azza1625/createdebate-arguments huggingface dataset:
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

The Jews should get the western half because they have settlements there.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I believe that some of the land belongs to Palestine because the Palestinians have always lived on the land and never left in large amounts. They have stayed there. While the Jews left and when they returned, made the Palestinians, who've been staying there, leave their homes.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

The Palestinians never left the country unlike the Jews did so they should get some of the land.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

The jews fully developed the land. Not the Arabs. So even if the jews left, they should still get it back. They were forced to leave.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Although they fully developed it, they did leave it. Unattended. It's common sense to not leave something that you spent a lot of effort just in the dust, so the Muslims got to take what they started and carry it forwards.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Israel should get the Gaza strip and most of the west bank because those are their main spots and then they would share Jursilm with everybody.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I disagree with that because it is the Palestine who occupy more of that land, even though its controlled by Israel
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree with the fact that many of the Jewish Holy Sites are located in the area of the West Bank. I also believe that the city of Jerusalem should be recognized as a Holy Place for those that practice Judaism and Christianity. What do the Muslims find to be sacred about Jerusalem?
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I also think that the Palestinians should get some of the land, more specifically, the southern part of the land. I gave the Palestinians this land because it includes the Gaza Strip, and the Muslims already occupy this area. I also gave them more land than the Israelis because a lot of their land is desert, and can't be used for agricultural purposes. Also, because the Palestinians never left, so it only seems fair for the Palestinians to get to keep more of the land that they developed and settled in then the Israelis who just came back to the country that they barely, if they did anything, helped develop.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I believe taking geography/ physical features of the land into consideration is absolutely necessary. In order to be "fair" each group should be given arable land as well as water access.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree with this statement. The fairest way to divide the land would be splitting it down the middle vertically so each group gets both arable land and water access.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I think that whatever country is on the bottom should get a little bit more land because it is mainly mountains.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I also agree, because if your country is in the middle of a desert, you might not do so well.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Also, although parts of Israel are populated with mostly Palestinians, the Jews are starting to take over, not letting them have their own laws and government. It is unfair for the Palestinians to be kicked out of the land that they had lived in while the Jews left. Israel was given to the Jews, so, therefore, they should get some of the land, but they should also let the Palestinians, who lived there the whole time, have some land for themselves to control.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree with this because it has never been the Israeli's land to take. They have fought their way into the country, but that doesn't mean that the Arabs should be kicked out. Both of the countries deserve land to occupy
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree because the Palestinians have stayed there the whole time and deserve some of the land to control.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Yes, both sides have reason to believe that the land should be theirs, but while the Jews left, the Palestinians stayed and started a successful country and way of life. Because of this, the Palestinians should get to pick which half of the land they want, while the Jews will get the other half of the land. So both sides get the land they deserve, and the people who stayed, get the land that they want.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I think that the should get a little bit of the land because they have been there longer and there are some religious places in Israel that are important to their religion.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Although Palestine is a holy place for Jews, it is a holy place for Muslims as well. throughout the history, this land has been very important to the Muslim faith as well.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree that some places in Israel are holy places and important to the Muslims, but almost all of their holy places are in northern Israel, and those are almost always used for Jewish purposes. That is why I made the southern West Bank neutral so that both groups could access holy places that are for multiple religion, Jewish and Muslim. It is also important to give each side easy access to the neutral section so that they don't have to go through each other's countries to enter it.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

The Jews could have fled to somewhere else, and the British could have given them a different part of land than the Palestinians.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Palestine has had basically all of their land taken from them by the Israeli who just barged in and used the land the UN gave them to make an empire. Maybe if the UN gave THEM some land, they might be able to take the land away from the Israeli though I doubt that will happen.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Palestine's never left and the Israelis left now came back and are trying to kick them out
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Since the Ottoman empire was mostly Muslim, and they ruled the area for so long, with success, it might be a good idea to have the Muslims rule the area again.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Palestine should be able to claim and keep what is rightfully theirs!!! The Jews didn't have to leave...they chose to flee eventually to Europe.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

That's true that they didn't have to leave, however, when they came back the UN granted them some of the Palestine's land. The Israelis have a right to some of the land because of this.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

The palisteins might want different rules the Israelites, based on their religion, so it might be good for them to have a lot of the land, and have their own rules
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I think that Palestine deserves better treatment. Imagine being all happy in a house that you just got when all of a sudden the previous owners came and took back the house and let you have the yard. Then, they took away all of that land until you were living in a small shed in the back of the yard while the previous owners are living the good life in what is supposed to be YOUR HOUSE!
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

(Both sides should have some) Palestinian communities are split apart nad their connection to the land had weakened, while Jewish communities put down roots in territory meant for the Palestinians
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I believe the land of Jerusalem should be neutral between the two groups. This is because Jerusalem is a holy place for both Muslims and Jews so it should be shared. If the land isn't shared then war will occur about who should get the holy place. War won't solve this conflict only make it worse.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree with this because Jerusalem is a holy place for both.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

It is time for both sides to come to a peaceful agreement. Will it be the UN that facilitates this or are the 2 groups able to figure it out????
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

The Jewish people left Israel and came back forcefully. They made Palestinians leave their homes and flee to refugee camps in neighboring countries.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Israeli forces defeated the Palestinian militias (a military that is raised from the civil population to help a regular army in an emergency) and Arab armies in a conflict that turned 700,000 Palestinian civilians into refugees. All this just because the Palestinians were developing a country that the Jews had left, and then wanted back, after the Palestinians had already started to successfully make their way.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Yes, the both of these peoples have been refugees at one time, and I feel like that kind of evens everything out.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

This shows that the Jews shouldn't deserve the land that God gave to them because they were being very aggressive and mean to many of the people who lived there, they can't deserve something like that since they hurt many.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I think that the Palestinians deserve their fair share of the land. When the land was granted to the Jews, no one asked the opinion of the owner of the land. This would be like someone taking something from you without your consent. The Arabs have been there the whole time, and why should the Jewish deserve to be on that land if they are just going to disturb how things were running. When the Jewish decided to dispute everything that the Arabs did to the land, it gave the Jewish the idea that they could do whatever they wanted to. The Jewish didn't come to the land until WW2 and the Holocaust because they weren't safe in their land anymore. The Jewish people made the Arab's unsafe in their land, basically doing what happened to the Jews. The Arabs deserve a good chunk of the land.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Palestine is the name of the large area of land within which Israel exists. Even ancient Israel does not extend to all of Palestine. But the debate premise contains a serious error: there are Muslims and Jews and Atheists and Christians who live in Israel, just as there are Christians, Jews, atheists and Muslims in the West Bank & Gaza. The West Bank and Gaza are not an Arab group of lands per se, and Israel is not a Jewish land per se. They are both Palestinian, and both Semitic lands. Arabs are Semites. Assyrians are Semites. Israelis are Semites. Tigrans are Semites. M Akkadians, Phonecians, Syrians, all Semites. And crucially, with the exception of Southern Arabia, they are all Palestinians by right.Saying that Palestine belongs to the Jews is a little like saying America belongs to Christians. Saying Palestine doesn't belong to Palestinians is a little like saying that America doesn't belong to Americans.The point is, Palestine, historically speaking, is the huge area covering modern Palestine, modern Israel, Western Jordan, Northern Arabia, North Eastern Egypt, the Lebanon, South Western Turkey, Cyprus, Syria and Western Iraq.Israelis are -- by the geography of where Israel is situated -- Palestinians.I know that you are referring to the modern partition when you use the terms Israel and Palestine, but really, in terms of heritage and geography, the partition is superficial. If what you are asking is should Israel be given to the Arabs in the West Bank and Gaza, I think the answer is no.That said, the state of Israel needs to stop invading and taking land that was not agreed as part of the state of Israel. It is internationally illegal, and a small majority of Israelis disagree with it.As for anybody who cites historical religious claim as a justification for the illegal occupation of lands, then consider that by the same logic: America ought also to belong to the Natives. Bye bye American citizens. Move out tomorrow.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I think that Israel and Palestine should make a two-state agreement. Both sides would have exactly 8,323.2671 miles of land including Jerusalem. Jerusalem would be neutral ground for both countries because there are multiple religions that consider it Holy and theirs. Israel would get the lower half, and Palestine would get the upper half. There would be one currency and one government so that there would be fewer arguments and less terrorism. I think that this would work because each side gets an equal amount of land and power over the country.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree they would also have one big government for the whole country and then a smaller government for each state
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree with this, they should have one big government for the whole country and a smaller government for each state, and have Jerusalem as a neutral area, just like Washington D.C. in the U.S.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I think their big government could be a parliamentary democracy.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I think that the two countries should be one, with two states inside of it. They could have Jerusalem as their shared capital, and have capitals of their own. This way, they could have two different governments in each state, and different laws in each, similar to the U.S. They could both have the same currency and regulations, so it would be easier to go to one place to another. They could also have one big governing body that controls the entire country.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree, however, I would like to make a few changes. Both Israelis and Palestinians have done good to the land, and in order to separate it so both religions have the same equal chances, we might want to think about the shape of the land. It should be separated so the Palestinians and Israelis both have equal amounts of land near the water (which could be used for agriculture) and dry land. I believe the lower half has many mountains, so Israel, being the first people to develop and defend the land would get the short end of the stick.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree that it would be a good idea to have a two-state solution, where both sides have equal land. Having the same currency, and Jerusalem as shared territory would be beneficial for uniting the two together to show that they have equal power. The only thing is, humans can be selfish, and as the Jews claim that the land was given to them by God, and the Palestinians also deserve the land because it was always theirs, the two might continue to fight as they think that they should both deserve the whole country. Other than that, though, I think that it is a plan that will prove successful.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

One government and currency wouldn't really make sense for the religions that are extremely different.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

That is a good idea, but Palestine would be back in another few years demanding more land and claiming it was theirs.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I mostly agree with this statement, but I don't think using one currency and one government would be a good idea, mostly one government. If you are going to split the two groups into different areas, they are in their own state. They should be able to create whatever type of government they want, and it wouldn't make sense for two different states to have one ruler if they are different areas.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

The Jews have been through terrible hardships, the holocaust, and deserve the land because of all they've been through.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I agree with this statement also the Jews have real evidence on why and how they own the land in Israel. The Palestinians don't have any evidence that is legit like the Jews do.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I don't believe that the Jews should get the land just because they are pitied. They should rightfully deserve to live Palestine.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree that the Jews have been through a lot, but the Palestinians also developed basically all of the land. I don't think it's fair for Israelis to get to leave, and then come back to a country that they didn't develop, and take over all of the land. That's like in school if you barely started a project, and then the other group member did basically all of the work, and you take full credit for having done most of it.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree that the Jews were wrongly mistreated during the Holocaust and that this forced them to flee their country to safety. The United Nations then gave the land to the Jews as a place that they could go and be safe, but was it ever the UN's land to give away? This was supposed to bring about peace, but the Palestinians had been living on the land for the entire time that the Jews had left. By giving the Jews land, that did not belong to the UN, was unfair for the Palestinians, which is why they should get to keep some of the land and get first pick for what they should want.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

The Israelis should not get the land just because they have been through hardships. They should deserve the land like the Palestinians do. They stayed in the land of Israel and developed it, only to be kicked out by the Jews because they are pitied? While yes, the Jews have been through a lot and deserve a place to live but so do the Palestinians. The land should be split in half so that both sides can make a country that they want. They should be able to make their own laws without being forced to by the other side.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

Out of all the things that the Jewish people have been through, such as the holocaust, I believe that they should get the land. I also believe they should get the land because they were there first.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I think that Isreal and Palestine should have a 2 state but Israel should get more of the land because of how they never left the land unlike Palestine but I believe that Palestine should also get the land because they lived there with holy places so they should at least get a small part.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I agree that they should have a two state solution but I disagree that Isreal should have more land, I think that they should each have about the same amount.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

the jews were the ones that left Israel, the Palestinians were there the whole time
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

It's not like the Jews wanted to leave Israel. They were forced to leave, otherwise there would be even less of them now then there are.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

The Jewish people were the ones who settled there first and developed the land. As far back, the Jewish people occupied the land.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I disagree with this because it was the Palestinians that were there first. During the Holocaust and WW2, the Jewish fled looking for a new country to establish themselves in.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

Yeah, the Jewish people wanted somewhere that they could have refuge in.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

While yes, the Jews were there first, the Palestinians took the land after they left. If the Jewish people left Israel, how is it fair for them to come back, claiming everything that WAS theirs but is now being occupied by a new group of people who deserve the land as much as the Jews do. The Palestinians have their own way of living and want their own land, just like the Jews do. They may be considered Arabs, but they still deserve their own land to occupy without being pushed out.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I have a question for you, how/ when were they forced to leave?
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

During world war 2 the germans were going to take them so they had to leave.
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

My question is when did the Jews be forced to leave Israel? And by whom?
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

I'm also wondering that, why did they leave? Can somebody please answer that?
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Palestine

during world war 2 the germans forced they out. (holocaust)
Debate: Palestinian (Arab/Muslim) & Israeli (Jewish) Conflict
Side: Land Belongs To Israel

I think that the Jews and the Muslims can work this one out, by each of the sides getting some of the land, but I think that the Jews should get more land because they don't have any other land, and they were promised it by the U.N.