Two intervention types, the specialist epilepsy nurse and self-management education, have some evidence of benefit. However, we did not find clear evidence that other service models substantially improve outcomes for adults with epilepsy. It is also possible that benefits are situation specific and may not generalise to other settings. These studies included only a small number of service providers whose individual competence or expertise may have had a significant impact on outcomes. At present it is not possible to advocate any single model of service provision.
A Prospective Evaluation of the Effects of a 12-Week Outpatient Exercise Program on Clinical and Behavioral Outcomes in Patients with Epilepsy.
Purpose. We hypothesized that patients randomized to an exercise program would demonstrate a measurable improvement in behavioral outcomes with no adverse clinical outcomes, as compared with control patients.Methods. This randomized, prospective, parallel, and controlled study spanned 12 weeks. Twenty-eight patients were randomized either to participate in a supervised exercise program (Exercise) or to continue their current level of activity with no planned intervention (Control). The Exercise group worked with an exercise physiologist three times per week. At specific intervals, behavioral (QOLIE-89, POMS, PSDQ, Self-Esteem) and clinical (seizure activity, antiepileptic drug (AED) concentrations) outcomes were measured.Results. Twenty-three patients completed the study (Exercise n = 14, Control n = 9). Of the four patients in the Exercise group with active seizures, two had no change, one had an increase, and one had a decrease in seizure activity. Of the three patients in the Control group with active seizures, one had no change, one had an increase, and one had a decrease in seizure activity. In all patients, there was <26% coefficient of variation in AED concentrations over the 12-week study, suggesting little or no impact of the exercise intervention. The overall quality of life and two domain scores improved from baseline to Week 12 in the Exercise group (P = 0.031), while the Control group score did not change (P = 0.943). In the Exercise group, there were several measures of physical self-concept and vigor that improved and total mood disturbance decreased from the beginning to the end of the program.Conclusion. This is the first randomized, controlled study of exercise in patients with epilepsy. Behavioral outcomes are positively influenced by moderate exercise and there is no impact on seizure frequency. This suggests that exercise should not be discouraged in the care of epilepsy patients. The ability to offer an exercise program adds a health promotion component to the current plan of care provided by our comprehensive epilepsy program.