Question: Which cemetery in Suffolk County, New York, is the permanent resting place of more 18th and 19th century sea captains that in any other Long Island cemetery?

Context paragraphs:
Oakland Cemetery (Sag Harbor, NY): Oakland Cemetery is a public, not-for-profit cemetery located in the village Sag Harbor, New York.  It was founded in 1840 and currently sits on 26 acres bounded by Jermain Ave to the north, Suffolk St to the east, and Joels Ln to the west.  It is the permanent resting place of over 4,000 people, including more 18th and 19th century sea captains than in any other Long Island cemetery.  It was incorporated in 1884.

Williamsburg Cemetery: Williamsburg Cemetery is a historic cemetery located at Hampton Corners in Livingston County, New York.  It was established in 1792 and is one of the earliest European American settlement period cemeteries in Western New York and is the last surviving above ground remnant of the now vanished village of Williamsburg.  Williamsburg was established by Captain Charles Williamson acting in his capacity as agent for British investors in The Pulteney Association in the late 18th century.  Notable burials include U.S. Representative Charles H. Carroll (1794–1865) and William Fitzhugh, an early investor in what is now Livingston County, and business partner of Colonel Nathaniel Rochester, founder of that city.  It is also the final resting place of Henry Fitzhugh (1801–1866) and James G. Birney (1792–1857), son in law of William Fitzhugh and candidate for President of the United States by the Liberty Party in the 1840 and 1844 presidential elections on an abolitionist platform.  Stones bear dates that range from about 1814 to about 1910 and it is an important reminder of the early settlement of the Genesee Valley.

Dunning Street Cemetery: Dunning Street Cemetery is a historic rural cemetery located at Malta, Saratoga County, New York.  The cemetery was established about 1775, and incorporated by the Dunning Street Cemetery Association in 1908.  It is the final resting place of many important early Malta residents, including veterans of American Revolutionary War and includes a number of notable examples of 19th century local funerary art.  It remains an active burial ground.

Mount Hope Cemetery (Rochester): Mount Hope Cemetery in Rochester, New York, founded in 1838, is one of the United States' first municipal rural cemeteries.  Situated on 196 acres (793,000 m²) (0.3 square miles) of land adjacent to the University of Rochester on Mount Hope Avenue, the cemetery is the permanent resting place of over 350,000 people.  The annual growth rate of this cemetery is 500-600 burials per year.

Riverside Cemetery (Rochester, New York): Riverside Cemetery in Rochester, New York was founded in 1892 to serve the growing population in the northern part of the city.  Situated on 123 acres (498,000 m²) (0.2 square miles) of land between Lake Avenue and the Genesee River, the cemetery is the permanent resting place of over 250,000 people.  Since 1942, the cemetery has been owned and operated by the City of Rochester.

Sag Harbor, New York: Sag Harbor is an incorporated village in Suffolk County, New York, United States, in the towns of East Hampton and Southampton.  The population was 2,169 at the 2010 census.

Cemetery of the Evergreens: The Cemetery of the Evergreens is a non-denominational cemetery in Brooklyn and Queens, New York, colloquially called Evergreen Cemetery.  It was incorporated in 1849, not long after the passage of New York's Rural Cemetery Act spurred development of cemeteries outside Manhattan.  For a time, it was the busiest cemetery in New York City; in 1929 there were 4,673 interments.  The cemetery borders Brooklyn and Queens and covers 225 acre of rolling hills and gently sloping meadows.  It features several thousand trees and flowering shrubs in a park-like setting.  The Evergreens is the final resting place of more than 526,000 people.

Salem Fields Cemetery, Brooklyn: Salem Fields Cemetery, located at 775 Jamaica Avenue in the Cypress Hills neighborhood of Brooklyn, New York, United States, was founded in 1852 by Temple Emanu-el.  Part of a larger complex of cemeteries spanning into the borough of Queens, including likewise Jewish Machpelah Cemetery, where Harry Houdini is buried; Union Field Cemetery; Mount Judah Cemetery, where several prominent Rabbis lie; Mount Carmel Cemetery; and the non-denominational Cypress Hills Cemetery and Cemetery of the Evergreens, it is the final resting place for many of the prominent German-Jewish families of New York City.  Among those laid to rest in the cemetery are members of the Fox family, founders of 20th Century Fox Film Corp.; the Guggenheim family of mining, newspaper, and museum fame; the Lewisohn family of mining, banking, and philanthropic interests; and the Shubert family, builders of the largest theatre empire in the 20th century.

Earlham Road Cemetery, Norwich: Earlham Road Cemetery, Norwich also known as Earlham Cemetery or Norwich Cemetery is a cemetery located in Norwich which was officially opened on 6 March 1856 and covers 34 acres .  The cemetery is divided into two distinct sites by Farrow Road A140 which runs north-south across the site.  To the east of the road is the original 19th century cemetery and to the west of the road lies the 20th century addition.  Today, it caters for all faiths with separate burial grounds and chapels for Jews and Catholics and a growing one for Muslims together with two military cemeteries.  The 19th century cemetery is designed with an informal "garden cemetery" layout with winding paths while the remainder is a more formal grid type which was favoured by cemetery designer John Claudius Loudon.  Much of the original cemetery is a County Wildlife Site and contains grassland and a wide selection of mature trees.

Magnolia Cemetery (Mobile, Alabama): Magnolia Cemetery is a historic city cemetery located in Mobile, Alabama.  Filled with many elaborate Victorian-era monuments, it spans more than 100 acre .  It served as Mobile's primary, and almost exclusive, burial place during the 19th century.  It is the final resting place for many of Mobile's 19th and early 20th century citizens.  The cemetery is roughly bounded by Frye Street to the north, Gayle Street to the east, and Ann Street to the west.  Virginia Street originally formed the southern border before the cemetery was expanded and now cuts east–west through the center of the cemetery.  Magnolia contains more than 80,000 burials and remains an active, though very limited, burial site today.

Supporting paragraphs: Oakland Cemetery (Sag Harbor, NY) Sag Harbor, New York
Answer: Oakland Cemetery