Question: Which American rock band is from New Mexico Circa Survive or The Shins?

Context paragraphs:
The Amulet (album): The Amulet is the sixth studio album by American rock band Circa Survive, released on September 22, 2017.  The Amulet is Circa Survive's first album released through Hopeless Records, after departing their previous label, Sumerian Records.  As with previous Circa Survive albums, Esao Andrews created the album artwork.

Violent Waves: Violent Waves is the fourth studio album by the American rock band Circa Survive.  It was released on August 28, 2012.  As Circa Survive wanted a record that would capture the band's live sound, where they felt the magic of the band lay, they recorded the album in one week and produced it themselves.  Violent Waves is also Circa Survive's first and only album released without a record label.

The Shins: The Shins are an American indie rock band from Albuquerque, New Mexico, formed in 1996.  The band's current lineup consists of James Mercer (vocals, guitar, songwriter), Jon Sortland (drums), Mark Watrous (guitar), Casey Foubert (guitar), Yuuki Matthews (bass), and Patti King (keyboards).  The band is based in Portland, Oregon.

Juturna (album): Juturna is the debut studio album by American rock band Circa Survive.  It was released on April 19, 2005 through Equal Vision Records.  Upon the album's release, it debuted on the "Billboard" 200 at No. 183 on May 7, 2005.  Up to July 19, 2006, it had sold 74,896 copies.

Circa Survive: Circa Survive is an American rock band from the Philadelphia suburb of Doylestown, formed in 2004.  The band, led by Anthony Green, consists of former members from Saosin, This Day Forward, and Taken.

Descensus (album): Descensus is the fifth studio album by the American rock band Circa Survive, released on November 24, 2014.  Descensus is Circa Survive's first album released through Sumerian Records, aside from the Deluxe CD/DVD version of the band's previous album, "Violent Waves" which was released on August 28, 2012.  As with Circa Survive's previous albums, Esao Andrews created the album artwork.

Blue Sky Noise: Blue Sky Noise is the third studio album by American rock band Circa Survive, released on April 20, 2010 through Atlantic Records.  It serves as the band's first release after departing from Equal Vision Records, and is a follow-up to their second studio album, "On Letting Go" (2007).

Translating the Name: Translating the Name is the debut EP by American rock band Saosin, released on June 17, 2003 through Death Do Us Part.  The album was released before Anthony Green departed from the band to form the rock band Circa Survive.  It is also the band's only release to feature bass guitarist Zack Kennedy, as well as the only release to not feature drummer Alex Rodriguez.  Guitarist Beau Burchell stated that Rodriguez intended to track the drums for Translating the Name but had a prior commitment with his former band Open Hand before he could join.  Pat Magrath was hired as a session musician and performed with Saosin briefly before Rodriguez joined.

On Letting Go: On Letting Go is the sophomore studio album by American rock band Circa Survive released on May 29, 2007 through Equal Vision Records.  The album was produced by Bryan McTernan and was recorded throughout 2007 at the Salad Days Recording Studios in Baltimore, Maryland.  It follows-up the group's debut full-length studio album, "Juturna" (2005).  The album charted at No. 24 on the U.S. "Billboard" 200, selling about 24,000 copies in its first week.  As of July 11, 2007, it had sold 51,357 copies in the US.

Vince Ratti: Vince Ratti (born in Philadelphia), is an American songwriter, record producer, recording and mixing engineer based out of Philadelphia.  Vince has worked throughout his career with various notable artists like Panic!  at the Disco, Circa Survive, Brand New, The Wonder Years, Citizen, Balance and Composure, August Burns Red, Title Fight, Mewithoutyou among others.  Vince is also a core member of the band Zolof the Rock & Roll Destroyer where he is the guitarist and vocalist.  Vince currently operates out of The Skylight Studio in Fairless Hills and occasionally out of Studio 4 in Conshohoken, both located near Philadelphia.

Supporting paragraphs: Circa Survive The Shins
Answer: The Shins