1922-06-15

[Stage Direction]
Hon. D. D. McKENZIE (Solicitor General) moved for leave to introduce Bill No. 141, to repeal the Lake of the Woods Regulation Act, 1921.
Some hon. MEMBERS:: Explain.


Mr. McKENZIE:: Some time in 1921,
before the opening of the session of that year, a certain agreement was arrived at between the Dominion of Canada, as represented by the right hon. the Prime Minister of that day, now leader of the Opposition (Mr. Meighen), and the province of Ontario, represented by the present Prime Minister of that province. I understand that the province of Manitoba also had something to do with the arrangement and was represented by its present Prime Minister. The agreement in question provided for the control of the Lake of the Woods and its water power by a board to be appointed jointly by the province of Ontario and the Dominion Government. To implement that agreement it was arranged that confirmatory legislation should be passed by this Parliament and by the legislation of Ontario. The then Prime Minister, the present right hon. leader of the Opposition, carried out his part of the arrangement and the act is known as Chapter 10 of the statutes of last year; but the Premier of Ontario was unable to carry a similar bill through the Ontario legislature. Upon his failure to do this he requested that no further steps should be taken until he was able to fulfil his part of the arrangement. However, as Chapter 10 was useless without joint legislation by Ontario, the right hon. gentleman introduced another bill under which the Dominion assumed absolute control of the Lake of the Woods, and this bill was passed by this Parliament and is now Chapter 38 of the statutes of last session. Section 10 of this act provides that if at any time the legislature of Ontario should enact the joint legislation agreed upon Chapter 38 should be repealed. The legislature of Ontario having recently passed the legislation contemplated in the agreement I have referred to. I am introducing this bill simply for the purpose of repealing Chapter 38.


Right Hon. ARTHUR MEIGHEN (Leader of the Opposition):: Anent the explanation of the Solicitor General, I can only say that it affords a very good reason why there need be no such bill at all. He is quite right in stating that the second bill introduced last session contained a proviso that upon the government of Ontario implementing the agreement to which he refers, then the bill last introduced and passed here automatically is repealed, save as to one section which it is necessary to retain. If the act is repealed automatically when Mr. Drury carries out his promise, why does the Government introduce a special bill to effect the same purpose?
Motion agreed to and bill read the first time.



INDIAN ACT AMENDMENT

[Stage Direction]
Hon. CHARLES STEWART (Minister of [DOT]the Interior) moved for leave to introduce Bill No. 142, to amend the Indian Act.
He said: The first purpose of this bill is to repeal Section 7 dealing with the compulsory enfranchisement of Indians, which section was added to the act last session. I find that this feature meets with a great deal of opposition from the Indians themselves. Indeed, it is bitterly resented by the Six Nations Indians with whom we have had some little difficulty during the past month. This amendment simply repeals the section which gives the Deputy Superintendent General power to enfranchise an indian with or without his consent, and reverts to the former practice under which any indian desiring enfranchisement must make personal application.
The second section is intended to clarify the situation in regard to the ownership of land remaining in the control of the band, particularly land upon which returned indian soldiers have been re-established. I do not think there is really any legal doubt on the point, but inasmuch as an earlier amendment to the act has reference to the Soldiers' Settlement Act, which covers land taken as security by the Soldiers' Settlement Board, we are by this second section making it absolutely clear that the ownership of the land, whether occupied by a soldier settler or by any other indian, remains under the control of the band.
Motion agreed to and bill read the first time.


[Stage Direction]
Bill No. 138 (from the Senate), for the relief of Frank Clifford Gennery.-Mr. Rankin.
Questions
[Stage Direction]
Bill No. 139 (from the Senate), for the relief of Sarah Brackinreid.-Mr. Kay.
Bill No. 140 (from the Senate), for the relief of Mildred Catherine Touchbourne.- Mr. Kay.

[Stage Direction]
(Questions answered orally are indicated by an asterisk.)

Mr. CHURCH:: What action does the Government intend to take to disallow an act and schedule agreement of the province of Ontario for the alienation of 3,000 square miles of Ontario's resources to E. W. Backus?


Hon.   S@: The act cannot be identified by the question. The time for disallowance of the 1921 legislation expired on the 4th June. The legislation* of the session of 1922 has not been considered.


CANADIAN MERCHANT MARINE-MONTREAL EMPLOYEES
Mr. DESLAURIERS:: 1.	How many persons, residents of Halifax, Nova Scotia, are employed by the Canadian Merchant Marine at Montreal, Quebec?
2.	Could not the positions occupied by the said persons be filled by residents of Montreal?


Hon. Mr. KENNEDY:: 1.	Employees of Canadian Government Merchant Marine are moved from point to point as required. At the close of inland navigation last year, 71 were transferred from Montreal to Halifax. On opening of
inland navigation this year, 58 employees were moved from Halifax to Montreal for the summer season. The reduction in staff is accounted for by the laying up of some of the fleet.
2.	Employees in question are residents of Montreal in summer, and of Halifax in winter.


MONTREAL HARBOUR COMMISSION- POLICEMAN
Mr. DESLAURIERS:: 1.	How many policemen are there employed by the Montreal Harbour Commission?
2.	What are their names and nationality?
3.	How long have they been in the service?
4.	How many of the said employees were appointed during the period between December 1st, 1921, and June 1st, 1922?
5.	What are the names of the said persons, their nationality, and how long have they resided in Canada?


Hon. Mr. LAPOINTE:: 1.	One chief, three captains, fifty-one constables.
2.	See list below.
3.	See list below.
4.	All men in second portion of attached list have been appointed between December 1, 1921, and June 1, 1922. Constables Sanscartier, Brisebois, Raymond, Lacombe, Roger, Hebert and Lanctot are only new men appointed between above dates. Remainder on second list are men who have been employed as constables previous seasons of navigation since dates opposite their respective names.
5.	See list below.
Name
Nationality
Started
Came to Canada
E. A. Williams, Chief	
N. Rondeau, Captain	
A. W. Evison, Captain	
J. Cowley, Captain	
Constables-
H. Barrett	
J. Cabara	
J. D. Fogarty	
B. J. McDermott	
T. Pearson	
H. Light	
T. Walsh	
O.	Trudeau	
J. Garneau	
N. Millette	
G. King	
G.	Lebeau	
D. Hayes	
J. H. Dodd	
A. Jackman	
S.	Timperley	
J. St. Louis	
H.	Arsenault	
J. Heaney	
T.	Bennett (Constable and fireman)
L Ethier	
Scotch Canadian French Canadian
English	
English	
English	
French Canadian, Irish Canadian... Irish Canadian...
English	
French Canadian, Irish Canadian... French Canadian French Canadian French Canadian
English	
French Canadian
Irish	
Irish Canadian...
English	
English	
French Canadian French Canadian Trish Canadian...
Irish	
French Canadian
Nov.	l-i,	1918.April	20,	1915June	6.	1917.April	16,	1914.Oct.	3,	1911Aug.	1,	1914.July	6,	1915April	12,	1918.May	3,	1918.M ay	25,	1918.Fune	7,	1918.July	11,	1918.July	19,	1918.Aug.	20,	1918.April	25,	1919.May	16,	1919.May	10,	1919.Sept.	25,	1919May	5,	1920.June	23,	1920.May	15,	1918.1,	1920.1,	1920.2,	1921April	15,	191"
April, 1913. Sept., 1912.
Oct., 1911. April, 1904.
Sept., 1907.
March, 1910.
July, 1909. Aug., 1912.
June,1905.
(Died April 22, 1922


DEATH OF CAPTAIN HUESTON
Mr. CHURCH:: 1.	Will the Department of Civil Re-establishment, the Militia Department, the head of the military district in question, or other government authority proceed fo open a military or other court of inquiry into the murder of one Captain Hueston, a returned soldier and veteran of the Great War, in the Fort Francis district, Ontario, as requested by some of his comrades in arms?
2.	Will the Government, in view of the failure of the provincial authorities, try and bring the perpetrators of the murder of this returned man to justice, and make an inquiry into the murder as requested by the murdered man's comrades in arms, and see that justice is done in the premises to a returned man, and his family given some redress, protection and pension or compensation?
3.	If not, why?


Hon.   S@: The Department of Justice has no particulars or information concerning the case. The administration of justice in criminal matters is charged upon the provincial governments and the government of the Dominion has no constitutional power or function to conduct criminal prosecutions in the provinces.


DOMESTIC LOAN MATUKITIES
Mr. IRVINE:: In the case of loan issues embracing maturities of five years and multiples of five years, what are the amounts represented by each five yearly denomination on all the war loans and Victory loans?


Hon. Mr. FIELDING:: Bonds of domestic war and Victory loan issues become due as follows:
Amount outstanding
Year	March 31,1922
1922		$182,834,500
1923		 172,459,650
1924		 107,955,650
1925		 42,014,500
' 1927	 63,437,250
1931	 52,931,600
1933		 446,663,800
1934		 511,910,650
1937	 326,465,750


QUESTION PASSED AS ORDER FOR RETURN
Mr. VIEN:: 1. What amounts have been paid by the Government. and to whom, for auditing public expenditure since the Civil Service Act of 1918 became effective?
Pensions Board

2.	What is the total amount of the claims of the Clarkson Commission for inquiry and audit in the Militia Department in respect of the sterling exchange payments to returned soldiers and others?
3.	Were any or all of the sterling exchange payments made by the chief accountant, audited by the audit staff of the Militia Department?
4.	What is the total amount it is computed or estimated has been fraudulently obtained in exchange transactions by or on behalf of returned soldiers or others?
5.	Did any of the officials or employees of the Accounts Branch, Militia Department, who were connected with or responsible for handling sterling exchange payments to returned soldiers or others, receive any increase in pay or were they classified in a higher grade by the Civil Service Commission after undertaking this sterling exchange work?
6.	If so, what are the names of such officials or employees?
7.	At what rate of pay were Messrs. Allen, Lowe and Hubbell paid each fiscal year since their appointment, and on what dates did increases of pay by re-classification or otherwise become effective?
8.	Before being permanently appointed, did these men pass any examination prescribed by the Civil Service Commission?


PENSIONS BOARD
[Stage Direction]
On the Orders of the Day:
Mr. L. W. HUMPHREY (West Kootenay):: Before the Orders of the Day are called, Mr. Speaker, I would like to direct the attention of the Government to an article appearing in the press this morning in which the head of the Pensions Board is charged with "concealment," and to ask the right hon. leader of the Government if any steps have been taken to have the charges thoroughly investigated?


Hon. H. S. BELAND (Minister of Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment) :: I read this morning a statement published in one of the local newspapers in connection with the action of the Pensions Board with reference to certain applications for pensions. I asked the chairman of the board to supply me with a memorandum regarding the matter; I hold it in my hand, and with your permission, Mr. Speaker, I shall read it to the House. I may say that in the article referred to it was stated that this action of the Board of Pension Commissioners had relation to recent months. This is not a correct statement of the facts, as the House will see from the memorandum. The memorandum reads:
The minute made by the Board of Pension Commissioners under date of 29th September, 1921, was a statement in abbreviated form for the use of the board's medical advisors at headquarters.

The medical advisors in question were perfectly familiar with the points under discussion, and! the memorandum merely indicated and confirmed what had always been the interpretation of the policy of the board.
The board has always interpreted the intention of section 25 (3) of the act to mean that if an ex-member of the forces reached an actual theatre of war, and was found on discharge to have a physical condition which pre-existed enlistment, and which had progressed in any way on service, whether affected by service in any way or not-a simple progression having taken place on service-that although it were recognized that the condition must have preceded enlistment, and further recognized that in the ordinary course of events, in a sheltered existence, the condition would have progressed, no weight was to be given to such information, but the man would be pensionable, not only for the amount of progression, but for the total amount of the disability present.
Section 25 (3) of the act therefore would modify, to the extent outlined above, the qualifications for pension of any ex-member of the forces as defined by section (11) of the act. It was found, however, that there was a very occasional and rare case where a condition on discharge was found to exist and where it was established to the satisfaction of all concerned that there had been no progression of any kind on service; no cause or effect even remotely connected in any way with service; a condition present previous to enlistment, unchanged by, or on service. The further question then arose as to whether or not basically such a ease would be pensionable if there had been service in an actual theatre of war. The Board interpreted the act to mean that section 24 (3) in such a case would be modified by section fll) and that there must be a service connection in some way, shape or form, before there wou d be pension-ability.
The explanation of the Board in its Interpretation is very plain to the effect that if there has been any progression of a condition on service, if the condition is shown to be in any way worse on discharge than on admission, the pensioner, if he reached an actual theatre of war, must be considered, under Section 25 (3) of the act, to be pensionable for the whole extent of such disability. Section 2b (3) of the act states plainly that-"No deduction shall be made from the pension of any member of the
forces	on account of any disability
or disabling condition which existed In him previous to the time at which he became a member of the forces...." This has always been interpreted by the board to mean that before section 25 (3) of the act becomes applicable there must be presumed to be grounds for pension ; and section 25 (3) taken in conjunction with section (11) of the act, does not mean that an ex-member of the forces having served in an actual theatre of war must be pensioned for a disability, unless It can be shown that there has been an increase In the disabling condition on service.
It was pointed out to the board by Its medical advisors that those cases would be very rare where disability existed after service in an actual theatre of war, and where there would be, as a medical fact, no progression In the disabling condition. In this opinion, as advanced by its medical advisors, the board fully concurred.
An interpretation of the act which would permit of pensions being granted in cases where

Pensions Board
there was no claim on the part of any one that service had in any way affected the condition, or that there had been progression on service ; or, in other words, that the man entered the service and left it in exactly the same condition, would be to change entirely the principle upon which pensions are granted, and would be contrary to the statutes.
This is the memorandum which was handed to me by the Chairman of the Board of Pension Commissioners. A memorandum setting forth the interpretation of the act was placed in the hands of the medical advisers of the board on the 29th of September, 1921, and' has not since been changed in any way.


Levi William Humphrey: May I repeat my question and ask if it is the intention of the minister to have a full investigation of these charges?


Henri Sévérin Béland: It is my intention to investigate further as to whether the regulations have been carried out according to that interpretation in all cases.


Hon. R. J. MANION (Fort William and Rainy River):: In connection with the statement which the minister has just made, there certainly does seem to be an impression-I have obtained it myself both through letters and statements in the press [DOT]-that certain changes have been made by the Board of Pension Commissioners making the regulations more strict. Is the minister in a position to make a statement in regard to that impression, which, judging from the number of letters I receive from soldiers in various parts of the country and from what I see in the press, seems to be pretty widespread.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I am not in a position to make any statement in that regard. The board, I understand, considers a large number of cases every day which, of course, are never brought to the attention of the minister. I myself receive a number of- shall I say,-complaints from pensioners who claim that their pensions should not have been decreased or should have been increased, and in some cases that they should not have been cut off. In all such cases I have the file brought before me and go through it. Occasionally I discuss the case with the chairman of the board himself, and I may say that in most cases I have been able to give satisfaction to the complainant. The great majority of the cases which are submitted to the board never come before the minister. As the House is well aware, the Board of Pension Commissioners is a tribunal whose decisions are final.
Mr. MAN10N: I was not speaking of individual cases so much as of the general impression, which perhaps the minister himself has gained from the press, to the effect I stated. Rightly or wrongly many soldiers have the impression that the regulations or the rules regarding pensions have been made more strict. As the board is practically an independent body, and the minister the intermediary between the board and this House, would it not be possible for the board to have made the regulations more severe without the minister being aware of it?


Henri Sévérin Béland: If the board has interpreted the provisions in any narrower way recently, it has certainly not been in consequence of any instructions or suggestions that have been made by myself. I have never attempted to interfere with the work of the board. Occasionally I have asked the board to reopen and reconsider a case, with a view to using all their discretionary powers in favour of the applicant.


Robert James Manion: I did not mean to suggest that the minister had interfered in any way. I was just giving him the impression that I have received from a number of letters and from statements in the press. I might say that personally I have had a good deal of satisfaction in cases I have taken up with the board, particularly recently.


Mr. L. H. MARTELL (Hants):: I should like to ask the minister whether his department has under consideration the advisability of amending that section of the act which sets a limitation on the time within which application for a pension may be considered. I have a case in my con-constituency of a young man who was killed overseas. During the time he was overseas his mother was receiving separation allowance and assigned pay, and she managed to save something from that, and for some three years she did not deem it necessary to make application for a pension. She was absolutely ignorant of the fact that the law provided a limitation. I believe the provision is that the application must be made within three years from the death of the person on whose account a pension is requested.


Mr. SPEAKER:: This whole discussion is out of order. The subject, I know, is a very important one, but I thought when the memorandum had been read by the minister the matter would rest there for

Pensions Board

the -time being. Hon. members are naturally anxious to know of any new regulations that may have been passed by the board, but I think they should defer their questions until the minister's estimates are before the House. It is certainly stretching a point to allow questions of this nature at this stage. I am in the hands of the House, however, but we shall never pass on to the Orders of the Day, judging by my own experience in the House, if individual cases are to be brought up one after another. Perhaps the minister would state that at a later stage hon. members will have fully opportunity to bring up cases in which they are interested.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I entirely agree with your suggestion, Mr. Speaker. At a later stage, when the Pension Act is being amended, all these questions would be in order. Perhaps, however, you would allow the hon. member for Hants, (Mr. Martell) to put his question now.


Mr. CALDWELL:: I would point out that there is a report to be brought in by the Pensions Committee that may possibly cover some of these points, and I think the discussion might very well be deferred until that report is before the House. I think possibly it would be out of order to answer questions along this line until that report has been presented.


CIVIL SERVICE BONUS
[Stage Direction]
On the Orders of the Day:
Hon. H. H. STEVENS (Vancouver Centre):: I should like to ask the Prime Minister a brief question regarding the payment of bonus to the civil servants. I hold in my hand a most pathetic letter from the wife of a civil servant who is drawing $64 a month. This man has a family of several small children, and has had no bonus for two months. Would the Prime Minister state when the bonus will be paid under the proposals which he made to the House some time ago?


Right Hon. W. L. MACKENZIE KING (Prime Minister) :: The bonus proposals will come before the House when the Supplementary Estimates are brought in, and I hope we shall make sufficient progress to be able to bring them in next week.



BUSINESS OF THE HOUSE

[Stage Direction]
On the Orders of the Day:
Arthur Meighen: I suppose we are now

within a couple of weeks of the end of the session. It is certainly time the Government had stated to Parliament its full programme for the session. Indeed, it is past the usual time. I should like to ask the Prime Minister what further legislation the Government have, and to express the hope that the indications, only too pronounced in to-day's Order Paper, that the end of the session is to be the only pregnant part of the session, will not be too closely lived up to.


William Lyon Mackenzie King: I think I shall be able to tell my right hon. friend in a day or two what further legislation the Government intends to bring down. I can promise that it will not be a very elaborate programme.



VANCOUVER HARBOUR

[Stage Direction]
On the motion of Hon. Ernest Lapointe (Minister of Marine and Fisheries) for the third reading of Bill No. 106, to amend the Vancouver Harbour Commissioners' Act.
Henry Herbert Stevens: With the indulgence of the House I should like to ask one question. The Board of Trade have certain rights in regard to port wardens. Will the new act interfere in any way with those rights?


Mr. LAPOINTE:: No.


Henry Herbert Stevens: That is all I am concerned about.


Ernest Lapointe: The only change ithat the two officers referred to in the bill will be under the control of the department.
Motion agreed to and bill read the third time.



FISHERIES ACT, 1914, AMENDMENT

[Stage Direction]
House again in Committee on Bill No. 70 to amend the Fisheries Act, 1914, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
On Section 2-Burden of proof.
Ernest Lapointe: When this bill was
before the committee at the previous sitting, clause 1 was adopted, but there was some objection to clause 2 as being too drastic in placing the burden of proof upon the accused party, and my hon. friend from Hants (Mr. Martell), following the objection of my hon. friend from St. John city (Mr. Baxter), moved that the clause be struck out. Some discussion took place, and finally I agreed to re-draught the clause so as to meet the objections. I understand that my hon. friend from

Canada Temperance Act
Hants agrees to the new clause as I will now propose it:
Failure to produce a license Issued pursuant to the provisions of the Fisheries Act, or any regulation made thereunder, shall be deemed prima facie evidence of Intent or knowledge when intent or knowledge is neceslsary to constitute an offence under this section.
Section as amended agreed to.
Bill reported, read the third time, and passed.



CANADA TEMPERANCE ACT AMENDMENT

[Stage Direction]
On motion of Hon. D. D. McKenzie (Solicitor General) Bill No. 132 to amend the Canada Temperance Act was read the second time and the House went into Committee thereon, Mr. 'Gordon in the Chair.
On Section 2-Upon receipt of an Order of Lieutenant-Governor in Council, the Governor in Council may issue proclamation.
Mr. GUTHRIE:: I have just read over
this section and I assume that it is intended to apply to those provinces where export houses are at present maintained under Dominion license. I do not think there are any export houses or bonded warehouses in the province of Ontario, but there are such in some of the western provinces-I think in the province of Saskatchewan, and perhaps in the province of British Columbia, too. This section in its present form provides that on receipt of a certified copy of an Order in Council from the Lieutenant-Governor of a province the Government of Canada may pass an Order in Council fonbidding the further export from that province, or from Canada, of liquor now stored in bonded warehouses. I understand that in some of these bonded warehouses they have considerable stocks. If the section passes as it is now, confiscation of these stocks might result. I do not suppose it is the intention of the Government, or of the draughtsman of the bill, that liquor in any sense should be confiscated. What I would suggest is, that a reasonable time be given to the owners of liquor now in bonded warehouses for the disposal of their stocks-three months, or six months, or twelve months, whatever time the committee might think reasonable. I do not think it would be wise to pass the clause as it is now; it would be practically confiscation of property which is leg-
190J	_	i ! j* :3 (
ally held by the present licensees in bonded warehouses under the authority of this Government.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: The real cause for the putting forward of this section, which came particularly from the province of Saskatchewan, is that a great deal of illegitimate selling and disposing of liquors is being done in some provinces because of the existence of warehouses where liquor is being kept. It has never been submitted to me, nor to any member of the Government that I am aware of, that any person in any province-at least, in the province of Saskatchewan-has any license for a bonded warehouse, or has a legally established warehouse, in which to keep liquor for the purpose of traffic. If there are such establishments, it has not been brought to my notice, except in a general way, such as the observations of the hon. member from South Wellington (Mr. Guthrie). If the hon. member, or any other hon. member, will satisfy this committee-he need not satisfy me more than anybody else-that the case which has been put forward is true, I would certainly not take any step that would confiscate any person's property. But, so far I am not aware, that neither the hon. member from South Wellington, or any other member of this House, has such definite information. However, the conditions in any province, with regard to this or any other matter, are better known to the members of the local government than to the members of the Government of Canada. This act cannot come into force in any province, it cannot have any effect, until the local government of the particular province in which it is asked for passes an Order in Council bringing it into force. If there is, in any province, a lawfully conducted business, and if the persons engaged in it have a right to carry it on, though it may be an unpopular business, if these people came before the government of that province, and said, You have the power under a Dominion statute to call in force in this province a law that will confiscate my property and cause me to lose a large amount of money; I am asking you not to put that law in force in this province until I have an opportunity of disposing of that property; if you do otherwise, you are doing a great wrong, and forfeiting a great deal of that property ",-it strikes me the premier, and government of that province, would
Canada Temperance Act

very properly say, "Very good, we shall not do anything that will affect your property until you have an opportunity of disposing of it, providing you have it legally in stock Now, if there is to be leniency of that kind shown, it is just as much the power of one government as of the other. All this parliament is doing is passing a law, and making it optional for any province to put it in force. That kind of legislation in regard to liquor has been gaining ground for the last ten years. Practically, nothing has been done in this House in regard to intoxicating liquor for a number of years anyhow unless it is first approved by the province. In this particular instance, the provinces are asking for ancillary legislation, or legislation to help to carry into effect local laws which they have themselves enacted. All we have done is to say " You can
4 p.m. bring this law into force, if you like, but you need not bring it into force unless it is the will of the province to do it. I am afraid I will be submitting this House to a great deal of criticism, if we recognize as legitimate, and protect by the voice of this parliament, business and property that is not held in possession, or owned according to the law of the province.


Mr. JACOBS:: Where do they get the power to do it, if it is done legally?


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: I am satisfied that for the last year and a half no person, either in Nova Scotia, New Brunswick, Ontario, or Saskatchewan or Alberta, could import any intoxicating liquor legally, nor could they manufacture it legally. That provision is to be found in part IV. of the Canada Temperance Act. If I am asked to-day in this House by what right are you going to put a proviso in the act to protect people in Alberta or Saskatchewan who have those houses in which they hold liquor for import?-by what law do they get it in, or by what law are they holding it?-I cannot give any answer. If there is any hon. member who knows there is such a law, and who knows it is legitimate property and legitimate trade, he has the right, the power, and the privilege of presenting that authority to the House. I am unfortunate enough not to know there is any such law, and I am unfortunate enough not to know that there is, in that province, such legal business, recognized in Saskatchewan, and until it is brought home to me that legal business is affected, I do not feel called

upon to ask this i'cii iiuu*ctiL Oi to legalize, to protect, or safeguard, any business, however popular it might be under certain circumstances, carried on in this country. If anybody in the House will move such an amendment, I will certainly as representing the Government, not accept it. If it is the voice of this House that such an amendment is to be made to the Bill, I will not oppose it, but I assure hon. members I am not going to accept it, nor am I going to propose it myself as at present informed.	[DOT]


Mr. MOTHERWELL:: Explaining the liquor business in Saskatchewan seems to be as difficult as explaining the wheat board. I may say that a situation grew up in Saskatchewan* as a result of the interim of four months between the vote taken on the referendum in November, 1920, and the enacting of the law. During that time a large number of export warehouses were established in Saskatchewan, containing from one to ten carloads of liquor. There was nothing illegal about it. They took advantage of the long period between the time the will of the people was expressed at the poll and the putting of the law into force. I do not know how many millions worth of property was stowed away during those four months. I know there were 59 export liquor houses-not bonded warehouses; the hon. member from South Wellington is mistaken in regard to that. None of these houses is either licensed or bonded; they are quite distinct from bonded warehouses; they are there, and the province cannot get rid of them. In 1917 the province of Saskatchewan passed an Act-and so did the province of Alberta-attempting to get rid of the export houses, and failed, because the Act was declared by the court to be ultra vires. The desire out there, no matter how foolish it may appear down here, is to get rid of the liquor in that province. We want to be dry, and we have not been dry largely because of the existence of these export houses. In order to carry out the will of the people, in so far as provincial law is ineffectual for the purpose, it is proposed1 to pass this supplementary legislation. The whole question is, how long shall we give these export houses to get rid of their wares? It is true that they got these supplies in legally in the first instance, but they have no real right to keep them in the province now. Now, 1 am not an authority on the question as to how long it takes to drink a million dollars' worth of liquor, which I understand

Canada Temperance Act
is the estimated quantity in Saskatchewan. There was several million dollars' worth there, but it has all been consumed, presumably outside the province.


Samuel William Jacobs: Are they not complaining about the dry season in Saskatchewan?


William Richard Motherwell: Yes, but that is a different sort of dryness. Let me say that this is no joking matter in Saskatchewan, or in Alberta either. Like the Solicitor General (Mr. McKenzie), I have no desire whatever, and I do not think anybody has, to confiscate the property of any one whether it be liquor or anything else. We want to be fair to these men. They put one over on the province in getting the liquor in in the first place, although the law did not forbid them to do so; and I have no doubt that they reaped a substantial harvest thereby. Well, if they should happen to lose a little they must take the chance. Mind you, I do not take the ground that I want them to lose anything; I simply want them to get out, and that is why I desire to see the legislation go through. If it appeals to the committee, as I think it will, as a fair proposition that the will of the people out there be given expression to, then there should be no trouble about the matter. We do the same thing in the case of British Columbia or any other wet province. British Columbia wants to handle wet goods and we are facilitating the people there in carrying out their wishes. But in Saskatchewan and Alberta-at least I can speak for my own province-the people want the place to be dry and they feel that their wish in this regard cannot be carried out so long as these export houses remain there. I have suggested that these houses should be given three months to get rid of their liquor. As I say, they are presumably not doing an illegal business; they got the liquor in legally, and are shipping it out legally. But liquor leaks out, and it is impossible to observe the will of the people with these institutions carrying on business in this way. I have suggested three months to my colleague, but he apparently does not favour that suggestion at all, because he feels that these houses are there illegally. At any rate, that is how I interpret his attitude. My hon. friend to my right, on the other hand, thinks that they are there legally, and I am disposed to agree with him. And we cannot get rid of them because of our provincial
limitations; only this Parliament can put them out. If a longer period than three months is requested in which to dispose of the liquor without risk of loss, then I take the ground that the law should be changed with regard to the time limit between votes. So far as I can recall- I have not had time to look into the law, but I think I am right-when we voted on the matter in November, 1920, we did so on the understanding that another vote could not be taken for three years; in other words, the will of the people could not be consulted again until the law had been given a fair trial. The intent of legislative bodies when they put a law on the statute book is that it shall be given a fair trial. That period of three years between votes was regarded as a fair term. One year and four months has passed of that period, but the law has not had what can be regarded as a fair trial simply because of the existence of these export houses and, as a matter of fact, the dry sentiment of this province has been prejudicially affected by the operation of this business. If you allow these houses eight months, say, in which to get rid of their liquor, it will 'be eight months added to the year and four months that has passed in which the law has had but a partial and unsatisfactory trial, that is to say, two years of the three, which was the period of trial, will have passed without affording anything like a proper test. I might put it this way: whatever time we allow these houses to get rid of their liquor will be added to the wet era, and correspondingly subtracted from the period of trial. My proposal is that if you extend the three months I have suggested to six months you should correspondingly extend the period between votes. As a matter of fact, there is no real prohibition in these provinces at all. The present condition is perhaps in some respects worse than legalized traffic. I am not by any means suggesting that there should be legalized traffic, but I say that the present state of things in some respects is worse than that, because there are a great many objectionable features in connection with it. I repeat, we do not want to confiscate property or do anything that is not fair, but we do want to carry out the people's wishes. The law applies to the other provinces as well, and whenever they so desire they can take advantage of it. The province of Saskatchewan has already sent down to my colleague two strongly worded
Canada Temperance Act

petitions from the legislature during the past couple of sessions asking that the present condition in Saskatchewan be terminated. They have expressed themselves in a pronounced way on the matter.


Samuel William Jacobs: The question before the committee is, shall we confiscate certain property which is now in Saskatchewan, or shall we not? I understand that the question has particular reference to that province. The Solicitor-General (Mr. McKenzie) declares that he is not in favour of making any amendment to this section, while the Minister of Agriculture (Mr. Motherwell), who comes from that province and probably knows something about the benefits of a little liquor there, suggests a period of three months in which the people who have this property stored in their warehouses shall get rid of it. The Solicitor-General has told us that this liquor is illegally in the province of Saskatchewan. I rather fancy that he did not look into the legal aspect of the case with the same care which he usually exercises when drafting bills that present -some legal difficulties. This liquor is legally in the province of Saskatchewan; it came there legally. If it is not there legally, then, of course, the authorities should forthwith confiscate it. How is it that the Department of Customs has not confiscated these goods if they are illegally in Saskatchewan? They are there legally, and all that is asked now is that a reasonable time be given these people to get their goods out of the province. They are engaged in a traffic which, although it may be unpopular, is none the less legal. It must be borne in mind that the sale of spirituous liquor in the western hemisphere is somewhat restricted at present, in fact there is practically no market for it. A small quantity of these goods might possibly be sold in Mexico or the West Indies, but a million dollars' worth -and I am told that is the quantity they have there-cannot be -sold in Europe, which is about the only market left, within a period of three months, for it takes a considerable time to dispose of such a large quantity. Therefore these people ask-and I think it is a reasonable request-that they should have a sufficient period of time within which to dispose of their property. I think that under the circumstances six months is not an unreasonable time to be given for the disposal of goods which cannot be offered for sale on the local market. If you fix a shorter [ Mr. Motherwell. ]
time, say three months, it is practically equivalent to confiscation, and I am sure it is not the desire of this Parliament to take such harsh measures. In view of all the circumstances I am in favour of giving these people a reasonable time within which to dispose of their property, and therefore I beg leave to move, seconded by the hon. member for St. Antoine (Mr. Mitchell):
That at the end of section 157 there be added the following proviso: "Providing that such order-in-council shall n-ot be passed prior to the 1st day of January, 1923 ''


Sir HENRY DRAYTON:: You say that this business is now carried on legally. What is the practice followed? What licenses are granted and what are the restrictions on export business?


Samuel William Jacobs: I am not familiar with
the law of Saskatchewan, but the business would be legal even if the goods were merely kept in warehouses, and I fancy, that before this law comes into force the goods can be legally exported from the province. This section declares that " on and after the Lieutenant Governor in Council notifies the Secretary of State, the goods cannot be exported." Consequently there is nothing for these owners to do but to destroy their property, and it is for the purpose of enabling them to get it out of the province before prohibition against exportation is put into effect that I am moving this amendment.
Mr. LEW'IS: I concur in the judgment of the Solicitor General. I think that the people of Saskatchewan themselves have the right to say whether there shall be an extended time of three months or otherwise, for they are in a better position to know what time is required to get rid of these liquors than hon. members down here. For that reason I am not in favour of the amendment. We are sufficiently familiar with the men who control the liquor stores in Saskatchewan to suspect that these liquors did not come into the province in a very legitimate manner. It did not take them very long to bring in their goods when they knew that Saskatchewan was against importation; and it does seem to me that when Saskatchewan has voted definitely against the sale of liquor within the province, it cannot be said that these liquors are there legitimately ; they1 were forced upon the province against the expressed will of the electorate. Therefore, I think the bill should

be passed without any amendment whatever. The government of Saskatchewan know the local conditions thoroughly, and they also know the men who own these liquor stores, and if the members of that government feel it is essential to grant the owners a three months' extension of time to get rid of their property, well and good, but in view of the expressed will of the people of the province the quicker we get rid of this menace the better. We in Saskatchewan do not believe that it is a legitimate business, we do not believe that those who engage in it have a right to bring their goods into the province against the expressed will of the people. For that reason I am heartily in favour of the bill being passed without amendment, leaving it to the provincial authorities who know the whole situation to grant any extension of time that may be necessary to enable the owners to get rid of this stuff that is destroying the moral fibre of our life.


Mr. MILLAR:: I think this committee is wasting a lot of sympathy on the men who are engaged in this export liquor business. I am confident that if hon. members had an opportunity of becoming acquainted with the methods pursued by these liquor exporters they would not spend five minutes sympathizing with them. As the Minister of Agriculture has said, these people took advantage of the opportunity they had before the new law came into force to stock up. They are not exporting to Europe now, as has been suggested, but they are supplying bootleggers in the province and conveying the liquor across the international boundary line into the United States Now', every bottle of liquor carried across the line is carried across in defiance of the law. Recently I took a clipping from an American newspaper severely criticizing the Canadian Government for allowing the traffic to go on. I have not the clipping at hand, in fact I lent it to the Prime Minister to peruse. This is the way the business is carried on. Fast motor cars are loaded with liquor in the middle of the night, and the men engaged in this business make for the international boundary line, followed perhaps by a police automobile. The men in both cars are well armed, and in many cases a fight takes place on the road. Now, the people in the southern part of the province when they are out driving do not enjoy the prospect of being shot in the course of one of these running fights.
Canada Temperance Act


Samuel William Jacobs: Is the hon. gentleman in favour of having these goods confiscated and destroyed by the government of Saskatchewan?


John Millar: I am coming to that in a minute. The men who carry liquor to the United States in this way have boasted again and again that in one trip they make enough money to buy an expensive automobile such as a McLaughlin. Now, if they have been making that profit for about two years, I do not think we need worry very much about whether this liquor is confiscated or not. Those men do not want time to sell their goods in Europe. If they knew that in three months' time the law was going to be changed, they would get rid of this liquor very quickly. They have plenty of associates in the business, and with few exceptions they are a bad bunch. I have no hesitation in making that statement; it can be backed up by the men who live in the southern part of the province. I have been down there and have been told by the people: "This is the road on which the bootleggers carry on their traffic during the night; they pass our very doors." The business is carried on by the use of the fastest automobiles that can be got. A short time ago an automobile started from one of these export liquor houses and some twelve miles out the police stopped them and took charge of the liquor; yet under the law nothing could be done. I would like to read to you an extract from some remarks made by Chief Justice Brown when one of these cases was tried before him. I suggest that those hon. members who have sympathy for this people should listen to this:
We have our own province in which there exists a prohibitory law and likewise we see liquor imported from our own province into neighbouring provinces, and we sit down practically helpless, doing nothing and apparently not wanting to do anything to help them enforce that law. The matter it seems to me could be largely remedied by a simple piece of legislation on the part of the Parliament of Canada, making it illegal to export liquor or sell liquor for export to any country or any province where prohibition is in force. As I have already indicated I cannot believe that the people of Canada generally realize the demoralizing condition of affairs that exists; otherwise, it seems to me the Parliament of Canada would have before this passed legislation to the effect I have already suggested. We can only hope that the matter of our responsibility in this matter and the true condition of affairs may be more fully realized by our people generally and if_ it is, then it seems to me we will get the legislation that is necessary to remedy the situation. Not only has this court been largely oocupied
Canada Temperance Act

with cases that have arisen as a result of this traffic, but the same has characterized all the courts that have been held in the southern part of this province during the last few years. It is a condition of affairs that certainly should not exist, and it seems to me fit and proper that I should call attention to the matter in this way at this particular time.
This is not a matter of prohibition or otherwise; it is a case of complying with the expressed wish of the province to be freed from this traffic. I can scarcely conceive of the people of Canada wishing to continue to force this sort of thing on the province of Saskatchewan when the people there have expressed themselves as they have. I entirely concur in the view of the Solicitor General: the people of Saskatchewan know the conditions even better than we in this House do; they know just about how much consideration should, be extended to those affected by any change and I cannot conceive of their doing any injustice in that connection. In fact, they can say how long a time the persons affected shall have within which to dispose of his liquor. Personally I think six months is too long; I think the Solicitor General's view is the correct one.


Henry Lumley Drayton: This legislation seems to be proceeding upon proper lines. In fact, it conforms to the policy of the late government, which was to give effect to the wishes of the different communities which had adopted laws dealing with this liquor question. We always held ourselves as desirous of implementing the legislation on the one hand and the desires on the other of the provincial governments. So far as this particular matter is concerned, if my recollection is correct the position taken by the Customs Department under the former government-and still maintained, I believe, under the present Administration-is that no bonded warehouse licences should be issued in any of the provinces except with the consent of the local administration. It seems to me that, carrying out the policy of implementing provincial legislation and the provincial desire wherever possible, it is the duty of this House to take the action proposed on this occasion. Now, we have to bear in mind the distinction between a business which may be inherently vicious and one which may simply have developed into the practice of rum-running, and the like. If the whole of this business is illegal; if the storing of liquor in these warehouses is against the law, why is section 163 drafted as it is in the bill? That is the section which is the prohibitory provision. It says: 
Subject to the provisions of subsection two of this section, and notwithstanding the provisions of this or any other act to the contrary, no person shall Import, send, take or transport into any province in which the prohibitions of this subsection are in force any intoxicating liquor.
But I find an exception, as follows:
The importation of intoxicating liquor into a province by a person engaged in and carrying on the business of exporting intoxicating liquor from that province, where the intoxicating liquor so imported is imported solely for the purpose of his export business and while kept by him in the province, is kept in a liquor warehouse which conforms in all respects to the requirements of the law governing such warehouses, and when sold or disposed of by him is actually exported from that province:


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: I may point out that the first part of this bill is an amendment of Part IV of the Canada Temperance Act, passed in 1919. The section to which my hon. friend refers may be regarded as new legislation; it has no connection with the section we are considering. It is an amendment of Part V.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Then my hon. friend is now legalizing, under Part V, that business which he had previously looked upon as illegal.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: Part V has reference to provinces which have themselves undertaken the whole of the business of handling the liquor, as in the case of British Columbia and Quebec.


Mr. MITCHELL:: I am inclined to agree with the ex-Minister of Finance that in any part of the Dominion where there is a desire to get rid of the liquor business, it should be within, entirely within, the jurisdiction of the province or section, as the case may be, to deal with the matter. Under the old Canada Temperance Act, as I understood it, any province or county could, by a vote, put that act into force. Under the old act, however, importation was allowed into all the provinces, notwithstanding the fact that the Canada Temperance Act was in force. I know that in the city of Quebec the Canada Temperance Act was in force, and in the rest of the province, with two exceptions, we had the Quebec Prohibition Act, under the provisions of which there could be no importation into any part of the province. But it was held that there could be importation into the city of Quebec under the provisions of the Canada Temperance Act. Subsequently the Doherty Act was passed, which was an endeavour to extend to the provinces the right to prohibit importation. But it was

Canada Temperance Act
found, I believe, that it did not go that far -and, so far as that is concerned, the act was held to be unconstitutional. If I understand this legislation correctly, it is an endeavour to go a step further and to give to the provinces exactly what they want. 1 am entirely in accord with that. But under the provisions of the act as it has existed these people who do have stocks on hand had them there legally, and it is for this House to decide whether, if citizens holding stock there legally, no matter what they may have been doing with them heretofore-and the stocks held have been stated to be worth a million dollars-we should legislate here to-day and say that ipso facto on the passing of the Order in Council, all that merchandise shall be destroyed without warning. This is a question that has often been debated; it has been debated in England and almost every other country in the world, and I do not think a case can be found where the government of a country confiscated the goods of its citizens without giving them some time to dispose of the stocks on hand. If I have a suggestion to make to the mover, it would be that the government of Saskatchewan be authorized to pass their Order in Council at once, and that once the Order in Council is passed these people be given time-the six months that is spoken of-to ship their goods out. The goods will then remain in bond under the control of the government, and they cannot be bootlegged throughout the province, whereas if you leave these stocks there and give them this six months without passing the Order in Council, there will be a danger of spreading the stocks throughout the province in the meantime. If you allow the province to pass their Order in Council immediately, and give these people six months to dispose of their goods before confiscating, that would seem to me to be much more fair, and in accord with precedent in every country that I ever heard of.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Just one further thought arising out of what my hon. friend has said: I do not think any one of us wants to do anything we ought not to do. I think we are all anxious to see that the wishes expressed by the province of Saskatchewan be carried out. Why cannot this act be passed just as it is without doing the slightest degree of harm? In the first instance, the local government have to act. They have a right to pass their Order in Council and to fix their day. In the second instance, their act by itself is
nothing, as I read this section, until this Government gives effect to that Order in Council.


Walter George Mitchell: If I may interrupt
the hon. gentleman, I do not think he has quite understood the section. If we pass the act as it is, the local government would have absolutely no power to give the delay to which he refers. Otherwise, I would not have a word to say. But neither the local government, nor this Government without the necessary authority, could give one minute's delay.


Henry Lumley Drayton: I would point out that this is the usual section, clothed in the ordinary language, giving jurisdiction to a government to act by Order in Council. We know the difficulties which always attend the administration of government, and I venture to say that if this act goes through just as it is, it will be some little time before it is put into final effect. The section reads:
Upon receipt by the Secretary of State of Canada of a duly certified copy of an order in council passed by the Lieutenant-Governor in Council of any province in which the importation of intoxicating liquors into the province has been prohibited under this part, and in which such prohibition is still in force, requesting that the keeping of intoxicating liquor in such province for export and the exportation of intoxicating liquor therefrom by persons other than brewers and distillers duly licensed by the Government of Canada, be forbidden-
Forbidden as and from when? Surely there is an effective date to be given in that Order in Council, and after that first Order in Council is passed, it is not effective unti the Governor in Council by Order in Council declares-it says "may", not "shall"- that such prohibition shall come into force in such province on a day to be named in such order. It does not seem to me that the respective governments will know very much more, with the whole facts of the case before them, than this House can.


Mr. SHAW:: I thoroughly agree with
the sentiments that have been expressed by many hon. members who have spoken. I do think the province should have the say as to the time when these provisions are to come into effect. I would recommend to the minister that the wording be changed slightly to read something as follows:
-requesting that the keeping o'f intoxicating liquor in such province for export and the exportation of intoxicating liquor therefrom by persons other than brewers and distillers duly licensed by the Government of Canada be forbidden on and after a date to be named, and
Canada Temperance Act

the Governor in Council may by Order in Council declare that such prohibition shall come into force in such province on the day fixed by the Order in Council of the executive of the provincial government.


William Richard Motherwell: The word "order" in that section surely refers to the federal order rather than to the provincial. Whenever a term like that is used, it always refers to the one nearest it.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: That is the difficulty that
I see.


William Richard Motherwell: One of them is
the Governor in Council, and the other is the Lieutenant-Governor in Council.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: That is quite right, as I
understand it. The word "order" last mentioned in the paragraph refers to the order of the Governor in Council, not of the Lieutenant-Governor in Council.


William Richard Motherwell: That is right.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: My suggestion is that the Lieutenant-Governor in Council not only ask that the exportation he forbidden, but also ask that it be forbidden as of a particular date, and that that date be adopted by the Governor in Council in the Order in Council which they propose. It may be that that is the intention of this act but on a casual reading I would say that it is not. It does seem to me that the provincial government should be the best judge as to when the Order in Council shall become effective.
There has been some misapprehension, I think, in connection with the operation of this particular amendment. The press have, to some extent, at least, circulated the idea that it is applicable only to the province of Saskatchewan. I may say that that has caused some concern in the province of Alberta, for I have received a telegram from the Attorney General of that province in which he requests that similar legislation be passed for the province of Alberta. He also points out in his telegram :
The Alberta cabinet meeting to-day-
That is yesterday.

strongly urge this legislation be applied to the province of Alberta, as our greatest difficulty under Liquor Act results from the operation of liquor export houses.
Now we are anxious to give the province the fullest possible control in order that the existing laws may be made watertight, and may be effectively enforced. The greatest difficulty in the way of doing that

has been tne operations of these liquor exporting houses. I have only been able to consider casually the purposes of the bill, and I would like to receive an assurance from the Solicitor General that it contains nothing that would limit its operation to the province of Saskatchewan.


Walter George Mitchell: It applies to all the provinces.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: I wanted an assurance from the Solicitor General that it applies also to the province of Alberta, if other provinces are going to get the benefit of it.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: That is the way I understand it.


Mr. WOODS:: I want to express my approval of the bill, especially since we have been assured it covers all the provinces of the Dominion. The province of Ontario has gone to its limit in regard to temperance legislation; if not, it is endeavouring to do so. Any federal law which would strengthen its hands and enable it to fully carry out and enforce the provisions of the Ontario Temperance Act will be heartily received throughout the province. We are all aware of the bootlegging and the disorderly conduct which has occurred in western Ontario in the past, and especially the transportation of liquor from that part of this country to the United States. Any legislation prohibiting the transportation of liquor other than by steam railway or water will undoubtedly strengthen the hands of Ontario in its endeavours to put an end to that traffic. It will stop the carriage of liquors by motor vehicles along the public highways of the province, and will be of the utmost importance in strengthening the hands of the provincial authorities in their endeavours to carry out the provincial legislation to the fullest extent.


Mr. BLACK (Yukon):: It is quite evident that the bill is intended in its application to prohibition provinces to increase the power of the local authorities so as to give effect to prohibitive legislation; and in provinces where the provincial governments are dealing in liquor to give them a further monopoly of the liquor business. Now it has been stated in the province of British Columbia, for instance by the Attorney General of the province, that the provincial authorities were unable to administer the local liquor law satisfactorily because of the operations of export houses, and that until he gets co-operation in the way of federal legislation he cannot im-

Canada Temperance Act
prove his administration of the provincial liquor law. I would ask the Solicitor General if the views and requests of the Attorney General of British Columbia have been fully met in the present bill?


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: When this bill was first drafted its general nature and applications had reference to British Columbia because the request for federal legislation came from there. The bill was drafted by the Attorney General of British Columbia with some assistance, I think, from the Department of Justice; I have every reason to believe that as it stands to-day it grants all that was asked for by the province of British Columbia through its Attorney General.


Mr. MORRISON:: My constituency is in the southern part of Saskatchewan and there are several export houses established there, one of them being located in a horse livery barn only about twenty-five miles from the international boundary line. Just imagine, Mr. Speaker, an export house keeping its liquor in a horse livery barn! Four, five or half a dozen high-powered cars are used for the carriage of liquor across the boundary line, and these cars travel at the rate of about forty or fifty miles an hour on their nefarious mission. I consider these operations are a disgrace to any Canadian province. People in Saskatchewan have protested against such proceedings, and have expressed their wishes to see them abolished, but we find that the liquor interests are strong fighters; they have put up a fight worthy of a better cause, and when we nail them on one point they have recourse to some other. My hon. friend from St. Antoine (Mr. Mitchell) says it is not fair, in a sense, to close these liquor houses out in three months. I contend that the liquor interests have established these export houses to frustrate the laws of Saskatchewan, and they break not only the Canadian law but the law of the country to the south of us. While I do not want to be harsh or unreasonable in this matter, yet I think that men who have been deliberately and persistently frustrating the law cannot now claim very much leniency. In the past they have taken advantage of the leniency of the law right along. We do not want to confiscate their property, but we do want to place the responsibility for this traffic where it belongs. The provincial authorities have been saying that they have gone to the limit and have done
all they could, and that it is now up to the federal authorities to act. In Saskatchewan we want to see this bill go through as it stands so that the wishes of the province with respect to prohibition of the liquor traffic may be carried out.


Walter George Mitchell: When this bill was originally drafted it was prepared by the authorities for the province of British Columbia and the province of Quebec, and was not intended at all to apply to any of the provinces that have voted dry. It was only after the bill was introduced, or after it began to be studied by the officers of the Crown, that its provisions were extended to the dry provinces. Unfortunately I have seconded the motion of my hon. friend from George Etienne Cartier (Mr. Jacobs), but I am a little sorry for it now because he is asking that six months be allowed before the province should put this law into force. Now, I consulted with the Attorney General of Quebec, and discussed this matter with him. That province wants to get authority to control the transportation just as the province of Saskatchewan wishes to do, but I believe-although the Attorney General has not so informed me-that if he were consulted as regards giving the proprietors time, to dispose of the stocks which they now legally hold, he would be willing to give them six months. At any rate, it is desired that the legislation come into effect at once so that control may be vested in the provincial government within two weeks or a month from the time the law goes into force. I would therefore suggest to the Solicitor General that the committee report progress and see if it is not possible to redraft this amendment in order to bring the act into force, with the understanding that the provincial governments be empowered to give these proprietors six months' notice.


Mr. KENNEDY (Glengarry) :: I quite
agree with what has been said, that the whole trend of federal prohibitive legislation has been in the direction of placing the responsibility for enacting and enforcing prohibitory laws on the provinces. That is quite as it should be. The present bill proceeds along the same lines by supplementing acts that have been passed by the provincial legislatures. Although the traffic in Saskatchewan which has been discussed this afternoon is legal, it is quite obvious that it has been carried
Canada Temperance Act

on contrary to the very emphatically expressed opinion of the people. If parties imported into Saskatchewan a few million dollars' worth of liquor between the time the people expressed their opinion, and the time the law went into effect, if they did not see fit to secure licenses from the federal authorities to conduct a bonded warehouse, I do not think this Parliament should regard them in any other light than as outlaws. They simply carried on this business, taking advantage of a loophole in the law, and have no right to expect the protection of Parliament. I think the provinces should have the absolute right to determine when this supplementing legislation shall go into effect. Although I am not a lawyer, I am a little doubtful whether this section, as it stands, gives them that right. I think, as pointed out by an hon. member, a little change in that wording is necessary. As I view it, this legislation is going to give the province the right to pass an Order in Council, and when that is done, the Dominion authority shall pass an Order in Council, naming the day on which the provincial Order in Council shall go into effect.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: That is not quite the procedure. The Lieutenant Governor's order in council has nothing to do with the question of the date when the law shall go into effect. He simply makes the request that this Government shall bring the law into effect; and this is following exactly the provisions of part IV of the Canada Temperance Act. I am quite familiar with the steps to be taken under Part IV of the Canada Temperance Act. That law was passed by this Parliament in 1919, and it contained a proviso that, if any province asked that this law should go into force within its bounds, the legislature of the province would pass a resolution asking the Government of Canada for an election, so that the people of the province could declare their will as to whether such a law should be enacted. When the Government received that resolution they called an election. The election would be held and then, by Order in Council, the Dominion government would bring the law into force. The province never had anything to say as to when the law should come into force, they were simply making the request, and every step in regard to it was taken by the Dominion government, except that the request for it, and the request for the preliminaries, came from the recognized authorities under the law. In draughting and providing for this bill, amending Part IV of the Canada Tem-

perance Act, we are simply following the statute.


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Would it not be quite proper to give to the provinces the privilege of requesting that this section should come into effect upon a certain date?


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: My hon. friend is an honest and well-meaning man, but, as he says he is not a lawyer. If he were a lawyer he would understand that we cannot delegate any power to the local legislature.
They have powers given to them
5 p.m. under the British North America Act which are exclusively theirs, and we cannot give them any of our powers-these powers we have to exercise ourselves. We cannot say to any province, "you shall on a certain date bring a certain act into force." They are absolute monarchs of all they survey within their own jurisdiction.


Mr. McTAGGART:: I am entirely in sympathy with the proposed bill, but, as I understand the discussion, the date when exportation from the various provinces shall cease depends entirely upon the federal government, and the proposal in the amendment, I believe, is that the date shall be extended until the first of January. I am very much opposed to that, for this reason: there are two export houses in the constituency which I represent. I was in that district last fall, and I will say, in all frankness, that the situation there is a discredit to the authority which allows it to go on. There would appear- to be, in the province of Saskatchewan, some large stores of liquor, because almost every week, at the little town of Govenlock, in my constituency, liquor is unloaded by the carload. I do not think that anything is gained by extending the time for six months. I would not wish that the date should be set at, probably, less than three months. There must be in Saskatchewan somewhere large stores of liquor.
Amendment (Mr. Jacobs) negatived.


William Richard Motherwell: We have voted down the suggestion that the time limit be six months. As it stands now, it might be six years or it might be sixty years.


Henry Lumley Drayton: You have no faith in yourselves?


Mr. RYCKMAN:: The time for bringing prohibition into force is plainly in the

Canada Temperance Act
hands of the Governor General in Council, and, I think, my hon. friends can quite well leave it to them.


William Richard Motherwell: I have suggested that the section stand until we understand what it means.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: I do not see what there is in this section that requires to stand. It is perfectly clear to every one. The amendment was voted down, and what is it that is going to stand? Is it a case of Micawber, waiting for something to turn up?


Mr. BAXTER:: I think we should get some assurance from the Solicitor General (Mr. McKenzie) that he is really in earnest and really honest about it. The Minister of Agriculture is suspicious of the Solicitor General (Mr. McKenzie), and has no faith in him. He does not like to trust the act to him and other members of the Government. We may be getting a little sidelight as to why some great reforms promised during the last election have not been carried out. Perhaps, it is not because a certain minister was a private citizen at the time. It may be because he finds some wicked colleague will not allow him to carry his design into execution. The only thing this matter need stand for is the possibility of a reconciliation amongst the members of the Government, and the establishment of the mutual confidence that should exist.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
On section 3-Importation of intoxicating liquor prohibited:
Joseph Tweed Shaw: The apparent anxiety of
the Chairman to get the discussion over cannot well impress some of us. I want to suggest with regard to section 2, if i may be permitted to do so-


The CHAIRMAN:: I must call the attention of the hon. member to the fact that section 2 has been carried. We are on section 3.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: I understood that the
member for St. John was speaking to section 1.


George Newcombe Gordon: There was nothing before the Chair when that hon. member was addressing it.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: Am I to understand that I am out of order in dealing with section 2?


George Newcombe Gordon: Yes, section 2 has been passed; we are now on section 3,
the marginal note of which has been read.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Some hon. members seem to think that they have not had an opportunity to consider section 2, and I move, by consent of the committee, that we revert to that section.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to.
Joseph Tweed Shaw: I wanted to deal with the suggestion I made in regard to the date upon which the act is to come into effect. I am not asking that the provincial government be given power to fix the date. I merely suggest that it might request that the traffic be forbidden on and after a date to be named; if that were satisfactory the Governor in Council could by Order in Council declare that such prohibition should come into force in the province on that date. The Governor in Council would then know exactly when the province desired to have the act put into force. In order to ascertain the views of the committee I would move that after the word " forbidden," in the twenty-second line, the words " on a date therein named " be inserted, and that the last two lines be struck out and the following substituted therefor:
That such prohibition shall come into force in such province on the date named.


George Newcombe Gordon: Rule 42 requires
that amendments shall be in writing.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: I appeal to the committee for some consideration in this matter. I stated a little while ago that the bill was drafted partly by the Attorney-General of British Columbia, partly by the Attorney General of Quebec, and partly by some legal authorities in Saskatchewan; and with any assistance that I could secure, there fell to me the very hard task of so adjusting and welding together these different fragments as to produce the bill in its present form. I have put days and nights into the1 work, and have devoted to it all the energies I possess, and I do dislike to have it broken up. It is all right as it is, and should not be changed.


Mr. LEWIS:: I have listened to the member for West Calgary (Mr. Shaw), and although there seems to be some point to his amendment, I think the power is already m the provinces. The section reads:
Upon receipt by the Secretary of State of Canada of a duly certified copy of an Order In Council passed iby ithe Lieutenant-Governor in Council of any province, etc.

Canada Temperance Act
The Lieutenant Governor need not take action until he- is satisfied that the time is ripe for it. He need not apply to the federal government until the province is ready to have the act put into force.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: I am heartily in accord with the remarks of the Solicitor General. It does not require one line of legislation to enable the province to make a request, and even if there were some supererogation in the draughtsmanship of the bill conferring power in the matter, that power already exists. A province can come and ask for anything; it need not be empowered to do that. It would not vitiate the Order in Council contemplated if it did state a date and request that on that date the federal government should bring its legislation into effect; it would not hurt a bit. But from a very short experience of the work of government, I may suggest that it would be quite easy for a province, perhaps very zealou-s and1 well-intentioned, to name a date that would not possibly permit the consideration of their request in time to issue the proclamation to bring the law into force on that date. It is not possible to drop all other business of the Dominion and take up an isolated subject like this. The province might fix, for instance, one week from the date of the passing of legislation. I am not prepared to concur in the proposal that the province should fix the date. I am certainly not here in support of the present Government, but I am not here to raise fantastic objections to their mode of carrying on business, and I should have to assume that they intended, in a sense, to betray the province which made a request of this kind if I agreed to the proposal that the province should fix the date. I believe that when a province makes the request, the Order in Council will be granted just so soon as it can be passed in the ordinary course of business. I am not going to accuse the Government of intended bad faith, when I have not the slightest bit of evidence o<n which to base such an accusation. It will be quite time enough to deal with the Government when it is found acting in bad faith. I do not anticipate that that opportunity will ever occur in this matter, I am quite prepared to trust the Solicitor General and' his confreres, in the perfect assurance that the request of any province will be met in proper time without the slightest attempt to do anything other than exactly what the province asks.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: The implicit trust of the member for St. John in the Government to-day is very amazing, and it does suggest the "morganatic alliance" of which we have heard before. I have also every confidence in the Government in this matter, but my intention was simply to give the provincial government an opportunity to convey to this Government their desire that the prohibition should come into force on a particular date. I am satisfied that the Governor in Council will see to it that the request of any province, regardless of its politics, will receive proper consideration. If the Solicitor General feels that he cannot accept this very simple amendment I am not going to press it.


Walter George Mitchell: Subsection (h) of
Section 158 provides:
The carriage or transportation through such province of intoxicating Mquoi which may lawfully be exported therefrom shall only be by means of a common carrier by water or by railway and not otherwise,
It is pointed out to me that the prohibition might go so far as not to allow delivery from a brewery, distillery or warehouse, as the case may be, to the common carrier by water or by railway, when the brewery, distillery or warehouse was not situated on a railway siding. I would therefore suggest to the Solicitor General that after the word "otherwise" in the fourth line he add the words, "excepting for delivery to and from such common carrier." Without that amendment a brewer delivering to a train or steamboat might have his motor truck seized and confiscated.


John Millar: In the event of this
amendment being accepted, would there be anything to prevent those delivering liquor from travelling to any part of the province so long as later on they were going to deliver to a common carrier?


Walter George Mitchell: The delivery must be from the warehouse to the common carrier, and I presume if those delivering are found several miles away from the point of delivery they would be presumed to be going somewhere else with the liquor.


John Morrison: The word "direct"
would cover that point.


Mr. JOHNSON (Moosejaw) :: While the amendment offered at first glance looks very innocent, we who have seen the facility with which such provisions of the law can be violated are a little suspicious

Canada Shipping Act
of its effect-not of the intention of the hon. member. For instance, on the prairies the points of delivery are frequently very many miles apart, and I know of one particular road between two towns some forty-two or forty-three miles apart which was kept open last winter for weeks after the ordinary automobile traffic ceased in order that this particular traffic might continue.


Walter George Mitchell: This will apply only to British Columbia and Quebec, because you will not have any export houses in Saskatchewan after this law comes into effect.


Robert Milton Johnson: If that is correct the hon. gentleman's amendment may be accepted. But we have warehouses there even if they are not used for export.


Walter George Mitchell: I agree with the hon. gentleman for I had charge for several years of the enforcement of the prohibition law in Quebec, and I know all the difficulties he speaks of. But this was pointed out to me as a defect which should be remedied.


Samuel William Jacobs: Inasmuch as the Solicitor General thinks his bill should not be spoiled seeing he spent so much time on it, and as I am a supporter of the Government, I shall oppose the amendment.


Arthur John Lewis: I object to the words, "to and from the common carriers". That is to say, between common carriers themselves liquor can be transported, if I understand the amendment aright.


Walter George Mitchell: No.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Why not strike out the words, "and from"?


Walter George Mitchell: That would not do. Supposing you take shipments from the province of Ontario, where most of the distilleries are, and bring them into the province of Quebec, you land them at the Bonaven-ture station, Montreal, and have to take them to the government warehouse.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Quite right.


[Stage Direction]
Amendment agreed to.
Section as amended agreed to.
Bill reported as amended, read the third time and passed.


[Stage Direction]
On motion of Hon. Ernest Lapointe (Minister of Marine and Fisheries) the
House went into committee to consider the following proposed resolution, Mr. Gordon in the Chair:
Resolved, That it is expedient to amend sections 850 and 854 of Part XII of the Canada Shipping Act, chapter 113 of the Revised Statutes, 1906, relating to Public Harbours and Harbour Masters, and to provide:-
1.	That section 850 be amended so as to provide that Part XII shall apply to such ports only as have been or may be hereafter designated for that purpose by proclamation, or have been or may be created public harbours by proclamation under that Part, but shall not apply to the ports of Quebec, Montreal and Three Rivers in the province of Quebec, to the ports of Toronto, Hamilton and Belleville in the province of Ontario, to the iport of Halifax in the province of Nova Scotia, to the port of iSt. John in the province of New Brunswick, to the ports of Vancouver, North Fraser and New Westminster in the province of British Columbia, or to the port of Winnipeg and St. Boniface in the province of Manitoba, or to ary harbour or port with respect ito which there is or may be established under an act of the Parliament of Canada a harbour commission or other special authority having powers to enact special regulations for the government and control of the harbour placed under its charge, unless and until application from such harbour commission or special authority to have this Part so apply shall have been received and granted by the Governor in Council. If such harbour commission or special authority is abolished the harbour may thereafter be proclaimed a public harbour under the provisions of section 849 of the act.
2.	Thait section 854 be amended so as to provide that the Governor in Counci, may make rules and regulations for the government of any public harbour or port in Canada, but in the case of any harbour or port to which Part XII does not aipply under the provisions of section 850 as amended, any such rule or regulation as may be inconsistent with any rule or regulation in force in any such harbour or port shall not be held to apply to the said har bour or port until application therefor from the harbour commission or other special authority shall have been received and granted by the Governor in Council.
Ernest Lapointe: Part XII of the
Canada Shipping Act gives power to the Governor in Council to appoint harbour masters and defines their duties. Section 850 states that certain ports are exempted from the provisions of Part XII, being the ports administered by harbour commissions. In such cases the harbour master is appointed by the harbour commissioners and is under their control, and the rules and regulations adopted by the Harbour Commission are followed. Since the passage of the Canada Shipping Act many new harbour commissions have been created by statute, and the purpose of the proposed legislation is to add to the exceptions stated in section 850 the additional harbours which are now under control of a harbour commission. It is
Canada Shipping Act

proposed aido to apply a similar exemption to ports which in the future may be placed under a harbour commission. Section 2 has practically the same purpose: when there is no harbour commission the rules and regulations adopted by the Governor in Council apply; when there is a harbour commission the regulations of the Governor in Council do not apply if they come in conflict with those of the commission. It is also provided that harbour commissions may at any time request that the general regulations of the Governor in Council should apply to their ports as well as to the others.


Henry Lumley Drayton: As I understand it, the theory is to place the control and management of the harbours entirely in the hands of harbour commissions, where they exist?


Ernest Lapointe: So far as the harbour master is concerned.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Subject only to the qualification that the port warden is to be appointed by the Government.


Ernest Lapointe: The duties of the
port warden do not relate to any of the functions of the harbour commission. The duty of the port warden, as of the shipping master, is to see to the enforcement of the Canada Shipping Act and the regulations of the Department of Marine. He must be under the Department of Marine; but the functions of harbour master are directly connected with those of the harbour commissioners.


Henry Lumley Drayton: The practice is then to leave the management of harbours to the harbour commissioners, aside from the offices referred to. Is any change made by this legislation from previous practice, and if so, to what extent?


Ernest Lapointe: The ports of Quebec, Montreal, Three Rivers, Toronto, Halifax, Pictou, and St. John were the only ports excepted from the provisions of Part XII of the Canada Shipping Act. We are adding to these the following ports now administered by a commission: Hamilton, Belleville, Vancouver, North Fraser, New Westminster, Winnipeg, St. Boniface. It is to give autonomy to these ports and place them on the same footing as the ports of Montreal, Quebec, St. John and Halifax.


Henry Lumley Drayton: I understand that, but what I want to know is whether any change in practice is being made. I
[Mr. Lapointe. 1
have understood that these ports are already autonomous. I suppose my hon. friend thinks the law is not quite right, and by this legislation he seeks to remedy that?


Ernest Lapointe: No; as it is, the
harbour master is appointed by the Department of Marine and Fisheries; under the law as it will be, the harbour master will be appointed by and be under the control of the harbour commissioners.
Resolution reported,' read the second time and concurred in. Mr. Lapointe thereupon moved for leave to introduce Bill No. 144, to amend the Canada Shipping Act (Public Harbours and Harbour Masters).
Motion agreed to and bill read the first and second times, considered in committee, reported, read the third time and passed.



FISHERIES ACT, 1914, AMENDMENT

[Stage Direction]
On .motion of Hon. Ernest Lapointe (Minister of Marine and Fisheries) the House went into committee to consider the following proposed resolution, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
1.	Resolved, That it is expedient to amend the Fisheries Act, 1914, by repealing paragraph (b) of subsection two of section 18 as enacted by chapter fifty-two of the statutes of 1919, and providing in. lieu thereof that the annual fee for a salmon curing establishment shall be:-
Ffty cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted salmon puit up in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted salmon put up in one season does not exceed ten tons;
Seventy-five cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted1 salmon put up In the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted salmon put up in one season exceeds ten tons but is not more than twenty tons ;
One dollar on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted salmon put up in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted1 salmon put up in one season exceeds twenty ton's but is not more than fifty tons ;
One dollar and1 twenty-five cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted salmon put up in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted salmon put up In one season exceeds fifty tons.
2.	That the said act be amended by inserting the following provisions relating to Herring DrySalting Establishments:
[Stage Direction]
(1)	In British Columbia no one shall operate an establishment for dry-isalting herring for commercial purposes excepting under license from the minister.
(2)	The annual fee on such license shall be:-
Fifty cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted herring put uip in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted herring put up in one season does not exceed ten tons ;

Fisheries Act Amendment
Seventy-five cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted herring put up in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted herring put up in one season exceeds ten tons but is not more than twenty tons;
One dollar on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted herring put uip in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted herring put up in one season exceeds twenty tons but is not more than fifty tons ;
One dollar and twenty-five cents on each ton or fraction thereof of dry-salted herring put up in the establishment during the season, when the total quantity of dry-salted herring put up in one season exceeds fifty tons.
Provided that these fees shall not apply to an establishment which is being used in a bona fide manner in the canned or pickled herring industry.
Ernest Lapointe: The purpose of this resolution is more especially to make more proportionate the fees paid for a cannery license and for a curing establishment license. It is also for the purpose of bringing about a better proportion between the fees paid by the smaller and the larger operators. The existing fee for a salmon curing establishment is $50. This is unfairly high for the small operator, and a very low fee for the big operator. For instance, the salmon cannery license is $500, plus four cents per case of 48 pounds of sockeye salmon put up, and three cents per case of all other varieties. Several salmon salteries in British Columbia put up over 100 tons of dry-salted salmon in a season, which would be equivalent to about 2,300 cases of canned salmon. Keeping in view the cost of operation involved, and the market for dry-salted salmon, it is considered that a fee of $1.25 per ton would compare fairly with the salmon cannery license.
The other change is to require a license for dry-salted herring. An important trade in dry-salted herring for the oriental market is now carried on in British Columbia. This business is largely in the bands of orientals. At the present time there is no license fee. It has been thought desirable that there should be a license, in order to allow the department to exercise proper supervision over these establishments. It is also considered that a fee similar to that required for salmon curing is reasonable, for while the product is worth less it costs very much less to produce and cure it. On the other hand we must do everything to encourage the pickling and canning of herring, as this means not only a much larger expenditure in the province, but a much better food product and a larger financial return for the country.
It is therefore proposed to exempt from a fee, bona tide operators who are seeking to develop the pickled and canned herring industry and \tfho are using the herring not fit for such purposes for dry salting. This canned and pickled herring industry in British Columbia is not in the hands of the people I have just mentioned, and there is not the same objection to exempting them from that fee. As I have already stated they use for the purpose only the herring that could not be canned in their industry. I know that this legislation has been asked for by almost everybody in British Columbia, and it has been represented that it is most unfair to the salmon canning industry that the salted salmon industry carried on by the orientals largely should not pay a fee at least equivalent to the fee paid by the salmon canners.


Henry Lumley Drayton: I would like
to ask the minister how the value of the dry salted salmon compares with that of the canned salmon?


Ernest Lapointe: I have not that information here but I can secure it for my hon. friend.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Never mind.
From what the minister says I would have thought that most of the business of putting down this dry salted salmon would be done in the smaller units but I see that he has fixed a tax of fifty cents a ton when the amount is only ten tons, and $1.25 when the production exceeds fifty tons. What is the idea of that?


Ernest Lapointe: I do not think anybody fears competition with the small operators. There are some people out there who really put up only a few tons of salmon, and under the present law they were paying $10 for their license. It was felt that that was really too high and that a smaller fee should be charged.


Henry Lumley Drayton: I agree with
that.


Ernest Lapointe: This provision is
rather to hit the larger operators who export to other countries.


Henry Lumley Drayton: But what is
the underlying idea of this graduated scale? Is it merely to assist the canned salmon operators, or is it something that has been scientifically worked out?


Ernest Lapointe: The idea is not to
make the burden heavy on the small opera-

Fisheries Act Amendment

tors, but to equalize it as between the larger operator in this industry and the operator in the canning industry.


Henry Lumley Drayton: With a view
of equalizing the cost of production?


Ernest Lapointe: Yes.


Mr. NEILL:: I would just like to ask
the minister about that last paragraph; I did not quite understand what he said. I gather that these fees will not apply to an establishment that is operating in the canned or pickled herring industry if it goes into the dry salting business. It does not pay any license in that case?


Ernest Lapointe: That is the meaning
of it.


Alan Webster Neill: Well then I would submit
that is hardly just. That will allow a canner, for instance, who is operating a cannery, presumably on a profitable basis, to compete with a man who does not own a cannery in the dry salting of salmon business. Why should that man be exempt from this taxation because he happens to own a cannery somewhere. It puts a direct premium upon the operations of the man who owns a cannery as against the very people the minister has been undoubtedly trying to help with his previous resolution-I refer to the small operator. The man who puts up ten tons will have to pay a license of fifty cents a ton, and so on, up to $1.25 and his product will have to compete with that of the man who happens to own a cannery somewhere in the province and who does not pay any fee on the salted herring. Is that the situation?


Ernest Lapointe: Well, he pays a high fee for his license but he would not pay for that side line, as my hon. friend says. He only uses the herring that cannot go into the canning industry. He does so in order that the product may not be lost altogether. We want to encourage the industry of pickling and canning herring. This provision is not directed against the same people as the rest of the section, as my hon. friend knows.


Alan Webster Neill: I do not know that there are many canners who can herring but here is the situation: We will say there are two men within twenty miles of each other. One is a canner and he makes money out of it or I suppose he would not run the establishment. He runs it for six months in the year and in the winter season uses
[Mr. Lapointe.!
the plant to put up dry salted salmon. He may put up 100 tons and yet pay no license fee for it whatever. His product competes with that of the man who is putting up solely this dry salted salmon. That does not appear to me to be equitable.


Ernest Lapointe: Of course a salmon canner has to pay a license; I do not think there is any cannery which specializes in the canning of herring.


Henry Lumley Drayton: I do not understand this resolution either in the way my hon. friend from Comox-Alberni (Mr. Neill) understands it or in the way the minister understands it. I thought that this exception had nothing whatever to do with the canning or pickling of salmon but had to do with the canning or pickling of herring-


Ernest Lapointe: That is right.


Henry Lumley Drayton: -and that in so far as dry salted salmon was concerned they would have to pay whether they had canneries or not.


Ernest Lapointe: No it relates to herring.


Henry Lumley Drayton: So that the exception is for herring.


Ernest Lapointe: That is right.


Henry Lumley Drayton: The minister gave us a fee as to the salmon but he did not mention the fee paid by the canned or pickled herring industry. Do they pay fees?


Ernest Lapointe: I do not think they do as such, but it is always the salmon cannery that goes into the business of canning herring; there is no herring cannery.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Well, then, my hon. friend from Comox-Alberni was right in the point he was making because these pickled herring industries are really salmon industries.


Ernest Lapointe: Except that they are already paying a fee of $500 as salmon canners, and the others are not paying anything.


Henry Lumley Drayton: Let us make this clear. The only exception is as to herring?


Ernest Lapointe: Yes.


Henry Lumley Drayton: And there is no exception whatever as to the fees in the case of dry salted salmon whether it is a cannery or not; is that right?

Fisheries Act Amendment


Ernest Lapointe: Yes.


Alan Webster Neill: We will take the example of a man who has a cannery up in the Naas district, away up in the north of British Columbia; it may be that he happens to own that cannery, or it is owned by a big company. Why should they be favoured as against the man who confines himself to putting up dry salted salmon? Will the minister explain that? It is a direct advantage to the man or the company having a number of canneries; I cannot see what is the purpose of the provision enabling him to escape this tax.


Ernest Lapointe: He does not escape on dry salted salmon.


Henry Lumley Drayton: As far as I can understand it the situation is that although the salmon packing plants are the ones that do go into this herring business, in so far as the herring pickling activities of those plants are concerned they are only small. The minister desires to advance the herring industry and therefore makes no charge, in so far as the dry salted herring are concerned, provided the cannery is in the canning and herring pickling business. That is as I understand it.
Resolution reported, read the second time and concurred in. Mr. Lapointe, thereupon, moved for leave to introduce Bill No. 145, to amend the Fisheries Act, 1914.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to, and bill read the first and second times and the House went into committee thereon.
On section 2-British Columbia herring curing establishments to have license; fees.
Alan Webster Neill: There is nothing to be gained by railroading things through. I think we should have time to look through the bill. I have not yet seen a copy.


Ernest Lapointe: I am sorry. I was under the impression my hon. friend was agreeing to that legislation.


Alan Webster Neill: Yes, I thoroughly agree with the whole bill, except the last paragraph. It is in the right direction, and I heartily approve of it, with that exception. It seems to me that will open the door to the evasion of the fee by an establishment that owns a cannery, to the detriment of the man solely engaged in the dry salted herring industry. Do I understand this
191i
only applies to an establishment actually engaged in canning herring and not salmon?


Ernest Lapointe: Absolutely.


Alan Webster Neill: Well possibly it may work out all right, but I have my doubts.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
Bill reported, read the third time and passed.

[Stage Direction]
On motion of Hon. H. S. BELAND (Minister of Health) Bill No. 137, to amend the Opium and Narcotic Drug Act was read the second time, and the House went into committee thereon, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
At six o'clock the committee took recess.
After Recess
The committee resumed at eight o'clock.
House again in Committee on Bill No. 137, to amend the Opium and Narcotic Drug Act, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
On section 1-Dealing in drugs. A written order required in connection with all sales of narcotics to druggists and others.
Mr. STORK:: I am satisfied that in
British Columbia the larger part of this traffic is carried on by foreigners; and in addition to the penalties provided for here I would suggest deportation in the case of aliens.


Henri Sévérin Béland: Section 2 provides a
more severe penalty than has heretofore been imposed. My hon. friend (Mr. Stork) suggests deportation in the case of aliens. That is a matter for the consideration of the committee. When we reach another section of the bill I shall submit an amendment which, I think, will meet this suggestion. I shall make a statement regarding the number of aliens who have been convicted during the last fiscal year, and the committee will see that if deportation of aliens were included among the penalties a very large number of the traffickers in this business would be affected. There is no particular change in section 1, except that it sets out more clearly the law regarding the traffic in drugs by licensees, by retail druggists who are not licensed, and by physicians, veterinary surgeons and dentists. The

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
section is very clear and I see no objection to it. The fine of $500 has been reduced to $200, not because we want to make it easier for licensees or for physicians and dentists to evade the law, but because in the case of physicians and dentists, the association to which they belong, the various colleges of physicians and surgeons, have certain rules and regulations to which they are subject, and any physician who engages in the illicit sale of cocaine, morphine or opium is liable to suspension by his association. The maximum term of imprisonment has been placed at eighteen months. I think this clause is quite clear.


Mr. ANDERSON:: Does this mean that a physician must give an order under his own signature?


Henri Sévérin Béland: It must be a written order in every case.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
On section 2.-Subsection 2-Penalty for importing, etc.
Henri Sévérin Béland: It will be noticed that this is an important departure from the previous law. There is a very general desire that this traffic be suppressed if at all possible, and numerous requests have reached me not only from benevolent, charitable and religious bodies, but also from hon. members on both sides of the House, asking that in the case of the conviction of illicit dealers the magistrate should have no option to impose a fine. Heretofore these traffickers on conviction were subject to fine or imprisonment. This clause provides that upon summary conviction the illicit dealer will be liable "to a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars and costs and not less than two hundred dollars and costs, and to imprisonment for any term not exceeding eighteen months and not less than six months."


Henry Herbert Stevens: It says "or" here.


Henri Sévérin Béland: If my hon. friend will read subsection 2 of section 2 he will find the following:
Subsection two of section 5A of the said act, as enacted by chapter thirty-one of the statutes of 1920 and amended by chapter forty-two of the statutes of 1921, is amended by striking out all the words after the word "Minister" in the third line of paragraph (e) of the said subsection, and substituting therefor the following :-"shall be guilty of a criminal offence and shall be liable, upon indictment to imprisonment for any term not exceeding seven years,-

That is in the case of minors.
-or upon summary conviction to a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars and costs and not less than two hundred dollars and oosts, and to imprisonment for any term not exceeding eighteen months and not less than six months ;
I think this is a very wise provision.


Mr. LADNER:: The proposed changes in the Opium and Narcotic Drug Act are, I believe, highly commendable, and as there is an evident desire to expedite business of the House, I do not propose to go into the subject at such length as I had originally intended to do.
Some hon MEMBERS: Hear, hear. Let us save time.


Leon Johnson Ladner: Hon. gentlemen say "hear, hear." If they will concur in the suggestions which I am about to make, the passage of this bill will be greatly facilitated. The amendments which the minister has brought down have, I think, the support of our people generally throughout the country. On the Coast large numbers of organizations such as those mentioned by the minister, boards of trade, community service clubs, and other bodies recently conducted an investigation into the drug traffic, and the appalling disclosures made caused them to urge very strongly upon the Government the amendments which are now incorporated in this bill, and others which are not so incorporated, and to the latter I will address myself in a moment.
In order that the House may understand the idea behind the movement in western Canada and other parts of the Dominion, I propose to read a resolution passed by the Vancouver Board of Trade which contains practically my 'argument on this subject. The Vancouver Board of Trade is one of the largest in Canada, and at a meeting held on the 7th February last, it passed this resolution:
"Whereas, the illegal sale and traffic in drugs or narcotics appears from an investigation by certain organizations in Greater Vancouver to have grown in this and other cities to an alarming extent, bringing in its wake degeneracy, crime and moral and physical ruin ,
And whereas, various service clubs and public bodies deem it expedient to arouse the public to the seriousness of the situation and necessity for remedial measures to prevent the existing illegal traffic and its increase;
It is, therefore resolved that this meeting of the Vancouver Board of Trade, strongly urges the proper authorities to immediately amend or alter the existing laws pertaining to the illegal sale and traffic in drugs in order to provide for the enforcement of the following remedies:
(a) The elimination of fines as a penalty for illegal selling of drugs or narcotics and the

Opium, and Narcotic Drugs
substitution therefore of a prison sentence of not less than one year and not more than ten years with lashes upon entering ar in the discretion of the magistrate upon leaving, for all cases;
(ib) And in addition to the prison sentence deportation for all aliens or those possible under the law; and in the case of those who under the law cannot be deported, they shall report periodically and for such time and to such person as the sentencing judge may determine; failure to report to incur further imprisonment or restraint in a proper public institution ;
(c) In the case of a naturalized alien convicted of selling, cancellation of naturalization papers and deportation after prison sentence.
Some of those suggestions are not embodied in these proposed amendments. I believe the minister was willing to introduce the penalty of deportation, and I strongly urge upon the Government the wisdom of including it in the bill. I believe that if a foreigner is convicted of illegally selling a drug-and many of these traffickers are foreigners-he should be deported; he is no good.in Canada. I beg to offer in amendment to subsection 2:
That after the word "summarily" in the fifteenth line of subsection 2 there shall be added the following words, "and shall at the discretion of the judge be liable to whipping."
Of course, I admit that that is a severe penalty. In the fifteenth line of this subsection there is the following proviso:
-Provided that any person who unlawfully sells, gives away or distributes any drug to any minor shall be proceeded against by indictment and not summarily.
Now, Mr. Chairman, I contend that the man who induces a minor to indulge in the drug habit should not be relieved from such a penalty as whipping. The chief purpose of such an amendment will not be so much in its application as in its deterrent effect upon those men who contemplate engaging in this traffic, for when they know that the law contains a priviso of that kind the dread of being subjected to the lash will effectually deter them from incurring the risk. I have examples here of the most monstrous action on the part of men engaged in this traffic, involving young girls of fifteen and sixteen. I say that if a man is convicted for perhaps the third time of selling these drugs to a girl of sixteen whom he has seduced and brought into the traffic, there should be power in the hands of the magistrates to have the lash applied. Some hon. members may think it ip too extreme a punishment, but for many other offences under the criminal code the application of the lash is provided, as, for instance, in the
case of rape, hold-up with intent to wound, and burglary. The effect of the carrying on of the drug traffic upon the moral qualities of manhood and womanhood is to bring about diseases of the vilest kind and crimes of all sorts-theft, murder, hold-up. The court records disclose the interesting fact that in the majority of cases the people engaged in these criminal enterprises are followers of the drug traffic. I have here a number of cases which were investigated by a responsible body of citizens in Vancouver and other cities. Out of the forty or fifty cases which I have before me I will take just one. A young girl of sixteen was brought before the committee and examined-and I may say that other inquiries were made with a view to determining the correctness of this evidence, which was established beyond any doubt. This girl is a morphine or cocaine addict, is afflicted with venereal disease, prostitutes with Chinamen. She is a resident of Vancouver and has been during her whole life. She acquired the habit through mixing with men engaged in the traffic. On the morning of the investigation she was engaged in this unfortunate pursuit in order to earn sufficient money, $5.50, to buy drugs to last her for the day. This traffic is carried on in a cool and calculating way. The men who sell the drug do not themselves use it; they know its terrible effects, but they exercise all their resourcefulness and ingenuity to induce others to acquire the habit. They have what are called " snow parties ", a kind of social entertainment in which they get the confidence of people and induce them to try the cocaine or whatever it may be. They dare them to try it, and by doing this again and again they ensure for themselves a market for their wares. I say it is not too much to ask that Parliament confer upon the judges trying these men the power to administer the lash, as is done in such other cases as I have mentioned. In fact, the effects of the drug traffic are even more serious than the consequences of the other crimes that I have referred to. I submit that the members of the committee should stand behind this amendment. It is sound in principle, and the result of its adoption would be to deter those who otherwise would be engaged in the traffic-in other words, to protect the young people of our country.


Henri Sévérin Béland: By the bill which is now under consideration we provide more severe
Opium and Narcotic Drugs

penalties than have hitherto been applied in the case of those who carry on illicit trade in narcotics. Besides it is my intention to move a little later that all aliens convicted under this act shall be deported. The committee will have an idea of the effect of a deportation clause upon the traffic when I say that for the year ended September 30, 1921, there were in Canada 1,864 convictions, and of that number 1,211 were Chinese. So that if the amendment I propose becomes law and that number of Chinamen are affected, there would be 1,211 deportations. Of course, there would still be a number at large, but hon. members will admit that the remedy would be an effective one.


Alan Webster Neill: Is there any record of how many of these Chinese were not naturalized?


Henri Sévérin Béland: I have not the figures before me, but I understand that only a limited number of Chinamen are naturalized; from information which I have received, I understand that most of them are aliens. So far as the proposal of my hon. friend (Mr. Ladner) is concerned, I know that the crime is a serious one. But the application of the lash has so far been confined to cases of physical crime, and it is a question whether it would be advisable to apnly that punishment in the case of convictions in connection with traffic in narcotic drugs. Possibly we should not adopt the provision embodied in my hon. friend's amendment, at least until we have seen, in the course of the next twelve months- what the result will be of the new provisions made for stricter punishment. Of course, I am in the hands of the committee in this respect, but I suggest that my hon. friend wait until next session before pressing his amendment.


Mr. McQUARRIE:: What proportion of the 1,211 Chinese could have been deported if the amendment which is to be proposed by the minister had been in effect last year?


Henri Sévérin Béland: My hon. friend from Comox-Alberni asked me the same question, and I replied that I was not in a position to say how many of these 1,211 were naturalized. I think that very few of them would be Canadians.


William Garland McQuarrie: There might be
others. A great many of our Chinese in British Columbia come from Hong Kong and other British possessions. What would
rMr. Beland. ]
you do in a case of that kind? I am extremely doubtful if we would be able to deport a great number of these persons if convicted.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I am surprised to hear that statement, because I took it for granted that the deportation provision would hit at the very heart of the trade amongst the Chinese.


William Garland McQuarrie: I think it is a good provision, but I do not know how it will work out.


Alan Webster Neill: Would the minister go so far as to say "or naturalized aliens"? I think that would meet the situation.


Henri Sévérin Béland: My hon. friend will realize that that would be a very unusual provision. The moment an alien becomes naturalized he is a Canadian, and I do not know but what it would be declared ultra vires.


Leon Johnson Ladner: I would ask the minister, who is a medical man, if he does not consider that the extension of the drug traffic is a physical crime, because it brings about a physical disability that results in crime?


Robert James Manion: I should just like to say a few words on this question. I have looked up the Hansard of last year, because I remembered that when this same question came up then, the then hon. member for Red Deer, myself, and some other medical men in the House at that time, including the minister, I think, were opposed to using the lash in cases of this kind on the general ground that it was hardly called for. However, I believe that the hon. gentlemen who represent British Columbia in this House are more familiar with this question than perhaps the rest of us, even those of us who are in the medical profession. I do not see, after all, that there would be any great harm, in fact, there might be a great deal of good, in accepting the amendment moved by my hon. friend from Vancouver South. While what the minister says is true that lashing should be kept for certain crimes of physical violence, I think perhaps moral violence as in this case is a much more serious crime. No one, however, understands the deplorable effects of the use of these habit-forming drugs better than the minister and myself, who are both members of the medical profession. I would ask the minister, with no desire to be contrary at all, to rec'onsider this amendment. I can see no real reason why the clause as drafted by the hon. member for

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
Vancouver South should not be accepted. It leaves it to the discretion of the judge to use this method of punishment. I believe that good would come of it. I cannot see how it would hurt the bill in any shape or form, and I therefore again appeal to the minister to reconsider, and insert this clause in the bill.


Henry Herbert Stevens: Before the minister replies, might I also point out to him one or two other matters? First, this extreme penalty of flogging is proposed to be applied to those traffickers who have been supplying drugs to minors. I wish the House could fully appreciate the horrible nature of this traffic. I know of no act that one human being could do to another more despicable and more fraught with utter depravity in its results than to supply these drugs to minors. We have seen so many, many cases that to us the traffic seems sickening, appalling. One would not dare to describe publicly the effects of these drugs. The minister gave the committee the number of convictions the other night. I think the two cities most seriously affected are Montreal and Vancouver, and perhaps Victoria, but Vancouver more particularly. Therefore, I say to the minister and to the House, that we might very well add this penalty of flogging in the case of traffickers convicted of selling drugs to minors. I might remind the House that I moved this amendment myself last year and the House very nearly accepted it. There was a pretty narrow division of opinion at that time, and I think it was my own inability to bring the matter strongly enough before the House that prevented the amendment from carrying.
Regarding the other point, I think that the clause the minister is adding providing for the deportation of aliens will very, very materially strengthen the bill and and the arm of the law. I also agree with him in his estimate that a very large proportion of these 1,200 Chinese would be aliens, and therefore subject to deportation. Comparatively few of these Chinamen would be naturalized. We may find it necessary in the working out of this provision, to strengthen it later on, but I wish to say to the minister with the utmost sincerity that we appreciate very much indeed his attempt to strengthen the bill, and we accord to him the highest commendation. I would ask him, however, and the House most earnestly to accept the amendment moved by my hon. friend from Vancouver South, and
add this .penalty of flogging in the case of those convicted of trafficking in drugs to minors.


Mr. GOULD:: As the hon. member for Fort William (Mr. Manion) has stated, there was a debate in the House on this question last year. At that time I opposed the principle of applying the lash, not only in this but in other cases, and I think the House was well advised in taking the stand it did on that occasion. I have not changed my views on that point since. I sympathize with the sentiments expressed by the minister. I think that we should first exhaust all other means of punishment before resorting to the lash. It does seem to me that we are reverting to the dark ages when we ask for that punishment of this kind be administered. I am sure that science and the brains of individuals to-day are capable of devising ways and means whereby this traffic which we all admit is one of the greatest evils extant in the country, could be eliminated without the application of the lash. I have no desire in any way to save individuals who may be convicted of this heinous crime, but I would plead along the line suggested by the minister, that we at least try out for a time the penalties proposed in the resolution offered by the minister before we endorse the sentiments expressed in the amendment.


Mr. TOLMIE:: I am sure we all very greatly appreciate the additions which the minister has made to the bill with regard to deportation. I quite understand, too, that it might be impossible to get rid of these orientals or foreigners who have become naturalized, but if we deport those who have been convicted of taking part in this traffic, I can readily see that we are moving in the direction of solving this oriental question.
There are certain points in discussing this matter which must not be overlooked. In the first place, very large profits are made out of this business, and consequently we have found in the past that these men will take almost any chance, and that they adopt the most ingenious methods for evading the law and carrying on this traffic. Again, we have another class of dealer who is himself subject to this habit, a man who take narcotics himself, and the strong desire to secure those narcotics and the high prices which they realize would induce that man to himself take any possible chances to obtain

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
money to buy drugs for his own use. Now, I cannot understand any argument which proposes to give any quarter to a trafficker in narcotics, particularly to one who supplies narcotics to a minor. I have been shown through some of these opium dens in British Columbia and the sights are simply appalling. Take the effects of the narcotics as described by the hon. member for Vancouver South (Mr. Ladner). There are hundreds of these cases out there, the traffic is increasing very rapidly, and I feel that we are quite justified in adopting any measure whatever that will overcome this traffic before it gains any further headway. Even if by the application of the lash, in cases where the magistrate thinks it is necessary, we can save only one or two persons during the coming year I think we should adopt the required measures right now and not postpone the legislation for another year. I think it is generally acknowledged by those who have been keeping close tab on this traffic that fine and imprisonment have not been nearly so effective as we thought these penalties would be when the law was first applied.


William Garland McQuarrie: I also would like to support the amendment, but before dealing with it I would say that I think the minister's action in providing for the deportation of aliens who are convicted of this crime, is most commendable and I congratulate him on having gone that far. At the same time deportation will not cover all the offenders. Even on the figures that were given, if all the Chinese could be deported, that would cover only 1,200 out of 1,800 and would leave some 600 not subject to deportation. Now, what is going to happen to them? These people will pay a fine without any hesitation; they can afford to do so because there is a very large profit made in this traffic. I have had a good deal of experience in connection with the administration of the criminal law and I know that there are men who will take imprisonment with a smile on their face-that imprisonment does not seem to have a great deal of effect in a great many cases. But where a man is faced with a sentence that will subject him to whipping I have seen the most hardened criminals cringe, and I say it is the greatest deterrent that could possibly be placed in the Criminal Code. This crime, to my mind, is even more serious than the crime of robbery with violence. To hold a man up at the point of a gun and take his money
[Mr. Totalled
away from him is serious of course, but it is not so serious as to give drugs to a minor and take away his future. To render that minor an addict to the drug habit is the most terrible thing that could happen to him or to her. I would much rather have anyone hold me up, and shoot me for that matter, than sell me drugs and cause me to become a drug addict. I have seen the effects of this traffic; it is a terrible thing. We are not going too far when we give a judge discretion to order a lashing in what he considers to be an extreme case. I would press that view on the minister. I know he is trying to do his very best to meet the situation, I know that he appreciates its gravity, not only in places like Vancouver where investigations have been held, but elsewhere throughout Canada. In all the cities and towns of the Dominion this condition exists to a greater or lesser extent. Even here in the city of Ottawa the police could give information which would open the eyes of anyone who is nor acquainted with the facts. If we knew what was happening, if we knew what the true conditions were here in Ottawa-and in every city in Canada for that matter- I do not think we would hesitate for a moment in supporting this amendment. I know what it means to have a provision of this kind in the act, and I am convinced that if these traffickers knew that they would be lashed if they were convicted the traffic would be stopped to a very great extent.


Mr. BROWN:: I am not in a position to express very clear opinions based upon personal knowledge with regard to this traffic, but it is quite evident that the hon. members who represent our Pacific coast province have come into close contact with the trade, or into such close contact with it that we ought to be impressed by the representations they have made. In order that the committee may form some idea of the extent to which the traffic has gone I might give some figures that I saw this evening in the Literary Digest. The statement was there made that the United States was using ten times the amount of opium that European countries are using and the figures given were these: That 270 tons of crude opium, which would produce thirty-one tons of morphine, were imported into the United States, whereas one ton was sufficient to take care of the legitimate needs of the country. Now I do not know whether those figures are correct or not, but evidently the writer of tb$

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
article knew something about the matter; and if the situation is anything like as serious as that writer contends then it seems to me that no steps that we can take can be too strong to put'a stop to the traffic. I know the tendency of penal legislation in the present day, is, perhaps, towards more moderate methods than have been pursued in the past, and yet in this particular case it does seem to me that no steps which we can take can be too strong to prevent the degradation and the corruption of the young people of our land.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I see that the amendment reads:
-and shall at the discretion of the judge, he liable to whipping.
I also understand that this amendment is to apply exclusively to traffickers who sell to minors. My impression at first was that the penalty of the lash was to be applied in every case coming under subsection 1 of section 5 which we are now considering. However, it is proposed to be applied only to traffickers who sell, or furnish, or give narcotics to minors, and the punishment is to be administered at the discretion of the judge. I have an open mind on the question. I know that the traffic must be suppressed if at all possible. My hon. friend a moment ago referred to the fact that perhaps the people of the East were not fully in possession of the facts, were not fully aware of how serious the situation was. But the traffic, as my hon. friend knows, is very large in the city of Montreal. I have received a personal letter from one of the most- eminent, I would call him-magistrates of the city stating that the traffic in Montreal has reached very large dimensions, and that .the situation had to be met in the most severe manner. I call the attention of the House to the fact that, in the United States, the laws with regard to narcotic drugs do not provide for the application of the lash. They provide for very severe penalties in fines and imprisonment, and also for the deportation of aliens, but, as far as whipping is concerned, they do not inflict it. I am in the hands of the House, and if the committee decide the amendment should carry, I am willing to incorporate it in the bill.


Mr. GOOD:: I desire to support the
proposed amendment offered by the hon. member for Vancouver Sou h (Mr. Ladner). I think flogging is quite proper in
a case of this kind, where the crime is coolly premeditated. I think it is entirely in order, and the provision will probably not be abused if it is left to the discretion of the judge.


Mr. MARCIL (Bonaventure) :: Referring to conditions in the city of Montreal for the last few years, I desire to concur in all that the minister has said. A recent report published a few weeks ago by the Chief of Police, Mr. Belanger, attributed to foreigners the responsibility for, perhaps, 75 per cent of the crime committed in the city of Montreal. On Lagauchetiere street, in that city, and in that district we have a Chinatown, many houses have been converted into Chinese dives, and raids on the opium dens are a daily occurrence. The illicit sale of opium, cocaine and other drugs has become a terrible nuisance, and must be put down. It is worse than a nuisance, it has become a crime. I remember one case, in particular, where $35,000 worth of opium was seized when a raid was made, and brought down to the police court, to be exhibited in court, if necessary It was left in the police station, but the station was broken into and the opium was stolen. The traffic is ten times worse than ihe liquor traffic. The people engaged in this drug business are in the worst business, and no penalty is too severe to fit the crime. I think the most severe punishment is absolutely necessary, because the paying of the money penalty is nothing to these people, who make large sums out of the traffic. I will strongly support the amendment.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: With regard to the
application of the lash, I would like to bring before the committee the method of carrying out the sentence. If you say that a man has to pay $100 fine, we know exactly what it is. When we say he has to spend two years in penitentiary, we understand what it means. We have a trained judge to measure out the penalty, either imprisonment or fine, but when we say that a man shall receive ten, twenty of fifty lashes, who is going to administer them? We have no officials who are trained for that purpose and who understand what the lash means. The great country to the south of us has not adopted the principle of administering the lash.


An Hon. MEMBER:: They have lynch
law.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: Lynch law is an outrage on civilization. No country cares to

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
adopt it, it has no statutory approval or sanction, and is only applied where the people take the law into their own hands. Now, who is going to apply the lash? There cannot be any uniformity about it. The lash depends upon the strength, the character and the nature of the man in whose hands it is operated. I bring this matter to the attention of the committee, so that they will know why there is such a reluctance in the country about imposing this penalty. Last year' this matter was put before us in another shape, and we were asked by the Minister of Justice to pass a law by which young boys, instead of being imprisoned, should receive flogging or lashing, and the House was unanimously against it. It received no quarter at all. If deportation and fiines or imprisonment will meet the case, I am with hon. members at every turn, but I am opposed to the frightful brutality of the lash, when you put it in the hands of a man who has had no training in administering it. You know what a dollar is, and what imprisonment is, but you do not know what a lash is. It may have no appreciable effect at all. I hope that we shall be able to carry out criminal laws to the extreme, without using the lash.


Leon Johnson Ladner: I am surprised at the Solicitor General (Mr. McKenzie)-although undoubtedly it was not done purposely-creating the impression that the lash would be indiscriminately used. The Criminal Code provides distinctly the method by which it shall be applied. It says that the Convicted person shall, first, be examined by a doctor to ascertain whether he is in a condition to receive the lash. It shall be a cat o' nine tails. It shall be applied by a certain official of the penitentiary, and, if he is not available, by a man appointed by the Justice Department. The most careful provision is made in the law for the application of the lash. It is applied in many cases, and this would only be applying a principle of justice now in practice.


Alan Webster Neill: I wish to add what
small weight my local knowledge will furnish in favour of the amendment. While	I understand all	that can
be said against the principle of flogging-people say it is out of date and brutalizing, and so it is-I fully belieVe the conditions justify its use, and no one who has not lived in the West can understand the conditions. While flogging may be un-

pleasant for the party, think of the living hell these young people are sentenced to by reason of the use of these drugs, mot for an hour or two or a month or two, but for all their lives, and, perhaps, for eternity. Some 60 or 70 years ago there was ah epi-dtmic of garrotting in London, England, and it spread to a tremendous extent. It was easily done. A foot pad came behind a man and twisted a cord or shawl around the man's neck, and he was either rendered insensible or choked to death. It was difficult to detect, because it was so easily done, and no evidence was left. It went on to a remarkable extent, and people were terrified to go out after dark. Where the victims were not killed, and the garrotters were convicted, the judge gave the lash, and inside of three months the practice totally ceased. You will find in some of the treatises on criminal codes, how speedily that simple application of the lash absolutely caused that practice to cease. These men who are capable of committing these low, beastly crimes, are afraid of their own skin. Very often, when a man is going to be hanged, he asks, not in regard to his future, but "Will it hurt?" and they suffer perhaps more from the thought of being lashed than from the idea of being hanged. The situation in British Columbia fully justifies this amendment.


[Stage Direction]
Amendment agreed to.
Robert James Manion: Subsection 2 (a) reads:
Any person who manufactures, imports, exports, sells or distributes any drug and neglects or refuses to keep the record required, etc.
Does that apply to physicians in the country? Have they to keep records?


Henri Sévérin Béland: No.


Mr. GARLAND (Carleton) :: Has the department a sample of the record that must be kept by druggists?


Henri Sévérin Béland: This is a matter of regulation. The regulations are being authorized by Order in Council, and the department has no sample record.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
Henri Sévérin Béland: I move two amendments. The first has reference to the appeal that can be taken under the present law from a judgment of the inferior court to the higher court. I am prompted to submit this amendment by reason of a personal communication which has reached me from an important magistrate in the city of Montreal, and which convinces me that

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
these appeals should be restricted to cases where legal points are in dispute. I do not want to delay the committee but I shall read a few paragraphs from this letter. The letter is personal and I shall not give the name of the writer:
It was called upon to preside at the sessions of the Court of King's Bench in appeal against decisions of lower courts of criminal jurisdiction, and I think it is my duty to place .before you certan suggestions which came to my mind in the course of the hearings of these cases.
Out of 76 cases inscribed for appeal, 60 of them at least were cases where the appellant had been condemned by the lower court for having been found in possession of drugs, such as cocaine, morphine or opium, or for having sold or purchased drugs, or for having visited places where such drugs are supplied.
In most cases the charge was upheld. The accused flies an appeal, either in order to obtain sufficient delay to enable him to find the sum which he has to pay as a penalty, or in order to postpone his imprisonment in cases where he is condemned to serve a term in jail. In both cases the accused hopes that his solicitor will find irregularities in the wording of the charge, or in the sentence or in other procedures, through which he might obtain his discharge.
I may slate that I did not "fall" for the clever arguments of lawyers on technicalities.
Abuse is being made of the right to appeal. If you knew, Sir, the shameful traffic of drugs which is carried on in Montreal '. Young men and very young girls are enticed into supposed-to-be honest places of amusement, and, under the pretext of experimentation, drugs are served to them as wine would be. The law can never be too severe on the traffickers and distributors of drugs.
Further on the writer says:
I believe, Sir, that you would render an immense service to the community if you were to make the law as severe as possible against those engaged in this ignominious trade.
He concludes by asking that appeals should be restricted. I therefore move, as section 5, the following:
The said act is amended by inserting the following section immediately after section 10 thereof:
(10a) : Sections 749 to 760, inclusive, of the Criminal Code shall not apply to any conviction, order or proceeding in respect of any offence under this act.
I am informed by the Minister of Justice that these sections mentioned refer only to appeals from decisions of lower courts in criminal cases. Section 761 of the Criminal Code provides for an appeal on any stated case on a point of law. I do not think there can be objection to the proposed amendment.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: I suppose the minister has carefully considered this matter, but it seems to me that it introduces a dangerous principle into our jurisprudence. I have every possible sympathy with this act and
the way in which it has been amended to make the punishments for this crime as severe as possible. I have no sympathy with merely technical appeals; and yet the right to appeal, the right to have a sentence reviewed is, I think, inherent in the administration of justice as we know it. A man should not be wrongly punished. After all, the great feature of Magna Charta was that no man should be imprisoned or executed without the lawful judgment of his peers under the law of the land. And when you say that not merely an irregularity but something worse may exist and there shall be no remedy, I think you are going to a very dangerous length. Bad as may be the crime for which this act provides punishment, it cannot be worse than many other crimes that are punished by the law. Yet it has always been the boast of our jurisprudence that the meanest criminal has the right to be heard and the right to the punctual observance of all the forms of law. I do not contend for a moment that the form should override the substance, but there are so many formal errors that are now cured by the Criminal Code that nothing is left except matters of a rather substantial character. It seems to me therefore, that we ought not unduly to smooth the path for magistrates who will not prepare themselves or who are careless in the exercise of g their jurisdiction. In the cities where this class of crime will be principally dealt with there is no excuse for slothfulness or bungling on the part of magistrates, and I have no sympathy with weak appeals from magistrates who either do not know their duty or are too careless to observe the sanctions which the law has framed, not for the purpose of allowing the guilty to escape, but of preventing the innocent from suffering. The old saying, "It is better that ninety-nine men should escape than that one innocent man should suffer" is outworn. But our Criminal Code has destroyed the great bulk of the old technical objections, and I would ask the minister to consider very carefully before he introduces this new principle into our law. It cannot be necessary if competent men are adequately discharging their functions. Once in a rare while you will have someone blundering, but it will not be so ordinarily. It is all very well to say that there may be an appeal by a reserved case, but why should the ordinary right of appeal be denied for this particular class of crime when it applies so generally to other Classes? We
Opium and Narcotic Drugs

do not want a man to be convicted except according to the law. The principle involved is a great deal wider than the mere scope of this act.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I appreciate very much indeed the remarks made by the hon. member for St. John. I surmise that he was not in his seat when I read the letter which I received from one of the magistrates in the city of Montreal who lately sat in appeal there on several of these cases.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: I saw the minister
reading something, but the conversation going on in the Chamber prevented me from hearing him.


Henri Sévérin Béland: The learned magistrate stated that out of 76 cases inscribed for appeal before him 60 were cases where the appellant had been condemned by a lower court for trafficking illegally in drugs. He contends, and I think he is justified, that appeal in most cases is taken in order to gain time and find the money wherewith to pay the fine and escape imprisonment. Wealthy traffickers come to the rescue of their poorer friends and supply the money. The magistrate also said: "In order to obtain satisfactory results from the severe sentences imposed, it would be necessary to take away the right of appeal as it has been done in the case of disorderly houses." The principle is not a new one, at least so far as the province of Quebec is concerned, where there is no appeal in the case of conviction for keeping a disorderly house. This provision. I think, is one more weapon in the hands of the Government in its efforts to suppress the drug traffic, and that was the object I had in view when I introduced the amendment.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: Strange as it may seem, Mr. Chairman, I find myself in agreement with the hon. member for St. John! I think there are two kinds of cases to be taken into consideration. My recollection is that if in the case of a disorderly house the conviction is by way of what is known technically as "summary conviction" there is a right of appeal; but there is no such right in the event of conviction by a. police magistrate. Now, a police magistrate in most of our large cities has a jurisdiction which is substantially the same as that of a district or county court judge. But this bill gives the power of conviction to an ordinary justice of the peace, a man who is not specially trained, and who perhaps is not accustomed to weighing carefully the

value of evidence; yet this justice of the peace is given the power to take away the liberty of the individual for a period of six months in addition to imposing a fine. I think it is highly desirable that in cases of this kind where the conviction is by way of summary proceedings there should be a right of appeal. The letter read by the minister indicates that even in the city of Montreal, where there is a trained judge trying the cases at the outset, some appeals were allowed. It seems to me that the appeal right should not be taken away where convictions under this Act are made by ordinary justices of the peace.
In the act as it stands I presume that no imprisonment can be imposed, because the Montreal judge suggested that those convicted commenced appeal proceedings for the purpose of gaining time to pay their fines; but under this bill it is obligatory on the court to impose imprisonment.


Henri Sévérin Béland: I beg my hon. friend's pardon. It is not obligatory in all cases. Those licensed to sell drugs may upon conviction for breaches of the act be condemned either to pay a fine or go to gaol; but illicit traffickers must be condemned to imprisonment.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: I accept the minister's statement. In the event of appeal the minister is aware that the accused person must put up security to the satisfaction of a district court judge, and must take other steps in order to prosecute his appeal within a limited time. I see no objection to allowing an appeal. I do not see how any one is going to be prejudiced, and it maybe that only in a few cases will the sentence be reversed, but it is important in those cases that justice be done, and therefore I think we should hesitate about taking away from any person his right of appeal. The minister suggests that the person convicted has a right to appeal by way of a case stated, so called; but in such an event there is no deliberation by the appellate body to consider the weight to be given to the evidence, the only matter under consideration is a point of law, and consequently even in that event injustice may be done to the accused.


Lewis Herbert Martell: I heartily concur in most that has been said by the hon. member for Calgary and the hon. member for St. John. I think it behooves us to be very careful in taking away from the citizen any right which will insure him justice. Many of the magistrates who try these cases by way of procedure known as summary ecmvic-

Opium and Narcotic Drugs
tion are absolutely unskilled in the law and do not know anything at all about the admissibility of evidence. There cannot be, as mentioned, an appeal by way of a case stated, where the ordinary right of appeal is taken away by the special statute under which the conviction is made. An examination of the Criminal Code will show that in cases of summary conviction Parliament has gone as far as it could go toward removing the defendant's right of certiorari except where there is a want of jurisdiction in the magistrate. It used to be the right of the accused-the right has now been almost entirely taken away -that a person could bring about a review of a magistrate's decision by a writ of certiorari. If the conviction was bad, and a person was confined to gaol he could obtain a writ of habeas corpus and a writ of certiorari in aid of habeas corpus in order that the evidence might be reviewed for the purpose of seeing whether the conviction was a proper one or whether there was sufficient evidence to support it. In the province of Nova Scotia it was held in the case of the Queen vs. Walsh that when a matter was brought up by way of certiorari it was not competent for the courts to go into the evidence; in fact, they were not permitted to look at the evidence at all if the conviction was complete and regular on its face. Other provinces, however, held that when a matter was brought up on certiorari, the court dealing with the writ of certiorari had a right to look at the evidence. There was, therefore, this conflict of decision. But a short time ago the Law Lords who are the judicial committee of the House of Lords held that the Nova Scotia court was right in the case of the Queen vs. Walsh; so that the law as regards certiorari was really established by the Nova Scotia decision in the case to which I have referred. So that now with the Criminal Code taking away as far as it can the right of certiorari, save where there is an absolute want of jurisdiction, and with the taking away of the right of appeal as now proposed, you are putting the defendant, in many cases, entirely in the hands of ignorant magistrates. I submit that the department is not running any risk by leaving where it is the right of appeal so that a man may have his case as tried by the magistrate determined de novo by a higher court. There should be no tendency in any way to derogate in any way from the rights of the individual. At any rate, in most of our laws we are
putting upon the defendant the burden of proving himself innocent rather than letting the Crown prove him guilty. If we persist in amending our laws in such a way that these rights are taken from the people, we shall soon come to a condition under which a man who is accused of a crime, whether there is bona fide reason for the charge or not, will be obliged to prove his own innocence rather than have his guilt established by the prosecution. We should jealously guard the rights of the individual. We should be very cautious in taking away the right of appeal, the only protection the defendant has, particularly when he is tried by magistrates who, as happens in many cases, are incompetent. iSo long as I occupy a seat in this House I shall by my voice and vote uphold the principle that the defendant in an action shall not be deprived of any of his rights; that he shall at least have extended to him the old presumption of British law that he is innocent until proven guilty. When the department ask for an amendment to take away from the subject rights which he has always had, it seems to me that they are getting lazy and do not want to take the trouble of obtaining the proper evidence to make convictions; they rather wish to act as a sort of autocratic body.


Leon Johnson Ladner: I would like to add a word in support of the minister on this question. I think that too much emphasis has been laid upon the innocent man being deprived of all his rights and privileges and being made the subject of czarism and autocracy. That is not the principle of the minister's suggestion. The man who is affected in this case has the right of appeal in law.


Lewis Herbert Martell: You are taking it away from him.


Leon Johnson Ladner: No; we are taking it away in relation to the facts.


Lewis Herbert Martell: Is not the magistrate the judge of the facts as well as of the law? Has not the judge on appeal the . right to treat the whole thing de novo?


Leon Johnson Ladner: My hon. friend misses the point of my contention. The question of appeal relates to the right of appeal on a point of law, and that would necessarily involve the facts as brought out before the magistrate. In most cases the facts are brought out at the trial before the magistrate, and even if some facts are
Opium and Narcotic Drugs

omitted there is always, under the Criminal Code, the right, in the case of error or the discovery of new evidence, to adduce the facts in question, so that there would really be no prejudice to the defendant. The amendment suggested by the minister would greatly aid in carrying out the spirit and purpose of this law, which is to down the traffic, not to give protection to those engaged in it.


Mr. CARROLL:: I must protest against a government which is uplifting morals by legislation. My hon. friend (Mr. Ladner) says there is always the right of appeal under the Criminal Code, but if the legislation proposed by the minister becomes law, there is no appeal. I take the ground that every person is entitled to an appeal from the magistrate to a county or district or superior court judge, and if the legislation proposed by the minister goes through, that right is denied him. We have the same thing in liquor legislation; in our province a man who is convicted of an offence against the prohibition act may not take an appeal. It simply means that the magistrate may convict on very slender evidence or no evidence at all, and if he does, there is no appeal from the facts, no right to take the case to a superior court judge. There is always, of course, the right of certiorari, of which the hon. member for Hants (Mr. Martell) has spoken, and the right of habeas corpus. But if the Government or friends of the Government take the stand that a man should be prohibited from taking appeal, it looks to me like poor legislation. It looks to me as if the government were taking a stand on a question the soundness of which there were doubtful of. It looks to me as if they are putting the machinery of the law in this country into the hands of magistrates, who, as the hon. member for Hants has said, very often misconduct trials-I know it is so in my province. There should be no such thing as depriving a man of the right to appeal, a right which, my hon friend will perhaps say, is statutory-a right which is as old as the statutes themselves. I know that the min' ister is legislating in respect to a very serious matter, and I hope that through the legislation he is bringing in he will be able to put the traffic in drugs and intoxicating liquors and that of thing out of business. But I think he would be well advised to put that kind of illegal traffic out of business by means which are sanctioned under our constitution, and which
fMr. Ladner.]
have been handed down to us in the British system of law.


Henri Sévérin Béland: Is my hon. friend aware that in the case of prosecutions for the sale of liquor in the province of Quebec, there have never been any appeals?


William F. Carroll: 'So much the worse for the province of Quebec, and so much the worse for the people who legislate in that direction. We have no appeals in the province of Nova Scotia, hut two wrongs do not make a -right, and I for my part protest, and protest most vigorously, against that sort of legislation, whether in the province of Quebec or any other province.


Lewis Herbert Martell: My hon. friend from St. John stated that there might be an appeal by way of a stated case, but I find that subsection 2 of section 769 of the Criminal Code provides:
Where, toy any special act, it is provided that there shall be no appeal from any conviction or order, no proceeding's shall be taken to have a case stated or signed as aforesaid in any case to which such provision as to appeal in such special act applies.
So if there is no appeal provided for in this special act, there is no right to appeal by way of stated case.


[Stage Direction]
Amendment agreed to.
Henri Sévérin Béland: I move:
That the said act be amended by inserting the following section immediately after section 10A thereof:
Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in the Immigration Act, any alien who at any time after his entrance is convicted under subsection 2 of section 5A of this act shall upon the termination of the imprisonment imposed by the court upon such conviction be kept in custody and deported in accordance with section 43 of the Immigration Act.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: In the last amendment I think the minister went too far, and I am wondering if in this one he is going as far as he may go. I am a little bit afraid that some of these people may not be aliens, and yet they may be persons who have come into Canada from some'where else, in fact, be what we call Hong Kong British subjects. I would very much like to see the provision wide enough to bundle them out of the country too, and treat them just as aliens. I would be very glad if the minister would consider extending this provision to make It apply to anyone not a native of Canada, so that a man could be sent back to where he came from. We do not want that kind of people nor that kind

Bankruptcy Act Amendment
of traffic in this country, and I think it would be well to turn them out.


[Stage Direction]
Amendment agreed to.
Bill as amended reported, read the third time, and passed.

[Stage Direction]
On the motion of Hon. A. B. Copp (Secretary of State) the Bouse went into Committee to consider the following proposed resolution, Mr. Gordon in the Chair:
Resolved, That it is expedient to extend for one year the operation of the Public Service Retirement Act, chapter 67 of the statutes of 1920, as amended by chapter 49 ot the statutes of 1921.
Resolution reported, read the second time and concurred in. Mr. Copp thereupon moved for leave to introduce Bill No. 146, to extend for one year the operation of the Public Service Retirement Act.
Motion agreed to, 'bill read the first and second time, and the House went into committee thereon, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
Hugh Guthrie: Will the minister explain just what the amendment amounts to because we have no copies of the bill.


Mr. COPP:: I did not intend that the bill should be considered in committee to-night, and I therefore propose that the committee rise and report progress.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to.

[Stage Direction]
On motion of Sir Lomer Gouin (Minister of Justice) Bill No. 107 to amend the Bankruptcy Act was read the second time, and the House went into committee thereon, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
On Section 2-Notice of Suspension of Payment.
Sir LOMER GOUIN:: As I informed the House in introducing the bill the amendments proposed are not of a substantial character. This legislation is to dispose of certain doubts which have arisen as to the meaning of certain provisions and to provide for a more expeditious and satisfactory enforcement of the act. The first amendment seeks to add to the grounds on which a debtor may be adjudicated bankrupt. At present a creditor in order to force the debtor to turn over his assets to a trustee has first to take action against him, get judgment, and have an execution issued. After that lengthy, and sometimes
expensive, course, if the execution is not satisfied, after a delay of fourteen days, application can be made to the judge on bankruptcy for a receiving order. Business men all over the country have represented to us that it is very difficult for them to prevent a debtor from disposing of assets during litigation. It appears to me that if a debtor gives notice to any of his creditors that he has suspended, or is about to suspend payment of his debts, the creditors should be entitled to petition the court for a receiving order. Similarly, if he ceases to meet his liabilities as they become due, he is to all intents and purposes insolvent, and the court should have jurisdiction to deal with his assets for the benefit of his creditors accordingly. That principle is already embodied in our Winding Up Act, and it was in the Insolvency Act of 1875. We have been requested as I have said, by the business men of Canada to adopt this amendment and I hope the House will consent to this being done.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
On Section 3-Avoidance of general assignment of book debts:
Lomer Gouin: Section 30 of the statute, which it is proposed to amend, provides in effect for the avoiding of general assignments of book debts. It was the intention of Parliament to prevent a debtor from giving preference to certain creditors by means of a secret assignment of book debts. Different cases were brought to court and it was decided, especially in Ontario, that even in the provinces where there was no such registration provided by law assignments were not avoided. A contrary decision was rendered in Nova Scotia, and it is in order to dispose of that doubt that we propose to amend the law and ask to have the section read as it is found in the bill. We make it very clear that the principle is that assignments are to be avoided, and we make special exception only for provinces where they have legislation providing for registration.


Hugh Guthrie: If I understand the minister aright the effect of this amendment is that in provinces where there is no provision for the registration of an assignment of book debts, the assignment will not be permitted.


Lomer Gouin: That is it.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
[Stage Direction]
Bankruptcy Act Amendment
On Section 6-Courts of bankruptcy not now to be so called; Appeal Courts of Bankruptcy not now to be so called.
Lomer Gouin: I move to strike out the word "are" in the third line of subsection 2.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
On Section 8.-Single judges to be assigned to bankruptcy work by Chief Justice instead of by Minister of Justice:
Hugh Guthrie: Would you explain
this section?


Lomer Gouin: Under the law
at present, fees are paid to the officer, and he is not required to account to the province. As the provinces have charge of the whole administration of this law-they give their court houses and their officers and so on-it is proposed that the fees paid to the registrar should be paid by the registrar to the province, and the province will pay a salary to the officers. The same obtains under the election law.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
Lomer Gouin: I have an amendment to propose to paragraph " o " of section 2. The act authorizes the continuation of proceedings instituted under the Winding-up Act, before or after the coming into force of the Bankruptcy Act, after leave of the court is obtained. A decision was rendered by the Court of Appeal for Ontario, where it was decided that leave could not be granted by a judge in bankruptcy, in case of a corporation being insolvent, to bring the case from the Bankruptcy Act to the Winding-up Act, and it is to remove a doubt on that point that we propose that paragraph " o " of section 2 of the Bankruptc y Act, Chapter 36 of the Statutes of 1919, as enacted by Section 2 of Chapter 34 of the Statutes of 1920, be amended by ading thereto the following-[DOT]
Moreover an order of the court, whether made heretofore or hereatfer, granting leave to extend or apply to any such corporation the Winding-up Act shall not be invalid or subject to any objection by reason only that the corporation had previously made an assignment under the provisions of this act, or that proceeding in bankruptcy under this act were at the time pending against the. corporation, and in any such case the provisions of the Winding-up Act shall apply and prevail, and the bankruptcy proceedings shall abate subject to such disposition of the costs thereof, to be made in the winding-up proceedings as the justice of the case may require.

This covers the cases which were instituted before and on which doubts have arisen.
Section, as amended, agreed to.
Bill, reported, and read the third time and passed.



ESCHEATS ACT AMENDMENT BILL

[Stage Direction]
House again in committee on Bill No. 124, to amend the Escheats Act, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
On Section 1.-Escheat extended to property of defunct corporations:
Daniel Duncan McKenzie: We had a discussion
of this bill a couple of days ago, and the hon. senior member for St. John (Mr. Baxter) took exception to the term of two years mentioned in the bill. After consulting my colleagues, I have agreed to change the time to five years, in order to meet the suggestion of my hon. friend.


Hugh Guthrie: Then the word "two"
on page 2, line 3, should also be stricken out.


Daniel Duncan McKenzie: Yes. I move that the
word "two" in line 31, page 1 of the bill, be stricken out, and the word "five" be substituted therefore; and that the word "two", in the third line on page 2, be stricken out and the word "five" substituted therefor. .
Section, as amended, agreed to.
Bill, reported, and read the third time and passed.



TRADE AND COMMERCE

[Stage Direction]
The House in Committee of Supply, Mr. Gordon in the Chair.
Trade and Commerce-Canada rnd the West Indies or South America or both, service or services between, $340,666.66.
Henry Herbert Stevens: I desire to bring to the attention of the minister a matter of great importance. I have reference to the establishment of a steamship service between the Atlantic and Pacific Canadian ports. There are certain classes of cargo which it does not pay at all to ship across the continent by rail. One of these is lumber. It is true we do ship by rail into Ontario a good deal of lumber of the more expensive kind, but the rate is so high that it is almost prohibitive. Large quantities of southern pine are also imported into that province. By the establishment of a steamship service we could ship cargoes of lum-

Steamship Services
ber around by the Panama canal route to Toronto. Indeed, I think we shipped twenty or thirty million feet to Toronto for harbour works within the last few years, which shows the feasibility of such a service. The difficulty is that we have not a regular steamship service. There is another matter that I would bring to the attention of the minister (Mr. Kobb), and also to the attention of the Minister of Railways (Mr. Kennedy, Essex), under whose department the operation of the steamships no doubt comes. The service from the Atlantic to the Pacific ports would touch the West Indies and points in Mexico. It could take traffic from eastern Canada to those ports, picking up cargoes through the West Indies and in Mexico and carrying them to the Pacific coast, and the reverse on the return trip. We have a market in the West Indies for many of our commodities, such as fish of all classes, and canned goods, lumber, shingles and, when we can get space, hay and oats. And there are many classes of goods that we require from the West Indies and from Mexico. I believe our various commercial bodies are strongly of the opinion that a service of this kind is necessary. The difficulty up to about a year or so ago has been the lack of shipping facilities; there were not sufficient vessels. That is not the case to-day. Now there are more than we have use for. There was, I believe, a question in the mind of the management of the Canadian Government Merchant Marine that we ought to demonstrate beyond any doubt that the cargoes were there. That is not the way in which steamship services are to be established on new routes. I should like to see the minister put on a regular service for a while. He has some vessels of 5,000 ton register and he might give one or two of them a chance to prove their usefulness. I recall an objection that was raised to the effect that this would be taking traffic from the railways. I do not think this objection is sound. The freight on the railway from coast to coast is so exceedingly high that, except in the case of package freight, the railways would not be affected by such a steamship service at all. From the eastern states a great deal of freight is shipped into the Pacific province by the American railways. We get none of the haulage in Canada at all. A lot of that freight could be picked up by these vessels at New York, and that would not only be helping the marine but it would at the same time be extending the trade of the country. I 192
would urge this matter very strongly upon the minister's attention.


Mr. GARLAND (Bow River):: Would the hon. member suggest that a subsidy be paid to the line he proposes?


Henry Herbert Stevens: At the moment I am not suggesting a subsidy. I suggest, however, that the Government might use one or two or more of their idle ships many of which are now lying, I understand, in the port of Montreal. If any hon. member thinks that the proposal is not a wise one, let me inform the committee that the Pacific end of the Government Merchant Marine has been fairly successful. We have had very excellent results from its operation on the Pacific and if we opened up the route I suggest I have no doubt it would be successful and would ultimately pay well.


Edward Joseph Garland: Are there any vessels of the Canadian Government Merchant Marine calling at ports that are now being served by the steamships that are subsidized by the Government, or at neighbouring ports?


Mr. ROBB:: Not regularly.


Edward Joseph Garland: Do they sometimes call at those ports?


James Alexander Robb: They have done so occasionally.


Edward Joseph Garland: In other words, I take it, we have a steamship line subsidized by the Government operating in competition with the Canadian Government Marine.


Mr. MACLEAN (Halifax) :: The reverse is right.


James Alexander Robb: My hon. friend (Mr. Garland) , who is a new member of t'he House, is probably not aware that we entered into a trade arrangement with the West Indies which provided for a subsidized service with certain equipment for carrying the products of the West Indies to Canada and for the transportation of mails to and from the Mest Indies. If my hon. friend has looked into the question he must know that Canada enjoys a considerable percentage of customs preference with the West Indies, with which she is developing an increasing trade. It was because of that increasing trade that within the past year Or so the Canadian Merchant Marine management put their boats on to get some of the business that had been worked up by subsidized lines-lines started many years be-



Steamship Services
fore we had a merchant marine. Indeed, we have had complaints from this subsidized line that unless we call off the Canadian government service their boats would be unable to continue the (Service at the subsidy we were giving them. It is important that we should retain that subsidized service because of the trade we enjoy. We have made no attempt to interfere with the work of the Canadian Merchant Marine. Our vessels were no't built for passenger service1, and the service we have agreed to establish between the West Indies and Canada calls for reasonably good passenger accommodation.
Regarding the point raised by my hon. friend from Centre Vancouver (Mr. Stevens), I know that he has taken a great deal of interest in it, and has made representations to the Government, and we are alive to the importance of giving the project very careful consideration. The opening up of the Panama canal introduces new channels of trade as between the East and the West. I am not prepared to-night to say what the policy of the Governinent will be; it is more a matter for consideration by my hon. friend the Minister of Railways and Canals (Mr. Kennedy), but I think the Government will take into consideration the representations made by my hon. friend, and if the line should look profitable, something may result.


Edward Joseph Garland: Being a new member, Mr. Chairman, I have not yet become accustomed to the delightful sarcasm of my hon. friend, the Minister of Trade and Commerce. I protest against the continuation of this subsidy of $340,000 odd to a steamship line between Canada and the West Indies when we have a merchant marine some of which are already engaged on this route. The minister mentioned that our boats cannot be used in this service because they are not equipped with passenger accommodation. I understand that when the matter came up in the House last year Sir George Foster, the then Minister of (Trade and 'Commerce, stated that two of our boats had been equipped with passenger accommodation.
I might also call the (attention of the minister to the fact that last year, when in opposition, the present Solicitor General i Mr. McKenzie) took exception to the continuation of this subsidy. The remarks he made on that occasion are not very long, and I shall quote them. After stating that he

agreed very heartily with the point raised by Mr. Sinclair, he said:
The ipoint made by my hon. friend (Mr. Sinclair) is perfectly clear. We have an item of $340,366.60 for a line to the West Indies and South America. Now, we are told that we have our own boats serving a part of that route, so that we are in competition with the vessels running there. Yet the Government is so exceedingly generous that it gives to a company with whom it is competing for trade the sum of $340,000 odd. They gLve them that magnificent handicap and then boldly and proudly step up and say: We will get plenty of profit notwithstanding this handicap we are giving them. Does it strike my hen. friend as good business that we should be spending $75,000,000 of the people's money in the building of boats and in looking for trade and then when we find an old service established on this route which we intend to work, instead of trying to displace those competitors, give them a subsidy?
I sincerely trust that the Solicitor General has not altered his mind on this question, and I hope to get some support from him in my opposition to this particular item.
With regard to the contention raised by the minister that this subsidy was necessary because of the extent of our trade with the West Indies, I find that up to the end of the fiscal year, 1922, our import trade amounted to $8,113,000, while in 1917 it was $14,239,000. In fact, the figures received from the department indicate that there has been a falling off in our trade with the West Indies since 1917 to the extent of $6,125,000. If we take 1918 and compare the figures with this year we observe a falling off of $2,437,000. In the export trade there is a deficiency of about $4,000,000 over last year. I am not comparing the figures for this year alone with those for last year alone, because I agree with the contention-which no doubt will be raised-that last year was an exceptionally bad year, there being a great depression in the sugar industry and a consequent falling off in the value of the imports from the West Indies. But going back to 1917 and 1918, you find an appalling falling off of that business. There are reasons for that decline, Mr. Chairman. I believe that the British Undersecretary for the Colonies, Mr. Wood, is about to pay a visit to the West Indies to endeavour to co-ordinate their trade relations with other countries. It seems that at the present time there are-I do not know how many governments down there, but there are quite a large number of them; for instance, the Leeward Islands, the Windward Islands, British Honduras,

Steamship Services
the Bahamas, and so on, are all under separate governments, have separate trade regulations and different tariffs-
I am sorry to say, Mr. Chairman, that they have actually got tariffs down there. Mr. Wood is of the opinion that trade with the British West Indies is a matter of great difficulty, that it must be done in small parcels, in many cases hardly worth handling, particularly in view of the additional fact that as one of the direct results of this lack of co-operation no adequate shipping arrangements exist either between the United Kingdom and her Caribbean Colonies or between the Islands themselves. We are endeavouring to establish something in the way of shipping arrangements with the West Indies, but I would call the minister's attention to the fact that there are no adequate shipping arrangements between these different islands. In short, when a ship goes down to pick up a cargo it has to jump from one place three or four hundred miles to another place; there is no such thing as co-operation for trade purposes.
I might also call the minister's attention to the fact that the board of directors of the Canadian Government Merchant Marine in their report last year refer to the West Indies service on which they have boats and state:
It must be remembered in connection with this service that the Canadian Government Merchant Marine are pioneers in opening up a new route with a view to developing and extending Canada's trade. As it has been the practice of many governments to supplement the earnings of companies engaged in this work, and as steamship subsidies are paid by the Dominion Government for services that are much more remunerative than this West Indies service, it would only be reasonable that your company should be guaranteed against loss when engaged as in this case, in opening up a new route at the request of the Government.
The Canadian Merchant Marine is now appealing for subsidies, Mr. Chairman! There might have been some excuse for granting subsidies in the old days before we had our own merchant marine, but I submit that the practice should now cease. The minister raises the point that our merchant marine cannot be equipped for passenger service, but Sir George Foster says it can, and that two of the boats are already so equipped. They can also be equipped for cold storage. At the present time our trade with the West Indies must oniy be a summer trade, for we have no warehousing facilities for a winter trade; but it has been recently suggested that there
should be in South America, at a point of call on the way back from the West Indies, warehousing facilities established so you could take in your West Indian trade during the winter as well as summer. I call the minister's attention to one other remark made by Mr. Stollmeyer, speaking at a meeting of the Agricultural Society in Trinidad. He said:
We have in the Canadian Government Merchant Marine a means of transport which needs encouragement.
I heartily agree with the statement of that gentleman; it needs encouragement, and we might encourage it. The attitude of the Canadian manufacturers has, unfortunately, a great deal to do with the difficulty of this trade. It seems to be very difficult to get return cargoes.


An hon. MEMBER:: Carried.


Edward Joseph Garland: My hon. friends seem to be in a hurry; they always are when we touch the manufacturers. Mr. Jones, president of the Canada Cement Company, whom the manufacturers will have a great deal of respect for, lately returned from South America. Discussing an address that had been made with regard to trade with South America and the West Indies, he sai:
What struck me most forcibly was the one
sided view Canadian business men took on thes questions of import and export.
You cannot expect the West Indies to accept your imports unless you accept her exports.
I think the time has come, Mr. Chairman when we might cut out this subsidy. 1 am sure that it would be of great assistance to the Minister of Finance (Mr. Fielding) if we did so.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: My hon. friend (Mr. Garland) has stated that this country might well dispense with further subsidies to steamship services. That may be true as a general principle, but there are many cases in which it is quite proper and profitable for a country to subsidize a steamship service. At any rate, the reason my hon. friend gives for the abandonment of a subsidy to this service is not a sound one. He says the subsidies should not be further paid because we have a Canadian Merchant Marine. I say we should abandon our merchant marine and leave the carrying on of this service to private companies, even if we have to give them a subsidy; in the end it would be much cheaper for the country. I hope the Gov-
Steamship Services

eminent will very shortly make an effort to get rid of the steamships which they own and which they are operating at a very heavy loss-a loss which this country cannot very long sustain. I should like to point out further that many years ago a trade convention was negotiated between Canada and the British West Indies; I think it was some time between 1904 and 1908. Under that convention the West Indies received preferential treatment from Canada and we received preferential treatment in the West Indian markets. It was a part of that convention that we should establish a regular steamship service between Canada and the West Indies, suitable for the carrying of passengers and of the mails. I think the West India Islands contribute some small amount to the cost of this service. Now, the Canadian Merchant Marine are not capable of carrying out this service ac cording to the terms of that trade convention. The service between Canada and the West Indies has been a good thing for Canada and a good thing for the West Indies; therefore, I say we cannot look upon the matter as one involving merely the question of subsidy; it is tied up with the convention treaty with the West Indies. I suppose some steamship service would be carried on between Canada and the West Indies by private interests if there was no subsidized service, but it would not be a regular service. Our trade with the West Indies has been built up largely because of the fact that on a certain day every two weeks of the year a steamship sails from a Canadian port to the West Indies and on a certain day a steamship leaves a port in the West Indies for Canada. The Canadian exporters rely upon the regularity of the service, and the result is that Canadian trade has been very much built up. In that respect, therefore, there is some advantage in having (this subsidized service.
My hon. friend further stated that there had been a great diminution in export and import trade between the West Indies and Canada, and he compared the figures of last year with those of 1917-18. I have not studied the figures; I had not heard them until they were cited by my hon. friend. But I have no doubt that there were very good reasons for that decline in our trade with the West Indies when expressed in dollars. The products of the West Indies in 1917 were very high priced compared with those of to-day; Canadian products exported to the West Indies were very much

higher in price than they are to-day. A statement of the tonnage of this year as compared with that of 1917 would be a truer reflection of the volume of trade being carried on to-day as compared with that carried on in 1917. The decrease in the prices of commodities would explain a great deal of the difference between the figures for this year and those for 1917-18. It may be said also that the decline in this trade is owing partly to the world-wide depression which has prevailed.
I should like to say just a few words to the minister. I understand that this subsidized service between the Wes! Indies and Canada was renewed e few months ago for two years more Trade between Canada and the Wes' Indies has developed so much in recent years that the present four steamers engaged in that service are hardly sufficient to meet the trade requirements, and in other respects the boats used are not equal to the demands for passenger service. The contract is with the Royal Mail Steam Packet Company. They are quite willing to build four new steamers. They realize that the present boats are hardly fitted for the business to-day, but they do not feel warranted in proceeding with the construction of new boats unless they are sure that they are to have a contract covering a considerable period of time. It would take some time to complete the construction of two or three boats, and I think it is only fair that they should be advised as soon as possible whether or not the contract is to be renewed for a definite and extended period.
As I have said, I do not think that this service could be carried on without a subsidy. The people of the West Indies insist upon a passenger service, and that could not be carried on except by subsidized boats.


Joseph Tweed Shaw: Does my hon. friend suggest that the Canadian Merchant Marine cannot come up to the requirements set out in the statute embodying the Canada-West Indies trade agreement?


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: No; they have no steamers suitable for carrying on the service. They are not fitted with passenger accommodation, and their deck construction is not fitted for the carrying on of trade in tropical countries. It is true that some of these steamers might be reconstructed to meet demands of that character.

Steamship Services


Edward Joseph Garland: I am
afraid the hon. member is a little in error in this matter. Some of our merchant marine have already been equipped for passenger service.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: A very
limited service indeed. They would not be equal to the passenger demands that are made on the subsidized boats.


Edward Joseph Garland: There is
no reason why they should not be. They have been equipped for this very service to the West Indies. I would also submit to the minister that last year the then Minister of Trade and Commerce (Sir George Foster) stated-definitely, as appears on page 1488 of Hansard, that this subsidy was simply being continued for another year in order to give an opportunity of getting an improved weekly service. The department has had a whole year in which to think it over, and I now move, Mr. Chairman, that this item be struck out.


Mr. DUFF:: We are very glad indeed to hear the hon. member from Bow River discuss the service between Halifax and the West Indies. It seems to me that before moving to strike out this item, he should try and find out what he is talking about. In making his motion, he shows that he is entirely without knowledge of the facts concerning this service, and when he talks about the Canadian Government Merchant Marine vessels being able to carry on this service, he shows he knows absolutely nothing about the subject. Will my hon. friend believe me when I say that the Canadian Government Merchant Marine vessels can carry only eighteen passengers, while the Royal Mail steamers carry two hundred? During the winter months these subsidized boats are full to capacity with people from Montreal, Quebec, and other parts of Quebec, going south to winter in the Bahamas and other islands in the West Indies. Yet the hon. member from Bow River, three thousand miles from the coast, comes here and tells the committee that these boats are not required, and that the subsidy should be cut off.


Edward Joseph Garland: I did not
say that the service was not required, but that the subsidy was unjustifiable, and I still maintain that.


William Duff: What reason can you give
for cutting off the subsidy?


Edward Joseph Garland: I have
given my reasons.


William Duff: The hon. member has given no sound reason whatever. He knows nothing about it. This service cannot be carried on without a subsidy. It is a very important service to the people of Canada, and just as important to the people living in the hon. member's province as it is to people in the East because these boats carry flour, cereals and other products of Western Canada to the West Indies. These boats leave Halifax fortnightly for the West Indies carrying passengers and mails and Canadian products, and bring back from the West Indies good? which are required in Canada. If the subsidy is cut off, these boats will not be able to carry on the service, and therefore I would ask the hon. member to withdraw his motion.


Charles Marcil: The
amendment of the hon. member for Bow River, being simply negative, is out of order. His remedy, if he is opposed to the item, is to vote against it.


James Alexander Robb: I should like to convince my hon. friend from Bow River that he should support the item as presented. It is quite true that the intimation was made that the contract was expiring and that new tenders were to be asked for, but the purpose in asking for new tenders was to provide an even better service, so as to carry out our obligations to the West Indies under the treaty that was made. As has already been intimated iby the hon. member for Lunenburg (Mr. Duff) Canadians go down to the West Indies in the winter season, and West Indies come up to Canada in the summer season, and i is just possible when my hon. friend goes home he may run across some West Indians who have come to the foothills of the Rockies to escape the heat of the southern clime.


Edward Joseph Garland: I will
let the minister know if I find any.


James Alexander Robb: For the information of my hon. friend from Halifax (Mr. Maclean) the government in September last called for tenders, which were opened on the 31st of January. The only tender received was from the Royal Mail Steam Packet Company, which asked for a net return of 71 per cent on the investment. That was more than the government would agree to, so to carry out our obligations to the people of the West Indies and continue the service, we have simply renewed the old agreement for a period of two years. In the mean-
Steamship Services

time we shall see what will develop. My hon. friend from Vancouver Centre to-night has introduced another idea, which with other suggestions will be taken into consideration. I am sure that when the Minister of Railways takes up his estimates, he will satisfy the hon. member for Bow River that there are no vessels in the merchant marine equipped to carry out the promise we made to the West Indies when they gave us a preference in that market.


Mr. CRERAR:: Has the minister reference to the treaty negotiated the year before last with the West Indies?


James Alexander Robb: Yes.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: It was just a renewal of the old treaty.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: In reference to the item before us, this subsidy is given, I understand, in view of the treaty. Of course, this Government must carry out the obligations that have been entered into with the West Indies. The question whether the subsidy is justified or not might be debatable, but I think that the carrying out of our obligations under the treaty is an aspect of the question that my hon. friend from Bow River did not take into account when he moved to strike out the item. Those obligations must be lived up to.
As to the Government Merchant Marine, my own view is that those vessels should be used wherever they can be used to carry on the trade of this country, but they were not built as passenger vessels. The Government Merchant Marine was built as a freight marine, and consequently the vessels are not equipped for the particular trade between Canada and the West Indies at the present time. The people of Nova Scotia and of eastern Canada generally who are prosperous can afford to spend a few months in the West Indies in the winter.


James Alexander Robb: I have met some Winnipegers down there too.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: There may be also some from the remote West who can afford to go to the West Indies during our cold winter. I believe entirely in the development of trade with the West Indies and with the outside world wherever we can develop it. I hope to see that trade expand and grow. I might draw the attention of the committee to this fact, and I have mentioned it when this question was under consideration in preceding sessions, that it is rather inconsistent to subsidize 
steamships for the promotion of trade with other countries and at the same time maintain a system of tariffs that makes trade with those countries almost impossible. I think that when my hon. friend the Minister of Trade and Commerce gives this question that careful thought and study that he gives to problems that come before his deparment, he will realize the truth of what I say, and I am very hopeful that when another session comes round he will be among the ardent supporters in this House of a substantial reduction in the tariff.


Lewis Herbert Martell: 
James Alexander Robb: This is the first time the matter has been drawn to my attention; I will look into it.


Edward Joseph Garland: It causes me great regret to realize that owing to my remarks I have incurred the contumely of the hon. member for Lunenburg (Mr. Duff). As a general rule his criticisms are directed at the leader of the Opposition (Mr. Meighen).


William Duff: That is a very smart observation on the part of the hon. gentleman.


Edward Joseph Garland: I feel
very flattered to know that the remarks directed at me also apply to the Solicitor General (Mr. McKenzie), because the latter last year raised the same point that I have raised to-night. On that occasion the Solicitor General protested against the continuance of this subsidy. He stated his reasons very clearly and I have read them to the committee, but I suppose the hon. member for Lunenburg was not in the House at the time. With regard to the point raised by the hon. member for Marquette (Mr. Crerar) the agreement between this country and the Canadian government does not call for a subsidized steamship line, it calls for a steamship freight and passenger service. On the other hand it is declared that if a subsidized service is arranged for, then something else will berequired. Whatwill be required is that the governments of the colonies in question shall arrange for bungalows, hotels, and other accommodation for the class of passengers that are carried on these vessels. I am sorry that unfortunately conditions in the West will prevent me from going to the West Indies and taking advantage of this kind of accommodation.


An hon. MEMBER:: Why not go to
California?


Edward Joseph Garland: Nor shall I be able to go even to that land of sunshine; I must remain in Canada under present conditions of agriculture. I repeat that all that is asked for in the agreement referred to is that the government of Canada shall use its best endeavours to arrange for a passenger and freight service to go into effect as soon as possible. It is not necessary to have this service subsidized.


Mr. MacLAREN (St. John) :: The vessels now subsidized by the Canadian government run from Halifax to the West Indies, and in return from the West Indies to St. John, and cater for freight and passengers. There is considerable freight, and also a very considerable number of passengers, carried by that line. I know this because the service comes under my observation regularly every year. The suggestion advanced by an hon. gentleman to my left is that this trade could be done by the vessels of the Government Merchant Marine. I would like to point out that those vessels were built for the carriage of freight not for the carriage of passengers. Now the accommodation for passengers on the service between the West Indies and St. John and Halifax must be suitable. It must also be comfortable; otherwise, it would not be used. I do not think it at all likely that the freight boats owned by the government could be made suitable for the comfort and convenience of passengers. I am therefore of the opinion that in this case the subsidies should be continued in order to provide a suitable and popular service between the West Indies and the ports of Halifax and St. John.


William Charles Good: How is the amount of this subsidy determined? Was there any competition before the amount was arrived at? I think we ought to know at least that we are protected in the matter of the amount of this subsidy.


James Alexander Robb: The contract was renewed at the same rate that had prevailed heretofore.


William Charles Good: How do we know that the subsidy is not five times too large?


James Alexander Robb: As a matter of fact the company demanded a higher rate. We advertised for tenders and their's was the lowest, indeed the only, tender that was received in public competition.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: The contract was originally put up for tender?


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
Steamship Services
[Stage Direction]
Canada and Australian or New Zealand, or both, on the Pacific ocean, steam service between, $130,509.
Joseph Tweed Shaw: I notice that the imports from New Zealand have decreased very rapidly and are back to the figures of 1912. I would like to know if the minister has had this fact under his consideration in connection with the giving of this particular subsidy? As a matter of fact the imports into this country from New Zealand last year totalled only $783,500 as compared with something like over $7,000,000 worth at one time.


James Alexander Robb: I think your figures axe incorrect. The figures appear to be-
1914	 $3,000,000
1920. .		 3,494,000
1921	 4,219,000


Joseph Tweed Shaw: For the year ending 31st March, 1922, according to the figures furnished by the department, the amount was $1,000,000 odd.


James Alexander Robb: Yes. Perhaps my hon. friend will agree with me that it may be more a shrinkage of value than of tonnage.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: To whom were these subsidies paid for the Australian serivice?


James Alexander Robb: They were paid to the Union Steamship Company of New Zealand, and the agents of this company are the Cana-dian-Australian Royal Mail Line.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: How long was the contract for?
Mr. ROB'B: This contract expires on July 31st, 1922. The service is also subsidized by the postal authorities of England, who recently inquired if we would be willing to extend the contract until March 31st, 1924, so that our contract should run concurrently with theirs, and we agreed to that. This contract has been renewed until March 31st, 1924, and1 this service forms the only connection between Canada and New Zealand.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: In respect to a great many of these subsidies, I think the Government would be well advised to take into consideration, if not the total abrogation, at any rate, a reduction, of some of them. I think there are cases where subsidies are justified, but it is a very easy matter, when you have developed the habit of giving subsidies, to continue giving them, whether the case merits it or not, and the services now between Australia, New Zealand and Canada are pretty well looked after by various

steamship lines. There is competition in the service, and when you get competition of an active kind in a service, surely the need for subsidies must disappear. That does not exist in the case of a subsidy we were considering to the West Indies a few moments ago, but, in the case where, practically one continent is trading with another continent, there should be sufficient competition, so that subsidies should not be necessary to maintain the necessary services, and I trust the 'Government will take that fact into their careful consideration, as these subsidies expire.


James Alexander Robb: There is very much force in the argument of my hon. friend from Marquette (Mr. Crerar). Indeed this particular subsidy bas been decreased. It was $180,000 and it has been reduced to $130,-
000.	There is much farce in the argument that as trade develops they should be selfsustaining.


William Charles Good: For how many years Will these contracts run as a rule? How long are we tied up by them?


James Alexander Robb: Some of these contracts are given for a period of years. This particular one extends for two years, until March 31st, 1924, but in all these contracts there is a clause stating that it is subject to a vote by Parliament, so that, if Parliament to-night refuses to vote the amount, it Is cancelled.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
Pelee Island and the mainland-steam service between, $11,000.
Thomas Alexander Crerar: Where is Pelee Island?


James Alexander Robb: On Lake Erie.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
Quebec, Natashquan and Harrington, and Bras d'Or and other ports on the north shore of the gulf of St. Lawrence, steam service between, $85,000.
Thomas Alexander Crerar: There is an increase in that?


James Alexander Robb: That provides for an increased service. It is a considerably better service. Last year there was one steamer employed in the service. The contractors this year have put on two vessels, the North Shore and the Labrador, with which they are performing a weekly service, running the North Shore every two weeks to Natashquan, calling at Anticosti Island, and running the Labrador every two weeks

Steamship Services
to Harrington and other way ports between Harrington and Bras d'Or hay. This extension of this service to Bras d'Or bay is expected to divert the trade of that part of the coast which in the past has been going to Newfoundland, to Canada, and in view of the fact that this increase has been given to the North Shore service, the contractors have, although it is not so specified in the contract, much improved their south shore service, having put on a large new steamer, the Gaspesia, of about 1,200 tons.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: What is the real need for this subsidy, or is there any? It seems to me rather a remarkable thing that steamships running up and down the gulf of St. Lawrence should require a subsidy.


James Alexander Robb: Yes, if there is one service in all the list that is needed, it is this service. It extends 626 miles east from Quebec city, down along the north shore of the St. Lawrence, where there is no railway. There are settlers established along there, and the service has developed industries along the coast.


William Duff: It is the only communication they have with the outside world.


Mr. CASGRAIN:: Will the minister do something to extend and improve the service between Murray Bay and Tadoussac? On the 11th April last year I introduced a resolution, urging upon the Government the establishment of a steamboat service between Murray Bay and Tadoussac, especially for the winter months, or from November to May. Last year, when the late government was in office, we were refused the service because it was claimed it was not necessary. This year I have presented to the Government petitions from all the boards of trade in the county, but, up to the present time, I have not received any favourable answer. I think the hon. minister might give me an answer.


James Alexander Robb: It is only fair to say to my hon. friend from Charlevoix-Montmorency (Mr. Casgrain) that he has bombarded my office, I would not say every day, but, at least, once a week, since the opening of the session, and knowing, as you all know, what a nice pleasant chap he is, you can understand how hard it is to resist his demands. We have subsidized a small service from St. Catharine's bay to Tadoussac for the winter season. That was passed some time ago. I understand he wants a somewhat wider service, but I think he will have to
exercise patience for, at least, this year. I will not commit myself to what will be done next year.


Joseph Philippe Baby Casgrain: The people living between Muray Bay and Tadoussac have no good railway service, and no good roads, especially in the winter season; therefore, this steam service is very necessary for them and would serve a useful purpose.


James Alexander Robb: We will take it under consideration.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
St. John and Digby, steam service between, $15,000.
Thomas Alexander Crerar: That is across the bay of Fundy?


James Alexander Robb: Yes.


Robert James Manion: What is the explanation for the increase?


James Alexander Robb: The subsidy in 1920-21 was $20,000. Then it was reduced to $10,000. The company has submitted a statement showing a very heavy operating loss amounting to nearly $100,000 in three years, and it states that unless the subsidy is increased the service will be discontinued. It is the only service these people have.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
Sydney and Whycocomagh, steam service between, $7,000.
Robert James Manion: What are the particulars of this item?


James Alexander Robb: This is one of the oldest services that we have subsidized. It was carried on by an old steamer, the Marion, and the directors have been endeavouring to secure a new boat. In consideration of a new and better steamer being put on the route we promised a subsidy of |$7,000, bult they have been unable so far to secure such a steamer. The Marion is being repaired, and in view of the expense involved in the work we have consented to pay them $5,000, and have also agreed that if they succeed in getting a better steamer we will pay them the $7,000.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
RAILWAY® AND CANALS
Railways and Canals-Loan to the Canadian Government Merchant Marine, $4,360,720.
Hon. W. C. KENNEDY (Minister of Railways and Canals):: The amount required for payment of bank advances,



Supply-Merchant Marine
outstanding vouchers, and insurance premiums, payable as at the 31st December, 1921, was $3,000,000. The estimated amount required to meet deficit in operations, on the basis of operating thirty-seven vessels for the year ending 31st December, 1922, is $1,000,000, and to carry on to the end of the fiscal year ending March 31st, 1923, there is an additional estimate for the three months of $250,000, making a total of $1,250,000. The amount required for capital expenditure on the vessels is $110,720, making a total in all, as outlined in the estimates, of $4,360,720.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: What is the nature of the capital expenditure of $110,000 odd?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: I will read the particulars.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: Is the amount properly chargeable to capital?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Yes, these
items are: Two propellers at $5,500 each, $11,000; superheater, $11,500; steam driers, 20 at $150 each, $3,000; soot blowers, 20 at $1,366, $27,320; governors, 20 at $1,100, $22,000; intakes 4 at $600, $2,400; winches, 14 at $1,100, $15,400;-


Thomas Alexander Crerar: That is quite enough.


George Newcombe Gordon: Carried.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: Before you write that "carried", Mr. Chairman, I want to ask another question. . I do not recall any statement of the operations of the merchant marine having been submitted this session. Will such a statement be included in the annual report of the Canadian National Railways, which I understand has been published?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: The report
of the Canadian National Railways will be tabled in a day or two and, incorporated in it, a statement in regard to the merchant marine for the past year.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: A statement showing
profit and loss in operation?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Yes, and
giving the report of the directors.


Mr. McBRIDE:: I think we ought to
have some information in connection with the merchant marine.


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: I shall be
glad to give my hon. friend any information he requires to-night.


Thomas George McBride: I would like to know what you are going to do with the mer-
:Mr. W. C. Kennedy.)
chant marine? You have sixty-five boats and those of less than 5,000 tons, I think, will never pay. I do not think they will pay operating expenses. These boats are deteriorating in value all the time. I do not think they should be kept by the Government.


An hon. MEMBER:: There is no doubt about that.


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: I may tell
the hon. member that his views coincide with those of the board of directors of the National Railways. There are twenty-seven smaller vessels which they propose to lay up this year twenty of which are in fact laid up at the present time. It is the intention to dispose of them to the best possible advantage, retaining the larger ones for the time being. This matter, as in the past, will be dealt with by the board of directors.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: The construction of these ships has been criticised by some people, but it was a policy initiated during the war, and might very well be looked upon as an insurance premium against national loss. The construction of the ships was undertaken at a time when it looked as though the German submarine warfare would be most disastrous to British shipping the world over. It was the desire of the British government as well that Canada should at that time construct ships, and the policy was supported by every member in Parliament as well as by the Canadian people at large. The policy had reference only to the construction of ships to bridge us over the imminent danger that existed at that time. It was never the settled policy of the government that they should] continue the ownership and operation of these vessels, and I think that the Government should divest itself of that ownership. The vessels are being operated at a tremendous loss, and it is the experience and the judgment of those men who are best able to speak on such matters that government operation of ships must inevitably be carried on at a loss. The United States constructed about 1,500 ships for the same reasons that we built 60 or 70. About 1,000 of those ships are now laid up in the ports of the United States. The others are being operated at a net annual loss of $50,000,000. The policy of the United States is to get rid of these ships just as soon as they can, but they find it rather difficult to do so. The head of the United States Shipping Board, in an address delivered lately at Washington, stated that in his judgment it was not

Supply-Merchant Marine
sound public policy for the people of the United States to further continue the operation of these ships by the government.
Now, I submit that it is not fair for us to have government-operated ships in competition with shipping services originated, developed and carried on by private companies which have devoted much time and money to the building up of their business. They find themselves in the position of facing the competition of government-owned boats operating at a loss, which loss they, the owners of these privately operated ships, have to help pay.
Last year I called attention to the fact that there were two or three steamship lines operating between Canada and Newfoundland, none of which are subsidized. These services were started many years ago and there is a great deal of Canadian money invested in them. The Canadian Merchant Marine saw fit to enter into competition with these long-established services when those services were quite capable of handling all the business that was offering. The result is that these privately owned services are being slowly destroyed, they cannot stand this one-sided competition much longer, and ultimately they will have to go out of business altogether. In a year or so our government-owned boats will be worn out, and we certainly will never embark on a construction policy again. Consequently we will have no service at all between our ports and Newfoundland, and the time, energy and money put into the development of these privately-established services will be absolutely lost and we shall not have gained anything in return. If we ever hope to establish a merchant marine our only chance is in encouraging private capital to embark in the enterprise.
Now, what should be done with our government-owned ships? I would suggest to the Minister of Railways that he immediately take into consideration the advisability of parting ownership with them. I would advise him to endeavour to sell the ships to Canadians so they may be under Canadian registry if possible. If proposing purchasers have not the money to pay down, I would advise him to take a mortgage for the full amount of the purchase price, asking the purchasers, of course, to insure the ships up to the amount of the mortgage. I think it would be preferable to get rid of these ships rather than operate them through government agencies. In the event of his not being able
to sell them, I would suggest that he turn over their operation to Canadian shipping companies. It is not sound business to be operating these ships at a loss of $10,000,000 a year. And they never will pay their way. It is the one class of business that a government is absolutely unfitted to engage in. You can make an argument in favour of government ownership and operation of railways, because the railway business is in the nature of a monopoly, but in shipping free trade exists, and there is more than enough tonnage to-day to do the world's shipping business. Our shipping needs can be amply met if we dispense with our government-owned boats and depend on the service which the shipping of the world to-day affords.
I cannot conceive of any sound reason justifying further continuance of the operation of these ships by the Government. I am not entering any complaint against the management. I have no doubt they are doing the best they can and are zealous in the development of the service; but unfortunately there is the result, and it always will be that way. If there was any national interest being served by continuing our ownership and operation I might submit to the policy, I suppose, but in the circumstances I cannot see any justification whatever for such continuation, and I hope if the Minister of Railways has not already power to dispose of these ships, that he take steps before the session ends to secure the necessary enabling powers to deal with any possible situation that may develop in connection with their disposal.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: With a great deal of what my hon. friend the senior member for Halifax (Mr. Maclean) has said, I agree. He has stated the reasons, whether they were good reasons or not at the time, that led to the building of this merchant marine. Unquestionably the country cannot go on facing the heavy losses that result in the operation of these ships. A suggestion has been made by one of my hon. friends from British Columbia that the smaller vessels will prove of no value and should be disposed of. My hon. friend from Halifax would go further and dispose of the whole lot. It occurs to me that the larger vesesls might be of some use as complementary to the railway system which the country has. I do not know how far that would be justified on sound, business principles, but I do know that other transportation companies have water connection in ocean-going vessels, and I would suggest
Supply-Merchant Marine

to the minister not to display the eager haste which my hon. friend from Halifax counselled in disposing of these vessels, particularly the larger ones. I think the question of their disposition should be thoroughly inquired into.


Alexander Kenneth Maclean: If my hon. friend will allow me to interrupt a moment -I did intend to qualify my remarks somewhat in the direction indicated by him. It might be desirable, particularly if it be found difficult to dispose of the larger ships, to continue their operation in the ocean services. There is something to he said for that.


Thomas Alexander Crerar: That is what I had in mind. The whole situation should be carefully canvassed and examined before these vessels are disposed of at bargain-counter prices or given away to the first person who will take them. The smaller vessels will not be of service in that respect. I do not know whether it would be possible to make use of them on the lakes where smaller boats can be Used, but at any rate I agree with my hon. friend that this is a question which should receive the attention of the board of directors of the National Railways.
There is one other thought that I have to offer in that connection. Even if disposition of these vessels is made by sale, I do not know that the present time is best suited for the purpose. We know that trade has been depressed in the last few years greater than it has ever been in the memory of any within reach of my voice tonight. We believe that trade conditions are going to revive, and that in a few years' time the commercial world will be resuming operations on something like the old scale. Unquestionably at that time a greater demand for ships will arise. My suggestion to the minister would be not to act too hastily in this connection; it is possible that a year or two hence he would get a much better price for the vessels, or for those that the board of directors of the National Railways wished to sell, than could possibly be got at the present time.


Thomas Langton Church: Every country has to have a merchant marine in connection with the solution of its transportation problems. This matter was partly discussed in the debate on the naval estimates; the value of a merchant marine, not only for ordinary purposes of trade and commerce but in time of war, was brought out. One of the reasons why England is the great commercial country that she is to-day and has been for

centuries is found in the operations of her merchant marine. Drake, Frobisher, Hawkins-all these men were men of the merchant marine; their activities were the foundation of the great trade and commerce of the Mother Country. Australia and New Zealand have taken a leaf out of the Mother Country's book. The Government have said that they are going to give the National Railways a chance. What kind of chance is it going to be? If some of the papers in the Montreal district had their way, the National Railways would be under the control of the Canadian Pacific, and so would Canada's merchant marine; and it would be a sorry day for Canada if that took place. Look at what the United States are doing in an effort to solve their transportation problems; they have turned all their war plants into peace plants. Government ships as well as ships for private concerns are being built with a view to holding the great trade that came to the United States as a result of the war. Canada also took a leading part in the war; is she to dispose of her merchant marine, as has been suggested by the hon. member for Halifax (Mr. Maclean) ? It is true that these ships were built rather from the unemployment standpoint than from the economic standpoint; they cost a great deal more than the price at which they could have been purchased in the old land. But if we are to make a success of our National Railways we must provide feeders for them -ocean feeders as well as lake feeders. It is true that there have been deficits1, and we may expect them for some time to come. But take a case of private ownership: the Canadian Pacific did not pay when it was first started; not until ocean services, lake services and hotel services were added to the rail system was success achieved. I say that if we are to fulfil the important part we should play in the Empire in the future we must go out on the seven seas and secure our share of the world's trade. The people of the United States have had deficits in connection with their merchant marine. The same criticisms were offered in Australia but both in that country and in New Zealand the operations were extended and large surpluses were subsequently obtained. I am surprised, Mr. Chairman, at the carping criticism which has been offered in respect to this item. The minister has been doing the best he could; he has made very substantial progress and I think the committee should give the merchant marine a chance. If they

Supply-Merchant Marine
will not do that, then we may as well cut off the railways as well, because the two are interlocked. It has been established by evidence submitted to the Interstate Commerce Commission of the United States and by reports made to Congress and to the Senate at Washington that steam roads cannot operate profitably without feeders in the way of ocean and lake services. In my opinion this is a vote in the right direction; instead of being curtailed it ought to be increased. If these various services are operated on business lines there is no doubt in my mind that within a few years we shall have in them a great asset.


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Are any of the ships of the Canadian Merchant Marine engaged in carrying Canadian wheat and flour to the British market?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: I am not in a position to give an answer at the moment, but I am inclined to think they are not at present; they are not suitable for it.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: Is this the last railway item?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Yes.


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: May I be permitted to put a question to the minister under this head with regard to a railway matter?


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: Yes:


John Babington Macaulay Baxter: I would inquire whether the Government have had any proposal from the government of New Brunswick with reference to what is known as the Valley Railway? From answers to questions put some time ago in the House it appears that in the taking over of the Canadian Northern, Ontario was in effect relieved of obligations amounting to over $7,000,000; Manitoba of over $25,000,000; Saskatchewan, in connection with the Canadian Northern and the Grand Trunk Pacific, of over $28,000,000; Alberta, in connection with the same lines, of about $21,000,000; British Columbia of about $40,000,000. These obligations are being met by the federal government. The St. John
Valley Railway was built for the purpose of connecting the Transcontinental _ with the port of St. John. It was not completed according to the original design, owing to the intervention of the war and to largely increased costs. But I notice that with some reductions which have been made it stands on the books of the province at something less than $7,000,000. It has cost the province $340,000 by way of interest, and it has also occasioned some loss to the federal government as well. It would seem to me that in fairness this road, which was constructed, as I say for the purpose of connecting the Transcontinental with the port of St. John, should be assumed by the federal government. It means the addition of a very considerable burden in proportion to the roads the liability for which has been removed from the other provinces. In fact, I think every province except Quebec and Prince Edward Island has shared in relief, and I trust the province of New Brunswick will not go without some measure of relief.


Thomas George McBride: Now I do not wish to be misunderstood in what I have suggested. I did not suggest that the Government dispose of the larger vessels of 10,000 tons and up. I see no reason why they cannot be made profitable to this country, but the smaller vessels will never be an asset to Canada, and I think the Government should dispose of them.


Donald MacBeth Kennedy: There has,
so far as I know, been no definite proposal from the government of New Brunswick with respect to the sale of the railway to which my hon. friend from St. John refers. I did have an interview with two of the ministers, and that suggestion was made. The matter is now under consideration, but the Government is not in a position to say anything definite at the present time.


[Stage Direction]
Item agreed to.
On the motion of Mr. Fielding the House adjourned at 11.35 p.m.

[Stage Direction]
Abbreviations:	lr., 2r., 3r., = first, second, third reading. Admn.=Administration. Amdt.=
Amendment. Com. ^Committee. Dept.-Department. Div.-Division. Govt.- Government. M.=Motion. Neg.= Negative. Qu. = Question. Ref .= Reference. Rep. = Report. Res. = Resolution. Sec.=Section.
Abattoirs. See also Cold Storage; Health of Animals; Meat and Canned Foods Maritime provinces in, M. 992, 1023
Accountants. See House of Commons; Senate
Accounts. See Consolidated Revenue and Audit Act; Finance; Public Accounts
Accredited Herds. See Health of Animals Acme Grain Company, default of, 2834 Acoustics. See House of Commons Actions. See Escheats Act Arndt.
Active Militia. See Militia; National Defence Adamson, Mr. Justice, appointment of, 1670
Address in reply to Governor General's Speech, 10, 15, 50, 98, 122, 173, 211, 260, 303, 326
Mover (Mr. McMurray) 10; Seconder (Mr. Mercier) 15
Speakers, Messrs: Baldwin, 60; Baxter, 98; Beaubien, 280; Brown, 332; Campbell, 356; Carmichael, 155; Church, 116; Crerar, 50; d'Anjou, 306; Denis (St. Denis), 348; Dickie, 341; Drayton, 195; Evans, 300; Forke, 76; Gouin, 140; Harris, 307; Hughes, 224; Irvine, 211; Johnson (Moosejaw), 112; Kennedy (Edmonton), 142; King (Mackenzie), 38; Ladner, 321,	326; Lewis, 149;
Logan, 105; Macdonald (Pictou), 186; MacKelvie, 159; MacLaren, 353; MacLean (Prince), 335; Maclean (York), 63; McBride, 316; Manion, 263;. Marler, 243; Meighen, 19; Neill, 169; Pritchard, 250; Putnam, 309; Raymond, 253; Robitaille, 320; Ross, 95; Ryck-man. 284; St. PSre, 281; Sexsmith, 293; Sheard, 294; Speakman, 80; Stansell, 359; Stevens, 230; Stork, 330; Tur-geon; 273; Warner, 349; Woods, 92; Woodsworth, 84
Motion agreed to, 362; acknowledgment of address by Governor General, 746-7
Adjournments. See House of Commons
Adjustment of War Claims. See War Claims
Administration of Justice. Sec Justice
Administration of Oaths of Office bill, lr., 6
Admiralty Act Arndt, bill (Deputy Registrar and Deputy Judge) lr., 245-6; 2r„ com., 2822; 3r., 2823
Admiralty Court vacancy at Quebec, 1275
Adulteration of Food. Sec Food; Health
Advertising. See American Magazines
Aerial Patrol. See Air Service
Aeronautics, control of. See Air Board Act
Aeroplanes. Sec Air Service
Age of consent. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Agents Provacateur. See National Defence; Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Ages, Population by. See Population
Agricultural bloc in United States, 69, 210, 988. See also Budget; Customs; United States
Agricultural Commodities. See Farm Products
Agricultural Fairs. See Exhibitions
Agricultural Fertilizers. See also Fertilizers Inquiry as to legislation, 3041 Speaker's ruling, 1282
Agricultural Fertilizers, Regulation and Sale of, bill. Res. 3043; lr., 3044; 2r., 3044; ref. to Com. on Agriculture, 3044; com., 3194; 3r., 3195. Senate amdts., 3607
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

ii

Agricultural Implements, 2185,	2217, 2360,
2464, 2564, 2620
Brantford factories, closing of, 2375 Duties on, reduction, 2115, 2175, 2206, 2217, 2230, 2360, 2375, 2381, 2484, 2534, 2592, 273i, 3118-3120, 3141. See also speeches on Address; Budget; Customs Tariff Drawbacks and refunds, 2175, 3122 Ploughs, 3121, 3229
M. (Mr. Johnston - Last Mountain) to reduce, 3121, 3229
Imported from United States, 2413-14, 2486
By United Grain Growers, 3118-19 International Harvester Company, 2382 Massey-Harris Company, 2175 Price of, 1476, 2188. See also Address; Budget
At home and abroad, 2452, 2620 Protection, 2697
Manufacturers, and, 2575 Raw Materials for, 302, 309, 766. See also Customs Tariff
Raymond, Mr., and, 254, 255, 2705. See also speeches on Budget Repair parts, 1901 Standardization of parts, 2406 Tariff, and, See Address; Budget; Customs Tariff
Agricultural Institute, 657, 969
Agricultural Instruction Act, 651-2, 994, 1012 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 1032
Agricultural Labourers. See Immigration; Labour; Unemployment
Agriculture. See also speeches on Address; Budget
Accredited herds, 995, 2556, 2734-43
Diseases, 968. See also under this title, Health of Animals Valuation, 1000
Animal) diseases. See Animal Contagious Diseases; Health of Animals Bacon, production and marketing, 1025 Bounty to, 1698
Bovine Tuberculosis. See under this title.
Health of Animals Butter. See also Oleomargarine Accumulation in England, 997 Colouring of, 1778 Imported, qu. 613, 803
New Zealand, from, qu. 614 Protection against oleomargarine, 177.
See also Oleomargarine Vitamines in, 1781
Agriculture -[DOT] Con.
Cattle. See also Live Stock Embargo on. See Cattle Embargo Free carriage of, 1029 Cold storage, 818, 992, 998, 2557
Abattoirs, maritime provinces, 992-3, 1023 Quebec, 1471 Warehouses, 3521
Commissioner of, qu. 609, 645, 3501. See also Marshall, Mr. Duncan Committee on. See Agriculture and Colonization
Competition. 2698
Conditions and prospects, 16, 53, 78, 81. 85, 113, 150, 231, 252, 300, 2147, 2149, 2153, 2156, 2163, 2216, 2403, 2885. Set also speeches on Address; Agriculture Estimates; Budget
Statement by Manitoba Agricultural College, 2332
Contributions to railway tonnage, 1927.
See also Freight Rates; Wheat Board Dairying. Sec that title Depression in, 1475, 2147. See also Address; Budget
Department	[DOT]
Calgary live stock branch, qu. 607 Comparison of average salaries, 750 Dominion Apiarist, 592 Estimates, 1018, 1718, 3520 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, appointment of, 3501. See also that title Salaries and contingencies, 588, 644, 3504 Destructive Insect and Pest Act, 590, 3520.
See also under this title, Entomology Diseases of Animals. See under this title, Accredited Herds; Health of Animals Entomology, 813
Exhibitions, 993, 1026, 3521. See also that title
Experimental and illustration Farms, 795, 2557, 3521
Buildings, expenditure on, 1264 M. (Mr. Sutherland) to reduce item, 812 Mont Laurier, 994
Saunders, Dr. C. E., Dominion Cerealist, gratuity to, 590, 3522 Export figures, 2446, 2638 Farm labourers, 79, 87, 251, 1153 Harvest excursions to West, 337 Immigration of. See Immigration Unemployment. See Unemployment Fertilizers. See Agricultural Fertilizers; Fertilizers
Fruit Industry. See that title Importance of, 2386. See Address; Budget International Institute of, 657, 969


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
iii
Agriculture - Con.
Health of Animals, 967. See also under this title, Accredited Herds Bovine tuberculosis, 2556 Hog cholera, 1007, 1028 Alderson claim, 1004 Tuberculosis, 3521. .S'ce al^ i Animal contagious Diseases
Japanese engaged in, 345-6. See also Oriental Aliens Lecturers, 1023 Live Stock. See that title Manitoba Agricultural College, statements on, 2332
Markets, 251,	2149. See also Address;
Budget; Cattle Embargo; Wheat , Board
Military and agricultural expenditures, comparison, 1137 Mixed farming, 2592 Potatoes. See that title Root Vegetables. See that title Saunders, Dr. C. E., Dominion Cerealist, gratuity to, 590, 3522 Seed, Feed, and Fertilizer Control, 1011 Seed Grain, 3522
Stock-grazing and feeding, 1718. See also Live Stock.
Unemployment, and, 2158, 2331. See also Labour; Unemployment Wheat Board. See that title
Agriculture and Colonization, Committee on Bouchard, Mr., substituted for Mr. Stein, 2035
Canadian Council of Agriculture Memorandum ref. to, 377
Constitutionality of Wheat Board, Law Officers' opinion, 940 McCoig, Senator, attendance of, 1900, 2406 Reports
Inquiry as to, 1929 Second and third, 657 M. to concur in, 703, 726, 776
Arndt. (Mr. Meighen) to refer back, 779
M. as amended, agreed to, 786 Third, concurred in, 786 Fourth, concurred in, 865 Fifth, M. to concur in, 2915
Arndt. (Mr. Sutherland), 2951; neg.
See Wheat Board, for further proceedings Standardization of parts of agricultural machinery, 2406
Air Board, qu. 366. See also Militia and Defence; National Defence
Air Board

Con.
Aeronautical research, 3499 Biggar, Col. O. M„ resignation of, 1726 Civil aviation, 1722. See also Air Force Estimates, salaries, etc., 1722 Expenditure, details of, 1728
Air Board Act, 1919, Amdt. bill (Compensation for death or injury)
Res. 2357, 2820; lr., 2821, 2r., com., 3r., 2826
Aircraft Limitation. See Limitation of Arm-maments
Air Force. See also Air Board; Militia, National Defence
Aeroplanes, danger of attack from, 2085-98 Civil Aviation, and, 1047, 1722 Aerial patrol, High River, Alta., 1048;.
qu. 1066, 1723 Camp Borden, 1728 Co-operation with provinces, 1722 Customs patrol, Vancouver, B.C., 1730, Forest patrol, 1047
High River station, 1048; qu. 1066, 1723 Railway Belt, B.C., 1730 Gasoline for aeroplanes. See Gasoline Pensions, Widowed mothers, 1305
Air Service. See Air Force
Aird, Sir John, 1128
Alberta
Dry areas, 1042 Harbours and rivers, 2004 Indian schools. See Indians Meeting of defeated candidates, 2858 Public buildings, 1254 Second homesteads, 1042 Soldier's Civil Re-establishment hospitals, 1344
Alcohol. See also Customs Tariff; Opium and Narcotic Drugs; Prohibition; Special War Revenue Act Country doctors and, 2177 Retail druggists, for, ques. 1213, 1400; 2114, 2176-7, 2191
Alderson Claim. See Agriculture, Health of Animals
Aldred, Mr. J. E., 1128
Ale. See Liquor; Special War Revenue Act; Taxation
Algoma Steel Corporation, rails, 1689
Volume I* 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
[Stage Direction]


Aliens. See "also Immigration; Labour; Unemployment
Deportation of. See Immigration Act Arndt.; Opium and Narcotic Drugs Enemy property, custodians of 1672, qu. 1904
C.P.R. shares held by, 1672	,
Muivey, Mr. Thomas, qu. 3363 Prince Rupert, 3606, 3601 Fisher & Oughton, qu. 1773, 3601, 3606 Thorsch, Mr., qu. 1772 Williams & Manson, qu. 1772, 3601, 3606
Lord Kitchener, news of his death, and, 2155
Oriental Immigration. See Oriental Aliens Taxation of, 2155
Women of Alien Birth. See Dominion Franchise Act, M. (Mr. Euler)
Allan, Sir Montagu, 872. See also Banks, Merchants Bank
Alliances, Political, 2095,	2097. See eilso
Nationalists; Progressive Party "Morganatic alliance", 2095, 2344
Alpine Club, grant to, 1053, 1387
Alternative Vote. See Proportional Representation
Aluminum Company of America, 71, qu. 728
Cedar Rapids power, qu. 1375
Amalgamation of Departments. See National Defence Bill
Ambassador, Canadian, at Washington. See Canadian Representation
American Bankers' Association, 2189
American Magazines, importation and competition, 3109
Amherst, N.S.
Car'repair contracts, 1702 Drill hall, 1238
Ammunition. See Militia and Defence
Anaesthetics, use of. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Anderson, Mr. R. K. (Halton)
Budget, 2364. Tribute to Finance Minister; taxation and the cost of living, 2364; tariff; import and excise duties; free trade; origin of protective policy in United States; population, increase
Anderson, Mr. R. K.-Con.
Budget - Con.
of; tariff reductions; a two and a half per cent budget; sales tax increase, 2365; party without definite fiscal policy; 2366; revenue and protective tariffs in England and United States; Fordney tariff, 2367; reciprocity with United States; British and American investment in Canadian industries, 2368; home manufacture; trade with Great Britain and United States, 2369; home market; difficulties due to war; debt and deficits, 2370; economy and expenditure; civil service; militia and naval service, 2371; taxation; railways; emigration; dumping clause, 2372; beet sugar; the amendment, 2373 Burlington channel bridge, 2007 Daylight Saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 954 Halifax and St. John quarantine stations, 1241
Halton county
Highways - Dundas Street, qu. 1065 Post offices, 1247
Immigration, medical inspection, 2021-2 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act, 3014 Orders in Council, qu. 935 Overseas service - categories, 3317 Penitentiary Act Arndt, 790 Pensions, commutation of, 1281 Public buildings Rentals, 1259 Water, 1266
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, care and medical examination of patients, 1281 Steel rods, refund of duties, 1774
Andrews, Mr. A. J., K.C.
Winnipeg Strike correspondence, 2042
Anglo-French Relations. See Genoa Conference; Limitation of Armaments
Anglo-Japanese Treaty, 168. See also Japan; Limitation of Armaments
Animal Contagious Diseases Act
Administration, 967, qu. 3362
Animal Contagious Diseases Act Arndt, bill
(Compensation for slaughtered animals), lr., 1283; 2r., com., 2102; com., 2734; 3r„ 2806
Animals, Cruelty to. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Annexation, 2550
"Annexationists of the prairie provinces", 1020
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1 922 V

[Stage Direction]
Annual Drill. S'ee Militia
Annuities Branch, Salaries, etc., 776
Anti-Conscription, 22. See also Military Service Act Arndt.
Anti-Dumping. See Budget; Customs; Fruit; Trade
Appeal Cases. See Judges' Act Amdt.
Appeal Judges, Saskatchewan. See Judges Act Amdt.
Appeals from Provincial Courts. See
Supreme Court Act Amdt.
Apples. See, Fruit Appropriation Acts
__ 1. Bill No. 26 (Interim Supply - for $53,-901,669.17 for 1922-23). Res., 362, 598; lr., 2r., com.. 3r., 599
2.	Bill No. 85 (for 1921-22, for $9,623,-
792.61 and 1922-23 for $88,517,204.53). Res., lr., 2r„ com., 3r., 1842-3
3.	Bill No. 202 (for 1922-23 for $175,766,-
646.71). Res. lr., 2r„ com., 3r., 3607
Appropriations not required. See Estimates
Archambault, Mr. Joseph (Chambly and Ver-cheres)
Bankruptcy Act, trustees for Montreal district, 1183
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine ships in Montreal harbour, qu. 2637 Criminal Code Amdt. (Mr. Woodsworth). See under this title, Immigration-Criminal Code
Health Dept, correspondence relating to drugs, 1289, 1377
Immigration-Criminal Code bills (Mr. Woodsworth)
Special Com. Reports, 1988, 2519, 3156. 3280
Isle Perrot bridge, qu. 1377 Military Service Act Amdt., 642 Montreal Harbour Commission, employees, 1289
Naturalization Act, 1914, Amdt. billi (Residence), 1062 Newspaper censors, 1069 Opium and Narcotic Drugs
Correspondence with wholesale druggists, 1289, 1377
Point of order - relevancy, 1890 Pratt vs. Delpliine, 302 Railway Commission. Chief Traffic Officer, ques., 1377, 2215, 2457
Archambault, Mr. Joseph - Con.
St. John harbour, qu., 1401
Trent canal, total expenditure, qu. 1376
Victoria bridge tolls, qu. 1377
War claims, details of estimates, qu. 1288
Welland canal1, total expenditure, qu. 1376
Architect. See Parliament Buildings
Archives. See Public Archives
Arctic Ocean, patrol. See Navali Service
Arctic Regions, Mounted Police in, 3497
Arichat, port physician, qu. 1773
Armaments. Sec Limitation of Armaments
Armorial Bearings of Canada, Welsh emblem, 3601
Armouries. See also Militia and Defence Fittings and alterations, 1261, 1288 Quebec, in, qu. 1287
Army and Navy Veterans, Oriental immigration, 1514
Arsenals. See Militia
Arthur Young & Company, 1490. See also Civil Service, Classification
Arthurs, Mr. James (Parry Sound) Canadian Transit Company Bill, 1771 Cash Bonus to Soldiers. 403;	M., 429
Empire and Ascension days, 1769 Fishing schooner race, 3514 Geodetic survey, 1986 Labour Dept.
Nova Scotia strike, 584 Salaries, 575 Temporary clerks, 567 Naval Service, cruisers, qu. 2039 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3440-53 Postal receipts, qu. 938 Railway Act Amdt. (Crowsnest pass) 3959 Reading of documents, 560 Returned soldier hikers, qu. 3153 Rural mail routes, qu. 3152 Soldiers' settlement, building loans, 3475 Transcontinental railway, 919
Articles. See League of Nations
Artillery. See Militia; Royal Canadian Artillery
Artisans, Immigration of. See Immigration; Labour
Ascension Day Adjournment. See House of Commons
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Vi

Asiatic	Exclusion	League of Canada,
Oriental Immigration, 1514
Asiatics. See also Immigration;	Oriental
Aliens
British Columbia in, 171, 183
Assiniboine River Floods, 1842, 2003. 3545 Relief measures, inquiry, 3491
Assistant Chief Electoral Officer. See Chief Electoral Officer
Athletics. See Cadet Camps
Atlanta, Ga., Penitentiary, 1278
Atlantic-Pacific, Canadian ports. Sec British Preference; Steamship Services
Atlantic Sugar Refineries, drawback, 2850
Audibility of Debates. See House of Commons
Audit, Supreme Court pre-audit, 1275
Audit Act. See Consolidated Revenue and Audit Act Arndt.
Auditor General
*Contingencies, 3504 Salaries, 793
Auditor General's Report, 380, 424
Public Works, expenditure of previous year, 1270
Ref. to Public Accounts Committee, 1462 Aurora, warship. See Naval Service Australia
Immigration policy, 1536 Preservation of Industries Act, 2411, 2648 Reciprocal trade with, 33, 174, 2110, 2802 Correspondence tabled, 9 Steamship services. See Steamship Services
Trade relations with, 2592
Automobiles. See also Taxation Duty on, 2116, 2186, 2206, 2232, 2574 Drawbacks, refunds, 2850 Excise sales tax, 2116, 2177, 2186, 2206, 2230, 2260, 2346-7, 2388, 3272-3, 3276 Amended, 2857
Ford car, cost in Detroit and Canada, 2186 Ford Motor Company, 3273 Duty paid by, qu. 3599 Output, 3273
Protection and profits. 2232, 2696 Imports, qu. 1633
Automobiles - Con.
Industry, protection of, 2696, 2730, 3132 Number of, by provinces, 2566 Refund of taxes, 3600 Results of protection of industry, 2696 Theft, penalty, 2831
Value, $1,000, to be admitted free for settlers, 2116
Aviation. See Air Board; Air Force
Bachelor Tax. See Taxation
Backus, Mr. E. W. See also Lake of the Woods Repeal Bill Lease of timber areas, 2805; qu. 2992
Bacon, production. See Agriculture; Live Stock
Conference on, 1025
Baddeck, N.S.
Public Buildings, 1238 Wharf, 1269, 1765
Baie des Chaleurs railway service. See Gaspe Railways
Baker, the late Colonel G. H-, M.P.
Memorial to, 1929
Appointment of Special Com., 2101 Second report, 3490
Baldwin, Mr. W. K. (Stanstead)
Address in reply, 60; congratulations to mover and seconder; Miss Macphail, income tax collections, 60; attitude of leader of Opposition, 60-61; conscription, 61; leader of Opposition, 62 Armouries, 1288
Budget, 2150. Public debt; sugar control; railways; economy, 2250; naval service; development of natural resources, 2251; geographical difference; party promises; water power development; St. Lawrence river waterway, 2252; tariff; Progressive party; Hon. Alexander Mackenzie; Sir John Macdonald and protection, 2253; wartime wages and prices; immigration, national spirit; inequalities of taxation, 2255 Oleomargarine, Manufacture and importation, M. (Mr. Neill) 1832
Balkan States, credit to. See Loans; Rou-mania
Ballantyne, Hon. C. C. See Banks; Ministers and Directorships


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II; 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
vil
Bancroft, Mr. L. P. (Selkirk)
Icelandic river improvements, 2004 Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3463 Pensions for lightkeepers, 1496 Selkirk wharf, 2004
Banff, Windermere road, 1051, 1682
Banking and Commerce, Committee on
Bouchard, Mr., substituted for Mr. Stein, 2035
Insurance Act, 1917, Arndt, bill, ref. to, 1210 Loan Companies Act Amdt. bill, ref to, 1210 Trust Companies Act Amdt. bill, ref. to, 1210
Bankruptcy Act, qu., 703
Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bills
1.	Bill No. 45 (Mr. Jacobs - additional
grounds for petition in bankruptcy) lr., 821; ref. to Com. on Banking and Commerce, 1395
2.	Bill No. 56 (Mr. Ethier 

 court to which
petition shall be presented) lr., 1132; 2r., ref. to Banking and Commerce Com., 1662
3.	Bill No. 107 (Sir Lomer Gouin) lr.,
2035; 2r., com., 3025; 3r., 3026 Sections and Subjects discussed: Avoidance of general assignment of book debts, 3025 Court of bankruptcy, 3026 Judges to be assigned by chief Justice, 3026
Senate amendments, concurrence in, 3611
Suspension of payment, notice of, 3025 Winding up Act, 3026
Banks and Banking. See also Finance; Loans; Taxation
American Bankers' Association, 2189 Bank Act, revision. See Address; Budget Bank balances and real wealth, 2497 Chartered banks, returns, 865 Cheque tax, 2117, 2177, 2329, 2852, 2856, 3258
Circulation, deposits, loans, etc., qu. 1901 Circulation, tax on, 2117, 2626 Commerce, 1085-7
Credit system, 1290. See also Financial Credits
Credits, 1071, 2729. See also Loans Currency, issue of, 2501 Deposits, ratio to capital, 2728 Gold in Canadian banks, qu. 2971 Grain trade, financing of, 2246
Banks and Banking - Con.
Income tax payments by, qu. 1400 Interest, 1291, 3601 Alleged violation of Bank Act, 2627 Interlocking directorates, 2503 Loans to directors, 1093 Merchants', 1085, 1092, 1121, 3604 Allan, Sir Montagu, 872 Amalgamation, 2727 Ballantyne, Hon. C. C., 1085 Independent inquiry by Parliament, 2396 Macarow, Mr. D. C., case against, qu. 2305
Merger, 158, 237, qu. 367, 872, 1085, 2727 Montreal Bank and, 1085 Royal Trust Company, and, 1085 Montreal Bank, 1071-85, 1129 Canadian Pacific, and, 64-66 Unemployed and, 87
Montreal City & District Savings Bank, 1087
Municipalities, withholding credit from, 2627
Nationalization of, 2325-8 New banks, starting, 2501 Number, reserves, deposits, loans, property, qu. 1182
Penny Bank Act Amdt. bill. See that title Penny Banks, depositories for money received, 1132
Profits, circulation, interest, etc., qu. 3598 Refusal to advance money to school board, 2627
Royal Bank, 1087
Special War Revenue taxation. See that title
Note circulation, payments on, qu., 1400 System, revision of, 138, 158, 223, 237. 352, 2501, 2506. See also Budget; Irvine
Barclay, Mr. A. J., qu., 963-4
Barkhouse, Captain, 1748
Barnet, Major. See Soldier Settlement Board
Barnjum, Mr. Frank J., Forest Protection, 1049
Battlefields Commission, 119, 771. See also War Graves
Battlefields Memorials. See also War Memorials
Estimates, 2098, 2975
Baxter, Mr. Charles W., Appointment of successor, qu., 2457
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
viii


Volume I:: 1-1015, Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
ix
Canadian National railways - wrecks caused by defective cars from United States, 1708
Immigration - Ukrainians, 3061
Beck, Sir Adam, 63, 71, 92, 123, 124, 134. 633, 1327, 1937. See nlso Hydro Electric; Maclean, Mr., (York); St. Lawrence. Waterway
Beef, Imports of, qu., 610
Beer. Sec Liquor; Taxation
Beet Sugar. Sec Budget; Inland Revenue Act #,Amdt.; Special War Revenue
Behring Sea Patrol, 1736. See nlso Naval Service
Beland, Hon. H. S. (Minister of Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment and Minister in charge of the Department of Health)
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3479-84 Canadian Red Cross Society bill, 3151, 3386
Canteen funds, disposal, 3329, 3308 Cash grants to soldiers, 394 M. (Mr. Arthurs) 441 ChaudiSre Valley floods, 3492 Conservation Commission, 456-7 Election promises, 402 Health, department of
Correspondence with wholesale druggists, 1289, 1377 Estimates, 2017
Immigration, medical inspection, 2021 Quarantine, 2021 Salaries, 775 Venereal diseases, 2022 Insurance claim of heirs of deceased soldiers, 1349. See nlso under this title Returned Soldiers Iusurance Opium and Narcotic Drugs
Correspondence with wholesale druggists, M. (Mr. Archambault) 1289, 1377 Enforcement of Act, 20i7 Prohibition and, 2018
Opium and Narcotic Drugs Act Arndt, bill, 775, 1841. 2823, 3013 Appeal, 3020 Deportation, 3024
Pension Act Arndt, bill. 3402, 3439-64 Pension Commissioners, Board of, 1339, 1349-50, 3336 Appeals, 3341 Charges against, 3041
Beland, Hon. H. S. - Con.
Pension Commissioners. - Con.
Discretion, 392
Memorandum of Chairman, 2994 Representation of Quebec, 1350 Pensions
Commutation, 392
European War and active militia, 1353, 1361
Expenditure under report of Special Com., 3523
Widowed mothers, M. (Mr. Power) 1307 Pensions, Insurance, etc.. Special Com. Appointe'l, 496 Final report, 3355 Shaw, Mr., 3326
Returned Soldiers, alleged ill-treatment of children of, 2639
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Arndt.
bill, 3319, 3358, 3388, 3398, 3437 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment dept. Amalgamation or abolition of, 1341 Employers' Liability compensation, 1348 Estimates, 1279, 1339 Hospitals, 1348 Nurses' salaries, 1342 Operating expenses and working capital, 1347
Patients, care and medical examination of, 1280
Pensions, 1349, 1353, 1361. See also under this title, Pensions
Royal Commission on Pensions, 388. See also under this title, Pension Commissioners Staff. 405, 1343 Reduction of, 3602
Salary increases, 385, 388. 401, 405, 551 Waddington, Mr., 385, 398 Unemployment relief, 1352, 3528 Vocational loans, 1346 Vocational training, 1281 War service gratuity, interest on, 1347 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Dept, bill, 3597, 3609
Soldiers' homes, establishment of, 1348 Unemploy'ment relief, 1352, 3528
Belgium, free trade and, 2525
Bell Telephone Company, rates increase, 132
Belley, Mr. Alfred, salary, 3504
Belley, Hon. Mr., and conscription. See Military Service Act Amdt.
Benefit Societies. See Insurance Act Amdt. bill
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Bertrand, Mr. T., qu., 937
Betting. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Beverages, Tax on, 2594,	2857. See also
Budget; Taxation
Bienfait, Briquetting plant at, qu. 6$4, 1233, qu. 1632, 2712-15 Expenditure and results, 2712-15
Big Bay Point, Lake Simeoe, removal of - sunken vessel, 2005
Big Bras d'Or wharf, 1765
Big Interests and Liberal party, 242, 2431, 2678, 2682. See also speeches on Budget
Biggar, Colonel O. M.
Resignation from Air Board, 1726. See also Chief Electoral Officer
Biggar, Mr., W. H., K.C., qu. 728
Biggs, Hon. F. C., 63
Bills. See Deputy Speaker; House of Commons; Speaker
For Public Bills See their individual titles;-For private Bills, See Private Bills Discussed
Binder Twine, 257, 265, 2405 2575 Brantford factory, 2375. See also Budget
Binders. See Agricultural Implements
Binette, Mr. Joseph (Prescott)
Campaign funds, qu. 1508 L'Orignal wharf, qu. 1212 Quebec riots, compensation for damage, qu. 1508
St. Lawrence river waterway, communication with Imperial Govt., qu. 1508
Biological Board. See Marine
Bird, Mr. T. W. (Nelson)
Budget, 2704. Political expediency; difficult to modify protective system, 2704; divergence of views of Mr. Mc-Master and Mr. Raymond; historic Liberalism represented by Progressive party, 2705; revival of Liberal spirit; attitude of Opposition towards Progressives; alleged inaccuracies, 2706; statement as to direct and indirect taxation; tariff a secondary revenue producer; sales tax; free trade and revenue, 2707; inheritance tax; protection and farmers, 2708; labouring man; competition under free trade;
Bird, Mr. T. W.- Con.
Budget -[DOT] Con.
Canadian wheat in England; workingman and protection, 2709; small industries and trusts, 2710; Wheat Board; protection and flagwaving; obstacles to united nationhood, 2711 Civil Service salaries, 554 Hudson Bay railway, completion, 2786 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 526 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 838
Birnie, Mr. Alexander, and others, petition of, 1929
Black, Mr. George (Yukon)	,
Alien enemy property, qu. 1904 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3004 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3483 Civil Service list, qu. 727 House of Commons Law Branch, qu. 2304 Senate, and,
Chief Accountants, qu. 2583, 2803 Expenditure, qu. 2583 McPherson, Mr. Duncan, superannuation, qu. 2805
Migratory Birds, 1686
Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1520 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3464 Pensions Committee, final report, 3334 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 838 Senate and House of Commons
Chief Accountants' salaries, ques. 2583, 2803
Yukon Territory
Administration of justice, 1275
Suggested union with British Columbia, 1275
Mining and mineral discoveries, 1276 Parcel post, 2802 Radio-telegraph service, 1749 Silver discovery, 1276
Black, Mr. William (South Huron)
Budget, 2448. Disappointment at proposals of Finance Minister; the tariff; jokers in budget; protection with an excise tax; boots and shoes; building materials and agricultural implements; exorbitant prices charged; manufacturers' rebate on raw materials: loss of population, 2449; immigration; railway situation; national railways; change of management necessary; merchant marine; civil service; mem-


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 xl

[Stage Direction]
Black, Mr* William - Con.
Budget - Con.
bers taking up too much time with speeches; trade relations with United States; export of cattle, 2450; immigration, 2450
Goderich harbour improvements, 2000 Harbours and rivers, Ontario, 2000
Black, Mr. W. J., Deputy Minister of Immigration
Appointment of, 3500. See also Immigration
Blackfoot Reserve. See Indians
Blake, Date Hon. Edward Better to West Durham electors, 2677 Malvern speech, 2655, 2677 Withdrawal! from leadership of Diberal party, 2655, 2657, 2677
Bland, Mr. C. H., Civil Service Commission, qu. 1773
Bl ankets. See Customs Tariff
Blind
Canadian National Institute for, grant, 3540 Soldiers. See Pensions Committee
Blood Indian Reserve. See Indians
Board of Commerce, 1118
Constitutionality of. See Wheat Board Cost, report, qu. 2583 Salary of secretary, 1715
Board of Pension Commissioners. See Pension Commissioners
Board of Railway Commissioners. See Railway Commission
Boivin, Mr. George H. (Shefford)
Business of the House
Questions requiring tabulated answers, 1132
Canadian National railways Board of management, 1698 Rail and car repair contracts, 1698 St. Malo shops, 1699 Cheque tax, 3261 Criminal Code, revision, 1717 Debates Committee, first report concurred in, 1258
Debates, Official, Unrevised Index, 3359 Health of Animals Hog cholera, 1007 Inspection of dairy herds, 1007 Rail and ear repair contracts, 1698 Unemployment, rail and car repair contracts, 1699
Bolshevism, 1290. See also Dabour; Nova Scotia Miners
Bona fide Contractors. See Wheat Board bill
Bonds. See also Finance; Loans Five year maturities, qu. 2993 Non-taxable Victory bonds, qu. 2971 Sale by public tender, 1468 Tax-exempt, 2567, 2725
Bonus. See Civil Service; Soldiers
Bookmaking. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Bootlegging. See Liquor
Boots and Shoes, 3238. See also speeches on Address; Budget; Customs Felt shoe industry, 3239 Price and labour costs, 2350 Protection of industry, 207-208 Tariff on, 102-103, 152-3, 159, 2341-2, 2465, 2488-9, 2632, 2685, 3236, 3237 M. (Mr. Shaw) to reduce duty, neg. 3238
3orden, Camp
Air force and civil aviation, 1728
Borden, Right Hon. Sir Robert Appointment to Limitation of Armaments Conference
M. (Mr. Casgrain) for papers, 373 Imperial Conference of 1918, 1864 Naval defence, on, 1864, 1876 Quebec Harbour, 1475
Report on reduction of naval armaments, 9, 42, 1737, 1743
Withdrawal from directorships, 1089
Bouchard, Mr. George J. (Kamouraska) Introduction, 1929
Boucher, Mr. Aime (Yamaska)
Naval policy, 2078
Sorel shipyard, men employed May 1921, qu. 1062
Bounties
Linen yarn, 3128 Steel, 304-5, qu. 3360
Sugar beet industry. See Inland Revenue
Bourassa, Mr. J. B. (Levis)
Levis lightkeepers, qu. 2583
Bovine Tuberculosis. See Animal Contagious Diseases
Bowen, Mr. Fred W. (Durham)
Campbell, Mr. W. E., qu. 937
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xii

Boy Scouts Association, 772
Boys, Mr. W. A. (South Simcoe)
Big Bay point, Lake Simcoe, wreck, 2005 Business of the House
Budget debate, conclusion of, 2639 Paired members inadvertently voting, 1462
Canada Gazette, expenditure Public Works, 1268
Coal, importation for public buildings, 1763 Dredging, 2005
External Affairs, salaries, 412 Harbours and rivers, Ontario, 2002 Militia-Naval Service, officers, 421 National Defence bill, Air Force, 677 Naval Service
Militia, and, deputy ministers, 421 Niobe, sale of. 2068 Patronage - rural postmasters, 3083 Penitentiary Act Arndt, bill, 790 Pensions Board, appeal, 390 Pensions, disability cases, 389 Public Buildings
Coal importations for, 1763 Ottawa
Elevator attendants, 1267 Expenditure on, 1268 Public works
Appropriations and expenditures, 2002 Estimates, 695, 698 M. to reduce, 695
Expenditure, monthly statement of, 1268, 1271
Riley's army, qu. 3364 Soldiers' land settlement, 2132
Brantford
Agricultural implement industries, 255, 2375. See vlso Budget; Raymond Meighen, Hon. Mr., speech at, 256
Breadner, Mr. R. W., Commissioner of taxation. salary, 2024
Brethen, Mr. G. A. (Bast Peterborough) Accredited herds. 1000 Agriculture - Deputy Minister, 653 Automobile tax, 3276-7 Budget, 2693. United Grain Growers and agricultural implement business; income tax - who pays? 2693; economy; reduction in cost of government; national debt; domestic loans; reciprocity, 2694; sales tax; excess profits, 2695; luxury tax; unimproved land values; automobile tax; protective tariff and automobile industry, 2696; Ford car; protection of agricultural implements, 2697; home market; prices
Brethen, Mr. G. A. - Con.	[DOT]
Budget [DOT]- Con.
fixed in markets of world; ability of agriculture and live stock industries to meet world competition, 2698 Customs Dept., estimates, 763 Grants to live stock associations, 1027 Live stock trade with South America, 647" Manufacturers, protection of. 2696, 3232 Oleomargarine, 3430 Woollen clothing and blankets, 3135
Brewing. See Inland Revenue
Bridges. See vilso Public Works Burlington Channel, 2007 Edmonton, 2007 Edmundston, 1239-53 False Creek, 3516 Grand river. York, Ont., qu. 1287 Isle Perrot, federal contribution, qu. 1377 Ottawa, lighting, 1267 Quebec, 1068 Red Deer river, 1964 Victoria, tolls, qu. 1377
Bridgetown, post office accommodation, 1245
Briquetting. See Bienfait; Lignite
Bristol, Hon. Edmund (Centre Toronto) Budget, 2407. Congratulation to Finance Minister; nothing for trade or agriculture, a "stand pat" budget; protection against competitors; wages and production costs in Germany, 2407; German exports to Canada, 2408; protection of industries in Great Britain; Safeguarding of Industries Act; United States tariff. 2409; protection against German competition; equalization of conditions; duty valuation based on Canadian selling price; safeguarding of French industries, 2410; Australian Industries Preservation Act; Tom Moore on German labour conditions; protection of Canadian industries, 2411; industrial development and tariff legislation in United States; iron and steel, comparison of English and American prices; steel rails; Germany underselling United States; nails; protection of Nova Scotia coal and steel industry, 2412; tariff revision long overdue, 2413; western farmer and tariff and freight rates; United States farmer opposed to free trade; tariff against Canadian agricultural products; protection against United States commodities;


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
xiii
Bristol, Hon. Edmund - Con.
Budget - Con.
free trade; agricultural implements, imjiortation from United States; effect of tariff reduction on implement factories; American factories in Canada; trusts and combines; woolens, 2415; free trade means destruction of Canadian industries and home markets; harmony between eastern and western Canada, 2416; deflation; building costs, coal; railway wages and freights; the amendment, 2417 Canadian ships damaged during war, 1183 Welland canal, 2748
Co-operation with the United States, 2751
Grain transportation, 2750
British Admiralty, war claims, 1752
British Board of Trade, relief of distressed seamen, 1676
British - Born
Disabilities under Immigration and Naturalization Acts, 1389-91
British Columbia
Aerial patrol of forests, 1724, 1730 Asiatics in. See under this title, Oriental Aliens
Banff-Windermere road, 1051, 1682 Burrard Dry Dock Company, 2008 Canada Temperance Act, 1017 Canada Temperance Act Arndt, bill, 2733, 2997. See also that title Canadian National branch lines, 331 Coal mines in, 178 Coastal services, qu. 3152 Dairymen's Association, 1794 D'Arcy Island, lazaretto, 2021 Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Company bill, 1156-63, 1353 United Farmers, and, 1354 Fisheries. See also Quebec Fisheries . Cost and revenue, 2306 Gasoline for fishing boats, 2313, 3116 M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 851, 863 Transfer to, 2042
Freight rates. See Crowsnest Pass Agreement
Fruit industry, 162, 225, 3417-3424 Tariff and. Sec Budget; Customs Fuel Oil, 178, 344. qu. 728 Competition with coal, 2312 Liquor traffic, 2018. See also under this title, Canada Temperance Act
British Columbia - Con.
Natural resources, 328. See also Natural Resources
Old age and mothers' pensions, 1375 Oliver, Hon. John, 322
Criticism by Vancouver Sun, 2236-7 Opium and Narcotic Drugs, 2017. See also that title
Oriental Aliens. See also that title
Competition with, 171, 173, 183, 316-19, 332, 344
Immigration, 167, 872, 967, 2310, 3104 Res. by Legislature, 1511, 1513 M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1509 Population, 1512 Voting, 172
Post offices, revenue from, qu. 824 Potlach Indian Institution, qu. 1377. Sec also Indians
Public buildings, improvements, etc., 1255 Railway Belt Forestry, 1046 Survey, 1043
Railway mail service, 2797 Union for judicial purposes with Yukon, 1275
British Columbia House, London, purchase [DOT] of,, 3537
British Empire Steel Corporation, 200, 1106, .1130. See also Nova Scotia Miners Business profits tax, qu. 1067 Compensation for loss, 1082
British Goods, Importation. See British Preference; Customs; Trade
British-Japanese Treaty Sec Limitation of Armaments
British Market. See British Preference; Cattle Embargo; Trade
British Ministry of Shipping
Account, 2975
Hospital ship, claim for loss of, 2976
British North America Act, powers under See Quebec Fisheries
British Preference, 2111, 2201. 2529, 2624-5. See also Budget; Customs; Trade Canadian Seaports, and, 2688 M. (Mr. Logan) 493, 707 Arndt. (Mr. Lewis) 772; withdrawn, 726 Further reduction of duties, 2113 Goods imported via United States, qu. 375 Sugar, 2116
British Shipping Board, credit, 2975
Volume I; 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xiv
[Stage Direction]
British Subjects, Wives of alien birth. See Dominion Elections Act
British Valuation. See Customs, Valuation
Brockville and Westport Railway, qu. 704
Brown, Hon. George, on political pledges, 2482
Brown, Mr. J. L. (Lisgar)
Address in reply, 332; reciprocity, live stock industry, 333; cattle embargo, 334
Animal Contagious Diseases Act Arndt. 2735
Automobiles, refund of taxes, 3600 British Preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 721 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3484 Canals, traffic through, qu. 705 Canned foods, marking, 3050 Civil Service, economy in, 423 Criminal Code, cruelty to animals, 2833 Experimental farms, 808 Fishing schooner race, 3512 Inaudibility of debates, 1751 Labour Dept. 

 economy, 568 Militia and Defence Estimates, 587 Quebec arsenal, 2095 Naval policy, 2069
O'Connor, Mr. James, dismissal of, 1674 Oleomargarine, manufacture and importation, M. (Mr. Neill) 1803 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 3018
Pensions Committee

Anal report, 3342
Political alliances, 2095
Prince Rupert Dry Dock Co., claim, 3516
Public Works estimates, 696
Rideau canal, 2765, 2767
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 840 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1207 St. Peter's Indian reserve, qu. 472 Soldier land settlement, 2134 Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 449 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, staff, 1345 Statistics, accumulation of, 580 Wheat Board bill, 3180 Wheat Board - point of order, 2949 Woollen goods, duty on, 3232
Brussels Financial Conference, 1138, 1292
Bryce, Dr. Peter, H., pamphlet, 1224
Bud Moth. See Forestry
Budget. See ulso Ways and Means Date of
Announcement, 1721 Inquiry, 1018, 1463, 1503 Debate, on, 2104, 2171, 2216, 2256, 2307, 2358, 24'07, 2459, 2519, 2523, 2585, 2640, 2692, 2842, 2859 Amendments
Crerar, Mr., 2473-4; Speaker's ruling 2520-23
Drayton, Sir Henry, 2179, neg. 2912 Divisions
Amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton) neg. 2912 Corrected division list, 2972 Motion (Mr. Fielding) for Ways and Means Com., 2104; agreed to, 2913 Ruling of Mr. Speaker on Amdt. to Amdt. (Mr. Crerar) 2520-23 Probable time for conclusion of, 2639 Speeches of Finance Minister, 2104, 2842 Speakers, Messrs: Anderson, 2364, Baldwin, 2250; Baxter, 2340; Bird, 2704; Black (Huron) 2448; Brethen, 2693; Bristol, 2407; Caldwell, 2660; Campbell, 2729; Cannon, 2909; Chaplin, 2616; Charters, 2561; Church, 2392; Coote, 2724; Crerar, 2459; 2522; Denis (Jo-liette) 2887; Drayton, 2127; Drummond, 2272; Elliott (Waterloo) 2348; Fansher, 2229; Fielding, 2104, 2842; Findlay, 2893; Fortier, 2274; Gardiner, 2624; Garland (Carleton) 2300; Good, 2429; Gouin, 2654; Gould, 2711; Guthrie, 2874; Hocken, 2675; Hoey, 2331; Hughes, 2225; Irvine, 2495; Jacobs, 2513; Johnston (Last Mountain) 2220; Kellner, 2280; King (Huron) 2301; King (Mackenzie) 2537; Kyte, 2358; Ladner, 2276; Laflamme, 2895; Lanctot, 2567; Lapierre, 2628; Lapointe, 2585; Lavigueur, 2398; Leader, 2510; Lewis, 2256; Logan, 2684; Lovett, 2270; Lovie, 2451; Low, 2445; MacKelvie, 2196; Maclean (Halifax) 2859; Maclean (York) 2321; Mac-phail, Miss, 2384; McBride, 2635; Mc-Conica, 2898; McCrea, 2314; McKenzie, 2604; McMaster, 2417; McMurray, 2474; McQuarrie, 2233; McTaggart, 2545; Malcolm, 2387; Manion, 2261; Marcil, 2905; Meighen, 2523; Millar, 2294; Milne, 2239; Morrison, 2699; Motherwell, 2548; Neill, 2307; Prevost, 2577; Putnam, 2282; Raymond, 2373; Robb, 2179; Sales, 2574; Speakman, 2881; Spencer, 2629; Stansell, 2290; Steedsman, 2721; Stevens, 2646; Ste-wart (Argenteuil) 2216; Stewart
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

Budget - Con.
Debate on - Con.
(Humboldt) 2597; Sutherland, 2481; Tolmie, 2591; Turgeon, 2188; Ward, 2400; Warner, 2204; White, 2352; Woods, 2183; Woodsworth, 2242 To continue from day to day, 2101 Resolutions, 2218 Amended, 2854
Building
Costs, 2416. See also Housing Trades
Conference, 582-3 Freight rates affecting, 133
Buildings. )See Public Buildings
Bukowinians. See Immigration
Bull Durham Tobacco, comparative prices, 2546
Bureau, Hon. Jacques (Minister of Customs and Excise)
Agriculture Committee Report, Wheat Board, 726
Civil Servants, appeal, 3079 Customs dept.
Drawbacks, 766 Estimates, 762, 1674 Officials, 764
Valuation of imports, 3413 Dominion Elections Act Arndt., 2810 Empire and Ascension days, 1769 Estimates, accounts chargeable to current and past year, 1675 Export liquor -warehouses, 768 Fishing schooner race, 3511 Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 641 National Defence Bill, Senate amdts., 2807 O'Connor, Mr. James, dismissal, 1674 Parliament, fall session, 3609 Public ownership, 1331 Quebec Harbour- Park St. Charles, 1470 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1332 Total trade, statement of, 1376
Bureau of Standards, 235, 1372
Bureau of Statistics. See Statistics
Burlington Channel, Bridge, 2007
Burrard Dry Dock Company, 2008
Burstall, Major General Sir Henry retirement, 742-3, 1145, qu. 1211. See also National Defence Bill
Business Profits War Tax. See Taxation
Butter. See Agriculture; Dairying Industry ; Oleomargarine
By-Elections. See House of Commons
Bylot Island, Mounted Police, 3497
Byng, Lord, Governor General. See References in Address
Cabinet. Sec Ministers and Directorships Personnel of, 241
Cables, Submarine, ques. 3151-2, 3360
Cadets. See Militia and Defence
Cahill, Mr. Frank S. (Pontiac)
Canadian Pacific railway bill, 1860 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1449 Montreal, Joliette and Transcontinental railway, 1577
Royal Canadian Navy, 1893 St. Lawrence river waterway, M. (Mr. Church) 1208
Vancouver and Fraser Valley railway, 798
Calder Act. See Civil Service; Public Serv * ice Retirement Act
Calder, Hon. Senator J. A., 1393
Calder, Senator, United States St. Lawrence river waterway 1206
Caldwell, Mr. Thomas W. (Victoria and Carleton, N.B.)
Abbatoir and cold storage piants in maritime provinces, 992 Agriculture
Cold storage facilities, 992-3 Department - salaries, 750 Exhibitions, 993 Fertilizer inspectors, 592 Lecturers, 1023
Saunders, Dr., resignation of, 591 Spruce bud moth, 595, 2668 Air Board Act Amdt. bill, 2821 Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt. bill, 2734-8
Blankets, duty on, 3131 British Columbia fisheries, M. (Mr. Mc-Quarrie) 856
Budget, 2660. Congratulations to Finance Minister; Minister of Justice applauded by Opposition; fallacy of the home market argument; wheat and potatoes; reciprocity with United States; Mr. Chaplin; taxation; inconsistency of
ume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 304U3619^


Volume I:: 1-1015. Vol


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
li
xviii


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-361T



[Stage Direction]
xix
Canadian National Institute for the Blind
Grant, 3540	[DOT]
Canadian National Parks. See Dominion Lands and Parks
Canadian National Railways. See also Address; Budget; Freight Rates; Railways; Transportation Accounting, 1908-18 Advances
$7,000,000, - 2779 $42,800,000, - 1905-33-69 Amalgamation of system, delay, 2585 Amount required for, 381 Annual report, 19,28
Annual statement by Minister of Railways, 873; Canadian Government railways; 873; Grand Trunk system, 877; estimates, 879; freight rates, 879; reorganization, 880; Canadian Government Merchant Marine, 882; summaries. 882 Board of Directors. See under this title, Directors
Bond sale in New York, 58 Branch lines, 1472, 1476, 1956 Bengough extension, 2770 British Columbia, 331 Eastern Maine railway, 1293 Hanna-Medicine Hat, 1965 Kamloops-Kelowna, qu. 937, 1134, 2797 Policy of Government, 1135 Business methods, 1692 Canadian Government Merchant Marine, and, 3036
Canadian Northern railway, 123 Acquisition of, 2614 Advances to, qu, 471 $42,800,000, - 1905-33-69 Agriculture, contribution to freight tonnage, 1927 Arbitration, 204
Bonded indebtedness, 190, qu. 368
Assumption by Dominion Govt.. 2458 Co-ordination, 1907 Deficit, 191, 1907
Electrification of. 1317. See also Electrification
Federal subsidies, qu. 1504 Guarantee bill, 1914, legal expenses, 1667 Indebtedness of western provinces, 229 Insurance, qu. 471 Invasion of Ontario by, 202 Liabilities, qu. 368
Loans and subsidies to, 189-90, 204, qu.
1504, 3 921 Mackenzie-Mann
Amounts paid to, qu. 935 Subsidy, qu. 607
Canadian National Railways - Coil. Canadian Northern Railway - Con. Mileage, qu. 368 Operating deficit, 1905 Responsibility for loans, 204. See also under this sub-title, Loans Rorketon branch line, 2139 Subsidiary lines, 202 Taking over.of, 190, 1907 Canadian Pacific railway, competition with, 65. See also Address; Budget;. Railways
Car and locomotive contracts
Canadian Locomotive Company, 2794 Eastern Car Company, 2794 Car repairs. See under this title, Rail and Car Repair Contracts Carey, Mr., 2858 Coal
Importations, qu. 926, qu. 2213 Purchases, qu. 2306
Consolidation, 6. 11, 28, 72, 73, 89. See also speeches on Address; Budget Dams impeding ascent of fish, 2168 Deficits, 1905-69, 1920
Corrected statement, 1919 Dining car and restaurant service, qu. 2040 Menus, cost of printing, qu. 1931 Rivers and Melville, Sask., restaurants,, qu. 2038
Directors, Board of, 1924, 2194, 2791 Appointment of, 1936 Connection with supply companies, 2792 Hanna, Mr. D. B., 1924, 1959, 1962 Labour costs, and, 2317 Interested in other companies, 1129 Mitchell, Mr. A. J., 1924 Public ownership, sympathy with, 2852 Representation of employees, 2798 Statement of Prime Minister, 2792 Drayton-Acworth report, 45-46 Edith Cavell road, Jasper Park, 1052 Electrical operation, 1206, 1323. See also Electrification; St. Lawrence river waterway; and under this title, Public Ownership
Electrification, M. (Mr. Deslauriers) 627 Estimates, 1905
Fraser, Mr., right-of-way agent, 1134 Freight
Careless handling of, 1965 Rates. See also Crowsnest Pass Agreement ; Freight Rates Advertising campaign, qu. 1375 Coal from maritime provinces, 1763 Quebec and, 1472-5 Special Committee, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) 1213
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
xxi
Canadian National Railways - Con. Telegraphs, qu. 3360 Ties, ques. 934, 2209
Purchases of in Quebec, qu. 1659 Toronto Globe editorial, 1134 Toronto railway viaduct, qu. 1660 Transcontinental railway, 111, 125, 278, 919, 1921, 2493 Cost, 2193
Enlisted men, allowance to, 3518 Freight rates, Quebec and, 1472-5 Grain shipments by, 2194 Lease of Eastern division, legal expenses, 1667
Opposition of Canadian Pacific to, 545, 2194
St. John valley, 3039 Unification, 1907, 1923-5,	2585. See also
under this title Consolidation; Public Ownership
Water supply, Ste. Anne-St. Pierre, qu. 2213
Working expenditures, 2779
Canadian Navy. See Naval Service
Canadian Northern Railway. See that title under Canadian National Railways
Canadian Pacific Railway, 146, 191. Sec also Address; Canadian National Railways; Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway; Freight Rates
Advance in price of stock, 129 Beatty, Mr. E. W., 126, 127, 1128 Labour costs, 2317
Canadian Pacific Railway Company bill, 1606, 1856
Coali lands, transfer of, qu. 2214 Competition with Grand Trunk, 64. See also that title Cost, 2193
Dams impeding ascent of fish, 2167
Directors, voting trust, 1936
Electrical operation, 71, 1206. See also St.
Lawrence River WaterwTay Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Company bill. See that title False creek bridge, removal; 3516 Freight Rates. See that title Immigration and, 351 Indian Department, payment to, 3518 Labour conditions, 2315 Mail contracts, ques. 2040, 2213 New England states, connection with, 1294 Palais station, Quebec, 1068 Public ownership, 1937, 2329 Rail and car repair contracts, 1688-1710 Rates, See Freight Rates
Canadian Pacific Rail, ay - Con.
Scares held by cust idians of alien enemy property, 1672 Success of, 123
Transcontinental railway, opposition to, 2194
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill
Res. 3156, 3366; lr., 3366; 2r„ com., 3477; 3r., 3484
Canadian Press, Limited, 772
Canadian Red Cross Society bill
lr., 3151; 2r., com., 3387; 3r„ 3388
Canadian Representation in the United States, 1383, 2026, 2864, 2990 International Labour Conference, qu. 824, 1060, 1070, 3437, 3490 Printing of report, 3601 Limitation of Armaments Conference. See that title
Canadian Seaports, trade through, 104. See' also British Preference; Steamship Services; Trade
Canadian Towing and Wrecking Co., 1677
Canadian Transit Company. See Private * Bills -Discussed
Canadian Vickers. See Vickers
Canadian Wheat Board. See Grain and Grain Trade; Wheat Board
Canadian Wheat Board Bill. See also Grain and Grain Trade; Wheat Board Res. 3174; lr., 2r., com.. 3179; com., 3379; 3r„ 3387 Arndts:
(Mr. Johnson, Moosejaw) 3178 (Mr. Maclean, Halifax) 3180 (Mr. Johnson-Mr. Robb) agreed to, 3383
Canadians
Distressed, relief for, 2027 Emigrating. See Immigration
Canalization. See St. Lawrence River Waterway; Welland canal
Canals. See also Railways and Canals; St. Lawrence River Waterway Chambly, improvements, 3518 Frankfurt, 1189
Georgian Bay, 1184, 1199, 1200-1209, 1319, 1397-8
Volume I:: Canals 

 Con.
Lachine
Widow of late James Innes, allowance, 2779
Manchester, 1189 Ontario-St. Lawrence, 2779 Quebec, 2779 Rideau, 2764
Construction of storehouse at Ottawa, 2764
Expenditure on, 2860 Improvements, 2769
St. Lawrence river waterway, M. (Mr. Church) 1183. See [DOT]also that title St. Lawrence ship canal, 2767 Soulanges
Improvements, 2768 Roadway, 2768 Traffic through, qu. 705 Panama, Suez and Soo canals, 1203 Trent
Estimates, 2764 -Nassau dam, qu. 2457 Total expenditure on, qu. 1376 Welland, qu. 827, 1184, 1205, 1207, 2747 Contracts for sections 3 and 4, qu. 3600 Co-operation with United States, 2749-51 Estimates, 2747
Amdt. (Mr. Millar) to reduce vote by $4,000,000, 2758
Port Colborne elevator, claim of Mr. J. A. Jamieson, 1687
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1321. See [DOT]also that title Tonnage, qu. 936 Total expenditure on, qu. 1376 Water power rights, 2747. Sec also St. Lawrence River Waterway
Cancellation of Leases. See Dominion Lands
Canned Fish. See Fisheries Act Amdt.; Meat and Canned Food
Canned Goods, Marking of. See Meat and Canned Foods
Canneries, Inspection. See Meat and Canned Foods
Cannes Conference, 1716. See also Genoa Conference Submarines, 1845
Canning Licenses. See British Columbia Fisheries; Fish and Fisheries
Cannon, Mr. Lucien (Dorchester)
Budget, 2909. Defeat of Tory party; administration facing serious situation; Progressive party; reasons for
Cannon, Mr. Lucien

Von.	[DOT]
Budget - Con.
Liberal victory; tribute to Prime Minister; platform of 1919; restoration of constitutional liberty; responsibility for conduct of public officials; responsible government and commission control, 2910; Canadian National Rail ways; a word to the West; Quebec the friend of the West; provincial autonomy, 2911; railways; Liberalism, hope of the Wrest; division amongst Progressive forces, 2912 Canadian National Railways, public- ownership, 1936-42
Dominion Lands, Cancellation of Leases bill. Senate admts., 3615 Limitation of Armaments, 3166 Maclnnes, Mr. Hector, payments to, 2772 Militia, arsenals Lindsay, 2088 Quebec, 2092 Naval policy, 2085
Point of order, parliamentary committee, 3354
Public Works estimates, preparation of, 1270
Royal Canadian Navy, 1887-90,
Canteen Funds, undistributed, disposal of, qu. 2215, 3290, 3308, 3328, 3331, 3334, 3346, 3350
Capital Ships. See Limitation of Armaments
Caraquet and Gulf Shore Railway, 1183, qu. 1504
Carey, Mr., and Canadian National Railways, 2858
Caribou. See Hudson Bay Railway
Carleton, N.B., returning officer, 3538, 3603, 3606
Carmichael, Mr. A. M. (Kindersley) Address in reply, 155. French language; western opinions, 156; financial and economic outlook in the West, tariff question, 157; freight rates; grain speculation, banking conditions, 158 Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim for flax shipment, 2834
Canada Grain Act, administration of, 2834
Canadian Pacific Railway Company bill, amdt. 1606
Deputy Minister of Finance, 753 Experimental farms, 800


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
xxiii
Carmichael, Mr. A. M. - Con.	.
Income War Tax Act, 1917, Amdt. 34S6 Justice Dept. - Private secretary, 1669 Kindersley post office building, 1254 Militia, annual drill, 1177 Public building's, Saskatchewan, 1253 Telephone lines. Saskatchewan, 2012 Wheat Board, 3181
Carroll, Mr. William F. (Cape Breton South and Richmond)
Burstall, Sir Henry, 743
Canadian Transit Company, bill, 1771
Cold storage, 819
Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 957 Dominion Elections Act. Arndt. 2812 Fuel oil, 178
Harbours and rivers. Prince Edward Island. 1991
Indians, Sydney reserve, 1215 Judges' Act Amdt. bill, 426 Labour dept, increases, 568 Labour men and unions, 228 National Defence bill, 743 Nova Scotia Miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 499, 532
Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1800 Opium and Narcotic 'Drug Act Amdt., appeal, 3024
Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3442 Pensions Committee, final report, 3316 Pensions - Royal Commission, 3327 Unemployment situation, 1076 Steel rails contracts, 1076 Sydney steel workers, 1076
Carruthers, Mr. John (East Algoma)
Civil Service - patronage, 3086
Little Current harbour improvements, 2002
Cars. See nlso Railways Governor General's, 1688 Repairs. See Canadian National Railways Shortage of. See Freight Rates
Cartier Square militia stores shed, qu. 2038
Carty, Captain, qu. 1062
Carvell, Hon. F. B. See Railway Commission
Casgrain, Mr. Pierre F. (Charlevoix-Mont-morency)
Budget, 2670. Congratulations to Prime Minister upon title of Imperial Privy Councillor; Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; budget proposals; abnormal conditions, 2670; principles of the Liberal party; platform of 1919; Opposition amdt. not to be taken serious-
Casgrain, Mr. Pierre F. - Con.
Budget [DOT]- Con.
ly; theories and arguments of the official Opposition and Progressive party; the golden mean; moderate protection, 2671; sales tax; inequality of income tax; burden borne by small wage-earners; proposed exemption of heads of large families; tax on cigarettes and cigars; exemptions from sales tax, 2672; cheque tax; leaf tobacco; tariff reductions; automobile tax, 2673; Borden and Meighen Governments responsible for present conditions; Canadian National Railways, management, board of directors, deficits; Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine; public debt; economy; Purchasing Commission; Civil Service Commission, 2674; reduction in civil service; public works in Charlevoix-Montmo-rency; Canada's future, 2675 Belley, Mr. Alfred, salary, 3504 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 956 Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway bill, 1356 Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 642 Steamship service, Murray Bay-Tadoussac, 3035
Superintendent of Lighthouses, Quebec, qu. 2584
Cash Grants to Soldiers. See Soldiers' Bonus
Cassels, Professor Gustavus, 1292
Cattle. See also Agriculture, Accredited herds, Health of Animals; Live stock industry
British embargo on. Sec Cattle Embargo Decline in prices of, 77. See speeches on Address; Budget
Diseases of. See Animal Contagious Diseases Bill
Exported to United States, 2450, 2695 Fordney tariff and. See United States, Fordney
Markets for, 977
Cattle Embargo, 93, 334, 361, 970, 973, 979, 985, 989, 992, 1002, 1031, 1283, 2182, 2571, 2597. See also Live Stock Industry
Alleged statement of Hon. Mr. Larkin, High Commissioner, 1020, 1463, 1502 Doherty, Hon. Manning, visit to England, 1283
Removal of, 2597
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xxiv

Cedar Rapids power, 71, qu. 728, qu. 1375. See wIso St. Lawrence River Waterway
Census of 1921, 20, 56. See also Immigration; Population; Redistribution; Statistics Agricultural assets and liabilites, 2159 Completion of, 1363 Cost, 1363 Enumerators, 1366 Appointment of, 1368 Payment of, 1367-9 Irregularities, 1363, 1365, 1367 Population, by ages, qu. 1632 Redistribution, and, 1363-71 Registration of Canadians, 1363 Report of Commissioner, 1366 Verification of figures, 1366
Central Vermont Railway. See Grand Trunk Railway
Chair rulings of. See Deputy Speaker; Speaker
Chairman of Committees. See Deputy Speaker
Chamberlin, Mr. R. G., grant to, 3497
Chambly Canal. See Canals
Champlain, steamship, qu. 1400
Chaplin, Mr. James D. (Lincoln) Agriculture Dept. - salary increases, 657 Boots and shoes, duty on, 3237 Budget, 2616. Ross rifle, war wagons and equipment; acquisition of Grand Trunk; congratulations to Finance Minister; reciprocity treaty, 2616; tariff proposals; automobile tax; tax on soft drinks, grape juice, 2617; consumption of farm produce in Canada; discrepancy as to agricultural exports; padded figures; non-agricultural commodities included in statement of exports, 2618; value of home market; agricultural implements, 2619; home and foreign trade in; prices in Canada and abroad, 2620; trend of tariff legislation in United States; Mr. Crerar's prophecy, 2621; farmers' platform; alleged effect of protective tariff; statement that consumer pays $4 for every dollar of revenue collected, 2622; export freight rates, 2623; cost of collecting customs duties; prices of kodaks in Canada and United States; political pledges; speech of late Hon. J. Israel Tarte, 2624 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1771
Chaplip, Mr. James D.

Con.
Cash bonus to soldiers, 402 Cheque tax, 3260
Dominion lands, temporary employees, 1036 Experimental farm employees, 652 Ford automobiles, 3274 Government printing, 1972 Hamilton-Queenston highway, qu. 471 Harbours and Rivers Manitoba, 2004 New Brunswick, 1993, 1997 Imperial Mining Resources Bureau, 1238 Interior Dept., salary increases, 457 Migratory birds, 1685 Militia and Defence Arsenals, 1979
Lindsay, 2086	[DOT]
Quebec, 2091
Military property in Lincoln county. 1980 Pay of staff, 1982 Permanent force, 1983 Staff reduction, 420 Junior clerks, 416, 419 Transport and freight, 1986 Mutual insurance, 3255 Orders in Council, qu. 934 Printing and stationery supplies, 454 Privy Council officials, 410 Public buildings
Maritime provinces, 1244 St. Catharines post office, 1246-50 Rail and car repair contracts, 1709 St. Thomas-Niagara Falls highway, qu. 936
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment 'Salaries and officials, 398-9 Salary increases, 386 Welland canal, construction, 2753
Charges of Management. See Finance
Charlevoix-Montmorency public works, 2675
Charlottetown, quarantine station, 2021
Chartered Banks. See Banks and Banking
Charters, Mr. Samuel (Peel)
Budget, 2561. Speech of the Minister of Agriculture; Wheat Board; Liberal pledges; introduction of national policy; the amendment; Government's failure to implement promises, 2561; Mr. Murphy at Milton; Government by Order in Council; business and luxury taxes; profiteers; inaction of Minister of Labour, 2562; sales tax; Civil Service Commission; patronage; the tariff; protection and free trade, 2563; statement of Finance Minister;


Volume I:: 1-1015, Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX- 1922 XXV

[Stage Direction]
Charters, Mr. Samuel - Con.
Budget 

 Con.
manifesto of Progressive party; tariff changes; agricultural implements; fruit industry, 2564; pessimistic view of present day conditions; reciprocity; rural population; rural school, attendance; value of farm lands; farm production, 2565; automobiles; Ontario Government immigration literature, 2566; future of Canada, 2567 Long Branch rifle range, qu. 372
Cheques. See Special War Revenue; Taxation
Chevrier, Mr. E. R. E. (Ottawa)
Civil Service
Absence through sickness, 3509 Bonus, 3531 Commission, 3064 Pensions Com., final report, 3337 Senate indemnity, 3509
Chief Architect's Branch. See Public Works
Chief Electoral Officer
Assistant, salary of, 3538 Carleton, N.B., returning officer, 3539, 3603, 3606
Report of Fourteenth Generali Election, of 1921, 1258 Report, printing of, 871 Residential qualification, 1297
Chi Idren
Dependent. See Income War Tax Act Health of. Sec Daylight saving; Health Immigration. See that title Infant mortality in cities, 2634 Miners of, in Nova Scotia, 529 Oleomargarine, effect on health, 178. See also that title
Pensions to. See Pensions Com. report Save the Children fund, 3516 School attendance, 2565. See also Education
Soldiers of
Alleged ill-treatment, 2638 Education. See Pensions Com.
Provision for, 3315-16
China
Commissioner of Immigration in, ques. 2026, 2214
Dr. Tsur, Chinese Consul General, 1776 Eggs, importation from, 177 Treaties with. See Chinese Customs Tariff Treaty; Far Eastern Treaty
Chinese Customs Tariff Treaty, 3161
Chinese Immigration. See Oriental Aliens
Chippewa electrical development, 72, 1327. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway
Chisholm, Mr. A. W. (Inverness)
Civil Service, officials receiving more than deputy ministers, 1508 Inverness pier, 1766 Margaree breakwaters, 1767
Church, Mr. Thomas L. (North Toronto) Address in reply, 116. Congratulations to Speaker; standing of different parties, 116; race and religious differences, 118; Speech of Hon. Ernest Lapointe; Battlefields Commission, 119; tax-tion methods, 120; unemployment and housing, 121; Good roads; public ownership, 122; Hydro-electric, 123, 131; public ownership of railways, 133; work of Sir Adam Beck, 134; radial railways, 134; St. Lawrence river waterway, 135; German trade; Senate reform; Civil service reform, 138; Conservative and Liberal gains and losses, 138-139; combines; ties with mother land; High Commissioner, 139 Alienation of natural resources, qu. 2992 Backus, Mr. E. W., lease of timber area, 2805
Blind soldiers, pensions, 3310, 3358, 3404 Bonds, sale of by public tender, 1468 Budget, 2392. Tariff not a political question; Tories and Radicals; Conservatives and protection; national policy; home market, 2392; the Progressives; United Farmers' platform; Liberals and free trade; protection and the growth of cities and towns ; tariff increase world wide; protectionist budgets of Liberal governments; tariff reduction and sales tax increase; Progressives and big interests, 2393; farmers and other producers highly organized; time for consumers to get together; tax burden on urban population; cigarette and tobacco taxes; railway problem; Canadian Pacific and Crowsnest pass agreement; trade with Germany, 2394; trusts, combines and war profiteers; tax evaders; taxation in Ontario; war time amusement tax; cheque tax; protest of Toronto and other municipalities, 2395; posterity should pay; Wheat Board; cost of living; Bank Act; Merchants Bank. 2396; judges serving on political eom-
Vo!lime I: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
[Stage Direction]


Church, Mr. Thomas L.

Con.
Budget - Con.
missions; prison reform; civil service, 2397; St. Lawrence river waterway, 2398
Business of the House, Mondays and "Wednesdays, 1462 Cadet corps, 1147, 1973 Canadian battlefields, 119, 771 Canadian Exporter, wreck, qu. 1210 Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, 3038 Canadian National Railways, 68 Carey, Mr., 2858
' Directors' sympathy with public ownership, 2858
Canadian representation in the United States, 2990
Civil Service retirement fund, income tax, qu. 937
Coal, price of, qu. 2039 Combines Investigation Act, qu. 1902 Committee speeches, relevancy, 555-6 Criminal Code *- poolselling, bookmaking, etc., 2973
Cruisers, armed, on Detroit river, qu. 2214 Customs receipts, qu. 470 Daylight saving, qu, 372 M. (Mr. Kay) 946 Disability soldier cases, 3318 Elevators
Ontario, in, 2978 Terminal, qu. 3152
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 489 Federal subsidies to Ontario, qu. 2214 France, trade relations with, 2990 Freight Rates
Crowsnest pass agreement, 2563-94 Railway Act Arndt, bill (suspension of agreement) 3594; amdt. 3595 Special Com. on, third report, 3560-4 Fuel, price of, qu. 1774 " General " Macdonald's army, reception of, 2256
Government office building in Ottawa, 1252 Haney, Mr. M. J., contracts, 1375 Hueston, Captain, inquiry into death of, qu. 2993
Imperial Mining Resources Bureau, 1238 Judges' Act Amdt. 546 Judges and commissions, qu, 366, 2397 Labour dept., policy, 464-5, 559 Lake of the Woods control, 2805 Joint board, qu. 2970 Lambton, steamer, loss of, 3365 Life-saving stations, qu. 367 Merchant lake marine, qu. 3362 Merchants Bank case, qu. 367, 2396, 3604 Case against D. C. Macarow, qu. 2305
Church, Mr. Thomas L. - Con.
Military expenditure and policy, 1177 Militia and Defence
Annual drill, 1177, qu. 1285 Arsenals, Quebec, 2093 Cadet services, 1147, 1973 Expenditure and policy 1890-1913, qu. 1285
Annual drill, proposed reduction, 1613 First Canadian contingent, qu. 1376 Ministers and directorships, 1125 National Defence bill, 742 Naval policy, 2043 Naval Service
Navy men, travelling expenses, qu. 3156 Royal Canadian Navy, 1894, 2043 Patronage, appointments to penitentiary. 1277
Penitentiary inmates, qu. 3362 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3442-62 Amdt. (Blind soldiers) 3358, 3404 Pensions
Evidence, 3357 Mothers, qu. 1375 Old age, qu. 1375
Pensions Committee final report, 3309 Postal affairs, qu. 368 Post Office, drop letter rate, 1250 Prince of Wales Leinster regiment (Royal Canadians) qu. 1065 Prison reform, 1277, 2397
Inspection by Grand juries, qu. 1773 Jail farms, qu. 1773 Youthful offenders, qu. 1773 Provincial commissions, Hon. Mr. Justice Riddell and Mr. Justice Latchford, qu. 3600
Public buildings Flags, 1260
Maritime provinces, 1244 Ontario, 1246-51 Rental and purchase of, 1262 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1467. 1482
Railway Act Amdt. bill (special passenger rates) 1460
Rental and purchase of buildings, 1252 Returned Soldiers' Insurance bill, 3391 Ritchie, Mr. Hugh, qu. 3361 St. Lawrence river waterway, 135, 2398 Correspondence with United States, 2357 International Joint Commission report, 2357
M. (Mr. Church) 1183 Toronto
Customs house, qu. 470 Harbour improvements, 1467
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
xxvii
Church, Mr. Thomas L. - Con.
Toronto - Con.
Public buildings, 1246-7 Railway viaduct, qu. 1660 Steam railway freight, qu. 936 Trade commissioners and commercial agents, 2990 Welland canal, qu. 827 Construction, 1687 Tonnage, qu. 936
Cigars and Cigarettes, tax on. See Budget; Inland Revenue; Taxation; Tobacco
Civil Aviation. See Air Force
Civil Pensions. See Pensions
Civil Service. See a Iso Supply. For individual departments, See their titles. For references generally, see speeches on Address; Budget Absence through sickness, 3509 Amalgamation of departments. See National Defence bill Appointments, 337, 2559, 3065, 3098 Members, and, 3074-3077
Recommendations of. See wider this title, Patronage
Outside service, post offices, 3073-4 Procedure, 573
Soldiers, 3330, qu. 3361. See also Soldiers Bonus, qu. 472, qu. 606, 733, 1258, 2397-8, 2513, 2801, 2805, qu. 3364, 3531 Announcement by Prime Minister, 1503 Appropriation, 3528 Inquiry as to payment of, 2996 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, nurses, 1342
Withdrawal of from certain civil servants, qu. 3598
Calder Bill. See Public Service Retirement Act
Classification, 455, 466. 494, 693, 3067, 3089 Appeals against, qu. 1508 Arthur Young Company, 1490 Bland, Mr. C. H„ qu. 1773, qu. 1904 Board of Hearing, 1491 Examination of masters and mates, 1490 Foran, Mr. J. J., qu. 2214 Militia dept., 416
Post Office, money order branch, qu. 1285 Printed copies of, qu. 1930 Responsibility for, 1491 Commission
Abolition of, recommended, 2563, 2674-5 Appointments agriculture dept., 2599 Appraisers, Paris and London, 1068 Bland, Mr. C. H., qu. 1773, qu. 1904
Civil Service - Con.
Commission - Con.
Census enumerators, appointment, 1368 Commissioners
Annual salary and travelling expenses, qu. 364-5
Appointment of, 2659 Cost of, qu. 364-5 Employees
Number of, qu. 364 Salaries, 3093 Estimates, 3102 Exemptions, 3078-9
History of and legislation creating, 3065 Jurisdiction, 736-7 Salaries over, 2801 Militia dismissals, 423 Officials and employes, qu. 364-5, 3093 Organization branch, qu. 935 Putnam, Mr.. C.V., qu. 935, 3090 Powers of, 553, 554 Report, qu. 826
Salaries and contingencies, etc., qu.
364-5, 386, 3091, 3509 Secretary, qu. 826
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, and. See that title
Deputy ministers, qu. 3364 Increase in salaries, 2805 Militia and Naval Service. See National Defence
Dismissals, 3083-3090
Economy in, 401, 423, 2057-61, 2371. See also Address; Budget Examination, 871 Hours, 2321, 2371,
Income tax department, 1663 Industrial councils, 1061 List, qu. 727
Married women employed in, qu. 1658 Memorandum of Hon. Mr. Robertson, 555 Militia services amalgamation, 418-19.
See also National Defence Overmanning of, 2371, 2450, 3099. See also speeches on Address; Budget Patronage and, 199, 2563, 3073, 3080, 3094, 3096
Promotions, 576, 3066
Public Service Retirement Act. See that title
Qualifications, 3070 Reduction of, 2674-5 Reform, 138, 3075
Reorganization, 2061. See also wider this title, Classification Griffenhagen and Associates, 1490 Sherbrooke post office inspector, 1507
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xxviii

Civil Service - Con.
Responsibility, 3076
Retirement. See ulso Public Service Retirement Act Fund, qu. 826
Income tax, qu. 937 Bightkeepers, 1496 Rural postmasters, 3079, 3095-6 Salaries and remuneration, 552, 2243, 2321, 2397, 2513, 2805, 3075, 3081, qu. 3364 Employees receiving less than $600, qu. 1067
Hours and, 2321, 2371 Officials receiving more than deputy ministers, 1508
Paying of. See Interim Supply Recommendations, 550 Reductions, 2690-1
Salaries of $960 and less, qu. 1660, 1775 Statement of Hon. Mr. Robertson, 555 Tariff Commission, appointment of, 1663 Temporary employees, 1036. See ulso individual departments
Vacancies, filling of, 79'2. See also under this title Appointments
Clark, Mr. J. A. (Burrard)
Alien enemy property, custodians of, 3601 Messrs. Fisher & Oughton, Prince Rupert, qu. 1772, 3606 Ammunition, shipment from Great Britain, 1337
Income tax collections, 1919-20-21, qu. 1063 Militia and Defence, expenditure and policy, 1335
National Defence bill, 678 Naval Service - Royal Canadian Navy, 1878, 2061
Northwest Rebellion, pensions of Mounted Police, 3523
Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1523
Quebec Harbour, appropriations for, 1486 Pension Act Arndt, bill. 3443-55 Pensions Com., 391 Final report, 3327
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act, 3400 Revenues from imports, qu. 827 Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Doctors Dovering and Taylor, qu. 1211 Industrial disputes, 679 Northwest Rebellion, pensions and claims, 3523
Royal Canadian Navy, 1878, 2061 Vancouver Drydock, 3542 Harbour work, 1485 Terminal railway, 1485 War, preparation for, 1335
Clark, Dr. Michael, 295
Clarke Trading Co., transport of supplies, 1681
Classification. See Civil Service
Clay Products, 1234
Closure, application of. See Interim Supply
Clothing, duty on, 2186, 2465, 2662. See ulst Budget; Taxation
Coal. See ulso Fuel; Mines; Natural Re sources; Railways
Anthracite importations, qu. 2356, 2686 Bituminous, 2686 British Columbia, mines in, 178 By products of, 3525 Canadian, 2687
Use of in public buildings, 1759 Canadian National Railways Imported for, qu. 926, qu. 2213 Purchases, qu. 2306
Canadian Pacific lands, transfer of, qu. 2214
Competition Fuel oil, 2312
United States Mines, with, 2612 Conservation of supply by power development, 1188. See ulso St. Dawrence River Waterway Drumheller mines, 85 Duty on, 2342
Investigation of low grade, 3525 Freight rates. See ulso that title Manitoba from, 1763 Japan from, qu. 963, 2312, 3406 Dabour. See also that title
Canmore employers and miners dispute, 1058
District No. 18 Board, 1058 Drumheller mines, 86 Employers and miners' dispute, 1058 Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1058
Nova Scotia Miners' strike, 1054. See ulso that title
Oriental aliens, 2312. See ulso that title Cumberland mines, in, 2407 Wages in Nova Scotia, 1078. See also Nova Scotia Miners Bands
Transfer by Canadian Pacific, qu. 2214 United States in, purchase of, 2611 Dignite
Bienfait briquetting plant, qu. 604, 1233.
qu. 1632, 2712-15 Utilization Board, 1233, 3524


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3032 Volume IV: 3041-361P



INDEX -1622 XXIX

[Stage Direction]
Coal -[DOT] Con.
Lightboats, for, qu. 606 Mineral development, 686 Mining industry, protection, 2312 Montreal requirements, 630 Nova Scotia, 2412
Freight charges on, 193, 194 Miners. See that title Powdered, 2713-5
Price of. 465, 1758, 1774, qu. 2037, qu. 2039 Effect of freight rates on, 132-133 Reduction in, 1490, 1494 Public buildings, heating, 1758 Importation for, 1763 Railways
Canadian National Railways, qu. 926, 2213
Purchases for, qu. 2306 Grand Trunk Railway, qu. 606 Royalties, qu. 375 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1316 Smoky river, lease of coal lands, 3465 Supply, control, 71 Transportation. See Freight rates Waterpowers and, 2182
Coats, Mr. R. H. See Statistics, Bureau of
Cocaine. See Opium
Cocoa and Chocolate. See Customs Tariff
Cockshutt, Lieut. Governor, 1128
Cockshutt Plough Company, Minister of Justice and, 242
Codling Moth. See Entomology
Coinage. See also Currency Act Arndt, bill Nickel coin blanks, qu. 3152 Nickel, five cent piece, 1132 Silver, millesimal fineness, 1132
Cold Storage. See Agriculture
Collective Bargaining, 2322
Colonial Status. See Naval Service; Prime Minister's Conference
Combines, 139. See also Address; Budget; Trusts
Combines Investigation Act, qu. 1902
Commerce. See Board of Commerce; Trade
Commercial Travellers. See Budget; Income War Tax Act Arndt.
Commissioner of Agriculture. See Agriculture; Marshall
Commissions
Judges serving on, qu. 366, 546, 2397
Committee of Supply. See Supply
Committees. See House of Commons
Commodity Rates. See Freight Rates; Railways; Transportation
Commodity Tax. See Taxation
Companies Act, Privy Council appeal, legal expenses, 1671
Compensation. See Animal Contagious Diseases amdt.
Compensation for injuries. See Air Board Act Amdt.
Compulsory Enfranchisement. See Indian Act Amdt.
Compulsory Legislation. See Wheat Board
.Compulsory Military Service. See Military Service Act 1917 Amdt. bill
Con Rein, sinking of, M. (Mr. Macdonald, Pietou) 1382, agreed to, 1384
Concurrence. See Supply
Condensed Milk tax on, 2492, 3264-71, 3409
Confectionery, tax on, 2177, 2641, 2676, 2852, 2857
Confederation, basis of, 154
Maritime provinces and, 228. See also Intercolonial Railway
Conferences
Brussels Financial, 1138, 1292 Building trades, 582-3 Cannes, 823, 1716, 1845
Genoa, 7, 58, 156, 212, 582, 1292, 1463, 1675, 1715-6, 1845, 2035, 2337 Expenses, 1715 Europe, in, 1336
Imperial, 1864. See also under this title Prime Ministers'
International Labour, qu. 824, 1060, 1070, 3437, 3490
Printing of report, 3601 Limitation of Armaments, 7, 1283, 1731, ' 1737, 1844-95
Borden, Rt. Hon. Sir Robert, report M. (Mr. Casgrain) for papers, 373 National Industrial, qu. 1375 Postal, 7, 15 Potato growers, 3367
Prime Ministers', 1624, 1864, 1883, 2042. 2082
Trades Union, Rome, 1060
Volume I:: 1-1011). Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
xxxi
Copp, Hon. A. B. (Secretary of State)
Alien enemy property, custodians of, 1672, 3601
Prince Rupert, 3606
Alleged election promises in Charlotte County, N.B., 1994 Archives Branch, Dr. Doughty, 702 Canada Temperance Act, 2024 Civil Service
Commission, 3102 Examinations, 872
Harbour and Rivers. New Brunswick, 1992 Lusitania reparation claims, 3599 Moncton car shops, 1709 Naturalization Act, Amdt. bill, 3104, 3436 Naturalization expenses, 1671 Provincial wharves, New Brunswick. 1992 Public Service Retirement Act Amdt. bill, 1661, 3025, 3148
Rail and car repair contracts, 1708 Secretary of State dept.
Estimates. 701, 1671, 2977, 3499 War claims, adjustment of, 1672, 2977
Privilege, correction of report in Montreal Gazette, 1721 Corporation Control. See Railways Corporation-Owned Railroads in United States, 67-70. See also Railways, Public ownership
Correction of Division List. See House of Commons Divisions
Correspondence, quoting from. See Speaker's
Rulings
Cost of Living, 2349, 2359, 2396, 2578. See 'also Address; Budget; Civil) Service Bonus; Labour; Nova Scotia Miners; Unemployment Labour Gazette and, 1057 Prices, deflation of, 1216-18 Purchasing power of money, 1151-3, 1175, 1177, 1292, 2331, 2603 Sales tax, and, 2676. See 'also that title Tariff and, 2882. See also speeches on Budget
Taxation on, 2364. See also Speeches on Budget
Wages based on, 1303 Cotton Industries
Duties, 2469, 3127. See also Customs Tariff Wages, hours, etc., qu. 1903 Coughlin Shipbuilding Company, 3542 County Courts, establishment in Quebec, 3496
County Fairs. See Agriculture, Exhibitions Courtenay Bay, qu. 365. Sec nlso St. John Harbour
Courtney, B.C., post office building, 1258
Cow Bay wharf, 1766
Cream Separators. See Agricultural Implements
Credits. See Banking; Finance; Financial Credits; Housing; Loans; Roumania and Greece; Unemployment
Crerar, Hon. Thomas A. (Marquette, Leader of the Progressive party)
Address in reply, 50. Congratulations to Speaker, Miss Macphail, mover and seconder of Address; speeches of Prime Minister and leader of Opposition, 50-51; election campaign, 51; negotiations between Government and Progressives, 51; attitude of Progressive party, 52; condition of agriculture; wheat marketing, 53; production costs; transportation costs; freight rates: tariff revision, 54; Sir Lomer Gouin; railways, public ownership, 55-56; immigration, burden of taxation, 56-57; soldiers' re-establishment, 57; Limitation of Armaments; Genoa Conference; economy, need for; burden of taxation, 58; redistribution; proportional representation, 59 Adjustment of war claims, 1672 Agricultural exports, figures used in budget debate, 2638 Agriculture
Condition and prospects, 53, 2156, 2471 Dept., salary increases, 588 Agriculture and Colonization Com.
McCoig, Senator, attendance before, 1901 Wheat Board report, 780. See nlso under this title. Wheat Board Alien enemy property, 1672 American magazines, 3113 Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt. bill, 2102
Audibility of debates, 708 Board of Commerce, 1715 British Columbia, and, 2234-9 British Preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 716
Budget, 2459. Congratulations to Prime Minister; tribute to Finance Minister; difficult and perplexing problems; unsatisfactory financial position; debt and taxation, 2459; railway expenditures; revenue and expenditure; discrepancy between income and outgo, 2460; limit of taxation about reached; economy; new taxation; reorganization of departments and elimination
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xxxii

Crerar, Hon. Thomas A. - Con.
Budget - Con.
of duplication; new administration buildings; overlapping of Dominion and provincial expenditures, 2461; sales tax, inequitable and uns'ound; cheque tax; tax on foreign insurance companies, 2462; co-ordination of financial policy; overlapping of taxation; reciprocity with United States; valuation and marking goods; valuation of currency, 2463; trade with Germany; a protectionist budget; no statement of government policy; agricultural implements, 2464; inconsistencies in agricultural machinery schedule; government failure to implement pledges; clothing; boots and shoes; household equipment, 2465; tariff reductions counterbalanced by sales tax increase; tariff platform of 1919; Liberal resolution of 1921; tariff proposals' not what country requires; discrimination against United States, 2466; tariff legislation before Congress; American factories in Canada; opposition to protection in United States, 2467; Progressive party unalterably opposed to protection; development of natural resources; home market fallacy; manufacture of rubber goods; cotton; raw material and finished product; protection sectional and selfish; movement of population; exodus of Canadian workmen; maritime provinces under protective policy, 2469; rural depopulation in Ontario; prairie provinces; Vancouver and free port proposal, 2470; agriculture prospers in spite of protection; development of west; prosperity from 1900 to 1912 not due to tariff; export of natural products, 2471; tendency of economic thought in Europe; trade begets friendship; the amendment, 2472; no constructive proposal; amdt. to amdt. proposed, 2473 Business of the House
Budget (amdt. to amdt., Sir Henry Drayton) 2473, 2507, 2522 Budget debate, conclusion of, 2640 Easter adjournment, 820 Empire and Ascension Days, adjournment, 1905
Government orders, Monday and Wednesday, 1461, 1720
Privilege on Orders of Day, right to raise, 2638
Crerar, Hon. Thomas A . - Con.
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, loan to, 3036
Canadian National Railways Deficits, 1920
Canadian Northern, 1907 Immigration, 1927
Public ownership and operation, 1920 Rail and car repair contracts, 1689, 1707, 1925
Revaluation of, 1925 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1772 Civil Service
Commission, 3078 Patronage, 3080, 3096 Cold storage warehouse, Montreal, 819 Crowsnest pass agreement, 3595
M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1414-20-29, 1433, 1454 Telegram from Minister of Agriculture to Calgary Board of Trade, 235S Customs
Drawbacks, 766 Dumping clause, 3423 Estimates, 762 Officials, 764
Debates, Official) Report of, insertion of documents not read, 1540 Dominion Iron and Steel Co. contract for steel plates, 1678
Elevators, terminal, administration, 2980. See also under this title, Grain Inquiry Commission
Emigration, record of, 2158 Estimates, accounts chargeable to current or past year, 1675 Freight Rates
Crowsnest pass agreement. See under this title Crowsnest Immigration and, 2157 Genoa Conference, 1715 Cannes Conference, 823 Reported subscription of Canada to consortium, 1463
Governor General's cars, 1688 Grain and grain trade. See nlso under this title Wheat Board
Manitoba Court of Appeal, decision, 1933 Russia, competition in wheat market, 2157
Grain Inquiry Commission, 49, 2982, 2895 Secret session at Fort William, 2983 Hyndman Commission, 2982 Immigration
Central European, 2157 Policy, 2156
Railways, and, 1929, 2157


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
xxxiil
Crerar, Hon. Thomas A. - Con.
Immigration Act Arndt, bill (Mr. Woods -worth) 1394
Intercolonial Railway, maritime management, 193
Interior Dept., economy, 453 Judges' Act Amdt. bill, 426 Justice Dept., contingencies, 1668 Labour
Estimates, 579180 Technical education, 459 Liberal party, negotiations with, 34-35, 51 Limitation of Armaments Conference, 9, 3167
Militia and Defence Co-ordination of services, 417 Expenditure and policy, 1593 National Defence bill, 739-40 Naturalization expenses, 1671 Naval Service
Empire defence contribution, 2081-2 Fleet 420 Policy, 2081
Nova Scotia miners, 508 M. (Mr. Irvine) 542 Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3429 Oleomargarine, manufacture and importation of M. (Mr. Neill) 1821 Ploughs, duty on, 3121-3122 Political inquesting, 404 Population, need of increased, 2158 Privilege, questions of Agricultural figures used in budget debate, 2637
Member's right to raise on Orders of day, 2638
Proportional representation, M. (Mr. Good) 1652
Public ownership, 1920, 1923 Rail and car repair contracts, 1684, 1707, 1925
Railway Act Amdt. bill (Crowsnest pass)
Railway policy 1920, 1923 Responsibility as leader of Opposition, 73 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 835
Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 444 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Salary increases, 398, 404 Discussion out of order, 398, 404 Speaker, election of, 4 Speaker, Mr., death of father, 496 Steamship services Canada-Australia-New Zealand, 3034 Canadian Govt. Merchant marine, subsidies, 3032 Revision of, 3034 West Indies, 3032
Crerar, Hon. Thomas A. - Con.
Steel industry, subsidies to, 1692 Supreme Court Act Amdt. bill, 2974 Tariff, immigration and, 2157 Tractors, duty on, 3124 Treaties of peace with Hungary and Turkey, bill, 3490
Union Government, resignation from, 2490 United Grain Growers, Limited, 2489 Terminal elevator, 2983 Welland ship canal, grain transportation, 2750
Wheat Board, 377, 2922 Fixation of prices, 2588 Proceedings in Committee, 2934 Wheat Board bill, 3186, 3191, 3384, 3386
Crime. See also Criminal Code; Penitentiaries
Foreign immigration and, 1392-4 Criminal Code
Reprinting and revision, 1278, 1717
Criminal Code Amendment Bills
1.	Criminal conspiracy and sedition (Mr. Woodsworth) lr., 364; 2r., 493, 865; com,. 865, 1388; ref. to Special Com., 1395, 1503; report, 1988. For further stages, see Immigration Act Amdt. (Mr. Woodsworth)
2.	Newspaper ownership (Mr. Jacobs) lr.
3.	Scrip Frauds (Mr. Kennedy, Edmonton)
lr., 1062; 2r„ 3211-3217; com., 3217; 3r 3221
4.	Age of consent; automobile theft; bribing police commissioners; carrying animals by railways; carnal knowledge; clerk of peace, Quebec; indecent assault; protection of English hall marks; recovery of penalties from corporations by civil process; retention of fines by municipalities in Ontario (Sir Lomer Gouin) lr., 1841; 2r., com., 2S30, 2973; 3r., 2974; Senate amdts., 3607
Subjects and sections discussed;
Age of consent, 2830-1 Calhoun, Mr., telegram from, 3601 Conveyance of cattle, 2831-34 Feeble-minded person, carnal knowledge of, 2973 Game of chance, 2973 Pool-selling, bookmaking, 2973
Criminal Conspiracies. See Criminal Code Amdt.
Cronyn, Mr. Hume, reference to. See Pensions Committee, final report
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volun^TlV: 304U3619

xxxiv


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX- 1922

[Stage Direction]
Customs Tariff, 1907, Act Arndt, bill (Marking of imported goods; duties; amended rates; drawbacks; prohibited goods) Res. lr., 2r., com., 3476; 3r., 3477
Customs Tariff Items
Adzes, cleavers, etc., 3127 Agate ware, 3118
Anti-dumping clause. See under this title, Dumping
Blankets, 3128, 3132, 3231
M. (Mr. Spencer), 3234, neg. 3235 Book and coated papers, 3108 Boots and shoes, 3236 M. (Mr. Shaw) to reduce, neg. 3238 Changes in. See 'also Tariff revision Chinese. See that title Cigarettes, 3107 Cigars, 3107
Clothes wringers, etc., 3140 Coated papers, 3108 Cocoa, 2116, 3106 Cotton fabrics, 3127 Cultivators, harrows, etc., 3120 Dairy tinware, 3118 Drugs, 3114
Dumping clause, 304, 2184, 2197, 2275, 2494, 2641, 2879, 3188, 3411-13, 3477. See also Customs Tariff Act Amdt.
Pishing hooks, etc., 3140 Flannels, 3137
Fruit and vegetable grading machines, 3126
Gasoline, 3115 Glass bottles, etc., 3117 Harness and saddlery, 3137 Hatters' bands, 3139 Hatters' plush, 3141 Incubators, etc., 3126 Iron and steel tubing, 3118 Linen yarn, 3128 Magazines, 3108 Marking Act, repeal, 8104 Milking machines, 3126 Mowers and harvesters, 3118 Paper invalid cups, 3115 Paper milk bottle caps, 3113-14 Ploughs, etc., 3121, 3229 M. (Mr. Johnston) to reduce, 3121, 3229 Portable and traction engines, 3231 Pump parts, 3127 Sawmill machinery, 3126 Settlers' effects, 3140 Silk cloth, 3137 Street rollers, 3126 Sugar, 3107
Threshing machines, parts, 3124 Tools, 3127 Tractors, 3123
Customs Tariff Items - Con.
White cotton fabrics, 3128 Window shades, etc., 3127 Wool and cotton yarns, 3127 Wool and woollen goods, 3233 Woollen clothing, 3235
Dairy Cattle. See Agriculture, Accredited Herds; Live Stock
Dairying Industry. See also Address; Budget; Oleomargarine
British Columbia Dairymen's Association, 1794
Butter. See that title under Agriculture Competition with other countries, 178 Duties on utensils, reduction in, 2115, 2205, 3118
Exports and imports, 209 Grading of products, 655-6 Implements, reduction of duties on, 2115, 2205, 3118
Milk supply, inspection of herds, 2740. See also Agriculture, Accredited Herds, Health of Animals
National Dairy Council and oleomargarine, 1791
Oleomargarine, 1791, 2205. See uIso that title
Dalrymple, Mr. J. E., qu. 728
Dandurand, Hon. Senator, 1128
d'Anjou, Mr. Emmanuel (Rimouski)
Address in reply, 306; parliamentary rights of French language, 306; economy in Government expenditure, 307 Military expenditure and policy, 1593
D'Arcy Island lazaretto, 2021
Dartmouth, N.S. air station, 1724
Dauphinee, Mr. Charles, dimissal oft 1902,
2458, 2584
Davies, Mr. C. C. (North Battleford)
Wheat Board, participation certificates; funds, qu. 2304
Davies, Right Hon. Sir Louis, K.C.M.G., Deputy of the Governor General, 3610
Daylight Saving, 227, qu. 372 House of Commons, and, 1282 M. (Mr. Kay) for legislation to prohibit, 942, 943
Amdt. (Mr. Duff) 969; Neg. 1314
Deathbed Cases. See Returned Soldiers Insurance Act Amdt.
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II; 1017-2033. Volume III; 2035-3039. Volume IV; 3041 3619
0}



Debates. See House of Commons
Debeaux, Mr. Robert, claim of, 2306
Debt, Public. See Address; Budget; Finance; Loans; Public Debt
Deceased Soldiers. See Soldiers Insurance claims of heirs, 1349. See ulso Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Widowed Mothers. See Pensions
Dechene, Mr. A. M. (Montmagny) Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1801
Deep Sea Racing. See International Deep Sea Racing
Deep Waterway and Power Association.
See St. Lawrence River Waterway
Defence. See Militia and Defence; National Defence; Naval Service
Deficits. See Canadian National Railways
Deflation of Credit. See Finance
Deflation and Inflation of prices. See
speeches on Address and Budget
Delinquents. See Juvenile delinquents Delphine, Colonel, 303 Delta, Manitoba, protective works, 3545 Demers, Captain, 1492
Demers, Mr. M. J. (St. Johns and Iberville) Income tax, Montreal office, qu. 607
Demobilization. See also Militia, Annual Drill; War Claims Estimates, 1171 Expenditure, 1155, 1163, 1171
Denis, Mr. J. Arthur (St. Denis)
Address in reply, 348. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; immigration; Laurier-Fielding tariff, 348 Lamontagne, Mr. Ernest, qu. 824
iDenis, Mr. Jean J. (Joliette)
Budget, 2887. Tribute to Finance Minister; budget proposals generally satisfactory; extravagance of Union Government; acquisition of Railways; Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine; credits to Balkan states; revenue and expenditure, 2888; Progressive party; compromise and co-operation Canada a hard country to govern; Wheat Board; freight rates, 2889; railway
Denis, Mr. Jean J. - Con.
Budget - Con.
deficits made good by East; free trade, 2890; tobacco industry, protection of, 2891
Milk supply, inspection of herds, 2740 Ministers and Directorships, 1113 Solders' insurance, 3321
Denmark, Expedition to Ellesmere Island, 1751
Dennis Building, Halifax, qu. 3360
Department of National Defence bill. See
National Defence
Departmental Expenditure. See Supply
Departmental Law officers, 683, 2572
Dependency. See Pensions, Widowed Mothers
Deportation. See Immigration; Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Arndt.; Oriental Aliens
Depreciated Currency. See Currency; Customs
Deputy Ministers. See Militia Estimates; National Defence Bill; Naval Service Salaries of, 752
Deputy Registrar. See Admiralty Act Arndt, bill
Deputy Sergeant-at-Arms, appointment, 5
Deputy Speaker and Chairman of Committees (Mr. George N. Gordon) Election of, 363
Rulings and statements of. See also House of Commons; Marcil; Speaker Amendments
Already covered, 3147-8 Anticipatory, 2973 Increasing charge on revenue, 3404 Member having already spoken, cannot move, 3558
Moved separately, 3401 Previous, 3148 Bills
Casting vote of Chairman, 3473 New sections proposed, 3445 Private
Com. may not refer back, 1747 Relevancy, 1858 Public
Arndt, dealt with by another amdt. on order paper, 2973


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
xxxvil
Deputy Speaker and Chairman of Committees - Con.
Rnlings and Statements of - Con.
Chair
Decision given, final, 3354 Member may not criticise ruling, 555, 2974
Ruling of non-debatable, 1898 Debate
Inaudibility of, 1755 Member speaking given opportunity to answer questions, 1889 Rule 18, tedious repetition, 1361 Debates, Official Report of Insertion of documents not read, 1539, 3526
Decorum, courtesy to member speaking, 2090
Language, " Breach of duty ", 3354 Members
Desiring to speak, must rise, 1985 May ask question but not make statement, 2489
May not criticise ruling of Chair, 555, 2974
Must put question without argument, 2340
Not in order in discussing ruling of Chair, 555, 2974
Speaking, need not answer questions unless willing, 2318, 2619, 2710 Opportunity to answer, 1889 To rise if vote desired, 3456 Ministers
Not required to answer questions, 2777 On item, may discuss general policy, 555 Motions
Arndt, to Arndt, in supply, 1579 Involving charge on revenue, must be made by minister, 3404 Non-debatable
That committee rise, 1181 Supply, in, 1579
Two, amending same item, 1982 Questions to be put without argument, 2340, 2489
Railway Commission, salaries not included in vote, 2776-8 Reference to judges and high officials, 2778
' Relevancy, 404, 406, 671, 736, 1470, 1476, 1898, 3141
Cash bonus to soldiers, discussion, 404 Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway, bill, 1603
Grain Inquiry commission, 2988 Hudson Bay railway, 2780
Deputy Speaker and Chairman of Committees - Con.
Rulings and Statements of - Con.
Senate, indemnity, 3509 Supply
General policy of department, 560 No question before com. on which to base discussion, 1900 Relevancy, 1135, 2089, 3527, 3545 Lindsay arsenal, 2089 Militia and Defence items to be discussed separately, 1139-40-42 Penitentiaries, 1279 Quebec arsenal, 2095 Quebec riots, 2090 Rails and car repair contracts, 1698 Railway commission, estimates, 2776-8
Railways and Canals, 1135 Two motions, amending same item, 1982 Vote
Casting of, by Chairman, 3473 Desire for in com. to be indicated by members rising, 3456
Derelicts. See Marine and Fisheries
Desbarats, Mr. J. B. See National Defence
Deserted Wives. See Pensions
Deslauriers, Mr. Hermas (St. Mary) Aluminum Electric Co., qu. 728, qu. 1375 Bland, Mr. C. H„ qu. 1773 Boon, Mr. W. R., qu. 728 Canada-West Indies steamship service, qu. 2356
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, employees at Montreal, qu. 2992 Canadian National Railways Electrification, M. 627 Champlain steamer, sale of, qu. 1400 Civil Service
Classification, printed copies of, qu. 1930 Commission, Mr. Putman, 3090 Imperial council, qu. 2803 Marconi Wireless Telegraph Co., qu. 1065 Militia and Defence, permanent force, qu, 2637
Montreal Harbour Commission Paint purchases, qu. 602 Policemen, qu. 2992 Tugs, qu. 600
Occupational diseases, protection against, M„ 1378
Personal explanation, Civil Service estimates, 3365
St. Vincent de Paul penitentiary, qu. 2804 Veit, Mr. A. E. J. M., qu. 1773
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xxxviii


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX- 1922

[Stage Direction]
xxxix
Dominion Lands - Con.
Sub-agencies closed, qu. 1181 Surveys, 1037 Dr. Deville, 1044 M. to reduce, vote, 1039 Reduction of vote by $30,000, 1044-6
Dominion Lands, Notices of Cancellation of Leases bill
lr„ 3151; 2r„ com., 3465; 3r., 3475 Senate amdts., non-concurrence; free conference 3613; concurrence, 3616
Dominion Lands and Parks
Canadian National parks, 168, 1051 Visitors to, 1052 Migratory birds, 1684
Wolves, destruction of live stock by, 990, 998
Dominion Notes. See Finance
Dominion Observatory, Ottawa Building, 1265
Dominion Police. See National Defence; Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Dominion Public Buildings. See Public Buildings
Dominion Statistician. See Statistics
Dominion Textile Company, 200, 583, 1106, 1130
Dorchester Penitentiary. See Penitentiaries
Doughty, Dr. A. B., 702
Douglas Credit System. See Finance; Irvine
Doukhobors. See Immigration
Drainage. See Dominion lands
Drawbacks. See Customs
Drayton, Hon. Sir Henry L. (West York) Address in reply, 195. Provincial prejudices; Mr. Macdonald of Pictou; Minister of Finance and railways, 196; financial outlook; election, popular support of parties, 197; redistribution, campaign literature, 198; public works and unemployment; Halifax patronage committee, 199; Minister of Labour and trusts and combines; Sir Charles Gordon; Canada Cement and Dominion Textile Companies, 200; British Empire Steel Corporation, 200-1; position of Prime Minister and Mr. Crerar; railway policy, 201; Canadian Northern in Ontario, 202; railway
Drayton. Hon. Sir Henry - Con.
Address in reply - Con.
lines in United States, 204; national ownership, 205; Sir Lomer Gouin and the big interests, 206; proposed King-Crerar alliance; leader of Opposition and insult to Quebec; 207; tariff present and former, 208; reciprocity; Fordney tariff, 209; imports and exports of agricultural commodities, 209; reciprocity, 208-211 Adjournment, item stands, 596 Admiralty Act Arndt, bill, 2822 Agricultural implements, drawback, 3122 Air Board, 1728, 1735 Air Board Act Arndt, bill, 2821 Alcohol tax, 1213 American magazines, 3110 Auditor General's office, 793 Budget, date of, inquiry, 1018, 1463, 1503 Budget, 2127. Loans; congratulations to Minister of Finance; financial situation; revenue, 2171; optimism and work; taxes, estimated revenue from; trade agreements; customs and currency valuations, 2172; German competition, 2173; marking of goods; income tax; tariff changes, 2174; agricultural implements, drawbacks, 2175; alcohol for druggists, 2176; beet sugar industry; new taxation, 2177; trade with United States; unemployment, 2178; political honesty; amdt. proposed, 2179 Business of the House
Members, payment of, 3611 Canada Grain Act, administration, 2834 Canada Shipping Act Amdt. bill, 3010 Pilotage, 2820
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 2733 Senate amendments, 3608 Canadian Institute for the Blind, 3540 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3477-86 Census
Completion of, 1363 Cost, 1363
Civil service bonus, 3530 Coal for public buildings, 1759 Criminal Code Amdt. bill, 2831 Fines to municipalities, 2832 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com. 1442 Amdt. 1444. See also under this title Freight Rates
Customs Act and Dept, of Customs bill, 3477
Customs and Excise Dept., employees, 765
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Drayton. Hon. Sir Henry - Con.
Customs tariff
Book and coated papers, 3108
Cigars, 3107
Cocoa, 3106
Drugs, 3114
Gasoline, 3116
Marking Act, 3105
Pump parts, 3127
Wool and Woollen goods, 3129, 3130, 3233 Customs Tariff Act Amdt. bill, 3476 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 957 Anonymous letters, 944 Drayton-Acworth report, 126 Elevators, terminal, 2978 Estimates
Accounts chargeable, current or past year, 1675
Discussion of general policy, 767 Exchequer Court, estimates, 1274 Finance Dept.
Charges of management, 770 Salaries, 753
Fisheries Act Amdt. bill, 3011 Fishing tackle, 3140
Freight rates, Special Com., third report, 3555
Amdt. 3559. See also under this title Crowsnest pass French trade treaty, 3224 German goods, valuation, 2172, 3227 Grain
Inquiry Commission, 2984-6 Shipment of via Quebec, 1466 Grand Trunk arbitration, newspaper comments, 821
Harbours and rivers, estimates, 1765 Health dept, estimates, 775 Housing, 774
Immigration facilities at Quebec, 1466 Income War Tax Act Amdt. bill, 3485 Inland Revenue
Alcohol for druggists, 3242 Sugar beet, tax on, 3242 Inland Revenue Act Amdt. bill, 3477 Insurance Dept. 792 Interim Supply, 373, 378, 383, 598 Interior dept.
Economy, 456 Salaries, 452 Typewriters, 455 Justice dept.
Appropriations exceeded, 1279 Contingencies, 1669 Labour dept.
Appointments, 462 Salaries, 548
Drayton. Hon. Sir Henry - Con.
League of Nations, 3174
Secretariat, Canada's contribution, 3990 Loans, 2127
New Canadian, 1133 Special Loans bill, 3476 Meat and Canned Foods bill, 3149 Militia and Defence Amalgamation of services, 419 Naval Service, 422 War claims, adjustment, 2974 Montreal Harbour Commission bill, 3199 Naval service, 1737
New departmental buildings, Ottawa, 3541 Non-productive assets, 1467 Nova Scotia miners, 509, 512 M. (Mr. Irvine 540)
Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3489 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 2824
Penitentiaries, inmates, increase in number, 1279
Penny Bank Act Amdt. bill, 3043 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3404, 3439-64 Pensions
Commutation of, 390 Widowed mothers, M. (Mr. Power) 1308 Prime Minister, secretaries, 411 Printing plants, tax, 3410 Public Accounts, delay in closing, 1264 Public buildings Coal for, 1759 Expenditure, 1260
Public Service Retirement bill, 3148 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1465-86, 3195
Quebec harbour, Parc St. Charles Co., 1470 Railway Commission, statement of Mr. Carvell, 2774 Redistribution
Census and, 1363, 1369 M. (Mr. Shaw), 1769 Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Amdt.
bill, 3389, 3397, 3438 Revenue and Audit Act, 3042 St. Lawrence river waterway, correspondence, 2207
Sales tax collections, 1921-22, qu. 1212 Saskatchewan, export of liquor, 3000, 3002' Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Capital expenditure, 1279 Patients, care and medical examination of, 1280
Soulanges canal, 2768
Special War Revenue Act Amdt. bill, 3477 Cheque tax, 3258
Supreme Court Act Amdt. bill, 2974 Supreme Court, pre-audit, 1274


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 xll

[Stage Direction]
Drayton. Hon. Sir Henry - Con.
Tariff Commissioner, appointment, 1664 Transcontinental railway, 917 Transportation Costs, Special Com. See under this title, Crowsnest pass; Freight Rates
Treaties of Peace with Hungary and Turkey, bill, 3547
United States, operation of railways in Canada, 192
Vancouver Harbour Commission bill, 2822 Vickers, Limited, 2975-7 War claims
Adjustment of, 2974, 2977 Exchange, 1758 War Graves Commission, 774 Weston post office building, 1259
Drayton-Acworth report, 46, 125, 130
Dredges and Dredging. See also Marine; Public Works Estimates, 2005 Plamonder, 2006 Port Nelson, 2006 Quebec harbour, 1483 Red river channel, 2007 St. Lawrence river ship channel De Beaujeu bank, 1495 New elevator dredge, 1495 St. Marys river, 2006 Shuswap lake, 2006
Druggists, alcohol for, 2114. See also Alcohol
Drumheller mines, 85, 1058
Drummond, Mr. J. D. F. (West Middlesex) Beet sugar industry, 2273, 3251 Budget, 2272. Progressives, attitude towards; public debt; duty on beet sugar, 2272; tariff, duty on agricultural implements; farmers not asking special privileges, 2274 Goderich harbour, improvement, 2002
Drury, Hon. E.C., and Drury Government,
63, 125, 127, 134, 334
Lake of the Woods, control. 2991. See that title
Land tax, and, 2491 Dry Docks
Burrard Dry Dock Company, 2008 Esquimau, 347
Appropriation, 3541	;
Pacific Coast on, 2401 Subsidies to, 2008 Vancouver, 2005, 2008, 3542
Drysdale, Mr. Justice, retirement of, 1275
Duff, Mr. William (Lunenburg)
Air Board, qu. 366 Air Force and civil aviation, 1724 Banff-Windermere road, 1683 British Columbia fisheries, M. (Mr. Mc-Quarrie) 857
Canada Shipping Act Arndt. (Pilotage) bill, 2819
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine Cost, etc., qu. 469 Subsidized steamship services, 3031 Canadian national parks, expenditure, 1681 Canned fish, marking of tins, 3048 Civil Service
Commission, qu. 364 Overmanning, 3099 Patronage, 3094 Rural postmasters, 3095-6 Con Rein, sinking of, 1384 Courtenay Bay works, qu. 365 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) amdt. 959 Distressed seamen, relief of, 1676 Dominion Iron and Steel Corporation contract, 1677
Fishing schooner race, 1384, 3513 Flags, cost of, qu. 599, 1264, 1268 Halifax terminals, qu. 364 Harbours and rivers Expenditure, details of, 1272 Ontario, 2000
International deep sea racing M. for encouragement, 1384, 3513 Marine and Fisheries Capt. O'Hara, 1490
Examination of masters and mates, 1490 Migratory birds, 1685	*
Military and naval expenditures, reduction, 1139
National Defence bill, 740 Naval policy, 2052 Naval Service
Aurora, cruiser, 2053 Royal Canadian navy, qu. 366, 1848, 1871, 2052
Navigation off Newfoundland coast, aids to, 1498
Nova Scotia pensioners, qu. 615
Public buildings, flags, qu. 599, 1264, 1269
Toronto harbour works, qu. 365
Tourist traffic, 1683
Unemployment, 1683
War service badge, 1754
Wooden ships, qu. 364
Dumping Clause. See Customs and Excise
Duties. See Customs and Excise; Customs Tariff
Dynevor Hospital, 1218
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xlil

Easter Adjournment. See House of Commons
Eastern Car Company, car repairs, 1706
Eastern La Have Transportation Company. See Con Rein
Eastern Maine Railway, 1293
Economic Depression, 6, 10, 85, 157, 237-8, 3299. See also speeches on Address; Budget
Economy in Administration, necessity for, 7, 52, 97, 122, 455-6. See also speeches on Address; Budget; Civil Service; Supply
Eddie, Captain, 1493
Edison, Mr. T. A., credit system, 2505
Editorial Committee, 1235-6
Edmonton
Indian school, proposed, 1227-9. See also Indians
Post office building, alteration, 1254
Edmundston
Post office, qu. 608 Public building, 1239, 1242
Education
Indians. See that title Orientals in British Columbia, 317. See also Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) Rural schools in Ontario, 2385, 2565 School boards, refusal of bank to advance money to, 2627 School lands, 339 School system, 2385 Taxes in school districts, 2714
Eggs
Chinese, importation of, 177 Cold storage in, 2562 Exportation, 813 Imported into Canada, qu. 612 Inspection and standardizing, 177, qu. 727, 811-812
Eight-Hour Day. See Daylight Saving; Labour
Election Day. See Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill
Election of Speaker. See Speaker
Election of 1921
Campaign, 21, 40-41, 51, 61, 99, 140, 198, 265, 288. See to Iso Address; Budget; Proportional Representation
Election of 1921 - Con.
Campaign - Con.
Brantford at, 255, 256 Charlotte, N.B., county in, 1997 Funds, and protected interests, 2437, 2732 Literature, 99
Statements by Sir Lomer Gouin, 140 Chief Electoral Officer, report, 1258 Deposits refunded, qu. 1067 Liberal pledges, cash grants to soldiers, 102, 400. See also Liberal Convention; Soldiers' Bonus
Maritime provinces in, 315-316 Minority government, 197. See also speeches on Address; Budget Number of votes cast, 197 Pledges and promises, 243. See also Liberal Convention; Soldiers' Bonus Rail and car repair contracts, prior to, 1688 Results, 61, 142, 186, 197, 2282, 2654, 2851, 2909-2910,
By provinces, 46
Returning officer, Carleton, 3538, 3602, 3604 Unit of representation, 198 Voters, failure to vote, 1112 Women, 1113
Electoral System. See Proportional Representation
Electric Power. See also Aluminum Company; Hydro Electric; Lake of the Woods; St. Lawrence River Waterway; Water Powers Campbell river, 1355 Railways and, 1940
Electrical storm in the West, 3493
Electrification of Railways, 133, 630. See also Canadian National Railways; Railways; St. Lawrence River Waterway M. (Mr. Deslauriers) withdrawn, 639
Elevators. See Grain and Grain Trade; Wheat Board
Elk Island Park, fencing, 1051
Ellesmere Island
Danish expedition to, 1751
Royal Canadian Mounted Police at, 3497
Elliott, Mr. William (South Waterloo) Budget, 2348. Tribute to Minister of Finance; tariff proposals a step in the right direction; national debt; revenue and expenditure; civil service; United States tariff; development of natural


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
xlill
Elliott, Mr. William - Con.
Budget - Con.
resources, 2348; markets, building' up of industry at expense of agriculture; high cost of living, unemployment; labour conditions; boots and shoes; labour cost; woollen cloth, labour cost, 2350; woollen clothing, price and labour cost, 2350; permanent {tariff commission; claims for tariff protection, 2351
Galt post office building, 1247
Embargo
Cattle. See Cattle Embargo Manure, exportation of, 1021
Emigration. See Immigration
Empire, British
Foreign policy and defence, 1629. See also Limitation of Armaments; National Defence bill; Naval Service
Empire Day adjournment. See House of Commons
Employment Offices Co-ordination Act, 1058
Employment Service. See Labour
Enemy Debts. See Treaties with Hungary and Turkey
Enemy Property. See Aliens, Enemy Property
Enfranchisement
Indians of. See Indian Act Arndt, bill Women of alien birth. See Dominion Elections Act
English River water powers. See Lake of the woods
Entomology, 813. See also Destructive Insects Spruce bud moth, 1049
Escheats Act Arndt, bill (Time in which action must be brought) lr., 2456; 2r„ com., 2826; 3r., 3026; Senate amdts. 3486
Espionage. See Labour; Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Esquimalt. See also Naval Service Dry dock; 347, 596-7 Appropriation, 3541
Royal naval college at 2047, 2203, 2450
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company
bill. See Private Bills Discussed
Essence de I'Erable, qu. 1774
Estimates. See also Deputy Speaker; House of Commons; Interim Supply; Speaker; Supplementary Estimates; Supply. For departments, See their titles Accounts chargeable to current or past year, 1675
"Appropriations not required", 1269 Classification and preparation, 569 Comparison with last year, 384 Consideration of, 3526 Deta'ils of, 1347
Government economy in, 381-382 Information not up to date, 1267 Items, reading of, 3545 Main
Comparison with last year, 381 Tabled, 363
One-fourth vote. See Interim Supply Supplementary, tabled, 1258, 3463 War claims, details of, qu. 1288
Ethier, Mr. J. A. C. (Laval-Two Mountains) Bankruptcy Act Amdt bill, 1132, 1662 Indians, Oka agent, 1217
Euler, Mr. William D. (North Waterloo) Agriculture Com. report, Wheat Board, 781 Alien Birth, women of, enfranchisement, M., 473, 480
Canadian National Railways Canadian Northern deficit, 1906 Public ownership operation, 1948 Re-valuation, 1926 Civil Service, promotions, 576 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 950 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1788 Quebec public utilities, 1912 Railway policy, 1948
European Credits. See Loans
European War. See War
Evans, Mr. John (Saskatoon)
Address, 300. Agriculture in a deplorable state; rates on grain; railway consolidation, 300; tariff and trade prevention, 301; national policy a failure, 302: freer trade relations, 303; protected combines; railway question, 304; tariff views of different parties; returned soldier farmers, 305 Agricultural implements Dumping clause, 2360 Importation by United Grain Growers, 3118, 3119
Agriculture dept., professional men, 588 American magazines, 3113
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xliv

Evans, Mr. John - Con.
Apple Industry, 3417
Armorial bearings of Canada, "Welsh emblem, 3601 Beef hides, 3138 Blankets, duty on, 3130 British preference and Canadian ports, M. (Mr. Logan) 711
Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1963
Canadian Pacific Railway bill, 1608 Canadian Press, Limited, 772 Crowsnest pass agreement Telegram of Mr. Motherwell to Calgary Board of Trade, 2358 Customs
Drawbacks, 765, qu. 828, 1067 Dumping clause, 2360, 3417 Fruit-growers, protection, 3417, 3425 Hudson Bay railway, completion, 2795 Humboldt-Fort Pitt telegraph line, 2007 Immigration Medical inspection, 759 Money qualification, 3058 Unrestricted, 3062 Live stock industry, 989 Mowers and harvesters, 3118 Naval policy, 2072 Post office salaries, 2801 Railway policy, 1963 Saskatoon post office building, 1253 Soldiers' land settlement, 305, 2132 Steamship subsidies, qu. 614 Welland ship canal, 2758
Excess Profits tax. (See Taxation
Exchange. See also Finance Claim by British Admiralty for refund, 1752
Foreign, 2264 Rate of, 286
Soldiers' money on, 3339, 3348
Exchequer Court of Canada
Admiralty, vacancies, 1275. See also Admiralty Act Estimates, 1274
Excise Taxes. See Customs and Excise; Inland Revenue Act Amdt.; Special War Revenue Act
Exemptions. See Income Tax Act; Special War Revenue Act
Pilotage dues, from. See Canada Shipping Act Amdt.
Exhibitions, 2582. See also Agriculture; Live Stock; Trade and Commerce
Exhibitions 

 Con.
Agricultural. See that title Canadian National, 2990 Estimates, 2026 France, in, 2031, 2990 Grants to, 649, 977, 3521 London, 2027 Tampa, Florida, 2026
Expenditure. See Finance; Public Expenditure
Experimental and Illustration Farms. See
Agriculture
Explosives Act, 1234
Export Liquor warehouses. See Liquor
Exports. See that title under Imports and Exports; Trade
Ex-service Men, representative. See Pensions Committee
External Affairs, Department of Con Rein, sinking of, 1382 Doherty, Hon. Manning, 1283 Papers and memorandum, 1334 Salaries and contingencies, 411, 3509 War claims, adjustment of. See War claims
Fafard, Mr. J. Fernand (L'lslet)
Butter imports, qu. 614 Canadian National railways, water supply, qu. 2213
Fair Wage Clause. See Labour
False Creek, removal of bridge, 3516
Fansher, Mr. B. W. (East Lambton)
Beet Sugar industry, 2232, 3246, 3251 M. to reduce duty, 3248 Budget, 2229. Fiscal policy; tariff revision; encouragement of native industries; agricultural implements; sales tax; business profits tax; protected industries, 2230-1; automobiles, duty and tax; beet sugar industry, 2232
Customs drawbacks, qu. 2356
Far Eastern Treaty, 3160. See also Limitation of Armaments
Farm Implements. See Agricultural Implements
Farm Lands, value of, 2565


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 xlv

[Stage Direction]
Farm Products
Consumption in Canada, 2650. See also Budget
Decline in prices, 6, 11, 77, 93, 95, 113, 150, 225, 231. See also Address; Agriculture; Budget; Live stock
Fordney tariff, effect of, 209. See also United States, Fordney tariff Exchange value of, 2576 Importation, 209 Trade in, 226. See also Trade
Farmers
Block in United States, 69, 210, 988. See also Address; Budget; Trade; United States
Eight-hour day and, 227. See also Daylight Saving
Geographical advantages, 297-9 Immigration of, 145, 225. See also that title Income tax returns, 226, qu. 1063, 2241, 2631. See also Income Tax Labour, 79, 87, 251, 337, 1153. See also Address; Budget; Immigration; Labour; Unemployment Loyalty of, 526 Need of encouragement, 252 Profits, comparison of, 2333 Protection and. See Agricultural Implements; Budget Remedial legislation, 157 Representation in Parliament. See Progressives
Sons, exemption from military service, 440, 448-9, |268i5. See '.also, Military Service Act Amdt.
Transportation problems. See Freight rates
"Want of confidence in future, 143 Western, 146-7, 357
And wheat marketing. See Wheat Board
Grievances, 2652
Farmers' Movement and Party. See Progressive Party
Federal Civilian Force. See National Defence bill; Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Federal Elections Act. Sec Dominion Elections Act
Federal Representation by provinces, in 1877, qu. 1183
Federal Subsidies. See Subsidies
Feed Control Act, 1011
Female Suffrage. See also Dominion Elections Act
Failure of women to vote, 1113
Fertilizers. See also Agricultural Fertilizers bill
Cost of, 770 Duty on, 3140-3141 Freight rates on, 1022 Ground limestone, 1024 Inspectors, 592
Natural, exportation of, 1019 Tariff and, 2664
Fiduciary Interest. See Ministers and Directorships
Fielding, Hon. W. S. (Minister of Finance) Agricultural implements, duty on, 3120, 8141. See also under this title, Customs Tariff
Alcohol for druggists, duty on, 2114, 3241 Alleged election promises, Charlotte, N.B. 1997
American magazines, 3108-3111 Appropriation Acts, 363, 598-9, 1842-3, 3607 Auditor General's office, 793 Auditor General's report Public Works, expenditure of previous year, 1270
Referred to public Accounts Com., 1462 Automobiles, 2850, 2853, 3275. See also under this title, Special War Revenue Act
Refund of taxes, 3600 Value up to $1,000 for settlers, 2116 Banks
Circulation, tax on, 2117 Interest rates, 3602 Beet Sugar. See under this title, Sugar Board of Commerce, 1715 Boy Scouts, 772-773
British Columbia government, criticism, 2237
Budget, inquiries as to date of, 1018, 1463, 1503
Budget Speech, 2104; Financial position of Dominion, 2104-17; economy, income and expenditure, 2104; public debt, 2106; loans, 2107; trade, 2108; trade agreements and negotiations; tariff revision, 2110-14; British preference; trade with United States, 2111; Marking and valuation; currency, 2113; certificate of trade or consular agent; tariff reductions. 2114; new taxation, 2116; financial situation; tariff resolutions, 2118
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xlvi

Fielding, Hon. W. S. - Con.
Budget - Con.
Supplementary statement, 2842. Acknowledgement of tributes and congratulations, 2842; attitude of Progressives towards Budget, 2842; step in right direction; Liberal policy as declared, in 1921, supported by Progressive members; a policy of moderation; tariff and sales tax, 2843; land and inheritance taxes; tariff proposals; tariff revision of 1897; predictions of bankers and manufacturers; trade revival; reduction in duties, 2844; change in policy of Sir John Macdonald; British preference; Sir Charles Tupper; reciprocity; "no truck or trade with Yankees"; opposition of Conservative party to trade arrangement; Liberal party ready to discuss question; value of United States market; Windsor Hall speech, 2846; industrial condition of Germany, 2847; depreciated currency; value of mark and commodity prices; trade with Germany; treaty of Versailles; valuation of currency, 2848; increased taxation effect of currency valuation on Italian trade; a protectionist budget; downward revision; Progressives would not have been able to do more; direction in which Liberal party is looking, 2849; drawbacks and refunds; Ford motor company; Atlantic Sugar refineries; goods in transit; manufacture for export, 2850; Opposition amdt.; Liberal platform of 1919; verdict of electors; proposed changes in budget proposals; amended resolutions, 2851; tax on confectionery; soft drinks; ale, beer,* porter and stout; cigarettes; fertilizers and dried beet pulp; cheque tax, 2852; bond and stock transfers, 2853; beet root sugar; raw leaf tobacco; receipts; cigars; automobiles; depreciated currency, 2853 Business of the House. See also under this title, Estimates; Supply
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Crerar) 2473-74, 2522
Civil government items, 374
Daylight saving, 1282
Member interrupting, must ask permission, 255-6
Privilege, right to raise on Orders of the day, 2638
Questions standing as orders for returns, 1660
Fielding, Hon. W. S. - Con.
Business of the House - Con Special loan bill, 3151 Supplementary estimates, 3365 Supply, concurrence, 1842 Business profits war tax, 1658, 2024 Canadian battlefields, 772 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3156, 3366, 3477-86
Canadian Press, Limited, 772 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1747, 1771 Cattle embargo, reported statement of Mi Larkin, 1023
Chartered banks, returns, 865 Cheque tax, 2117, 2852, 3258 Cigars and cigarettes, tax on, 2852, 3239, 3240
Commissioner of Taxation, salary, 2024 Confectionery, tax on, 2852 Congratulations to on fortieth year of public life, 3279
Consolidated Revenue and Audit Act Amdt. bill, 1210, 3042 Currency Act, 1910, Amdt. bill, 1132, 3042 Currency, depreciated, valuation for customs, 2113, 2849, 2853 Customs Act and Dept of Customs and Excise Act Amdt. bill, 3222, 3476, 3477 Depreciated currency, 3223, 3224, 3410 Dumping clause, 3225, 3411 German goods, valuation, 3229 Invoices certificates, 3221 Wines and spirits in bond, 3229 Customs drawbacks, 2850, 3141 Customs Tariff
Blankets, 3128, 3131, 3136, 3234
Book and coated papers, 3108
Boots and shoes, 3238
Cigars, 3107
Cocoa, 3106
Cotton, fabrics, 3128
Gasoline, 3106, 3115, 3116
Glass bottles, 3117
Grading machines, 3126
Hatters' bands, 3140
Invalids' wheel chairs, 3115
Marking Act, 3105
Mowers and harvesters, 3118
Paper invalid cups, 3115
Paper milk bottle caps, 3114
Ploughs, 3121, 3229
Pumping machinery, 3127
Reductions, 3239
Saw-mill machinery, 3126
Silk, 3127
Tools, 3127
Tractors, 3123


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
Xlvii
Fielding, Hon. W. S. - Con.
Dominion Iron and Steel Corporation, claim, 2170
Dumping clause, 3225, 3411.
Estimates. See also under this title; Supply Accounts chargeable to current year, 1675
" Appropriations not required ", 1269 Items, urgent, 409 Procedure, 409 Tabled Main, 363
Supplementary, 1258, .2465 Fabre, Madame, pension, 2024 Fertilizers, duty on, 2852, 3141 Finance Dept.
Charges of management, 770 Deputy minister, 753 Estimates, 751, 1663, 3495 Legal expenses, railways, 1667 Loans, 771. See also under this title, Loans, Unforeseen expenses, 771 Fire prevention, 794
Fiscal year, ending of, 1210. See also under this title, Consolidated Revenue and Audit Act
Fisheries, reduction in duties on, 2116 Fishing schooner race, 3512 France-Belgium trade treaties, 3223 Girl guides, 774
Governor General's Secretary's office, 751 Harbours and rivers New Brunswick, 1998 Nova Scotia, expenditure in 1921-22, 1269 Prince Edward island, 1989-90 Housing, 774
Immigration Act Arndt, bill (Mr. Woods -worth) 865
Imperial Convention, of Teachers, 1673 Imports, marking and valuation of, 2113, 2849, 2853, 3229 Income tax
Cost of collection, 2025 Legislation, 3104
Income War Tax Act Arndt, bill, 3278-9, 3359, 3484
Inland Revenue Act Arndt, bill, 3477 Alcohol for druggists, 2114, 3241 Cigars and cigarettes, 3239, 3240 Home brewing, 3141 Sugar beets, 2117, 2853, 3242, 3248 Insurance Act Arndt, bill, 1210, 1464, 3143, 3607
Insurance officials, 791 Insurance premiums, tax, 3253, 3255, 3477 Interim Supply, 373, 378, 383, 598 Bill, 362, 598-9
Fielding, Hon. W. S. - Con.
Labour and capital, 2117 Liberal platform of 1919, tariff plank, 2529, 2851
Loan Companies Act Amdt. bill, 1210, 1464, 3142, 3607 Loans, 771, 2107 New Canadian, 1131, 1133 Special loans bill, 3476 Merchants' Bank, inquiry, 3604 Nova Scotia miners, 497 M. (Mr. Irvine) 543
Nova Scotia Supreme Court, vacancy, 3437 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1814 Penny Bank Act Amdt., bill, 1132, 3043, 3148
Pensions to Imperial forces, 864 Personal statement, correction, 681 Private Bills Com., substitution of names, 2355
Public Accounts, closing of, 1210, 1264-66 Public buildings Flags, 1265
Generally, expenditure, accounts not closed, 1263-66 New, 1256
Public Works estimates, 696, 697, 750 Rail and car repair contracts', 1697 Railways, annual statement, 926 Reciprocity with United States, 2111, 2845-6
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Amdt. bill, 3320, 3392, 3395
Revenue and Audit Act Amdt. bill, 1210, 3042
Root vegetables, inspection and sale of, 2744
St. Lawrence river waterway, 786 Co-operation with the United States, 2765 Sales tax, 2116, 2843, 2851. See also under , this title, Special War Revenue Act Save the Children fund, 3516 Senate indemnity, 3509 Soldiers' Bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 442 Special loans bill, 3476 Special War Revenue Act Amdt. bill, 3477 Automobiles, 3275 Ford company, 3276 Cheque tax, 3258
Insurance premiums, tax, 3253, 3255, 3477 Matches, 3263 Mineral waters, 3278 Receipts, 3262 Sales tax, 2116, 3264, 3269 Amdt. (Mr. Speakman) 3271 Condensed milk, 3268, 3409 Job printing, 3409 Steamship services, 2029
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume 111: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xlviil

Fielding, Hon. W. S. - Con.
Sugar
British preference increased, 2116 Excise duty on beet sugar, 2117, 2863, 3242, 3248
Supply bills, 362, 598-9, 1842-3, 3607 Supply, concurrence, 1769, 1842 Tariff Commission, 1663 Tariff reductions, 2114, 2844, 2851, 3123 Tariff revision, 2110-14, 2844, 2849 Taxation, increases in, 2116, 2843, 2848, 2851-3
Tobacco, duties on, 2115, 2852-3, 3107, 3239 Trust Companies Act Amdt. bill, 1210, 1464, 3142, 3607 United States
Reciprocity with, 2111, 2845-6 Visit to Washington, 2112 War claims, exchange, 1754 War Graves Commission, 774 Wrangel island, 1750
Filled Milk and cream, qu. 963. See also Milk; Oleomargarine
Films, Educational. See Trade and Commerce
Finance. See also Banks; Budget; Financial Credit; Loans
Additional currency issue, qu. 3155
Bank deposits, qu. 3155
Bank notes in circulation, qu. 3155
Banking conditions, 158
Bonds
And stock, transfers, tax, 2853 Tax-free, maturing, qu. 826 Canada's financial position, soundness of, 2497
Commitments, 208
Credit .Systems. See Financial Credit Department
Charges of management, 770, 1663 Deputy Minister, 751 Estimates, 1662 Expenditure, economy in, 1475 Dominion Notes, qu. 705, qu. 935, qu. 3153, qu. 3154
Expenditure, monthly statement of, 1271 Legal expenses, 1667 Paper Control inqury, 1673 Salaries, 751, 3504 Unforeseen expenses, 771 Estimate of wealth and production, 2497 Excise profits and watered stock, 2714 Financial position of country, annual statement of Minister, 2104-2118 Gold reserve, qu. 3154, qu. 3155 Gold standard and credit system, 219
Finance - Con.
Grain trade, 2246 Loan department, 220
National wealth, 222. See also Natural Resources
Per capita wealth, 2630 Sinking funds, 1663
Financial Conference, Brussels, 1138, 1292
Financial Credit, 208, 219, 221, 2497-8. See also Banks; Finance; Loans; Money Banks and, 1290, 2501, 2714 Brussels Conference, 1138, 1292 Community power, use of for private interest, 1291, 2501
Control of, 222, 1292, 2445, 2500 Germany in, 2500 Credit systems, 2634 Attempts to inaugurate Guernsey Island, 2505 St. Louis Municipal currency, 2506 Definition of Credits, 2503 Douglas system, 220, 222, 2502 Financial organizations, consolidation, 2245-6
Gold standard and, 219, 1291, 2506 Greece and Roumania, qu. 1400 Industrial stagnation and unemployment, 1291. See also Industrial depression Inflation and deflation, 2502 Loans, 1292. See also that title M. (Mr. Irvine) for Parliamentary Com., 1289, 1396
National credit power, 1291, 2499 Private monopoly of, 2501 Purchasing power, 1292 Restricted, 2629-30
Scientific inquiry and experimentation, 1289 Sociological laboratory, 1290 Systems, 2282
Financial Depression and Outlook. See speeches on Address; Budget
Findlay, Mr. J. W. (South Bruce)
Budget, 2893. Protection and blind party-ism; reciprocity, 2893; Ontario farmer not a protectionist; Progressives in Ontario; Laurier naval policy; tariff reductions; public morality and political honour; pledges and promises; Senate reform, 2894; debt and increased taxation; expenditure; reduction of sessional indemnity; drawbacks; protective budget, 2895 Potlach, Indian institution, 1578 Indians serving gaol sentences, 1721


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
xlix
Fines, payable to municipalities, 2832. See also Criminal Code Arndt, bill
Finney, Colonel John, 1189
Fire
Insurance. See Insurance Losses, railways from, 628 Prevention, 794. See also Air Service; Forestry; Insurance
First Contingent, training, qu. 1376
Fiscal Changes. See Budget; Tariff resolutions; Taxation
Fiscal Year. See Consolidated Revenue Act Arndt, bill/
Fish and Fisheries. See also Marine and Fisheries
Boats admitted as settlers' effects, 2116 British Columbia. See also that title Depletion of, 346
Orientals engaged in, 167, 171, 344. See also Oriental Aliens M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 851, 863 Salmon traps, 346
Transfer, 2042. See also Quebec Fisheries
Canning. See Meat and Canned Foods Act Canning and curing licenses, 3010 Deep sea, conservation and development, 2169
Department of Fisheries, 2166 Dry salting, 3010 Estimates, 2166 Fish culture, 2169 Fishermen's supplies, 2690 Fishing schooner race. See International Deep Sea Racing Fishing vessels, pilotage, 2819 Fishways in rivers, 2166 Gasoline for fishing boats, 2313, 3116 Guardians, salaries, 2166 Hatcheries, 2169 Herring, dry salting, 3010 Herring, in Alaska, 70
Improved methods, Gulf and Gaspesian coasts, qu. 1401
International deep sea racing. See that title Licenses. See Quebec fisheries Lobster, 1399, 2817, 2996 Market, 2166
Mildred McColl, patrol boat, qu. 3598 Officers and guardians, salaries, 2166	'
Orientals. See Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie)
Patrol service, 2166
Boats, qu. 1503, qu. 3598 "Phalarope", qu., 1503
Fish and Fisheries - Con.
Pollution of streams, 2168 Prince county, illegal fishing, qu. 371 Protection service. See Marine; National Defence; Naval service Publicity and marketing, 2169 Quebec, transfer of, 142. See also Quebec Fisheries
Range lights for fishermen, 1498 Rope, twine, etc., duty on, 2359 Salmon, 1399, 2817, 2996 Dry salting, 3010 Sardines, export, qu. 1182 Supplies, reduction in duties, 2116, 2359 Tariff reductions on implements of, 2191 Transportation, 2166 Vocational loans to fishermen, 1346
Fisher and Oughton, Messrs. See Aliens
Fisheries Act, 1914, Arndt, bills
1.	Protection of Salmon and Lobster Fisheries. lr., 1399; 2r., com., 2817; com., 2996; 3r., 2997
2.	Salmon Curing and Herring Drying.
Res. 2306, 3010; lr., 2r., com., 3r., 3013
Fisheries Protection Service. See Marine; National Defence bill; Naval Service
Fishing Schooner Race. See International
Flag-Waving, 1265, 1386, 2711
Flags
Cost of, qu, 599
For public buildings, 1260, 1264, 1268 Flavelle, Sir Joseph, 634. See also Canadian National Railways, Directors
Flax
Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim of, 2834 Canadian bounty on linen yarn from, 1361
Flour
Exports to United States, 209 Insurance on mills, 3255
Flynn, Mr. Harry, and soldiers' bonus, 394, 402
Fontaine, Mr. J. E. (Hull)
Gatineau Point-Rockliffe ferry, qu. 1399, qu. 1661
Old age pensions, M., 1303 Post Office
Classification, 3089 Employees receiving $600, qu. 1067 Married women, qu. 1658 Money Order branch, qu. 1285
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Food and Drug Act, administration, 2017
Food and Drugs. See Health; Meat and Canned Foods
Food Inspection, 820
Foot and mouth Disease. See Cattle Embargo
Foran, Mr. J. J., qu. 2214
Foran, Mr. W., See Civil Service Commission
Ford Car. See Automobiles
Ford, Mr. Henry, credit scheme, 2505
Fordney Tariff. See Budget Speeches; United States
Foreign-Born wives of British subjects. See Dominion Election Act Amdt.
Foreign Currency. See Customs, Marking; Currency
Inflation. See Customs and Excise Dept, bill
Foreign Fraternal Societies. See Insurance Act Amdt.
Foreign Loans. See Loans
Foreign Markets. See Trade
Foreign Monetary Standards. See Customs; Currency
Foreign Warships. See Canada Shipping Act Amdt. bill
Foreigners. See also Aliens Crime and, 1392, 2517
Foreign-born wives and children of British subjects. See Dominion Elections Act Amdt.
Immigration. See that title Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth) 1388-94
Textile industries, engaged in, 2518
Forest, Mr. MSdard, qu. 2355
Forestry. See also Natural Resources; Research; Timber Aerial patrol, 1047, 1722 Gaspe, 1733
High River, Alta., qu. 1066, 1048, 1723 Railway belt, B.C., 1730 Fire losses, 628 Fire towers, 1048
Forest area under federal control, 1048 Protection of timber in West, 1046 Pulpwood and round logs, duty, 2667
Forestry - Con.
Spruce bud moth, 1049, 2668 Tree culture in West, 1046 Turtle Mountain reserve, qu. 615
Forke, Mr. Robert (Brandon)
Address in reply, 76. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker, mover and seconder, 7677; reciprocity with United States; marketing of farm products, 77; tariff revision; railway problems, 78; taxation burdens; immigration, 79 Agriculture, condition and prospects, 2149 Assiniboine river floods, 2004, 3546 Boy Scouts, 773 Cigarettes, tax on, 3241 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special com., 1424 Distribution of labour and goods, 2149 Fishways, 2168 Freight rates, 1424 Harbours and rivers, Manitoba, 2004 Immigration policy, 2148 Indians
Education, Elkhorn school, 3537 Oak lake and Pipestone, 1223 Militia and defence, Lindsay arsenal, 2086 Naval policy, 2079 Progressives, patriotism, 720 Rideau canal, 2765 Soldier land settlement, taxes, 2134 Soldier Settlement Board, qu. 469 Transportation, 2149 Woollen goods and blankets, 3234
Fort Churchill. See Hudson Bay Railway
Fort George, 119
Fort Mississauga, 119
Fort Qu'Appelle Sanitarium, 1345
Fort William
Car repair contracts, 1696-1705 Grain overages, qu. 1210 Terminal elevators. See Grain and Grain Trade
Fortier, Mr. H. A. (Labelle)
Agricultural exhibitions, 993 Budget, 2274. Congratulations to Minister of Finance; Government policy; amendment; revenue requirements and taxation, 2274; income tax; suggested concession to heads of families; population, suggested methods of increasing; railways and public ownership, 2275; economy in public expenditure, 2276
Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 961


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
Fortier, Mr. H. A.- Con.
Demonstration farm at Mont Laurier, 994 Military Service Act, 1917, Arndt, bill, 643 Ministers and directorships, 1123 Oleomargarine, manufacture and importation, M. (Mr. Neill) 1798
Fournier, Mr. C. A. (Bellechasse)
Carty, Captain, qu. 1062 Chief Architect's branch, Public Works, qu. 963
Civil Service Commission, qu. 826 Bland, Mr. C. H., qu. 1904
Four-Power Treaty. See Limitation of Armaments
France
Canadian exhibition in, 2031
Exhibition train from, 2990
Industries, protection of, 2410
Post war conditions, 2643
Trade relations with. 2990. See also Trade
Trade treaty with, 2110
Franchise. See also Dominion Elections Act Amdt.
Extension of, 2242 Public ownership, and, 1944
Fraser River Fisheries. See British Columbia, Fisheries
Fraser Valley Railway. See Vancouver and
Fraser Valley
Fraternal Benefit Insurance. See Insurance Act Amdt.
Frauds, Scrip, prosecution for. See Criminal Code Amdt.
Fredericton
Military property, 1980 Officers' square, 1980
Free Freight outlay, qu. 704
Free Trade. See Address; Budget
Freight, careless handling of, 1965
Freight Rates. See also Address; Budget; Canals; Railway Commission; Railways; St. Lawrence River Waterway; Transportation
Advertising campaign, qu. 1375 Calgary, free outlay, qu. 704 Coal from maritime provinces, 1763 Comparison between freight and duty, 2175
Freight Rates - Con.
Crowsnest pass agreement, 146, 176, 350, 1412. See also under this title, Excessive. See Speeches on Address; Budget Special Com. to inquire into effect upon Railway Rates
M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for, 1213, 1402 Amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton) 1444; neg. 1457
M. agreed to, 1458 Named, 1502 Reports First, 1657 Second, 1719 Third, 3546
M. (Mr. Maclean, Halifax) for adoption of, 3548 Amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton, 3559; neg. 3586
Amdt. (Mr. Baxter) 3586; neg. 3586
M. agreed to, 3588
Position of Ministers of Agriculture and Interior on, 242
Railway Act Amdt. bill, lr., 3588; 2r., com., 3595; 3r., 3597 Rule 11, suspension of, 1502 Telegram from Minister of Agriculture to Calgary Board of Trade, 2358 Excessive, 33, 47, 54, 78, 83, 131-132, 275, 350, 2219, 2314, 2453. See also tinder this title, Crowsnest Pass Agreement, and Speeches on Address; Budget Export, 2633 Fertilizers, on, 1022 Immigration and, 2157 Lumber industry, 234, 2311 Norris, Premier, reported statement of, 1213
Quebec, and, 1472, 1473 Railway labour, and, 2315 Regulation by water carriage competition, 1688
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1204. See also that title
Subsidized steamships, 2028 Wheat on, 235. See also Wheat Board
French, early pioneers in West, 2912
French-English Canadians, unity between, 168-9. See also Address
French Language, 155
Civil Service classification, qu. 1930 Parliament in, 155, 244, 306, 356 Pension Commissioners, Board of, .1351 Soldier Settlement Board, Sherbrooke, qu. 1658
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

lii

Fruit Industry, 220, 2564 Apple-growing, 171, 967 Importations, qu. 612 Protection of, 225, 2197 Baxter, Mr. Charles W., appointment of successor, 2457
British Columbia in, 2593. See also that title Competition with United States, 2903 Dumping clause, 2280, 2310, 2372, 2593, 2641, 2879	2903. See also speeches on
Address; Budget
Freight rates. See Crowsnest pass agreement
Fruit Commissioner, qu. 2457 Grape juice, tax' on, 2594, 2617 Okanagan Valley, 162. See also British Columbia
Oriental Aliens engaged in, 1535. See also that title
Protection. See Budget; Customs, Dumping clause Tariff, 2197
Transportation. See Freight Rates Trees, protection from insects. See Entomology
Fuel. See also Coal; Mines; Natural Resources
Oil, 344, qu. 728
Competition with coal, 2312 Importation, 178 Tank at Louise Basin, 1484 Tariff against, 1761 Peat, 1235
Price, 1490, qu. 1774. See also Coal
Further Legislation. See House of Commons
Futures, trading in. See Wheat Board
Gaboury, Mr. L. J., salary and duties, qu. 3599
Galicians. See Immigration
Galt post office building, 1247
Gambling. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Game. See Migratory Birds; Dominion Lands and Parks
Games of Chance. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Gaols. See Prisons; Penitentiaries
Garbage Feeding. See Hog Cholera
Gardiner, Mr. Robert (Medicine Hat) Budget, 2624. New national policy, 2624; fiscal plank; substantial reduction of customs tariff; British Preference; free
Gardiner, Mr. Robert - Con.
Budget - Con.
food stuffs; machinery for conversion of natural resources and raw materials; time to be allowed for industrial readjustment; claims for protection to heard in public; parliamentary committee on tariff; tariff commission, 2625; effects of tariff; exploitation of the people; tariff increases prices but not values; tariff reductions; revenue; land tax; inheritance tax; excise tax on manufactured goods; sales tax, 2626; circulation tax; bank interest violation of Bank Act; withholding of credit from municipality; unem ployment; an inequitable budge 2627
Canadian National Railways Branch lines, 1964 Bridge over Red Deer river, 1964 Canadian Pacific Railway bill, 1859 Cheque tax, 3260 Civil Service bonus, 1258 Dominion lands, oil leases, 1046 Fishing tackle, 3140
Income War Tax Act, 1917, Amdt. bill, 3481 Port Nelson dredging, 2006 Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Amdt. bill, 3438
Rural mail delivery contracts, 2800
Seed Grain Commission, 1011
Steamship services, 2027
Tar Sands, 1236
Timber wolves, 1001
Venereal diseases, 2022
Wheat Board, 785
Garland, Mr. E. J. (Bow River)
Additional currency issue, qu. 3155 Aerial forest patrol, High River, Alta., 1048, qu. 1066, 1723
Agriculture Com. report - Wheat Board, 783
Agriculture dept. - Mr. Duncan Marshall, 651, 652
Bank notes in circulation, qu. 3155 * Boy Scouts, 773
Business of the House - eleven o'clock adjournment, 2033 Canadian exhibition in France, 2032 Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine West Indian trade, 3928; amdt. 3031 Canadian INational Iraalway, (securities, qu. 3154
Criminal Code Amdt. (Half breed scrip) 3216
Dominion lands, surveys, 1038, 1044 M. to reduce vote, 1039


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1923

[Stage Direction]
liii
Garland, Mr. E. J. - Con.
Dominion notes, qu. 3154 Dredging, 2006 Fish culture, 2169
Forest aerial patrol, High River, Alta., qu. 1066, 1048, 1723 Gold reserve, qu. 3154, qu. 3155 Immigration of children, 2148, 3063 Indians
Blackfoot reserve, pasture lands, qu. 2215 Greater production, 1224, 1288 International boundaries, 1033 Mixed farming, 983 National gallery, 2011 Naval Service
Ntiobe, sale of, 2043, 2067 Royal Canadian Navy, 2043 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 522 Parliament, fall session, 2608 Pensions Com., report, 3349 Posit office, ruling respecting newspaper or magazine subscriber, qu. 3599 Redistribution, meeting of defeated candidates in Alberta, 2858 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 3497 Enlistment in Canadian Expeditionary Force, qu. 2038
Soldiers' land settlement, homestead rights, 2135
Steamship service^, 2027, 3028, 3506 Arndt, 3031
Tax-free bonds, qu. 826 Telegraph and telephone lines, Alberta, 2012
Garland, Mr. W. F. (Carleton)
Budget, 2300. Congratulations to Finance Minister; war expenditure; Canada Cement Company; income tax; tariff on agricultural implements; British preference; Mr. Fielding's trip to Washington; trade with United States; civil service dismissals; bonus; superannuation, councils, 2300; sales tax, 2301
Canada-Great Britain postal rate, qu. 3364 Civil Service
Bonus, qu. 472, qu. 606, 2300, 3531 Withdrawal from certain civil servants, qu. 3598
Commission, salaries, 407 Councils, 2300
Increase to deputy ministers, bonus, salaries, qu. 2805 Remuneration, qu. 3364 Retirement fund, qu. 826 Superannuation, 2300 Connaught rifle range, qu. 3153 Egg inspection, 811
Garland, Mr. W. F. - Con.
Exhibitions, prizes, 654
Experimental farms, 811
Grand Trunk, salaries of officials, qu. 728
Highways
Ottawa-Kingsiton, qu. 1904, 2794 Ottawa-Pembrooke, qu. 1661, 2794 Ottawa-Prescott, tree planting, qu. 2039 Mail contracts
Gascons-Quebec, qu. 2213 Lachenaie, qu. 2805
Miiitia dept, shed, Cartier square, Ottawa, qu. 2038
Poultry inspection, 656, 807 Rideau canal, 2766
Gas and electricity, inspection, 1373
Gascons-Quebec mail contract, qu. 2213
Gasoline, price of, 2106, 2296, 2313, 3115
Gaspe Peninsula
Aerial forest patrol, 1733 Fisheries, qu. 1401
Railways, M. (Mr. Marcil) for papers, 623
Gatineau-Point-Rockliffe ferry privilege, qu. 1399, qu. 1661
Gauvreau, Mr. C. A. (TOmiscouata)
Acoustics of the Chamber, 3613 Canadian National Railways Intercolonial
Pension fund, qu. 938 Repairs to cars, qu. 1212 RiviOre du Loup shops, qu. 1181, 1690 Indemnity of members, 3613 Juvenile delinquents, qu. 469 Lighthouse boats, fuel for, qu, 606, qu. 1183 Lighthouses and wireless telegraphy, qu. 370
Prison reform, 1279
Privilege - alleged statement of Miss Mac-phail, 3221
Rail and car repair contracts, 1690 Riviere du Loup arsenal, qu. 1181, 1690
Gendron, Mr. R. M. (Wright)
Dennis building, Halifax, qu. 3360
General Election. See Election of 1921
" General " Macdonald's Army. See also Riley's Army; Unemployment Government action in regard to, 2458 Reception of, 2256
Genoa Conference, 7, 58, 156, 212, 582, 2337. See also Address; Budget; Conferences Canadian delegation to, expenses, 1715, 2864
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
liv

Genoa Conference - Con.
Cannes conference, documents, 823 Tabled, 865
Correspondence with Govt, of Italy, 1905, 2035
Gordon, Sir Charles, 58, 582 Dominion Textile Company, and, 583-4 Money vote for, 1675 Montpetit, Professor, 582 Reported subscription of Canada to consortium, 1463 Submarines, 1845
Geodetic Survey
Estimates, 1033 Ottawa building, 1265
Geological Survey. See also Mines and
Minerals
Anthropological division
Potlach institution, qu. 1377. See also Indians
Camsell, Mr. Charles, 1262
Co-ordination of survey work, 1236
Estimates, 1233, 1236
Maps, 1237
Publications, 1237
Reduction of vote, 1237-62
Specimens, purchase of, 1237
George, Right Hon. Lloyd, 2203, 2337 Empire defence, responsibility of dominions for, 1630
Georgian Bay Canal. See Canals
German, Mr. W. M. (Welland)
Freight rates. Special Com., third report, 3587-8
Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3441 St. Lawrence river waterway, M. (Mr. Church) 1319
Trenton Harbour bill, 3494
German Goods, valuation of. See Budget; Customs Act Amdt.
..German Mark, decline in value of. See Budget; Currency, depreciated
Germany. See also Budget; Customs Tariff; Imports; Trade
Agents of manufacturers in Canada, 2647 Commercial development, 2643 Competition with, 2114, 2140, 2173-4, 2203, 2412, 2420, 2487, 2878 Credit control, 2500 Exports to Canada, 2408, 2421, 2863 Pocket-Knives, valuation of, 2876 Financial situation, 2499, 2642 Indemnity, payment in goods, 2500
Germany 

 Con.
Industrial condition, 2499, 2847 Labour conditions in, 3227. See also Labour Mark, value of, 2417, 2644, 2848. See alse Budget; Currency, depreciated Paper money, 2499 Proposed loan, 2500 Reparations paid to Allies, qu. 375 Tariff wall against goods, 174 Trade relations with, 138, 2183, 2263, 2287, 2347, 2394, 2421-22, 2464, 2487, 2848, 2876
Foreign, 2644
Wages and production costs, 2407, 2499, 2884
War debts, 174 Working hours, 2499
Gervais, Mr. Theodore (Berthier)
Inglis boiler works, qu. 732
Gillen Board. See Labour; Nova Scotia Miners
Girl Guides, grant, 774
Glanders. See Health of Animals
Glass
Customs duties on, 3117 Industry, occupational diseases. See Labour
Globe, Toronto, imaginary speeches of Mr. Meighen, 207
Goderich Harbour improvement, 2000
Gold
Central reserves and gold held in Canadian banks, qu. 2971 English hall marks, protection of. See Criminal Code
Refining. See Charges of Management Reserve. See Finance Standard, 1291
Gold and Silver Marking Act, administration of, 1372
Good, Mr. W. C. (Brant)
Agate and granite ware, 3118 American magazines, 3108, 3113 Automobiles, tax on, 3273, 3277 Beet sugar industry, 3250 Blankets, duty on, 3234-5 British preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 722
Budget, 2429. Tariff record of Liberal party; repudiation of tariff plank of 1919 platform; history of fiscal legislation, 2429; inception of protective


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 304 ' 3619



INDEX -1922 Iv

[Stage Direction]
Good, Mr. W. C.- Con.
Budget -Con.
policy; position of Liberal party on tariff question in seventies; Liberal convention of 1893; condemnation of protection system; campaign of 1911, 2430; reciprocity agreement; Liberal protectionists; the "great apostacy"; the "interests"; possible explanation of Liberal attitude, 2431; expediency of compromise; geographical considerations; examination of protective system without reference to locality or occupation; social versus individual advantage, 2432; trade a form of cooperation, not competition; protectionist philosophy; political boundaries and tariff walls, 2433; tariffs for revenue and protection; "plucking the goose with the least squawking "; direct and indirect taxes; protection by boundary dather than by tariff; encouragement of infant industries; protection of all industries impossible; favourable trade balance; international trade; cheap foreign labour; real and nominal wages; retaliatory tariffs, 2435; diversified industry; decadence of agriculture; effect on manufacturing industries; free raw material and lower labour costs; free trade and advantage to manufacturers; competition against old established industries, 2436; protective tariffs and monopoly; price-fixing combinations; has protection assisted Canadian manufacturers?; the system corrupting, demoralizing and indefensible; contributions to campaign funds; national existence and integrity, 2437; economic self-sufficiency; sentiment in favour of protection; public opinion distorted; quotation from Mr. J. A. Hobson, 2438; consumers not organized to protect themselves; Canadian Manufacturers' Association propaganda; objects of protection; how has the policy worked out?, 2439; loss of population; indictment of system by United Farmers of Ontario; war profiteering; revenue raising expedients, 2440; excess profits tax; no promise of relief in budget; taxes on consumption; sales tax, 2441; income and inheritance taxes; ability to pay, 2442; property tax; taxation of land value; 2443; increased production; booms and depressions; public works; credit control, 2445
Good, Mr. W. C. - Con.
Business of the House Estimates, consideration of, 3527 Mondays and Wednesdays, 1720 Business profits war tax, qu. 1657 Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1961
Cattle embargo, 991-992 Chamberlin, Mr. R. S., grant to, 3498 Civil Service Commission, salaries, 3509 Coated papers, duty on, 3108 Condensed milk, tax, 3269 Contingencies, expenditures for, 415 Cotton fabrics, duty on, 3128 Debates, inaudibility of, 1755, 1996 Ford motor company, 3273 German importations, value of, 3228 Governor General's cars, 1688 Harbours and rivers, Ontario, 2001 Hydrographic survey, 1746 Immigration Passports, 3064 Salaries, 3499 Income war tax act, 3278 Indians
Medical attention, 1220 Six Nation reserve, 1222 Lambton, loss of, 3507 Live stock industry, 992 Military expenditures and policy, 1144 Naturalization expenses, 1671 Naval defence, obligation of Canada, 1745 Oleomargarine, manufacture, etc., M. (Mr. Neill) 1836
Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 3019
Pool selling, bbokmaking, etc., 2973 Prince Rupert Drydock Co. claim, 3515 Proportional Representation, M. for adoption, 1633
Public buildings, Ottawa
Elevator attendants, 1267 Expenditure, 1268
Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1485 Quebec harbour, pare St. Charles, 1470 Rail and car repair contracts, 1705 Railway policy, 1961
Root vegetables bill, potato grades, 3376 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 843 Senate indemnity, 3509 Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 436 Steamship subsidies, contracts, 3034, 3506 Supply, discussion, method of, 1142 Tariff amendments, 3238-9 Telegraph and Telephone lines, 2012 Tools, tax on, 3127
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
lvi

Good, Mr. W. C.

Con.
Unemployment Causes of, 3526 Military expenditures, 1144 Relief, 3526
Wheat Board bill, 3187 Woollen goods, duty on, 3130
Good Roads. See Highways
Gordon, Sir Charles, 58, 200, 239, 1128 Genoa conference, 1715
Gordon, Mr. George N. (West Peterborough.) See also Deputy Speaker O'Connor, Mr. W. F., K.C., payments, qu. 2037
Gouin, Hon. Sir Lomer (Minister of Justice and Attorney General)
Adamson, Mr. Justice, appointment of, 1670
Address in reply, 140. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; statements made in last general election, 140; Order in Council government, 141; Quebec fisheries; results of general election, 142 Allan, Sir Montagu, 872 Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bill, 3025 Senate amdts. 3611
Budget, 2654. Fiscal policy, protection and free trade; issue of the election campaign; Liberals not free traders; history of tariff legislation; Hon. Alex. Mackenzie; Mr. Blake's Malvern speech, 2655; principles which have inspired Liberal party; fiscal policy of Government found in speeches of Prime Minister and Finance Minister, 2656; budget proposals in consonance with declarations of leaders, 2657; expenditure and debt; revenue necessities; manufacturing important factor in developing Canada, 2657; late Sir Wilfrid Laurier on encouragement of Canadian industries; progress of manufacturers since 1870; exodus during last ten years; investment in industrial establishments, 2658; grievances of the West; proposals for tariff reduction; strict economy needed; immigration policy; the amendment; no deception of electors, 2659; budget proposals consistent with Liberal .promises Canada Grain Act
Decision of Manitoba Court of Appeal, 1133, 1841, 1932
Chamberlain, Mr. R. S., grant to, 3497 Criminal Code Amdt. bills, 1841, 2830, 2973, 3607
Gouin, Hon. Sir Lomei

Con.
Criminal Code Amdt. bills - Con. Half-breed scrip, 3219 Mr. Woodsworth
M. for reference to Special Com., 1503 Dominion lands, Cancellation of leases bill, 3468-75 Senate amdts. 3615 Exchequer court
Admiralty vacancies, 1275 Estimates, 1274
Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth)
M. for ref. to Special Com., 1502 Judges Act Amdt. bill, 424, 2830 Judges, Quebec, 3497 Justice department of,
Estimates, 1274, 1668 Litigated matters, 1276 Salaries, 451, 4395 Yukon territory, 1275 King v, Manitoba Grain Company, decis ion, 1133, 1841, 1932
Newfoundland-Labrador boundary, 1276 Nova Scotia Supretne Sourt, vacancy, 3437 Pecuniary Claims Convention with United States, 1276 Penitentiaries Estimates, 1276
Inmates, foreign and native, 1279 Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill, 545, 787 References to, 21, 26, 55, 206, 207, 239, 242, 243, 1128, 2679, 2682, 2718. See also Budget; Ministers and Directorships Revenue and Audit Act Amdt. bill, 3042 Royal Canadian Mounted Police Estimates, 2129 Pensions, 2131
Soldiers' civil re-establishment bill, 3597 Supreme Court Act Amdt. bill, 2456, 2974 Supreme court estimates, 1274 Trial of Indian murderer, Lebeaux expenses, 1669
White, Mr. James, employment of, 3496 Yukon territory, 1275
Gould, Mr. O. R. (Assiniboia)
Agriculture department Officers, 650 Professionnal men, 589 Air force and civil aviation, Saskatchewan, 1724
Allan, Sir Montagu, 872 Bank, loans to directors, 1093 Bee-keeping, 592
Bienfait briquetting plant. See under this title, Lignite Blankets, duty on, 3129


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
lvii
Gould, Mr. O. R.

Con.
Budget, 2711. Congratulation to Finance Minister; grievance of the West and its solution; briquetting plant at Bien-fait, 2712-15; farmers and the income tax; excessive profits and watered stock; banks1 and credit, 2714; liquor exportation from Saskatchewan; banking system, 2716; cheque tax; national debt, 2717; taxation; Sir Lomer Gouin and protection; tariff on implements of production, 2718; inconsistent attitude of Conservatives towards tariff; a disappointing budget; failure of Government to carry out platform of 1919; similarity of Liberal and Progressive platforms, 2720; Liberals will not implement pledges,. 2721 Civil service economy, 793 Clothes wringers, 3140 Criminal Code, carriage of calves, 2831 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 962 Defence branches, amalgamation, 423 Departments, economy in, 458, 793 Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill, 2814 Dominion lands, surveys, 1041 Electrical storm in the West, 3493 Elevators, complaint of unfair dealing, 2987
Entomology, qu. 472, 590, 817 Export liquor warehouses, 768, 2716 Fishing schooner race, 3511 Grain- Growers' Grain Company, 2489 Grasshopper plague, qu. 472, 590, 817 Harbours and rivers, expenditure, 1272 Harness, hides, prices, 3139 Immigration, medical inspection, 2022 Insurance Act Arndt, bill, 3143 Judges Act Amdt. bill, 546 Lignite
Bienfait briquetting plant, qu. 604, 1233, qu. 1632, 2712-15 Utilization board, 3524 Live stock, diseases, 650 Military district No. 12, 1176, 1602, 1987 Military expenditure and policy, 1148, 1175, 1610
Militia and Defence
Annual training, 1175, 1600-10 Customs duties, 1978 Permanent force, 1982 Saving in, 418 Temporary clerks, 587 Transport and freight, 1987 Ministers and directorships, 1091 Ministers, salary increases, 1093 Ocean and river service, 3508 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 3017
Gould, Mr. O. R. - Con.
Public Works, average salary, 750
Quarantine, 2021
Raw materials, duty on, 3131
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 839 Steamship subsidies, 3506 Woodmen of the World, 1905 Woollen goods, 3137
Government Departments
Co-ordination of, 180-181. See also National Defence
Payment to each other for services rendered, 1724
Government, Federal, responsibility for unemployment, 1069-94. See also Address; Budget; Unemployment
Government, group system of. See Proportional Representation
Government-Owned Railways. See Canadian National Railways
Government Printing. See Printing; Publications
Governor General
Cars, 1688
Deputy of the Governor General, 3610 Secretary's office, 751
Speech on opening of Parliament; new appointment as Governor General; world-wide economic disturbances and industrial depression; unemployment; decline in prices of farm products; Customs tariff revision; co-ordination of government railway systems, 6; immigration, 6-7; re-establishment and medical treatment of soldiers; natural resources of western provinces; coordination of defence forces; limitation of armaments; Genoa conference; Postal conference; need for economy, 7 Address in reply. See that title Warrants, 1990
Canadian Expeditionary Force, repatriation of dependents, 1711	,
Dominion Iron and Steel Corporation, contract for steel plates, 1677 Dominion lands and parks, 1681 Expenditure by, 1353 Genoa Conference, 1716 Penitentiaries, 1670 Unemployment relief, 1719 Welland canal construction, 1687 Yukon territory, 1681
Grading of Vegetables. See Root Vegetables
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
lviii


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
lix
Graham Miss Nora, qu. 599
Graham, Mr., agent at Regina, 682
Grain and Grain Trade. See also Address; Agriculture; Budget; United Grain Growers; Wheat Board Acme Grain Company, default of, 2834 Banks and, 2246. See also that title Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim for flax shipment, 2834 Canada Grain Act
Administration of, 2834 Constitutionality of, 2837
Decision of Manitoba Court of Appeal, 1132, 1841, 1932 Inquiry, 1770
Canadian National railways, grain leakages, 1401, 1930
Canadian Wheat Board, advance, 3541. See also Wheat Board Car demurrage, 2981 Elevators
Private, 2981
Licenses to, 2838 System of, 114, 233 Terminal, 2980
Excess overages, qu. 609, qu. 1401, 2837 Fort William Inspector, 2983
Port Arthur, and, overages, qu. 1210 Government, 233, qu. 3152 Grain Commission, and, 2980 Maintenance and equipment of, 2978 Quebec, 1466, 1471, 1474, 1483 United Grain Growers, 2983 Freight rates on grain, 146. See also Freight Rates
Grades, mixing of, 2839, 2981 Grain Board. See Wheat Board Grain Growers and oleomargarine. See Oleomargarine
Grain Inquiry Commission, 49, qu. 705, 777, qu. 1181, 2839, 2842, 2982 Hyndman Commission, 2982 Secret session at Fort William, 2983 Terminal elevators, 2980 Grain leakages on Canadian National railways, 1401, 1930
Handling of. See under this title, Elevators;
Transportation Long hauls to market, 146-7 Manitoba Court of Appeal, decision. See under this title, Canada Grain Act Mixing grades, 2839, 2981 In transit, 2838
Montreal harbour, shipment of grain through, 1489 Oats, price of, 225
Grain and Grain Trade - Con,
Overages, qu. 609, qu. 1401, 2837, 2838; 2980 Per capita production, 2159 Price fixed in Liverpool, 1203-08 Production and shipment, 1203 Quebec, shipment of grain through, 1466, 1471, 1472
Russia, competition of, 2157 St. Lawrence river waterway, 269, 1183, 1317, 1325. See also that title Sample market, 2838
Saskatchewan Co-operative Elevator Co., 2989
Screenings, recleaned, 2490 Selling without growers' permission, 2989 Shipment. See under this title, Montreal; Quebec; St. Lawrence River Waterway
Shrinkage and leakage in transit, 232. See also under this title, Elevators Speculation in, 158. See also Wheat Board Bill
Transcontinental railway, 2194 Transportation, 235, 300. See also Freight Rates; Railways; St. Lawrence River Waterway; Welland Canal Water by, 69-70. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway
United Grain Growers, terminal elevator, 2983 Wheat
Marketing, 2915, 2951,	2969. See also
Wheat Board Production and cost, 2333
Grain Growers Grain Company, alleged contribution to political organization, 2488
Grand Anse, C.B., mail service, qu. 938
Grand Manan, wharves and breakwaters, 1993
Grand River bridge, qu. 1287
Grand Trunk Pacific Railway. See that title under Canadian National Railways
Grand Trunk Railway. See that title under Canadian National Railways
Grape Juice, tax on, 2117, 2594, 2617
Grasshopper Plague, qu. 472, 2726, 3520
Gravel, Mr., Quebec Harbour Commission, 1477
Great Britain
British Preference. See that title Free trade and, 2526. See also speeches on Budget
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
Ixi
Guthrie, Hon. Hugh - Con.
Govt, publications, demand, 1374 Gwatkin, Major-General, 742 Harbours and rivers New Brunswick, 1997 Amdt. to reduce item by $20,000, 199S Nova Scotia, expenditure, 1269 Ontario, Goderich, 2000 Prince Edward Island, 1988 Quebec, 1999
Hospital ship, claim for loss of, 2976 Immigration Act Amdt. bill, (Mr. Woods-worth) 1393
Immigration of farm workers, 3052 Indian Affairs, officials, 683 Judges Act Amdt. bill, 2830 Labour dept., salary increases, 564 Linen yarn bounty, 1362 Military expenditures, 1138 Militia and Defence Ammunition,
Reserve of, 2086
Shipment from Great Britain, 1154-73 Annual drill, 1154, 1155
Artillery ammunition from Great Britain, 1154-73
Liberal attitude in 1920, 1921, and 1922, 1154
Arsenals, Lindsay, 2085 Cadet services, 1972, 1977 Expenditure and policy, 1594 Permanent force, 1983 Reduction of staff, 586 Topograpric survey, 1043, 1986 War claims, adjustment of, 2976 Ministers and directorships, 1094 Montreal Harbour Commission bill, 1488 Municipal taxation, payment by Government, 1256
Munitions, shipment from Great Britain, 1154-73
National Defence, Department of, bill, 659, 738, 1747
Bill should be preceded by resolution,
Naturalization Act, 2024 Naval policy, 2051 Naval service
Fisheries protection service, 1747 Gift of ships to Canada, 2050 Royal Canadian navy, 1846, 1972 Royal naval college, 2049 Opium and Narcotic drugs, 2020 Parliament buildings, 2014 Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill, 787 , Pilotage, administration of, 1499 Preston, Mr. W. T. R., claim of, 3503 Progressive party, attitude towards redistribution, 1364
Guthrie, Hon. Hugh-Con.
Public buildings Expenditure, 1261 Improvements, repairs, etc., 1238 Ontario, 1251, 1259 Public Service Retirement Act, 3025 Public Works estimates, 964, 747 Contingency vote, 748 Reductions, 698
Quebec harbour advances, 1473 Redistribution and the census, 1364 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Dept.
Amalgamation or abolition of, 1340 Statutes
Printing of, 1972 Revision of, 1717 Steamship services, 2020, 3505 Survey and map work, proposed co-ordination, 1033, 1986
Toronto harbour improvement, 1474 War claims, adjustment Naval service, 1752 Vickers, 2976 War medals, 2977 War memorials, Yimy, 2100 Warlike stores, sale of, 1171 Wheat Board, 2968 Wrangel island, 1751 Yukon territory, 1034
Radiotelegraph service, 1750
Gwatkin, Major-General, 421, 422, 742, qu. 1211. See also National Defence bill
Halbert, Mr. Robert H. (North Ontario) Campbell, Mr. Alex., qu. 606 Cattle embargo, Mr. Doherty, 989 Customs tariff, ploughs, 3231 Doherty, Right Hon. C. J., qu. 704 Hatters' plush, duty on, 3141 Labour dept., employees, 566 Lake of the Woods bill, 2309 Lindsay arsenal, 1979 Military expenditure and policy, 1179 Militia and defence Annual drill, 1179
Expenditure and policy, 1597, 1617, 1984 Permanent force, 1984 Plough parts, duty on, 3123, 3231 Riordon Company, taxes, qu. 607, qu. 927 Root Vegetables bill, potato grades, 3373-4
Half Breed Scrip, Frauds, 148-9. See also Criminal Code Amdt. bill
Halifax. See also Naval Service Dennis building, qu. 3360 Fortifications, 1581 Ocean terminals, qu. 364 Ocean tonnage, 2008
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

ixii
Halifax -* Con.
Patronage committee, 199 Port of. See British Preference, M. (Mr. Logan)
Public buildings, expenditures, 1244 Quarantine station, repairs, 1238, 2021
Halkett, Mr. Andrew, 3051
Hamilton
Post office building, 1246-51, 1258 Queenston-Hamilton highway, qu. 471
Hammell, Mr. W. J. (Muskoka)
Parry Sound lighthouse inspector, qu. 827
Haney, Mr. M. J., contracts, 1375
Hanna, Mr. D. B., 192-3, qu. 471. See also Canadian National Railways, Directors
Hanna-Medicine Hat line, 1965
Hansard. See House of Commons, Debates
Hanson, Mr. Richard B. (York-Sunbury) Alcohol for druggists, 3242 Business of the House, Saturday sittings, 2033
Canada Temperance Act, 2024 Caraquet and Gulf Shore Railway Co., 1183, qu. 1504 Coal
Anthracite, importations, qu. 2356 Public buildings, for, 1763 Defence, deputy ministers, 419 Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill, 2810 Edmundston public building, 1239, 1251 Election promises in Charlotte County, N.B., 1994
Experimental farms, 795 External Affairs, contingencies, 3509 Graham, Miss Nora, qu. 699 Harbours and rivers New Brunswick, 1991 Nova Scotia, 1765 Expenditure, 1269 High Commissioner, 414 Indians, Devon band, removal, 1215 Insurance premiums, tax, 3256 International operation of railways, 192 Joggins breakwater, 1767 Justice department, contingencies, 1669 Labour investigators, 462 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 647 Matches, tax on, 3262 Migratory birds, 1685 Militia and defence
Military property at Fredericton, 1980 Transport and freight, M. to reduce item by $50,000, 1987
Hanson, Mr. Richard B. - Con.
Municipal taxation, payment by Government, 1256
Naturalization Act, 2024 Nickel coin blanks, qu. 3152 Nova Scotia Coal strike, 461 Supreme court vacancy, 3436 Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3451 Pension Board, appeals, 391 Post Office Dept.
Printing and stationery, 691 Reorganization, 2800 Rural delivery, 2800
Provincial wharves, New Brunswick, 1991 Public buildings, Maritime provinces, 1243 Public Works estimates, 693 Purchasing Commission, 2025 Reid Newfoundland railway, 2027 Root Vegetable bill, 3369 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 735 St. John and Quebec railway, 1295 Acquisition by Canadian National railways, qu. 1774
St. John terminal facilities, M. (Mr. Caldwell) 847
St. Lawrence river waterway, survey, 2768 Senate indemnity, 3509 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment dept. Salary increases, 391 Vocational loans, 1346 Soldiers' homes, establishment of, 1348 Sorel shipyard, qu. 605 Statistics, Dominion Bureau of, 1363 Steamship services, 2029, 3506 War trophies, director, 702 Wharves in tidal waters, qu. 2209 White slave traffic, suppression of, 3497
Harbour Masters. See Canada Shipping Act Amdt.
Harbours. See St. Lawrence River Waterway. For individual Harbours, see
their titles
Advances to. See Montreal, Quebec and Harbour Commission bills
Harbours and Rivers
Alberta, 2004, 3547 British Columbia, 2005, 3547 Esquimalt, 3541
Estimates, 1269, 1765, 1988, 3541 Expenditures on, 1465 Lake Huron, harbour of refuge, 2002 Little Current, 2002 Manitoba, 2003, 3545


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
lxiii
Harbours and Rivers - Con.
Montreal Harbour Commission, employees, 1289. See also Montreal Harbour Commission bill New Brunswick, 1991
Arndt. (Mr. Guthrie) to reduce Item by $20,000, 1998
Provincial wharves, 1991 Nova Scotia, 1765, 3545 Expenditure, 1921-22, 1269 Ontario, 1999
Port Arthur and Fort William, 3541 Prince Edward Island, 1270, 1988 Quebec, 1998, 3545
Quebec Harbour Commission, 1283. See also Quebec Harbour Commission bill St. John
Expenditure, qu. 1401 Improvement, 2013
Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2004, 3547 Shuswap lake, wharf, 3547 Toronto, 3541
Harding, President, 69 St. Lawrence River Waterway, 133, 1184
Hardy, Hon. Senator, A. C., 2695
Harris, Mr. Joseph H. (East York)
Address in reply, 307. Liberals and Progressives, 307; immigration; railway policy; 308; manufacturers and raw material, 309
Aliens, taxation of transient, 2155 Customs department, secretaries, 764 Foreigners, 2155
Hog cholera, garbage feeding, 1007-9, 1028 Immigration Policy, 2154 Undesirable, 2154 Insurance premiums, tax, 3258 Lord Kitchener's death, foreigners and, 2155
Militia and defence, Lindsay arsenal, 2085 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3464 Pensions Com., final report, 3350 Public buildings, Ontario, repairs, 1250
Harvest Excursions, 337
Hatfield, Mr. Paul L. (Yarmouth and Clare)
Canned goods, marking, 3050 Fishing schooner race, 3511 Rural postmasters, 3080
Hatters' Bands, Plush, and bindings, 2855, 3139, 3141
Hawaian Islands, Japanese immigration, 1515
Health. See also Immigration; Indians; Tuberculosis Department
Estimates, 2017 Salaries, etc., 775
Diseases, infectious of prisoners. See Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill Honey, 2017
Housing, and, 121. See also Housing Immigration, medical inspection, 2021. See also Immigration
Narcotic drugs, 2017. See also Opium and Narcotic Drugs Act Amdt. bill Correspondence with wholesale druggists, 1289
Occupational diseases. See Labour Quarantine, 2021 Unemployment, 86-87 Venereal diseases, qu. 935, 2022
Health of Animals. See Agriculture; Animal Contagious Diseases
Hearst Publications, 3111
Herring,. Dry-salting. See Fisheries Act Amdt. bill
Hides, price of, 2623, 3138
High Commissioner in London, 58 British Columbia house, purchase of, 3537 Cattle embargo, and. See also that title Alleged statement on, 1020, 1463 Income and taxation, 139 Salaries, etc., 413
High Cost of Living. See Cost of Living High River, Alta.
Aerial Forest patrol, 1050, qu. 1066, 1723 [DOT]
Highways, 63, 75, 122 Banff-Windermere, 1051, 1681 Biggs, Hon. F. C., 63 Dundas Street, Halton county, qu. 1065 Edith Cavell, 1051 Grand Circle tour, 1683 Hamilton-Queenston, qu. 471 Indian reserves, 1216 Isle Perrot bridge, qu. 1377 Ontario, qu. 372 Ottawa-Kingston, qu. 1904, 2794 Ottawa-Pembroke, qu. 1661, 2794 Ottawa-Prescott, treeplanting, qu. 2039 Road materials, investigation, 1234 Road projects, submitted, qu. 2040 St. Thomas-Niagara Falls, qu. 936 Soulanges canal road, 2768 Tourist traffic and, 1682 Transcontinental, 319, 2636
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume Ml: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Highways -* Con.
Transportation, 1939 Unemployment relief, 1082 Windermere road, 1051, 1681
Hikers. See Macdonald's Army; Riley's Army
Historic Sites, 119. See also Battlefields Monuments, qu. 469
Hocken, Mr. H. C. (West Toronto) Agriculture Com. report, Wheat Board, 785 American magazines, importation of, 310809, 3112
Budget, 2675. Expected modifications in budget proposals. 2675; taxes on cheques, confectionery and cigars; sales tax and cost of living; dissatisfaction of Agrarian party with budget; tariff record of Liberal party; pledges and promises broken, 2676; reduction in agricultural implement duties; protection and the maintenance of industries; record of Conservative party; inconsistencies of Liberals; Mr. Blake's Malvern speech; his letter to West Durham electors, 2677; unrestricted reciprocity; commercial union; Mr. Fielding's disavowal of tariff items of Liberal platform; concealment of views on public questions; reciprocity; government created by big interests, 2678; big business behind Sir Lomer Gouin, 2679; Proposed coalition of Agrarians and Liberals; national railways; responsibility for railway building, 2680; effort to form Liberal-Progressive government; progressives and reactionary factions in government; Minister of Marine and Fisheries; conflicting opinions in Liberal ranks; national railways; speech of Minister of Justice; full value for support of big interests; protection; diversified industries, 2682; relief from burdens not to be had through tariff reduction; feeling between East and West; rural depopulation of Ontario; agricultural conditions; manufacturers in unsatisfactory position, 2683; amenities of rural life, 2684 Canada's credit, 1919
Canadian National railways, deficits, 1919 Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill, 2811 Residential qualification, M. (Mr. Rin-fret) 1298
Empire-Ascension Day's, adjournment, 1905 Finance, deputy minister's salary, 752
Hocken, Mr. H. C. - Con.
Fishing schooner race, 3513 Income taxes, qu. 705 Labour dept.
Mr. Harrison, 575-6 Promotions, 576
McDonald, Mr. John N., qu. 3361 Military expenditure, 1137 Military hospitals, expenditure, 1261 Public buildings Expenditure, 1261 Flags, 1265 Water, 1266
Public works estimates, 747, 748, 1261
Reciprocity, Mr. Putnam, 2286
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 833 St. Lawrence river waterway'
M. (Mr. Church) 1314 Welland canal, and, 2754 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, salary increases, 388, 398
Toronto Suburban railway, qu. 2456 Welland ship canal, 2754
Hodgins, Mr. A. L. (East Middlesex)
Animal contagious diseases, 2103 Telegraph and telephone lines, 2013 Water powers, surveys, 1051
Hoey, Mr. R. A. (Springfield)
Budget, ,2331. Financial obligations; precarious position of agriculture; Canadian workman, purchasing power; unemployment, 2331; Western Canada; statements prepared by Manitoba Agricultural College staff; wheat production and cost, 2332; farmers' profits compared with those of other businesses, 2333; probable permanency of conditions; rural discontent; the solution, 2334; drastic tariff reductions; lower freight rates, wider markets; tendency to lean on government, 2335; protection and the agricultural industry; Fordney tariff; opportunity for reductions in Canadian tariff; Genoa Conference; Mr. Lloyd George and spirit of nationalism; source of revenue; development of basic industries, 2337; the amendment, 2338; broken promises; tariff commission; redistribution; party system of government, 2339
Census, completion of, 1365	,
Cost of living, 1175, 2331 Gordon, Sir Charles, 584 Immigration statistics, 756-7 Labour dept., salaries, 551


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
Hoey, Mr. R. A. - Con.
Military expenditure and policy, 1175 Militia and defence Annual drill, 1175 Quebec arsenal, 2097 Ministers and directorships, 1111 Rail and car repair contracts, 1705 Redistribution and the census, 1365 Winnipeg river, bridge, 2011
Hogs
Cholera. See also Agriculture; Animal Contagious Diseases bill; Health of Animals
Compensation, 1028 Extermination of, 2594 Grading, 2594
Holiday on Election Day. See Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill
Holland, immigration from, 2144
Holland, Lee, order for deportation of, 1283
Holland, Major, death of, 2821
Holstein Cattle trade with United States in, 2695
Holt, Sir Henry, 1128
Home Brewing. See Inland Revenue
Home . Markets. See Budget; Markets; speeches on Address
Homesteads. See Dominion Lands; Immigration; Soldiers' Land Settlement Re-entry, 1041
Honey, 2017
Honorary Advisory Council of Industrial and Scientific Research. See Industrial and Scientific Research
Horse Power. See Electric Power; Water Power
Horse Racing, Federal control of, 2596 Horses. See Live Stock Hose, Captain. See Naval Service Hosmer, Mr. Charles R., 1128 Hospital Ships
Claim by British Ministry of Shipping for loss, 2975
Exemption from pilotage dues. See Canada Shipping Act
[Stage Direction]
House of Commons. See also Deputy Speaker; Speaker
Acoustics, 1053, 1751, 3544, 3612. See also under this title, Audibility of Debates Adjournments
Easter, 546, 820, 823 Empire day and Ascension day, 1760, 1769, 1905
To discuss matter of urgent public importance
M. (Mr. Irvine) Nova Scotia miners, 497; withdrawn, 545
Audibility of debates, 385, 411, 658, 708, 1053, 1578, 1721, 1751, 1755, 1996, 2831, 3544, 3613
Bills, money, to be preceded by res, 547 Business of the House Budget debate, probable date of conclusion, 2639 Daylight saving, 1282 Further legislation, 2996, 3041, 3103, 3151, 3364-5
Government orders, Mondays and Wednesdays, 1460, 1719 Private members', 1719 Public accounts, closing of, 1210 By-elections. See under this title Vacancies Chamber, acoustics. See under this title. Acoustics; Audibility of Debates Committees, Select Standing, 8, 323. For proceedings and reports, See titles of the several Committees Changes in, 497, 545, 596, 871, 1398 Powers of, 326
Criminal Code, reprinting of, 1717 Debates
Audibility of. See under this title Acoustics; Audibility of Debates Official Report of Committee Appointed, 325 First report, 1132, 1258 Second report, 3359 Incorporation of documents not read, 1539, 3526
Tabulated statements in answer to questions, 1132, 1660 Decorum
Conversation, 1755, 2640 Courteous bearing to member speaking, 2090
Deputy Speaker, election of, 363. See also that title
Deputy Sergeant-at-Arms, 5 Divisions Budget
Amdt. to Amdt. (Mr. Crerar), ruling of Mr. Speaker on, 2523
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

lxvi

House of Commons -Con.
Divisions - Con.
Budget - Con.
Amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton), neg. 2912 Correction of division list, 2971; Corrected list, 2972
M. (Mr. Fielding) for Com. of Ways and Means, agreed to, 2913 Orowsnest Pass Agreement
M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) and amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton) 1457-8 Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Company bill, amdt. (Mr. Neill) neg. 1163 Freight Rates, amdt. (Sir Henry Drayton) to M. (Mr. Maclean, Halifax) for adoption of third report of Special Com. on Transportation Costs, 3586 Lake of the Woods Regulation bill, 3435 Ministers and Directorships, M. (Mr. Mc-Master) neg. 1131
Oleomargarine, Manufacture and Importation, discontinuance of, M. (Mr. Neill) neg. 1840
Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) and amdt. (Mr. Stewart, Argenteuil) 1577
Paired members inadvertently voting, 1462
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) neg. 843 Soldiers' Bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) neg. 450
Estimates, 2026. See also that title
Discussion of particular item on M. to go into Com. of Supply, 1337 Expenditure, qu. 2583
Expense of sittings and cost per hour, 1476, 2170, 2635
Hansard. See under this title, Debates, Official Report of
House of Commons and Senate Act, 1088.
See also Ministers and Directorships Indemnity
Payment of, 361
Proposed reduction, 2513, 2690, 2895, 3613 Internal Economy Commission, 8 Members
Attendance of, 2513 Deceased
Baker, the late Colonel G. H., memorial to, 1929
McGibbon, Mr. Peter (Argenteuil) 39 New
Election and introduction of
Bouchard, Mr. Georges (Joseph) 1929 King, Hon. J. H., 496 Ouimet, Joseph Rodolphe, 323 Private, business of, 1719
House of Commons-Con.
Members - Con.
Speeches, length of, 2450, 2635 Ministers and directorships. See that title Motions
Amdt. to amdt. (Mr. Crerar) 2473, 2507 Speaker's ruling, 2519 Non-debatable
That Com. rise, 1181 Oleomargarine (Mr. Neill) time fixed for discussion, 1719	*
Redistribution, M. (Mr. Shaw) opportunity for discussion, 1719 Supply in, 1579
Orders for returns. See under this title. Returns
Orders of the Day
Right of member to raise qu. of privilege, 2638
Pairs. See under this title, Divisions Petitions, Birnie, Mr. Alex, and others, 1929 Privilege
Baxter, Hon. Mr. - C&rleton, N.B., returning officer, 3492 Caldwell, Mr. - Carleton, N.B., returning officer, 3602
Copp, Hon. Mr. - Correction of report respecting War claims, 1721 Crerar, Hon. Mr. - Budget debate, agricultural figures quoted in, 2637 Deslauriers, Mr. - Correction of speech, 3365-6
Fielding, Hon. Mr. 
 Clerk Assistant, 681 Gauvreau, Mr. 
 Statement of Miss Mac-phail, 3'221
Hoey, Mr.-Denial of newspaper reports. 2458
Johnston, Mr. (Last Mountain) - Charge that Progressives are delaying budget debate, 2692
Kay, Mr. - Wheat Board, 872 Maclean, Mr. (York)-Crowsnest pass agreement, 3608
Right of member to raise qu. on orders of the day, 2638 Questions
Lengthy answers to, 1660 Tabulated statements in official report of debates, 1132 Returns
Inquiry for, 1283, 1988, 2042 Questions requiring tabulated answers, 1132
Rules, suspension of Rule 11, 1502 Senate, and, expenditure, qu. 2583 Sergeant-at-Arms
Parliamentary messengers, qu. 1376, 1335


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume 111: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
Ixvil
House of Commons - Con.
Sittings
Eleven o'clock adjournment, 2033 Empire and Ascension days, 1769 Saturday, 1905, 2032, 2458 Suspended, 3611-14 Wednesday at 3 p.m., 49 Wednesday evenings, 1905, 2033, 2170 Speaker. See that title Speeches, length, 2450, 2635 Staff
Chief accountant, salary, qu. 2583, qu. 2803
Chief of stationery division, 3608 Law branch, 2304 Organization, 3221 Amended, 1335
Reading room, assistant curators, 1335 Stenographers and messengers, pay, qu. 1376
Statutes, reprinting of, 1717 Supply
Amendment to amendment, 1579 Discussion of particular item of estimates on M. to go into Supply, 1337 Motion, movers of, 1579 Motion for, latitude in discussion, 2238 Vacancies
Kamouraska, 1459
House of Commons and Senate Act Arndt.
bill. See Ministers and Directorships; Salaries Act Arndt.
Housing, 121, 219, 774, 3524. See also Labour; Returned Soldiers; Unemployment Building costs, 2417
Returned soldiers, for, 271, 3304, 3314, 332122, 3329, 3332. See also that title Shortage of, 1072 Unemployment, and, 3524
Howe, Hon. Joseph, 1387
Hubbs, Mr. John (Prince Edward)
Alcohol tax, retail druggists, 1213
Hudson, Mr. A. B. (South Winnipeg) Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1444 Immigration-Criminal Code bills, 3283 Lake of the Woods repeal bill, 3199, 3210
Hudson's Bay Company
Northwest country and, 148 Supplies to northern Indians, 1712
Hudson Bay Railway, 2602 Completion of, 2779
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033.
ea
Hudson Bay Railway - Con.
Hudson Bay
Navigability and fishery resources of, 2781, 2779-99 Port Nelson, 1970
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1208, 1325 Senate committee, report, 2781
Hueston, Captain, inquiry into death of, qu. 2993, 3314
Hughes, Mr. J. J. (King's P.E.I.)
Address in reply, 224. Reciprocity and class legislation, 224; immigration and unemployment, 225; Prince Edward island markets and government inspection; income tax, administration of Act, 226; sales tax; daylight saving; eight-hour day and farmers, 227; labour unions; railways and the maritime provinces; 228 Administration, economy in, 3077-8 Budget, 2225. Financial situation, idebt, expenditure, economy; borrowings, 2225; the amendment, 2226; income tax, comparison with systems in other countries, 2227; sales tax; extravagant war expenditures, 2228; Wartime Elections Act, 2229
Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1925, 1956
Canned goods, inspection of, 3049 Civil Service Commission, 3076 Civil Service, economy, 2060 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 955 Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill Residential qualification, M. (Mr. Rin-fret) 1299
Harbours and rivers, Prince Edward island 1989
Income tax, comparison with systems in other countries, 2227 Military expenditures and policy, 1143 Militia, annual drill, 1144 Montague, P.E.I., post office building, 1264 Railway policy, 1956
Humane Society, Criminal Code Arndt., 2831
Humphrey, Mr. L. W. (West Kootenay) Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1526 Pension Board, charges against, 2994 Postal revenue, qu. 2040 Remuneration of railway employees - Mr. McCrea, 2316
Hungary, Treaty with, 3359, 3490, 3547, For Bill, See Peace Treaties
Hutterites. See Immigration


Volume III:: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Ixviii

Hydro Electric, 632, 1326, 1937, 2327, 2747. See also Electrification; Maclean, Mr. (York); St. Lawrence Biver Waterway; Water Powers Commission, 1937
Difference with Ontario Government, 1080
Power development in Ontario, 63, 71, 131, 1950
St. Lawrence river waterway, 136, 1188-9. See also that title
Hydrographic Survey, 1736, 1746. See also Naval Service
Hyndman Commission. See Grain Inquiry Commission
Ice-breakers
Claim of Canadian Towing & Wrecking Co., 1677
Repurchase of, 1490 Thunder Bay, at, 1677 Vickers company contract, 320
Iceland, immigration from, 2144
Immigration, 6-7, 56, 79, 80, 82, 88, 145, 164, 182, 236, 282, 297, 311, 336, 348, 2243, 2254. See also Address; Budget; Census; Labour; Oriental Aliens; Unemployment Advantages, 2516 Agents,
Bonus to, 3062 Promises by, 3058, 3063 Agricultural labourers, 297, 2143,	2161,
2193, 2514, 3053-5
Agriculture, condition and prospects, 2147 Alien enemies, 2146
Asiatic. See under this title, Oriental Aliens
Attitude towards the immigrant, 2151, 2157, 2160
British, 2144, 2150, 2515 Artisans, 2258, 2516 Ex-service men, qu. 3152 Buildings, repairs, etc., 1757 Bukowlnians, 2159
Canadian National railways, and, 1927 Canadians emigrating, qu. 1182. See also under this title, Emigration Central European, 2154-8, 2166, 2477 Child, 2144, 2148, 2153, 2161, 2163, 3063 Chinese, 2026. See also Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie)
Commissioner at Canton, qu. 1901, qu.
Immigration- Con.
Classes prohibited after May 9, 2514 Crime, and, 1392-4, 2517
Deportation. See Immigration-Criminal Code Bills (Mr. Woodsworth)
Aliens trafficking in drugs, 2019 Desirable, 3057
Domestic servants, 2143, 2514, 3053-4 Doukhobors, 167, 2160 Eastern Canada, 2165 Eastern Europe, 80
Emigration from Canada, 2260, 2372, 2516, 2865. See also Population Canadians, qu. 1182 Exodus from Canada, 2478, 2516 Losses through, 2516 Record of, 2158
Europe, from, 308. See also under this title, Central European Follow up policy, 2160 Foreign-born and crime, 1392-4, 2517 Galicians, 2159 Great Britain, from, 2480 Growth of wealth under, 13 Highland family, alleged unjust treatment of, 2145 Holland, 2144
Holland, Lee, deportation of, 872, 1282 Household workers, 2143, 2514, 3053-4 Hutterites and Mennonites, qu. 723, 2160, 3060
Icelandic, 2144
Industrial centres, from, 236
Inspection, 2143
Investigation of conditions in Europe, 1711 Italian, 2171
Japanese. See under this title, Oriental Aliens
Land, speculation in, 2152-9 Language qualification, 2515 Literature, Ontario Government, 2566 " Man with the sheepskin coat ", 2151, 2153, 2518
Manitoba Liberal Convention, res. 2478 Maritime provinces, and, 2165 Meals for immigrants, qu. 2971 Medical inspection, 2021, 2143 Mennonites, qu. 723, 2160, 3060
Emigration to Mexico, qu. 732, 2160 Mentally unfit, 2145 Minister's statement, 2143 Money qualification, 2148, 2208, 3058 Montreal Board of Trade res. 2517 "Nomination system", 3056 Oriental, 319, 2143. See also Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie)
Asiatic, 173, qu. 732 British Columbia in, 167


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume
II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
lxix
Immigration- Con.
Oriental - Con.
Chinese, restriction of
M. (Mr. Stevens) for papers, 1776 Japanese, restriction of, qu. 1289, qu. 1399
M. (Mr. Stevens) for papers, 1776 Oriental Aliens, 319. See that title Poland, 2145 Policy
Criticisms, 2579
Minister's statement, 17, 2143, 2476, 2481 Physically fit, 3055-6 Printers, 3055 Problems of, 350 Qualifications, 2479 Quebec, facilities at, 1465 Racial groups, 236 Assimilation, of, 2517 Rate of, 269
Reception of the immigrant, 2151, 2157, 2160
Regulations, 249-250, 2148, 2215, 2513-14
Res. of Manitoba Liberal Convention, 2478
Restricted, 167, 2513-14, 3056
St. John immigration buildings, 2027
Scandinavian, 2144
Shandro's plan, 2153
Sifton, Sir Clifford, and, 268
Undesirable, 1389, 2154
Ukrainians, 3061
Unemployment, and, 151, 182, 225, 1071. See also that title
Union of Canadian municipalities resolution, 236, 2156
United States, from, 658, 2147, 2150, 2162, 2477. See also that title Work, lack of, 251. See also under this title, U nemployment
Immigration Act
Disqualification of British-born under, 1389-91
Immigration Act Arndt, bills
1. Trial by jury, deportation, (Mr. Woods-worth) lr., 364; 2r., 493, 864 Ref. to Special Com., 1388-94, 1502 Additions to Special Com., 1719 Special Com. reports, 1988, 2519, 3104, 3156. See also Criminal Code bill (Mr. Woodsworth)
Final report, 3280
M. (Mr. Woodsworth) to refer back,
>3282-83
. Arndt, neg. 3286
M. (Mr. Archambault) to concur M. agreed to, 3286 (Subjects and sections discussed)
Immigration Act Arndt, bills - Con.
Trial by jury - Con.
Arrest without warrant, 1390 Assumption of powers of government, 1391
British subject, naturalization of, 1391 Decision of immigration authorities, 1389 Deportation of British subject without trial, 1390 Domicile, 1389 Enemy aliens, 1389 Foreigners, 1392
Organized Government, disbelief in, 1389 Overt acts and thoughts, 1390 Prohibited or undesirable classes, 1389 Repeal of provisions of 1919 Act, 1392 Retroactive legislation, 1391 Trial by jury, 1388
2. Intending Immigrants to make written application. (Mr. Neil) lr., 2207
Immigration and Colonization
Department	[DOT]
Civil government estimates, 3499 Contingencies, 3051 Deputy Minister, qu. 2970 Estimates, 1711, 2026 2143, 3499 Representative at Canton, China, qu.
1901, qu. 2214 Salaries, etc., 754, 3502
Imperial Conference. See also Conferences; Prime Minister Conference Naval defence, 1864
Imperial Convention of Teachers, grant, 1673 Imperial Council, qu. 2803 Imperial Defence. See National Defence bills Imperial Forces, pensions. See Pensions Imperial Mining Resources Bureau, 1237
Imperial Order of Daughters of the Empire,
Implements. See Agricultural Implements
Imported Goods, marking of. See Budget; Customs; Imports
Imports and Exports. See also Budget; Customs ; Germany; Trade Agricultural figures, 209, 2618-19 Automobiles and parts, qu. 1633. See also
that title
British goods, qu. 966 Via United States, qu. 375 By countries, 2109 Coal for public buildings, 1759 Duties, 2668. See also Customs
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Imports and Exports - Con.
Exports
Decrease, 2579
Fiscal years, 1876-77 and 1921-22, qu. 1376
Restriction of exports, 2883 United States, to, 209. See also United States
1911-1922, qu. 1661
Germany, from, 2421, 2644. 'See Germany Marking, 2113, 3476-7. See also Customs Meat, of, qu. 610 Quantity, and, value of, 2182 Revenue from, qu. 827 Statement for last three years, 2109 Structural steel, qu, 1931 Valuation, 2113, 3413
For duty, amended regulation, 2854
Income Tax. 2174, 2220, 2691, 2693. See also Address; Budget; Taxation; Ways and Means
Administration of, 226, 2024 Aliens, non-residents, 1301 Amount collected, qu. 366 Average, by classes, 2298 Banks, payments by, 1400 Branch, appointments to, 1663 By provinces, qu. 705, qu. 1340 Civil Service retirement fund, qu. 937 Classification of taxpayers, 1063 Collections, 60
In 1919-20-21, qu. 1063 Manufacturers, from, 60 Commercial travellers, 2174, 3484. See also Income War Tax Act Amdt. Comparison with systems of other countries, 2227 Exemptions, 2275 Farmers, and, 352, 2714 Great Britain, reductions in, 2860 Inequalities, 2672	[DOT]
Inquiry for legislation, 3103 Montreal office employees, qu. 607, 1288 Payments by grades, qu. 3362 Revenue and classification of taxpayers, 1063, qu. 1399
By provinces, qu. 705, qu. 1340 Winnipeg, qu. 1340 Riordon Paper Company, qu. 927 St. John, N.B., office, qu. 826 Systems in other countries, 2227 Widows and widowers, 2174
Income War Tax Act, 1917, Amdt. bill
Res. 3478; lr., 3359-3360; 2r., com., 3484; 3r., 3486
Sections and subjects discussed:
Banks not entitled to deductions, 3485
Income War Tax Act, 1917, Amdt. bill - Con. Sections and Subjects discussed - Con. Exemptions, 3359 Children, 3484 Forms, 3486 Non-resident aliens M. (Mr. German) 1301, agreed to, 1303
Taxation of American citizens, 3485 Travelling expenses of trainmen and commercial travellers, 3485
Indecent Assault. See Criminal Code
Indebtedness. See Budget; Finance; Loans; Public Debt
Indemnity of Members. See House of Commons
Index, Unrevised Edition. See House of Commons, Debates
Indian Act Amdt. bill (Enfranchisement of Indians; Ownership of land) lr., 2991; 2r., com., 3191; 3r., 3194
Indian Affairs, Department of Estimates, 1214, 1712, 3536 Salaries, etc., 681 Indians
Agents. See also under this title, Reserves Oka, 1217
Sturgeon Falls, qu. 1285 Agitation and unrest, 1223 British Columbia, 1713 Lands, 330 Legal expenses, 3536 Bryce, Dr. Peter H., pamphlet, 1220, 1224 Complaints, 1223 Destitute, relief for, 1712-14 Edmonton school, proposed, 1227-9, 3536 Education, 1227, 1715, 3536 Edmonton school, 1227-9, 3536 Elkhorn school, 3537 Morley school, 1218, 3536 Red Deer school, 1229 Round Lake school, 3537 Stony reserve, qu. 965, 1218, 1227, 3536 Enfranchisement. See Indian Act Amdt. Expenditure, 1216, 1225 Field and garden seeds, 1712 Food allowance, 1220 General expenses, 1226, 1712 Greater production campaign, 1216-20, 1224, 1288
Half-breed scrip frauds, 148-9. See also Criminal Code Health, 1220, 1230
Hospitals and medical attention, 121824, 1713


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
lxxi
Indians - Con.
Janse brothers, land in Ermineskins reserve, 1713
Lafferty, Dr. J. D„ 1225 Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Alberta and northwest, 1218 New Brunswick, 1215 Nova Scotia, 1214 Number in Canada, 685 Ontario and Quebec, 1216 Potlach Institution, qu. 1377, 3191
Indians serving gaol sentences for, 1578, 1721 Reserves
Blackfoot, 1224
Greater production, 1288 Pasture land, qu. 2215 Blood, 1219
Land leased, qu. 2969 Devon band, proposed removal, 1215 Ermineskins, 1712
Keeseekoose-Saskatchewan, qu. 608 Oak lake and Pipestone, 1223 Oka, Indian agent, 1217 St. Peters, qu. 472 Saskatchewan, qu. 608 Six Nation, 1220-1 Stony, 1218
Education, qu. 965, 1227, 3536 Sydney
Medical attendance, qu. 2216 Proposed transfer, 1215 Tobique, illegal cutting of timber, 1233 Settlers. See Indian Act Arndt, bill Smallpox and other diseases, 1714. See also under this title, Health Treaty No. 11, 1219, 1227 Tuberculosis, 1714 Yukon, 1226
Industrial and Scientific Research, 1372
Industrial Conference. See National Industrial Conference
Industrial Depression, 6. 10, 52, 85, 105, 210, 212, 218, 219, 223, 235. See also Address; Budget; Trade
Industrial Disputes. See Labour Investigation Act, 1054, 1058. See also Nova Scotia Miners
Industrial Re-establishment. See Labour; Returned Soldiers; Unemployment
Industrial Warfare. See Nova Scotia Miners
Industries. See also Address; Budget; Trade Basic and secondary, 2384 Boot and shoes, cost of labour, 2350
Industries 

 Con.
Canadian, encouragement, 2658. See also Budget
Exhibitions of industrial products in France, 2031
Financial credit, M. (Mr. Irvine) 1289, 1396 Home, 2149, 2229. See also Budget Key, 2379
Infant, encouragement, 2434 Manufacturing, 2377 Occupational diseases. See Labour Protection and maintenance of, 144, 2677, 2409-11
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1318 Subsidizing, 2402
United States, branches in Canada, 2389, 2546
Woollen, cost of labour, 2350
" Industry and Humanity reference to, 253, 534
Infant Mortality, 1380, 2634
Infectious Diseases. See Penitentiary Act Arndt, bill
Inglis Boiler Works, qu. 732
Inheritance Tax. See this title under Taxation
Inland Revenue Act Arndt, bill (Excise duties changed). Res. 3239; lr., 2r., com., 3r„ 3477
Sections and subjects discussed;
Alcohol for druggists, 3241 Beet sugar, 3246
Amdt. (Mr. Fansher) negatived, 3252 Cigars and cigarettes, 3239 Home brewing, 3141, 3142, 3252 Molasses, 3242 Raw leaf tobacco, 3241 Sugar, 3242
Inquiry for Returns. See House of Commons, Returns
Insect Pests. See Agriculture; Destructive Insect and Pest Act; Grasshoppers
Inside Service. See Civil Service
Inspection and Sale of Root Vegetables. See
Root Vegetables
Insular Dominions. See Limitation of Armaments
I nsurance
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, qu. 605 Canadian National railway, qu. 471, qu. 610
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
lxxii


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
lxxiii
Irvine, Mr. William - Con.
Address - Con.
official Opposition; speeches of Prime Minister and leader of Opposition, 217; co-operation in government; production, consumption and unemployment, 218; unemployment insurance; industrial disturbance, 218; housing; gold standard and credit system; 219; protection and wages; home markets, 221; credit systems, 222; trade competition, 223; industrial problems - British labour party, 224
Agriculture and unemployment, 3058
British Empire Steel Corporation, 1082
Budget, 2495. Congratulations to Minister of Finance; taxation; public debt; chasing the financial	blue-bird;
colossal lie upon which budget is based; credit proposal to meet expenditures and debt; panic of national leaders, 2496; soundness of Canada's financial position; bank balances and real wealth; estimate of wealth and production, 2497; difference between production and consumption; average income of Canadian bread-winner; purchasing power, 2498; credit question at centre of national problems; Germany's industrial and financial position, wages, working hours; paper money, 2499; payment of indemnity in goods; proposed German loan; control of credit, 2500; the banking system; starting a new bank; issues of new money; issue of currency by Govt.; interest; private monopoly of social credit; indebtedness of Canada, 2501; inflation and deflation; underconsumption; shut off interest taps of financiers; the Douglas system, 2502; definition of credit; ability to produce and deliver goods; a social asset; banking and interlocking directorates, 2503; regulation of prices, 2504; schemes proposed by Mr. Henry Ford and Mr. T. A. Edison, 2505; practical attempts to inaugurate credit system; island of Guernsey, 2505; St. Louis municipal currency; the gold basis; collapse of financial system; investigation of banking system, 2506; taxation of consumer; the amendment; attitude of Opposition; amendment to the amendment, 2507; attitude of Progressives; Farmers' platform; fiscal policy of Canadian Council of Agriculture; speech of leader of Progressive party; tariff proposals of Canadian
Irvine, Mr. William - Con.
Budget - Con.
Council of Agriculture, 2509; tax on unimproved land values; inheritance tax, 2510
Debate, M. for adjournment, 2448, 2451, 2455
Business profits war tax, 2024 Calgary live stock branch, qu. 607 Canadian exhibition in France, 2032 Canadian Government railways, deficits, qu. 607
Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1953
Canadian Patriotic Fund Act, 3478-84 Customs department, estimates, 769 Ex-service men, qu. 3152 Financial credit, M. 1290 Free freight outlay, qu. 704 Gold in central reserves and chartered banks, qu. 2971
Immigration-Criminal Code bills (Mr. Woodsworth) 1393, 3285 Immigration, medical inspection, 2022, 3060 Labour department
Employment specialist, 461 Statisticians, 462 Wage investigators, 463 Labour and unemployment, 3060 Loans, five year maturities, qu. 2993 Mackenzie-Mann subsidies, qu. 607 Military expenditure and policy, 1150, 1617 Ministers and directorships, 1120 Non-taxable bonds, qu. 2971 Nova Scotia miners
M. to adjourn House to discuss, 497, 539; withdrawn, 545
Quarantine, immigrant refusing vaccination, 2022
Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3456 Pensions Com., final report, 3345 Prime Ministers' Conference, naval defence, 1745
Rail and car repair contracts, 1705 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 836 Shoe industry, protection, 3238 Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 436 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, 1617 Tariff against France, 2032 Unemployment Insurance, 1081 National Conference, 1082 Public works and highways, 1082 Relief, 2023 Situation, 1080 Standing committee, 1082 War, causes and effects of, 1618
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
lxxiv

Isle Perrot bridge, See Bridges Italy
Genoa Conference, correspondence, 1905, 2035
Immigrants from, 2171
Trade, effect of currency valuation, 2849
Jacobs, Mr. S. W. (George Etienne Cartier) Air Board, 1722
Animal Contagious Diseases bill, 2734 Archives branch, 703
Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bill (petition in bankruptcy) 1395
Budget, 2513. Immigration, restrictive regulations; certain classes of immigration prohibited after May 9; agriculturists; farm labourers and domestic servants, 2514; discrimination in favour of British immigrants; language qualification;- attempt to secure farmers bound to fail, 2515; artisan class should be admitted; immigration of the last ten years; exodus; loss of a million people; advantages of immigration; immigration into the United States, 2516; resolution of Montreal Board of Trade; curious notions in regard to immigration; Imperial Order of Daughters of the Empire; assimilation of races; foreign-born and crime, 2517; Miss Macphail's objection to sheepskin coats; foreigners engaged in textile and other trades; government by Order in Council, 2518 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, amdt., 3000, neg. 3006
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, 3104 Census Cost, 1363
Enumerators, appointment of, 1368 Chamberlin, Mr. R. S., grant to, 3498 Cigars and cigarettes, tax, 3240 Criminal Code Amdt. bill, (Mr. Jacobs) 1395
Criminal Code revision, 1717 Dominion Chain Company, Limited, 3490 Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 477
"Foreigners and crime" propaganda, 1392, 2517
Grecian and Roumanian loans, qu. 1400 Immigration, 2513-2517 Department of, 3500 Deputy Minister, Mr. W. J. Black, qu. 2970, 3500 Dutch, 2144
Jacobs, Mr. S. W. - Con.
Immigration - Con.
Lord Kitchener's death, foreigners and. 2155
Meals for immigrants, 2971 Immigration Act Amdt. bill, (Mr. Woods-worth) 1391, 1392
Insurance premiums, taxation, 3254-5 Linen yarn bounty, 1362 Lusitania reparation claims, qu. 3599 Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3425 Palestine, mandate over, 1716 Redistribution and the census, 1365 Saskatchewan liquor export, 3000 Steamship subsidies, qu, 614 Supreme Court Act Amdt. bill, 2974
Jamieson, Mr. J. A., claim of, 1687
Japan
Army reduction, 1610
Coal, importation from, 2406. See also Coal Immigration from. See Oriental Aliens Lemieux agreement, 1459 Rights and disabilities of Canadians in, qu. 1289, 1511, 2208
Treaty with, 1510. See also, Limitation of Armaments
Jasper Park, Edith Cavell road, 1051
J el I iff, Mr. L. H. (Lethbridge)
Air force and civil aviation, High River, 1734
Customs tariff, woollen clothing, 3235 Irrigation, Southern Alberta, 761 Lighthouses and lightkeepers, 1497 Live stock, loss through wolves, 990, 1001 Rotary rod weeders, duty on, 3121 Sales tax, 3272
Soldiers' civil re-establishment, salary increases, 406
Job Printing. See Special War Revenue, Sales Tax
Joggins, breakwater, 1767
Johnson, Mr. R. M. (Moosejaw)
Address in reply, 112. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; position of Progressive party, 112; agricultural conditions, 113; marketing of grain, 114; tariff; natural resources of western provinces; public ownership of railways, 116 Agriculture, retirement of Dr. Saunders, 590, 3522
Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt. bill, 2103, 2737


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 lxxv

[Stage Direction]
«
Johnson, Mr. R. M. - Con.
Canada Grain Act Constitutionality of, 2837 Overages, 2838
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3009 Canadian National railways. Bengough extension, 2770
Canadian Wheat Board, qu. 472, 2951. ISee also under this title, Wheat Board bill Advance to, 3541 Customs, dumping clause, 3419 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 2810 Dominion lands, cancellation of leases bill, 3469
Fishing schooner race, 3510 Freight rates, Quebec and, 1472 Goderich harbour, grain shipment through, 200-2
Government publications, 1374 Grain companies, default of, 2837 Judges' Act Amdt. bill, 427 Justice dept, estimates, 1668 Labour dept.
Temporary clerks, 567 Wage investigators, 462-3 Lignite Utilization Board, 3526 National Defence bill, 2808 Portable and traction engines, 3231 Public buildings Heating, 1759
Western provinces, discrimination against, 1254
Quebec harbour advances, 1471 St. Lawrence river waterway, 2762 Saunders, Dr. C. E., gratuity, 590, 3522 Soldiers' civil re-establishment, Fort Qu'Appelle sanitarium, 1345 Threshing machines, 3124-25 Welland ship canal, grain transportation, 2762
Vheat Board bill, 3177, 3180, 3182, 3188, 3384
Amdt. 3178
Johnston, Mr. J. Fred (Last Mountain) Accredited herds, diseases, 968 Air force and civil aviation, 1724 Bacon, production and marketing, 1025 Budget, 2220. Congratulations to Finance Minister; reciprocity; financial situation, 2220; revenue and expenditure; debt; war obligations; profiteering; failure to tax wealth; tariff reductions; sales tax, 2221; income tax; immigration; increased production, 2222; markets; trade with United States; Wheat Board; amendment, 2223; failure of Government to propose progressive policy, 2224
Johnston, Mr. J. Fred - Con.
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, qu. 469 Cultivators, etc., duty on, 3120 Customs Act, valuation, 3415 Dominion lands, sale of, qu. 376 Hudson bay railway, 1970 Immigration
Deputy Minister, 757 Officials, 760
Implement parts, duty, 3120 Lighthouses and lightkeepers, 1497 Militia and Defence, pay of staff, 1982 Ministers and Directorships, 1120 Ottawa public buildings, 1252 Ploughs, etc., duty on, 3121 M. to reduce, 3121
Printing Bureau, plant and publications, 1971
Privilege, Progressives and delay in budget debate, 2692
Redistribution and the census, 1370 Rural and urban population, qu. 376 War memorials, 2101
Joint Industrial Councils. See Labour
Jones, Mr. George B. (Royal)
Canadian National railways, coal importations, qu. 2213
Grand Anse, C.B., mail service, qu. 938 Le Blanc, Dr. B. A„ Arichat, qu. 1773 St. John terminal facilities, 848
Judges. See also Bankruptcy Act Amdt.; Exchequer Court; Justice; Supreme Court
Adamson, Mr. Justice, appointment of, 1670 Admiralty, local judge in, 1274 Gravelbourg, Sask., appointment at, 3496 Judges Act, Ministers and Directorships, 1088
Nova Scotia Supreme Court vacancy, 3436 Political commissions, on, 2397 Provincial commissions, on, qu. 366 Latchford, Hon. Mr. Justice, qu. 3600 Riddell, Hon. Mr. Justice, qu. 3600 Salaries, 2512, 3496 Yukon territory, 1275
Judges Act Amdt. bill (Saskatchewan Court of Appeal
Res. 424; lr., 429; 2r., com., 546; 3r., 547 Senate amdts., 2830
Judicial Districts. See Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bill
Justice
Administration of
Exchequer Court, 1274
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Justice - Con.
Administration of - Con.
Litigated matters, 1276 Pecuniary Claims, 1276 Penitentiaries, 1276 Supreme Court, 1274 Yukon territory, 1275 Civil Government, 1668 Estimates, 1274, 1668, 3495 Minister of, directorships and, 242-3. See also Ministers and Directorships Pecuniary claims convention with United States, 1276
Prisons and penitentiaries, inspection of by Grand Juries, 1279 Salaries and contingencies, 451 Trial of Indian murderer, Lebeaux, expenses, 1669
Juvenile Delinquents
Prison farms for, qu. 1773 Special schools for, qu. 469 16, 17, and 18 years old, qu. 1773
Kamloops
Model city, 318
Post office building, 1255
Kamloops-Kelowna Railway. See Canadian National Railways
Kamouraska, vacancy, 1459
Kay, Mr. W. Fred (Missisquoi)
Agricultural implements
Standardization of parts, 2406 Appearance of Senator McCoig before Com. on Agriculture, 2406 Agriculture and Colonization Com. reports McCoig, Senator, attendance of, 1900 M. for concurrence in fifth report, 2915 Wheat Board, 657, 703, 726, 776, 865, 1929 Baker, the late Col. G. H., M.P., memorial to, 2101
Daylight saving, M., 942-3 Privilege, Wheat Board, 872 Reference to, 1282
Kelley, Mr. Howard G., qu. 729
Kellner, Mr. Donald F. (East Edmonton)
Air force and civil aviation, 1723 Animal contagious diseases, compensation, 2806
Budget, 2280. Congratulations to Minister of Finance, 2280; attitude of Progressives to old parties; little change in policy indicated by budget proposals; new taxes; principle of taxation; depression throughout the country, 2281; position
Kellner, Mr. Donald F. - Con.
Budget - Con.
of the farmer; workingman and business man; labour and capital; public debt; credit system, 2282 Canteen funds, undistributed, qu. 2215 Criminal Code Amdt. (Scrip frauds) 3216 Immigration regulations, compliance with, qu. 2215
Soldier land settlement, 2141 Soldiers' pay, exchange on, qu. 826 Winnipegosis wharf, 3545
Kemp, Sir Edward, ammunition shipment from Great Britain, 1169
Kennedy, Mr. Donald M. (West Edmonton) Address in reply, 142. Constituency of West Edmonton, 141-142; conditions in western Canada; tariff question, 143; protection of industries, 144; immigration, 145; Wheat Board; freight rates on grain; Crowsnest pass agreement, 146; soldier settlers, 147; railways, western provinces, natural resources, 147-8; half-breed scrip, 148 Air force and civil aviation, 1724 Banks, income and note circulation taxes, qu. 1400
Criminal Code Amdt. bill (Scrip frauds) 1062, 1395, 3213, 3220 Calhoun, Mr., telegram from, 3601 Dominion Iron and Steel Company, contract for steel plates, 1680 Edmonton bridge, 2007
Harbours and rivers, Alberta and Saskatchewan, 2005 Indians, 1232
Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 499 Prince Rupert Drydock Co. claim, 3515 Public buildings, furniture, etc., 1758 Public Works dept., average salary, 749 Rural mail contracts, subletting, 2801 Steamship subsidies, fair wage clause, 3506
Steel industry, 769
Kennedy, Mr. J. Wilfred (Glengarry and Stormont)
Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt. bill, 2737
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3005 Liquor, export of, 3005 Canadian Government Merchant Marine, wheat carriage, 3039 Customs
Drawbacks, 769 Officials, 765 Valuations, 3416


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
lxxvli
Kennedy, Mr. J. Wilfred - Con.
Dairy Grading Act, 652
Director of Commercial Intelligence, 700
Immigration figures, 758
Oleomargarine Act Arndt, bill, 3425
Railway finances, qu. 471
Sugar beet industry, 3245
Kennedy, Hon. William C. (Minister of Railways and Canals)
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, loan to, 3035
Canadian National railways Annual statement, 873 Branch lines, Bengough extension, 2771 Canadian Northern, advance to, 1905 Consolidation, 1963 Deficits, 875-86
Corrected statement, 1919 Directors, 2791
Appointment of new board, 2772, 2794 Representative of employees, 2794 Freight, careless handling of, 1965 Grand Trunk Pacific Advances to, 3520 Branch lines, 3520
Intercolonial, employees' provident fund, 2769
Kamloops-Kelowna railway, 1135 New board of directors, appointment, 2772, 2794
Rolling stock, repairs, 1212 St. John and Quebec railway, 1295 Toronto Globe editorial, 1134 Transcontinental, allowance to enlisted men, 3518
Canadian Transit Co. bill, 1772 Canals. See also under this title, St. Lawrence
Rideau, 2769 Soulanges, 2768 Trent, 2764 Welland, 2747
Construction, 1687
Port Colborne elevator, Jameson claim, 1687
Crowsnest Pass Agreement. See under this title, Freight Rates
Electrification of railways, M. (Mr. Des-lauriers) 638
Freight Rates, M. for Special Com., 1213, 1492-3, 1502 Gaspe railways, 627 Governor General's cars, 1688 Hudson Bay railway, completion of, 1970, 2798
Ottawa-Kingston highway, 2794 Rail and car repair contracts, 1689
Kennedy, Hon. William C. - Con.
Railway Commission
Carvell, Hon. F. B., alleged statement at Calgary, 2775	[DOT]
Motherwell, Hon. Mr., alleged statement, 2774
Representation of labour, 2776 Railway estimates, 407-8, 1133, 1905, 1933, 2747
St. John valley railway, 3039 St. Lawrence river waterway, surveys, 2768 St. Lawrence ship canal, 2768 Shipbuilding, cost of, 3508
Key Industries Act, 2424
Kindersley, post office building, 1254
King, Hon. J. H. (Minister of Public Works) Big Bay point, sunken vessel, removal of, 2006
British Columbia govt., reply to criticism of, 2237
Courtenay Bay, 2014 Customs dumping clause, 3418 Introduction, 496 National gallery, 2011
Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1547 Public buildings
Appropriations and expenditures, 192122, 1259 Calgary, 1254 Coal for, 1758 Edmundston, 1240 Flags, 1264
Furniture purchases, 1757 Galt, 1247
Generally, expenditure, 1260 Halifax expenditures, 1244 Hamilton, 1246-51, 1258 Heating, 1758 Kamloops, 1255 Maritime provinces, 1243 Montagu, P.E.I., 1264 Ontario, 1245 Ottawa, 1252
Dominion observatory, Geodetic survey, 1266
Elevator attendants, 1266 Lighting, 1267
New departmental, architects' designs, 3541
Water, 1266
Parliament buildings, 2014 Architects' fees, 2014-16 Furniture, purchase of, 1757 Tower, 2016 Quebec, 1245
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Ixxviii

King, Hon. J. H. - Con.
Public Buildings - Con.
Rentals, 1259
Rideau hall, fuel and light, 1756 St. Catherines, 1258 St. John quarantine station, 1240-1 St. George public building, 1240 Saskatoon, 1253 Swift Current, 1253 Toronto, 1246-7 Victoria, 1255 Weston, 1260 Public Works Dredging, 2005
St. Marys river, 2006 Drydocks,
Esquimau, 3541-2 Vancouver, 1255, 2005, 2010 Harbours and rivers, 1988'
British Columbia, 2005 Icelandic river improvements, 2004 Manitoba, 2004 New Brunswick, 1991
Provincial wharves, 1992 St. John, 2014 Nova Scotia, 1765 Expenditure, 1269 Inverness pier, 1760 Joggins breakwater, 1767 Ontario, 1999 Goderich, 2000 Prince Edward Island, 1270 Quebec, 1998
Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2005 Selkirk, wharf, 2004 Shuswap lake wharf, 3547 Winnepegosis wharf, 3545 Public Works dept.
Employees transferred, 696 Estimates, 692, 747, 749, 1238, 1270, 1755, 1988, 3541
River guaging and metering, 2011 Roads and bridges, 2007 Edmonton, bridge, 2007 St. John, N.B.
Harbour improvement, 2014 Terminal facilities, 849-50, 851 Telegraphs and telephones, 2012
Humbolt-Fort Pitt telegraph line, 2007 Yukon radio-telegraph service, 1750
King, Mr. J. W. (North Huron)
Budget, 2301. Congratulations to Minister of Finance; Progressives from Ontario; fiscal policy; small' percentage of land under cultivation; drift towards the cities; infant industries; reciprocity with the United States; tariff proposals, 2302; friendly rela-
King, Mr. J. W. - Con.
Budget - Con.
tions between Canada and United States, 2303
Grand Trunk railway, employees pension rights and status, 2041
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie (Prime Minister; Secretary of State for External Affairs; President of the Privy Council	.
Acoustics of the Chamber, 3613 Address in reply, 38. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker, mover and seconder, 38; welcome to Dord Byng; late Mr. Peter McGibbon; Miss Macphail, 39; remarks of the leader of the Opposition; followers of Mr. Meighen in present Parliament, 40; campaign literature and election results, 40-41; natural resources of western provinces, 41; treaties; Imperial Conference, Limitation of Armaments, 42; customs tariff revision, 43-44; position at Liberal Convention, 44; railway situation; government ownership, 45-46; marketing of wheat, 46-47; railway freight rates; party formation and names, 47; negotiations with Progressive party, 48; Liberal administration, 48-49; Mr. Stewart (Argenteuil) and Mr. Motherwell, 49	(
Ammunition, artillery, shipment from Britain, 1154, 1156, 1163, 1165, 1172 Annual drill, 1155, 1165
Demobilization expenditure for, 1155-65 Annuities, 776
Armorial bearings of Canada, Welsh emblem, 3601
Assiniboine river floods, 1842 Auditor General's report, 424 Australia, reciprocity with, 9, 2803 Banff-Windermere road, 1681 Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bill, (Mr. Ethier) 1662
Bankruptcy Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Jacobs) 1395
Board of Commerce, 1715 Borden, Right Hon. Sir Robert
International disarmament conference, papers, 1283. See also under this title, Limitation of Armaments British Columbia house, London, purchase, 3537
Budget, 2537. Conflicting amendments evidence of wisdom of budget proposals, 2537; taxation, re-adjustment of; speeches of Progressive and Op-


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
lxxix
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con.
Budget - Con.
position leaders; extreme points of view; amendment to amendment; a protectionist budget; repeal of protectionist legislation; reduction of duties; effort to carry out Liberal policy; protection versus free trade not the issue, 2538; tariff revision; amendment; no constructive suggestions; Sir Henry Drayton's tariff proposals of 1920, 2539; platform of National Liberal Conservative party; trade with the mother country; disregard of political honour; promised revision of tariff, 2540; pledges of Liberal party; Liberal Convention of 1919; chart, 2541; statement of policy last session; budget consistent with campaign utterances; no deception of electorate, 2542; Mr. Meighen's London speech; Liberal handbook, 2543; tariff revision on basis of revenue; duties on instruments of production and necessaries of life; pledges fulfilled; tribute to Finance Minister; stability and confidence, 2544
Business of the House
Budget debate, conclusion of, 2639 Customary procedure, 7 Debates on naval service estimates, 1899 Easter adjournment, 546, 821, 823 Eleven o'clock adjournment, 2033 Empire and Ascension days, adjournments, 1769, 1905 Estimates, 569, 2167, 3527 Govt, orders on Monday and Wednesday, 1460
Legislation to be introduced, 2996, 3041, 3102, 3103, 3365
Mines and Minerals Com., 1398 Mondays and Wednesdays, 49, 1719, 2169 Order of, 374 Private members', 1719 Prorogation, 3365
Questions standing as orders for returns, 1660
Quotations from anonymous letter, 1480 Saturday sittings, 2033, 2458 Wednesday sittings, 49 Evening, 2169
Canada Grain Act, Manitoba Court of Appeal decision, 1770
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, Senate amdts. 3613-4
Canadian Expeditionary Force, repatriation of dependents, 1711
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con.
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, 3104 Coal importations, from Japan, 2406 Canadian National Institute for the Blind, 3540
Canadian National parks, 1681 Canadian National railways
Amalgamation of system, 2585 Co-ordination, 73
Directors, sympathy with public ownership, 2858
Canadian offices in England, co-ordination, 414
Canadian representation in the United States, 1384
Canadian Wheat Board bill. See under this title, Wheat Board
Cattle embargo, alleged statement of High Commissioner, 1463
Chamberlin, Mr. R. G., claim of, 3498 Chief Electoral Officer, report, 871 Civil Service Appointments, 573-4 Bonus, 733, 1258
Appropriation, 3528-36 Inquiry as to payment, 2996 Economy, 424 Salaries, 552 $960 and less, 1660
Civil Service Commission, salaries, 3509 Coal
Importation from Japan, 2406 Mined by Orientals, 2407 Con Rein sinking, 1384 Contingencies, vote for, 415 Criminal Code Amdt. (Half-breed scrip) 3220
Criminal Code Amdt. (Mr. Woodsworth) 865, 1719
Criminal Code and statutes, reprinting, 1717
Crowsnest pass agreement. See also under this title, Freight Rates Telegram from Minister of Agriculture to Calgary Board of Trade, 2358 Dauphinee, Mr. Charles, dismissal of, 2458 Death of brother, Dr. MacDougall King, 211, 224, 230, 276
Debates, Official Report, insertion of documents not read, 1540 Debeau, Mr. Robert, claim of, 2306 Deputy Speaker, election, 363 Doherty, Hon. Manning, visit to England, 1334
Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 2814 Dominion Lands, cancellation of leases bills. Senate amdts., 3614 Editorial Committee, 1236
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con. Enfranchisement of foreign-horn women, M. (Mr. Euler) 487 Esquimau dry dock, 597 Estimates, classification of, 569, 2167, 3527 External Affairs Salaries, 412, 3509 Secretaries, 411
Fielding, Hon. Mr., congratulations to, 3279
Financial credit, M. (Mr. Irvine) 1293 Freight Rates (Crowsnest pass agreement) Special Com., ref to M. (Mr. Kennedy), Essex) 1213, 1432-8, 1453-4
Railway Act Amdt. bill, 3588 Reports, 3546, 3560 " General " Macdonald's army, 2256 Genoa Conference, 582, 823, 1715 Cannes documents tabled, 865 Correspondence tabled, 865 With Italy, 2035
Reported subscription to consortium, 1463 Grand Trunk Arbitration
British newspaper article, 374, 822 Grand Trunk railway, pension rights and status of employees M. (Mr. Boys) 863, 1382, 2041, 3437 High Commissioner
Alleged statement re cattle embargo, 1463, 1502 Office of, 414
House of Commons. See also under this title, Business of the House Organization, amendment of, 1335 Sittings suspended, 3611-14 Staff, 3221 Immigration Chinese, 3437
Investigation of conditions in Europe, 1711
Oriental. See under this title, Oriental Aliens
Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth) 864, 1388, 1394, 1719 Imperial Convention of Teachers, 1673 Indians
Estimates, 1712 Potlach institution, 1578
Number serving gaol sentences, 1721 Interim Supply bill, 379 Interior dept., printing and stationery, 1680 International Disarmament. See under this title, Limitation of Armaments International Labour conference, 3437, 3490 Report and printing of, 3601 Japan
Lemieux agreement, 1459 Rights of Canadians in, 1289, 2208
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con. Labour dept, estimates, 564, 569, 577 Lake Huron marine allowance, 1930 Lake of the Woods repeal bill, 3206, 3211, 3436
League of Nations Permanent secretariat
Canada's contribution, 2990 Expenses, 3173
Protocols of proposed amdt. to covenant, 2583, 2692, 3171 Limitation of Armaments, 786 Papers, 1283
Report tabled and ordered printed, 596 Res., 3157 Treaty tabled, 9
Liquor importation, 7331. See also under this title, Canada Temperance Act Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 639 Ministers and directorships, 1098 Ministers' secretaries, 413 Munitions, shipment from Britain, 115465-72
National Defence bill, 547, 662, 680 Natural resources transfer to western provinces, 1017
M. (Mr. Meighen) for correspondence
Provincial governments, correspon' -ence with, tabled, 1769 Naturalization Act, 2024 Naval defence, 1873-1899 Naval service
Gift of ships to Canada, 2051 Royal Canadian navy, 1873-1899 Newmarket, speech at, 35 Norris, Premier, statement on freight rates and natural resources, 1213 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 536, 597
Occupational diseases, M. (Mr. Deslauriers) 1381
Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3427-35 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill), time for discussion, 1719 Oriental aliens, 872, 967, 3104 Immigration
Chinese, restriction of
M. (Mr. Stevens) for papers, 1776 M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion of, 1554, 1573-6
Japanese, restriction of
M. (Mr. Stevens) for papers, 1776 Parliament, fall session, 3608 Pensions, Insurance, etc.
Special Com., appointed, 496-7 Widowed mothers, M. (Mr. Power) 1308 Preston, Mr. W. T. R., rent of house in London, 3504


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 lxxxl

[Stage Direction]
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con. Prime Ministers' Conference, 5 Correspondence, 1068
Naval defence, reported statement of Lord Lee, 1742
Opportunity for discussion of, 2042 Proceedings tabled, 8 Prime Ministers' secretaries, 411 Privy Council Estimates, 410 Private secretaries, 410 Proportional representation, M. (Mr. Good) 1655
Public buildings appropriations, 1259 Purchasing Commission, 2025 Quebec fisheries, 8 Railway Act Arndt, bill, 3588 Railway Commission, Hon. Mr. Motherwell, 2774, 3491 Redistribution, 733
Bill to be introduced next session, 3608 Meeting of defeated candidates in Alberta, 2858
M. (Mr. Shaw), opportunity for discussion, 1719, 1769
References to, (Sir Henry Drayton, "jilting Quebec") 206, 1365, 1754, 2969. See also Address; Budget Regional Bureau of the International Catalogue of Scientific literature, 3528 Returned soldiers. See also under this title, Pensions; Soldiers Announcement of Govt.'s policy, 2637 Unemployment of, 2458. See also under this title, Unemployment Returns, inquiry for, 1283 Royal Canadian Mounted Police Industrial disputes, and, 666 M. (Mr. Woodsworth), 834 Macleod detachment, reported removal of, 2585
Russian relief, 3516
St. Lawrence river waterway
Co-operation with United States, 2760 Correspondence with United States Govt., 23-57, 2583, 2760, 2767 Tabled, 2256
International Joint Commission, report, 2357
Treaty with United States Govt., 2207, 2760
Save the Children Fund, 3516 Soldiers' bonus, 396 M. (Mr. Arthurs) 431, 437 Speaker, Mr. Bereavement of, 496 Congratulations to, 3489 Election of, 1
King, Right Hon. W. L. Mackenzie - Con. Steamship services, 2027 Tariff commissioner, appointment of, 1666 Tourist traffic, 1682
Treaties of Peace with Hungary and Turkey, 3490, 3547
Unemployment. See also under this title, Returned Soldiers Banff-Windermere highway, 1682 Federal, provincial and municipal obligations, 1073-9 Insurance, 1073 Relief, 1719
Returned soldiers, 2458 Situation, 1073-9
Unemployment Service Council, recommendations, 2803 Vancouver dry dock, 3544 War memorials, 2099
Washington conference papers, 1283. See also under this title, Limitation of Armaments
Wheat Board, 378, 783, 2921, 3179
Concurrence in report of Special Com., delay, 2306
Constitutionality of, opinion of Law Officers, 940
Wheat Board bill, 3190, 3383 Wrangel island, 1751 Russian claim to, 2208 Yukon territory, administration of, 1681
King-Crerar Alliance, negotiations, 48, 206. See also references in Address
King v. Manitoba Grain Company, decision. See Canada Grain Act
Kingston
Election petition, 2692 Penitentiary. See Penitentiaries-
Klim, competition with milk, 981
Knives, German production of. See Budget; Customs Act; Currency; Guthrie; Stevens
Knox, Mr. Andrew (Prince Albert)
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3484 Coal royalties, qu. 375 Customs tariff, ploughs 3230 Easter adjournment, 546 Experimental farms, 800 Hudson bay railway, 2750, 2779 Mines dept., field work, 690 Natural resources of western provinces, 457-8
Northwest rebellion, pensions for Mounted Police, 3523
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

lxxxii

Knox, Mr. Andrew - Con.
Port Nelson, examination of masters and mates, 1491 Rideau canal, 2769 Riordan Company, taxation, qu., 372 Royal Canadian Mounted Police pensions Inadequate, 2131 Northwest rebellion, 3523 St. Lawrence ship channel, 1495 Welland ship canal, 2750
Kodaks, prices in Canada and United States, 2547, 2624
Kootenay, Burlington channel bridge, 2007
Kyte, Mr. George W. (Cape Breton South and Richmond)
American magazines, 3109 Budget, 2358. Congratulations to Finance Minister; testimony of opposition to wisdom of Minister's proposals, 2358; tariff an issue no longer, burden of taxation; revenue tariff; sales tax; the workingman; cost of living; articles which do not pay the tax; interpretation of customs law; fishermen's rope; lumber; technical ruling of officials; agricultural implements, 2360; revenue tariff; England's tariff policy; protective duty counterbalanced by excise tax; origin of protective tariff in United States, 2361; manufacturers and war profits; propaganda of Canadian manufacturers; alleged reconstruction committee, 2362; election campaigns of 1896 and 1911; reciprocity with United States; increase of population under Liberal and Conservative rule; immigration, 2363 Migratory birds, 1685 Militia, civil pensions, 3499 Paired members inadvertently voting, 1462 Rail and car contracts, 1693, 1694 Unemployment at Sydney, rail orders in advance, 1691
Labour. See also Civil Service; Housing; Immigration; Industrial Disputes; Oriental Aliens; Returned Soldiers; Shipbuilding; Unemployment Administration, 1058 British labour party, 224 Bureaux, 3314
Canadian Government Merchant Marine Wages, qu. 3598 Canadian National railways Representation on Board of directors. See Canadian National Railways, Directors
La bo u  -Con.
Canadian Pacific, conditions on, 2315 Capital and, 2117, 2191, 2250, 2282. See also Speeches on Budget Coalt See also N. S. Miners Canmore and Drumheller, miners' dispute, 1058
Competition with foreigners, 2154, 2435 Orientals, with, 317,	345. See also
Oriental Aliens
Conciliation and Labour Act, 1053 Conditions, 2350
Cost of living, 1175, 1303, 2331. See also that title
Costs, 2317, 2349-50
Cotton industry, wages, hours, etc., qu. 1903
Lower, 2436 Department Annuities branch, 776 Bertrand, Mr. T., qu. 937 Classification, 494
Director of Technical Education, 578 Estimates, 1053, 1719, 1970 Officials and economy, 464-5 Printing bureau, 1970 Salaries and contingencies, 458, 493, 548 M. (Mr. Stevens) to reduce item, 562, 579, agreed to, 581 Statistical branch, 1366 Technical education, 459, 460, 578 Temporary clerks, 548 Wage investigators, 462 Departments employing organized and unorganized labour, qu. 2303 Distribution of, 2149 District No. 18, board, 1058 Economic injustice to, 2323 Eight-hour day, 184, 2311. See also Daylight Saving
Employment Offices Co-ordination Act, 1058
Espionage, 670-9 Exodus of workmen, 2469 Fair wage clause, 1469, 1486, 3506 Farms, on, 79, 87, 251, 337, 1153. See also Address; Budget; Immigration Genoa Conference. See that title Germany, conditions in, 2411. See also Germany
Hours, 2317. See also under this title, Eight Hour Day
Housing, 219. See also that title Immigration of farm workers and domestics, 2480, 3053-4. See also Immigration Industrial centres, 236
Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1054, 1058


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
lxxxiii
Labour

Con.
Industrial disputes, Mounted Police and, 667, 679. See also Royal Canadian Mounted Police M. (Mr. Woodsworth)
International Labour Conference, qu. 824, 1060, 1070, 3437, 3490 Report, printing of, 3601 Joint industrial councils, 1060 Labour Gazette, 1053, 1057 Leaders, 2118 McAdoo award, 1707
Mounted Police and, 670. See Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woods-worth) : National Defence bill Nova Scotia miners. See that title Occupational diseases, protection against M. (Mr. Deslauriers) 829, 1378, withdrawn, 1382
O'Dell, Mr., on cost of labour in boot and shoe industry, 2350
Old age pensions, 1303. See also that title Organized, 2321, 2324
Oriental, 2330. See also Oriental Aliens Party, composition of, 214 Public ownership and, 130 Quebec harbour commission, wages of employees, 1465, 1469, 1486 Railway, 2315
Canadian National, 2315
Representation on board of directors. See Canadian National Railways, Directors
Canadian Pacific, 2315 Costs, 2317
Wages, 357, 1707, 2315, 2417. See also Crowsnest Pass Agreement Railway Commission, representation on, 2776
Skilled, protection of, 2379 Specialization of, 2149 Strike-on-the-job, 1054 Strikes, 2320, 2322 District No. 18, miners' strike, 1058 Nova Scotia miners. See also that title Gillen board, 1054 Railway employees, 2324 Winnipeg, 841, 1068 Cost of trials, qu. 1182 Literature, 837
Trades Union Conference, Rome, 1060 Unemployment. See also that title Agriculture and, 2158, 2331 Calgary Trades and Labour Council, 1082 Rail and car repair contracts, 1688 Relief, 1719, 1970, 2022, 3526 Situation, 1069 Steel workers, Ss^dney, 1076 Trades and Labour Congress, and, 1081
Laboui

Con.
Unions, 228, 2295, 2317-8, 3059 International, 2317 Unorganized, 2628
Unrest, 14, 17, 90. See also Address; Budget Wages
Average income, 2498 Canadian Government Merchant Marine, qu. 3598
Fair wage clause, 1469, 1486, .3506 Germany, in, 2407 Investigators, 462 Protection, and, 2298 Quebec Harbour Commission, employees, 1465, 1469, 1486 Railway, 357, 1707, 2315, 2417 Shops, 1707
Real and nominal, 2435
Labour Gazette, 1053-7 Cotton industries, wages and hours, qu. 1903
Labrador Boundary, qu. 704, 2572
Lachenaie, Que., mail service, qu. 2805
Ladner, Mr. L. J. (Vancouver South)
Address in reply, 321, 326; four parties in politics, 321; Liberal party in British Columbia; Hon. John Oliver, 322; national railway, 326; returned soldier problems, 327; natural resources of prairie provinces, 328; British Columbia claims, 329 Belgium, trade with, 3223 British Columbia house, London, purchase of, 3538
British Preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 720
Budget, 2276. Tribute to Minister of Finance; Budget of sixteen years ago; promises and policy of Liberal party, 2277; the amendment; tariff changes; British Columbia industries and protection, 2298; danger of Japanese competition; results of protective policy; weakness of budget; trade with Germany, 2279; sales tax; dumping clause and fruit industry, 2280 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3608 Canneries, inspection of, 3048 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) 1448 Fisheries Act Amdt. bill, 2818 Indian Act Amdt. bill, 3191 Labour estimates, increase, 495 Oleomargarine
Further legislation, inquiry, 3041 Importation, 654
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
lxxxiv


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 lxxxv

[Stage Direction]
Lapierre, Mr. E. A. - Con.
Budget - Con.
chasing power; adjustment of tariff to financial exigencies; retail trade and prices, 2629 Georgian Bay canal, 1199 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1199 Sturgeon Falls Indian agent, qu. 1285 Postmaster, qu. 1285 Sudbury mail contract, qu. 1285
Lapointe, Hon. Ernest (Minister of Marine and Fisheries)
British Columbia fisheries, M. (Mr. Mc-Quarrie) 857
Budget, 2585. Congratulations to Finance Minister, 2585; leader of Opposition; amendment; no violation of Liberal platform; political pledges and honour, 2586; a Liberal budget; no political party in favour of free trade; campaign bogeys; an academic question; protection an economic heresy; national as opposed to individual interest; geographical considerations, 2587; United States farmers and protection; Wheat Board, fixation of prices; financial and economic consequences of war; tariffs of Switzerland, Belgium, Holland and Spain, 2588; Government tariff proposals, 2589; Liberal platform of 1893; reciprocity; not free trade but freer trade; revenue tariff; protection and revenue features of tariff legislation; exaggerated statements as to Canada's condition, 2590; hatred and class war; the future; fair play for the government, 2591
Business of the House, questions, 1660 Canada Shipping Act Amdt. bills Harbours and harbour masters, 1578 Pilotage dues, 1487, 2819, 3009 Coolie labour on British ships, 2043 Criminal Code Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth) 865
Distressed seamen, relief of, 1676 Dominion Iron and Steel Co.
Contracts, steel plates, 1677 Damage action against Govt., settlement of, 2170
False Creek bridge, 3516 Fisheries. See also under this title, Marine and Fisheries Department of, 2166 Fish culture, 2169 Fishways, 2167 Marketing, 2109 Protection service, 678
Lapointe, Hon. Ernest - Con.
Fisheries Act, 1914, Amdt. bill, 2306, 2817, 2 9 9 6 , 30 1 0
Fishing schooner race, 1387, 3510 Genoa Conference, expenses, 1715 Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth) 864
International deep sea racing, 1387, 3510 Judges Act Amdt. bill, 428 Lambton steamer, loss of, 1497, 3365, 3507 Limitation of Armaments, 3169 Marine and Fisheries. See also under this title, Fisheries Biological board, 3051 Capt. Demers, 1492
Department, estimates, 1489, 1676, 2166 Examination of masters and mates, 1490 Icebreaking, 1677 Life saving service, 1494 Lighthouse and coast service, 1496 Lambton, steamer, wreck of, 1497, 3365, 3507
Marine agencies, 1496 Marine signal service, 1499 Navigation, aids to, 1498 Navigation schools, Capt. Eddie, 1493 Ocean and river service, 1494, 3507 Pilotage, administration of, 1496 Removal of obstructions in navigable waters, 1493 Port Dalhousie, 1493 St. Lawrence ship channel, 1494 Dredges, 1494 Steamboat inspection, 2169 Wrecks, investigation, 1492 Meat and Canned Foods Act, 3045, 3149 Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 640 Militia and Defence
Annual drill, amdt. to amdt. to reduce vote by $400,000, 1579; agreed to, 1631 Quebec arsenal, amdt. to reduce vote by $50,000, 2091 Montpetit, Prof., 582 Montreal Harbour Commission Employees, 1289 Revenue, 1465
Montreal Harbour Commission bill, 1488, 3199
Naval Service Niobe, sale of, 2067
Transfer of services to Marine and Fisheries, 3611
Navigation, Rainy river lights, 1499 Pilots and pilotage, administration, 1499 Fees, regulation of, 1500 Prince Rupert Dry dock and Engineering Co., claim, 3514
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Ixxxvi

Lapointe, Hon. Ernest - Con.
Quebec fisheries, 377 M. (Mr. Marcii) 619, 622 Quebec harbour
Parc St. Charles Co., Limited, 1470	,
Revenue and expenditures, 1471 Quebec Harbour Commission Papers, 1584
Political patronage, 1477 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1464-86, 3195
Fair wage clause, 1469 Returned Soldiers' Insurance bill, 3399 Steel plates Contracts, 1677 Delivery, 3508 Trenton harbour bill, 3493 Vancouver
Ballantyne pier, 1485 Drydock, 1485
Vancouver Harbour Commission bill, 1929, 2821, 2996
Larkin, Hon. P.C. See High Commissioner
L'Assomption and Montcalm
Excise officers, qu. 2355 Lightkeepers, qu. 1904, qu. .2215	|
Latchford, Hon. Mr. Justice, qu, 366, qu. 3600
Laurier, Sir "Wilfrid. See also speeches on Address; Budget
Canadian military responsibilities, 1629 Canadian Northern loan, 1957 Canadian ports and German submarines, 2089
Conscription and. See Military Service Act Amdt. bill
Grand Trunk lines in United States, 191
Monument, qu, 936
Naval policy, 1849
Old age pensions, 1305
Railway administration, 202
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1333, 1398
Laurier-Fielding Tariff, 141, 144, 208, 290. See also Address; Budget
Lavigueur, Mr. Henri E. (Quebec County) Budget, 2398. Tribute to Finance Minister; extravagance and mismanagement of former government; public debt; unfair treatment of province of Quebec, 2398; no confidence in public ownership of railways; transcontinental railway; Champlain market station; St. Malo repair shops; car repairs, 2399; St. Charles river improvements; wharf at Ste. Petronille;
Lavigueur, Mr. Henri E. - Con.
Budget - Con.
wharf at St. GrSgoire de Montmorency; expenditure and economy, 2400 Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1938
Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 643 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1474
Law, Bowman B., M.P., the late, memorial tablet, 2835
Law Officers
Departmental, 1678, 2573 Opinion of. See Canada Grain Act, constitutionality
Leader, Mr. Harry (Portage la Prairie) Accredited herd system, 2739-41 Animal Contagious Diseases Act, qu. 2739, 3362
Assiniboine river floods, 1842, 2003, 3545 Budget, 2510. Finance Minister's proposals disappointing; tariff reductions counterbalanced by sales tax increase; better trade relations with United States; apology for having voted against reciprocity; rejection of treaty a disaster; live stock industry; little difference between two old parties; origin of Progressive party; promises and performance of Liberals; the amendment; broken promises of Conservatives; Mr. Meighen's declarations on tariff policy; salaries of Ministers and judges, 2512; proposed reduction in indemnities of Senators and Members; Civil Service bonus; shortening of session; absence of members from House, 2513
Harbours and rivers, Manitoba, 2003 Health of animals, tuberculosis, 3522 Immigration, Hutterites, 3060
League of Nations. See also Limitation of Armaments
Article X of the Covenant, 3170 International Labour Conference, 1060 Permanent secretariat, 2026 Canada's contribution, 2990 Protocols of proposed amendments to covenant, 2583, 2692, 3171
Leases, Cancellation of. See Dominion Lands
Leblanc, Dr. B. A., Arichat, qu. 1773
Lee, Lord, of Fareham, 1852. See also Limitation of Armaments


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
lxxxvii
Legal Expenses, 1668. See also Justice; Law Officers
Companies Act, appeal, 1671 Departmental counsel, 1678, 2572-3 Dominion Iron and Steel Co., damage claim, 1677
Employment of outside lawyers, 1678 Trial of Indian murderer, Lebeaux, 1669
Legal Officers, concentration of, 683, 2572-3
Leger, Mr. A. T. (Kent, N.B.)
Canadian National railways, purchase of ties, qu. 2209
Experimental farms, 806, 808 Harbours and rivers, New Brunswick, 1991 Lighthouse and coast service, 1495 Migratory birds, 1685
Oleomargarine, manufacture, etc., M. (Mr. Neill) 1792
Richibucto repair works, qu. 375 St. John income tax office, qu., 826
Legislation. See also House of Commons; Senate
House of Commons, 2026 Printing, 1972 Senate, 2026
Lemieux, Hon. Rodolphe. See Speaker
Lemieux Agreement with Japan, 1459
Lepers, Number of, 2021
Lesueur, Mr. R. V. (West Lambton)
Sugar beet industry, 3243-4
Letter Carriers. See Post Office
Letters, Anonymous, quoting from, 943-944
L'Evenement, Quebec, 1480
Levis
Gravel, Mr., resignation from Quebec Harbour Commission, 1477 Lightkeepers, qu., 2583
Lewis, Mr. Arthur J. (Swift Current) Address in reply, 149. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; common platform in politics, 149-50; real conditions in the West; Great War burdens, 150-151; unemployment; wider markets, agricultural and economic conditions, 151152; tariff and protection; natural resources of western provinces, 153154; consolidation of railways, 155 Blankets, duty on, 3233 British preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) Arndt. 722
Lewis, Mr. Arthur J. - Con.
Budget, 2256. Congratulations to Minister of Finance; Progressive party and government; fiscal policy; free trade; similarity of Liberal and National policies, 2257; forty-four years of protection; tariff for revenue; reductions in tariff and increases in sales tax, 2258; economy; Welland canal; St. Lawrence river waterway; emigration and race suicide; cigar and cigarette duties; automobiles; luxury tax, 2260; British preference; reciprocity with United States, 2261
Canadian National railway, public ownership, 1954
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3484 Canned fish, marketing, 3049 Cattle embargo, 1020 Cigars and cigarettes, duty, 3239 Dominion Bureau of Statistics, 1368 Dominion Election Act, residential qualification, 1301 Dominion lands, 1036
Experimental farm, Swift Current, 796, 3521
Grand Trunk Pacific branch lines, 3520 Gravelbourg, Sask., appointment of Judge, 3496
Indians, education of, 1230 Mines dept., field work, 690 Mixed farming, dairying, 996 Naval service, 1737 Royal Canadian navy, 1852, 2065 O'Connor, Mr. James, dismissal of, 1676 Paper cups, 3115 Pilotage dues, 1500 Post Office estimates, 692 Proportional representation M. (Mr. Good) 1645 Public Works estimates, 692 Rail and car repair contracts, 1689 Railway policy, 1954 Railways, branch lines, 1688, 3520 Residential qualification, 1301 Royal Canadian navy, 1852, 2065 Saskatchewan liquor export, 3000 Soldier Settlement Act Arndt, bill, 3406 Soldier settlement, land purchase, 2140 Swift Current
Experimental farm, 796, 3521 Post office building, 1253 Tractors, duty on, 3123 Welland canal construction, 1688, 2260, 2749
Liberal Convention of 1919. See also Address; Budget
Cash grants to soldiers, 393, 397, 429
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Ixxxviii

Liberal Convention of 1919 - Con.
Old age pensions, 1305 Platform, 25, 2529, 2541, 2896, 2910 Tariff, 2466, 3235
Mr. Fielding's disavowal, 2666 Res. of 1921, 2466 Position of Mr. King, 44-45
Liberal Party
Administration of railways before 1911, 189 Appointments, 138
Big interests and, 242. See also Big interests; Ministers and Directorships Caucus, 1338
Fiscal attitude, 2430. See also Address; Budget
Gains and losses, 138-9. See also Elections of 1921
Government, 188
History of, 2430, 2548-9. See also Speeches on Budget
Interpretation of Liberalism, 26 Opposition in, and Estimates, 378-385
Library of Parliament
Joint Committee on, 211, 326 Salaries, 3517 Staff, 3091-2
Life-Saving Service. See Marine and Fisheries
Lights and Light-Keepers. See also Marine and Fisheries
Fuel for lightboats, qu. 1183 L'Assomption and Montcalm, qu. 1904, qu. 2215
LOvis, qu. 2583
Lighthouse and coast service, 1495, 1677, 3508
Maintenance and repairs to lighthouses, 1498
Parry Sound inspector, qu., 827 Pensions of lightkeepers, 1496 Salaries and allowances, 1497 Superintendent, Quebec district, qu. 2584 Wireless telegraphy, qu., 370
Lignite. See Coal
Limitation of Armaments, 7, 10, 20, 42, 58,
1143,	1174,	1179. See also Military
Policy; Militia and Defence; National Defence
Air service, 1731
Approval of treaties signed at Washington, 786, 3157
Borden, Right Hon. Sir Robert, 1283 Report of, 1737, 1743 Canada's representation, 43
Limitation of Armaments - Con.
General Smuts, 1283
Naval armament, reduction of, 1737, 1844-
5.	See also National Defence; Naval Service
Naval holiday, 1737
Report tabled and ordered printed, 596
Sherman, General William T., 1336
Submarines, 1845
Treaty tabled, 9
Lindsay Arsenal. See Militia and Defence
Linen Yarn
Bounty, 1361
Dominion Linens, Limited, 1362 Duty, 3128
Ling, Mayor. See Nova Scotia Miners
Liquor. See also Alcohol; Canada Temperance Act; Inland Revenue; Special War Revenue
Ale, beer, porter and stout, tax on, 2117, 2852, 2857
Beverages, containing 21 per cent proof spirit, 2857
Bootlegging, cost to country, 2282 Confiscation of, 2997 Export, 2716
Warehouses in Saskatchewan, 767-8, qu., 1211, qu. 1660, 2997 Government, sale of, 1017 Importation, 733. See also Canada Temperance Act
British Columbia into, 1017
Excise duty on, qu. 828
Saskatchewan into, qu. 2037, 2303 Quebec government, and, 71 Sales tax on ale, beer, etc., 2117, 2852, 2857
Little Current
Harbour improvement, 2002 Tugboat, 3086-7
Live Stock, 333, 971, 2511. See also Accredited herds; Address; Agriculture; Animal Contagious Diseases Act; Budget; Cattle Embargo; Health of Animals Animals, cruelty, to. See Criminal Code Amdt.
Associations, grants to, 1027 Bacon, 1025
Bovine tuberculosis. See Animal Contagious Diseases bill Carload and free freight policy, 1029 Commission men, 1031 Competition, 2695, 2698 Destruction by wolves, 990, 998


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
Ixxxix
Live Stock - Con.
Estimates, 1018
Exhibitions, 3521. See also Agriculture Feed shortage in western Canada, 1030 Fordney tariff, effect on, 2453-4. See also that title
Garbage feed, 1029 Grants to exhibitions, 3521 Hog cholera, compensation, 1028 Hogs, grading, 1025
Industry, 334. See also Cattle Embargo
Marketing in United States, 94
Milk supply, inspection of herds, 2740
National live stock records, 1026
Pure bred sires, 1032
Sheep-raising, 2592
Stallion clubs, 1031
Stockgrazing and feeding, 3522
Stockyards, 1030
Trade with South America, 647
Tuberculosis, 2595
Lloyd George. See George, Lloyd
Lloyds, steel plates, delivery, 3508
" Loafing-on-the-Job ". See Industrial Disputes; Labour; Nova Scotia Miners
Loan Companies, 2299
Proposed taxation of, 2299 Renewal of loans, 1476
Loan Companies Act Arndt, bill lr., 1210; 2r., ref. to Banking and Commerce -Com., 1464; Com., 3142;	3r.,
3142; Senate amdts., 3607
Loans. See also Finance; Special Loans bill, 2107, 2171 Domestic, 2694
Five-year maturities, qu. 2993 German, proposed, 2500 Grecian, qu. 1400
Morgan, Messrs, J. P., & Co., 1131 New Canadian, $100,000,000, announcement of, 1131, 1133 New York, 2107-27 Roumanian, qu. 1400 .
Soldiers, to. See Soldier Settlement Special Bill. See Special Loans bill $100,000,000, 1292, 1131
Lobster Canning. See Meat and Canned Foods
Lobster Fisheries. See Fisheries Act Amdt. bill
Local Council of Women, Hamilton, Oleomargarine, 1835
Logan, Mr. Hance J. (Cumberland)
Acoustics of Chamber, 708, 3612 Address in reply, 105. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker, 105. Intercolonial railway, management and operation, 106; history of the Intercolonial; 107; separate operation necessary, 111 British preference
And Canadian seaports, M. 493, 707, 7'25 Goods imported through United States, qu., 375
Budget, 2684. Mr. Hocken's flirtation with Progressives; official Opposition; Bourbons; decline of Conservative party; optimism should give place to despair; the amendment; platform of 1919; changed conditions, 2684; public promises; consaription of farmers by Union Government; tariff; not sufficient time for investigation; boot and shoe industry; problem of unemployment, 2685; leader of Progressive party; revenue necessities; transportation; income, inheritance and land taxes; no question of free trade or protection; revenue tariff; incidental protection; not a protectionist budget; anthracite and bituminous coal; suggested duty on anthracite; bituminous coal duty, 2686; distinction between revenue and protective tariffs; importance of Canadian coal industry; imports; valuation of imports for duty purposes, 2687; British preference and Canadian seaports; direct shipments; transportation question as it affects the maritime provinces; South African railways, 2688; Intercolonial railway; sales tax; exemptions, 2689[DOT]„ fishermen's supplies; economy; civil service salary reductions; indemnity of members; equality of sacrifice; Opposition and budget; compromise on tariff issue; reciprocity; a united Canada, 2691 Canadian National railways Intercolonial, 106-111, 2688, 2689 Employees, enlistment, 3519 Rail and car repair contracts, 1702, 1925 Revaluation, 1926
Transcontinental, enlisted men, allowance, 3518
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3478 Coal
Anthracite and bituminous, suggested duty on, 2686
Investigation of low grade, 3525 Public buildings for, 1759
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Logan, Mr. Hance J. - Con.
Fishing schooner race, 3512
Joggins breakwater, 1767
Lignite Unitilization board, 3525
National defence, 422
Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 523
Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill, 790
Pensions, widowed mothers, 1310
Prison reform, 1278
Rail and car repairs, 1702, 1708, 1925
U nemployment
Canadian coal miners, 1759
Rail and car repair contracts, 1702
Logan, Mr. R. S., 728
Long Branch rifle range, qu., 372
Long Sault. See St. Lawrence River Waterway
L'Orignal wharf, 1212
Louisburg quarantine station, 2021
Lovering, Dr., qu. 1211
Lovett, Mr. L. J. (Digby-Annapolis) Bridgetown post office accommodation, 1245 Budget, 2270. Waste of time in useless discussion; slow progress of Nova Scotia, 2270; freight rates and trade restrictions; reciprocity; emigration; sectional interests, 2271; public debt; financial chaos; taxation; tariff reductions, 2272	[DOT]
Civil Service patronage, 3084 Rural postmasters, 3080
Lovie, Mr. W. J. (Macdonald)
Bovine tuberculosis, Carman, Man., deputation, 2743
Budget, 2451. Congratulations to Finance Minister; tariff reductions not sufficient; handicap upon agriculture, 2451; farmer cannot pass on taxation; manufacturer beneficiary of protection; agriculture the basic industry; implements sold cheaper in foreign countries than in Canada; agricultural depression, 2452; injustice of protective tariff to farmers; freight rates reduction; marketing of wheat; export markets; reciprocity with United States; effect of Fordney tariff on live stock industry; potatoes and poultry products; garden truck; Kubanka wheat; freight rates; statement of Mr. Sandford Evans; wheat and commodity prices, 2454; war profiteering;
Lovie, Mr. W. J. - Con.
Budget - Con.
income tax; religious institutions penalized, 2455 Civil Service bonus, 3535
Low, Hon. Thomas A. (South Renfrew) Budget, 2445. Congratulations to Finance Minister; tariff views of Mr. Good; serious problems confronting government; effort to reduce expenditure, 2445; the tariff; the home market; agricultural production; ratio of exports to domestic consumption; agricultural implements; reciprocity agreement; railways, 2446; freight rates; history repeating itself; cheap transportation for the West; national ills and financial burdens; progressive immigration policy, 2447; settlers from the United States, England and northern Europe and countries
Lucas, Mr. W. T. (Victoria, Alta.)
Canada Grain Act, car demurrage, 2981 Canadian Pacific Railway bill, 1861 Elevator overages, qu. 609 Immigration, Mr. Shandro's proposed colony, 2159
Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1519
Lumber. See also Tariff resolutions; Timber Cargoes for the Orient, 2311 Dressed on one side only, duty, 2360 Freight rates on, 175, 234, 2311. See also that title
Japanese, acquisition of timber in British Columbia, 2310
Machinery and tools, reduction in duties, 2116
Orientals in industry. See Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie)
Lusitania reparation claims, qu. 3599
Macarow, Mr. D. C. See Merchants' Bank
Macbrien, General, 1151, 1169, 1179, 1617
Reported utterances, 1662 Topographic survey, 1986
Macdonald, Mr. E. M. (Pictou)
Address in reply, 186. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker and previous speakers, 186; results of election, 186-7; Mr. Meighen's political campaign, 186-8; responsible government once more restored; public ownership of railways, 188; Canadian Northern and government railways 190; Grand Trunk lines


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
Macdonald, Mr. E. M. - Con.
Address- Con.
in United States, 191; Intercolonial railway management, 192; deficits on railways, 194; financial burdens, 195 Agriculture Com. report, Wheat Board, 783 Canada Shipping Act Arndt, bill (pilotage) 1487
Canadian National railways, 190 Coal
Importations, qu., 926 Purchases of, qu., 2306 Insurance, qu., 471, qu., 610 Operation, 66 Public ownership, 1924 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3480 Civil Service classification, 494-5 Con Rein, sinking of, 1382 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1440-2 Dominion Elections Act Arndt, bill, 2814 Dominion notes and gold reserve, qu., 705 Freight Rates, Special Com., on, third report, 3570
Grand Trunk, coal for, qu., 606 Judges Act Amdt. bill, 427, 429 Labour dept., temporary employees, 566 Naval defence, 1743 Naval service
Reduction in, 1743 Royal Canadian navy, 1870, 2062 Rail and car repair contracts, 1706 Redistribution of 1914, 1369 Reference to, 2536 Royal Canadian navy, 1870, 2062 War claims, loss of hospital ship, 1753 Washington disarmement conference, 1743 Yukon territory
Administration, cost of, 1681 Population, and expenditure, qu., 2456
Macdonald, "General", army of, 3315 Reception of, 2256
M aclnnes, Mr. Hector, K.C., payments to, 2772
Maclnnes, Mr. W. W. B., Immigration Commissioner in China, qu. 1901, qu. 2214
M acKelvie, Mr. John A. (Yale)
Address in reply 159. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; boots and shoes, tariff on, 159-160; statements of Mr. Meig-hen and Sir Lomer Gouin, 160; Tory party, 161; tariff revision, 162; fruitgrowing in British Columbia; protective tariff and fruit; railway situation, 166; immigration; Orientals in British
xci
Mackelvie, Mr. John A. - Con.
Address - Con.
Columbia, 167; natural resources; soldiers' re-establishment; attitude of Sir Lomer Gouin, 168; unity between French and English-speaking Canada, 168-9
Budget, 2196. Congratulations to Finance Minister; tariff; fruit-growing industry; Liberal platform of 1919, 2197; promises and performances; British preference, 2198; reciprocity; dumping clause, 2199; fruit growing industry, 2200; taxation; retrenchment; militia expenditure; cadet training, 2202; naval service; German trade and competition, 2203; the amendment, 2204
Cadet training, 2202
Canadian National railways, Kamloops-Kelowna line, 1134 Customs, dumping clause, 2199, 3422 Dominion lands, sub-agencies closed, qu., 1181
Entomology, codling moth, 814, 816 Fruit growers, protection, 2197, 2200, 3422 George, Rt. Hon. Lloyd, 2203 Interior dept., publicity agent, 454 Militia, expenditure and policy, 2202 Naval college, Esquimalt, 2047, 2203 Naval service, 2203
Royal Canadian navy, 2047 Oriental Aliens, M„ (Mr. McQuarrie) 1534 Telegraphs and telephones, Okanagan district, 2008
Mackenzie and Mann, 189. See also Canadian National Railways Loans to, 189-190 Subsidy, qu. 607, qu., 935
MacLaren, Mr. Murray (St. John City and Counties of St. John and Albert) Address in reply, 353; national railway system; Grand Trunk railway and Portland terminus, 353; Intercolonial railway, 354; natural resources of Prairie Provinces, 355; returned soldiers, 356
American magazines, 3110 Biological Board, 3051
British preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 721
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, steamship services, and, 3033 Canadian National railways, Intercolonial employees, 3519
Canadian Red Cross Society, 3387 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1771
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xcii

MacLaren, Mr. Murray - Con.
Canned goods, marking, 3048
Cold storage, 3521
Edmundston public building, 1240
Harbours and rivers, New Brunswick, 1273
Immigration
Medical inspection, 3052 Officials, 756
Imports of British goods, qu., 966 Inter-allied permanent commission, 3403 Military expenditure and policy, 1149 Militia estimates, 588 Naval policy, 2053 Negro point, breakwater, 2013 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3403', 3442 St. John Ambulance Association, 3387 St. John harbour, 2013 Submarine cables, qu., 3151, qu., 3360 Tracadie lazaretto, 2021 West Indies subsidies steamship services, 3033
Mac Lean, Mr. A. E. (Prince, P.E.I.)
Address in reply, 335. The Prime Minister and Prince Edward Island, 335; Progressive and Liberals; potato trade, 336; harvest excursions; civil service; railway situation in Prince Edward Island, 337; Intercolonial railway; tariff; natural resources and Prince Edward Island, 338-9 Census enumerators, 1366 Civil Service Commission, 364 Hog cholera, 1029
Illegal fishing, Prince county, qu., 371 Migratory birds, 1684 Rail and car repair contracts, 1710 Range lights for fishermen, 1498 Theshing machines, 3125 Tormentine reef, buoy, 1490 Unemployment, Canadian National railways, 1710
Maclean, Hon. A. K. (Halifax)
Budget, 2869. Amended resolutions; effect of taxation on trade; depreciated cur-qncy; Germany, trade with; debt and revenue necessities, 2859; income tax expenditure, reduction of, 2860; economic problems and proposed remedies; Progressive party not an occupational group; class organization; restriction of output; consequences of the war; European recovery; interdependence of nations; international trade; international politics, 2862; German rehabilitation ; reparation payments; restriction of German exports, 2863; Canadian representation at Genoa Con-
Maclean, Hon. A. K. - Con.
Budget - Con.
ference; reciprocity with the United States; tariff legislation of Congress; Canadian representation at Washing-tion; business conditions, 2864; emigration; reconciliation of adverse interests; Maritime Provinces commercial relation with rest of Canada, 2865; Ontario and Quebec, industrial development; Prairie Provinces, 2866; British Columbia; depression of trade; exchange value of commodities; primary products low in price; manufactured products abnormally high, 2868; wages, labour conditions and production; deflation of manufactured products; effect of taxation on prices; amendment, '2869; Liberal platform of 1919; tariff revision vertically and horizontally; chart and compass; Prime Minister's utterances at convention and in campaign, 2870; protection and free trade, 2871; United States competition; compromise on fiscal policy; tendency in United States .towards reduction of tariff, 2872; imports and interests, 2873
Canadian Government Merchant Marine Ownership and operation of, 3036 Subsidized steamship services, 3029 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1420-6. See also under this title, Freight Rates Dominion lands, Cancellation of leases bill, 3469
Freight Rates, Transportation costs. Special Com., Third report, 3456 M. for adoption of, 3548-55 Insurance Act Amdt. bill, 3143, 3145 Loan Companies Act Amdt. bill, 3142 Naval policy, 2055 Naval service Royal Canadian navy, 2055 Royal Naval college, 2055 Public buildings, alleged discriminate i against western provinces, 1254 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1464 Rideau canal, 2764 Welland ship canal, 2763 Wheat Board powers, 781 Wheat Board bill, 3175, 3180, 3380, 3385 M. Com. rise, neg., 3383
Maclean, Mr. William F. (South York) Address in reply, 63. Public ownership of utilities; hydro-electric developments, 63; public ownership of railways, 64;


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
xciii
Maclean, Mr. William F.

Con.
Address

Con.
competition of C.P.R. with government-owned railways, 64-66; corporation-owned railways in United States, 67; water transportation, 6970; electrical developments, 71; transportation and marketing of wheat, 72; co-ordination of government railways, 73; railway grades and duplication; community centres, 75; goods roads, 75-76
Alien enemy property, 1672 Blake, Hon. Edward, 2655 British Preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 723
Budget, 2321. Mr. McCrea and organized labour, 2321; war profiteering; pulp and paper industry; speculation in paper stocks; collective bargaining, 2322; farmers and strikes; the farmers* bloc in United States Congress; economic injustice to labouring population; railways, public ownership; consolidation of national railways, 2323; strikes of railway employees; organization of capital, labour and industry; Canada's status; federation of dominions with written constitution; court of last resort; the war and defence, 2324; scientific methods of destruction; race aggression; transportation; bill of rights of Canadian public services; nationalization of transportation communications, banking, marketing, waterways, finance, 2325; post office, express, telegraph and telephone services, cables; community centres, 2326; St. Lawrence river waterway; water-borne competition with railways, 2327; national banking system of United States; watered stock; co-ordination of railways, 2328; opposition to public ownership from Canadian Pacific Railway; new taxation; soft drinks; cheque tax; immigration, 2329; Oriental labour; redistribution, 2330 Budget debate, conclusion of, 2639 Canada Temperance Act Arndt, bill, 2733 Canadian National railways
New board, appointment of, 2722 Shares held as alien property, 1.672 Census
Completion of, 1365 Enumerators, 1366 Cheque tax, 3259
Maclean, Mr. William F. - Con.
Crowsnest pass agreement, 175-6. See also under this title, Freight Rates Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 953 Electrification of railways, M. (Mr. Des-lauriers) 632
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 491
Freight Rates, Special Com., on, third report, 3564
Grand Trunk lines in United States, 191 Hydro-electric Commission and Ontario Govt., 1080
Hydro-electric power developments in Ontario, 1937
Manufacturers and profiteering, 3275 National Defence bill, 680 Prison reform, 1278
Privilege-Crowsnest pass agreement, 3608
Public ownership, 1933 Quebec fisheries, 622
Railway Act Arndt, bill (Crowsnest pass agreement) 3595 Railway policy, 1933 Redistribution and the census, 1365 Returned Soldiers'
Bonus, 3290
Early announcement of government's policy, 2637
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Arndt, bill, 3319, 3392
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 831 St. Lawrence river waterway M. (Mr. Church) 1326 United States, co-operation with, 2752-55 Sugar beet industry, 3249 Toronto and Tork county, representation, 1365
Traffic charges on boat services, 182 Unemployment situation, 1080 "Water-power rentals, 2747 Welland canal, 2747
Co-operation with United States, 2752-55 Wheat Board, 2967
MacLennan, Mr. Justice, Admiralty Court at Quebec, 1275
Macleod, Alberta
Post Office, revenue, building, qu., 2804 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, detachment at, 2584
MacPhail, Miss Agnes C. (Southeast Grey) Alleged statement, denial of, qu. 3221 Annual drill, 1174
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
xciv

MacPhail, M iss Agnes C. - Core.
Budge* 2384. Liberal party and protection; no material gain in budget proposals; argument of Mr. Raymond; basic and secondary industries; effect of protection, rural depopulation, 2384; protection of industries at expense of agriculture; rural schools; United States farmers demanding protection; unsatisfactory school system; farmers' credits; high transportation costs; taxation of all for the benefit of the few, 2385; proof that farming does not pay; importance of agriculture in development of Canada; trade and national greatness; high protection and revenue; the manufacturer the principal beneficiary, 2386; infant industries; cotton and woollen goods; discrimination against goods used by common people in favour of luxuries; direct and indirect taxation; national expenditure, 2386 Immigration Child, 2153
" Man with the sheepskin coat", 2153 Policy, 2153
Military expenditure and policy, 1174 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 533 References to. See Address; Budget Rural population, movement towards cities, 2153, 2384
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, Supervisor of expenditure, 405
McAdoo Award, 2315, 2317. See also Canadian National Railways
McBride, Mr. T. G. (Caribou)
Address in reply, 316. Oriental question in British Columbia, 316-17,	319;
soldier settlement, 318; unemployment; transcontinental highway, 319; Oriental immigration, 319 Budget, 2635. Length of speeches; free trade; tariff on farm implements and mining machinery; dumping clause, 2635; transcontinental highway, 2636 British Columbia and Progressive party leader, 2239
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, 3039 Loan to, 3036
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3482 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1746, 1770 Chinese, arrival of at Vancouver, .3437, 3604 Civil Service Bonus, 3533-5 Commission, 3072
McBride, Mr. T. G.- Con.
Criminal Code Amdt., branding of cattle. 2833
Customs, dumping clause, 2635, 3419 Debates, inaudibility of, 1053 Dominion lands, Cancellation of leases; bill. 3465
Dredging, Shuswap lake, 2006 Elevators at Vancouver, 2980 Experimental farms, 804-5 Fuel oil, tariff against, 1761 Grain Inquiry Commission, 2984 Housing, 774
Hudson bay railway, completion, 2797 Immigration, Chinese, 3437, 3604 Income War Tax Act Amdt. bill, 3485 Kamloops-Kelowna railway, qu., 937, 3797 Kamloops post office building, 1255 Lambton, steamer, loss of, 3507 Militia and Defence
. Cadet services, 1978 Lindsay arsenal, 2088 Quebec arsenal, amdt. to reduce item by $110,000, 2091 Milking machines, 3i270 Naval Service, Royal Canadian navy, 1854 Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1531 Pensions Com., report, 3351 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 3196 St. Lawrence river waterway, 2762 Shuswap lake Dredging, 2006 Wharf, 3547
Soldier land settlement, 2142 Steamship services, 2027 Telegraphs and telephone lines, 2008 Woollen blankets and clothing, 3135
McCoig, Senator, leave to attend Agriculture Com., 1900, 2406
McConica, Mr. T. H. (Battleford) Agricultural exhibitions, 984 Agriculture Com., report, Wheat Board, 748. See also under this title, Wheat Board
Budget, 2898. Amendment; political promises; tariff revision, 2898; tribute to Finance Minister; old and new taxes; reciprocity, 2899; Sir George Foster's trip to Australia and China; treaty of 1854; abrogation; efforts at renewal; trade routes; acquisition of railways in United States, 2900; trade complications; wheat market; manufacturers of Eastern Canada, 2901; purchasing power of West; position of the farmer; changed conditions, 2902; self-


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 xcv

[Stage Direction]
McConica, Mr. T. H. - Con.
Budget - Con.
contained country or world power; production costs in United States; hothouse industries; competition with United States; fruit industry; debt; financial problem of the United States after Civil War; work; opportunities multiplying; high protection, 2964; substantial reduction of tariff; congratulations to Prime Minister, 2905 Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim for flax shipment, 2836
Canadian Pacific Railway Company bill, 1856
Arndt. (Mr. Carmichael) 1609 Canadian Transit Company bill1, 1772 Dominion Iron and Steel Co. contract, 1678 Judges' Act Arndt, bill, 428 Live stock industry, 985 Mixed farming, 985
Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 525 St. Lawrence river waterway, 2753 Soulanges canal, 2769 Welland ship canal, 2743, 2753 Wheat Board, 3183 Point of order, 2935 Wheat Board bill, 3381
McCrea, Mr. Francis N. (Sherbrooke) Budget, 2314. The railway situation; high freight rates; deficits, 2314; Government ownership; international labour unions; McAdoo 'award; eight hour day; labour costs in general, 2317; remuneration of railway employees; specialization of work; strikes; thrift and industry, 2316; reduction of labour costs necessary; incorporation of labour unions; formation of labour board; walkouts and lockouts should be made illegal; arbitration for settlement of labour disputes, 2319; civil service, 2320
Canadian Pacific Railway bill, 1857 Organized labour, 2321-2
McDonald, Mr. Angus (Timiskaming) Multigraph machines in departments, 1508 Population by ages, qu., 1632 Quebec Harbour Commission, wages of employees, 1465 Unemployment, 2318
McDonald, Mr. John N., au., 3361
McGiverin, Mr. Harold B. (Ottawa)
Civil Service Bonus, 1503, 3529
McGiverin, Mr. Harold B. - Con.
Civil Service- Con.
Commission, 3071 Ottawa, Gas Company bill, 1657 Pensions Com., final report, 3331
McKenzie, Hon. D. D. (Solicitor General) Admiralty Act Arndt, bill, 2456, 2822 Animal Contagious Diseases bill, 2735 Baddeck wharf, repair to, 1765 Big Bras d'Or wharf, 1765 Budget, 2604. Group representation in Parliament; Progressives; duties of citizenship, 2604; public men; tribute to Finance Minister, 2605; Liberalism in Nova Scotia; one change of government in fifty years; Hon. George Murray, 2606; Right Hon. Sir John Thompson; opposition criticisms; responsibility of former government for public debt, 2607; methods of collecting revenue; new taxes; war debt; extravagance; unfit men mobilized; patronage, 2608; Ross rifle; purchase of military equipment; amendment; no suggestion to offer; Liberal platform of 1919; trade with United States, 2610; reciprocity; transportation facilities; purchases of railways in United States; seaports at New London and Portland; purchase of coal lands in United States, 2611; competition with Canadian mines; taking over of Grand Trunk, 2612; Liberal opposition to proposal, 2613; Canadian Northern railway; Grand Trunk Pacific; verdict of the people, 2614; campaign promises made good; record of Liberal party; administration of Sir Wilfrid Laurier, 2615; time to restore prosperity, 2616 Campbell. Mr. J. A., claim of, 2837 Canada Temperance Act Arndt, bill First reading, 1017 Withdrawn, 2733
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, (No. 132) 2733, 2997
Date of coming into effect, 3007 Senate amendments, 3608 Canadian National railways Amalgamation, 916 Public ownership, 1939 Criminal Code Amdt. bill., 2831 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 2809 Concurrence in amdts., 3486 Residential qualification, M. (Mr. Rin-fret) 1299
Dominion franchise, 1300
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



XCV1 COMMONS DEBATES

[Stage Direction]
McKenzie, Hon. D. D. - Con.
Dominion lands, cancellation of leases, 3473 Escheats Act Arndt, bill, 2456, 2826, 3026 Senate amdts. concurred in, 3486 Grain trade, alleged abuses of, 2840 Harbours and rivers, Nova Scotia, 1765 Interruptions, point of order, 558 Lake of the Woods regulation bill, 2991, 3202
Opium and Narcotic drugs, prosecutions, 2017, 3019
Public buildings, Ontario, 1248-51 Statutes, arrangement with Mr. W. J.
O'Connor for revision, 1718 Sydney-Whycocomagh steamship service, 2031
Transcontinental railway, 917 Wheat Board, point of order, 2933
McKillop, Mr. Hugh C. (West Elgin) Mulvey, Mr. Thomas, qu„ 3362
McLachlan, Mr. J. B. See Nova Scotia Miners
McMaster, Mr. A. R. (Brome)
Animal Contagious Diseases bill, 2734 Audibility of debates, 411 Bankruptcy Act Amdt. (Mr. Jacobs) 821 Boy Scouts, 773
Budget, 2417. The Tariff a tax; German competition; purchasing power of the mark in Germany; working hours and conditions; production costs; Mr. Bristol's speech "made in Toronto"; prosperity of the United States; tendency towards free trade, 2418; Nova Scotia coal and steel industries; Dominion Iron and Steel Co.; watered stock; free trade in Australia; western farmers and protection; congratulations to finance Minister; inflation and depreciated currency; German competition, 2420; German imports and exports; cheap labour; international hatred and bitterness; treatment of French Canada after siege of Quebec, 2421; spirit of international peace and comity; trade with Germany; German rehabilitation necessary for stabilization of world conditions; fiscal policies of Switzerland, Holland, Belgium, 2422; free trade Great Britain; the big industries; the Safeguarding of Industries Act; history of free trade movement in England; the carrying trade of Great Britain and the United States. 2424; budget proposals; sales tax, 2425; cumulative payment b3' consumer; tariff reductions; Liberal
McMaster, Mr. A. R. - Con.
Budget - Con.
party and tariff; revisions of 1904 and 1907, 2426; reciprocity agreement of 1911; Liberal platforms of 1893-1919, 2427; abuses of protection; price-fixing by manufacturers; tyranny of the trusts; collars and silk stockings; the new feudalism; the amendment, 2428; Liberal party stands for progress and freedom, 2429
Criminal Code Amdt. (Mr. Jacobs) 821 Customs dumping clause, 3418 Depreciated currency, 2420, 3411 Dominion lands, cancellation of leases, 3467-75
Empire defence, Canada's responsibility, 1629
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 483 Essence de L'Erable, Qu. 1774 German valuation of goods, 3227 Girl guides, 774 Immigration figures, 758 Insurance premiums, tax, 3257 MacBrien, General, utterances of, 1662 Militia and defence, expenditure and policy, 1628
Ministers and Directorships, M„ 1084, 1128 Paired members inadvertently voting, 1462 Point of order, reading of documents, 560 Proportional representation, M. (Mr. Good) 1648
Public Accounts Com., first report, 1460 Railway Act, 1919, Amdt. (Mr. Jacobs) 821 Root Vegetables bill, 3376 Sales tax, 3265
Special War Revenue, flour, 3265 Voting when paired, explanation, 1462 Wheat Board, 2957, 3185 Wheat Board bill, 3189, 3380 Amdt, 3384; agreed to, 3385
McMurray, Mr. E. J. (North Winnipeg) Address in reply to Governor General's Speech moved, 10. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; Miss Macphail; Lord Byng, 10; abnormal conditions at home and abroad; financial burdens; state-owned railways; agriculture unprofitable; tariff revision, 11; natural resources of western provinces, 11-12; seat for Hon. Mr. Stewart; unemployment; returned soldier problems; forest and mineral wealth, 12; immigration; wider markets, 13; Wartime Elections Act; labour troubles; harmony between races, 14
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II; 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX-1922

[Stage Direction]
xcvii
McMurray, Mr. E. J.- Con.
Andrews, Mr. Alfred J., 1068, qu., 1182 Budget, 2474. Serious financial conditions, 2474; national debt; railroad deficits; legacy of the war; no constructive proposals; shifting the burden; production of wealth; Canada's future, 2475; immigration policy of former Liberal government; development of the West; prosperity interrupted by war; aggressive immigration policy needed, 2476; immigrants from central Europe; settlers from United States, 2477; exodus from Canada; statement of Lord Shaughnessy; declaration of Manitoba liberal convention; qualifications of the immigrant; criticisms of immigration policy answered; conditions In West improving, 2479; immigrants from the British Isles; foreigners and Canadian national life; the labour argument; policy of the United States; Canada's problems less than those of other countries, 2480; probable results of active immigration policy, 2481
Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1439 Lake of the Woods Repeal bill, 3205 Natural resources, prairie provinces, 1017 Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1527 Winnipeg strike, cost of trials, qu., 1182
McPherson, Mr. Duncan, superannuation of, 2805
McQuarrie, Mr. William G. (New Westminster)
Asiatic immigration, qu., 732. See also tinier this title, Oriental Aliens British ^Columbia fisheries, M., 851 Budget, 2233. Progressive party' attitude towards Government; tariff reductions, 2233; reciprocity; British Columbia, protection of farms, mines and fisheries, 2234; free trade; immigration; unemployment; the amendment; pledges and moral code of the Liberal party; "political trickery"; Hon. John Oliver, Premier of British Columbia, criticism of by Vancouver Sun; alleged purchase by provincial government of warehouse site from President of Liberal Association; Vancouver World; resignation of provincial Attorney General, 2237; Minister of Public Works; national debt, 2238
McQuarrie, Mr. William G. - Con.
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, coal mined by Orientals, 2407 Carriage of mails, qu., 825 Census enumerators, payment of, 1367 Civil Service bonus, 733 Patronage, 3084
Salaries $960 and less, qu., 1660, qu„ 1775 Condensed milk tax, 3269 Exhibitions, grants to, 1026 Indians, New Westminster agency, 3536 Oliver, Hon. John, criticism by Vancouver Sun, 2026, 2296-37
Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 3018, 3016
Oriental aliens, 872, 967, 3104 M. for exclusion or, 1509 Pensions Act Amdt. bill, 3445 Quebec fisheries, M. (Mr. Marcil) 169, 622. See also under this title, British Columbia Fisheries Small manufacturers, 2710 Vancouver and Fraser Valley railway, 798 Widowed mothers, pensions, 3293
McTaggart, Mr. Neil H. (Maple Creek) Budget, 2545. Congratulation to Finance Minister; budget proposals disappointing; speeches of leaders; debt, taxation, idle factories; unemployment; abandonned farms; readjustments in economic structure; downward revision of the tariff; failure of protection, 2545; sales tax; suggestion from Canadian Manufacturers Association; protectionist budget; revenue; investment of American capital in Canadian industries; abuse of Customs tariff by United States companies, 2546; duty on cigarettes, cameras; comparative prices in Canada and United States, 2547; tariff reduction; ability to compete with outside industries; Progress, ive party, 2548
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3006 Customs revenue, 770 Dominion lands, surveys, 1041 Saskatchewan, liquor export, 3006
Machinery. See Agricultural Implements
Madawaska customs collections, qu., 607
Magazines, American, imports of, 3109
Magna Charta, 1388
Mail Carriers. See Post Office
Mail Contracts. See Post Office
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

xcviii

Mail Services. See Post Office; Railways; Steamship Services
Malcolm, Mr. James (North Bruce)
British Preference and Canadian seaports, M. (Mr. Logan) 719
Budget, 2387. Tariff and taxation proposals of Minister of Finance, 2387; consideration given to all sections of country; sales tax; stamp and stock transfer taxes; automobiles tax; the tariff, 2388; United States tariff; reciprocity; British preference; American branch industries and export trade; marking and depreciated currency acts, 2389; income tax; effect on capital; confiscation; enterprise should not be discouraged; immigration, 2390; emigration; the farmer and industrialism; problems of prairie provinces; markets; transportation costs; fiscal policy, 2391
Goderich harbour improvement, 2001 Harbours and rivers, Ontario, 2002 Lake Huron, harbour of refuge, 2002 Soldier Settlement Act, 1919, Amdt., 2035
M anagement, Charges of. See Finance
M anion, Hon. Robert J. (Fort William and Rainy River)
. Address in reply, 263. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker; speech of Mr. Raymond, 263; different tariff policies of Liberals, 264; election campaign, 265; record of Union Government, 266; defeat of Union Government, 267; immigration; national debt and railway problem, 268; natural resources; St. Lawrence river waterway, 269; race and creed bigotry, 270; soldiers' reestablishment and pensions, 271; housing; tariff and protection, 272; railway rates, 273
Agriculture, subsidies to, 1698 Budget, 2261. Congratulations to Finance Minister; loans; Liberal and Progressive platforms, 2261; resolution moved by Minister of Finance while in opposition; the tariff, 2262; farmers and the budget; trade with Germany, 2263; foreign exchange; protective legislation in the United States; tariff for revenue; free trade not possible, 2265; sectional demands; Wheat Board; Crowsnest pass agreement; St. Lawrence river waterway; the home market; sales tax, 2266; Great Britain and tariff legislation; 2267; free trade
Manion, Hon. Robert J. - Con.
Budget - Con.
and protection, 2268; advisory tariff board or commission; cheque tax, 2269; receipt tax; the amendment, 2270 Burstall, Sir Henry, 743 Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, claims qu., 606
Canadian National railways Grain leakages, qu., 1401, 1930 Orders in anticipation of requirements 1698
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3481 Canadians emigrating, qu., 1182 Census, remarks by Mr. Johnston (Last Mountain) 1370
Civil Service Commission, 3087 Cost of living, .1057 Daylight saving, 948-9, 961 Dominion Bureau of Statistics, 1366 Dominion lands and surveys, 1037, 1039 Election pledges, cash bonus to soldiers, 403
Empire and Ascension days, 1760 Employment offices, 1058 Fisheries estimates, discussion, 2166 Forest protection, 1048 Harbours and rivers, Ontario, 1999 Health, department of, 2017 High Commissioner's office, 414 Immigration
Estimates, opportunity for consideration, 2162-4
Physically fit, 3055-6 Policy, 756	.
Immigration dept., labourers, 3054 International Labour Conference, 1060 Labour Gazette, 1057 Labour, technical education, 460 Militia and defence
Arsenals, Quebec, 2093 Expenditure and policy, 2092 Officials, 586 Staff reduction, 422 Naval service staff, 418, 422 Navigation lights in Rainy River, 1499 Opium and Narcotic drugs, 2017, 3016 Prohibition, and, 2017 Parliament buildings, tower, 2016 Patronage, rural postmasters, 3083 Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill, 788 Pension Board, 392, 1350 Regulations, change, 2995 Pensions
European war and active militia, 1361 Widowed mothers, 1311 Pensions Committee, final report, 3302-3


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
xcix
Manion, Hon. Robert J.- Con.
Point of order, general policy, 556 Public building, location of services in, 1757
Rail and car repair contracts, 1696, 1698 Returned soldiers, alleged treatment of children of, 2638
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act Arndt, bill, 3394, 3400
Revenue and protective tariffs, 719, 2265 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1200 Co-operation with United States, 2760 Grain transportation, 2758 Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 445 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Estimates, details of, 1347 Expenditure, 1340 Hospital staff, 1345 Salary increases, 387 Soldiers' disabilities, 392 Unemployment relief, 1352 Vocational loans, 1346 Soldiers, land settlement, 2023 Statistics, co-ordination of work in, 1366 Steel industry, subsidies to, 1697 Tariff, permanent advisory board or commission, 2269
"Tories and militarists", 1598 U nemploy ment
Rail and car repair contracts, 1696 Situation, 1074
Vancouver and Fraser Valley bill, 798 Welland ship canal, grain transportation,
Wheel chairs for invalids, 3115 Wrangel island, 2208
Manitoba	.
Agricultural College, western agricultural conditions, 2332
Court of appeal decision on Canada Grain Act, 1770, 1841, 1932-3. See also Wheat Board
Flags on public schools, 1265 Forestry in, 1046 Harbours and rivers, 2003 Liberal Convention, res. on Immigration, 2478
Natural resources, control of, 24, 1018. See also Western Provinces Norris, Premier, on freight rates and natural resources, 1017, 1213 Unemployment conference, 1069 University of, percentage of students of foreign extraction, 2151, 2157 White Mud river fishway, 2167
Manufactured Goods, tax on. See Customs Tariff
M anufacturers. See also Canadian Manufacturers' Association Eastern Canada in, 2901 Income tax paid by, qu., 1063-4 Production of wealth by, 2378 Progress since 1870, 2658 Propaganda, 2362
Protection of, 55, 102-3, 144, 153, 303, 343, 2435-2440. See also Speeches on Address; Budget
Sales tax. See Special War Revenue
Manure, exportation of, 1018. See also Fertilizers
Maple Products. See also Health
Maple Products Act, administration of, 201T
Maps, Topographical. See Dominion Lands
and Surveys
Marcil, Hon. Charles (Bonaventure)
Air force and civil aviation, 1733 Budget, 2905. Twenty-two years of parliamentary life; interest in the West; 2905; Liberal party and western development; a united Canada; hardships of pioneers, 2906; conditions and advantages of the western railways; market for the farmers; employment for the workingman; reciprocity; opposition of manufacturers; 2907; trade relations with United States; tariff reductions; British preference; development of St. Lawrence waterway; better understanding between East and West; the amdt., 2908 Business of the House Budget debate, conclusion of, 2639 Sub-amendment (Mr. Crerar), 2473 Canadian National railways, public ownership, 1938
Canadian representation in the United States, 1383
Canned goods, marking, 3050 Census enumerators Appointment of, 1371 Payment of, 1368 Census figures, verification, 1366 Civil Service Commission, 3072 Patronage, 3074
Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 952 Debates, official report of. insertion of documents not read, 1540 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill. 2813 Fisheries, Gulf and Gaspesian coasts, qu. 1401
French-Belgian treaty, 3223
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Marcil, Hon. Charles. - Con.
Gaspe railways, M. for papers, 623 House of Commons staff, stenographers and messengers, qu., 1376 Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. Woods-worth) 1393
Insurance claims of heirs Of deceased soldiers, 1349
Meat and canned foods, 3047 Montreal Harbour Commission, Capt. Dan-dry, 1481
Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1800 Opium and Narcotic drugs, 3019 Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3444 Pension Commissioners, Quebec representation, 1350-1
Pensions, widowed mothers, 3293 Proportional representation, M. (Mr. Good) 1656
Quebec fisheries, 377, M., 493, 616 Receipt tax, 3262 References to, 1298
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act, 3395 Root Vegetables, potato bags, 3377 Rulings as Acting Speaker:
Member moving res. has right to close debate, 540
Member withdrawing motion, 545 Relevancy, 3539-40, 3542 Res. involving charge on revenue, 3476 Supply, point of order, 1337 Vocational loans to fishermen, 1346
Marcile, Mr. J. E. (Bagot)
Bankruptcy Act, qu., 703
Dominion Elections Act, qu., 470
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, qu., 377
Marconi Company, 1736, 1749
Margaree breakwater, 1767
Marine and Fisheries. See also Canada Shipping Act Arndts.; Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine; Fish and Fisheries; Naval Service. For vessels, see that title
Barkhouse, Captain, 1748 Biological Board, 3051 Demers, Captain, 1492 Deputy Minister of Fisheries, 2166 Derelicts, removal, Windsor, N.S., 1493 Distressed seamen, relief of, 1676 Estimates, 1489, 1676, 2166, 3507 Examination of masters and mates, 1490
Marine and Fisheries - Con.
Dife-saving
Equipment, qu., 1284 Services, 1494 Stations, qu., 367
Dighthouse and coast service. See that title
Dittle Current tug boat, 3086 Marine agencies, 1495 Marine signal service, 1499 Meteorological service, 1501 Navigation, aids to, 1498 Newfoundland coast, 1498 Rainy river lights, 1499 Navigation schools, 1492 Ocean and river service, 1676, 3507 Expenditure, 1494
Murphy, Capt. Frank, compensation, 3508 Relief of distressed seamen, 1676 Steel plates, 3508 O'Hara, Captain, 1490 Pilotage
Administration of, 1499 Exemption from dues. See Canada Shipping Act Amdt.
Prince Rupert Drydock Co., claim, 3514 Publicity and marketing division, 2169 Range lights for fishermen, 1498 Removal of obstructions from navigable waters, 1493
St. Lawrence ship channel, maintenance, 1494
Select Standing Com. on, changes, 1398 Steamers and icebreakers, 1489 Steamboat inspection, 2169 Sorel shipyard Maintenance, 1494 Men employed, 1062 War claims, adjustment of, 1677 Wrecking plants, subsidies, etc., 1493 Wrecks, investigation, 1492 Lambton, 1497
Maritime Provinces
Coal fields, 108, 2611. See also Coal Condition prior to Confederation, 107	'
Intercolonial and, 107, 192. See also that title under Canadian National Railways Natural resources, 340. See that title Public buildings, 1243 Railways, 131
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1316
Mark, value of. See Currency, depreciated; Germany
Marketing of Wheat. See Wheat Board


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922 cl

[Stage Direction]
Markets, Foreign, 221. See also Trade Necessity for, 2149. See Speeches on Address; Budget Reciprocity and. See that title Restricted, 343
Marking Act. See Customs
Marking of Goods. See Budget; Customs Tariff
Marler, Mr. Herbert (St. Lawrence-St.
George)
Address in reply, 243; congratulations to Mr. Speaker; unity of purpose in government; elections and the province of Quebec, 244; government by co-operation; railway situation, 246; merchant marine, 24V; tariff revision, 248; Liberal tariff views; immigration, 249, 250
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, 246-247 Insurance, qu., 605
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 486 Mines and Minerals, Com., on, 1398 Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3444-55 Pensions Committee First report, 726 Final report, 3286, 3348 Adoption of, 2253 Meetings, 3335
Returned Soldiers' Insurance Act, 3393 Soldiers' Settlement Act Arndt, bill, 3408 Speech on tariff before election, 240 Vickers, dry dock, qu. 936
Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 647, 754, 1012, 1032. See also Agriculture Cattle embargo and, 1032
Martell, Mr. L. H. (Hants)
Agricultural exhibitions, 995-6 Barkhouse, Capt., 1748 Biological Board, Mr. Halkett, 3051 British Empire Steel Corporation, taxation, qu., 1067
British Preference and Canadian seaport^, 719
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, passenger traffic, qu. 939 Canadian Pacific Railway bill, 1859 Canadian Transit Company bill, 1771 Canned lobsters, inspection, 3048 Civil Service Inside service, 580-1 Overmanning, 3081, 3100 Patronage, 3087
Martell, Mr. L. H.- Con.
Coal transportation on national railways, 1763
Cold storage, 818, 996 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 951 Departmental law officers, 683-4 Esquimau and Nanaimo railway bill, 1163 Fisheries Act Arndt, bill, 2818 Fisheries Protection service, 678, 1747 Fishing schooner race, 3510 Food inspection, 820 Income tax, qu., 366
Indians Sydney reserve, medical attendance, qu., 2216
Labour department salaries, 549 Legal costs, 2772
Maclnnes, Mr. Hector, K.C. Halifax, payments to, 2772 Marine and Fisheries Capt. O'Hara, 1491 Lighthouse and coast service, 1496 Ocean and river service, 3507 Select Standing Com., on, 1398 Wrecks, investigation, Capt. Demers, 1492
Meighen, " the King-maker ", 35 Military expenditure, 1137, 1141 Militia dept., officials, 741 Motion transferred. 942 National Defence bill, 665, 737 Nova Scotia miners, 524 Oleomargarine Act Arndt, bill, 3489 Opium and Narcotic Drugs bill, 3022 Parents, support of by children, 1310 Parliament buildings, architects' fees, 2015 Pelagic Sealing treaty, 1844 Pensions
Limitation of time for application, 2995 Widowed mothers, M. (Mr. Power) 1309 Pensions Act Arndt, bill, 3445-62 Preston, Mr. W. T. R., claim, 3504 Removal of derelict in channel at Windsor, N.S., 1493
Royal Canadian navy, 1855, 1890 St. John terminal facilities, 849 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, staff, 1343 Steamship services, freight rates, 2028, 3032 Welland ship canal, 2749 West Indies steamship services, 3032 Wheat Board, 3182 Windsor, N.S.,
Lease of wharves to C.P.C., 2749 Wreck at, 1493
Women and the franchise, 483
Massey-Harris Company, 1106, 2175. See also Agricultural Implements
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cii

Masters and Mates. See Marine and Fisheries
Matapedia Valley. See Quebec Oriental Railway
Match Industry, Occupational diseases. See Labour
Matches
Bill respecting, lr., 3598 Tax on, 3262
Maybee, Mr. M. E. (Northumberland, Ont.) Baxter, Mr. Charles, successor to, qu., 2457
Meat and Canned Foods Act, administration of, 967
Meat and Canned Foods Act Arndt, bill Res. 3044; lr., 2r., 3050; com., 3050, 3149; 3r., 3150
Meat Inspection, 226. See also Animal Contagious Diseases; Cattle Embargo
Meat Products. See also Live stock
Meats, Cold storage. See Agriculture
Medical Advisory Board. See Pensions Committee
Medical care. See Indians
Medical Examinations. See Returned Soldiers Insurance Act
Medical Inspection. See Immigration
Medicines. See also Opium and Narcotics Duties, reductions in, 2116
Mediterranean of America, 1202. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthur (Leader of the Opposition)
Abattoir inspectors, 969 Adamson, Mr. Justice, appointment of, 1670 Address in reply, 19. Congratulations to mover and seconder; Miss Macphail; New Prime Minister; Limitation of Armaments conference, 19-20; census returns; expansion of trade, 20; Liberal speeches and campaign literature; Sir Lomer Gouin and Mr. Mitchell, 21; natural resources of western provinces, 22; tariff revision, 24; Liberal platform; speeches of Sir Lomer Gouin, 26; Hon. Walter Mitchell; the Prime Minister on the tariff, 26-27; Mr. Raymond, 27; Mr. Marler, 28; public own-
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthur - Con.
Address - Con.
ership; 30; wider markets; Minister of Agriculture, 32; reciprocity pact; reduction of freight rates, 33; Liberal administration; negotiations with Progressives, 34; Mr. Crerar, 34-35; Newmarket speech; Union Government negotiations, 35; Mr. Gardiner's statement, 36; responsible government, 37; Orders in Council, 37-38 Agricultural implements, duty, 3119 Agriculture Com. report, 726, 776, 1929.
See also under this title, Wheat Board Agriculture dept., Mr. Duncan Marshall, 645
Air Board, 1722
Details of expenditure, 1728 Estimates, 1722-35
Alien property, custody at Prince Rupert, 3606
Alpine Club, 794, 1053 Archives, 702
Assiniboine river floods, relief measures, 3491
Australia, reciprocity with, 9, 10, 2802 Banff-Windermere highway, 1682 Birthday, congratulations on, 3102 Borden, Sir Robert, correspondence, 3l73 International disarmament conference, 1283
Budget, 2523; Tribute to Finance Minister; financial position; debt; taxation and fiscal policy; moderate protection, 2524; free trade principles; the Netherlands, Belgium, 2525; Great Britain; abandonment of protection would mean disaster to Canada; ability to compete abroad; reciprocal trade; peculiar situation of Canada; United States an intermediary between us and the outside world, 2526; east and west routes of trade; reciprocal arrangement with United States; rejection of Reciprocity treaty; Fordney tariff, 2527; American farmers and competition in home market, 2527; free trade in wheat; results seen in United States tariff legislation; amendment, 2528; Liberal pledges broken; brazen apost-acy; British preference; microscopic reduction in duties; Liberal platform of 1919, 2529; Finance Minister should have declared his position; tariff; general reduction and detailed adjustment, 2530; voters betrayed; contract broken; revised policy of Liberal


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX-1922

[Stage Direction]
ciii
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthui

Con.
Budget - Con.
party; declaration of Prime Minister; promised reductions in duties on food, 2531; clothing, building materials; failure to implement pledges, 2532; responsibility of Progressive party; invitation to Government to abandon pledges; grant to returned soldiers; Mr. Crerar's position, 2533; amendment to amendment; failure of Progressives to achieve their desire; responsible government; agricultural implement duties; 2534; Opposition votes for government; freight rates; faults of the budget; German and Austrian trade; exchange; inflation of currency; marking of imports, 2535; Government by Order in Council; dumping clause; possible tarilf reductions; sales tax; Mr. Raymond and agricultural implement duties; Hr. Macdonald (Pictou) and steel and coal duties, 2536; special platforms for individual constituencies; Government's difficulties of their own creation, 2537 Budget amendment, 2338 Building trades, 583 Business of the House, 373
Amdt. to amdt., (Mr. Crerar) 2522 Budget debate, conclusion of, 2639 Daylight saving, 1282
Debate on naval service estimates, 1742, 1900
Debates, Official, insertion of documents not read, 1540 Decorum, 2090
Delay in proceeding with, 7 Further legislation, inquiry, 2996, 3102, 3365
Government orders on Mondays and Wednesdays, 1461, 1720 Privilege, right of member to raise on orders of the day, 2638 Questions standing as orders for returns, 1660
Supplementary estimates, 3364 Wednesday, hour of sitting, 49 Canada Shipping Act Amdt. bill (Pilotage) 1487
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, Senate amdts., 3614
Canadian National parks, 1053 Canadian National railways Accounting, 1918
Amalgamation of system, delay, 2585 Canadian Northern, 1907 Deficits, 1918
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthui

Con.
Canadian National railways - Con. Estimates, 1907-54 Minister's annual statement, 912 Canadian offices in England, co-ordination, 414
Canadian Transit Company bill, 1747 Cash grants to soldiers, 393, 394, 2533 Liberal pledge, 400 Relevancy, 404 Cattle embargo, 985
Alleged statement of High Commissioner, 1022, 1463
Census enumerators, appointment, 1368, 1372
Chamberlin, Mr. R. G., grant to, 3497 Chinese customs tariff, 3168 Civil aviation, 1722 Civil Service Act, 1368 Civil Service
Classification, Arthur Young Co., 1491 Economy, 2057
Marine and Fisheries department, 1491 Militia services, organization of, 423 Reorganisation of, 2061
Griffenhagen and Associates, 1491 Russell, Mr. T. A., superannuation of, 1667 Coal for public buildings, 1758 Committees, changes, 497 Criminal Code Amdt. bills
Half-breed scrip, 3103, 3211, 3219 Mr. Woodsworth Special Com., second report, 1988
Crowsnest pase agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 10411-21-24-49-53. See also under this title, Freight Rates Customs Drawbacks, 766
Dumping clause, 2535-6, 3119, 3413, 3421 Estimates, 763 Valuation for duty, 3225, 3414 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 948 Debates, Official Report of, insertion of documents not read, 1540 Defence, preparation for, 1621. See also under this title, National Defence Demobilization, military hospitals, 1262 Deville, Dr., 1044, 1048 Dinosaurs, museum specimens, 1237 Director of commercial intelligence, 700 Distressed seamen, relief of, 1676 Doherty, Hon. Manning, visit to England, 1283, 1334
Dominion Elections Act, 470 Dominion Iron & Steel Company Contract for steel plates, 1677 Damage action against Govt., 2170
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
civ

Meighen, Right Hon. Arthui

Con.
Dominion lands And surveys, 1044 Homestead re-entry, 1042 Dominion lands, cancellation of leases, bill, 3466-75
Senate amdts., 3614 Editorial Committee, 1235-6 Election campaign, 21, 187 Election of Speaker, 2 Election promises, 21 Liberal handbook, 400 Ellesmere Island, 1751
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 479 Estimates
"Appropriations not required," 1269 Information not up-to-date, 1267 This year's accounts charged to previous years, 1715
Exemption of farmers' sons, 440 Experimental farms, expenditure, 126'1 Extra-territorial rights, 1068 False creek bridge, 3516 Finance, deputy minister, 751 Fire prevention, 794 Fisheries protection service, 1747 Fishing schooner race, 3511 Freight rates. See also under this title Crowsnest Pass Agreement Crowsnest pass agreement, 3589 Railway Act Arndt, bill, 3589 Special Com., ref. to, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) 1213 Third report, 3589 Gasoline tax, 3116 GaspS railways, 627 Genoa conference, expenses, 1715 Geological survey, co-ordination of survey work, 1236
German goods, valuation, 3225 Government departments, payments to each other, 1724
Grain Inquiry Commission, 50 Grand Trunk Railway
Arbitration, British newspaper article, 375
Financial statement. 1933 Harbours and rivers Expenditure for 1921-22, 1269 Prince Edward Island, 1270 High Commissioner
Alleged statement of, 1022, 1463 Office, 414
Hydrographic survey, 1746 Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Mr. 'Woods-worth) 1503, 1988
Immigration-Criminal Code bills, 3284
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthui

Con.
Immigration dept., 3051
Black Mr., appointment, 3500 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 755 Work of, .760
Immigration of Hutterites, 2160 Imperial Convention of Teachers, 1673 ImperiaL Mining Resources Bureau, 1338 Income tax
Comparison with systems in other countries, 2228
Naturalization, and, inquiry as to legis lation, 3103
Non-resident aliens, M. (Mr. German) 1303
Income War Tax Act. Amdt., 3359 Indian Act Amdt. bill, 3192 Indian Affairs
Estimates, 681, 684, 1712 Indians
Agitation and unrest, 1223 Complaints, 1223 Expenditure, 1216 Hospital grants, 1218 Medical attention, 1218 Six Nation reserve, 1222 Soldiers Settlement Board, 1222 Stony reserve school, 1229 Insurance department, 792 Interim Supply bill, 380 Interior Department
Conservation Commission employees, transfer, 457 Estimates, 3517 Printing and stationery, 1680 International Labour Conference, 3437 Judges' Act Amdt. bill, 424, 428 Justice dept, salaries, 452 Labour department Duplications, 577 Salaries 550
Lake of the Woods Repeal bill, 2991, 3200, 3207, 3435
Lawyers, employment in Justice dept., 1679 League of Nations, 3162, 3171, 3174 Limitation of Armaments, 43 Loyalty of western Canada, 1023 McCoig, Senator, attendance before Com.
on Agriculture, 1900 Marine and Fisheries Life-saving service, 1494 Removal of obstructions in navigable waters, 1493
St. Lawrence ship channel, 1494 Steamers and icebreakers, 1490 Marler, Mr., and railway situation. 28, 247 Marshall. Mr. Duncan, appointment, 3501 Meat and canned foods, 3045, 3050


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cv

[Stage Direction]
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthur - Con.
Military Service Act Amdt. bill, 640 Militia and Defence Annual drill, proposed reduction of vote, 1620-9 Arsenals Lindsay, 2088 Quebec, 2091, 2096 War claims, adjustment of, 417 Mines department Additional officials, 689 Estimates, 686
Ethnologist and ornithologist, 687 .Ministers and directorships, 1104 Montreal Harbour Commission, 1489 National Defence bill, 663, 674, 734, 738, Senate amdts., 2807
Natural resources, transfer to western ' provinces, 41-42 M. for correspondence, 1509 Naturalization Act Amdt. bill, 3436 Naval defence, 1862-1900 Naval policy, 2056-81 Naval service, 1738
Empire defence, contribution to, 2081 Niobe, sale of, 2065
Royal Canadian navy, 1741, 1862-1900, 2056
Empire defence, needs of, 1741 Minister's proposals, criticism of, 1741 Staff, 418
Nelson, Mr. Frank, 3517 Norris, Premier, reported statement, 1213 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 503, 524-539, 544, 597, 1054 Nova Scotia Supreme Court, vacancy, 3437 Ocean and river service, expenditure, 1494 Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3426-32 Orders in Council, government by, 663, 2535-6
Ore-dressing plant, 1235 Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1561, 1567, 1575
Paper milk bottle caps, 3114 Parliament buildings, lighting, 1755 Parliament, fall session, 3609 Peace and war, 1621 Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill, 789 Pension Commissioners, Board of, 1350, 1351
Charges against, 3041 Representation of Quebec, 1351 Pensions
European war and active militia, 1353 Expenditure under report of Special Com., 3522
Meighen, Right Hon. Arthur - Con.
Ploughs, duty on, 3123, 8125
Amdt. (Mr. Johnston, Last Mountain, 3230
Political alliances, 2097 Political promises - Mr. Hoey, 2338 Portage la Prairie exhibition, qu., 1391 Post Office estimates, 691 Preston, Mr. W. T. R., rent of house in London, 3504 Prices, deflation of, 1216 Prime Minister, private secretaries, 410, 412 Prime Ministers' Conference, 1629 Correspondence, 1068 Naval defence, 1742 Lord Lee, reported statement of, 1742 Report, reference to, 5 Prince Rupert Dry Dock & Engineering Co., 3514
Privy Council, increases, 410 Promises of Union Government, 2339 Public buildings	.
Coal for, 1758
Flags, 1264, 1268
Generally, expenditure, 1262
Heating, 1758
Maritime provinces, 1243
Ontario
Alleged neglect by former government, 1249
Appropriation and expenditure, . 124559-60 Ottawa
Elevator attendants, 1266 Lighting, 1267 Water, 1266
Public expenditures, 1249 Public Works
Classification, 693 Estimates, 692, 697, 699, 747 Public buildings, 1755. See also under this title, Public Buildings Salaries, 749
Quebec fisheries, M. (Mr. Marcil) 377, 493 622
Quebec Harbour Commission Inquiry for papers, 1283 Political patronage, 1477 Resignation of former commissioners, 1477-8
Quebec Harbour Commission bill, 1477 Radiotelegraph service, 1749 Railway Commission
Chairman, alleged statement of Mr. Motherwell, 3491 Freight rates, 193
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cvi

Meighen, Right Hon. Arthur - Con.
Railway estimates, 409 Railway policy of Government, inquiry, 407 Railways, annual statement of minister, 921 Raymond, Mr., and the tariff, 255, 2536-7 Reciprocal trade with Australia-, 10, 2802 Inquiry for correspondence, 9 Reciprocity with the United States, 2845 Redistribution, 733, 3611
Census, and, 1364, 1367, 1371 Resolution should embody bills, 3179 Returns, inquiry for, 1283 Rideau hall, fuel and light, 1756 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 734 Amalgamation with Dominion Police, 673 Estimates, 2129 Ruling of Chair, 3354 St. John quarantine station, 1241 St. John terminal facilities, M. (Mr. Caldwell) 844
Saunders, Dr. C. E., gratuity to, 3522 Secretary of State, estimates, 701 Seed grain advances, 1053 Seed grain commission, 1011 Soldier land settlement, 3294, 3296 Estimates, 2135 Homestead rights, 2135 Land purchase, Irregularities charged, 2139
Taxes, collection of, 2135 Soldiers' bonus, 393, 394, 400, 404, 436, 2533 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Hospitals, 1262 Medical treatment, 392 Parliamentary Com., 393 Salary increases, 385 Unemployment relief, 1352 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment bill, 3597, 3609
Sorel shipyards, dismissal of employees, 1283
Speaker, Mr., bereavement of, 496 Speaker's election, 2
Statistics, co-ordination of work, 580, 1366 Statutes, revision of, 1718 Steamship subsidies, 3505 Steel, structural, importation, qu., 1931 Stefansson expedition, 1750 Supply. See also under this title, Estimates Concurrence, 1769 Method of discussion, 1142 Motions in, 1579 Latitude in discussion, 2238 Supreme Court estimates, 1274 Tariff Commissioner, appointment of, 1663 Tariff revision, 2540 Tourist traffic, 1682
Meighen, Right Hon Arthui

Con.
Tractors, duty on, 3124
Trade and Commerce officials, 700-01
Treaties of Peace with Hungary and Turkey, 3490
Trial of Indian Lebeaux, expenses, 1669
U nemploy ment
Banff-Wlndermere highway, 1682 Canadian coal, use of by railways, 1759 Insurance, 1080
Policy of government as to, 3491 Relief, 1719 Situation, 1079
Welland canal, 2750	.
United Grain Growers, agricultural implements, 3120
United States, discriminatory legislation 1303, 2527-8
Washington conference. See also under this title. Naval Service Empire naval defence, 1744 Papers, 1283
Welland canal, 2750
Western provinces, natural resources. See Natural Resources
Wheat Board, 2915, 2924, 2953, 3175, 3184. 3190, 3381, 3386. See also under this title, Agriculture Committee Concurrence in report of special Com., delay, 2306
White, Mr. James, employment of, 3495
Winnipeg strike, Mr. Alfred J. Andrews, 1069
Wrangel island, 1750
Yukon territory
Administration of, 1681 Expenditure, 1275 Radiotelegraph service, 1749
Melchior, Dr., on value of German mark, 2645
Mellish, Mr. Justice, 1275
Melville, Sask., railway restaurant, qu., 2038
M embers. See House of Commons
M emorials, War. See Baker, Lieut. Col.; Battlefields; Historic Sites; War Graves Commission; War Memorials
M ennonites. See Immigration
Merchant Marine. See Canadian Government Merchant Marine
Merchants' Bank. See that title under Banks and Banking


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cvii
Mercier, Mr. Paul (Westmount-St. Henri) Address in reply to Governor General's Speech, seconder, 15. Change of government; Baron Byng of Vimy, 16; congratulations to Mr. Speaker; encouragement of agriculture, commerce and industry, 16-17; immigration; labour, 17; financial burdens; political parties, 18
Electrification of railways, M. (Mr. Des-lauriers) 638
St. Lawrence river waterway, 786, 1383 M. (Mr. Church) 1396
Meredith, Sir Vincent, 1128
M essengers and Stenographers, qu., 1376
Metal File Cabinets, 1252
Metals. See Mines and Minerals
Meteorological Service, magnetic observatory, 1501
Mexico
Postal rate to, qu., 3364 Trade with, 699, 700, 2989
Mewburn, Hon. S. C. (East Hamilton) Ammunition shipment from Great Britain, 1169
Battlefields memorials, 2098 Hamilton post office building, 1246 Military expenditure and policy, 1152, 1579 Militia and defence
Annual drill, 1152, 1579 Expenditure and policy, proposed reduction, 1579 Services co-ordination, 416 National Defence bill, 665, 666, 737, 744, 745 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, industrial disputes, 667
Royal commission on pensions, 386
Michaud, Mr. Pius (Restigouche and Mada-waska)
Audibility of debate, 385
Criminal Code Arndt., fines, payment, 2832
Customs revenue, qu., 607
Damage by floods in New Brunswick, 3492
Edmundston
Post office, qu., 608 Public building, 1242 German reparations, qu., 375 Lighthouse and coast service, 1496 St. John terminal facilities, 847 St. Lawrence river waterway, 2753 Welland ship canal, 2753
Migratory Birds, 1684
Military Forces, preparedness. See Militia and Defence; National Defence; Naval Servicee
Military Hospitals, 1261, 1341, 1344, 3287-9, 3345. See also Pensions Com. report; Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, 1339-48
Military Service. See also Pensions Com. Medical inspection, 3317
Military Service Act, powers under, 780
Military Service Act, 1917, Repeal bill (Mr. Woodsworth
lr., 424; order for 2r., stands, 493; M. for 2r., 639; Mr. Speaker rules bill out of order, 644
Militia and Defence. See also National Defence bill
Adjustment of War claims, 1155, 2098, 2974 Air force, 1722
Allowances, active militia, 1135 Ammunition, 2085
Shipment from Great Britain, 1156-63, 1337
Small arms, 1979
Annual drill, 1137, 1139, 1144, 1146, 1151, qu., 1285, 1335, 1578, 1610, 2835 Arndt. (Mr. Power) to reduce vote by $L100,000, 1174, 1578 Arndt, to amdt. (Mr. Lapointe) to reduce vote by $400,000, 1579; agreed to, 1631
Expenditure for 1911-21, qu., 1287 Armouries
Fittings and alterations, 1261 Quebec, qu., 1287 Arsenals
Danger of attack by aeroplanes, 2085-98 High explosive shells, 1170 Lindsay, 1165, 1171, 1979 Site, purchase of, 2087-8 Quebec, 1165, 1171, 1978-9, 2085
Amdt. (Mr. Lapointe) to reduce vote by $50,000, 2091; agreed to, 2098 Amdt. (Mr. McBride) to reduce vote by $110,000, 2091; neg., 2098 Customs duties, 1978 Rivi&re du Loup, qu., 1181 Burstall, General Sir Henry, retirement of, qu., 1211. See also National Defence Cadet camps, 1147, 1973, 2202 Militarism, 1974 Cadet services
M. (Mr. Murdock) to reduce vote by $100,000, 1972; agreed to, 1978
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cviii

Militia and Defence - Con.
Civil pensions, 1711, 3499 Clothing- and necessaries, M. (Mr. Murdock) to reduce item by, $21,000, 1978 Defensive forces, 1135 Demobilization expenditure, 1155, 1163 Department
Estimates, 415, 586, 1578, 1610, 1972, 2974, 3498
Reductions, 1174, 1578, 1631, 1972-87, 2091-98
Salaries and contingencies, 415, 586, 1985 District auditors, 1145 Engineer services and works M. Mr. Murdock) to reduce item by $50,000, 1980 Expenditure
Policy and, 1174, 1335, 1578, 1610, 2202. See also under this title, Arsenals, Naval Service
Reductions proposed by minister, 1578 Reduction of, 1135 1890-1913, qu., 1285 1911-22, qu., 1287
First Canadian Contingent, qu., 1376 General staff, 1145 Generals, 1145
Gwatkin, General, retirement of, qu., 12.11.
See also National Defence Lindsay arsenal. See under this title, Arsenals
Long Branch rifle range, qu., 372 Lord Grey on military protection, 1136 MacBrien, General, 1151
Reported utterances of, 1662 Maintenance of military properties, 1980 Military districts, 1580, 1775 District No. 12, 1602 London, 1983 Toronto, 1983
Military holiday, 1146, 1338	[DOT]
Military hospitals, 1341. See also that title Militia council, qu., 2039 Montreal ordnance stores building, 1246 Munitions. See also under this title Ammunition
Shipment from Great Britain, 1154-63 Officers and men at headquarters, 1775 Ordnance arms and lands M. (Mr. Murdock) to reduce item by $9,000, 1982
Ordnance building, Quebec, repairs, 1711 Pensions. See also that title European war and active militia, 1349, 1353, 1361
Permanent force, 1136, 1147, 1152, 1580, 1982 Estimates, 1982
Militia and Defence - Con.
Permanent force-Con.
Expenditure, 1140
Royal Canadian Artillery, 1982
Strength of, 1136
Ten years' service or more, qu., 2637 Prince of Wales Leinster regiment, qu., 1065
Quebec arsenal. See under this title, Arsenals
Rental of buildings, 1764 Royal Military College, 1985 Schools of instruction M. (Mr. Murdock) to reduce item by $50,000, 1985
Service overseas, 1140-80
Shed on Cartier square, Ottawa, qu., 2038
Staff, 661
Pay of, amdt., (Mr. Murdock) to reduce item by $10,000, agreed to, 1982; amdt (Mr. Sutherland) to reduce item by $25,000, neg., 1982
Tobin, Lieut. Col., and 29th Battalion, 1975 Topographical maps, qu., 1632 Topographic survey, 1985 Training areas, 1986 Training camps, qu., 2584 Transport and freight, 1986 Arndts. (Mr. Hanson) to reduce by $60,000 and (Mr. Spencer to reduce by $10,000, 1987
War claims, adjustment of, 1155, 2098, 2974 Warlike stores, 1137, 1154-63 Sale of, 1171-3
Milk. See also Dairying Industry Competition with Klim, 981 Condensed, tax, 2492, 3264-5, 3271, 3409 Filled milk and cream, qu., 963 Herds supplying. See Accredited herds Paper caps for bottles, 3114 Products, taxation, 3263-4
Milking Machines, 3270
Mill Feeds, adutleration of, 1012, 2490. See also Grain and Grain Trade
Millar, Mr. John (Qu'Appelle)
Agricultural implements, price of, 1476 Agriculture
Condition and prospects of, 1475, 2163 Plant pathologist, 593-4 Animal Contagious Diseases bill, 2736 Banks, interest rates, 3601 Beet sugar industry, 3251 Budget, 2294. Congratulations to Finance Minister; war indebtedness; failure


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 clx

[Stage Direction]
Millar, Mr. John

Con.
Budget - Con.	[DOT]
to meet larger proportion of cost during the war; public debt; revenue and expenditure; encouragement of basic industries; agriculture bled white, 2294; monopolies and political contributions; labour unions; extracting profits from the consumer, 2295; insufficient tariff reductions; agriculture languishing; price of gasoline; Sir Richard Cartwright and Mr. Meighenon the tariff, 2296; the tariff and mergers; increased prices of textiles; white lead, protective duty added to price; sales tax, the poor man hit, 2297; free food, boots and shoes; protection and wages; average income tax by classes; cost of fostering home industries, 2298; income tax, introduction of; loan companies, 2299
Canadian National railways Branch lines, 1476, 2772 Freight, careless handling of, 1965 Census
Completion of, 1363 Registration of Canadians, 1363 Civil Service, overmanning, 401 Dairy industry, 980
Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 485 Estimates, 401
Expenditure, necessity for economy in, 401, 1475
Export liquor warehouses, Saskatchewan, 767, qu„ 1211 Legality of, qu., 1660 Fish culture, 2169 Fishing schooner race, 3513 Fort William-Port Arthur terminal elevators, qu., 1210
Hudson bay railway, completion of, 2784 Immigration
Foreigners, loyalty of, 2163 German, 3052 Policy, 2163 Indians
Education and health, 1228 Round lake school, 3537 Liquor
Export warehouses, 767, qu., 1211, qu., 1660, 3001
Importation into Saskatchewan, qu., 2037, qu., 2303
Loan Companies Act Arndt, bill, 3142 Loan companies, renewal of loans, 1476 Parsons, W. Reuben, qu., 3362
Millar, Mr. John - Con.
Quebec harbour advances, 1475 St. Lawrence river waterway, 1198 Grain transportation, 2756 Saskatchewan liquor export. See under this title, Liquor
Soldier land settlement, land purchases, 2139
Terminal elevators, overages, qu., 1210, 2837
Welland canal
Estimates, amdt. to reduce vote by $4,000,000, 2758; neg., 2764 Grain transportation, 2756 Wheat Board bill, 3385, 3181 Woollen goods, duty on, 3136
Milling Combines, 304, 2633. See also Wheat Board
Milne, Mr. Robert (Neepawa)
Agriculture dept., officials, 654 Budget, 2239. A six country; new fiscal policy needed; amendment; no solution; loss of faith in political parties, 2239; economy; tariff inconsistencies; unfairness as between manufacturer and farmer; free raw materials and protected product; sales tax, 2240; farmers and the income tax; agriculture the mainstay of the country, 2241 Fishways in White Mud river, 2167
Milton, speech of Hon. Mr. Murphy, at, 2562
Mineral Resources Bureau. See Imperial
Mineral Resources
Mineral Waters, tax on. See Taxation
Mines and Minerals. See also Coal; Geological Survey; Natural Resources Assay office, Vancouver, 1236 Canadian Institute of Mining and Metallurgy, 1237 Clay products, 1234
Imperial Mining Resources Bureau, 1237 Lignite Utilization Board, 3524 Machinery and tools, reduction in duties, 2116
Mineral rights. See Soldiers' Settlement Act Amdt.
Miners' strike, district No. 12, 1058 Mines dept.,
Estimates,, 685, 1233 Salaries, 685
Statistical branch, 1366 Topographical maps, qu., 1632 Ore dressing plant, 1236
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Mines and Minerals - Con.
Publications, 1234-6 Resources, 12 Investigation of, 1234
Reduction in vote, 1236-62 Road and materials, 1234 Select Standing Com., 1398 Tar sands, 1236
Yukon, mineral discoveries, 1276
Ministers and Directorships, 241-243 M. (Mr. McMaster), 1084; neg., 1131 Bank directors, 1091 Bank of Montreal, 1129 Board of Railway Commissioners Act, 1088, 1101
Borden, Sir Robert, 1089 Directors of large corporations, names, 1128
Government's attitude, 1095-1117, 1124 Great Britain, practice in, 1089-99, 11071128
House of Commons and Senate Act, 1088,
1100,	1111, 1113, 1129 Interlocking directorates, 1086, 1100, 1115,
Judges' Act, 1088
Merchants' Bank, 1085, 1096, 1121
Practice in other countries, 1090, 1096,
1101,	1114
Tariff beneficiaries, 1088 White, Sir Tomas, 1089, 1102
Ministers of the Crown
Salaries, 1093, 2895 Trips to Europe, 14
Minority Candidates. See Elections
Minority Government. See Elections
Minors, sale of drugs to. See Opium and
Narcotics
Miscou-Shippegan Islands, service, 2029
Mitchell, Mr. A. J., 46, qu., 471
Mitchell, Mr. Walter (St. Antoine)
Canada Temperance Act Amdt. hill, 3002 Carriage or transportation, amdt., 3008 Canadian National railways Deficits, 1910
Investigation proposed, 1908-17 Public ownership and operation, 1907 Rails and car repair contracts, 1694, 1709, 1961
Reference to by Mr. Meighen, 21, 207 Monckton Papers, purchase of, 1673
Moncton
Intercolonial headquarters, 313, 355, 2289 Railway .shops, 1709
Money. See also Banks and Banking; Currency; Finance Gold standard, 1291
Purchasing power of, 1151-3, 1175, 1177, 1292, 2331, 2603, 2629. See also Address; Budget
Mark, German. See Germany Money Bills. See Appropriation; Supply Montpetit, Professor. See Genoa Conference
Montreal (city)
Bank of. See Banks
Canadian National railways' employees, 1288
Census figures, 1366
Clerks of the peace. See Criminal Code Amdt.
Cold storage warehouse, 819 Customs and excise employees, 1288 Foreigners, immigration of, 1392-4 Income tax office, qu., 607, 1288 Merchants' Association, 1392 Ordnance stores building, repairs, 1245 Post office employees, 1288 Post offices, business done, qu., 1065 Soldiers' civil re-establishment, staff, 1342 Suburban steam service, 135 Wages of workmen, 1465
Montreal (port). See also British Preference, M. (Mr. Logan)
Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, qu., 263* Employees, qu., 2992 Expenditure to date, 1488 Facilities, 1472, 1473 Grain shipments through, 1489 Ocean tonnage, 2008 Revenue, 1465
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1183-1209, 1315-34
Montreal Gazette
Canadian National railways, 1923 King-Crerar alliance, 206 Montreal Harbour Commission, resignation, 1481
Montreal Harbour Commission, 1289, 1335. See also Quebec Harbour Commission Employees, 1289
Harbour master, Capt. Landry, 1481 Paint purchased, qu., 602 Policemen, qu., 2992 Resignation of commissioners, 1478-81 Tugboats, qu., 600


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxl

[Stage Direction]
Montreal Harbour Commission Advances bill Res., 1335, 1488; lr., 1489; 2r., com., 3r., 3199
Monty, Hon. Mr., and conscription. See Military Service Act Arndt, bill
Monuments. See also Battlefields; War Memorials
Historic sites, 119, qu.„ 469
New Brunswick, historic sites, qu., 469
Parliament hill, qu., 936
Moore, Mr. Tom, and immigration, 3053
Moosejaw public building improvements,
Morgan, J. P„ & Company, 1131, 1133
Morganatic Alliances. See Alliances
Morin, Mr. L. S. Rene (St. Hyacinthe-Rou-ville)
Canadian Northern railway, qu., 368 Wheat Board, 2926
Morphine. See Opium and Narcotic Drugs
M orrison, Mr. John (Weyburn)
Budget, 2699. Comparative prices of wheat and farm implements in Saskatchewan and North Dakota; shifting burden of taxation, 2699; exports of farm implements; competition in foreign markets; protection of industries; customs tariff inadequate to raise revenue, 2700; excise duty on manufactured goods; expense of running the Government; to much overhead, 2701; comparative development of Canada and the United states; freight rates and Crowsnest pass agreement, 2702; export rates on manufactured goods and agricultural products; prices of hides, wool, boots and shoes and clothing; exchange value of wheat and commodities, 2703
Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim for flax' shipment, 2836
Canada Temperance Act Arndt, bill, 3005 Crowsnest pass agreement, 2702
M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1425-6
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, M. (Mr. Woodsworth) 836 Sales tax collections, qu., 375 Saskatchewan liquor exports, 3005 Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 435
M-mrissy, Mr. John (Northumberland, N.B.) Harbours and rivers, New Brunswick, 1992 Provincial wharves, 1992
Mothers, Widowed, pensions to. See Pensions
Motherwell, Hon. W. R. (Minister of Agriculture)
Abattoir inspectors, 969 Accredited herds, 649, 999 Diseases, 969 Valuation, 1003
Adulteration of mill feeds, 1012 Agricultural Fertilizers bill, 1282, 3041, 3043, 3195
Agricultural Instruction Act, 1013 Agricultural lecturers, 1024 Agriculture department Deputy Minister's salary, 653 Employees, 651
Estimates, 644, 1718, 3504, 3520 Lynton, Mr. T. J., 588 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 645, 651, 1013 Officials, 654-5 Professional men, 589 Salary increases, 588, 657 Saunders, Dr., 590 Alderson claim, hog cholera, 1004 Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt.
bill, 2102, 2734-43, 2806 Bacon, production and marketing, 1025 Budget, 2548. Fulfilment of election pledges; Liberal platform of 1893, 2548; tariff pledge; British preference; reciprocity, defeat of, 1911; free trade, 2549; unrestricted reciprocity; cry of annexation; opposition of manufacturers to proposal, 2550; Canada's tragic mistake; protection; infant industries; protection for the farmer, 2551; not a protectionist budget; a substantial step in right direction; Liberal platform of 1919; revision of Progressive platform, 2552; excise duty on manufactured articles; revenue, 2553; free trade and revenue duties; motor cars; Mr. Crerar's pre-election statements; gradual reduction of tariff, 2554; elimination of protective feature; Regina speech; time inopportune for drastic action, 2555; Department of Agriculture; accredited herds; tuberculosis in cattle, 2556; cold storage; experimental farm system, 2557; staff; Civil Service Commission, 2559; patronage, 2560
Canada Temperance Act Amdt bill, 2998 Carvell, Hon. F. B., 2773, 2774, 2778-9 Cattle embargo, 970, 979, 1021 Cattle, free carriage of, 1029 Cold storage, 818, 998, 1024, 2557, 3521
Volume 1: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxii
[Stage Direction]
Motherwell, Hon. W. R.- Con
Criminal Code, cruelty to animals, 2834
Dairies, inspection of, 1006
Dairy produce, grading, 652, 656
Dairying industry, 982
Destructive Insect and Pest Act, 3520
Entomology
Botanical section, 816 Insect pests, 815 Exhibition grants, 649, 979 Experimental farms, 795, 799, 804, 812, 1014, 2557
Illustration farms, 3521 Fertilizers
Inspectors, 692
Manure, exportation of, 1021 Grasshoppers, 3520
Health of animals. See also under this title, Accredited Herds Contagious diseases, 967 Hog cholera, 1008 Compensation, 1028 Tuberculosis, 2556, 3521 Hogs, grading of, 1025 Hudson Bay railway, completion, 2784 International Institute of Agriculture, 969 Klim, competition with milk, 981 Liquor, export of, 2998 Live stock industry, 978
Feed shortage in western Canada, 1030 Grazing and feeding, 1719, 3522 National live stock records, 1027 Provincial governments, overlapping, 997 Stockyards, 1030 Wolves, destruction by, 998-999 Milk supply, inspection of herds, 2740 Mixed farming, 998 Oleomargarine, 654
Manufacture and importation, M. (Mr. Neill) 1804
Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3358, 342532, 3487
Pure bred sires, 1032 Railway Commission
Carvell, Hon. F. B., alleged statement in regard to, 2773, 2774, 2778-9 Root Vegetables, sale and inspection of, 1282, 2724, 3142, 3194, 3369, 3486 Rust investigations, 594 Saskatchewan liquor export, 2998 Saunders, Dr. C. E., gratuity to, 3522 Seed Grain Commission, 1011 Spruce bud moth, 595 Wheat Board, 377, 2940 Wheat Board bill, 3382 Wool industry, 997
Motor Cars, Theft of. See Criminal Code Amdt.
Motor Trucks for transportation, 134
Mounted Police. See Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Moving Pictures. See Trade and Commerce
Mowing Machines. See Agricultural Implements
Mulvey, Mr. Thomas, qu., 3363
Municipal Prison Farms, 1277. See also Prison Reform
Municipal Taxation, payment of by Government, 1256	.
Municipalities
Unemployment relief, 1069
Munitions. See Guthrie; King, Mackenzie, Militia and Defence; War
Munro, Mr. E. A. (Fraser Valley)
Oleomargarine, manufacture, etc., M. (Mr. Neill) 1793
Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1537
Murdock, Hon. James (Minister of Labour) Building trades, 583
Canmore and Drumheller coal miners' dispute, 1058
Civil Service, report of Hon. Mr. Robertson, 554
Conciliation and Labour Act, 1054
Cost of living, 1058
Employment offices, 1058
Gordon, Sir Charles, 584
Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1058
International Labour Conference, 1060
Joint industrial councils, 1060
Labour department
Classification of employees, 494, 575 Director of technical education, 578 Economy and work, 465 Estimates, 1970, 3526 Outside employees, 493, 494 Permanent and temporary employees, 460-1
Staff and salaries, 458-9, 562, 575 Statistical work, 580 Wage investigators, 462 Labour Gazette, 1058 Militia and Defence
Cadet services, M. to reduce item by $100,000, 1972
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxiii
Murdock, Hon. James-Con
Militia and Defence - Con.
Clothing and necessaries, M. to reduce item by $21,000, 1978 Engineer services and work, M. to reduce item by $50,000, 1980 Ordnance arms, lands, etc., M. to reduce item by $9,000, 1982
Pay of staff, M. to reduce item by $10,000, 1982
Nova Scotia miners, 46, 1054 Labour department officer, 585 M. (Mr. Irvine) 505 Printing Bureau, 1970 Rail and car repair contracts, 1696, 1701 Unemployment relief, 1074, 1719, 2022, 3526 Policy of government, inquiry, 3491 Rail and car repair contracts, 1696 Whitley councils, 1061
Winnipeg strike, correspondence with Mr. Andrews, 2042
Murphy, Hon. Charles (Postmaster General) Belley, Mr. Alfred, salary, 3504 Militia expenditure and policy, 1582 National Defence bill, 677 Post Office department Employees Bonus, 2801
Salaries, 691, 2801, 3504 Estimates, 1711, 2799 Inspectorates, reorganization, 1507 Outside service, 2799 Railway mail service, 2800 Reorganization, 2800 Rural mail delivery contracts, 2800, 2801 Subletting, 2802 Yukon, parcel post, 2802
Murray Bay-Tadoussac service, 3035
Musk Ox in northern Canada, 2785
Mutton, imported, qu., 610	.
Mutual Insurance. See Insurance
Nanaimo, B.C Post office revenue, qu., 2040
Nanton, Sir Augustus, 1128
Narcotic Drugs. See also Opium and Narcotic 'Drugs
Correspondence with wholesale druggists, 1289
Nassau Dam, qu., 2457
National Battlefields Commission. See Battlefields Commission
National Debt. See Public Debt
National Defence. See also National Defence bills
Department of
Ashton, Major General, 661 Burstall, Major General Sir Henry, 661, 742
Canadian air force and civil aviation, 1722
Currie, Sir Arthur, 659, 743 Elmsley, Major General, 661 Gwatkin, Major General, 742 MacBrien, Major General, 661, 742 Morrison, Sir Edward, 661 Naval students in armories, physical drill, 1741
Services, co-ordination, 91, 97, 1747
National Defence, Department of, bills respecting
1.	No. 15. lr., 363-4; order for 2r., discharged, 547-8
2.	No. 27. Res., 644, 657; lr., 2r., com., 681;
com., 733; 3r., 787; Senate amdts., 2806 Sections and subjects discussed:
Air Service, 658, 677 Amalgamation of services, 658 Appointment of officer to exercise powers of deputy, 737 Controller, 741 Defence Council, 746 Deputy Minister, 737 Desbarats, Mr. J. B., 737 Federal laws, enforcement of. 680 Holder of position abolished may be appointed to another, 741 Militia, 658 Naval Service, 658 Officers, retirement of, 661, 742 Officials, 736 Orders in Council, 661 Powers of Minister and deputy, 746 Regulations, 746
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 658 Secret service, 670-9 Services included, 733
National Gallery, 2011
National Industrial Conference, unemployment insurance, qu., 1375
National Livestock Records, 1026
National Parks. See Dominion Lands and Parks
National Railways. See Canadian National Railways
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

cxiv


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxv

[Stage Direction]
Navigation. See also Marine Aids to, 1498 Detroit river, 1498 Life-saving equipment, qu., 1284 Rainy river lights, 1499 St. Lawrence river waterway, M. (Mr. Church) 1183 Schools of, 1492
Navy. See Canadian Government Merchant Marine; National Defence; Naval Service; Royal Canadian Navy
Neill, Mr. Alan W. (Comox-Alberni) Address in reply, 169. Congratulations to preceding speakers; Miss Macphail, 169; comparison of parties; British Columbia and protection, 170; Mr. Crerar, 170-171; Orientals in British Columbia, 171; personal position and platform, 172-3; unemployment; wider markets, 174; railway rates, 175; the tariff; free trade and protection, 176; Chinese eggs, 177; butter and oleomargarine, 177-8; coal mines in Vancouver Island; fuel oil importations, 178; Hon. Mr. Stevens and Mr. Clements; vote in Cumberland district, 179; railways and government ownership, 180; necessaries and luxuries, 182; immigration, 182-3; Asiatics, competition with; soldier settlement, 183; inheritance tax; eight hour day; old age pensions; removal of Dominion Elections Act from statutes, 184 British Columbia
Coastal services, qu., 3152 Fisheries, cost and revenue, 2306 Fisheries, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 860 Post offices, qu., 824 Public buildings, 1258 British Columbia house, London, purchase of, 3537
Budget, 2307. Free trade and protection: a question of geography, 2307; the tariff, a compromise; economic position of British Columbia; support of government during session; expenditures in Vancouver and Victoria; rural constituencies neglected, 2309; political arguments for Conservative members; fruit industry and dumping clause; Oriental aliens; exclusion of, 2310; acquisition of British Columbia timber areas by Japanese; immediate action demanded; the workingman and the
Neill, Mr. Alan W. - Con.
Budget - Con.
eight hour day; lumber industry and freight rates, 2311; protection of coal mining industry against fuel oil; importation of coal from Japan; fishing industry; reduction in gasoline practically no benefit to fishermen; dairy industry; fruit industry; dumping clause; industries of Comox-Alberni, 2313; country districts suffering injustice; views of constituents, 2314 Canadian Freighter, Japanese coal imports, qu., 963
Civil Service reform, 3100 Courtney post office building, 1258 Criminal Code, carriage of calves under three weeks' old, 2831 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1438 Debates, official report, insertion of documents not read, 1540 Debeaux, Mr. Robert, claim of, 2306 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 2811 Election day a public holiday, 2812 Enfranchisement of foreign-born women M. (Mr. Euler) 485
Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Company bill, 1354, 1439, 1602-6 Amdt. 1156, neg., 1163 Fisheries Act, 1914, Amdt. bill, 3012 Fuel oil, British Columbia, qu., 728, 2312 Gasoline for fishing boats, 2313, 3116 House of Commons, accoustics, 3544 Immigration Methods, 3057
South-eastern Europe, from, 3057 Immigration Act Amdt. bill (Intending immigrants to make application) 2207 Indians, medical attention, 1219 International Labour Conference, qu., 824 Japanese in British Columbia, 2310. See also under this title, Oriental Aliens Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 521 Oleomargarine, Manufacture and importation, M„ 1777, 1836
Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 3016
Oriental Aliens
Japanese, acquisition of timber areas in British Columbia, 3210 M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion of, 1539 Paper mills, 3113 Pensions Com., final report, 3332 Point of order
Rule 18, tedious repetition, 1360 Rule 19, offensive words, 1361
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
Hi
cxvi

Neill, Mr. Alan W. - Con.
Quebec Harbour Commission bill, fair wage clause, 1469
Soldier Settlement Act Arndt., 3407 Special War Revenue Act Sales tax, 3269 Stumping powder, 3268 Statistics, co-ordination of, 581
Neill, Mr. C. E., 1128
Nelson post office revenue, qu., 2040
Neutrals and Non-Combatants. See Limitation of Armaments
New Brunswick
Floods, 3492
Harbours and rivers, 1991 Arndt. (Mr. Guthrie) to reduce vote, 1998 Immigration and, 2165 Public buildings, 1239 St. John and Quebec railway, 1293, qu., 1774
Salmon rivers, fishways, 2167 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment staff, 1344 Wharves Provincial, 1991 Tidal waters in, qu., 2209 Transfer of, qu., 2305
New London, Conn., seaport, 2611
New York Central Railway, 128
New Zealand
Butter. See Oleomargarine Government ownership of railways, 181
Newfoundland
Canada-Newfoundland steamship service, 2027
Navigation, aids to, 1498 Reid-Newfoundland railway, 2027 Trade between Prince Edward Island and, 226
Newfoundland-Labrador Boundary
Reference to Privy Council, 1276 Doherty, Hon. C. J. reported engagement of, 2572	[DOT]
White, Mr. James, technical adviser, 3495
Newmarket, speech of Prime Minister at, 34-35
Newspapers
Censors, 1069
English, comment on Grand Trunk arbitration, 374, 821
Extracts. See Speaker, Rulings
Niagara Power Development, 134. See also Electrification; St. Lawrence river waterway
Nickel. See also Coinage
Nickel Coin Blanks, qu., 3152
Nickel Currency. See Currency Act Amdt.
Niobe and Rainbow, 1736. See also Naval Service
Non-Taxable Bonds. See Bonds; Finance
Norman Dam. See Lake of the Woods
Normand, Hon. Dr., references to. See Military Service Act Amdt.
Norris, Hon. T. C., Premier of Manitoba Natural resources, 1017
And freight rates, reported statement on, 1213
North Sydney quarantine station, 1238, 2021
Northern Islands and Waters
Patrol. See Naval Service Policy respecting, 1750
Northwest Rebellion
Royal Canadian Mounted Police, pensions. See Pensions-
Smith, Mr. Leo, pension to, 3523 Notices of Cancellation. See Dominion Lands Nova Scotia
Admiralty, local Judge in, 1275 Air station at Dartmouth, 1724 Coal industry, protection of, 2412 Coal strike, 461. See also Nova Scotia Miners
Harbours and rivers, estimates, 1269, 1765 International deep sea racing. See that title
Liberal party in, 2606
Migratory birds, resolution of legislature, 1684
Pensioners in, qu., 615 Public buildings, 1238 Shipbuilding, 1387 Supreme Court, vacancy, 3436 Unemployment, 1075-6
Nova Scotia Miners, qu., 605, 1054. See also Labour Inquiry, 597
McLaehlan correspondence, qu., 704 M. (Mr. Irvine) 497, 539, 545


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxvii
Noxious Gases and Chemicals, use of. See
Limitation of Armaments
Observatory. See Dominion Observatory Occupational Diseases. See Labour Ocean
Ports, 1464-86 Tonnage, 2008 Vessels
Quebec, 1471
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1183-95, 1205
Ocean and River Service. See Marine
O'Connor, Mr. James, Snowflake, Man., dismissal, 1674
O'Connor, Mr. W. F., K.C.
Payments to, qu., 2037 Revision of statutes, 1718
Official Report of Debates. See House of Commons
O'Hara, Captain, 1490
Oil. See also Natural Resources
Duty on oil drilling machinery, 2726 Fuel Oil, 344, qu., 728
Competition with coal mining industry, 2312
Importations, 178
Tank at Louise basin, 1484	'
Tariff against, 1761 Leases, speculation in, 1046 Mackenzie and Peace river, cost of surveys, 1044
Okanagan Valley, fruit growing, 163. See also Budget; Customs, Dumping clause; Fruit
Old Age Pensions, 184, 1070, qu., 1375. See also Pensions
And mothers' pensions, qu., 1375 M. (Mr. Fontaine) 1303-5
Oleomargarine, 2205. See also Agriculture; Butter; Dairying
British Columbia Dairymen's Association, res., 1794
Children fed on, 178 Competition with butter, 177 Further legislation, inquiry, 3041 Great War Veterans' Association, 1798 Importation and Manufacture, qu., 613, qu., 1506
Discontinuance of, M. (Mr. Neill) 1720, 1776, neg., 1840
Oleomargarine - Con.
Local Council of Women, Hamilton, 1835 Materials, importation of, qu., 704, qu., 727, 3270
National Dairy Council, and, 1791 Regulations under Act, qu., 1702 Retail Merchants' Association and, 1797
Oleomargarine Act, 1919, Arndt, bill (Extension for one year)
Res., 3358, 3425; lr., 3435; 2r., 3487; com., 3489; 3r., 3489
Oliver, Hon. John, Premier of British Columbia, criticism of by Vancouver Sun,, 2236, 2237
One-Fourth Vote. See Interim Supply
Onion Grades, 2744. See also Root Vegetables
Onta rio
Alienation of natural resources, qu., 2992 Canals, 2779. See also that title Flags on public schools, 1265 Harbours and rivers, 1999
Lis,one batue sites, 119-120 Hydro Electric Power Commission. See that title
Public buildings, 1245 Appropriations not required, 1259 Improvements, repairs, etc., 1258 Rural population, loss of, 301. See also Budget; Population Taxation of, 131
Water powers. See Lake of the Woods
Ontario Athletic Commission, cadet camps,
Ontario Temperance Act. See Canada Temperance Act
Opium and Narcotic Drugs. See also Health Chinese, 2018 Cocaine, 2019
Correspondence with wholesale druggists, 1377
Enforcement of Act Prosecutions, 2017 Japanese, 2017
International Opium Convention, qu., 1066 Morphine, 2019
Oriental traffic in, 1529, 2017. See also Oriental Aliens
Production and export of, 2019 Prohibition and, 2017 Smuggling, 2020
Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Arndt, bill Res., 1841, 2823; lr., 2826; 2r., com., 3013; 3r., 3025; Senate amdts., 3607
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxviii

Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. - Con..
Sections and subjects discussed: Appeal, restriction of right, 3020 Dealing in drugs, 3013 Deportation, 3013, 3024 Penalties, 3013, 3014, 3020 Whipping, 3015
Opposition. See also Progressive Party Attitude of, 60-61. See also Speeches on Budget
Position of. See Interim Supply Representation in Parliament, 40 Status of leader of, 73
Orchards, protection of. See Entomology; Fruit Industry
Orders in Council, qu., 935
Canadian National railways, management, 192
Government by, 38, 141, 660, 662, 2518, 2536, 2562, 2880
Intercolonial railway operation, 107 Number passed, qu., 934, qu., 935
Ordnance Lands, local improvements fronting, 1681
Orient, trade with, 85. See also Trade
Oriental Aliens, 967
Australian legislation, 1536 Birth rate, 317
British Columbia in, 167, 171, 316, 332, 855 Resolution of legislature, 1513 Restrictive legislation, 1510 Canadians, disabilities in Japan, 1511, 2208 Chinese, 1510, 2026 3437	.
Arrival of at Vancouver, 3604 Opium and Narcotic drugs, 2020 Coal mined by, 2407 Coolie labour on British ships, 2042 Demands for exclusion of, 1513 Education, cost of, 317 Fisheries, engaged in, 345, 855 Franchise and, 483, 485 Fruit growing and, 1535. See also Fruit Industry
Gentlemen's agreement, 1511 Immigration, 319, 2161. See also that title Chinese. See also under this title, Chinese Restriction of, M. (Mr. Stevens) 1776 Inquiry for opportunity to discuss, 967, 1461, 3104 Japanese
Restriction of, M. (Mr. Stevens) 1776
Oriental Aliens - Con.
Rights of Canadians in Japan, 1511, 2208
Minister's statement, 2143 Money qualification, 2148 Written application by intending im migrants, 2207 Japan, treaty with, 1511 Japanese, qu., 1399, qu., 1459, 1510
Acquisition of timber limits in British Columbia, 2310
Competition in British Columbia, 2279 Lemieux agreement, 1459 Opium and Narcotic drugs, 2017. See also that title
Labour, competition with, 317 Land occupation by, 1534 Number in Canada, 1512 Motion (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion of, 1509
Amdt. (Mr. Stewart, Argenteull) for " effective restriction ", 1567; agreed to, 1577
Canada's right to legislate, 1550 " Effective restriction ", 1567
Opium and Narcotic drug traffic, 1529, 2017
Osier, Sir Edmund, 1128
Ottawa
Cartier square Militia dept., shed, qu., 2038 Daly building, purchase of, 1252 Daylight saving, 1282
Dominion observatory and geodetic survey building, 1265
Local improvements fronting ordnance lands, 1681
New departmental buildings, 3541 Noon gun, 1756
Ottawa Gas Company bill. See Private Bills Discussed
Ottawa-Kingston highway, qu., 1904 Parliament buildings, 2014. See also that title
Proposed donation of Rideau canal to, 2764 Public buildings, 1245, 1252, 1265, 1755 Char service, 1756 Elevator attendants, 1266 Lighting, including roads and bridges, 1267
Rental of buildings in, 1252, 1764 Rideau hall, maintenance, 1756 Telephone service, 1757 Water, 1266	.
Ouimet, Mr. Joseph Rodolphe (Vaudieuil-Soulanges)
Introduction of, 323


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxlx

[Stage Direction]
Outside Service. See Civil Service
Overages. See Grain and Grain Trade; Elevators
Pacific and Great Eastern Railway, 342
Pacific Naval Powers. See Limitation of Armaments
Pairs. See House of Commons, Divisions
Palais Station, Quebec, 1068
Palestine, mandate over, 1716
Panama Canal, 191, 1326-9. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway
Panet, Mr. L. C., appointment as Deputy Sergeant-at-Arms, 5
Paper Control Inquiry, 1673
Paper tor magazines, taxation, 3108
Parc St. Charles, 1469, 3197. See also Quebec Harbour Commission
Parent, Mr. George (Quebec West) Appraisers, Paris and London, 1068 Civil Service examinations, 871 Insurance premiums, 3253 Labour dept., organized and unorganized labour, qu., 2303
Military Service Act Arndt, bill, 641 Naturalization expenses, 1671 Quebec bridge, 1068 Quebec riots, qu., 1508 Royal Canadian Artillery, qu., 370
Parents, support of by children, 1310. See also Pensions; Widowed Mothers
Paris Agency, 2025	,
Parks. See Dominion Lands and Parks
Parliament
Fall session, 3608 Opening of, 1 Prorogation of, 3616
Representation of provinces in 1877, qu„ 1183
Parliament Buildings
Architects' fees, 2014 Cost to date, 2014 Estimates, 2014 Furniture, purchase of, 1757 House of Commons Chamber, accoustics, 1751, 1755, 1996, 3613. See also that title Lighting, 1755 Tower, 2016
Parliament Hill monuments, qu., 936
Parliamentary Counsel, 2572
Parliamentary Guide, 2024
Parliamentary Procedure. See Deputy Speaker; House of Commons; Speaker
Parliamentary Restaurant
Com. appointed, 326 Loss in, 184
Parry Sound
Lighthouse inspector, qu., 827 Postal receipts, qu., 938
Parsons, Mr. W. Reuben, qu., 3362
Party Representation, 214
Party System of Government, 2339. See also Address; Budget
Party System of Politics, 117-118, 214, 215. See also Address; Budget
Passenger Rates. See Railway Act Amdt. bills
Passport Office, 2066
Patent Record, 2026
Paternalism. See Pensions Committee
Patricia, warship, qu., 827. See also Naval Service
Patriot, warship, qu., 827. See also Naval Service
Patriotic Fund. See Canadian Patriotic Fund
Patronage, 2608. See also Budget; Civil Service; Speeches on Address Appointments to penitentiary, 1277 Census enumerators, appointment of, 1368, 1372
Civil service, 1663 Civil Service Commission, 2559, 2563 Intercolonial railway and, 106 Quebec Harbour Commission, 1477
Peace River block, 330
Peace Treaties. See Limitation of Armaments; Treaties
Pears, Vice Admiral Sir Edmund, 2061
Pearson, Mr. John A., Architect. See Parliament Buildings
Pearson Institute, Toronto, 3457
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxi
Pensions -Con.
Widowed mothers, 1312, 3324 M. (Mr. Power) 1305. 1313 Widows, 1070 Wrenick, Mrs., 3457
Pensions, Insurance and Re-establishment
of Returned Soldiers Special Committee appointed, 496-7 Change in names, 596 First report, 726 Final report, 3286
M. (Mr. Marler) for adoption, 3286 Arndt. (Mr. Shaw) to refer back, 3308; Withdrawn, 3349 Recommendations, expenditure under, 3522
Pilotage
Administration of, 1499 Dues, exemption from, 1500. See also Canada Shipping Act Amdt. bill Fees to pilots and regulation of, 1499
Pleuro-Pneumonia. See Cattle Embargo; Health of Animals
Ploughs, duty on. See Agricultural Implements
Pocket-Knives, Competition, 2646, 2876. See Budget; Currency, depreciated; Customs Act; Germany
Police Commissioners, bribing of. See Criminal Code
Political Alliances, "Morganatic", 2095. See also Nationalists; Progressive Party
Political Contributions, by Monopolies, 2295. See also Election of 1921
Political Patronage. See Patronage
Polls. See Dominion Elections Act Amdt.
Pollution of Streams, 2168
Pool Selling. See Criminal Code Amdt. bill
Population. See also Budget; Census; Immigration By ages, qu., 1632
' Drift towards the cities, 2153, 2302
Increase under Eiberal and Conservative govts., 2362, 2365 Loss of, 2439-40, 2449
Rural. See under this title, Rural Ten years, in, 2516 Need of Increased, 2148-58, 2275
Population - Con.
Oriental In Canada, 1512. See also Oriental Aliens
Rural, 2564-5
Decline in, 2153, 2156, 2158, 2384, 2439-40, 2449, 2683
Loss in Ontario, 2369, 2683 Movement to cities and towns, 2153, 2302, 2403
Urban, and, qu., 376 Infant mortality and, 2634 Slow growth of, 2158 Yukon territory, 1681
Pork Imports, qu., 611
Port Arthur
Canadian Towing and Wrecking Co. claim, 1677
Port Dalhousie, 1493 Port Hood breakwater, 1768 Port Nelson, dredging, 2006
Portage La Prairie
Assiniboine river floods, 1842, 2004 Exhibition grant, qu., 1931 Post office revenue, qu., 2040
Porter, Mr. E. G. (East Hastings)
Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3457 Trenton harbour bill, 3494 Wrenick, Mrs., pension, 3457
Portland Terminus, 2611 Competition with Canadian ports, 104, 2611. See also Grand Trunk Railway; British Preference, M. (Mr. Logan)
Ports, United States in preference to Canadian, 353-4
Postal Conference, 7, 15
Postmasters. See Civil Service; Post Office
Post Office
Department Appointments, 3073 Belley, Mr. Alfred, salary, 3504 Classification, 3089
Employees receiving salary of $600, qu., 1067
Estimates, 1711
Gaboury, Mr. L. J., salary and duties, qu., 3599
General superintendent of postal service, 1711
Married women employees, qu., 1658
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxii

Post Office - Con.
Department - Con.
Money Order branch, qu., 1285 Outside service, estimates, 2799 Postal employees, 3076 Printing and stationery, 1741 Salaries and contingencies, 69, 3504 Drop letter rate, 1250
Better rate, Canada-Oreat Britain, qu., 3364 Mail, carriage of, qu., 825 Mail contracts
Canadian National railways, qu., 2038 Canadian Pacific railway, and, qu., 2040, qu., 2213
Gascons-Quebec, qu., 2213 Grand Anse, qu., 938 Lachenaie, qu., 2805 Richmond and Wolfe, qu., 1505 Rigaud-St. Redempteur, 1776 Sudbury, qu., 1285 Money orders tax, 2857 Montreal
Employees, 1288
Gaboury, Mr. B. J., salary, qu., 3599 Post offices and business done, qu., 1065 Postal receipts, qu., 938 Postmasters
B'Assomption-Montcalm, 1775 Sturgeon falls, qu., 1285 Post offices in British Columbia, qu., 824 Railway mail service, 2797 Reorganization, 2799 Revenue, qu., 2040
Richmond and Wolfe post offices, qu., 1507 Ruling respecting newspaper or magazine subscription, qu., 3599 Rural mail routes, qu., 3152 Savings banks, reduction in interest rate, qu.; 1932
Sherbrooke inspectorate, qu., 1507 Subsidized steamships and carriage of mails, 2028
Toronto, revenue, qu., 368, 1250 Potatoes
Conference of growers, 3367 Cost of growing, 2665 Duty on, 239, 2601 Grading machines, 3126 Market for, 225
Marking and grading. See Root Vegetables Prices of, 94 Shipment to Cuba, 2028 Shipping . cost. See St. John Terminal Facilities
Trade with United States, 336. See also Budget
Potlatch Institution. See Indians
Poultry Industry, 226, 807
Power, Mr. C. G. (Quebec South)
Admiralty Court, vacancy at Quebec, 1275 Cash grants to soldiers, 394 Fishing schooner race, 3510 Maclnnes, Mr. Hector, K.C. (Halifax) pay ments to, 2772 Militia
Annual drill, amdt. to reduce vote bi $1,100,000, 1173, 1174, neg., 1631 Engineer services and works, 1980 Expenditure and policy, annual training, 1611
Pension Act Amdt. bill, 3402, 3443 Pensions
Mothers of deceased soldiers, M., 1313 Widowed mothers, M., 1305, 1312 Point of order - not permissible to read evidence to controvert member, 3540 References to, 1339
Returned Soldiers' Insurance bill, 3396 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, salary
increases, 398
Power Development. See Electrification; Hydro Electric; St. Bawrence River
Waterway
Prairie Provinces
"Annexation of", 1020 Forestry in, 1046
Natural resources. See Western Provinces Pratt vs. Delphine, 302
Preference, trade. See British Preference; Trade; United States
Premiums, Insurance tax on. See Special War Revenue
Prescriptions, refilled. See Opium and Narcotics
Preservation of Industries Act, 2648
President Harding, St. Bawrence river waterway, 1326
Press. See also Canadian Press; Newspapers Censors, 1068
Preston, Mr. W. T. R., rent of house in Bondon, 3503
Prevost, Mr. Jules E. (Terrebonne) Bertrand, Mr. T., qu., 937 Budget, 2577. Tribute to Finance Minister, his difficulties and responsibilities; the


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxiii
Prevost, Mr. Jules E. - Con.
Budget - Con.
tariff, 2577; proposals in harmony with Liberal policy; new taxes; inheritance of debts from former governments; effort to lower cost of living; economy, 2578; national debt; militia or naval expenditure; expansion of external trade; decrease in exports; restoration of normal conditions, 2579; Canadian market insufficient for natural products and manufactured goods; trade with Great Britain and the United States; Fordney tariff; transportation; interior systems of communication, 2580; direct intercourse with foreign countries; duty of the department of Trade and Commerce; consuls and trade agents; information; trade commissioners; qualifications, 2581, fairs and exhibitions; serious problems; the future; new political groups; development of Canadian national spirit, 2582
Civil Service Commission report, qu., 826
. Dominion Elections Act, residential qualification, 1298
Imports and exports, 1911-1922, qu., 1661
Militia and Defence Annual drill
Expenditure 1911-21, qu., 1287 Armouries in Quebec, qu., 1287 Expenditure 1911-22, qu., 1287
Stationery, purchase of by Government, 1288
Pribyloff Islands, protection of fur seals, 1844
Prices. See also Budget; Coat of Living; Finance; Trade
Price-fixing combinations, 2428, 2437
Regulations of, 2504
Prime Minister's Bereavement, reference to death of brother. See King
Prime Ministers' Conference, 42. See also Naval Service
Anglo-Japanese Treaty, 168
Correspondence, 1068
Empire naval defence, 1629, 1883, 2082 Canada's contribution, 1742 Resolution respecting, 1742
Opportunity for discussion of, 2042
Report, 5 Tabled, 8
Royal Canadian Navy. See Naval Service
Prince County, illegal fishing, qu., 371
Prince Edward Island
Harbours and rivers, 1270, 1988 Migratory birds, resolution of legislature, 1684
Natural resources, 339 Potato-growing, 225, 337 Public lands, 229
Railway, 229, 337, 1249. See also Canadian National Railways
Prince of Wales Leinster regiment, qu., 1065 Prince Rupert
Alien property, custodians of, 3601 Post office building, 1257 Post office revenue, qu., 2040 Prince Rupert Dry Dock & Engineering Co., 3514
Rental of buildings, 1257 Vessels constructed at, qu., 606
Princess Mary, marriage of, 39
Printers, immigration of, 3055
Printing. See also Printing Bureau; Publications
Canadian National menus, qu., 1931 Customs and excise, 1674 Joint Committee on, 211, 326, 1132 Public archives, 1673
Printing Bureau
Government printing, 1373 Government publications, distribution of, 1971
Legislation, 1972 Plant New, 1970
Repairs and renewals, 1970 Statutes, 1972
Supreme Court reports, 1274
Printing and Stationery
Criminal Code, 1717 Interior, 1680
Post Office department, 1711 Statutes, 1717
Prison Reform, 1277-8; qu., 1773, 2397 Atlanta penitentiary, 1278 Dorchester penitentiary, 1278 Inspection by grand juries, qu., 1773, 2397 Jail farms, 1277-9; qu., 1773 Youthful offenders, qu., 1773
Prisoners, Contagious diseases of. See Penitentiary Act Amdt. bill
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxiv

Pritchard, Mr. John (North Wellington) Address in reply, 250. Congratulations, etc., parliamentary groups and class representation, 250; manufacturers and the tariff, 251; agricultural conditions, 252
Experimental farms, 806, 810
Private Bills, Committee, 374 Bouchard, Mr., substitution for Mr. Stein,
Vien, Mr. substitution for Mr. Ouimet, 2355
Private Bills Discussed
Canadian Pacific Railway Company Arndt. (Mr. Carmichael) 1606, 1856 Canadian Transit Company, 1746, 1770 Dominion Chain Company, Limited, 3490, 3495
Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Co., 1353, 1439
Arndts. (Mr. Neill) 1156, neg. 1163; 1354, neg. 1357; 1602, neg. 1606 Eraser Valley and Southern Railway Company, 1577
Montreal, Joliette and Transcontinental Railway Company, 1577 Niagara River Bridge Company, 1486 Ottawa Gas Company, refund of fees, 1657
Private Bills Undiscussed. See Journals of the House
Private Secretaries. See Privy Council
Privilege, questions of. See House of Commons
Privy Council
Appeals, 139
Salaries and contingencies, 410
Proclamation. See Canada Temperance Act
Progressive Party, 295. See also Address; Budget; Canadian Council of Agriculture; Crerar; United Grain Growers; Wheat Board Alleged split, denial, 2458 Alliances of, 2095-7
Attitude towards Government, 2233, 2507, 2842
Big interests and, 2393-4 Budget debate and, 2692 Canadian Pacific, and, 130 Class legislation and, 224. See also Address; Budget
Liberal negotiations with, 34, 48, 51, 240-1 Oleomargarine, attitude on, 2380. See also that title
Progressive Party - Con.
Ontario in, 2301, 2893-4	i
Origin of, 2512 Platform, revision, 2552 Redistribution, attitude towards, 1364-70
Prohibition. See also Canada Temperance Act; Liquor
Opium and Narcotic drugs, 2017
Property, alien enemy. See Aliens
Proportional Representation, 59. See also Dominion Elections
M. (Mr. Good) for adoption of alternative!
vote method, 1633 Residential qualification, 1301
Prorogation of Parliament, 3616
Proscription. See Criminal Code (Scrip frauds)
Protection, 143,	228. See also Address;
Budget
Boots and shoes, 102
Manufacturers and, 2435-40. See also Budget
Policy of, 1088
Tariff and, 170, 2110. See also Tariff
Protocols. See League of Nations
Provinces. See also Natural Resources. For individual provinces, See their titles Air Force and civil aviation, 1722 Unemployment relief, 1069 Western. See that title
Provincial Rights, infringement. See Lake of the Woods bill
Ptomaine Poisoning. See Meat and Canned
Foods
Public Accounts. See also Consolidated Revenue and Audit Act Committe, report, 1460, 3359 Date of closing, 1264-66 Non-productive assets, 1467
Public Archives
Estimates, 702, 1673, 2025 Monckton papers, purchase of, 1673
Public Buildings, 1755. See also their respective titles; Public Works; Supply Alberta. 3545
Appropriations and expenditures for 1921 -22. 1259-60 Chambers, Mr., 1244 Char service. See Ottawa


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II; 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxxv

[Stage Direction]
Public Buildings - Con.
Coal, importation of, 1759 Estimates, 1238, 1258, 1755 Expenditure, accounts not closed, 1262-66 Fittings, supplies and furniture, 1757 Flags, qu., 599, 1264 Generally, 1260-5 Heating, 1755-1758 Immigration, repairs, 1757 Maritime provinces generally, 1243 New, 1255, 2461 New Brunswick, 1239 New departmental designs, 3541 Nova Scotia, 1238 Ontario, 1245-59, 1258, 3544 Alleged neglect of, 1248 Ottawa, 1245-52, 1265, 1755. See also that title
Parliament buildings. See that title Penitentiaries, 1277 Quebec, 1245
Rental and purchase of, 1764 Calgary, 1254 Ottawa, 1252 Prince Rupert, 1257 Waterbury, Mr., retirement of, 1244
Public Debt, 2106, 2225, 2370, 2496, 2501, 2895. See also Address; Budget; Finance; Loans
Taxation and, 2459
Public Expenditure, 1249, 2276, 2860
Capital expenditure on harbours and rivers, 1472
Comparison by departments, 1137 Debt, and, 2557
Dominion and provincial overlapping, 2461 Economy in, 1475. See also Address; Budget
In 1877 and 1922, qu., 1211 Income and, 2104
Reduction of. See Address; Budget; Militia and Defence; Naval Service
Public Harbours. See Harbours
Public Health. See Health
Public Lands. See Dominion Lands and Parks; Natural Resources
Public Ownership. See Address; Budget; Canadian National Railways; Railways; St. Lawrence River Waterway
Public Service Retirement Act Arndt, bill (Extension for one year)
Res. 1661, 3025; lr., 2r., com., 3025; com., 3148; 3r„ 3149
Public Services, nationalization of, 2324, 2328. See also Address; Budget; Canadian National Railways
Public Works. See also Public Buildings; Supply
Bridges. See that title
Dauphinee, Mr. Charles, dismissal of, ques., 1902, 2458, 2584 Department
Carty, Captain, 1062 Chief Architects' Branch, qu., 963 Estimates, 1238, 1755, 1988, 3531 Estimates branch, 1270 Expenditures, 1249
Minister, selection of from British Columbia Government, 2238 Salaries, etc., 692, 747
M. (Mr. Boys) reduce item, 695, 699 Harbours and rivers. See that title Miscellaneous, 2008 New public buildings, 1256 Quarantine stations, 1238-45 Public buildings. See that title Roads and bridges, 2007 Burlington, 2007 Edmonton, 2007
Telegraphs and telephones, 2007, 2012
Unemployment relief, 1082
Yukon territory, expenditure in, 1275
Publications, Government. See also Editorial Committee
Co-ordination and economy, 1374 Demand and distribution, 1344, 1971 Geological survey, 1237 Mines, 1234-6
Printing and translation, 1373. See also Printing Bureau Printing, unnecessary, 1374
Publicity Agent. See Labour
Pulp and Paper Industry, 2322. See also Natural Resources; Paper Control British Columbia in, 175 Export duty on pulpwood, 2667
Purchasing Commission, 2674 Coal, for public buildings, 1758 Estimates, 2025
Goods purchased, origin of, 2042 Suggested abolition of, 2674 Warlike stores, sale of, 1173
Purchasing Power of Money, 1151-3, 1175, 1177, 1292, 2331, 2603. See also Address; Budget; Civil Service; Cost of Living; Money
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxvi

Putman, Mr., C. V., qu., 935
Putnam, Mr. Harold (Colchester)
Address in reply, 309. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker, 309; Progressives and the party spirit, 310; leader of the Opposition; immigration; tariff; railway problems, 311; Intercolonial railway, 312; elections and campaign literature, 315
Budget, 2282. Election issues and results; congratulations to Finance Minister; tariff reductions; no time for drastic changes; Liberal platform of 1919, 2283; interprovincial trade; geographical, physical and climatic difficulties, 2284; reciprocity with the United States, 2285; tariff reductions, 2286; trade with Germany; sales tax; the amendment, 2287; political pledges and promises, 2288; Liberal platform of 1919; record of the Opposition party, 2288; Union government; public honour; War Time Elections Act; tariff commission; intercolonial railway; promise of Mr. McCurdy to restore headquarters to Moncton, 2289; the Progressives, 2290
Canadian National railways, ties, qu., 934 Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3478 Civil Service, returned soldiers, 3088 Condensed milk, tax on, 3265 Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3425-34 Rural postmasters, 3080
Quadruple Pacific Treaty, 3160
Qualification of Voters. See Dominion Elections Act
Quarantine. See also Health; Immigration Detention at Partridge Island, 2021 Estimates, 2021
Immigrant refusing vaccination, 2022 Stations
Grosse Isle, repairs, 1245 Halifax, repairs, 1238 North Sydney, repairs, 1238 St. John, repairs, 1239-40 William's Head, improvements, 1255
Quebec (City)
Admiralty, local judge in, 1275 Arsenal, 1979, 2085, 2091 Customs dues, 1978
Canadian National railway terminals, 1475 Champlain market station, 1475, 2399 Newspapers, political policies of, 1480
Quebec (City)-Con.
Palais station, 1068 Plains of Abraham, 1467 Riots, 676, 3089
Compensation for damage, qu., 1508
Quebec (Port). See also Quebec Harbour Commission bill Appropriations for, 1486 Borden, Right Hon. Sir Robert and, 1474 Elevators, 1471, 1483 Grain shipments through, 1466, 1471 Harbour Commission, 1283, 1464. See also Quebec Harbour Commission bill Ocean tonnage, 2008
Parc St. Charles Co. Ltd., proposed payment to, 1469 Political patronage, 1478 Revenue and expenditure, 1471
Quebec (Province)
Attitude of towards Opposition, 168-9, 187, 206-7, 290. See also Budget; Speeches on Address
Attitude towards West, 2912 Board of Pensions Commissioners, representation, 1350
Canals, 2779. See also that title Census figures, 1366 ChaudiSre valley floods, 3492 Conscription and. See Military Service Act Amdt. bill
Election issues and results, 245 Fisheries, 142
Transfer to province, M. (Mr. Marcii) 377, 493, 616, 623 Order in council tabled, 8 Request for order in council, 5 Harbours and rivers, 1998 Harmony with, 14, 270, 291, 362, 2421 Public buildings, improvements, 1245 Public expenditure in, 1468 Public ownership and, 71. See Address; Budget
Superintendent of lighthouses, qu., 2584 Unfair treatment, alleged, 2398
Quebec and Western Railway. See Canadian National Railways; Gaspfi Railways
Quebec Battlefields Commission, 119
Quebec Chronicle, 1477
Quebec Harbour Commission
Gravel, Mr. 1477
Inquiry for return, 1283
Tremblay, General, 1477
Watson, Major-General Sir David, 1477


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxvii
Quebec Harbour Commission bill (Further advances)
Res. 1464; reported, 1486; lr., 1486; 2r., com., 3195; 3r., 3198
Quebec, Oriental and Atlantic Railway. See
Canadian National Railways; Gasp6
Questions. See their several titles. For rulings, See Deputy Speaker; House of Commons; Speaker
Questions Passed as Orders for Returns
Accounts branch, Dept., of Militia and Defence (Mr. Vien) 2994 Animal diseases, compensation for, (Mr. Sutherland) 940 Armouries (Mr Baldwin) 1288 Army Service Corps (Mr. Lanctot) 1905 Auditing, payments for, (Mr. Vien) 2993 Bankruptcy Act, Montreal district trustees (Mr. Archambault) 1183 Binder twine and rope (Mr. Gordon) 1905 Blackfoot reserve, greater production (Mr. Garland, Bow River) 1288 British Columbia fisheries (Mr. Neill) 2306 Calgary, Government office buildings, (Mr. Shaw) 939
Canadian National railways, coal purchase (Mr. Macdonald, Pictou) 2306 Canadian Northern, payments from, 1914 (Mr. Kennedy, Glengarry), 615 Chief Architect's branch employees, (Mr. Fournier) 1067 Civil Service
Appeals against classification (Mr. Lanctot) 1508
Bonus and statutory increases (Mr. Lanctot) 939
Number and salaries paid, 1912 and 1922 (Mr. Sdguin) 1832
Officials receiving more than deputy ministers (Mr. Chisholm) 1508 Permanent employees, 1920-1922, (Mr. Demers) 706 Coal importations
Canadian National by, (Mr. Macdonald, Pictou) 2306
Government, by, (Mr. Logan) 939 Doherty, Right Hon. C. J., amounts paid to since 1855, (Mr. LanctOt) 472 Grand Trunk and Grand Trunk Pacific, amounts paid to since 1914, (Mr. Kennedy, Glengarry) 615 Halifax dry dock, (Mr. Stevens) 706 Harbours, improvements and expenditures, (Mr. Church) 828
From 1900 to 1921 (Mr. McBride) 372
Questions passed as Orders for Returns -
Con.
Homestead pre-emptions, areas, (Mr. Mc-Taggart) 732
Hotels owned and operated by Canadian National railways (Mr. Coote) 2806 Military districts' (Mr. Laneot) 1775, 2305 Militia and Defence
Buildings occupied (Mr. LanctSt) 2305 Officers and men at headquarters (Mr. Lanctot) 1775, 2305
Ministers' trips to Europe (Mr. Lanctot) 1402
Multigraph machines (Mr. McDonald, Timiskaming) 1508 Montreal
Canadian National railways, employees (Mr. Archambault) 1288 Customs, Income Tax, Post Office, employees (Mr. Archambault) 1288 Drydock (Mr. Stevens) 706 Parry Sound customs collections (Mr. Arthurs) 967 Postmasters
L'Assomption-Montcalm (Mr. S£guin) 1775	'
Richmond-Wolfe (Mr. Tobin) 1508 Prince Rupert dry dock (Mr. Stevens) 706 Quebec dry dock (Mr. Stevens) 706 Quebec Harbour Commission, advances to Sir Henry Drayton) 615 Railway systems, purchase of bonds (Mr. Baxter) 828
Rental of public buildings (Mr. Lucas) 615 St. John drydock, (Mr. Stevens) 706 School lands, sale of (Mr. Spencer) 1661 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment and Pensions, 615
Stationery, purchase of, (Mr. Prevost) 1288 Trade agents (Mr. Prevost) 1661 Transcontinental railway, amounts paid, (Mr. Kennedy, Glengarry) 165 Vancouver drydock, 706 (Mr. Stevens) Victoria, drydocks, 706 (Mr. Stevens) War
Advances to Imperial Government (Mr. Vien) 1288
Material furnished British Govt. (Mr. Vien) 1067
Race and Religious Differences, 14, 270, 2912, 362, 2421
Race Disqualification. See Dominion Elections Act M. (Mr. Euler)
Racing, Fishing schooners. See International
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxviii

Radial Railways. See Hydro-Electric
Radiotelegraph Service, 1749
Radium. See Nanaimo and Esquimau Bailway
Rail Contracts. See Bailways Rails, Steel, bounty on, 304-5
Railway Act, 1919, Arndt, bills
1.	Beturn Tickets. (Mr. Jacobs) lr., 821;
2r., ref. to Bailway Com., 1395
2.	Special passenger rates (Mr. Church)
lr., 1460; 2r., 1719
3.	Transportation Costs. (Crowsnest pass
agreement (Mr. Kennedy, Essex.) lr., 3588; 2r., com., 3595; 3r., 3597
Railway Commissioners, Board of. See also Crowsnest Pass Agreement; Freight Bates; Bailways Applications to, 201-202 Board of Bailway Commissioners Act, 1088 1101
Campbell, Mr. W. E., qu., 937 Carvell, Hon. F. B., alleged statement at . Calgary, 2775
Statement of Mr. Motherwell, 2773, 3491 Chairman of, 233. See also under this title, Carvell
Chief Traffic Officer, qu., 1377, qu., 2215, qu., 2457
Coastal boat service, and, 182 Commodity rates, 234 Drayton-Acworth report, 125 Freight rates, 234,	276, 2773. See also
Crowsnest Pass Agreement Intercolonial rates, 193, 312 Norris, Premier, reported statement of, 1213
Official report of proceedings, 2776 Kates. See also Freight Bates Grain on, 300 Increases, 131
Becommendations to by Drayton-Acworth report, 126
Tenure of office, 2777
Railway Transportation Costs, Special Committee on. .See Freight Rates
Railways. See also Canadian National Railways; Speeches on Address; Budget Advances to, qu., 471
Annual statement by Minister of Railways, 872
Branch lines, 1688 Canada Car Company, 1696
Railways - Con.	i
Canadian in United States, 312 Canadian National railways. See that title Canadian Railway Board of Adjustment, No. 1, 1060 Car demurrage, 2981 Car repairs, 1688, 2399 Car shortage, 166 Caraquet and Gulf shore, qu., 1504 Carriage of mails by, qu., 825. See also Mail Contracts
Co-ordination of, 2328. See also Address; Budget
Deficits, 2314, 2890 Drayton-Acworth report, 45-46, 1921 Duplication and waste, 125 Eight-hour day and, 228, 2316-17 Electric and steam locomotives, 630, 1188 Electrification of, 70, 1317, 1323, 1326, 1330, 1940
M. (Mr. Deslauriers) 627. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway Expenditure on in last 25 years, 111 Exploitation, 2245. See Budget; Speeches on Address
Freight and commodity rates, 131, 175, 233, 234, 261, 273, 357. See also Freight Rates
Coal on, 193 Legislation, qu., 934 Tonnage into Toronto, qu., 936 Government-owned, administration in United States, 67 Harvest excursions, 337 Labour conditions, 2315. See also Labour Loans and subsidies to, 1921 Mileage in 1877, qu., 1183 Nationalization of, 235. See also Address; Budget
New Zealand, 181 Overbuilding of, 202, 2569 Paralleling of existing lines. 203 Passes in maritime provinces, 315 Passenger rates. See Railway Act Amdt. bills
Increase, 132
Policy, 201, 1905, 1920, 1933 Prince Edward Island, cost of, 229 Problems. See Address; Budget; Freight Rates
Provincial obligations, 229 Public ownership, 2570. See also Budget; Canadian National Railways; Freight Rates; Speeches on Address Rail and car repair contracts, 1688 Shipping facilities. See St. John terminal facilities


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
cxxix
Railways *-[DOT] Con.
Steel rails
Bounty on, 304-5 Purchase of, 1912 South Africa, 2688
United. States, purchase in, 2611.. See also Canadian National Railways; Grand Trunk
Vote for, saving in, 884 Wages, 2317, 2417. See also Labour Water transportation competition, 69. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway Western provinces, indebtedness for, 229
Railways and Canals. See also Canals Department
Estimates, 1133, 16S7, 1905, 1933. 2747, 3035, 3518	[DOT]
Salaries and contingencies, 407, 1133 Governor-General's cars, 1688 Loan to the Canadian Goverment merchant Marine, 3035
Rail and car repair contracts, 1688 Surveys and inspections, 2779 Welland ship canal. See that title muler Canals
Rainbow. See Naval Service
Rankin, Mr. J. P. (North Perth!
Canadian Transit Company bill, 1770 Penitentiary Act Arndt, bill, 791
Rates, Special. See Railway Act Arndt, bills
Raymond, Mr. W. G. (Brantford)
Address in reply, 253; congratulations to Mr. Speaker; Liberal party and big interests, 253; Mr. Church and Toronto; Mr. Meighen's reference, 254; election campaign, 255; Mr. Meighen's election manifesto, 255-6; attitude of - Brantford manufacturers, 257-258; binder twine industry; liberty of the franchise, 258; War Time Elections Act; manufacturers and taxation, 258; basic and key industries, 259; tariff policy to build up country, 260; transportation rates, 261; national railway system; Liberal party and big interests, 262
Budget, 2373. Tariff; " Liberal protectionist"; congratulations to Finance Minister, 2373; amendment; duties of members; Liberal party and protection; free trade, 2374; agricultural implements; reduction of duty on; Brantford factories closed; binder twine factory, 2375; basic industry argument; manufacturing industries and
Raymond, Mr. W. G.

Con.
Budget 

 Con.
production of wealth, 2377; United States competition, 2378; key industries; Great Britain's mercantile marine; world trade; protection for the skilled labourer; United States tariff; capital, 2379; Progressive party and oleomargarine; Wheat Board, 2380; revenue tariff giving incidental protection; duty on binders, 2381; International Harvester company; principles of the two old parties; history of Liberalism; Toryism and tyrannical power, 2383
Customs duties on agricultural implements, 3230-1
References to, 27, 255, 263, 2384, 2536, 2705
Receipt Tax. See Special War Revenue Act Amdt.
Reciprocal Trade. See Reciprocity
Reciprocity. See also Trade
Australia with, 9, 33, 2900
United States with, 33, 53, 77, 94, 102, 208, 224, 278,	333,	2201,	2234. See also
Address; Budget; United States
Red Cross. See Canadian Red Cross; Canadian Patriotic Fund bill
Redistribution, 59, 198, 283, 2330, 2339, 3611. See also Proportional Representation
Announcement of Prime Minister, 3608, 3611
Census, completion of, 1363-71
Former, 1369
Inquiry, 733
M. (Mr. Shaw) opportunity for discussion of, 1719, 1769
Meeting of defeated candidates in Alberta, 2858
Progressive party, attitude towards, 136470
Re-establishment. See Pensions; Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment
Reed, Mr. William S. (Frontenac)
Mixed farming, Kingston fair, 992
Refills. See Opium and Narcotics
Regina, Speech of Hon. Mr. Motherwell at,
Regional Bureau, International Catalogue of Scientific Literature, 3528
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922 cxxxl

[Stage Direction]
Rinfret, Mr. Fernand- Con.
Montreal Gazette editorial comment, 15S4 Montreal post offices, business done, qu., 1065
Peat, deposits and experiments, qu., 1505 Railway mileage, in 1877, qu., 1183 Railway, policy, 1942
Representation of provinces in 1877, qu., 1183
Revenue and expenditure in 1877 and 1922, qu„ 1211
St. Lawrence river waterway, 1195 Topographical maps, qu., 1631
Riordon Company
Income tax, 60
Collections, qu., 372; qu., 607; qu., 927
Ritchie, Mr. Hugh, qu., 3361
River St. Lawrence ship channel. See Marine and Fisheries; St. Lawrence
Riviere du Loup
Arsenal, qu., 1181, 1690 Car shops, qu., 1181, 1690
Roads. See Highways; Public Works
Roads and Bridges. See Bridges; Highways; Public Works
Robb, Hon. J. A. (Minister of Trade and Commerce)
Budget, 2179. Reforms long overdue; the amendment; tariff reductions; Liberal platform of 1919,	2180; war time
extravagance; restoration of confidence; economy; markets; Mr. Fielding's visit tc Washington, 2181; trade with Great Britain and United States;
[DOT] cattle embargo; imports and exports, quantity and value of; uniform development; coal and water power, 2182; tariff policy; German trade; marking of goods, 2183
Campbell, Mr. J. A., claim for flax shipment, 2836
Canada Grain Act, administration of, 2834 Car demurrage, 2981 Complaints of unfair dealing, 2987 Canadian exhibition in France, 2031 Canadian Wheat Board, advances, 3541.
See'also under this title, Wheat Board Census	.
Cost, 1363 Enumerators, 1366 Payment of, 1369 Registration of Canadians, 1363
Robb, Hon. J. A.- Con.
Dominion Bureau of Statistics, 1363 Dominion Chain Company, Limited, 3490 Elevators
Licenses to private, 2838 Ontario, in, 2978
Terminal, maintenance and equipment, 2978
Government publications, 1373 [DOT] Demand and distribution, 1374 Grain Inquiry Commission, 50, 2982 Implements, agricultural, duty on, 3120 Industrial and Scientific Research, 1372 International Customs Tariff Bureau, 1372 Linen yarn bounty, 1361, 3128 Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3429, 3488 Pratt vs. Delphine, 303 Redistribution and the census, 1363-71.
See also under this title, Census Statistics, co-ordination of work, 1366 Steamship services, 2027, 3505 Canada, Australia, New Zealand, 3034 Canada, West Indies, South America, 3026	-
Freight rates, 2028 Quebec and north shore ports, 3034 St. John-Cuba, 2028 Trade and Commerce department Director of commercial intelligence, 700 Estimates, 1361, 2834, 2978, 3026, 3505, 3541	'
Officials, 700
Trade commissioners and agents, 2989 Trade with Mexico, 700 Wheat Board, 50
Wheat Board bill, 3174-5, 3184, 3188, 3380, 3383, 3386
Robb, Mr. W. D., qu., 728
Robertson, Hon. Senator, 505 Statement on Civil Service, 555
Robertson, P. L. Company, refund of duties,
qu., 1774
Robinson, Mr. E. W. (Kings, N.S.)
Root Vegetables bill, potato grading, 3378
Robitaille, Mr. Clement (Maisonneuve) Address in reply, 320. Public ownership of railways; Wheat board; returned soldiers' pensions, 320
Rockefeller Foundation, 61
Rods. See Steel
Rome, International Institute. See Agricut ture
Volume 1: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
[Stage Direction]
cxxxii
[Stage Direction]
Root Vegetables, Sale and Inspection of, bill Res., 2743; lr., 2747; 2r., ref. to Com. on Agriculture, 2972; com., 3142, 3194, 3367; 3r., 3487	.
Ross, Mr. A. E. (Kingston)
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3482 Militia expenditure, policy, 1587 Niobe, sale of, 2068 Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3450 Pensions Com., final report, 3343 Soldiers' civil re-establishment Hospital staffs, 1345 Nurses, salaries of, 1342 Venereal diseases, qu., 935
Ross, Mr. Thomas E. (North Simcoe) Address in reply, 95. Congratulations to Miss Macphail; decline in prices of farm products, 95; soldier settlers, 96; re-establishment; economy in administration; increase in sessional indemnity, 97
Ross Rifle, 2609, 2616
Roumania, loan to, qu., 1400, 2888
Round Table, 3170-1
Routhier, the late Sir Adolphe, 1275
Royal Assent, 722, 1988, 1995, 3617
Royal Canadian Artillery, qu., 370, 1982
Royal Canadian Mounted Police. See also National Defence bill
Amalgamation with Dominion Police, 675 Barracks, Fairmont, improvements, 1255 Buildings, 2129
Canadian expeditionary force, in, qu., 2038 Detachments in Arctic regions, 3497 Discontinuance of, qu., 377 Enlistments from A and B squadrons in Canadian expeditionary force, qu., 2038 Estimates, 2129
Income tax office, Hamilton, 1253 Indians, relief to destitute, 1715 Labour espionage and, 670 Lethbridge, Drs. Lovering and Taylor, qu., 1211
Macleod detachment, removal of, 2584 Naturalization, investigations, 1671, 2024 Opium and Narcotic Drugs Act, reports, 1289, 1377 Pensions, 2131
Northwest rebellion, 3523 Removal from British Columbia, 173, 184, 327, 522
Royal Canadian Mounted Police - Con. Salaries, 775 Secret service, 670-9
Unorganized territories in, M. (Mr. Woods-worth) to confine to, S29; neg. on div., 843
Winnipeg strike, 671 Zaneth, Corporal, 671
Royal Canadian Navy. See Naval Service
Royal Military College, 1985
Royal Naval College, 2047, 2203, 2458
Royal Trust Company, 1085
Rubber Goods, manufacture, 2469
Rubber Industry, occupational diseases. See Labour
Rulings. Sec Deputy Speaker; Speaker
Rural Depopulation, 301,	2470. See also
Address; Budget; Census; Population
Rural Mail. See Post Office
Rural Postmasters. See Civil Service; Post Office
Russell, Mr. T. A., 1663, 2695
Russia
Competition in wheat market, 2157 Consortium to re-establish trade, 1463 Public ownership, 1942 Re-establishment of business in, 1463 " Save the Children Fund ", 2516 Wrangel Island, 1751
Ryckman, Mr. Edmond B. (East Toronto) Address in reply, 284. Congratulations to Mr. Speaker, 284; economy in government; Mr. Church's record, 285; protective tariff; Great Britain and the tariff, 286; protection for farmers, 287; Liberal tariff and election campaign, 288; speeches of Prime Minister and Minister of Justice, 289-90; Sir Lomer Gouin and Quebec attitude, 291; sectionalism in politics, 292 Arsenals
Lindsay, 2088
Quebec, 2093	[DOT]
Canada Temperance Act Arndt, bill, 3006 Canadian National railways, consolidation, 1962
Cigars and cigarettes, tax on, 3241 Dominion lands and surveys, 1038
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxxiil
Ryckman, Mr. Edmond B. - Con.
Dominion Textile Company, 584 Lambton, loss of, 3508 Mines department, economy, 688-9 Parliament buildings, architects' fees, 2014 Public buildings, heating, 1761 Sales tax, 3269
United States tax on German goods, 3411 Ste. Agathe Sanitarium, 1342 Ste. Anne Hospital, 1342
Ste Anne de la Pocatiere, water supply, qu., 2213
St. Catherines Post office building, 1246-50 St. Charles Park. See Parc St. Charles St Charles River Improvements, 2400 St. George, N.B., public building, 1240
St. John, N.B.
Cold stox'age, 3521 Courtenay bay, 2013 Harbour, qu., 1401 Improvements, 2013 Immigration buildings, 2027 Income tax office, qu., 826 Negro Point breakwater, 2013 Ocean tonnage, 2008
Port. See British Preference, M. (Mr. Logan)
Quarantine station, 1239-40, 2021 Terminal facilities, M. (Mr. Caldwell) 639, 844; withdrawn, 851
St. John Ambulance Association, 3387
St. John and Quebec Railway
Acquisition by Canadian National, qu., 1774, qu., 1293
M. (Mr. Caldwell) 1293; neg., 1296 St. John River
Pollution of by United States mill owners, 2168
*Wharves on tidal wraters, qu., 2200 St. John Valley Railway, 3039
St. Lawrence River Ship Channel
De Beaujeu bank, dredging, 1495 Elevator dredge, 1494 Maintenance and operation, 1494 Pilotage dues, 1499 Self-propelling hopper barge, 1495 Sorel shipyard, 1494. See also that title
St. Lawrence River Waterway, 70, 121, 134, 137,	269, 2266,	2327,	2398. See also
Address; Budget; Canals; Quebec Harbour Commission; Transportation; Waterpowers; Welland Ship Canal Calder, United States Senator, 1206 Climatic conditions, 1187 Coal, conservation of supply, 1188 Co-operation with United States, 2750, 2767
Correspondence with United States Government, 2207, 2583, 2755, 2760, 2767 Tabled, 2256
Cost, 269, 1191, 1195-99, 1203-07, 1315, 1320, 1329
Deep Waterways Association, 1206-8 Electric power development, 1188, 1205, 1317, 1319, 1321, 1326, 1397 Export of power, 1203 Niagara river, 1322, 1327 Electrification of locomotives and railways, 133, 1188, 1317, 1323, 1326, 1330. See also Electrification; Railways Finance, 1189, 1195, 1318, 1320 Finney, Col. John, 1189 Freight rates, 1204 Georgian bay canal, 1199, 1204, 1209 Grain production and shipment, 1203 Great Lakes-St. Lawrence Tidewater Association, 1319
Harding, President, 133, 1184 History of project, 1185 Imperial Government, communication with, qu., 1508
Industrial development, 1318 Information available, 1195 International Joint Commission, 1191, 1199, 1206, 1315-21, 1469 Report, qu., 377 Distribution of, 2357
International partnership, 1191, 1199, 1209, 1315, 1332, 1396
Land adjacent to development, 1200 Long Sault, 1199 Manchester ship canal, 1190 M. (Mr. Church) 1183, 1314, 1396 Navigation, 1195 Negotiations, inquiry, 786 New York state commission, 1197 Progress report, 2969 Ocean steamers, 1193-95, 1205 Opportunity for further discussion, 1462 Opposition to project, 1184, 1193, 1199, 1202, 1206, 1209
Proposed bond issue, 1318, 20 Public ownership, 1189, 1318-31 Support of western states, 1184
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxxiv


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX- 1922 cxxxv

[Stage Direction]
Sanitarium. See Solcliei's' Civil Re-establishment
Sardines, export of, qu., 1182
Saskatchewan
Aerial patrol, 1724
Canada Temperance Act Arndt., 2997. See also that title	.
Dry areas, 1042 Harbours and rivers, 2004 Indian reserves, qu., 608 Liquor
Export of, 2077
Warehouses, qu., 1211; qu., 1660 Importations, qu., 2037; qu., 2303 Public buildings, improvements, 1253 Second homesteads, 1042 Wheat marketing, 115. See also Wheat Board
Saskatchewan Court of Appeal. See Judges Act Arndt, bill
Saturday Sittings. See House of Commons, Sittings
Sault Ste. Marie, Algoma Steel Co. rail contracts, 1704
Saunders, Dr. C. E., resignation of, 590, 3522
Savard, Mr. Edmond (Chicoutimi-Saguenay)
_ Canadian National railways, right of way and lease agent, qu., 1633
Save the Children Fund, 3516
Savoy, Mr. J. Clovis, qu., 3363
Sawmill Machinery, 3126
Scandinavia
Immigration, 2144 Trade relations with, 2990
Schools. See also Education Closing in West, 152
Lands, 339. See also Dominion Lands; Natural Resources
Nova Scotia in. See Nova Scotia Miners Refusal of banks to advance money to, 2627
Scientific Research. See Research
Scott, Mr. Frank, qu., 728
Scrip Frauds. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Sea-Going Vessels. See St. Lawrence River Waterway
Seals, destruction by. See British Columbia Fisheries	.
Seaports, Canadian. See British Preference
Secondary amendments. See House of Commons ; Speaker
Secord Case. See Criminal Code (Scrip Frauds)
Secret Proceedings. Sec Prime Ministers' Conference
Secret Service. See Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Secretariat. See League of Nations
Secretary of State department Adjustment of War claims, 1672, 2977 Estimates, 601, 1670, 3499 Public archives, 1673
Sedition. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Seduction. See Criminal Code Arndt.
Seed Grain
Advances, 1053 Freight on, 3522 Purchasing Commission, 1011
Seguin, Mr. P. A. (L'Assomption-Montcalm) Forest, Mr. Mfidard, customs officer, qu., 2355	1
Gaboury, Mr. L. J., salary, qu., 3599
L'Assomption and Montcalm Excise officers, qu., 1774 Employment and dismissal of, qu., 2355 Lightkeepers, qu., 1904, qu., 2215 Postmasters, 1775
Tobacco experimental station, 1776
Select Standing Committees. See House of Commons
Selective Conscription. See Military Service ' Act Amdt.
Senate
^Amendments concurred in:
Agricultural Fertilizers bill, 3607 Criminal Code Amdt. bill, 3607 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 3486 Escheats Act Amdt. bill, 3486 Insurance Act, 1917, Amdt. bill, 3607 Loan Companies Act, 1914, Amdt. bill, 3607
National Defence Department bill, 2806 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act bill, 3607
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxxvi

Senate - Con.	\
Amendments concurred in - Con.
Trust Companies Act, 1914, Arndt, bill, 3607
Amendments, non-concurrence: Bankruptcy Act Arndt, bill, 3611 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3608 Dominion Lands, Cancellation Leases bill Concurrence, 3616 Conference, 3614
Chief accountant, salary, qu., 2583, qu., 2803 Expenditure, qu., 2583 Free conferences with, 3613, 3616 Indemnity, proposed reduction, 2513, 3509 Reform, 138, 2894
Salaries and contingent expenses, 2026
Senate and House of Commons Act. See
Salaries Act Amdt.
Senn, Mr. Mark C. (Haldimand)
Corn-borer, destruction by, 818
Grand River bridge, York, Ont., qu., 1287
Sergeant-at-Arms. Sec House of Commons Serums. See Accredited Herds; Agriculture
Sessional Indemnity. See House of Commons; Members
Settlers. See Immigration
Sexsmith, Mr. Edward J. (Lennox and Addington)
Address in reply, 293. Change in administration; agriculture; railway problems, 283; soldier settlement, 294 Dominion Elections Act Amdt. bill, 2812 Soldiers bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 447 .
Sexual Offences. Sec Criminal Code
Sbaughnessy, Lord
National railway scheme, 89-90, 127 On immigration, 2478
Shaw, Mr. Joseph T. (West Calgary) Agriculture Com. report, Wheat Board, 782 Banff-Windermere road, 1683	.
Blankets, duty on, 3136 Boots and shoes, M. to reduce duty, 3238 Calgary, post office building, 1254	#
Cariada-Australia, steamship service, 3034 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3003 Date of coming into effect, 3007; Withdrawn, 3008
Canadian National railways Representation at meeting of steamship companies, 2584
Canadian Patriotic Fund bill, 3484 Coal lands, transfer of by Canadian Pacific Railway Company, 2214
Shaw, Mr. Joseph T. - Con.
Criminal Code Amdt bill, fines, 2832 Expenditure, comparison by departments, 1137	'
Explosives Act, 1234
Freight rates, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1444-8 Grain companies, security of, 2837 Indians
Education, 1227, 3536
Stony Reserve school, qu., 965, 1218, 1227, 3536
Military and other expenditures, 1137 Militia and defence
Expenditure and policy, 1590 Permanent force, 1983 War medals, 2976 Ministers- and Directorships, 1126 Naval service, 1738 Opium and Narcotic Drugs, 3022 Pensions Com., final report, 3305 Amdt., 3349, 3358
Prime Ministers' Conference, naval defence, 1742, 1745
Railway Commission, Carvell, Hon. F. B., alleged statement of Mr. Motherwell, 2775, 2779 Redistribution
Inquiry as to intention of Government, 3611
M. (Mr. Shaw), opportunity for discussion, 1719
Reply to leader of Opposition, 3611 Royal military college, 1985 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, Alberta hospital, 1345 Tariff commissioner, 1665 Tariff, reciprocal arrangement with France, 2032
Tourist traffic, 1683
Trade commissioners and commercial agents, 2989 War memorials, 2101 Wheat Board, 3182 Wrangel island, 1751
Sheard, Mr. Charles (South Toronto) Address in reply, 294. Congratulations to [DOT] Mr. Speaker; defeat of Meighen Government due to taxation, 294; Progressive party; railway problem, 295, 296; immigration; tariff and protection, 297 Criminal Code Amdt. bill, docking of horses, 2833
Soldier Civil Re-establishment, salary increases, 386


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxxvii
Sheep Industry. See Agriculture; Live Stock
Shelburne wharf, 1768
Shellfish. See Meat and Canned Foods
Shells. See Ammunition
Sherbrooke
Post Office inspector, qu., 1507 Soldier Settlement Board employees, qu., 1658
Sherman, General William T., war, 1336
Shibley, Mr. A. D., Secretary-Treasurer of Union of Canadian Municipalities, 1392
Ships and Shipbuilding. See also Canadian Government Merchant Marine; Labour; Limitation of Armaments; Marine; Naval Service; St. Lawrence River Waterway; Steamship Services; Unemployment; Vessels British Ministry of Shipping, claim for hospital ship, 1752
Canada Shipping Act. See that title Canadian navigation companies, lifesaving equipment, qu., 1284 Con Rein, sinking of, 1382 Coolie labour, 2042
Dominion Iron and Steel Co., steel plates, 1677
Drydocks. See that title
International deep sea racing. See that title
Nova Scotia, 1387
Pilotage dues, 1499. See also Canada Ship-ing Act
Registration of, 1493 Sorel shipyard, 2169
Dismissal of emplbyees, qu., 605, 1283 Maintenance, 14941 Men employed, qu., 1062 Steamboat inspection, 2169 Steel plates, cost of delivery, 3508 Vickers Company, elevator dredge, 1494 Wooden ships constructed at Victoria, B. C„ qu., 364
Shuswap Lake
Dredging, 2006 Wharf, 3547
Siberia, Service of Mounted Police, in, qu., 2038
Silk Fabrics, duty on, 2662, 3137
Silver. See also Coinage; Mines and Minerals Coins. See Currency Act Amdt. bill Discovery in Yukon, 1276 English hall marks, protection of. See Criminal Code
Simpson, Mr. T. E. (West Algoma)
Dredging, St. Mary's river, 2006 Good roads, Ontario, qu., 372 Lambton, wreck of, 1497, 3508 Rail and car repair contracts, 1703 Receipt tax, 3262
Sales tax, workmen's clothing, 3272 Sault Ste. Marie wharf, 2006 Unemployment	[DOT]
Insurance, 1075
Rails and car repair contracts, 1704
Sinclair, Hon. J. E. (Queen's, P.E.I.) Harbours and rivers, Prince Edward island, 1990
Root Vegetables bill, potato grades, 3375
Single Tax, 2191. See also Budget; Taxation
Six Nation Reserve. See Indians
Slaughter Houses, Inspection. See Meat and Canned Foods
Smuts, General, International Disarmament Conference, 1283
Socialism, 1290
Soft Drinks, tax on, 2329, 2617, 2852, 2857. See also Taxation
Soldier Land Settlement, S3, 96, 147, 183, 252,
294, 305, 318, 327, 345, 3294, 3298, 3307, 3333, 3338. See also Address; Budget; Pensions Committee Abandoned farms, 2132 Building loans, 3475 Cost and results, 2159 Estimates, 2023, 2131 Expenditure, statement of, 2132 Foreclosure, 2132 Homestead rights, 2132 Inflated values, 2133 Land speculation, and, 2136 Municipal taxation, payment by Government, 1257
Revaluation of land, 2136-42 Taxes, collection' of, 2134
Soldier Settlement Act Amdt. bills
1.	Mineral rights. (Mr. Malcolm) lr., 2035
2.	Consolidation of Indebtedness. (Mr. Stewart, Argenteuil)
Res. 3358, 3405; lr., 3409; 2r., com., 3475; 3r„ 3476
Soldier Settlement Board, qu., 608 Amounts loaned, etc., qu., 469 Estimates, 2023, 2131-43
Comparison with last year, 382
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxxxviii


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922

[Stage Direction]
cxxxix
Speaker, Hon. Rodolphe Lemieux-Con. Rulings and Statements-Con.
Crowsnest pass agreement, suspension of Rule 11, 1502
Daylight saving, discussion in order, 944 Debate
Closed by mover, 835, 1295, 1836 Relevancy
Criticism of British Columbia Government during Budget debate, 2238 Hon. John Oliver, quotation from Vancouver Sun; 2236 Debates, Official Report
Insertion of documents, 942 Decorum, conversation in Chamber and lobbies, 2640 Election of, 1, 4
Kingston election petition, 2692 Language, " False " or " falsely ", 3603 Libellous statements reflecting on honour of Canada, 822 Letters, anonymous, 944 Library of Parliament, 3517 Salaries, 3517 Members	-
Customary to speak from seats, 632, 3286
May speak only once on motion for 3r„ 3487
Must address Chair, 2415 Must address other members in third person, 165 Payment of, 3611
Speaking, not to be interrupted, 2361 Motions
Arndt, to amdt. (Mr. Crerar on Budget) 2473-4, 2519
For concurrence in, notice required, 703 In advance of report of Com., 1901 Non-debatable, 865 Notice given in Votes and Proceedings, 378
Ministers and Directorships, seconder, 1084, 1094
Private members, involving expenditure, out of order, 844 Re-drafted, in order, 844 Newspaper extracts, 821 Orders of the Day
Arguments not permissible, 822, 1721, 1842, 2256, 2995, 3492, 3601 Member may make personal explanation or ask question, 3602-3 Question not debatable, 3602 Reading newspaper extracts, 303, 374-5 Right of members to raise question of privilege on, 2638
Speaker, Hon. Rodolphe Lemieux - Con. Rulings and Statements - Con.
Pairs, 1463
Petitions, irregular, 1929 Privilege
Member may make personal explanation or put question, 3602-3 ' Member must confine himself to question, 3366
Must affect honour of member, 3493 Right of member to raise on Orders of the day, 2638
Prorogation of Parliament, 3610 Questions
Argumentative, 2805-2806 Discretion of Ministers respecting, 1775 Standing- as orders for returns, 1660, 1775
Reading of letters, 948 Resolution
Adopted, binding on Government, 639 Affecting civil rights of provinces, 829 Money, should originate with GovernMent, 639
Must be positive, 644 Royal Assent, 1988 Rule 11, suspension of, 1502 Senate, free conference, 3613 Sergeant-at-Arms to prevent disorder in lobby, 3606	*
Supply
Concurrence, 1843
Discussion of particular item on motion, 1337
Redress of grievances before going into Com., 1337	[DOT]
Tedious repetition, 944 Unanimous consent, 703, 726, 3597 Bill, introduction of, 3597 Vacancies
Kamouraska, 1459	.
War memorials, 2100
Wheat Board, point of order, 2935, 2949
Speaker, Mr., Bereavement of, 496, 596
Speakman, Mr. Alfred (Red Deer)
Address in reply, 80. Co-operation necessary; agricultural prosperity, 81; tariff for revenue; taxation forms; immigration, 82; unemployment; soldier settlement, 83
Agriculture, subsidies to, 1698	'
Budget, 2881. Alleged selfishness of [DOT] prairie provinces; Budget as it affects the West; protection, 2881; tariff and cost of living; textile Industry; protection and prices; price of agricul-
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxll

[Stage Direction]
Spencer, Mr. Henry E. - Con.
Census, agricultural assets and liabilities, 2159
Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1423 Dominion notes, qu., 935 Fabre, Madame, pension, 2024 Farming industry, 809, 2158, 2159 Grain, per capita production, 2159 Grain Growers' Grain Co., alleged contributions to political organizations, 2488	.
Immigration
Central European, 2158 Land speculation, 2159 Pamphlets, 759 . Policy, 2158
Imported liquor, excise duty, qu., 828 Income tax-payers, qu., 3362 Livestock industry, 984 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 590 Militia and Defence
Transport and freight, amdt. to reduce item, 1987 Mixed farming, 983 Naturalization Act, 2024 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 515 Population
Rural, decline in, 2158 Slow growth of, 2158
Post office saving' banks, interest, qu., 1932 Soldier settlement, cost and results, 2159 Steamship services, 2027 Welland canal, qu., 3600 Wheat Board, 3185 Wheat Board bill, 3380
Sportsmen's Patriotic Association, cadet camps, 1973
Spruce Bud Moth, 595, 815, 2668. See also Entomology
Stamp Tax. See Special War Revenue Act
Standard of Living. See Oriental Aliens
Standard of Valuation. See Customs
Standard Time. See Daylight Saving
Standards, Bureau of, 235, 1372
Stanfield, Dr., Bienfait briquetting plant, 1234
Stansell, Mr. J. L. (East Elgin)
Accredited herd system, 995, 999 Address in reply, 359. Definition of party names; farmers and protection, 360;
Stansell, Mr. J. L. - Con.
Address - Con.
defeat of late government; economy; cattle embargo; railway situation, 361; racial differences, 362 Agriculture dept., estimates, 994 Budget, 2290. "Grit and "Tory"; suggested identity of Liberal and Progressive policies, 2290; tribute to the Minister of Finance; attitude of Progressives, 2291; sales tax; income tax, 2292; constructive criticism; tariff and the masses; protection; adjustment of tariff to changing conditions; revenue, 2292; encourage maximum production; sales tax; increase of burden upon consumers, 2293; income tax,; taxes passed on to consumers, 2294	*
Canned milk industry, 3264 Civil service patronage, 3087 Commissioner of Agriculture, qu., 609 Experimental farms, 809 Freight rates, Special Com. report, 3596 Live Stock industry, 994 Ministers and directorships, 1124 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1825 Railway Act Amdt. (Crowsnest pass) 3597
State-Owned Railways. See Canadian National Railways
Stationery. See Printing and Stationery
Statistics. See also Census; Population; Trade
Concentration of, 580 Dominion Bureau of, 1363
Dominion Statistician, Mr. R. H. Coats, 1364-71
Statutes
Printing of, 1972 Revision of, 1717
Steamship Services, qu., 614. See also Trade and Commerce
British Columbia coastal, qu., 3152 Canada-Australia-New Zealand, 3034 Canada-Newfoundland, 2027 Canada-West Indies-British Guiana, qu., 2356
Canada-West Indies-South America, 2027, 3026
Charlottetown-Pictou-New Glasgow, 3506 Charlottetown-Victoria-Halliday's Wharf, 3506
Competition with railways, 182 Freight rates, 2028 Halifax-Canso-Guysboro, 3507
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cxlii

Stefansson Expedition, 1750
Steamship Services - Con
Mails, carriage of, 2028 Miscou-Shippegan Island, 2020 Mulgrave-Arichat-Petit de Grat, 2020 Murray Bay-Tadoussac, 3035 Newcastle-Neguac-Escuminac, 2020 Pelee Island and mainland, 3034 Pictou-Mulgrave-Cheticamp, 3050 Port Mulgrave-St. Peters-Irish Cove, 3507 Quebec Natashquan-Bras d'Or, 2020, 3034 St. Catherines Bay-Tadoussac, 2020 St. John-Bay of Fundy-Minas Basin, 3507 St. John-Bear River, 3507 St. John-Cuba, 2028 St. John-Digby, 2030 St. John-St. Andrews, 2030 St. Stephen-Deer Island-Campobello, 2030 Sydney-Bras d'Or lakes, 2031 Sydney-Whyqocomagh, 2030, 3035 Arancouver-Howe Island, 2027 Victoria-Vancouver-Skagway, 2027
Steedsman, Mr. James (Souris)
Budget, 2721. Inconsistencies of the tariff; implement duties; opportunities for manufacturing in British Columbia, 2721; prairie farmers paying tribute to manufacturers and fruit growers; cost of wheat production beyond market value; farming unprofitable, 2722; survey of conditions in West; boot and shoe industry, 2723 Tractors, 3124
Turtle Mountain reserve, qu., 615
Steel. See also Railway estimates; Rail repairs
Bounties, 304-5, qu., 3360 British Empire Steel Corporation. See that title
Dominion Iron and Steel Company, contract for ship plates, 1677, 2170 Drawbacks, 2175 Industry, subsidies to, 1692, 1696 Plates, 1677, 2170 Delivery of, 3508 Prices, 2411-12 Rails
Competition with Germany, 2412 Contracts for, 1688 Price of, 1680-1709, 2412 Purchases of, 1913	.
Unemployment, 1077 Rods, refund of duties, qu., 1774 Steel plates, 1677
Damage claim of Dominion Iron and Steel Co., 1677 Settlement of, 2170 Structural, importation of, qu., 1931
Stevens, Hon. H. H. (Vancouver Centre) Address in reply, 230. Death of Prime Minister's brother; debate on address opportunity for vigorous discussion, 230; importance of aids to agriculture; marketing of wheat, 231; Wheat Board, 232; elevator facilities, 233; freight rates on commodities, 234; bureau of ' standards, industrial and scientific research, 235; immigration, 236; Bank Act, revision of; unemployment, 237; the tariff question; customs taxes, cost of collecting, 239; tariff, platform of Liberal Convention; speech of Mr. Marler, 240; survey of ministers, 241; Minister of Justice and big interests, 242; minister and directorships, 242-3 Air board, 1722 Air Force and civil aviation
Customs aerial patrol, Vancouver, 1730 Forest patrol in Railway Belt, 1730 Archives, book binder, 703 British Columbia house, purchase of, 3537 Budget, 2640. Tariff announcement will allay alarm of manufacturing interests; cheque tax, 2640; discriminatory tax on confectionery; repeal of antidumping clause; fruit; marking act and depreciated currency clause, 2641; German situation; depreciated currency, 2642; post war industries and commercial development of Germany; position of France; reparations; physical suffering; Germany's budget deficits; issues of paper currency; unemployment; comparison of conditions in 1915 and 1921, 2643; Germany's foreign trade; adverse balance; Canada's imports from Germany; purchasing power of the mark; internal and external value; Mr. Maynard Keynes; Dr. Melchior; situation in France, 2645; Austria, Hungary; prohibitory tariffs in central Europe; German exports to Canada; pocket knives, 2646; German goods, method of distribution; agents of German manufacturers in Canada, 2647; sale of brokers' goods; enormous profits of German manufacturers; congratulations to Prime Minister on recently bestowed honour; Australian Preservation of Industries Act; direct and indirect taxation, 2648; inaccurate statements issued by Canadian Council of Agriculture; Mr. Crerar's figures


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxliii
Stevens, Hon. H. H.-Con.
Budget - Con.
as to agricultural exports, 2619; consumption of agricultural products in Canada, 2650; taxation of capital; income tax - who pays?; per capita payment of customs duties, 2691; grievances of western farmers; technical and not fiscal problems, 2652; the tariff; business profits and taxation; United Grain Growers; watered stock, 2653; business principles enunciated in Grain Growers' report, .	2654
Canadian exhibition in France, 2031	.
Canadian National railways, deficit, 1919 Canadian Pacific railway bill, 1858 Cash grants to soldiers, Liberal pledge, 399, 433
Chinese immigration
Agent in China, 2026, qu., 2214 Estimates, 2026
Civil service bonus, inquiry, 2996 .
Coal, Canmore and Drumheller miners' dispute, 1058
Conciliation and Labour Act. 1053, 1054 Congratulations to Mr. Fielding, 3279 Customs Act, depreciated currency, 2642, 3224, 3410 Dredging, 2005
Shuswap lake, 2006 Dumping provision, 2641, 3412 Employment offices, 1058 Enfranchisement of foreign-born women, M. (Mr. Euler) 487
Fisheries, salmon canners' license fees, 1748 Ford automobile company, 3274 Forests, depletion of, 1046 Fraser Valley and Southern Railway, 1577 Fruit growers, protection, 2641, 3423-4 German valuation of goods, 2642-48, 3226 Government publications, 1373 Grain Inquiry Commission, qu„ 705; qu., 1181, 2842
Harbours and rivers British Columbia, 2005 Quebec, 1998 Hides, price of, 3138 Immigration
. Commissioner of at Canton, China, qu., 1901, 2026; qu., 2214 Foreigners admitted as farmers, 1068 Industrial and scientific research, 235, 1372 Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1058 Interior dept., economic adviser, 455 International Opium Convention, qu., 1066 Job printers, taxation, 3264
Stevens, Hon. H. H. - Con.
Labour department Employees, 460, 468 Estimates, 571
M. to reduce item, 562, 579 Salary increases, 562 Liquor importation, 733 MeCoig, Senator, attendance before Agriculture Com., 1901
Mclnnes, Mr. W. IV. B., qu., 1901, 2026; qu.,
Marine and Fisheries Eddie, Capt., 1492 Ice-breaker, repurchase of, 1490 Lightkeepers, salaries, 1497 Navigation schools, 1492 Steamers and ice-breakers, 1490 Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 754 Mennonite emigration, qu., 732 Mexico, trade with, 699 Militia and Defence Purchasing agents, 416-17 Training camps, qu., 2584 National Defence bill, ,739 National Liberal-Conservative platform, trade, 2540 Naval Service
Royal Canadian navy, 1882-91 Royal Naval college, closing of, qu., 2458 Niagara River Bridge Company bill, 1486 Northwest rebellion, pensions for Mounted police, 3523	.
Nova Scotia miners strike, 1054 Opium and Narcotic Drugs, 775, 3017 Oriental aliens, and, 2018 Prohibition, and, 2018 Oriental aliens Immigration
Chinese, restriction, M. for papers, 1776 Japanese, restriction, M. for papers, 1776
M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion of, 1548, 1573 Pilotage dues, 1500 Point of order
M. in advance of report of Com., 1901 Right of member to complete speech, 3540
Unfinished statement of member ruled out of order, not debatable, 3603 Post office, railway mail service in British Columbia, 2799
Public buildings, heating, 1758 Radiotelegraph service, 1749 Railway Commission, Hon. F. B. Car veil, statement, 2777
Volume I:: 
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 cxlv

[Stage Direction]
Stewart, Hon. Charles - Con.
Indians - Con.
Six Nations, 1221
Enfranchisement, 2991 Soldier Settlement Board, 1221 Sydney reserve, proposed transfer, 1215 Interior department
Employees, transfer to, 457 Estimates, 3517 Printing and supplies, 464 Salaries, 452
International boundaries, 1033 Lignite
Bienfait briquetting plant, 1233 Utilization board, 3524 Mines and Minerals
Clay deposits, investigation of, 1234 Estimates, 685
Investigation of resources, 1234 Reduction of vote, 1236-62 Officials, 687
Ore-dressing plant, 1235 Tar sands, 1236 Nelson, Mr. Frank, 3517 Oriental aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) for exclusion, 1565
Amdt. " effective restriction ", 1567, 1574 Preston, Mr. W. T. R., claim of, 3503 Public buildings expenditure, 1262 Research council, 1233 Seat for, in Quebec province, 12 Seed grain advances, 1055 Soldier settlement, 2024 Estimates, 2131-42 Land purchases, irregularities, 2140 Taxes, collection of,, 2134 Soldier Settlement Act Amdt. bill, 3405, 3475 Water powers, surveys, 1051 Wheat Board bill, 3189 Tukon territory government of, 1034
Stewart, Mr. C. Wallace (Humboldt)
Budget, 2597. Progressive amendment, 2597. Amendment; does not express progressive view; budget proposals; congratulations to Finance Minister, 2598; the average citizen and public affairs; taxation; revenue; debt; economy; reciprocity with the United States; direct taxation; freer trade; marking and valuation of currency acts, 2599; tariff reductions; agricultural implements; sales tax; undue burden on people with small incomes, 2600; political pledges; constructive criticism; income tax; business profits tax; inheritance tax; land tax; estimated revenue from, 2601; conditions of
Stewart, Mr. C. Wallace - Con.
Budget - Con.
western farmers; need of wider markets; Wheat Board; transportation; Hudson Bay railway; branch lines, 2602; purchasing power; re adjustment of taxation; immigration; unoccupied lands, 2603 Hudson Bay railway, completion of, 2602, 2789
Insurance premiums, tax on, 3255 Macphail, Miss, alleged statement of, 3221
Stewart, Major Duncan, qu., 823
Stewart, Mr. H. A. (Leeds)
Brockville and Westport railway, qu., 704 Canadian Ford company, taxes, qu., 3599 Canadian National railways, passenger traffic, qu., 927 Condensed milk, tax, 3271 Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 955 Militia and defence, cadet services, 1978 Nova Scotia miners, McLachlan correspondence, qu., 704 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1791 Returned Soldiers Insurance bill, 3391-2
Stewart, Hon. John A. (Lanark)
Alcohol for retail druggists, qu., 1400 Canadian National railways
Board of management, 913	/
Minister's statement, 912 Public ownership and operation, 1956 Rail and car repair contracts, 1914, 1958 Toronto Globe editorial, 1134 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1427-32 Genoa Conference, 582
Grand Trunk and Grand Trunk Pacific railways, qu., 2037
Intercolonial railway management, 408 Labour department
Director of technical education, 577 Policy, and building trades, 582 Publicity agent, 466 Supplies clerk, 585 Public Works estimates, 698 Rail and car repair contracts, 1690, 1694, 1700. See also under this title Canadian National Railways
Railway Commission, alleged statement of Mr. Motherwell, 2777 Railways
Administration, 408 Co-ordination, 408 Freight rates, legislation, qu., 934 Policy, 1956
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume 111: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619

cxlvi


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cxlvii
Supply, Committee of - Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Canadian National railways - Con. Advances - Con.
Canadian Northern ($42,800,000) 1905, 1933
Grand Trunk ($25,750,000) 1969
Grand Trunk Pacific ($15,900,000) 1969
Grand Trunk Pacific ($800,000) 3520 Rail and car repair contracts, 1688 Canadian Press, Limited, 772 Canadian Representation in United States, 2026, 2990 Canals
Chambly, 3518
Ontario-St. Lawrence, 2779
Quebec, 2779
Rideau, 2764, 2769
St. Lawrence ship canal, 2767
Soulanges, 2768
Staff and repairs, 2779
Trent, 2764
Welland ship canal, 1687, 2747 Civil aviation, 1722 Civil Service Bonus, 3528 Commission, 3064 Conciliation and Labour Act, 1053 Customs and Excise, 762, 1674 Distressed Canadians, relief of, 2027 Dominion lands, 1035, 1051 Dominion lands and parks, 1681, 3517 Employment offices, 1058 Exhibitions, 2026 External affairs, 411, 3508 Finance, 770
Charges of management, 1663, 3495 Paper Control inquiry, 1673 Tariff commissioner, 1663 Forestry protection, 1046 Geodetic survey, 1033 Geological survey, 1233, 1236 Genoa Conference, 1715 Girl guides, 774
Governor General's Secretary's Office, 751 Grain Inquiry Commission, 2982 Harbours and rivers. See also under this title. Public Works.
Nova Scotia, 1269, 3545 Prince Edward Island, 1270 Health, 775
Immigration, medical inspection, 2021 Quai'antine, 2021 High Commissioner's office, 413 House of Commons, 2026 Housing, 774
Supply, Committee of - Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Immigration, 754, 1711, 2143, 3051 Adjustment of war claims, 1711 Chinese, 2026
St. John immigration building, 2027 Salaries, 3499 Indians, 681, 1215, 3536 British Columbia, 1713 Destitute, 1712-14 Education, 1715, 3536 Field and garden seeds, 1712 General expenses, 1712 Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1058
Insurance, 791 Interim. See Interim Supply Interim Supply bill, 378, 598 Interior, 452, 1033
Dominion lands and parks, 1681, 3517 Migratory birds, 1684 National parks, 1051, 1681 Printing and stationery, 1680 Yukon, administration of, 1681 International Labour Conference, 1060 Joint Industrial councils, 1060 Justice, 451, 1274
Civil government, 1668, 3495 Exchequer court, 1274 Litigated matters, 1276 Supreme court, 1274 Yukon territory, 1275 Labour, 458, 493, 548, 1053
Conciliation and Labour Act, 1053 Employment Offices Co-ordination Act, 1058
Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1058
Unemployment relief, 1970, 2022 Lake of the Woods Control Board, 2025
Lignite
Bienfait briquetting plant, 1233 Utilization board, 3524 League of Nations, Permanent Secretariat, 2026
Lighthouse and coast service, 1495, 1677 Live stock, 971, 1018, 3521 Marine and Fisheries, 1676, 3051
Deep sea fisheries, conservation, 2169 Examination of masters and mates, 1490
Fish culture, 2169 Fishways, 2166
Investigation into wrecks, 1492 Life-saving service, 1494 Lighthouse and coast service, 1405, 1677 Salaries and allowances, 1497
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
'cxlviii

-Supply, Committee of-Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Marine and Fisheries - Con.
Marine signal service, 1499 Meterological service, 1501 Navigation, aids to, 1498 Navigation schools, 1492 Ocean and river service, 3507 Pilotage, administration of, 1499 Prince Rupert Drydock Co. claim, 3514 Registration of shipping, 1493 Removal of obstructions in navigable waters, 1493
St. Lawrence ship channel, 1494 Salaries of officers and guardians, 2166 Sorel shipyard, 1494, 2169 Steamboat inspection, 2169 Steamers and icebreakers, 1489 War claims, adjustment, 1677 Wrecking plants, subsidies, 1493 Militia and Defence, 415, 586, 1163, 1578, 1601, 1922, 2974, 3498 Allowances, active militia, 1135 Annual drill, 1163, 1578, 1610 Arsenals
Lindsay, 1979, 2085 Quebec, 1979, 2091 Battlefields memorials, 2098 Cadet services, 1972 Civil government, 415, 586, 3498 Civil pensions, 1711, 3499 Clothing and necessaries, 197S Customs duties, 1978 Engineer services and works, 1980 Maintenance of military properties, 1980
Ordnance arms, lands, etc., 1982 Ordnance building, Quebec, repairs, 1711
Permanent force, 1982 Reductions, 1174, 1578, 1631, 1972-87, 2091-98
Royal Military College, 1985 Salaries and wTages, 1985 School of instruction, 1985 Staff, pay of, 1982 Topographic survey, 1985 Training areas, 1986 Transport and freight, 1986 War claims, adjustment of, 2098, 2974 Mines and Geological Survey, 1233, 3524 Mines and Minerals, 685, 1234 Naturalization Act, 2024 Naval Service, 418, 1735 Dockyards, Halifax and Esquimau, 1752 Fisheries protection service, 1747 Hydrographic survey, 1746
Supply, Committee of - Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Naval Service - Con.
Patrol of northern waters, 1750 Radiotelegraph service, 1749	..
Royal Canadian navy, 1735, 1843, 1972, 2043
Salaries and contingencies, 1745 War claims, adjustment of, 1752 Newfoundland-Labrador boundary, 1276 Paris agency, 2025 Parliamentary guide, 2024 Passport office, 2026 Patent record, 2026 Penitentiaries, 1670 Pensions, 3522
European war and active militia, 1349 Madame Fabre, 2024 Post Office, 691, 1711 Outside service, 2799 Printing and stationery, 1711 Printing Bureau, 1970 Privy Council, 410 Public Archives, 702, 2025 Public health, 2017 Public Works, 692, 747, 1238 Dredging,, 2005 Harbours and rivers, 3541 British Columbia, 2005, 3547 Manitoba, 2003, 3545 New Brunswick, 1991 Nova Scotia, 1269, 1765, 3545 Ontario, 1999
Prince Edward Island 1270, 1988 Quebec, 1998, 3545 St. John harbour improvements, 2013 Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2004, 3547 Miscellaneous, 2008 Public buildings Alberta, 1254, 3545 British Columbia, 1255 Fittings, supplies and furniture, 1757 Generally, 1260-4 Immigration buidings, 1757 Lighting, etc., 1755 Maritime provinces generally, 1243 Ontario, 1245-68, 3544 Ottawa, 1265
Parliament buildings, 2014 Rents, repairs, etc., 1238, 1265, 1764 Rideau hall, 1756 Quarantine stations, 1238-45 Halifax, 1238 St. John, 1238-45 Williamshead, 1255 Quebec, 1245 Saskatchewan, 1253


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
cxlix
Supply, Committee of

Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Public Works- Con.
Telephone service, 1757 Roads and bridges, 2097 Telegraphs and telephones, 2007, 2012 Purchasing Commission, 2025 Railway Commission, 2773 Railways and Canals, 407, 3518 Arbitrations and litigation, 2772 Canadian Govt. Merchant Marine, loan, 3035
Canadian National railways, 1933. See also that title
Canadian Northern advance, 1905, 1933 Canals. See under this title. Canals Governor Generals cars, 1688 Giand Trunk arbitration, 2779 Hudson Bay railway, 1970 Intercolonial, 2767 Port Colbourne elevator, 1687 Railway policy, 1905, 1933 Salaries and contingencies, 1133 Surveys and inspections, 2779 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 775, 2129
Royal Canadian navy, 1735, 1843, 1972, 2043
Secretary of State, 701 Civil government, 1670 Naturalization expenses, 1671 Public archives, 1673 War claims, adjustment of, 1672, 2977 Seed Grain advances, 1053 Senate, 2026
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, 385 Capital expenditure, 1279 Employers' liability compensation, 1348 Operating expenses and working capital, 1347 Pensions
European war, active militia, 1349, 1353, 1361 Salaries, 1339
Unemployment relief, 1347, 1352, 3524 Vocational loans, 1346 War service gratuity, interest on, 1346 Soldier settlement, 2023, 2131 Statutes, reprinting, 1717 Steamship services, 2027, 3026, 3505 Supplementry estimates, 1662 Taxation, business profits, income, 2024 Trade and Commerce, 699, 3541
Canada Grain Act, administration of, 2834
Dominion Bureau of statistics, 1363 Gas and electricity, inspection, 1373 Gold and Silver Marking Act, administration, 1372
Supply, Committee of - Con.
Subjects and items discussed - Con. Trade and Commerce - Con.
Industrial and Scientific Research, 1372 International Customs Tariff Bureau, 1373
Linen yarn bounty, 1361 Printing of publications, 1373 Steamships services, 2027, 3026, 3505.
For individual services see that title Terminal elevators, 297S Trade commissioners and commercial agents, 1373, 2989 Unemployment relief. 1061, 3524-6 Victorian order of nurses, 772 War Graves Commission, 774 Water powers, 1051 Wheat Board, 3541 Yukon territory, 1034, 1275
Supreme Court
Cameron, Mr. E. R., K.C., estimate and expenditure, 1274 Decision. See Wheat Board Estimates, 1274 Library, 1274	.
Reports, 1274
Supreme Court Act Arndt, bill (Appeal from provincial courts of final resort) lr., 2456; 2r., com., 3r., 2974
Survey and Map Work. See also Interior Department Co-ordination of, 1986
Surveys. See also Dominion Lands; Geodetic; Geological; Topographic Water power resources, 1051
Sussex public building, 1239
Sutherland, Mr. Donald (South Oxford) Accredited herds, diseases, 1001 Adulteration of mill feeds, 1011, 2490 Agricultural implements, duty, 3134 Agricultural Instruction Act, 1012-1013 Air Force and civil aviation, 1731 Alderson claim, 1002-3 Beet sugar industry, 3251 Blake, late Hon. Edward, 2657 Budget, 2481. After war conditions; tribute to Finance Minister, 2481; election promises not carried out; breach of faith; the amendment; leader of Progressive party making excuses for Government; Hon. George Brown and violation of political pledges, 2482; statement of Prime Minister; Liberal declarations in favour of free trade;
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



Sutherland, Mr. Donald-Con.
Budget- Con.
Finance Minister chastises colleagues; opposing views in government party, 2483; a policy to suit every constituency; tacit understanding between Progressives and Liberals; public statements as to fiscal policy of Liberal party; Mr. Fielding and protection; duty on agricultural implements, 2484; reciprocity agreement; attitude of United States towards Canada; proposed duties under reciprocity, 2485; importation of agricultural products from the United States; world tendency to increase tariff barriers; valuation of currency, 2486; trade with Germany; labour costs; marking of goods; United States legislation to prevent unfair competition; industrial development of the West; sectionalism; two-party system;, 2487; Progressive party, origin and policy; record of the old1 Tory party; Union government tariff policy; Wartime Elections Act; tariff concessions to western Canada; Grain Growers' Grain Company contributions to political organizations, 2488; resignation of Mr. Crerar from Union government; statement of Mr. Rice Jones; Mr. Crerar's salary as president of United Grain Growers, 2489; oleomargarine; recleaned screenings; adulteration of mill feed, export duty on dairy produce; Mr. Rowell and Mr. Clark on tariff proposals of Union government; protective policy; Premier Drury and land tax, 2491; tax on unimproved land values; free trade; sales tax; condensed milk, 2492; railway situation; debt; inheritance from former Liberal government; Transcontinental railway, 2493; dumping clause; value of German mark; economy in administration, 2494; amendment, 2495 Cattle
Embargo, 1002, 1031 Free carriage of, 1029 Freight on, 1010 Stockyards, 1030 Condensed milk tax, 2492, 3266 Crowsnest pass agreement, M. (Mr. Kennedy, Essex) for Special Com., 1437, 1455
Customs revenue, qu., 614 Drainage tiles, 3270-1
Sutherland, Mr. Donald - Con.
Experimental farms, number of, 797, 801, 805, 813, 1015 M. to reduce item, 812 Farm tractors, duty on, 769 Feed Control Act, 1011 Filled milk and cream, qu., 963 Freight on hay for stock, 1007 Health of animals, Alderson claim, 1002-3-5 Hides, price of, 3139 Hog cholera, 1009 Alderson claim, 1005 Immigration
Bonus to agents, 3062 Unemployment and, 3058 Imports into Canada, qu., 610; qu., 612; qu., 613
Marshall, Mr. Duncan, 1032 Meat and Canned Foods Act, 3050 Militia _and Defence Arsenals
Lindsay, 2091 Quebec and, 1982, 2087-97 Expenditures and policy, 1981 Military properties, 1981 Naval Service, co-ordination with, 420 Pay of staff, M. to reduce item, 1982 Milk herds, tuberculosis, 1006	[DOT]
National Defence, department of, 1732-4, 1981
Naval policy, 2073 Royal Canadian navy, 2073 Oleomargarine
Importation of materials, qu., 613; qu., 704; qu., 728
Manufacture and importation, M. (Mr. Neill) 1816 Materials for, 3270
Oleomargarine Act Amdt. bill, 3432, 3487 Parliament buildings, purchase of furniture, 1756-7
Pensions Board investigation, 3156 Pensions Committee, 3348-9, 3357 Final report, 3351 Sales tax, 3270
Soldiers' bonus, M. (Mr. Arthurs) 447
Stallion clubs, 1031
Standard of living, 3139
Sugar beet industry, 3267
Wheat board, 2947
Wool, duty on, 3132-35
Sutherland, Hon. Dir. Justice, qu., 366 Swift Current post office building, 1253
Sydney, N.S.
Pilotage district, 3508 Reserve. See Indians


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX - 1922 Cll

[Stage Direction]
Sydney, N.S. - Con.
Steel workers, unemployment, 1076 Unemployment contracts for steel rails, 1688
Tadoussac-Murray Bay steamship service, 3035
Tampa Exhibition, 2026
Tar Sands. See Mines and minerals
Tariff, 1290. See also Budget; Customs; Trade. For items discussed See Customs Tariff
Amended resolutions, 2854 Australia, preferential treatment, 2110	*
Automobiles, 2116, 2186, 2206, 2230. See also Budget
Book paper for magazines, 2855 Canada-West Indies trade agreement, 2110 Changes, 2174, 2851 Cigarettes, 2855
Commission, proposed pex-manent, 2269, 2339,' 2351, 2625 Commissioner, 1663 Salary, 3504
Comparison with Laurier-Fielding tariff, 208
Dumping clause, 2184,	2197. See also
Speeches on Budget Duty on boots and shoes, 159-160 Fordney. See United States France, 2032
Fruit, 2197. See also that title Fuel oil, 344, 1761 Immigration and, 2157 Inquiry, 1920-21, cost, etc., qu., 2215 Legislation, history of, 2184, 2429-30, 2655 Liberal policy. See Liberal Convention of 1919
Ministers and Directorships, 1088 Prohibitory Central European, 2646 Reduction, 2111, 2114, 2286, 2844 Resolutions, 2118. For items See Customs Tariff
Amended, 2851, 2874 Bill, 3476-7 Revision, 2110-14 Former, 2426
Necessity for. See Speeches on Address; Budget
Shoe manufacturers and, 141. See also Boots and Shoes Tractors, 2115. See also Budget Unemployment and, 3527 Valuations for duty, 3413-15
Taschereau, Premier, and St. Lawrence river waterway, 137, 1191
Taxation, 2496. See speeches on Budget; Revenue Bills Amusement, 2395
Automobiles. See under this title, Sales tax Bachelor, 82 Bank circulation, 2117 Beer, ale, etc., 2117, 2567, 2852, 2857 Bond and stock transfers, 2117, 2853 Bonds held in United States non-taxable, 1133; qu., 2971
Breadner, Mr. R. W., Commissioner, salary, 2024
Burdensome, 2242, 2248, 2600, 2661. See also speeches on Address; Budget Urban population on, 2394 Business profits, qu., 1657, 1658, 2024, 21729, 2281, 2562, 2653 Administration of, 2024 British Empire Steel Comporation, qu., 1067
Canadian Ford Company, qu., 3599 Cheque tax, 1036, 2117, 2177, 2269, 2329, 2462, 2640, 2676, 2852, 2856, 3258 Protests against, 2395 Classification of income tax-payers, 1063 Condensed milk, 2492, 3264, 3271, 3409 Confectionery, 2177, 2641, 2676, 2852, 2857 Commodity tax, 2883 Consumer of, 2507 Customs. See Customs Tariff; Tariff Debt and, 2459. See also Public Debt Direct and indirect. 2386, 2402, 2648, 2707 Effect on trade, 2859 Estimated revenues from, 2172 Evasions, 2395 Excess profits, 2441, 2695 Express money orders and travellers cheques, 2856
Garbage collection tax in Ontario, 1256 Income, 2442, 2686. See also that title Administration of, 2024 Banks, payments by, qu., 1400 Forms, 3485
Members of provincial legislature, 3486 Railway men and commercial travellers, 3485
Revenue and classification, 1063; qu., 1399-1400 Inequalities, 2255
Inheritance tax, 184, 2442, 2510, 2601, 2626, 2686, 2708, 2844 Insurance
Foreign companies, 2462 Premiums, 2117, 3253
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
clii

Taxation - Con.
Land values, 2191, 2405, 2443, 2492, 2510, 2626, 2686, 2695-6, 2844,
Estimated revenue from, 2601 Loan companies, 2299 Luxuries, 2260, 2561, 2696 Modification of, 230. See Speeches on Address; Budget
Municipal, payment of by Government, 1256, 1257
Mutual insurance companies, 3477. See also under this title, Insurance New, 2116, 2177, 2329 Non-taxable bonds, 1133, 2971 Overlapping, 2463 Per capita, 2341 Post Office money orders, 2857 Principle of, 2281 Property, 2443
Provincial, payment to British Columbia govt., 1714
Receipts, 2270, 2853-7 Riordon Company, qu., 372; qu., 607 Sales tax, 2220, 2843. See also Special War Revenue bill
Ale, beer, etc., 2117, 2567, 2852, 2857 Automobiles, 2116, 2186, 2206, 2260. See also Automobiles; Budget Collections, qu, 375 Confectionery, 2117, 2641, 2676 Exempted goods, 2126 Beet pulp dried, 2852 Fertilizers, 2852
Goods on which tax was collected, 192122, 1212 *
Increase, 2393 Mineral waters, 2117
Soldier settlement, municipal taxes, 1257 Special War Revenue Act. See that title Stocks and bonds, 2856 Stock transfers, 2117, 2853 Telegrams and cables, 2117, 2178, 2856 Transient aliens, 2155
Taylor, Dr., qu., 1211
Technical Education. See Labour
Telegraphs. See also Wireless
Telegraphs and Telephones
British Columbia, 2008, 2012 Canadian National lines, qu., 3360 Humboldt-Fort Pitt telegraph line, 2007 Lower St. Lawrence and maritime provinces, 2012
Prince Edward Island, 2012 Public buildings, Ottawa, 1757 Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2007, 2012
Telegraphs and Telephones - Con.
Telegrams and cables, tax on, 2117, 2178, 2856
Yukon, cost of, 1275, 2012
Telephones. Sec Telegraphs and Telephones
Temperance. See Canada Temperance Act
Ten Eyck, Congressman, 1396
Terminal Elevators. See Grain and Grain Trade
Terminal Facilities. See St. John
Territorial Waters, Fishing beyond. See Fisheries Act Amdt.
Territories, Unorganized. See Royal Canadian Mounted Police
Textile Industry, 2882. See Speeches on Budget
Foreigners engaged in, 2518 Occupational diseases. See Labour Profits, 2632
Thompson, Colonel Andrew, soldiers' bonus, 403, 432
Thompson, Colonel ,T. T. C. See Pensions Board
Thompson, Mr. T. H. (East Hastings)
Dairy inspection, 1009
Dairy produce, grading of, 655-6
Stamp tax on cheques, 3261
Three Rivers Clerk of the Peace. See Criminal Code
Threshing Machines. See Agricultural Implements
Thunder Bay, icebreaking, 1677
Thurston, Mr. John J. (Victoria, Ont.) Immigration, travelling expenses, 757 Militia and Defence, Lindsay arsenal, 2085 River-gauging and metering, 2011 Trent canal, Nassau dam, qu., 2457
Tidal Fisheries. See Quebec Fisheries
Tidal Survey. See Naval Service
Timber. See also Lumber Acquisition of British Columbia areas by Japanese, 2311 GaspO, in, 625
Illegal cutting on Tobique reserve, 1233 Lease of Ontario areas, 2805; qu., 2992 Protection of. See Forestry


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
cliii
Tobacco
American Tobacco Company, 2547 Bull Durham, comparative prices, 2544 Cigarettes, duties on, 2394, 2547, 2852-3 Cigars, duties on, 2115, 2853, 2857 Duties, 2115, 2394, 2546, 2891 Experimental station at L'Assomption, 1776 Imperial Tobacco Company, 2546 Industry, protection, 2891 Raw leal, 2115, 2673, 2853
Tobin, Mr. E. W. (Richmond and Wolfe)
Canadian National railways, purchase of ties, qu., 1659
Oleomargarine, importation and manufacture, qu., 1506 Richmond and Wolfe Post offices, qu., 1507 Postmasters, qu„ 1508 Rural mail routes, qu., 1505
Tobin, Lieut. Col., Vancouver, letter of, 1975
Tobique Reserve. Sec Indians
Todd, Mr. W. F„ election promises in Charlotte, N.B., 1994
Tolmie, Hon. S. F. (Victoria City) Accredited herd system, 2738 Agricultural exhibitions, 650 Agriculture
Cattle embargo, 973-4 Dept., Mr. T. N. Lynton, 588 Live stock industry, 971.
Livestock trade with South America, 648 Salaries, 656
Animal Contagious Diseases bill, 2734-43 Bovine tuberculosis, 2738 Budget, 2591. Duration of previous Parliament; congratulations to Finance Minister, 2591; tariff and agricultural implements; trade relations with Australia; agricultural conditions; mixed farming, 2592; wool and sheep raising; dumping clause; British Columbia fruit industry; United States competition, 2593; tax on temperance beverages; fruit juices; grading hogs for the British market; extermination of hog cholera, 2594; United States system of dealing with disease; eradication of bovine tuberculosis, 2595; horse racing, Federal control of and revenue from, 2596; cattle export; embargo; new taxes; amendment, 2597;
Cold storage, 818
Entomology, orchard protection, 816
Tolmie, Hon. S. F.

Con,
Esquimau and Nanaimo railway bill, 1156, 1161, 1353, 1355, 1604 Esquimau dry dock, 597
Experimental farms, British Columbia, 796 Fisheries dept., 2166 Fishing schooner race, 3512 Fruit growers, protection, 2593, 3424 Health of Animals
Diseases, 968, 2594, 2738 Tuberculosis, 2594, 3521 Hog cholera, 2594, 2738 Horse-racing, federal control, 2596 Immigration of Japanese, 1289, qu., 1459 Marine and Fisheries
Examination of masters and mates, 1491 Lightkeepers' salaries and allowances, 1497
Ministers' secretaries, 413 Oleomargarine, M. (Mr. Neill) 1785 Opium and Narcotic Drug Act Amdt. bill, 2825, 3017
Oriental Aliens, M. (Mr. McQuarrie) 1567 Oriental immigration
Japanese, 1289, qu., 1399, qu., 1459 Patronage, civil service, 3083 Victoria post office building, repairs, 1255-8
Topographic Maps, qu., 1631 Topographic Survey, 1043 Tormentine Reef, buoy, 1499 T oronto
Campaign advertisement, 198-199 Cheque tax, 2395, 2329 Customs house, 198-9, 1246-51 Harbour improvements, qu., 365, 1187, 1467, 1471, 1474, 3541
Imperial convention of teachers, 1673 International yacht race, 3513 Post Office, qu., 108-9, 368 Building, 1246-51 Revenue, 1250
Power plant, public ownership, 123 Prison reform, municipal farms, 1277 Railway facilities, 66 Viaduct, qu., 1660 Railway grades, reduction of, 74 Rate increases, 131 Representation of, 1365
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment staff, 1343 Steam railway freight, qu., 936 Street railway Public ownership, 1937 Service, 63
Toronto Suburban railway, qu., 2457 Transportation commission, 130 Unemployment, 86
Volume I; 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
cliv
[Stage Direction]
Toronto Electric Light Company, 123 Tourist Traffic
Banff-Windermere highway, 1681 Highways, 1681. See also that title Visitors to Canadian National parks, 1052
Town Planning, Banff, 1052
Townsend, United States Senator, 1206
Tracadie Lazaretto, 1240, 2021
Tractors, 769, 2354, 3123. See also Agricultural Implements
Value $1,400 and less to be free, 2115
Trade and Commerce, 2108. See also Customs and Excise; Exports; Imports; Speeches on Budget; Tariff Agreements and negotiations, 2110, 2172 Agricultural implements, in, 2620-1. See also that title
Australia, with, 9, 174-5. See also Steamship Services Austria, with, 2535
Bills to be preceded by resolution, 1283 British Preference and Canadian seaports.
See British Preference Canada-Mexico, qu., 606, 699-700, 2989 Canadian ports by, 104. See also British Preference Channels of, 336-7
Competition, 223. See Speeches on Budget Consular agents, repeal of Act of 1921, 3222, 3477
Consular certificates, 2114, 3222, 3477 Department
Canada Grain Act, administration, 2834 Estimates, 1361, 2834, 2978, 3026, 3541 Salaries, etc., 699
Elevators, terminal, maintenance and equipment, 2978
Exchange value of commodities, 2868 Expansion, 2021
Export. See St. John Terminal Facilities Exports and imports, 1876-77 and 1921-22, qu., 1376. See also Imports Foreign. See also Germany France-Belgrium, 3223 Freight rates, effect on, 276 Germany, with, 138, 2203, 2279, 2535, 2859.
See also Customs; Germany; Speeches on Budget
Great Britain, 2540. See also British Preference
And United States, 2369 International, 2862 Interprovincial, 2284
Trade and Commerce - Con.
Italian, effect of currency valuation on, 2849
Mexico, with, qu., 606, 699-700, 2989 Necessity for revival, 105. See also Budget; Industrial Depression; Speeches on Address
Potatoes. See that title Russian, consortium to re-establish, 1463 Southern Pacific dominions, 2990 Steamships Services. See that title Total
1876-77 and 1921-22, statement, 1376 1900-1921, qu., 1633 Statement, 1376
Trade commissioners and commercial agents, 1373, 2114, 2581, 2989 United States with, 2223, 2449-50. See also that title
West Indies. See St. John Terminal Facilities; Steamship Services
Trades and Labour Congress
Oriental immigration, 1514 Unemployment insurance, 1081
Transatlantic Traffic. See St. Lawrence River Waterway
Transcontinental. Sec Canadian National Railways
Transportation, 2580, 2611. See also Crows-nest Pass Agreement; Freight Rates; Railways; St. Lawrence River Waterway
Cattle, free carriage of, 1029 Commodity and freight rates, 234 Costs. See Freight Rates Farm products of, 231 Fish, 2166 Loss of, 175
Maritime provinces in, 106-111, 2687-8 Nationalization, 2325. See also Canadian National railways
Problems. See Budget; Speeches on Address. See also that title St. Lawrence River Waterway, 269 M. (Mr. Church) 1183, 1203-8 Tonnage rates, 234 Water, 1939
Trawlers. See Naval Service
Treaties. See also Conferences Anglo-Japanese, 168 Chinese Customs Tariff Treaty, 3161 Far Eastern, 3160
Four Power. See Limitation of Armaments
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
civ
T reaties - Con.
France-Beigium, 3223 Hungary and Turkey, 3490, 3547 Tabled, 3359
International Opium Convention, qu., 1066 Japan, with, 1511
Lemieux treaty with, 1459 Limitation of Armaments, 3158 Peace treaty with Germany, Lusitania claims, 3599 Pelagic Sealing, 1844
Prevention of use of noxious gases and 1 chemicals, 3159
Protection of neutrals and non-combatants at sea. 3159
Quadruple Pacific, 3160 Versailles, 2848
Treaty of Peace with Hungary and Turkey
bill
lr„ 3490; 2r., com., 3r., 3547
Tree Planting. See also Forestry Provincial highways, qu., 2039
Tremblay, General, Quebec Harbour Commission, 1477
Trent Canal. See Canals
Trenton Harbour bill
Res., 3436, 3493; lr., 2r., com., 3494; 3r„ 3495
Trepanier, Alderman, of Montreal, 1392
Trial by Jury, 1388. See also Criminal Code Arndt.
Trusts and Combines, 2395, 2414. See also Address; Budget Minister of Labour and, 200
Trust Companies Act Arndt, bill
lr., 1210; 2r., ref. to Banking and Commerce Com., 1464; com., 3r., 3142; Senate amdts., 3607
Tsur, Dr., Chinese-Consul General, 1776
Tuberculosis. See also Health; Hospitals Bloc areas, 3521
Bovine, 2556, 2595, 3521. See also Animal Contagious Diseases bill Indians, 1225, 1228
Returned Soldiers. See Pensions; Returned Soldiers' Insurance; Soldiers' Civil Re - establishment
Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment hospitals, 1344
Tupper, Sir Charles, and maritime union, 107108
Turgeon, Mr. Onesiphore (Gloucester)
Address in reply, 273. Congratulations; maritime provinces and the Intercolonial, 274-276; government ownership of railways, 277; tariff questions, 278; natural resources of western provinces, 279
Budget, 2188. Mr. Fielding's visit to Washington; Fordney tariff; relations with the United States, 2189; public debt; income and business profits taxes; economy; British preference; duties on farm implements, 2190; fishing industry; lumber; alcohol for medicinal purposes; sales tax; taxation of land values, 2191; Liberal platform of 1919; capital and labour; immigration, 2192; railways; Transcontinental; opposition of C.P.R., 2193; board of directors; grain shipments, 2194; public ownership; Intercolonial, 2195; regional control of Canadian National railways, 2196
Canadian National railways Board of directors, 2194 Hanna and Mitchell, Messrs., salaries, qu., Public ownership, 2193 471
Transcontinental
Grain shipments, 2194 Opposition of Canadian Pacific to, 2194 Canadian Pacific railway, cost, 2193 Civil Service patronage, 3082 Immigration, agricultural workers, 2193 St. John terminal facilities, 848 Single tax, 2191
Turkey, Peace Treaty with, 3359, 3547
Turtle Mountain Forest reserve, qu., 615
Ukrainians. See Immigration
Ultra Vires, Canada Grain Act, 1132
Undesirables, deportation of. See Criminal Code; Immigration; Opium and Narcotic Drugs
Unemployment, 1290, 2331, 2627. See also Address; Budget; Canadian Patriotic Fund bill; Housing; Immigration; Labour; Returned Soldiers Agricultural conditions and, 2158 Banff-Windermere road, 1052, 1682 Canada, number in, qu., 3362 Cities, in, 86
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
clvi


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039.	IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
clvii
United States-Con.
Medical inspection of immigrants for Canada, 2022	.
Military expenditure, 1622
Oriental immigration, 1515
Pecuniary claims convention with, 1276
Pelagic Sealing Treaty, 1844
Railway difficulties, 67-70, 129, 1917-18
Railways
Dines in Canada, 204 Purchase of, 2611
Reciprocity, 77, 102, 2111, 2201, 2285, 2368, 2463, 2485, 2511, 2527, 2616, 2694, 2846. See also Address; Budget St. Dawrence and Welland canals, 2749 St. Dawrence river waterway, 1184, 1315 1396. See also that title Treaty, consideration of proposed, 2207 Steel prices, 2412 Tariff discrimination, 2466 Tariff legislation, 113, 988, 2487, 2620-1, 2864. See also under this title Fordney Trade, 2111, 2178, 2610,. See also under this title, Reciprocity Cattle, 2695 Relations, 2908 War operations, 1336 Washington
Hon. Mr. Fielding's trip to, 2112, 2189, 2300
Wrangel Island, 1751 Russian claim to, 2208
Unopposed Motions for Papers
Algoma Indian lands, timber leases (Mr. Simpson) 942
Appraisers, Paris and Dondon, (Mr. Parent) 1068
Avignon, Que., post office (Mr. Marcil) 829 Bonaventure
Mail contract (Mr. Marcil) 829 Post office, (Mr. Marcil) 829 Caisse, Mr. J. J., Montreal post office (Mr. Marcil) 828
Canadian Expeditionary Force, 112th Battalion band instruments (Mr. Martell) 372
Canadian Northern and Grand Trunk insurance (Mr. Macdonald, Plctou) 828 Canadian Northern bonds (Mr. Stevens) 2458
Canadian ships, damage during war (Mr. Bristol) 1183
Caraquet and Gulf shore railway (Mr. Hanson) 1183
Carleton, Que., post office (Mr. Marcil) 829 Cattle embargo, Hon. Manning Doherty (Mr. White) 616
Unopposed Motions for Papers

Con.
Civil Service bonus, (Mr. Garland, Carle-ton) 828
Dauphinee, Mr. Charles, dismissal (Mr. Baxter) 2584
Dominion Iron and Steel Co., contract (Mr. Caldwell) 616
Extra-territorial rights (Mr. Meighen) 1068 Fisheries
Establishment of independent department (Mr. Martell) 372 Transfer to British Columbia (Mr. Me-Quarrie) 2042
Fort Edward lands (Mr. Martell) 372 Genoa conference (Mr. Boys) 1905 Grand Trunk Railway Company 1921 loan, (Mr. Putnam) 828
Griffenhagen and Associates report (Mr. Seguin) 1633
Holland, Dee, deportation (Mr. Meighen) 372
Hudson Bay, St. John parish patents (Mr. Garland, Carleton) 829 Hudson, Govt, cutter (Mr. Baxter) 3600 Immigration
Foreigners admitted as farmers (Mr. Stevens) 1068
Western lands, on, 616 (Mr. Stevens) Indian agency, Bear river, N.S., (Mr. Dovett) 828
Inverness Railway and Coal Co., (Mr. Chisholm) 372
Kootenay flats (Mr. Humphrey) 286 Degal costs, payments (Mr. Martell) 2971 McQuarrie, John C., dismissal of, 377 Mail contract, Rigaud-St. Redempteur (Mr. Ouimet) 1776
Migratory Birds Convention, infraction, (Mr. Martell), 377
Nanaimo County judge (Mr. Neill) 2042 Nautical assessors (Mr. Church) 1633 Newspaper censors (Mr. Archambault) 1068 Nova Scotia
Barristers, payments (Mr. Martell) 707 Miners, McBachlan correspondence (Mr. Stewart, Deeds) 616
Order of Grain-Baggers (Mr. Stevens) 2806 Page, Mr. H. W. A. claim (Mr. Neill) 2042 Palais station, Que. (Mr. Parent) 1068 Parc St. Charles Company (Mr. Marcil) 372 Paspebiac post office, (Mr. Marcil) 829 Post Office department (Mr. Seguin) 3600 Purchasing Commission, origin of goods (Mr. Raymond) 2042 Quebec
Bridge (Mr. Parent) 1068
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
clviii

Unopposed Motions for Papers - Con. Fisheries (Mr. Mareil) 616 Harbour Commission (Mr. Meighen) 372 Sardines for export (Mr. Grimmer) 1183 Shigawake post office, (Mr. Mareil) 829 Sorel shipyards, dismissals, (Mr. Hanson) 377
Tobacco experimental station L'Assomp-tion (Mr. SSguin) 1776 Tug Pekin (Mr. Maclean, Prince) 1289 Victory bonds, (Mr. Putnam) 942 Winnipeg strike (Mr. McMurray) 1068 Yukon territory
Royalty on minerals (Mr. Black) 616 Transfer of mineral claims, (Mr. Black) 616
Universal Postal Union, 3173
Universities, Physical drill and military training, 1615
Unrestricted Reciprocity, Hon. Edward Blake on, 2677
Urban Population, loss of. See Immigration; Population
Vancouver
Anti-Japanese riots, 1511-16 Assay office, 1236
Ballantyne pier, wages of workmen, 1465, 1469
Board of Trade drydock, 2009 Customs aerial patrol, 1730 Drydock, 1255, 1484, 2005, 2009, 3542 Board of Trade telegram, 2009 Expenditure in, 2309 Free port, proposal, 2470 Harbour, 1473. See also Vancouver Harbour Commission bill Mounted Police barracks, Fairmont, 1255 Ocean tonnage, 2008 Post office building repairs, 1255 Railway duplication at, 74-75 Shipment of grain from, 235 Sun, criticism of Hon. John Oliver, 2237 Unemployment conference, 1069 Unemployment relief camps, 86
Vancouver, Fraser Valley and Southern Rail-
*way Company, 798
Vancouver Harbour Commissioners Act
Arndt, bill (Port Warden and Shipping . Master) lr., 1929; 2r., com., 2821; 3r., 2996
Vancouver Island coal mines, 178
Vancouver Sun, criticism of Hon. John Aliver, 2236-7
Vegetables. See also Root Vegetables Dumping clause, 2372. See also Speeches on Budget
Production of near Montreal, 1019
Versailles, Treaty of, 2848
Vessels. See also Canadian Government Merchant Marine; Shipbuilding Aurora. See Naval Service Britisher, 3514
Canadian Exporter, wreck of, qu., 1210 Canadian Farmer, 2311 Canadian Freighter, qu., 963, 2311 Canadian Inventor, 2312 Canadian Prospector, 2311 Canadian Winner, 2311 Champlain, qu., 1400 Con Rein, 1382
Foreign ships of war, exemption from pilotage dues. See Canada Shipping Act
Hudson, Government cutter, qu., 3598 James Whalen, 1677 Lambton, wreck of, 1492, 3507 Mildred McColl, 3598 Niobe, sale of. See Naval Service Ocean-going, 1471. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway Patrician. See Naval Service Patriot. See Naval Service Pekin, 1289
Phalarope, patrol boat, 1503 Plamonder, dredge, 2006 Quebec, in and out of, 1471 Scottish, 3514
Vickers Company, 320, qu., 936 Claim, 2975 Elevator dredge, 1494
Victoria, B.C.
Drydock, 2009. See also Quebec Harbour Commission bill Govt, expenditure in, 23.09 Lightkeepers' salaries, 1497 Ocean tonnage, 2008 Post office building, 1255 Wooden ships constructed at, qu., 364
Victoria Bridge. See Bridges
Victoria Memorial Museum
Geological specimens, 1237
Potlach institution, 1377. See also Indians
Victorian Order of Nurses, 772
Unemployment, relief of, 86


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



[Stage Direction]
clix
Victory Bonds. See also Finance Exempt from taxation, 263 Five year maturities, qu., 2993
Vidal's Point Park, 1052
Vien, Mr. Thomas (LotbiniSre)
Daylight saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 948 Dominion lands, cancellation of leases bill, 3467
Senate amdts., 3615 Duty on apples, 164
Esquimau and Nanaimo Railway Company bill, 1161
Judges' Act Arndt, bill, 426 Military expenditure and policy, 1145 National Defence bill, 661 Mounted police, 675 Pension Act Arndt, bill, 3451 Point of order, Rule 18, tedious repetition, 1360
Rail and car repair contracts, 1695 Royal Canadian Navy, 1868-89 Soldiers' bonus, 440
War, advances to Imperial Government, 1288
Wheat Board, 2969 Vimy Memorial, 2098
Vitamines, 1781	#
Voters, qualification of. See Dominion Election Act; Euler; Rinfret
Wabana Ore, 2412-13
Waddington, Mr., 398
Wage Cuts. See Nova Scotia Miners
Wage Investigators. See Labour
Wages. Sec Labour; Unemployment
Wallace, Mr. J. A, (Norfolk)
Tuberculous cattle, 2742
Wallace Shipbuilding Company, 3542
War. See also Militia and Defence Battlefields memorials, 2098 Canadian and United States armies, operations, 1336
Claims, adjustment of, 1155, 1672, 1677, 2098, 2977
British Admiralty, 1752 Details of estimates, qu., 1288 Hospital ship, claim for loss, 1082, 2975 Militia and defence, 2974 Naval service, 1752
Repatriation, dependents of soldiers, 1711
War - Con.
Conscription and, 2570. See also that title Conscription of wealth, 2725 Debts, 90, 174. See also Address; Budget; Public Debt
Demobilization, expenditure for, 1155, 1163, 1171
Equipment, 2616 Expenditures, 2228
First Canadian Contingent, qu., 1376 Foreign ships, exemption from pilotage dues. See Canada Shipping Act Imperial War Graves Commission, 2099 Indebtedness, 2294 Kemp, Sir Edward, 1169 Laws of. See Limitation of Armaments Medals, 1752, 2975 Mewburn, Hon. S. C., 1169 Mobilization of unfit men, 2608 Munitions, shipment of from Great Britain, 1154-63 Newspaper censors, 1068 Overseas ministry, 1169 Pensions. See that title Preparation for, 1335. See also Militia and Defence; National Defence; Naval Service
Profiteering, 2221, 2247, 2395, 2440, 2455.
See also speeches on Budget Reparation claims, Lusitania, 3599 Results, 91, 2588, 2861-2, 2895 Scandals, 90
Taxation and, 2567. Sec also that title War memorials Commission, 2098
War Finance Corporation, 54
War Graves Commission, 774, 2098
War Measures Act, 662, 663, 1362
War Purchasing Commission, sale of warlike stores, 1171
Ward, Mr. W. J. (Dauphin)
Animal Contagious Diseases Act Amdt. bill, 2738
Apple-growing industry, 3419 Boy Scouts, 773
British Columbia fisheries, M. (Mr. Mc-Quarrie) 863
Budget, 2400. Congratulations to Finance Minister; reactionary and mysterious budget, 2400; the tariff; protection and indirect taxation; drydock on Pacific qoast; purpose and principle of protection; invisible government; Canadian manufacturers a Bourbon; free trader when purchasing; pro-
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922 clxl

[Stage Direction]
Water Powers - Con.
St. Lawrence and Ottawa rivers, on, 629 St. Lawrence river, M. (Mr. Church) 1183, 1205, 1314. See also that title Surveys, 1051 Welland canal, 2747
Water Transportation, 70, 73-74. See also St. Lawrence River Waterway Canals in United States, 68
Waterways. See Canals; International Joint Commission
St. Lawrence river, 1183. See also that title
Watson, Major General Sir David, 1477
Ways and Means, Committe of, 362, 599, 1842, 2104, 2854, 3104, 3246, 3409, 3476, 3604, 3607
Amended resolutions, 2854 Interim Supply bill, 599 M. for (Mr. Fielding) 2104 Resolutions, 2118; amended, 2854 Supply hill, 3607
Wednesday Sittings. See House of Commons
Welland Ship Canal. See Canals
West Indies
Canada-West Indies trade agreement, 2110 Subsidized steamship services and freight rates, 3026, 3032
Trade with. See St. John Terminal Facilities
Western Provinces. See Budget; Natural Resources; Speeches on Address Agricultural depression, 1475 Flags on public schools, 1265 Marketing of grain, 114. See Wheat Board Natural resources, 7, 12, 22, 41, 148, 279, 328, 1017. See also that title Interest of other provinces In, 23, 340, 355, 1017
Public buildings, alleged discrimination against, 1254
Weston post office, 1259
Westport Railway. See Brockville and Westport
Wharves. See also Harbours and Rivers; Public Works Baddeck, 1269 L'Orignal, qu., 1212
Provincial, New Brunswick, transfer, qu., 2305
Wharves - Con.
Provincial wharves and tidal waters, 1991 Sault Ste. Marie, 2006 Selkirk, 2004
Tidal waters in, 1991, qu., 2209
Wheat. See also Agriculture; Grain and Grain Trade; Wheat Board Competition with Russia, 2157 Cost of production, 114 Dumping of. See Customs, dumping clause Duty on, 239
Early seeding in West, 115 Exports to United States, 209 Fordney tariff and, 210. See that title under United States Free trade in, 2528
Freight rates on, 300. See also Freight Rates
Kubanka, 2454
Marketing, 46-47,' 53, 115, 151, 231, 2453. See also Budget; Speeches on Address; Wheat Board Prices of, 152
Shipments through Vancouver, 235 Transportation, 233. See also Railways;
St. Lawrence River Waterway United States demand for, 333
Wheat Board, 31, 283, 338; qu., 472, 1118-20. See also Agriculture and Colonization Com.; Budget; Grain and Grain Trade; Grain Commission; speeches on Address
Agriculture Com. report of:
Arndt. (Mr. Sutherland) to M. for concurrence in, 2951; neg., 2969 Concurrence in report, delay, 2306 Canadian Council of Agriculture memo, 377 Constitutionality of, opinion of Law Officers, 940 Fixation of prices, 2588 Kay, Mr. privilege, 872 Participation certificates, qu., 2304 Re-establishment of, demand for, 72, 115, 146, 152, 158, 232
Wheat Board Bill. See Canadian Wheat Board Bill
White, Mr. James
Newfoundland-Labrador boundary, 1276, 3495
White, Mr. J. F. (London)
Budget, 2352. Congratulations to Finance Minister; election pledges, promises and arguments; tariff proposals; proposed permanent tariff commission,
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619
i

clxii

White, Mr. J. F. - Con.
Budget - Con.
2352; western agriculture; freight rates; climatic conditions; Wheat board; agriculture and protection; importation of farm produce; wider markets; free trade; farm tractors; tariff and manufacturers' profits; trade with Germany; unemployment, 2354
Experimental farms, 810 Lake Huron, marine allowance, qu., 1930 Soldiers' Civil Re-establishment, salary increases, 406
White, Sir Thomas, resignation of directorships, 1089, 1102
White Lead, duty on, 2297
White Slave Traffic, Suppression of, 3497
Whitley Councils, 1061
Widowed Mothers, Pensions. See Pensions' Committee
Wife Disertions. See Pension Act Amdt. bill
Wilson, Mr. G. C. (Wentworth)
Highways, approved, qu., 2040
Windermere Road, 1051, 1682
Windsor, N.S. removal of derelict in channel, 1493
Windsor, Ont., Canadian Transit bill. See Private Bills Discussed
Wines and Spirits. See Customs Act Amdt. bill
Winnipeg
Strike, 1068
Andrews, Mr. Alfred J., 1068 Royal Canadian Mounted Police, 671-9 Trials, cost of, qu., 1182 Unemployment, 86
Winnipeg River. See Lake of the Woods
Winnepegosis Wharf, 3545
Winter Ports in Canada. See Intercolonial Railway
Wireless Telegraphy. See also Radio Lighthouses and, qu., 370 Marconi Wireless Telegraph Co., qu., 1063
Wives, Foreign-born, of British Subjects. See Dominion Elections Act, M. (Mr. Euler)
Wolves, destruction of livestock by, 990, 998999
Women
Alien born. See Dominion Elections Act Representation in Parliament. See Mac-phail. Miss
Voting in last election, 185
Wooden Ships, qu., 364
Woodmen of the World, 1905
Woods, Mr. R. J. (Dufferin)
Address in reply, 92. Congratulations to Miss Macphail, 92; changes in political parties; attitude of Progressive party; greater markets for farm products, 93; tariff revision; farmers not concerned with politics, 94
Budget, 2183. Tariff; history; classification; reductions; sales tax; added burden to consumer; dumping clause, 2184; free raw materials and high duties on finished products, protection on farm implements, 2185; duty on clothing, woollens, etc.; automobiles; Ford car; effect of 25 per cent duty; drawback system; farmers and protection, 2186; speeches of the Prime Minister in 1920; manufacturers free traders in raw materials; protection as it affects the consumer, 2187; agricultural implements, 2188 Canada Temperance Act Amdt. bill, 3004 Daylight Saving, M. (Mr. Kay) 953 Militia and Defence Annual training, 1582 Expenditure and policy, 1582 Sales tax, 3264
Woodsworth, Mr. J. S. (Centre Winnipeg) Address in reply, 84. Economic disturbance, 84-85; demand for markets; home market; unemployment, 85; unemployment insurance, 88; production, factors of; equipment; transportation question, 89; tariff revision; national debt and taxation; war fortunes and war scandals, 90; Defence department; relations with United States; war legacies, 91; reconstruction-, 92 Blankets, duty on, 3132 Budget, 2242. Conservatives and Liberals, origin and policy; extension af franchise to ordinary people; agriculture and business interests not identical; labour view; sales tax unduly burdensome to family man, 2242; civil service pay;


Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619



INDEX -1922

[Stage Direction]
clxili
Woodsworth, Mr. J. S. - Con.
Budget - Con.
immigrants to pay taxes and feed the railways; an administration bankrupt in ideas; no economic changes proposed; drifting and borrowing; "mortgaging the homestead"; foreign ownership of natural resources, 2243; concentration of wealth; railway exploitations; alieniation of lands and resources, 2245; mergers and watered stock; consolidation of financial organizations; grain trade and, 2246; the Great War and profiteering; financing, 2247; burden of taxation; repudiation; capital levy; income tax, 2448; profits and property rights vs. human welfare; labour and capital, 2250 Cadet camps, 1973
Canadian Government Merchant Marine, employees' wages, qu., 3598 Canadian National railways Directors, representation of employees, 2798
Steel cars, qu., 2213 Civil Service, 3075 Bonus, 3533
Industrial councils, 1061 Patronage, 3097 Salaries, 2243
Criminal Code Arndt. (Sedition and Criminal Conspiracies) 364, 865, 1396, 3104 Debates, inaudibility of, 1755 Disarmament, 1143 Pishing schooner race, 3510 Immigration Act Arndt. (Bill 16) 364, 864, 1388, 3104
Immigration, British artisans, 2208 Immigration-Criminal Code bills Report of Special Committee, 3281 M. to refer back, 3282 Income tax, taxpayers, qu., 1399-1400 International Labour Conference, 3601 Joint industrial councils, 1060 Labour
Industrial engineer, 494 Mounted Police and, 670-1 Military policy and expenditures, 1143 Military Service Act repeal bill, 424, 639 Ministers and Directorships, 1127 Mounted Police in unorganized territories, M., 829, 841
National Defence bill, 670 Naval Service, Royal Canadian navy, 1854 Nova Scotia miners, M. (Mr. Irvine) 516; qu., 605
Woodsworth, Mr. J. S. - Con.
Oriental labour on British ships, 2042 Post Office employees' salaries, 2801 Quebec Harbour Commission bill, fair wage clause, 1486
Railway Commission, representation of labour, 2776 Russian relief, 3516 Save the Children Fund, 3516 Unemployment Relief, 3526
Returned soldiers, 2458 Situation, 1069-84
Unemployment Service Council, 2803 Winnipeg strike, Andrews correspondence, 2042
Wool. See also Agriculture; Livestock Blankets, duty on, 3128 Duty on, 2415 Prices of, 985, 997
Woollen clothing, prices and labour cost, 2205, 2350, 2632. See also Speeches on Budget
Workmen. See Labour
Workmen's Compensation Act, 88, 1381
Wrangel Island, 1750, 1751 Russian title to, 2208
Wrecks. See Marine and Fisheries; Ships and Shipbuilding
Yacht Racing. See International Deep Sea Racing
York County, Ont., representation, 1365
Yorkton, Sask., Speech of Prime Minister at, 2730
Young, Arthur and Company, qu., 365, 1490
Yukon Territory
Administration of Cost, 1681 Justice, 1275 Expenditure, 1275 Expenses, population, qu., 2456 Government of, 1034 Mineral discoveries, 1276 Parcel post, 2802 Radiotelegraph service, 1749 Telegraph line, 1749
Union for judicial purposes with British Columbia, 1275
Zaneth, Corporal, 671
Volume I:: 1-1015. Volume II: 1017-2033. Volume III: 2035-3039. Volume IV: 3041-3619