Question: Which magazine ks based in New York City, VIVmag or Elle Girl?

Context paragraphs:
Estelle Lefébure: Estelle Lefébure (] ; born 11 May 1966) is a French actress and model.  She was one of the top fashion models in the 1980s and 1990s.  Estelle Lefebure, as she was known in the early 1980s, was discovered by George Gallier and managed by him exclusively at Prestige Models in Paris, France.  George Gallier then moved to New York City to start American Model Management, and managed her career until 1991.  Her national recognition was immediate after the first Guess (clothing) campaign shot by Wayne Mazer in the early 1980s; she then shot several covers of American Vogue (magazine) with photographer Richard Avedon, several covers of American Elle (magazine) with Marc Hispard, Gilles Ben Simon and Bill King.  French "Elle" magazine model editor Odile Saron was also instrumental in helping Estelle's career take off.  In 1991, she switched agencies, moving from American Model Management to Elite, moved to California, and married singer David Hallyday.  During her marriage with David Hallyday, she was known professionally as Estelle Hallyday.

Katherine Oliver: Katherine Oliver is an American media and entertainment executive based in New York City.  Oliver is currently a Principal at Bloomberg Associates, a philanthropic consultancy firm founded by Michael Bloomberg to provide advice and long-term solutions to cities worldwide.  On August 1, 2002, she was appointed by New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg as the Commissioner of The New York City Mayor's Office of Film, Theatre and Broadcasting, which facilitates all aspects of film, television and commercial production in New York City, coordinating on-location filming, liaising with the community and promoting the City as an entertainment capital.  Oliver was the main liaison between the Mayor's Office and Hollywood and aimed "to make filmmakers and production companies happy to return to New York."  In 2013, Oliver and Mayor Bloomberg were featured on the cover of Variety and were credited for their role in "revitalizing the city's entertainment sector."  An economic impact study released by the Boston Consulting Group in 2012 found that New York City's entertainment industry during Oliver's tenure as film commissioner had grown to account for a $7.1 billion annual direct spend in New York City, an increase of $2 billion since 2002, and that the local industry created 30,000 jobs in New York City since 2004, growing to employ 130,000 people.  AM New York noted that: "New York's film and TV industry is stronger than it has ever been, pumping $7.1 billion into the local economy in 2011 and bringing in some $60 billion over the last decade."  After Bloomberg announced that former president and co-founder of NYC Media Group Arick Wierson was returning to the private sector, Bloomberg named Oliver as the incoming president of NYC Media and general manager of NYCTV.  In July 2010, Oliver became the commissioner of the Mayor's Office of Media and Entertainment, the city agency that includes the Mayor's Office of Film, Theatre and Broadcasting, NYC Media, and NYC Digital.

Peter Pennoyer: Peter Pennoyer FAIA (born on February 19, 1957 in New York City, New York, United States of America) is an award-winning architect and principal of Peter Pennoyer Architects in New York City.  Pennoyer, his four partners, and his fifty associates have an international practice in traditional and classical architecture, or New Classical Architecture.  Many of the firm's institutional and commercial projects have involved historic buildings, and it is stated by Institute of Classical Architecture & Art that the firm's strength is for "deftly fusing history and creative invention into timeless contemporary designs. "The firm's projects have been widely featured in newspapers, books, and periodicals, including "The New York Times", "Architectural Digest", The Wall Street Journal, Elle Decor and "House & Garden".

Bridget Harrison: Bridget Harrison (born 22 February 1971) is a freelance journalist and Contributing Editor at the Times Magazine.  She is also an editor on the Times T2 and Times Weekend sections.  She has also written for The Times, Sunday Times Magazine, Sunday Times Style, Red, Elle, Grazia, GQ, Stylist, Glamour, Cosmopolitan among others.  She was formerly the deputy editor of "thelondonpaper", a free London newspaper published by News International which had a circulation of 500,000 and closed in September 2009.  Before this she worked at the New York Post from 2000 to 2005 as a reporter, columnist and editor.  Before this she was an assistant features editor at The Times.  Her book "Tabloid Love: Looking for Mr Right in All the Wrong Places" ISBN  chronicles her dating experience and the trials and tribulation as a 30-something single woman in New York City.  Unlike "Sex and the City" by Candace Bushnell, the book is a memoir rather than a fiction, although the names of many characters in the book have been changed to protect their identity.  In 2008 Bridget Harrison married Dimitri Doganis, MD of Raw Television, they have two sons.  Bridget Harrison was educated at St Paul's Girls' School and Manchester University and has a MSc.in Development Studies from School of Oriental and African Studies, London.

Elle Girl: Elle Girl was the largest older-teen fashion and beauty magazine brand in the world with 12 editions and supplements worldwide.  Launched in August 2001, it was the younger sibling to "Elle" magazine, and similarly focused on beauty, health, entertainment and looked at daring fashion—its slogan: ""Dare to be different"".  The magazine was published monthly and was based in New York City.

City &amp; State: City & State is a political journalism organization based in New York City.  The company publishes a weekly magazine covering politics and government in New York City and New York State that is distributed to New York State legislators, county executives, municipalities, the New York Congressional delegation, New York City Council members and others leaders in New York business and government.  After years of publishing a twice-monthly print edition, "City & State" has announced plans to switch to a weekly in January 2016.  "City & State" also publishes on their website and sends out a free First Read daily email.  In May 2016 the company also launched a monthly magazine based in Philadelphia and a website.

VIVmag: VIVmag is one of the earliest exclusively digital, interactive women's lifestyle magazines.  Launched in 2006 and backed by Canadian industrialist David Harrison Gilmour (the founder of FIJI Water LLC), the bimonthly magazine is distributed by Zinio Systems, Inc.  The first issue appeared in January-February 2007.  There is no print version.  The paperless title can be viewed in most browsers or downloaded to your computer and read via the Zinio Reader.  The magazine is based in Thousand Oaks, California.

Tara McPherson: Tara McPherson (born April 7, 1976 in San Francisco, California) is an American artist based in New York City.  She studied art at Santa Monica Community College and earned her BFA from Art Center in Pasadena, CA in August 2001.  While in college, she interned with Rough Draft Studios.  In a brief 2008 piece concerning concert artwork, "Elle" magazine referred to her as "the crown princess of poster art.  She opened the Cotton Candy Machine boutique in New York City in 2011.

Catherine Texier: Catherine Texier, novelist, journalist, and creative writing professor, was born and raised in France and now lives in New York City.  She is the author of four novels, "Victorine" (2004), "Chloé l’Atlantique" (1983), "Love Me Tender" (1987) and "Panic Blood" (1990), and a memoir, "Breakup" (1999).  She was the coeditor of the literary magazine "Between C & D", is a regular contributor to "The New York Times", and has written for "Newsday", "ELLE", "Harper's Bazaar", "Cosmopolitan", "Marie Claire", and Nerve.com.  She also edited the anthologies "Between C and D: New Writing from the Lower East Side Fiction Magazine" (1988) and "Love is Strange: Tales of Postmodern Romance" (1993), both with former spouse Joel Rose.

Project Runway (season 2): Project Runway Season 2 was the second season of Bravo's successful "Project Runway", a reality competition for fashion designers.  Season 2 began airing on December 7, 2005.  Following a nationwide search earlier in the year, sixteen designers were chosen as semi-finalists and brought to New York City in June 2005.  After the first challenge, called "Road To The Runway", fourteen went on to compete as finalists.  The winning designer, Chloe Dao, received $100,000 in seed money to help launch her own line, a 2007 Saturn Sky roadster, a spread in "ELLE" magazine, and a mentorship with the Banana Republic Design Team.  Winning alongside Dao was her model, Grace Kelsey, who received the ELLE Magazine spread.  Michael Kors and Nina Garcia returned as judges for the second season.  The fourth judging seat rotated each week, based on the challenge.  Tim Gunn, fashion chair at Parsons The New School for Design, returned as a mentor for the designers.

Supporting paragraphs: VIVmag Elle Girl
Answer: Elle Girl