Despite reviewing 39 eligible trials, few firm conclusions could be reached because of the multiple comparisons considered, the small size of individual trials, and their low quality. Whether or not to use a particular policy is usually a trade-off between the risks of morbidity (especially infection) and risks of recatheterisation.
Timing of antibiotic prophylaxis with cefotaxime for prostatic resection: better in the operative period or at urethral catheter removal?
There are two critical moments for the development of severe infectious complications following transurethral prostatectomy (TURP): the operative and immediate postoperative periods, and the day that the postoperative drainage catheter is removed. To optimize the timing of antibiotic prophylaxis with cefotaxime, two prospective randomized studies were conducted in patients with preoperatively sterile urine. In Study 1, all patients (n = 50) received cefotaxime 1 g intramuscular (i.m.) 1 hour preoperatively and were then randomized to receive either a second identical dose of cefotaxime 1 hour before catheter removal 24 hours later, or no further antibiotic treatment. In Study 2, patients (n = 89) were randomized to receive either cefotaxime 1 g i.m. 1 hour preoperatively or no preoperative antibiotic, after which all received cefotaxime 1 g i.m. 1 hour before catheter removal. Results were compared using identical evaluation criteria for infection in both studies: incidence of fever (temperature > 38 degrees C), bacteriuria (10(5) organisms/mL) and positive blood cultures, and duration of hospital stay (days). In Study 1, infection was significantly reduced with respect to all parameters in the group receiving two doses of cefotaxime, and total drug treatment costs were halved. In Study 2, the groups did not differ with respect to any parameter. We conclude that a single dose of cefotaxime 1 g i.m. 1 hour preoperatively provides inadequate cover for urethral catheter removal 24 hours later, and that prophylaxis with a single dose of cefotaxime 1 g i.m. 1 hour before catheter removal is just as effective as two doses given 1 hour preoperatively and 1 hour before catheter removal. Prophylactic coverage is essential during the action of removing the catheter and the time immediately following the operation. Long-term antibiotic coverage (24 hours or more) is not necessary. Thus, following TURP in patients with preoperatively sterile urine undergoing continuous bladder irrigation for 24 hours postoperatively, the optimal dose schedule for antibiotic prophylaxis with cefotaxime is a single 1-g dose given i.m. 1 hour before catheter removal.