Question: Who was an operatic tenor, Anita Vogel or Armand Tokatyan ?

Context paragraphs:
Anita Vogel: Anita Vogel (born November 24, 1969, California) is an American news reporter for the Fox News Channel.

Joseph Kaiser: Joseph Kaiser is a Canadian operatic tenor.  In 2005, he won second prize in Plácido Domingo's Operalia International Opera Competition while competing as a baritone.  The judges were keen to his talents and potential as a tenor, and proposed that he make the switch to tenor.  He has performed as a soloist with the New York Metropolitan Opera, making his debut in October 2007 as Roméo in Charles Gounod's "Roméo et Juliette".  In November he returned to the Met sing the role of Tamino Mozart's "Die Zauberflöte".

Jack Harrold: Jack Harrold (June 10, 1920 – July 22, 1994) was an American operatic tenor and voice teacher.  Admired for his comedic skills, he specialized in the tenor buffo repertoire.  He had a particularly long association with the New York City Opera from the 1940s through the 1980s.  He also appeared in several Broadway musicals. Danny Newman of the Lyric Opera of Chicago stated that, "Jack Harrold was one of American musical theater's most beloved and most versatile performers, possessing a clarion tenor voice that practically bounced off the back walls of the biggest theaters."

Félix Rienth: Félix Rienth (born 24 June 1970) is a Swiss operatic tenor.  Born in Basel, he was a member of the Basel Boys Choir in his youth.  He made his first opera appearance as a boy with Theater Basel as the first boy in Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's "The Magic Flute".  He attended the University of Basel where he earned diplomas in the Spanish and German languages.  He then studied singing privately in Basel with Heidi Wölnerhanssen before entering the Hochschule der Künste Bern; graduating from there in 2000 with a degree in opera performance.  He has since had a major career as a concert singer in the oratorio repertoire; appearing with important ensembles and at major music festivals throughout Europe, including a recital in presence of Her Majesty, Queen Fabiola of Belgium.  He has made about 20 recordings on a variety of labels.  A highly acclaimed production was the recording of Johann Christoph Pepusch]]'s "Tenor Cantatas" with his wife, Muriel Rochat Rienth, recorder player, and Swiss baroque ensemble "La Tempesta Basel".  His CD of Spanish baroque songs "Tonos humanos" by José Marín was considered as a reference recording by German magazine "Klassik heute".  2014 is appearing Georg Philipp Telemann's "Tenor Cantatas" with "La Tempesta Basel", elected among "Best CDs of the month" by Spanish magazine RITMO.

Armand Tokatyan: Armand Tokatyan (June 16, 1894 – June 12, 1960) was an operatic tenor.  An Armenian born in Plovdiv, Bulgaria, he travelled to Egypt with his parents where he sang in cafés to a favorable response.  He was then sent to Paris to study tailoring, but instead sang in Left Bank cafés.  In 1914, he returned to Egypt and earned his living by again singing in the cafés.  He took up operetta, soon becoming a matinee idol, then in 1919 went to Milan to pursue an opera career.  His operatic debut was in 1921 at the Teatro Dal Verme in Puccini's "Manon Lescaut".  With the help of Italian conductor Giuseppe Bamboschek, he joined the touring Scotti Opera Company in the United States, and was soon noticed by the Metropolitan Opera where he debuted in 1923.  For many years he performed there and at many other opera houses in the US and Europe.  He was proficient in numerous languages.  Many recordings were made of his performances.

Francisco Araiza: José Francisco Araiza Andrade (born 4 October 1950), is a Mexican operatic tenor and lied singer who has sung as soloist in leading concert halls and in leading tenor operatic roles in the major opera houses of Europe and North America during the course of a lengthy career.  Born in Mexico City, he studied singing at the Conservatorio Nacional de Música de México and later in Germany, with Mozartian tenor Richard Holm, and lieder interpretation with Erik Werba.  He made his operatic debut in 1970 in Mexico City as First Prisoner in Beethoven's "Fidelio".  Araiza initially came to international prominence singing in Mozart and Rossini operas, but in the 1980s broadened his repertoire to include Italian and French lyric tenor roles and Wagnerian roles such as Lohengrin and Walther von Stolzing.  He was made a Kammersänger of the Vienna State Opera in 1988.  Now retired from the opera stage, he teaches singing and serves on the juries of several international singing competitions.

Agustarello Affre: Agustarello Affre (23 October 1858 - 27 December 1931) was a French operatic tenor.  He possessed a powerful, firm and exceptionally beautiful voice which garnered him the nickname the "French Tamagno" in comparison to the great Italian tenor.  He was one of the leading operatic tenors in Paris from 1890-1911.  He spent the last years of his career singing and directing operas in the United States.  After World War I, he lived in retirement in France.

Hans-Dieter Bader: Hans-Dieter Bader (born 16 February 1938) is a German operatic tenor.  He performed for decades leading parts as both a dramatic and a lyrical tenor at the Staatsoper Hannover.  He appeared in around 90 operatic roles and in concert and oratorio.

Robin Donald: Donald Robin (Smith) (born 26 March 1942) is an Australian operatic tenor who was known professionally as 'Robin Donald'.  He is the son of arguably Australia's greatest operatic tenor voice Donald Smith (Dr Donald Smith O.B.E.).

Charles Craig (tenor): Charles James Craig (3 December 191923 January 1997) was an English operatic tenor.  He received early encouragement from Sir Thomas Beecham, and sang in his 1952 recording of "A Mass of Life" by Frederick Delius.  He was known as one of "the most Italianate of English operatic tenors".  From 1957 to 1980 he performed leading tenor roles at London's Royal Opera House and English National Opera.  One of his most famous roles was Verdi's Otello, which he sang in Chicago, Vienna, Berlin, Naples, Munich, Venice, Salzburg, Turin, Lisbon, Düsseldorf.

Supporting paragraphs: Armand Tokatyan Anita Vogel
Answer: Armand Tokatyan