azza1625/createdebate-arguments huggingface dataset:
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

I don't think he is the typical fraud. I think he has had a really convincing hallucination. I ask you this, why would your wonderful God show this guy a vision and not show anyone else causing him to destroy his career?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I don't think he is the typical fraud. I think he has had a really convincing hallucination.He is a nuerologist with years of experience. If the explanation is that simple, then he wouldn't convert.I ask you this, why would your wonderful God show this guy a vision and not show anyone else causing him to destroy his career?Theres plenty of people who lost even their life in the name of God. What makes him any different?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

He is a nuerologist with years of experience. If the explanation is that simple, then he wouldn't convert.He had a near death situation, I think you over estimate his resolve. His brain has implanted a false memory so powerful that he can't think it could be something else. Well, the brain controls his thoughts, so yeah, that will happen.Theres plenty of people who lost even their life in the name of God. What makes him any different?Thank you. Do you realize you just lost? You just pointed out that his claims are just as fake as everyone else.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I will reply later. I have work for now
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

He had a near death situation, I think you over estimate his resolve. His brain has implanted a false memory so powerful that he can't think it could be something else. Well, the brain controls his thoughts, so yeah, that will happen.It doesnt make any difference you are still insisting that he is lying. And under that logic, I ask you what purpose does he need to lie to the world and ruin his name in the process?Do you realize you just lost? You just pointed out that his claims are just as fake as everyone else.sighIt appears like you misunderstood your own words. You said "why would your wonderful God show this guy a vision and not show anyone else causing him to destroy his career?"Which means that you are asking for a reason why no one else was granted such an experience. From which I replied that it is a normal feat if you were chosen.And then suddenly, you are claiming that he is a fakesighPlease keep this debate civil by keeping track of what you post
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

It doesnt make any difference you are still insisting that he is lying. And under that logic, I ask you what purpose does he need to lie to the world and ruin his name in the process?Didn't he sell a book? I am saying that is lying, but he doesn't realize he is lying. To him it is the truth.It appears like you misunderstood your own words. You said "why would your wonderful God show this guy a vision and not show anyone else causing him to destroy his career?"Which means that you are asking for a reason why no one else was granted such an experience. From which I replied that it is a normal feat if you were chosen.And then suddenly, you are claiming that he is a fakeThere was nothing sudden about it, I have been saying he is fake the whole time. You were saying that his fake visions aren't any more special than anyone else. You also said his fake visions were special and proof of God, so what is it? Are his visions special or are they the same as everyone else's?Please keep this debate civil by keeping track of what you postI am being civil, you lost, I wasn't trying to rub it in or anything, it is just that I won, no big deal, you lost.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Didn't he sell a book? I am saying that is lying, but he doesn't realize he is lying. To him it is the truth.There was nothing sudden about it, I have been saying he is fake the whole time. You were saying that his fake visions aren't any more special than anyone else. You also said his fake visions were special and proof of God, so what is it? Are his visions special or are they the same as everyone else's?Ahhh...I can get the point now. You are saying that he went into a delusion right before his full recovery, right?Well, it was also discussed on his critics page that I linked to you. to deny the possibility of any natural explanation for an NDE, as Dr. Alexander does, is more than unscientific — it is antiscientific."..."The one most plausible hypothesis in Dr. Alexander's case...is that his NDE occurred not during his coma, but as he was surfacing from the coma and his cortex was returning to full function. It is curious that he does not allow this obvious and natural explanation, but instead insists on a supernatural one."From which Alexander replied: ""My synapses—the spaces between the neurons of the brain that support the electrochemical activity that makes the brain function — were not simply compromised during my experience. They were stopped. Only isolated pockets of deep cortical neurons were still sputtering, but no broad networks capable of generating anything like what we call 'consciousness.' The E. coli bacteria that flooded my brain during my illness made sure of that. My doctors have told me that according to all the brain tests they were doing, there was no way that any of the functions including vision, hearing, emotion, memory, language, or logic could possibly have been intact.""After that, the doctors no longer repliedYou can read more of the discussion on his wiki if you want.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Alexander is lying for real then.Unless he is claiming that his brain does not currently functioning. Otherwise his explanation is completely bogus because he has no way of knowing when his "memory" occurred. there was no way that any of the functions including vision, hearing, emotion, memory, language, or logic could possibly have been intact.If he can see, hear, remember, speak, and use logic right now, then his explanation is completely worthless. Because obviously, his brain could make it all up now, right?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Alexander is lying for real then.Unless he is claiming that his brain does not currently functioning. Otherwise his explanation is completely bogus because he has no way of knowing when his "memory" occurred.If he can see, hear, remember, speak, and use logic right now, then his explanation is completely worthless. Because obviously, his brain could make it all up now, right?Say, did you read his wiki page yet?This question was raised right after he woke up. He hired his friends to reach an explanation but in the end, he and his team reached the same conclusion-his vision did not came from his brain.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

This question was raised right after he woke up. He hired his friends to reach an explanation but in the end, he and his team reached the same conclusion-his vision did not came from his brain.His friends are dumb, I wonder how many malpractice lawsuits they have against them.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Denials can only take you so far
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Not true, it has taken you this far. It looks like denials have worked out great for you.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Trying to hang a bait for a flame war?Sorry, but I am not interested in it
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

No, I am not trying to start a flame war. You want to deny the explanations of the universe. Therefore, you are in denial.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Our topic is about Eben Alexander. If you have nothing else to add to the argument, then I shall take my leave.If you will excuse me, that is
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Eben Alexander, says that his brain didn't work at time A. He then says he has memories at time B which is after his brain started working again. He is in denial when he says that the only possible time that his memories could be from is time A.Is he claiming that he was telling people about his memories when his brain was still not functioning?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

We already tackled this topic and you should know what I will reply next. Sorry, but I have no intention of repeating the argument
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Yeah, I know. You will say read his wiki page because you don't actually have any knowledge that you claim to have. You know that his brain was perfectly functional when he told all of his stories. Therefore, his explanation is worthless because he doesn't know when the "memories" actually occurred.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Indeed. The fool will always refuse the book.So if you will excuse me, I would like to leave now.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Ok, fine. Thank you for admitting that his brain works just fine and he could have easily made up whatever he is saying.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

So...did you read the discussion yet or you are gonna give me another excuse?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

I read it, but when there are unsubstantiated claims I kind of tune out. He is rather boring. I just want to know one thing. The very first time he told his "memories" was his brain fully functioning? I can't tell. I may have missed it. Since you have read it can you point to where it talks about his initial recovery?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Only the naive will doubt.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

That's a 45 minute video with a boring ass loser and a 30 second musical intro. Where is what I asked you?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Just watch it. Its the information that you seek, right?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

It is 45 minutes of him droning on and on. You have 5 minutes to convince me. You failed.He says that when his brain was not working that he could not speak. This means that any time he talked about his "memories" his brain was fully functional. This means that he cannot be sure that his "memories" are actually from the time of the coma. Since he cannot verify that, his claim that the part of the brain that would be responsible for making it up was not working is unsubstantiated. Which 1 minute of the video does he show otherwise?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Seems like you fear to learn. Pity
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

I watched.He says that when his brain was not working that he could not speak. This means that any time he talked about his "memories" his brain was fully functional. This means that he cannot be sure that his "memories" are actually from the time of the coma. Since he cannot verify that, his claim that the part of the brain that would be responsible for making it up was not working is unsubstantiated. Which 1 minute of the video does he show otherwise?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

I can't believe she's still bringing that guy into arguments. I gave her some pretty convincing evidence a while ago, that he was full of shit, including his reputation for lying and the lawsuits against him.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

WHAT!?!?!?! He is full of crap? Why doesn't anybody tell me this stuff? I seriously didn't know he was a liar. I just thought that his explanation had holes on my own.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

He hadn't been working for a year before the incident and he had multiple malpractice lawsuits. My theory is that he wasn't in the best situation financially and decided that a former athiest neurosurgeon turned Christian after a near death experience, would land him some well-paying interviews and a best-selling book.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

NO! I have heard that some believers in God can't think of any possible motivation for him to do what he is doing, so you must be wrong.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

That's because they find it way too difficult to believe that he is still an atheist, after he has made such a name for himself in the Christian community.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

LIAR! He is not an Atheist, he saw heaven, he can't be an Atheist.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

SighYou need to do your research... YOU IGNORANT MOTHERFUCKER! HOW DARE YOU QUESTION ME!Lol I have a feeling that's what Centifolia's really thinking whenever she says "sigh".
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

It seems like something like that, hehe. :)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

They must think he is the only person to go through an ordeal such as his. Why would God reward an atheist in the way that he did? Isn't that against one of God's rules?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Good questions. Does he still claim to be an Atheist? Or was that just before?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

He claims to be a Christian now... but he also claimed to be a Christian before, but apparently that was only by "name" and he didn't really believe in God. So he basically admitted that he used to be a liar.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Well, I believe that his memories are real to him, but that he is still wrong. Maybe it will come out some day like all of these cheating athletes.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I think his "memories" are made up. He's made millions off his story. Where'd that money go? I'm pretty sure it went in his pocket.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Dang man, you are mean, kind of like a good detective. :)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

We had that argument already but you stopped replying. I feel cheated that you wont continue the discussion for me.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I lost it. If you want to continue and know where to find it, then leave a comment on it and I'll continue the argument.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Nah, lets just meet again someday
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Actually, he never said anything about his brain functions. But thankyou for proving that you never watched the video.With such refusal to learn, I cant help but feel sorry for your parents(His coma experience starts at 12:00 by the way)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Actually, he never said anything about his brain functions.A) I asked you to show that his brain was not functioning properly when he first told his "memories" to people to show that his version of the truth is correct. Now you claim that the video evidence you provided doesn't even have the evidence you are providing, good job.B) Yes, he talks right away about how his brain functions were attacked and he was not able to speak. So, you didn't watch the video.But thankyou for proving that you never watched the video.It is not a video really. It was a really boring guy with a monotone talking about what he thinks his experience was.With such refusal to learn, I cant help but feel sorry for your parentsI have read your "research" articles. I watched your video "evidence". There is nothing to learn. You have nothing. And, after talking with you it is clear that you believe that because you subscribe to M Theory and admit that your God has nothing to do with it.(His coma experience starts at 12:00 by the way)It takes him 12 minutes to talk about the only thing worth hearing from him. Good choice in evidence.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

A) I asked you to show that his brain was not functioning properly when he first told his "memories" to people to show that his version of the truth is correct. Now you claim that the video evidence you provided doesn't even have the evidence you are providing, good job.B) Yes, he talks right away about how his brain functions were attacked and he was not able to speak. So, you didn't watch the video.sigh At the very beginning of the video, he made it clear that his cortex stopped working. Please stop wasting my time
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

At the very beginning of the video, he made it clear that his cortex stopped working. Please stop wasting my timeYou are the one who is attacking your own video evidence and being wrong about it. You are wasting my time. You are the one who said that in the video he never mentioned anything about his cortex not working. I am trying to explain something to you. It is almost like you don't want to learn or something.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

0:22 Topic was: Current State of your Cortex(Then he started explaining it.)Your shameless ways of pretend is painful to watch. Please stop.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

YOU ARE THE ONE WHO SAID IT WAS NOT IN THE VIDEO. I said it was. Now you are saying that I was correct when I said that in the video he talked about his brain functionality, WHICH MEANS YOU ARE SAYING I WATCHED THE VIDEO.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Hmm...Im pretty sure it would be better if you just see it for yourself than await my explanation.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

The video does not explain how you can think that he does and does not talk about his brain problems. So, watching the video is not as useful as waiting for you explanation.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

sighDont give me excuses, your ignorance is your own choice. If you cant face the facts, then dont disturb those who can. Please?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Fact 1:You said the video does not have any part where he talks about his brain not working.Fact 2:You said that the video talks about how his brain doesn't work. There is no ignorance on my part. You said 2 completely opposite things. That means that the ignorance is on your part.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Thanks, I figured out this misunderstanding while on coffee break.Anyway, I take back my words. Eben did said something about his brain. But according to what he said at 12:00, he mentioned nothing about his state while on recovery. That is all. Now, will you mind watching it?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I did. He said that when he was sick his brain was so damaged that he could not speak. This means that when he was recovering and telling people about his memories, his brain obviously was working because he was able to speak. I didn't see anything else special about his lecture.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

exasperated sigh15:00 After giving explanation of the damages in his brain then waking up, he made a time skip of four months. He mentioned nothing about his recovery state. Quit pretending already.You dont want to be called "Ferrous Cranus" now do you?Now that you know your warrior type, can you leave me alone now?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Please explain how if he says that the proof that his brain doesn't work is that he can't speak, then he is able to speak about his "memory", that his brain had not recovered. Please explain how you think that the person in the video had a brain that wasn't functioning.Stop projecting on me. I gave you a perfectly good explanation for my thought process. You only give your worthless opinion that is not backed up by anything.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Watch it, then leave me alone
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I am trying to explain to you that watching the video doesn't give me the answers to my questions other than to support my position, so I will allow you to concede and leave you alone.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

sighFinally, thankyou
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

You're welcome.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Hehe. You have posted that the wise have doubts and that the naive have doubts. What's next?
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Its a proverb. Its meaning depends of the situation.:)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Right. When you have the doubts, the proverb applies. When someone else has the doubts it doesn't.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Proverbs never takes a side, rather, they come in contradicting pairs. Its your loss that you cannot use one.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

I didn't say proverbs takes a side, I said you use proverbs incorrectly. You are the one using them badly, not me. You have said the exact opposite thing that you have said before. It is fun for me knowing that my opponent is a complete liar. :)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Whatever then.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Liar and quitter. :)
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

sigh Whatever makes you happy, I guess
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Thanks, I am glad you want others to be happy.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

There is no chance that Science will be able to prove God but neighter will they be able to disprove him either.The same goes for religion.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Exactly why I choose the side "True" for the question. -_-
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

But you've made it pretty clear that you believe in God. If you actually agree that there are equal chances of each theory being true... then you are not a Theist, but rather an Agnostic.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

I believe in a God, yes. But I am not biased towards the chances of being wrong.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

Both sides have positive thoughts. Both sides can be listened to with tolerance.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: False

Seeing as there are many many Theism ideas it would appear that Theism is less likely because no one can seem to get it right.
Debate: Atheism and Theism have equal chances of being true
Side: True

1. There are also many atheism ideas.2. You say no one can get it right, that would be false - because with that statement you are basically implying you know what is right, and you are someone - then someone got it right.