1912-02-28

Mr. SEXSMITH moved:: j That the first report of the Select Standing Committee on Agriculture and Colonization be referred to the Joint Committee of both Houses on the Printing of Parliament..


Mr. HENDERSON.: Mr. Speaker, before that motion is adopted I would like to say that it seems to involve a different procedure from what we have been accustomed to in past years. Formerly the House ordered at once the printing of the report of the evidence taken -before the committee on Agriculture and Colonization and members were -able to get copies -during the session and send them out into the counties. Now, if w-e have to awiait the -action of the Printing Committee, which -only sits now and again, I am afraid we will not receive these copies nn-til -after the House prorogues -and -the result will be that they will be sent ho-me to us when we will be too busy, or when we will not h-av-e the facilities for distributing them, and they will practically be unused. I would certainly favour very much th-e old procedure in which the House adopts the report-s and recommends the printing of them forthwith.


Sir WILFRID LAURIER.: I have to remind my hon. friend (Mr. Henderson) that we -adopted a different rul-e this very session, only a few days -ago. Everything now has to go to the committee on printing.


David Henderson: I was not -aware of su-oh a rule. If such -a -change has been made I db no-t think it is in the interest of this report.


Mr. SPEAKER.: I w-o-uld like to say in reference to this report that it was handed in -before, that the committee h-av-e sat a-i least once or twice since -and it might have been passed long ago. But, -at any rate, the rule was adopted th-at no printing of this nature would -be -ordered unless it was submitted to the Printing Committee -appointed for the purpose of considering such questions.
Motion -agreed'to.



QUESTIONS.

[Stage Direction]
(Questions answered orally are indicated by an asterisk.)
['The policy involved in the proposition made requires some discussion, but we will take it on the second reading of the Bill.\nResolution concurred in and reported.\nMr. BORDEN moved for leave to introduce Bill (No. 116), to amend the Civil Service Act.']
Thomas Simpson Sproule: With reference to questions Nos. 2 and 3, -I notice that they are not in proper f-orm, and therefore will stand until they -are brought within -the rule.


Wilfrid Laurier: I understand you to rule, Mr. Speaker, that question No. 2 is at variance with the rules of the House. The question i-s as follows:
Is the government aware that Frederick Passmore Gutolius, recently appointed to the National Transcontinental Commission, is not a British .subject?
Mr. -SPEAKER, There is -an allegation o-f fact in the queisfion.


Wilfrid Laurier: 
Wilfrid Laurier: That is a sufficient answer, that he has not been.


Mr. BORDEN.: We -are not dealing with the -answer, but with -the propriety of the question.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: The -statement of fact i-s th-at he is not a British subject. The -ques-

tion should have 'been asked, is hie a British subject ?


Wilfrid Laurier: May I ask you, Mr. Speaker, about your ruling on the question of Mr. Lainarche respecting the resolution of Mr. Sevigny, relating to the repeal of the tew respecting the naval service of Canada ? I understood you to rule that it was out of order.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: I did not rule tlrat question out of order. I merely requested that it stand to be a Mttle differently arranged. My attention was drawn to it hurriedly just before coming into the House, and I thought it well to let it stand until I could consult the member who is asking it, 'and have it put in proper form.



Mr. MACDONALD:: 1.	Is John Fraser still acting as inspector of the roundhouse extension at Stellarton, Nova Scotia?
2.	If not, when did he cease to act as inspector P
3.	How much has been paid him for his cervices ?


Mr. COCHRANE:: 1.	No.
2.	February 23, 1912.
3.	Two hundred and twenty-five dollars ($225).


NATIONAL TRANSCONTINENTAL RAILWAY-INSPECTOR OF STATIONS.
Mr. PAQUET.: 1.	Is there in. the service of the Transcontinental Railway Company, as inspector of stations from Li vis to Ste. Perpetue, an employee named Goulet, and what is his Christian name?
2.	When was he appointed, and what is his salary?
3.	What was his former occupation?
4.	What qualifications has he for the position of inspector?
5.	Who recommended him?
6.	Where does he live now, and where did he live before his appointment?
7.	Is it the intention of the government to keep him in the same position?


Mr. COCHRANE.: The following information has been received from the National Transcontinental Railway Commission:
1.	Yes. Theodore.
2.	September 12, 1911, salary $100 per month and $25 monthly for board.
3 and 4. Saw mill operator and building contractor.
5.	Recommended by Division Engineer Dick, and appointed by the eommision-ers.
6.	He lives at St. Anselme now and lived at Indian Lorette before his appointment
7.	Yes.


PROVINCE OF MANITOBA-EXTENSION OF BOUNDARIES.
Mr. OLIVER:: 1.	What is the eastern boundary of the territory to he added to the province of Manitoba, in accordance with the resolution of which notice has been given by the Prime Minister?
2.	What is the approximate area of the territory to be added to the province of Manitoba by .the resolution?
3.	What annual sum is to be paid as and from the 1st day of July, 1908, in accordance with the terms of subsection (b) of the resolution, and on what date is the first of these payments to be made?
4.	What is the basis of the deductions to be made from the payments of interest on capital allowance in lieu of debt mentioned in subsection (b) of the resolution, and what are the details of such deductions?
5.	What deductions are to be made on account of swamp and university lands, or on any other accounts, from the annual payment of $562,500 to the province of Manitoba under subsection (c) of the resolution?
6.	Upon what basis are the deductions mentioned to be made and what are the details of those deductions?
7.	Is any portion of the swamp and university lands mentioned in subsection (c) of the resolution to be returned to the Dominion? If so, what acreage is to be returned?
8.	What amount is to be paid annually to the province of Manitoba as and from the first day of July, 1908, in accordance with the terms of subsection (o) of the resolution, after all deductions mentioned in said subsection (c) have been made?
9.	On what date is the first payment under subsection (c) of the resolution to be made ? ?
10.	What is the basis of the calculation upon which the sum of $201,723.57 is to be paid tc the province of Manitoba towards the construction of public buildings?


Thomas Simpson Sproule: I do not know whether it is present to the mind of the hon. gentleman (Mr. Oliver) but I notice that this refers to a Bill which is before the House. Perhaps the question was asked with the intention of bringing out this information at a time when the Bill may not have been before the House.


Robert Laird Borden: I think the information was sent to the hon. gentleman yesterday. It was also given in debate as far as I know. Perhaps the question might drop.


Mr. OLIVER.: The information given in the debate may have covered the points embraced by the questions, but the questions were asked before the Bill was brought forward. Certain consecutive, and at the same time, pertinent questions are asked, and I think they are entitled to an answer.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: 


Robert Laird Borden: be transferred to the government of Canada. Approximately 838,484.16 acres have been sold by the province out of the 2.005.439.96 acres of swamp lands conveyed to Manitoba under this section up to the end of 1909. No portion of the university lands will be returned to the Dominion under the resolutions.
8 and 9. As to the four years, July 1, 1908, to June 30, 1912, there will be payable to the province approximately an estimated arrearage for each of the four years of $342,000, made up as follows: Allowance in lieu of lands . . . . $562,500 Swamp lands deduction,
average say	$105,500
University lands deduction	 15,000
Heretofore received under section 3 of chapter 50 of the Acts of 1885.. .. 100,000	220,500
Estimated	arrearage	for	each
year	 $342,000
Estimated arrearage for the four years, payable whenever any Act founded on these resolutions comes into effect	$1,368,000
There will be payable to the province of Manitoba yearly, after July 1, 1912, in respect of indemnity for want of public lands, until the population of the province exceeds 800,000, as follows:
Indemnity	for	want	of	public
lands	 562,500
Swamp lands deduction,
approximately	$134,230
University lands deduction	 15,000

  149,230

10. The provinces of Alberta and Saskatchewan respectively received, under ' The Alberta Act,' and ' The Saskatchewan Act,' to provide for the construction of public buildings, the sum of $468,750, the payment of which was spread over five years. The province of Manitoba has heretofore received from the Dominion, on account of the construction of. the legislative buildings and Government House at Winnipeg, the sum of $267,026.43. The $201,723.57 referred to in the resolutions is the difference between the amounts already mentioned.


INTERCOLONIAL-GRAND TRUNK ARBITRATION.
*Mr. DAVIDSON:: 1.	When was the Arbitration Board, provided by Chapter 16, 4th Edward VII., respecting arbitration between His Majesty and the Grand Trunk Railway Company relative to the Intercolonial railway, appointed?
2.	What matters are still undetermined that were referred to that board?


Mr. BORDEN.: 3.	How often have extensions been obtained under the fourth section of said chapter, and when was the last extension?
4.	What explanation, if any, is given for the delay in closing this arbitration?
5.	Is the Grand Trunk still continuing the alleged violation of the agreement with the Crown as to routeing of freight?
6.	What sums of money have been paid by the Crown to arbitrators and to counsel and solicitors up to the present time, and what are the names of the recipients of the respective amounts?


Mr. COCHRANE:: 1.	The dates of the appointment of the
members of the board are:	Eugene Lafleur, Esq., K.C., on the 12th October, 1903, and on his refusal to act the Hon. Charles Peers Davidson, Esq., was appointed on the 5th day of May, 1904. George F. Shepley, Esq., K.C., on the 21st day of August, 1903 ; the appointment of Mr. Justice Killam as third Arbitrator was assented to by the government on the 26th day of April, 1904; on the decease of Mr. Justice Killam, Chief Justice Falconbridge was appointed in June, 1909.
2.	A claim by the Crown known as the Quebec Central railway dispute and having reference to the deliveries by the Intercolonial of freight received from the Quebec Central railway.
A claim by the Crown in reference to the improper division of through rates.
A claim by the Crown in reference to diversion of traffic by the Grand Trunk railway.
A claim by the Crown in reference to diversion by Intercolonial railway.
A claim of the Crown in reference to the improper division of through rates under the contract of February 1, 1898.
A claim in reference to a number of disputed accounts.
3.	No extension has been obtained. Section 4, of chapter 16, of 4, Edward VII, having been amended by chapter 15 of 5 Edward VII.
4.	The matters involved being of an extremely complicated and difficult character; the death of Mr. Justice Killam and later the illness of Mr. Shepley.
5.	No.
6.
A. C. Killam	$6,250	00


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: Falconbridge 1,000	00


George F.: Shepley	
11,262	20Judge Davidson	
750	00
The following amounts have been paid to solicitors:
William Cook	
3,750	00J. W. Cook	
11,572	91A. Falconer	
4,215	00R. C. Smith	
4,065	73Cook and Magee	
121	50


MARRIAGE LAW.
[Stage Direction]
Question not in order.
The following question having been called:
Mr. BURNHAM.: 1.	Has the right hon. the leader of the opposition seen the article from the Toronto ' Star as quoted below


THE MARRIAGE LAW.
[Stage Direction]
Although Judge Charbonneau's judgment clears the air, it does not settle the question. It is not the judgment of a final tribunal, and there are other decisions which conflict with it. Even if a judgment of the Supreme Court of Canada or the Judicial Committee be obtained it may not cover the whole ground.
The Dominion parliament ought to enact a law covering the full extent of its power. At present, although it is generally admitted that the Dominion Parliament has full power to declare who shall and who shall not be competent to marry, the federal statute legalizes a marriage with a deceased wife's sister. The law should set forth exactly what are the prohibitions to marriage. It should declare that no spiritual court has any power to annul a marriage or grant a divorce, and impose a penalty upon any person attempting to exercise that authority.
Mr. Holmested, in his book on the marriage law, says that all provincial courts which now grant divorce should be superseded by a Dominion court. At present the law is not uniform, and the administration is not uniform. In the maritime provinces and in British Columbia there are divorce courts; and there is a different law on the Atlantic and on the Pacific. In the other provinces there is no divorce court, and resort must be made to the Senate. It is easy to see how this diversity would facilitate the making of unfounded claims to authority in the province of Quebec.
A Dominion statute, covering the grounds thoroughly, would be a strong assertion of the civil power, which would tend to discourage usurpations and unfounded claims to authority. It is true that the provinces have power to deal with solemnization. But the question of solemnization may be confused with that of competence. Thus, in Quebec, the attempt was made to distinguish between the kind of solemnization necessary for Protestants and the kind necessary for Catholics.
It may also be found that provincial legislation is necessary. Mr. Holmested, for instance, says that a minister should be forbidden to exact, as a condition of solemnizing marriage, any condition as to the education of children. It mav be necessary also to make further provisions for surrounding the solemnization of marriage with safeguards, and protecting innocent parties from deception. The more strongly and definitely the civil power asserts itself, the less danger will there be of clerical interference. The State has been neglecting its duty; the remedy lies in its doing its duty.
2.	If so, does he approve of the sentiments contained in the same?
3.	If not, wherein does he disapprove of them, speaking generally?
Thomas Simpson Sproule: In my Opinion this question cannot be asked as at present worded in that it does not comply with the rules. Under the rule, it is the right of an hon. member to ask any question of a minister of the Crown or of a private member as to a Bill, or motion, or some order before the House in which that private member is interested, and beyond that I do not think the rule goes. I shall quote several decisions of Mr. Speaker Brand, which apply to questions of this kind, so that hon. members may have knowledge of the rule and be guided by it in puting questions on the order paper. Mr. Speaker Brand says:
A question which involves a matter of argument and statements of opinion is irregular.
This question asks for a statement of opinion from an hon. member and is, therefore, irregular. Mr Speaker Brand further says:
A question must not contain a statement of fact which is disputed nor a matter of opinion.
This question contains a statement of fact which may be disputed and it asks as well for an expression of opinion, all of which is irregular. Then, (Mr. (Speaker Brand says:
Expressions of opinion cannot take the form of a question.
This question asks for an expression of opinion and to that extent it is outside the rule. Mr Speaker Brand further says:
An argumentative question, not referring to anything arising out of debate in the House, or with intention to draw an argument from a comparison of two statements is out of order.
In my opinion this question to some extent violates that rule. Mr. Speaker Brand also says:
An allegation, of fact which is disputed ought not to appear in a question.
This question deals with an allegation of fact which is, of course, disputed, and to that extent it would be irregular. For these reasons I will have to ask the question to stand until the hon. member puts it in proper form.


NAVAL SERVICE ACT.
[Stage Direction]
Question out of order.
The following question on the order paper, having been called.
Mr. MiONDOU.
1. Does the government intend to repeal the Naval Service Act?
[Stage Direction]
2.	Will the proposal for the repeal of this Act he followed immediately by the proposal of another Act containing the new policy of the government in the matter?
3.	If so, will this new policy >be submitted ,for the approval of the people before being put in force?
Thomas Simpson Sproule: In my judgment this question ought to be put in different form before it is properly permissible to be asked in the House.


HUDSON BAY PORTS.
Mr. AIKINS:: 1.	What steps have been taken during this year, or are being taken, to ascertain the practicability of Port Churchill or the mouth of the Nelson river as ocean ports, and as to which of the two will be the better for a terminus of the Hudson Bay railway?
2.	What steps are being taken to provide for the better navigation of Hudson straits?


Mr. HAZEN:: 1.	Department of the Naval Service.-In the season of 1910 a hydrographic survey was made of Port Churchili by the Department of the Nava] Service. A chart of the harbour has been prepared, which is at present in the hands of the printer, and will shortly be published.
In the seasons of 191 [DOT] and 1911 hydrographic surveys were made at Port Nelson by the Department of the Naval Service. A chart of the harbour has been prepared, which is at present in the hands of the printer, and will shortly be ready for publication.
Department of Railways and Canals.-The department is sending engineers to make observations, and report, as to the conditions of the harbours of Port Nelson and Churchill, that may assist in reaching a conclusion as to the suitability of those points for the terminus of the Hudson Bay Railway.
2.	Department of Railways and Canals.- This department has taken no steps in the matter.


MONTREAL HARBOUR EMPLOYEE, .T. A.
Mr. MACDONALD:: 1.	Is the honourable the Minister of Marine and Fisheries aware that J. A. Masse, employed by the Harbour Commission of Montreal, is said to have published over his signature in ' La Patrie ' of February 22nd ultimo, a letter censuring the conduct of the Hon. C. J. Doherty, Minister of Justice, in the matter of patronage?
2.	Is it the intention of the honourable minister to dismiss Mr. Masse?


Mr. HAZEN:: 1. The Minister of Marine and Fisheries has no knowledge of the letter in question.


Mr. MONDOU.: 2. No. The power of dismissal is not vested in him.


MONTREAL HARBOUR OFFICIALS.
Mr. CARVELL:: 1.	Who appointed the various officials employed by the Harbour Commission of Montreal?
2.	Are said officials allowed to canvass members of parliament to obtain promotion?
3.	Are any of the officials of the Harbour Commission of Montreal to be shortly superannuated ?
4.	Is it the intention of tlie Minister of Marine and Fisheries to promote Toussaint Bourassa, deputy harbour master of Montreal ?


Mr. HAZEN:: 1. The Harbour Commissioners of Montreal.
2 and 3. The Department of Marine and Fisheries has no information on this subject.
4.	No. Under section 18 of the Montreal Harbour Commissioners Act, 1899, the right of appointment is vested solely in the Harbour Commissioners.


BOUNDARIES OF QUEBEC.
[Stage Direction]
Mr. BORDEN moved that the House do to-morrow go into Committee of the Whole to consider the following proposed resolutions :
[Stage Direction]
Resolved, that it is expedient to extend the limits of the province of Quebec so that the boundaries thereof shall include, in addition to the present, territory of the said province, the territory hounded and described as follows:-Commencing at the point at the mouth of East Main river where it empties into James hay, the said point being the western termination of the northern boundary of the province of Quebec as established by virtue of chapter 3 of the statutes of 1898, intituled ' An Act respecting the Northwestern, Northern and Northeastern Boundaries of the Province of Quebec/ thence northerly and easterly along the shores of Hudson bay and Hudson strait; thence southerly, easterly and northerly along the shore of Ungava bay and the shore of the strait; thence easterly along the shore of the said strait to the boundary of the territory under the jurisdiction of Newfoundland; thence southeasterly along the westerly boundary of the said last mentioned territory to the middle of Baie du Rigolet or Hamilton inlet; then westerly along the northern boundary of the province of Quebec as established by the said Aot to the place of commencement.
Motion agreed to.

[Stage Direction]
Mr. BORDEN moved that the House do to-morrow go into Committe of the Whole to consider the following proposed resolution.-

Resolved, that it is expedient to extend the limits of the province of Ontario so that the boundaries thereof shall include, in addition to the present territory of the said province, the territory bounded and described as followsCommencing at the most northerly point of the westerly boundary of the pro-yince of Ontario as determined by the Canada (Ontario) Boundary Act, 1889, chapter 28 of the statutes of 1889 of the United Kingdom (the said westerly boundary being the easterly boundary of the province of Manitoba)'; thence continuing due north along the same meridian to the intersection thereof with the centre of the road allowance on the twelfth base line of the system of Dominion Land Surveys; thence northeasterly in a right line to the eastern point of Island lake, as shown m approximate latitude 53° 30' and longitude 93° 40' on the railway map of the Dominion of Canada, published, on a scale of thirty-five miles to one inch, in the year one thousand nine hundred and eight, ' by the authority of the Minister of the Interior; thence northeasterly in a right line to the point where the eighty-ninth meridian of "LeSTT l°n"titude intersects the southern shore [DOT]ot Hudson bay; thence easterly and southerly following the shore of the said bay to the point where the northerly boundary of the province of Ontario, as established under the said Act, intersects the shore of James bay; thence westward along the said boundary, as established by the said Act, to the place of commencement.
Motion agreed to.

[Stage Direction]
For a copy of all charges made against Dr. t. R. McLeod, port physician at Port Hawkes-bury, N.S., the evidence taken before H. P. Duchemin in support of such charges, and his report on the same, and of all correspondence and telegrams between the said H. P. Duchemin and the Department of Marine and Fisheries or any official thereof in relation thereto.-Mr. Kyte.
For a copy of all charges made against Dongald R. Boyle, fishery overseer at West Arichat, Nova Scotia, and of all correspondence and telegrams between the Department of Marine and Fisheries or any official thereof and any other person in relation thereto - Mr. Kyte.
For a copy of all petitions, correspondence, orders in council, memoranda, or other papers or documents bearing date after January 1, 1910, in the possession of the Department of Marine and Fisheries, relating to the granting of licenses to fish for herring, salmon and all kinds of fish in the waters on the coast of the province of British Columbia, and also relating to the transfer of such licenses to any *person other than the original licensees, also relating to the licenses to pack fish in British Columbia.-Mr. Sinclair.
For a copy of all documents, letters, requests, _ reports and recommendations in the possession of the Post Office Department, relating to the dismissal of Done Daoust, postmaster at Alfred county of Prescott, and the appointment of his successor.-Mr. Proulx.
For a copy of all papers, recommendations to council, orders in council, or any other papers in connection with or having reference to the promotion of Mr. Binks to he superintendent of the Dead Letter Office.- Mr. Henderson.

[Stage Direction]
_ Mr. PARDEE. I wish to call the attention of the Minister of Public Works to a return which was asked for on the 22nd of January, regarding certain harbour improvements in the town of Sarnia, and which has not yet been brought down.
Robert Laird Borden: I will direct the attention of the Minister of Public Works to the question of my hon. friend.


ST. JOHN VALLEY RAILWAY.
[Stage Direction]
. Mu CARVELL. I wish to call the attention of the Minister of Railways to a question which was answered on the 14th of February, regarding a proposed agreement between the Dominion government and the government of New Brunswick, and the Quebec & New Brunswick Railway Company. In his answer to that question the minister stated:
As soon as the necessary documents are prepared a copy of the same will be laid on the table of the House.
I would ask the hon. minister if an agreement has been entered into, and, if so, will the document be laid on the table of the House?
Mr. COCHRANE, It has not yet been entered into; it is under discussion.

[Stage Direction]
^ House again in Committee on Bill (No. 77), to encourage and assist the improvement of highways.-Mr. Coohranie.
On section 5-provisions of agreement.
Wilfrid Laurier: I would like to ask my hon. friend if it is intended to have a general rule with regard to the maintenance of highways, applicable to all the provinces, or is each case to be dealt with by itself?
Mr. _ COCHRANE. There is nothing in the Bill about maintaining highways. It refers to the construction and improvement of highways.


Wilfrid Laurier: This section says: ' That provision may be made for the future maintenace of such highways in good condition, according to a specified standard and to the satisfaction of the Governor in Council.' This legislation is altogether new,_ and everybody can foresee that in the application it must meet with several practical difficulties. It has been observed in the discussion of this Bill that the
[DOT]394-

maintenance of the highways may be as costly as their original construction, if not more so. What I asked my hon. friend is, whether he intends to have a general rule, applicable to all highways or whether each case shall be left to itself. That is to say: Will the Dominion itself undertake to maintain any highways or will these be left to the local authorities? Or is it intended by my hon. friend to maintain some highways and leave others to the care of the province? In many provinces the municipality within which the highway is .situated, is charged with the maintenance, and it would seem to me to be obvious that a general rule should be applied in the case of all highways, otherwise serious difficulties are liable to be encountered.


Francis Cochrane: There is a great deal in what the right hon. gentleman says, but I think that for the first few years at least the money should first be expended on the improvement of highways leaving the other matter to the counties in the province until later on at all events. The object of the Bill is to obtain good roads all over this Dominion as soon as we can possibly get them, and I think it, would be a safe policy to leave their maintenance, for a time at any rate, to the provinces or to the counties in which they are situated.


Mr. MACDONALD.: Will the minister tell us what he proposes to do in a case where the right to open a new highway in a province is vested in the municipal council, and the provincial council as such has nothing to do with the matter? _ Apparently under this section the minister proposes to leave that as a matter of agreement to the provincial government, but that may not give them any right whatever in the road at all. In the province of Ontario, I think, the title to a highway is vested jin the municipality. The right to open a new road, or to divert or close any existing road, or anything of that kind, must come from the municipality. How does the minister propose to reach the municipality in such a case?


Francis Cochrane: Through the provincial governments. I do not anticipate any trouble of that kind. I think the hon. gentleman is right about the municipality having control of the roads within its boundaries, and if it objected I do not know but that we would have to stop unless some amicable arrangement was made. I do not think there is any law to compel the municipality to give up control. However I do not anticipate any trouble, on the contrary I think the municipalities will welcome the proposal.


Wilfrid Laurier: Obviously however there is some difficulty. At the present time in the province of Ontario and the province of Quebec the highways Sir WILFRID LAURIER. ,
are all under the control of the municipal council. The municipal council would have no objection at all-


Francis Cochrane: In Ontario the county council has jurisdiction too I think.


Wilfrid Laurier: The county council has jurisdiction over some roads, the local council has jurisdiction over others. I am prepared to believe there is nto municipal council, whether it be a county council or a local council, which will have any objection to its roads being improved, but the law may be of such a character as to make the maintenance of highways more expensive than it is at the present time. I foresee some difficulties in regard to this matter-difficulties not unsolvable by any means, but certainly of a real character-and what I was anxious to know was, whether my hon. friend (Mr. Cochrane) intended to have a set of rules published and made known so that all municipalities might be aware of them, or whether if it is his intention to have each case determined by itself as it arises?


Robert Laird Borden: Conditions of course might vary, not only as between provinces but within a province-


Wilfrid Laurier: I understand that.
Mr. BORDEN-and I do not know whether it is possible in considering this matter to foresee how best to deal with all those varying conditions. It was in the mind of the members of the government, in framing this measure, that it would not be a wise policy to spend a great deal of money in bringing any particular road up to a high standard, unless some reasonable arrangement could be made for maintaining that standard. The right hon. gentleman says very truly that that might perhaps be a larger burden than the province or municipality might be willing to undertake. I appreciate that fact, and certainly it must be taken into consideration in carrying out the assistance which is proposed by this Bill. I do not know at the present moment that we can foresee what difficulties such considerations may absolutely present, but I do thoroughly realize that these difficulties will have to be met. I agree with the right hon. gentleman that such difficulties ought not to be insuperable; that where a road has been constructed, according to a certain standard, by the assistance of moneys contributed under this Bill, it would be practicable to provide some measure of assurance that that road would be maintained at the standard at which it had been constructed.


Wilfrid Laurier: What I had in mind was, that unless the minister in charge of this Bill.came to the conclusion

that we must have a general set of rules which ought to be applicable in all cases- not in any absolute manner, because it would not be possible-that he will be led into very serious difficulties. If such a set of rules were published, which every municipality would be aware of, and to the standard of which it would endeavour to attain, I think a great many difficulties would be obviated.


Robert Laird Borden: I think there is a great deal of force in what the right hon. gentle-has observed in that regard, and we shall certainly bear it in mind. As I understand him, he thinks the government should prescribe some general standard, for a particular district at least-


Wilfrid Laurier: Hear, hear.


Robert Laird Borden: And that standard must be lived up to before aid is to be given. I think there is a great deal to be said in favour of that idea.


Mr. G. H. BAKER (Brome).: Before the clause passes I have a word or two to say in reference to the matter. It seems that on the second reading of this Bill the general principle of road aid was pretty well admitted, and for very apparent reasons. The roads form an important part of the large problem of transportation, to which the government has given great attention. We can understand that the broad question of aid to roads would be a principle to be generally admitted. Transportation is one of the principle factors in the nationalization of our country. It is an important factor in commerce and in production, for without good roads the development of our country would be absolutely impossible. Of what avail would be the great crops of our farm and the products of our mines if there was not proper transportation to carry these products to the markets of the world? The good roads question has received the attention of the several provinces. Within comparatively recent years the province of Quebec took the matter up, and has now a measure before it to deal with the matter. Last year the province of Quebec spent about $400,000 on the development of highways. Previously its policy took the form of aiding the different parishes and the different municipalities, by making to them certain grants and paying for a certain proportion of the work. That scheme went on for several years and some advantage has been derived from it. Now it seems they are departing from that mode of giving aid, and have set aside $10,000,000 by which they propose to pay interest and a sinking fund to aid municipalities. That is to say the municipalities will borrow money for the purpose of the construction of roads, and the provincial government will undertake to
pay two per cent on the interest and two per cent on the sinking fund so that the debt will be eventually wiped off.
The amount of aid granted under this new system will not be materially more than the aid under the old system. Under the_ old system about $400,000 was granted, which is just the interest at 4 per cent on $10,000,000. But, for some reason or other the Quebec government felt that they would rather have the money in their pocket in order to deal with the matter in this new way. I would not presume to venture an opinion, but perhaps they feel that the way to their return to power in the next provincial elections would be improved, if they had the money in their pockets


Mr. BUREAU.: Is that the way you feel about this measure so far as the federal government is concerned?


George Harold Baker: I have no particularly keen feeling about the measure, Mr. Chairman; I am only remarking that though the scheme in relation to Quebec is changed, yet the amount of aid is not really materially increased; and some of us are of the opinion that the fact that the general elections are about to come off in Quebec may have something to do with the change of system, and the desire of the government to have cash in their pockets before they discuss the question of highways. That may or may not be, but from experience in the past, some of us hold that opinion. Now, in Quebec the dealing is directly with the municipality; each parish, each township is dealt with directly by the government in constructing these good roads. In Ontario, the system is different. Before the Ontario government will aid in the development of roads, the county must take over the roads, lay out a large county system and then expend the money in the development of that system. In that way in Ontario they would have between forty and fifty county systems, which, you can readily understand, could be developed into a provincial system. But in the province of Quebec, dealing as they do with municipalities, parishes and .townships, they would have about six hundred separate systems, about six hundred different modes of building roads, making it much more difficult to reconcile differences and unite all in a provincial system. Viewing this question from a Dominion point of view, my opinion is that we must not come in too close contact with the separate municipalities. We must keep at a view point from which we can see the system as a whole and consider its advantages to the Dominion as a whole. Therefore, it seems to me better to deal with the provinces than with the municipalities. Although I am interested in getting all possible aid for for the province of Quebec, yet I am in



regard to the topography of the country. In many cases it will 'be found expedient to build around grades and hills which will make the road very much easier and, therefore, much more useful to one public. Under the direction of a scientifically trained engineer, who understands the technical requirements of road planning and construction and who is familiar with the topography of the country, .a road could be built in such a way that its usefulness to the public would be very materially increased. By forming these roads in the provinces, by joining them up into Dominion roads, by having a Dominion highway when the time comes for it, and I trust it will not be very many years, an extra bond will be created to bind the different parts of this country together. The present bond of the railways has worked wonders, but the great distances between the stops, travelled at a high rate of speed, lessens the advantages of this mode of intercommunication as compared with the advantages that will be derived from a national highway. There will be upon the national highway greater intercourse between the people of the different provinces, there will be slower locomotion and the life on the roads will tend to bring the citizens of the different provinces shoulder to shoulder in daily intercourse, and will do much in the way of enabling the citizens of the different provinces to understand each other's weaknesses, and each other's strength. In that way there will grow up. I believe, through the aid granted to these national highways, one great Dominion fellowship the effect of which will be greatly enhanced by the existence and influence of such a gigantic work as that which is contemplated by the measure now before the committee. For these reasons I have great pleasure in supporting the Bill.


[Stage Direction]
Section agreed to.
On section 6-the minister may undertake construction and improvement of highways,
Mr. PBOULX.: I think the government is making a mistake in going into the construction of roads and not giving the money to the provinces. The provinces have now a system of road construction. Ontario went into the construction of roads some years ago. The government of Sir George Boss provided $1,000,000 to help the counties in building roads. About) twenty counties received the provincial aid. What the people want is not trunk roads. The Ontario Good Boads Association met the other day in Toronto and that opinion was expressed by many of its members, amongst whom was the president, who said that the people wanted township and Mr. BAKER.
county roads, and not trunk roads. The province, I think, is in a better position to build township and county roads than trunk roads. If the government is going to undertake to build roads it is going to duplicate the work of the provinces, and, therefore, it is going to spend tne money uselessly. I think the proposition of the hon. member for Guysborough (Mr. Sinclair), was right that the money should be given to the provinces according to population. The province of Quebec also inaugurated a system of good roads a few years ago, and it is going into the work this year very extensively. I believe that the people would get much more benefit from the money spent in this way 'than if the work were left to the Dominion. We want roads leading to the villages and towns, especially the county towns, to the local markets of the farmers, since we cannot get the American market. I therefore, propose that section 6 be stricken out.


Andrew Archibald MacDonald: Before this clause is considered I would like to say a word or two in order that I may understand really just what is the position of the government, in regard to this whole Bill. On the first reading of the Bill my right hon. friend the leader of the opposition asked the Minister of Bailways, the following question:
I would ask the hon. gentleman to tell us if there is any basis of allotment among the provinces. The provincial subsidies are based on population; is this based on population?
The Minister of Bailways and Canals said:
It is to be on the same basis as that on which subsidies are granted to the provinces, in other words, by population.


Mr. BLAIN.: What page? ,


Andrew Archibald MacDonald: That is read by the minister at page 3734 of ' Hansard.' When this Bill was introduced and discussed on the second reading it clearly went on the assumption that we were dealing with a proposition by the government to grant to each one of the provinces, under a system which would be on a parity with that which exists in regard to subsidies, a certain sum of money to be devoted to tire improvement of roads.
Sections 3, 4 and 5 of the Bill contemplate the federal government making a grant to the provincial government in aid of the construction of roads, the presumption being that the expenditure would be made by the provincial government. I do not think there can be any objection to that method, but if that method be not pursued, then we will have a most curious jumbled up system of road expenditure in the country. Apparently, under the first five sections of the Bill, the idea is, that the Dominion gov-

eriiment will, in agreement with the provincial government, utilize all the provincial and municipal machinery and have a unification of authority and a practical working out of a system under which the roads will get the benefit of the money without _ any unnecessary expenditure for supervision or inspection by the federal government. But section 6 is entirely out of touch with that theory. Under section 6 it apparently is contemplated to originate a new system of expenditure by the federal government in the construction of roads, entirely apart from the provincial and municipal arrangements. The Prime Minister argued the other day that at the end of section 6, there was a limitation, because the federal government had to obtain the authority of the provincial legislature and the consent of the Lieutenant Governor in Council, but that addendum does not mean anything at all, because it was not possible for the federal government to enact any law that would enable it to spend any money upon any provincial road in this country without the consent of the provincial government or the municipality that owned the roads. The officers of the federal government would be trespassers if they ventured to go on any road anywhere in Canada without the consent of the provincial government. The important feature of this is that under section 6, the minister is given power to take the whole amount allotted to any province to expend it as he pleases. We ought to be frankly told what the policy of the government on this question is, because if it be as I have indicated then I would move that the clause be stricken out. I submit that the provinces are the proper authorities to deal with the roads; they own them, they have for fifty years provided machinery for making and approving them.


Francis Cochrane: Did you not say that the townships owned the roads?


Andrew Archibald MacDonald: Yes.


Francis Cochrane: Thena according to your view, we would have to go back to the townships.


Andrew Archibald MacDonald: Certainly, you would have to go to the municipalities. If the minister expends any money on roads in Nova Scotia he would have to go to the municipalities. Not only that, but we have the statute labour system there under which every person who lives along the highway is compelled to contribute in labour or money annually for its maintenance. The provinces have had years of experience of working in conjunction with the municipalities; they have provincial engineers who know all about the character of the soil and the difficulties to be met with in permanent road construction and drain-mi
age, all of which must be considered when you come to expend money on roads, and if the federal government is to spend the money, exercising only its own judgment, then we will be throwing away the experience of fifty years that the provinces and the municipalities have had in road construction. Where you have had wise expenditure on roads by municipalities and provinces, and in view of the growing public opinion and the growing interest in favour of good roads, it seems to me that the federal government should not directly enter into the arena and complicate the whole situation. I can conceive that the federal government could render valuable aid in this matter by the establishment of a good roads bureau such as the federal government has established in the United States, and by which uniformity of conditions could be brought about throughout the Dominion. But, if the federal government is going to undertake the work of constructing roads themselves, I believe they will throw away a tremendous lot of money on inspection and supervision before they get down to actual real expenditure of money on the roads themselves. The first five clauses of the Bill, with certain amendments which have been suggested, would meet with my approval, but section 6 is entirely in subversion of the principles laid down in the previous clauses.


Robert Laird Borden: It seems to me that my hon. friend (Mr. Macdonald) is unduly disturbed about this. The first part of the Bill provides for grants out of the federal treasury to the provinces, under certain safeguards as to expenditure, cost of construction and various other considerations which ought he taken into account, and my hon. friend is willing that these sections should become law, while to section 6 he strongly objects. Well, the sixth section provides that where the government of a province is willing, the federal government may undertake the work itself instead of handing the money over to the province, and that seems to be a very proper provision. The hon. member inquires whether there is to be a general policy of federal expenditure under this section in every province of Canada.
No one could give him that information in the first instance, 'because I am sure he would be the first to understand that the efficiency of the organization may vary greatly in different provinces. In one province you may have a thoroughly effective system, under which the construction and improvement and maintenance of highways are carried on. In such a province it is perfectly clear that the best course would be to hand the money over to the provincial government or under some ar-

rangement with the provincial government, so that the existing official organization anight be made use of in the expenditure of money. But it may happen that in some other province the organization is not very effective, and that the provincial government itself, under the authority of the provincial legislature, might desire the expenditure of the proposed aid in this way. If such a condition should arise, the money could only be expended in that way with the consent of the province. I see no reason why authority should not be given in this Bill to enable a proposal of that kind to be carried out. It was for that reason that this clause was inserted in the Bill. It is possible that it may be used only very occasionally, but, whether occasionally or otherwise, it seems to me to be one to which no valid objection can be made, and one which might be found very useful in carrying out the proposal of the government for the improvement of highways in the various provinces.


Mr. DEVLIN.: What organization does the right hon. gentleman refer to when he says that the organization in some of the provinces may be effective?


Robert Laird Borden: The organization of the road service.


Mr. GORDON.: I want to ask the Prime Minister a question in reference to this matter. This is one of the most important proposals ever made in the country, and the government deserve great credit for it. What I want to see is something that- can be worked out in a practical way to bring the greatest good to the farmers who use ilihe Ihighways. The federal government might make a grant of a certain percentage, to be supplemented by the provincial government wherever the people in any community agree to raise a certain amount for the purpose, and then have the counties take over and maintain these roadways thereafter at their own expense. The community in which I am interested is ready at the present time to raise a certain amount of money; but how can it under this Act get the assistance it wants from the provincial and federal governments, and then get the money expended in a way that will secure permanent roadways by having uniform specifications and a method of construction that will ensure the judicious expending of the money? If the community wishes to get the assistance that is supposed to be within its reach through the medium of this Bill, how can that be worked out so that the parties will all come together and build these roadways?


Robert Laird Borden: I can say to my hon. friend, who has made a very practical suggestion, that in the course of preparing this Bill a good many suggestions more or less Mr. BORDEN
along the line which he has mentioned were brought to our attention. We had under consideration the placing in this Bill of some percentage which must be provided by the province and by the municipality if a certain other percentage were provided by the federal government; but it was impossible to get the necessary information as to conditions in all the provinces of Canada to justify us in fixing a hard and fast rule of that kind in this Bill. I would like to assure my hon. friend that the idea which he has just presented very clearly to the House is one that has been in the mind of the government, and I would like also to assure him that it would be perfectly possible under the provisions of this Bill to work out a scheme of that kind, and it is for that reason that the provisions of this Bill are couched in the general form in which they now appear.


Wilfrid Laurier: The question at present 'before the House is not one connected with the general purpose of the Bill. That general purpose is to aid out of the federal treasury in the building of highways. Up to the present time this has been considered to be not only a provincial work but a municipal work. Section 6 is not at all a corollary of the previous sections. All the previous sections converge to one idea, that is, that the money should be voted by parliament and should be expended by the provinces or in concert with the provinces. But the section now under consideration defeats to a large extent the previous sections. It provides that the money, instead of being handed over to the provinces to be by them expended, may be expended by the Dominion government or by the Minister of Railways. My hon. friend from Pictou (Mr. Macdonald) has I think very properly suggested the objection there is to investing the Minister of Railways with such a power as is described in that section, and the only answer which the Prime Minister has made is that if it is to be done at all, it must be done by the Governor in Council. So far so good. What I say is that there should not be even the power to make such a bargain with the local governments. This work is not intended and cannot be intended to come within the purview of the federal parliament. It cannot be contended that it was ever the intention of the British North America Act, in making a division of powers between the local legislatures and the Dominion parliament, that the Dominion government should become highway constructors. The fathers of Confederation laid dowrn very clearly what should be the duties of the local legislatures and what should be the duties of the Dominion parliament. We are going to some extent out of our way, but sti' 1 we are within our

jurisdiction, when we provide that out of the federal treasury assistance shall be given to the provinces, not for general purposes, but for one specific object, that is to say, the making or improving of highways.
But, Sir, it is conceivable if the Railway Department is going to become a constructor of highways that it will be able to do the work to-iday which is done by the local legislature? It is part, and a most important part, of the duties of the local legislatures to look after highways, and as has been stated by my hon. friend from Piotou (Mar. Macdonald), a moment ago, they have a special organization for that purpose. 'That money should be supplied to them, more than they have been given, for the purpose of making or improving highways, is accepted by 'everybody, but, Sir, power is given now to the Minister of Raiways to inaugurate a new system altogether, and himself to become the contractor or builder of these roads. That in my humble judgment, as reducing very much the usefulness of the Minister of Railways. At present the minister has only to do with administering the railways and canals of the country. If, in addition, to that, he is given the subsidiary task of looking .after the highways of the country be must have a new staff, a new organization. What reason can there be why the organization which now exists in all the provinces should not be continued as it is at the present time? The policy proposed can be carried out with the consent of the provinces I know, but I repeat that it is not at all in accordance with the spirit of the constitution, and I can conceive of no reason why there will be more advantage in having this work performed by the Minister of Railways than by any of the provincial governments. The minister is not equipped for this work, it has never 'been the object of his department to do it, it is a new thing altogether, and when the machinery already exists in the provinces to carry out the work which is intended, I cannot see why new machinery should ,be organized, which, in the nature of things, cannot construct highways as efficiently as that construction must and can be done by the local authorities.
'Mr. DEVLIN. Unfortunately when the first discussion in connection with this measure took place I was not in my seat. Like a good many hon. gentlemen oppoisite I was engaged in examining the highways-


Wilfrid Laurier: And the byways.
Mr. DEVLIN-and the byways of the county of 'South Renfrew, and so I must apoligize if some of the remarks I may make this afternoon might have been
delivered at an earlier stage. I want to say that I am entirely in favour of aniy aid which may be given to the highways of our country, but I think there should be some provision in the Bill by which the money grant to toe made under it shall reach the municipalities and the portions of a county where the money is most needed. I asked the Prime Minister a moment ago what nature of 'organization he was referring to when he said that the money would be given either to the organization or to the Minister of Railways, to act in conjuction with the organization in this province. From my modest experience in matters of organization when dealing with the government of the day, the only organizations I know of are political organizations, and I hardly think that it would 'be in the interest of the country, much less in the interest of the rural municipalities, that the Minister oif Railways should toe let loose to deal with political organizations in handling the money of the country given for the purpose of aiding in the construction of roads. I would very modestly suggest to the government that they go about this matter of improving our highways in a more systematic manner. Speaking more particularly for the province of Quebec, I know of no particular organization *such as that to which the Finance Minister refers. The custom there is for the legislature to vote a certain amount which is placed at the disposal of the Minister of Colonization. That minister visits the different parts of the province and studies the local needs personally and accepts advice from those who are most concerned in the matter of municipal roads, how best to expend the provincial funds in improving colonization and other roads. There is absolutely no such provision in this Bill. In the province of Quebec the money is handed over to some party who is directly interested-and preferably to the municipalities-somebody who is authorized by the municipalities to expend that money. If the government of the day were to establish a system by which they would hand first to the provinces a set sum of money with the understanding that the provinces would get into touch with the counties, and that that money should be expended for the purpose first of municipal roads, then county roads, and then provincial and interprovincial roads, all parts of the country would be benefited. But to say that the Minister of Railways shall go forth with a sum of money in his pockets and meet his friends in the different counties and have the right to expend that money is simply ridiculous. That money will not reach the portions of the country where it is most needed for the highways. On the other hand, if by this Bill the gov-

emment of the day, through the Minister of Railways, is forced to expend that money right in the municipalities where it is needed, then I conceive that this Bill will work for the greater advantage of the country. I believe that no amount of money, properly expended, will be too great to aid in the construction of roads in this country; but I want to see the money reach the proper source, and under the Bill in its present form I cannot possibly see how that will occur. I know that the Minister of Railways, having power to expend this money right and left, will want to disburse it for the greater advantage of the country, but if he goes into the county of Wright, for instance, I hardly think he will go to any of those who may be friends of this political party and ask their advice. Rather will he go to the friends of hon. gentlemen opposite, and spend that money in those portions of the county which will benefit the party to whom that expenditure has been entrusted. I say without taking a partisan view at all of the subject-


Some hon. MEMBERS: Hear, hear.


Emmanuel Berchmans Devlin: I am in earnest in that statement because I foresee that the moment this Bill becomes law it will be placed in operation by the present government. But in a few years' time, perhaps sooner, hon. gentlemen may have changed places, and we on this side of the House may take their seats and operate the Bill to the disadvantage of municipalities that may not be exactly in sympathy with the political views wthich they entertain. Now is the time, whilst the Bill is under consideration, to insert provisions which will prevent any operation of the measure against the advantage of the whole country, so that neither hon. gentlemen opposite, nor any other political party for the time being in power, will be able to use the people's money for any other purpose, good, bad or indifferent, than the improvement of the highways and the byways of Canada.
Mr. Chairman, I think this clause, giving the minister power to go throughout the country with the people's money in his pocket, and to expend it where he will, without any rider attached to the clause, is a very dangerous power to give to any gentleman in this House or in the government. I do not wish to hamper the government in any way in improving the highways of this country, but I would like to see the people's money reach a proper object.


Mr. BENNETT (Simcoe).: Living close to the province of Ontario as the hon. member for Wright (Mr. Devlin) does, and having taken, as he has always taken, a lively interest tm Ontario provincial politics, he has probably heard from hon. members on his own side, who have been in the local Mr. DEVLIN.
legislature, how their friends, when in power in Ontario, annually dispensed an amount of approximately half a million dollars on roads in that province. And he probably knows that his political friends got good political results from the plan which he says might be followed by this government in the expenditure of the moneys under this proposed new system.. But I hope for the sake of the government, and for the reputation of the Dominion, that this government will not resort to the means resorted to by the hon. gentleman's friends in Ontario in road expenditure.


Emmanuel Berchmans Devlin: Will the hon. gentleman allow me a question? Under the clause as it stands, if the political party in power in this country, wishes to do so, will they not be able to carry out the plan which he condemns?


Richard Bedford Bennett: I think my hon. friend is unduly afraid that the bad example set by his friends in Ontario-and it may be also in the province of Quebec- will be followed. And, knowing that this plan was used very successfully from a political point of view by his friends in Ontario, he thinks the same force may be arrayed against him under the present proposal. But the principle here is a larger one. It contemplates probably a very large expenditure. And as this whole plan rises above the realm of party politics, I think the people of the Dominion will feel secure in the belief that this fund will be administered rightly, and not merely for political purposes, as was unfortunately the case in the province of Ontario for so many years. Speaking for myself, and I think I voice the sentiments of hon. gentlemen on this side, I would be loath to believe that a Minister of Railways and Canlals, representing the government of the day, would ever resort to mere pettifogging in the matter of this expenditure. I believe the whole scheme will be a broad, comprehensive one that will enure not only to, the political advantage of the party now in power, but to the practical advantage of each province where the work may be undertaken.


Emmanuel Berchmans Devlin: 
Richard Bedford Bennett: Will the hon. gentleman (Mr. Devlin) answer me a question? 1s there not every year in the estimates a very large aggregate amount voted for dredging? And is not the Minister of Public Works empowered to spend that grant as he will? I have not charged my memory with the amount of this vote for each province, but it is a very large sum, and it is not voted for any particular work.
Mr. DEVLIN But tenders must be *called for.


Richard Bedford Bennett: Not necessarily in every case. But the point is that the work is undertaken at the discretion of the minister. The expenditure of the money may be safeguarded afterwards by calling for tenders which is right; but the Minister of Public Works can allot the money to this work or that, as he *chooses, without asking the authority of parliament for that distribution of the vote.


Emmanuel Berchmans Devlin: If I may be allowed- and I do not wish to speak too often- that is a purely administrative matter. But here is a case where one gentleman will have the right to go about this broad Dominion expending money right and left wherever he likes without parliament being able to say a solitary word about it, and not always, perhaps, applying the money to an object to which this House would wish to have it applied.


Richard Bedford Bennett: But is it not exactly the case of the Minister of Public Works under the general grant for dredging?


Mr. TURGEON.: I desire to say only a few words in support of the arguments of the right hon. leader of the opposition (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) on the constitutional aspect of this clause. We havei heard a great deal about the conservation of our wealth, the conservation of our resources and the conservation of our flag. I am in favour of conservation, and especially of the conservation of the flag. But, as a Canadian, I am in favour of the conservation of our constitution which is the best protection that our flag can have. A few years ago, the government of the day, increased the allowance made to the several provinces. This was done upon a plan which received the unanimous assent of the provinces themselves. For my part, I stated at the time my regret that the increase of subsidies to the provinces was not made larger, as I believed that the time would come when the provinces would have to come back to the Dominion government for still further additions to their subsidies in order to efficiently maintain the schools and roads for which especially these subsidies are granted. I agree that it is an advantage to have more money spent upon our highways with a view to improving this means of communication throughout the Dominion. But I believe, as the right hon. leader of the opposition has said, that we should give the money to the provinces according to their population, the basis adopted years ago, and allow the provinces to distribute that money. This plan would avoid the friction which is certain otherwise to arise. It was stated in this debate a few days ago, I believe by an hon. gentleman on this side representing a Nova Scotia constituency, that, as the government of the province of Nova Scotia is a liberal government, it was likely to be discriminated against in the distribution of this money. I come from a province where the provincial government is to-day Conservative. But, as every member on the other side of the House knows, I am rather indifferent to the influence of any provincial government in any own riding, regardless of the money that may be at their disposal.
I say that according to the constitution, when you give money for local and provincial purposes, you should give it to be distributed by the provincial legislatures themselves, who are the properly constituted authorities for that purpose. That is the only way in which we can avoid future friction between the Dominion and the provincial governments. I have no doubt that the present Minister of Railways will endeavour to do the best he can. I am in favour of the federal government assisting the provinces to build roads; but my objection to this clause is based altogether on the constitutional ground that the money should be spent oy the provinces and not by the Dominion government, and that is why I shall oppose this clause.


Mr. CARVELL.: I think the Minister of Railways would do well to take the advice tendered him this afternoon by the hon. member for Brome (Mr. Baker). Of course, the member for Brome was not discussing section 6, he was discussing the general principle on which this money is to be spent. It is all very well for the member for East Simcoe (Mr. Bennett) to defend the Minister of Railways, and say that he

will not do what the local government in Ontario did prior to 1905. I want to tell my hon. friend from East Simcoe that the old government of Ontario were human, the present government of Ontario is human, and so is the present Minister of Railways, and so will all the gentlemen be who will compose the Dominion government in all time to come. Now it may be that the Liberal government in Ontario were able to do everything crooked and wrong and that the present government may be able to do everything right. But I want to say that there is a Conservative government in power down in New Brunswick to-day who can do everything which the old Liberal government did in the province of Ontario; and I think I can ask this House to believe that it is possible that the present Minister of Railways may be influenced by his friends, at least in the province of New Brunswick, to do the very things that the member for East Simcoe objected to. Why, Sir, there is no use in mincing matters; the most, of us have had a hand in provincial politics, I have for one, the Minister of Railways has for another, and we all know how this road money has been bandied about and used as a matter of barter and sale from time immemorial. What I fear is that notwithstanding the good intentions of the Minister of Railways and the government as a whole, notwithstanding all their professions, the actual result will be, if this clause 6 becomes law, that they will be doing the very things which have been pointed out by the hon. member for Wright (Mr. Devlin) and others on this side of the House. If you want to know what the result will be, you have only to go back to South Renfrew during the last three weeks. There you find half-a-dozen government members of this House going the length and breadth of that riding, and telling the people: You should vote for the Conservative candidate because we are suing to give you a great slice out of this road money.


Mr. TURRIFF.: What did the minister say?
Mr. CARVELI,. I am only speaking of the men who are behind the minister. This will be the result if you place the Minister of Railways and Canals in a position of an ordinary road builder, and the pressure behind him will be so great that, I do not care who he may be, he will not be able to resist it. Even if this Bill provided that he should build permanent roads, it would not be so bad; if he had even said that he was going to drain his roads, it would not be so bad; it would have been much better if he had said: we must build a macadamized road with steel bridges and culverts.


Frank Broadstreet Carvell: But without one specification anywhere, without saying whether it is to be a permanent road or a mud road, every time an election is brought on, even a municipal election, you will find the changes will be rung, the party whip will be cracked and men will be told: ' If you don't vote for the county council we want you to vote for, you won't get any portion of this grant.' The member for Simcoe says: But we are bigger and broader than all that, this is a great national enterprise, we are going to run it on big broad lines. That is what we were told in New Brunswick before the elections of 1908; we were told that when the Conservative party got into power they were going to take the roads out of politics and hand them over entirely to the municipalities. They appointed in each parish a road board, composed of two municipal councillors, and a third man appointed by the government, and let me show you how it works out after three years of experience. In that province, we do not have local councils as they do in Ontario, we have municipal councils, consisting of two members from each parish, and all meet together in a county council. Wherever we have a Liberal and a Conservative on the road board, the government appoints a Conservative as a third man, and naturally he is the whole thing, he is president, secretary, treasurer, and the board is run on Conservative lines. Where we have two Liberal councillors, then invariably they are wholly ignored, and the road money is handled entirely by the man appointed by the government. I can tell him that there are dozens and dozens of road boards in the province of New Brunswick, that only meet once a year when they have to have an annual meeting, and they have squandered the money just as bad as it was squandered by these men that the member for East Simcoe was telling us about. Now they will be able to do these things in the future, just the same as they have done in the past, they will make these roads grants for purely political purposes. They j*will rake up the mud which was raked up the year before, and put it on top of the road, and they will pay the good money of the country for doing so, if they can get votes out of it. That is what they are doing in New Brunswick, and what they will continue to do under this Bill. _ Therefore, I think my hon. friends opposite must realize that this legislation is not in the spirit of the British North America Act. Does anybody suppose that when the British North America Act was framed a nroviso was put in making the Minister of Railways a road builder with a right to go on any highway and by way in any province and build roads?


Francis Cochrane: This Bill does not give the minister that right.


Frank Broadstreet Carvell: Of course it does not say-so, there is a saving clause which says that permission must be obtained from the legislature. But does the Minister of Railways suppose that any legislature in Canada will refuse to allow him to go into that province and spend money on its roads? He knows better than that, he is not sincere in making that statement. Under the wording of this Bill he can give a $5 grant to build a little culvert if he thinks he can get a vote out of it; he can spend money on any road wholly or in part, and do absolutely as he likes with it. He does not even have to call for tenders. The hon. member for Simcoe told us about the expenditure of a general grant for dredging; but there at least tenders were supposed to be called for. But here the Minister of Railways is not even supposed to call for tenders, and he proposes legislation in the most vicious form known in order to get political support. Wherever a by-election comes on, he can appropriate a portion of this road money, and put it into 'the hands of his political friends, and they will say to the electors: Now you vote right and you will get so much. They will go further than that and they will say: You will not get this grant until the election is over, and if the election does not go right, you will not get the money at all. I "am only pointing out what they are doing in New Brunswick, and I am pointing "out what they will do all over this country, if this legislation goes through. Therefore, I say it is a piece of vicious legislation, and ought not to be passed.


Edmond Proulx: Under the Ontario system the initiative was left with the counties. The county passed a by-law and adopted _ the system and the government had to ' contribute a portion of the cost of the road to the county. If this government gave the money to the provinces then the provinces could increase the sum to the counties and still leave the initiative with the counties. I think the suggestion of the hon. member for Kent is a very good one. The people should be interested and the initiative should be left with the counties.


Andrew Archibald MacDonald: I asked the right hon. leader of the government (Mr. Borden) in the few remarks I made a few minutes ago, to explain to the committee whether he understood the effect of clause 6, to mean that the federal government were to enter practically into the business of looking after the roads of the country. That, I submit, would be the effect of the section because it would give them the power to do so. The right hon. gentleman stated that this was intended to apply to a case where, for instance, a province did not have an adequate system in regard to the expenditure of its road money, under which circumstances the government could
go in and expend the whole of the money that was appropriated for that province itself. That answer is not a satisfactory one because it is not to be supposed that any province would consider itself as not having an adequate i system for spending troad moneys and it would not therefore give to the federal government an opportunity of making that expenditure. The right hon. gentleman has given no reason why the government should enter into the arena of provincial powers and engage in the task of looking after the roads of the country. He was good enough to say to the hon. member for Kent, who made a very practical suggestion as to the utilization of the road money generally, which mean1, nothing more nor less than a suggestion that we had previously made, that the wisdom of the expenditure of roil mom/ depended on the unification of the authoi ity so that the roads would get the bem'fit cf the assistance that came from the di'iyrent quarters. If that was the proposal that came before the government it can never be worked out under section 6. It would be impossible to work conjointly with the provinces or with the municipalities along the lines proposed here. Manifestly the Minister of Railways and Canals has not the equipment in his department to deal with roads at all. Before the minister could pass judgment upon the question as to whether the roads system of any province was good or not, or the engineering facilities and equipment of the province were such as that the country could expect a wise and prudent expenditure of the road money entrusted to him, the minister would need to gather around him a very large staff of specialists on that subject, not a staff which would be adequate for any particular province, but a staff greater and more numerous than that which they have in any province to-day. The minister would need to have such a staff before he could safely expend a dollar of the money that was put in his hands for better roads. Are we going to originate a system of that kind? The government disclaim any such idea. Still, they have power to do it at any time and, as my hon. friend from. Carleton, New Brunswick (Mr. Carvell) has pointed out, evil results will follow from it. My right hon. friend said, with regard to the constitutional difficulties that were suggested the other day, that no province would object to the federal government giving them money, or spending money in the province, and that therefore there was no constitutional obstacle. Well, the fathers of confederation, fifty years ago, said that it was a wise and prudent thing for Canada that the provincial governments should look after the roads of the country. Having regard to that distribution of power they said: We will provide the provinces with funds from the

central treasury in order that they may look alter the roads of the country. They have been doing it for fifty years. This government say that they propose to continue that system by giving additional aid, yet they put in the Bill a power which will nullify the rest of it and endanger the constitutional system adopted fifty years ago. It certainly will dislocate the system under which municipalities all over the country, look after the repair of the roads because it will nullify the system of statute labour. I submit that this is not a wise measure and I would therefore move, seconded by Mr. Proulx, that the clause be struck out.
Amendment negatived (Yeas 48, nays 52.).


Mr. KNOWLES.: ' I would ask whether the hon. member for Perth was in the chamber when the motion was read.


Mr. FOSTER (North Toronto).: The vote has been declared. Put your question on the order paper.


William Erskine Knowles: I want to know whether the hon. member for North Perth, or South Perth, was in -the chamber when the question was put.


Mr. DEPUTY SPEAKER.: I understand this rule does not apply in committee.
Bill reported.


CIVIL SERVICE ACT AMENDMENT-CUSTOMS, OUTSIDE SERVICE.
[Stage Direction]
House in committee on the following proposed resolutions:
Resolved, that it is expedient to amend the Civil Service Act and the Acts in amendment thereof, and to provide as follows:-
1.	(As section 39, subsection 2), that a person who has served -seven years as a chief clerk in the outside service of the Customs may be appointed to the rank of senior chief clerk, subject to such examination cn tlie duties of office and other qualifications as is prescribed by the deputy head in a report to be concurred in by the head of the department. The salary of such senior chief clerk shall be from $2,200 -to $2,800 per -innurn.
2.	(As section 39, subsection 3), that a person who has served over three years as a clerk in the outside service of the Customs may be appointed to the rank of senior clerk, subject to such examination on the duties of office and other qualifications as is prescribed by the' deputy head in a report to be concurred in by the head of the department. The 'salary of such senior clerk shall be from $1,290 to $1,600 per annum.
3.	Th-at the part of schedule * B ' of the Civil Service Aot which relates to Customs be repealed and the following substituted therefor:-*
Andrew Archibald MacDonald: 


SCHEDULE ' B ' CUSTOMS.
[Stage Direction]
Higher Classes.
Collectors, salary per annum	from	$ 300	to $4,500
Chief inspector, salary per
annum	"
Inspector of ports, salary
per annum	 "
Assistant inspectors, salary
per annum	 "
Chief clerks, salary per annum		"
Senior chief clerks, salary
per -annum	 "
Surveyors, salary per annum	 "
Assistant surveyors (comprising tide surveyors, chief waiters and chief lockers), salary per annutm	 "
Technical Officers.
Dominion appraisers, salary per	-annum	from	$2,200	to	$2,600Apraisers, salary per annum	
"	1,200	r'	2,200
Assistant appraisers, salary
per annum	
"	900	"	1,600Gaugers, salary -per annum	
"	900	"	1,600Other	Classes.
Senior clerks, salary per
annum	from	$1,200	to	$1,600
Clerks and landing waiters,
salary per	annum..	..	"	400	"	1,200
Examining officers (including preventive officers whose duties are not chiefly clerical, and -lockers), salary per annum.. "	100 " 1,000
Packers and messengers, salary per annum	 "	400 "	800
Robert Laird Borden: I understand from the Minister of Customs that this , is practically the same legislation as was introduced by the late government last session, but on account of the sudden dissolution, no doubt, it was not proceeded with. I would suggest that the resolution be passed and the discussion, if any, take place on the second reading.


Wilfrid Laurier: The policy involved in the proposition made requires some discussion, but we will take it on the second reading of the Bill.
Resolution concurred in and reported.
Mr. BORDEN moved for leave to introduce Bill (No. 116), to amend the Civil Service Act.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to, and Bill read the first time.

[Stage Direction]
Mr. WHITE (Leeds) moved that the House go into Committee of Supply.
[', Request re Removal of: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 577 (i).', '\n M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 582\n(i).\nStatistical Officers: in Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).\nStatue erected on Federal Land du Quebec City by Provl. Govt.:\tQues. (Mr. Bellemare) 2667 (ii).\nStatutes of Previous Sessions, Delay re Distribution :\tRemarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke)\nin Com. of Sup., 678 (i).\nSteamboat Inspection: in Com. of Sup., 5238\n(iii).\nSteamboat Inspection Report:\tPresented\n(Mr. Hazen) 1571 (i).\nSteamship Connections with I.C.R., Subsidies &c.:\tRemarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in\nCom. of Sup., 5597 (iv).\nSteam Trawling on Canadian Coasts: M. for Papers (Mr. Sinclair) 2461 (ii).\nSteam Trawlers and Fisheries Bounties: M. for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 5957 (iv).', " Protection against: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 5388 (iii).\nSteel and Iron Bounties, Par. in Montreal 'Gazette': Remarks (Mr. Kyte) 2588 (ii).\nSteel and Iron Bounties re Budget Speech: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4249 (iii).\nSee ' Bounties/\nStellarton Postmaster, Mr. John Fraser, Dismissal: M. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) for Cor* 1589 (i).\nStellarton Station Mail Service, Cancellation of:\tM. for Cor* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)\n2247 (ii).\nStenographic Assistance for Members:\tRemarks (Mr. Pugsley) 1846 (i).", ' in Com. of Sup., 6461 (iv).\nSterling Life Ass. Co. of Can.:\tSee B. No.\n72/\nStewart, Ethel May, Relief of:\tSee \' B. No.\n120/\nStorey, Wm, Dismissal, Investigation, &c.: Ques. (Mr. J. Reid) 5054 (iii).\nStoves, Ranges, Incubators exported to Argentine Republic, Value, &c.:\tQues. (Mr. H. V. White) 561 (i).\nStratheona Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2213 (ii).\nStrikes and Strike Funds: See \' B. No. 87/\nSudbury Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1953\n(i). "', ' Dismissals:\tRemarks (Mr. Boyce) in\nCom. of Sup., 2033 (ii).\nSunnybrae to Country Harbour Ry., Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com., 6228 (iv).\nSunnybrae to Guysborough Branch Line, I.\nC.R., Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 542 (i).', 'Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2289 (ii).', "M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4262 (iii).\n-:   Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of\nSup., 4213 (iii).\nSupply Bills: See ' B. Nos. 18 and 193/"]
William Erskine Knowles: Before you leave the Chair, Mr. Speaker, I
3.200	" 4,000 2,000 " 3,000 1,600 " 2,000
1.200	" 2,200 2,200 " 2,800 1,200 ' 2,800
1,200 " 1,600

would like to draw the attention of the government to the need of an armoury in the city of Moosejaw. I want, for the benefit of the Prime Minister, to read certain correspondence which has passed between the city of Moosejaw and the government, or rather the Minister of Militia and Defence. The following is a letter addressed to the Hon. Colonel Hughes by Mr. W. F. Heale, city clerk of Moosejaw:
Honourable Colonel Hughes,
Minister of Militia and Defence,
Ottawa.
Sir,-I am instructed by the Moosejaw City Council to communicate with your department re the delay in bringing the armouries on the Fairford Street site. The following resolution was passed by the council at their meeting held on January 8th and I am instructed to forward it to you with the request that you kindly deal with the matter as early as possible.
That the council very much regret that no move has been made to construct the armouries so long promised, .and that the Minister of Militia and Defence be requested to state as early as possible the intention of his department in this connection, as the council are desirous of using this very valuable site for other purposes unless used by the department .without further delay.
I am. Sir,
Your obedient servant,
W. F. HEALE, City Clerk.
A reply was made to that letter, and it is to that reply that I ask the very particular attention of the Prime Minister. This is it:
Minister's office,
Ottawa, February 1, 1912.
Re Drill Shed.
Dear Sir,-I beg to acknowledge receipt of your letter of January 10th, 1912, with the 4 instructions ' from your city council re ' the delay in building the armouries on the Fair-ford street site.'
I do not understand what your letter means. Nor can I comprehend what you mean by your use of the word ' delay.' Nor can I imagine what your reference is about the 4 armouries so long promised.'
I have been Minister of Militia since October, and am responsible for no promise made before that time. Will you permit me to say that I think it would be muoh better ta9te on the part of your council, instead of passing a resolution of regret and fault-finding, to have quietly made a request and placed the facts before me.
Your fault-finding letter is the first intimation I have had officially that there is such a place as Moosejaw or that you want an armoury. While in the west, I met a number of splendid fellows from Moosejaw, officers and others, who spoke to me like gentlemen on this matter, and I promised them, and have carried out my promises, to recommend a sum of money, not for an armoury, which is of no use for a large and growing place like Moosejaw, but for a drill hall and armouries.
I also suggested the formation of a city corps for Moosejaw.
Might I suggest that as 

our council seems to go about it in a blundering sort of fashion that they should appoint some of those gentlemen whom I had the privilege of meeting in the west to carry on the negotiations1 in the matter? They seemed to know their business and were very judicious.
If it were left to them, I think Moosejaw would soon have a splendid drill hall and armouries attached and would also have a city regiment.	[DOT]
Yours faithfully,
(Sgd.) SAM HUGHES.
City Clerk,
W.F. Heale, Esq.,
Moosejaw.
I wish to say that the property offered by the city of Moosejaw had been accepted by the government, but there was a slight cloud on the title, the circumstances being that the prior holders of the title had passed it over to the city as part of a park, and in the deed to the city it is stated that it must not be used for commercial purposes, and must not be alienated. The city of Moosejaw naturally can only give the same kind of title to the government that they themselvesi have, and I understand that between the Department of Public Works, the Department of Militia and the Department of Justice who are mixed up in it, there is delay because of this. In reference to the answer given to the city of Moosejaw by the Minister of Militia, without saying anything offensive to the Minister of Militia, I deem the letter he wrote to be unworthy of the high and dignified position that he for the moment holds.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: The hon. member (Mr. Knowles), is scarcely within the amenities of debate when he says that a certain tion is unworthy of any member of the House.


William Erskine Knowles: Well, it is quite worthy of the Minister of Militia. I submit to the government and especially to the right hon. the Prime Minister, that I would be very pleased if any technical difficulties with regard to the transfer of this site to the government could be overcome as soon as^ possible, so that the city may not use this property for any other purpose. I would be personally very glad to see an armoury erected on this property, and I trust that a good substantial armoury and drill hall will be erected there such as the minister suggests.


Mr. HUGHES (Victoria).: The hon. member did not do me the honour of sending me word that he w.as going to bring this matter up to-day, or I would have been in my place in the House when he began his remarks. I may inform him that the negotiations in reference to the mat-

ter to which he has referred have been handed over to the Moosejaw Board of Trade, the city council being too hidebound a Grit institution to treat any one with proper courtesy. This action has had this effect: The city council of Moosejaw, having been relieved of the necessity of sending letters of a blustering and threatening description, the matter is working out very nicely. It appears that the property which Moosejaw is offering does not belong to Moosejaw, but was handed over to that municipality by the Canadian Pacific Railway Company for public purposes, and it cannot be sold or used for any other purpose.


William Erskine Knowles: ' I think the minister is in error. They never said they would alienate the property. They would use it for other purposes.


Samuel Hughes: The city may use it for public purposes, but it cannot sell it to any one. These gentlemen talk as if they owned the property and were giving us a $40,000 site. However, the matter is proceeding very nicely now. The Moosejaw council has come to its senses, and the board of trade is dealing with the matter.



Frank Oliver: Mr. Speaker, I desire to move the following resolution, of which I gave notice some time ago:
That all the words after ' that ' in the main motion he struck out and the following be substituted therefor:
That the House heard with satisfaction from the Minister of Trade and Commerce that as a result of a conference recently held by him and at his request with representatives of the three railway systems operating in western Canada, these railways have ' lowered their rate, making the rate to Dulilth and Minneapolis the 'same as to Port William and Port Arthur.'
And that as a further result of the conference mentioned, ' application has been made to the Interstate Commerce Commission of the United States for leave to file grain rates from the Northwest down to Minneapolis and Duluth, and to ease the pressure in the congested districts by taking the grain away by more western routes down towards the south.'
The House is informed by the public press that the reduced rates as mentioned have been granted by the Canadian Pacific and Canadian Northern railways on wheat and oats for export only.
As the reduction of rates so announced can only affect the situation to a limited degree, the House would urge upon the government the advisability of securing further consideration of the matter by the Railway Companies with a view to having the reduced rates apply to wheat and oats for grinding in bond and for consumption in the United States as well as for export;


Samuel Hughes: The House would further urge that such means as may be practicable be taken by the government to have the through rates on barley and flax to Duluth and Minneapolis which became effective on January 23 reduced to 'the Fort William rate.


George Eulas Foster: If my hon. friend will allow me for a moment, this motion was given notice of, I think, some two weeks ago. As a great many things have happened, and some of them began to happen about that time, and as nothing has since been said about it by my hon. friend, I had supposed that it had passed out of the region of discussion, and was not aware that my hon. friend intended to bring it up. Now, this will bring on a discussion on a very wide subject, and I imagine that my hon. friend wants to have the matter discussed with all the information possible. If it is agreeable to him to postpone his motion to another day, it would be much more to the interest of a general discussion on the whole matter. I suggest this to him; it is for himself to make his own decision.


Frank Oliver: I have no objection, if my hon. friend will fix a day this week for the discussion; but I have been anxious to press this discussion forward ever since I gave notice of the motion, and this is the first occasion on which it seemed convenient to bring it up.


George Eulas Foster: Does my hon. friend intend to press the matter to a vote?


Frank Oliver: Yes, that is the intention.


George Eulas Foster: If not, Friday might be agreeable to both of us. If the hon. gentleman intends to press it to a vote, he might let it go over to Monday or Tuesday of next week.


Frank Oliver: I certainly could not move such an important motion without bringing it to a vote, and either Thursday or Friday would suit my purpose very well; but I would not like to postpone the discussion any longer than is absolutely necessary except on the responsibility of the government. The conditions which the resolution takes notice of are urgent, and, as my hon. friend has said, many things are happening and I would wish to have this matter considered before the condition to which it relates has passed out of existence by effluxion of time. I have been ready to bring the motion forward on every day since I gave notice of it, but this is the first occasion on which it seemed convenient to bring forward a motion of such importance.


George Eulas Foster: Well, my hon. friend can go on.


Frank Oliver: Mr. Speaker, it is my purpose to call attention as strongly as I can to the condition of affairs which exists today in the western provinces, and which is generally spoken of as the grain blockade. I do not suppose it will be necessary for me to spend any serious length of time in demonstrating that there is such a blockade. About the time this notice was given the leading newspaper of the west took measures to inquire into the conditions as they then existed. That paper wired on January 29 to 150 points. At the time notice was given of this resolution it had heard from 49 points, and at only nine of them was it reported that there was no blockade.
I will not trouble the House with any long list of the facts as shown by the newspaper mentioned, the ' Free Press.' They are, I have no doubt, within the knowledge of many members of the House. But here is one instance, the very first one I took down. The wire is from Quill Lake, Saskatchewan. There were 52 orders or cars. A car was ordered on November 9, which was placed on January 23, and 50 per cent of the grain was still in the farmers' hands. At Foam Lake, Saskatchewan, there were 60 orders on the order book, the elevators were full, there were
100.000	bushels in the farmers' hands, and
50.000	bushels threshed. Other members
of the House will, no doubt, give the committee further information as to the existence of the blockade. But it may be of interest to give some facts as to why there is a blockade, and why that blockade should be of such an extraordinary character and at such an extraordinary time of the year as this information establishes it to be. A blockade is the condition in which grain is offered for sale beyond the quantity that can be, or is being, transported to market. In every year there is shortly after the beginning of threshing, and before the close of navigation, in the nature of things, if the markets are good, necessarily a rush of grain, and a car shortage, or a blockade, or a partial blockade, during that period of the year is something that has occurred frequently, and may be looked for to occur in the future on many occasions.	Last year it did not occur.
The year before it did occur, and so on from year to year, as the occasion was, the blockade existed or did not exist. But this yfear the conditions were extraordinary. In the first place the acreage under crop was much larger than it ever was before. In the next place the crop, so far as its growth was concerned, was probably generally heavier than it ever was before in the history of the country. Over and above that, the season was unfavourable for harvesting, and the harvesting
did not begin as early as usual. When the work of transporting the crop to thle lake front began, it began later than usual, and the result has been that from the time transportation of the crop to the lake front began until thie present time, there has been a condition of grain blockade. Under ordinary circumstances the car shortage or blockade that would exist between the beginning of the transportation of the crop and the close of navigation, would be to some .extent practically eliminated after the close of navigation. The rush to get the grain forward would stop at that period, and the gradual movement of grain out of the terminal elevators by the all-rail route to the seaboard, and the gradual coming forward of the grain, would militate against a condition of car shortage or grain blockade shortly after the close of navigation.
This season the condition is that instead of the close of navigation marking a finish of the grain blockade, it was after the close of navigation that the grain blockade became more acute than before, and that the damage to the business interests of the country resulted more strongly than before. The conditions have been aggravated by the fact that, owing to the bad weather of last fall, it is practically impossible to get all the grain threshed, and a great deal of the grain that has been threshed was in a damp condition at that time, and having been placed in storage, in the farmers' granary or in a country elevator; has become liable to destruction, because of being heated as the result of its being damp when it was stored. So that we are in the face of a condition which not only operates against the price which the farmer received for his grain, but that tends to the actual destruction of a considerable part of the total crop of the northwest by reason of the blockade.


Mr. SCHAFFNER.: Have you any definite, or fairly definite, information as to what percentage of the grain has not been threshed as yet, and what percentage is in a damp condition and likely to be destroyed?


Frank Oliver: The most definite information that I can give is the representation of the manager of the Ogilvie Milling Company, who reports that there are 30,000,000 bushels of damaged wheat in the west unfit for milling, and about that amount was unthreshed in the middle of January. This is the condition as it exists at the present time. With a larger crop than we ever had before, and with that crop in danger of being destroyed to a considerable extent, because it is not going forward, we have a more extraordinary condition of grain blockade than ever before existed in the northwest. Just as

to the magnitude of the damage, I will not say the disaster, to the interests of the country let me give the figures as. to the amount of grain that has to be handled. I take the estimate of Sir Byron Walker as placed before the directors of the Bank of Commerce at their annual meeting. He estimates the total yield as 400,000,000 bushels ef grain, of which 175,000,000 bushels are wheat, 180,000,000 oats., 35,000,000 barley, and 6,000,000 flax, and he values this crop at $200,000,000. He also states that the crop of wheat was expected at one time to be 200,000,000 or 225,000,000 of bushels, so that the condition is that the farmer of the west who-by reason of the area that he had sown, by reason of the expenditure that he had incurred, by reason of the conditions that prevailed in the early part of the growing season-had reason to expect 200,000,000 or 225,000,000 bushels of wheat, has only, as a matter of fact, secured 175,000,000 bushels. That is to say by reason of the unfavourable season the farmer is short, according to Sir Byron Walker, between 25,000,000 and
50.000.	000 bushels of his reasonable expectation.
And let it he remembered that these expectations are not pencil and paper estimates, but are based upon the expenditure that the farmer has incurred. He has ploughed his land, he has sown his seed, he has maintained his help and, having incurred all these expenses, he might reasonably have expected results aggregating
200.000.	000 or 225,000,000 bushels. But, notwithstanding these expenditures on his part, he has secured only 175,000,000 bushels. That is, he is between 25,000,000 and
50.000.	000 bushels short of his reasonable expectations of the result of his investment, the shortage being due to the unfavourable conditions of the harvest season.


Richard Blain: Does that include the three western provinces?


Frank Oliver: I assume that it does. I am merely giving the House Sir Byron Walker's statement, which, I understand, covers the three western provinces. And I know of no place where I could get a more complete, comprehensive and, i presume, accurate statement.


Mr. BRODER.: That result might follow great drought as well as too much rain.


Frank Oliver: Certainly. I am merely giving the facts Sir Byron Walker has stated. My hon. friend need not be alarmed; these facts have only an indirect bearing on the argument I wish to make. Of the movement of this crop, Mr. Thompson, of the Ogilvie Mills, estimates that there were 100,000,000 bushels of wheat marketed by January 11. Estimating that 25,000,000 bushels would be needed for seed Mr. OLIVER.
and bread, that would mean 50,000,000 bushels of wheat still to he marketed on January 10. Then, as I have already said in answer to the bon. member's inquiry, the same authority estimates that there was from 25,000,000 to 30,000,000 bushels of wheat still in the farmers' hands at that time much of it unthreshed, most of it damp, and all of it unfit for milling. As to the grain going forward, there was inspected at Winnipeg up to January 10, of wheat 67,000,000 bushels, of oats 17,500,000 bushels, of barley 250,000 bushels, of flax 250,000 bushels. So that, of 100,000,000 bushels of wheat marketed up to January 10, only 67,000,000 bushels had reached Winnipeg up to that time.
Deliveries began about September 10. Owing to unfavourable conditions of weather, the deliveries were not very strong at first. About November 10 the blockade became acute and continued until the close of navigation.	It was expected that at the close of navigation the blockade would be to some extent relieved. But, contrary to common expectations and the experience of previous seasons, the blockade has been more acute, not less acute, since the close _ of navigation. At the close of navigation there was 6,000,000 bushels of wheat in store at the terminal elevators. At last account there was 18,000,000 bushels in store at terminal elevators at Fort William, and these elevators were full. The total capacity of the elevators is, of course, much greater than the figure I have given; but, owing to the great number of grades this season and to the damaged crop, the actual capacity of the elevators is reduced to this extent. So, we have this condition: A blockade beginning on September 10th which continued until the close of navigation, and which after the close of navigation became more acute, and continued to January 10th, the date I have mentioned. Of the 100,000,000 bushels of wheat marketed -according to Mr. Thompson's statement -up to January 10th, at least half must have been marketed under blockade conditions. That is the season began on September 10th. We will assume that there was no blockade until November 10th. Two months marketing, free of blockade up to November 10th, and from that date to January 10th two months of actual blockade. Therefore, it is fair to assume that if we had 50,000,000 bushels marketed free of blockade, we must have had the other 50,000,000 bushels marketed during the blockade. So, whatever loss would occur from blockade conditions would have to be suffered on not less than 50,000,000 bushels.
When I gave notice of this motion, the terminal elevators were full of grain, and no matter what the world's market price might be, the grain in the farmer's hands

must remain in his hands. It could not be stored in country elevators, for the country elevators were full; the country elevators could not empty into the terminal elevators because the terminal elevators were full; and apparently it was not possible to transport the grain from the terminal elevator to the eastern seaboard at a rate that would give any substantial relief to the condition of blockade existing. I have here a despatch appearing in the Winnipeg '(Free IPrefcs;' of January 25, which states the condition in regard to the elevators at Fort William:
There were in the Fort William books last night 3,577 cars on order not loaded

That is, ears ordered for eastern shipment.
-representing over 4,326,500 bushels of grain of all kinds; and for over three weeks there has never been less than 3,000 oars on order, but not loaded. The daily storage on 3,577 cars is $1,300 and the interest on money thus tied up is over $600 per day, making a direct daily loss to the shippers of $12,000 or $14,000 per week, making no allowance whatever for the heavy losses sustained because shippers cannot fill contract while these cars remain undelivered at destination. Railways promised to load 200 cars a day. Evidence that they have requested terminal elevators not to load grain. Situation worse now than two weeks ago. Fort William key of situation. Without relief at terminals situation in interior becomes increasingly acute. Must move 300 cars a day from terminals.
At six oclock the House took recess.
After Recess.
House resumed at eight o'clock.


Frank Oliver: When the House rose at six o'clock I was reading a dispatch to the Winnipeg ' Free Press,' dated January 25, which showed that on that date a condition of blockade existed in the terminals at Fort William. How long previous that condition had existed we are not able to say. But I assume, for the purposes of my calculation, that it began not later than January 10. At that time there was about 18 million bushels of all kinds of grain in storage in the terminals, and I find by the latest report of the Department of Trade and Commerce that on the week ending February 2 the amount in s'ore at the terminal elevators was still approximately 18 million bushels, showing that whatever the condition was at the time mentioned, it still continued up to February 5. What I desire to bring to the attention of the House is the statement made by the ' Free Press ' that the railway company was not able to forward the grain from Fort William at the rate of 200 cars a day, and allowing a period from January 10 to April 1 for the relief of the blockade conditions in time to be of any use
in the case of damp grain, we have eleven and a half weeks. Moving that grain at the rate at which this despatch says it can be moved, something less than 200 cars a day, the railway company would be able to imove 12 million /bushels during that time, and they would relieve the terminal storage to that extent. If they were also able then to bring 12 million bushels forward from the wheat fields to the terminals they would relieve the conditions in the wheat fields to that extent. But on the statement of Mr. Thompson, of the Ogilvie Milling Company, that on January 10 there were 30 million bushels still in the wheat fields, that is to say, in the farmer's hands, either in the stook or threshed, there would still be from 13 to 18 million bushels left in the fields or on the farmer's hands on the 1st of April, after which date the grain that was damp and liable to heat would practically be useless for commercial purposes. Unless damp grain is kept in condition by cold weather or reaches a drying plant before the 1st of April, it has, in all human probability, become destroyed, so far as commercial value is concerned. Therefore, on the statement which I have before me, and I am sure it is a very moderate statement, the country is face to face with a probable loss of some 13 to 18 million bushels of wheat by reason of this blockade.
I have said that the loss to the farmer on the expectation of his crop was estimated at about 25 million bushels. At 60 cents a bushel the loss to the farmer will be $15,000,000. But, unfortunately, besides the shortage of the crop is the loss to the farmer by reason of depreciated quality, owing to the unfavourab'e season of late growth and harvest. What the depreciation actually is must be a matter of estimate. But we can form a fair estimate fey taking the quality of grain in store at the terminals at a certain date. I find also in a statement of the Department of Trade and Commerce that theie was in store in the terminals in January, twelve and a half million bushels of wheat. Of this, four and a half million bushels graded No. 3 and upwards;
3	and a quarter millions graded 4, 5 and 6;
4	and three-quarter millions were below No. 6. That is to say, speaking roughly, one-third of the total was good milling wheat, one-third was poor milling wheat, and one-third was unfit for milling. As to the depreciation in price because of the depreciation in quality, I quote Winnipeg prices of January 25. No. 1 Northern was worth 961 cts.; No. 3 Northern, 88 cts.; No. 5, 73 cts.; Feed, 57 cts.; Feed tough, 51 cts; a spread of 8 cents between 1 and 3 Northern, of 15 cents between 3 and 5 Northern, of 16 cents between 5 Northern and Feed, and a spread of 6 cents between


Frank Oliver: at the close of navigation, conditions settle. The grain goes into storage, it is not forwarded as rapidly, some relief is given by transportation eastward, and, generally speaking, the condition of blockade ceases at or soon after the close of navigation. But, in the case of this season, instead of the expectation of relief being realised, the condition of blockade was made permanent and was accentuated. While there was a reasonable reflex on the farmer in his price because of the blockade condition existing before December 10, after December 10 a panic condition ensued and panic prices became the rule to the farmer. Instead of the country operator paying the farmer the winter price subject to the reduction that I have made for storage, insurance and other charges, being faced with the possibility that he could not get the grain forwarded at all, or did not know when he could get it forwarded panic prices resulted to the farmer, panic conditions prevailed and have prevailed ever since.
I have already said that unless the damaged grain gets to the hospital elevator by the first of April it is, in all probability, destroyed. This fact, of course, accentuates the panic condition that prevails this season. Of course, all figures must be estimates, actual accuracy cannot be demonstrated, but the figures which I propose to give the committee are unquestionably within the mark. On the 50,000,000 bushels of grain marketed between November 10 and January 10-that is marketed between the first blockade condition and January 10 when the blockade condition was demonstrated to be impossible of relief-estimating the loss to the farmers at six cents a bushel, the loss to the farmers would be $3,000,000. But, on the 50,000,000 bushels remaining to be marketed after J anuary 10, and, which, according to the statement of Mr. Thompson of the Ogilvie Milling Company, must be marketed under panic conditions, I think it is a very moderate estimate to say that the loss would be ten cents a bushel to the farmers, or a loss of $5,000,000 from January 10 to the end of the season and of $3,000,000 from the beginning of the blockade on November 10 to January 10.


Frederick Laurence Schaffner: Do I understand the hon. gentleman to say that 50,000,000 bushels was the amount of wheat in the farmers hands on January 10?


Frank Oliver: Yes.


Frederick Laurence Schaffner: I presume that the hon. gentleman must know that it has never been the custom of the western farmers to ship all their grain out, but that- a great deal of the grain is kept over until the following summer and that it would

not have been shipped if there had been ever so many cars.


Frank Oliver: I have already said to the committee that the fact of so much of the grain being damp, makes it necessary that the grain shall be got forward to the drying or hospital elevators, or it will go out of condition. It will be seriously damaged or altogether destroyed. The conditions this season differ from ordinary conditions.


Mr. STAPLES.: What percentage of this
50,000,000 bushels was damaged?


Frank Oliver: I have the statement of Mr. Thompson, of the Ogilvie Milling Company, and also of a Mr. Black, I think- at any rate of two gentlemen connected with the Ogilvie Milling Company-both estimating that 30,000,000 bushels will be remaining in the farmers' hands or damaged by reason of being damp, a large part of it unthreshed at that time, and a considerable part of it is unthreshed yet. My hon. friends, _ who are acquainted with farming conditions, know that if grain in the stook when the snow comes on, is threshed, that grain must get to where it will be dried before the hot weather comes on, because, otherwise it would be very much damaged.


Frederick Laurence Schaffner: It is not threshed yet, is it?


Frank Oliver: A great deal of it is not threshed. When a blockade exists, and it becomes impossible for either the farmer or the dealer to get the grain forwarded, then certainly the grain is safer in the stook than it is in the farmers' granary or in the country elevator.
There is no doubt that there is a great deal of grain to-day remaining unthreshed in the stooks, that if there was no blockade would have been threshed and gone forward, and the farmer would have got the money for it.


William D. Staples: How does the hon. gentleman make that out?


Frank Oliver: My hon. friend (Mr. Staples) lives in a farming constituency, and he knows perfectly well that what I am saying is correct, and there is m use arguing it between us.


William D. Staples: I am only asking the hon. gentleman for information. I am proud to say I am a farmer and have a fair knowledge of what takes place amongst the farming community, and I can state that every available threshing machine has been working overtime trying to get the grain threshed.


Frank Oliver: Well, I am not disputing that at all. I have said that there is a great deal of the grain still unthreshed, 128
and I have said that in my judgment it is more than likely that a great deal of that grain would have been threshed if there had been no blockade.. But, there being a blockade, there was no object in threshing it when it would have suffered greater damage after being threshed than it was suffering by remaining in the stooks, when it was not possible to get it forwarded properly.


William D. Staples: Does the hon. gentleman mean that the threshing machines in the west have been idle instead of operating?


Frank Oliver: I mean in some cases they have undoubtedly.


William D. Staples: I can assure you they have not.


Frank Oliver: My hon. friend (Mr. Staples) is no doubt familiar with the constituency he represents, but the conditions in that constituency, as the House knows, are not the same as they are in other parts of the west.


William D. Staples: I have a fair knowledge of the whole west.


Frank Oliver: Then my hon. friend will have to allow us who represent other parts of the west to speak for our own constituencies just as we will be glad to have the hon. gentleman speak for the part of the west he represents.


William D. Staples: Then I understand the hon. gentleman to say that in the part of the west he represents the threshing machines have been idle.


Frank Oliver: Yes, at some parts of the year undoubtedly. I was giving the House an estimate, a conservative estimate I believe, of the direct loss to the farmer as the result of the blockade conditions. I got as far as the estimated loss on wheat, but I wish to add that in my judgment it is reasonable to consider that on oats, barley and flax, which are subject to the same blockade conditions, there would be a loss of no less than two million dollars. My estimate is that on wheat, oats, barley and flax, and because of the depreciation in price to the farmers resulting from blockade conditions in this season the farmers have suffered a loss of not less than ten million dollars.


Mr. STEVENS.: The hon. gentleman stated that there was a loss of five million dollars on wheat, taking fifty million bushels at ten cents a bushel, but a moment afterwards' the hon. gentleman admitted that there were about thirty million bushels of this which was damaged and it would necessarily be forced to go forward, and, as we know, it is the custom of the farmers to hold a large quantity over. So, I think,



if he is fair in_his estimate, it would be right to cut his five million bushels down to at least three million bushels. We want to have as fair an estimate as we can.


Frank Oliver: I want to say to my hon. friend and to the House generally that I have made this estimate as moderate as in my judgment the circumstances will admit in accordance with truth. When my hon. friend suggests that we have thirty million bushels of damaged grain which must go forward or be lost, and which cannot go forward by reason of the blockade, he surely must also admit that my estimate is below the mark rather than above it. But I want to dwell a little on this point of the damaged grain and the liability of the total destruction of that grain. I have only dealt with the loss that is accruing to-day, and it is a very moderate estimate of the loss that I have given on the grain that is going forward; that is, the grain upon which the commercial value is not altogether destroyed. But there is no doubt that there is a large part of the grain crop-and the evidence of Mr. Thompson and of Mr. Black and the evidence of the sense of any man who has travelled in the west this -winter shows it, there is a large part of the grain crop that stands in danger of total destruction. To repeat: every man knows that when wheat is threshed in a damp condition, when that wheat is stored as it must be stored, unless it is dry before being stored it is bound to heat and if it heats its commercial value will either be destroyed or be depreciated to such an extent as to be a very great loss. That is the condition we are face to face with. Remember, I have shown that on the statement made as to the possibility of transportation out of the terminal elevators there must be left in the farmers' hands anywhere from thirteen million bushels to eighteen million Ibushels of wheat until April 1st.


Mr. BURNHAM.: Can they not feed that wheat to anything?


Frank Oliver: If they had something to feed it to they could-well, perhaps I had better stick to the subject. I was going to make a remark about certain classes of live stock that might be used to feed the wheat to if we had our farms near Peterborough, hut I won't. I said, Mr Speaker that on Mr. Thompson's estimate there were thirty million bushels unfit for milling, on Mr. Black's estimate there were thirty million bushels unthreshed at the time he made the estimate, and I say that if the damaged grain is not in the hospital by April 1, its value will be either altogether or largely destroyed. The farmers have been advised Mr. STEVENS.
to build granaries; the farmers have been advised to do a great many things, but I want to say to the House that the farmers' granary does not meet this case. Let the farmer have as fine a, granary as he may please, if he stores that grain in it that grain will be damaged or destroyed and the same exactly applies in the case of a country elevator which has no drying facilities. The damaged grain must get forward to the drying plant before 'the warm weather sets in or it will be lost. I am assuming that out of the thirty millions that are said to be unthreshed there is a possible loss of fifteen million bushels. If the value of that is estimated at forty cents a bushel to the farmer-because understand it is damaged grain and not grain of full value-that would be a loss of six million dollars. I want to impress upon the House and upon the Government the contingency which they are face to face with in this case. I therefore estimate the unavoidable loss to the farmers from shortage of crop and from damage to grain in this season at thirty-five million dollars, or one-third of the total value of their wheat crop. _
But if he is to lose $10,000,000 by reason of the grain blockade-and any man who is interested in either the growing or marketing of grain will say that he is going to lose a great deal more-and if on top of that, he is to lose $6,000,000 by reason of damaged grain, his loss will he on account of unavoidable causes, $35,000,000, and on account of avoidable causes, $16,000,000; a total of $51,000,000, or one-half of the total value of his crop. We have heard that the west is a rich country and that the people there are optimistic and recover from a condition of difficulty very easily; and it is pointed out to us that parts of that country have been settled for 30 years, and that the farmers should be in a condition to take care of their crop, and should not be in such a condition as to have no place to store it safely when it is out of condition. Let me remind the House that 150,000 homesteads have been taken in the four years from 1908 to 1911, as many as were taken in the years from 1875 to 1903. That is, there were as many homesteads taken in the western provinces in the last four years as were taken in the 28 years which ended in 1903. That is to say, we have as many absolutely new settlers in the country as we had old settlers between those dates. It is a necessary condition of the rapid expansion of settlement in that country that there must always be, so long as that rapid expansion continues, a very large proportion of people who are only in the beginning of establishing themselves who are not by any possibility in a position to protect themselves on such an occasion as the present season. It is well, I

think, that the House and the country should understand that at least one-third of the homesteading population of that country, have come there within the past three years; and let it be remembered that it is on the new settler, who is not well fitted with buildings and equipment, who is farthest from the railroad and therefore, under the greatest disabilities, that the bulk of the loss falls. I want to impress upon the House the serious damage that is being done to the progress of that country by reason of the losses that are being suffered this year.
It is not only the settler who suffers loss. The farmer buys largely on credit, and the storekeeper sells when he knows that the farmer has no money. They all expect to get their money out of the crop. So that the store bills, and all other bills and notes' mature in November or December; and when the whole business of the country depends upon the collection of the year's accounts in either of these months, and the accounts cannot be collected, because the grain has not been marketed, although it has been grown, there is a disarrangement of the business of the country, which is damaging to its every interest. The damage is not confined to the farmer; it spreads into every line_ of business. Cases have come to my notice, and I have no doubt to the notice of many other members of the -House, of not only farmers, but business men who have been actually put out of business by reason of the grain blockade this year. Farmers and business men who were doing the best they could, and would have succeeded, even in the face of the unfortunate weather conditions that prevailed; have been put out of business absolutely because the money that the crop was worth, could not be realized because of this blockade.
As the resolution which I have placed before the House mentions, action has been taken by the government to give some measure of relief. The railway companies have been consulted, and I presume, in response to suggestion or pressure by the government, have made certain arrangements which will result in their being able to give transportation to elevator accommodation by shorter hauls Jhan up to the present time exist. I have inquired into the measure of relief that has been proposed, and I desire to give to the House some of the particulars. The Canadian Pacific railway has issued a rate sheet on wheat and oats to Minneapolis and Duluth, giving the same rate of freight to those points as to Fort William. This rate became effective on February 16, and it expires on April 30. It is effective for 74 days. But 34 days expired between the date of the issue of the rate sheet, and the date of its coming into effect, and 67 days expired between the close of navigation and the com-1261
ing into effect of this rate. This rate applies only to the province of Saskatchewan and only to grain for export.
The Canadian Northern railway have given a rate on wheat to Duluth and it is also the^ same rate as to Fort William, which applies only on shipments in transit in bond through the tjnited States for exports. It was approved by the Interstate Commerce Commission on January 20, 1912, and_ became effective on January 29. It expires on April 30, and will be in force 91 days. It became effective 49 days after the close of navigation, and was effective 9 days after it was approved by the Interstate Commerce Commission. The Canadian Pacific railway also gave a rate on barley and flax to Minneapolis. This rate was issued on December 20, 1911, and became effective on January 23, 1912. It expires on April 30, and is effective 98 days. It became effective 43 days after navigation closed, and 34 days expired between the date of its issue and the date of its coming into effect. This rate on barley and flax is not the Fort William rate. It is 4 cents higher per 100 pounds than the Fort William rate, ion barley and flax from Manitoba, and 9 cents per 100 pounds higher than the Fort William rate on barley and flax from Saskatchewan. The difference is practically 2 cents a bushel for barley and flax in Manitoba, and 41 cents a bushel in Saskatchewan. I want to give the House some facts in regard to the possibilities of the marketing of barley under this arrangement. Because it will be observed, Ijhat "while the wheat rate is only, for bonding in transit, the barley and flax rate is for consumption in the United States, and so it is interesting to us to know if there is any market for barley for consumption in the United States. I have here a statement in regard to a car of feed barley shipped from Carman, Manitoba, to Minneapolis, on December 8, 1911. The car contained 1,253 06 bushels, and was sold at Minneapolis at $1.07 a bushel realizing $1,340.84. ' That is to say less freight charges $72.53, customs entry charges $1.20, weighing charges 40 cents, switching charges $1.50, commission in Minneapolis $12.53, commission in Winnipeg $12.53, total $100.69; net proceeds of the car in Minneapolis $1,240.15. The Fort William price was 50 cents a bushel, the Minneapolis price was $1.07 a bushel. The Minneapolis net price, that is less the expenses I have mentioned was 99 cents a bushel.


Mr. BRADBURY.: What was the duty?


Frank Oliver: The duty was 30 cents a bushel,: and the Minneapolis net price less duty, was 69 cents a bushel. The value of the car at Fort William was. $626.54, and the net value of the car at Minneapolis was


George Henry Bradbury: If these figures are accurate, and I presume the hon. gentleman thinks they are, does it not seem reasonable that the farmers would ship all their barley to the United States and pay the duty?


Frank Oliver: I think they are going to ship a very large proportion of it there once they get the freight rates. But the rates that applied on that car were rates on the Great Northern which has always had a through rate to Minneapolis. Points on the other two railway systems did not have through rates to Minneapolis until this arrangement was entered into which became effective on the 23rd of January. Since that rate became effective there is no doubt that very large shipments have been taking place, and that the congestion or grade blockade has been relieved to some extent by that means.
But what I want, to draw your attention to, is the paragraph in the resolution which I have placed before the House which asks the government to make such arrangement, or to urge such arrangement, as will give the same rate on barley and flax to Minneapolis as to Fort William. On the barley that is now being shipped to Minneapolis the farmer pays two cents a bushel more than if it were shipped to Fort William, if it is from Manitoba, and 44 cents a bushel more than if it is shipped from Saskatchewan. That makes a difference of $25 a car on barley from Manitoba, and $56 a car on barley from Saskatchewan. The barley crop is estimated at 35 millions of bushels the flax crop at 6 millions of bushels. I find from the returns from the Trade and Commerce Department that 2 million bushels of barley, and 2 million bushels of flax have been received at Fort William between September 1st and December 21st. If 2 million bushels of that grain came from Manitoba, and 2 million bushels from Saskatchewan, it means that the farmers have had to pay $130,000 more upon that barley and flax in order to get the advantage of the Minneapolis market. I want to impress upon the government there is no reason, there is no justice, in making that discrimination in these rates; that if they are going to give an outlet to the western farmer who grows barley and flax, if the railroads can afford to haul wheat at the same rate to Minneapolis and Duluth as to Fort William, they can afford to haul the barley and flak at the same rate, and the


Frank Oliver: farmer should not be required to pay that 2 cents a bushel from Manitoba, and 44 cents a bushel from Saskatchewan for the privilege of getting the benefit of the Minneapolis market after paying the duty as well.
I have given the House the informa-do in order to relieve the conditions of which we have complained. Now I want to draw attention to what they might have done in order to relieve those conditions and to demonstrate how very far short they have fallen of even measurably attempting to meet these requirements. I have pointed out that the panic condition which exists to-day in the west is the consequence of the blockade in the terminal elevators.
And the reason for the continuance of the blockade in the terminal elevators is that the railway company, or companies are not able to forward the grain fast enough to the ocean port to relieve that situation. The only remedy is to find a shorter outlet. The outlet in such a case is any placS that will take the grain; and Minneapolis and Duluth are the places which are able to store the grain and are able to mill and market such of the grain as is fit for milling and marketing. As to the effort to relieve the grain blockade, let us consider a few figures. The length of haul from Winnipeg to St. Paul is 462 miles, as compared with a haul from Winnipeg to St. John of 2,178 miles-four and a half times the distance. From Moosejaw to St. Paul is 738 miles, and from Moose-jaw to St. John 2,571 miles, or three and a half times as far. From Calgary to St. Paul is 1,166 miles, and from Calgary to St. John 2,979 miles, or two and a half times as far. By taking measures which will enable the grain marketed within a radius of Winnipeg to be sent to St. Paul instead of to St. John, the capacity of the rolling stock of the railway is practically increased four and a half fold. That is if they have been able to carry 10,000,000 bushels from Winnipeg to St. John, they would have been able to carry 50,000,000 bushels in the same time from Winnipeg to St. Paul. It is obvious that there was a means of preventing the blockade, a means of breaking the blockade, but the means were not taken in time to do the work. Let me point out that if my hon. friend (Mr. Foster), had taken in time the measures which he proposes to take-I understand from the press-there would have been no blockade and the losses that have been suffered1 would not have been suffered;. If the rates and conditions which, I understand, it is proposed to put into effect on Maroh 7, had been put into effect on November 10, when a condition of blockade actually existed, not in expectation but in fact, the Canadian Pacific

railway wheat rate would have been 98 days longer; the Canadian Northern railway wheat rate 74 days longer, and1 the Canadian Pacific railway rate 74 days longer. On the average there would have been twice as 'long a time in which to deliver this grain and reduce the blockade. But although these special rates are allowed until April 30, again I submit to the committee that the month of April may be counted out so far as the transport of damaged grain is concerned with any result of saving its full value. If the period of transportation at the rates that came into effect on the date I have mentioned are taken with that month of April deducted, as it must be, the Canadian Pacific railway are giving the wheat rate for 44 effective days, the Canadian Northern railway for 61 effective days, and the Canadian Pacific railway on barley for 68 effective days. I claim on behalf of the people of the west that measures should have been taken to have these rates brought into effect at any rate as soon as the condition of blockade existed, and that had that action been taken the blockade, which had begun, would have been relieved and the country would have been many millions of dollars better off than it is going to be to-day.
To what purpose did my hon. friend take pleasures with the railway companies in this direction? Was it to relieve the situation for the farmer? If it was, then he certainly did not take measures as he should have done. Why did he restrict the operation of the rate on wheat and oats over the Canadian Pacific railway to the province of Saskatchewan? Why were the rates on barley and flax made higher than the corresponding rates on wheat and oats? Why were not these rates secured at an earlier date? Was it because he and the railway men came together and said: Thgre is so much storage in Minneapolis and Duluth and we will reduce these rates low enough to enable us to haul the grain that will fill that storage, and if we do that the rest of the grain can wait our convenience to haul it out as it best suits us? For what other reason could it have been that my hon. friend secured the regulations with these restrictions? Does he say that it was because the Interstate Commerce Commission would not give permission sooner? All I can say is that all he had to do was to ask the Interstate Commerce Commission sooner and he would have got the permission that much sooner. There is no possibility of laying the blame anywhere except on the shoulders of my hon. friend and of the government of which he is a prominent member. I find a reference to the despatches in the press that the Interstate Commerce Commission did not put any bar of lapse of time in the way of notice of the going into effect to these rates. The following despatch appeared in the Winnipeg 'Free Press' of January 22:
Washington, D.C., January 21.-The United States laws require 'thirty days' notice, and the commission never grants permission to establish rates on less time except under extraordinary emergencies. The commission's invariable policy is never to grant permission to establish rate9 on grain because it is such a sensitive proposition, inasmuch as a slight disturbance of a rate line of adjustment at any given point throws the whole matter out of gear.
In these cases it was represented to the commission that grain at certain Canadian points was damp and spoiling. The rates of Canadian carriers have hitherto been made to Fort William and Port Arthur, but storage capacity at these places has been entirely exhausted, and was so inadequate that it was desired to establish these new rate9 to United States points only for storage, drying &c., while in transit in bond through the United States for export only.
Now, in face of that fact, I want to draw the attention of the House to the rate sheet issued by the Canadian Pacific railway on the 12th of January 1912, giving rates on carloads from stations in the western provinces. It became effective on the 16th day of February, 1912. I presume that this rate sheet had the approval of the commission before it was issued; if so, I ask what excuse was there for not giving effect to that rate before the 16th of February. In the case of barley and flaxseed, the rate issued on the 20th December became effective on the 23rd of January. In the case of the Canadian Northern railway, for some reason or other, there was not the same interval between the issue of the rate sheet and its coming into effect. The Inter-state Commerce Commission gave permission, and in nine days afterwards the rate became effective. I think it is demonstrated that the delay that has occurred in bringing these rates into effect is not due to the Inter-state Commerce Commission, it is due to the arrangement entered into between my hon. friend and the Canadian railway companies, and I want to insist that that arrangement was entered into for the benefit of the railway companies instead of the benefit of the farmers. If not, why these restrictions? Why not open the door, if it had to be opened, as soon as' possible and as widely as possible? My hon. friend must have known that the conditions were as I have stated. He has under his control the machinery of the Grain Act, he has officers in touch with the grain situation throughout the west, there clould not be a grain blockade in the western country without his having knowledge of it. I say, therefore, that when he has taken action at all he is condemned be-

cause he did not, take action in time to be effective. To make it sure that the government had knowledge of these conditions, I read the report of E. D. Eddy,
B.S.A., published by the Department of Agriculture under date of Ottawa, January 12. This report deals with the crop and climatic conditions throughout the west, it is a part of the public service for which this country pays, and the government not only had it in their hands, but it is their statement for which they are responsible. This report says:
The climatic conditions prevailing throughout the prairie provinces of Canada were very abnormal during the season of 1911. Seeding was largely done about the usual time, from the middle of April to the middle of May and under favourable conditions. During the latter part of May and June the conditions were favourable, with sufficient rain in most parts and reasonably warm weather. July was cloudy, showery and cool, growth being rapid and almost rank, but toward the end of the month rust appeared in some parts and there was little sign of ripening. During August unseasonably cold weather prevailed, preventing ripening, rust became prevalent in some districts, and frost occurred from August 22 to Aug 28 doing great damage. During September the weather was generally cold and wet with heavy damage resulting to the crops from frost and rust. Damaging frosts occurred in many districts on September 6, 8, 21 and 25. During the first part of October the weather was moderately dry and warm, but owing to rust and the abundant supply of moisture crops refused to ripen. The freeze up came on October 25, or three weeks earlier than usual. Much cutting still remained to be done, and as the stocks were wet from recent rains considerable injury resulted to even fairly well matured grain which was in etook. The latter part of October was cold, and on November 1st the temperature dropped to 6 below zero. On November 4th something very unusual in Saskatchewan and Manitoba, after tho freeze up, happened; the weather suddenly turned warm and rain fell all day. This was followed on November 8 with from 3 to a inches of snow and on November 10, 20 below zero was registered. The snow and extreme cold in November came when a large proportion of the threshing remained to be done. December was remarkably fair and mild and the threshing was continued, but the grain that was in stock is very tough and. a large proportion of it unmarketable.
With these facts in hand, with the knowledge of the conditions that must have come to the Minister of Trade and Commerce, I again ask what excuse has he to offer for failing to take the action that lay before him from the beginning of the season?	When he did take action
why did he not take effective action? I have asked	a question, and I
propose to give to the House the answer that appears to be correct. I think a large part of the answer may be found in a dispatch from Duluth, Minnesota, dated Mr. OLIVER.
January 21, which appears in the Winnipeg ' Free Press ' of January 22, 1912. It reads as follows:
The expected advantages to Duluth millers from the granting of a special low rate on grain from the Canadian Northwest to this city, have been dispelled by advices received here that a ruling had been made prohibiting the admitting of this grain unless the duty on it, plus the difference between the regular rate and the special rate, shall first be paid. The ruling is said to be the result of a protest by Canadian millers, who claimed that permission to mill grain here without additional costs could constitute discrimination against them.
I have a further light on that subject contained in an interview which appeared in the Montreal 1 Gazette " of July 11 with Mr. F. W. Thompson, vice-president and managing director of the Ogilvie Flour Mills Company in which he said:
Even Canadian millers may experience considerable difficulty in getting sufficient high grade wheat to fully meet their requirements, and the question of an export duty on the high grade wheats, as a mutter of protection to the home requirements and seed, may with every justification be seriously considered.
I find in the speech that the hon. Minister of Finance (Mr. White) delivered in this House on November 23, 1911, the following remarks:
Why should Canada not do the milling business that will go to the millers of Minneapolis?


Thomas Simpson Sproule: I am afraid that the hon. gentleman is transgressing the" rule. It is not permissible to refer to a previous debate.


Frank Oliver: I shall not make any further reference to it and I shall not quote any further from it. The rule was not in my mind or I would not have transgressed, I assure you, Mr. Speaker. Action should have been taken by the government according to the knowledge that was in their possession at the time.
The policy of the government, as they are pleased to say, looks to building up the industries and interests of this country of ours by a process of restriction. It. is distinctly in giving effect to that policy that these millions of bushels of damaged wheat in the Northwest are in danger of absolute destruction and it is in pursuance of that policy that the people of the Northwest, the farmers and business men, have lost the millions of dollars that they have lost during the past season from the blockade conditions. There is no escape from the condition. The remedy my hon. friend proposes shall be taken on the 7th of March when, if the newspapers inform us correctly, the rates on barley and flax to Minneapolis and Duluth will be

reduced to the Fort William rates and the rates on wheat and oats will be the rates for grinding in bond and for home consumption as well as for export. But I say that if these conditions had been allowed to prevail at the beginning of the grain blockade on November 10 there would not have been that loss and damage to ^his country that have occurred. If my hon. friends see fit in pursuance of their policy of building up this country by a process of restriction to violate that policy, then it is only right that the country should be made aware of the consequences that are being suffered now by reason 'of that policy. It is too late, I am sorry to say, to save the situation now. My hon. friend has allowed it to go too far, but he shows that he has knowledge of how it could have been saved and he shows that even this process of restriction which he advocates so capably, and which is none the better for his capable advocacy, has broken down and he is compelled by the force of circumstances to abandon it, but he is abandoning it too late. The condition which has existed this past season and which, in the estimation of my hon. friend himself and his colleagues, has called for the abrogation of that- policy of restriction at the last moment when it is too late, may be repeated in future seasons. Probably it will be measurably repeated in all near future seasons unless the country has suffered such a set-back by reason of the results of last season's operations that its expansion in production will be checked.
If, that expansion in production proceeds as rapidly in the future as it has in the past then it will be, if not as neees-say, yet still necessary to find an outlet for our western grains by the shortest rail-haul in future seasons or the country will suffer damage-incalculable damage -such as it has suffered this season. My hon. friend and his colleagues are face to face now with a condition, not a theory. I hope I have been able to impress, that point on their minds and that if they are instrumental in bringing into effect on the 7th March a reduction in grain rates from western points in Minneapolis and Duluth and placing them on the same level as to Fort William they will use the same endeavours to have these rates permanently continued for the benefit of the western producer and for the benefit of the developement of this whole country. I want to ask my hon. friend and those of his colleagues and supporters who believe in that policy of restriction in this country where the benefit to any interest comes out of the loss that is being suffered on the prairies to-day. I ask, is it the banker, is it the merchant, is it the manufacturer, is it the railway company-which of all these interests if benefiting by that
loss? It is a loss to the farmer, it is true, but it is a loss to every other interest in this country. Right in the cities of Toronto and Montreal, the very chapel, the very church, the very cathedral of the doctrine of the restrictive policy, in these ivery centres, the effect of the losses that are being suffered to-day by 'reason of the restrictive policy of the government that is in power, is being felt. Those losses are being suffered in those cities as well as on the prairies of the west. Although we have great confidence in the future of our country, although our country has made great progress in the past and we believe will make good progress in the future I want to warn my hon. friend that it cannot stand a continuation of such shocks and losses as it has suffered this season at the hands of himself and his colleagues and still prosper and progress as we wish it to do.


Mr. DAVIDSON.: I would like to know what effect the resolution of the hon. gentleman (Mr. Oliver) would have upon the trusts the mergers and the combines; I ,do not think he made that point clear.


Frank Oliver: If my hon. friend will explain to the House what relation his question bears to the subject I have been dealing with, I will try to answer him.


Avard Longley Davidson: I thought that was a point the hon. gentleman left out.


Mr.  H. H.@: STEVENS (Vancouver.) It is not my intention to detain the House at any length in speaking on this question. I certainly congratulate the hon. member (Mr. Oliver) for the exhaustive study he has made of this question, and I also wish to state that a great deal of the information he has gathered will no doubt be of great value to the members of the House and to the public. But, I do not agree entirely with him in the conclusions he has arrived at. In the first place, I think every member of the House will agree that it is a most regrettable thing that this grain blocade prevails to-day in the Northwest Territories. We are all exceedingly sorry that certain losses will occur, but I think it reasonable and fair that we should take info consideration all of the factors that have operated in the causing of this, what we may call, almost a national calamity. The hon. member (Mr. Oliver) has pointed out that there will be considerable monetary loss occurring as the result of the damage to the crops of the Northwest, but the chief object of his speech was to lav upon the shoulders /of the present administration certain responsibility for the prevailing conditions.


Frederick Laurence Schaffner: That is his whole object.


Henry Herbert Stevens: I wish to draw the attention of the House to some of the causes which have led to the existing conditions. The chief reasons for the conditions which obtain in the northwest at the, present time are natural causes over which no human power has any control. In the first place as pointed out by the hon. member in the quotation he gave from the official bulletin of the Department of Agriculture, the season was a most extraordinary one, wet weather having come in the middle of the year. I think if the hon. gentleman had been as careful to quote the press reports up to about the first of August he would find the utmost optimism running through them, and the cry ' bumper crop * was on the lips of every one from ocean to ocean. We all rejoiced at the prospect of the large crop that the farmers of the west were going to have, but a little later in the season a most unusual thing occurred, when wet and cold weather set in, with the result that the grain did not ripen. That was a condition over which no government had control and against which it was impossible for any human agency to guard. It was consequently, late in the fall before harvesting was begun, and then when harvesting was actually in progress, the continued wet weather hampered further harvesting operations, and threshing. As a matter of fact, a great deal of the grain had been cut green, taking the chance of it drying in the stooks. No matter what your transportation facilities might have been, that grain which was cut partially green, would have been of a much inferior grade, and in all probability would have gone to the elevators in a semi-ripened condition. All these factors are entirely beyond the control of any government or of any human being. Another point I wish to draw attention to, is that, the congestion of grain in the northwest is a thing that will obtain every year, just so long as the farmers of the northwest follow the system of harvesting and marketing which they follow at the present time. A few weeks ago those of us who were not prairie farmers, were told we should mind our own business, and not make suggestions to the farmers of the Northwest, regarding granaries. But, I make bold to state that if the farmers of the Northwest were to provide suitable granaries for their grain, they would experience a great deal less trouble. I want to tell hon. gentlemen opposite, who scoff at that idea now, that the time is coming when the farmers of the northwest will have to provide granaries for their grain, and they might just _ as well admit the fact now as later. How in the name of common sense can they expect that the huge harvest in the west in a good season, can be marketed within four or five weeks, and that is really what they are demanding.


Frederick Laurence Schaffner: They cut their grain, thresh it right out of the stooks, and haul it immediately -to the-market, and expect to have cars enough to carry that grain to the seaboard within a few weeks. It would be far better for the farmers of the west, if they had granaries in which to store their grain, so that they could market it gradually.


William Erskine Knowles: Does the hon. gentle, man recall the fact that 150,000 of these farmers are still homesteaders who have gone in within the last four years. How could they be expected to have granaries, considering their financial circumstances?


Henry Herbert Stevens: What the hon. member
says

Mr. CLARK (Red Deer;. They are glad to get shacks.


Henry Herbert Stevens: The hon. member from Red Deer is heard from.


Mr. CLARK (Red1 Deer).: I know all about it.


Henry Herbert Stevens: As a matter of fact it is not the homesteader who has just gone on his land and cropped twenty-five or thirty acres that is to blame; it is the men with four hundred acres, one thousand acres, and two thousand acres who cause the congestion.


Frank Oliver: They are not the men who suffer.


Henry Herbert Stevens: The man who suffers is the homesteader w'ho has just cropped his few acres of land. I say that it is the system that is followed by the old timers comparatively speaking of the Northwest that is responsible to a large extent for the suffering of the other settlers.


Frank Oliver: I understand the hon. gentleman (Mr. Stevens), is familiar with the conditions in the west, and I want to ask him: if a farmer has a granary, the best that ever was built, and his grain is damp when he threshes it or has snow in it, and he stores it in that granary, and it remains until the warm weather sets in, what happens to that grain?


Henry Herbert Stevens: As a matter of fact the condition of the grain when it is threshed is a thing over which no transportation companies or no government can exercise any control whatever, and while it is a matter for regret that that man shall suffer because of that fact, we cannot blame the government, because his grain is wet when he threshes it.


Frank Oliver: Will the hon. gentleman answer my question?


Henry Herbert Stevens: Yes; I will go a little further; I do not say that a man should1 put his grain in his granary and keep it

there -until the hot weather comes-. The hon. member (Mr. Oliver), is authority for the statement that if it is not moved by May, I think that is w-hat he said.


Frank Oliver: I said if it is not in the drier by the 1st of April in an ordinarily early spring it is practically gone.


Henry Herbert Stevens: Take it at the first of April, and, therefore, the farmer is not called upon to store his grain until late in the summer. The point is this, that if the farmers had these granaries the bulk of this partially damaged grain, or grain that would be damaged if it is kept into the spring, could be moved1 during the winter months. The hon. member will agree with me that in the majority of seasons the farmer is better off to hold his good grain until May or June.


Frank Oliver: No.	.


Henry Herbert Stevens: Well, I think that is the case. I will tell you what a number of farmers in the northwest are doing at present, because some of them have told me this themselves.
They get the grain to the market as rapidly as they can, and then play the wheat market in Winnipeg for a rise in the price, and get a profit in that way. They sell their grain in the fall instead of holding it, and then buy wheat on margin in Winnipeg for a rising price. Any number of them do that, and it is a practice for which I have very little sympathy. On the -other hand, if the farmer had his granary, so that he could hold his wheat and sell it whenever he liked, he could control the market and get a better price. But none of the farmers have granaries, and the result is that they are compelled to sell their grain at the price which the owners of the small elevators in the small centres choose to give them. If these elevators are full, the farmer has to keep his grain, and his only choice is to leave it in the fields or bring it to market and sell it at a figure which is arbitrarily fixed by a congested maiket.


Mr. WHITE (Victoria, Alberta).: Does the hon. gentleman know that tin cash price of wheat to-day in Minneapolis is four cents over the May price?


Henry Herbert Stevens: That may be. I am not disputing that fact at all.


Frank Oliver: Why would the farmer hold his wheat m that case?


Henry Herbert Stevens: It is optional. If a man has his wheat in his granary, he can sell it, or he can hold it and control the market. The reason the market is not steady is that at certain periods of the year it is flooded with grain while at other periods there is not sufficient supply. In any case, if the present system were changed
so that the farmer had granaries in which his grain would be stored, the present conditions would be corn'pletely changed. I quite admit that this year is an extraordinary one. There is a large amount of grain which it is necessary to rush to the drying elevators; but that is accentuated by natural conditions -over which no government could have any control. The hon. member for Edmonton tried to estimate the loss which was sustained in the northwest, saying that 50,000,000 bushels of grain were in the hands of the farmers, of which he admitted that only 30,000,000 bushels were partially damaged. It is well known that a large number of farmers are in the habit of holding their wheat until May, June or July -of the following year, and sometimes it is held over for two years, but not very frequently.


John Gillanders Turriff: They must have granaries if they do that.


Henry Herbert Stevens: There are a few. The 50,000,000 mentioned by the hon. member for Edmonton represent about the average that is held, compared with the full crop this year. So that it is reasonable to say that his estimate of the loss is an exaggeration by at least two or three million dollars. There is no necessity under present conditions of exaggerating the loss that will occur this year, nor is it necessary to draw these pessimistic pictures which have been drawn here for the last couple of months of conditions in the northwest, with one sole object, namely, to cast reflections on the present administration. As a matter of fact, the present administration have done everything that is within human power to do to meet the conditions that obtain in the Northwest at the present time.


William Erskine Knowles: Would it not help the farmers in the northwest to have access to the drying facilities in Minneapolis and Duluth, not to mention better prices, and cculd not the government have got that if they had wished?


Henry Herbert Stevens: As a matter of fact, the government have got it. I am perfectly sure that had the hon. member from Edmonton been on the treasury benches at the present time, he could not have done anything more to secure that relief than the present Minister of Trade and Commerce has done.


Mr. MARTIN (Regina).: Reciprocity.


Henry Herbert Stevens: Reciprocity is dead. All that the hon. members of the opposition hoped to have received from reciprocity was access to the American market. If the American people wish to remove the duty from wheat, they can do so, we are not hindering them. All that we refused to do was to pay them a bonus

to remove that duty. When the hon. members trot out reciprocity as a relief to the farmers of the northwest in the the present condition, it is an absolute bugaboo.


William Erskine Knowles: The hon. member has not answered my question. I ask: suppose reciprocity had been taken advantage of, and access to the American market had been secured for our farmers, does the hon. member not think that it would have afforded a very substantial measure of relief for them this season?


Henry Herbert Stevens: I do not, for this reason. Had reciprocity passed, it would gimply have made a slight difference_ in the duty on wheat going into the United States.
. Mr. MARTIN (Regina). 25 cents a bushel.


Henry Herbert Stevens: If the American people want our wheat so badly as the hon. members intimate they do, they can remove the duty and get it; but they are not inclined to do that. As a matter of fact, the hon. gentleman's question was fully answered on the 21st of September. The hon. member for Edmonton asks why action was not taken sooner in order to give certain relief which as he suggested could have been given by the Minister. In the same sentence almost he made the statement that the wheat was in the stook, and that it was impossible to harvest and thresh it up to a very recent period. As a matter of fact, throughout the whole northwest to-day every threshing machine, as far as I have been able to learn, is working overtime trying to thresh the grain that has been lying on the ground during the winter. The reason the grain has not been threshed is not because the farmers do not want it threshed, but because there are not the necessary threshing facilities to do it.


Frank Oliver: My hon. friend has presumed to quote me, and I wish to say that he has not quoted me correctly.


Henry Herbert Stevens: The hon. gentleman will admit that he read a circular as the authority of the government for its knowledge of the conditions, and it set out the exact conditions that I have stated.
During the balance of the season and through certain rains that came on in December, and through a subsequent thaw, and through snow, and so on, it has been impossible to get, thushing done. Now I think I am perfectly correct in that statement, and so I affirm that I care not what the transportation facilities were, the same condition would have obtained, namely, that a large amount of the wheat would have been lying on the ground at the present time in exactly the condition in which it is, because every threshing machine has Mr. STEVENS.
been doing its utmost and working to its full capacity to thresh that grain. Therefore, I want to point out to the hon. members opposite, that the condition which obtains in the northwest to-day in reference to the grain blockade, is to a large extent, or almost entirely, the result of natural conditions, over which no human being has any control, and to the system which obtains in parts of the northwest. Another point is this-I have not the exact figures here, I have not time to secure them, but I think probably the Minister of Trade and Commerce may have them, and will supply them later on-I think some 10,000 cars more were moved within a given time this year by the Canadian Pacific railway than were moved last year or in any other previous year, showing that the transportation companies have done a great deal more to move the grain this year than they ever did before, and that it is unreasonable to expect a transportation company to ha.ve sufficient cars lying idle on the prairies of the Northwest to handle all the wheat, out of the large crop of last year, within the short period of two weeks. Another thing that the transportation companies are faced with is this: A farmer will order a car for, we will say, the 20th of October, or some like date. When that date comes around Mr. Farmer is not prepared to load the car, and he puts his name down the list a month, with the result that while the car may have been assigned to him he is not using it, and it is necessary for the transportation company to switch that car off to some other farmer. This is a matter of common occurrence. I think it is only reasonable and fair that we should take into consideration all the facts of the case, and while I have no brief for any railway or transportation company, not for one moment, at the same time, I do believe that the blockade conditions are due more to natural causes than they are due to the negligence of the railroads in the northwest. I certainly think no case has been made out which would warrant hon. members of this House in condemning the_ administration in this matter, but the Minister of Trade and Commerce should rather be highly commended for his efforts to relieve the situation there, and not only that, but for the introduction of the Grain Bill, which is one of the most up-to-date pieces of legislation which has ever been introduced into this House. I believe that instead of trying to work up an ima-ginery case, based on inferences, and not facts, against the administration, it would be a great deal better if hon. gentlemen opposite had some concrete and reasonable suggestion to make which would assist the administration, rather than to hamper it.


Mr. W. A. BUCHANAN (Medicine Hat).: Mr. Speaker, the matter now before the House I consider, as a western mem-

ber and also as a citizen of this Dominion, is one of the most vital questions that has so far been presented for our consideration during the present session, and I believe that every hon. gentleman will agree with me in that view. If western Canada suffers from a car shortage, or suffers in any other respect, so that the people there cannot get returns for their crops, then the rest of Canada must suffer as a result. I have heard gentlemen in this House make the statement that the welfare of eastern Canada depended upon the welfare of western Canada, and I believe most of us will concur in that observation. In considering this matter I want to discuss it as fairly as possible, but before entering upon some arguments in regard to the resolution now before the House. I would like to enlighten the hon. member for Vancouver (Mr. Stevens), although I am afraid any attempt to enlighten that hon. gentleman along the lines indicated in his speech would take up a great deal too much of our time. All that I can say to him is that I would be very glad to exchange my place of abode with him for a few months each year and give him the opportunity to become acquainted close at hand with the conditions in the prairie provinces. I believe that if he had been acquainted with those conditions he would not have made the remarks he did to-night in regard to this question. The hon. gentleman endeavoured to relieve the present government of any blame in connection with the situation in western Canada and he said there were exceptional conditions there, which we all knew of or heard of through the press and from reports that came down from the west. I admit we had to face exceptional conditions, but I urge the government should have immediately proceeded to deal with them in the most drastic manner possible, and should have put into effect what we are urging to-night in this resolution-that is have given the western farmer other trade outlets for his grain, the closest possible outlets, in order to relieve the congestion which has prevailed in the -wept during the past season. That was the duty of the government, and the members on this side are criticising them to-night, because of their inaction in this critical matter. They attempted to afford relief in regard to export grain, but they should have gone further at the same time and given the farmers in the west an opportunity of getting their grain into Minneapolis either for grinding in bond or for consumption in the United States. I can tell hon. gentlemen that there was a ready demand for the grain of western Canada in Minneapolis. I had a statement
riiade to me by a gentleman from western Canada, who was in the elevator business, or at least is in touch with large interests there, that the representatives of one of the grain growers' associations of Saskatchewan went down to Minneapolis and ascertained that they could sell there to a commission house 100 cars each of every grade of grain up to No. 6, and also what is known as Feed Wheat. They could have sold that grain in the markets of Minneapolis. All they wanted was to get a better railroad rate and they could have obtained, even after paying the duty, a better price for their grain than could be got in Canada. I was informed of that condition by a man who is intimately acquainted with the elevator business in the province of Saskatchewan. I want to say that if we had had in western Canada a crop such as seemed probable in the early part of the season, we would have had the greatest crop that the west ever had. If we had had that crop and ideal conditions for harvesting, the railroads there simply could not have handled it any more than they are in a position to handle the crop that we actually had this year smaller and damaged though it was.
I also want to point out to my hon. friend from Vancouver (Mr. Stevens) that when he states that the railroads have been keeping in touch with the advance of western Canada in regard to the supplying of cars, he is, in my opinion, entirely mistaken. I do not believe that the railroads have been keeping in touch with the growth of the country in that respect, and I think one of the reasons for the car shortage this year is that the railroads have not the motive power and have not the cars available to relieve the prevailing congestion. In my part of the province of Alberta-and I had occasion to draw the attention of the Minister of Trade and Commerce to the conditions there some time ago-they have now" the first car shortage they ever experienced. I believe that particular part of western Canada is in better shape this year than any other part of the country, I believe that more of its crop is threshed and ready to be shipped than in any other district of the various provinces. Nevertheless they have a car shortage. I would like to point this out: I know a farmer in the vicinity of a village called Barons, near the city of Lethbridge, who was 294th on the list for a car at that station. He was 294th on the list in the early part of September of last year and up to the first of this month he had not been able to get a car. That is in the southern part of the province of Alberta. I also have the statement that a farmer in the vicinity of High River had only been able to get one car since December 31st. He wrote me to that effect in the beginning of this month, and he said there

400S
were 144 cars at that time on the order book at the station of High River. Now these are simply two instances to show that the Canadian Pacific railway in that particular part of the country has not been able to keep up with the demand for cars. They have not been sufficiently acquainted with the crop conditions and the need of cars to supply the demand in that particular section of the west. The railways are not prepared to meet the emergency, and I say more that the railways are responsible, to a considerable extent, for the prevailing conditions. Now let me explain that statement. The railways in the west make the announcement very freely that they are going to build a certain branch line immediately. Two instances of that occurred in my own district. For instance the Canadian Northern company announced two or three years ago that it was going to rush the Goose Lake branch of its line. People flocked in there and homesteaded in that country. Others bought what land they could buy, they have been in there for two or three years, they have had to raise crops in order to live, and some of them have had to go 70 to 80 miles to sell and to ship their grain. These' people would not have gone into that district if the railroad had not induced them to go in there by stating it was going to build that branch line immediately. A similar instance has occurred in the southern part of Alberta, in that part of the country south of the Crows Nest branch of the Canadian Pacific railway which is thickly settled.
The people have to go from fifty to sixty miles to sell their grain. These people went into the country because the Canadian ' Pacific railway promised to build the Wey-burn branch, and they thought that that line was to be immediately put under construction. And now we find that construction is only to commence this year. The railways have encouraged the people to come into the country; they encouraged them to raise crops. Yet, when they do raise crops, they have to go fifty or sixty miles to a station, and when they get there they find that the Canadian Pacific railway cannot supply them with cars and that there is no elevator accommodation. Frequently these farmers have to go back with their grain that distance. It means practically a complete loss of the crop. My hon. friend from Vancouver (Mr. Stevens) has had something to say about storage. He advises the farmers of western Canada to store their grain, and wait until they have a favourable opportunity , to sell it. The hon. gentleman is totally out of touch with the conditions in western Canada. Those farmers who are in the best financial position provide storage facilities. But he must understand that the people who are going on homesteads in our west, Mr. BUCHANAN.
are people, as a rule, with very little capital. They come to the west to make a home and a fortune for themselves. Most of them have been there but a few years, and the greater part of their money has been spent in building a home and barns, and in purchasing machinery at the high protection prices they have to pay. They must sell their crop as soon as they possibly can, in order to get the money to meet their payments. They cannot afford to store their grain and hold it until the Canadian Pacific railway or some other railway can supply them with cars or the elevator can afford them storage. They do not want to store their wheat, and cannot store it under present circumstances. Something was said by my hon. friend from Vancouver also with respect to reciprocity. He expressed the views that I expected he would, when he said that reciprocity was practically a bonus to the United States. Those of us who lived in western Canada, do not so regard it. We think that recipro-procity would have met a situation such as that which has arisen. But we believe that the attitude the people of Canada took on that occasion was a bonus to eastern Canada, and not to the advantage of western Canada. And I believe that the manufacturers and interests of eastern Canada, in taking the action they did on September 21, did the thing which was most injurious to themselves. I found this feeling among our western farmers during the discussion of reciprocity. Reciprocity would be helpful to^ them and would not injure any of the interests of eastern Canada; but, in the face of that, the men who have been made rich by the development that has taken place and the business they have secured from the farmers of the west have opposed what was considered by the farmers of the west to be in their own interest. If there is any cleavage between east and west, it is not due to what the farmers, did on the 21st of September, but- to what Ihe manufacturers of eastern Canada did on that day. I believe we have in eastern Canada people who will soon come to realize that it is in the interest of all Canada that the farmers should have the opportunity to sell their grain in the nearer market of the United States. What we want is the larger market and nearer market, and I believe that the people of the east will come to'realize the benefit that that will afford to the whole country, as we have realized it already. We are simply demanding in this resolution that we should be given an opportunity to sell our grain in the United States markets, with a railroad rate which is better than that afforded us at the present time. We believe that the government had an opportunity to relieve the situation I that has arisen from this blockade which

commenced six months ago and it sadly neglected to provide it.


George Eulas Foster: Mr. Speaker, the rather long and exhaustive speech of my hon. friend of Edmonton (Mr. Oliver) had a good deal in it which was an attack upon Providence, but it ended up with an attack directed against the government and particularly against the Minister of Trade and Commerce on the ground that he had not performed the duty he might have performed. The one question that came to me over and over again while my hon. friend was speaking might be expressed in the old Latin words ' Cui Bono?' I could not but ask myself as he was speaking, what is the good of all this that he is saying? A man in the responsible position of my hon. friend, an old and tried statesman, one who has been a member of the government for years, is not generally supposed to occupy the time of a deliberative assembly unless he has something in view for the benefit of the public. The first half of his speech, taking up an hour or more, was devoted to detailing the hard usage which nature and Providence had dealt out to the western farmer during the last season. What remedy does my hon. friend propose? He cannot move a vote of want of confidence in nature and Providence. If he did it would not have much effect; he would not be able to turn nature and Providence out of office or change their action. He detailed with minute particularity the loss to the farmer in the west.
The first thing they lost was a slice of their expectations. For some reason or other they ploughed, they harrowed and sowed their seed, and came to the conclusion that if Providence was at all fair to them they ought to get 225 million bushels. It turned out they only got about 175 million bushels; there was a big slice off their expectations. Does my hon. friend blame the government for that? Worse-still happened. Not sufficiently satisfied with cutting a slice off their expectations -not asking here whether their expectations were pitched1 too high or not-not satisfied with that, Providence continued to pour too much rain down, and give inlet to too little of the sun's rays. So the crop, instead of ripening as it should have, continued to grow rather than to ripen, refused to ripen, and the season was, we will say, a month late. Is my hon. friend going to move a vote of want of confidence in the government because the sun refused to shine with sufficient brilliancy, because the heavens refused to be economical of their stores, and were lavish during all that month? It is a thing for which nobody is to blame or can be blamed, and a thing which could not
have been avoided, even if somebody had acted as somebody should have acted.
There was another point to be taken. Contrary to the wishes of the government, there occurred a row between the miners and the mine owners, and the miners refused to work without certain conditions, and the mine owners refused to come up to those conditions. Work stopped in the mines, and a thing which, in some respects, is just as bad as the loss of the harvest, threatened the people of the northwest. The very farmers and dwellers that my hon. friend is rightly concerned about, were threatened with a coal famine. My hon. friend knows that. Does he blame the government for that? The railways had to meet the situation; and, talk as you will about the railways, and rail against them as some people who are not over thoughtful, do, talk as you will and rave against them, the railways came to the aid1 of that situation in the northwest, and they took 600,000 tons and mere of coal and spread it througn all portions of the northwest, in order to provide against a possible famine and a possible freezing in consequence of a coal famine. That took a great deal of the available resources of the transport companies. They carried their cars, subject to delay, and with these heavy burdens of traffic, carried them to all parts of the northwest. When these were unloaded and were ready for transport -out, the season was so far behind and the harvest was so unready for shipment, that there was not grain to be put into these cars to be taken back at that particular time. Does my hon. friend propose to move a vote of want of confidence in the government because of that occurrence and the consequent disruption of business?


Frank Oliver: In what direction was the coal hauled by these cars?


George Eulas Foster: It was not hauled easterly. So I will allow my hon. friend to exercise his judgment to find in what direction it was hauled.


Frank Oliver: The coal was hauled westerly. In which direction was the grain hauled?


George Eulas Foster: The largest part of the grain was hauled easterly.


Frank Oliver: My hon. friend will have to be more than amusing in order to satisfy the House that hauling coal westward prevented the hauling of grain eastward at the samp. time.


George Eulas Foster: My hon. friend has made his rejoinder to that after I had stated the facts of the case. If the grain was not ready to be hauled it could not be placed in the cars for hauling.


Frank Oliver: Then the hauling of coal west did not have any effect on the case.


George Eulas Foster: My hon. friend does not know much about the transport conditions, if he does not know of that shortage of coal in the west, and if he does not know that the hauling of that coal resulted in disorganization and confusion to the railway traffic. He will only have to talk to railroad managers to understand that, but I think he does understand it. There was then another thing that operated very hardly. The harvest was late in coining to maturity and afterwards was late in coming to the point where it could be transported. The season was, as my hon. friend admitted, at least a month or a month and a half shorter for haulage purposes. Thus you had a larger output of grain to be hauled, and you had the hauling season a month or a month and a half later than it usually began, and consequently the railway was deprived of that 'much of the time for the transport of the grain. Now take all these things into consideration, and going no further than the time of the freezing of the lakes and the stoppage of lake traffic, the disadvantage that the railroads were under from these reasons was a great disavantage.. Every man who wishes to talk of the question in a businesslike way, and fairly, must take that into account. Now what did the railroads do? My hon. friend read a list of cases, in one of which a car, loaded at a certain time, was 64 days before it got to its point of consignment; another that was loaded at a certain other point, was 113 days before it got to the place to which it was consigned. So you could read dozens, scores, and hundreds of abnormal cases. My hon. friend gave little credit to the 'far larger number of cases in which assistance was rendered to the extent of the railroads' power. Take the total number of cars that are being hauled on the railroads in the northwest, and put against them the whole list you have read of these abnormally long delays that took place, and when you bring it down to a percentage, these abnormal delays were a very small proportion indeed in comparison with the whole number of cars that were hauled.
Now what have the railways done in the way of hauling? I think it is well for us to look into that for a moment. I have here a statement of the shipments of grain at Fort William and Fort Arthur and the receipts. If you take two years and compare them, you will find this result:	In
four months ending on the 31st December and 3 weeks of the month of January bringing it down to the 21st day of January in the season of 1911-12, you have the total receipts of sixty-five and a half million bushels of wheat at Fort William and Port Mr. FOSTER (N. Toronto).
Arthur; of all grain you had a total of 82,243,230 bushels. You had shipments at Port Arthur of wheat in that time of fiftv three and a half million bushels and of all grain of sixty-six and a half million bushels. If you compare that with what was carried in the preceding year, you will find that the percentage is very much larger i" the short season of 1911-12 than in thp longer season of 1910-11.


John Gillanders Turriff: Were there not three railways hauling that number of cars this year as against two railways in all previous years?


George Eulas Foster: There were three, but the third, although it took a certain quantity, took an inappreciable quantity as compared1 with the others.


John Gillanders Turriff: The Canadian Pacific railway was double tracked.


George Eulas Foster: The Canadian Pacific railway and the Canadian Northern railway did the bulk of the hauling and the Grand Trunk railway, while they did some, did not count very much in the total. What do you find? In 1910-11, for the five months ending January 31, 61,014 cars were hauled. In 1911-12, 96,829 cars were hauled. Take the first week ending February 7, 1911, and 356 cars were hauled; in the corresponding week of 191112, 3,021 cars were hauled. In the second week of February, 687 cars were hauled in 1910-11, and 3,131 in 1911-12. In the week ending the 21st February 1910-11, 999 cars were hauled, and in the week ending the 21st February, 1911-12,	3,888 cars were
hauled. That is that 63,056 cars were hauled1 in the preceding year and 106,869 cars were hauled in the year that we are now passing through, about 70 per cent more than were hauled in the preceding year, and in a season which was at least six weeks shorter than the preceding season.
But, there is something more than that, and let us state it to be perfectly fair. It has been a Jong series of years since such a prolonged spell of absolutely strenuous weather prevailed in the west as prevailed through a portion of December and through the month of January of this year. Any one who knows the northwest and has seen railway traffic taken on there with the thermometer, 10, 15, 20 and 40 degrees below zero, knows that it is almost impossible to maintain traffic under those conditions. The best engine that you have and under the best management that you can get, under certain conditions of atmosphere there, has, perforce, to lie still. If she goes to work she blows herself to pieces, she so lames herself that she cannot do effective work. That must be taken into account as well and yet this six weeks of hard weather for which Providence must

be held responsible and for whicn my hon. friend should not blame the government, had an important effect upon the haulage of grain. Notwithstanding the shorter season, notwithstanding the trouble in reference to the coal famine, notwithstanding the late harvest, notwithstanding this extremely cold weather we have the result that I have just read that the railway companies took out 106,000 cars, where, in a previous season, without these disabilities, they only hauled 63,000 cars. Blame the railway as much as you reasonably can but do put the other side at least when you are making up the whole account and let us see what lies to the credit of the transportation companies as well as the disadvantages under which they labour.
My hon. friend went on to say that not only were there late crops and a diminution in the expected1 crops, but that there was also a degradation in quality, and he makes an elaborate calculation as to how much the farmers of the northwest have lost by a depreciation of price owing to the poorer quality of the grain. The government is surely not responsible for the poorer quality of the grain. He counts that $20,000,000 have been lost by the farmers of the northwest for that reason alone. That is surely not a count that he can make up against the government or the administration. Then he goes on to calculate the shortage at $15,000,000, making $35,000,000, then he goes on to make a loss of $10,000,000 on account of depreciation by blockade and $6,000,000 on account of what may be the total loss, making altogether $51,000,000-an enormous loss if the calculation is correct, but not one cent of which loss can be attributed to the fault of any government or any administration, as it seems to me.
My hon. friend went on to draw this gloomy picture. What boots it to have drawn such a gloomy picture as this? It seems to be almost like a man who had suffered from wounds by accidents and who was laid up in the hospital; he gets out of it, gets back to his home, and is able to move fairly comfortably. Some kind friend knocks at the front door and when he goes to the front door the friend hauls him out, tears apart every one of his wounds, takes every plaster off the healing bruises, drags him out into the light of day, and shows him to his neighbours with his wounds uncovered and freshly opened, but he applies to them no balm, he pours no oil into them. What kind of a mind must a man have - who expects to help his neighbour by that kind of treatment? So I thought and when my hon. friend was speaking I asked again the question: What good is coming out of all this? What man is to be helped by opening his wounds afresh? Does it give him
greater hope, instil into him a greater spirit of optimism, put into him courage and vigour? I do not think it does. Does it help Canada as a whole to have that dull, dark picture brought again to view, not once, or twice but for the tenth or eleventh time? Surely we want as bright an atmosphere and as hopeful an outlook as possible. What in the world would become of us as a community if when a man got sick all sorts of physical troubles were portrayed to him. Would it help that man or the community or the country in which he lived? So my hon. friend was not doing any good to the farmer of the northwest and he was not doing any good to the reputation of Canada. He was not doing anything to help Canada's future prospects in the eyes of the world by portraying these dark pictures of how Providence maltreated and illused the farmer in the northwest.
But, he says, this present government do not seem to have alleviated the situation. What about himself and his own government? Had not he the Northwest Territories in his hand? Was not every man in the northwest his particular charge? He knew them, their paths, their trails, their incomings and their outgoings. He was the strong member of a strong government.
For fifteen years that government and for eight or nine years he, as a member of that government, had the northwest at heart, slept with it at night and walked with it by day; the country they had decried in preceding years they took to their bosom and made their pet child of it for fifteen years, and yet left it in this kind of incapacity which we are told of to-day. And the hon. member (Mr. Oliver) comes down like the wolf on the fold on a poor Minister of Trade and Commerce who has been here only four months, and he wants to know why I have not made everything right within that time. Well, my hon. friend (Mr. Oliver) travelled through that northwest at a period very slightly anterior to the time when we came into power, did he not? He was travelling in the northwest for the benefit of the farmers of the northwest; of course he was. Did he not know that there were troubles; did he not know that Providence was not smiling, that the heavens were pouring out too much moisture, and that the sun was not doing its proper business for the farmer. He saw all these conditions about him, and what steps did he take? Coming down to one simple thing, that which would have done more to have alleviated this trouble and to have broken this blockade than anything else, would have been another line of railway out of the congested district down into that eastern portion of Canada. Why was it not built and ready? In 1903

my hon. friend (Mr. Oliver) and his government undertook to build another outlet from the northwest. There was no other reason presented by them for that huge scheme of the Grand Trunk Pacific. It I was to be another outlet for the west [DOT]where the grain was piling up breast high, and there was 'but one single track to bring it out. Well, Canada put all ner courage and all her energy into getting that other outlet; Canada put all her credit at the back of it, and you over there used it right royally, too. Canada put her good millions in your hands; what did you do with the money? You talked about making another outlet for the grain of the northwest, but you went down diligently and spent thirty million dollars of it between Quebec and Moncton where you did not expect to get a bushel of gram out from the northwest; you sunk a lot of it in tne Quebec bridge, and you piled it up west of ^Quebec, but you diligently kept from building that portion of the road from Winnipeg to Cochrane, which, if you had built, would have given you an outlet. Canada was not to blame because she did not put money in your fists; you had all of it you should have had, and a mighty sight more. There was no lack of money and credit, and you gentlemen and my hon. friend (Mr. Oliver), as one of you, were recreant to the bargain by which you got authority to build that road >in that very essentia part which should have been first built but which you neglected to build.
And the things you ought not to have done you diligently went on to do in a lavish manner. And so, ever since August of last year there has not been another pair of shining rails from the congested wheat district out to the east, and the reason is that these gentlemen opposite did not do their duty in their fifteen years of power. And now they come and they have-what shall I say-they come and they have the assurance to throw all this blame^ upon the present administration. Well, if this present administration stays in power not fifteen years but five years and does not do more to alleviate the conditions in the northwest than you did in your fifteen years of office,


An hon. MEMBER.: Turn us out.


George Eulas Foster: Yes, turn us out. Now, my hon. friend (Mr. Oliver) after drawing that dark picture on the canvas, after having presented the wounds of his friends and patrons in the west, dragged them out and made them bleed anew, and then he comes to his point. And what is his point? It is: you should have less restriction and more reciprocity. What is the use of fighting over the events of last September in the attempt to find a remedy for what lies before us at the Mr. FOSTER (N. Toronto..)
present time or in the near future. What ever gentlemen may think as to reciprocity being good or bad, the country never had as fair a chance at any subject as it had on the 21st day of last September. These gentlemen opposite brought forward their scheme the fruition of fifteen years of cogitation and incubation, and they exhibited it to this country and praised it up for at least nine or ten months. Then they went to the country with all their power and eloquence and force and they again exhibited that nostrum for the healing of Canada as ably as any Liberal party has ever presented its case in this country. And the people, without excitement, and after studying and weighing the question for eight, ten, or eleven months, came to vote and give their answer. Why may we not just as well for present purposes accept that answer in good faith and instead of bringing it out in this way, put our minds to some practical thought as to what can be done under the present circumstances? Do not let us cry for the moon when there is a piece of good cheese near at hand to satisfy our appetite. Now, Sir, this government is not going to cry for the moon, it is going to set itself to work to remedy as quickly as possible these grievances and evils such as they are in the northwest. Will hon. gentlemen opposite help us to do that or will they continue the somewhat dark practice they have lately entered upon; will they continue to harp back upon the differences between the east and the west; draw a gloomy picture of the travails and trials of the west, and in that way fan a feeling of discontent. Will they help us by some hopeful impulse and hopeful energy to portray the bright side of the question and will they set themselves with us to a helpful and hopeful attempt to solve the difficulties of the northwest? That is not to be accomplished by preaching cleavage between manufacturers and farmers; it is not to be accomplished by playing on the feelings of antagonism between capitalists and labouring men; it is to be accomplished only by a calm and frank and hearty acceptance of the situation, saying to us and with us: 'Here is the country's position; we will not make this a disunited Canada; we will further you in your efforts to make it a united Canada.'
The farmers of the west and the men engaged in the industries of the east are not aliens to each other, neither are they enemies tearing out each other's hearts. As the one prospers, the other prospers ; the interests of both are intertwined; and we do better, all of us, to show the identity of interest between the two than to dwell upon imaginary differences. Does anyone pretend to tell me that a great railway company goes into that northwest and de-

liberately tries to block its development? Why, a man would be a fool who scared away or killed the trout in the stream before he let the fly fall upon the water; and the railway organization, if it lives at all and has profits, has to live out of the prosperity of the people through whose district it runs. It would be a fool not- to do its best to develop that country, and in the large I believe the railway companies have done their best to develop it. T am not in favour of railway monopoly or railway control, and I believe the farmer, the storekeeper, the man of leisure, the man in the college or the school, every man, has a right to be protected by the central government against arbitrary or wrongful exactions by any man or any set of men. So I believe the railroads ought to be carefully supervised and controlled, and we are doing that. There never was so much supervision and control exercised over the transportation interests of this country as there is this very day, and there never was better accord between the transportation interests and the great interests of the shippers and producers than there is to-day. Not to say that they are all agreed on all points; but they are agreed on more points than they have been up to the present time, and our object should be to bring them to agree on still more points of confidence and helpfulness one towards the other. I am not a farmer, but I have a right to my opinion. I was born on a farm, I grew up on a farm, I have had interests connected with farming ever since I was a boy, and I have full sympathy with the farming community. But I say that our brothers and kindred in the northwest would do well to pay attention to the methods of cultivation and farming in the east. I have no sympathy with the miner in the shape of an agriculturist, who goes into the great northwest and takes hold of 2,000 or 10,000 acres of the bank that God has filled with rich vital energy, and makes it his sole purpose to mine every ounce of that out that he can by machinery and all the agencies that he can add to his power. I would like to see that man cut up into about 20 different men on the same amount of land; for I believe that ten farmers with 160 or 320 acres, and farming it well, will do much better than a smaller number of men who are mining out the energy and vitality of the country. The small farmer in the northwest has a good deal of ground for complaint against that class of farmer. His lot is made harder because that class of farmer exists there. A question was put to my hon. friend: suppose the eastern farmer has coarse grain, and it is injured by frost to a certain extent, he does not much feel the loss of that-why? Because he feeds it; he has something to feed 127 '
it to, and he makes more by feeding it and selling the product than he would if he had sold the grain even if it had been good. And w'hen we hear about these places in the west with their frozen grain, we ask, why do they not feed it, and the answer comes, they have nothing to feed it to. Should we not remedy that condition of affairs as soon as possible? And shall we remedy it in any other way than by constant teaching, constant advocacy and constant impulse along the. right line? In this matter the Northwest must help itself, or it never can be best helped, iby changing graudually but surely its method of farming, and introducing mixed farming-not putting all the eggs into one basket. Instead of going to outside countries to bring in all their food except grains from time to time, they have an inestimable opportunity there for the production of all that class of articles. That is one part of this problem of coarse grain. Then, I think we cannot put the question too strongly to the farmers of the west that they must look to the storing of their own grain to a certain extent. My hon. friend's argument seemed to have weight when he said, what is the use of having a granary and putting damp grain into it? But all the grain of the northwest is not damp grain. There is plenty of grain there which was not and is not (damp, and which maybe would have paid the farmer still better if he had had a granary into which to put it and keep it. It would certainly make him the master to some extent. When he goes now with his grain and wants to sell it to the elevator man, and it has to be transported to Fort William and to stay there until the navigation season opens, he knows that he is paying storage for all those months, and he is paying a good slice more than the storage because of the lessened price that he gets from the man who buys it who has [DOT]that storage possibility and contingency in view. A granary owned by that man at home, in which he would store that grain, would to my mind have two effects: it *would make him a master of the situation to this extent, that if the street buyer did not give him what he thought he ought to have, he could put his grain into the storage granary and keep it.
He would he (paying the cost of his granary, (but if he had not the granary, and had sold bis grain at the lower price, *and with a discount on it for the storage for 4, 5 or 6 months, he. would lose more in the second transaction, whereas he would gain if he had taken the first method of handling his grain. Now, I am not here to teach the farmers, tout that seems to me to be sensible. I think it is sensible, and I think the older farmers in the west arp procceeding along that line, and the sooner more of them do that, the sooner this



problem will be solved. What else will help to solve that? It seems to me that it will be helped by extra storage outside of individual granaries, and farmers. That is what we should bend our energies to, and to that the government is devoting its energies.


Frank Oliver: Is the minister under t' impression that the farmers of the north west do not have granaries on their farm?


George Eulas Foster: I am under this impression, which I think is th< true one: That the system pursued by the farmers in the west, is very different from the system pursued by the farmers in fhe east. The first thing an eastern farmer looks out for, is to get some place to sto*-his products until he makes a sale of them. Almost the last thing the ordinary settler in the west looks at, is to get some storage capacity for that which he raises. Now, that is my impression. Am I right?


Frank Oliver: No, you are absolutely wrong. If my hon. friend wishes to be correct, let me say to him that the first thing the farmer does in the northwest when h has wheat, is to provide some storage on his place for it. But the question is not the storage of the grain on his farm, it i' a question of storage of the grain at the railway station. That is where the grain is piled on the streets.


George Eulas Foster: My hon. friend tries to persuade this House that a man who has a granary which can store his grain and keep it from the weather will, instead of storing it in that granary, draw it out and pile it up in a lean-to somewhere. Well now, that is less of a compliment to the western farmer than I would like to pay him. I do not believe the western farmer deserves a left handed compliment like that.


Frank Oliver: I am anxious to inform the hon. gentleman, and if he will not ac cept the information, I cannot help it.


George Eulas Foster: It is always well when information is handed out to you in that way, to exercise a little caution before you accept the information as toeing correct, and I aim bound with what sense I am gifted, to discriminate in the kind of information that I am going to take in to digest, and I cannot take that kind of information. Now I do not want to keep this House any longer. There is one point that I have yet to mention. Here was the question that- my hon. friend put to me: Why did you not compel the railways to make effective and so get into operation these reduced traffic rates to the south part of Canada before you did? Why didn't you move earlier? Well my hon. friend will recollect that his government kept in office so long beyond what they Mr. FOSTER (N, Toronto),
should have, that they prevented-us from getting where we could find out the facts of the case until it became later than it otherwise would have been. My hon. friends did not vacate there until, I think it was the 6th, 7th or 8th. of October.


Mr. LENNOX.: They hated to leave.


George Eulas Foster: Now to get an effective rate on the arrangement with the United States through the Interstate Commerce Commission by the 10th of November, as my hon. friend said we should have, we would have had to make a movement several days before the 10th of October. Did my hon. friend who knew the conditions make that movement? When our railways deal with the railways to the south to arrange a rate and have it made effective; they have to deal with the Interstate Commerce Commission, and the rule of the Interstate Commerce Commission is that it will not grant an effective rate without thirty days' notice being given and that they adhered to. The Canadian Pacific railway on December 28, took up this matter with the United States connections, agreed upon a schedule of rates, and made application to the Interstate Commerce Commission, to make it effective within three days. The Interstate Commercei Commission gefused Ito make it effective within three days. That was not my fault nor the fault of the Canadian Pacific Railway Company. The second application was made, -and an urgent appeal went With it, and the permission was given to put rates into effect on short notice but to be confined to export through the United States and not for the market of the United States. That much was gained and it was gained as speedily as under the rules of the Interstate Commerce Commission, it could be obtained. The other permissions were in the same way followed up and got just as soon as, with the time limit which was obligatory, they could have been got. The Interstate Commerce iCoumnission, declined to allow the new rates and make them effective on short notice for consumption within the United States. They said:	'This thirty days'
notice is for the purpose of a caution and warning, we do not think we can, within shorter notice than the legally authorized rules, do this thing, which will bring articles from Canada into competition with our own supply on this side of the line. Our people ought to have warning, and they ought to have what the law gives them, a thirty days' notice.


Frank Oliver: Did the Interstate Commerce Commission insist on a thirty days' notice on the application for rates for export only?


George Eulas Foster: No. I have just stated that they refused at first

when the proposition was made to them to put it into effect on three days' notice. Afterwards another request was made and an urgent appeal went -with it. Then they gave permission to put the rates into effect but for export' only.


Frank Oliver: How long after the second application was the consumption permission given?


George Eulas Foster: I think the permission, if my information here is right for export rates, went into effect [DOT]on either the 20th or 23rd of January. My hon. friend has stated what was done with reference to the Canadian Northern railway, and, so far as I gathered he has stated the circumstances correctly. Afterwards, and in gradual order, as the notice was conformed with and tide Interstate Commerce Commission gave their permission these rates came into effect, and on the 7th of March all of them will he effective not only for export but for domestic purposes, for consumption within the United States. So far as fair despatch, and urgency impelling to fair despatch, goes our railway companies, and I myself-not as an autocrat of those companies for I am not, neither is the government-with a sympathetic endeavour to hasten things as rapidly as possible, made every effort that could be made and these rates have gone into effect just as soon as they could have gone into effect.
Unless, indeed, my hon. friend, knowing the circumstances very well before he went out, had started the ball rolling before he went out of office and so had ar.WIated the action that took place afterwards. I am willing to take the responsibility tha< fairly falls to me, and the government is willing to take all the responsibility tha fairly falls to it. In this matter, I think the government and I are not to blame. By the way, my hon. friend, I think, read some of the quotations for wheat, going to show that prices in the United States wen much higher than in Canada. I have a telegram here which advises me that Max wheat in Minneapolis is at present only four cents higher than May wheat in Winnipeg.
Now, although 1 have not .fully covered [DOT]all tire ground, I think I have made a fair reply to my hon. frientd. I came now for a moment, to ask what my hon. friend wants by his motion. I should think, by the speech which was made by the ho-member from Lethbridge (Mr. Buchanan? that the motion had more point to it thar it seems to have. What is the first clause?
That the House lias heard with satisfaction from the Minister of Trade and Commerce that as a result of a conference held by hon. member and at his request with representatives of the three railway systems operating in western Canada, these railways have lowered their rate, making the rate to Duluth and
r
to Minneapolis the same as to Fort William and Port Arthur.
Is there any reason in this why a motion of want of confidence in the government should be moved? ' Heard with satisfaction'-the hon. gentleman and his friends are satisfied, and say they are satisfied. Then, what is all this bother about so fi as this is concerned? And the second clause is this:-
And that as a further result of the conference mentioned, application has been made to the interstate commission of the United States for leave to file grain rates from the northwest down to Minneapolis and Duluth, and so ease the pressure in the congested districts by taking the grain away by more western routes down towards the south.
My hon. friend is pleased with this. Why then, a vote of want of confidence in the government so far as this is concerned with which he is so much pleased? Again:
The House is informed by the public press that the reduced rates as mentioned have been granted by the Canadian Pacific and Canadian Northern railways on wheat and oats for export only.
So far, so good. He is pleased that this has gone


Frank Oliver: No.


George Eulas Foster: The hon. gentleman is not pleased that from 250 t 400 cars a day are leaving taking grain or' of congested districts and carrying it down
to storage? And not being pleased, he moves a vote of want of confidence in the government, because that is being done. And again:
As the reduction of rates so announced can only affect the situation to a limited degree, the House would urge upon the government the advisability of securing further consideration of the matter by the railway companies with a view to having the reduced rates apply to wheat and oats for grinding in bond and for consumption in the United States as well as for export.
The government has done it. The reduced rate goes into effect on March 7th, as soon as the time limit runs out. Is my hon. friend displeased with that? Is he moving a vote of want of confidence in the government because we, before he moved his resolution, took action in the matter Why, this has been done; it is now in the way of fulfilment. It does seem to me that my hon. friend is somewhat belated. The bugaboo died, and it is a corpse he is exhibiting. The living bugaboo departed this life two or three weeks ago. In the name of common sense and philanthropy, I want to know why a motion of want of confidence is moved on any of these four counts. He has got it all, he gives thanks for it all, and yet he gets up and moves

a motion of want of confidence because he has got what he wanted. And here is the last clause:-
The House would further urge that such means as may be practicable he taken by the government to have the through rates on barley and flax to Duluth and Minneapolis which became effective on January 23 reduced to the Fort William rate.
If may information is correct, the Fort William rate will rule upon this also after March 7.
Then, what is it that my hon. friend wants? I do not think there is any use of my belaboring this stiffened corpse-l'tke bugaboo any longer. I would invite my hen. friend to withdraw it from the public gaze. Though it was a child of his own and dear to his heart, w'hy the indecent spectacle of having the corpse dragged around?


Michael Clark: Mr. Speaker, if anything could justify the motion of want of confidence it would be the frivolous manner in which-


Some hon. MEMBERS: Oh, oh.


Michael Clark: -my hon. friend the Minister of Trade and Commerce (Mr. Foster) approaches a condition of real suffering in western Canada and the hilarity with which his frivolous remarks are hailed by the gentlemen behind him. I shall endeavour before I sit down, to show that we are dealing with a larger problem than the government, I think, have any proper conception of. My hon. friend the Minister of Trade and Commerce (Mr. Foster) asks about the speech of my hon. friend from Edmonton. 'Cui bono', Well, the answer seems to me to be on the surface. If he means that this debate cannot do much good in regard to the present condition of affairs, one may agree with him. But there will be other seasons, So the problem is much larger than my hon. friend (Mr. Foster) has yet seen it to be; and if, out of this debate the government can be guided to some better conception of the problem with which they ore dealing, and if suffering be saved in future seasons, Canada will have reason to be grateful to the people who have raised this debate and have taken part in it in a serious way, however little she may think of those who consider the present economic conditions of western Canada a matter for levity, hilarity and fooling.


Some hon. MEMBERS: Oh, oh.
Mr. CLARK (Red Deer) My hon. friend (Mr. Foster) went on from his Latin query to give an excellent example of what I will venture, with due deference, to call confused thinking. In making the wealth of a nation there are two elements: One is production and the other is the Mr. FOSTER (N. Toronto).
disposal of the produce. As my hon. friend from Edmonton (Mr. Oliver) pointed out Providence and nature had a great deal to do with production but the government has to do with the disposal of the produce. My hon. friend (Mr. Oliver) was dealing with the disposal of the produce; and by a turn of sophistry of which my hon. friend the Minister of Trade and Commerce used to be a master-we have not had so much of it from him while he has been on the government benches-he proceeds to distract the attention of his easily misled followers from the question of disposal for which he is responsible to the question of production, and he says to my hon. friend from Edmonton:	Do
you blame the government because Providence and nature have not been as kind to you as you had hoped?.
It is my hon. friend himself who blamed Providence, and yet he tried to shift the attack from the government for their failure to dispose of the produce, to Providence and nature, forsooth, for some breakdown in their methods. Well, that is marvellous sophistry, and I hope my hon. friend, before he goes to sleep, will be proud of it. Now if his economical thinking was a little halting, I must say his surgery is bad in the extreme. He turned to the member for Edmonton (Mr. Oliver) and he says: What is the use of taking the dressings off the wound? Well, I think I may speak to him on this subject; I will not say I may give him lessons even in thinking, but certainly I have a right to talk to him as a surgeon, and I must tell him that the proper way to treat a wound is not to keep the dressings on it until it stinks and the patient dies. That is the kind of medical metaphor with which my hon. friend pleases his friends. I am tempted to try a little Latin myself. There is an old Latin proverb which says: Parvum parva plaeent- little things please little minds. Then, of course, when my hon. friend was in the vein of bad logic he could not get off the use of the tu quoque. He says that my hon. friend has slept with the west. Wonderful discovery. He says, you have walked with the west. A very original idea. But he says, what did you do to relieve the evils? We provided a remedy, which you misled the country to turn down. Then my hon. friend goes on to say, what reformatory steps ought to be taken? And he gets back to his old calling of an instructor of the farmers. He says, you have got to improve your methods of cultivation. If we improve our methods of cultivation what will be one of the first results? Increased crops, more grain to dispose of. So my hon. friend's method of treating a grain blockade is to double the amount of grain he has got to handle. He has got more to handle now than he can take care of, and his recom-
.FEBRUARY 28, 1912
ruendation to the western farmers is, improve your methods of cultivation, double your crop, and then you will get rid of your grain. Then of course mixed farming came in. Well, now the difficulty with my hon. friend, as with some others who have spoken here is that they really do not know the west. There are places in Saskatchewan where you cannot water your stock within seven miles of your farm buildings. In addition to that, when men go into the west they go for the purpose of tilling large quantities of land, and taking advantage of that very wheat production which my hon. friend is condemning here, which is the secret of Canada's prosperity to-day, the secret of the growth of the cities of which you are so proud. Then my hon. friend went on to give other directions to the farmers. He says they have got to store their grain. The hon. member for Vancouver (Mr. Stevens) gave the same advice. Well, now I speak with some knowledge on this question, and I want to tell my hon. friends in all good faith that I have been living ten years among those people, I have been endeavouring to make my livelihood upon the western lands, and I want to assure them that when men go into that western country they have to make a careful reckoning of cents and dollars before they undertake any expenditure whatever. I do not know the owner of a homestead who would not be anxious to improve his buildings, improve his dwelling house, I do not know one in my own neighbourhood. But I know that a large number of them have a great anxiety to keep out of debt. They want to get along in the world. I intend to preach this doctrine to eastern Canadians, _ because a large number of eastern Canadians are only removed two generations from the time when their own forefathers were going through the same trials and difficulties that the western pioneers are going through to-day. To tell a man who has got to his last dollar that he must build barns is rather an unfeeling way to approach this problem. I make that personal appeal with an intimate knowledge of the conditions. But I want to go a step further. My hon. friend says, store the grain. How far will that carry you? We do not raise grain to store it, but we raise grain to sell it. We raise it to get it to its final repository, which is the stomach of a human being, either in this country or some other country. If you store your grain, and go on and break up your soil and produce more for next year, does my hon. friend not see that lie simply moves his problem six months back, and that the next year things will be worse than they are now? The farmer cannot build a granary in every field. I think that is a fair way of looking at it.
But there is an additional reason under this head, why I think this is an absolutely insufficient and paltry remedy to offer to the farmer. The farmer has to sell his grain in the fall, because, apart from the mere matter of a living, he need's the money to pay his way. What is the use of telling a farmer who is being worried by the representative of a firm of implement dealers in Toronto for a high price for his implements, and who has interest to pay on that price to store his grain? The implement agent does not say that; he says: here is your note, can you settle it? Between the implement dealer who says: here is my note, can you settle it? and my friend who says: store your grain, the farmer is in a pretty tight position. I am the farmer, I feel that difficulty. I hope that my hon. friend, when he talks about barns and storehouses-and he reminds me of the foolish man in the Scripture when he does it-will deal with this point, and that he will tell me how the farmers of western Canada are going to get out of this difficulty.
I do not know that there was a great deal in the speech of the hon. gentleman further than what I have already dealt with, but I am far from having said all I want to say on this problem, because when I rose I promised to endeavour to show to the government that it was a bigger problem than they have any comprehension of. The Minister of Trade and Commerce said: What is the use of fighting the battles of last September again? He re-echoed a remark in tne speech of the hon. member for Vancouver (Mr. Stevens), and it had been re-echoed already by the hon. member for Vancouver from the maiden speech of the hon. Minister of Finance (Mr. White), in this House. I do not want to fight any battle of this life over again except in so far as I can learn lessons from it for the future battles of this life. I take it that it is the duty of the government, who are responsible for dealing with the affairs of the country, to solve this problem. We are all alike in being anxious to do the best we can for Canada. I would like to say to my hon. friend's that they might happen to have on this reciprocity question a change of heart and a change of mind. I know that none of us can teach the hon. Minister of Trade and Commerce anything about the great principles of politics. He knows, if any man knows in this House, that, as Mr. Asquith said the other day, there is no finality in politics. It is excusable in the hon. member for Vancouver, it is excusable in an inexperienced member like the Minister of Finance, to say that reciprocity is dead. That is the kind of political opinion we expect from such inexperienced quarters, but I know that, like Mr. Asquith, the

pire that I would sever, politically speaking, from another particle of dust in the British Empire. I believe that the British Empire is the greatest engine that the world has seen up to now for the propagation in this world of the principles of freedom and justice, and I would not lift my little finger to break or hurt that empire in any way or to sever the sections of the integral portions of that empire. But when we are talked to in that way as to the necessity of maintaining a proper connection between the East and the West I want to say in conclusion that the only way you will maintain it is in the way my hon. friend indicated: by tackling manfully these problems, and if my hon. friends opposite are to be allowed to imagine all they like about building a few railroads I ask them to extend their imagination to the production of some hundreds of millions of more bushels of wheat than Britain can possibly take, and then I ask them where they are going to turn for a market. Consistency has been described as the last infirmity of noble minds-let me concede to my hon. friends all the nobleness of mind they like but I say to them: for goodness sake don't hang on to the last, infirmity.
Look into the history of your own party and see if there is not yet time to turn in the one direction in which you can turn for a ready and larger market for your products. We can only solve the problem' of east and west by the sincere spirit of the closing words of my hon. friend. Now, I want to put this to my hon. friends in the east: if they were western farmers, would their attachment to the east be increased by your saying to them: produce your wheat, it is a beautiful thing to grow wheat, sell it if you can after we have built the Hudson Bay railway and have made a way out for it through the icebergs to a limited market; hut do not sell it to the Yankees; they eat wheat and will pay a good price for it, but they should not eat Canadian wheat; do not sell it to them. If you were a farmer in the west would you he bound by ties of affection to the people of eastern Canada if they said: we are going to put all the obstacles possible in the way of vour selling your produce, and at the same time we are going to take the last cent out of you by preventing you from buying where you like? I do not think anything can shake the loyalty of the west, and I want to say that there is no section of the people of the west who are more loyal than our recent American immigrants. I want to pay that testimony to them. Nine out of ten of them say: we prefer the laws of this country to the laws of the United States, and to that extent they are loyal; but their loyalty will not he strengthened by the Mr. CLARK (Red Deer).
kind of treatment I have described. You cannot show your affection for a man by hanging around his neck with one arm and rifling his pocket with the other. It is not a square deal to tell us, You must be restricted where you sell and equally restricted where you buy. This question will have to be carefully looked into. I really think from the careful way in which my hon. friend is following me that he is taking this thing seriously, and I have good hopes that he will look into this question thoroughly. Let him throw consistency to the winds, as all the great statesmen have done. Sir Robert Peel went into power in 1841 pledged to maintain protection, and in 1846 repealed the com laws; and the people of Huddersfield erected to his memory a monument which I walk around every time I visit that town and read the inscription on it. Let the hon. gentleman throw consistency to the winds and deal squarely with this problem, and then you will see a prosperous Canada, a Canada that will be the marvel of the world because I think that with a proper economic system and good government it is destined to be the greatest nation on earth.


Mr. FOWLER.: The hon. member for Red Deer (Mr. Clark) has treated the House to a dissertation the major portion of which consisted of platitudes uttered with a loud voice and in a bumptious manner that rejoiced hon. gentlemen on that side of the House who mistook noise for argument. The hon. gentleman, during the course of his somewhat discursive speech, the best portion of which consisted of quotations from John Morley on Gladstone, took occasion to read to this House a lesson on parliamentary ethics. The hon. gentleman seemed to find, fault with a harmless and innocent remark that was made on this side of the House while he was speaking. The words used were, ' go easy,' surely harmless, innocent words, that one would think would not call forth the diatribe that we heard from til? hio. mcmbi i. The hon. member told us aboat the mother of parliaments. It strikes me, judging from the usual condition of tie hon. m.unbor for Red Deer, that he is rn.tih better acquainted with the purlieus of Whitechapel and Seven Dials than he if with West minster.


Mr. CLARK (Red Dser).: Mr. Speaker, I rise to a point of order. Everybody knows that Whitechapel is a district where you will find the lowest class that inhabits the city of London, and I think it is an injurious remark for any hon. gentleman to suggest that another hon. member of this House is fitted to he an inhabitant of those purlieus.
1' LBRUARY 28, 1912


Thomas Simpson Sproule: The remark was scarcely within the amenities of the debates of parliament, and I would ask the hon. member (Mr. Fowler) to withdraw it.


George William Fowler: Mr Speaker, just a moment

.


Some hon. MEMBERS: Order, chair.


George William Fowler: You will permit me to say that many very good people, actuated by the very best motives, go into the purlieus of Whitechapel.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: I think the hon. member is only making the offence worse attempting to justify the remark. I think it would be more appropriate to withdraw it.


George William Fowler: In deference to your ruling, Mr. Speaker, if I have made use of any remark which is unparliamentary, which if it were not for your ruling I would not consider so, I will of course come within the parity rule and withdraw the remark. But at the same time, I have a right to say this, that the personal remarks made by the hon. member for Red Leer were quite as injurious, as far as I was concerned, as anything I said about him. The hon. gentleman has told us that he himself is a farmer; aud, Sir, if any argument were needed to back up the statement made by the hon. Minister of Trade and Commerce that a considerable part of the difficulty in the country was due to bad farming, the statement made by the hon. member for Red Deer that he is a farmer would amply supply that argument. it is a remarkable thing that men .who have been failures in every other sphere of life, hearing of those fertile lands in the west have gone there hoping to achieve success, and that is one of the ills that this country is suffering from at the present time. I will not say that there are not other ills. I will not say that the transportation facilities are yet sufficient to carry out the products of the country. But it does seem to me that what the hon. Minister of Trade and Commerce pointed out is absolutely true, that the fault cannot lie with the government, who have not had either time or opportunity to take this matter into proper consideration and provide the necessary remedy.
But, Sir, the fault does lie at the door of hon. gentlemen opposite, and mainly and principally at the door of the exMinister of the Interior, the man who moved this resolution. Because. Sir, charged as he was to look after the interests of the people of the west he took no steps whatever to provide the necessary remedy for evil which he never saw impending but which was rapidly approaching. My hon. friend from Red Deer (Mr. Clark) in dealing with this matter can only hark back to the old threadbare subject of reciprocity, a subject which was threshed out in this country from end to end, and which the people of Canada voted against with such almost surprising unanimity on the 21st of September last. The hon gentleman is not original at all. He never makes a speech in this House in which he does, not discuss the question of reciprocity. That seems to be the only tiling on which he can talk with any lucidity at all, that is the very thing which is troubling him most. The hon. gentleman also says:	You cannot expect Britain to
take your grain no matter what means of transportation you may supply, no matter how you may increase the facilities for carrying that grain to the markets of the world. Then what country is going to take it? ' Oh, tile United States '. Mr. Speaker, the lack of knowledge the hon. gentleman has with regard to farming, the lack of knowledge that he has, with regard to parliamentary ethics is to be regretted. The same hon. gentleman quoted my allusion to Whitechapel and was so lacking in proper respect to members of this House as to refer to the Minister of Trade and Commerce as ' My frivolous old friend'. The hon gentleman holds himself at all times as conforming to the proper parliamentary attitude as observed m the Mother of parliaments, where they almost fought across the benches on one occasion a few months ago. We have not yet come to that in this House, although with the example of the hon. member for Red Deer before us I do not know to what length we may ultimately go. Well, Sir, he has told us that the great remedy, the sovereign panacea, the cure-all for the ills from which the people of western Canada are suffering to-day, is to send their grain away to the United States which to-day exports more wheat than we in Canada raise altogether. That is the sort of remedy this great and wonderful statesman from- 1 will not say Whitechapel because you Mr. Speaker, have said that I should not use the term-but this great and wonderful statesman this modern miracle worker in statesmanship is able to supply to the people of western Canada. It seems to me that nothing could be more absurd, robbed as I say of its noise and its quotations from Gladstone, than the speech we have listened to to-night from the hon. member for Red Deer.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: Is the House ready for the question?


Frank Oliver: I have the right to close the debate.


Thomas Simpson Sproule: No, this is not a substantive motion.



House divided on the amendment (Mr. Oliver):
YEAS:
Messieurs
Boland,
Boivin,
Bourassa,
Brown,
Buchanan,
Bureau,
Cardin,
Cor veil,
Cash,
Chisholm (Antigonish) Chisholm (Inverness), Clark (Red Deer), Cruise,
Delisle,
Demers,
Ethier,
Fortier,
Gauthier (St. Hyacintlie), Gauvreau,
Guthrie,
Kyte,
Lachance,
Lanctot,
Lapointe
(Kamouraska), Laurier (Sir Wilfrid) Law,
Loggie,
Maclean (Halifax), MacNutt,
McCraney,
McCoig,
McCrea,
McMillan,
Marcile (Bagot), Martin (Regina), Michaud,
.Molloy,
Nesbitt,
Neely,
Oliver,
Paeaud,
Papineau,
Proulx,
Reid (Restigouche), Seguin,
Sinclair,
Thomson (Qu'Appelle), Tobin,
Turgeon,
Turifi,
Verville,
Warnock,
White (Victoria,
, Alta.) and Wilson (Laval).-54.
NAYS: Messieurs
Algudre,	Lamarche,
Ames,	Lancaster,
Armstrong (Lcmbton),Lavallee,
Arthurs,
Ball,
Barnard,
Barrette,
Beattie,
Bellemare,
Best,
Blain,
Blondin,
Borden,
Boulay,
Bowman,
Brabazon,
Bradbury,
Broder,
Burnham,
Burrell,
Clark (Bruce), Clarke (W7ellii: Clements,
Cochrane,
Cockshutt,
Coderre,
Crocket,
Cr others,


Thomas Simpson Sproule: Lennox,
Lesperance,
Lewis,
McCurdy,
McKay Marshall, Middlebro, Munson, i Nantel,
Paq uet,
Paul,
Perley,
Porter,
Rainville,
Reid (Grenville), Eobidoux,
Roche,
Rogers,
, Schaffner, Sevigny, Sexsmith,
Sharpe (Lisgar),
Shepherd,
Staples,
Steele,
Davidson,	Stevens,
Donnelly,	Stewart. (Hamilton),
Edwards,	Sutherland,
Elliott,	Taylor, Thornton,
Ebon,	
Poster (Kings, N.S.).	Tremaine,
Foster (Toronto, N.),	W alker,
Fripp,	Wallace,
Gauthier (Gaspe),	Webster,
Goodeve,	Weichel,
Guilbault,	White (Renfrew),
Hartt,	W ilson
Kemp,	(Wentworth) and
Kidd, Lalor,	Wright.-84.
PAIRS:	
Ministerial.	Opposition.
Messieurs	
Hughes (Victoria),	German,
White (Leeds),	Emmerson,
Hazen,	Murphy,
Pelletier,	Lemieux,
Stanfield,	Pardee,
M'acdoneil,	Devlin,
Thompson (Yukon),	Carroll,
Sharpe (Ontario),	Ross,
Davidson,	Chisholm (Inverness),
Wilcox,	Clarke (Essex),
Stewart (Lunenburg),	McKenzie,
*Tameson,	Douglas,
Boyce,	Richards,
Ilaggart,	Gordon,
Cromwell,	Lovell,
Henderson,	Knowles,
Thoburn,	Robb,
Mondou,	Marcil (Bona venture),
Achim, Fowler,	Bickerdike,
	Pugsley,
Smyth,	Boyer, Charlton,
Bristol,	
Baker,	Kay,
Rhodes.	Macdonald.
Amendment negatived.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to, and House went into Committee of Supply.
Progress reported.
Mr. BORDEN moved the adjournment oi the House.
Wilfrid Laurier: What business will be taken up to-morrow?


Robert Laird Borden: Bills first, probably beginning with the Grain Bill; afterwards the Tariff Bill and any other Bills standing on the order paper; and then Supply, taking up the estimates of the Department of the Interior.


[Stage Direction]
Motion agreed to, and the House adjourned at 12.15 a. m. Thursday.

[Stage Direction]
Abbreviations of well known words and Parliamentary expressions are used in the following :-1°, 2° 3°, First Reading, Second Reading, Third Reading ; 3 m. h., 6 m. h., 6 w. h., Three Months' Hoist, Six Months' Hoist, Six Weeks'Hoist without remarks or debate ; Accts., Accounts; Adjn., Adjourn; Adjd., Adjourned; Amt., Amendment; Amts., Amendments; Amalg., Amalgamation; Ans., Answer; Ass.; Assurance; B., Bill; B.C., British Columbia; Can., Canada or Canadian; C.P.R., Canadian Pacific Railway ; Com., Committee ; Co., Company ; Cone., Concur, Concurred, Concurrence ; Consd., Consider' Consdn., Consideration ; Cor., Correspondence ; Deb., Debate; Dept., Department; Depts., Departments Div., Division ; Dom., Dominion ; Govt., Government; His Ex., His Excellency the Governor General; Hse., House ; H. of C., House of Commons ; Incorp., Incorporation ; Ins., Insurance ; I.C.R., Intercolonial Railway; Man., Manitoba; Mess., Message; M., Motion; m., moved; Neg., Negatived; N.B., New Brunswick; N.W.T., Northwest Territories ; N.S., Nova Scotia; O.C., Order in Council; Ont., Ontario ; P.E.I., Prince Edward Island ; P.O., Post Office ; Par., Paragraph; Prop., Proposed ; Q., Quebec; Ques., Question ; Recoin., Recommit; Ref., Refer, Referred, Reference; Rep., Report, Reported ; Reps., Reports ; Res., Resolution ; Ret., Return ; Ry., Railway ; Rys., Railways ; Sel., Select; Sen., Senate ; Sp. Special; Stmnt., Statement; Sup., Supply; Suppl., Supplement, Supplementary; Wthdn., Withdrawn ; Wthdrl., Withdrawal ; Y.N., Yeas and Nays; Names in Italics and parentheses are those of the mover.
ACHIM, Mr. H., Labelle.
C.N.R. and Carillon & Grenville Co.'s (B. 42) 1°* 970 (i).
La Compagnie du Chemin de fer de Colonisation du Nord (B. 45) 1°*, 970 (i).
AIKINS, Mr. J. A. H., Brandon.
Address, The, on Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Lau-rier) 94 (i).
Civil Service Increases since 1900 (M. for ret.*) 561 (i).
Cockshutt Plough Co.'e Prices, &c. (remarks) 855 (i).
Denny, James, Relief (B. 112) 1°*, 3630 (ii). Grain Act Amt. B. 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2186, 2318, 2773, 3795 (ii).
Hudson Bay Ry., Copy of Cor. re Construction, &e. (M. for papers) 1213, 1264 (i). Hudson Bay Ports, Surveys, &c. re Navigation (Ques.) 3943 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 (M. for reps.*) 3756 (ii).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on Prop. Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2124 (ii).
Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mt.
Burrell) in Com., 6029 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Patent Relief B. 84, on Order for
Com., 3332 (ii).

AMES, Mr. H. B.-Con.
Supply-
Labour Dept., (Gazette) 1481 (i).


Tariff Commission B.:  Reply to Amt. (Mr. Lemdeux) 4109
(iii)	.
Postal Regulations, Commission re Investigation (prop, res.) 2251 (id).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6262 (iv).
London Postmaster, Dismissal, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1542 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
iii
BEATTIE, Mr. T.-Con.
Wills, Annie Greek Relief (B. 173) 1°*, 5680 (iv).
BELAXD, Hon. H., Beauce.
Asbestos Importations, Total Value, &c. (M.
for ret.) 1590, 1817 (i).
Boucher, Mr. O. F„ Pet. re Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 975 (i).
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6306 (iv).
Cattle Quarantine at Beauceville, Res. from Chamber of Commerce, 4984 (iii).
Civil Service (mail clerks) Amt. B. 106 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 4784 (iii).
Dalaire, L. P., Dismissal of (Ques.) 2454 (ii). Duchaine, Pierre, Dismissal of (Ques.) 2454
(ii).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: (Mr. Monk) in Com. on Res., 6057 (iv).
Farly, Mrs., Postmistress at St. Gabriel de Brandon, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 2579 (ii).
G.	T. Ry. Assiniboine River Bridge Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 6061 (iv).
Henry, Norbert, Contract re Mails between Scott Junction and Station (Ques.) 975 (i). See ' Scott/


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3727 (ii).
Jacques, Leander, Postmaster, Dismissal, Ac. (Ques.) 3339 (ii).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5408 (iii); in Com. on Res., 5959 (iv).
Lacombe, J. A., Dismissal from St. Sebastian P. O., Inquiry re (Ques.) 974 (i).

 (M. for reps., &c.*) 4263 (iii).
See ' Lewis/


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6305 (iv).
St. Charles and Huron River Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6308 (iv).
Scott Junction Mail Contract, Cancellation re (M. for cor.*) 2459 (ii).
Supply-
Agriculture (animals health) 6477; (census) 6462; (International Institute) 6479 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Inland Revenue (private secretary) 6490 (iv).
Ai
BELAND, Hon. H.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Immigration (agencies) 3915 (ii).
Inland Revenue (explosives apparatus) 6604 (iv).
Justice, Administration of (Montreal circuit court) 6597 (iv).
Labour Dept, (conciliation boards) 1511
(i).
Militia (annual drill) 5478 (iii). Miscellaneous (counsel fees re Lanetot inquiry) 6486 (iv).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5342 (iii). Post Office (mail service) 6289; (salaries, &c.) 6618 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-N.S. (Tracadie * Lazeretto) 1530 (i).
Thibodeau, George, Resignation, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6618 (iv).
BELLEMARE, Mr. A., Maskinongi.
Budget, The, 5146 (iii).
Election Expenses in Maskinonge, Settlement of (Ques.) 4776 (iii).
Dismissals by Hon. Mr. Lemieux, Par. in ' Le Devoir ' (read) 2452, 2664 (ii).
, Medical Director General, Apptmt., &e. (Ques.) 2667 (ii).
St. Lawrence Channel Ice Breaker (Ques.) 5680 (iv).
Statue erected on Federal Land in Quebec City by Prov. Govt. (Ques.) 2667 (ii). Victoria Memorial Museum, Number of Employees, Dismissals, &c. (Ques.) 2294 (ii).
BENNETT, Air. R, B,, Calgary.
Address, The, in answer to His Ex/s Speech (moved) 14 (v).


Agricultural Aid B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 

BENNETT, Mr. W. H.-Con.
Ducharme, Mr., Apptmt. a a Com m issioner (remarks) re Attacks on, 2830 (ii). Elevators, Control by Govt., ref. to in debate on. Address, 137 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2977 (ii).
Temiiskaming and Northern Ontario -By. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6421 (iv).
BEST, Mr. .1. A., Dufferin.
Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt. B. 179 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 6094 (iv).
Dom. Atlantic Ry. Co.'s B. 22 (Mr. Jameson) in Com., 2011 (ii).
Personal Explanation, Remarks re Agricultural Com. Par. in Toronto ' Globe,' 2155
(ii).
Supply-
Railways-N. T. Ry. (construction) 5770 (iv).
BICKERDIKE, Mr. R., Montreal, St. Lawrence.
British Preference, Increase of (Ques.) 553 (i).
BICKERDIKE, Mr. R.-Con.
Cattle Embargo by G. B., Abolition of (Ques.) 557 (i).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1082 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 180 (Mr. Monk) in Com., 6202 (iv).
Educational Bills, Ques. of Order, re Jurisdiction of Dom. Govt., 3873 (ii).
See ' Queens.'


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 
INDEX-1911-12 v
[Stage Direction]
BLAIN, Mr. K.-Con.
Freight Rates, Discrimination re, on Amt.
(Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3211 (ii). Freight Rates, &c., on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 668 (i).
Inquiries Act.   A@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2537, 2775, 3167 (ii).
Grain Shipments in the West, Freight Rates, &c., on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3979
(ii).
Horse Racing: See ' Criminal Code,' &c. Judges Act (salaries) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Ccyn., 6006 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 4198 (iii).
N. T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1878 (i), 3375, 3411 (ii). Parcel Post Extension, on Amt. (Mr. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2350 (ii).
Public Accounts Com., on M. (Mr. Middle-bro) to cone, in 2nd Rep., 5836 (iv).
Public Accounts Com., Attendance of R. C.
Miller, on M. to adopt 3rd Rep., 6335 (iv). Race Track Meets: See ' Criminal Code,' &c.
Railway Committee, 13th Rep. (presented) 5999 (iv).
Rural Mail: See 'Civil Service,' 'Parcel Post.' Rural Telephone System., Placing in Post Offices (Prop, res.) 2247 (ii).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2895, 3011, 3542 (ii).
BOIVIN, Mr. G. H., Shefford.
Address, The, 497 (i).
Beauchemin, J. A., Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 3337 (ii).
Fenian Raid Vets. Land Grant, &c. (Ques.) 3334 (ii).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6642 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: Precedence re (M.) 9 (i).

 (M.) to Present, 519 (i).

Reply from H.R.H. (presented) 932
(i)	.


Agricultural Aid B.: Quebec Ministers of the Cabinet,
Choice of Min. of Public Works (Ans.) 545 (i).

 Stmt, by Hon. Mr. Monk (Ans.)
526 (i).
Cable Rates to G. B., on M. for Sup. (remarks) 3238 (ii).
Cable Rates Reduction, Papers laid on Table, 931 (i).
Cable Rates with G.B., Res. on Order Paper, Withdrawal of (remarks) 3448 (ii).
See ' Postal.'
Canadian Missionaries in China, Relief re Dangers (remarks) 230; (stmnt.) 268 (i).


BORDEN, Rt. Hon. R. L.-Uon.
Canadian Northern Alberta Ry. Co. Subsidy (M.) for Cbm. on Res., 5841 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@:  Investigation re Political Partisanship (Ans.) 1582 (i).
Civil Service Reform and Outside Service (Ans.) 727 (i).
Coffin, Mr. Henry, Reinstatement as Sessional Messenger (Ans.) 2289 (ii).
Commisioners of Investigation appointed by Govt., Number &c., (remarks) re Question, 5680 (iv).
See ' Dismissals/ ' Marine.'
Committees, Sel. Standing (M.) 10 (i).
-1- List (presented) 703 (i).

 (M.) to present Rep., 794 (i).

Ruling of Dep. Speaker on Objection
(Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 3255
(ii).


 See ' Marine/ ' Civil Service,' ' Commissioners.'
Dismissals from Ottawa Dept., on Inquiry for Ret., 3834 (ii).

House of Commons Dismissals, on Inquiry (Mr. C. A. Wilson) for Ret., 6807
(iv).
See ' Sessional, &c.'

 (remarks) re Question, 3148 (ii).
Farmers' Bank Investigation, Aptmt. of Sir William Meredith (remarks) 3332 (ii).


Fast Atlantic SS.: Service (remarks) 5696
(iv).	,	.
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6514 (iv).
Fife, Duke of, Decease (remarks) 2154 (ii).
Fisheries Jurisdiction re Provinces (Ans.) 3339 (ii).
Fish Reduction Works at Aricliat, Tel. from Prime Minister (Ans.) 2289 (ii).


Fort Osborne Barracks Sale B.: 185 (Mr. Hughes) in Com. on Res., 5706, 6067 (iv).
French Translator, Apptmt. of Mr. C. E. Duckett (M.) 1969 (ii).
Georgian Bay Canal, Policy of Govt, (remarks) 1971, 3060 (ii).
Good Roads Bill: See 'Highways/
Govt. Ownership: See 'Elevators,' 'Public ownership/


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
BORDEN, Rt. Hon. R. L.-Con.
G. T. Ry. Co.'s B. 130 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6749, 6766 (iv).
G. T. P. Ry. Co.'s B. 20 (Mr. Macdonald) on M. for 1°, 712; on M. for 2°, 790 (i).
G. T. P. Ry., Assiniboine Bridge Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 6060 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Subsidy Bill, on prop. Res. (Mr. White) 2297 (ii).
Gutelius, Mr. F. P., Form of Question, on Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 3934 (ii). Guysborough Branch Ry. Co.'s Appropriation, on it. for Sup., 1460 (i).
Hansard, French Edition, Delay in Distribution (remarks) 269 (i).
Health Dept., Legislation re (Ans.) 1585 (i). Highways Improvements B. 77 (Mr. Cochrane) on M. for 2°, Objection (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) re Ref. to Gov. Gen., 3639, 3643; in Com., 3668, 3948 (ii); on .Senate Amts., 6398 (iv).
Hindoo Immigration: See 'Sikhs'.
Horse Racing: See ' Criminal Code B. 165.' House of Commons, Employees, Salaries Increases (M.) to colic, in Rep. of Speaker, 6660 (iv).
Hudson Bay Ry. Contract, on M. (Mr. Neely) for O. Cs., 751 (i).
Immigration in Out., Promise of Premier re Assistance (Ans.) 546 (i).
Indemnity to Members, &c.: See 'Sen. & H. of C.', Ac.
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Legislation re Acquisition (Ans.)
569 (i).
I.C.R. Branch Lines, on prop. Res. (Mr. Emmerson) 1000 (i).
I.C.R. and Brotherhood Unions, on M. (Mr. Maclean) for Papers, 793 (i).
I.C.R. Management Board, Abolition of (Ans.) 570 (i).

Ticket Collectors, Apptmt. of (remarks) 6787 (iv).
Internal Economy Commission (presented) 11 (i).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5408 (iii).
Keewatin Separate Schools, Pet. re (Ans.) 4241 (iii).

 See ' Man. Boundaries Bill.'
Laforce, Mr. J. E., Emplymt. by Govt. (Ans.) 3535 (ii).
Legislation, Joint Com. (M.) 2217 (ii). L'Evenement Publishing Co., Minister acting as Director (Ans.) 1813 (i).
Library Committee (M.) 795 (i).
vii
BORDEN, Rt. Hon. R. L.-Con.
Librarv of Parliament, Rep. (presented) 11
(i).


Live Stock Records Association B.:  Discussion of School Question (Ans.)
534 (i).
See ' Separate Schools.'

 Eastern Extension (Ans.) 3936-7 (ii).

 Eastern and Western Line, &c. (Ans )
971 (i).

Financial Terms, &c. (Ans.) 558, 716
(i).


 on Inquiry for, 1820 (i).

 on Inquiry for Papers, 3834 (ii).

 Manitoba Questions, (remarks) re
answers, 581 (i).

 Memorial, Stmnt. re Finances, &c.
(remarks) 3631 (ii).

 Papers re (remarks) 3448 (ii).

Settlement re, Cor. with Man. and
Out. &e., on M. (Mr. Macdonald) 777 (i).
Man. Boundaries: See ' Ont. Boundaries.'
Marcil, Mr. Tancrede, Application re Govt. Position (Ans.) 2069 (ii).
Marine Hospital Ships, Establishment of re Fishermen (remarks) 6787 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Ref. to (Supreme Court (remarks)
3332 (ii).
Marriage Question re Catholic Hierarchy, (Ans.) 574 (i).
See ' Ne Temere.'
Miner, Bill, Escape &c. (remarks) 939 (i).
Monday Sittings, Precedence of Govt. Business (M.) 2376 (ii).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners, Res. from Corn Exchange Protesting re Removal (Ans.) 2070 (ii).

viii
BORDEN, Rt. Hon. R. L- Con.
Montreal, Patronage Committee, Recommendations re (Ans.) 1866 (i).
Montreal Harbour, National and Eree Port (Ans.) 554 (i).
Morine, Mr. A. B., Charges re (Mr. Car-vell) as Public Service Commissioner, on M. for Sup., 6541 (iv).
See ' Dismissals/

Objection re Candidate at Elections
(Ans.) 6336 (iv).
Morning Sessions: See 'Business of the House/
Mounted Police, Increase in Pay (remarks) 4743 (iii).

Report (presented) 971 (i).
Naval Bill, Discussion re (Ans.) 4240 (iii).
Naval Policy (remarks) in debate on Address, 58 (v).

Interview with Hon. Geo. H. Perley, &c. (remarks) 1576 (i).
Naval Policy, Promise re Rereferendum (Ans.) 526 (i).

 Repudiation by Nationalists (Ans.)
714 (i).

Speeches in Election Campaign, &c.
(Ans.) 552 (d).
N.	T. Ry. Act (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1869 (i); 3141, 3393, 3437 (id).
N. T. Ry. Commission of Investigation re Construction (remarks) 2061 (id).
See ' Gutelius/
N. T. Ry. Station at Quebec City (remarks) 6786 (iv).
National Waterways Treaty, Negotiations re (remarks) 3833 (ii).
Naturalization, Legislation re Uniformity, on M. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) Iot Cor., 767, 771 (i).
Ne Temere Decree, Power of Parlt, (remarks) re Answer to Questions, 798 (i).

Questions asked of late Govt., Concurrence by present Govt. (Ans.) 7.19 (i).

 Redistribution Bills, &c., Stmnt. by
Hon. Mr. Taylor, 545, 715 (i).
Peace Memorial Monument, Govt. Action re (remarks) 2590 (ii).
Peace River and Ry- Belt Water Power B.
149 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 5969 (iv). Pelagic Sealing Treaty, Ratification of (remarks) 4460 (iii); (explanation) 4550 (iii). Petroleum, Crude and Refined, Quantity -imported yearly .since 1902 (Ans.) 730 (i). Picotte, Mederic, Dismissal from H. of C. (Ans.) 2066 (ii).
Postal Regulations, on Prop. Res. (Mr. Armstrong) 2285 '(ii).

on M. to take in Mondays (remarks)
2376 (ii).
See ' Cable/
Preferential Trade within the Empire (remarks) in debate on Address, 55 (i). Prime Minister's Visit to Archbishop of Quebec (Ans.) 534 (i).
P. E. I., Better Terms, on M. for Sup., 5173
(iii)	.
P. E. I. Subsidy B. 178 (Mr. White) m Com,, 6143 (iv).
P. E. I. and Mainland Govt. Car Ferry Service, Tel. sent to A. A. McLean (Ans.) 1578, 1581 (i).
Printing of Parliament, Com. (M.) 795 (i). Private Bills, Consideration of (remarks) 6578 (iv).

 Extension of Time (M.) 930 (i).

 Refund of Fees (M.) 930 (i).
Private Secretaries: See 'Civil Service B. 60/
Provincial Boundaries, Res. from Sask. Legislature re Transfer of Resources (Ans.) 2578 (ii).
Provl. Boundaries:Nee ' B.C.', ' Man.' ' Ont/ ' P.E.I/, 'Ungava/ ' Que/
Public Accounts Com. (Diamond Light, Co.) on M. (Mr. Middlebro) to cone, in 2nd Rep., 5833 (iv).
Provincial Control of Western Natural Resources, Promises re (Ans.) 553 (i).


INDEX-1911-12 IX
[Stage Direction]
BORDEN, Rt. Hon. R. L.-Con.
Public Ownership of Govt. Utilities, on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 657, 1916 (i).
Quebec Boundaries Extension (B. 151)-(M.) for Com. on Res., 3944 (ii); in Com. on Res., 5268 (iii); 2°*, in Com., 6160; 3° m., 6188, 6338 (iv).
Quebec Bridge Reconstruction, Plans, Tenders, &c., on M. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) for Papers, 1402 (i).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) 4757;
on Order for Com., 4237 (iii).
Questions not answered (M.) re, 6732 (iv). Race Tracks: See ' Criminal Code B. 165/ Ry. Act (tariffs) Amt. B. 6 (Mr. Turriff) on M. for 2°, 1016; on M. to resume adjnd. debate, 1821 (i).
[Stage Direction]
(remarks) 2499, 2531 (ii).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  (stmnt.) 5831 (iv).
Seed Grain Distribution, Res. from Wilcox Board of Trade (remarks) 2301 (ii).
Senate and House of Commons Act (indemnity) B. 75, in Com. on Res., 1498 (i).
Senate Amendments to Railway Bills (remarks) 6493, 6577 (iv).
Senate Vacancies (remarks) 5162 (iii).
Senate Vacancy, Apptmt. of Acadian in N.B. (Ans.) 541 (i).
Senate Vacancies in N.S. (remarks) 1576 (i).

Pet. re French Apptmt. (remarks)
2755 (ii).
Separate Schools, Man. and Iveewatin, Demand from Members (Ans.) 4247 (iii).
See ' Man. Boundaries/
Sessional Employees, Number dismissed' (Ans.) 569 (i), 2064 (ii).
Sikhs, in B.C., Decision re bringing in their Wives (Ans.) 2457 (ii).
Solicitor General, Appmt. of (Ans.) 546, 1816 (i).

Payments to Min. of Jus., &c. (Ans.)
725 (i).

Vacancy (remarks) 1577 (i), 5162 (iii).
Speaker, Election of (M.) 2; Reply to Sir Wilfrid Laurier, 5 (i).
' Speaker, Deputy (M.) 519, 523 (i).
Steam Trawling on Canadian Coasts, on M. (Mr. Sinclair) for Papers, 2462 (ii).
Supply-
Archives (salaries) 6462 (iv).
Canals-Welland (surveys) 5789 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Archives (dep. minister) 6460
(iv).	.
Civil Govt.-Gov. Gen/s Office (salaries) 1035 (i).
Civil Govt.-Inland Revenue (private secretary) 6490; (promotions) cone., 6771
(iv).
Civil Govt.-Privy Council (salaries) 6460 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Public Works (private secre-
, tary) cone., 6779 (iv).
Fisheries (International Fishery Commission) cone., 6778 (iv).
Legislation-House of Commons (stenographers, &c.) 6461; Senate (sessional indemnity) 6460 (iv).
Militia (automobiles) 5520 (iii). Miscellaneous (Champlain monument) 6485; (claim of Mrs. Wiley) 6489; (counsel fees re Lanctot inquiry) 6486; (hono-rarias re Pelagic Sealing) 5810; (La Society Nationals Gymnastique) 5811; (Olympic games) 6486; (retiring allowance to Staff Sergeant Codd) 5811 (iv). Mounted Police (pay, subsistence, &c.)
5175 (iii); (pensions) 6485 (iv).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5342 (iii). Public Works-Buildings (Chatham, cone., 6804	(iv); Ottawa (examining warehouse) 1950; Ottawa (H. of C., addition) 1951 (i).
X

BORDEN, Et. Hon. R. L.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers (French River) cone., 6777 (iv).
Railways-I.C.R. (Halifax docks) 5597; (rolling stock) 6461 (iv).
Trade and Commerce (Annuities Act) 701
(i).
Weights and Measures (inspection) 5828 (iv).
Supreme Court of Canada, Division of (Ans.) 547 (i).


Tariff Commission B.:  on M. (Mr. Pugsley) to Com. of Sup.,
6692 (iv).	*

Ratification of Apptmt. by late Govt.
(Ans.) 533 (i).
See 'Boundai'y Waters.'
Wednesday Sittings, Govt. Business (M) re Precedence, 1969 (ii).
Winnipeg Military Property Sale: See 'Fort Osborne.'
BORDEN, Et. Hon. E. L.-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 123 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5405 (iii).
BOULAY, Mr. H., Rimouski.
Beauchesne, Mr., Dismissal from Customs (Qiw|s.) 3151 (ii).
Bourque, Geoffrey, Accident on I.C.R., Inquiry re (M. for reps.*) 2459 (ii). Buildings leased by Govt., Rentals, &c., (Ques.) 1358 (i).
Courehesne, Mr. P. E. C., Dismissal from Inland Revenue (Ques.) 1864 (i). Dismissals on I.C.R. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5807 (iv).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1550 (i). Dismissals in Rimouski County (remarks) 1276 (i).
Dupont, Rene, Dismissal as Immigration Agent (Ques.) 1864 (i).
I.C.R., Board of Commission (remarks) in Com. of :Sup., 5655 (iv).

Fences, Number of Rods, &c., Campbellton Division, (Ques.) 6748 (iv). Laurier, C. A., Immigration Agent at Marquette, Mich. (Ques.) 2454 (ii).
Laurier, B., Immigratio'n Agent at Detroit (Ques.) 2454 (ii).
Lavoie, Mr. Absolon, Inquiry re Death on I.C.R. (M. firm cor.*) 426o (iii).
Lemieux, Mr., Appointments to Govt. Service, List (read) in Com. of Sup., 6297 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  (M. for papers, 4c.,) 1391 (i).
St. Laurent, Xavier, Claims for Loss of Horse killed on I.C.R. (M. for cor.*) 42G3
(iii).
Sayabec Post Office, Apptmt. of Miss Boulay (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6297 (iv). Sorel Workshops Investigations, Payments re (Ques.) 1205 (i).
Supply-
Justice, Administration of (Montreal Circuit court) 6597 (iv).
Militia (properties) 5539 (iii).
Post Office (mail service) 6297 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Ont. (Sudbury) 1953 (i).
Railways-I.C.R. (highway crossing) 5601; (locomotives) 5655 (iv).
Sussex Street Property, Purchase by Govt., Total Amount paid, &c. (Ques.) 1359 (i).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xi
BOULAY, Mr. H.-Con.
Temiskaming Lake Dam Construction, &c. (M. for cor.*) 4262 (iii).
Tourigny, Judge, Charges re, Govt. Action (Ques.) 3147 (ii).
BOYCE, Mr. A. C., West Algoma.
Algoma Eastern Ey. Co.'s (B. 34) 1°*. 969
(i).
Canadian Missionaries in China, Eefusal of British Gunboat for Protection, Bep. re (remarks) 1198 (i).
Can. Northern Ey. Co.'s B. 38 (Mr. Staples) in Corn., 5201 (iii).
Can. Pacific Ey. Co.'s B. 98 (Mr. MeCraney) in Com., 5199 (iii).
Copper Cliff Post Office. Dismissal &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2034 (ii).
Dismissals from Govt. Offices (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2033 (ii).
Pacific and Atlantic Ev. Co.'s (B. 51) 1°*, 970 (i).
Bailway Bates, Transportation, ie., on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 1940 (i).
Bainy Biver Eadial By. Co.'s B. 121 (Mr. Beattie) in Com., 5198 (iii).
Sudbury Post Office, Dismissals (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2033 (ii).
Universal Eyesight Co.'s incorp. B. 126 (Mr. McLean) in Com., 5908 (iv).
BOYEE, Mr. G., Vaudreuil.
Broun, \Y m., Postmaster at Point Fortune, Complaints re (Ques.) 4779 (iii).
Carillon Canal Hydraulic Power, Name of Lessee (Ques.) 2293 (ii).
Cuillerier, Mr. Jos., Soulanges Canal, Electrician, Dismissal, &e. (Ques.) 4457
(iii); 6183 (iv).
Dismissal of Conservative Postmaster re Political Partisanship (Ques.) 2295 (ii).
Gauthier, Alderic, Dismissal from Soulanges Canal (Ques.) 4976 (iii).
Isidore Chevrier, Charges re, &c. (Ques.) 4039
(iii).
Lalonde, Damien, Eep. re Assault, &c. (Ques.) 4255 (iii).
Legault, Ophir, Postmaster at L'lle Perrot, Dismissal of (Ques.) 5950 (iv).
Leroux, Mr., Soulanges Canal, Dismissal (Ques.) 6183 (iv).
Methot, Denis, Apptmt. on Soulanges Canal (Ques.) 4255 (iii).
Mont petit, Dr. E., Pet. sent to l'.M.G. re Dismissal of William Brown (Ques.) 4977 (iii).
Mount Oscar Postmaster, Dismissal of I. Chevrier (Ques.) 4780 (iii).
BOYEE, Mr. G.-Con.
Postmasters, Dismissals, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6632 (iv).
Bigaud Postmaster, Applications re (Ques.) 2294 (ii).
Bobert, Wm, Dismissal from Val des Ebou-lis Post Office (Ques.) 3537 (ii).
Ste. Anne de Bellevue and L'lle Perrot Mail Contracts, Expiration of (Ques.) 5951 (iv). Ste. Anne de Bellevue, Non-delivery of Mail, &c. (Ques.) 5260 (iii).
Soulanges Canal, Charges re Damien Lalonde (Ques.) 4249 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Claims of Denis Martin for Damages
(Ques.) 2292 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Employees, Names, &c. (Ques.) 4250
(iii)

Patronage, &c. (Ques.) 3536 (ii).
Supply-
Excise (tobacco stamps) 5827 (iv).
Militia (annual drill) 5484 (iii).
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries) 6632 (iv).
Weights and Measures (inspectors) 5828
(iv).
Val des Eboulis and Eigaud Mail Service, Contract re (Ques.) 4249 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Date of Wm. Bobert's Contract
(Ques.) 4778 (iii).
Valois, J. B., Dismissal from Vaudreuil Post. Office (Ques.) 3537 (ii).
BEABAZON, Mr. G. II., Pontiac.
Quinze Biver and Ottawa By. Co.'s iucorp. (B. 54) 1°*, 970 (i).
BBADBUEY, Mr. G. 1L, Selkirk.
British American Trust Co.'s incorp. (B. 155) 1°*, 5400 (iii).
Canadian Offices in London, Cor. re Accommodation, &c. (M. for copies) 1398 (i). Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2026 (ii).
Fenian Baid Veterans Bounty B.: 
Highways Improvements B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 36S0 (ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: BRADBURY, Mr. G. H.-Con.
Railway Question: See 'Grain Shipments/ Reciprocity Treaty with U.S., Cor. with British Ambassador (M. for copies*) 1817
(i)

	Cor. between Can. Govt, and U.S.
(M. for copies*) 1817 (i).
Red River Pollution, on M. for Sup., 5166
(iii).
Supply-
Justice-Penitentiaries (bonus) 6600 (iv). Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1479 (i).
Militia, Ques. of Order, 5538 (iii). "Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commissioners incorp. B. 138 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 5991 (iv).
BRODER, Mr. A., Dundas.
Budget, The, 5083 (iii).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6255, 6456 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 3169 (ii).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulations of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3979 (ii).


Highways Improvements B.:  Govtl. Action re (remarks) on M.
for Sup., 1714 (i).
Coal Strike in Alberta (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1507 (i).
Coal Strike in the West, Stmnt. of Min. of Ini. re Settlement (Ques.) 571 (i).
Dom. Lands Agent at Medicine Hat, Suspension or Dismissal (Ques.) 552 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 3498 (ii), 4077 (iii).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulation of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 4004 (ii).
See ' Car,' &c.
Lethbridge Armoury, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ques.) 729 (i).

 Site re (remarks) in Com. of Sup.,
2210 (ii).
Lethbridge Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ques.) 728 (i).
Police Point Reserve Transfer (M. for papers*) 5557 (iv).
Supply-
Labour Dept, (industrial disputes investigation act) 1498 (i).	,
Public Buildings-Alberta (Lethbridge) 2212 (ii).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6305 (iv).



[Stage Direction]
xiii
BUREAU, Hon. J.-Const. Tite Postmaster, Dismissal of (Ques.) 1210 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6285 (iv).
Supply-
Civil Govt.-Charges of Management (dom. notes) 1033; Customs-Outside Ports (salaries) 1077; Customs (salaries) 1010; Inland Revenue (salaries) 1040, 1061; Marine Dept., (salaries) 1056; Militia (salaries) 1038; Post Office (salaries! 1067 (i).
Mines (French reports) 6490; (ore deposits) 6190 (iv).
Post Office (mail service) 6285 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Ont. (Toronto warehouse) 1963 (i).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6449 (iv).
Three Rivers, Inland Revenue Charges against Collector C. D. Hebert (Ques.) 1209 (i).
BURNHAM, Mr. J. H., West Peterborough. Address, The, 318 (i).
Ballots, Voting by Divisions (Ques.) 4979 (ii'i).
Budget, The, 5101 (iii).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1178 (i).
Dom. Elections Act (deposit) Amt. (B. 8) l°m., 337; 2°m., 1017 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 4068 (iii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3704 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Purchase of Paintings, &c. (Ques.)
6184 (iv).
N. T. Ry. Act (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1875 (i), 3379
(ii).
N. T. Ry. Repair Shops, Erection at Quebec and Winnipeg (Ques.) 4977 (iii).
Old Age Pensions (prop, res.) 1362 (i).

 (remarks) 1829 (i).
P.E.I. Subsidy B. 178 (Mr. White) in Com., 6133 (iv).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) in Com., 3877 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: Completion of (Ans.) 5261 (iii).
Continental Can Co.'s Patent Relief B. 119 (Mr. Fripp) in Com., 5206 (iii). Conservation Commission, Water Powers Report (presented) 407 (i).
Copyright Bill, Legislation re (Ans.) 557, 1208 (i).

 (remarks) 936 (i).
Dairying Industry in Canada, Complaints re Weighing Cheese (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5744 (iv).
Horses destroyed at Weyburn, Rep., &c. (remarks) 6790 (iv).
Horses imported from U.S., Destruction for Glanders (remarks) 5694, 5940 (iv).
Kettle Valley Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5899, 6220, 6322 (iv).
Kettle Valley Ry. Bridge Subsidy, in Com., 6327 (iv).
Kootenay Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5899, 6219 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com.
on Res., 5899; in Com., 6219. 6320 (iv). Regina Census Return (remarks) upon Inquiry for (Mr. Knowles) 1574 (i).
Ste. Anne de la Pocatiere Experimental Farm, Buildings re (Ans.) 578 (i).
Seed Grain Distribution, Res. from Wilcox Board of Trade (remarks) 2301 (ii).
Supply-
Agriculture (animals health) 6469 (iv) : (census, &c.) 619 (i), 6462; (experimental farms, branch stations) 6477; (experimental farms, farm bulletins) 6465; (experimental farms, tobacco growing) 6478; (live stock industry) 6469; (Seed Control Act) 6469 (iv).
Agriculture-Miscellaneous	(Destructive
Insect and Pest Act) 6479; (Dom. Exhibition) 6479; (fumigating stations) 6479 ; (International Institute! 6478; (Toronto exhibition) 6480; Agriculture, &c. (Year , Book). 6465 (iv).
Archives (salaries) 6461 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Agriculture (salaries) 1041
(i); (promotions) 6185 (iv).
Veitch Farm, Purchase of by Govt. (Ans.) 933 (i).
Wheeler, Seager, Congratulations re Prize Wheat at New York (Ans.) 542 (i).
CARDIN, Mr. P. J. A., Richelieu. Dauphimiais, Mr. J. O., Dismissals, &c. (M.
for papers*) 4782 (iii).
Dupre, Dr. H., Dismissals from St. Robert Post Office (M. for papers*) 4782 (iii).

 (Ques.) 3753 (ii).
Govt. Dredges, Contracting re Boarding Employees (Ques.) 5953 (iv).
Govt. Dredges and Tugs, Instructions re Appointments (Ques.) 5952 (iv). Investigations re Political Partisanships, Cost of (Ques.) 5950 (iv).
Lalonde, Alfred, Complaints re (Ques.) 4779
(iii).

 (M. for cor.*) 6783 (iv).
Marlin, Mrs. A. S., Postmistress, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 3753 (ii).
Peloquin, Mr. F., Postmaster at St. Joseph de Sorel, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 3753 (ii).
CARDIN, Mr. P. J. A .-Con.
St. Lawrence Ship Channel, Govt. Dredges, Emplvmt. of &c. (Ques.) 4256 (iii).
St. Martin, Madame, Dismissal from St. Louis de Bonseeours (M. for papers*) 4782
(iii).
Salute Eochs Wharf (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6657 (iv).

(Ques.) 4248 (iii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6643 (iv).
Sorel and Ste. Victoria Mail Contracts, Contracts, Tenders, &c. (M. for papers*) 4782
(iii).
Supply-
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries) 6643
Weights and Measures (inspectors) 5828
(iv).
GARRICK, Mr. J. J., Thunder Bay and Rainy River.
Grain Act, Amt. B. 32 (Mr. Poster) in Com., 2182, 2383 (ii).
CARROLL, Mr. W. I'., South Cape Breton. Civil Service Association, Representations to Govt. &c. (Ques.) 3334 (ii).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1162 (i).
Glace Bay Mail Delivery, Delay, &c. (Ques ) 804 (i).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Prove., on prop.
Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2092 (ii).
Labour Gazette Correspondents, Dismissals, &e., on M. for Sup., 1444 (i).
Lightkeepers in N. S., Investigation re Charges (remarks) in Com. of Cup., 5234 (iii).
Lobster Twine Customs Duties (remarks) on M. for Sup., 1072 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
INDEX-1911-12 xv
[Stage Direction]
CARROLL, IMr. W. F.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N. S. (Burke's Head) 2015; (Cape Breton) 2052; (Cow Bay) 2055 (ii).
Weights and Measures (inspectors) 5831
(iv).
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2872 (ii).
CARVELL, Mr. F. B., Carleion, N.B.
Address, The, on Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Laur-ier) S2 (i).
Advertisements for Govt. Contracts, Tenders re (Ques.) 2449 (ii).


Agricultural Aid B.:  (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1074, 1166
(i).
See ' Marine.'
Dredges and Boiler Inspection (Ques.) 5953 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6252, 6256 (iv).
See 'Volunteer.'
Franco-Canadian Relations (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5759 (iv).
Gutelius, Mr. F. P., Apptmt. to N.T.Ry. Commission, British Subject, &c. (Ques.) 4038 (iii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3966 (ii).
Immigration Agent, Mr. Sevigny, Apptmt., Remuneration, &c. (Ques.) 1588 (i).
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity in Can., on M. (Mr. Macdonald) to Com. of Sup., 2429 (ii).
I.C.Ry. Supt., Application of Member of H. of C. (Ques*) 4040 (iii).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5409 (iii); in Com. on Res., 5959; in Com., 6010 (iv).
L'Evenement Publishing Co., Minister acting as Director (Ques.) 1813 (i).
McLean, W. S., Dismissal from Customs at L'Etang (Ques.) 4780 (iii).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6621 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 2nd Rep. on M. (Mr. Middlebro) to
cone. 5832 (iv).
See ' Diamond Light.'


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6211 (iv).
Railway Ties, Contract with Dame Boulay (M. for cor.*) 5957 (iv).
Regiments of Foreign Born Citizens, Organization of (Ques.) 531 (i).
Renfrew, S., Election, on M. (Mr. A. H.
Clarke) to adjn. Hse., 2237 (ii).
Robinson, Fred. P., Apptmt. as Preventive Officer, N.B. (Ques.) 1211 (iii).
Rural Mail: See ' C. S. Bill 79.'
St. John Valley Ry. Subsidy, Agreement re (Ques.) 3049 (ii).

(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1235 (iii).


Customs Collector P.   J.@: Inquiry for Papers, 3946 (ii).
Sayabec Postmistress, Apptmt. of Miss Boulay (Ques.) 2068 (ii).

Dismissal, Apptmt. re &c. (Ques.)
2585 (ii).
Sevigny, Mr. J. E., Apptmt. in Immigration Office, &c. (Ques.) 1205, 1811 (i). Southampton Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6224 (iv).
Supply.
Arts, Agriculture, &c. (census) 6162 (iv). Canals (statistical officers) 5801 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Customs-Outside Service (salaries) 1071; Railways (salaries) 1061
(i).	.
Excise (customs duties) 5827; (salaries) 5812; (travelling expenses) 5826 (iv). Legislation-Senate (indemnities) 6460 (iv). Militia (annual drill) 5454; (allowances) 5417; (associations and bands) 5529; (armouries) 5541; (automobiles) 5493; (clothing) 5521; (customs dues) 5522; (headquarters staff) 5536; (salaries) 5546; (schools of instruction) 5516 (iii). Miscellaneous (counsel fees re Lanctot Inquiry) 6487 (iv).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5309 (iii). Post Office (mail service) 6282; Outside Service (salaries) 6621 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings, Dom. (London, England), 6655 (iv).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N. B. (St. John dry dock) 3300 (ii); Ont. (French River) 6658 (iv).
Railways-I.C.R. (Board of Management) 1137; (Campbellton) 1162; (construction) 4131; (working expenses) 1163 (iii). Railways-Miscellaneous (staff salaries) 5801 (iv).	'
CARVELL, Mr. F. B.-Con.
Supply-Con.	_
Weight and Measures (inspection electric lights) 5828 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 137 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 6177, 6150 (iv).
See ' Fenian.'
Wadge, Thomas, Patent Relief B. 16 (Mr. Aikins) in Com., 2981, 2986, 3280, 3479 (ii).

reported from Com., 3280 (ii).
White, James, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 3338
(ii).
Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commissioners incorp. B. 138 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 5997 (iv).
Woodstock, N.B., Apptmt. of Excise Officer (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5812 (iv).
Yule, Mr., Collector of Customs at Aurora, Dismissal of (Ques.) 5950 (iv).
CASH, Mr. E. L., Mackenzie.


Grain Act B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Boundaries Extension B.: 151 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 6163 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xvii
CHISHOLM, Mr. A. W.-Con.
Kennedy, Allan, Govt. Telegraph Repairer, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 3757 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2020 (ii).
MeFarlane, J. D., Postmaster at Southwest Margaree, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 3756
(ii).
Mclsaac, Colin, Preventive Officer at Port Hood, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 5956 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5816 (iv).
McLean, Donald E., Dismissal, &c. (M. for papers*) 4980 (iii).
McLennan, Mr., Dismissal from Inverness Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2017 (ii).
McPhee, Lames, Customs Officer, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 3757 (ii).
Orangedale to Cheticamp Ry. Construction (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4226 (iii).
Port Hawkesbury, Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1345 (i), 2016 (ii).
Supply-
Lighthouse and Coast Service (aids to navigation) 5236 (iii).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Bras d'Or Lakes) 4735 (iii).
Militia-(armouries) 5545 (iii).
Ocean and River Service (life savin0-awards) 5228 (iii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers, Mar Provs. (creosoted timber) 2410 (ii). Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- N.S. (Inverness) 2056; (Melford) 2056 (ii). Public Works Telegraphs-Alta, (gener-. ally) 2822 (ii).	8
Railways (surveys, &c.) 4226 (iii).
Weights and Measure (electric light inspection) 5828 (iv).
Telephone Wires strung on Telegraph Poles, permission of Govt, (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2822 (ii).
CHISHOLM, WM., Antigonish.
Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5295 (iii).
Antigonish County Public Works, Appropriations re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2438 (ii).
Antigonish to County Harbour, Ry. Subsidy (remarks) 6227 (iv).
Antigonish Harbour Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2022 (ii).
Decoste, Capt. Peter, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.) 1268 (i).

(Ques.) 548 (i).

Defective Answer to Question (remarks) 803 (i).

(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3256 (ii).
Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2030 (ii).
Dismissals re Inland Rev. Dept., Policy of Min. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5819 (iv).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1560 (i).
B
CHISHOLM, Mr. Wm.-Con.

Apptmt. of Commissioners re Investigation (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3250
(ii)	.


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3715 (ii).
McAdam, Alex. R., Fishery Officer at Antigonish, Dismissal, &e. (M. for cor.*) 3343
(ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 4630 (iii).
Manitoba Boundaries, Settlement re, on M.
(Mr. Macdonald) for Cor., 783 (i).
Pictou Cattle Disease, Compensation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6472 (iv). Public Works for N. S., Appropriations re Estimates (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2796 (ii).


Quebec Boundaries Extension B.: 151 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 6171 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: - 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6224 (iv).
Senate Vacancies in N. S. (remarks) 1576
(i).
Southampton Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. 6227 (iv).
Steam Trawling, &c., on M. (Mr. Sinclair) for Papers, 2466 (ii).
Supply-
Agriculture (animals health) 6470, 6477;
(bulletins) 6465 (iv).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Pictou and Cheticamp) 4736 (iii).
Militia (automobiles) 5496, 5519 (iii). Public Works-Buildings-Ont. (Port Arthur) 1952 (i).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Mar. Provs. (creosoted timber) 2440 (ii). Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N.
S.	(Bayfield) 2041; (Blue Rocks Island) 2041; (Cribbin's Point) 2046; (Gillis Point) 2056 (id).
Railways-I.C.R. (Moncton * shops) 5604 (iv); (Sylvan Valley) 4226; (Truro) 4231
(iii)	.
CLARE, Mr. Geo. A., South Waterloo.


Berlin P.O.: Clock (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i).
CLARK, Mr. H., North Bruce.
Fisheries Jurisdiction re Provinces (Ques.) 3339 (ii).
xviii

CLARK, Mr. H.-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com. on Res., 5913 (iv).
Simcoe, Grey and Bruce Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5913 (iv).
Supply-
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1487 (i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2996 (ii).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6406 (iv).
CLARK, Mr. M., Red Deer.
Address, The, on Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Lau-rier) 210 (i).
Budget, The (remarks) 5085 (iii).
Christmas, Adjournment, on M. (Mr. Borden) 927 (i).


Civil Service Act B.: 106 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 5265 (iii).	.
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1187 (i), 2039 (ii). Grain Act, Amt. B. 32 (Mr. Poster) in Com., 3475, 3818 (ii).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulation of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 4023 (ii).
See ' Ry. Rates.'


Highways Improvement B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1311 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 

[Stage Direction]
xix
CLEMENTS, Mr. II. S., Comox-Atlin.
Budget, The, 5144 (iii).
Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2029 (ii).
Esquimau and Nanaimo Ry. Co/s (B 90) 1°*, 2217 (ii).
Fisheries Protection Service on Pacific Coast, Capt. Newcombe's Rep. (M. for copy) 2167 (ii).
Kootenay Central Ry. Co/s (B. 91) 1°*, 2217
(ii).
Prince Rupert Dry Dock, Subsidy, Completion, &c. (Ques.) 1811 (i).
Public Works Expenditure for last ten years in Different Provinces (Ques.) 2061
(ii).
M hart's, Total Expenditure for last ten years (Ques.) 1811 (i).
COCHRANE, Hon. F. (Minister of Railways) Nipissing.
Alberta Pacific Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6315 (iv).
Albert Mines and Hillsborough Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6246, 6305 (iv).
Albert Mines Ry. Co/s- Subsidy (amt.) in Com., 6395 (iv).
Algoma Central and Hudson Bay Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5897, 6216, 6312
(iv).
Antigonisli to Country Harbour Ry. Subsidy (remarks) 6227 (iv).
American Freight passing through Welland Canal (Ans.) 3536 (ii).
Archibald, Mr. P. S., Employmt. by Ry. Dept. (Ans.) 933 (i).
Belanger, Amedee, Dismissal from I. C. Ry.
Investigation re (Ans.) 3051 (ii).
Bourque, Mr. Jeffrey, Claims re Damages on I.C.R. (Ans.) 2244 (ii).
Bruce Mines and Algoma Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6314 (iv).
Burrard Inlet Tunnel and Bridge Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6318 (iv).
Calgary and Fernie Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6323 (iv).
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6305 (iv).
Can. Northern Alberta Ry. Co/s Subsidy (B 189) 1°*, 6083; in Com., 6372 (iv).
Can. Northern Pacific Ry. Co/s (B. 187) in Com. on Res., 6081; 1°*, 6082; 2° m., 6331; in Com., 6339; 3° m., 6371 (iv).
Can. Northern Ry., Bridge at Morris, Man., Objections re (Ans.) 2587 (ii).
Can. Northern Quebec Ry., Maintenance of Road on L'lle Bourdon (Ans.) 5262 (iii). C.P.Ry. (Toulon) R,y. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6217 (iv).
Canals, Capital Expenditure, Total Expenditure (Ans.) 1811 (i).
COCHRANE, Hon. F.-Con.
Canal Staffs, Dismissals, &e. (remarks) in Com of Sup., 5801 (iv).
Canal Traffic, Total Tonnage of Freight, &c. (Ans.) 3051 (ii).
Cap. de la Magdeleine Ry. Co/s B. 43 (Mr. Paquet) in Com., 2014 (ii).
Caribou, Barkerville and Willow River Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6320 (iv).
Carillon Canal Hydraulic Power Lease, Name of Lessee (Ans.) 2293 (ii).
Car Shortage, re Transportation of Hay Crop (remarks) 2754 (ii).
Cement supplied to Ry. Dept., Tenders, Contract Price, &c. (Ans.) 4245 (iii).
Cliateauguay Inundated Lands, Investigation re (Ans.) 6661 (iv).
Chatham and Newcastle Ry. Accommodation, Pets, from Boards of Trade (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4192 (iii).
Clarkboro, Sask., C.N.R. Right of Way, Title re (Ans.) 934 (i).
Couture, Mr. A., Dismissal from I.C.R. (Ans.) 2242 (ii)..
Cuillerrier, Mr. J., Soulanges Canal Electrician, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 6183 (iv).
*-[DOT]

 Complaints re (Ans.) 4458 (iii).
Cresine, Geo., Quarter Master on SS. Scotia, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 1583 (i).
Dismissals, Policy of Govt, (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4187 (iii).
See ' Canals/ ' I.C.R/, &c.
Doucet, Mr. A. E., Position on N.T. Ry. (Ans.) 2246 (ii).	'
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6221 (iv).
Falconer, Ii. S., Dismissal of as Inspector, &c., on I.C.R. (Ans.) 544 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Emplymt. as Contractor re Public
Works (Ans.) 5261 (iii).
Fraser, John, Emplymt. by Govt, (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4189 (iii).
Fraserville Wharf, Cor. re Construction (Ans.) 3534 (ii).
Fredericton and Grand Lake Coal and Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6224 (iv).
Freight Rates in the West, Complaints re (remarks) 666 (i).
Freight Rates on Rys., on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3217 (ii).
Gass, Trueman, Emplymt. and Dismissal on I.C.R. (Ans.) 2242 (ii).
Gauthier, Alderie, Dismissal from Soulanges Canal (Ans.) 4976 (iii).
Goods Roads Bill: See ' Highways/
Goulet, Apptmt. as Inspector of Stations, N.T.Ry. (Ans.) 3935 (ii).
Grain Act B.: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2320
(ii).



COCHRANE, Hon. F.-Con.
Grain Congestion in tlie West, Transportation, &c. (remarks) on M. (Mr. Oliver) to Com. of Sup., 6205 (iv).
See ' Freight Rates,' &c.
Grand Lake and Belle River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6307 (iv).
G.T.P. Ry. Co. (Brandon) Subsidy, in Com., 6321 (iv).

Branch Lines, Extension, on Prop.
Res. (Mr. Emmerson) 994 (i).

Coal Supply, Tenders re (Ans.) 2457
(ii)	.

Condon, D. Murray, Transfer of Passenger Agent (Ans.) 3337 (ii).

Control by Ry. Commission, Res. re
(Ans.) 4979 (iii).

Dismissals on I.C.R. (remarks) in
Com. of Sup., 5807 (iv).

Dartmouth to Denis Branch Line,
I.C.R., Tenders re (Ans.) 543 (i).
_____Employees Retirement Fund, Refund
to dismissed men (Ans.) 2450 (ii), 5934 (iv).
COCHRANE, Hon. F.-Con.
I.C. Ry., Estende to Baddeck Branch Line, Tender re (Ans.) 576 (i).

Estmere to Baddeck Branch Line,
Tenders, &c. (Mr. McKenzie) on M. for papers, 2498 (ii).

Fences, Number of Rods on Campbellton Div. (Ans.) 6748 (iv).

Fraser, John, Dismissal as Inspector
at Stellarton (Ans.) 3935 (ii).
______Freight on Fish, Aid re Transportation (Ans.) 6749 (iv).

 Guysborough Branch, Construction re
(Ans.) 571 (i).
______Hillsborough Branch, Rails loaned,
&c. (Ans.) 4978 (iii).

 Hagerty, S. W., Lismissal from Inspectorship of Ry. Station at Mulgrave (Ans.) 4976 (iii) *
______ Holiday and Sunday Pay, &e. (Ans.)
1583 (i)'	*	~\T u
______Inspector, Application from Member
of H. of C. (Ans.) 4040 (iii).
______ I.C.R. and G.T.Ry. Arbitration, Delays re Settlement (Ans.) 3940 (ii).
______Matapedia Branch, Inspection re Subsidy (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4196 (iii).
______Moncton Office, Tenders re Heating,
Stmnt. re (Ans.) 6744 (iv).
______ Moncton Shops, Heating Tenders, on
Inquiry for Papers, 5762 (iv).
______Moncton Shops, Transfer to Fraserville (Ans.) 544 (i).
_____< Ocean Limited,' Instructions re
Transportation of Private Cars (Ans.)
2241 (ii).	..
______Pay Day, Change re (Ans.) 3340 (ii).
______Pullman Car Porters, Promotion, &c.
(Ans.) 1413 (i).
_____Ry. Ties at Sayabec, Name of Contractor, Price, &c. (Ans.) 4041 (iii).
_____Riviere du Loup, Workshops at, Removal to Fraserville (Ans.) 570 (i).
_____ gte. Anne de la Pocatiere Fence Poles,
Charges re Removal, &c. (Ans.) 2586 (ii). _____ Snow Blockade, Delays re Trains (remarks) 1409 (i).
_____-Station at Truro, Tenders re Construction (Ans.) 1413 (i).	_
James Bay Ry. Subsidy, in Com., 6309 (iv). Kettle Valley Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com.
on Res., 5899, 6322 (iv).	.
Kettle Valley Ry. Co.'s Bridge Subsidy, in Com., 6327 (iv).
Kootenay Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6219 (iv).
Lachine Bridge: See 'Highlands.
Lac Seul, Rat Portage and Keewatin Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6217 (iv).



[Stage Direction]
COCHRANE, Hon. F.-Con.
Lake Erie and Northern Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6312 (iv).
Lalonde, Damien, Rep. re Assault (Ans.) 4256 (iii).
Lauzon, Desire, Emplymt. by Govt., References as to character (Ans.) 3538 (ii).
Leroux, Mr., Sonlanges Canal, Dismissal (Ans.) 6183 (iv).
Manitoba and Northwestern Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6314 (iv).
Methot, Denis, Emplymt. on Soulanges Canal (Ans.) 4255 (iii).
Naas and Skeena River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6321 (iv).
N.	T. Ry. Co.'s (B. 21) 1°*. 713; 2" m., 797 (i).
N. T. Ry. Act (Commission) Amt. (B. 76) 1° m., 1571; in Com., 1866 (i); 3126, 3364
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Stmnt. re Cost and Progress, in Com.
on Bill, 3127 (ii).
N. T. Ry. Branch Lines to Montreal, Construction of (Ans.) 554 (i).
N. T. Ry. Commission, Apptmt. of Mr. Leonard, Duties assigned &c., (Ans.) 533
(i)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Payments to Mr. E. Taschereau (Ans.)
2245 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Payments to Taschereau, Cannon &
Co. (Ans-) 2245 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Commission, Report re (remarks) 2157
(ii)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Commissioners, Notification of Dismissal (remarks) 11B6, 1199 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Damages in Dorchester County,
Amounts paid (Ans.) 6184 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Estimated Cost, Stmnt. re (Ans.)
3127 (ii), 6733 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Investigation, Apptmt., Salary, &c.,
of Messrs. Gutelius and Lynch Staunton (Ans.) 4242 (iii).
See 'Gutelius.'
[Stage Direction]
Moncton to Levis, Portion uncompleted (Ans.) 932 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Pets, re Subsidy to Montreal Branch
Line (Ans.) 573 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Quebec-Moncton Section, Completion
re Operation by Govt. (Ans.) 723 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Repair Shops, Erection at Quebec and
Winnipeg (Ans.) 4977 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 St. Damien Station, Change of Plans
(Ans.) 3533 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Station at Quebec, Contract re Building, on M. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) for Cor., &c., 759 (i).
N. T. Ry. (Montreal Branch), Subsidy, in Com. 5896, 6215 (iv).
xxi
COCHRANE, Hon. F.-Con.
New	Glasgow	to	Thorburn	Ry.	Co.'s
Lease <Sc., Legislation re (Ans.) 933 (i).
Newmarket Canal, Meeting re (remarks) 3058 (ii).
New	Glasgow	to	Thorburn	Ry.	Co.'e
Subsidy, in Com., 6230 (iv).
North Shore Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com.,. 6235 (iv).
Ottawa, Brockville and St. Lawrence Ry. Co.'s B. 161 (Mr. Fripp) in Com., 6127 (iv).
Parent, Hon. S. N., Resignation of (Ans.) 578 (i).
Pariseau, Mr. S. B., Employee of Ry, Dept, and Cedar Rapids Co., (Ans.) 973'
(i).
P. E. I. Car Ferry, Construction, &c. (Ans.)1 1206 (i).
P. E. I., O'Leary to West Point Ry. Branch Line, Construction re (Ans.) 721 (i).
P. E. I., Winter Communication with Mainland, Ry. Service (remarks) 3832 (ii).
Public Works on Rys., Suspension re, Names-and Locations (Ans.) 531 (i).
Quebec Bridge, Erection of Shops (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5810 (iv).
Quebec Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6305 (iv).
Quebec and Saguenay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6214 (iv).
Ry. Bridges in N.B. Subsidy (B. 188) 1°*, 6083; in Com., 6374; 3° m., 6394 (iv).
Ry. Construction in the West, Shortage of Steel Rails (remarks) 6543 (iv).
Railway Question:	See ' Freight Rates,'
' Grain Congestion.'
Railway Subsidies (B. 183) in Com. on Res., 5894, 6080; in Com., 6211, 6304; (M.) to ref. back to Com., 6395; 3°im., 6395; on Amt. (Mr. Emmerson) to M. for 3°, 6396
(iv).
Rainy River Radial Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6312 (iv).
Roy, Wan., Complaint of Mr. Boulay re I.C.R. (Ans.) 934 (i).
Ste. Agathe des Monts Ry. Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5895, 5896 (iv).
St. Charles and Huron River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6308 (iv).
St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal Co.'s B. 161 (Mr. Fripp) in Com., 6127 (iv).
St. Jean-Iberville Bridge, Amount voted re Construction (Ans.) 571 (i).
St. John, N.B., Ry. Crossing at Haymarket Square, on M. (Mr. Pugsley) for Cor., 1406 (i).
St. John Valley Ry. and Bridges, Subsidy, in Com., 6211 (iv).
See ' Ry. Bridges B. 188.'
xxii
[Stage Direction]
COCHRANE, Hon. F-Con.
St. John Valley Ry., Agreement re Construction (remarks) 4461 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Agreement re (remarks) in Com. of
Sup., 4233 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Subsidy, Agreement re (Ans.) 3050
(ii)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Subsidy, Contract to Grand Falls
(Ans.) 4978 (iii).

 Contract re (Ans.) 577 (i).
[Stage Direction]
on Inquiry (Mr. Carvell) for papers,
3946 (ii).,
Sauve, L. A., Dismissal from Soulanges Canal (Ans.) 575 (i).
Senate Amendments to Railway Bills, on M. for Sup. (remarks) 6546 (iv).
Simcoe, Grey and Bruce Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 6912 (iv).
Soulanges Canal, Claims of Denis Martin for Damages (Ans.) 2292 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Employees, Names, &c. (Ans.) 4250
(iii)	.
Soulanges Canal Patronage, &c. (Ans.) 3537 (ii).
Souris Wharf, Repairs to (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5662 (iv).
Southampton Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. 6224 (iv).
Sunnybrae and Guysborough Branch Ry., Appropriation re (Ans.) 2290 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Tenders re (Ans.) 543 (i).
Supply-
Canals-Cornwall (lower look) 5797 (iv). Canals- Lachiue (lock improvements) 6611 (Rockfield bridge) 5790 (iv).
Canals-Galops (upper lock) 5797 (iv). Canals-Murray (high spots) 5798 (iv). Canals-Rideau (Bank St. bridge) 5791
(iv).
Canals-St. Peters (improvements) 5798
(iv).
Canals- Sault Ste Marie (locks) 5791 (iv). Canals-Soulanges (guard pier) 5798; protection works) 5791 (iv).
Canals-Trent (improvements) 5799; (Newmarket) 5792 (iv).
Canals-Welland (construction) 6607; Port Colborne elevator) 5796; (surveys) 5786 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Railways (private secretary) 5808 (iv); (salaries) 1064 (i).
Highways (subsidies) 6611 (iv).
Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 5762, 6605 (iv).
Railways-I. C.R. (air brakes) 4136; (board of management) 4136; (branch lines) 4135 (iii), 5618, 5621 (iv); (bridge strengthening) 4137 (iii); (Campbellton) 4162; (Chatham diversion) 4137; (coal contracts) 5611 (iv); (construction) 4131; (construction, working expenses) 4162 (iii); (equipment account) 5677 (iv); (extensions, &c.) 674 (it; (facilities) 5809 (iv); (gratuity to Cuthbertson children) 5678; (Halifax docks) 5596 (iv); (Hampton) 675 (i), 4225 (iii); (highway crossings) 4226 (iii); 5595 (iv); (locomotives) 5609
COCHRANE, Hon. F- Con.
Supply-Con.
(iv); (Moncton office) 5653, 6601; (heating at Moncton) 5611; (Moncton shops) 5604; (North Sydney diversion) 5610; (Riviere du Loup) 5654; (rolling stock) 5653; (Sydney diversion) 5658 (iv); (Truro) 4231
(iii)	; (Wallace Harbour spur line) 6604
(iv)	.
Railways-Miscellaneous (board of commissioners) 5800 (iv); (litigation) 5801; (remuneration to G. T. P. Director) 5801; (staff salaries) 5801 (iv).
Railways-N. T. Ry. (construction) 5765 (iv).	. .
Railways-P. E. I. (car ferry) 5663: (facilities) 5661; (Hiarmonj>Elmira branch) 5659 (iv).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario and G. T. R. Co.'s B. 145 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6769 (iv).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy (B. 186) 1°*, 6082; in Com., 6402 (iv).
T.	& N. O. Ry. Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 6080 (iv).
Thibault, Theophile, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 3339 (ii).
Tilsonburg, Lake Erie and Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6217 (iv).
Toronto, Lindsay and Pembroke Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5898, 6217 (iv). Transportation Question :	See ' Freight
Rates,' ' Grain Congestion.'
Trent Canal Water Powers, Claims of Prov.
(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5794 (iv).
Yale Railroad, Operation by I.C.R. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5615 (iv). Vancouver, Westminster and Yukon Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on lies., 5898, 6218 (iv).
Vancouver, Westminster and Yukon Ry.
Bridge Subsidy, in Com., 6325 (iv). Welland Canal Freight: See " American Freight.'
Welland Canal Water Power, Diversion, &c. (Ans.) 6748 (iv).
COCKSHUTT, Mr. W. F., Brantford.
Budget, The, 5118 (iii).
Cocksliutt Plough Co., Stmnt. of Member for Edmonton re Prices in East and West, on M. for Sup., 807 (i).
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity in Canada, on M. (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 2429 (ii).
N. T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1897 (i).
Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Hamilton Harbour B.:  Stmnt. of Min. of Int. re Settlement
(Ans.) 571.
Conciliation Board, Apptmt. of, re International Disputes (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1509 (i).


Fenian Baid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6259 (iv).
Grand Trunk By.'s B. 130 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6563 (iv).
G. T. By. Trainmen's Strike, Settlement of by late Govt., Eep. of Judge Barron, &c. (Ans.) 2581 (ii); 6563 (iv).
Guvsborougli Branch By. Appropriation, on M. for Sup., 1468 (i).
CEOTHEBS, Hon. T. W.-Con.
Hale, Thomas, Dismissal as Labour Gazette Cor., Apptmt. of Successor (Ans.) 4459
(iii).
House of Commons Waiters: See 'Waiters.' Inquiries Act Amt. B. 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1419 (i).
I.C. By. Provident Fund (remarks) 5933 (iv). Labour Conditions in B.C. (remarks) 178
(i).
Labour Gazette Correspondents, Apptmts.
in Eichelieu County (Ans.) 2292 (ii). Labour Gazette Correspondents, Names of Apptmts. (Ans.) 1865 (i).

Dismissals, &c. (Ans.) 1411 (i).

Dismissals, &c., on M. for Sup., 1442
(i).
Living, Cost of. Special Eep. (presented) 6332 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2912 (ii).
Technical Education Commission's Rep. (Ans.) 1202 (i).
United Shoe Machinery Co.'s Appeal (Ans.) 6783 (iv).

Investigation, Application to Min. of
Justice re (Ans.) 3148 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com. on Amt. (Mr. Oliver) 4684 (iii).


Fenian Eaid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6255 (iv).
Flaxseed, Stmnt. re Shipment of (Mr. Turriff) 661 (i).
Freight Rates, &c., on Public Ownership (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 664 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Live Stock Records Association B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2880, 3569 (ii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3722 (ii).
I.C.E. and G.T. Ry. Arbitration, Delays in Settlement, &c. (Ques.) 3939 (ii).
I.C. Ry. Branch Lines, Accommodation, Ac.
(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4218 (ii). Lowe, Robt. S., Emplymt. by Public Works Dept. Leave of Absence, &c. (Ques.) 3754 (ii).
Public Works, Appropriations for N.S. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2810 (ii).
Seamen, St., Annapolis Co., Post Office, Date of Opening (Ques.) 3754 (ii).


INDEX-1911-12 XXV
[Stage Direction]
DAVIDSON, Mr. A. L.-Con.
Supply-
Railways-I.C.R. (branch lines) 5615 (iv). Yarmouth Harbour Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3276 (ii).
DELISLE, Mr. M. S., Portneuf.
Laforce, Mr. J. E., Emplymt. as Immigration Agent (Ques.) 2242 (ii).
Matte, J. Arthur, Postmaster at Montau-ban, Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 5957 (iv). Neuville and C.N.Ry. Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of (Ques.) 2067 (ii). Notre Dame des Anges Postmaster, Dismissal of (Ques.) 554 (i).
Poulin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Customs, Quebec City (Ques.) 2071 (ii).
St. Vallier Wharf, Award of Contract, &c. (Ques.) 2068 (ii).
DEMERS, Mr. M. J., St. John, Iberville. American Goods shipped into Canada, Names of Firms, &c. (Ques.) 3533 (ii). Bank Act Amt. B. 169 (Mr. White) in Com. 5852 (iv).
Census Employees, Payments to (Ques.) 3335 (ii).
Dismissals on I.C.R. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5808 (iv).
Farmers' Bank, St. Jean, Indemnity to Depositors (Ques.) 551 (i).
Garceau, Resignation as Commissioner (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5816 (iv). Manitoba Boundaries Extension B. 115 (Mr. Borden) on Amt. (Mr. Beland) to M. for 3°, 4962 (iii).
Postmasters, Dismissal of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6640 (iv).
St. Jean and Iberville Bridge, Amount voted re Construction (Ques.) 551, 571 (i). Supply-
Excise (revenue officers) 5824; (tobacco stamps) 5826 (iv).
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries) 6640 (iv).
Tuberculosis in St. Jean and Iberville, Govt. Information re (Ques.) 3533 (ii).
DEVLIN, Mr. E. B., Wright.
Address, The, 348 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 169 (Mr. White) in Com., 5855 (iv).
Cockshutt Plough Co.'s Prices, &c. (remarks) 859 (i).
Combines in Trade, Restraint re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1520 (i).
Dismissals from Public Works, Par. in Newspapers (remarks) 3058 (ii).
Dismissals in Hull, Official Inquiry (remarks) 550 (i); 4140 (iii).
DEVLIN, Mr. E. B.-Con.

on M. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) for Papers, 954 (i).
Dom. Notes and Stamps Printing Contract, (remarks) 5845 (iv).
French River (remarks) re Vote, 6729 (iv). Georgian Bay Canal, Policy of Govt, (remarks) 3060 (ii).

Rep. in Ottawa Citizen re P.M.G.
Speech, 1970 (ii).
Georgian Bay Canal Route and French River (remarks) 6785 (iv).
Grand Lake and Belle River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6307 (iv).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3959 (ii).


Inquiries Act.   A@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1316 (i).
Judges Act (salaries) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6010 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Sale of (Ques.) 2859 (ii).
Peat Industry (remarks) in Com. of Sup.,. 6603 (iv).
Political Literature, Application re Free Postage (remarks) 1587 (i).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) in Com., 4766 (iii).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6307 (iv).
St. Peter of Wakefield, Postmaster, Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6286 (iv). South Renfrew Elections, Speech of Minister of Customs (remarks) 1573 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt-Finance (contingencies) 1069; Naval Dept, (salaries) 1063 (i); Post Office (H. B. Verret) 6278 (iv).
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1474 (i). Miscellaneous Printing Bureau (plant) 6613 (iv).
Post Office (mail service) 6286 (iv).
Publio Works-Bridges (Ottawa River) 6806 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Que. (Louisville) cone., 6800 (iv).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6420 (iv).
Wright County Public Works Employees, Dismissal of (Ques.) 550 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 2 (Mr. Bickerdike) in Com., 939 (i).
Letellier, Judge Blaise, Residence, &c. (Ans.) 3151 (ii).
McRae, Mr. F. D., Pets, re Clemency (Ans.) 713 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xxvii
EDWARDS, .Mr. J. W.-Con Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt. B. 179 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 6103 (iv).
Civil Service Apptmt#, between Dissolution of Parlt. and Sept. 31st (M. for stmnt.*) 562 (i).
Dairying Industry in Can., Grievances re weighing at Montreal (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5711 (iv).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1084, 1179 (i). Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B. 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6266 (iv).
Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 370G (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Fort Osborne Barracks Sale B.: 185 (Mr. Hughes) in Com. on Res., 6078 (iv).
Fredericton and Grand Lake Coal and Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6224 (iv).
Govt. Ownership: See 'Public.'
G.T.P. Ry., Esquimalt and Nanaimo Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5900 (iv).
Great Northern Mining & Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 0224 (iv).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on prop. Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2110 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1298, 1418 (i).
I.C. Ry., Board of Management, Abolition of, on M. for Sup., 5571 (iv).

Ques. 569 (i).
I.C.R. Branch Lines, Legislation re Acquisition (Ques.) 569 (i).

 Branch Lines (prop, res.) 985, 1011
(i).
I.C.Ry., Instructions re Holiday and Sunday Pay, &c. (Ques.) 1583 (i).

Moncton Office, Tenders re Heating
(Ques.) 6743 (iv).

 Provident Fund, Payments to Dismissed officials (remarks) r#i M. for Sup., 5930 (iv).

Ticket Collectors, Apptmt. of (remarks) 6787 (iv).

xxviii
EMMERSON, Hon. H. R.-Con.
I.C. Ry., Transfer of D. Murray Condon, Passenger Agent (Ques.) 3337 (ii)-
Judges Act (salaries) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6014 (iv).


Lire Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6024 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 115, in Com., 4609 (iii).


Man.   G@: 32 (Mr. Poster) in Com. on Res., 871 (i).
Moncton Heating Tenders, Inquiry for Papers, 5762 (iv).
N.T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1870, 1878 (i), 3130, 3372
(ii).
N.T. Ry. Commission, Apptmt. of Mr. R. W. Leonard (M. for cor., &c.#) 2246 (ii).

Resignation of (remarks) 1199 (i).
N.T. Ry. (Montreal Branch) Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5897 (iv).
Newmarket Canal, Meeting at Newmarket, Representations (remarks) 3057 (ii).


Northern N.B.: Explanation re (remarks) 6493 (iv).
Railway Com., G. T. Ry., Apptmt. of Subcommittee, Liberals omitted (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5616 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 
INDEX-1911-12 XXIX
[Stage Direction]
EMMERSON, Hon. H. R.-Con.
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2862, 2887 (ii).
Universal Eyesight Co/s incorp. B. 126 (Mr. McLean) in Com., 5907 (iv).


Wadge Thomas Patent Relief B.: 16 (Mr. Aikins) in Com., 2984 (ii).
Winnipeg Govt. Property Sale: See 'Fort. Osborne/
ETHIER, Mr. J. A. C., Two Mountains. Address, The, 295 (i).
Brazeau, Emiler, Postmaster at Cote Ronge, Dismissal (Ques.) 6337 (iv).
Canadian Navy, Repudiation by Nationalists &c. (Ques.) 714 (i).

Speeches re Election Campaign, &c.
(Ques.) 552 (i).
Debates, Official, Correction re Vote of member for St. James, Montreal, re Man. Bill, 4983 (iii).
Doherty, Mr., Payments to by Govt. (Ques.) 725 (i).
Hansard, French Edition, Delay re Distribution (remarks) 268 (i).
Houle, Stanislas, Emplymt. on Soulanges Canal (Ques.) 3537 (ii).
House of Commons Messengers, Dismissals, &e. (M. for stmnt.*) 562 (i).
Judges of Superior Court, Superannuation, &c. (M. for cor.*) 2459 (ii).
Lauzon, Desire, Emplymt. by Govt., References re Character, &c. (Ques.) 3538 (ii). Mail Carrier, Como to Oka, Compensation re Death (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: Payment to Agents (Ans.) 974 (i).

Dismissal of Agents, &c. (Ans.) 727
(i).	.
Appropriations omitted from Estimates, 1913 (i).

on M. (Mr. Sinclair) for Ret., 1819 (i).
Arichat and Canso SS. Subsidy (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4734 (iii).
Bras d'Or Lakes SS. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5937 (iv).
British West Indies and British Guinea, on Inquiry (Mr. Murphy) for Ret., 1S20
(D-
See 'Trade Relations/
Canada-France Steamship Service, Contract re (Ans.) 5262 (iii).
Canadian Agents, Apptmt. of, in Europe (Ans.) 5261 (iii).
Canada and G. B. Mail Service, Renewal of Contract re (Ans.) 547 (i).
See ' Supply-Mail Subsidies ' ' G. B. and Can/
Canadian Marine Insurance, Govt. Co-operation (Ans.) 1582 (i).
Car Shortage in the West, Govtl. Action re, on M. for Sup., 1716 (i).
Christmas Holidays, Adjournment re (remarks) 702 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 106 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 5267 (iii).
Commercial Agent in France, Apptmt. as Successor to Mr. A. Poindron (Ans.) 4041
(iii).
Customs Weighing of Goods, Decree of French Govt. (Ans.) 721 (i).
Dismissal of Public Officials, on M. (Mr. Maclean) for Papers, 897 (i).

 M. to take up Govt. Orders, 869 (i).

 Notice of Amendment, 3630 (ii).
See ' Man. Grain B. 96/
Grain Act, Farmers' Interests, &c. (remarks) 4744 (iii).
Grain Bill, Notice for Discussion (remarks) 1575 (i).[DOT]
Grain Carriage to Duluth, Stmnt. re Washington Despatch, 2577 (ii).
Grain Congestion in the West, on Inquiry (Mr. Oliver) 6187 (iv).

Number of Cars despatched (stmnt.)
5954 (iv).

Par. in Toronto Globe (remarks)
5929 (iv).
Grain Shipments from Canadian Ports, Quantity, &c. (Ans.) 536 (i).
Grain Shipments from Port Arthur and Fort William (Ans.) 541 (i).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulation of Freight Rates, &c. (remarks) on Prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3976, 4009 (ii).
G.B. and Canada Mail Service, Letter of Quebec Board of Trade (remarks) 1844 (i).
Harvey & Salisbury Ry., on Inquiry for Ret., 1843 (i).
Highlands Bridge Construction, Ques. of Order, 1197 (i).
Hudson Bay Ry. Contract, on M. (Mr. Neely) for O.Cs., &c. 747 (i).
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity in Canada, on M. (Mr. Macdonald) to Com. of Sup., 2426 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Inquiries Act.   A@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com. on Res., 5902 (iv).
Reciprocity', ref. to in Debate on Address, 76 (v).
Rooms alloted to Liberal Members, Complaints re (remarks) 670 (i).
Seed Grain Distribution, Res. from Wilcox Board of Trade (remarks) 2301 (ii). Stenographic Assistance for Members (remarks) 1847 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt.-Justice-Exchequer Court (salaries) 1036, 1039; Marine Dept, (salaries) 1047 (i).
Labour Dept, (combines investigation Act) 1503 (i).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Bad-deck, &c.) 4714; (Bras d'Or Lakes) 4734; (Canada and Australia) 4714; (Can. and Cuba) 4721; (Can. and G.B.) 4715 (iii); (Can. and Mexico) 5934 (iv); (Can. and Newfoundland1) 4725; (Can. and S. Africa) 4726: (Halifax, Newfoundland and England) 4727; (Halifax and W. Indies) 4740; (Magdalen Islands) 4730 4iii); (North Sydney &c.) 680 (i); (Pic-tou and Cheticamp) 4736; (Quebec and Gaspe) 4739 (iii); (St. John and Halifax) 678 (i), 4740 (iii); (St. John and W. Indies) 640 (i); (Sydney and Wycoco-magh) 4741 (iii).


INDEX-1911-12 XXXI
[Stage Direction]
FOSTER, Hon. Geo. E.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Trade and Commerce (annuities) 688; (bounties Act) 687 (i); (iron and steel bounties) 5934 (iv).
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2962 (ii); on Senate Amts., 6671, 6821 (iv).
Telegraph and Telephone Lines, Govt. Ownership (remarks) 2607 (ii).
Trade Agents: See 'Can. Agents/
Trade and Commerce Deptl. Report (presented) 971 (i); 2591, 3630 (ii); 6780 (iv). Trade Relations between W. Indies, Australia and Canada, on M. (Mr. Pugsley) to Com. of Sup., 1995 (ii).
See ' Supply-Mail Subsidies/
Universal Eyesight Co/s ineorp. B. 126 (Mr. McLean) in Com., 5908 (iv).
FOWLER, Mr. Geo. W., Kings and Albert. Albert Mines and 'Hillsborough Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6248 (iv).
Debates, Official, 1st Rep. of Com., on M.
(Mr. Lalor) to cone., 2842 (ii).
Dismissals of Public Officials, on M. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) for Papers, 961 (i).

 Irrelevancy of Debate, 952 (i).
Freight Rates, &c., Public Ownership, on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 666
(i).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulations of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 4032 (ii).
Harvey and Salisbury Ry., Contract re Rails (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4166
(iii).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com. on Res., 3864 (ii). Manitoba Boundaries, Settlement, on M.
(Mr. Macdonald) for Cor., 784 (i).
N.T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1892 (i).
North Shore Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6234 (iv).
Pink Rock Wharf, N.B. Total Cost, &c. (Ques.) 4257 (iii).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6234, 6310 (iv).
FOWLER, Mr. Geo. W.-Von.
Steele, Col., Apptmt. to Headquarters Staff (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6653 (iv). Supply-
Agriculture-Experimental Farms (branch stations) 6485 (iv).
Militia (ordnance) 6653 (iv).
Post Office-Outside Office (salaries) 6621
(iv).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers, N.
B. (St. John) 627 (i).
Railways-I.C.R. (board of management) 5676; P.E.I. (car ferry) 5665 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Edmond F.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
XXX11 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
GAUVREAU, Mr. C. A.-Con.
Morin, Mr. Theo., Reinstatement (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5654 (iv).
Naval Cadets, Emplymt. by Govt, (remarks) 6786 (iv).
Poirier, N. P., Investigation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5815 (iv).
Postmasters in Temiscouata County, Dismissal, Charges &c. (Ques.) 548 (i). Supply-
Excise (inspectors) 5815 (iv).
Railways-I.C.R. (Riviere du Loup) 5654 (iv).
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 3616 (ii).
Temiscouata Election Expenses, Delays re Payment to Dep. Ret. Officer (remarks) 1707 (i).
GERMAN, Mr. W. M., Welland.
Address, The, 346 (i).
Buck, Mr. A. E., Postmaster at Crystal Beach, Dismissal of (remarks) 3908 (ii), 5960 (iv).
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B. 187 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6355 (iv). Civil Service (commissioners) Act Amt. B.
104 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 3145 (ii). Crystal Beach Postmaster, Dismissal, &c., Remarks (Mr. German) 5960 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2183 (ii).
Grand Trunk Ry. Co.'s B. 130 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6570 (iv).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2972, 3549 (ii).
GERMAN, Mr. W. M.-Con.
Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commissioners incorp. B. 138 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 5990 (iv).
GIRARD, Mr. J., Chicoutimi and Saguenay.
Dairying Industry in Canada, Complaints re Weighing Cheese (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5731 (iv).
Ha Ha Bay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6213 (iv).


Railway Subsidies B.: 
Highways Improvements B.: 
Railway Subsidies B.: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Comu 6223 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3959 (ii).
GRAHAM, Hon. G. P., South Renfrew. Agricultural Aid B. 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5278 (iii).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xxxiii
GRAHAM, Hun. G. P.-Can.
Algoma Central and Hudson Bay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5897, 6216, 6312, 6317 (iv).
Bruce Mines and Algoma Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6314 (iv).
Burrard Inlet Tunnel and Bridge Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6319 (iv).
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6223 (iv).
Estimates, Discussion re (remarks) re adjournment, 5938 (iv).
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6307 (iv).
Canadian Northern Alberta Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B. 144 (Mr. White) in Com. on Res., 5165
(iii)	.
[Stage Direction]
 B. 189 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6372
(iv)	.
Can. Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B. 187 (Mr. Cochrane) on M. for 2°, 6331; in Com., 6343; on M. for 3°, (amt.) 6495 (iv). C.P. Ry. (Toulon) Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6217 (iv).
Caribou, Barkerville and Willow River Ry.
Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6320 (iv).
Criminal Code (race tracks) Amt. B. 165 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5886 (iv).
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6269 (iv).


Fort Osborne Barracks Sale B.: 
Highways Improvements B.: 
Northern N.B.: and Seaboard Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6230 (iv).
North Shore Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6242 (iv).


Ontario Boundaries Extension B.: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 
Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3702 (ii).
Joliette County, Returning Officer, Payments re (Ques.) 4979 (iii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1422 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
INDEX-1911-12 XXXV
[Stage Direction]
HAGGART, Hon. J., South Lanark.
Criminal Code (race tracks) Amt. B. 165 (Mr. Dolierty) in Com., 5891 (iv). Dismissal of Public Officials, on M. (Mr. Maclean) for Papers, 909 (i).
G. T. Pacific Ry. Co.'s B. 20 (Mr. Macdonald) on M. for 2°, 796 (i).
Magdalen Island Marconi News Service (remarks) 4161 (iii).
Ry. Act (tariffs) Amt. B. 6 (Mr. Turriff) on M. for 2°, 1016 (i).
HARTT, Mr. T. A., Charlotte.
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6526 (iv).
HAZEN, Hon. J. D. (Minister of Marine and Fisheries) St. John City and County.
' Aboukir ' Cruiser, Paying off of Crew (remarks) 408 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Purchase of by Govt, (stmnt.) 489 (i).
Adams, Mr., Resignation as Examiner of Master and Mates (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5227 (iii).
Address, The, on Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Lau-rier) 162 (i).
[Stage Direction]
on M. (Mr. Loggie) to adjn. debate,
487 (i).
Agricultural Aid B.: 

HAZEN, Hon. J. D.-Con.
Gaspe Tidal Wave, Govt. Aid re (Ans.) 2859
(ii)	.
Godbout, Mr. J., Emplvmt. by Govt., Dismissal, &e. (Ans.) 3752 (ii).
Goucher, Wesley, Dismissal as Lightkeeper, &c. (Ans.) 4977 (iii).
Govt. Dredges, Contract re boarding Employees (Ans.) 5953 (iv).
Govt. Dredges and Tugs, Instructions re Appointments (Ans.) 5952 (iv).
Govt. Steamers, B.C., Use for Political Purposes (Ans.) 5263 (iii).
Griever, Mr. S., Charges re Lighthouse Keeper (Ans.) 135S (i).
Harbour Commissioners Rep. (presented) 1571 (i).
Hatfield, Air., Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5252 (iii).
Herring Fishery in B.C., Close Season, &c. (Ans.) 4256 (iii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Air. Cochrane) in Com., 3713 (ii).
Hudson Bay Ry. Terminal Ports, Surveys re Navigation, &c. (Ans.) 3943 (ii).
Hurley, Air. J. M., Fishery Inspector at Belleville, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 2860 (ii).
He Rouge Lighthouse Keeper, Dismissal of (Ans.) 4260 (iii).
I.C.R. Branch Lines, on prop. Res. (Mr. Emmerson) 1004 (i).
International Fisheries Treaty, AXemoran-dum (read) in Com. of Sup., 6646 (i).
See ' Fisheries/ &c.
' Kestrel ' Cruiser, Condemnation of (Ans.) 550 (i).
Kidson's Island Lighthouse, Tenders re, &c (Ans.) 3054 (ii).
Lake Winnipegosis Fishery, Limit of Catch (Ans.) 3055 (ii).
Lightkeepers in N .S., Investigation re Charges (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5233
(iii)	.
Lightkeepers in P. E. I., Charges, Investigation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5232
(iii).
Lighthouse Keepers at Repentigny, Investigation re (Ans.) 5949 (iv).
Lobster Fishing Season in N. B., Date of Opening (Ans.) 722 (i).
Alagdalen Island Alarconi Connections (remarks) 3833 (ii).

 (stmnt.) 4041 (iii).


Alanitoba Boundaries Extension B.:  Dismissal of Air. J. A. Masse (Ans.)
3943 (ii).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners, Dismissal (remarks) 2057 (ii).

Resignation of Ms. Geoffrion and
Ballantyne (remarks) 6555 (iv).

Res. from Board of Trade re Dismissal (Ans.) 1813 (i).

Res. from Corn Exchange, Delegation,
&c., re Removal (Ans.) 2070 (ii).

Retention of (Ans.) 2062 (ii).
See ' Bourassa/ ' Harbour/
Alontreal Harbour Commission, Total Debenture Debt (Ans.) 1357 (i),
Alontreal Harbour Officials, Apptmt. and Promotions, &c. (Ans.) 3944 (ii).
Murray, Dr., Charges re Poaching in East River (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5248
(iii).
Naval Bill Repeal, &c. (Ans.) 4242 (iii).
Naval Cadets, Emplymt. by Govt, (remarks) 6786 (iv).
Naval Defence, Pacific Coast, Res. from B. C. Legislature (Ans.) 4458 (iii).
Naval Discipline Act, Application to Canada (Ans.) 1203 (i).
Naval Service, Depth Rep. (presented) 970
(i).
Naval Service, O. C. re Instructions, Circulars, &c. (Ans.) 2065 (ii).
Naval Service, Tenders re Shipbuilding, &c. (Ques.) 527, 558 (i).
Naval Ships for Canada, Ref. re Completion (Ans.) 1206 (i).
Naval Service, Visit of Alinister to England (remarks) 938 (i).
' Niobe ' and ' Rainbow/ Contracts re Provisioning (Ans.) 2859 (ii).

Sale of (Ans.) 2859 (ii).

Repairs re (Ans.) 577 (i).
North Sydney Harbour Improvements (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5225 (iii).
Oysters; See 'Fisheries Act/
Pelagic Sealing, Compensation re Treaty (Ans.) 4776 (iii).


INDEX-1911-12 XXXV11
[Stage Direction]
HAZEN, Hon. J. D.-Con.
Pictou-Georgetown Winter Service, Contract re Supplies (Ans.) 876 (i).
Pictou Winter Steamers, Amounts paid to, &c. (Ans.) 5949 (iv).
Powers, Laurence, Dismissal from Lobster Hatchery at Arichat, Charges re (Ans.) 3751 (ii).
P.B.I. Winter Service, Car Ferry, &e. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5211 (iii).
Provost, Raoul, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 2453
(ii).
Public Works Contracts given without tender (Ans.) 877 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt. (B. 31) 1° m., 869 ; 2° m., 1025 ; 3° m., 1709 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commission, Names of Members in 1896 and after (Ans.) 579 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Resignation of Members (Ans.) 579
(i).
[Stage Direction]
 Solicitor, Apptmt. of (Ans.) 1814 (i).
Railway Bridges in N.B., Subsidy B. 188 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6377; on M. for 3°, 6394 (iv).
See ' St. John Valley,' &c.
Rainy River Radial Ry. Co.'s B. 121 (Mr. Beattie) in Com., 5198 (iii).
Richards, Mr. S., Dismissal, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6652 (iv).
Rivers, Lachapelle and L. Dubois, Messrs. Charges re (Ques.) 3752 (ii).
Returns, on Inquiry for, 5259 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 on Inquiry for (Mr. Kyte) 5939 (iv).
Revillon Freres Trading Co.'s incorp. B, 114 (Mr. Baker) in Com., 5203 (iii).
St. John Harbour Dredging, Tenders re (remarks) 5694 (iv).
Customs Collector P.   J.@:  (remarks) on M. for Sup., 3239 (ii).
Canada Shipping Act (masters and mates) Amt. B. 143 (Mr. Hazen) in Com. on Res., 5161 (iii).
xxxviii


Highway Improvements B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3694 (ii).
Immigration Agents and Ontario Farm Labour (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3923 (ii).
Inspection and Sale Act (grain) Amt. B.
178 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 6198 (iv).
Parcel Post Extension, on Amt. (Mr. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2350 (ii).
Public Works, Appropriations re Estimates (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2804 (ii).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com. on Res., 5919 (iv).
Renfrew, S., Election, Issue of Writ (remarks) 2059 (ii).


Rural Mail Delivery B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5297 (iii).
HUGHES, Mr. J. J.-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3715 (ii).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on prop. Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2136 (ii)-Lightkeepers in P.E.I., Investigation re Charges (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5232 (iii).
Magdalen Islands Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3278 (ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5279 (iii).
Airships for Military Purposes, Purchase by Govt. (Ans.) 533 (i).


INDEX-1911-12 XXXIX
[Stage Direction]
HUGHES, Hon. S.-Con.
Aldershot Rifle Range, Caretaker (Ans.) 3536 (ii).
Arsenal at Qnebec, Payment to Employees (Ans.) 579 (i).
Automobiles, Purchase of:	See 'Militia
Touring Cars/ ' Supply-Militia/
Battlefields Commission (remarks) re Vote, 5300 (iii).
Bisley Buies: See ' N.R.A.'
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1190 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. of Order, 1183 (i).
Drill Halls, in the West re Donation of Lands for Sites (Ans.) 1816 (i).
See ' Moosejaw/ ' Regina/ ' Supply-Militia/
Past Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, Ques. of Order, 6522 (iv).
Penian Raid Veterans Bounty (B. 190) prop, res., 5558; 1°*. 6083; in Com., 6252, 6454 (iv).
Penian Raid Vets, Land Grants to (Ans.) 3334 (ii).
Port Osborne Barracks, Sale (B. 185) (prop, res.) 5557 (iv); in Com. on Res. 5696-7, 6064; 1°*, 6080; in Com., 6203 (iv).
Lavergne, Capt. Arm and, Apptmt. re Capt. of 61st Regiment (Ans.) 723 (i).
Lethbridge Armoury, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ans.) 729 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3707 (ii).
Steam Trawlers, Protection against (remarks) .in Com. of Sup., 5389 (iii). Supply-
Fisheries (protection service) 5389 (iii). Immigration (agencies, &c.) 3326 (ii). Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (St. John and Halifax) 4739 (iii).
KAY, Mr. Wm. F., Missisquoi.
Bedford Postmaster, Dismissal, Inquiry for Ret., 5161 (iii).



KIDD, Mr. E., Carleion, Out.
Hull City Hall Square, Improvements by Ottawa Commission (Ques.) 2293 (ii).
KNOWLES, Mr. W. E., Moosejaw. Agricultural Aid B. 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5285 (iii).
B. C. Lumber Combine, Challenge of Mr. A. E. Watts (remarks) 2297 (ii).
Cement Merger, Charges re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1518 (i).
Census Enumerators at Regina, Instructions, Complaints <tc. (M. for stmnt.) 563 (i).

 (remarks) 1440, 1574 (i).
Coal Strike in Alberta (remarks) in Coni, of Sup., 1500 (i).
Dismissals, &c., Investigation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3263 (ii).
Elevators, Ownership and Operation by Govt, (remarks) 2853 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Tel. from Sec. Grain Growers' Association (read) 4744 (iii).
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulations of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 4000 (ii).
[DOT]-[DOT]-[DOT] Car Service (remarks) 5956 (iv). Health Department, Legislation re (Ques.) 1585 (i).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5411 (iii).
Lumber Dpties, Interpretation and Enforcement (M. for papers) 582 (i).

 Violation of Customs Act, on Amt.
(Mr. Turriff) 1755 (i).
Members Travelling Allowance during Adjournments (remarks) 1848 (i).
Moosejaw Armoury, Cor. (read) 3972 (ii).

 Construction (remarks) in Com. of
Sup., 2040 (ii).

 Delegation re (remarks) in Com. of
Sup., 2439 (ii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2206 (ii).
Moosejaw District, Proposed Sites, &c. (Ques.) 3342 (ii).
Moosejaw Post Offices, Names and Locations (Ques.) 976 (i).


Moosejaw P.   O.@: Inspector, Pete, re Apptifit. (M. for cor.*) 1590 (i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. W'hite) in Com. on Res., 2158; in Com., 2372 (ii). Volunteer Bounty Act Amt. Bill (remarks) 1577 (i).
KYTE, Mr. Geo. W., Richmond, N.S. Aldershot Rifle Range, Caretaker, &e. (Ques.) 3536 (ii).
Arichat and Canso SS. Subsidy (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4733 (iii).
Bissett, Geo. E., Dismissal from Govt, (remarks) in Com. o-f Sup., 1534 (i).
Boyle, Dougald R., Fishery Overseer at Arichat, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.) 3945 (ii). Breakwaters, N.S., Inquiry for Ret., 44614
(iii)	.
Brymer, Arthur, Fishery Officer at Lower L'Ardoise, Dismissal, &e. (Ques.) 3752 (ii).
*

 (M. for papers*) 4781 (iii).
Canal Staffs, Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5802 (iv).
Chapel Cove Breakwater, Pet. re Extension (Ques.) 1585 (i).
Charles Forest's Cove Breakwater, Contract re Construction (Ques.) 1584 (i).

 (M. for cor.*) 2460 (ii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2039 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xli
KYTE, Mr. Geo. W.-Con.
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1193 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inside and Outside Service, Dismissals, &c. (M. for ret.*) 2387 (ii).
Empire Trade Commission, Apptmt. of Representative (Ques.) 5951 (iv).
Fishing Twine for Lobster Nets, Duty re, on M. for Sup., 5590 (iv).
Pish Reduction Works at Aricaht, Tel. re from Prime Minister (Ques.) 2289 (ii).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2783 (ii).
Guysborough Branch Appropriation, on M. for Sup., 1464 (i).
I.C. Ey. Branch Lines (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4223 (iii).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5411 (iii). [DOT]
Little Ause Harbour (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2043 (ii).
Londonderry Postmaster, Dismissal of (Ques.) 6337 (iv).
McLeod, Dr. J. R., Dismissal from Port Hawkesbury, Charges, &c. (M. for papers*) 3945 (ii).
N. T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1867, 1895 (i), 3130, 3364 (ii).
Payson, Mr. W. \V., Dismissal from Deep Brook Post Office (Ques.) 2243 (ii).
Pelagic Sealing, Compensation re Treaty (Ques.) 4776 (iii).
IPlbrt Richmond Breakwater, Contract re Construction (Ques.) 1585 (i).
-:

 (M. for copies*) 2460 (ii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).
Powers, Laurence G., Supt. of Lobster Hatchery at Ariehat, Dismissal, Charges re (Ques.) 3751 (ii).

 (M. for cor.*) 4781 (iii).
Public Accounts Com. (Diamond Light, &c., Co.) on M. (Mr. Middlebro) to cone, in 2nd Rep., 5834 (iv).
Public Service Commission, Apptmt. of Messrs. Jackson and Schwitzer as assistants (Ques.) 5954 (iv).
Public Work.-, in N. S., Appropriations re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2803 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Reorganization of (Ques.) 580 (i).

Resignation from Board of Members
(Ques.) 579 (i).	,
LAFORTUNE, Mr. D. A., Montcalm. Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1565 (i).


Highway Improvements B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3698 (ii).
Montcalm Postmasters, Pets, re Removal (Ques.) 575 (i).
St. Jacques Post Offiee, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ques.) 560 (i).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2442 (ii).
St. Patrick de Brandon, Population, Revenue of P.O., &c. (Ques.) 724 (i).
LALOR, Mr. F. R., Haldimand.
Budget, The (remarks) 5070 (iii).
Cable Rates, &c., on Amt. (Mr. Leinieux) to M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4104
(iii).
Dunnville Customs Revenue for 1910-11, Postal Revenue &c. (Ques;) 2066 (ii). Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B. 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6260 (iv).
Freight Rates on Rys., on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3202 (ii).
Inspection and Sale Act (grain) Amt. B.
178 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 6198 (iv).
N.T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr-Cochrane) in Com., 3141 (ii).
Parcel Post Extension, on Amt. (Mr. W.
F.	Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2353 (ii).
St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal Co.'s (B. 172) in Com., 6127 (iv).
Supply-
Agricultural Experimental Farms (bulletins) 6467 (iv).
xlii

LABOR, Mr. F. R.- Con.
Supply-Con.
Immigration (agencies, &c.) 3927 j (regulations) 3914 (ii).
Militia (armouries) 5542; (associations and bands) 5530 (iii).
LAMARCHE, Mr. P. E., Nicolet.


Manitoba Boundaries B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2978 (ii); on Senate Amts., 6674 (iv). Volunteer Bounty Act Amt. B. 137 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 6454 (iv).
LANCTOT, Mr. R., Laprairie & Napierville. Budget, The, 5147 (iii).
Census Population of Canada, and Quebec Cities, &c. (Ques.) 731 (i), 3336 (ii). Napierville Public Building. Purchase of Site (M. for cor.*) 5263 (iii).

 Instructions re (remarks) 3153 (ii).

Payment to Mr. Bourgeois (remarks)
on M. to adjn., 2373 (ii).
Supply-
Public Works-Buildings-Que.	(Napierville) 1354 (i).
LAPOINTE, Mr. E., Kamouraska.
Belanger, Amedee, Dismissal from I.C.Ry. (Ques.) 3050 (ii).
Courcy, Mr. P., Appmt. at St. Pacome de Kamouraska (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5821, (iv).

 Emplymt. in Inland Revenue (Ques.)
5952 (iv).
Deschenes, Louis, Wharfinger at River Ouelle, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 3756 (ii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6651 (iv).
(iv).
Desjardins, Baptiste, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 6784 (iv).
Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1554 (i).
Dismissals on I.C.R. (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5806 (iv).
Garceau, Mr. N., Appmt. as Inquiry Commissioner (Ques.) 2860 (ii).
Girard, Louis, Dismissal as Postmaster at Ste. Angela de Merici, (M. for pets.*) 2587 (ii).
Herbert, Auguste, Postmaster at St. Pascal, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 3756 (ii).

 Letters missing from Ret. (remarks)
in Com. of Sup., 6291 (iv).
I.C.R. Employees Retirement Fund, Refund to dismissed men (Ques.) 2450 (ii). Lavergne, Capt. Armand, Apptmt. re Capt. of 61st Regiment, Montmagny (Ques.) 723

Lebel, Mr. W., Dismissal from Customs (Ques,) 1864 (i).

 (M. for cor.*) 3756 (ii).
Lizotte, Luc, Postmaster at Pacome, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 3756 (ii).
Madore, Alphonse, Claims for Damages on I.C.R. (M. for cor.*) 3055 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 

[Stage Direction]
xliii
LAPOINTE, Mr. E.-Con.
Railway Bills, Senate Amendments (remarks) 6577 (iv).
Returns, Inquiry for, 4714 (iii).
Rosignol, Major J. E., Qualifications re Commandant of 61st Regiment (Ques.) 723 (i).
St. Anaclet Postmaster, Request re Dismissal (M. for cor.) 2588 (ii).
St. Andre Wharf, Discontinuance of Work re (Ques.) 724 (i).
Ste. Anne de la Pocatiere, Experimental Farm, Tenders re Erection of Buildings (Ques.) 577 (i).
St. Germain, Dismissal of Postmaster, (M.
for cor.) 1592 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 (Ques.) 1579 (i).
St. Pascal Mail Contract, Cancellation re (Ques.) 2294 (ii).
St. Valier Wharf, Contract of Alex.
Duchesneau (M. for cor.*) 4263 (iii). Supply.
Agriculture-Experimental Farms (branch stations) 6478 (iv).
Civil Govt.-Marine and Fisheries (salaries) 6651 (iv).
Justice, Administration of (Montreal circuit court) 6598 (iv).
Militia (annual drill) 5499 (iii).
Post Office (mail service) 6292 (iv).
Syrian Immigration, Pet. re O.C. (Ques.) 1209 (i).
Ungava Territory, Legislation re Extension (Ques.) 577 (i).
LAPOINTE, Mr. L. A., Montreal, St. James. N.T. Ry. and Montreal Branch Lines, Cor.
O.Cs., &e. (M. for copies*) 582 (i).
[Stage Direction]
(Ques.) 573 (i).
LAURIER, Rt. Hon. Sir Wilfrid, East Quebec and Soulanges.
Address, The, 33, (amt.) 49; Neg. (Y. 77; N. 121) 517 (i).
Anderson, Mr., Salary Increase (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1044 (i).
Archives B.: 66 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 1494
(i).


Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5290 (iii).
Agriculture and Colonization Com., on M. (Mr. Sexsmith) to ref. to Printing Com., 3933 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6260 (iv).
Fife, Duke of. Decease of (remarks) 2155 (ii).


Fort Osborne Barracks Sale B.: 185 (Mr. Hughes) in Com. on Res., 6064; in Com., 6203 (iv).
Fishery Regulations re Hague Tribunal (remarks) 3830 (ii).
Freight Rates on Rys., &c., on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 667 (i).
Govt. Business, Precedence on Mondays (remarks) 2377 (ii).

Precedence on Wednesdays, on M.
(Mr. Borden) 1969 (ii).
Govt. Steamers, B.C., Use for Political Purposes (Ques.) 5262 (iii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: LVUBIER, Rt. Hon. Sir WILFRID-Con.
Gutelius, Mr. F., Form of Question, on Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 3934 (i).
Hague Tribunal: See ' Fishery.'
Ha Ha Bay Ry. Co's Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5895 (iv).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 2 (Mr. Bickerdike) in Com., 943 (i).
L'Assomption Public Works (remarks) re Answer, 6782 (iv).


Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6023 (iv).
Lobster Twine, Customs Duties, on M. for Sup., 1072 (i).
Lumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act, on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) 1781 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.:  Memorial from Premier to Gov. Gen.
(remarks) 3630 (ii).

 Swamp Lands, Aoerage, Inquiry for
Stmt., 3751 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  (remarks) re Factums, 2589 (ii).
See ' G.T.P.'
N.T.Rv. Station at Quebec, Contract re Building (M. for cor. &e.) 755, 763 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com. on Res., 5895 (iv).
Reciprocity, Ref. to in debate on Address, 36 (i).
Renfrew, S. Election. Issue of Writ, on M.
(Mr. A. H. Clarke) to adjn,, 2230 (ii). 

 (remarks) 1576, 1707 (i), 1971, 2059, 2377
(ii)	.

 Speech of Min. of Customs re Georgian Bay (remarks) 1573 (i).
Ste Agathe des Monts Ry. Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5895 (iv).


INDEX-1911-12 xlv
[Stage Direction]
LAURIER, Et. Hon. Sir WILFRID-C'on. Senate Amendments to Railway Bills, (remarks) 6577 (iv.)
Senate and House of Commons Act (indemnity) B. 75 (Mr. Borden) in Com. on Res., 1498 (i).
Separate Schools: See * Man. Boundaries B. 115.'
Speaker, Election of (remarks) 5 (i). Speaker, Mr., Congratulations rt Reading Prayers in French, 1808 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt-Agriculture (salaries) 1041; Charges of Management (dom. notes) 1033, 1034; Customs-Outside Ports (salaries) 1092 (i); Inland Revenue (promotions) cone., 6771 (iv); Inland Revenue (salaries) cone., 6770 (iv); Justice-Exchequer Court (D. Clark) 1035; Militia (salaries) 1037; Naval Dept, (salaries) 1063 (i).
Mounted Police (pay of force) 5179 (iii). Naval Service (maintenance) 5310,	5358
(iii)	.
Public Works-Bridges (Ottawa River) 6806 (iv); Buildings-Ottawa (grounds) 3240 (ii); Que. (Louiseville) cone., 6799
(iv)	; Que. (Quebec P.O.) 1851 (i).
Tariff Commission B.: 
Yukon Judges Annuities B.: 123 (Mr. Doherty) in Com. on Res., 4556 (iii); in Com., 5569 (iv).
LAVALLEE, Mr. J. O., Bellecliasse.
Chicago Drainage Canal, Damage to Navigation, &c. (Ques.) 4260 (iii).
Doucet, Mr. A. E., Cor. re Ry. Station Sites (M. for copies*) 2460 (ii).

Position re N. T. Ry. (Ques.) 2245
(ii).
Keewatin Separate Schools, Pet. re (Ques.) 4241 (iii).
Lettelier, Judge Blaise, Residence re (Ques.) 3150 (ii).
N. T. Ry. St. Damien Station, Change in Plans (Ques.) 3532 (ii).
LAVALLEE, Mr. J. O.-C'on.
Sorel Wharf, Claim of Mr. Lariviere for Timber supplied (Ques.) 3535 (ii).

Contractors re (Ques.) 2859 (ii).
LAW, Mr. B. B., Yarmouth.
Fish Trap Licenses issued to Capt. J. H. Thorburn (M. for copy of pets.*) 2861 (ii).
Hatfield, A. M., Charges re (M. for copy*) 5263 (iii).

(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5253 (iii).
Inspection and Sale Act (grain) Amt. B. 78 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 6193, 6680 (iv).
Kelley's Cove Breakwater, Tenders re (Ques.) 3340 (ii).
Supply-
Fisheries (inspectors, Ac.) 5252 (iii).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (St.
John and Halifax) 67S (i).
Ocean and River Service (govt, steamers) 5187; (life saving awards) 5228; (schools of navigation) 5229 (iii).
Trade and Commerce (annuities act) 694
(i).
Webster, Dr., C. A., Port Physician at Yarmouth, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 6186 (iv).
Yarmouth Harbour Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3273 (ii).
Yarmouth Post Office Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3269 (ii).
LEMIEUX, Hon. R., Rouville.
Address, The, 241 (i).


Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5282 (iii).
Annuities Branch, Transfer to P. O. Dept., Dismissal of Agents (Ques.) 727 (i).

Extra Payment to Agents (Ques.)
973 (i).
Anse aux Canards Breakwater, Tenders re Construction (Ques.) 878 (i).
Anse a Valeau Postmistress, Charges re Madame Proulx (Ques.) 2072 (ii).
Atlantic Mail Service: See ' Mail Service.'


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 169 (Mr. White) in Com., 5S47 (iv).
Banking Act, Legislation re (remarks) 1820
(i)-
Battlefields Commission (remarks) re Vote, 5299 (iii).
Bergeron, Mr. J. G. H., Apptmt. as Commissioner of Inquiry, &c. (Ques.) 2062 (ii).
Berlin Post Office Clock (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i).
Bird Rocks Lighthouse, Drowning of Keeper (remarks) 5258 (iii).
Bourgoin, Geo., Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 5557 (iv).

Inquiry for Papers, 5259 (iii), 6188
(iv).
Bourque, Mr. Jeffrey, Claims for Damages re I.C.R. (Ques.) 2243 (ii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5610 (iv).
xlvi

LEMIEUX, Hon. B-Con.
B.C. International Boundary Line, Par. from Washington (remarks) 2751 (ii).
Cable Eates Exchange (M. for cor.*) 5557 (iv).
Cable Eates to G. B., on M. for Sup., 3237
(ii).
Cable Eates, Eeduction of Fees (remarks) 931 (i).
Cable Eates, Parcel Post, &c., on M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4088, (amt.) 4097, Neg. (T. 40, N. 70) 4120 (iii).
Campaign Literature: See ' Political Literature.'
Campeau, Michel, Dismissal of (M. for pets.*) 2460 (ii).
Canada-France Steamship Service, Contract re (Ques.) 5262 (iii).

Notice for Discussion, 4742 (iii).
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ey. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6306 (iv).
Canadian Marine Insurance, Govt. Co-operation, &c. (Ques.) 1582 (i).


Moosejaw P.   O.@: , Pet. re Change of Name (Ques.) 1204 (i).
Causapscal Post Office, Pet. re Site (Ques.) 1020 (i).
Census Enumerators, Delays in Payments (Ques.) 2244 (ii).

* Percentage retained of Salaries
(Ques.) 933 (i).

 Translation, 6613 (iv).
Deschamps, Mr. E., Apptmt. by Govt, (remarks) 6277 (iv)
Dismissals from Govt. Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1275, 1955 (i), 3252 (ii).
Dismissals by Hon. Mr. Lemieux, Par. in Le Devoir (remarks) re Question, 2453 (ii).
Dismissals from Post Offices (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2035 (ii).
See ' Inquiries Act, &c.'
Dom. Notes and Stamps Printing Contract, Complaints of British Tenderers (remarks) 1842 (i); 5843 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 180 (Mr. Monk) on prop. Ees., 5560; in Com., 6201 (iv).
Ducharme, Mr. G. N., Apptmt. of (M. for cor.*) 4980 (iii).

Attack re Apptmt. to Commission
(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2830 (ii).


Fenian Eaid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6253, 6454 (iv).
Fidelity Trust Co., Incorporation &c. (M. for papers*) 3757 (ii).
Franco-Canadian Eelations, Apptmt. of Agents (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5747 (iv). See ' Can. and France, &c.'
Franking:	See ' Political Literature.'
Gaspe Basin Marine Agency, Apptmt. of (Ques.) 878 (i).

Deptl. Inquiry, Salary &c. (Ques.)
1358 (i).
Gaspd Landing Pier, Appropriation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
Gaspe, Magdeleine and Chlorydormes Mail* Contracts, Annulment of (Ques,) 1204 (i).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
xlvii
LEMIEUX, Hon. R-Con.
Gaspe Basin to Matapedia Line of Ry., Inspection re Subsidy (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4194 (iii).
Gaspe Shore Tidal Wave, Govt. Aid, re (Ques.) 2858 (ii).
Georgian Bay Canal, Govt. Construction &c. (Ques.) 544 (i).
Godbout, Mr. ,T„ Emplymt. by Govt., Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 3752 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 (M. for cor.*) 4980 (iii).
Govt. House Property, Toronto Sale B. 182 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6181 (iv).
Govt. Ownership:	See ' Cable/ ' Parcel/
' Telegraph/ &e.
Griever, Mr. S., Lighthouse Keeper, Chargee re (Ques.) 1358 (i).
Guimond, Eugene, Dismissal, of (M. for cor.*) 2460 (ii).
Ha Ha Bay Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 5895, 6212 (iv).
Hamel, Hector, Customs Appraiser Montreal, Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 3343 (ii).
Harbour Commissioners, Dismissal, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1960 (i).
Harbour, Geo. T., Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Letter re Dismissal (read) in Com. of
Sup., 3252 (ii).
Harbours and River Works, Policy re Tenders (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).
Highways Improvement B.:  Snow Blockade, Delay of Trains (remarks) 1409 (i).

Ties contracted for at Sayabec, Name
of Contractor, &c. (Ques.) 4041 (iii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1311 (i).
James Bay Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com., 6309 (iv).
Japan, Trade Relations with, Stmnt. by Japanese Consul at Vancouver (Ques.) 559 (i).
Justice, Dep. Min., Travelling Expenses (Ques.) 3150 (ii).
LEMIEUX, Hon. R-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 2 (Mr.. Bickerdike) in Com., 940 (i).
La Banque de St. Hyacinthe, Investigation re Liquidation (Ques.) 2069 (ii).

 and La Banque St. Jean, Reimbursements &c. (Ques.) 528 (i).
Laberge, Mr., Mail Carrier, Compensation to widow (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6284 (iv).
Langevin Block, Overcrowding:	See 'Post
Office/
L'Assomption Public Works (remarks) re Answer, 6782 (iv).
Lepage, M. J., Preventive Officer, Rimouski, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 4458 (iii).
Levis Dry Dock, on Inquiry for Ret., 6492 (iv).
Longshoremen's Strike in Montreal, Settlement &c. (remarks) 269 (i).
Magdalen Islands, Dredging, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3277 (ii).
Magdalen Islands Marconi News Service, Copy, of Instructions re (M. for papers*) 4459 (iii).
*

 (remarks) 3833 (ii), 4159 (iii).

 (remarks) on stmnt. (Mr. Hazen)
4042 (iii).

Salary of Correspondent (Ques.) 4262
(iii).
Mail Bags Repairs, Names of Firms, &c. (Ques.) 4777 (iii).
Mail Clerks: See 'C.S. Bill 106/
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (M. for ret.*) 2460 (ii).

Inquiry for Ret., 5693 (iv).
Mail Service between G.B. and Canada, Letter of Board of Trade, Quebec (read) 1843 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.:  (remarks) 3907 (ii).
Montreal Customs House, Dismissals (Ques.) 4040 (iii).
xlviii

LEMIEUX, Hon. R-Con.	.
Montreal Docks Construction, &e. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6652 (iv).
Montreal Dry Dock, Contract re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3301 (ii).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners, Dismissal, &c. (remarks) 1708 (i), 2057 (ii).

Resignation of Messrs. Ballantyne and
Geoflrion (remarks) 6551 (iv).

Res. from Corn Exchange Protesting
re Removal, Delegations, Ac. (Ques.) 2069 (ii).
Montreal Longshoremen's Strike, Settle- | ment of by Govt. (Ques.) 572 (i).
Montreal Military School, Purchase of Site (Ques.) 4610 (iii).
National Ports (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2837 (ii).
N.T.Ry. (.Montreal Branch) Subsidy, in Com., 5896, 6215 (iv).
Naval Policy of Govt. ref. to iin debate on Address, 250 (i).
Naval Service Cor. between Can. and G. B. (M. for copy*) 562 (i).
Naval Ships, Construction of, Rep. of Admiral Kingsmill (M. for copy*) 2459 (ii).
Nicolet and St. Monique Mail Contract, Complaints re (Ques.) 721 (i).
Old Age Pensions, on prop. Res. (Mr. Burnham) 1381, 1832 (i).


Ontario Boundaries Extension B.: 152 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 6158 (iv).
Ottawa City Federal District, Referendum re (Ques.) 1356 (i).
Ottawa County Superior Court, Apptmt. of Additional Judge (remarks) 4121 (iii)-
Parcel Poet System, on Amt. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2337 (ii).
See ' Cable,' ' Postal Regulations,' Ac.
Parcel Post Convention between Canada and France, Signature re (Ques.) 569 (i).

 (M. for papers) 1396 (i).

 Salaries: See 'Bill 106.'

List read, 6636 (iv).
Pouliot, Louis, Dismissals, &c. (Ques.) 4459
(iii)	.
Private Secretaries: See 'Bill 60.'
Privy Council Chamber, Improvements re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).
Provident Trust Co., Incorporation, Ac. (M. for papers*) 3755 (ii).
Public Works, Dismissal of Workmen (Ques.) 2584 (ii).


Quebec Boundaries Extension B.: Subsidy, Rep. re (remarks) 6493 (iv).
Quebec Harbour Board, Removal of Members, &c. (Ques.) 560 (i).
Quebeo and Saguenay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 5896, 6214 (iv).
Queen's Hotel Co., Limited, Litigation re (M. for cor.*) 3755 (ii).


Railway Subsidies B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 137 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 6176 (iv).
Williamsville Post Office, on Ques. of Priv.
(Mr. Edwards') 6274 (iv).


Yukon Judges Annuities B.: 123 (Mr. Doherty) in Com. on Res., 4557 (iii); in Com., 5405, 5567 (iv).
Yule, Mr., Customs Officer at Aurora, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 4779 (iii).
LENNOX, Mr. H., South Simcoe.


Agricultural Aid B.: 100 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 5291 (iii).
Alberta, Peace River and Eastern Ry. Co.'s B. 129 (Mr. Chabot) in Com., 5905 (iv). Cap de la Magdeleine Ry. Co.'s B. 43 (Mr. Paquet) in Com., 2012 (ii).
Coekshutt Plough Co.'s Prices (remarks) 847 (i).
Debates, Official, 1st Rep. of Com., on M.
(Mr. Taylor) to cone., 2841 (ii).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 

[Stage Direction]
MACDONALD, Mr. E. M.-Con.
Cable Rates, &c. on Amt. (Mr. Lemieux) to Com. of Sup., 4102 (iii).
Canada and G.B. Mail Service, Renewal of Contract re (Ques.) 547 (i).
See ' G. B. and Canada.'
Can. Pacific Ry. Co.'s B. 98 (Mr. McCrauey) in Com., 5199 (iii).
Canada Shipping Act (masters and mates) Amt. B. 143 (Mr. Hazen) in Com. on Res., 5161 (iii).
Cavanagh, Geo., Dismissal from Customs Service (M. for cor.*) 3342 (ii).
Census Returns, Number of Males, Females, &e. (M. for ret.*) 561 (i).
Christmas Adjournment, 927 (i).
Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt. B. 179 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 6085 (iv).
Coal used in Govt. Buildings, Canadian (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3286 (ii). Connolly, John, Coal Inspector, Complaints re (M. for cor.*) 2588 (ii).
Continental Can. Co.'s B. 119 (Mr. Fripp) on M. for 2°, 4396; in Com., 5204 (iii). Criminal Code (race tracks) Amt. B. 165 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5866 (iv). Dartmouth and Denis Branch Line, I.C.R., Tenders re (Ques.) 543 (i).
Deschamps, Raoul, Apptmt. by Govt. (Ques.) 2667 (ii).
Dismissals, Apptmt. of Commissioners in N.S. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3247 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Objections to Ruling of Dep. Speaker
in Com. of Sup., 3254 (ii).
Dismissal of Public Officials, on M. (Mr. Maclean) for Papers, 921 (i).
' Earl Grey ' and ' Minto,' Govt. Steamers, Names of Employees (M. for ret.*) 1816
(i).
East River, Pictou County, Deepening, &c.
(remarksi) in Com. of Sup., 2020 (ii). Elevator Men in Govt. Employ (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3245 (ii).
Estimates, Discussion re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2439 (ii).
Excavators purchased from Mr. Harris &c. (Ques.) 559 (i).
Falconer, R. S., Dismissal as Inspector on I.C.R., Apptmt. of Successor (Ques.) 543
(i).
False Creek Flats, Date of Application for Lease from Messrs Marpole and Macdonald, (Ques.) 5953 (iv).
*

 (M. for papers*) 6186 (iv).
Farmers Bank Investigation, Apptmt. of Sir William Meredith (remarks) 3332 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 O. C. re Apptmt. of Sir William Meredith (M. for copy*) 3756 (ii).
Ei
li:
MACDONALD, Mr. E. M.-Con.
Fenian Raid, Veterans Bounty B. 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6257 (iv).
See ' Veterans.'
Fishery Act Prosecutions in Pictou County^ (M. for papers*) 1589 (i).
Fraser, John, Emplymt. by Govt, (remarks\ in Com. of Sup., 4188 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Dismissal of (Ques.) 3935 (ii).
Fraser, Mr. John, Postmaster at Stellarton, Dismissal of (Ques.) 546 (i).
See ' Stellarton.'
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5626 (iv).
Hale, Thomas, Dismissal as Correspondent Labour Gazette, Apptmt. of Successor (Ques.) 4459 (iii).

 (M. for cor.*) 4263 (iii).
Hawkes, Mr.; See 'British News.'


Highway Improvement B.: Dismissal of Mr. J. A. Masse &c.
(Ques.) 3943 (ii).
Murray, Dr., Poaching on East Eiver for Salmon (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5242
(iii).
N. T. Ey. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1880 (i); 3378 (ii). N. T. Ey. Commission, Investigation re Construction (remarks) 2060 (ii).

Eep. re (remarks) 2157 (ii).
National Bifle Association, Eules re Competition at Bisley (remarks) 3730 (ii). Naturalization Legislation, 'Uniformity in (M. for cor. &c.) 765 (i).
Naturalization: See 'Imperial.'
Naval Defence of the Pacific Coast, Ees., from B. B. Legislature &c. (Ques.) 4458 (iii).
Naval Discipline Act. Application to Canada (Ques.) 1203 (i).
Ne Temere Decree: See 'Marriage.'
MACDONALD, Mr. E. M-Con.
Old Age Pensions, on prop. Ees. (Mr. Burnham) 1822 (i).
Pariseau, Mr. S. B., Employee of Ey. Dept.
and Cedar Eapids Co. (Ques.) 973 (i). PiotouAGcor goto win Winter Mail Service, Contract Supplies to Crews, &c. (Ques.) 876 (i).
Pictou Mail Service, Tenders, &c. (Ques.) 2580 (ii).
Pictou Winter Steamers, Amounts paid to, &o. (Ques.) 5949 (iv).
Poaching for (Salmon on East Eiver (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5242 (iii). Postmasters, Dismissal of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6625 (iv).
Postmasters and Town Councillors, Eegu-lations re Acceptance (Ques.) 2587 (ii). Post Office Act (ry. mail clerks) Amt. B.
105 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 3355 (ii).
P. E. I. Car Ferry (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5189, 5210 (iii).
P. E. I. Ferry Papers, Inquiry for 4232 (iii). P. E. I. Subsidy B. 178 (Mr. White) in Com., 6118, 6130 (iv).
Public Works, Contracts re (Ques.) 559 (i)-Public Works Contracts, Amounts given without Tender (Ques.) 877, 1578 (i).

Contracts in Montreal and Quebec,
given without tender (Ques.) 877 (i). Public Works, Deptl. Supplies, Orders without Tenders, &c. (M. for ret.*) 2459 (ii). 

 (Ques.) 1204 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioner's Solicitor, Apptmt. of (Ques.) 1814 (i).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) in Com., 3884 (ii).
Eailway Estimates, Annual Stmmt. (remarks) 4121 (iii).
Bailway Facilities in N. S. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4213 (iii).
Eayne, E. W., Caretaker, Truro Armoury, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 6184 (iv).
Eitchie, Hon. Mr. Justice, Apptmt. (remarks) 3331 (ii).

 (personal explanation) 3449 (ii).
Eiver John, Mail Carrier, Name, Amount paid, &c. (Ques.) 1579 (i).

 (M. for cor.*) 2247 (ii).
Eural Mail: See ' C. S. Bill 179.'
Salmon Fisheries, B. C., Negotiations re Exportations, &c. (M. for papers*) 3756 (ii).
Scotch Village Postmaster, Apptmt. in 1903, Charges re (Ques.) 2666 (ii).
Senate Vacancies (remarks) 5161 (iii). Smith, Angus, Pilot of D. G. S. ' Earl Grey Suspension of (M. for papers*) 1590 (i). Solicitor General, Apptmt. of (Ques.) 546 (i).



[Stage Direction]
liii
MACDONALD, Mr. E. M.-Con.
Solicitor General, Vacancy (remarks) 5162
(iii).
Stellaiton Postmaster Mr. John Eraser, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 1589 (i).
See ' Fraser.'
Stellarton Station Mail Service, Cancellation of (M. for cor.*) 2247 (ii).
Sunny Brae to Guysborough Branch Line, I.C.R., Tenders re (Ques.) 542 (i). Sunnybrae Branch Ry. (remarks) in Com. of of Sup., 4216 (iii).
See ' Guysboro.'
Supply-
Fisheries (oyster culture) 5255 (iii). Immigration (agencies) 3307 (ii).
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1468; (combines investigation act) 1501; (conciliation board) 1509; (industrial disputes act) 1500 (i).
Lighthouse and Coast Service (International Congress) 5237; (pensions) 5236
(iii)	.
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Can. and G. B.) 4718; (Can. and Newfoundland) 4725; (Can. and S. Africa) 4726; (Halifax, Nfld. and England) 4728; (Magdalen Islands) 4732; (North Sydney) 678 (i).
Militia (annual drill) 5453; (allowance) 5449; (associations and bands) 5528; (automobiles) 5492,	5513; (camps) 5521;
(customs dues) 5522 (iii).
Ocean and River Service (govt, steamers) 5189, 5210; (patrol vessels) 5231; (St. Lawrence channel) 5231; (wrecks) 5229; (wreck subsidies) 5231 (iii).
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries, &c.) 6625 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Ont. (Port Arthur) 1951 (i).
Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (electric power) 3286; (lighting) 3291 (ii).
Public Works-Telegraphs (P.E.I. system) 3303 (ii).
Railways-I.C.R. (air brakes) 4136; (branch lines) 4135 (iii), 5620 (iv); (bridge strengthening) 4137 (iii); (coal contracts) 5611
(iv)	; (construction) 4130 (iii); (Guysborough branch) 676 (i): (SS. subsidies improvements) 5597 (iv); (working expenses) 4163 (iii).
Trade and Commerce (bounties act) 687 (i). Supreme Court of Canada, Division re (Ques.) 547 (i).
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com. on Res., 2159; in Com., 3551 (ii). Technical Education Commission, Report re (Ques.) 1202 (i).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy, B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6406, 6439 (iv).
Vale Ry. Lease Bill, and Acadia Coal Co., Legislation re (Ques.) 933 (i).

Operation by I.C.R. (remarks) in
Com. of Sup., 5612 (iv).
Venoit, Mr. Joseph, Complaints re Suspension, &c. (M. for cor.*) 1817 (i).
MACDONALD, Mr. E. M.-Con.
Veterans of 1866-7, Bounties to (Ques.) 1202
(i).
See ' Fenian.'


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Archives B.: 66 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 1440 (i)-
Baldwin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Customs at Coaticooke (M. for cor.) 1361 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 169 (Mr. White) in Com., 5846 (iv).
Barcelona Tramway Light and Power Co.'s
B.	36 (Mr. Macdonell) in Com., 2410 (ii). Beaver Bank Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6286
(iv).
Bedford Mail Contract, Cancellation (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv). Biological Board of Canada B. 118 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 4551 (iii).
Braine, Dr. Lawrence, Indian Medical Attendant at Chester, N.S., Dismissal &c. (Ques.) 4976 (iii).
B. C. Railway Belt, Unalienated Lands, O.
C.	re (remarks) 1200 (i).
Budget, The, 5011 (iii).
Can. Northern Ont. Ry. Subsidies, Guarantee, &c. (M. for papers*) 4781 (iii).
liv

-MACLEAN, Mr. A. K.-Con.
-Canada Shipping Act (masters and mates) Amt. B. 143 (Mr. Hazen) in Com. o-n Res., 5160 (iii).
Civil Service Act (private secretaries) Amt. B. 60 (Mr. Boi'den) in Com., 3344 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 106 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 5264 (iii).
Census Enumerators, Delay re Compensation (remarks) 1199 (i).
Chester Canal, N.S., Discontinuance of Work (Ques.) 716 (i).

 (remarks) 806 (i).

 (.remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2049 (ii).
Criminal Code (lumber) Amt. B. 9 (Mr. Stevens) in Com., 2532 (ii).
Digby Clock Keeper, (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3272 (ii).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1076 (i).

 Ques. of Order, 1183 (i).
Dismissal of Public Officials (M. for papers, &c.) 878 (i).
See ' Inquiries B. 19/
Elevator Men in Govt. Employ (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3244 (ii).
Estimates, Discussion of Irrelevant Subjects (remarks) on Ruling (Mr. Dep. Speaker), 2444 (ii).
Estimates, Suppl., Inquiry for, 1575 (i).
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 4196, 4719 (iii), 6496
(iv).
Fishery Treaty with U. S., Withdrawal re (remarks) 408 (i).
Financial Review, 6707 (iv).
Fritz, Henry, Dismissal as Fishery Overseer (Ques.) 4977 (iii).
Goucher, Wesley, Lightkeeper at Margarets-ville, N.S. Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 4977 (iii).
Govt. House Property, Toronto Sale B. 182 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6181 (iv).
Govt. Loans, Amount, Rate of Interest, &c. (Ques.) 4777 (iii).
Guysborough Branch Ry. Co/s Appropriation, on M. for Sup., 1460 (i).
Halifax Terminal Facilities (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4196 (iii), 6496 (iv).
Ham, Robt., Dismissal from Trachoma Hospital, Halifax (Ques.) 875 (i).
Hawke, Mr. A., Apptmt. in Immigration Dept, on M. (Mr. Oliver) for O. C., 617 (i).	.
Hayden, W. W., Wharfinger iat Digby,. Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 5957 (iv).
Hefferman, Mr. F. S., Dismissal from Customs, (Ques.) 4039 (iii).
MACLEAN, Mr. A. K.-Con.


Highways Improvement B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1300, 1420 (i).
I. C. R. Brotherhood Unions, Agreements, &c. (M. for papers) 793 (i).

Pullman Conductors, Promotions &c.
(Ques.) 1413 (d).

* Truro Station, Tenders re Construction (Ques.) 1412 (i).
Labour Gazette Correspondents, Dismissals, &c., on M. for Sup., 1443 (i).
Lawlor's Island Quarantine Station, Memorials, &c. (M. for copies*) 2460 (ii).

[DOT] (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1531 (i).
Lobster Fishing Season in St. John, Date of Opening (Ques.) 722 (i).
Lobster Traps, Customs Change in Tariff on Twines (M. for papers) 1362 (i).
Lobster Twine Customs Duties, on M. for Sup. (remarks) 1070 (i).
Me Each ran, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Tatamagouche Post Office tlj-ies.) 2243 (ii).
Mader, D., Dismissal from Mahone Post Office (Ques.) 722 (i).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (ren i rks) in Com. of Sup., 6621 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Boundaries Extension B.: 
INDEX-1911-12 lv
[Stage Direction]
MACLEAN, Mr. A. K.-Con.
Royal N.  W. M. P.@: , Annuties to families of Inspector Fitzgerald and others (remarks) in Cam. of Sup., 5176 (iii).
Spry Bay Post Office, Removal re (M. for cor*.) 582 (i).

 (Ques.) 577 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt.-Customs-Outside Ports (sal. aries) 1076; Marine Dept-(salaries) 1053
(i); Post Office (promotions) 6279 (iv). Fisheries (lobster hatchery) 5256 (iii);
(medical attendance, free) 680 (i). Highways (subsidies) 6611 (iv). Immigration (agencies, salaries. Sue.) 3305; (agents) 3918 (ii).
Labour Dept, (combines investigation act) 1501; (Gazette) 1476; (industrial training commission) 1527; (inspection dangerous machinery) 1527 (i).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Canada and Australia) 4714; (Can. and Cuba) 4721; (Can. and G. B.) 4719 (iii); (Canada and Mexico) 5935 (iv); (Halifax and W. Indies) 4748; (Magdalen Islands) 4730; (St. John and Halifax) 4739 (iii); (St. John and W. Indies) 641 (i).
Militia (associations and bands) 5530 (iii). Ocean and River Service (govt, steamers) 5186, 5216 (iii).
Post Office (mail service) 6286; Outside Service (salaries) 6616, 6621 (iv).
Public Works-B. C. (generally) 2215 (ii). Public Works-Buildings-Dom. (caretakers) 3293 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings, N.S. (Lawlor's Island) 1341; (Lunenburg) 1313; (Traca-die Lazeretto) 1531 (i).
Public Works-Ottawa-(H. of C. telephones) 3243 (ii); (observatory) 1322; (Sussex St.) 1322 (i).
Public Works-Buildings-Que. (Montreal P. O.) 1353 (i).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N.S. (Devil's Island) 2055 (ii); (dredging) 639 (i); (Yarmouth) 2056 (ii).
Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 677
Railways-I.C.R. (branch lines) 622; (Dartmouth branch) 670 (i); (Halifax docks) 5596, 5601 (iv).
R.N.W.M.P. (pay of force, &c.) 5176 (iii). Trade and Commerce (bounties on steel and iron) 5934 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: Notice of Discussion, 1494 (i).
Reciprocity in Trade (remarks) on M. for Sup., 645 (i).
Supply-
Labour Dept, (combines act) 1516 (i). Trade and Commerce (annuities act) 68S; (bounties act) 687 (i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com. on Res., 2158; in Com., 2959 (ii). United Shoe Co.'s Machinery, Investigation, Application to Min. of Justice re (Ques.) 3148 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: MaoNTJTT, Mr. T.-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
Inquiries Act.   A@: 169 (Mr. White) in Com., 5855 (iv).
Broderick Post Office, Change of Name (M. for cor.*) 5263 (iii).
Canadian Pacific Ry. Co.'s (B. 98) 10#, 2664 (ii); in Com., 5198 (iii).
Coal in the West, Remission of duties (remarks) 178, 230 (i).
Drill Halls, in the West, Donation of Lands re Sites (Ques.) 1815 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
lvii
McKENZIE, Mr. D. D.-Con.
Canada Shipping Act (masters and mates) Amt. B. 143 (Mr. Hazenj in Com., 5103
(iii).
Christmas Adjournment (remarks) 703 (i). Civil Service Act (customs) Amt. B. 116 (Mr. Reid) in Com., 4582 (iii).
Civil Service Commission, Attack re Ap-ptmts. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2831
(ii).
Clock Towers in Public Buildings, N.S., Votes re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1344
(i)	.
Continental Can Co.'s Patent Belief B. 119 (Mr. Pripp) in Com., 5205 (iii).
Day, Luke, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 2861 (ii).
Dismissals, Generally (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5803 (iv).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1158 (i).
See ' Inquiries B. 19/
Dismissals from Public VVorks, Investigation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3251
(ii)	.
Estmere to Baddeck Branch Ry., Tenders re (M. for cor.*) 1589 (i).
Exchequer Court Act (judges) Amt. B. 168 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5893 (iv).
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6521 (iv).
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6457 (iv).
Gillies, Cap., Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3261 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2563, 3507, 3767 (ii).
Grand Narrows Canal, Obstruction (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5678 (iv). Guysborough Branch Ry. Appropriation, on M. for Sup., 1456 (i).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3710 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1301, 1416 (i).
I. C. R., Estetide to Baddeck Branch Line Tenders re (Ques.) 576 (i).

Estmere to Baddeck Branch Line,
Surveys, Tenders, &c. (M. for papers) 2494 (ii).

' Market Tickets' to Employees (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5809 (iv).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5409 (iii).
Kidson's Island Lighthouse, Tenders re &c. (Ques.) 3054 (ii).
Lighthousekeepers, Investigation re Charges (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5234 (iii).
McKENZIE, Mr. D. D.-Con.


Live Stock Records Association B.: 

Agriculture-Experimental Farms (branch stations) 6477; Miscellaneous (Toronto exhibition) 6481 (iv).
Excise (inspectors) 5825 (iv).
Fisheries (cold storage for bait) 6653 (iv);
(protection service) 5388 (iii). Immigration (agencies, &c.) 3309, 3916 (ii). Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1475; (industrial training commission) 1527; (inspection re dangerous machinery) 1526 (i). Lighthouse and Coast Service (aid to navigation) 5238; (salaries) 5232 (iii).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Baddeck, &e.) 4714; (Bras d'Or Lakes) 4734; (Can. and Newfoundland) 4725; (Halifax and Nfld.) 4727 (iii); (North Sydney) 679
(i); (Sydney and Wycocomagh) 4740 (iii). Marine (steamboat inspection) 5238 (iii). Militia (armouries) 5544; (associations and bands) 5535; (customs dues) 5523 (iii). Miscellaneous (honoraria re pelagic sealing) 5811 (iv).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5372 (iii). Ocean and River Service (govt, steamers) 5186; (life saving awards) 5228; (live stock inspection) 5229; (registration! 5229 (iii).
lviii

McKENZIE, Mr. D. D.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Public Works-Buildings-Dom.	(caretakers) 3293 (ii); (generally) 1340 (i); (rents, &c.) 3290 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings-N.B. (Baddeck) 6658 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (leases) 1324 (i); (water supply) 3294 (ii).
Public Works-Telegraphs (Cape Breton) 2817; (Wood Mountain) 2821; (working expenses) 3302 (ii).
Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 5765, 6607 (iv).
Railways-I.C.R. (bridge strengthening) 4137; (Chatham diversion) 4139 (iii); (extensions) 673 (i), 5641; (Moncton shops) 5607; (refrigator cars) 5603; (Sydney diversion) 5658 (iv).
Trade and Commerce (annuities act) 691 (i).
Weights and Measures (inspectors) 5829
(iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2873, 3551 (ii), 4080 (iii). Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6423 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Tariff Commission B.: Inquiry for, 4983 (iii).
Civil Service Act (customs) Amt. B. 116 (Mr. Reid) in Com., 4579 (iii).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6456 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com. on Amt. (Mr. Oliver) 4687, 4701 (iii).
Morine, A. B., Charges re Candidate in last Election (Ques.) 6185, 6335 (iv).
Mounted Police, Increase re Pay (remarks) 4743 (iii).
Natural Resources, Provincial Control of in the West, Promise re (Ques.) 553 (i). Pacific Trans-Canada and Hudson Bay Ry.
Co.'s incorp. (B. 52) 10#, 970 (i). Provincial Boundaries, Res. from Leg. of Saskatchewan, re Negotiations for transfer of Resources (Ques.) 2577 (ii). Reciprocity Treaty, ref. to in debate on Address, 466 (i).



[Stage Direction]
lix
MARTIN, Mr. W. M.-Con.
Saskatchewan Central Ry. Co.'s (B. 146) 10#, 5257 (iii).
Seed Grain Distribution, Res. from Board of Trade of Wilcox (remarks) 2299 (ii).
Supply.
Public Works-Buildings-Sask. (Regina) 2212 (ii).
Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: Reps., &e. (M. for copies*) 2460 (ii).
St. John Valley Ry. Subsidy, Contract to Grand Falls (Ques.) 4977 (iii).
Supply.
Immigration (agencies) 3915 (ii).
MIDDLEBRO, Mr. W. S., North Grey. Debates, Official, 1st Rep. of Com., on M.
(Mr. Taylor) to cone., 2847 (ii). Dismissal of Public Officials, on M. (Mr. Carvell) for Papers, 956 (i).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 4th Rep. (presented) 6492 (iv).

5th Rep. (presented) 6732 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 4596 (iii).
Man. Boundaries, Conference re Separate Sohools (Ques.) 715 (i).

Eastern and Western Line, &c. (Ques.)
971 (i).
Parliament, Duration of Present Redistribution Bill, Stmnt. by Hon. Mr. Taylor (Ques.) 557, 715 (i).



MONDOU, Mr. A. A., Yamaska.
Abenakis Indian Agent. Apptmt., Salary &c. (Ques.) 1587 (i).
Address, The, 263, 270 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.:  (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2050 (ii).
Civil Service Commission, Apptmtts. re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2835 (ii).
See ' Dismissals/ ' Ducharme/ &c.
Coal, Canadian used for Govt. Buildings (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3286 (ii).
Clocks in Towers of Public Buildings, N.S. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1345 (i).


Collingwood Dry Dock Subsidy B.: defective answer (remarks) 804 (i).

on M. (Mr. Wim. Chisholm) for C'or.,
1270 (i).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3262 (ii).
Descham.ps, Raoul, Emplymt. by Govt. (Ans.) 2667 (ii).

 (remarks) 6278	(iv).
Dismissals from Govt. Offices (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1956 (i), 2018 (ii).
See ' Inquiries B. 19/ ' Ottawa/

Resignation re	(Ans.)	4979	(iii).
Dumelong, Mr. E., Dismissal from DAs-somption P. O. (Ans.) 720 (i).
Dunn, Albert, Charges re Political Partisanship (Ans.) 4039 (iii).
East River, Pictou County, Deepening, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2021 (ii).
Eganville Post Office, Purchase of Site, &c. (Ans.) 725 (i).
Elevator Men Employed by Govt, (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3244 (ii).
Estimates, Discussion of Irrelevant Subjects (remarks) re Ruling (Mr. Dep. Speaker), 2444 (ii).
Excavators purchased from Mr. Harris, &e. (Ans.) 559 (i).



[Stage Direction]
lxi
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Fraserville Wharf and. Dredging, Expenditure re (Ans.) 3150 (ii).
Gaspe Landing Pier, Appropriation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2788 (ii).
Georgian Bay Canal, Govt. Construction re (Ans.) 544 (i).
Gooseberry Cove, N.B., Improvements re (Ans.) 555 (i).	.
Govt. Works Tolls Act Amt. (B. 103) in Com., 3450 (ii).
See ' Timber.'
Guillemette, Mr. N., Dismissal &c. (Ans.) 1210 (i).
Harbours and Rivers Works, Policy re Tendering (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2044
(ii).
House of Commons, Desks, Change of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 623 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Improvements in Acoustics (remarks)
in Com. of Sup., 1336 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Parliamentary Restaurant, Payment
to Waiters (Ans.) 2861 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Telephones in H. of C. (remarks) in
Com. of Sup., 3243, 3539 (ii).
Ice-Breaker at St. Gerard, Tenders re Construction (Ans.) 2452 (ii).
lie Bezard and Ste. Genevieve Wharfs, Completion of Repairs, &c. (Ans.) 557 (i).
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity in Can., on M. (Mr. Macdonald) to Com. of Sup., 2427 (ii).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1299 (i).
I. C. Ry., Passes to Employeee, Instructions
re Newspaper Reporters, &c. (remarks) 2329 (ii).

 Ocean Limited Express, Hauling Private Cars (remarks) on cone., 6776 (iv).
Inverness Public Building, Dismissal of Caretaker (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1535
(i).
Kelley's Cove Breakwater, Tenders re (Ques.) 3340 (ii).
Kennedy, Mr., Charges re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2020 (ii).
Kennie, Capt. Edmund, Dismissal (Ans.) 6782 (iv).
L'Achigan Ice Breaker, Tenders re Construction (Ans.) 2295 (ii).
Lalonde, Mr. Alfred, Complaints re (Ans.) 4779 (iii).
Lapointe, Mr. Joseph, Apptmt. as Overseer at Lake Aylmer (Ans.) 4550 (iii).
Larry's River Dredging, Apptmt. of Inspector (Ans.) 5055 (iii).
L'Assomption Public Works, Votes in Estimates (Ans.) 5951, 6781 (iv).
L'Assomption Wharf, Appropriation for (Ans.) 2451, 2579 (ii).
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Laurentides Public Building, Acquisition of Property (Ans.) 2451 (ii).
Lemieux, Hon. R., late P.M.G., Par. in ' Le Devoir' re Dismissals (Ans.) 2665 (ii).
Lethbridge Armoury, Site re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2210 (ii).
Lethbridge Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ans.) 728 (i).
Little Anse Harbour (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2043 (ii).


Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6025 (iv).
Lorneville Cove, Tests re Foundations (Ans.) 555 (i).
Lowe, Mr. R., Emplymt. by Govt., Leave of Absence, &c. (Ans.) 3754 (ii).
McLennan, Mr., Dismissal from Inverness Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2017 (ii).
Magdalen Islands Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3277 (ii).
Maisonneuve Postal Station, Erection of (Ans.) 550 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: Presentation of Oil Painting by H.R.
H.	Princes^ Louise (announcement) 5056
(iii).
National Ports (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2837 (ii).
Naval Policy (remarks) in debate on Address, 234 (i).
Naval Question, Speech of Hon. Mr. Monk at Hull (Ans.) 551 (i).
New Harbour Breakwater (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2045 (ii).
lxii

MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Ontario and Minnesota Pulp and Paper Co., Prohibition re Grinding Machines (remarks) 2060 (ii).
Ottawa Dismissals, Investigation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3262 (ii).
See ' Dismissals/ &c.
Ottawa Plaza, Fences and Posters, Responsibility re (Ans.) 876 (i).
See ' Sussex St./ ' Supply-Buildings- Ottawa/
Petawawa Public Wharf, Tenders re, Contract awarded (Ans.) 532 (i).
Petite Lameque Wharf, Construction re (Ans.) 1358 (i).
Pink Rock Wharf, Total Cost, &c. (Ans.) 4257 (iii).
Point Aux Anglais Drainage Works (Ans.) 4778 (iii).
Port Hawkesbury Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1345 (i), 2016 (ii).
Port Richmond Breakwater, Contract re Construction (Ans.) 1585 (i).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).
Prince Rupert Dry Dock, Subsidy, Completion, &c. (Ans.) 1811 (i).
Printing Bureau, Policy of Govt, re Erection (Ans.) 546 (i).
Privy Council Chamber, Improvements re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).
Public Buildings in Alberta and Sask., Purchase of Sites, Govt. Policy re (Ans.) 2069 (ii).
Public Expenditures, Scandals, &c., by late Govt, (remarks) in debate on Address, 231
(i).
Public Works in Cape Breton, Tenders re (remarks) 805 (i).
Public Works in N.B., Appropriations re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2436 (ii).
Public Works Contracts re (Ans.) 559 (i).
Public Works Contracts given without tender (Ans.) 877 (i).
Public Works Expenditure for last ten years in Different Provs. (Ans.) 2064 (ii).
Public Works Employees, Dismissal of workmen (Ans.) 2584 (ii).
Public Works, Engineering Branch (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1058-9 (i).
Public Works now under construction, Approval of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 621
(i).
Public IVorks, Govt. Policy re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i).

 Purchases for Public Works, Tenders
re (Ans.) 1204 (i).

 (remarks) 1579 (i).
Public Works, Suspension of, Names and Locations, &c. (Ans.) 530 (i).
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Public Works, ATotes for last year, Continuation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).
Quebec Bridge, Reconstruction, Reps., Plans, Tenders, &c., on M. (Sir AA7ilfrid Laurier) for Papers, 1402 (i).
Quebec Dry Dock, Construction re (Ans.) 4260 (iii).

 (remarks) 6785 (iv).

 Rep. re Subsidy (remarks) 6493 (iv).
Quebec Harbour Board, removal of Members (Ans.) 560 (i).
Reciprocity Treaty, (remarks) in debate od Address, 231 (i).
Reid, Mr. Watson E., Dismissal, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1528 (i).
Returns, on Inquiry for, 4460 (iii), 6494 (iv).
Rideau Hall Improvements, Amount expended from 1896 to 1911 (Ans.) 876 (i).

 Amount expended re H.R.H. Occupency (Ans.) 547 (i).

 Lighting and Heating (remarks) re
Com. of Sup., 3234 (ii).

 Strnnt. re Expenditure, &c. (Ans.)
727 (i).
Riviere des Prairies, Drainage, Continuation of, &c. (Ans.) 715 (i).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 621 (i).
Roy, ffm., Charges re, Rep., &c., on M. (Mr. Boulay) for Papers, 1394 (i).
St. Andre Wharf, Discontinuance of Work re (Ans.) 724 (i).
St. Jacques de FAchigan Post Office Site (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2442 (ii).
St. Jean and Iberville Bridge, Amount voted re Construction (Ans.) 551 (i).
St. John Harbour, Tugs employed, Amount paid per day (Ans.) 548 (i).
St. John Harbour Works, Contract re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3295 (ii).
St. John and Courtenay Bay Contract, Signing, &c. (remarks) 6187 (iv).
See ' Courtenay/
St. Vallier Wharf, Award of Contract, &e. (Ans.) 2068 (ii).
Separate Schools: See 'Man. Boundaries B. 115/
Shediac Island Wharf (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2373 (ii).
Sorel Deep Water Wharfs, Contracts re (Ans.) 2859 (ii).

 Claim of Mr. Lariviere for Timber
supplied (Ans.) 3535 (ii).
Speaker, Mr.. Congratulation re Reading prayers in French, 1808 (i).
Stenographic Assistance for Members (re marks) 1848 (i).
Storey, Wm, Dismissal, Investigation, &c. (Ans.) 5055 (iii).



[Stage Direction]
lxiii
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Supply.
Civil Govt.-Conservation Commission (salaries) 1069 (i); Inland Revenue (promotions) cone., 6771 (iv); Marine Dept, (salaries) 1050 (i); Public Works (private secretary) cone., 6779 (iv); Public Works (salaries) 1064, (i).
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1469 (i).
Miscellaneous (art gallery) 2825 (ii).
Public Works-Bridges (Ottawa river) 6806 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Alberta (Calgary) 2204; (Edmonton) 2206; (Lethbridge) 2212; (Strathcona) 2213 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings-B.C. (generally) 2215 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings-Dom. (caretakers) 3293; (furniture) 3286 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings, N.B. (Hampton) 1527; (Hillsboro) 1528; (St. John quarantine) 1530 (i); (Shediac) cone., 6794 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings, N.S. (Lawlor's Island) 1341; (Lunenburg) 1343; (Tra-cadie Lazeretto) 1530; (Wolfville) 1343
(i).
Public Works-Buildings-Ont. (Ganano-que) 1855; (Kingston R.M.C.) 1855; (Midland) 1855; (Port Arthur) 1951; (Renfrew) 1953; (Seaforth) 1953; (Sudbury) 1954; (Toronto warehouse) 1964 (i).
Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (Eastern Block addition) 1339 (i); (electric power) 3286 (ii); (examining warehouse) 1949 (i); (furniture) 3279; (grounds) 3239; (heating, &e.) 3278 (ii); (leases) 1324; (library improvements) 1950 (i); (lighting) 3291 (ii); (observatory) 1321 (i); (rents, &c.) 3290; (Rideau Hall furniture) 3285; (site for new buildings) 3242; (snow cleaning) 3279 (ii); (Sussex St.) 1322 (i); (water supply) 3295 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings-Qije. (Lachine) 1346, 1953; (Levis armoury) 1346 (i); (Louiseville) cone., 6795 (iv); (Maison-neuve) 1347; (Montreal barracks) 1350; (Montreal customs) 1351; (Montreal P.
O.	enlargement) 1348; (Montreal postal station F) 1352; (Napierville) 1354; (Quebec customs house) 1849; (Quebec drill hall) 1849; (Quebec P.O.) 1851; (Rigaud) 1852; (St. Lambert) 1853 (i); (St. Laurent) 6804 (iv); (St. Therese) 1854; (Shawinigan) 1852; (Sherbrooke) 1853; (Three Rivers) 1854 (i).
Public Works-Buildings-Sask. (Battle-ford) 2204; (Humboldt) 2211; (Regina) 2212; (Weyburn) 2213 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Alta. (Athabaska river) 2815; (Edmonton) 2816 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Generally (repairs, &e.) 3235 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Man. (repairs, &c.) 2814 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Mar. Provs. (creosoted timber) 2440 (ii); (dredging) 2816 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N. B. (Bathurst) 2363 (ii); (Beaumont) 2366; (generally) 2368; (Goose Creek) 2373 (ii); (St. John) 627 (i); (St. John dry dock) 3297 (ii); (Sackville) cone., 6805 (iv).	-
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-N. S. (Arichat) 2040; (Bayfield) 2041; (Blue Rocks Island) 2041; (Burke's Head) 2045; (Cape Breton) 2053; (Cole Harbour) 2055; (Cow Bay) 2055; (Devil's Island) 2056 (ii); (dredging) 639 (i); (Gillis Point) 2056; (Inverness) 2056; (Melford) 2056; (repairs, &c.) 2051; (Yarmouth) 2056 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-Ont. (French River) cone., 6777 (iv); (Toronto harbour) 2445 (ii); (Wheatley Creek) 640 (i); (York bridge) 2817 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-Que. (Levis graving dock) 3296; (Quebec Harbour) 2836; (Rivieres des Prairies) 2441; (St. Charles River) 2837; (Three Rivers) 2441 (ii).
Public Works-Miscellaneous (monuments) 2823; (Temiskaming dam) 2827 (ii). Public Works-Telegraphs-Alta. and Saskn. (Athabasca Landing) 2819; (Fort McMurray) 2819; (Moose to Durlingford) 2820; (North Battleford) 2823; (Peace River) 2822; (Wood Mountain) 2821 (ii). Public Works-Telegraphs, Generally 3303; (repairs, &c.) 2817; (working expenses) 3303 (ii).
Public Works-Telegraphs, N.S. (Cape Breton) 2817 (ii).
Public Works-Telegraphs (P.E.I. system) 3304 (ii); cone., 6794 (iv).
Public Works-Telegraphs (Gaspfi) 3305;
(Magdalen Islands) 3302 (ii).
Public Works-Telegraphs (Yukon system) 3303 (ii).
Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 623 (i)-
Sussex St. Property, Purchase by Govt., Amount paid, &e. (Ans.) 1359 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Explanation (Mr. Pugsley) 2010 (ii).
Sutherland, Mr. Roderick, Dismissal of (remarks) 1274 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2019
(ii).
Swift Current Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3268 (ii).
Temiskaming Dam, on Inquiry for Ret., 6662 (iv).
Tolls for Timber on Govt. Works (B. 103) l°m., 3049 (ii).
See ' Govt. Tolls B. 103.'
Tower Clock, Repairs to (remarks) 1575 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 (explanation) in reference to repairs,
1708 (i).
Vegreville and Lloydminister Public Buildings (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2214 (ii).
Victoria Memorial Museum, Number of Employees, Dismissals, &c. (Ans.) 2294 (ii).
Waterways Commissioners, Dismissal and Apptmts., on M. (Mr. Pugsley) to Com. of Sup., 6705 (iv).
Weedon Public Building, Construction, &e. (Ans.) 4550 (iii).
Ixiv
[Stage Direction]
MONK, Hon. F. D.-Con.
[Stage Direction]
on Inquiry for Ret., 6492 (iv).
Westville Public Building, Dismissal of Caretaker (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1531 (i).
Wharfs, Total Expenditure for ten years (Ans.) 1812 (i).
Wright County Public Works Employees, Dismissal of (Ans.) 551 (i).
Yarmouth Harbour Dredging (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3274 (ii).
MORPHY, Mr. H. B., North Perth. Agricultural Committee, on Personal Explanation (Mr. Best) re Par. in Toronto 'Globe,' 2156 (ii).
Cattle diseased, Compensation re Damages (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6471 (iv). Criminal Code (race tracks) Amt. B. 165 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5882 (iv). Dairying Industry in Canada, Complaints re Weighing (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5740 (iv).
Farmers Bank Failure, Inquiry by Chief Justice Meredith (remarks) 6710 (iv). Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B. 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6459 (iv).
G.T.Ry. Co.'s B. 130 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6757 (iv).
Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6043 (iv).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 3011 (ii).
MURPHY, Hon. C., Russell.
Address, The, 501 (i).
Airships for Military Purposes, Purchase by Govt. (Ques.) 533 (i).


Archives B.: 66 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 1495
(i).
Bread Combines, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1521 (i).
Burrard Inlet Tunnel and Bridge Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6320 (iv).
Cabinet Ministers from Quebec, Stmnt. by Hon. Mr. Monk (Ques.) 526 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Limitations re Tenders (remarks) on
M. for Sup., 1841 (i).
Farmers' Bank Failure, Reimbursement to Depositors (Ques.) 527 (i).

Indemnifying Shareholders, Speech
Hon. Mr. Crothers re (Ques.) 3147, 3332
(ii)	.

 Promises to Reimburse by Ministers,
&o. (Ques.) 713 (i).
Grand Trunk Ry. Co.'9 B. 130 (Mr. Currie) in Com., 6569 (iv).
Gutelius, Mr. F. P., Naturalization of, &c. * (Ques.) 4242, 4978 (iii).
Hawkes, Mr. Arthur, Apptmt. re Immigration Dept. (Ques.) 527 (i).
House of Commons Sessional Employees, Number dismissed, &c. (Ques.) 568 (i), 2064 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1309, 1426 (i).
James Bay Ry. Subsidy, in Com., 6309 (iv). Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5413 (iii).
King's Printer, Apptmt. of Assistant (Ques.) 1809 (i).
Maritime Law International Conference, Invitation to Govt, re (Ques.) 2586 (ii). Military Stores Building, Contract re Racks (Ques.) 532 (i).
Militia Touring Cars, Order to Ford Motor Co. (Ques.) 4040 (iii).
N. T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1879, 1889 (i),
N. T. Ry. Commission, Duties assigned to New Chairman (Ques.) 533 (i).

 Investigation re Apptmt., Salary &c.,
of Messrs Gutelius amd Staunton (Ques.) 4242, 4978 (iii).
Naval Policy, Interview with Hon. Geo. H.
Per ley in London (remarks) 1576 (i). 

Promise re Referendum (Ques) 526
(i)-


INDEX-1911-12 Ixv
[Stage Direction]
M1JRPHY, Hon. C.-Con.
[Stage Direction]
Tenders re Construction of Ships,
Deposits, &e. (Ques.) 526 (i).
Petewawa Public Wharf, Tenders re, Contract awarded (Ques.) 532 (i).
Printing Bureau Employees, Changes re Duties (Ques.) 2243 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissals and Apptmts. (Ques.)
1809 (d).
[Stage Direction]
Salary Increases, &c. (Ques.) 2066 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Weekly Consultations (Ques.) 2243
(ii).
Printing Bureau, Policy of Govt, re Erection of (Ques.) 546 (i).
Public Works on Rys., Suspension re, Names land Locations (Ques.) 531 (i). Public Works, Suspension of, Names and Locations, &c. (Ques.) 530 (i).
Renfrew, S. Election, Issue of Writ, on M.
(Mr. A. H. Clarke) to adjn. Hise. 2238 (ii). Returns, Inquiry for, 4836 (iii), 5560 (dv). Rockliffe Rifle Range, Acquisition of Additional Land (Ques.) 533 (i).
Supply-
Agriculture, Experimental Farms (branch stations) 6484; (International Institute) 6478 (iv).
Archives (salaries) 6462 (iv).
Canals-Lachine (lock improvements) 6611;
Welland (construction) 6610 (iv). Charges of Management (coin circulation) 1034 (i).
Civil Govt-Agriculture (promotions) 6485
(iv); Customs (salaries) 1040 (i); Inland Revenue (private secretary) 6490; Inland Revenue (promotions) cone., 6771 (iv); Interior (salaries) 1039; Jus'tice- Exchequer Court (salaries) 1035	(i);
(promotions) 6585 (iv); Militia (salaries) 1037; Post Office (salaries) 1067; Public Works (salaries) 1065; Secretary of State (printing bureau) 1038; (salaries) 1038 (i).
Civil Service Commission (additional commissioner) 6615 (iv).
Conservation Commission (Chicago canal) 6582 (iv).
Inland Revenue (explosives apparatus) 6604 (iv).
Justice (pecuniary claims) 6579 (iv). Labour Dept, (combines investigation act) 1500; (Gazette) 1472; (industrial tnain-ing_ commission) 1527 (i).
Militia (Rockliffe ranges) 6654 (iv). Miscellaneous (Champlain monument) 6485; (claim of Mrs. Wiley) 6489; (counsel fees re Lanctot inquiry) 6486; (Olympic games) 6486 (iv).
Printing Bureau (plant, &c.) 6611 (dv). Public Works-Bridges (Ottawa River) 6806 (iv).
Public Korks-Buildings-Ont. (Gana.no-que) 1855 (i).
Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (Sussex St.) 1333 (i).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers-Ont (French River) 6657; cone., 6776 (iv). Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 6607 (iv).
E
MURPHY, Hon. C.-Con.
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) on Senate Amts., 6670 (iv).
Typewriters and Supplies, Names of Firms, &c. (Ques.) 1809 (i).
Vancouver, Westminster and Yukon Ry.
Bridge Subsidy, in Com., 6326 (iv). Waterways Commission, Ratification of Apptmt. by late Govt. (Ques.) 533 (i).
W. Indies Trade Arrangements, Negotiations re (M. for papers*) 977 (i).

Inquiry for, 1820 (i).
NANTEL, Hon. W. B. (Minister of Inland Revenue) Terrebonne.
Conroy, Mr. P., Apptmt. at St. Pacome de
Kamouraska (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5822 (iv).

Emplymt. in Inland Revenue (Ans.)
5952 (iv).
Courchene, Mr. P. E. C., Dismissal from Inland Rev. Dept. (Ans.) 1864 (i). Desmarais, Mr., Charges re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5817 (iv).
Dismissals from Inland Rev., Letter sent out (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5820 (iv). Dumontier, Joseph Alphonse, Apptmt. as Inland Rev. Inspector, Quebec (Ans.) 3340
(ii)	.
Flemming, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Inland Rev. Dept, at Petrolia (Ans.) 4259
(iii)	.
Forest, Mr. Medard, Excise Officer at L'Epi-phanie, Dismissal, Charges, &c. (Ans.) 726 (i).
Garceau, Mr. N., Apptmt. as Inquiry Commissioner (Ans.) 2860 (ii).
Inland Revenue Reports (presented) 565 (i) Locas, Mr. Henri, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 3338 (ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: NANTEL, Hon. W. B.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Mines (French reports) 6491; (ore deposits) 6602, 6490; (peat industry) 6491 (iv). Public Works-Roads and Bridges (Doncaster Indian reserve) 6806 (iv).	_
Weights and Measures (inspection electric lights) 5828 (iv).
Therien, J. F., Dismissal of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5824 (iv).

Investigation re Political Partisanship (Ans.) 1413 (i).
Three Rivers, Charges re Collector C. D.
Hebert (Ans.) 1209 (i).
Woodstock, N.B., Apptmt. of Excise Officer (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5812 (iv).
NEELY, Mr. D. B., Humboldt.
Bounties on Steel Rods, &c. (Ques.) 529 (i). Census Enumerators and Returning Officers, Delays re Payment (remarks) 2156 (ii). Cockshutt Plough Co., Prices re (remarks 824 (i).
Hudson Bay Ry., Contract (M.) for O. Cs.,
&e., 732 (i).


Grain Act B.: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2187, 2306, 2392 , 2545, 2770, 3160, 3762 (ii), 4155
(iii).
Lumber Duties, Interpretation and Enforcement, on M. (Mr. Knowles) for Papers, 592 (i).
Railway Question, Transportation, Ac., on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 1927 (i).
Supply-
Public 'Works-Buildings (generally) 2215;
Sask. (Humboldt) 2211 (ii).
Railways-Hudson Bay (construction) 622
(i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2904 (ii).
Tariff Commission, Apptmt. of, &c. (Ques.) 529 (i).
NESBITT, Mr. E. W., North Oxford.
Alberta, Peace River and Eastern Ry. Co.'s B. 129 (Mr. Chabot) in Com., 5907 (iv). Barcelona Tramway, Light and Power Co.'s B. 36 (Mr. Macdonell) in Com., 2411 (ii). Budget, The, 5134 (iii).
Cable Rates, &c., Rural Mails, &c., on M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4088
(iii).
Can. Pacific Ry. Co.'s B. 9S (Mr. McCraney) in Com., 5200 (iii).
Canal Staffs, Dismissals (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5802 (iv).
Civil Servants and Elections (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1538 (i).
Continental Can Co.'s Patent Relief B. 119 (Mr. Fripp) in Com., 5204 (iii), 5903 (iv). Criminal Code (race tracks) - Amt. B. 165 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5862 (iv).
NESBITT, Mr. E. W.-Con.
Dominion Trust Co.'s B. 80 (Mr. Macdonell) in Com., 4238 (iii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com.
on Res., 872 (i); in Com., 2184, 2556 (ii). Highways Improvement B. 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3682 (ii).
Lumber Combine in B.C., Ques. of Order, 2299 (ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Rural Mail Delivery B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
Ixvii
NESBITT, Mr. E. W.-Con.
Universal Eyesight Co.'s incorp. B. 126 (Mr. McLean) in Com., 5908 (iv).
West Ontario Pacific Railway Co.'s (B. 28) 1°*, 795 (i).
Yukon Judges Annuities B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Agricultural Aid B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6455 (iv).
Freight Rates on Rys. on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3216 (ii).
See ' Ry.'


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: Further Information, Inquiry for,
6186 (iv).
Grain Congestion, Transportation, &c., Remarks on M. for Sup., 6203 (iv).
Grain Shipments from the West, Freight Rates, &c. (prop, res.) 3975; Neg. (Y. 54; N. 84) 4035 (ii).
See ' Freight Rates.'
Grain Shipments to Terminal Elevators (remarks) 6792 (iv).
Grain Storage at Minneapolis. Inquiry for Papers, 6493 (iv).
Grain Transportation in the West, Par. in Toronto Globe (remarks) 5928 (iv).
G.T.P. Ry. (Brandon) Subsidy, in Com., 6325 (iv).
G.T.P. Ry., Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 5901 (iv).
lxviii

OLIVER, Hon. F.-Con.
Hawkes, Mr. A., Apptmt. in Immigration Dept. (M. for O.Cs.) 60S (i).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3721 (ii).
Horses imported from U.S., Destruction for Glanders (remarks) 5693, 5939 (iv). Horses destroyed at Weyburn, Rep. re (remarks) 6790 (iv).
House of Commons, Ventilation re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1336 (i).
Hudson Bay Railway Construction, on M. (Mr. Aikins) for Papers, 1240 (i).

 on M. (Mr. Neely) for O.Cs., &c.
746 (i).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on prop. Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2146 (ii). Immigration, Rep. of Mr. Hawkes, Inquiry for, 6551 (iv).
See 'Hawkes.'
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity in Canada, on M. (Mr. Macdonald) to Com. of Sup., 2428 (ii).
Inspection and Sale Act (grain) Amt. B. 78 (Mr. Poster) in Com., 6189, 6679 (iv). James Bay Ry. Subsidy, in Com. on Res., 6310 (iv).
Judges Act (salaries) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6015 (iv).
Kettle Valley Ry. Bridge Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6327 (iv).
Kettle Valley Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com.
on Res., 5899, 6220, 6322 (iv).
Kootenay Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com.
on Res., 5899, 6219 (iv).


Live Stock Record Association B.: 
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: Eastern Boundary Extension (Ques.)
3936 (ii).

Financial Terms, &c. (Ques.) 558 (i).

Inquiry for Papers (remarks) 3448,
3834 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 

[Stage Direction]
Ixixi
OLIVER, Hon. F.-Con.
Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Grain Act B.: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2542 (ii).
Supply-
Canals-Trent (Newmarket) 5793 (iv). PACAUD, Mr. L. T., Megantic.
Doucet, Odilon, Postmaster at Notre Dame de Lourdes, Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 1863 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 

PELLETIER, Hon. L. P. (Postmaster General), Quebec County.
Anse a Valeau, Charges against Postmistress Madame Proulx (Ans.) 2072 (ii).
Archambault, Emile, Letter Carrier, Dismissal (Ans.) 5950 (iv).
Australian Pacific Cable, Proposals re (Ans.) 576 (i).
Bedford Postmaster Dismissal, on Inquiry for Bet., 5161 (iii).
Boucher, Mr. F. 0., Pet. re Dismissals (Ans.) 976 (i).
Braaeau, Mr. Emile, Postmaster iat Cote Rouge, Dismissal (Ans.) 6337 (iv).
British Mails, Landing at North Sydney, Tests re (Ans.) 5918 (iv).
Brown, Wm., Postmaster at Point Fortune,
' Complaints re (Ans.) 1780 (iii).
Brown, William, Pet. from Dr. E. Mont: pet it re Dismissal (Ans.) 4977 (iii).
Buck, Mr. A. E., Postmaster at Crystal Beach, Dismissal of (remarks) 3910 (ii).
Cable Rates, Reduction of Pees, Tel. from Imp. P.M.G. (read) 931 (i).
See ' Australia.'
Cable Rates to G. B. (remarks) on M for Sup. 3238 (ii).
Cable Rates, &e., on Amt. (Mr. Lemieux) to M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4114 (iii).
See ' Parcel Post/ &c.
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ry. Co/s Subsidy, in Com. 6306 (iv).
Canadian Marine Insurance, Govt. Co-operation (Ans.) 1582 (i).
Canso Postmaster, Pet. re Dismissal (Ans.) 1207 (d).


Cap Chat P.O.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 180 (Mr. Monk) on prop. Res., 5560; in Com. on Res., 6051; in Com., 6201 (iv).
East Roman Valley Post Office, Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2028 (ii).
Early, Airs. Paul, Postmistress at St. Gabriel de Brandon, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 2579 (ii).
Franking Privilege: See 'Political Liter-attire/
Fraser, Air. John, Postmaster at Stellarton, Dismissal of (Ans.) 546 (i).
Gaspe, Alagdeleine and Chlorydormes Alail Contracts, Annulment of (Ans.) 1204 (i).
Georgian Bay Canal, Govt. Policy (remarks) 1971 (ii).
Glace Bay Alail Delivery, Delay, &c. (remarks) 804 (i).
Govt. Ownership; See 'Parcel Post. Postal Regulations/ ' Rural Telephones/
Henry, Norbert, Alail Contract between Scott Junction and Station (Ans A 975 (i).
I. C. R. Branch Lines, in prop. Res. (Air. Emmerson) 1010 (i).
Investigations re Political Partisanships, Cost of (Ans.) 5951 (iv).
Jacques, Leander, Postmaster, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 3339 (ii).
Kirouac, Air., Postmaster at Alanseau, Dismissal, &e. (Ans.) 2579 (ii).
Laberge, Air. H., Compensation re Death as Letter Carrier (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6284 (iv).
Lachenaie Postmaster, Charges re (Ans.) 5949 (iv).
Lacombe, J. A., Dismissal from St. Sebastien P. O., Inquiry re (Ans.) 975 (i).
Langevin Block, Condition of: See 'P. O. Deptl. Bldg/
Lavoie, Air. Calixte, Postmaster, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 3339 (ii).
Legault, Ophir, Postmaster at L'lle Perrot, Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 5950 (iv).
Leigh, Air. W. M., Dismissal from Kirkton Post Office (Ans.) 5949 (iv).
Linwood and Grosvenor's Alail Service (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).



[Stage Direction]
lxxi
PELLETIER, Hon. L. P.-Con.
Londonderry Postmaster, Dismissal (Ans.) 6337 (iv).
Lotbiniere County Postmasters, Dismissed, Number, Names, &c. (Ans.) 972 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6291 (iv),
McEackren, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Tatamagoucke Post Office (Ans.) 2243 (ii).
McPherson, John H., Dismissal of (Ans.) 4259 (iii).
Mader, Mr. D., Dismissal from Malione Bay P. 0. (Ans.) 722 (i).
Magdalen Island Marconi News Service, Salary of Correspondent (Ans.) 4262 (iii).
-	

 (remarks) 4042 (iii).
Mail Bags Repairs, Names of Pirms (Ans.) 4777 (iii).
Mail Clerks: See ' C. S. Act/ P. 0. B. 105/
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6621 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 on Inquiry for Ret., 5693 (iv).
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6214, 6305, 6321 (iv!
Ixxii

 Number of Boxes in Ont. (Ans.)
6782 (iv).

Routes, Pets, re (Ans.) 4978 (iii).

 Routes, &c. (remarks) 5561 (iv).

Tenders re Mail Boxes (Ans.) 1580 (i).
Rural Telephone System, Placing in Post Offices, on prop. Res. (Mr. Blain) 2250 (ii).
St. Adelaide de Pabos Postmaster, Charges re R. Molloy, Investigation (Ques.) 2068 (ii).
St. Agathe des Monts, Post Office, Dismissal of Mrs. Bedard (Ans.) 973 (i).

 Investigation re Charges, on M. (Mr. Lemieux) for Cor., 1592 (i).
St. Aldwyn Post Office, Change of Name from Broderick, on M. for Sup., 5926 (iv).' St. Amour Post Office, Changes since Jan. 1912 (Ans.) 2667 (ii).
St. Ancilet Postmaster, Request re Dismissal, on M. (Mr. E. Lapointe) for Cor., 2588 (ii).
St. Angele de Laval Postmaster, Charges rs (Ans.) 3755 (ii); 4039 (iii).
Ste. Anne de Bellevue and L'lle Perrot Mail Contracts, Expiry of (Ans.) 5952 (iv). Ste. Anne de Bellevue, Non-delivery of Mail (Ans.) 5260 (iii).
St. Charles and Huron River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6308 (iv).
St. Germain, Dismissal of Postmaster C. Michaud, on M. (Mr. E. Lapointe) for Cor., 1594 (i).

Changes re Apptmt. (Ans.) 1579 (i).
St. Isidore Postmastership, Pet. re (Ans.) 3055 (ii).
St. Jacques Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c. (Ans.) 561 (i).
Ste. Monique Mail Contract, Annulment of (Ans.) 1584 (i).
St. Pascal Mail Contract, Cancellation re ] (Ans.) 2294 (ii).
St. Paul L'Ermite Mail Carrier, &c. (Ans.) 2583 (ii).
PELLETIER, Hon. L. P- Con.
St. Paul L'Ermite Mail Service, Cancellation of Contracts (Ans.) 3342 (ii).
St. Peter of Wakefield Postmaster, Dismiss. al, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6288
(iv),
Ste. Therese and Laurentides Post Offices, Revenues, &c. (Ans.) 3336 (ii).
St. Tite Postmaster, Dismissal of (Ans.) 1210 (i).
Sayabec Postmistress, Apptmt. of Miss Bou-lay (Ans.) 2068 (ii).

 Dismissal of Postmistress, and Apptmt. (Ans.) 2585 (ii).
Scotch Village Postmaster in 1903, Charges re &c. (Ans.) 2666 (ii).
Sea-men -St., Annapolis County, Post Office, Date of Opening (Ans.) 3755 (ii).
Small Pox in Ottawa Post Office (explanation) 1242 (i).

 (remarks) 1280 (i).
Sorel and St. Victoria Mail Service, Date of Tenders, &c. (Ans.) 4248 (iii).
Spry Bay Post Office, Pet. re Removal (Ans.) 577 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt.-Naval Dept, (salaries) 1064 (i); Post Office (H. B. Verret) 6278 (iv); (salaries) 1066 (i); 6278 (iv).
Inland Rev. (salaries) cone., 6770 (iv). Naval Service (maintenance) 5306 (iii). Post Office (mail service) 6282; Outside Service (inspectors) 6646; (salaries) 6616
(iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Que. (Quebec drill hall) 1851; (Quebec P.O.) 1852 (i). Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Ont. (French River) 6657 (iv).
Trade and Commeroe (annuities act) 691
(i).
Sydney and Glace Bay Mail Service, Delay, &c. (stmnt.) 934 (i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2906 (ii).
Thibodeau, George, Resignation &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6618 (iv).
Val des Eboulis and Rigaud Mail Service, Contract re (Ans.) 4249 (iii).
Val des Eboulis Mail Service, Date of William Roberts' Contract (Ans.) 3537 (ii), 4778 (iii).
Vaudreuil Post Office, Dismissal of J. B. A.
Valois (Ans.) 3537 (ii).
Weedon Public Building (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6656 (iv).
Whitehead, N. iS., Dismissal of Postmaster (Ans.) 2855 (ii).
PERLET, Hon. G. H., Argenteuil.
Dry Docks Subsidy Act (prop, res.) 5559 (iv). St. John Harbour, Dredging Tenders re (remarks) 5695 (iv).



[Stage Direction]
lxxiii
PORTER, Mr. E. G., West Hastings. Marriage Act Amt. B. 3 (Mr. Lancaster) on M. for 2°, 1678 (i),
POWER, Mr. Wm., West Quebec.
Past Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6510 (iv).
Mullaly, Mr., Emplymt. in P.O. Dept., Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 1583 (i).
Supply-
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries) 6631 (iv).
PROULX, Mr. E., Prescott.
Agricultural Committee, Personal Explanation (Mr. Best) re Par. in Toronto Globe, 2156 (ii).
Car Shortage re Transportation of Hay Crop (remarks) 2753 (ii).
Daoust, Done, Postmaster at Alfred, Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 3945 (ii). Highways Improvement B. 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3955 (ii).
Judges Act (additional) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5413 (iii), 6001 (iv); on M. for 3° (amt.) 6062 (iv).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6620 (iv).
Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: Contracts awarded, &c. (Ques.) 2856
(ii).

Dismissal of Govt. Officials (Ques.)
2856 (ii).
St. Amour Postmaster, Changes since Jan., 1912 (Ques.) 2666 (ii).

 Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 2861 (ii).
St. Isidore de Prescott Postmastership, Pet.
re (Ques.) 3055 (ii).
Supply.
Legislation-Senate (salaries) 6460 (iv). Mines Branch (ore deposits) 6602 (iv). Yukon Judges Annuities B. 123 (Mr. Doherty) in Com. on Res., 4561 (iii).
PUGSLEY, Hon. Wm., St. John City. Address, The, on Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 139 (i).


Agricultural Aid B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: Negotiations re (remarks) 3833 (ii).
See ' Waterways.'
Brodie, Mr., Dismissal re St. John Drill Hall (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1529 (i).
Cable Rates, &c., on Amt. (Mr. Lemieux) to M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4099, 4111 (iii).
Cap de la Magdeleine Ry. Co.'s B. 43 (Mr. Paquet) in Com., 2012 (ii).
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B. 187 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6350 (iv).
Census Enumerators and Commissioners, Payments to (remarks) 1020 (i), 3835 (ii).
Clianee Harbour, N.B., Improvements re (Ques.) 554 (i).
Christmas Holidays, Adjournment re (remarks) 702, 927 (i).
Civil Service Act (private secretaries) Amt. B. 60 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 1435 (i).
Civil Service Act (customs) Amt. B. 116 (Mr. Reid) in Com., 4577 (iii).


Collingwood Dry Dock Subsidy B.: r Inquiry for Ret., 1843 (i).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6024 (iv).
Lorneville Breakwater, N.B., Tests re Foundation, &c. (Ques.) 555 (i).
PUGSLEY, Hon. Wm.-Con.


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: Ques. of Privilege, Signing of Resolution, 801 (i).
'Man. Grain Act Amt., on prop. Res. (Mr. Foster) 869; in Com. on Res., 871 (i). Marcil, Mr. Tancrede, Application re Govt.
Position (remarks) 2069 (ii).
National Ports (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 2839 (ii).
N. T. Ry. Act (commissioBers) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 1868 (i).
N, T. Ry. Commissioners, Notification of Dismissal (remarks) 1196 (i).
N.T. Ry., Moncton to Levi6, Portion uncompleted (Ques.) 932 (i).
Naval Ships for Canada, Ref. of Min. of Marine re Completion (Ques.) 1206 (i).
Ne Temere Decree, Powers of Parlt. (remarks) re Answer to Questions, 797 (i).

Questions asked by the late Govt.,
Concurrence by present Govt., &c. (Ques.) 719 (i).


Ontario Boundaries Extension B.: 152 (Mr. Borden) in Com., 6155 (iv).
Peace River and Ry. Belt Water Power B.
149 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 5968 (iv).
Post Office Deptl. Building, Charges re Condition (remarks) on M. for Sup., 1858 (i). Preferential Tariff with G. B., prop. Res.
(M.) to withdraw, 1390 (i).
P.E.I. Subsidy B. 178 (Mr. White) in Com., 6119, 6151 (iv).
Provincial Subsidies: See ' Highways,' ' Man. Boundaries,' &c.
Public Works Engineering Branch (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1059 (i).
Public Works, N.B., Appropriation last year (correction) 2436 (ii).
Public Works, now under construction (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 621 (i).


Quebec Boundaries Extension B.: 
INDEX-1911-12 lxxv
[Stage Direction]
PUGSLEY, Hon. Wm.-Con.
Reciprocity, ref. to in debate on Address, 142 (i).
Reid, Hr. Watson E., Dismissal as Inspector of Hillsboro Public Building (remarks) in ,Com. of Sup., 1528 (i).
Returns, Inquiry for, 2377 (ii).
Returning Officer AV. H.: Downey, Delay in Payments (remarks) 2057 (ii).
Rideau Hall, Expenditure re, Ques. of Priv., re Par. in ' Mail and Empire,' 799 (i). 

Amount expended re H.E.H. Occupancy (Qnes.) 547 (i).

Strnnt. of Hon. Mr. Kemp re Expenditure, &e. (Ques.) 726 (i).
Riviere a la Prairie Improvements re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 622 (i).
Rooms alloted to Liberal Members, Complaints re (remarks) 670 (i).
St. John Harbour Dredging, Tenders re (remarks) 5694 (iv).
r

 Improvements (remarks) in Com. of
Sup., 623, 669 (i), 2371 (ii).

 Improvements, Tel. re Terminal
Facilities (Ques.) 566 (i).


 Wharf Appropriation (remarks) in
Com. of Sui)., 2370 (ii).
St. John Harbour, Tugs employed, Amount paid per day (Ques.) 548 (i).
St. John Ry. Co.'s Crossing at Haymarket Square (M.) for Cor., Ac., 1402 (i).
St. John Aralley Ry., Agreement re Construction (remarks) 4461 (iii).


 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4232 (iii).
See ' Ry. Bridges.'
Salisbury and Harvey Ry. Co., Cor. re Opening of Hillsborough Ry. (M. for copy*) 562 (i).

 Inquiry for Papers, 938 (i) .
Stenographic Assistance for Members (remarks) 1846 (i).
Sussex St. Property and Govt. Buildings Explanation re Abandonment, 2007 (ii). Supply-
Arts, Agriculture, Ac. (census aud statistics) 619 (i).
Civil Govt.-Aud. Gen.'s Office (salaries) 1040; Charges of Management (dom. notes) 1033; (salaries) 619; Conservation Commission (salaries) 1069; Finance (contingencies) 1068 (i); Inland Revenue (promotions) cone., 6771 (iv); (salaries; 1062; Justice-Exchequer Court (salaries) 1036,	1039; Marine and Fisheries
(salaries) 1041; Militia (salaries) 1037; Naval Dept, (salaries) 1062; Public AA'orks (salaries) 1064; Railways (salaries) 1064 (i).
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1469; (inspection re shipping machinery) 1525 (i).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Can. and Cuba) 4721; (Can. and G. B.) 4718
(iii); (Canada and Mexico) 5935 (iv); (Halifax and Nfld.) 4729; (Halifax and
PUGSLEY. Hon. Wm .-Con.
Supply-Con.
\X. Indies, Ac.) 4740 (iii); (Mar. Provs. and Porto Rico (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 686 (i); (Pelee Island) 678; (St. John and Cuba) 678; (St. John and \A. Indies) 640 (i).	.
Militia (armouries) 5543; (automobiles) 5515; (customs dues) 5522 (iii); (public buildings) 620 (i).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5319, 5327
(iii).
Ocean and River Service (govt, steamers) 5187 (iii).
Public Works-Miscellaneous (waterstorage dams, Temiskaming dam) 2827; (monuments) 2825 (ii).
Public Works-Buildings (generally) 623
Public AYorks-Buildings-N.B. (Hampton) 1527; (Hillsboro) 1528; (St. John drill hall) 1529 (i).	^
Public Works-Buildings-Out. (Ganano-que) 1855; (Kingston R.M.C.) 1855 (i). Public Works-Buildings-Que. (Quebec customs house) 1849; (Quebec P.O.) 1852; (St. Lambert) 1853; (Shawinigan) 1852
(i)	.
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Man. (repairs, Ac.) 2814 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Mar. Provs. (creosoted timber) 2441; (dredging) 2816 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- N.B. (Bathurst) 2363; (Goose Creek) 2372
(ii)	; (St. John) 623 (i).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- N.S. (Burke's Head) 2045; (repairs, Ac.) 2051 (ii).
Public AYorks-Harbours and Rivers- Ont. (Toronto Harbour) 2445; (York bridge) 2817 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- Que. (Rivieres des Prairies) 2441; (Three Rivers) 2441 (ii).
Public AYorks-Telegraphs-Alta. (Athabasca Landing) 2819; (North Battleford) 2823 (ii).
Railways-I.C.R.	(Chatham diversion)
4137; (construction) 4133 (iii); (extensions) 5639 (iv); (Hampton) 4225 (iii); (Hampton spur) 675 (i); (working expenses) 4165 (iii).	_
Trade and Commerce (annuities act) 689; (bounties act) 687 (i).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 3044, 3541 (ii); 4080 (iii); on Senate Amts., 6668 (iv).

Appeal from Ruling (Mr. Bennett)
3615 (ii).
Temiskaming Dam, Inquiry for Ret., 5928, 6661 (iv).
See ' Lake Temiskaming.'
Transportation Question; See 'Fast Atlantic,' ' National Ports,' ' Dry Docks, St. John.'


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 137 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 6180 (iv).
Waterways Commission, Apptmt. of Commissioners (M. for O. Cs., Ac.) 981 (i).
lxxvi

PHGSLEY, Hon. Wm.-Con.
Waterways Commission, Dismissal and Apptmts., on M. for Sup., 6680 (iv).

 (remarks) 966 (i).
See ' Boundary/
West Indies, Australia and Canada Trade Relations, on M. for Sup., 1971 (ii).
RAINVILLE, Mr. J. H., Chambly Vercheres.
Address, The, 337 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.:  (remarks) 1071 (i).
See ' Twine.'
Lumber Duties, Interpretation and Enforcement, (amt.) suggested, 582; Reply to, 589 (i).

 Violation of Customs Act, on Amt.
(Mr. Turrifi) 1803 (i).
McLean, W. S., Dismissal from Customs at L'Etang (Ans.) 4780 (iii).
Miner, Bill, Escape (remarks) 939 (i). Montreal Customs House, Dismissals, &c. (Ans.) 4040 (iii).
Mosher, Mr. G. A., Preventive Officer at Ship Harbour (Ans.) 4040 (iii).
Mundle, Mr. D. I., Dismissal from Customs at Richibucto (Ans.) 4780 (iii). N.T.Ry. Act (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3366 (ii).
Oyster Pond Preventive Officer, Pet. re Dismissal (Ans.) 1207 (i).
Poulin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Quebec Customs (Ans.) 2071 (ii).
Rambaut, Thomas D., Patent Relief B. 83 (Mr. Ames) in Com., 3280 (ii).
Renfrew Election, Minister's speech re Georgian Bay Canal (remarks) 1573 (i). Returns, on Inquiry for, 2057 (ii).
Robinson, Fred. P., Apptmt. as Preventive Officer, N.B. (Ans.) 4241 (iii).
Stoves, Ranges, Incubators exported to Argentine Republic, Value, &c. (Ans.) 561
<i>-
Supply-
Civil Govt.-Customs (salaries) 1040; Outside Ports (salaries) 1073 (i).
Marine (Govt, sfearaers) 1964 (i). Railways-I.C.R. (branch lines) 622 (i). Therrien, J. F., Dismissal from Inland Revenue (Ans.) 3152 (ii;.
Twine Materials Importations (Ans.) 3536 (ii).
See ' Lobster.'


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
lxxvii
REIT), Hon. J. D.-Con.
Yule, Andrew, Customs Collector at Aurora Dismissal (Ans.) 4779 (iii), 5950 (iv).
RHODES, Mr. E. N., Cumberland.
Fast Atlantic Service, and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6501, 6516 (iv).
Guysborough Branch Line Subsidy (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5628 (iv).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provinces (prop, res.) 2072 (ii).
Molson, Kenneth Relief (B. 110) 10#, 3449 (ii).
Political Literature, Distribution re. Racial Prejudices (remarks) on M. for Sup., 6516
(iv).
Supply.
Railways-I.C.R. (branch lines) 5628; (double tracking) 5637; (extensions) 5639
(iv).
RICHARDS, Mr. J. W., Prince, P.E.I.
O'Leary to West Point Ry. Branch Lines, Construction re (Ques.) 721 (i),
ROBB, Mr. J. A., Huntingdon.
Cedar Rapids Power Co., Water Power Concessions to re St. Lawrence River, &c. (Ques.) 728 (i).
Cement Importations, Quantity and Value for 1910-11 (Ques.) 3534 (ii).
Civil Service Act (customs) Amt. B. 116 (Mr. Reid)-in Com., 4572 (iii).
Cream Exports into H.S., Quantity and Value for 1911 (Ques.) 3535_(ii).
Dairying Industry in Canada, Complaints re Weighing at Montreal (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5741 (iv).
Dynamite and Explosives, Legislation re (Ques.) 724 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Live Stock Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6032 (iv).


Railway Subsidies B.: Dismissals and Apptmts. (Ans.) 1809
(i)	.

Employees, Changes re Duties (Ans.)
2243 (i).

Salary Increases, &c. (Ans.) 2067 (ii).

Weekly Consultations (remarks) 224S
(ii)	.
Renfrew, N., Contracts awarded, &c. (Ans.) 2857 (ii).

 Dismissal of Govt. Officials (Ans.)
2857 (ii).
Renfrew, S., Apptmts. to Govt. Service (Ans.) 3334 (ii).
Ixxviii

ROCHE, Hon. W. J.-Con.
Renfrew, S., Contracts awarded, &c. (Ans.) 2856 (ii).

Dismissal of Govt. Officials (Ans.)
2856 (ii).
St. Patriot de Brandon, Population, Revenue, &c. re P.O. (Ans.) 725 (i). Secretary of State, Report (presented) 565
(i).
Supply.
Civil Govt.-Secretary of State (salaries) 1038 (i).
Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1472 (i). Miscellaneous (additional commissioner) 6615; Parliamentary Documents (translation) 6614 (iv).
Printing- Bureau (plant, &c.) 6611 (iv). Tuberculosis in St. Jean and Iberville, Information re (Ans.) 3533 (ii).
Typewriters and Supplies, Names of Firms, Ac. (Ans.) 1809 (i).
Vickers-Maxim Co., Contract re Montreal Dry Dock (Ans.) 2450 (ii).
Yamaska Electoral Agent, &e. (Ans.) 1584
(i.).
ROGERS, Hon. R. (Minister of the Interior) Winnipeg.
Abenakis Indian Agent, Apptmt. and Salary (Ans.) 1587 (i).
Asselin, Mr. Oliver, Emplymt. by Immigration Dept. (Ans.) 1814 (i).
Braine, Dr. Lawrence, Medical Indian Attendant at Chester, N.S., Dismissal, &c. (Ans.) 4976 (iii).
B.	C. Railway Belt Lands, O. C. re Transfer (remarks) 1200 (i).
British News, &c., Purchase of by Int. Dept. (Ans.) 6660 (iv).
See ' Hawke.'
Can. Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B.
187 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6371 (iv). Carpet Weavers Union, Violation of Immigration Act by J. C. Murray (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1514 (i).
Census Enumerators, Payments to (remarks) 2668 (ii).
Chard, Mr. J. A., Indian Agent at Grand View, Charges re (Ans.) 2458 (ii).
Coal -Supply in the West, Remission of Duties (remarks) 230 (i).
Combines in Trade, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1519 (i).
Crown Lands in Man., Alberta and Sask., Number of Acres, Reservations for School Lands (Ans.) 1588 (i).
Dom. Lands Agent at Medicine Hat, Suspension or Dismissal (Ans.) 552 (i).
Dupont, Rene, Dismissal at Immigration Agent (Ans.) 1864 (i).
Eastern Township, Field for Immigration (remarks) 6558 (iv).
ROGERS, Hon. R,-Con.
Farm Labourers Immigration: See 'Immigration.'
Forts and Military Property, Improvements re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 620 (i);
Freight Rates on Rys., on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3212 (ii).
French Canadian Repatriation (remarks) 619 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2781 (ii).
Grain Congestion in the West, Car Distribution (remarks) 6557 (iv).

 

 (remarks) on M. for Sup., 6205 (iv).
Grain Shipments to Terminal Elevators (remarks) 6792 (iv).
Ham, Robt., Dismissal from Trachoma Hospital at Halifax (Ans.) 875 (i).
Hawkes, Mr. Arthur, Apptmt. in Immigration Dept. (Ans.) 527 (i).

on M. (Mr. Oliver) for O. C., 615 (i).
See 'British News,' 'Immigration.'


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3727 (ii).
Homestead Inspectors in Sask., Number dismissed, &c. (Ans.) 1588 (i).
House of Commons Desks, Change of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 623 (i).
Immigrants deported, Number, Amount expended, 4c. (Ans.) 1213 (i).	.
Immigration Agents in Belgium, Number, &c. (Ans.) 878 (i).
Immigration Agents, Dismissals, Number and Names (Ans.) 877 (i).
Immigration Agents re Farm Labourers, Number appointed (Ans.) 874 (i).

 in Quebec, Number, &0-. (Ans.) 1359
(i)	.
Immigration Agents in France, Names and Salaries (Ans.) 878, 1212 (i).
Immigration Agents, Notification to Booking Agents re Bonus (Ans.) 875 (i).
Immigration Agents and Ontario Farm Labourers (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3928
(ii)	.
Immigration from U.S., Opposition of Govt, (remarks) 3154 (ii).
Immigration Hospitals, Number and Location (Ans.) 1210 (i).
Immigrant Inspection before sailing for Canada (remarks) 618 (i).
Immigration Literature, French Publications (Ans.) 1212 (i).
Immigration Medical Examiners, Number, Names, &c. (Ans.) 1213 (i).
Immigration, Money expended, Number of Immigrants, &c. (Ans.) 1211 (i).
Immigration Office in London, Out. (Ans.) 2451 (ii).



[Stage Direction]
Ixxix
ROGERS, Hon. R.-Con.
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on prop.
Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2143 (ii).
Immigration Premiums, Amount expended (Ans.) 1212 (i).
Immigration, Rep. of Mr. Hawkes, 6551 (iv). See ' Hawkes.'
Immigration Societies, State-Aid, Amount expended, &c. (Ans.) 1211 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1319 (i).
Japanese, &c., Immigration, Legislation re (Ans.) 875 (i).
Laforce, Mr. J. W., Emplymt. as Immigration Agent (Ans.) 2242 (ii).
Land Grant to Railways in Western ProTS., prior to 1896 (Ans.) 726 (i).
Laurier, R., Immigration Agent at Detroit, (Ans.) 2454 (ii).
Laurier, C. A., Immigration Agent at Marquette (Ans.) 2454 (ii).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 
Inquiries Act.   A@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2170, 2181, 2304, 2383, 2535, 2759, 3157, 3458, 3473 (ii), 4069 (iii).
Grain Carriage to Duluth, &c.. Ref. to Washington Despatch (remarks) 2576 (ii). Grain Shipments from the West, Regulation of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3978 (ii).
Hudson Bay Railway Construction, on M.
(Mr. Aikins) for Papers, 1248 (i).
Hudson Bay Ry., Contract re, on M. (Air.
Neely) for O. Cs., &o., 734 (d).
Lumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act, on Amt. (Mr. Turrifl) 1731 (i).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) in Com., 4763 (iii).
Railway Rates, Transportation, &c., on Al. (Air. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 1945 (i).



SCHAFFNER, Mr. F. L.-Con.
Supply_
Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (rentals, &c.) 1331 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2967 (di).	,
Wheat Grades, &c. (remarks) on Public Ownership debate, 663 (i).
SEGUIN, Mr. P. A., L'Assomption.
Arcbambault, Emile, LetteT Carrier, Montreal, Dismissal (Ques.) 5950 (iv); (M. for cor.*) 5957 (iv).
Can. Northern Quebec Ry. Co., Maintenance of Road on L'lle Bourdon (Ques.) 5261 (iii).
Chiairlemagme Mail Contract, Name of Contractor, &o. (Ques.) 1862 (i).
Coffin, Henry, Apptmt. as Messenger H. of C., Dismissal of M. Picotte (M. for cor.*) 2159 (ii).
Dumelong, M. E., Dismissal from L'Assomption P. 0. (Ques.) 580, 720 '.).
Forest, Mr. Medard, Excise Officer at L'Bpiphiande, Dismissal, Charges (Ques.)
SEVIGNY, Mr. A .-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Grain Act B.: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2557 (ii).
726 (i).
Ice-Breaker at St. Gerard, Tenders re Construction (Qnes.) 2451 (di).
Lachenaie Postmaster, Complaints re (Qnes.) 5949 (iv).
L'Achigan Ice-Breaker, Tenders re Construction, &o. (Ques.) 2294 (ii).
L'Assomption Public Works, Votes in Estimates (Ques.) 5951, 6781 (iv).
L'Assomption Wharf, Appropriation re (Ques.) 2451, 2579 (ii).
Laurentide-s Public Building, Acquisition of Property (Ques.) 2451 (ii).
Lighthouse Keepers at Repentigny, Charges re &c. (Ques.) 3752 (ii), 5949 (iv).

 (M. for cor.*) 6784 (iv).
Locias, Mr. Henri, Dismissal, &c (Ques.) 3338 (ii).
Picotte, Mederic, Messenger H. of C., Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 2065 (ii).
St. Paul L'Erimite Ac., Mail Carrier, &o. (Ques.) 2583 (ii).

Mail Service, Cancellation of Contracts (Ques.) 3341 (ii).
Ste. Therese and Lanrentides Post Office, Revenue, Ac. (Ques.) 3335 (ii).
SEVIGNY, Mr. A., Dorchester.
Address, The, in Answer to His Ex.'s Speech (seconded) 27 (v).
Dugas, Hon. Mr. Justice, Date of Apptmt., &c. (Ques.) 2858 (ii).
Ha Ha Bay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6213 (iv).
Joint Stock Companies, Inspection, &c. (Ques.) 2857 (ii).
SHARPE, Mr. S., North Ontario.
Chats Falls Timber Slide, Date of Deed to
D.	O'Connor, &c. (Qnes.) 4549 (iii).
Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt. B. 179 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 6089 (iv).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 
Live Stock Records Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6038 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
SUPPI Y
[Stage Direction]
' Labour Dept. (Gazette) 1493 (i); Militia (customs dues) 5525 (iii); Railways P.E.I. (car ferry) 5672 (iv).
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 3018, 3557 (ii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 137 (Mr. Rogers) in Com., 6451 (iv).
Wadge, Thomas, Patent Relief B. 16 (Mr. Aikins) in Com., 2984 (ii).
SHARPE, Mr. W. H., Lisgar.
Budget, The, 5109 (iii).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2312, 2777, 3165, 3498, 3520 (ii), 4159 (iii).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
lxxxi
SHARPE, Mr. W. H.-Con.
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 2891 (ii).
SHEPHERD, Mr. E. H., Nanairno.
B. C. Herring Fishing, Authority re Close Season (Ques.) 4256 (iii).
Fish Hatcheries, B.C., Cost of Construction (Ques.) 4256 (iii) .
Fisheries Protection Service on Pacific Coast, on M. (Mr. Clements) for Papers, 2481 (ii).
Post Office Act (ry. mail clerks) Amt. B. 105 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 3360 (ii).
SINCLAIR, Mr. J. H., Guysborough.
Address, The, 323 (i).
Appropriations omitted from Estimates of 1913 (M. for ret.) 1819 (i).
Barss, Mr. Archibald, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 6784 (iv).
Biological Board of Canada B. 118 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 4552 (iii).
Biological Board, Names, Salaries, &c., (Ques.) 4257 (iii).
Blind River Post Office, Change of Name (M. for cor.*) 4262 (iii).

Inquiry for Papers, 5928 (iv).
B. C. Fishing Licenses, Transfer, &c. (M. for pets.*) 3945 (ii).
Canadian Coal for Govt. Buildings (re-1 marks) in Com. of Sup., 3288 (ii).
Canals, Capital Expenditure, Total Cost (Ques.) 1811 (i).
Canal Tolls, Abolition of, O.Cs., &e. (M. for copies*) 2861 (ii).
Canso Public Buildings, Dismissal of Caretaker (remarks) 581 (i).

Dismissal of R. Sutherland (M. for
cor.*) 1409 (i).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: (M. for cor.*) 3055 (ii).
Fishery Inspectors, N.S., Names, &e. (Ques.) 4257 (iii).
Fishery Protection Service on Pacific Coast, on M. (Mr. Clements) for Papers, 2470 (ii). Fish Scrap sold as Fertilizer, Increase in Price (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 684 (i). Fishing Twine for Lobster Nets, Duties re (remarks) on M. for Sup.. 5587 (iv). Gasolene Engines on Fishing Boats, Number, &c. (Ques.) 2666 (ii).
Gass, Trueman, Emplymt. and Dismissal, &c. (Ques.) 2242 (ii).
Gerrior, Mr. William, Dismissal from Customs at Larry's River, N.S. (Ques.) 3051
(ii)	.
Ixxxii

SINCLAIR, Mr. J. H.-Con.
Gerrior, Mr. William, (M. for cor.*) 3056 (ii).
Glenelg, N.S. Postmastei, Complaints re Pets., &c. (M. for papers*) 3817 (i).
Guysborough Branch Line Subsidy (remarks) 1445 (i), 5261 (ivf.
Hagerty, S. W., Dismissal from Inspector ship of Ry. Station (Ques.) 4976 (iii).
Halifax Terminal Pacilities (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4205 (iii).
Harris, W. H., Postmaster at White Head. Dismissal, &c. (M. for papers*) 2588 (ii).
Hattie, Mr. W. A., Preventive Office, Mul-grave, Dismissal (Ques.) 1815 (i).

(M. for cor.*) 2460 (ii) .
Hendsbee, David S., Dismissal from Marine and Fisheries Dept. (M. for cor.*) 3342
(ii).


Highways Improvements B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3703 (ii).
House of Commons, Improvements re Acoustics (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1335
(i).
I.C.R., Guysborough Branch, Construction re (Ques.) 571 (i).
Judges Act (salaries) Amt. B. 156 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 6006 (iv).
Kelly, Edward, Dismissal from Canso Reduction Works (M. for cor.*) 3341 (ii).
Land Grants to Railways in Western Provs. prior to 1896 (Ques.) 725 (i).
'Carry's River Dredging, Apptmt. of Inspector (Ques.) 5055 (ii).
Linwood and Grosvenor's Mail Service (re marks) in Com. of Sup., 6281 (iv).
McGrath, James, Postmaster at Aspen, N.S. (M. for cor.*) 2587 (ii).
McPherson, John H., Complaints re as Postmaster at Tracadie Road (Ques.) 4259 (iii).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6622 (iv).
Man. and N.S., Federal Subsidies, &c. (Ques.) 4258 (iii).
Marine Hospitals, Ships for Fishermen (remarks) 6787 (iv).
Melford, N.S., Wharf, Notice to suspend Work, &c. (Ques.) 549 (i).


Montieal Harbour Commissioners B.: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 1S3 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6228, 6305 (iv).
Reciprocity Treaty, Ref. to in debate on Address, 323 (i).
Reciprocity with U.S. from 1890 to 1891 (M. for cor.*) 5263 (iii).
Richards, Mr., Dismissal (remarks) in Com.
of Sup., 5821, 6652 (iv).
Roberts, Capt. Alex., Postmaster at Canso, Dismissals, &c. (M. for cor.*) 3341 (ii). Rogers, J. M., Dismissal from East Roman Valley Post Office, N.S. (Ques.) 722 (i).

 (M. for pets.*) 1409 (i).
Senate Vacancy, Apptmt. of Acadian in N.B. (Ques.) 541 (i).
Smith, Lyman C-, Customs Collector at Osliawa, Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 2861
(ii)	.

Letter (read) in Com. on Bill, 4575
(iii)	-
Steam Trawling on Can., Coasts and Outside (M.) for Papers, 2461 (ii).
Steam Trawlers and Fisheries Bounties, (M. for pets.*) 5957 (iv).
Steam Trawlers, Protection against (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5388 (iii).
Steel and Iron Bounties, re Budget Speech (Ques.) 4249 (iii).
Sunnybrae and Guysborough Branch Ry-, I.C.R., Appropriation re (Ques.) 22S9 (ii). 

(M. for cor.*) 4262 (iii).



[Stage Direction]
Ixxxiii
SINCLAIR, Mr. J. H.-Con.
Sunnybrae to Country Harbour Ry. Subsidy (remarks) in Corn, on Ry. Bill, 6228 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1213 (iii).
Supply-
Agriculture-Experimental Farms (bulle-Dns) 6168; (fumigating stations) 6479; (Toronto exhibition) 6481 (iv).
Civil Govt. - Customs - Outside Ports ^salaries) 1088 (i); Post Office (salaries) 6278 (iv).
Fisheries (lighthouse keepers) 6650 (iv); (protection service) 5387 (iii); (scrap as fertilizer) 684 (i).
Labour Dept, (combines investigation act) 1503 (l).
(Cl Subsidies and SS. Subventions (Canada and Australia) 4714; Can. and G.B.) 4719; (Can. and S. Africa) 4727; (Halifax and Nfld.) 4728 (iii); (North Sydney) 679 (i); (Sydney and Wycoco-magh) 4742 (iii).
Marine (Govt, steamers) 1964 (i).
Miscellaneous (Champlain monument) 6486; (pelagic sealing) 5811 (iv).
Naval Service (maintenance) 5308, 5383 (in).	'
Post Office (mail service) 6281. 6294; Outside Service (salaries) 6622 (iv).	'
o° Works-Buildings-JLS. (Wolfville)
H^;,XntX(Sarnia) 1952: Ottawa (leases) * v WA Ottawa (rents, &c.) 3290 (ii).
Public Works-Harbours and Kivers- *>rovs- (creosoted timber) 2440: (Cole Harbour) 2055; (Melford) 2056 (ii).
(iv)^5-^uc*son (construction) 6600
®'ttl'''ay®~I-O.R. (board of management) 4136 (iii); (branch lines) 5621 (iv) [DOT] 671 W: (double tracking) (highways) 4226; (Mulgrave) 111) * ('SS. Scotia) 5655; (wages) o809; (Wallace Harbour spur line) 6604
^ (iv).
Trade and Commerce (annuities act) 695-(bounties act) 687 (i).
Sutherland, Mr., Dismissal of (remarks) in
Com. of Sup., 2018; Cor., &c. (read) 2022
(ii).
(remarks) 1274 (i).
See ' Canso/
Tariff Commission B.: 88 (Mr. White) in Com., 3549 (ii).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6418 (iv).
Tory, H. L., Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.#) 6783 (iv).
Tracadie Road Post Office, Charges re (M. for cor.*) 4459 (iii).
Twine Materials Importations, &c. (Ques.) 3536 (ii).
Webber, James, Dismissal (M. for cor.*) 6783 (iv).
IV hite Head Island Lighthouse, Dismissal of Patrick Conway, Investigation, &c. (Ques.) 2857 (ii).
See ' Conway/
Fi
SINCLAIR, Mr. J. H.-Con.
Whitehead, N. S., Dismissal of Postmaster, &c. (Ques.) 2855 (ii).

 Cor., &c. (read) in Com. of Sup., 6302
(iv).
Williams, Mr., Dismissal from H. of C.
(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3279 (ii). Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commissioners incorp. B. 138 (Mr. Hazen) in Com., 5999 (iv).
SMITH, Mr. Wm., South Ontario.


Lire Stock Association B.: 167 (Mr. Burrell) in Com., 6038 (iv).
SPEAKER, Mr. (Hon. T. S. Sproule) East Grey.
Address, The, on Ques. of Order (Mr. Blon-din) 372 (i).
Address, The, ' Trusts and Mergers/ applied to Min. of Fin., Member asked to withdraw, 63 (i).
Agriculture, 1st Rep. of Com., Irregularity re (remarks) 2375 (ii).


Highways Improvement B.: 
Inquiries Act.   A@:  (ruling) re Procedure, 1281 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 156 (Mr. Doherty) on M. for Com. on Res., 5958 (iv).
SPEAKER, Mr. (Hon. T. S. Sproule)-Con. Juvenile Delinquents B. 2 (Mr. Bickerdike) on M. for Com. (remarks) 939 (i).
Labour Gazette Correspondents, Dismissals, &e., Members remarks checked, 1412 (i). Lobster Twine, Customs Duties, Members remarks checked, 1072 (i).
Lumber Combine in B. C., Distribution in Member's Boxes (personal explanation) 2299 (ii).

 (remarks) re M. to ref. back to Conn.,
4890 (iii).
Manitoba Boundaries, Cor. re Settlement, &c, on M. (Mr. Macdonald) for cor. (remarks) 777 (i).

 Eastern Boundary Extension (ruling)
re Question (Mr. Oliver) 3936 (ii).

Members remarks checked, 490 (i).
Mian. Grain Act, on M. for Com. on Res., 869 (i).
Marine Hospital Ships, Members remarks checked, 6787 (iv).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Correction re Ruling on Question,
6335 (iv).
Napierville Post Office Site, Members remarks checked, 3153 (ii).
National Art Gallery, Question re Ownership (remarks) 6337 (iv).
N. T. Ry. Station at Quebec, on M. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) for O. Cs. (remarks) 760
(i).
Naval Service Act, Repeal of (ruling) re Question (Mr. Mondou) 3943 (ii).
Ne Temere Decree, Questions asked, Members remarks checked, 720 (i).


INDEX-1911-12 Ixxxv
[Stage Direction]
SPEAKER, Mr. (Hon. T. S. Sproule)-COn.
Newspaper Articles, Reading of, &c. (ruling) 3059 (ii).
Ontario and Ottawa Ry. Co.'s B. 50 (Mr. Currie) on M. for 3°, (remarks) 2414 (ii).
Ottawa, Montreal and Eastern Ry. B. 99, on Senate Amts, (ruling) 5679 (iv).
Plamama Canal, Tolls, Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) checked, 2447 (ii).
Parcel Post Extension, on Amt. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) members remarks checked, 2346 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
on Ques. of Order (Mr. Armstrong)
2348 (ii).
Parliament Opening, Com. from Gov. Gen's Sec., 6 (v).
Peace Memorial Monument, Members remarks checked, 2590 (ii).
Peace River and Ry. Belt Water Power B. 149 (Mr. Rogers) on M. for 3°, 6188 (iv).
Piper, E. F., Patent Relief B. 53 (Mr. Fripp) on M. for 2°, 1202 (i).
Political Literature. Application re Free Postage, Ques. of Order, 1587 (d).
P. E. I., Better Terms, Member (Mr. J. J. Hughes) remarks checked, 5172 (ini).
Printing Com., 1st Rep. of Joint Com., on M. (Mr. Currie) to come., 3330 (ii).
Private Bills, Rep. of Examiner of Pets., &c., Divergency re Rules (remarks) 643 (i).
Prorogation, Com. from Gov. Gen.'s 'Sec. (read) 6780 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Mess from the Senate, 6824 (iv).
Public Accounts Com., 2nd Rep., Ques. of Order., 5839 (iv).
Publio Ownership, Members remarks checked, 666 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Renfrew S.: , Election, Issue of Writ, Members remarks checked, 2059 (ii).

 Vacancy (notification) 926 (i).
Rideau Hall Expenditure, on Quies. of Prlv. (Mr. Pugsley) Members Remarks checked, 800 (i).
SPEAKER, Mr. (Hon. T. S. Sproule)-Con. Rural Telephone System, prop. Res. (Mr. Blain) Ruled out of Order, 2250 (ii).

Further Ruling, 2287 (ii).
St. John Harbour Dredging, Members remarks checked, 5695 (iv).
Seed Grain Distribution, Members remarks checked, 2300 (ii).
Senate Amendments Railway Bills (remarks) 6550-1 (iv).
Soulanges Canal, Charges re Damien La-londe, Objection re Question, 4249 (iii)-Speaker, (remarks) re Election, 6 (v). Speaker, Dep., on M. (Mr. R. L. Borden) to appoint, Member asked to withdraw Stmt., 522 (i).
Speech from the Throne (read) 8 (i). Stenographic Assistance for Members (remarks) 1847 (i).
Shipping Act Amt. Bill, Ruling re M. to introduce, 229, 267 (i).
Supply-
Civil Govt-Inland Revenue (promotions) cone., 6771, 6772 (iv).
Dismissals, &c., members remarks checked, 2039 (ii).	.
Public Works-Bridges (Ottawa River) 6806 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings-Que. (Louise-ville) Members remarks checked, on cone., 6797 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 88 on Appeal from Chairman (Mr. Pugsley) 3616 (ii).

 Member (Mr. Oliver) cannot impute
motives, 2688 (ii).

 Senate Amendments (presented) 6808
(iv).

 Members remarks checked, 1960 (i).

on Ques. of Order (Mr. Maclean)
1184 (i).
Estimates, Members remarks checked, 2439
(ii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., Members remarks checked, 3711 (ii).
lxxxvi

SPEAKER, Mr. DEPUTY (Mr. P. E. Blondin) -Con.
I. C. Ry. Estimates, on Ques. of Order (Mr. Stevens) 4219 (iii)-
Napierville Post Office Site, Payments re Members remarks cheeked, 2373 (ii). Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Niekle) in Com. on Amt. (Mr. Poster) 4759 (iii).

(ruling) re Amts., 4774 (iii).
Rambaut, Thomas D., Patent Relief B. 84 (Mr. Ames) in Com., 2992 (ii).
St. Jacques de l'Achigan Post Office Site, Members remarks checked, 2442 (ii). Sterling Life Assurance Co.'s B. 72 (Mr. Blain) in Com., 2448 (ii).
Supply.
Members remarks checked, 2043 (ii). Militia, Member called to Order, 5538 (iii). Naval Service (maintenance), Member called to order, 5317 (iii).
Post Office, Irrelevancy of debate (ruling) 6299 (iv).
Tariff Bill, Amt. (Mr. Pugsley) ruled out of Order, 3615 (ii).
[DOT]- 

on Ques. of Order (Mr. H. Clark)
2997 (ii).

on Ques. of Order (Mr. Currie) 3617
(ii).

Market Tickets to Employees (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5810 (iv). Railway Com., G.T. Ry. Bill, Apptmt. of sub-Committee, Liberals omitted (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5617 (iv).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6304 (iv).
Returns, Inquiry for, 2057 (ii).
Supply.
Immigration (agencies, &c.) 3306 (ii); Public Works-Buildings-Ottawa (H. of C., addition) 1951 (i); Weights and Measures (inspectors) 5830 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2309/2541, 2759, 3168, 3187, 3467, 3781 (ii). Grain Shipments in the West, Freight Rates, &c., on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3985 (ii).
Lumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act, on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) 1726 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Tariff Commission B.: 
Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 190 (Mr. Hughes) in Com., 6266 (iv).


Highways Improvements B.: 
INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
Ixxxvii
STEVENS, Mr. H. H.-Con.
Elevators, Terminal, ref. to in debate on Address, 287 (i).
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6222 (iv).
Fishery Protection Service on Pacific Coast, on M. (Mr. Clements) for Papers, 2473
(ii)	.
Fisheries Question in B.C., ref. to in debate on Address, 290 (i).
Freight Rates on Rys., on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3232 (ii).
See ' Ry. Rates.'
Good Roads, ref. to in debate on Address, 284 (i) .
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulations of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3986, 3998 (ii).
I. C. Ry. Estimates, Ques. of Order, 4218
(iii)	.
' Kestrel ' Fishery Cruiser, Condemnation of (Ques.) 349 (i).
Logs, Stealing of: See ' Criminal Code B. 9.' Lumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act, on Amt. (Mr. Turriff) 1747 (i).
N.T. Ry. Act (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3423 (ii).
Naval Policy, ref. to in debate on Address, 291 (i).
North Arm Bridge and Ry. Co.'s (B. 14) 1°*, 643 (i).
Oriental Immigration into B.C., Total Number (Ques.) 4779 (iii).
See ' Chinese.'
Railway Rates, Transportation, &c., on M. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 1925 (i).
See ' Freight Rates.'
Railway Subsidies B.: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6218, 6318 (iv).


Tariff Commission B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2554, 2767 (ii).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3695 (ii).
SUTHERLAND, Mr. D.-Con.
Immigration Agents re Farm Labourers Number appointed, &c. (Ques.) 874 (i).

 Notification to Booking Agents re
Bonus, &c. (Ques.) 875 (i).
Immigration Agents for Placing Farm Labourers in Ont., Complaints re (M. for papers*) 4781 (iii).

 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 3923 (ii).

 (M. for cor.*) 5263 (iii).
Immigration Policy re Mar. Provs., on prop.
Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2126 (ii).
Supply-
Agriculture-Experimental farms (branch stations) 6485 (iv); Immigration (agencies, &c.) 3923 (ii); Railways-I. C. R. (branch lines) 5624 (iv).
Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Ry. Subsidy B. 186 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6412 (iv).
TAYLOR, Mr. J. D., New Westminster. Debates, Official, 1st Rep. of Com. (M.) to cone., 2840 (ii).
Lumber Duties, Interpretation and Enforcement, on M. (Mr. Knowles) for Papers, 594 (i).

 Violation of Customs Act, on Amt.
(Mr. Turriff) 1766 (i).
THOBURN, Air. Wm., North Lanark.
Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt. B. 179 (Mr. Pelletier) in Com., 6090 (iv). Cockshutt Plough Co., Prices re (remarks) 82S (i).


Fenian Raid Veterans Bounty B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 181 (Air. Rogers) in Com., 6182 (iv).
THOAISON, Air. L., Qu'Appelle.
Gold Coinage by Alint (Ques.) 1213 (i).
lxxxviii

THOMSON, Mr. L.-Con.


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2183, 2301, 2323, 2397, 2536, 2783, 3794 (ii), 4064, 4158 (iii).


Man.   G@: 
Grain Act B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Live Stock Records Association B.:  (M. for papers*) 4781 (iii).
Desmarais, Mr., Dismissal re (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 5817 (iv).
Disraeli Postmaster, Dismissal, &c. (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv). Garthby, Lake Aylmer Wharf Construction (M. for papers, &c.*) 4781 (iii).
Ham Nord Postmaster, Dismissal (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Lapointe, Mr. Joseph, Apptmt. as Overseer on Lake Aylmer (Ques.) 4550 (iii). Postmasters dismissed, Investigation, &c.
(remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6617 (iv). Shurtleff, Dr., Investigation re J. Clouthier (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6629 (iv). Supply-
Agriculture (animals health) 6472 (iv). Militia (headquarters staff) 5537 (iii).
Post Office-Outside Service (salaries, &c.) 6615 (iv).
Public Works-Buildings, Generally (London, Eng.) 6656 (iv).
Weedon Public Building, Construction, &c. (Ques.) 4550 (iii).

* (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 6656 (iv).

(M. for cor.*) 4781 (iii).

Inquiry for Ret., 6492 (iv).
TREMAIN, Mr. H. B., Hants.
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals, on M. for Sup., 6512 (iv).
TURGEON, Mr. O., Gloucester.
Address, The, 388 (i).
Annuities Branch Lecturers, Charges re J. B. Leger &c. (Ques.) 1413 (i).
Caraquet North Shore Ry. Branch Line (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 4192 (iii).


Customs Collector P.   J.@: Venoit, Dismissal of (M. for cor.*) 1590 (i).
Fishery Overseer, J. A. Doucet, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 1590 (i).
Fishery Overseer, W. C. Robichaud, Dismissal, &c. (M. for cor.*) 1589 (i).

 Dismissal of, Inquiry for Ret., 5259
(iii).
Fishing Twine for Lobster Nets, Duty re (remarks) on M. for Sup., 5594 (iv).


Highways Improvement B.: 77 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3965 (ii).
I.C.R. Branch Lines, on prop. Res. (Mr. Emmerson) 1003 (i).


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) on Amt. (Mr. Pugsley) in Com., 4585 (iii).
Petite Lameque Wharf, Construction re (Ques.) 1358 (i).


Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: 183 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6230 (iv).
Supply-
Public Works-Harbours and Rivers- N.B, (Bathurst) 2364 (ii).
TURRIFF, Mr. J. G., Assiniboia.
Alberta Peace River and Eastern Ry. Co.'s B. 129 (Mr. Chabot) in Com., 5945 (iv).
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy B. 187 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 6368 (iv).
Census Enumerators, Delay re Payments (remarks) 4460 (iii).
Cockshutt Plough Co.'s Prices, &c. (remarks) 842 (i).
Customs Tariff, Changes re Jute Cloth, Dressed Lumber, &c. Rulings, &c. (M. for copies*) 2459 (ii).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 1176 (i).
Election Accounts, Payments of (remarks) 4460 (iii).
Flaxseed, Shipment of, Excessive Freight Rates (remarks) 661 (i).
Freight Rates, Discrimination in the West (amt.) on M. for Sup., 3194 (ii).

 Notice of Discussion, 3048 (ii).
See ' Grain Shipments.'
Govt. Ownership:	See ' Public.'


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 32 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 2317, 2535, 2758, 3169, 3502, 3761 (ii), 4065 (iii).
INDEX-	1911-12 lxxxix
TURRIFF, Mr. J. G.-Con.	TURRIFF, Mr. J. G.-Con.
Grain Congestion in the West, Transporta-	Supplytion, &c. (remarks) on M. for Sup., 6207	Post Office (mail service) 6303 (iv).
(iv).	Tariff Commission B. 88 (Mr. White) in
Grain Shipments in the West, Regulation	Com., 2928, 2969, 3024 (ii); on Senate Amts.
of Freight Rates, on prop. Res. (Mr.	6673 (iv).
Oliver) 1012 (ii).	Yukon Judges Annuities B. 123 (Mr
Hudson Bay Railway Construction, on M.	Doherty) in Com. on Res., 4557 (iii).
(Mr. Aikins) for Papers, 1252 (i).	
on M. (Mr. Neely) for O.Cs., &c.	VERVILLL, Mr. A., Maisonneuve.
742 (i).	Address, The, 276 (i).
Immigration from U.S., Opposition of	Budget, The, 5056 (iii).
Govt, (remarks) 3154 (ii).	Caunpeau, Michel, Dismissal from P.O. at St.
re Wm. Pearson Co. (remarks) 3152	Louis du Mile End (Ques.) 1414 (i).
(ii).	Cold Storage Establishments in Canada,
I.C.R. Branch Lines, on prop. Res. (Mr.	Number, &c. (M. for ret.*) 3343 (ii).
Emmerson) 1008 (i).	Inquiry for Ret., 5561 (iv).
Lumber Duties, Inspection as reported in	Cote, Mrs. J. N., Dismissal as Charwoman
Winnipeg ' Free Press' (remarks) 2446	(Ques.) 2667 (ii).
(ii).	I.C.R., Freight on Fish, Aid re Transpor-
Lumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act	tation (Ques.) 6748 (iv).
(amt.) 1723; neg. (Y. 62; N. 107) 1806 (i).	Labour Gazette Correspondents, Apptmt. in


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 

WAR,NOCK, Mr. D.-Von.
Alberta, Peace River and Eastern Ry. Co. s B. 129 (Mr. Chabot) in Com., 5906 (iv).
Coal Shortage in the West, for Household Consumption, &c. (Ques.) 568 (i).
Coal Strike in Ferule, B. C., Information re (Ques.) 568 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
Canadian Northern Pacific Ry.   S@: Limitations re Tenders (remarks) on
M. for Sup., 1841 (i).



[Stage Direction]
xci
WHITE, Hon. W. T.-Con.
Financial Review (reply) rtx>
Mr. A. K. Maclean, 6722 (iv).
See ' Budget.'
Hold Coinage, by Mint (Ans.) 1213 (i). Govt. Loans, Rate of Interest, &e. (Ans.) 1778 (iii).
G. T. P. Ry. Implementing Judgment (B. 95) prop. Res., 2296; in Com. on Res., 2378; 1°*, of B., 2381, 2°m., 3060, 3115 (ii).
See ' N. T. Ry/
Hull City Hall Square Improvements re (Ans.) 2293 (ii).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 19 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 1301 (i).
La Banque de St. Hyacinthe, Investigation re Liquidation (Ans.) 2069 (ii).
La Bainque do St. Hyacdnthe and La Banque St. Jean, Reim bur semen ts re (Ans.) 528, 551 (i).
Loans: See ' Govt/


Manitoba Boundaries Extension B.: 115 (Mr. Borden) in Com. on Res., 3848 (ii); in Com., 1530 (iii).
Man. and N.S. Federal Subsidies, &e. (Ans.) 1259 (iii).


Inquiries Act.   A@:  (remarks) 935 (i).
Dismissals from Ottawa Depts., Inquiry for Ret., 3834 (ii).
Govt. Employees, Dismissal, resigned, &c. (M. for ret.) 1818 (i).
G.T.P. AVorkshops at Quebec, Site for Building (Ques.) 3050 (ii).
House of Commons Dismissals, Inquiry for Ret., 6807 (iv).
lie Bezard and Ste. Genevieve Wharfs, Completion of Repairs (Ques.) 557 (i).
Inspection and Sale Act (grain) Amt. B. 178 (Mr. Foster) in Com., 6194 (iv).
Maple Sugar, O.C. re Standard, Annullment of (Ques.) 716 (i).


Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
XC11 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
WILSON, Mr. C. A .-Con.
Penitentiary Employees Salaries, Increase re (Ques.) 1205 (i).
Queen's University B. 68 (Mr. Nickle) in Com., 3876 (ii).
Rivieres des Prairies, Drainage, Continuation of, Amount voted re (Ques.) 714 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 (remarks) in Com. of Sup., 621 (i).
Supply-
Justice-Penitentiaries (St. Vincent de Paul) 6586 (iv).
Public Works-Roads and Bridges (Doncaster Indian Reserve) 6807 (iv).
WILSON, Mr. C. A.-Con.
Supply-Con.
Railways

I.C.R. (locomotives) 5657 (iv). Yukon Act (judges) Amt. B. 123 (Mr. Doherty) in Com., 5571 (iv).
WILSON, Mr. G. C., Wentworth.
N. T. Ry. (commissioners) Amt. B. 76 (Mr. Cochrane) in Com., 3420 (ii).
WRIGHT, Mr. Wm., Muskoka.
Cockshutt Plough Co.'s Prices (remarks) 853, 861 (i).

[Stage Direction]
Abenakis Indian Agent, Apptmt. and Salary: Ques. (Mr. Mondou) 1587 (i).
' Aboukir ' Cruiser, Paying off of Crew: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 408 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Stmnt. (Mr. Hazen) 489 (i).
Adams, Mr.. Resignation as Examiner of Pilots: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5227 (iii) .
Adams, Wm. Holloway, Relief of: See ' B. No. 122/
Address, The, in Answer to His Royal Highness' Speech: Moved (Mr. R. B. Bennett) 14; Seconded (Mr. Sevigny) 27 (i).
Debate.
(Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 33 (amt.) 49; Neg. (Y. 77. N. 121) 517; (Mr. R. L. Borden) 50; (Mr. Guthrie) 62; (Mr. Poster) 72; (Mr. Carvell) 82; (Mr. Aikins) 94; (Mr. E.	M. Macdonald) 107; (Mr. W. H. Bennett)	127;	(Mr.	Pugsley)	139;	(Mr. Hazen) 162; (Mr. McKenzie) 178; (Mr. A. DeWitt Foster) 201; (Mr. M. Clark) 210; (Mr. Monk) 223, 231; (Mr. Lemieux) 241; (Mr. Mondou) 263, 270; (Mr. Ver-ville)	276;	(Mr.	Stevens)	281;	(Mr. Ethier) 295; (Mr. Burnham) 318; (Mr. Sinclair) 323; (Mr. Rainville) 337; (Mr. Devlin) 348; (Mr. Northrup) 357; (Mr. German) 364; (Mr. Webster) 372; (Mr. Turgeon) 388; (Mr. Weichel) 401; (Mr. Buchanan) 403; (Mr. Fripp) 409; (Mr. Emmerson) 413; (Mr. W. T. White) 440; (Mr. Oliver) 448; (Mr. W. M. Martin) 464; (Mr. Gauthier) 475; (Mr. J. J. Hughes) 482; (Mr. Loggie) 487, 491; (Mr. Boivin) 497; (Mr. Murphy) 501 (i).
Address, The, Precedence: M. (Rt. Hon. Mr. Borden) 9 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. to Present (Mr. Borden) 519 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Reply from H.R.H.:	Presented (Mr. Borden) 932 (i).
Advertisements for Govt. Contracts, Tenders re-. Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 2449 (ii).
See ' Public Works.'
Agriculture, Govt. Aid to: See ' B. No. 100.'

[Stage Direction]
Agriculture, Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1041 (i), 6485 (iv).
Agricultural and Colonization Com., 1st Rep.: M. (Mr. Sexsmith) to ref. to Printing Com., 3933 (ii) .
[Stage Direction]
M. (Mr. Sexsmith) to cone., 2375; objection (Mr. Speaker) 2375 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Personal Explanation (Mr. Best) re
Par. in Toronto ' Globe,' 2155 (ii).
Animals destroyed at North Ham, Pet. re Compensation: Remarks (Mr. Tobin)
AGRICULTURE-Con.
in Com. of Sup., 6472 (iv).
Animals Health, Inspection, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6469 (iv).
Apples and Fruit Growers Association, N.S., Resolution re Industry:	Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 1719 (i).
Archives Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 6461
(iv).
Arts, Agriculture and Statistics: in Com. of Sup., 6462 (iv).
Cattle Diseased, Compensation re Damages: Remarks (Mr. Morphy) in Com. of Sup., 6471 (iv).
Cattle Embargo by G.B., Abolition of: Ques. (Mr. Bickerdike) 557 (i).
Cattle Quarantine at Beauceville, Ree. from Chamber of Commerce: Remarks (Mr. Beland) 4984 (iii).
Dom. Exhibition, Grant to Ottawa: in Com. of Sup., 6479 (iv).
Experimental Branch Stations for Farms: in Com. of Sup., 6477 (iv).
Experimental Farm Bulletins, Distribution, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6465 (iv).
Fumigating Stations: in Com. of Sup., 6479 (iv).
Horses imported from U.S., Destrucfcfm of for Glanders: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 5693, 5939, 6790 (iv).
International Institute of Agriculture: in Com. of Sup., 6478 (iv) .
Live Stock Industry: in Com. of Sup., 6469 (iv).
Nursery Stock, Purchase of for Experimental Farm, N.S.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 3333 (ii).
Paris Exposition, Payments for Space: M. for Stmnt.* (Mr. Paquet) 582 (i).
Pictou Cattle Disease, Compensation re-. Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 6472 (iv).
Tobacco Growing, Aid to:	in Com. of
Sup., 6478 (iv).
Toronto Exhibition Grant: in Com. of Sup., 6480 (iv) .
Wheeler, Seager, Congratulations re Prize Wheat at N.Y. Exhibition: Ques. (Mr. McCraney) 542 (i).
Year-book: in Com. of Sup., 6465 (iv).
Aids to Navigation: in Com. of Sup., 5236 (iii).
See ' Marine.'
Air Brakes, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 4136 (iii).

[Stage Direction]
Airships for Military Purposes, Purchase by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
Alabama Traction Light and Power Co.: See 'B. No. 160/
Alberta Electric By. Co.: See ' B. No. 33/
Alberta Great Waterways Ry., Disallowance of: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 1575 (i).
Alberta Pacific Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com., 6311 (iv).
Alberta, Peace River and Eastern Ry. Co.: See 'B. No. 129/
Alberta Ry. and Irrigation Co.: See ' B. No 79/
Albert Mines and Hillsborough Ry. Co/s Subsidy; in Com., 6216, 6301 (iv).
See ' Harvey/
Alder Point Lobster Hatchery, Tenders, Contracts, &c.-. Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 3053 (ii).
Aldershot Rifle Range, Caretaker, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3536 (ii).
Algoma Central and Hudson Bay Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5897, 6216, 6312 (iv).
Algoma Eastern Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 34."
American Freight passing through Welland Canal: Ques. (Mr. G. V. White) 3535 (ii).
American Goods shipped into Canada, Names of Firms, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Demers) 3533
(ii).
American Shoe Machinery Co., Discontinuance of Proceedings re-. Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 572
(i)	.
See ' United Shoe/
Anderson, Mr., Salary Increase: in Com of Sup., 1013 (i).
Animals destroyed at North Ham, Pet. re Compensation: Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6472 (iv).
Animals Health, Inspection, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6469 (iv).
Annual Drill: in Com. of Sup., 5152 (iii).
Annuities Branch: in Com. of Sup., 688 (i).
Annuities Branch Lecturers, Charges re J. B. Leger, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Turgeon) 1413 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Extra Payment to Agents: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 973 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Transfer to P. 0. Dept., Dismissal of
Agents, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 727 (i).
Anse anx Canards Breakwater, Tenders re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
Anse au Canard Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
Anse a Valeau. Postmistress, Charges re Madame Proulx: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2072
(ii)	.
Antigonish County Public Works Appropriations: Remarks (Mr. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2438 (ii).
Antigonish Harbour Dredging: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2022 (ii). Antigonish to Country Harbour Ry. Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. on Ry. Bill, 6227 (iv).
See ' Railways/
Apples and Fruit Growers' Association, N.S., Resolutions re Industry: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 1719 (i).
Appropriations omitted from Estimates of 1913: M. for Ret. (Mr. Sinclair) 1819 (i). See ' Public Works/
Archamfeault, Mr. Emile, Dismissal re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Seguin) 5957 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 5950
(iv).
Archibald, Mr. P. S., Emiplymt. by Ry. Dept.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 933 (i). Architectural Institute of Can.: See ' B. No. 35/
Archives De.pt.: See ' B. No. 66/
Archives, Dep. Minister: in Com. of Sup., 6460 (iv).
Archives Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 6461 (iv). ' Arctic ' Steamship, Maintenance, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5398 (iii).
Arichat and Canso Mail Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Kyte) in Com. of Sup., 4733 (iii). Arichat, Retaining Wall: in Com. of Sup., 2039 (ii).
Armouries and Public Buildings, Militia: in Com. of Sup., 620 (i).
Armouries: in Com. of Sup., 5541 (iii).
See ' Public Works/
Art Gallery: in Com. of Sup., 2825 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Purchase of Paintings: Ques. (Mr. Alaodonald) 1865 (i).
See ' National Art Gallery/
Asbestos Manufacture Imports, Total Value, &e.: M. for Ret. (Mr. Beland) 1590. 1817
(i).
Ash, Mr. Earl, Claims re Damages for Fire on I.C.R.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Eimnerson) 2346 (ii).
Ash Wednesday, Adjournment for: M. (Air. Borden) 3343 (ii).
Asseliu, Mr. Oliver, Emplymt. by Immigration Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Carvall) 1813 (i). Assent to Bills: See 'Bills/
Athabasca Landing to Grand Prairie Tel.
Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2819 (ii). Athabaska River Landing: in Com. of Sup., 2814 (ii).
Atlantic Coast Surveys: in Com. of Sup., 5399
(iii).
Aud. Gen/s Office, Temporary Clerks: See 'B. No. 113/
Aud. Gen/s Report: Presented (Air. AV. T. White) 970 (i).

[Stage Direction]
Aurora Public Building, Papers, Reports, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Armstrong) 561 (i). Australian Pacific Cable, Proposals re, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 576 (i).
See 'Cable.'
Australian Trade Possibilities: Remarks (Mr. Ames) 1981 (ii).
Automobiles purchased for Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5192 (iii).
See ' Militia.'
Baddeck, Grand Narrows and Iona Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4711 (iii).
Baddeck Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 6658 (iv).
Bait, Cold Storage: in Com. of Sup., 6653 (iv). See 'Fisheries.'
Baldwin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Customs at Coaticooke: M. for Cor. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1361 (i).
Ballots, Voting by Divisions:	Ques. (Mr. Burnham) 4979 (iii).
Bands, and Associations Grants, re Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5528 (iii), 6653 (iv). Banking Act Amt. Bill (Mr. Demers) on M.
to introduce (Mr. Speaker) 407 (i).
Bank Act (extension of charters) Amt.: See ' B. No. 169.'
Banking Act, Legislation re-. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1820 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 938
(i).
Barcelona Tramway, Light and Power Co., Ltd.: See ' B. No. 36.'
Bars®, Mr. Arohibald, Dismissal, &e.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6784 (iv).
Bassano Post Office, Pet. re-. Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 5557 (iv).
Bath Postmistress, Dismissal: in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pug'sley) 966 (i).
See ' Boham.'
Bathurst Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2363 (ii).
Battlefields Commission: M. (Mr. White) to strike out vote, 5299 (iii).
Babtleford Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2204 (id).
Bayfield Breakwater1: Remarks (Mr. Wm.
Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2041 (ii). Beauchemin, J. A., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boivin) 3337 (ii).
Beauchesne, Mr., Dismissal from Customs: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 3151 (ii).
Beaumont Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2366 (ii). Beaver Bank Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 6286 (iv).
Bedford Mail Contract, Cancellation of: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Bedford Postmaster, Dismissal: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Kay) 5161 (iii).
See ' Jones.'
Belanger, Amedee, Dismissal from I. C. Ry.: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3050 (ii).
Benoit, Mr. Joseph, Complaints re Suspension, &c.: M. for Cor* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1817 (i).
[Stage Direction]
* Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in
Com. of Sup., 4184 (iii).
Bergeron, Mr. J. G. H., Apptmt. as Commissioner of Inquiry: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2062 (ii).
See ' Dismissals.'
Moosejaw P.   O.@: Clock: Remarks (Mr. Clare) in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i).
Berthier-en-Haut Post Office, Purchase, Repairs, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Barrette) 1409 (i).


XCV1 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 10) Respecting the British Colonial Fire Insurance Company.-(Mr. Co-derre).
I0*, 643; 2°*, 1120; in Com., and 3°*, 1577
(i)	.
Bill (No. 11) Respecting the Canadian Birk-beck Investment and Savings Company, and to change its name to The Canadian Mortgage Investment Company.-(Mr. Osier).
1°, 643, 2°*, 1120 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2061
(ii)	.
Bill (No. 12) Respecting the Erie, London and Tilsonburg Railway Company.-(Mr. Clarke, Essex).
1°, 643 ; 2°*, 1120 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2015 (ii).
Bill (No. 13) To incorporate the Liverpool-Manitoba Assurance Comjrany.-(Mr. Bickerdike).
1°, 643 ; 2°*, 795 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2062
(ii).
Bill (No. 14) To incorporate the North Arm Bridge and Railway Company.-(Mr. Stevens).
1°, 643 ; 2°*, 1530 (i).
Bill (No. 15) To incorporate the Vancouver Life Insurance Company, of Vancouver, B.C.-(Mr. Stevens).
1°, 643; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2062 (ii).
Bill (No. 16) Respecting certain Patents of Thomas Wadge.-(Mr. Aikins).
1°, 643 ; 2°*, 1200 (i); in Com., 2854, 2983, 3280; 3°*, 3283 (ii).
Bill (No. 17) To amend the Dominion Elections Act.-(Mr. Macdonell).
1°, 644 (i).
Bill (No. 18) For granting to His Majesty certain sums of money for the Public Service for the financial year ending the 31st March, 1912.-(Mr. White, Lee'ds).
In Com. on Ways and Means, 702, 1°*, 2°* in Com., and 3°*, 703 (i).
Bill (No. 19) To amend the Inquiries Act.- (Mr. Doherty).
1°, 710; 2m., 1021; ruling, 1281; 2° and in Com., 1283, 1318, 1414 ; 3°*, 1494 (i).
Bill (No. 20) Respecting the Grand Trunk Pacific Railway Company.- (Mr. Macdonald) .
M. for leave to introduce, 711; 10#, 713; 2°, 795; in Com., and S0#, 797 (i).
Bill (No. 21) Respecting the National Transcontinental Railway.-(Mr. Cochrane).
1°*, 713; 2°*, in Com., and 3°*, 797 (i).
Bill (No. 22) Respecting the Dominion Atlantic Railway Company.-(Mr. Jameson).
10#, 794: 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., 2011; 3°*, 2012 (ii).
Bill (No. 23) Respecting the Harbour of Hamilton.-(Mr. Stewart, Hamilton).
1°*, 794 ; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., 2449; in Com., and 3°*, 3672 (ii).
Bill (No. 24) Respecting the Montreal Terminal Railway Company.-(Mr. Coderre).
1°*, 794; 2°*, 1121 (i).
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 25) Respecting the Ottawa Northern and Western Railway Company.- (Mr. Pripp).
I0*, 794; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., and 3°*. 2015 (ii).
Bill (No. 26) To incorporate the Saskatchewan Life Insurance Company.-(Mr. McKay).
1°*, 794; 2°*, 1121; in Com., and 3°*, 1577
(i).
Bill (No. 27) Respecting the Security Life Insurance Company of Canada.-(Mr. Coderre).
1°*, 794 ; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2062 (ii).
Bill (No. 28) Respecting the West Ontario Pacific Railway Company.-(Mr. Nesbitt).
1°*, 795 ; 2°*, 1121 (i); m Com., and 30#, 2015 (ii).
Bill (No. 29) Respecting the Dominion Guarantee Company, Limited, and to change its name to the Dominion Gresham Guarantee and Casualty Company.-(Mr. Barker).
1°*, 795; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2449 (ii).
Bill (No. 30) Respecting the Montreal, Ottawa and Georgian Bay Canal Company. -(Mr. White, Renfrew).
1°*, 795; 2°*, 1121 (i); in Com., 4699; 3°*, 4701 (iii).
Bill (No. 31) To amend the Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act, 1899.-(Mr. Hazen).
1°, 869; 2°, 1025; in Com., 1032; 3°, 1709 (i).
Bill (No. 32) Respecting Grain.-(Mr. Foster).
Res. prop., 793, 869; in Com. on Res., 870; 1°* of Bill, 874 (i); 2°, 2161; in Com., 2179, 2186, 2302, 2382, 2535, 2560, 2755, 3156, 3451, 3491, 3630, 3757 (ii); 4042, 4153, 4787; 3°m., 4788; agreed to, 4835 (iii).
Bill (No. 33) Respecting the Alberta Electric Railway Company, and to change its name to ' The Alberta Interurban Railway Company/-(Mr. Bennett, Calgary).
1°*, 969; 2°*, 1200 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2015 (ii).'
Bill (No. 34) Respecting the Algoma Eastern Railway Company.-(Mr. Boyce).
1°*, 969 ; 2°** 1200 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2015 (ii).
Bill (No. 35) Respecting the Architectural Institute of Canada.-(Sir Edmund Osier).
1°*, 969; 2°*, 1530 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2449 (ii).
Bill (No. 36) Respecting Barcelona Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited, and to change its name to ' Barcelona Tramway, Light and Power Company, Limited/-(Mr. Macdonell).
1°*, 969 ; 2°*, 1201 (i); in Com., 2410; 3°* 2413 (ii).
Bill (No. 37) Respecting the Calgary and Fernie Railway Company.-(Mr. Good-eve).
1°*, 970 ; 2°*, 1201 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2015 (ii).

[Stage Direction]
xcvii
BILLS-Con.
BILLS-Con.
Bill (N°. 38) Respecting the Canadian Northern Railway Company.-(Mr. Staples).
1 #, 970 ; 2°* 1318 (i); in Com., 5201; 3°*, 5202 (iii).
(No. 39) Respecting the Canadian Northern Montreal Tunnel and Terminal ComPany>
Limited.-(Mr. Guilbault).
1°* 970; 2°*, 1201 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 4701 (iii).
Bill (No. 40) Respecting the Canadian Nor them Ontario Railway Company.-(Mr. Currie).
1°*, 970; 2°*, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2415 (ii).
41L Respecting the Canadian .Northern Quebec Railway Company.-(Mr. Guilbault).
l0*>
fO.i. 2°*>
1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2415 (11).
Blllw 421 Respecting the Canadian Northern Ontario Railway Company and the Carillon and Grenville Railway Company.-(Mr. Achim).
I0*, 970; 2°* 1201 (i).
Bill (No. 43) Respecting the Cap de -la Mag-deleme Railway Company.-(Mr. Pa-
1°*'	. 2°*>
1201 (i); in Com., 2012- 3°*,
<sU15 (n).
Bill (No. 44) Respecting the Central Raill-,a970?^*,al[20MO 'Jnada-(Mr- Baker)'
BB1 (No. 45) Respecting La Compagnie du Lhemin de fer de Colonisation du Nord -(Mr. Achim).
X°01201 (d)< ia Com- -and 3«, 2015 (n).
Bill (No. 46) Respecting the Dominion Trust Company, and to change its nome to British Empire Trust Company.'-(Mr Cromwell).	v
10Ioo!7?-'

\2°' 1201 iQ Com- -and 3° 4237 (ill).
BIB (N-o. 47) Respecting the Hamilton, Waterloo and Guelph Railway Company.-(Mr. Barker).
10LF?.N2°* ,1201 Ws ^ Com., and 3°*, 2415 (n).
BdB*i?°h 1®) R^sPe°tin& the Kootenay and Alberta Railway Company.-(Mr. Co-derre).
'"'ii™;.,2*. 1318 (i); in- Com., and 3°*, 3415 (n).
Bill (No. 49) Respecting the Montreal Cem-tral Terminal Company.-(Mr. Ames)
1°*, 870; 2°*, 1318 (d); in- Com., and 3°*, 2415 (ii).
Bill (No. 50) Respecting the Ontario and Ottawa Railway Company.-(Mr. Currie)
1°*, 970; 2°#, 1318 (i); in Com., 2413- 3°m. 2414; 3°*, 2784 (ii).	'
Bill (No. 51) Respecting the Pacific -amd Atlantic Railway Company.-(Mr. Bovce)
4°*, 970; 2°*, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2015 (ii).
Bill (No. 52) To incorporate the Pacific Trans-Canada and Hudson Bay Railway Company.-(Mr. Martin, Regina).
1°*. 970; 2°*, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°* 3284 (ii).
G
Bill (No. 53) Respecting certain Patents of Edmund P. Piper.-(Mr. Pripp).
1°*, 970 ; 2°m., 1201; 2°*, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 2449 (ii).
Bill (No. 54) To incorporate the Quinze River and Ottawa Railway Company.- (Mr. Brabazon).
1°*, 970; 2°*, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 4171 (iii).
Bill (No. 55) Respecting certain Patents of Thomas D. Rambaut.-(Mr. Ames).
1°*, 970; 2°* 1530 (i).
Bill (No. 56) Respecting the South Ontario Pacific Railway Company.-(Mr. Nesbitt).
1°*, 970; 2°#, 1318 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 57) Respecting the Union B-ank of Canada.-(Mr. Barker).
1°*, 970; 2°*, 1318 (i); -i-n Com., and 3"*, 2062 (ii).
Bill (No. 58) Respecting the Department of External Affairs.-(Mr. Borden).
1°, 971; 2°*, 1434; in Com., and 30#, 1434
. *>[DOT]
Bill (No. 59) To amend the Patent Act.- (Mr. Macdonell).
1°, 1020 (i).
Bill (No. 60) To amend the Civil Service Act-(Mr. Borden).
Res. Prop., 1018; in Com. on Res., 1032; 1°* of B., 1033 ; 2° and in Com., 1434 (i); 3343, 3540; 3°*, 3631 (ii).
Bill (No. 6-1) Respecting the Gatineau and U-ngava Railway Company, and to change its name to The Ottawa and Un-gava Railway Company.-(Mr. Chahot).
1°*. 1069: 2°*, 1530 (i); in C-om., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 62) Respecting the Kettle Valley Railway Company.-(Mr. Goodeve).
1°*, 1069 ; 2°*, 1530 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 63) To incorporate the Premier Lite Jnisninan)oe Company.-(Mr. Bennett, Calgary).
1°*, 1069 ; 2°*, 1530 (i); in Com., amd 3°* 2449 (ii).
Bill (No. 64) To amend the Navigable Waters Protection Act.-(Mr. Bradbury)
1°, 1069 (i).
Bill (No. 65) To correct certain Clerical Errors in the French Version -of the Revised Statutes, 1906.-(Mr. Doherty).
1°, 1197; 2° and in Com., 1438- 3°* 1440 (i).	'
Bill (No. 66) Respecting the Public Archives. -(Mr. Borden).
In Com. on Res., 1282; 1°# of B., 1282 - 2° 1440; in Com., 1494; 3°*, 1713 (i).
Bill (No. 67) Respecting the Interprovincial and James Bay Railway Company.-(Mr White, Renfrew).
1°*, 1409; 2°*, 1577 (i); in Com., and 3°* 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 68) Respecting Queen's College at Kingston, and to change its name to ' Queen's University at Kingston.'-(Mr. Nickle).
I0*, 1410 (i); 2°*, 2560; Remarks, 3730, 3873; in Com., 3874 (ii), 4237, 4745; 3° 4869 (iii); Sen. Amts., 6770 (iv).
xcviii
[Stage Direction]
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 69) To incorporate Queen's Theological College.-(Mr Nickle).
1°* 1410 (i); 20#, 2560 (n); in Com., 4237, 4775; 3°*, 4869 <iii).
Bill (No. 70) To incorporate the Roman Catholic Episcopal Corporation of Kee-watin.-(Mr. McKay).	,	0#
1°*, 1410; 2°*, 1577 (i); m Com., and 3°*, 3672 (ii).
Bill (No. 71) Respecting a certain patent of the Spirella Company of Canada, Limited.-(Mr. German).
I0*, 1410; 2°*, 1577 (i); m Com., and 3 *, 2449 (ii).	.
Bill (No. 72) To incorporate the Sterling Life Assurance Company of Canada.- (Mr. Blain).
1°*, 1410; 2°*, 1577 (i); in Com., 2448 ; 3 *, 2559 (ii).
Bill (No. 73) Respecting the Vancouver Island and Eastern Railway Company.- (Mr. Barnard).
I0*, 1410; 2°*, 1577 (i); in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 74) Respecting the use of Flags.- (Mr. Bradbury).
1°, 1411 (i).
Bill (No. 75) To amend the Senate and House of Commons Act.-(Mr. Doherty). Res. prop., 1414; in Com. on Res., 1497; 1°* of B„ 1498; 2° and in Com., 1713; 3°*, 1714 (i).
Bill (No. 76) To amend The National Transcontinental Railway Act.-(Mr. Cochl°^ai571; 2° and in Com., 1866 (i); 3126, 3364; 3°*, 3539 (ii).
Bill (No. 77) To Encourage and Assist the Improvement of Highways.-(Mr. Coch-
1°. 1571 (i); 2°, 3633; in Com., 3667, 3672, 3946 (ii); 3°, 4140 (iii); Sen. Amts., 6397, 6731 (iv).
Bill (No. 78) To amend the Inspection and Sale Act.-(Mr. Foster).
In Com. on Res., 1839; 1°* of B„ 1839 (i); 2° and in Com., 6188, 6678; 3°*, 6680 (iv). Bill (No. 79) Respecting the Alberta Railway and Irrigation Company-(Mr. Buchanan).	_	, „„„1°*, 1862 (i); 2°*, 2186; m Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).	,	„	. .	„
Bill (No. 80) Respecting the Dominion Trust Company, Limited, and to change its name to Dominion Trust Company.- (Mr. Macdonell).
1°* 1862 (i); 2°*. 2062 (ii); in Com., 4237; 3°*, 4238 (iii).	,
Bill (No. 81) To incorporate the High River, Saskatchewan and Hudson Bay Railway Company.-(Mr. Martin, Regina).
1°*, 1862 (i); 2°*, 2186; in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).	,	,, ,T ,,Bill (No. 82) To incorporate the Northern Territorial Railway	Company.-(Mr. McKay).	. _	, 00*
1°*, 1862 (i); 2°*, 2415; m Com., and 3U*,
3284 (")[DOT]	,,	„ , , ,
Bill (No. 83) Respecting the Saskatchewan Power Company.-(Mr. McKay).
I0*, 1862 (i); 2°*, 2186; m Com., and 3°*. 8672 (ii).
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 84) Respecting certain Patents of Thomas D. Rambaut.-(Mr. Ames).
1°*, 1862 (i); 2°*, 2186; in Com., 2855, 2985, 3280, 3284, 3332, 3479; 3°* 3491 (ii).
Bill (No. 85) To amend the Lord's Day Act. -(Mr. Verville).
1°, 2057 (ii).
Bill (No. 86) To amend the Railway Act.- (Mr. Macdonell).
1°, 2058 (ii).
Bill (No. 87) To amend the Industrial Disputes Investigation Act,	1907.-(Mr. Macdonell).
1°, 2058 (ii).
Bill (No. 88) To provide for the appointment of a Tariff Commission.-(Mr. White, Leeds).
Res. prop., 1839 (i); in Com. on Res., 2157; 1°* of B., 2161; 2°m„ 2591, 2668; Amt. (Mr. Guthrie) 2614, Neg. (Y. 52; N. 104) 2752; in Com., 2862, 2939, 2994, 3540 (ii), 4079 ; 3° m., 4144 (iii); Sen. Amts., 6663, 6808 (iv).
Bill (No. 89) To incorporate the Bank of Saskatchewan.-(Mr. Knowles).
I0*, 2216; 2°*, 2415; in Com., and 30#, 2854
(ii).
Bill (No. 90) Respecting the Esqnimalt and Nanaimo Railway Company.-(Mr. Clements).
1°*, 2216; 20#, 2415; in Com., and 3°*, 3284
(ii).
Bill (No. 91) Respecting the Kootenay Central Railway Company.-(Mr. Clements ) 1°*, 2217; 2°*, 2415; in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 92) Respecting the Manitoba and North Western Railway Company of Canada.-(Mr. Cash).
1°*, 2217. 2°*, 2415; in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 93) Respecting the United Gold Fields of British Columbia (Limited).- (Mr. Buchanan).
1°*, 2217; 2°*, 2415; in Com., and 3°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 94) Respecting the Windsor, Chatham and London Railway Company.- (Mr. Wilcox.)
1°*, 2217; 2"*, 2784 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 4171 (iii).
Bill (No. 95) Respecting the National Transcontinental Railway. - (Mr. White, Leeds).
Res. prop., 2296; in Com. on Res., 2378; 1 of B. 2381; 2°, 3060; in Com., and 3°*, 3126 (ii).
Bill (No. 96) To amend the Manitoba Grain Act.-(Mr. Foster, Toronto).
Res. prop., 793 (i); in Com. on Res., 2405; 1°*, of B., 2°*, and in Com., 2406 ; 3°, 2575 (ii).
Bill (No. 97) To provide for further Advan ces to the Harbour Commissioners of Montreal-(Mr. Hazen.)
Res. prop., 2205; M. for Com. on Res., 2406 , 2415; in Com. on Res., 2420; 1° of B., 2420 ; 2°*, in Com., and 3°*, 3<632 (ii).

[Stage Direction]
xcix
BILLS-Cora.
Bili (No. 98) Respecting the Canadian Pacific Railway	Company.-(Mr.	Mc-
Craney).
3284 (")5 in Com., 5198; 3"*
5201 (ill).
Bill (No. 99) Respecting the Ottawa, Montreal and Eastern Railway Company.- (Mr. Bickerdike).
1°#, 2664; 2°*, 3284 (ii); in Com., and 3°* 4171 (iii).	'
Bill (No. 100) For the Aid and Encouragement of Agriculture.-(Mr. Burrell).
1° m„ 2849 (ii); 2° and in Com., 5277 (iii); 3° m., 5561 (iv).
Bill (No. 101, from the Senate) To incorporate the British Western Loan Company-(Mr. Martin, Regina).
1°*, 3049 ; 2°*, 3284 (ii).
Bill (No. 102, from the Stuaiel For the Relief of Edna Wells.-(Mr. Beattie).
1°*, 3049; 2°*, 3285; in Com., and 3°*, 3672
(ii).
Bill (No. 103) To amend the Government Works Tolls Act.-(Mr. Monk).
1°, 3049 ; 2° and in Com., 3450 ; 3°*, 3539
(ii).
Bill (No. 104) To amend the Civil Service Act.-(Mr. Borden).
Res. prop., 2862; in Com. on Res., 3143; 1°* of B., 3146; 2°, 3347; in Com., 3349; 3°*, 3539 (ii).
Bill (No. 105) To amend the Post Office Act.-(Mr. Pelletier).
Res. prop., 3056; in Com. on Res., 3154; 1°* of B., 3155; 2°, 3349; m Com., 3355; 3°*, 3364 (ii).	'
Bill (No. 106) To amend the Civil Service Act.-(Mr. Pelletier).
Res. prop., 3056; in Com. on Res., 3155; 1° of B., 3155 (ii); 2° and in Com., 4782, 5264 ; 3°*, 5268 (iii).
Bill (No. 107, from the Senate) Respecting
the Pollution of Navigable Waters._______
(Mr. Bennett, Simcoe).
1°*, 3449 (ii).
Bill (No. 108, from the Senate) Respecting The Trust and Loan Company of Canada.-(Mr. Baker).
1°*, 3349; 2°*, 3672 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 4237 (iii).
Bill (No. 109, from the Senate) For the relief of Herbert Horsfall.-(Mr. Kay).
1°*. 3449; 2°*, 3672 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 4701 (iii).
Bill (No. 110, from the Senate) For the relief of Kenneth Molson.-(Mr. Rhodes).
1°*, 3449 ; 2°*, 3672 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 4701 (iii).
Bill (No. Ill) To authorize the payment of a subsidy to the Collingwood ShipBuilding Company, Ltd.-(Mr. Monk).
Res. prop., 3343; in Com. on Res., 3450; 1°* of B„ 3451; 2°, 3633; in Com., and 3°*, 3633 (ii).
Bill (No. 112, from the Senate) For the relief of James Denny.-(Mr. Aikine).
1°*, 3630 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 4701 (iii).
Gi
BILLS-Cora.
Bill (No. 113) To amend the Civil Service Act.-(Mr. White, Leeds).
Res. prop., 3539; in Com. on Res., 3632; 1°* of B., 3633 (ii); 2° and in Com., 4081: 3°*, 4082 (iii).
Bill (No. 114, from the Senate) To incorporate Reviillon Freres Trading Company, Limited.-(Mr. Barker).
1°*, 3828 (ii); 2°*, 4171; in Com., 5202 ; 3°*, 5304 (iii).
Bill (No. 115) To provide for the Extension of th© Boundaries of the Province of Manitoba.-(Mr. Borden).
Res. prop., 3538; in Com. on Res., 3835; 1° of B„ 3898 (ii); 2°m., 4263, 4353; Amt. (Sir Wilfrid Lauriier) 6 m. h„ 3886 4375 [DOT] Amt. Neg. (Y. 65; N. 103) 4395 ; 2° resmd'. 4397, 4461; agreed to (Y. 114; N. 76 ) 4495in Corn., 4496, 4584, 4656, 4701, 4836 ; 3°m.' 4838; Amt. (Mr. Motndou) Separate Schools, 4839; Neg. (Y. 24; N. 160 ) 4925; Amt. (Mr. Beland) 4934; Neg. (Y. 53: N. 108) 4973 ; 3° agreed to, 4974 (iii).
Bill (No. 116) To amend the Civil Service Act.-(Mr. Reid, Grenville).
Res. prop., 3829, in Corn, on Res. 3971; j B., 3972 (ii); 2°, 4563; in Com., 4564; 30#, 4787 (iii).
Bill (Ko. 117, from the Senate) To change the name of Ezra Butler Eddy Bessey.- (Mr. Fripp.)	J J
1 , 4139; 2°, 4238; in Com. and 3°* 4701
(m).
Bill (No. 118) To create the Biological Board of Canada.-(Mr. Hazen).
1°, 4037; 2° and in Com., 4551- 3°* 4555 (111); Sen. Arndts., 5690 (iv).	'
Bill (No. 119, from the Senate) Respecting certain Patents of the Continental Can Company.-(Mr. Fripp).
1°*, 4236 ; 2°, 4395; in Corn., 5204 5483 (iii) -5903; in Com., and 3°*, 5947 (iv).	'
BiB (No 120 from the Senate) For the relief of Ethel May Stewart.-(Mr. Clark).
1° , 4237 ; 2°*, 4397; in Com., and 3°* 5259
. (in).
Bill (No. 121, from the Senate) Respecting
,fch'9 tunny Riy©r Ra-dial Railway Compuny.-(Mr. Beattie).
1°*, 4457; 2°*, 4701; in Com., 5198- 3°* 5198 (iii).
Bill (No. 122, from the Senate) For the relief of William Holloway Adams.-(Mr. MacNutt).
1°* 4457 ; 2°*, 4701; in Com., and 3°*, 5259
(in).
Bill (No. 123) To .amend the Yukon Act.- (Mr. Doherty).
Res. prop., 3630 (ii); in Com. on Res.. 45551 of B., 4563 ; 2° and in Com., 5405'
(iii); 5567; 3°*, 5571 (iv).
Bill (No. 124) Respecting the Civil Service -(Mr. Pelletier).
Ros. prop., 4042; in Com. on Res., 4583; 1°# of B., 4584; 2°*, in Com., and 3°*, 4787 (iii).
Bill (No. 125, from the Senate) To incorporate the Western Dominion Railway Company.-(Mr. Martin, Regina).
1°*, 4835; 2"*, 5259 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5911 (iv).
c
[Stage Direction]
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 126, from tlie Senate) To incorporate the Universal Eyesight Insurance Company.-(Mr. McLean, Queens).
1°* 4835 ; 2°*, 5259 (iii); in Com., 5907, 5940; 3°*, 5942 (iv).
Bill (No. 127, from the Senate) To incorporate the Canadian Public Health Association.-(Mr. Schafiner).
1°*, 4835; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3 ,
5947	(iv).
Bill (No. 128, from the .Senate) To incorporate the Montreal Transcontinental Kailway Company.-(Mr. Coderre).
I0*, 4835; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Corn., and 3° [DOT]
5948	(iv).
Bill (No. 129, from the Senate) Bespecting the Alberta, Peace River and Eastern Railway Company.-(Mr. Chabot).
,1°*, 4835; 2°#, 5260 (iii); in Com., 5904, 5942; 3°#, 5946 (iv).
Bill (No. 130, from the Senate) Respecting the Grand Trunk Railway Company of Canada.-(Mir. Currie).
1°*, 4835 ; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., 5947, 6563, 6749; 3°*, 6769 (iv).
Bill (No. 131, from the Senate) For the relief of Ieabell Isaac.-(Mr. MacNutt). 1°*, 4835; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5948 (iv).
Bill (No. 132, from the Senate) Respecting Mexican Interurban Electric Traction Company, Limited, and to change its name to Mexican Inherturban Electric Railway Company, Limited.-(Mr. Mac-donell).
1°*, 4835; 2°*, 5260 (ii); in Com., and 3°*, 5948 (iv).
Bill (No. 133, from the .Senate) Respecting the Methodist Church.-(Mr. Aikins). 1°*, 4975; 2°#, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5948 (iv).
Bill (No. 134, from the Senate) Respecting the British Columbia and Dawson Railway Company.-(Mr. Goodeve).
1°* 4976; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3°#, 5911 (iv).
Bill (No. 135, from tbe Senate) Respecting the Vancouver, Fraser Valley and Sou therm Railway Company.-(Mr. Stevens).
1°*, 4976; 2°*,-5260 (iii); in Com., ,and 3°*, 591,1 (iv).
Bill (No. 136, from the Senate) To incorporate the Prince Edward and Hastings Railway Company.-(Mr. Hephurn).
1°*, 4976 ; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5911 (iv).
Bill (No. 137). To amend the Volunteer Bounty Act, 1908.-(Mr. Rogers).
1° 4974 (iii); 2°, 5968; in Com., 6176, 6450; 3°*, 6454 (iv).
Bill (No. 138) To incorporate the Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commissioners.-(Mr. Hazen).
1°, 4976 (iii); 2° and in Com., 5988 ; 3°*, 6062 (iv). '
Bill (No. 139, from the Senate) To incorporate the Ottawa and Lake McGregor Railway Company.-(Mr. Devlin).
2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5911 (iv).
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 140) To amend the Fisheries Act. -(Mr. Hazen).	__
1°, 5053; 2°, 5271; in Com., 5276 ; 30#, 5277
(iii).
Bill (No. 141, from the Senate) To incorporate The Interprovincial Fire Insurance Company.-(Mr. Lesperance). I0*, 5156; 2°*, 5260 (iii); in Com. ,and 3°*, 5911 (iv).
Bill (No. 142, from the Senate) For the relief of Alvena Bell Leaitch.-(Mr. Macdonald).
1°* 5156; 2°*, 5260 (in); m Com., and 3°*,
5947	(iv).	_	.
Bill (No. 143) To amend the Canada Shipping
Act.-(Mr. Hazen).
Res. prop., 5156; in Com. on Res., 5161; 1°* of B., 5161; 2° and in Com., 5400 ; 3°*, 5404 (iii).
Bill (No. 144) Respecting Aid toward the construction of the Canadian Northern Alberta Railway.-(Mr. White, Leeds). Res. prop., 4140; in Com; on Res., 5162; 1°* of B., 5166; 2° and in Com., 5404; 3°*, 5405 (iii).
Bill (No. 145, from the Senate) To ratify and confirm certain Agreements between tbe Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Railway Commission and the Grand Trunk Railway Company.-(Mr. Currie). 1°*, 5257; 2°*, 5484 (iii); in Com., 5947, 6769; 3°*, 6770 (iv).
Bill (No. 146, from the Senate) Respecting the Saskatchewan Central Railway Company.-(Mr. Martin, Regina).
I0*, 5257; 2°*, 5484 (iii); in Com., and 3 ,
5948	(iv).
Bill (No. 147, from the Senate) For the relief of Isabella Helen Horncastle.- (Mr. Clark, Red Deer).
1°* 5257 ; 2°*, 5484 (in); m Com., and 3 , mi (iv).
Bill (No. 148, from tbe Senate) To incor-corporate International Guarantee Company.-(Mr. McCraney)_.
1°*, 5257; 2°*, 5484 (iii); m Com., and 3 , 5947 (iv). .	.
Bill (No. 149) Respecting "Water in tbe Railway Belt and Peace River Block of Lana. -(Mr. Rogers).	„„„„
1° 5257 (iii); 2° aud in Com., 5968, 61(5; 3 in., 6188, 6338, 6401 (iv).
Bill (No. 150) Respecting the Harbour Commissioners of Montreal.-(Mr. Mazen).
1° 5258 (iii); 2° and in Com., 5690; A , 5960 (iv).
Bill (No. 151) To extend tbe Boundaries of the Province of Quebec.-(Mr. Borden). Res. prop., 3944 (ii); in Com. on Res., 5268; 1°* of B., 5270 (iii); 2° and m Com., 6160, 3°, 6188, 6338 (iv).
Bill (No. 152) To extend the Boundaries of the Province of Ontario.-(Mr. Borden). Res. prop., 3944 (ii); in Com. on Res., 5270; 1°* of B., 5271 (iii); 2°, 6155; m Com., 6155; 3°*, 6188 (iv).
Bill (No. 153, from the Senate) For the relief of George MacKay Sutherland - (Mr. MacNutt).
1°*, 5400; 2°*, 5484 (iii); m Com., and 3 *, 5947 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
ci
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 151, from the Senate) To incorporate The Guarantee Life Insurance Company of Canada.-(Mr. MacNutt).
1°*, 5400; 2°*, 5181 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5948 (iv).
Bill (No. 155, from the Senate), To incorporate the British American Trust Company.-(Mr. Blain).
1°*, 5100; 2°*, 5181 (iii); in Com., 5916; 3°*, 5917 (iv).
Bill (No. 156) To amend the Judges Act.- (Mr. Doherty).
In Com. on Res., 5107, 5958; 1°* of B„ 5115 (iii); 2° and in Com., 6000 ; 3° m., 6062 (iv).
Bill (No. 157, from the Senate) Respecting the Subsidiary High Court of the Ancient Order of Foresters in the Dominion of Canada.-(Mr. Macdonell).
1°*, 5550 (iii); 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6770 (iv).
Bill (No. 158, from the Senate) To incorporate the Grand Lodge of the Loyal Order of Moose in the Dominion of Canada.-(Mr. Macdonell).
1°*, 5550 (iii); 2°*, 5903; in Com., 6126; 3°*, 6127 (iv).
Bill (No. 159, from the Senate) Respecting the Mexico Northwestern Transportation Company, Limited, and to change its name to Mexico Northwestern Pacific Railway Company.-(Mr. Macdonell).
[DOT]	g0*, 5550 (iii); in Com., and 3°*, 5918
(iv).
Bill (No. 160, from the Senate) Respecting Alabama Traction, Light and Power Company, Limited.-(Mr. Macdonell).
I0*, 2°*, 5550 (in); in Com., and 3°*, 5918
(iv).
Bill (No. 161, from the Senate) Respecting the Ottawa, Brockville and St. Lawrence Railway Company.-(Mr. Fripp).
1°*, 5550 (iii); 2°*, 5903; in Com., 6127; 3°*,
6127	(iv).
Bill (No. 162, from the Senate) For the relief of William Alexander Hunt Jenkins.-(Mr. Beattie).
I0*, 5550 (iii); 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*,
6128	(iv).
Bill (No. 163, from the Senate) For the relief of Edith Harriet Duffy.-(Mr. Wallace).
I0*, 5519 (iii); 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 164, from the Senate) For the relief of John Angus Kennedy.-(Mr. Mc-Craney).
10#, 5550 (iii); 2°*	5903; in Com., and
3"*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 165) To amend the Criminal Code. -(Mr. Doherty).
1°, 5549 ; 2° and in Com., 5862; 3°m„ 5892, 5960 (iv).
Bill (No. 166) To amend the Prisons and Reformatories Act.-(Mr. Doherty).
1°, 5552; 2° and in Com., 5892; 3°*, 5893 (iv).
Bill (No. 167) Respecting the Incorporation of Live Stock Record Associations.- (Mr. Burrell).
1°, 5553 ; 2°, 6021; in Com., 6023 ; 3°*, 6062 (iv).
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 168) To amend the Exchequer Court Act.-(Mr. Doherty).
1°, 5553 ; 2° and in Com., 5893 ; 3°*, 5894 (iv).
Bill (No. 169) To amend the Bank Act.- (Mr. White, Leeds).
1°, 5555; 2° and in Com., 5846; 3°*, 5859 (iv).
Bill (No. 170) To amend the Quebec Savings Bank Act.-(Mr. White, Leeds).
1°, 5556 ; 2°*, in Com., and 30#, 5859 (iv).
Bill (No. 171) To amend the Militia Act.- (Mr. Hughes, Victoria).
1°, 5556; 2° and in Com., 6061; 30#, 6062 (iv).
Bill (No. 172, from the Senate) Respecting the St. Clair and Erie Ship Canal Company.-(Mr. Lalor).
I0*, 5680; 2°*, 5903; in Com., 6127; 3°*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 173, from the Senate) For the relief of Henry Greek Wills.-(Mr. Beattie).
1°*, 5680 ; 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 174, from the Senate) For the relief of Keitha Seeley.-(Mr. Wallace).
1°#, 5831; 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 175, from the Senate) For the relief of David George Davidson.-(Mr. Lennox).
1°*. 5831; 2°* 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 176, from the Senate) To consolidate and amend the Acts relating to the Dominion Gresham Guarantee and Casualty Company.-(Mr. Barker).
I0*, 5831; 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°*, 6128
(iv).	.
Bill (No. 177, from the Senate) To incorporate Capital Trust Corporation, Limited.-(Mr. Tobin).
1°*, 5831; 2°*, 5903; in Com., and 3°#, 6128 (iv).
Bill (No. 178) To provide an additional Annual Grant to the Province of Prince Edward Island.-(Mr. White, Leeds).
Res. prop., 5558; in Com. on Res., 5859; 1°* of B., 5862; 2° and in Com., 6114, 6128; 3°*, 6154 (iv).
Bill (No. 179) To amend the Civil Service Act.-(Mr. Pelletier).
Res. prop., 5680; in Com. on Res., 5921; 1°* of B.. 5921; 2° and in Com., 6083; 3°*, 6114 (iv).
Bill (No. 180) To amend the Dry Dock Subsidies Act, 1910.-(Mr. Monk).
Res. prop., 5559; in Com. on Res., 6047; 1°* of B„ 5939; 2° and in Com., 6201; 3°*, 6203 (iv).
Bill (No. 181) To amend the Yukon Placer Mining Act.-(Mr. Rogers).
1°, 5939; 2°, 6181; in Com., 6182; 3°*, 6182 (iv).
Bill (No. 182) Respecting the Government House property, Toronto.-(Mr. Doherty).
In Com. on Res., 5957; 1° of B., 5957; 2° and in Com., 6181; 3°*, 6181 (iv).
cii
[Stage Direction]
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 183) To authorize the granting of Subsidies in aid of the Lines of the Railways and Bridges therein mentioned.-(Mr. Cochrane).
Res. prop., 5681; in Com. on Res., 5894, 5911, 6060; 1°* of B„ 6061; 2° and in Com., 6211, 6304, 6395; 3°m„ 6395 (iv).
Bill (No. 184) Respecting the Imperial Loan and Investment Company of Canada -(Mr. Sharpe, Ontario).
I0*, 6061; 2"*, 6128; in Com., and 3°*, 6770 (iv).
Bill (No. 185) To authorize the sale to the Province of Manitoba of certain Ordnance Lands, in the city of Winnipeg. -(Mr. Hughes, Victoria).
In Com. on Res., 5690, 6064; 1°* of B., 6080; 2° and in Com., 6203 ; 3°*, 6203 (iv).
Bill (No. 186) To authorize the granting of Subsidies to the Government of the Province of Ontario in aid of the construction of the Temiskaming and Northern Ontario Railway.-(Mr. Cochrane).
Res. prop., 5681; in Com. on Res., 6080; 1°* of B„ 6082 ; 2° and in Com., 6401; 3°*, 6449 (iv).
Bill (No. 187) To authorize the granting of a Subsidy to the Canadian Northern Pacific Railway Company, in aid of the construction of the Railway therein mentioned.-(Mr. Cochrane).
Res. prop., 5690; in Com. on Res., 6081; 1°* of B„ 6082 ; 2°m„ 6331; in Com., 6338; 3°, 6495 (iv).
Bill (No. 188) To aid the construction of certain Bridges on the Railway of the Saint John and Quebec Railway Company, and to confirm an agreement between the Company and the Governments of Canada and New Brunswick. -(Mr. Cochrane).
Res. prop., 5691; in Com. on Res., 6083; 1°* of B., 6083 ; 2°, and in Com., 6373; 3°, 6496 (iv).
Bill (No. 189) To aid the construction of the Canadian Northern Alberta Railway.-(Mr. Cochrane).
Res. prop., 5841; in Com. on Res., 6083; 1°* of B., 6083; 2° and in Com., 6372; 3°*, 6373 (iv).
Bill (No. 190) To authorize a Bounty to Volunteers who served the Crown during the Fenian Raids.-(Mr. Hughes, Victoria).
Res. prop., 5558; in Com. on Res., 6083; 1°* of B„ 6083 ; 2° and in Com., 6252, 6454 ; 3°*, 6460 (iv).
Bill (No. 191, from the Senate) To provide for the Incorporation of Railway Companies.-(Mr. Maclean, Halifax).
1°, 6492 (iv).
Bill (No. 192, from the Senate) To incorporate the Ottawa and Lake McGregor Railway Company.-(Mr. Barker).
1°, 6495; 2°, 6576; in Com., and 3°*, 6770 iv).
BILLS-Con.
Bill (No. 193) To grant to His Majesty certain sums of money for the Public Service for the Financial Years ending respectively 31st of March, 1912, and 31st March, 1913.-(Mr. White, Leeds).
In Com. on Ways and Means, 6807; 1°*, 2°*, in Com., and 3°*, 6808 (iv).
Bill (No. 194) To amend an Act of the present Session intituled An Act respecting the Montreal Central Terminal Company.-(Mr. Lennox).
1°, 6577 ; 2° and in Com. 6578; in Com., and 3°*, 6770 (iv).
Bill (No. 195) Respecting the Montreal and Eastern Railway Company.-(Mr. Lennox).
1°, 2°, 6578; in Com., and 3°*, 6770 (iv). Binks, Mr., Promotion to Dead Letter Offices M. for Cor.* (Mr. Henderson) 3946 (ii). Biological Board of Can.: See ' B. No. 118.' Biological Board, Names, Salaries, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Sinclair) 4257 (dii).
Bird Bocks Lighthouse, Drowning of Keeper: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 5258 (iii).
Bisley Rules: See ' N. R. A.'
Blind River Post Office, Change of Name: M. for Coir.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4262 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for Papers (Mr. Sinclair) 5928
(iv).
Blue Rocks Island Breakwater: in Com. of Sup., 2041 (ii).
Board of Management, I. C. R.: in Com. of Sup., 4136 (iii), 5800 (iv).
Bohan, John W., Dismissal from Customs at Bath: Ques. (Mr. Car veil) 3055 (ii).
Boots -and Shoes, Imports and Prices into Canada for 1908-9-10: M. for Ret. (Mr. CarveLl) 1267 (i).
Boucher, Mr. O. F., Pet. re Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Belaud) 975 (i).
Boundary Waters Treaty, Apptmt.: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Pugsley) 2589 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Negotiations re Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 3833 (ii).
See ' Waterways.'
Bounties on .Steel 'and Iron, Administration of Act: in Com. of Sup., 687 (i), 5934 (iv). Bounties on Steel Rods, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Neely) 529 (i).
See ' Steel.'
Bounties to Veterans: See ' B. Nos. 137 & 190.' Bourassa, Capt., Pet. re Dep. Harbour Master: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1814 (i). Bouirgoin, Dismissal, &e.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Leimieux) 5557 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Lemieux) 5259
(iii); 6188 (iv).
Bourque, Geoffrey, Accident on I. C. Ry., Inquiry re M. for Reps.* (Mr. Boulay) 2459
(id).

[Stage Direction]
ciii
Bourque, Geoffrey. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 5610 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Claims re Damages on. I. C. R.: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 2243 (ii).
Boyle, D. R., Fishery Overseer at A rich at, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Kyte) 3945 (ii).
Braine, Dr. Lawrence, Indian Medical Attendant at Chester, N.S. :* Dismissal, &c. Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4976 (iii).
Branch Lines, I C. R.: in Com. of Sup., 622
(i)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Subsidies to &e.: in Com. of Sup., 5618
(iv).
See * I. C. R.J
Bras D'Or Lakes Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4734 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) dm Com. of
Sup., 5936 (iv).
Brazeau, Mr. Emile, Postmaster at Cote Rouge, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 6337 (iv).
Breakwaters, N. S.: Inquiry for Rets. (Mr. Kyte) 4460 (iii).
Brian, Mr., Dismissals for Political Partisanship: Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke) in Com. of Sup., 1077 (i).
Bridge Strengthening I.  C. R.@: in Com of Sup., 4137 (iii).
British Admiralty, Memo re Conference between Can. and Australia, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 559 (i).
British American Trust Co.: See ' B. No. 155.' British Colonial Fire Insurance Co.:	See
' B. No. 10.'
B. C. and Dawson Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 134.' B. C. Boundary Agreement re Subsidy: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 971 (i).
B. C. Fishing Licenses, Transfers, &c.: M.
for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3945 (ii).
B. C. Fishing Rights: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 6277 (iv).
B. C. Herring Fishing, Authority re Close Season: Ques. (Mr. Shepherd) 4256 (iii). B. C. International Boundary Line, Par. from Washington: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 2754
(ii)	.
B. C. Lumber Combine, Challenge of Mr. A.
E. Watts: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 2297 (ii). B. C. Provincial Subsidy, Consultations with other Provs.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 573 (i).	.
B. C. Public Buildings, Generally: in Com. of Sup., 2215 (ii).
B. C. Railway Belt Lands, O. C. re Transfer: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1200 (i). British Empire Trust Co.: See ' B. No. 46.' British Mails, Landing at North Sydney, Tests re: Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 5948 (iv).
' British News,' &c., Purchase by Dept, of Int.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 6660 (iv). See ' Immigration.'
Britiish Preference, Increase of: Ques. (Mr. Bickerdike) 553 (i).
British Western Loiam Co.: See ' B. No. 101.' B. W. India Trade Arrangements, Negotiations re: M. for Papers* (Mr. Murphy) 977
(i)	.
Broderick Post Office, Change of Name: M. for Car.* (Mr. McCraney) 5263 (iii).
See ' St. Aldwyn.'
Bronte Village, Lease of Land, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Henderson) 3151 (ii).
Brown, Wm, Pet. from Dr. E. Montpetit, re Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4977 (iii).

Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4779
(iii)[DOT]
Brown, Mr., M.P., Smuggling: See 'Customs Smuggling.'
Bruce Mines and Algoma Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6314 (iv).
Brymer, Arthur, Eisheiry Officer at Lower L'Ardoise, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3752 (ii).

M. for Papers* (M.r. Kyte) 4781 (iii).
Buck, A. E., Postmaster at Crystal Beach, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. German) 3908
(ii)	, 5960 (iv).
Budget, The (annual statement) 4985:
Debate: (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 5011; (Mr. W. F. Miaclean) 5041; (Mr. Verville) 5056; (Mr. Broder) 5083; (Mr. M. Clark) 5085; (Mr. Lalor) 5070; (Mr. Oliver) 5093; (Mr. Marshall) 5102; (Mr. Burnham) 5101; (Mr. W. H. Sharpe) 5109; (Mr. Cockshutt) 5118
(iii); (Mr. Nesbitt) 5134; (Mt. Bellemare) 5146; (Mt. R. Lanobot) 5147; (Mr. Paquet) 5151; (Mr. M. Martin) 5154 (iii).
Budget: See 'Financial Review.'
Buildings leased by Govt., Rentals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1358 (i).
See ' Public Works.'
Bull, Mr. Robert, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 3338 (ii).
Burke's Head Breakwater: Remarks (Mir. Car-iroll) in Com. of Sup., 2045 (ii).
Burrard Inlet and Tunnel Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6318 (iv).
Burrard Power Co. v. The King, Judgment of Judicial Com.: M. for Copy* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1409 (i).
Business of the House, Morning Sittings: M. (Mt. Borden) 4980 (iii).
See ' Govt. Business,' &c.
Cabinet, Constitution of: Remarks in Debate on Address (Mr. Borden) 56 (i).
Cabinet Dissensions: Remarks in Debate on Address (Mr. Monk) 233 (i).



Cabinet Ministers from Quebec, Stmnt. by Hon. Mr. Monk: Ques. (Mr. Murpby) 526
(i)
See ' Ministers/ ' Que. Minister.'
Cable Bates Exchange: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Le-mieux) 5557 (iv).
Cable Rates to G. B. on M. for Sup.: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 3237 (ii).

Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker)
3237 (fi).

Res. on Order Paper, Withdrawal of:
Remarks (Mr. Borden) 3448; M. (Mr. Armstrong) 3448 (ii).

Parcel Post, &c.: M. (Mr. Armstrong)
to Com. of Sup., 4082; Amt. (Mr. Lemieux) 4097; Neg. (Y. 40; N. 70) 4120 (iii).

Papers laid on Table (Mr. Borden) 931
(D-
See ' Australian/ ' Telegraph.'
Cadet Corps, Drill: in Com. of Sup., 5452 (iii). Calgary and Pernie Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 37.' Calgary and Pernie Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6323 (iv).
Calgary Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2204 (ii).
Campaign Literature, Franking: See 'Political.'
Campeau, Michel, Dismissal from P.O. at St. Louis du Mile End: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 1414 (i).

 M. for Pets.* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).
Campbellton Ry. Accommodation: in Com. of Sup., 4162 (iii).	.
Camps for Militia Training: in Com. of Sup., 5521 (iii).
See ' Militia.'
Camrose Public Building: Remarks (Mr. Douglas) in Com. of Sup., 2214 (ii).
Canada and Australia Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4714 (iii).
Canada-Australia Trade: M. for Papers* (Mr. Ames) 582 (i).
See ' Trade Relations.'
Canada and Cuba Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4721 (iii).
Canada and G.B. Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4715 (iii).

Renewal of Contract: Ques. (Mr. E. M.
Macdonald) 547 (i).
See ' Post Office/ ' Fast Atlantic.' Canada, Mexico and S. America Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 5934 (iv).
Canada and Newfoundland Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4725 (iii).
Canada and South Africa Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4726 ;iii'.
Canada-France Steamship Service, Contract re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 5262 (iii).

Notice of Discussion (Mr. Lemieux)
4742 (iii).
See ' Franco-Canadian.'
Canada and Gulf Terminal Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6305 (iv).
Canadian Agencies in Europe, Names of Appointees: Que#. (Mr. Carvell) 5261 (iii), 5557
(iv).
Can. Birkbeck Investment and Savings Co.: See ' B. No. 11/
Canadian Coal used to heat Govt. Buildings: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 3286 (ii).
Canadian Marine Insurance, Govt. Co-operation, tic.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1582 (i).
Canadian Missionaries in China, Refusal of British Gunboat for Protection, Rep. re: Remarks (Mr. Boyce) 1198 (i).

Relief re Dangers: Remarks (Mr. A. H.
Clarke) 229	(i).

Stmnt.	(Mr. Borden) 268	(i).

Stmnt.	from	Home	Govt.: Read (Mr. Roche) 6559	(iv).
Canadian Navy, Repudiation by Nationalists: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 714 (i).


[DOT] - Speeches re Election Campaign, &c.:
Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 552 (i).

 Tenders re. Construction of Ships, Deposits, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 526 (i).
See ' Naval/
Can. Northern Alta. Ry., Aid to: See 'B. No. 144.'
Can. Northern Alta. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 189.'
Can. Northern Montreal Tunnel and Terminal Co.: See 'B. No. 39.'
Can. Northern Ont. and Carillon and Grenville Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 42/
Can. Northern Ont. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 40.'
Can. Northern Ont. Ry., Subsidy, Guarantee, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4781 (iii).
Can. Northern Pacific Ry. Co., Aid to: See ' B. No. 187/
Can. Northern Pacific Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 6081 (iii).
Can. Northern Que. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 41/
Can. Northern and Quebec Ry. Co.'s Maintenance of Road in L'lle Bourdon: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 5261 (iii).
Can. Northern Ry. Cd.: See ' B. No. 38/
Canadian Northern Ry. Bonds, Govt. Guarantees re Montreal Terminals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. M. Martin) 4247 (iii).
Can. Northern Ry. Bridge at Morris, Representations re Objections: Ques. (Mr. Molloy) 2587 (ii).


INDEX-1911-12 cv
[Stage Direction]
Canadian Offices in London, Cor. re Accommodation : M. (Mr. Bradbury) for Copies, 1396 (i).
See London.'
C.P. Ey. Co.: See ' B. No. 98.'
C.P. Ey. (Toulon) Subsidy: in Com., 6217 (iv).
C.P. Ey., Irrigation, Complaint from Alberta Farmers: Ques. (Mr. Bucbanan) 5262 (iii).
Can. Public Health Assn.; See ' B. No. 127.'
Can. Shipping Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 113.'
Canada Shipping Act (pilotage) Amt.: M. for Com. on Prop. Ees. (Mr. Edwards) 1817 (i).
Canada Shipping Act (pilotage dues) Amt. Bill (Mr. Edwards) on M. to Introduce: Ee-marks (Mr. Speaker) 229; Euling (Mr. Speaker) 267 (i).
CANALS:
American Freight passing through Welland Canal: Ques. (Mr. G. V. White) 3535 (ii). Canals, Capital Expenditure, Total Cost: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1811 (i).
Canal Staff, Dismissals: Eemarks (Mr. Kyte, &c.) in Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).
Canal Tolls, Abolition of, O. Cs.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Sinclair) 2861 (ii).
Canal Traffic, Total Tonnage for 1911: Ques.
(Mr. G. V. White) 3051 (ii).
Carillon Canal, Hydraulic Power Lease, Name of Lessee: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2293
(ii).
Chicago Canal, Eep., &e.: in Com. of Sup., 6579 (iv).
Cornwall Canal, Lower Lock: in Com. of Sup., 5797 (iv).
Galops Canal, Upper Lock: in Com. of Sup., 5797 (iv).
Lachine Canal Lock Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 6611 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Eockfield Bridge: in Com. of Sup.,
5790 (iv).
Murray Canal, Levelling High Spots: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
Newmarket Canal, Commission re Investigation: Eemarks (Mr. J. A. M. Armstrong) 1319 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Meeting at Newmarket: Par. in Press
(Mr. Emmerson) 3057 (ii).
Eideau Canal, Bank St. Bridge: in Com. of Sup., 5791 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
New Dredging Plant:	in Com. of
Sup., 5798 (iv).
St. Peters Canal Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
Sault Ste. Marie Canal Locks: in Com. of Sup., 5791 (iv).
Soulanges Canal, Claim of Denis Martin for Damages: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2292 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Charges re Damien Lalonde: Ques.
(Mr. Boyer) 4249 (iii).
CANALS-Con.
Soulanges Canal, Cueillerrier, Jos., Investigation re Charges: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 6183
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Employees, Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4250 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Guard Pier: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Houle, Stanislas, Emplymt.: Ques.
(Mr. Ethier) 3537 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Methot, Denis, Apptmt.: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4255 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Patronage, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Boyer)
3536 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Protection Works: in Com. of Sup.,
5791 (iv).
Trent Canal Improvements:	in Com. of
Sup., 5799 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Newmarket: in Com. of Sup., 5792
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Water Power, Claims of Prov. of
Ont.: Eemarks (Mr. Graham) in Com. of Sup., 5794 (iv).
Welland Canal, Construction: in Com. of Sup., 6607 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Quantity of American Freight passing through:	Ques. (Mr. G. V. White)
3535 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Surveys: in Com. of Sup., 5786 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Water Power, Diversion, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. G. V. White) 6747 (iv).
Canso Post Office, Dismissal of E. Sutherland: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 1409 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Pet. re Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair)
1207 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Eemarks (Mr. Sinclair) 581; Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 581 (i).
See ' Dismissals.'
Canso Eeduction Works, Dismissals, Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 974 (i).
Cap Chat P.O.: , Pet re Change of Name: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1204 (i).
Cap de la Magdeleine Ey. Co.: See 'B. No. 43.'
Cape Breton Public Works: Eemarks (Mr. Carroll) in Com. of Sup., 2052 (ii).
Cape Bi'eton Tel. Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2817 (ii).
Capital Trust Corporation, Ltd.: See ' B. No. 177.'
Caraquet and North Shore Branch Line, I.C. Ey., Inspection re Subsidy: Eemarks (Mr. Turgeon) 4192 (iii).
Caretakers for Militia, Wages, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5546 (iii).
Caribou, Barkerville and Willow Eiver Ey. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6320 (iv).
Carillon Canal Hydraulic Power Lease, Name of Lessee: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2293 (ii).
Carillon and Que. Ey. Co.: See ' B. No. 42.'
Carleton County Electoral Vacancy, Issue of Writ: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1810 (i).


CV1 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
Carmichael, Dr. A. G„ Supt. of Fish Hatchery, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A.W. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
Carriere and Laine Property, Levis, Rental, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Lesperance) 731 (i). Carrier, Mr., Postmaster at St. Franpois Xavier de Brompton, Investigation re-. Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Car Shortage in Grain Shipments: Remarks (Mr. W. M. Martin) 802 (i).
Car Shortage re Transportation of Hay Crop: Remarks (Mr. Proulx) 2753 (ii).
Car Shortage in the West: Remarks (Mr. Buchanan) 1709 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 1709 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Govtl. Action re-, on M. for Sup. (Mr. Buchanan) 1714 (i).
See ' Grain Congestion/ &c.
Cattle and Stock Pedigree Records: See ' B. No. 167/
Cattle diseased. Compensation re Damages: Remarks (Mr. Morphy) in Com. of Sup., 6471 (iv).
Cattle Embargo by G.B., Abolition of: Ques.
(Mr. Bickerdike) 557 (i).
Cattle killed by Rys.: See ' B. No. 7/
Cattle Quarantine at Beauceville, Res. from Chamber of Commerce:	Remarks (Mr. Beland) 4984 (iii).
Causapscal Post Office, Pet. re Site:	Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 1020 (i).
Cavanagh, Geo., Dismissal from Customs Service: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3342 (ii).
Cedar Rapids Power Co., Water Power Concessions to re St. Lawrence River: Ques. (Mr. Robb) 728 (i).
Cement Importations, Quantity and Value for 1910-11: Ques. (Mr. Robb) 3534 (ii). Cement supplied to Ry. Dept., Tenders, Contract Price, &e.: Ques. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) 4244 (iii).
Census Employees, Payments to: Ques. (Mr. Demers) 3335 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Delay in Payments:	Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 1971 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) 2668 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 935 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 933 (i), 2244 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1199 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 1020 (i), 3835
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 4460 (iii).
Census Population of Canada and Quebec Cities, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lanctot) 3336 (ii). Census in Regina, Complaints re Correctness: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 1440, 1574 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Stmnt. (Mr. Knowles) 563 (i).
Census Enumerators and Returning Officers, Delays in Payment: Remarks (Mr. Neely) 2156 (ii).
Census Returns, Number of Males, Females, &e.: M. for Ret.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 561 (i).
Census of Saskatchewan, Completion of: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 5261 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for (Mr. W. M. Martin) 4983
(iii).
Census Report: Presented (Mr. Burrell) 4037
(iii)	.
Census and Statistics: in Com. of Sup. 619
(i), 6462 (iv).
Central Ry. Co. of Canada: See ' B. No. 44/ Champlain Monument: in Com. of Sup., 6485
(iv)	.
Chance Harbour, N.B., Improvements re-.
Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 554 (i).
Chapel Cove Breakwater, Pet. re Extension: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 1585 (i).
Chard, Mr. J. A., Indian Agent at Grand View, Charges re-. Ques. (Mr. Cruise) 2458
(ii).
Charges of Management, Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 619, 1033 (i),
Charlemagne Mail Contract, Name of Contractor, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 1862 (i). Charles Forest's Cove Breakwater, Contract re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 1584 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mr. Kyte) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Kyte) in Com. of Sup.,
2039 (ii).
Charlos Cove Breakwater, in Com. of Sup., 2040 (ii).
Charlos Cove Lightkeeper, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1208 (i).
Charwomen, Pay, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1061
(i)-
Chateauguay County Inundated Lands, Investigation re-. Ques. (Mr. Brown) 6660 (iv). Chatham, I.C.R. Diversion: in Com. of Sup., 4137 (iii).
Chatham, N.B., Public Building: Cone., 6801
(iv).
Chatham and Newcastle Ry. Service, Pets, from Boards of Trade: Remarks (Mr. Log-gie) 4190 (iii).
Chats Falls Timber Slides, Date of Deed with D. O'Connor, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. S.
Sharpe) 4549 (iii).
Chauvin, Hector, K.C., Apptmt. re Investigation by Public Works Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1414 (i).
See ' Hull.'
Cheese Weighing at Montreal:	See 'Dairying/
Chester Canal Cutting: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 20^9 (ii).

[Stage Direction]
ovu
Chester Canal Cutting, Discontinuance of Work: Quee. (Mr. A. K. MoLean) 716 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 806 (i).
Chevrier, Isidore, Charges re, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4039, 4780 (iii).
Chicago Drainage Canal, Damage to Navigation: Ques. (Mr. Lavalee) 4260 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Rep. re, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6579 (iv).
Chicoutimi Controverted Election, Certificate of Judge:	Presented (Mr. Speaker) 11 (i).
Chinese Entering B.C.: , Total Number: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 4778 (iii).
Chinese and Japanese in B.C., Number naturalized, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 555 (i).
Chinese Tax in B.C.: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Stevens) 285 (i).
See ' Immigration.'
Christmas Holidays Adjournment for: M. (Mr. Borden) 927 (i).

 Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 702 (i).
Chubb, George, Customs Officer, N.B., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4459 (iii).
Cigarettes, Quantity manufactured and imported in each Prov. for 1905, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Blain) 556 (i).
Civil Service Act, Private Secretaries, Amts.: See ' B. No. 60'
Civil Service Act (C.S. commission) Amt.: See ' B. No. 104 and 106.'
Civil Service Act (customs, P.O. depts.) Amt.: See ' B. No. 113, 116, 124.'
Civil Service Act (rural mail) Amt.:	See
' B. No. 179.'
Civil Service Apptmts. between Dissolution of Parlt. and Sept. 21st: M. for Stmnt.* (Mr. Edwards) 562 (i).
Civil Service Association, Representations to Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Carroll) 3334 (ii).
Civil Service Commission, Addition to:	See
' B. No. 104.'
Civil Service Commission, Additional Apptmt: in Com. of Sup., 6615 (iv).

Increase in Number:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 728 (i).
Civil Service Commission of Investigation Apptmts., &c.: Remarks (Mr. Monk) in Com. of Sup., 283 (ii).
Civil Service Competitive Examination, Extension re:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
Civil Service Increases since 1900:	M. for
Ret.* (Mr. Aikins) 561 (i).
Civil Service Investigation re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1581 (i).
See ' Dismissals.'
Civil Service List:	Inquiry for (Mr. C. A.
Wilson) 6187 (iv).
Civil Service Reform, and Outside Service: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 727 (i).
Clarkboro, Sask., C.N.R. Right of Way, Title re-. Ques. (Mr. Meighen) 934 (i).
Clifford, Private: See ' N.R.A.'
Clock Towers on Public Buildings: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 1344 (i). Clothing for Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5521
(iii)	.
Clouthier, Jos., Dismissal, Postmaster at St. Alphonse Dudswell, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (iii).

Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 4549 (iii).
Coal Combine in B.C., Investigation re: Ques.
(Mr. Stevens) 4240 (iii).
Coal Contracts for I.C.Ry.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5611 (iv). See ' Can. Coal.'
Coal for Govt. Steamers, Average Cost per Ton, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 1203 (i).
Coal Shortage in the West for Household Consumption, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Warnock)
568 (i).
Coal Strike in Alberta Settlement: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 1502 (i). Coal Strike in Fernie, B.C., Information rer Ques. (Mr. Warnock) 568 (i).
Coal Strike in the West, Stmnt. of Min. of Int. re Settlement:	Ques. (Mr. Buchanan)
571 (i).

 Strikes in the West, Settlement of:
Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 567 (i).

Remission of Duties:	Remarks (Mr. McCraney) 178, 230; Stmnt. (Mr. Rogers) 230 (i).
Coasting Trade, Foreign Shipping, Pete., &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Kyte) 2861 (ii).

 O.C., Extending Time: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1814 (i).
Cockshutt Plough Co., Stmnt. of Member for Edmonton re Prices in East and West: on M. for Sup. (Mr. Cockshutt) 807 (i).
Codd, Staff Sergeant, Retiring Gratuity: in Com. of Sup., 5811 (iv).
Coffin, Henry, Apptmt. to H. of C., Dismissal of M. Picotte:	M. for Cor.* (Mr. Seguin)
2459 (ii).

Ques. (Mr. Guilbault) 2289 (ii).
Coin Circulation: in Com. of Sup., 1034 (i). See ' Finance.'
Coldbrook Postmaster, Name and Apptmt.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3148 (ii).
Cold Storage for Bait re Fisheries: in Com. of Sup., 5256 (iii).
See 'Fisheries.'
Cold Storage Establishments in Canada, Number, &c.: M. for Ret.* (Mr. Verville) 3343
(ii).

 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Verville) 5561
(iv)	.
cviii

Cole Harbour Wharf: in Com. of Sup., 2055
(ii).
Collingwood Dry Dock: See ' B. No. 111.' Combines Investigation Act, &c.:	Remarks
(Mr. Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 1515 (i). Commercial Agent in France as Successor to Mr. A. Poindron:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)
4041 (iii).
Commissioners re Investigations, Number of Appointees, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 5680, 6336 (iv).
See 'Dismissals.'
Committees, Sel. Standing: M. (Mr. Borden) 10 (i).

Lists: Presented (Mr. Borden) 703 (i).

 M. to present Rep. (Mr. Borden) 794 (i).

M. (Mr. Borden) to add Names, 1019
(i)	, 2217 (ii).
Companies Act Amt., Legislation reQues. (Mr. Murphy) 529 (i).
Companies Incorporation, Ref. to Supreme Court, Withdrawal by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 529 (i).
Connolly, John, Coal Inspector, Complaints re-. M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2588 (ii).	.
Conservation Commission, Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1069 (i), 6579 (iv).

 Water Powers Report: Presented (Mr. Burrell) 407 (i).
Continental Can Co., Patent Relief: See ' B. No. 119.'
Conway, Patrick J., Lightkeeper at White Island, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2587, 3342 (ii).
Copper Cliff Post Office, Dismissals, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Boyce) in Com. of Sup., 2034
(ii)	.
Copyright Bill, Legislation re-. Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 557, 1208 (i).

 Remarks (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 935 (i).
Cornwall Canal, Lower Lock: in Com. of Sup., 5797 (iv).
Cote, Mrs. J. N., Dismissal as Charwoman: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 2667 (ii).
Courehesne, Mr. P. E. C., Dismissal from Inland Revenue: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1864 (i). Courcy, Mr. P., Apptmt. at St. Pacome de Kamouraska: Remarks (Mr. E. Lapointe) 5821 (iv).

Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 5952 (iv).
Courtenay Bay Harbour Works, Contracts re: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 4743 (iii).
See ' St. John.'
Couture, Mr. A., Dismissal from I.C.R.: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 2242 (ii).
Cow Bay Protection Works: in Com. of Sup., 2055 (ii).
Cox, Mr. A. B., Dismissals, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6784 (iv).
Cream Exports into U.S., Quantity and Value for 1911: Ques. (Mr. Robb) 3535 (ii).
Creosoted Timber re Public Works: in Com. of Sup., 2440 (ii).
Cresine, Geo., Quarter Master on SS. 'Scotia,' Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1582 (i).
Cribbin's Point Breakwater: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2046 (ii).
Criminal Code (log stealing) Amts.: See ' B. No. 9.'
Criminal Code (race tracks) Amt.: See ' B. No. 165.'
Crown Lands in Man., Sask. and Alberta, Number of Acres, Reservations for School Lands: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1587 (i).
Crystal Beach Post Office, Dismissal of Mr. A. E. Buck: Remarks (Mr. German) 3908 (ii), 5960 (iv).
Cuillier, Ass't. Electrician, Soulanges Canal, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4457 (iii)

Investigation re Charges on Soulanges
Canal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 6183 (iv).
Customs, Outside Service, Salary Increases: See ' B. No. 116.'
Customs Collector, P. J. Venoit, Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Turgeon) 1590 (i).
Customs Contracts given without Tender: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 877 (i).
Customs Depth Report: Presented (Mr. J. D. Reid) 971 (i).
Customs Dues re Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5522 (iii).
Customs Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1040 (i).

 Outside Ports Salaries: in Com. of Sup.,
1073 (i).
Customs Smuggling Case by M.P., Par. in Montreal 'Star': Ques. (Mr. Baker) 2072 (ii).

Ques. of Priv. (Mr. Brown) 2216 (ii).
Customs Tariff, Changes re Jute Cloth Dressed Lumber, &e., Rulings, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Turriff) 2459 (ii).
Customs Tariff: See ' Tariff Commission B. 88.'
Customs Weighing of Goods, Decree of French Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Weichel) 721 (i).
Dairying Industry in Canada, Grievances re Weighing at Montreal: Remarks (Mr. Edwards) on M. for Sup., 5711 (iv).
Dalaire, Mr. L. P., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. BMand) 2454 (ii).
Dartmouth Branch Line, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 670 (i).
Dartmouth to Denus Branch Line, I.C.R., Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 543 (i).
Daoust, Done, Postmaster at Alfred, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Proulx) 3945 (ii).



[Stage Direction]
cix
Dauphin Custom House:	Remarks (Mr. Cruise) in Com. of Sup., 3244 (ii).
Davidson, David George, Relief of: See ' B. No. 175.'
Davis, John, Dismissal: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 6783 (iv).
Day, Luke, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. McKenzie) 2861 (ii).
Debates, Official, 1st Rep. of Com.: M. (Mr. Taylor) to cone., 2841 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Correction (Mr. Ethier) re Man. Bill
Voting on 3°, 4983 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 6613 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Reporters' Examination Papers, 6338
(iv).
Debt of Canada, Average Interest: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1811 (i).
Decoste, (Peter, Dismissal from Dredge Cape Breton: Ques. (Mr. W. Chisholm) 548 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Defective Answer to Question: Remarks
(Mr. Wm. Chisholm) 803 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) for Cor., 1268
(i)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com.
of Sup., 3256 (ii).
Delisle, L. Treffle, of Trois Pistoles, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 4781 (iii). Denny, James, Relief of: See ' B. No. 112.' Deputy Minister of Justice, Travelling Expenses: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3150 (ii).
See ' Justice.'
Deschenes, Louis, Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. E. Lapointe) in Com. of Sup., 6651 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
See ' Dismissals.'
Deschamps, Mr. R., Apptmt. by Govt.: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 6277 (iv).
Deschamps, Raoul, Apptmt. by Govt.: Ques.
(Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2667 (ii).
Desjardins, Baptiste, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 6784 (iv).
Devils Island Breakwater Extension: in Com. of Sup., 2055 (i).
Diamond Light and Heating Co., Investigation re: on M. to cone, in 2nd Rep. of Public Accounts Com., 5832 (iv).
See ' Pub. Accounts Com.'
Digby Clock Keeper, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3272
(ii)	.
Dionne, Thos., Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 2460 (ii).
Dismissals of Govt. Employees, Investigation re : See ' B. No. 19.'

[Stage Direction]
Anse a Valeaiu Postmistress, Chargee re Madame Proulx: Ques. (M,r. Leimieux) 2072 (ii).
DISMISSALS-Con.
Arohiambault, Emile, Letter Carrier, Montreal, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 5950 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor* (Mr. Seguin) 5957 (iii) -
Baldwin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Customs at Coaticooke: M. for Cor. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1361 (i).
Bares, Mir. Archibald, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6784 (iv)
Bath Postmistress, Dismissal: in Com of Sup., 6282 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Pugeley) 966 (i).
Beauchemin, J. A., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boivim) 3337 (ii).
Beauebesne, Mir., Dismissal from Customs: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 3151 (ii).
Belanger, Amedee, Dismissal from I. C. Ry.: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3050 (ii).
Bergeron, Mr. J. G. H., Apptmt. as Commissioner of Inquiry: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2062 (ii).
Bohan, John W., Dismissal from Customs at Bath: Ques. (Mr. Carvel-1) 3055 (ii).
Boucher, Mr. 0. F., Pet. re Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 975 (i).
Bourgoin, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 5557 (iv).
Boyle, D. R., Fishery Overseer at Ardchat, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mir. Kyte) 3945 (ii).
Braine, Dr. Lawrence, Indian Medical Attendant at Chester, N.S.: Dismissal, &c., Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4976 (iii)-
Brazeau, Mr. Emile, Postmaster at Cote Rouge, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 6337 (iv).
Brian, Mr., Dismissals for Political Partisanship: Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clairke) in Com. of Sup., 1077 (i).
Brown, Wm., Pet. from Dr. E. Montpetit, re Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. BoyeT) 4977 (iii).
Brymer, Arthur, Fishery Officer at Lower L'Ardoise, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3752 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Papers* (Mr. Kyte) 4781 (iii).-
Buck, A. E., Postmaster at Crystal Beach, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. German) 3908 (ii), 5960 (iv).
Bull, Mr. Robert, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mir. Ca-rvell) 3338 (ii).
Campeau, Micbel, Dismissal from P. O. at St. Louis <lu Mile End: Ques. (Mr. Ver-ville) 1414 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Pets* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).
Canals Staffs, Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Kyte, &c.) in Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).
Camso Postmaster, Pet. re Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1207 (d).
[Stage Direction]


DISMISSALS-Con.
Canso Postmaster, Dismissal of R. Sutherland: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 1109 (i).
See ' Sutherland/
Canso Public Buildings, Dismissal of Caretaker : Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 581; Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 581
(i)	.
Carmichael, Dr. A. G., Suipt. of Dish Hatchery, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
Caimmaigh, Geo., Dismissal from Customs Service: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3312 (ii).
Chard, Mr. J. A., Indian Agent at Grand View, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Cruise) 2458
(ii)	.
Charles Cove Lightbeeper, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1208 (i).
Chauvim, Hector, K.C., Apptmt. re Investigation by Public Works Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1414 (i).
Chevrier, Isidore, Charges re, Dismissal, &o.: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4039, 4780 (iii).
Chubb, George, Customs Officer, N.B., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4459 (iii) -
Clouthier, Joseph, Postmaster at St. Adolphe de Diudswell, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 4549 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Papers* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (iii).
Commissioners, Number employed by Govt., Remuneration, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 5680, 6336 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Apptmt. of Commissioners in Quebec:
Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2063 (ii).
Civil Service Investigation: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1581 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Investigation re Dismissals, Cost of,
&c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 5950 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Publio Service Commission, Apptmt.
of Messrs. Jackson and Schwitzer as Assistants: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 5954 (iv).
See ' Public Service/ ' Merino/ &c.
Connolly, John, Coal Inspector, Complaints re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2588 (ii).
Conway, Patrick, Lightkeeper at White Hoad Island: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2587, 3342 (ii).
Copper Cliff Post Office, Dismissals, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Boyoe) in Com. of Sup., 2034 (ii).
Cote, Mrs. J. N., Dismissal as Charwoman: Ques. (Mr. Vorville) 2667 (ii).
Conrchesne, Mr. P. E. C., Dismissal from Inland Revenue: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1864 (i).
Couture, Mr. A., Dismissal from I.C.R.: Que6. (Mr. Lemieux) 2242 (ii).
DISMISSALS-Con.
Cox, Mr., Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr Sinclair) 6784 (iv).
Cresine, Geo., Quartermaster on SS. 'Scotia/ Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1582 (i). Crystal Beach Post Office, Dismissal of Mr. A. E. Buck: Remarks (Mr. German) 3908
(ii)	, 5960 (iv)
Cuillier, AssJt Electrician, Soulanges Canal, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4457
(iii)	.
Dalaire, Mr. L. P., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 2454 (di).
Davis, John, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6783 (iv).
Day, Luke, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. McKenzie) 2861 (ii).
Deooste, Capt. Peter, Dismissal from Dredge ' Cape Breton ': Ques. (Mir. W. Chisholm) 548 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Answer to Question: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) 803 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) for Cor.,
1268 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in
Com. of Sup., 3256 (ii).
Delisle, L. Treffle, Trois Pistoles, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 4781
(iii).
Deschenes, Louis, Wharfinger at River
Onelle, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. E. Lapointe) in Com.
of Sup., 6651 (iv).
Desjardins, Baptiste, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Hr. E. Lapointe) 6784 (iv). Desmarais, Mr., Dismissal re: Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 5817 (iv). Digby Clock Keeper, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3272 (ii).
Dionne, Thos., Dismissal of: M. for Cot.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 2460 (ii).
Dismissals, &c., Apptmt. of Commissioners: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 3247 (di).
[Stage Direction]
Irrelevancy of Debate (Mr. Dep.
Speaker) 3253 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Objection to Ruling (Mr. Macdonald)
3254 (di).
Dismissal of Conservative Postmaster re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2295 (id).
Dismissals Generally, Govt. Policy: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 5803 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of
Sup., 2018 (ii), 4187 (iii).
Dismissals from Govt. Service: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 1955 (i).

[Stage Direction]
DIS/MISSADS-Con.	.
Dismissals in Hull, Official Inquiry re: Ques. 550 (i); Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 4140
(iii)	.
Dismissals re Inland Rev. Dept., Policy of Minister: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 5819 (iv).
Dismissals by Hon. Mr. Lemieux, Par. in ' Le Devoir ' read: Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2452 (ii).
Dismissals in Ottawa, Investigation re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1275 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. C. A. Wilson)
3834 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Monk) in Com. of Sup.,
3262 (ii).
Dismissals for Political Partisanship:	in
Com. of Sup., 1074 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. of Order (Messrs. A. K. Maclean
and Hon. S. Hughes) 1183 (i).
Dismissals of Public Officials: M. (Mr. A.
K. Maclean) for Papers, &c., 878, 944 (i). Dismissal from Public Works, Par. in Newspapers: Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 3058
(ii).
Dismissals from Public Offices from 1896 to 1911: M. (Mr. Goodeve) for Ret.* 1280 (i). Dismissals in Rimouski County: Remarks (Mr. Boulay) 1276 (i).
Disraeli Postmaster, Dismissal, &c.:	Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6616
(iv)	.
Dom. Lands Agent at Medicine Hat, Suspension or Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 552 (i).
Doucet, Odilon, Postmaster at Notre Dame des Lourdes, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pacaud) 1863 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pacaud) in Com. of
Sup., 6285 (iv).
Duchaine, Pierre, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 2454 (ii).
Ducharme, Mr. G. N., Apptmt. of as Commissioner: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 4980 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Resignation re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)
4979 (iii).
Dumelong, E., Postmaster at L'Assomption, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 580, 720
(i).
Dunn, Albert, Charges re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4039 (iii). Dupont, Rene, Dismissal as Immigration Agent: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1864 (i).
Dupre, Dr., Postmaster at St. Robert, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Papers* (Mr. Cardin) 4782 (iii).
East Roman Valley Post Office, Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Pelletier) in Com. of Sup., 2028 (ii).
DISMISSALS-Con.
Elevator Men in Govt. Employ: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3244 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux)
in Com. of Sup., 3245 (ii).
Falconer, R. S., Dismissal as Inspector on I.C.R., Apptmt. of Successor: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 543 (i).
Farly, Mrs., Postmistress at St. Gabriel de Brandon, Dismissal, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Boland) 2579 (ii).
Ferguson, S. M., Dismissal of: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 2459 (ii).
Fishery Guardians in Guysborough County, Names, Dismissals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 3053 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3056 (ii).
Fisheries Inspectors, Dismissal, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5242 (iii).
Fishery Overseer, J. A. Doucet, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Turgeon) 1590 (i).
Fishery Overseer, W. C. Robichaud, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Turgeon) 1589 (i).
Flemming, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Inland Rev. at Petrolia: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 4259 (iii).
Forest, Mr. Medard, Excise Officer at L'Epiphanie, Dismissal, Charges, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Nantel) 726 (i).
Fraser, Mr. John, Postmaster at Stellar-ton, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 546 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inspector at Stellarton, I.C.R., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
3935 (ii).
Fritz, Henry, Dismissal as Fishery Overseer: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4977 (iii).
Garceau, Mr. N., Apptmt. as Inquiry Commissioner: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2860
(ii).
Gass, Trueman, Emplymt. and Dismissal on I.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2242 (ii).
Gauthier, Alderic, Dismissal from Soulanges Canal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4976 (iii).
Gerrior, Mr. William, Dismissal from Customs at Larry's River, N.S.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 3051 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3056 (ii).
Gillies, Capt., Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 3261 (ii).
Girard, Louis, Dismissal as Postmaster at Ste. Angele de Merici: M. for Pets.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2587 (ii).
Glenelg, N.S., Postmaster, Complaints re Pets., &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Sinclair) 1817 (i).
cxn
[Stage Direction]
DISMISSALS-Con.
Godbout, Mr. J., Emplymt. in Govt., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3752 (ii).
_____M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 4980 (iii).
Goucher, Wesley, Dismissal as Lightkeeper: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4977 (iii).
Govt. Employees, Dismissal, Resignations, &c.: M. for Ret. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 1818
(i)	.
Govt. Employees, Inside and Outside Service, Dismissals, &c.: M. for Ret.* (Mr. Kyte) 2587 (ii).
Gray, W. W., Coal Inspector, Charges re, Investigation by H. P. Duchemin:	M.
for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2588
(ii)	.
Green, John B„ Homestead Inspector, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. White) 6183 (iii).
Griever, Mr. S., Charges re Lighthouse Keeper: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1358 (i).
Guillemette, Mr. N., Dismissal, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1210 (i).
Guimond, Eugene, Dismissal of:	M. for
Pets.* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).
Hagerty, Mr. S. W., Dismissal from Inspectorship of Ry. Station: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4976 (iii).
Hale, Thos., Dismissal as Correspondent, 'Labour Gazette/ Apptmt. of Successor: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 4459 (iii).
_____M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
4263 (iii).
Hamel, Hector, Customs Appraiser, Montreal, Dismissal of:	M. for Cor* (Mr. Lemieux) 3343 (ii).
Ham Nord Postmaster, Investigation, Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Harbour, Geo. T., Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Letter re Dismissal: Read (Mr. Lomieux) in Com. of Sup., 3252 (ii).
Harris, W. H., Postmaster at White Head, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Sinclair) 2588 (ii).
Hatfield, Mr., Dismissal:	Remarks (Mr. Law) in Com. of Sup., 5252 (iii).
Hattie, Mr. W. A., Preventive Officers, Mul-grave, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1815 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2460 (ii).
Hayden, W. W., Wharfinger at Digby, Dismissal: M. for Cor* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 5957 (iii).
Hebert, Auguste, Postmaster at St. Pascal, Dismissal: M. for Cor* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. Lapointe) in Com.
of Sup., 6291 (iv).
DISMISSALS-Con,
Hefferman, Mr. E. S., Dismissal from Cus toms at Spring Hill, N.S.: Ques. (Mr. A K. Maclean) 4039 (iii).
Hendsbee, David S„ Dismissal from Marine and Fisheries Dept.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3342 (ii).
Homestead Inspectors, Number employed in Sask., Number dismissed: Ques. (Mr. L. Thomson) 1588 (i).
lie Rouge Lighthouse Keeper, Dismissal of Mr. Irving: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 4259
(iii).
I.C.R. Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Lesperance) in Com. of Sup., 5806 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Employees in Pictou, Charges re Political Partisanship: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Macdonald) 2246 (ii).
Investigations into Dismissals: See 'Commission,' &c.
Jacques, Leander, Postmaster, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 3339 (ii).
Jones, Chas. O., Dismissal, Evidence, &c.: M. for Copy* (Mr. Kay) 3757 (ii).
Kelly, Edward, Dismissal from Canso Reduction Works: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3341 (ii).
Kennedy, Allan, Govt. Telegraph Repairer, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor. (Mr. A. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
Kennie, Capt. Edmund, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 6782 (iv).
Kirouac, Mr., Postmaster at Manseau, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Pacaud) 2579 (ii).
Labour Gazette Correspondents, Dismissals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 1411 (i).
Lacombe, Mr. J. A., Dismissal from St. Se-bastien P.O., Inquiry re: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 974 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Beland) in Com. of
Sup., 6618 (iv).
Lalonde, Mr. Alfred, Dismissal:	M. for
Cor.* (Mr. Cardin) 6783 (iv).
Laroche, Capt. Leon, Dismissal of:	Ques.
(Mr. Fortier) 4549 (iii).
Lavoie, Mr. Calixte, Postmaster, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Brouillard) 3339 (ii).
Lebel, Mr. W., Dismissal from Customs: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1864 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756
(ii).
Legault, Mr. Ophir, Postmaster at L'lle Per-rot, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 5950 (iv).
Leigh, Mr. W. M., Dismissal from Kirkton Post Office:	Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin)
5949 (iv).	.

[Stage Direction]
cxiii
DISMISSALS-Con.
Lemieux, Hon. Mr., late P.M.G., Par. in ' Lo Devoir ' re Dismissals:	Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2664 (ii).
Ques. Ruled out (Mr. Speaker) 2580
(ii).
Lepage, M. J., Preventive Officer, Rimouski, Dismissal, &e.:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)
4458 (iii).
Leroux, Mr., Soulanges Canal, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 6183 (iii).
Lightkeepers in N.S., Investigation re Charges: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5233 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of
Sup., 6650 (iv).
Lightkeepers in P.E.I., Investigation re Charges: Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) in Com. of Sup., 5232 (iii).
Lizotte, Luc., Postmaster at Pacome, Dismissal:	M. for Cor* (Mr. E. Lapointe)
3756 (ii).
Locas, Mr. Henri, Dismissal, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Seguin) 3338 (ii).
Londonderry Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 6337 (iv).
Lotbiniere County Postmasters, Dismissal, Number, Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Fortier) 972 (i).
McAdam, Alex. R., Fishery Officer at An-tigonish, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) 3343 (li).
McDonald, Dr. D„ Dismissal from Indian Reserve, Baddeck: M. for Cor.* (Mr. McKenzie) 2861 (ii).
McEachren, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Tatamagouche Post Office: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 2243 (ii).
McFarlane, J. D., Postmaster at Southwest Margaree, Dismissal: M. for Cor* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3756 (ii).
McGrath, James, Postmaster at Aspen, N.
S.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 2587 (ii). Mclsaac, Colin, Preventive Officer at Port Hood, Dismissal:	M. for Cor.* (Mr. A.
W. Chisholm) 5956 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) in
Com. of Sup., 5816 (iv).
McLean, Donald E., Dismissal, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 4980 (iii). McLean, W. D„ Dismissal from Customs at L'Etang:	Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4780 (iii).
McLennan, Mr., Dismissal from Inverness Public Building:	Remarks (Mr. A. W.
Chisholm) 2017 (ii).
McLeod, John, Dismissal as Postmaster at Denmark, N.S.:	M. for Cor* (Mr. Macdonald) 4460 (iii).
H
DISMISSALS-Con.
McLeod, Dr. J. R., Dismissal from Port Hawkesbury, Charges re*. M. for Papers* (Mr. Kyte) 3945 (ii).
McPhee, James, Customs Officer, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
McPherson, John H., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4259 (iii).
Mader, Mr. D., Dismissal from Mahone Bay P.O.:	Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean)
722 (i).
Marlin, Mrs. A. S., Postmistress, Dismissal, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
Matte, Arthur J., Postmaster at Montauban, Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Delisle) 5957 (iii).
Michaud, Mr. E., Dismissal from P.O. at St. Germain:	M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1592 (i).
Michaud, Mr. J., Postmaster at St. Moise Station, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 1864 (i).
Montcalm Postmaster, Pets, re Removal: Ques. (Mr. Lafortune) 575 (i).
Montpetit, Dr. E., Pet. sent to P.M.G. re Dismissal of William Brown:	Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4977 (iii).
Montreal Customs House, Dismissals: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4040 (Hi).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners, Retention of: Ques. (Mr. Ames) 2062 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1708	(i);
2057 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Res. from Board of Trade re Dismissals: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1812
(i).
Moreau, Mr. Jos., Dismissal, &e.: M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1818 (i).
Morine, A. B., Letter received by Prime Minister: Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 6185 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 6185 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Correction re Ruling on Question
(Mr. Speaker) 6335 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 6335 (iv).
Morine, Mr. A. B., Charges re as Public Commissioner:	Remarks (Mr. Carvell)
on M. for Sup., 6528 (iv).
Mosher, Mr. G. A., Preventive Officer at Ship Harbour, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4039 (iii).
Mount Oscar, Postmaster, Dismissal of I. Chevrier:	Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4780 (iii).
Mullaly, Mr., Emplymt. in P.O. Dept., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Power) 1583 (i).
Mundle, D. I., Dismissal as sub-collector at Richibucto, N.B.:	Ques. (Mr. Carvell)
4780 (iii).

[Stage Direction]
DISMISSALS-Con.
Notre Dame des Anges Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 554 (i).
O'Brien, A. J., Dismissal from Immigration Office at Halifax: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 717 (i).
Oyster Pond Preventive Officer, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1207 (i).
Payson, Mr. W. W., Dismissal from Deep Brook Post Office: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 2243
(ii).
Peloquin, Mr. F., Postmaster at St. Joseph de Sorel, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
Poirier, N. P., Investigation re Charges: Remarks (Mr. Gauvreau) in Com. of Sup., 5815 (iv).
Postmasters dismissed:	Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6617 (iv).
Post Office Dismissals, Govt. Policy re: Remarks (Mr. Carvell) in Com. of Sup., 6299 (iv).
Post Office Dismissals since Oct. 1911, Pets, re, Ac.: M. for Ret. (Mr. Lemieux) 1395, 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
List read (Mr. Lemieux) 6636 (iv).
Postmasters in Kamouraska County, Names, Dismissal, Ac.:	Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe)
6781 (iv).
Postmasters in Lotbiniere County, Dismissals:	Remarks (Mr. Fortier) in Com. of
Sup., 6294 (iv).
Postmasters in Temiscouata County, Dismissal, Charges re:	Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 548 (i).
Poulin, Mr. E., Dismissal from Customs, Quebec City: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 2071 (ii).
Pouliott, Louis, Dismissal, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4459 (iii).
Powassan Postmaster, Change re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Arthurs) 2459 (ii).
Power, Lawrence F., Supt. of Lobster Hatchery at Arichat, Dismissal, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3751 (ii); 4781 (iii).
Printing Bureau, Dismissals and Apptmts.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 1809 (i).
Provost, Raoul, Dismissal from Marine and Fisheries:	Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 2453 (ii).
Public Service Commission, Charges re A. B. Morine: on M. for Sup., (Mr. Carvell) 6528 (iv).
See ' Morine.'
Public Works, Dismissal of Workmen: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2584 (ii).
Rathburn Post Office, Removal of Postmaster, Ac.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Pardee) 4262 (iii).
DISMISSALS-Con.
Rayne, R. W., Caretaker Truro Armoury, Dismissal: Ques. (Mt. Macdonald) 6184
(iii).
Renfrew, N., Dismissal of Govt. Officials: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2856 (ii).
Renfrew, S., Dismissal' of Govt. Officials: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2856 (id).
Richards, Mr. S., Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Conn, of Sup., 5821, 6652 (iv). Rivers, Lachupelle and Dubois, Messrs., Dismissal Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3752 (ii). Roberts, Capt. Alex., Postmaster 'at Oamso, Dismissal, Ac.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3341 (ii).
Robert, Wm., Dismissal from Vail des Ebou-lia Post Office: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 3537 (ii).
Robibaille, Mr. J. C., Charges re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2858 (ii).
Rogers, J. M., Dismissal from East Roman Valley P. O., N.S.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 722 (d).
_____M. for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 1409 (i).
Rutherford, Mr. John, Land Agent at Moose-jaw, Dismissal, Ac.: M. (Mr. Knowlee) for Papers, 1395 (i).
St. Adelaide de Pabos Postmaster, Investigation re Charges: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2068 (ii).
St. Agathe des Monts, Dismissal of Posh mistress: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 973 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor. (Mr. Lemieux) 1591 (i).
St. Amour Postmaster, Changes since Jan. 1912: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2666 (ii).
_____M. for Cor* (Mt. Proulx) 2861 (ii)
St. Ancilet Postmaster, Request for Dismissal: M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2588 (ii).
St. Angele de Laval Postmaster, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3755 (ii), 4039 (iii). St. Germiadn Postmaster, Changes re Apptmt.: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1579
(i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1592
(i)-	^
St Martin, Madame, Dismissal .from St. Louis de Bonsecours: M. for Papers* (Mr. Cardin) 4782 (iii).
St. Paul d'Abbottsford Postmaster, P. L. St. Pierre, Investigation re:	M. for
Papers* (Mr. Lemieux) 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 6290 (iv).
St. Peter of Wakefield Postmaster, Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 6286 (iv).
St. Tite Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1210 (i).

[Stage Direction]
DISMISSALS-Con.
Remarks (Mr. Bureau) in Com. of Sup., 6285 (iv).
Sauve, Mr. L. A., Dismissal from Soulanges Canal: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 575 (i). Sayabee Postmistress, Pet. re Dismissal, Apptmt. &c.: Ques. (Mr. Oarvell) 2585
(ii).
Scotch Village Postmaster, Apptmt. in 1903, Charges re-. Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2666 (ii).
Sheltus, Anson, Dismissal, Ac.; M. for Cor.* (Mr. Kay) 3757 (ii).
Skurtloff, Dr., Investigation re J. Clouthier: Remiajrks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup.' 6629 (iv).
Smith, Angus, Pilot of D.G.S. ' Earl Grey/ Suspension of: M. for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1590 (i).
Smith, Lyman C., Customs Collector at Oshawa, Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2861 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. on
Customs Bill, 4575 (iii).
Stellarton Postmaster, Mr. John Fraser, Dismissal: M. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) for Cor* 1589 (i).
Storey, Wm., Dismissal, Investigation, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. J. Reid) 5054 (iii).
Sudbury Post Office, Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Boyce) in Com. of Sup., 2033 (ii). Sutherland, Mr., Dismissal of: Remarks (Mt. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 1274 (i), 2018; Cor. read 2022 (ii).
See ' Canso/
Therrien, F., Charges re Political Partisanship, Investigation re-. Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1413 (i), 3152 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 5823
(iv).
Thibault, Theophile, Dismissal, Ac.: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 3339 (ii).
Thompson, Dr., Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 6784 (iv).
Three Rivers, Inland Revenue, Charges re Collector C. D. Herbert: Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1209 (i).
Tory, Mr. H. L„ Dismissal, Ac.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 6784 (iv).
VaJois, J. B., Dismissal from Vaudrefuil Post Office: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 3537 (ii). Veit, Frederick, Dismissal, Ac.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Lemieux) 6783 (iv).
Venoit, Mr. Joseph, Complaints re Suspension, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1817 (i).
Waterways Treaty, Dismissal of Commissioners: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 966 (i). Hi
DISMISSALS-Con.
Webber, James, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6783 (iv).
Webster, Dr. C. A., Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Law) 6186 (iv).
Webster, Mr., Immigration Agent at Edmonton, Dismissal, Ac.: Remarks (Mr-Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 3922 (ii). Westville Public Building, Dismissal of Caretaker: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 1531 (i).	[DOT]
Whitehead, N. S., Dismissal of Postmaster, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2855 (ii). White Head Island Lighthouse, Dismissal of Patrick Conway, Investigation: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2857 (ii).
White, James, Dismissal, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 3338 (ii).
Williams, Mr., Dismissal from H. of C.: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 3279 (ii).
Yule, Mr., Customs Officer at Aurora, Dismissal, Ac : Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4779
(iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. Cairvell) 5950 (iv).
Disraeli Postmaster, Dismissal, Ac.:	Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6616
(iv).
Divorce: See ' B. Nos. 102, 109, 110, 112, 120, 122, 131, 142, 147, 162, 163, 164, 173, 174 and 175.
Documents handed in to 'Hansard' not read: Ruling (Mir. Speaker) 6718 (iv).
Dogfish Scrap, Price re-. M. for Cor. (Mr. Sinclair) 1391 (i).
Dom. Atlantic Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 22/
Dom. Gresham Guarantee Co.: See 'B. N. 29/
Dom. Gresham Guarantee and Casualty Co.t See ' B. No. 176/
Dom. Guarantee Co., Ltd.: See ' B. No. 29/
Dom. Exhibition Grant to Ottawa: in Com. of Sup., 8479 (iv).
Dom. Lands Agent at Medicine Hat, Suspension or Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 552 (i).
Dom. Lands in N.W. Area, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1587 (i).
Dom, Notes, Pri: * mvj. Ac.: in Com. of Sup., 1033 (i).
Dom. Notes and Stamps Printing Contract, Complaints re British Tenders: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 5843 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Limitation 'as to Tenders: Remarks
(Mr. Emmerson) 1820 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) on M. for
Sup., 1841 (i).
Dom. Trust Co.: See ' B. Nos. 46 and 80/
Doncaster Indian Reserve Road Repairs: Cone., 6806 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
Dorchester Penitentiary: in Com. of Sup., 6561
(iv).
Double Tracking, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 563T (iv).
Doucet, Mr. A. E., Cor. re By. Station Sites: M. for Copies* (Mr. Lavallee) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Position on N. T. By.: Ques. (Mr. Lavallee) 2245 (ii).
Doucet, Odilon, Postmaster at Notre Dame des Lourdes, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pa-*caud) 1863 (i).
_____Remarks (Mr. Pacaud) in Com. of Sup.,
6285 (iv).	.
Douglas Boad Post Office, Date of Opening, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 3754 (ii).
Downey, W. H., Returning Officer, Kings and Albert, Non-Payment of:	Remarks (Mr. Pugsley; 2057 (ii).
Dredges and Boiler Inspection: Ques. (Mr. Car veil) 5953 (iv).
Drill Halls in the West, Donation of Lauds re Sites: Ques. (Mr. McCraney) 1815 (i).
Dry Dock Subsidies Act Amt.: See ' B. Nos. Ill and 180/
See ' Collingwood.'
Duchaine, Pierre, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 2454 (ii).	.
Ducharme, Mr., Apptmt. to Civil Service Commission: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2830 (ii).
_____for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 4980 (iii) -
_____ Resignation re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)
4979 (iii).
Duffy, Edith Harriet, Relief of: See ' B. No.
East River, Pictou County, Deepening, &e.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 2020 (ii).
East Roman Valley Post Office, Dismissal : Be-marks (Mr. Pelletier) in Com. of Sup., 2028
(ii).
Eddy, Ezra Butler Bessey, Change of Name: See ' B. No. 117/
Edmonton Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2206 (ii).
Edmonton Wharf: in Com. of Sup., 2816 (ii). Eganville Post Office, Purchase of Site: Ques. (Mr. Low) 725 (i).
Election Accounts, Payments re: Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 4460 (iii).
Elections Act Amt.: See ' B. Nos. 4, 8, 17. Election Deposits: See ' B. Nos. 8 and 17/ Electric Light Inspection: in Com. of Sup., 5828 (iv).
Elevator Men in Govt. Employ: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3244 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in
Com. of Sup., 3245 (ii).
Elevators, Control of by Govt.: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 137
(i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ref. to in debate on Address, 154, 287
(i).	.
Elevators, Ownership and Operation by Govt.: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 2853 (ii).
See ' Grain B. 32/
Empire Trade Commission, Apptmt. of Representative: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 5951 (iv).
Erie, London and Tillsonburg Ry. Co.: See
163/
Dugas, Hon. Mr. Justice, Date of Apptmt., &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sevigny) 2858 (ii).
Dumelong, Mr. E., Dismissal from L'Assomp-tion, P. O.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 580, 720 (i). Dumontier, Joseph, Apptmt. as Inland Rev. Inspector at Quebec, Qualifications: Ques. (Mr. A. II. Clarks) 3340 (ii).
Dunn, Albert, Charges re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4039 (iii). Dunnville Customs Revenue for 1910-11, Postal Revenue, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lalor) 2066 (ii). Dupont, Rene, Dismissal as Immigration Agent: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1864 (i).
Dupre, Dr., Postmaster at St. Robert, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
_____M. for Papers* (Mr. Cardin) 4782 (iii).
Dynamite and Explosives, Legislation re: Ques. (Mr. Robb) 724 (i).
' Eai l Grey ' and ' Minto,' Govt. Steamers, Names of Employees: M. for Ret..* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1816 (i).
Eastern Block Addition: in Com. of Sup., 1339
(i).	.
Eastern Townships, Eield for Immigrants: Remarks (Mr. McCrea) 6557 (iv).
' B. No. 12/
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.: See ' B. No.
90/	.
Esquimalt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6220 (iv).
Estende to Baddeck Line I.C.R., Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 576 (i).
Estimates, The (1911-12) Presented (Mr. W.
' T. White) 525 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Suppl., Presented (Mr. W. T. White)
1	971 (i), 4974 (iii), 6154 (iv).
Estimates Discussion in Concurrence:	Re-
1 marks (Mr. Emmerson) 6805 (iv).
Estimates, Discussion of Outside Works: Re' Marks re Ruling (Mr. Dep. Speaker) 2443 (ii).
' Estimates, Discussion of: Remarks (Mr. Puga-' ley) re Adjournment, 5937 (iv).
Estimates, Suppl.: Inquiry for (Mr. A. J. Mac' lean) 1575 (i).
' Estimates Omitted: See 'Pub. Works/ &c.
9 Estmere to Baddeck Branch Ry., Tenders re: M. for Cor* (Mr. McKenzie) 1589 (i). Excavators purchased from Mr. Harris, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 559 (i).

[Stage Direction]
Exchequer Court Act. (asst, judge) Amt.: See 'B. No. 168/
Exchequer Court Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1035, 1039 (i).
Excise Customs Duties: in Com. of Sup., 5827
(iv).
Excise Inspectors: in Com. of Sup., 5812 (iv).
Excise Preventive Officers: in Com. of Sup., 5824 (iv).
Excise Salaries to Inspectors, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5812 (iv).
Excise Travelling Expenses: in Com. of Sup., 5826 (iv).
Experimental Farms: in Com. of Sup., 6477
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Branch Stations: in Com. of Sup., 6477
(iv).
See ' Agriculture/
Experimental Farm Bulletins, Distribution, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6465 (iv).
Explosive Apparatus Testing Machinery: in Com. of Sup., 6603 (iv).
External Affairs Dept.: See ' B. No. 58/
Eyesight, Insurance of: See ' B. No. 126/
Falconer, R. S., Dismissal as Inspector on I.C.R., Apptmt. of Successor: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 543 (i).
See ' Faulkner/
False Creek Flats, Date of Application of Lease from Marpole and Macdonald: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5953 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Macdonald) 6186 (iv).
Farly, Mrs., Postmistress at St. Gabriel de Brandon, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Belaud) 2579 (ii).
Farmers' Bank Failure, Indemnifying Shareholders, Speech of Hon. Mr. Crothers re: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 3147 (ii).
Farmers' Bank, Inquiry by Chief Justice Meredith: Remarks (Mr. Morphy) 6710 (iv).
Farmers' Bank Investigation, Apptmt. of Sir "William Meredith: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3332 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 O. C. re Apptmt. of Sir William Meredith: M. for Copy* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 2853 (ii).
Farmers' Bank. Promises to Reimburse by Ministers, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 713 (i).
Farmers' Bank Reimbursements:	(Ques.)
(Mr. Lemieux) 528 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 527 (i).
Farmers' Bank, St. Jean, Indemnity to Depositors: Ques. (Mr. Demers) 551 (i).
Farmers' Bank, Speech of Hon. Mr. Crothers: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 3332 (ii).
Farming Implements, Cost of:	See ' Cockshutt.'
Fast Atlantic Service and Halifax Terminals: (Mr. Maclean) on M. for Sup., 6496 (iv).
Fast Atlantic SS.: 
FINANCE.
[Stage Direction]
Aud. Gen.'s Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White) 970 (i).
Banking Act Amt. Bill (Mr. Demers) on M.
to introduce (Mr. Speaker) 407 (i). Banking Act, Legislation re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1820 (i).
Bounties on Steel and Iron, Administration of Act: in Com. of Sup., 687 (i), 5934 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Budget Speech: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair)
4249 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Par. in Montreal ' Gazette ':	Remarks (Mr. Kyte) 2588 (ii).
Bounties on Steel Rods, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Neely) 529 (i).
B.C. Provincial Subsidy, Consultations with other Provs.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 573 (i).
Budget, The, 4985 (iii).
Charges of Management, Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 619 (i).
Coin Circulation: in Com. of Sup., 1034 (i). Debt of Canada, Average Interest:	Ques.
(Mr. Sinclair) 1811 (i).
Dom. Notes, Engraving, Tenders re: Ques.
(Mr. Murphy) 4778 (iii).
Dom. Notes, Printing, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1033 (i).
Dom. Notes, Printing, &c., Limitations re Tenders: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) on M. for Sup., 1820, 1841 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Complaints re British Tenders: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 5843 (iv).
Estimates, The (1911-12):	Presented (Mr. W. T. White) 525 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Suppl. (1912): Presented, 4974 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
1912-13: Presented (Mr. W. T. White)
971 (i), 6154 (iv).
Farmers' Bank Failure, Investigation, O.C. re Apptmt. of Sir William Meredith: M. for Copy* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3756
(ii).	i n m
cxviii
[Stage Direction]
FINANCE-Con.	;5
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 2853 (ii)
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3332
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Morphy) 6710 (iv).
Farmers' Bank, Promises to Reimburse by Ministers, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 713
(i), 3147, 3332 (ii).
'Farmers' Bank Reimbursements:	Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 528 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 527 (i).
Farmers' Bank, and Bank of St. Jean, Indemnity to Depositors: Ques. (Mr. Demers) 551 (i).
Finance, Deptl. Contingencies: in Com. of Sup., 1068 (i).
Financial Review (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 6707
(iv).
Gold Coinage, by Mint: Ques. (Mr. Thompson) 1213 (i).
Govt. Loans, Amounts, Rates of Interest, &c.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4777 (iii).
La Banque de St. Hyacinthe, Investigation re Liquidation:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)
2069 (ii).
La Banque de St. Hyacinthe and La Banque St. Jean, Reimbursements, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 528 (i).
Man. and N.S. Federal Subsidies, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4258 (iii).
Meredith, Hon. Sir William, Application re Leave of Absence: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 5954 (iv).
P.E.I. Better Terms: Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) on M. for Sup., 5171 (iii).
Public Accounts Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White) 11 (i).
Royal Mint: in Com. of Sup., 6584 (iv). Fisheries Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 140.' FISHERIES.
Alder Point Lobster Hatchery, Tenders, Contracts, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. McKenzie)
3053 (ii).
B.C. Herring Fishing, Authority re Close Season: Ques. (Mr. Shepherd) 4256 (iii).
iB.C. Fishing Licenses, Transfers, &c.: M. for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 8945 (ii).
B.C. Fisheries Question: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Stevens) 290 (i).
Canso Reduction Works, Dismissals, Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 874 (i).
Cold Storage for Bait re Fisheries:	in
Com. of Sup., 5256 (iii), 6653 (iv).
Dogfish Scrap, Price re: M. for Cor. (Mr. Sinclair) 1391 (i).
Fish, Fresh, Expenditure re Transportation: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2666 (ii).
See ' I.C.R.*
FISHERIES-Con.
Fishery Act, Prosecutions in Pictou County: M. for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1589 (i).
Fisheries Contracts with Stewards on Cruisers: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 681 (i).
Fisheries Department, Reorganisation of: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 936 (i).
Fishery Guardians in Guysborough County, Names, Dismissals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 3053 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissals: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3056 (ii).
Fishery Inspectors, N.S., Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4257 (iii).
Fisheries Inspectors, Dismissal, &e.:	in
Com. of Sup., 5242 (iii).
Fisheries Jurisdiction re Provinces f Ques. (Mr. H. Clark) 3339 (ii).
Fishery Overseer, J. A. Doucet, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Turgeon) 1590 (i).
Fishery Overseer, W. C. Robichaud, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Turgeon) 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Turgeon) 5259
(iii).
Fisheries Protection Service: in Com. of Sup., 5386 (iii).
Fisheries Protection Service on Pacific Coast, Capt. Newcombe's Rep.: M. for Copy (Mr. Clements) 2467 (ii).
Fishery Treaty with U.S., Withdrawal re-. Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 408 (i).
Fish Hatcheries, B.C., Cost of Construction: Ques. (Mr. Shepherd) 4256 (iii).
Fish Reduction Works at Arichat, Tel. re: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 2289 (ii).
Fish Scrap as Fertilizer: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 684 (i).
Fish Trap Licenses issued to Capt. J. H. Thorburn: M. for Pets.* (Mr. Law) 2861
(ii).
Gasoline Engines on Fishing Boats, Number, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2666 (ii).
Hague Tribunal, Fishery Regulations re: Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 3830 (ii).
Hurley, Mr. J. M., Fishery Inspector at Belleville, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2860 (ii).
I.C.R. Freight on Fish, Aid re Transportation: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 6748 (iv).
See ' Fish, Fresh.'
International Congress re Fisheries, Delegates: in Com. of Sup., 5237 (iii).
International Fisheries Commission: in Com. of Sup., 6646; cone., 6778 (iv).
' Kestrel ' Fishery Cruiser, Condemnation of: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 549 (i).

[Stage Direction]
cxix
FISHERIES-Con.
Lake Winnipegosis Fishery, Limitation re Catch: Ques. (Mr. Cruise) 3055 (ii). Lapointe, Mr. Joseph, Apptmt. as Overseer on Lake Aylmer: Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 1550
(iii)	-	-
Lobster Fishing Season in St. John, Date of Opening: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 722
(i).
Lobster Hatchery: in Com. of Sup., 5256
(iii).
Lobster Traps, Customs Changes in Tariff: on M. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) for Papers, 1362 (i).
Marine Hospitals for Fishermen: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 6787 (iv).
Medical Attendance, Free, for Fishermen: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 680 (i).
Murray, Dr., Poaching for Salmon on East River, N.S.: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5212 (iii).
Oyster Culture: in Com. of Sup., 5255 (iii). Pelagic Sealing Treaty, Ratification of: Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1460 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Explanation (Mr. Borden) 1550 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Compensation re Treaty: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 4776 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Remuneration to Commissioners: in
Com. of Sup., 5810 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Treaty between G.B., U.S. and Japan:
M. for Copy* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1590
(i).
Salmon Fisheries, B.C., Negotiations re Exportations, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3756 (ii).
Steam Trawlers and Fisheries Bounties: M.
for Pets* (Mr. Sinclair) 5957 (iv).
Steam Trawling on Canadian Coasts: M. for Papers (Mr. Sinclair) 2461 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of
Sup., 5388 (iii).	.
Twine for Lobster Nets: Remark (Mr. Sinclair) on M. for Sup., 5587 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Importations, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 3536 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Customs Duties: on M. for Sup. (Mr. A.	K. Maclean) 1070 (i).
Flags, Flying of: .See ' B. No. 74.'
Flax Seed, Stmnt. of, Excessive Freight Rates: Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 661 (i).
Flemming, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Inland Rev. at Petrolia: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 4259 (iii).
Flour Bags, Inspection of: See ' B. No. 78.' Foresters, Ancient Order of: See ' B. No. 157.' Forest, Mr. Medard, Excise Officer at L'Epi-phanie, Dismissal, Charges, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Nantel) 726 (i).
Fort McMurray and Athabasca Tel. Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2819 (ii).
Fort Osborne Barracks, Sale of: See ' B. No. 185.'
Franco-Canadian Trade Relations: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) on M. for Sup., 5747 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 5262 (iii).
Franking Campaign Literature: See 'Political.'
Fraser, Mr. John, Inspector at Stellarton, I.C.R., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3935 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in
Com. of Sup., 4188 (iii).
Fraser, Mr. John, Postmaster at Stellarton, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 516 (i).
Fraserville Bridge Works, Interview with Messrs. LeBel and Riou: Ques. (Mr. Gau-vreau) 519 (i).
Fraserville Wharf and Dredging, Expenditure re: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 3150 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Cor. re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 3531 (ii).
Fredericton and Grand Lake Coal & Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6224 (iv).
Freight Rates, Discrimination in the West: Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 3194
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Notice of Discussion (Mr. Turriff) 3048
(ii).
See ' Railways.'
French Canadian Repatriation, Policy of Govt. (Mr. Paquet) 619 (i).
French River, Dredging, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6657 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Devlin) re Provision in
Estimates, 6729 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Murphy) Cone., 6776 (iv).
French Translation of Revised Statutes: See ' B. No. 65.'
French Translator, Apptmt. of Mr. C. E. Duckett: M. (Mr. Borden) 1969 (ii).
Fritz, Henry, Dismissal as Fishery Overseer: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4977 (iii).
Fumigating Stations: in Com. of Sup., 6479
(iv).
Galops Canal, Upper Lock: in Com. of Sup., 5797 (iv).
Gananoque Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1855
(i)	-
Garceau, Mr. N„ Apptmt. as Inquiry Commissioner : Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2860
(ii)	.
[Stage Direction]
Resignation as Commissioner: Remarks
(Mr. Demers) in Com. of Sup., 5816 (iv).
Garthby, Lake Aylmer, Wharf Construction: M. for Papers* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (ii).
Gasoline Engines on Fishing Boats, Number, &c.: (Mr. Sinclair) 2666 (ii).
[Stage Direction]


Gaspe Basin Marine Agency, Apptmt. of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry, Salary, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1358 (i).
Gaspe Landing Pier, Appropriation re-. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2785
(ii).
Gaspe, Magdeleine and Chlorydormes Mail Contracts, Annulment of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1204 (i).
Gaspe Shore Tidal Wave, Govt. Aid re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2858 (ii).
Gaspe Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3305 (ii).
Gass, Trueman, Emplymt. and Dismissal on I.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2242 (ii).
Gatineau and TJngava Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 61.'
Gauthier, Alderic, Dismissal from Souianges Canal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4976 (iii).
Geological Survey, Explorations, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6604 (iv).
Georgian Bay Canal:	See 'B. No. 30/
Georgian Bay Canal, Govt. Construction, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 544 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Govt. Policy re: Remarks (Mr. Devlin)
3060 (ii).
See ' French River/
[Stage Direction]
 Rep. in Ottawa ' Citizen ' re Speech of
P.M.G. at Renfrew: Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 1970 (ii).
Georgian Bay Canal Route and French River: Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 6785 (iv).
Gerrior, Mr. William, Dismissal from Customs at Larry's River, N.S.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 3051 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3056 (ii).
Gillies, Capt., Dismissal:	Remarks (Mr. Mc-
Kenzie) in Com. of Sup., 3261 (ii).
Gillis Point Wharf Construction: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
Girard, Louis, Dismissal as Postmaster at Ste. Angele de Merici: M. for Pets.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2587 (ii).
Girroir, John, Resignation from I.C.Ry.: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 4185 (iii).
Glace Bay Mail Delivery, Delay, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. Carroll) 804 (i).
Glenelg, N.S., Postmaster, Complaints re, Pets., &c.:	M. for Papers* (Mr. Sinclair)
1817 (i).
Godbout, Mr. J., Emplymt. in Govt., Dismissal, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3752 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 4980 (iii).
Gold Coinage, by Mint.: Ques. (Mr. Thompson) 1213 (i).
See ' Coin/
Good Roads, Aid to: See ' B. No. 77/
Good Roads, ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Stevens) 284 (i).
Goods purchased by Public Works Dept-since Oct. 1911, Tenders re:	Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 1578 (i).
See ' Pub. Works-Purchases/ Gooseberry Cove, N.B., improvements re: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 555 (i).
Goose Creek Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2372
(ii)	.
Goueher, Wesley, Dismissal as Lightkeeper: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4977 (iii). Goulet, Mr., Apptmt. as Station Inspector, N.
T.Ry.: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 3935 (ii).
Govt. Appointments of Relatives of Members: Remarks [DOT] (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 6295-7 (iv).
See ' Dismissals/
Govt. Business, Precedence on Mondays: M.
(Mr. Borden) 2376 (ii).
Govt. Dredges, Contract re Boarding Employees:	Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 5953 (iv).
See ' Marine.'
Govt. Dredges and Tugs, Instructions re Ap pointments:	Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 5952 (iv).
Govt. Employees, Dismissal, Resignations, &c: M. for Ret. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 1818 (i).
See ' Dismissals.'
Govt. Employees, Inside and Outside Service, Dismissals, &c.:	M. for Ret* (Mr. Kyte)
2587 (ii).
Govt. House Property, Toronto, Sale Gf: See ' B. No. 182/
Govt. Loans, Amounts, Rates of Interest, &c.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4777 (iii).
Govt. Ownership:	See ' Cable,' ' Freight
Rates,' ' Parcel Post,' ' Railways,' &c.
Govt. Printing Patronage to Quebec Papers: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1357 (i). Govt. Purchases for Public Works, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1204 (i). Govt. Railways Management, Abolition of Govt. Ry. Managing Board:	Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 569 (i).
See ' I.C.R.'
Govt. Steamers, B.C., Use for Political Purposes:	Ques. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 5262
(iii)	.
Govt. Steamers, Building, &c.: Remarks (Mr. J.	D. Reid) in Com. of Sup., 1964 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Repairs, Construction, &c.: in Com. of
Sup., 5186, 5207 (iii).
See ' Marine.'
Govt. Works Tolls Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 103.' Gov. Gen.'s Office: in Com. of Sup., 1035, 1041 0)-
Governor General of Canada, Letters Patent: M. for Copy* (Mr. Macdonald) 2247 (ii).

Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@:  Regulations, 2187 (ii).

Transportation, 2187 (ii).
Country elevators, rules, &c., 2562 (ii). Country elevators and warehouses, 2568, 3181 (ii).
See 'Warehouse.'
Fees, 2304, 2323, 2326, 2573, 3156 (ii).
Flat warehouses, 2568 (ii).
Fort William elevators, 2317, 2383 (ii). Grades, 2536, 2767 (ii).
Grading, 2535 (ii).
Grain in bond, 2401, 3453 (ii).
Grain delivery on receipts, 4046 (iii).
Grain rejected, 2554, 2767, 3176, 3456 (ii). Grain of same grade to be kept together, 2383 (ii).
Grain Survey Board, 2535 (ii).
Grain Offices in Winnipeg, 2536, 3159, 3453
(ii)	.
Hospital elevators, 2547, 2548, 3177, 3757 (ii), 4042 (iii).
Inspection, 3157 (ii).
Inspectors security, 2202 (ii).
Inspection at Terminal elevators, 2561 (ii). Interpretation, 2548 (ii).
Licenses, 2561, 3182, 3457, 3761, 3798 (ii). Loading platforms, 2570, 3188, 3461 (ii).
' Manitoba Hard/ 2538, 2771, 3162 (ii), 4155
(iii)	.
Manufacturing license, 2561 (ii).
Mixing, 2313, 3458, 3799 (ii).
Oaths, 2201, 2302 (ii).
Overage, 2399, 3452 (ii).
Reinspection, 2382, 2755 (ii).
Sample markets, 2306, 2383, 3630, 3799 (ii), 4077 (iii).
Samples, rejection, of, 2545 (ii).
Screenings, 2554 (ii).
See ' Grain rejected.'
Seed grain, 2564 (ii).
Seed elevators, 3761 (ii).
In committee-Con.
Security by licenses, 3798 (ii).
Standards, establishment of, 2203, 2302, 2305, 2397, 3157, 3161 (id).
Terminal elevators, acquisition of, 3526 (ii).

privileges, buying and selling, 3762,
3773 (ii), 4042, 4058 (iii).

Tel. from Grain Growers Association:
Read (Mr. Knowles) 4744 (iid).
Grain Carriage to Duluth, &<[DOT].., Ref. to Washington Despatches: Stmnt. (Mr. Foster) 2577 (ii).
Grain Congestion in the North West: Remarks (Mr. McOraney) on M. for Sup., 5760
(iv).
Grain Congestion in the West, Car Distribution: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 6186 , 6556 (iv).

Stmnt. (Mr. Foster) 5954 (iv).
Grain Congestion in N.W.: Remarks on M.
for Sup. (Mr. Oliver) 6203 (v).
Grain Shipments from Canadian Ports, Quantity, Grades, &o.: Ques. (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 536 (i).
Grain Shipments from Port Arthur and Fort William: Ques. (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 539
Grain Shipments to Terminal Elevators: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 6792 (iv).
Grain Shipments from the West, Regulation of Freight Rates, &c.: Prop. Res. (Mr. Oliver) 3975, Neg. (Y. 54; N. 84 ) 4035 (ii).
Grain Storage *at Minneapolis: Inquiry for Papers (Mr. Oliver) 6493 (iv).
Grain Transportation in the West, Par. in Toronto Globe: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 5928
(iv).
Grand Lake and Belle River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6307 (iv).
G. T. R. Co.: See 'B. No. 130.'
G. T. R. Trainmen's Strike: See ' B. No. 130/
cxxii

G. T. Ry., Strike's and Board of Conciliation: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. MaeNutt) 3756 (ii).
G T. Ry. Trainmen's Strike, Settlement by late Govt., Judge Barron's Rep.: Ques. (Mr. Macdonell) 2580 (ii).
G. T. R., Running Rights over T. & N. 0. R., See 'B. No. 145.'
G T. P. Ry. Co.'s (charter extension) Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 20.'
G. T. P. Ry., Privy Council Judgment: See 'B. No. 95.'
G. T. P. Ry. (Brandon) Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6324 (iv).

Bridge fat Assiniboine, Subsidy: in Com.
on Res., Amt. (Mr. Borden) 6060 (iii).

Esquima.lt and Nanaimo Ry. Co.'s
Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5900 (iv).

Remuneration to Govt. Director: in
Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).

Workshops at Quebec, Agreement re
Site: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 3050 (ii).
Gray, W. W., Coal Inspector, Charges re Investigation by H. P. Duohemin: M. foT Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2588 (ii).
Great Northern Mining & Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6224 (iv).
Green, John B., Homestead Inspector, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. White) 6183 (iii).
Griever, Mr. S., Changes re Lighthouse Keeper: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1358 (a).
Guarantee Life Ins. Co. of Can.: See ' B. No. 154.'
Guillemette, Mr. N., Dismissal, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1210 (i).
Guimond, Eugene, Dismissal of: M. for Pets.* (Mr. Lemieiux) 2460 (ii).
Gutelius, Mt. P. P., Apptmt. to N. T. Ry. Investigation Commission, British Subject, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4038 (iii).

Improper form of Question:	Ruling
(Mr. Speaker) 3934 (ii).	*

Naturalization of, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 4978 (iii).
See ' N. T. Ry.'
Guysborongh Branch Ry. Appropriation: Remarks (Mt. Sinclair) on M. for Sup., 1445
(i), 5621 (iv).
Giuysborough Branch Line, I. C. R.: in Com. of Sup., 676 (d).

Construction re: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair)
571 (i).
Hagerty, Mr. S. W., Dismissal from Inspectorship of Ry. Station: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4976 (iii).
Ha Ha Bay Ry. Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5895, 6212 (iv).
Hale, Mr. Thos., Discharge as Labour Correspondent: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 4263 (iii).

Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 4459 (iii). I
Halifax, &c., Newfoundland & G. B., Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4727 (iii).
Halifax Dock Accommodation, I. C. R.: to Com. of Sup., 5596 (iv).
Halifax Terminal Facilities: Remarks (Mr. A, K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 4196 (iid).
See ' G.B. and Can. Mail Service,' ' Fast Atlantic.'
Hamel, Hector, Customs Appraiser, Montreal, Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 3343 (ii).
Hamilton Harbour: See ' B. No. 23.'
Hamilton, Waterloo and Gmelph Ry. Co.: See 'B. No. 47.'
Ham Nord Postmaster, Investigation Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Ham., Robt., Dismissal from Trachoma Hospital, Halifax: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 875 (i).
Hampton Highway Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 4225 (iii).
Hampton Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1527 (i).
Hampton Spur Line, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 675 (i).

 Construction re, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 572 (i).
Hansard, French Edition, Delay in Distribution, 269 (i).
See ' Debates.'
Harbour Commissioners Report: Presented (Mr. Hazen) 1571 (i).
Harbour, Geo. T., Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).

Letter re Dismissal: Read (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 3252 (ii).
Harbours and Rivers, Generally: in Com. of Sup., 3235 (ii).

Improvements, &c., Govt. Policy re: Re
marks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).

Man., Repairs, &e.; in Com. of Sup.,
2814 (ii).

 Mar. Provs.: in Com. of Sup., 2440 (ii).

N.B.: in -Com. of Sup., 623 (i), 2366 (ii).

 Que.: in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
Harmony to Elmira Branch Ry., P.E.I.: in Com. of Sup., 5659 (iv).
Harris, W. H., Postmaster. at White Head, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Sinclair) 2588 (ii).
See ' Whitehead.'
Harvey and Salisbury Ry., Contract re Rails: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 4171 (iii).

 Ry.: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Pugsley)
1843 (i).
See ' Albert,' &c.



[Stage Direction]
cxxiii
Hatfield, A. M., Charges re: M. for Copy* (Mr. Law) 5263 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Law) in Com. of Sup.,
5252 (iii).
Hattie, Wm. A., Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1815 (i).
Hawkes, Mr. A., Apptmt. in Immigration Dept.: M. (Mr. Oliver) for O. Cs., 605 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. Murpby) 527 (i).
Hayden, W. W., Wharfinger at Digby, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. iA. K. Maclean) 5957 (iii).
Headquarters Stag, Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5536 (iii).
Health Ass'n.: See ' B. No. 127.'
Health Department, Legislation re: Ques. (Mr. Knowles) 1585 (i).
Hebert, Auguste, Postmaster at St. Pascal, Dismissal: M. for Cor* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Eemarks (Mr. E. Lapointe) in Com. of
Sup., 6291 (iv).
Hefierman, Mr. F. S., Dismissal from Customs at Spring Hill, N.S.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4039 (iii).
Hendsbee, David S., Dismissal from Marine and Fisheries Dept.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 3342 (ii).
Henry, Norbert, Contract re Mails between Scott Junction and Station: Ques. (Mr Boland) 975 (i).
Highlands Bridge Construction: Remarks (Mr. Bickerdike) 1197 (i), 5790 (iv).
High River, Saskatchewan and Hudson Bay Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 81.'
Highways and Road Construction: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Pugsley) 142 (i).
Highways, Assistance to: See ' B. No. 77.'
Highways Improvements, Subsidies: in Com. of Sup., 6611 (iv).
Highways in N.S., Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 4226 (iii).
Highway Crossings eliminated on I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 5595 (iv).
Hillsboro Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1528 (i).
Historic Tableaus in Ottawa Govt. Buildings: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 1336 (i).
Homestead Inspectors, Number employed in Sask., Number dismissed: Ques. (Mr. L. Thomson) 1588 (i).
Horncastle, Isabella Helen, Relief of: See ' B. No. 147.'
Horse Racing: See ' B. No. 165.'
Horses destroyed at Weyburn, Rep. re-. Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 6790 (iv).
Horses imported from U.S., Destruction of for Glanders: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 5693, 5939 (iv).
Horsfall, Herbert, Relief of: See ' B. No. 109.' Houle, Stanislas, Emplymt. on Soulanges Canal: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 3537 (ii).
HOUSE OF COMMONS:
Additional Accommodation for Members: in Com. of Sup., 1951 (i).
Ash Wednesday, Adjournment for: M. (Mr. Borden) 3343 (ii).
Ballots, Voting by Divisions: Ques. (Mr. Burnham) 4979 (iii).
Bibeau, Mr. A., Sessional Clerk, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 4248 (iii). Bills, Royal Assent, Com. from Gov. Gen.'e Sec.: Read (Mr. Speaker) 4775 (iii). Business of the House, Morning Sittings: M.
(Mr. Borden) 4980 (iii).
Carleton County Electoral Vacancy, Issue of Writ: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1810 (i). Chicoutimi Controverted Election, Certificate of Judge: Presented (Mr. Speaker) 11 (i). Christmas Adjournment for Holidays: M. (Mr. Borden) 927 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 702 (i).
Coffin, Mr. Henry, Emplymt. as Sessional Messenger, Reinstatement:	Ques. (Mr. Guilbault) 2289 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. Picotte: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Seguin)
2459 (ii).
See ' Picotte.'
Committees, Sel. Standing: M. (Mr. Borden) 10 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Lists: Presented (Mr. Borden) 703 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. to present Rep. (Mr. Borden) 794
(i).
Distribution Office, Salaries: M. to cone, in Senate Report, &c.: (Mr. Borden) 6660 (iv). Downey, W. H., Returning Officer, Kings and Albert, Non-Payment of: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 2057 (ii).
Govt. Business, Precedence on Mondays: M. (Mr. Borden) 2376 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Wednesday Sittings, M. (Mr. Borden)
re Precedence, 1969 (ii).
House of Commons Desks, Changes re-. Remarks in Com. of Sup., 623 (i).
House of Commons Employees, Salary Increases: M. (Mr. Borden) to cone, in report of Mr. Speaker, 6660 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Improvements re Acoustics: Remarks
(Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 1335 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Messengers, Dismissals, &c.: M. for Stmnt.* (Mr. Ethier) 562 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. C. A. Wilson)
6807 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Stenographers: in Com. of Sup., 6461
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks re (Mr. Pugsley) 1846 (i).

[Stage Direction]
HOUSE OF COMMONS-Con.
[Stage Direction]
 Ventilation: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) in
Com. of Sup., 1336 (i).
Internal Economy Commission, Names, presented (Mr. Borden) 11 (i).
Joliet-te County Returning Officer, Payments re: Ques. (Mr. Guilbault) 4979 (iii). Lanctot Investigation, Counsel Fees re: m Com. of Sup., 6486 (iv).
Legislation, Joint Com.: M. (Mr. Borden) 2217 (ii).
Library Committee: M. (Mr. Borden) 795
(i>.
Library, House of Commons, Improvements, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1950 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Report presented (Mr. Borden) 11
(i).
Me Don gall, J. M„ Counsel Fees re Lanotot Investigation: in Com. of Sup., 6486 (iv). Maskinonge Election Expenses, Settlement of: Ques. (Mr. Redlemare) 4776 (iii). Members Travelling Allowances during Adjournments: Bemarks (Mr. Knowles) 1848
(i).	.	.	.
Parliamentary Documents, Distribution: in Com. of Sup., 6613 (iv).
Parliament, Opening of Com. from Gov.
Gen.'s Sec.: Bead (Mt. Speaker) 6 (i). Picotte, Mederic, Messenger H. of C., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2065 (ii). See ' Coffin.'
Political Literature, Application re Free Postage: Ques. (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 1585
(i).
Private Bills, Extension of Time: M. (Mr. Borden) 930 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Eep. of Examiner re Pets., Divergency
of Buies: Bemarks (Mr. Speaker) 643 (i). Prorogation, Com. from Gov. Gen.'s Sec.: Bead (Mr. Speaker) 6780 (iv).
Quebec West Controverted Election, Certificate of Judge: Presented (Mr. Speaker) 407 (i).
Questions, Improperly drafted:	Bemarks
(Mr. Speaker) 4983, 5054 (iii).
Renfrew South, Electoral Vacancy: Notification (Mr. Speaker) 926 (i).
Restaurant Com.: M. for Com. (Mr. Borden) 710 (i).
Restaurant, Payments to Waiters: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 2861 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Minimum Wages paid in Cites: Ques.
(Mr. Verville) 3049 (ii).
Booms allotted to Liberal Members, Complaints re: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 670 (i). Saturday Sittings: Stmnt. (Mr. Borden) 5830
(iv).
Sessional Employees dismissed, Number &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 568 (i), 2064 (ii).
HOUSE OF COMMONS-Con.
Speaker, Election of: M. (Mr. Borden) 2, 5
(i).
[Stage Direction]
 Deputy: M. (Mr. Borden) 519, 523 (i).
Speaker, Mir., Congratulations re Beading Prayers in French (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1808 (i).
Statutes of Previous Sessions, Delay re Distribution: Remarks (Mir. A. H. Clarke) in Com. of Sup., 678 (i).
Telephones, Long Distance, &c., in H. of C.: Bemarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3243 (id).
Voters' Lists, Preparation of by Federal Govt., Stmmt. of Min. of the Int.: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 553 (i).
Voters' Lists in Man., Distribution re: M.
for Cor.* (Mir. Staples) 3056 (ii). Yamaska Electoral Agent: Que®. (Mr. Mon-don) 1584 (i).
Hudson Bay E,v. Construction: in Com. of Sup., 622, 677 (i), 5762, 6605 (iv).
Hudson Bay By. Construction, Cor. re: M. (Mr. Aikins) for Papers, 1213 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. (Mr. Nedly) for O. Cs., 732 (i).
Hudson Bay Ry.: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 132 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Bemarks (Mr. Murphy) 6776 (iv).
Hudson Bay Ports, Nav., &c.: M. for Reps.* (Mt. Aikins) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Surveys, re Navigation, &e.: Ques. (Mt.
Aikins) 3943 (ii).
Hull City Hall Square, Improvements by Improvement Commission: Ques. (Mr. Kidd) 2293 (ii).
Hull Dismissals: See 'Dismissals.'
Hull Superior Court, Apptmt. of Mr. Chau-vin: Ques. (Mir. Lemieux) 4261 (iii).
See ' Chauvin.'
Humboldt Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2211 (ii).
Hurley, Mr. J. M., Fishery Inspector at Belleville, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2860 (ii).
Hydro-Electric Commission, Power for Govt. Buildings: Bemarks (Mr. Armstrong) 3289
(ii).
Ice-breaker at St. Gerard, Tenders re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2151 (ii). lie Bezard and Ste. Genevieve Wharfs, Completion of repairs, &c.: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 557 (i).
H- Rouge Lighthouse Keeper, Dismissal of Mr. Irving: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreiau) 4259 (iii). IMMIGRATION-
Agents in Belgium, Number &e.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
Agents, Dismissals, Number and Names: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 877 (i).

[Stage Direction]
IMMIGRATION-Core.
Agencies, G. B. and Can., Salaries, &e.: in Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1212 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
Agencies, G. B. and Can., Salaries &c.:	in
Com. of Sup., 3305, 3911 (ii).
Agents, Notification to Booking Agents re Bonus: Ques. (Mr. Sutherland) 875 (i). Asselin, Mr. Oliver, Emplymt. by Immigration Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Cairvell) 1813
(i).
' British News,' &c., Purchase by Dept, of Int.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 6660
(iv).
Chinese entering B. C., Total Number: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 4778 (iii).
Chinese Tax in. B. C.: Ref. to .in debate on Address (Mr. Stevens) 285 (i).
Chinese and Japanese in B. C., Number naturalized, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 555
[Stage Direction]
Eastern Townships, Field for Immigrants: Remarks (Mr. McCrea) 6557 (iv).
Farm Labourers, Placing of, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sutherland) 5263 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Agents re &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sutherland)
874 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Complaints re: M. for Papers* (Mr. Sutherland) 4781 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Sutherland) in Com. of
Sup., 3923 (ii).
Farm Labourers in Quebec, Number, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1359 (i).
French Canadian Repatriation, Policy of Govt. (Mr. Paquet) 619 (i).
Hawkes, Mr. Arthur, Apptmt. re Immigration Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 527 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. (Mr. Oliver) for O. Cs. 605 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Report of Mr. Hawkes: Inquiry for
(Mr. Oliver) 6551 (iv).
Hospitals, Number and Location: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1210 (i).
Immigration, Amount expended, Number of Immigrants, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1211
(i).
Immigrants deported, Number, Amount expended: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1213 (i). Immigrant Inspection before Sailing for Canada: Remarks (Mr. Biokerdike) 618
(i).
Immigration Office in London, Out.: Ques. (Mr. Elsom) 2451 (ii).
Immigration in Ont., Promise to Premier re Assistance: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 546 (i).
Immigration Premiums, Amount expended: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1212 (i).
Immigration Regulations re entering Canada: in Com. of Sup., 3911 (ii).
IMMIGRATION-Con.
Immigration Societies, State-Aid, Amounts expended, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1211
(i).
Immigration from U.S., re Wm. Pearson Co.: Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 3152 (ii). Immigration from U.S., Opposition by Govt.: Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 3154 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 3154 (ii).
Japanese, Oriental, Immigration, Legislation re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 875
(i)	.
Labour Conditions in B. C., Emplymt. of Orientals: Remarks (Mr. Barnard) 177 (i). Laforce, Mr. J. W., Emplymt. as Immigration Agent: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 2242 (ii). Laurier, Mr. C. A., Immigration Agent at Marquette, Mich.:	Ques. (Mr. Boulay)
2454 (ii).
Laurier, Mr. R., Immigration Agent at Detroit: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 2454 (ii). Literature, French Publications:	Ques.
(Mr. Paquet) 1212 (i).
Mar. Provs. Immigration Policy:	Prop.
Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2072 (ii).
Medical Examiners, Number, Names, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 1213 (i).
Murray, J. P., Carpet Co., Breach of Immigration Regulations:	Ques. (Mr. Verville) 550 (i).
Negro Immigration: Remarks on Immigration Question (Mr. Thoburn) 608 (i). Oriental Immigration, Total Number: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 4779 (iii).
Sevigny, Mr. J. E., Apptmt. by Immigration Dept.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1205, 1588, 1814 (i).
Sikhs in B.C., Decision re bringing in their wives: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2457 (ii). Syrian Immigration, Pet. re O.C.:	Ques.
(Mr. Lapointe) 1209 (i)
Imperial Loan and Investment Co. of Can.: See ' B. No. 184.'
Imperial Naturalization, Uniformity re: on M. for Sup. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2420
(ii)	.
Indemnity to Members: See ' B. No. 75.' INDIANS:
Abenakis Indian Agent, Apptmt. and Salary: Ques. (Mr. Mondou) 1587 (i). Doncaster Indian Reserve Road Repairs: in Cone., 6806 (iv).
Indians, Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1039 (i).
Police Point Reserve Transfer: M. for Papers* (Mr. Buchanan) 5557 (iv).
Watha Indian Reserve, Tenders re Timber: Ques. (Mr. Henderson) 3055 (ii).
cxxvi
[Stage Direction]
Industrial Disputes Investigation:	See ' B.
No. 87/
Industrial Disputes Investigation Act:	in
Com. of Sup., 1498 (i), 6615 (iv).
Industrial Training and Education Royal Commission: in Com. of Sup., 1527 (i). Inland Revenue, Deptl. Salaries: in Cone., 6770 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Private Secretary: in Com. of Sup.,
6490 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Promotions, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6490
Cone., 6771 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1040, 1061 (i).
Inland Revenue Reports:	Presented (Mr. Nan tel) 565 (i).
Inquiries Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 19/
Insect and Pest Destruction Act, Enforcement of: in Com. of Sup., 6479 (iv).
Inspection and Sale Act Amt.:	See ' B. No.
78/
Inspectors re Weights and Measures: in Com.
of Sup., 5828 (iv).
INTERCOLONIAL RT.:
Air Brakes: in Com. of Sup., 4136 (iii). Archibald, Mr. P. B., Emplymt. by Ry Dept.:	Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
933 (i).
Ash, Mr. Earl, Claims re Damages for Fire on I.C.R.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Emmerson) 2246 (ii).
Benoit, Mr. Joseph, Dismissal from I.C.Ry.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 4184 (iii).
Board of Management: in Com. of Sup., 4136 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Abolition of:	on M. for Sup. (Mr. Emmerson) 5571 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 569 (i).
Bourque, Mr. Jeffrey, Claims re Damages on I.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2243 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Reps.* (Mr. Boulay) 2459 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 5610 (iv).
Branch Lines, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 622 (i), 4135 (iii).
Branch Lines: Prop. Res. (Mr. Emmerson) 985 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Accommodation, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Davidson) in Com. of Sup., 4218 (iii). Branch Lines, Acquisition by Govt., Tel. re: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 565 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Legislation re Acquisition:	Ques.
(Mr. Emmerson) 569 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Subsidies to, &c.: in Com. of Sup.,
5618 (iv).
Bridge Strengthening: in Com. of Sup., 4137
(iii).
INTERCOLONIAL-Con.
Brotherhood Unions, Agreements, &c.: M.
(Mr. A. K. Maclean) for Papers, 793 (i). Campbellton Ry. Accommodation: in Com. of Sup., 4162 (iii).
Caraquet and North Shore Branch Line, I.C. Ry., Inspection re Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Turgeon) 4192 (iii).
Chatham Diversion: in Com. of Sup., 4137
(iii).
Coal Supply, Tenders re:	Ques. (Mr. E.
M. Macdonald) 2457 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in
Com. of Sup., 5611 (iv).
Condon, D. Murray, Passenger Agent: Transfer of, Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 3337 (ii). Construction and Working Expenses:	in
Com. of Sup., 4130 (iii).
Dartmouth Branch Line: in Com. of Sup., 670 (i).
Dartmouth to Denus Branch Line, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 543 (i). Double Tracking: in Com. of Sup., 5637 (iv). Estende to Baddeck Branch Line, Tenders re-. Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 576 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Papers (Mr. McKenzie) 2494
(ii).
Extension Branches: in Com. of Sup., 673
(i).
Facilities on I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 5809; cone., 6774 (iv).
Fences, Number of Rods, Campbellton Division: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 6748 (iv).
Freight on Fish, Aid re Transportation: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 6748 (iv).
Girroir, John, Resignation from I.C.Ry.: Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 4185 (iii).
Guysborough Branch Line:	in Com. of
Sup., 676 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Construction re:	Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 571 (i).
Halifax Dock Accommodation: in Com. of Sup., 5596 (iv).
Hampton Highway Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 4225 (iii).
Hampton Spur Line: in Com. of Sup., 675
(i).
Highway Crossings eliminated: in Com. of Sup., 5595 (iv).
Hillsborough Branch, Rails Ipaned, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Fowler) 4978 (iii).
I.C.R. and G.T. Ry. Arbitration, Delays in Settlement, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Davidson)
3939 (ii).
I.C.R., Control by Ry. Commission, Res. re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 4979 (iii).

[Stage Direction]
INTERCOLONIAL-Con.
Lavoie, Mr. Absolon, Inquiry re Death on l.C.R.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 4263
(iii).
Locomotives manufactured at Moncton: in Com. of Sup., 5607 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 &c.: Remarks (Mr. Boulay) in Com.
of Sup., 5655 (iv).
Madore, Alphonse, Claims for Damages: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3055 (ii).
' Market Tickets ' to Employees: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 5809 (iv).
Matapedia to Gaspe Basin Line, I.C. Ry. Inspection re Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 4194 (iii).
Matapedia Water Works Co., Claims against I.C. Ry.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 4263
(iii)	.
Moncton Ry. Office, Fittings, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6604 (iv).
Moncton Office, Tenders re Heating, Stmnt. re: Ans. (Mr. Monk) 6744 (iv).
Moncton Shops, Contract for Heating, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5611, 5762 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Operation, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5604
(iv)	.
[Stage Direction]
Transfer to Fraserville: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 544 (i).
Morice, Theophile, Dismissal from: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 4262 (iii).
Mulgrave Highway Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 4225 (iii).
North Sydney Diversion Line: in Com. of Sup., 5610 (iv).
Ocean Limited, Instructions re Transportation of Private Cars: Ques. (Mr. Ernmer-son) 2241 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) on cone.,
6774 (iv).
Passes to Employees, Newspaper Reporters, &c., Instruction from Ottawa: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 2328 (ii).
Pay Day, Changes re: Ques. (Mr. Brouil-lard) 3340 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Instructions re Holiday and Sunday
Pay, &c,: Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 1583 (i).
Pictou Employees, Charges re Political Partisanship: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Macdonald) 2246 (ii).
Provident Fund, Payments to Dismissed Officials: M. (Mr. Emmerson) to Com. of Sup., 5930 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2450 (ii).
Pullman Conductors, Promotions, &c.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1413 (i).
Ry. Ties, Contract re at Sayabec: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4041 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Contract with Dame Boulay: M. for
Cor.* (Mr. Carvell) 5957 (iii).
INTERCOLONIAL-Con.
Refrigerator Cars: in Com. of Sup., 5603 (iv).
Riviere du Loup, Increased Accommodation: in Com. of Sup., 5654 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Shops Removal to Fraserville: Ques.
(Mr. Gauvreau) 570 (i).
Rolling Stock: in Com. of Sup., 5609, 5653, 6461 (iv).
Roy, Wm, Rep. of H. Boulay re Charges on l.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 934 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Papers (Mr. Boulay) 1391 (i).
Ste. Anne de la Pocati&re Fence Poles, Charges re Removal, Investigation, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Paquet) 2586 (ii).
St. Laurent, Xavier, Claims for Loss of Horse killed: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 4263 (iii).
Ste. Rosalie Branch Line, Accommodation, Complaints re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 4134 (iii).
Snow Blockade, Delay to Trains: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1409 (i).
Steamship Connections with l.C.R., Subsidies, &c.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5597 (iv).
Sunnybrae and Guysborough Branch Ry., l.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2289 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 542 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Supt., Application from Member of
H.	C.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4040 (iii).
Sydney Mines Diversion: in Com. of Sup., 5658 (iv).
Ticket Collectors, Appmt of.: Remarks (Mr. Gauvreau) 6786 (iv).
Truro Station: in Com. of Sup., 4231 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Tenders re Construction: Ques. (Mr. A.	K. Maclean) 1412 (i).
Yale Railroad, Operation by l.C.R.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5612 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Legislation re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 933 (i).
Wallace Harbour Spur Line: in Com. of Sup., 6604 (iv).
Working Expenses, Construction, &c., Statement (read): in Com. of Sup., 4162 (iii).
INTERIOR:
Crown Lands in Man., Sask. and Alberta, Number of Acres, Reservations for School Lands: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1587 (i).
Interior Depth Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1038 (i).
Internal Economy Commission Names: presented (Mr. Borden) 11 (i).
International Congress re Fisheries, Delegates: in Com. of Sup., 5237 (iii).
International Fisheries Commission: in Com.
of Sup., 6646; cone., 6778 (iv).
International Guarantee Co.: See r B. No. 148.'
exxviii
[Stage Direction]
International Institute of Agriculture:	in
Com. of Sup., 6478 (iv).
International Waterways: See 'Boundary/ Interprovincial Fire Ins. Co.: See ' B. No. 141/ Interprovincial and James Bay Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 67/
Inverness Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
Investigation re Govt. Dismissals: See ' B. No. 19/
See ' Dismissals/
Investigation re Dismissals, Cost of, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Cardin) 5950 (iv).
Isaac, Isobell, Relief of: See ' B. No. 131/ Jacques, Leander, Postmaster, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Bdland) 3339 (ii).
James Bay Ry. Subsidy: in Com., 6309 (iv). Japanese, Oriental, Immigration, Legislation re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 875 (i).
See ' Immigration/
Jenkins, Wm. A. Hunt, Relief of: See ' B. No. 162/
Joint Stock Companies Inspection, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Sevigny) 2857 (ii).
Joliette County Returning Officer, Payments re: Ques. (Mr. Guilbault) 4979 (iii).
Jones, Chas. O., Dismissal, Evidence, &c.: M. for Copy* (Mr. Kay) 3757 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks, 5161 (iii).
Judges Act (salaries) Amt.: See ' B. No. 156/ Judges for Ont., Apptmt. of Additional in Ont.: Remarks (Mr. German) in Com. of Sup., 1035 (i).
Judges in Yukon: See 'B. No. 123/
Judges of Superior Court, Montreal, Superannuation, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Ethier) 2459
(ii).
JUSTICE:
Burrard Power Co. v. The King, Judgment of Judicial Com.: M. for Copy* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1409 (i).
Deputy Minister of Justice, Travelling Expenses: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3150 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Extra Payments, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Cruise) 2458 (ii).
Dugas, Hon. Mr. Justice, Date of Apptmt., &c.: Ques. (M,r. Sevigny) 2858 (id).
Hull Superior Court, Apptmt. of Mr. Ohau-vin: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4261 (iii). Judges for Ont., Apptmt. of Additional in CXnt.: Remarks (Mr German) in Com. of Snp., 1035 (i).
Judges of Superior Court, Montreal,' Superannuation, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Ethier) 2459 (ii).
Justice, Deptl. Promotions: in Com. of Sup., 6584 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Litigation Expenses: in Com. of Sup.,
6561 (iv).
JUSTICE-Con.
Justice, Min. of, Payments to; Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 725 (i).
Letellier, Judge Blaise, Residence re : Ques.
(Mr. Lavallee) 3150 (ii).
Montreal Circuit Court Judge, Additional: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 545 (i), 2855 (ii).

Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 3907 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Additional Salaries: in Com. of Sup.,
6597 (iv).
Northwest Territories, Administration of Justice: in Com. of Sup., 6565 (iv).
Ottawa County Superior Court, Additional Judge: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 4121 (iii). Penitentiaries in Canada Report: Presented (Mr. Doherty) 970 (i).
Ritchie, Hon. Mr. Justice, Apptmt. of: Remarks (Mir. Macdonald) 3331 (ii).
Solicitor General, Apptmt. of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1816 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1577 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 546 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5162
(iii).
Solicitor General, Payment of Salary to Min. of Justice, &o.: Que-s. (Mr. Ethier) 725 (i).
Supreme Court of Canada, Division re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 547 (i). Tourigny, Mr. Justice, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 3147 (ii).
Juvenile Delinquents Act: See ' B. No. 2/ Keewia/tdn, Pet. re Educational Clause: Qraes. (Mr. Barrette) 3149 (ii), 4240 (iii).
See ' Man. Boundaries B. 115/
Keewatin. R. C.: Corporation: See ' B. No. 69/ Kelley's Cove Breakwater, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. Law) 3340 (ii).
Kelly, Edward, Dismissal from Causo Reduction Works: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3341 (ii).
Kennedy, Allan, Govt. Telegraph Repairer, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor. (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
Kennedy, John Rogers, Relief of: See ' B. No. 164/
Kennedy, Mr., Charges re: Remarks (Mr. A.
W. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2020 (ii). Kemnie, Capt., Edmund, Dismissal, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Pugsley) 6782 (iv).
' Kestrel ' Fishery Cruiser, Condemnation of: Ques. (Mr. Stevens) 549 (i).
Kettle Valley Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 62/ Kettle Valley Ry. Co/e Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5899, 6220, 6322 (iv).
Kettle Valley Ry. Oo/s Bridge Subsidy:	in
Com., 6327 (iv).
Kidsons' Island Lighthouse, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 3054 (ii).


INDEX-1911-12 CXX1X
[Stage Direction]
King's Printer, Apptmt. of Assistant: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 1809 (i).
Kingston, R. M. C. Buildings: in Com. of Sup., 1855 (i).
Kirounc, Mr., Postmaster at Mamseau, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Paoaud) 2579 (ii).
Kootenay and Alberta Ry. Co.: See ' B No. 48.'
Kootenay Central Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 91.'
Kootenay Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5899, 6219 (iv).
La Banque do St. Hyacinth® and La Banque St. Jean, Reimbursements, &c. -. Ques. (Mu-. Lemdeux) 528 (i).
See ' Farmers Bank.'
[Stage Direction]
 Investigation re Liquidation:	Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 2069 (id).
Laberge, Mr., Compensation to Family re-. Remarks (Mr. Ethiar) in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).
Labour Conditions in B. C., Eunplymt. of Orientals: Remarks (Mr. Barnard) 177 (i).
Labour, Deptl. Contingencies: in Com. of Sup., 6615 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Private Secretary: in Com. of Sup.,
6615 (iv).
' Labour Gazette ' Correspondents, Apptmt. in Richelieu County: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 2292
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissal®, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Verville)
1411 (i).
Remarks (Mr. Verville) on M. for Sup., 14-41 (d).
[Stage Direction]
in Com. of Sup., 1468 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Names of Apptmts.: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 1865 (i).
' Labour Gazette,' Printing and Distribution &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1468 (ii).
Labour Strike Funds: See ' B. No. 87.'
Lachenaie Postmaster, Complaints re-. Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 5949 (iv).
L'Aohigam Ice Breaker, Tender® re Construction, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2294 (ii).
Lachine Cana.l, Lock Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 6611 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Rockfield Bridge: in Com. of Sup.. 5790
(iv).
Lachine Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i), 1952 (ii).
Lacombe, Mr. J. A., Dismissal from St. Se-bastien P. 0., Inquiry re-. Ques. (Mr. Belaud) 974 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Beland) in Com. of Sup.,
6618 (iv).
Lao Seuil, Rat Portage and Keewatin Ry Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6217 (iv).
Laforce, Mr. J. E., Bmplymt. by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Michaud) 3535 (ii).
Laforoe, Mr. J. W., Emiplymt. as Immigration Agent: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 2242 (ii).
I
Labe Erie and Northern Ry. Co.'s Subsidy, in Com., 6312 (iv).
Lake Temiskaming Dam, Tenders, Contracts, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Pugsley) 2459 (ii).
See ' Pub. Works.'
Lake Wimnipegosis Fishery, Limitation re Catch: Quee. (Mr. Currie) 3055 (ii).
Lalonde, Alfred, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Clardin) 4779 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Cardin) 6783 (iv).
Lalonde, Mr. Damien, Rep. re Assault: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4255 (iii).
Lanctot Investigation, Counsel Fees re: in Com. of Sup., 6486 (iiv).
See ' House of Commons..
Land Grants to Railways in Western Provs., prior to 1896: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 725 (i)-
Land Scrip, &c., to Veterans: See ' B. Nos. 137 & 190.'
Lapointe, Mr. Joseph, Apptmt. as Overseer on Lake Aylmer: Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 4550 (iii).
Laroche, Capt. Leon, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Fortier) 4549 (idi).
Larry's River Dredging, Apptmt. of Inspector: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 5055 (iii).
La Societe National Gymmastique, Gaunt to: in Com. of Sup., 5811 (iv).
L'Assomption Wharf, Appropriations re: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2451 (ii), 5951, 6781 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Continuation of Construction:	Ques.
(Mr. Seguin) 2579 (ii).
Laurentides Public Building, Acquisition of Property:	Ques.	(Mr. Seguin) 2451 (ii).
Laurier, Mr. C. A., Immigration Agent at Marquette, Mich.:	Ques. (Mr. Boulay)
2454 (ii).
Laurier, Mr. R., Immigration Agent at Detroit: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 2454. (ii).
Lauzon, Desire, Emplymt. py Govt., References as to Character:	Ques. (Mr. Ethier)
3538 (ii).
Lavergne, Capt. Armand, Apptmt. re Capt. 61st Regiment:	Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe)
723 (i).
Lavoie, Mr. Absolon, Inquiry re Death on I. C.R.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 4263 (iii).
Lavoie, Mr. Calixte. Postmaster, Dismissal, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Brouillard) 3339 (ii).
Lawlor's Island Quarantine Station: in Com. of Sup., 134.1, 1531 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Memorials, re -. M. for Copies* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 2460 (ii).
Leaiteh, Alvena Bell, Relief of: See ' B No 142.'
Lebel, Mr. W., Dismissal from Customs: Ques. (Mr. E. Lajjointe) 1864 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
' Le Devoir,' Quotations from:	Ques. of Order (Mr. Blondin) 371; Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 372 (i).
[Stage Direction]


Legault, Mr. Ophir, Postmaster at LTle Per-rot, Dismissal, &c.t Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 5950 (iv).
Legislation, Joint Com.:	M. (Mr. Borden)
2217 (ii).
Leigh, Mr. W. M., Dismissal from Kirkton Post Office:	Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin)
5949 (iv).
Lemieux, Hon. Mr., Ex. P.M.G., Par in Le Devoir' re Dismissals:	Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2864. (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. Ruled out (Mr. Speaker) 2580 (ii).
Lemieux, Mr., Relatives appointed to Govt. Service: List read (Mr. Boulay) in Com. of Sup., 6297 (iv).
Lepage, M. J., Preventive Officer, Rimouski, Dismissal, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4458
(iii)-
Leroux, Mr., Soulanges Canal, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 6183 (iii).
Letellier, Judge Blaise, Residence re: Ques.
(Mr. Lavallee) 3150 (ii).
Lethbridge Armoury, Plans, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 729 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Buchanan) in Com. of
Sup., 2210 (ii).
Lethbridge Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 728 (i).
Lethbridge Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2212 (ii).
Level Ry. Crossings:	See ' B. No. 5.'
L'Evenement Publishing Co., Minister acting as Director:	Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1813
(i).
Levis Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i). Levis Dry Dock: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Belaud) 6492 (iv).
Levis Graving Dock, &c.:	in Com. of Sup.,
3295 (ii).
Library Committee: M. (Mr. Borden) 795 (i). Library, House of Commons, Improvements, &e.: in Com. of Sup., 1950 (ii).
Library of Parlt., Report Presented (Mr. Borden) 11 (i).
Life Saving Awards:	in Com. of Sup., 5228
(iii)	.
Lighthouse and Coast Service, Inspectors Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 5232 (iii). Lighthouses, Construction, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5237 (iii).
Lighthouse Keepers at Rcpentigny, Charges re, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3752 (ii), 5949
(iv)	.
Lighthouse Keepers, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 6650 (iv). Lightkeepers in N.S., Investigation re Charges:	Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5233 (iii).
Lightkeepers in P.E.I., Investigation re Charges:	Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) in
Com. of Sup., 5232 (iii).
Linwood and Grosvenor Mail Service:	Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 6281
(iv).
Little Anse Harbour Improvements: Remarks (Mr. Kyte) in Com. of Sup., 2043 (ii).
Liverpool-Manitoba Assurance Co.:	See ' B.
No. 13.'
Live Stock Industry: in Com. of Sup., 6469
(iv).
Live Stock, Inspection re Shipping: in Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Live Stock Record Assns.: See ' B. No. 167.'
Living, Cost of, Special Rep.: Presented (Mr. Crothers) 6332 (iv).
Lizotte, Luc., Postmaster at Pacome, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3756 (ii).
Lobster Fishing Season in St. John, Date of Opening: Ques. (Mr. A. Iv. Maclean) 722 (i).
Lobster Hatchery: in Com. of Sup., 5256 (iii).
Lobster Traps, Twine, Customs Changes in Tariff: on M. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) for Papers, 1362 (i).
[Stage Direction]
on M. for Sup. (Mr. A. K. Maclean)
1070 (i).
See * Fisheries.'
Locas, Mr. Henri, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3338 (ii).
Locomotives manufactured at Moncton I.C.R.: in Com. of iSup., 5607 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Renewing, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Boulay)
in Com. of Sup., 5655 (iv).
Logs, Stealing of: See ' B. No. 9.'
Londonderry Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 6337 (iv).
London, Eng., Dom. Building:	in Com. of
Sup., 6655 (iv).
See ' Can. Offices.'
Longshoremen's Strike, Montreal, Settlement re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 269 (i).
Lords Day Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 85.'
Lorneville Breakwater, N.B. Tests re Foundation, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 555 (i).
Lotbiniere County Postmasters, Dismissal, Number, Names, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Fortier)
972 (i).
Louiseville Public Building: Cone-, 6794 (iv).
Lowe, Robt. S., Emplymt. by Public Works Dept., Leave of Absence, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 3754 (ii).
Loyal Order of Moose: See 'B. No. 158.'
Lumber Duties, Inspection re, Report in Winnipeg 'Free Press':	Ques. (Mr. Turriff) 2446 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Interpretaion and Enforcement:	M.
for Papers (Mr. Knowles) 582 (i).

[Stage Direction]
Dumber Duties, Violation of Customs Act: Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com. of Sup., 1723 (i); Neg. (Y. 62; N. 107) 1806 (i).
Lumber, Stealing of; See ' B. No. 9.' Lunenburg Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i).
McAdam, Alex. R., Fishery Officer at Anfci-gonish, Dismissal, &c.; M. for Cor.* (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) 3343 (ii).
McAllister, Mr., Moving Expenses: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) in Com. of Sup., 6596 (iv). McAuley, Angus, Claims for Damages re Fire Investigation: M. for Rep* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3756 (ii).
McDonald, Dr. D., Dismissal from Indian Reserve, Baddeck: M. for Cor* (Mr. McKenzie) 2861 (ii).
McDougall, J. M., Counsel Fees re Lanctot Investigation: in Com. of Sup., 6486 (iv).
See ' Lanctot.'
McEaehren, Mr. Charles, Dismissal from Tatamagouche Post Office: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 2243 (ii).
Mcl arlane, J, D., Postmaster at Southwest Margaree, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3756 (ii).
McGrath, James, Postmaster at Aspen, N.S.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Sinclair) 2587 (ii). Mclssac, Colin, Preventive Officer at Port Hood, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 5956 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) in
Com. of Sup., 5816 (iv).
McLean, Donald E., Dismissal, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 4980 (iii). McLean, W. D., Dismissal from Customs at L'Etang: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4780 (iii). McLennan, Mr., Dismissal from Inverness Public Building: Remarks (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 2017 (ii).
McLeod, John, Dismissal as Postmaster at Denmark, N.S.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Macdo nald) 4460 (iii).
McLeod, Dr. J. R., Dismissal from Port Haw kesbury, Charges re-. M. for Papers* (Mr. Kyte) 3945 (ii).
McPhee, James, Customs Officer, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) 3757 (ii).
McPherson, John H., Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4259 (iii).
McRae, Mr. F. D., Pets, re Clemency: Ques.
(Mr. McMillan) 713 (i).
Madeleine de Vercheres Monument, Erection of: in. Com. of Sup., 2824 (ii).
Mader, Mr. D., Dismissal from Mahone Bay P.O.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 722 (i). Madore, Alphonse, Claims for Damages in I. C. Ry.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 3055
(ii).
Ii
Magdalen Island Dredging, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 3277 (ii). Magdalen Island Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4730 (iii).
Magdalen Islands Marconi News Service, Copy of Instructions: M. for Papers* (Mr. Lemieux) 4459 (iii).

Par. in Toronto * News ' re: Read (Mr. Lemieux) 4159 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks, 3833 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Salary of Correspondent: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4262 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Statement (Mr. Hazen) 4041 (iii).
Magdalen Island Telegraph and Telephone: in Com. of Sup., 3302 (ii).
Mahone Bay and Tancook Island Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4733 (iii).
Mail Bags Repairs, Names of Firms, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4777 (iii).
Mail Carriers, Como to Oka, Compensation to Family: Remarks (Mr. Etliier) in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).
Mail Clerks, Salary Increases: See ' B. No. 105.'
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of: in Com. of Sup., 6620 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Ret.* (Mr. Lemieux) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Lemieux) 5693
(iv).
Mail Service: in Com. of Sup., 6281 (iv).
Mail Service between G.B. and Canada, Letter of Board of Trade, Quebec: Read (Mr. Lemieux) 1843 (i).
See 'Can. and G.B.,' 'Fast Atlantic,'
' Tost Office,' &c.
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions: in Com.
of Sup., 640 (i), 4714 (iii), 5934 (iv). Maisonneuve Postal Station, Erection of: Ques. *(Mr. Verville) 550 (i).
Maisonneuve Public Buildings: in Com. of Sup., 1347 (i).
Manitoba Boundaries, Discussion re Man. School Question: Ques. (Mr. Nesbitt) 534 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Conference re Separate Schools: Ques.
(Mr. Molloy) 715 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Cor., &c., re Settlement with Provs. of
Man. and Out.: M. for Papers (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 774, 789 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Eastern and Western Line: Ques. (Mr. Molloy) 971 (i).
Quebec Harbour Commissioners Act Amt.   B.@: 
CXXX11 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
Manitoba Boundaries, Eastern Extension: Ruling (Mr. Speaker) re Form of Ques., 3936; Ans. (Mr. Borden) 3936-7 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Answer to Question:	Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 3755 (ii)'.
Manitoba Boundaries Extension, Cor. with Ont. Govt.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Meighen) 2459 (ii).	,
[Stage Direction]
 Extension of, Par. in ' Montreal Star :
Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 489 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Financial Terms, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Oliver) 558 (i).
Manitoba I|bundaries: Inquiry for Papers (Mr. Oliver) 3448, 3834 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for (Mr. Turriff) 1820 (i).
*

 Swamp Lands, Acreage, &c.: Inquiry for
Stmnt. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 3751 (ii).
_____Terms re -. Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
716 (i).
Man. Grain Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 96/
See ' Grain B. 32/
Manitoba and Northwestern Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 92/
Manitoba and Northwestern Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com., 6314 (iv).
Man. and N.S. Federal Subsidies, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Sinclair) 4258 (iii).
Manitoba Questions: Remarks re Answers (Mr. Nesbitt) 581 (i).
See ' Man. Boundaries B. 115/
Man. Separate School Bill: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Monk) 226, 231 (i).
Maple Sugar, Cancellation of O. C. re Standards: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 716
(i).
Marcil, Mr. Tancrede, Application re Govt.
Position: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 2069 (ii). Marconi Co., Negotiations re Wireless Messages to all Dominions: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2585 (ii).
See ' Magdalen/
Marieville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1348 (i).
MARINE:
' Aboukir ' Cruiser, Paying off of Crew: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 408 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Stmnt. (Mr. Hazen) 489 (i).
Adams, Mr., Resignation as Examiner of Pilots: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5227 (iii).
Aids to Navigation: in Com. of Sup., 5236
(iii).
[DOT] 'Arctic' Steamship, Maintenance, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5398 (iii).
Atlantic Coast Surveys: in Com. of Sup., 5399 (iii).
Biological Board, Names, Salaries, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Sinclair) 4257 (iii).
Bird Rocks Lighthouse, Drowning of Keeper:	Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 5258 1
(iii).
Coal for Govt. Steamers, Average Cost per Ton, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 1203 (i). Coasting Trade, O.C., Extending Time: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1814 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Foreign Shipping, Pets., &c.: M. for
Copies* (Mr. Kyte) 2861 (ii).
' Earl Grey ' and ' Minto ' Govt. Steamers, Names of Employees: M. for Ret.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1816 (i).
Fisheries Contracts with Stewards on Cruisers: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 681 (i).
Gaspe Basin Marine Agency, Apptmt. of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Deptl. Inquiry, Salary, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 1358 (i).
Govt. Dredges and Tugs, Instructions re Appointments: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 5952
(iv).
Govt. Steamers, B.C., Use for Political Purposes: Ques. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 5262 (iii).
Govt. Steamers, Building, &c.:	Remarks
(Mr. J. D. Reid) in Com. of Sup., 1964
(i).
[Stage Direction]
Repairs, Construction, &o.: in Com.
of Sup., 5186, 5207 (iii).
Ice-breaker at St. Gerard, Tenders re Construction: Ques. (Mir. Segniin) 2451 (ii). Insurance of Canadian Marine, Govt. Cooperation, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1582
(i).
Kidson's Island Lighthouse, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 3054 (ii).
L'Achigan Ice Breaker, Tenders re Construction, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Segum) 2294 (ii). Life Saving Awards: in Com. of Sup., 5228 (iii).
Lighthouses, Construction, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5237 (iii).
Lighthouse and Coast Service, Inspectors Salaries: in Com. of Su,p., 5232 (iii)-Lighthouse Keepers, Pensions to: in Com. of Sup., 5236 (iii).
Live Stock Inspection re Shipping: in Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Marine and Fisheries, Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1041 (d), 6651 (iv).
Marine Hospitals: in Com. of Sup., 5238 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Ships for Fishermen: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 6787 (iv).
Marine Workshops at Quebec, Instructions re Closing: Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 579 (d). ' Minto,' Apptmt. of Pilot, Name, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 876 (i).
Montreal Harbour, National and Free Port; Qiues. (Mr. Bickerdike) 554 (i).

[Stage Direction]
cxxxiii
NaviaJ Ships, Construction, of, Rep. of Admiral Kingsmill: M. for Copy* (Mr. Le-imieux) 2159 (ii).
See * Navy.'
Ocean and River Service: dm Com. of Sup., 51811, 5207 (iii).
Patrol Vessels in Northern Waters: in Com. of Sup., 5231 (iii).
Pictou Winter Steamers, Amounts paid to: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5949 (iv). Eadiotelegraphic Service, Wireless Stations: in Com. of Sup., 5399 (ii).
Registration of Shipping: in Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Repentigny Lighthouse Keepers, Charges re, &Q-: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3752 (ii), 5949 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Segiuin) 6784 (iv).
St. Lawrence Channel, Ice-breaker: Ques.
(Mr. Bellemame) 5680 (iv).
St. Patrick's Channel Lighthouse: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 5238 (iii).
Schools of Navigation: in Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Sorel Marine Yards, Inquiry re Administration: Ques. (Mr. Barrette) 974 (i). Steamboat Inspection: in Corn, of Sup., 5238 (iii).
Steamboat Inspection Report:	Presented
(Mr.. 11 azcn) 1571 (i).
Tidal Service, Surveying Steamers: in Com. of Sup., 5400 (iii).
Vickers-Maxim Co.'s Contract re Construction of Montreal Dry Dock: Ques. (Mr. Sevigmy) 2450 (ii).
Wireless Stations: in Com. of Sup., 5399 (iii).
Wrecks Investigations: i,n Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Maritime Law International Conference, Invitation to Govt, re: Ques. (Mr. Murphv) 2586 (ii).
Mar. Provs. Dredging: in Com. of Sup., 2816
(ii)-
Mar. Provs. Immigration Policy: Prop. Res. (Mr. Rhodes) 2072 (ii).
Maritime Telephone Co. and P. E. I. Connection: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 3303 (ii).
* Market Tickets' to I. C. R. Employees: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 5809
(iv).
Marlin, Mrs. A. S., Postmistress, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
Marriage Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 3.'
Marriage Act Amt., Decision of Privy Council: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 2855 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Ref. to Privy Council, Provl. Representation: Que3. (Mr. Lemleux) 3755 (ii).
Marriage Act Amt., Ref. to Supreme Court, 3332 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Correction in Speech (Mr. Pelletier)
3532 (di).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Lennox) re Order for 2°,
582 (i).
Marriages in Canada, Power of Dom. Govt, re Legalization: Ques. (Mr. Boivin) 575 (i). Marriage Law, Cor. with Federal Govt, re Legislation: M. for copies* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3341 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Cor. with Prime Minister re Legislation: M. for copy* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2861 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Par. in Toronto ' Star' : Ques. (Mr. Burnham): Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 3942 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Pet, re Dom. Legislation: Ques. (Mr. A. H. Clairke) 528 (d).
[Stage Direction]
Ref. to Supreme Court: Remarks (Mr. Lemleux) 3332 (ii).
Marriage Question re Catholic Hierarchy, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 573 (i).
See ' N© Temere.'
Maskinonge Election Expenses, Settlement of: Ques. (Mir. Belleimaire) 4776 (iii).
Masters and Mates Certificates: See 'B. No. 143.'
Matapedia to Gaspe Basin Line, I. C. Ry., Inspection re Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Le-mieiux) in Com. of Sup., 4194 (iii). Matapedia Water Works Co., Claims against
I.	C. Ry.: M. for Cor* (Mr. Boulay) 4263
(iii)	.
Matheson, Jas. W., Chargei re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5263 (iii).
Matte, Arthur J., Postmaster at Montauban,
Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Delisle) 5957 (iii).
Medical Attendance, Free for Fishermen: Remarks (Mir. A. K. Maolean) in Corn, of Sup., 680 (i).
Medical Director General, Apptmt., &c., &c.: Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2667 (ii).
Melford Wharf Construction: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Notice to suspend work: Ques. (Mir.
Sinclair) 549 (i).
Members Indemnity: See ' B. No. 75.'
Members Travelling Allowances during Adjournments: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 1848
(i).
Meredith, Hon. Sir William, Application re Leave of Absence: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 5954
(iv)	.
See ' Farmers Bank.'
Mess, from His Royal Highness, Estimates 1911-12: Presented (Mr. Speaker) 525, 971 (i), 4974 (iii), 6154 (iv).
Methodist Church: See ' B. No. 133.'
Methot, D., Apptmt. on iSoulauges Canal: l Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4255 (iii).

[Stage Direction]
Mexicali Interurbam Electric Ey. Co., Ltd.: See ' B. No. 133/
Mexico NouthwesteTu Pacific By. Co.: See ' B. No. 159/
Michaud, Mjr. E., Dismissal from P. O. at St. Germain: M. for Oor. (Mjr. E. Lapointe) 1592 (i).
Michaud, Mir. J., Postmaster at St. Moise Station, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Gauvireau) 1864 (i).
Midlamd Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1855 (i).
Militia Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 171/
MILITIA:
Airships for Military Purposes, Purchases by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i). Aldershot Eifle Eange, Caretaker, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 3536 (ii).
Allowances in Com. of Sup., 5447 (iii). Annual Drill:	in Com. of Sup., 5452 (iii).
Armouries: in Com. of Sup., 5541 (iii). Armouries and Public Buildings, Militia: in Com. of Sup., 620 (i).
Arsenal at Quebec, Payment to Employees, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 579 (i).
Automobiles purchased for Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5492 (iii).
Bands, and Association Grants, re Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5528 (iii); 6653 (iv). Battlefields Commission:	M. (Mr. White)
to strike out vote, 5299 (iii).
Cadet Corps, Drill: in Com. of Sup., 5452 (iii).
Camps for Militia Training:	in Com. of
Sup., 5521 (iii).
Caretakers for Militia, Wages, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5546 (iii).
Civil Engineers, Eecall from Quebec: Ques.
(Mr. Lachance) 580 (i).
Clothing for Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5521 (iii).
Customs Dues re Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5522 (iii).
Drill Halls in the West, Donation of Lands re Sites:	Ques. (Mr. McCraney)
1815 (i).
Fenian Eaid Veterans, Land Grant, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boivin) 3334 (ii).
See main heading.
Headquarters Staff: in Com. of Sup., 5536 (iii).
Kingston, E.M.C. Buildings:	in Com. of
Sup., 1855 (i).
Lavergne, Capt. Armand, Apptmt. re Capt. of 61st Begiment: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 723 (i).
Military Conference, Invitations re Canon Dauth, &e.:	Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 552 (i).
Militia Council Eep. (presented) 2668 (ii).
MILITIA-Con.
Militia, Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1037 (i).
Military Stores Building, Contract re Backs:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 532 (i).
Military Touring Cars, Order to Ford Motor Co.:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 4040 (iii).
See ' Automobiles/
Montreal Military School, Site re, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4040 (iii).
National Battlefields Eeport:	Presented
(Mr. W. T. White) 565 (i).
National Eifle Association, Eules re Competition at Bisley:	Eemarks (Mr. E. M.
Macdonald) 3730 (ii).
Ordnances: in Com. of Sup., 6653 (iv).
Papal Zouaves, Investigation re Eeception to Papal Legate:	Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe)
578 (i).
Properties: in Com. of Sup., 5539 (iii). Eegiments of Foreign born Citizens, Organization of: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 534 (i). Eifle Associations and Bands: in Com. of Sup., 5528 (iii); 6653 (iv).
Eoekliffe Eifle Eanges: in Com. of Sup., 6654 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Acquisition of Additional Land:
Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
Eosignol, Major J. E., Qualifications re Commandant of 61st Begiment:	Ques.
(Mr. E. Lapointe) 723 (i).
Schools of Instruction for Militia:	in
Com. of Sup., 5546 (iii).
S.A. Bounty Scrip, Delay in Distribution, &c.: Eemarks (Mr. Knowles) 3153 (ii). Veterans of 1866-7, Bounties to: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1202 (i).
Mines, Depth Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1066
(D

Ore Deposits, &c.: in Com. of Sup.,
6490, 6602 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Eeports, French Translation: in Com.
of Sup., 6490 (iv).
Mining Eights Administration, O.C. Besolu-tion: Eemarks (Mr. Eogers) 6792 (iv).
Ministers from Quebec, Statements at St. Eustache Election Campaign:	Ques. (Mr. M. Martin) 553 (i).
See ' Cabinet/
' Minto/ Apptmt. of Pilot, Name, &e.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 876 (i).
Molson, Kenneth, Belief of: See 'B. No. 110/
Moncton Ey. Office, Fittings, &c.:	in Com.
of Sup., 6604 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Shops, I.C.E., Contract for Heating,
&c.: in Com. of Sup., 5611 (iv).
See ' I.C.B/

Tenders re: Inquiry for Papers (Mr. Emmerson) 5762 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
Moncton Shop, I.C.R., Operation, &c.:	in
Com. of Sup., 5604 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Shops, Transfer to Traserville: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 544 (i).
Monday Sittings, Precedence of Govt. Business: M. (Mr. Borden) 2376 (ii).
Montcalm Postmaster, Pets, re Removal: Ques. (Mr. Lafortune) 575 (i).
Montpetit, Dr. E., Pet. sent to P.M.G. re Dismissal of William Brown:	Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4977 (iii).
See ' Dismissals/
Montreal Athletic Association at Nancy, Pet. re Govt. Aid:	Remarks (Mr. Lemieux)
1722 (i).
Montreal Barracks: in Com. of Sup., 1350 (i). Montreal Circuit Court Judges, Additional: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2855 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 3907 (ii).
Montreal Circuit Court Judges, Additional Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 6597 (iv).
See ' Justice/
Montreal Customs Appraiser Building: in Com. of Sup., 1351 (i).
Montreal Customs House, Dismissals: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 4040 (iii).
Montreal Dry Dock, Contract re-. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of iSup., 3301 (ii); 6652 (iv).
Montreal Harbour Commission: See ' B. Nos. 97 and 150/
Montreal Central Terminal Co.: See ' B. Nos. 49 and 194/
Montreal Harbour Commission, Apptmt. of Accountants re-. Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 6661 (iv).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners Delegations re from Corn Exchange, &c.-. Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2069 (ii).
*

 Dismissal of Mr. J. A. Masse: Ques.
(Mr.. E. M. Macdonald) 3943 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissals, &c.:	Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1708, 1960 (i), 2057 (ii), 6551 (iv). Montreal Harbour, National and Free Port: Ques. (Mr. Bickerdike) 554 (i).
Montreal Harbour Commissioners, Res. from Board of Trade re Dismissals: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 1812 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Retention of: Ques. (Mr. Ames) 2062
(ii).	_
Montreal Harbour Commission, Total Debt, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1357 (i).
Montreal Harbour Officials, Apptmt. of, Promotions, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 3944 (ii). Montreal Judiciary, re Increase of Judges, Ac.^Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 545 (i).
See ' Justice/
Montreal Longshoremen's Strike, Settlement of by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 572 (i).
Montreal Military School, Site re &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 4040 (iii).
Montreal, Ottawa and Georgian Bay Canal: See ' B. No. 30/
Montreal Postal Station F.:: in Com. of Sup., 1352 (i).
Montreal Post Office Enlargement: in Com. of Sup., 1348 (i).
Montreal Terminal Ry. Co.: See ' B. Nos. 24 and 194/
Montreal Transcl. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 128/ See ' Can. Northern/
Moose to Drulingville Loop Tel. Line:	in
Com. of Sup., 2820 (ii).
Moosejaw Armoury Site, Cor., &c.:	Read
(Mr. Knowles) 3972 (ii).

 Remarks (Mr. Knowles) in Com. of
Sup., 2040, 2206 (ii).
Moosejaw Post Office, Names and Locations: Ques. (Mr. KnowTes) 976 (i).
Moosejaw District, Proposed Site, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Knowles) 3342 (ii).

 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr.Knowles) 4237 (iii).


Moosejaw P.O.: Inspector, Pets, re Apptmt.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Knowles) 1590 (i). Moosejaw Post Office Inspector:	Inquiry for
Ret. (Mr. Knowles) 4981 (iii).

 Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 4982 (iii).
Moosejaw Public Building:	Remarks (Mr. Knowles) in Com. of Sup., 2439 (ii).

 Tender of MciDiarmid Co., Limited:
M. for Copy* (Mr. KnowTes) 562 (i).
Moose, Loyal Order of:	See ' B. No. 158/
Monuments, Erection of, Sites, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 2823 (ii).
Moreau, Mr. Jos., Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.
(Mr. E. Lapointe) 1818 (i).
Morice, Theophile, Dismissal from I.C.R.: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. Gauvreau) 4262 (iii).
Morine, Mr. A. B., Charges re as Public Commissioner : Remarks (Mr. Carvell) on M. for Sup., 6528 (iv).

Letter to Prime Minister re Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 6185 (iii).

 Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 6185 (iv).

Correction re Ruling on Question (Mr. Speaker) 6335 (iii).

 Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 6335 (iv).
See ' Dismissals/
Morin, Mr. Theo., Reinstatement of: Remarks (Mr. Gauvreau) in Com. of Sup., 5654 (iv). Mosher, Mr. G. A., Preventive Officer at Ship Harbour, Dismissal, &c.: Ques (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4039 (iii).
Mounted Police, Annuities to Families of Messrs. Fitzgerald, &c.: Remarks (Mr. A.

Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 5176 (iii). 	Pay of Force: in Com. of Sup., 5175 (iii).


'CXXXV1 COMMONS DEBATES
[Stage Direction]
Mounted Police, Pensions: in Com. of Sup., 6185 (iv).
See ' N. W. Mounted Police.'
Mount Oscar Postmaster, Dismissal of I. Che-vrier: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4780 (iii).
Mulgrave Highway Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 4225 (iii).
Mullaly, Mr., Emplymt. in P. O. Dept., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Power) 1583 (i).
Mundle, D. I., Dismissal as sub-Collector at Kichibucto, N.B.; Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4780
(iii).
Municipal Elections and Civil Servants: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1813 (i).
Murray Canal, Levelling High Spots: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
Murray, J. P., Carpet Co., Breach of Immigration Regulations: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 550 (i).
Murray, Dr., Poaching for Salmon on East River, N.S.: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5242 (iii).
Musicians Holiday on Sunday: See ' B. No. 85.'
Naas and Skeena River Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6321 (iv).
Napierville Post Office Site, Agreement, Instructions, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Lanctot) 3153; Members remarks cheeked (Mr. Speaker) 3153 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Payment to Mr. Bourgeois: Remarks
Mr. Lanctot) on M. for Sup., 2373 (ii).
Napierville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1354 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Purchase of Site: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lanctot) 5263 (iii).
National Art Gallery, Ownership of Painting: Ques. (Mr. Burnham) 6337 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Paintings, &c., purchased since 1891:
Ques. (Mr. Burnham) 6184 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Presentation of Oil Painting by H. R.
H.	Princess Louise: Announcement (Mr. Monk) 5056 (iii).
See ' Art Gallery.'
National Battlefields Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White) 565 (i).
National Ports: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2837 (ii).
National Rifle Association, Rules re Competition at Bisley: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 3730 (ii).
Natl. Transcl. Ry., Implementing Privy Council Judgment: See ' B. No. 95/
Natl. Transcl. Ry. Time Extension: See " B. No. 21/
N. T. Ry. Bill 95, Factums re-. Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 2589 (ii).
Natl. Transcl. Ry. Commissioners, Reduction of Number: See ' B. No..76/
NATIONAL TRANSCONTINENTAL RAID WAY:
Claims for Damages in Dorchester County, Amounts paid: Ques. (Mr. Sevigny) 6184
(iv).
Commission, Apptmt. of Mr. R. W. Leonard: M. for Cor., &c.* (Mr. Emmerson) 2246
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Duties assigned to New Chairman:
Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Notification of Dismissal: Remarks
(Mr. Pugsley) 1196 (i).	[DOT]
-:

 Resignation of: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 1199 (i).
Commission, Payments to Mr. E. Tasohe-reau: Ques. (Mr. Sevigny) 2244 (ii). Commission, Payments to Taschereaiu, Cannon & Co.: Ques. (Mr. Sevigny) 2245 (ii). Construction.:: in Com. of Sup., 5765 (iv). Douciet, Mr. A. E., Cos', re Ry. Station Sites; M. for Copies* (Mr. Lavaileo) 2460 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Position on N.	T.	Ry.:	Quos.	(M.r.
Lavaileo) 2245 (ii).
Estimated Cost, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Graham) 6732 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Stimnt. re: Ans. (Mr. Cochrane) 6733
(iv).
Goulet, Mr., Apptmt.	as Station	Inspector,Ques. (Mr. Paquet)	3935	(ii).
Gutelius, Mr. F. P., Apptmt. to N. T. Ry. Board, British Subject, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 4038 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Naturalization of, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 4978 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Improper form of Question: Ruling
(Mr. Speaker) 3934 (ii).
Investigation Commission, Rep. re: Remarks (Mir. E. M. Macdonald) 2157 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Apptmt., Salaries of Messrs: Gutelius
and Lynch Staunton: Qnies. (Mr. Murphy) 4242 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarries (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2060
(ii).
Moncton to Levis, Portion uncompleted: *Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 932 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Completion &c., Operation by Govt.:
Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 723 (i).
Montreal Branch Limes, Cor., O. Cs., &c.: M, for Copies* (Mr. L. A. Lapointe) 582
(i)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Construction of: Ques. (Mr. Bickerdike) 554 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Pet. re .Subsidy to: Ques. (Mir. L. A.
Lapointe) 573 (i).
Montreal. Branch Subsidy: in Com., 5896, 6215 (iv).
N. T. Ry. (implementing) Bill 95, Factums re-. Remarks (Sir" Wilfrid Laurier) 2589
(ii)

[Stage Direction]
NATIONAL TRANSCONTINENTAL RAILWAY- Con.
Parent, Hon. ,S. N., Resignation of: Ques.
(Mr. E. Lapointe) 578 (i).
Repair Shops, Erection at Quebec and Winnipeg: Ques. (Mr. Burnham) 4977 (iii).
St. Daimien Station, Change in Plans: Ques.
(Mr. Lavallee) 3532 (Si).
Station' at Quebec, Contract re Building: M. for Cor. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 755 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 6786
(iv).
Naturalization Legislation, Uniformity in: M. for Cor. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 765 (i). Naturalization: See 'Imperial/
Natural Resources: See ' Provl. Control/ Naval Bill Repeal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Mondou) 4242 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Discussion re: Ques. (Mr. Lamarche)
4239 (iii).
Naval Cadets, Eruploymt. by Govt.: Remarks (Mr. Gauvreau) 6786 (dv).
Naval Defence of the Pacific Coast, Res. from
B.	C. Legislature, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 559 (i), 4458 (iii).
Naval Defences: Remark on debate on Address (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 42 (i).
Naval Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1062
(i).
Naval Discipline Ac.t. Application to Canada: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1203 (d). Naval Policy, Interview with Han. G. H. Perley in London: Remarks (Mr. Murphy) 1576 (i).
Naval Policy of Govt.: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Borden) 58; (Mr. Monk) 234
(i); (Mr. Lemieux) 250; (Mr. Mondou) 270; (Mr. Northrup) 357; (Mr. Sinclair) 331; (Mr. Stevens) 291.
[Stage Direction]
 Promise re Referendum; Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 526 (i).
[Stage Direction]
.Speech of Hou. Mr. Monk at Hull;
Ques. (Mr. Devlin) 551 (d).
[Stage Direction]
 Repeal of: Ques. (Mr. Mondou) 3942;
Ruling (Mr. Speaker) 3043 (dd).
Naval Service, Cor. between Can. and G. B.: M. for Copy* (Mr. Lemieux) 562 (i). Naval Service in Canada, Report: Presented (Mr. Hazetn) 970 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Maintenance, Purchase of Ships, &c.:
*in Com. of Sup., 5303 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Minister's Visit to England re-. Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 938 (i).
[Stage Direction]
O. C. re Instructions, Circulars issued
&c.: Ques. (Mr. Devlin) 2065 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Tenders re Shipbuilding, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. Carroll) 558 (d).
Naval Ships, Construction of, Rep. of Admiral Kingsmiil: M. for Copy* (Mr. Lemieux) 2459 (i).
See ' Can. Navy/
[Stage Direction]
Ref. of Min. of Marine re Completion:
Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 1206 (i).
See ' Niobe/
Navigable Waters, Pollution of; See ' B. No. 107/
Navigable Waters Protection Act Amt.: See 'B. No. 64/
New Glasgow to Thorbuirn Ry. Co/s Lease, &c., Legislation re-. Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 933 (i).
Negro Immigration: Remarks on Immigro-tion Question (Mr. Thoburn) 608 (i).
No Temere Decree, Powers of Pairlt.: Remarks re Answer to Question (Mr. Pugsley) 797 (i).
No Temere Decree,- Questions asked by the late Govt. Concurrence by present Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 719 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 720 (d).
[Stage Direction]
Stmnt. by Member for Peterborough:
Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 731 (i).
No Teimeine Decree: See ' B. No. 3/ ' Mar-Tdiage/ &c.
Neuville and C.N.Ry. Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of:	Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 2067
(ii).	,
Newoombe, Mr., Expenses &c.: See 'Justice- Dop. Min/
New Barbour Breakwater: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).
Newmarket Canal, Commission re Investigation: Remarks (Mr. J. A. M. Armstrong) 1319 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Meeting at Newmarket: Par. in Press
(Mr. Emmerson) 3057 (ii).
Newspaper Article®, Reading re Questions-. Ruling (Mr. 'Speaker) 3059 (ii).
Newspapei-s, Postage re Dom. Elections Campaign: M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 1589
h-
New Waterford Mail Service, Change re: Remarks (Mr. Carroll) in Com. of Sup., 6294, 6630 (iv).
Nieolet and St. Monique Mail Contract, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 724 (i).
' Niobe * and ' Rainbow/ Contract re Provisioning:	Ques. (Mr. Devlin) 2859 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Sale of: Ques. (Mr. Devlin) 2859 (ii).
*:

 Repairs, &c.: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 577 (i).
See ' Naval/
North Arm Bridge and Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 14/
North Atlantic Trading Co.: Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Verville) 279 (i).
[Stage Direction]
cxxxviii
North Battleford Tel. Lines:	in Com. of
Sup., 2822 (ii).
North Battleford to Isle la Crosse Tel. Line: in Com. of Sup., 2822 (ii).
Northern, N.B. and Seaboard Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6229 (iv).
Northern Colonization Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 45/
Northern Territorial Ry. Co.:	See ' B. No.
82/
North Shore Ry. Co/s Subsidy:	in Com.,
6234 (iv).
North Sydney, I.C.R., Diversion: in Com. of Sup., 5610 (iv).
North Sydney Harbour Improvements:	Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 5223 (iii).
North Sydney Mail Subsidy:	in Com. of
. Sup., 678 (i).
N.W. Mounted Police, Increase re Pay: Remarks (Mr. W. M. Martin) 4743 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Police Report:	Presented (Mr. Borden) 971 (i).
See ' Mounted Police/
Northwest Territories, Administration of Justice: in Com. of Sup., 6565 (iv).
Northumberland County Mail Service, Contract re: Ques. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 6186 (iv).
Notes, Printing of Govt.: See ' Dom. Notes/
Notre Dame des Anges Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 554 (i).
Nursery Stock, Purchase of for Experimental Farm, N.S.:	Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean)
3333 (ii).
Oaths of Office:	See ' B. No. 1/
O'Brien, A. J., Dismissal from Immigration Office at Halifax: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 717 (i).
Ocean and River Service: in Com, of Sup., 5186, 5207 (iii).
' Ocean Limited,' Instructions re Transportation of Private Cars:	Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 2241 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 on cone., 6774 (iv).
Old Age Pensions: on M. (Mr. Burnham) 1362, 1822 (i).
Old Age Pensions: M. for Special Com., (Mr. Borden) 2217 (ii).
O'Leary to West Point, Ry. Branch Lines, Construction re:	Ques. (Mr. Richards) 721
(i).
Olympic Games, Aid to: in Com. of Sup., 6486 (iv).
Ont. Boundaries Extension:	See ' B. No.
152/	[DOT]
Ontario Boundaries, Extension: M. for Cor.* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1590 (i).
See ' Boundaries.'
Ont., Grant to re T. & N. 0. Ry.: See ' B. No. 186/
Ontario and Minnesota Pulp and Paper Co. Grinding Machines:	Remarks (Mr. Turriff) 2060 (ii).
Ont. and Ottawa Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 50/ Orangedale to Cheticamp Ry., Construction: Remarks (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 4226 (iii).
Ore Deposits, Investigation, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6490, 6602 (iv).
Oriental Immigration, Total Number: Ques. (Mr, Stevens) 4779 (iii).
See ' Immigration.'
Ottawa, Brockville and St. Lawrence Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 161/
Ottawa Buildings: in Com. of Sup., 1321 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Caretakers, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 3293
[Stage Direction]
 Electric Power, &c.: in Com. of Sup.,
3288 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Heating, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 3278 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Plumbing, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1855
(i) .

. 

 Rentals, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1324 (i);
3290 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Water Supply: in Com. of Sup., 3291
(ii)	.
See ' Pub. Works/
Ottawa City Estimates:	Remarks (Mr. Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 3235 (ii).
Ottawa County Superior Court, Additional Judge:	Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 4121 (iii).
Ottawa Dismissals, Investigation re:	Remarks (Mr. Monk) in Com. of Sup., 3262
(ii).
Ottawa Examining Warehouse, Site, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 1949 (i).
Ottawa Exhibition Grant, 6479 (iv).
Ottawa Federal District, Referendum re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1356 (i).
Ottawa Grounds: in Com. of Sup., 3239 (ii). Ottawa Improvement Commission and Architects Association re:	M. for Papers (Sir
Wilfrid Laurier) 977 (i).
Ottawa Improvement Commission, Minutes of Meetings, Amounts expended: M. for Ret.* (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 1588 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White)
565 (i).
Ottawa and Lake McGregor Ry. Co.:	See
'B. Nos. 139 and 192/
Ottawa, Montreal and Eastern Ry. Co.:	See
'B. No. 99/
Ottawa, Northern and Western Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 25.'
Ottawa Observatory: in Com. of Sup., 1321 (i). Ottawa, Plaza, Fences and Posters, Responsibility re: Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 876 (i).

[Stage Direction]
Ottawa, Sit© for new Depth Buildings:	in
Com. of Sup., 3242 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Snow Cleaning, Rideau Hall, &c.; in
Com. of Sup., 3279 (ii).
Ottawa River Bridges: Cone., 6806 (iv). Ottawa and Ungava Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 61.' Oyster Culture: See ' B. No. 140:'
Oyster Culture: in Com. of Sup., 5255 (iii). Oyster Pond Preventive Officer, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 1207 (i).
Pacific and Atlantic Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 51.' Pacific Trans. Can. and Hudson Bay Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 52.'
Panama Canal, Tolls, &e., Reps, of U.S. Papers: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 2446 (ii).
Papal Zouaves, Investigation re Reception to Papal Legate: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 578
(i)	.
Parcel Post Convention between Canada and Prance, Signature re-. Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 569 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. (Mr. Lemieux) for Papers, 1396 (i).
Parcel Post Extension of System: Amt. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2329 (ii). Parcel Post Rates to European Countries: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4776 (iii).
Parcel Post and Rural Mail System, on M. for Sup. (Mr. .1. E. Armstrong) 4082 (iii).
See ' Rural,' ' Post Office.'
Parent, Hon. S. N., Resignation of: Ques.
(Mr. E. Lapointe) 578 (i).
Paris Agency, Compensation to Mrs. Fabre: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 6614 (iv).
Paris Exposition, Payments for Space: M. for Stmnt.* (Mr. Paquet) 582 (i).
Pariseau, Mr. S. B., Emplymt. by Ry. Dept, and Cedar Rapids Co.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 973 (i).
Parliamentary Documents, Distribution: in Com. of Sup., 6613 (iv).
Parliament, Duration of Present and Redistribution Bill: Stmnt. by Hon. Mr. Taylor: Ques. (Mr. Molloy) 557, 715 (i).
See ' Taylor, Hon. Geo.'
Parliament, Opening of, Com. from Gov. Ge:.'s Sec.: Read (Mr. Speaker) 6 (i). Parliamentary Restaurant, Payments to Waiters: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 2861 (ii).
See ' House of Commons.'
Patent Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 59.'
Patent Relief: See ' B. Nos. 16, 53, 55, 70, 84 and 119.'
Patrol Vessels in Northern Waters: in Com. of Sup., 5231 (iii).
Patronage Committee, Montreal, Recommendations re: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1866 (i).
See ' Montreal Harbour Commission.' Payson, Mr. W. W., Dismissal from Deep Brook Post Office: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 2243
(ii)	.
Peace Memorial Monument in Queen's Park, Toronto, Action of Govt. re-. Remarks (Mr. German) 2590 (ii).
Peace River Block, Water Rights: See ' B. No. 149.'
Peace River Tel. Line, Building, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 2821 (ii).
Peat Industry: in Com. of Sup., 6491 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Graham) in Com. of
Sup., 6602 (iv).
Pecuniary Claims: in Com. of Sup., 6579 (iv). Pelagic Sealing, Compensation re Treaty: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 4776 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Remuneration to Commissioners:	in.
Com. of Sup., 5810 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Treaty between G.B., TJ.S. and Japanr
M. for Copy* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1590 (i). 

 Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 4460
(iii)	.
Pelagic Sealing, Ratification of Agreement: Explanation (Mr. Borden) 4550 (iii).
Pelee Island Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup.,. 678 (i).
Peloquin, Mr. F., Postmaster at St. Joseph de Sorel, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 3753 (ii).
Penitentiaries in Canada, Report: Presented (Mr. Doherty) 970 (i).
Penitentiary Employees, Bonus: in Com. of Sup., 6600 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Salary Increases: in Com. of Sup., 6596
(iv)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Salaries, Increases re-. Ques. (Mr. C. A.
Wilson) 1205 (i).
Pensions to Lighthouse Keepers: in Com. of Sup., 5236 (iii).
Personal Explanation (Mr. Best) re Par. in Toronto ' Globe ' re Agriculture Com., 2155 (ii).
Petawawa Public Wharf, Tenders re, Contract awarded: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 532 (i).
Petit de Grat Breakwater: Remarks (Mr. Kyte) in Com. of Sup., 2050 (ii).
Petite Lameque Wharf, Construction re -. Ques.
(Mr. Turgeon) 1358 (i).
Petroleum, Crude and Refined, Quantity imported yearly since 1902: Ques. (Mr. Beattie) 730 (i).
Picotte, Mederic, Messenger H. of C., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2065 (ii).
Pictou Cattle Disease, Compensation re -. Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 6472 (iv).
Pictou and Cheticamp Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4736 (iii).
Pietou-Georgetown Winter Mail Service, Contract re Supplies to Crews: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 876 (i).
Pictou Mail Service, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2580 (ii).
[Stage Direction]


Pictou Winter Steamers, Amounts paid to: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5949 (iv).
Pink Rock Wharf, N.B., Total Cost, &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Fowler) 4257 (iii).
Piper, E. F., Patent Relief: See ' B. No. 53.' Poaching in N.S.: See ' Murray.'
Point Aux Anglais, Drainage Works, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 4778 (iii).
Poirier, N. P., Investigation re Charges: Remarks (Mr. Ga-uvreau) in Com. of Sup., 5815 (iv).
Police Point Reserve Transfer: M. for Papers* (Mr. Buchanan) 5557 (iv).
Political Literature, Application re Free Postage: Ques. (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 1585 (i). Political Literature re Race and Religious Prejudices, Distribution of: Remarks (Mr. Rhodes) 6516 (iv).
See ' Campaign.'
Pollution of Navigable Waters: See ' B. No. 107.'
Pollution of Red River: See * B. No. 64.' Population, of Canada and Quebec Cities, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Lanctot) 731 (i).
Port Arthur Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1951
(i).
Port Arthur and Fort William Ice Breaking and Dredging: Personal Explanation (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 3331 (ii).
Port Colborne Elevator: in Com. of Sup., 5796 (iv).
Port Dover Harbour Works: M. for Rep.* (Mr. Charlton) 3755 (ii).
Port Hawkesbury Public Building: Remarks 1345 (i), 2016 (ii).
Port Richmond Breakwater: in Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Contract re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 1585 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Reports, &c.:. M. for Copies* (Mr
Kyte) 2465 (ii).
Porto Rico and Mar. Provs. Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 686 (i).
Postmasters and Assistant Postmasters, Salaries: See ' B. No. 124.'
Post Office Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 105.'
Post Office Dept., Grades of Clerks: See ' B.
No. 106.'

[Stage Direction]
Bassano Post Office, Pet. re: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 5557 (iv).
Beaver Bank Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 6286 (iv).
Bedford Mail Contract, Cancellation off: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 6616 (iv).
Binke, Mr., Promotion to Dead Letter Office: M. for Cor* (Mr. Henderson) 3946
(ii).
POST OFFICE-Con.
Blind River Post Office, Change of Name: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4262 (iii). British Mails, Landing at North Sydney, Tests .re: Ques. (Mr. McKenzie) 5948 (iv). Broderick Post Office, Change of Name: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. McCraney) 5263 (iii). Brown, Wrn., Postmaster at Point Fortune, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4779 (iii).
Cable Rates, Parcel Post, &c.:	M. (Mr. Armstrong) to Com. of Sup., 4082; Amt. (Mr. Lemieux) 4097; Neg. (Y. 40; N. 70) 4120 ip).
Canada and G. B. Mail Service, Renewal of Contract: Qnes. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 547 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Letter of Board of Trade, Quebec:
Read (Mr. Lemieux) 1843 (i).
Cap Chat P.O.: , Pet. re Change of Name: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1204 (i).
Charlemagne Mlail Contract, Name of Contractor, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 1862 (i). Coldbrook Postmaster, Name and Apptmt.: Qnes. (Mr. Kyte) 3148 (ii).
Douglas Road Post Office, Date of Opening, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 3754 (ii). Dunnville Customs Revenue for 1910-11, Postal Revenue, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lalor) 2066 (ii).
Gananoque Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1855 (4).
Gaspe, Magdeleine and Chlorydormes Mail Contracts, Annulment of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1204 (i).
Glace Bay Mail Delivery, Delay, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 804 (i).
Henry, Norbert, Contract re Mails between Scott Junction and Stations: Ques. (Mr. Beland) 975 (i).
Lachenaie Postmaster, Complaints re: Ques.
(Mr. Seguin) 5949 (iv).
Magdalen Island News Service, Marconi Connections:	Remarks (Mr. Lemieux)
3833 (ii).

Copy of Instructions: M. for Papers*
(Mr. Lemieux) 4459 (iii).

Par. in Toronto 'News' re:	Read
(Mr. Lemieux) 4159 (iii).

 Salary of Correspondent: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4262 (iii).

 Statement (Mr. Hazen) 4041 (iii).
Mail Bags Repairs, Names of Firms, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4777 (iii).
Mail Carriers, Como to Oka, Compensation to Family: Remarks (Mr. Ethier) in Com. of Sup., 6282 (iv).
Mail Contracts, Cancellation of: in Com. of Sup., 6620 (iv).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
cxli
POST OFFICE-Con.
Mail Contracts, M. for Ret.* (Mr. Lemienx) 2460 (ii).
*

Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Lemieux) 5693
(iv).
Mail Service: in Com. of Sup., 6281 (iv).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subventions: in Co:n. of Sup., 640 (i).
Moosejaw Post Office, Names and Locations: Ques. (Mr. Knowles) 976 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Inspector, Pet. re Apptmt.: M tor
Cor* (Mr. Knowles) 1590 (i).
Neuville and C. N. Ry. Station Mail Contract, Cancellation of: Ques:	(Mr. Delisle) 2067 (ii).
Newspapers, Postage re Dom. Elections Campaign:	M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. >i.
Clarke) 1589 (i).
New Waterford Mail Service, Change re: Remarks (Mr. Carroll) in Com. of Sup., 6294, 6630 (iv).
Nicolet and St. Monique Mi.l Contract, Complaints re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 724
(i)	.
Northumberland County Mail Service, Contract re-. Ques. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 6186 (iv).
Parcel Post Convention between Canada and France, Signature re: Ques. (Mr. Le-imieux) 569 (i).
[Stage Direction]

 M. (Mr. Lemieux) for Papers, 935,
1396 (i).
Parcel Post, Extension of System: Amt. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) to Com. of Sup., 2329 (ii).
Parcel Post and Rural Mail System, on M. for Sup. (Mr. I. E. Armstrong) 4082 (iii).
See ' Postal Regulations.''
Parcel Post Rates to European Countries: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4776 (iii).
Piet ou-Geo rge town Winter Mail Service, Contract re Supplies to Crews: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 876 (i).
Pictou Mail Service, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2580 (ii).
Porto Rico and Mar. Provs. Mail Subsidy: in Coim. of Sup., 686 (i).
Postage of Newspapers, Opinion of P.M.G. re Regulations: Ques. (Mr. Armstrong) 2291 (ii).
Postal Convention between Canada and France:	Request for Papers (Mr. Lemieux) 935 (i).
Postal Regulations, Commission re Investigation : Prop. Res. (Mr. Armstrong) 2251
(ii)	.
[Stage Direction]
Remarks on M. to take in Mondays
(Mr. Armstrong) 2376 (ii).
Postmasters and Town Councillors Regulations re Acceptance: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2587 (ii).
POST OFFICE-Con.
Postmasters dismissed since Oot. 1911: List read (Mr. Lemieux) 6636 (iv).
Postmasters dismissed: Remarks (Mir. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6617 (iv).
Postmasters in Kamouraska County, Names, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 6781 (iv).
Postmasters in Lotbinie.ro County, Dismissals: Remarks (Mr. Fortier) in Cam. of Sup., 6294 (iv).
Postmasters in Temiscouata County, Dismissal, Charges re: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 548 (d).
Post Offices, Change of Names: Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 3751 (ii).
Post Office Deptl. Block, Condition re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 1855 (i), 2610 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pelletier) 2015 (id).
Post Office Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1066 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Outside Salaries: in Com. of Sup.,
6615 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Promotions: in Corn, of Sup., 6278
(iv).
Post Office Dept., Stmnt. re Dismissals since Oct. 1911: M. for Ret.* (Mr. Lemieux) 1589 (i).
Post Office Dismissals, Govt. Policy re: Remarks (Mr. Carvell) in Cam. of Sup., 6299 (iv).
Post Office Dismissals since Oct. 1911, Pets. re &c.: M. for Ret. (Mr. Lemieux) 1395 (a).
Railway Mail Clerks, Answer to Question: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 5561 (iv).
Rigaud Postmaster, Application re-. Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2294 (ii).
River John Mail Carriers, Name, Amount paid, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1579 (d).
Raver John Mail Service, Cancellation of M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2247
(ii)	.
Rural Mail Delivery, Extension: Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke) 2061 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Number of Boxes in Out.: Ques. (Mr. Elson) 6782 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Pets, re : Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4978
(iii)	.
[Stage Direction]
Route: Inquiry for (Mr. Lemieux)
5561 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Tenders re Mail Boxes &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Staples) 1580 (d).
Ruiml Postmasters, Increase of Salaries: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 3060 (ii).
St. Aldwyn Post Office, Change of Name from Broderick, Car. &c.: Read (Mir. Mc-Cruney) 5922 (iv).
cxlii
[Stage Direction]
POST OFFICE-Con.
Ste. Ann© die Bellevue, Non-delivery of Mail: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 5260 (iii).
Ste. Amu© de Bellevue aind L'Ue Penrot Mail Contract, Ex.piry of: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 5951 (iv).
St. Isidore de Prescott, Postaruastership, Pet. re: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 3055 (ii).
St. Monique Mail Contract, Annulment of: Ques. (Mr. Lemdeux) 1584 (i).
St. Pascal Mail Contract, Cancellation of: Ques. (Mr. Lapointe) 2294 (ii).
St. Patrick de Brandon, Population, Revenue, &c. P. O.: Ques. (Mr. Lafortune) 724 (i).
St. Paul L'Ermite, &c., Miail Carrier, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2583 (ii).
St. Paul L'Enmite, Bepentigny Mail Ser-vioe, CanceLlaition of Contracts: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3341 (ii).
Ste Theres© and Laur-entides Post Offices, Revenues, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3335 (ii).
Sayabec Postmistress, A(pptmt. of Miss Bomlay: Ques.. (Mr. Car veil) 2068 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemiaux) in Com. of
Sup., 6295 (iv).
Seamen St., Annapolis Co., Post Office, Date of Opening: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 3754
(ii)	.
Scott Junction Mail Contraot, Cancellation re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Beland) 2459 (ii).
Small Pox in Ottawa Post Office: Explanation (Mr. Pelletier) 1242 (i).

Further Explanation (Mr. Pelletier)
1280 (i).
Sotrel and St. Victoria Mail Service, Date of Tenders &c.: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 4248
(iii)	.
[Stage Direction]
M. for Papers* (Mr. Cardin) 4782
(iii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Cardin) in Com. of
Sup., 6643 (iv).
Moosejaw P.   O.@: , Request re Remo all of: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 577 (i).

 M. -for Cor* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 582
(i).
Stellarton Station Mail Service, Cancellation of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2247 (ii).
Sydney and Glace Bay Mail Service, Delay, &c.: Stmnt. (Mr. Pelletier) 934 (i).
Tracadie Road Post Office, Charges re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4459 (iii).
Val des Eboulis and Rigaud Mail Service, Contract re-. Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4249 (iii).

Prop.	Res. (Mir. Pugsley)	M.	to	withdraw, 1390	(i).Preferential	Trade within the	Empire:	Remarks in debate cun Address (Mr. Borden) 55 (i).	^	,Premier Life Insurance Co.: See ' B. No. 63. Prime Minister's Visit to bishop of Quebec, &c.: Ques. (Mr. McCraney) 534 (i). Prince Edward and Hastings Ry. Co.:	See
'B. No. 136.'
P. E. I., Additional Subsidy to: See ' B. No. 178.'
P. E. I. Better Terms: Remarks (Mr. J. J.
Hughes) on M. for Sup., 5171 (iii).
P. E. I. Car Ferry, Construction &c.: Ques. (Mr. J. J. Hughes) 1206 (i).

Cor. with Govt, re Car Ferry System:
M. for Copies* (Mr. Emmerson) 2072 (ii). 

Investigation re:	Remarks (Mr. Graham) in Com. of Sup., 5663 (iv).
P.E.I. and Mainland Govt. Car Ferry, Tel. re-. Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 1580 (i).

Tel. sent to A. A. McLean: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 1577 (i).

 Tels. Letters, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Pardee) 2458 (ii).

 Inquiry (Mr. Macdonald) for Return,
4232 (iii).
P.E.I. Estimates:	Remarks (Mr. J. J.
Hughes) in Com. of Sup., 2439 (ii).
P.E.I. R,y., Claims for Compensation, Settlement of:	Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) in
Com. of Sup., 5659 (iv).

 Increased Facilities: in Com. of Sup.,
5661 (iv).
See ' Railways.'
P.E.I. Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3303 (ii); Cone., 6794 (iv).
See ' Mar. Telephone Co.'
P.E.I. Winter Communication, Ry. Accommodation: Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) 3830 (i). P.E.I. Winter Service, Car Ferry System: Remarks (Mr. A. A. McLean) in Com. of Sup., 5207 (iii).



[Stage Direction]
cxliii
Prince Rupert Dry Dock, Subsidy, Completion, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Clements) 1811 (i).
Printing Bureau, Clocks, Number installed, Expenditure: Ques. (Mr. White, Alberta) 2859 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Dismissals and Apptmts.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 1809 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Changes re Duties:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 2243 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Plant: in Com. of Sup., 6611 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Policy of Govt, re Erection of:	Ques.
(Mr. Murphy) 546 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1038 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Salary Increases:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy)
2066 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Weekly Consultations:	Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 2243 (ii).
Printing Com., 1st Rep.: Presented, M. (Mr. Currie) to cone., 3330 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 3rd Rep.:	M. (Mr. Currie) to cone.,
6578 (iv).
Prisons and Reformatories: See ' B. No. 166.'
Private Bills, Consideration of:	Remarks
(Mr. Currie) 6578 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Extension of Time:	M. (Mr. Borden)
930 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Rep. of Examiner re Pets, Divergency
of Rules: Remarks (Mr. Speaker) 643 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Suspension of Rules: M. (Mr. Ames)
5902 (iv).
See ' Senate Amts.'
Private Secretaries, Status of:	See ' B. No.
60.'
Private Secretaries, Salaries, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5808 (iv).
Privy Council Chamber, Improvements re: in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).
Privy Council Implementing Judgment re G.T.P. Ry.: See ' B. No. 95.'
Privy Council Salaries:	in Com. of Sup.,
6460 (iv).
Prorogation, Com. from Gov. Gen.'s Sec.: Read (Mr. Speaker) 6780 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Mess, from Senate, 6824 (iv).
Provident Trust Co., Incorporation, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Lemieux) 3755 (ii).
Provincial Boundaries, Res. from Legre. of Saskatchewan, re Negotiations for Transfer of Natural Resources: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 2577 (ii).
See ' Man. Extension Boundaries.'
Provincial Control of Western Natural Resources, Promise re-. Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 553 (i).
Provincial Railways and Public Buildings, Govt. Assistance:	M. for Cor.* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 562 (i).
Provl. Subsidies:	See ' B. Nos. 77, 115, 151,
152, 178 and 186.'
See ' Man. and N.S.' ' P.E.I.'
Provincial Subsidies re Agriculture:	See
B. No. 100.'
Provost, Raoul, Dismissal from Marine and Fisheries: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 2453 (ii). Public Accounts Com., Attendance of R. C. Miller, 3rd Rep.: M. to cone. (Mr. Middle-bro) 6333 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 2nd Rep.: M. (Mr. Middlebro) to cone.,
5832 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
4th Rep.: Presented (Mr. Middlebro)
6492 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 5tli Rep.: Presented (Mr. Middlebro)
6732 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 6th Rep.:	M. (Mr. Ames) to cone.,
6062 (iii).
See ' Diamond Light.'
Public Accounts Report:	Presented (Mr. W.
T. White) 11 (i).
Public Buildings in Alberta and Sask., Purchase of Sites, Govt. Policy re: Ques. (Mr. White, Alberta) 2068 (ii).
Public Expenditures, Scandals, &c., by late Govt.: Remarks in debate on Address (Mr. Monk) 231 (i).
Public Health Assn.: See ' B. No. 127.'
Public Officials, Inquiries re Conduct, Ap-ptmt. of Commissioners in Quebec: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2063 (ii).
Public Ownership of Public Utilities: on M. for Sup. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) 645 (i).
See ' Cable,' ' Freight Rates,' ' Parcel Post,' ' Railways,' &e.
Public Service Commission, Apptnit. of Messrs. Jackson and Schwitzer as Assistants:	Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 5954 (iv).
Public Service Commission, Charges re A. B. Morine: on M. for Sup. (Mr. Carvell) 6528
(iv).
See ' Dismissals,' &c.
PUBLIC WORKS:
Advertisements for Govt. Contracts, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 2449 (ii). Anse au Canard Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Breakwater, Tenders re Construction:
Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 878 (i).
Arichat, Retaining Wall: in Com. of Sup., 2039 (ii).
Athabasca Landing to Grand Prairie Tel.
Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2819 (ii). Athabasca River Landing: in Com. of Sup., 2814 (ii).
Aurora Public Building, Papers, Reports, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Armstrong) 561
(i).
cxliv
[Stage Direction]
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Baddeck Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 6658 (iv).
Bathurst Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2363 (ii).
Battleford Public Building:	in Com. of
Sup., 2204 (ii).
Beaumont Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2366
(ii).
Bertliier en-Haut Post Office, Purchase, Repairs, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Barrette) 1409 (i).
Blue Rocks Island Breakwater: in Com. of Sup., 2041 (ii).
B.C. Public Buildings, Generally: in Com. of Sup., 2215 (ii).
Buildings leased by Govt., Rentals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1358 (i).
Calgary Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2204 (ii).
Canadian Coal used to heat Govt. Buildings: Remarks (Mr. E. M. "Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 3286 (ii).
Cape Breton Tel. Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2817 (ii).
Causapscal Post Office, Pet. re Site: Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 1020 (i).
Chance Harbour, N.B., Improvements re: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 554 (i).
Chapel Cove Breakwater, Pet. re Extension: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 1585 (i).
Charles Forest's Cove Breakwater, Contract re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Kyte) 1584
(i)	.
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor* (Mr. Kyte) 2460 (ii).
Charlos Cove Breakwater: in Com. of Sup., 2040 (ii).	.
Chatham, N.B., Public Building: IConc., 6804 (iv).
Chester Canal, N.S., Discontinuance of Work: Ques. (Mr. A. It. Maclean) 716 (i). Cole Harbour Wharf: in Com. of Sup., 2055
(ii)	.
Cow Bay Protection Works: in Com. of Sup., 2055 (ii).
Creosoted Timber re Public Works: in Com. of Sup., 2440 (ii).
Devil's Island Breakwater Extension: in Com. of Sup., 2055 (ii).
Edmonton Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2206 (ii).
Edmonton Wharf: in Com. of Sup., 2816 (ii). Eganville Post Office, Purchase of Site: Ques. (Mr. Low) 725 (i).
Faulkner, R. S., Emplymt. by Public Works as Contractor: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 5261
(iii)	-
Fort McMurray and Athabasca Tel Lines: in C.'.iu. of Sup., 2819 (ii).
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Fraserville Bridge Works, Interview with Messrs. LeBel and Riou: Ques. (Mr. Gau* vreau) 549 (i).
Fraserville Wharf, Cor. re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 3534 (ii).
Fraserville Wharf and Dredging, Expenditure re: Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 3150 (ii). French River, Dredging, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 6657 (iv).
Garthby, Lake Aylmer, Wharf Construction: M. for Papers* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (iii). Gaspe Landing Pier, Appropriation re-. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
Gaspd Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3305 (ii).
Gillis Point Wharf Construction: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
Gooseberry Cove, N.B., Improvements re-.
Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 555 (i).
Goose Creek Harbour: in Com. of Sup., 2372
(ii).
Govt. Dredges, Contract re Boarding Employees: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 5953 (iv). Hampton Public Building: in Com. of Sup.,
1527	(i).
Harbours and Rivers, Generally: in Com. of Sup., 3235 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Man., Repairs, &c.: in Com. of Sup.,
2814 (ii).
_______ Mar. Provs.: in Com. of Sup., 2440
(ii).
_____N.B.: in Com. of Sup., 623 (i), 2366
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Que.: in Com. of Sup., 2785 (ii).
Hillsboro Public Building: in Com. of Sup.,
1528	(i).
Hull City Hall Square, Improvements by Improvement Commission:	Ques. (Mr. Kidd) 2293 (ii).
Humboldt Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2211 (ii).
lie Bezard and Ste. Genevieve Wharfs, Com. pletion of Repairs, &c.: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 557 (i).
Inverness Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
Kelley's Cove Breakwater, Tenders re : Ques. (Mr. Law) 3340 (ii).
Lachine Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1346, 1952 (i).	'
Larry's River Dredging, Apptmt. of Inspector: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 5055 (iii). L'Assomption Wharf, Appropriations re: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2451 (ii), 5951, 6781
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Continuation of Construction: Ques.
(Mr. Seguin) 2579 (ii).

[Stage Direction]
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Laurentides Public Building, Acquisition of Property: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2451 (ii). Lawlor's Island Quarantine Station:	in
Com. of Sup., 1341, 1531 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Memorials, re: M. for Copies* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 2460 (ii).
Lethbridge Armoury, Plans, Tenders, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 729 (i).
Lethbridge Post Office, Plans, Tenders, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 728 (i).
Lethbridge Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2212 (ii).
Levis Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1346 (i). Levis Graving Dock, Ac.: in Com. of Sup., 3295 (ii).
Lorneville Breakwater, N.B., Tests re Foundation, .Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 555
(i).
Louiseville Public Buildings: Cone., 6794
(iv).
Lunenburg Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i).
Magdalen Island Telegraph and Telephone: in Com. of Sup., 3302 (ii).
Maisonneuve Postal Station, Erection of: Ques. (Mr. Yerville) 550 (i).
Maisonneuve Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1347 (i).
Marieville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1348 (i).
Mar. Provs. Dredging: in Com. of Sup., 2816 (ii).
Melford Wharf Construction: in Com of Sup., 2056 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Notice to suspend work: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 549 (i).
Midland Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1855 (i).
Montreal Barracks: in Com. of Sup. 1350
(i).
Montreal Customs Appraiser Building: in Com. of Sup., 1351 (i).
Montreal Post Office Enlargement: in Com. of Sup., 1348 (i).
Montreal Postal Station F.:: in Com. of Sup 1352 (i).
Moose to Drulingville Loop Tel. Line: in Com. of Sup., 2820 (ii).
Moosejaw Public Building, Tender of Mc-Diarmid Co., Limited: M. for Copy* (Mr. Knowles) 562 (i).
Napierville Post Office Site, Payment to Mr. Bourgeois: Remarks (Mr. Lanctot) on M. for Sup., 2373 (ii).
Napierville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1354 (i).

Purchase of Site: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lanctot) 5263 (iii).
J
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
National Ports: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2837 (ii).
North Battleford Tel. Lines: in Com. of Sup., 2822 (ii).
North Battleford to Isle la Crosse Tel. Line: in Com. of Sup., 2822 (ii).
Ottawa City Buildings: in Com. of Sup., 1321 (i).

Caretakers, Ac.: in Com. of Sup.,
3293 (ii).

Eastern Block Addition: in Com. of
Sup., 1339 (i).

Electric Power, Ac.: in Com. of Sup.,
3286 (ii).

Examining Warehouse, Site, Ac.: in
Com. of Sup., 1949 (i).

Heating, Ac.: in Com. of Snp., 3278
(ii).

Leases, Rentals, Ac.:	in Com. of
Sup., 1324 (i), 3290 (ii).

 Observatory: in Com. of Sup., 1321
(i).

Plumbing, Ac.: in Corn, of Sup.. 1855
(i)	.

 Post Office Deptl. Block, Condition re:
Remarks (Mir. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 2010; Remarks (Mt. Pelletier) 2015 (ii).

Pr|ivy Council Chamber!, Improvements re: in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).

 Site for new Deptl. Building: dm Cbm.
of Sup., 3242 (ii).

 Sussex St. Property: in Conf. of .Sup.,
1322 (i).

 Sussex Street Property, Total Amount
paid, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1359 (i).

 Victoria Memorial Museum, Number
of Employees, Dismissals, Ac.: Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2294 (ii).

 Water Supply: in Com. of Sup., 3294
(ii)	.
Ottawa -City Grounds: in Com. of Sup., 3239 (ii).
Ottawa City, Rideau Hall, Furniture, Repairs, Ac.: in Com. of Sup., 3279, 3285 (ii). (ii).

 Improvements, Amount expended re
H.R.H. Occupancy: Ques. (Mir. Pugsley) 547 (i).

Improvements, Amount expented
from 1896 bo 1911: Ques. (Mr. Currie) 876
(i).

 Expenditure re: Ques. of Priv., re
Par. in ' Mail and Empire,' (Mr. Pugsley) 799 (i).

Snow Cleaning, Ac.: in. Com of Sup.,
3279 (id).
exlvi

PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Ottawa City, Rideau Hall, Stmnt. re Expenditure, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 726 (i). Ottawa River Bridges: Cone., 6806 (iv).
Peace River Tel. Line, Building, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 2821 (ii) [DOT]
Petawawa Public Wharf, Tenders re, Contract awarded: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 532
(i).
Petite Lameque Wharf, Construction ret Ques. (Mr. Turgeon) 1358 (i).
Pink Rock Wharf, N.B., Total Cost, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Fowler) 4257 (idi).
Plaza at Ottawa, Fences and Posters, Responsibility re: Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 8:6
(i).
Point Aux Anglais, Drainage Works, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Ethier) 4778 (iii).
Port Arthur Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1951 (i).
Part Arthur and Fort William Dredging: Personal Explanation (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 3331 (iii).
Port Dover Harbour Works: M. for Ret.* (Mr. Charlton) 3755 (ii).
Port Richmond Breakwater: dm Com. of Sup., 2044 (ii).

 Contract re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Itybe) 1585 (i).

Reports, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Kyte) 2460 (ii).
P. E. I. Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3303 tyi).
Prince Rupert Dry Dock Subsidy, Completion, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Clements) 1811 (i). Provincial Railways and Public Buildings, Govt. Assistance: M. for Cor.* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 562 (i).
Public Buildings in Alberta and Sa.sk., Purchase of Sites, Govt. Policy re: Ques. (Mr. White, Alberta) 2068 (ii).
Public Works, Appropriations of Last Year: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 2436 (d'i).
Public Works in Cape Breton, Tenders re: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 805 (i).
Public Works, Contracts re: Ques. (Mr. E.
M. Macdonald 559 (i).
Public Works Contracts, Amounts given without tender: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 877 (i).	*

Montreal and Quebec, Without tender: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 877 (i). Public Works, Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of .Sup., 1084 (i).	.

Private Sec's Allowance: Cone. 6779
(iv).
Public Works, Dismissal of Workmen: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2584 (ii).
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Public Works Engineering Branch, Salaries : Remarks (Mr. Monk) in Cam. of Sup.. 1058-9 (i).
Public Works Estimates, Information re: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 3278 (ii).
Public Works Expenditure for last ten years in different Provs.: Ques. (Mr. Clements) 2064 (ii).
Public Works, Govt. Policy re: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i). Public Works Omitted from Estimates: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) .in Com. of Sup., 2794
(ii)-
Public Works, Suspension of, Names and Locations, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 530, 531 (i).
Public Works Votes of Last Year, Continuation &c.: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 1340 (i).
Purchase of Goods by Public Works Dept, since Oct. 1911, Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 1204, 1578 (i).
_____ M. for Bet.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
2459 (id).
Quebec, Customs House: in Com. of Sup., 1849 (i).
_____Drill Ball: in Com. of Sup., 1849 (l).
_____Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1851 (i).
Quebec Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2836 (di).	^
Regina Armoury and Drill Hall:	n .mm.
of Sup., 2212 (ii).

 Erection of: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 580 (i).
Renfrew Public Building: ia Corn. -,f Sup., 1953 (i).
Rigaud Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1852 (d).
Rivieres des Prairies Nav. Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 2441 (ii).
_____Drainage, Amount voted: Ques. (Mr. C. A. Wilson) 714 (i).
St. Andrew Wharf, Discontinuance of Works, re-. Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 724
(*)* . , Ste Anne de la Poeatnere, Experimental
Farm, Tenders re Buildings: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 577 (i).
St. Charles River Improvements: in Com. of Suip., 2837 (ii).
St. Croix Wharf Construction:	M. for
Papers* (Mr. Fortier) 5557 (iv).
St. Jacques Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lafortume) 560 (d).
St- Johns and Iberville Bridge, Amount voted re Construction: Ques. (Mr. De-mersl 551, 571 (i).


INDEX-1911-12
[Stage Direction]
cxlvii
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
St. John, N.B., Drill Hall: in Com. of Sup., 1529 (i).
St. John Dry Dock. Contract, &c.; in Com. of Sup., 3296 (ii).
St. John Harbour Improvements, Tel. re Terminal Facilities: Ques. (Mr. Pugslev) 566 (d).
[Stage Direction]
Tugs employed, Amount paid par day:
Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 548 (i).
St. John Quarantine Station, Partridge Ts-land: in Com. of Sup., 1530 (i).
St. John Wharf, Appropriation re Site: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in, Com. of Sup., 2370 (id).
St. Lambert Public Building: ;in Corn, of of Sup., 1853 (i).
St. Laurent Public Building, Cone., 6801 (iv).
St. Lawrence Channel: i,n Com. of Sup., 5231
(iii)-
St. Lawrence Ship Channel, Emplymt. of Govt. Dredges: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 4256
(iii).
St. Theresa Publdo Building: in Com. of Sup., 1854 (i).
St. Vailier Wharf, Award of Contract, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Delisle) 2068 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Contract of Alex. Diuohesneau: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 4263 (idi).
Sackville, N.B., Harbour Improvements, Cone., 6805 (iv).
Sarnia Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1952 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Erection of: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 555
(i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. Pardee) 1589 (i).
Seaforth Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1953 (i).
Shawinigan Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1852 (i).	,
Shediac Public Buildings: Cone., 6793 (iv).
Sherbrooke Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1853 (i),
Sorel Workshops Investigations, Payments re: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1205 (i).
Sorel Deep Water Whafs, Contractors re: Ques. (Mr. Lavallee) 2859 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Claim of Mr. Lariviero for Timber
supplied: Ques. (Mr. Lavallee) 3535 (ii).
Strathcona Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2213 (ii).
Sudbury Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1953
(i).
Telegraphs, Working Expenses: in Com. of Sup., 3302 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Quebec, Repairs, &c.: in Com. of Sup.,
2817 (ii).
Temiskaming Dam., Water Storage Dam: in Com. of Sup., 2827 (ii).
Ji
PUBLIC WORKS-Con.
Temiskaming Dam, Construction, &c.: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 4262 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Tenders, Contracts, &c.: M. for Copies* (Mr. Pugsley) 2459 (ii).
Three Rivers Harbour, Deep Water Wharf: in Com. of Sup., 2441 (ii).
Three Rivers Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1854 (i).
Toronto Examining Warehouse: in Com. of Sup., 1963 (i).
Toronto Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2445 (ii).
Weedon Public Building, Construction of: Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 4550 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (iii).
Weyburn Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2213 (ii).
Wharfs, Total Expenditure for last ten years: Ques. (Mr. Clements) 1811 (i). Wheatley Creek Dredging: in Com. of Sup., 640 (i).
Wolfville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i).
Wood Mountain Tel. Line: in Com. of Sup., 2821 (ii).
Yarmouth Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
York Bridge over Grand River, Ont.: in Com. of Sup., 2817 (ii).
Yukon Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3303 (ii).
Quarantine Station Buildings: in Com. of Sup., 1341 (i).
See ' Lawlor.'
Quebec Arsenal, Payment to Employees, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 579 (i).
Quebec Boundaries Extension: See 'B. No. 151.'
Quebec Boundary Extension: M. for Cor.* (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1590 (i).
See ' Ungava.'
Quebec Bridge Construction Contract: Stmnt. (Mr. Graham) re English Criticism, on M. for Sup., 5415 (iii).
Quebec Bridge, Erection of Shops: Remarks (Mr. Graham) in Com. of Sup., 5810 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Reconstruction, Reps., Plans, Tenders,
&c.: M. (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) for Papers, 1401 (i).
Quebec Central Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com., 6305 (iv).
Quebec Customs House: in Com. of Sup., 1849 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Drill Hall: in Com. of Sup., 1849 (i).
Quebec Dry Dock, Construction re-. Ques. (Mr. Beland) 4260 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Construction: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux)
6784 (iv).
cxlviii
[Stage Direction]
Quebec Dry Dock, Site, &c.: M. for Reps.* (Mr. Belaud) 4263 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Subsidy, Reps, re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 6493 (iv).
Quebec and Gaspd Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 4738 (iii).
Quebec Harbour Commission: See ' B. No. 31/ Quebec Harbour Commission, Names of Members in 1896 and after: Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 579 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Removal of Members, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Xemieux) 560 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Reorganization re:	Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 580 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Resignation from Board of Members: Ques. (Mr. Lachance) 579 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Solicitor, Apptmt. of: Ques. (Mr. E. M.
Macdonald) 1814 (i).
Quebec Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2836 (ii).
Quebec Ministers of the Cabinet, Apptmt. by Min. of Public Works: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 545 (i).
See ' Cabinet/
Quebec Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1851 (i). Quebec and Saguenay Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5896, 6214 (iv).
Quebec Savings Bank Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 170/
Quebec West Controverted Election, Certificate of Judge: Presented (Mr. Speaker) 407 (i). Queen's Hotel Co., Limited, Litigation re: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 3755 (ii).
Queen's Theological College: See ' B. No. 68/ Queen's University at Kingston: See ' B. No. 68/
[Stage Direction]
Ref. to Minister of Justice re Provl.
Jurisdiction:	Remarks (Mr. Bickerdike)
3730 (ii).
Questions Improperly drafted: Remarks (Mr. Speaker) 4983, 5054 (iii).
Questions not Answered: M. (Mr. Borden) 6732 (iv).
Questions re Mr. Lemieux ruled out (Mr. Speaker) 2580 (ii).
Questions and Notices of Motions, Rules re Standing: Remarks (Mr. Speaker) 1015 (i). Quinze River and Ottawa Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 54/
Race Track Meets: See ' B. No. 165/ Radiotelegraphic Service-Wireless Stations: in Com. of Sup., 5399 (iii).
Railway Act Amts.: See ' B. Nos. 5, 6, 7, 86/ Ry. Belt and Peace River Block of Land: See ' B. No. 149/
Ry. Bridges in N.B., Aid to: See ' B. No. 188/ Ry. Cos., Incorporation of: See ' B. No. 191.' Ry. Crossings: See ' B. No. 6/
Ry. Mail Clerks, Salary Increases: See ' B. Nos. 105 and 106/
Railway Sections and Section Men, Jurisdiction of Ry. Commission: See ' B. No. 86/ Ry. Subsidies: See ' B. No. 183/
Ry. Tariffs: See ' B. No. 6/
RAILWAYS:
Alberta Great Waterways Ry., Disallowance of: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) 1575 (i).
Canadian Northern Ry. Bonds, Govt. Guarantees, &c.: Ques. (Mr. M. Martin) 4247
(iii).
Can. Northern Ry. Bridge at Morris, Representations re Objections: Ques. (Mr. Molloy) 2587 (ii).
Can. Northern Ont. Ry., Subsidy, Guarantee, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 4781 (iii).
Can. Northern and Quebec Ry. Co/s Maintenance of Road in L'lle Bourdon: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 5261 (iii).
C.P.Ry., Irrigation, Complaint from Alberta Farmers: Ques. (Mr. Buchanan) 5262 (iii).
Car Shortage in the West:	Remarks (Mr. Buchanan) 1709 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Members remarks checked (Mr. Speaker) 1709 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Govtl. Action re: on M. for Sup. (Mr. Buchanan) 1714 (i).
Chatham and Newcastle Ry. Service, Pets, from Boards of Trade:	Remarks (Mr. Loggie) 4190 (iii).
Clarkboro, Sask., C.N.R. Right of Way, Title re:	Ques. (Mr. Meighen) 934 (i).
Estmere to Baddeck Branch Ry., Tenders re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. McKenzie) 1589 (i).
Freight Rates on Rys., Discrimination in the West:	Amt. (Mr. Turriff) to Com.
of Sup., 3194 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Transportation, Generally:	Remarks
(Mr. W. F. Maclean) on M. for Sup., 645, 1902 (i).
G.T.Ry. Trainmen's Strike, Settlement by late Govt., Judge Barron's Rep.: Ques. (Mr. Macdonell) 2580 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Board of Conciliation:	M. for Cor*
(Mr. A. MacNutt) 3756 (ii).
G.T.P. Remuneration to Govt. Director: in Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).
Guysborough Branch Ry. Appropriation: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair} on M. for Sup., 1445 (i),
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of
Sup., 5621 (iv).
Hampton Spur Line, Construction re, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 572 (i).
Harvey and Salisbury Ry., Contract re Rails:	Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com.
of Sup., 4171 (iii).
Hudson Bay Ry. Construction: in Com. of Sup., 622, 677 (i); *762, 6605 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
cxlix
RAILWAYS- Con.
Hudson Bay Ey., Contract: M. (Hr. Neely) for O.Cs., 732 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Cor. re:	M. (Mr. Aikins) for Papers, 1213 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ports, Nav., &c.: M. for Reps.* (Mr. Aikins) 3756 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. W. H. Bennett) 132 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Surveys re Navigation, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. Aikins) 3943 (ii).
Land Grants to Railways in Western Provs. prior to 1896: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 725 (i).
New Glasgow to Thorburn Ry. Co.'s Lease, &c., Legislation re:	Ques. (Mr. E. M.
Macdonald) 933 (i).
Orangedale to Cheticamp Ry., Construction: Remarks (Mr. A. W. Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 4226 (iii).
P.E.I. Ry., Claims for Compensation, Settlement of: Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes) in Com. of Sup., 5659 (iv).
P.E.I. Car Ferry, Construction, ac.: Ques. (Mr. J. J. Hughes) 1206 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Cor. with Govt, re Car Ferry System: M. for Copies* (Mr. Emmerson) 2072 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Tel. re: Ques. (Mr. Emmerson) 1580
(i).
[Stage Direction]
Tel. sent to A. A. McLean:	Ques.
(Mr. Pardee) 1577 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Tels., Letters, &c.: M. for Copies*
(Mr. Pardee) 2458 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry (Mr. Macdonald) for Return,
4232 (iii).
P.E.I. Ry., Harmony to Elmira Branch Rv.: in Com. of Sup., 5659 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Increased Facilities: in Com. of Sup.,
5661 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 O'Leary to West Point, Ry. Branch
Lines, Construction re:	Ques. (Mr. Richards) 721 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Winter Communication, Ry. Accommodation:	Remarks (Mr. J. J. Hughes)
3830 (ii).
Rys. and Canals, Annual Stmnt.: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) 4122 (iii).
Railway Bridges, N.B., Aid:	Prop. Res.
(Mr. Borden) 5691 (iv).
Ry. Commissioners, Board of: in Com. of Sup., 5800 (iv).
Railway Committee, Apptmt. of Sub-Committee re G.T. Ry. Bill, Liberals Omitted: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) in Com. of Sup., 5616 (iv).
Railway Construction in the West, Shortage of Steel Rails:	Remarks (Mr. Turriff) on M. for Sup., 6543 (iv).
Railways Deptl. Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 1064 (i).	.
RAILWAYS- Con.
Railway Facilities in N.S.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 4213
(iii)	.
[Stage Direction]
Litigation Expenses:	in Com. of
Sup., 5800-1 (iv).
Railway Mail Clerks, Answer to Question: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) 5561 (iv). Railway Question:	Notice of Discussion
(Mr. W. F. Maclean) 1494 (i).
See ' Freight Rates.'
Railway Rates and Freight Charges: (Mr. Maclean) on M. for Sup., 645 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Staff Salaries: in Com. of Sup., 5801
(iv)	.
Railway Subsidies: Prop. Res., 5681 (iv). Railway Ties, Contract with Dame Boulay: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Carvell) 5957 (iii).
Ry. Ties, Contract re at Sayabec:	Ques.
(Mr.	4041 (iii).
St. John Valley Ry., Agreement re Construction:	Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 4233, 4461
(iii).
[Stage Direction]
Contracts re-. Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 4743 (iii).
St. John Valley Ry., Contract re: Ques. (Mr. Michaud) 577 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Contract to Grand Falls: Ques. (Mr. Michaud) 4977 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Copies* (Mr. Michaud) 2460
(ii).
St. John Valley Ry. Subsidy, Agreement re: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 3049 (ii).
Salisbury and Harvey Ry., Cor. re Opening of Hillsborough Ry.:	M. for Copy* (Mr. Pugsley) 562 (i).
*

 Negotiations re Supply of Rails: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 4125 (iii).
Students, Railway Fares, Reduction to: Remarks (Mr. Currie) 6277 (iv).
Subsidies to Railways in Man. and N.W., &e.:	M. for Stmnt.* (Mr. McCraney)
562 (i).
Sunnybrae to Country Harbour Ry. Subsidy:	Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com.,
6228 (iv).
Sunnybrae and Guysborough Branch Lines: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4262 (iii). Sunnybrae Branch Ry.: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 4213 (iii). Transportation Question:	See 'Freight
Rates.'
Rambaut, Thomas D., Patent Relief: See ' B. Nos. 55 and 84.'
Rainy River Radial Ry. Co.:	See ' B. No.
121.'
[Stage Direction]


Rainy River Radial Co/s Subsidy: in Com., 6312 (iv).
Rathburn Post Office, Removal of Postmaster, &e.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Pardee) 4262
(iii).
Rayne, R. W., Caretaker Truro Armoury, Dismissal: Ques. (Mr. Macdonald) 6184 (iii). Reciprocity in Trade: Remarks (Mr. W. F.
Maclean) on M. for Sup., 645 (i). Reciprocity Treaty with U.S., Cor. with British Ambassador:	M. for Copies* (Mr. Bradbury) 1817 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Cor. between Can. Govt, and U.S.: M.
for Copies* (Mr. Bradbury) 1817 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. Borden) 51; (Mr. Emmerson) 426; (Mr. Foster) 76; (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 36; (Mr. Lemieux) 244; (Mr. W. M. Martin) 466; (Mr. Monk) 231; (Mr. Oliver) 449; (Mr. Pugsley) 142; (Mr. Sinclair) 323; (Mr. Verville) 277; (Mr. W. T. White) 447 (i).
Reciprocity with TJ.S., from 1890 to 1891: M.
for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 5263 (iii).
Red River, Pollution of: See ' B. No. 64/
Red River Pollution: on M. for Sup. (Mr. Bradbury) 5166 (iii).
Refrigerator Cars on I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 5603 (iv).
Regiments of Foreign born Citizens, Organization of: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 534 (i).
Regina Armoury and Drill Hall: in Com. of Sup., 2212 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Erection of: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin)
580 (i).
Regina Census: Inquiry for Ret. (Mr.Knowles) 1574 (i).
See ' Census/
Registration of Shipping: in Com. of Sup., 5229 (iii).
Renfrew, N., Contracts Awarded, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2857 (ii).
Renfrew, S., Apptmts. to Public Service: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 3334 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Contracts awarded, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2856 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissal of Govt. Officials: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2856 (ii).
Renfrew, S., Election, Issue of Writ: M. (Mr. A. H. Clarke) to adjn. Hse., 2218 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1576,
1707 (i), 1971, 2058, 2377 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Speech of Min. of Customs: Remarks re
Georgian Bay Canal (Mr. Devlin) 1573 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Vacancy:	Notification (Mr. Speaker)
926 (i).
Renfrew Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1953 (i).
Repentigny Lightkeepers, Charges re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Seguin) 6784 (iv).
See ' Dismissals/
Restaurant Com.: M. for Com. (Mr. Borden) 710 (i).
See ' House of Commons/
Returns: Inquiry for (Mr. Kyte) 5939 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for (Mr. E. Lapointe) 4744 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 2056
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for (Mr. Monk) 6494 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for (Mr. Murphy) 4836 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for (Mr. Murphy) 5560 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for (Mr. Pugsley) 2377 (ii).
Revillon Freres Trading Co., Ltd.: See ' B. No. 114/
.Revised Statutes, French Version: See ' B. No. 65/
Richards, Mr. Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 5821, 6652 (iv).
Rideau Canal, Bank St. Bridge: in Com. of Sup., 5791 (iv).
Rideau Canal, New Dredging Plant: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
Rideau Hall, Expenditure re: Ques. of Priv., re Par. in ' Mail and Empire ' (Mr. Pugsley) 799 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Furniture, Repairs, &c.: in Com. of
Sup., 3279, 3285 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
*- Improvements, Amount expended re H.R.H. Occupancy: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 547 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Improvements, Amount expended from
1896 to 1911: Ques. (Mr. Currie) 876 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Lighting and Heating, &c.: Remarks
(Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of Sup., 3234 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
*' Stmnt. re Expenditure, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 726 (i).
See ' Pub. Works/
Rifle Associations and Bands: in Com. of Sup., 5528 (iii), 6653 (iv).
Rigaud Postmaster, Application re: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2294 (ii).
Rigaud Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1852 (i).	.
Ritchie, Hon. Mr. Justice, Apptmt. of: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) 3331, 3449 (ii).
Riviere du Loup, I.C.R. Increased Accommodation: in Com. of Sup., 5654 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Workshops, Removal to Fraserville:
Ques. (Mr. Gauvreau) 570 (i).
Rivieres des Prairies, Nav. Improvement: in Com. of Sup., 621 (i), 2441 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Drainage, Amount voted: Ques. (Mr. C.
A. Wilson) 714 (i).
River John Mail Carriers, Name, Amount paid, &c.: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1579 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Cor.* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
2247 (ii).

[Stage Direction]
cli
Rivers, Lachapelle and Dubois, Messrs., Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3752 (ii).
Roberts, Capt. Alex., Postmaster at Canso, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 3311 (ii).
Robert, Wm„ Dismissal from Val des Eboulis Post Office: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 3537 (ii).
Robinson, Mr. Fred. P., Apptmt. as Preventive Officer for N.B.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1211 (iii).
Robitaille, Mr. J. -C., Charges re Political Partisanship: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2858 (ii).
Rockfield Bridge, Lachine Canal: in Com. of Sup., 1197 (i), 5790 (iv).
Roekliffe Rifle Ranges: in Com. of Sup., 6651
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Acquisition of Additional Land: Ques.
(Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
Rogers, J. M., Dismissal from East Roman Valley P.O., N.S.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 722
(i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 1109 (i).
Rolling Stock, IC.R.: in Com. of Sup., 5609, 5653, 6161 (iv).
Rooms allotted to Liberal Members, Complaints re: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 670, 1951
(i).
Rosignol, Major J. E., Qualifications re Commandant of 61st .Regiment: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 723 (i).
Ross Rifle: See 'N.R.A.'
Royal Assent: See ' Bills.'
Royal Mint: in Com. of Sup., 6581 (iv).
Royal Society of Canada Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White) 565 (i).
Roy, Wm„ Rep. of II. Boulay re Charges on
I.C.R.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 931 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. foil- Papers (Mr. Boulay) 1391 (i).
Rural Mail Delivery, Prop. Res. (Mr. Pelletier) 5680 (iv).
Rural Mail Delivery, Establishment of: See ' B. No. 179.'
Rural Mail Delivery Extension:	Remarks
(Mr. A. H. Clarke) 2061 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Number of Boxes in Ont.: Ques. (Mr. Elson) 6782 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Routes: Inquiry for (Mr. Lemieux) 5561
(iv).
[Stage Direction]
Tenders re Mail Boxes, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Staples) 1580 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Pets, re *. Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1978
(iii).
See ' Post Office.'
Rural Telephone System, Placing in Post Offices: Prop. Res. (Mr. Blain) 2217; Ruling (Mr. Speaker) Res. out of Order, 2250; Remarks (Mr. Speaker) re M. to restore to Order Paper, 2287 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 M. (Mr. Blain) to stand, 2160 (ii).
Rutherford, Mr. John, Land Agent at Moose-jaw, Dismissal, &c.: M. (Mr. Knowles) for Papers, 1395 (i).
St. Adelaide de Pabos Postmaster, Investigation re Charges: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2068
(ii).	_
Ste. Agathe des Monts, Dismissal of Postmistress: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 973 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor. (Mr. Lemieux) 1591 (i).
Ste. Agathe des Monts lty. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5895 (iv).
St. Aldwyn Post Office, Change of Name from Broderick, Cor., &c.: Read (Mr. McCraney) 5922 (iv).	*
St. Amour Postmaster, Changes since Jan. 1912: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 2666 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor* (Mr. Proulx) 2861 (ii).
St. AneiLet Postmaster, Request fotr Dismissal: M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 2588 (ii).
St. Andrew Wharf, Discontinuance of Works re: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 721 (i).
St. Angele de Laval, County of Nicotet, Postmaster, Charges res Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 3755 (ii), 4039 (did).
She. Anne de Bellevue and L'lle Per.rot Mail ContraiIs, Expiry of: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 5951 (iv).
Ste. Anne de Bellevue, Nondelivery of Mail; (Mr. Boyer) 5260 (did).
Ste. Anne de la Pooa.tie.re, Experimental Farm, Tenders re Buildings; Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 577 (d).
St. Charles .and Huron River Ry. Co.'s .Subsidy; in Com., 6308 (iv).
St. Charles River Improvements:	in Com.
of Sup., 2837 (ii).
St. Clair and Erie .Ship Canal Co-.: See ' B. No. 172.'
St. Croix Wlharf Construction: M. for Papers* (Mr. Fortier) 5557 (iv).
St. Germain Postmaster, Charges re Apptmt.: Ques. (Mr. E. Papointe) 1579 (i).
St. Germain Postmaster, Mr. C. Michaud: M. for Cor. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 1592 (i).
St. Isidore de Prescott, Posten-aatership, Pet. re: Ques. (Mr. Proulx) 3055 (ii).
St. Jacques de l'Achigan Post Office Site; Remarks (Mr. Lafotrtiune) in Com. of -Sup., 2112 (ii).
St. Jacques Post Office, Plans, Tenders, &c.: Ques. (Mr. La-fortune) 560 (i).
St. John and Iberville Bridge, Amount voted re Construction: Ques. (Mr. Demers) 551, 571 (i).
*

bn Ambulance Association, Aid to; in Com. of Sup., 6583 (iv).
St John -and Courtenay Bay Contract: Remarks (Mr. Bmimersom) 4713 (ida), 6187 (iv).
St. John and Cuba Mail Subsidy: in Com. of -Sup., 678 (i).
clii
[Stage Direction]
St. John Drill Hail: in Com. of Slip., 1529
(i).
St. John Diry Dock, Contract, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 3296 (ii).
St. John and Halifax Mail Subsidy:	in
Com. of Sup., 678 (i), 4739 (iii).
St. John Harbour, Dredging Tenders re: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 5634 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mir. Pugsley) dm Com. of
Sup., 623, 669 (i).
______Contracts re: Remarks- (Mr. Emmer
son) 4743 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Tel. re Terminal Facilities: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 566 (i).
St. John Harbour, Tugs employed, Amount paid per day: Ques. (Mr. Pugsley) 548 (i). St. John Harbour Works, Contract: Remarks (Mr. Leimieux) in Com. of Sup., 3295 (ii). St. John Ry. Crossing at Baymarket Square: M. (Mir. Pugsley) for Cor., 402 (i).
St. John Quarantine Station, Partridge Island: in Com. of Sup., 1530 (i).
St. John Valley Ry., Aid to: See ' B. No. 188.' St. John Valley Ry., Agreement re Construction: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 4233, 4461 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Contract re:Ques. (Mr. Michaud) 577
(i) -	...
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 4743 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Reps., &c.: M. for Copies* (Mir. Michaud) 2460 (ii).
St. John Valley Ry. and Bridges, Subsidy: in Com. on Bill, 6211 (iiv).
St. John Valley Ry. Subsidy, Agreement re: Ques. (Mr. Cairvell) 3049 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Contract to Grand Falls: Ques. (Mr. Michaud) 4977 (iii).
St. John Va-lley Ry.: Inquiry for Papers (Mr. Carroll) 3946 (ii).
St. John Wharf, Appropriation re Site: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 2370
(ii)	.
St. John and W. Indies Mail Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 640 (i), 4740 (iii).
St. Lambert Public Building: in Com. of iSup., 1853 (a).
St. Laurent Public Building: Conic., 6804 (iv). St. Laurent, Xavier, Claims for Loss of Horse Killed on I.C.Ry.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Bou-lay) 4263 (iii).
St. Lawrence Channel: in Com. of Sup., 5231
(iii)	.
[Stage Direction]
 Ice-breaker: Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 5680
(iv)	.
St. Lawrence River Power, Res., from Montreal Board of Trade: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2456 (ii).
St. Lawrence Ship Chainmel, Average Depth of Water between Montreal and Quebec, Cap a la Roche at Low Tide: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 544 (i).
St. Lawrence Ship Channel, Emplymt. of Govt. Dredges: Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 4256 (iii).
St. Lorette Lake, Main., Pier, Completion of: Remarks (Mr. Staples) in Com. of Sup., 2813
(ii).
St. Martin, Madame, Dismissal from St. Louis de Bonsecours: M. for Pafpers* (M<r. Car-dim) 4782 (iii).
.St. Monique Mail Cointiract, Annulment of: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1584 (d).
St. Pascal Mail Contract, Cancellation, of: Ques. (Mr. Lapointe) 2294 (ii).
St. Patrick de Brandon, Population, Revenue of P.O.: Ques. (Mr. Laforbune) 724 (d).
St. Patrick's Channel Lighthouse: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Conn, of Sup., 5238 (iii).
St. Paul d'Abbattsford Postmaster, P. L.. St. Pierre, Investigation re: M. for Papers* (Mr. Lemieux) 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 6290 (iv).
St. Paul L'Ermite, Mail Carrier, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 2583 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
    Repentigny Mail Service, Cancellation
of Contracts: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3341 (ii).
See ' Dismissals.'
St. Peters Canal Improvements: iin Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
St. Peter of Wakefield Postmaster, Dismissal: Remarks (Mr. Devlin) 6286 (iv).
Saimte Roche Wharf: Remarks (Mr. Cardin) in Com. of Sup., 6657 (iv).
Ste. Rosalie Branch Lines, I.C.R., Accommodation, Complaints re: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 4134 (iii).
Ste. Therese and Laurentide Post Offices, Revenues, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Seguin) 3335 (ii).
Ste. Therese Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1854 (i).
St. Tite Postmaster, Dismissal of: Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1210 (d).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Bureau) in Cam. of Sup.,
6285 (iv).
Sit. Vallier Wharf, Aw^ard of Contract, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Delia]©) 2068 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Contract of Alex. Dncihesaieau: M. for
Cor.* (Mr. E. Lapointe) 4263 (iii).
Saimte Victor de Sorel Mail Contract: Remarks (Mr. Cardin) in Corn, of Sup., 6643
(iv).
See ' Post Office.'
St. Vincent de Paul Penitentiary: in Com. of Sup., 6586 (iv).
Sabbath Observance, See ' B. No. 85.'
Slackivdlle, N. B(, Harbour' Improvements, Conic., 6805 (iv).
Salisbury and Harvey Ry. Co., Oor. re Opening of Hillsborough Ry.: M. for Copy* (Mr. Pugsley) 562 (i).

[Stage Direction]
cliii
Salisbury and Harvey Ry. Co., Negotiations re Supply of Rails: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) in Com. of Sup., 4125 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry -for P-apers (Mir. Pugsley) 938
(i)	.
See ' Railways.'
Salmon Fisheries, B. C., Negotiations re Exportations, &c.: M. for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Maodoouaild) 3756 (id).
Sarnia Armoury: in Com. of Sup., 1952 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Erection of: Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 555 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mir. P-ardee) 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pardee) in Com. of Sup.,
2208 (ii).
Sarnia Winter Harbour: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Par-dee) 1589 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Inquiry for Ret., (Mr, Pardee) 3946
(ii)	.
Saskatchewan, Bank of: See ' B. No. 89.' Saskatchewan Central Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 146.'
Saskatchewan Life Insurance Co.:	See ' B.
No. 26.'
Saskatchewan Power Co.: See ' B. No. 83.' Saturday Sittings:	Stmnt. (Mr. Borden) 5830
(iv).
Sault Ste. Marie Canal Locks: in Com. of Sup., 5791 (iv).
Sauve, Mr. L, A., Dismissal from Soulang-es Canal: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux)' 575 (i). Sayabec Station Postmistress, Apptmt. of Miss Boulay:	Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 2068 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Pet. re Dismissal, Apptmt. &c.: Ques.
(Mr. Carvell) 2585 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 6295 (iv).
Schools of Instruction for Militia: in Com. of Sup., 5546 (iiid).
Schools of Navigation: in Com. of Sup., 5229
(iii)	.
Scotch Village Postmaster, Apptmt. in 1903, Charges re-. Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 2666 (id).
Scott Junction Mail Contract, Cancellation re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Belaud) 2459 (ii).
See ' Post Office.'
Seaforth Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1953 (i).
Seager Wheeler, Congratulations re Prize Wheat at N.T. Exhibition: Ques. (Mr. Mc-Craney) 542 (i).
Seamen, Sit., Annapolis Co., Post Office, Date of Opening: Ques. (Mr. Davidson) 3754 (ii). Sec. of State, Depth Salaries:	in Com. of
Sup., 1038 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Report: Presented (Mr. W. T. White)
565 ii).	*
Security Life Insurance Co.: See ' B. No. 27.'
Seed Control Act: in Com. of Sup., 6469 (iv). Seed Grain Distribution, Res. from Board of Trade of Wilcox:	Remarks (Mr. W. M.
Martin) 2299 (i).
Seeley Keitha, Relief of: See ' B. No. 174.' Sen. and H. of C. Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 75.' Senate Amendments, Railway Bills: Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) 6493, 6577 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) on M. for
Sup., 6544 (iv).
Senate, Sessional Indemnities:	in Com. of
Sup., 6460 (iv).
Senate Vacancy, Apptmt. of Acadian in N.B.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 541 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Pet. re French Apptmt.: Remarks (Mr. Michaud) 2755 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Wm. Chisholm) 1576 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5161
(iii)	.
Separate Schools in Main, and Keewaitin, Demand from Members: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4247 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Establishment of in Man.: M. for Pets.*
(Mr. Lemieux) 4263 (iii).
See ' Man. Boundaries.'
Sessional Employees, Number dismissed, &e.: Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 568 (i), 2064 (di).
See ' Dismissals,' ' House of Commons.' Sevigny, Mr. J. E., Apptmt. in Immigration Office, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Carvell) 1205 (i); 1814 (i).
Shawinigan Public Building:	in Com. of
Sup., 1852 (i).
Shediac Island Wharf:	Remarks (Mr. Emmerson) in Com. of Sup., 2373 (ii).
Shediac Public Buildings: Cone., 6793 (iv). Sheldon v. Rex.: M. for Papers* (Mr. Lemieux) 3756 (ii).
Sheltus, Anson, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Kay) 3-757 (ii).
Sherbrooke Post Office:	in Com. of Sup.,
1853 (i).
Shurtieff, Dr., Investigation re J. Clouthier: Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6629
(iv)	.
Sikhs in B. C., Decision re bringing in their Wives: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 2457 (ii). Simcoe, Grey and Bruce Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Corn, on Res., 5911 (Iv).
Small Pox in Ottawa Post Office: Explanation (Mr. Pelletier) 1242, 1280 (i).
Smith, Angus, Pilot of D.G.S. ' Earl Grey,' Suspension of: M. for Papers* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1590 (i).
cliv
[Stage Direction]
Smith, Lyman, C., Customs Collector at Osh-awa, Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 2861 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mir. Sinclair) in. Com. on
Customs Bill, 4575 (iii).
Solicitor General, Apptmt. of: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 546 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1816 (i).
Solicitor General, Payment of Salary to Min. of Justice, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Etliier) 725 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 1577 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 5162
(iii).
Sorel Deep Water Wharfs, Contractors re: Ques. (Mr. Lavallee) 2859 (ii).
Sorel Marine Yards, Inquiry re Administration: Ques. (Mr. Barnette) 974 (i).
Sorel and Ste. Victoria Mail Contracts, Tenders, &c.:	M. for Papers* (Mr. Cardin)
4782 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Cardin) 4248 (dii).
See ' Post Office/
Sorel Wharf, Claim of Mr. Lariviere for Timber supplied: Qiues. (Mr. LavaMee) 3535 (ii)-See ' Public Works/
Sorel Workshops Investigations, Payments re-. Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1205 (i).
Soulanges Canal, Charges re Damien Lalonde: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4249 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Claim of Denis Martin for Damages:
Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 2292 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Employees, Names, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4250 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
Guard Pier: in Com. of Sup., 5798 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Piatromage, &c,: Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 3536
(ii).
[Stage Direction]
Protection Works:	in Com. of Sup.,
5791 (iv).
S. A. Bounty Scrip, Delay in Distribution, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 2061, 3153 (ii).
Southampton Ry. Co/s Subsidy:	in Com.,
6224 (iv).
South Ont. Pac. Ry. Co.: See * B. No. 56/
Speaker, Election of:	M. (Mr. Borden) 2 5
(i).
[Stage Direction]
 Congratulations re Reading Prayers in
French (Sir Wilfrid Laurier) 1808 (i).
Speaker, Deputy: M. (Mr. Borden) 519; Reply, 523 (i).
Speech from Throne, 8 (i).
Spirella Co. of Can., Patent Relief:	See 'B.
No. 70/
Spittal, C. D., at Bisley: See ' N.R.A/
Spry Bay P.O.: , Request re Removal of: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 577 (i).


 M. for Cor.* (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 582
(i).
Statistical Officers: in Com. of Sup., 5801 (iv).
Statue erected on Federal Land du Quebec City by Provl. Govt.:	Ques. (Mr. Bellemare) 2667 (ii).
Statutes of Previous Sessions, Delay re Distribution :	Remarks (Mr. A. H. Clarke)
in Com. of Sup., 678 (i).
Steamboat Inspection: in Com. of Sup., 5238
(iii).
Steamboat Inspection Report:	Presented
(Mr. Hazen) 1571 (i).
Steamship Connections with I.C.R., Subsidies &c.:	Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in
Com. of Sup., 5597 (iv).
Steam Trawling on Canadian Coasts: M. for Papers (Mr. Sinclair) 2461 (ii).
Steam Trawlers and Fisheries Bounties: M. for Pets.* (Mr. Sinclair) 5957 (iv).

 Protection against: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 5388 (iii).
Steel and Iron Bounties, Par. in Montreal 'Gazette': Remarks (Mr. Kyte) 2588 (ii).
Steel and Iron Bounties re Budget Speech: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 4249 (iii).
See ' Bounties/
Stellarton Postmaster, Mr. John Fraser, Dismissal: M. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) for Cor* 1589 (i).
Stellarton Station Mail Service, Cancellation of:	M. for Cor* (Mr. E. M. Macdonald)
2247 (ii).
Stenographic Assistance for Members:	Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 1846 (i).

 in Com. of Sup., 6461 (iv).
Sterling Life Ass. Co. of Can.:	See B. No.
72/
Stewart, Ethel May, Relief of:	See ' B. No.
120/
Storey, Wm, Dismissal, Investigation, &c.: Ques. (Mr. J. Reid) 5054 (iii).
Stoves, Ranges, Incubators exported to Argentine Republic, Value, &c.:	Ques. (Mr. H. V. White) 561 (i).
Stratheona Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2213 (ii).
Strikes and Strike Funds: See ' B. No. 87/
Sudbury Post Office: in Com. of Sup., 1953
(i). "

 Dismissals:	Remarks (Mr. Boyce) in
Com. of Sup., 2033 (ii).
Sunnybrae to Country Harbour Ry., Subsidy: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com., 6228 (iv).
Sunnybrae to Guysborough Branch Line, I.
C.R., Tenders re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 542 (i).

Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2289 (ii).

M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4262 (iii).
-:   Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of
Sup., 4213 (iii).
Supply Bills: See ' B. Nos. 18 and 193/



[Stage Direction]
civ
Supply: M. for Com. (Mr. W. T. White) 525
(i).

[Stage Direction]
Committee:
Arts, Agriculture and Statistics:
Archives, 6461 (iv).
Census and Statistics, 619 (i), 6462 (iv). Destructive Pest Act, 6479 (iv). Distribution of Bulletins, 6465 (iv). Dom. Exhibition, Grant, 6479 (iv). Experimental Farms, 6465, 6477, 6484 (iv). Health of Animals, 6169 (iv).
. International Institute, 6478 (iv).
Live Stock Industry, 6469 (iv).
Seed Control Act, 6469 (iv).
Tobacco.Growing, 6478 (iv).
Toronto Exhibition, Grant, 6180 (iv). Year Book, 6165 (iv).
Charges of Management:
Dom. Notes, Printing, 1033 (i).
Foreign Coin in Circulation, 1034 (i). Public Debt, 619 (i).
Civil Government:
Agriculture, 1041 (i), 6485 (iv).
Archives, 6460 (iv).
Auditor General's Office, 1010, 1031 (i). Civil Service Commission, 6615 (iv). Conservation Commission, 1069 (i). Customs, 1040 (i).
Depts., Generally, 1067 (i).
Gov. Gen.'s Sec.'s Office, 1035 (i).
Indian Affairs, 1039 (i).
Inland Revenue, 1040, 1061 (i), 6490 (iv). Interior, 1038 (i).
Justice, 1035, 1039 (i), 6584 (iv).
Labour, 6615 (iv).
Marine and Fisheries, 1041 (i), 6651 (iv) Militia, 1037 (i).
Mines, 1066 (i).
Naval Service, 1062 (i).
Post Office, 1066 (i), 6278 (iv).
Privy Council, 1035 (i), 6460 (iv).
Public Printing and Stationery, 1038 (i). Public Works, 1064 (i).
Railway and Canals, 1061 (i), 5808 (iv). Secretary of State, 103S (i).
Customs:
General Vote, 1195 (i).
Salaries, Contingencies, &c., 1073 (i).
Excise:
Provisional Allowances, 5827 (iv). Salaries, &c., 5812 (iv).
Stamps, 5826 (iv).
Travelling Expenses, &c., 5826 (iv).
Weights and Measures:
Salaries, &c., 5828 (iv).
Fisheries:
Cold Storage for Bait, 6653 (iv).
* General Vote, 680 (i).
International Fisheries Commission, 6643
(iv).
Protection Service, 5386 (iii).
Salaries of Inspectors, &c., 5242 (iii).
Immigration:
Agents' Salaries, &c.. 3305 (ii). Contingencies, &c., 3911 (ii).
SUPPLY-Con.
Committee-Con.
Justice, Administration of:
Judges Allowances, 6597, 6601 (iv).
Legal Expenses, 6561 (iv).
Miscellaneous, 6580 (iv).
Moving Allowances, 6596 (iv).
N.W.T., 6560 (iv).
Penitentiaries, 6561, 6583 (iv).
Bonuses, 6600 (iv).
U.S., Pecuniar}- Claims Convention, 6579
(iv).
Labour Dept.:
Accident Inspectors, 1525 (i).
Combines Investigation Act, 1500 (i). Conciliation and Labour Act, Expenses, 1468 (i).
Contingencies, 6615 (iv)
Industrial Disputes Investigation Act, 1498 (i), 6615 (iv).
Technical Education Commission, 1527
<i>-
Legislation:
Members' Stenographers, 6461 (iv). Senate, 6460 (iv).
Lighthouse and Coast Service:
Aids to Navigation, 5236 (iii). International Navigation Congress, 5237 (iii).
Lighthouse and Buoy Steamer, 5237 (iii). Pensions to Pilots, 5236 (iii).
Salaries and Allowances to Keepers, 5232 (iii).
Mail Subsidies and SS. Subsidies:
General Vote,, 640, 677-680 (i), 4714-4742, 5934-5938 (iv).
Marine Hospitals, 5238 (iii).
Militia:
Allowances, 5447 (iii).
Annual Drill, 5452, 5484 (iii).
Clothing and Necessaries, 5521 (iii). Customs Dues, 5522 (iii).
Grants to Assns., 5528 (iii), 6653 (iv). Headquarters and District Staff, 5536
(iii)	.
Military Camps, 5521 (iii).
Military Properties, 5539 (iii).
Ordnance, &c., 5541 (iii), 6653 (iv). Quebec Arsenal, 6654 (iv).
Salaries, &c., 5546 (iii).
Schools of Instruction, 5546 (iii).
Mines Dept.:
Metallurgical Problems, Investigation, 6491 (iv).
Ore Deposits, Investigation, 6490, 6602
(iv)	.
Printing of Reports, 6490 (iv).
Salaries, &c., re Explosives Investigation, 6603 (iv).
Miscellaneous:
Champlain, Monument, 6485 (iv). Conservation Commission, 6579 (iv). Gymnastic Meet, Nancy, 5811 (iv).
Legal Expenses, Lanctot Charges, 6486
(iv).
Mint, Royal, 6584 (iv).
Olympic Games, Grant, 6486 (iv).
Paris Agency, 6614 (iv).
Parliamentary Documents, Distribution, 6613 (iv).
xlvi
[Stage Direction]
SUPPLY-Con.
Committee-Con.
Miscellaneous-Con.
Pelagic Sealing Congress, 5810 (iv). Printing Bureau, 6611 (iv).
Retiring Allowances, Sgt. Codd, 5811 (iv). St. John Ambulance Assn., 6583 (iv). Tuberculosis Assn., Grant, 6579 (iv). Wiley, Mrs., Claim, 6489 (iv).
Mounted Police:
General Vote, 5175 (iii).
Gratuities, 6485 (iv).
Naval Service:
Construction and Maintenance, 5303 (iii). Fisheries Protection Service, 5386 (iii). Hydrographic Surveys, 5398 (iii). Radiotelegraphie Service, 5399 (iii).
Ocean and River Service:
Cattle Inspection, 5229 (iii).
Maintenance and Repairs, &c., 5186, 5207
(iii)-	...
Patrolling Northern Waters, 5231 (iii). Registration of Shipping, 5229 (iii). Rewards for Saving Life, 5228 (iii). Schools of Navigation, 5229 (iii).
Wreck Investigations, 5229 (iii). Wrecking Plant, 5231 (iii).
Post Office:
Mail Service, 6280 (iv).
Salaries and Allowances, &c., 6615 (iv).
Public Works-Capital:
Buildings:
Eastern Block, Addition, 1339 (i). Halifax, Quarantine Buildings, 1311
(i) .	. London, Eng., Can. Office, 6655 (iv). Ottawa, New Buildings, 1321 (i).
Harbours and Rivers:
French River Improvements, 6657 (iv). Public Works-Income:
Buildings:
British Columbia, 2215 (ii).
Generally, 623 (i).
New Brunswick, 1527, 1530 (i).
Nova Scotia, 1343 (i), 2039-2056 (ii). Ontario, 1855, 1949-1966 (i).
Quebec, 1346-1356, 1849-1854 (i).
Rents, Repairs, &c., 3239-3279, 3285-3294
(ii)	.
Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2204-2213
(ii).
Dredging:
Mar. Provs., 2816 (ii).
Harbours and Rivers:
Generally, 623 (i), 3235 (ii).
Manitoba, 2813 (ii).
Maritime Provinces, 2440 (ii).
New Brunswick, 2363-2372 (ii).
Nova Scotia, 639 (i).
Ontario, 640 (i), 2445 (ii).
Quebec, 2441, 2785, 2836 (ii). Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2814 (ii).
SUPPLY-Con.
Committee-Con.
Public Works-Con.
Miscellaneous:
Monuments to Distinguished Canadians, 2823 (ii).
National Art Gallery, 2825 (ii).
Upper Ottawa, Storage Dams, 2827 (ii).
Roads and Bridges :
Grand River Bridge, York, Ont., 2817
(ii).
Slides and Booms, &c.:
Levis Graving Dock, 3295 (ii).
Telegraph Lines:
Cape Breton, 2817 (ii).
Generally, 3303 (ii).
' Lower St. Lawrence, &c., 3302 (ii). Quebec, 2817 (ii).
Saskatchewan and Alberta, 2819-2822 (ii).
Yukon, 3303 (ii).
Railways and Canals:
Canals:	*
Cornwall, 5797 (iv).
Lachine, 5790, 6611 (iv).
Rideau, 5791, 5798 (iv).
Sault Ste. Marie, 5791 (iv).
Soulanges, 5791, 5798 (iv).
Staff and Repairs, 5801 (iv).
Statistical Officers, 5801 (iv).
Trent, 5792, 5799 (iv).
Welland, 5786, 5796, 6607 (iv).
Miscellaneous:
Compassionate Allowances, 5678 (iv). G.T.P. Ry. Director, 5801 (iv). Litigation, 5800 (iv).
Railway Commission, 5800 (iv).
Railways:
Hudson's Bay Railway, 622, 677 (i), 5762, 6605 (iv).
Intercolonial Railway, 622, 670 (i), 41244137, 4162-4236 (iii), 5595-5658, 5809,
.	6461, 6604 (iv).
National Transcontinental Railway, 5765 (iv).
Prince Edward Island Railway, 56595677 (iv).
Steamboat Inspection:
General Vote, 5238 (iii).
Trade and Commerce:
Bounties, Expenses re, 5934 (iv).
Old Age Pension Fund, 688 (i).
Concurrence:
Doncaster Indian Reserve, Road, 6806
(iv).	.
French River Improvements, 6776 (iv). Inland Revenue, Salaries, 6770 (iv). Intercolonial Railway, 6774 (iv). International Fishery Commission, 6778 (iv).
Louiseville, Public Building, 6794 (iv). Mines Dept., Salaries, 6771 (iv).
Ottawa River Bridges, Clearing, 6806 (iv).
Public Works Dept., Private Secretary, 6779 (iv).
Sackville Wharf, 6805 (iv).
Shediac, Public Building, 6793 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
civil
Supreme Court of Canada, Division re-. Ques.
(Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 517 (i).
Sussex St. Property, Ottawa:	in Com. of
Sup., 1322 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Explanation (Mr. Pugsley) re abandonment, 2007 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Total Amount paid, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 1359 (i).
See - Public Works-Ottawa/
Sutherland, George Maekay, Relief of:	See
' B. No. 153/
Sutherland, Mr. Roderick, Dismissal of: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) 1271 (i)„ 2018 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Cor. Read, 2022 (ii).
See ' Dismissals/
Sutherland Rifle Sight:	See ' N.R.A/
Svaigher, A., Emplymt. by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Knowles) 6186 (iv).
Swift Current Public Building:	Remarks
(Mr. Knowles) in Com. of Sup., 3263 (ii). Sydney and Glace Bay Mail Service, Delay, &c.:	Stmnt. (Mr. Pelletier) 934 (i).
Sydney Mines Diversion:	in Com. of Sup.,
5658 (iv).
Sydney and Wycocomagh Mail Subsidy:	in
Com. of Sup., 1710 (iii).
Syrian Immigration, Pet. re O.C.; Ques.
(Mr. Lapointe) 1209 (i).
Tableaux in H. of C., 1336 (i).
Tariff Commission, Apptmt. of: See 'B. No. 88/
Tariff Commission, Apptmt. of, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Neely) 529 (i).
[Stage Direction]

 Legislation re: Remarks (Mr. A. K.
Maclean) 938 (i).
[Stage Direction]
 Ref. to in debate on Address (Mr. W.
M. Martin) 166 (i).
Taylor, Hon. Geo., Promise re Senate Apptmt. :	Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 545 (i).
See ' Parliament/
Technical Education Commission, Report re: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1202 (i).
See ' Industrial/ &c.
Telegraph Lines, Quebec, Repairs, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 2817 (ii).
Telegraph Working Expenses:	in Com. of
Sup., 3302 (ii).
Telegraph and Telephone Lines, Govt. Ownership: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 2007 (ii). See ' Cable/
Telephones, Long Distance, &c. in H. of C.: Remarks (Mr. A. K. Maclean) in Com. of Sup., 3213 (ii).
Telephone Wires, Permission of Govt, to place on Tel. Poles:	Remarks (Mr. A. W.
Chisholm) in Com. of Sup., 2822 (ii). Temiscouaia Election Expenses, Delays re Payment to Dep. Ret. Officer:	Remarks
1707 (i).
Temiskaming Lake Dam Construction, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Boulay) 1262 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Pugsley) 5928,
6661 (iv).
See ' Lake Temiskaming/
Temiskaming Dam, Water Storage Dam:	in
Com. of Sup., 2827 (ii).
T. & N.O.Ry. and G.T.R., Running Rights: See ' B. No. 145/
T. & N.O.Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com. of Sup., 6080 (iii).
T. & N.O.Ry., Subsidy to: See ' B. No. 186/
Therrien, F., Charges re Political Partisanship, Investigation re: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 1113 (i), 3152 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) in Com. of
Sup., 5823 (iv).
Thibault, Theopliile, Dismissal, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. Lemieux) 3339 (ii).
Thibodeau, George, Resignation, &c.:	Remarks (Mr. Beland) in Com. of Sup., 6618 (iv).
Thompson, Dr., Dismissal from Mounted Police:	Remarks (Sir Wilfrid Laurier)
6781 (iv).
Three Rivers Harbour, Deep Water Wharf-in Com. of Sup., 2111 (ii).
Three Rivers Inland Revenue, Charges re Collector C. D. Hebert:	Ques. (Mr. Bureau) 1209 (i).
Three Rivers Public Building:	in Com. of
Sup., 1851 (i).
Tidal Service, Surveying Steamers:	in Com.
of Sup., -5100 (iii).
Tilsonburg, Lake Erie and Pacific Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com., 6217 (iv).
Timber Slides, Dues: See ' B. No. 103/
Tobacco Growing, Aid to: in Com. of Sup., 6478 (iv).
Tobacco Growers of Yuma ska, Govt. Aid to: M. for Cor. (Mr. Lemieux) 1591 (i).
Tobacco Stamps: in Com. of Sup., 5826 (iv).
Toronto Examining Warehouse: in Com. of Sup., 1963 (i).
Toronto Exhibition Grant: in Com. of Sup., 6180 (iv).
Toronto, Govt. House, Sale of to Rys.: See ' B. No. 182/
Toronto Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2115 (ii).
Toronto, Lindsay and Pembroke Ry. Co/s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5898, 6217 (iv).
Tory, Mir. H. L., Dismissal, &e.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6781 (iv).
Tourigny, Mr. Justice, Charges re-. Ques. (Mr. Boulay) 3117 (ii).
' Tower Clock, Repairs to: Remarks (Mr. M. Clark) 1575 (i).
clviii
[Stage Direction]
Tower Clock, Explanation (Mr. Monk) 1708 (i).
Tracadie Lazaretto: in Com. of Sup., 1530 (i). Traoadie Road Post Office, Charges re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 4459 (iii).
Trade Agents: See 'Can. Agencies,' ' Commercial.'
Trade and Commerc© Deptl. Report: Presented (Mr. Foster) 971 (i), 2591 (id), 6780 (av). Trade Relations between Canada, Australia and W. Indies: (Mr. Pugsley) on M. for Sup., 1971 (ii).
See ' Bnitisih West Indies,' ' West Indies.'
Trade Relations with Japan, Stmnt. by Japanese Consul at Vancouver: Ques. (Mr. Le-mieux) 559 (i).
Trade Relations: See ' Franco-Canadian.' Trent Canal Improvements: in Com. of Sup. 5799 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Newmarket: in Com. of Sup., 5792 (iv).
See ' Canals.'
Trent Canal Water Power, Claims of Prov. of Out.: Remarks (Mr. Graham) in Com. of Sup., 5794 (dr).
Truro Station: in Com. of Sup., 4231 (iii). Trust and Loan Co. of Can.: See ' B. No. 108.' Tuberculosis Association, Grant to: in Com. of Su-p., 6579 (iv).
Tuberculosis in St. Jean and Iberville, Govt. Information re-. Ques. (Mr. Demers) 3533 (id).
Twine Materials Importations, &c.: Ques. (M-r. Sinclair) 3536 (ii).
See ' Fisheries.'
Typewriter Supplies, Names of Firms, &c.: Ques. (Mir. Murphy) 1809 (i).
Tyrian ' Telegraph .Service Boat: Remarks (Mr. McKenzie) in Com. of Sup., 3302 (di). Under Secretaries of 'State, Apptant. of: Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 3059 (ii).
Ungava Annexation, Cor. re-. Remarks (Mr. Lemieux) 2060 (ii).
See ' Que. Boundaries.'
Ungava Territory, Legislation re Extension: Ques. (Mr. E. Lapointe) 577 (i).
Union Bank of Can.: See ' B. No. 57.'
Union Jack Flag, Use of: See ' B. No. 74.' Union Labour Funds: See ' B. No. 87.'
United Gold Fields of B. C., Ltd.: See ' B. No. 93.'
United Shoe Machinery Co.'s Appeal: Ques. (Mr. A. K. Maclean) 6783 i,iv).
[Stage Direction]
Investigation, Application to Min. of
Jus.: Ques. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) 3148 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
Ques. (Mr. Pardee) 572 (i).
-[DOT]

 Proceedings re: Ques. (Mr. W. F. Maclean) 2455 (ii).
Universal Eyesight In^. Co.: See ' B. No. 126.'
Val des Eboulis and Rigaud Mail Service, Contract re-. Ques. (Mr. Boyer) 4249, 4778
(iii)	.
Vale Railroad, Operation by I.C.R.: Remarks (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 5612 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 933 (ii)-
Valois, J. B., Dismissal from Vaudreuil Post Office: Ques. (Mt. Boyer) 3537 (ii). Vanantwerp, C. B., Emplymt. by Govt.: Remarks (Mr. Bodvim) in Com. of Sup., 5826
(iv)	.
Vancouver, Eraser Valley and Southern Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 135.'
Vancouver Island and Eastern Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 73.'
Vancouver Life Insurance Co.: See ' B. No. 15.' Vancouver, Westminster .and Yukon Ry. Co.'s Subsidy: in Com. on Res., 5898, 6218, 6325 (iv).
Vegetables. Weight of Bag: See ' B. No. 78.' Vegreville and Lloydimdmster Public Buildings: Remarks (Mr. W. H. White) in Com. of Sup., 2214 (di).
Veitch Farm, Purchase of by Govt.: Ques. (Mr. Oliver) 933 (a).
Veit, Frederick, Dismissal, &c.: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Lemieux) 6783 (iv).
Venoit, J., Suspension: See 'Benoit.'
Verret, Mr. H. B., Promotion: in Com. of Sup., 6278 (iv).
Veterans, Bounties to: See ' B. Nos. 137 & 190.'
Veterans of 1866-7, Bounties to: Ques. (Mr. E. M. Macdonald) 1202 (i).
See ' Bounties.'
Vickers-Maxim Co.'s Contract re Construction of Montreal Dry Dock: Ques. (Mr. Sevigny) 2450 (ii).
Victoria Memorial Museum, Number of Employees, Dismissals, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Belle-mare) 2294 (ii).
Volunteer Bounty Act Amt.: See ' B. Nos. 137 & 190.'
Volunteer Bounty Act Amt.: Remarks (Mr. Knowles) 1577 (d).
Voters Lists in Man., Distribution re: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Staples) 3056 (id).
Voters' Lists, Preparation of by Federal Govt., Stmnt. of Min. of the Iuit.: Ques. (Mr. W. M. Martin) 553 (i).
Wadge, Thomas, Patent Relief: See ' B. No. 16.'
Waiters, Holiday on Sunday: See ' B. No. 85.' Waiters in Restaurants, Minimum Wages paid in Cities: Ques. (Mr. Verville) 3049 (ii).
See ' House of Commons.'
Wallace Harbour Spur Line, I.C.R.: in Com. of Sup., 6604 (iv).

[Stage Direction]
clix
Water in By. Belt, &c.: See ' B. No. 149.'
Waterways Commission, Apptmt. of Commissioners: M. for O. C.'s, &c.: (Mr. Pugsley) 981 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Dismissal, &e., and Appointments: M.
(Mr. Pugsley) to Com. of Sup., 6680 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) 966 (i).
[Stage Direction]
Ratification of Apptmt. by late Govt.:
Ques. (Mr. Murphy) 533 (i).
See ' Boundary Waters.'
Watlia Indian Reserve, Tenders re Timber: Ques. (Mr. Henderson) 3055 (ii).
Ways and Means-Financial Statement (Mr. White) 4985 (iii)-.
[Stage Direction]
M. for Com. (Mr. White) 702 (i).
See ' Budget.'
Webber, James, Dismissal: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Sinclair) 6783 (iv).
Webster, Dr. C. A., Dismissal of: M. for Cor.* (Mr. Law) 6186 (iv).
Webster, Mr., Immigration Agent at Edmonton, Dismissal, &c.: Remarks (Mr. Oliver) in Com. of Sup., 3922 (ii).
Wednesday Sittings, Govt. Business: M. (Mr. Borden) re Precedence, 1969 (ii).
Weedon Public Building, * Construction of: Ques. (Mr. Tobin) 4550 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 M. for Cor.* (Mr. Tobin) 4781 (iii).
[Stage Direction]
 Inquiry for Ret. (Mr. Tobin) 6492 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
*- Remarks (Mr. Tobin) in Com. of Sup., 6656 (iv).
Weights and Measures: in Com. of Sup., 5828 (iv).
Welland Canal, Construction: in Com. of Sup., 6607 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Quantity of American Freight passing
through: Ques. (Mr. G. V. White) 3535 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Surveys: in Com. of Sup., 5786 (iv).
[Stage Direction]
 Water Power, Diversion, &c.:	Ques.
(Mr. G. V. White) 6747 (iv).
Wells, Edna, Relief: See ' B. No. 102.'
Western Dom. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 125.'
West. Ont. Pac. Ry. Co.: See ' B. No. 28.'
West Indies, Australia and Canada Trade Relations: Remarks (Mr. Pugsley) on M. for Sup., 1971 (ii).
West Indies and British Guiana Trade Returns: Inquiry for (Mr. Murphy) 1820 (i).
[Stage Direction]
M. for Papers* (Mr. Murphy) 977 (i).
West Indies Mail Service, Establishment by Dom.: Remarks (Mr. McCurdy) in Com. of Sup., 685 (i).
Westville Public Building, Dismissal of Caretaker: Remarks (Mr. Macdonald) in Com. of Sup., 1531 (i).
Weyburn Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 2213 (ii).
Wharfs, Total Expenditure for last ten years: Ques. (Mr. Clements) 1811 (i).
Wheat Grades: Remarks (Mr. Sohaflnsr) 663 (i).
See ' Grain Bill.'
Wheatley Creek Dredging: in Com. of Sup., 640 (i).
Wheeler, Seager : See ' Seager.'
White Head Island Lighthouse, Dismissal of Patrick Conway, Investigation: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2857 (ii).
See ' Dismissals.'
Whitehead, N.S., Dismissal of Postmaster, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Sinclair) 2855 (ii).
See ' Harris.'
White, James, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Car-vell) 3338 (ii).
Wiley, Mrs., Claims re Yukon Property: in Com. of Sup., 6489 (iv).
Williams, Mr., Dismissal from H. of C.: Remarks (Mr. Sinclair) in Com. of Sup., 3279
(ii)	.
Williamsville Post Office, Removal: Personal Explanation (Mr. Edwards) 6271 (iv).
Wills, Henry Greek, Relief of: See ' B. No. 173.'
Windsor, Chatham and London Ry. Co.: See [DOT] B. No. 94.'
Winnipeg Ordnance Lands, Sale of: See 'B. No. 185.'
Winnipeg and St. Boniface Harbour Commission : See ' B. No. 138.'
Wireless Stations: in .Com. of Sup., 5399 (iii). Wolfville Public Building: in Com. of Sup., 1343 (i).
Wood Mountain Tel. Line: in Com. of Sup., 2821 (ii).
Woodstock, N.B., Apptmt. as Excise Officer: Remarks (Mr. Carvell) in Com. of Sup., 5812 (iv).
Wrecks Investigations: in Com. of Sup., 5229
(iii)	.
Wrecks Subsidies, &c.: in Com. of Sup., 5231
(iii).
Wright County Public Works Employees, Dis-* missal of: Ques. (Mr. Devlin) 550 (i).
See ' Dismissals.'
Yamaska Electoral Agent: Ques. (Mr. Mon-dou) 1584 (i).
Yarmouth Harbour Improvements: in Com. of Sup., 2056 (ii).
[Stage Direction]
 Remarks (Mr. Jameson) in Com. of
Sup., 3273 (ii).
Yarmouth Post Office Building: Remarks (Mr. Law) in Com. of Sup., 3269 (ii).
Year Book: in Com. of Sup., 6465 (iv).
York Bridge over Grand River, Ont.: in Com. of Sup., 2817 (ii).
Yukon Act (Judges) Amt.: See ' B. No. 123.' Yukon Placer Mining Act Amt.: See ' B. No. 181.'
Yukon Telegraph System: in Com. of Sup., 3303 (ii).
Yule,, Mr., Customs Officer at Aurora, Dismissal, &c.: Ques. (Mr. Lemieux) 4779 (iii), 5950 (iv).
(