either trastuzumab ( 6 mg/kg intravenously , with a starting loading dose of 8 mg/kg , for eight cycles , every 3 weeks ) or lapatinib ( 1000 - 1250 mg per day orally ) throughout all cycles before surgery . R and omisation was done by dynamic allocation with the minimisation method of Pocock and patients were stratified by participating site , HR status , and extent of disease ( cT1 - 3 cN0 - 2 vs T4 or N3 ) . The primary endpoint was pathological complete response ( defined as ypT0 and ypN0 ) and was analysed in all patients who received at least one cycle of EC . Participants and investigators were not masked to treatment assignment . Pathologists in centres assessing surgery outcomes were masked to group assignment . This trial is registered with Clinical Trials.gov , number NCT00567554 . FINDINGS Of 620 eligible patients , 309 were r and omly assigned to chemotherapy with trastuzumab ( ECH-TH group ) and 311 to chemotherapy with lapatinib ( ECL-TL group ) . Two patients in the ECH-TH group and three patients in the ECL-TL group did not start treatment because of withdrawal of consent or immediate surgery . 93 ( 30·3 % ) of 307 patients in the ECH-TH group and 70 ( 22·7 % ) of 308 patients in the ECL-TL group had a pathological complete response ( odds ratio [ OR ] 0·68 [ 95%CI 0·47 - 0·97 ] ;  p=0·04 )  . Chemotherapy with trastuzumab was associated with more oedema ( 119 [ 39·1 % ] vs 88 [ 28·7 % ] ) and dyspnoea ( 90 [ 29·6 % ] vs 66 [ 21·4 % ] ) , and ECL-TL with more diarrhoea ( 231 [ 75·0 % ] vs 144 [ 47·4 % ] ) and skin rash ( 169 [ 54·9 % ] vs 97 [ 31·9 % ] ) . 43 ( 14·0 % ) patients discontinued in the ECH-TH group and 102 ( 33·1 % ) in the ECL-TL group . 70 serious adverse events were reported in the ECH-TH group and 87 in the ECL-TL group . INTERPRETATION This direct comparison of trastuzumab and lapatinib showed that pathological complete response rate  with chemotherapy and lapatinib was significantly lower than that with chemotherapy and trastuzumab . Unless long-term outcome data show different results , lapatinib should not be used outside of clinical trials as single anti-HER2-treatment in combination with neoadjuvant chemotherapy . FUNDING GlaxoSmithKline , Roche , and Sanofi-Aventis
Longer trastuzumab duration ( hera : 2 years vs. 1 year ) showed no improvement in dfs or os and a higher rate of cardiac events .
In the neoadjuvant setting ( neoaltto , GeparQuinto , Neosphere ) , trastuzumab alone or in combination with another anti-her2 agent ( lapatinib , pertuzumab ) was compared with either lapatinib or pertuzumab alone and showed superior or equivalent rates of pathologic complete response .
In the adjuvant setting , lapatinib alone or in combination with trastuzumab , compared with trastuzumab alone ( altto ) or with placebo ( teach ) , was not superior in dfs .
BACKGROUND This systematic review addresses the question " What is the optimal targeted therapy for female patients with early-stage human epidermal growth factor receptor 2 (her2)-positive breast cancer ? "