Conclusions and Relevance In this systematic review and meta- analysis , neither intermittent nor daily dosing with st and ard doses of vitamin D alone was associated with reduced risk of fracture , but daily supplementation with both vitamin D and calcium was a more promising strategy
Importance Vitamin D and calcium supplements are recommended for the prevention of fracture , but previous r and omized clinical trials ( RCTs ) have reported conflicting results , with uncertainty about optimal doses and regimens for supplementation and their overall effectiveness .
Objective To assess the risks of fracture associated with differences in concentrations of 25-hydroxyvitamin D ( 25[OH]D ) in observational studies and the risks of fracture associated with supplementation with vitamin D alone or in combination with calcium in RCTs .
Serum 25-Hydroxyvitamin D Concentrations and Risk for Hip Fractures
Context Vitamin D supplementation may help prevent fractures , but the relationship between blood vitamin D concentrations and fracture risk is unclear . Contribution These authors observed an increased risk for hip fracture among women with lower serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D [ 25(OH ) vitamin D ] concentrations that was independent of measures of frailty , body mass index , physical function , and falls . Caution The authors did not measure bone mineral density ( BMD ) , so they could not determine whether 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations give different information about fracture risk than that offered by BMD . Implication Low serum 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations seem to be associated with a higher hip fracture risk . The Editors Vitamin  D deficiency is common in older adults , especially during the winter ( 1 ) and in homebound population s ( 2 ) , general medical in patients ( 3 ) , and community-dwelling women admitted to the hospital with acute hip fracture ( 4 ) . A recently published evidence -based report on vitamin D and bone health ( 5 ) found the level of evidence for an association between serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D [ 25(OH ) vitamin D ] concentrations and fracture risk to be inconsistent ( 5 ) . Since publication of that review , 1 prospect i ve study ( 6 ) reported no relationship between serum 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations and fractures , whereas another ( 7 ) reported a significantly lower risk for hip fracture with 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations greater than 60 nmol/L. Vitamin D concentration could be associated with fractures in several ways . It could influence muscle strength and balance , both of which contribute to falls and disability ( 810 ) . The association between 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations and fracture may also be influenced by renal function , because renal insufficiency has been linked to fracture ( 11 ) and to vitamin D deficiency ( 12 ) . Several interactions between vitamin D and estrogen receptors have been described ( 13 ) ; hormone therapy has been shown to reverse abnormalities in vitamin D metabolism ( 14 ) , and low vitamin D concentrations have also been linked to higher bone turnover ( 15 , 16 ) . Thus , sex-steroid hormones and bone turnover could contribute to the association between 25(OH ) vitamin D concentration and fractures . We conducted a nested casecontrol study within the WHI-OS ( Women 's Health Initiative Observational Study ) among 400 case- patients with adjudicated incident hip fracture and 400 control participants . We tested whether low serum 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations are associated with a higher risk for hip fractures in community-dwelling women and whether this relationship may be mediated by poor physical functioning , frailty , falls , sex-steroid hormones , renal function , or bone turnover . Methods Study Population Our study population came from the WHI-OS , a prospect i ve cohort study that enrolled 93676 women between 1994 and 1998 at 40 U.S. clinical centers ( age range , 50 to 79 years ) . Study methods are described in detail elsewhere ( 17 ) . In brief , women were eligible if they were postmenopausal , were unlikely to move or die within 3 years , were not enrolled in the WHI clinical trials , and were not currently participating in any other clinical trial . The human subjects review committees from each participating institution approved the study . Follow-up and Outcome Ascertainment We sent women question naires annually to report any hospitalization and other outcomes , including fractures . As of August 2004 , median follow-up duration was 7.1 years ( range , 0.7 to 9.3 years ) . At that time , 3.7 % of participants had withdrawn or were lost to follow-up and 5.3 % had died . We review ed medical records to verify cases of hip fracture , and blinded central adjudicators confirmed the cases ( 18 ) . We excluded patients with pathologic hip fractures . Nested CaseControl Study Design The present study is a casecontrol study nested within the prospect i ve design of WHI-OS . We excluded women who had a history of hip fracture ; were receiving hormone therapy up to 1 year before enrollment ; or were currently receiving and rogens , selective estrogen receptor modulators , antiestrogens , or other osteoporosis treatments ( bisphosphonates , calcitonin , or parathyroid hormone ) . We also excluded women with insufficient serum stored or of unknown ethnicity , leaving 39793 eligible participants . Of these , 404 women had a hip fracture . We r and omly selected 400 of these women to form the incident hip fracture group . For each case-patient , we selected 1 control participant who was within 1 year of the case-patient 's age at screening , was of matching race or ethnicity , and had their blood drawn within 120 days of the case-patient 's blood draw date ; 99 % of case- patients and control participants were matched within 30 days . Baseline Clinical Variables We divided clinical centers into 3 geographic regions on the basis of latitude : northern ( > 40 N ) , middle ( 35 to 40 N ) , and southern ( < 35 N ) . We ascertained all covariates at baseline . Clinic interviewers recorded current use of prescription medications by direct inspection of medicine containers . We entered prescription names into the WHI data base and assigned drug codes by using Medispan software ( First Data Bank , San Bruno , California ) . Average amounts of elemental calcium and vitamin D preparations were entered directly from supplement containers . Dietary intakes of calcium and vitamin D were assessed by using a semiquantitative food-frequency question naire ( 19 ) . Total calcium and vitamin D intake was defined as the sum of diet and supplements . We used question naires to ascertain date of birth , race or ethnicity , age at menopause , history of any fracture after age 55 years , smoking , parental history of hip fracture , self-rated health status , and alcohol consumption . We classfied physical activity on the basis of frequency and duration of walking and mild , moderate , and strenuous activities in the previous week . We calculated kilocalories of energy expended in 1 week as the metabolic equivalent ( kcal hours/week per kg ) ( 20 ) . We measured physical function by using the R AND Short Form-36 physical function scale , which comprises 10 items measuring whether health now limits physical function in moderate or vigorous activity ( 2 items ) ; strength to lift , carry , stoop , bend , or stair climb ( 4 items ) ; ability to walk various distances without difficulty ( 3 items ) ; and self-care ( 1 item ) ( 21 ) . The scale is scored from 0 to 100 , with higher scores indicating better physical function . We compared women with a score greater than 90 versus those with a score less than or equal to 90 , a cutoff value corresponding to the median score . We computed a frailty score , which included self-reported muscle weakness and impaired walking speed ( R AND Short Form-36 physical function scale score < 75 ) , exhaustion ( R AND Short Form-36 vitality scale score < 55 ) , low physical activity ( lowest quartile of physical activity ) , and unintended weight loss between baseline and 3 years of follow-up ( 22 ) . A woman was considered frail if she reported 3 or more of these indicators . Weight was measured on a balance-beam scale with the participant dressed in indoor clothing without shoes . Height was measured by using a wall-mounted stadiometer . Body mass index was calculated as weight ( in kg ) divided by height ( in m2 ) . Laboratory Procedures Laboratory personnel blinded to casecontrol status obtained a 12-hour fasting blood sample at the baseline visit , which was processed and stored at 80C according to strict quality control procedures ( 23 ) . Serum 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations and sex-steroid hormone levels were measured at the Reproductive Endocrine Research Laboratory at the University of Southern California .  25-Hydroxyvitamin vitamin D was measured by using a radioimmunoassay with DiaSorin reagents ( DiaSorin , Stillwater , Minnesota ) . The sensitivity of the assay was 3.75 nmol/L. The interassay coefficients of variation were 11.7 % , 10.5 % , 8.6 % , and 12.5 % at 14.0 , 56.8 , 82.5 , and 122.5 nmol/L , respectively . Estradiol and testosterone concentrations were quantified by using sensitive and specific radioimmunoassays after organic solvent extraction and celite column partition chromatography ( 2427 ) . The intra- and interassay coefficients of variation were 7.9 % and 8 % to 12 % , respectively , for estradiol and 6 % and 10 % to 12 % , respectively , for testosterone . We calculated bioavailable hormone concentrations by using mass action equations ( 2830 ) . We measured sex hormonebinding globulin by using a solid-phase , 2-site chemiluminescent immunoassay . The intra- and interassay coefficients of variation were 4.1 % to 7.7 % and 5.8 % to 13 % , respectively . Serum cystatin C , a marker of renal function that is independent of age and weight , was measured at Medical Research Laboratories International , Highl and Heights , Kentucky , by using the Dade Behring BN-II nephelometer and Dade Behring reagents ( Dade Behring , Ramsey , Minnesota ) in a particle-enhanced immunonepholometric assay . Serum C-terminal telopeptide of type I collagen and aminoterminal procollagen extensions propeptide were measured by immunoassay ( Synarc , Lyon , France ) . Statistical Analysis We used chi-square and t tests to compare baseline characteristics between case- patients with hip fracture and matched control participants . We assigned 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations to quartile categories defined on the basis of the distribution in the control participants . To further assess confounding , we compared baseline characteristics across quartiles of 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations in case- patients and control participants combined . We calculated the P values for trend by using logistic regression and coding the variable of interest as a continuous variable . We assessed the association between serum 25(OH ) vitamin D concentrations and incident hip fracture in conditional logistic regression models that retained the matched casecontrol design . We first examined the unadjusted associations and then adjusted for age ,
Conclusions and Relevance In this systematic review and meta- analysis , neither intermittent nor daily dosing with st and ard doses of vitamin D alone was associated with reduced risk of fracture , but daily supplementation with both vitamin D and calcium was a more promising strategy
Importance Vitamin D and calcium supplements are recommended for the prevention of fracture , but previous r and omized clinical trials ( RCTs ) have reported conflicting results , with uncertainty about optimal doses and regimens for supplementation and their overall effectiveness .
Objective To assess the risks of fracture associated with differences in concentrations of 25-hydroxyvitamin D ( 25[OH]D ) in observational studies and the risks of fracture associated with supplementation with vitamin D alone or in combination with calcium in RCTs .