aveni-ai/aveni-bench-convfinqa huggingface dataset:
devon energy corporation and subsidiaries notes to consolidated financial statements 2013 ( continued ) asset divestitures in conjunction with the asset divestitures in 2013 and 2014 , devon removed $ 26 million and $ 706 million of goodwill , respectively , which were allocated to these assets . impairment devon 2019s canadian goodwill was originally recognized in 2001 as a result of a business combination consisting almost entirely of conventional gas assets that devon no longer owns . as a result of performing the goodwill impairment test described in note 1 , devon concluded the implied fair value of its canadian goodwill was zero as of december 31 , 2014 . this conclusion was largely based on the significant decline in benchmark oil prices , particularly after opec 2019s decision not to reduce its production targets that was announced in late november 2014 . consequently , in the fourth quarter of 2014 , devon wrote off its remaining canadian goodwill and recognized a $ 1.9 billion impairment . other intangible assets as of december 31 , 2014 , intangible assets associated with customer relationships had a gross carrying amount of $ 569 million and $ 36 million of accumulated amortization . the weighted-average amortization period for the customer relationships is 13.7 years . amortization expense for intangibles was approximately $ 36 million for the year ended december 31 , 2014 . other intangible assets are reported in other long-term assets in the accompanying consolidated balance sheets . the following table summarizes the estimated aggregate amortization expense for the next five years . year amortization amount ( in millions ) .

1	year	amortization amount ( in millions )
2	2015	$ 45
3	2016	$ 45
4	2017	$ 45
5	2018	$ 45
6	2019	$ 44

.

Previous questions in this conversation: what is 45 times 4?
Previous answers: 180.0
Question: what is that plus the amortization cost in 2019?
Answer: 224
devon energy corporation and subsidiaries notes to consolidated financial statements 2013 ( continued ) asset divestitures in conjunction with the asset divestitures in 2013 and 2014 , devon removed $ 26 million and $ 706 million of goodwill , respectively , which were allocated to these assets . impairment devon 2019s canadian goodwill was originally recognized in 2001 as a result of a business combination consisting almost entirely of conventional gas assets that devon no longer owns . as a result of performing the goodwill impairment test described in note 1 , devon concluded the implied fair value of its canadian goodwill was zero as of december 31 , 2014 . this conclusion was largely based on the significant decline in benchmark oil prices , particularly after opec 2019s decision not to reduce its production targets that was announced in late november 2014 . consequently , in the fourth quarter of 2014 , devon wrote off its remaining canadian goodwill and recognized a $ 1.9 billion impairment . other intangible assets as of december 31 , 2014 , intangible assets associated with customer relationships had a gross carrying amount of $ 569 million and $ 36 million of accumulated amortization . the weighted-average amortization period for the customer relationships is 13.7 years . amortization expense for intangibles was approximately $ 36 million for the year ended december 31 , 2014 . other intangible assets are reported in other long-term assets in the accompanying consolidated balance sheets . the following table summarizes the estimated aggregate amortization expense for the next five years . year amortization amount ( in millions ) .

1	year	amortization amount ( in millions )
2	2015	$ 45
3	2016	$ 45
4	2017	$ 45
5	2018	$ 45
6	2019	$ 44

.

Previous questions in this conversation: what is 45 times 4? what is that plus the amortization cost in 2019?
Previous answers: 180.0 224.0
Question: what is the total cost divided by 5?
Answer: 44.8
the following performance graph shows the cumulative total return to a holder of the company 2019s common stock , assuming dividend reinvestment , compared with the cumulative total return , assuming dividend reinvestment , of the standard & poor ( "s&p" ) 500 index and the dow jones us financials index during the period from december 31 , 2009 through december 31 , 2014. .

1	12/09	12/10	12/11	12/12	12/13	12/14
2	e*trade financial corporation	100.00	90.91	45.23	50.85	111.59	137.81
3	s&p 500 index	100.00	115.06	117.49	136.30	180.44	205.14
4	dow jones us financials index	100.00	112.72	98.24	124.62	167.26	191.67

table of contents .

Question: what was the value of e*trade financial on 12/14?
Answer: 137.81
the following performance graph shows the cumulative total return to a holder of the company 2019s common stock , assuming dividend reinvestment , compared with the cumulative total return , assuming dividend reinvestment , of the standard & poor ( "s&p" ) 500 index and the dow jones us financials index during the period from december 31 , 2009 through december 31 , 2014. .

1	12/09	12/10	12/11	12/12	12/13	12/14
2	e*trade financial corporation	100.00	90.91	45.23	50.85	111.59	137.81
3	s&p 500 index	100.00	115.06	117.49	136.30	180.44	205.14
4	dow jones us financials index	100.00	112.72	98.24	124.62	167.26	191.67

table of contents .

Previous questions in this conversation: what was the value of e*trade financial on 12/14?
Previous answers: 137.81
Question: what is that less an initial $100 investment?
Answer: 37.81
the following performance graph shows the cumulative total return to a holder of the company 2019s common stock , assuming dividend reinvestment , compared with the cumulative total return , assuming dividend reinvestment , of the standard & poor ( "s&p" ) 500 index and the dow jones us financials index during the period from december 31 , 2009 through december 31 , 2014. .

1	12/09	12/10	12/11	12/12	12/13	12/14
2	e*trade financial corporation	100.00	90.91	45.23	50.85	111.59	137.81
3	s&p 500 index	100.00	115.06	117.49	136.30	180.44	205.14
4	dow jones us financials index	100.00	112.72	98.24	124.62	167.26	191.67

table of contents .

Previous questions in this conversation: what was the value of e*trade financial on 12/14? what is that less an initial $100 investment?
Previous answers: 137.81 37.81
Question: what is the percent change?
Answer: 0.3781
part ii item 5 . market for registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following table presents reported quarterly high and low per share sale prices of our common stock on the new york stock exchange ( 201cnyse 201d ) for the years 2010 and 2009. .

1	2010	high	low
2	quarter ended march 31	$ 44.61	$ 40.10
3	quarter ended june 30	45.33	38.86
4	quarter ended september 30	52.11	43.70
5	quarter ended december 31	53.14	49.61
6	2009	high	low
7	quarter ended march 31	$ 32.53	$ 25.45
8	quarter ended june 30	34.52	27.93
9	quarter ended september 30	37.71	29.89
10	quarter ended december 31	43.84	35.03

on february 11 , 2011 , the closing price of our common stock was $ 56.73 per share as reported on the nyse . as of february 11 , 2011 , we had 397612895 outstanding shares of common stock and 463 registered holders . dividends we have not historically paid a dividend on our common stock . payment of dividends in the future , when , as and if authorized by our board of directors , would depend upon many factors , including our earnings and financial condition , restrictions under applicable law and our current and future loan agreements , our debt service requirements , our capital expenditure requirements and other factors that our board of directors may deem relevant from time to time , including the potential determination to elect reit status . in addition , the loan agreement for our revolving credit facility and term loan contain covenants that generally restrict our ability to pay dividends unless certain financial covenants are satisfied . for more information about the restrictions under the loan agreement for the revolving credit facility and term loan , our notes indentures and the loan agreement related to our securitization , see item 7 of this annual report under the caption 201cmanagement 2019s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations 2014liquidity and capital resources 2014factors affecting sources of liquidity 201d and note 6 to our consolidated financial statements included in this annual report. .

Question: what was the closing price of common stock as of 2/11/11?
Answer: 56.73
part ii item 5 . market for registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following table presents reported quarterly high and low per share sale prices of our common stock on the new york stock exchange ( 201cnyse 201d ) for the years 2010 and 2009. .

1	2010	high	low
2	quarter ended march 31	$ 44.61	$ 40.10
3	quarter ended june 30	45.33	38.86
4	quarter ended september 30	52.11	43.70
5	quarter ended december 31	53.14	49.61
6	2009	high	low
7	quarter ended march 31	$ 32.53	$ 25.45
8	quarter ended june 30	34.52	27.93
9	quarter ended september 30	37.71	29.89
10	quarter ended december 31	43.84	35.03

on february 11 , 2011 , the closing price of our common stock was $ 56.73 per share as reported on the nyse . as of february 11 , 2011 , we had 397612895 outstanding shares of common stock and 463 registered holders . dividends we have not historically paid a dividend on our common stock . payment of dividends in the future , when , as and if authorized by our board of directors , would depend upon many factors , including our earnings and financial condition , restrictions under applicable law and our current and future loan agreements , our debt service requirements , our capital expenditure requirements and other factors that our board of directors may deem relevant from time to time , including the potential determination to elect reit status . in addition , the loan agreement for our revolving credit facility and term loan contain covenants that generally restrict our ability to pay dividends unless certain financial covenants are satisfied . for more information about the restrictions under the loan agreement for the revolving credit facility and term loan , our notes indentures and the loan agreement related to our securitization , see item 7 of this annual report under the caption 201cmanagement 2019s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations 2014liquidity and capital resources 2014factors affecting sources of liquidity 201d and note 6 to our consolidated financial statements included in this annual report. .

Previous questions in this conversation: what was the closing price of common stock as of 2/11/11?
Previous answers: 56.73
Question: and the high price for the quarter ended 12/31/10?
Answer: 53.14
part ii item 5 . market for registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following table presents reported quarterly high and low per share sale prices of our common stock on the new york stock exchange ( 201cnyse 201d ) for the years 2010 and 2009. .

1	2010	high	low
2	quarter ended march 31	$ 44.61	$ 40.10
3	quarter ended june 30	45.33	38.86
4	quarter ended september 30	52.11	43.70
5	quarter ended december 31	53.14	49.61
6	2009	high	low
7	quarter ended march 31	$ 32.53	$ 25.45
8	quarter ended june 30	34.52	27.93
9	quarter ended september 30	37.71	29.89
10	quarter ended december 31	43.84	35.03

on february 11 , 2011 , the closing price of our common stock was $ 56.73 per share as reported on the nyse . as of february 11 , 2011 , we had 397612895 outstanding shares of common stock and 463 registered holders . dividends we have not historically paid a dividend on our common stock . payment of dividends in the future , when , as and if authorized by our board of directors , would depend upon many factors , including our earnings and financial condition , restrictions under applicable law and our current and future loan agreements , our debt service requirements , our capital expenditure requirements and other factors that our board of directors may deem relevant from time to time , including the potential determination to elect reit status . in addition , the loan agreement for our revolving credit facility and term loan contain covenants that generally restrict our ability to pay dividends unless certain financial covenants are satisfied . for more information about the restrictions under the loan agreement for the revolving credit facility and term loan , our notes indentures and the loan agreement related to our securitization , see item 7 of this annual report under the caption 201cmanagement 2019s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations 2014liquidity and capital resources 2014factors affecting sources of liquidity 201d and note 6 to our consolidated financial statements included in this annual report. .

Previous questions in this conversation: what was the closing price of common stock as of 2/11/11? and the high price for the quarter ended 12/31/10?
Previous answers: 56.73 53.14
Question: and the difference between these two prices?
Answer: 3.59
part ii item 5 . market for registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following table presents reported quarterly high and low per share sale prices of our common stock on the new york stock exchange ( 201cnyse 201d ) for the years 2010 and 2009. .

1	2010	high	low
2	quarter ended march 31	$ 44.61	$ 40.10
3	quarter ended june 30	45.33	38.86
4	quarter ended september 30	52.11	43.70
5	quarter ended december 31	53.14	49.61
6	2009	high	low
7	quarter ended march 31	$ 32.53	$ 25.45
8	quarter ended june 30	34.52	27.93
9	quarter ended september 30	37.71	29.89
10	quarter ended december 31	43.84	35.03

on february 11 , 2011 , the closing price of our common stock was $ 56.73 per share as reported on the nyse . as of february 11 , 2011 , we had 397612895 outstanding shares of common stock and 463 registered holders . dividends we have not historically paid a dividend on our common stock . payment of dividends in the future , when , as and if authorized by our board of directors , would depend upon many factors , including our earnings and financial condition , restrictions under applicable law and our current and future loan agreements , our debt service requirements , our capital expenditure requirements and other factors that our board of directors may deem relevant from time to time , including the potential determination to elect reit status . in addition , the loan agreement for our revolving credit facility and term loan contain covenants that generally restrict our ability to pay dividends unless certain financial covenants are satisfied . for more information about the restrictions under the loan agreement for the revolving credit facility and term loan , our notes indentures and the loan agreement related to our securitization , see item 7 of this annual report under the caption 201cmanagement 2019s discussion and analysis of financial condition and results of operations 2014liquidity and capital resources 2014factors affecting sources of liquidity 201d and note 6 to our consolidated financial statements included in this annual report. .

Previous questions in this conversation: what was the closing price of common stock as of 2/11/11? and the high price for the quarter ended 12/31/10? and the difference between these two prices?
Previous answers: 56.73 53.14 3.59
Question: so what was the growth rate during this time?
Answer: 0.06756
item 5 . market for the registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following graph compares annual total return of our common stock , the standard & poor 2019s 500 composite stock index ( 201cs&p 500 index 201d ) and our peer group ( 201cloews peer group 201d ) for the five years ended december 31 , 2015 . the graph assumes that the value of the investment in our common stock , the s&p 500 index and the loews peer group was $ 100 on december 31 , 2010 and that all dividends were reinvested. .

1	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015
2	loews common stock	100.0	97.37	106.04	126.23	110.59	101.72
3	s&p 500 index	100.0	102.11	118.45	156.82	178.29	180.75
4	loews peer group ( a )	100.0	101.59	115.19	145.12	152.84	144.70

( a ) the loews peer group consists of the following companies that are industry competitors of our principal operating subsidiaries : ace limited , w.r . berkley corporation , the chubb corporation , energy transfer partners l.p. , ensco plc , the hartford financial services group , inc. , kinder morgan energy partners , l.p . ( included through november 26 , 2014 when it was acquired by kinder morgan inc. ) , noble corporation , spectra energy corp , transocean ltd . and the travelers companies , inc . dividend information we have paid quarterly cash dividends on loews common stock in each year since 1967 . regular dividends of $ 0.0625 per share of loews common stock were paid in each calendar quarter of 2015 and 2014. .

Question: what is the net change in loews common stock from 2013 to 2014?
Answer: -15.64
item 5 . market for the registrant 2019s common equity , related stockholder matters and issuer purchases of equity securities the following graph compares annual total return of our common stock , the standard & poor 2019s 500 composite stock index ( 201cs&p 500 index 201d ) and our peer group ( 201cloews peer group 201d ) for the five years ended december 31 , 2015 . the graph assumes that the value of the investment in our common stock , the s&p 500 index and the loews peer group was $ 100 on december 31 , 2010 and that all dividends were reinvested. .

1	2010	2011	2012	2013	2014	2015
2	loews common stock	100.0	97.37	106.04	126.23	110.59	101.72
3	s&p 500 index	100.0	102.11	118.45	156.82	178.29	180.75
4	loews peer group ( a )	100.0	101.59	115.19	145.12	152.84	144.70

( a ) the loews peer group consists of the following companies that are industry competitors of our principal operating subsidiaries : ace limited , w.r . berkley corporation , the chubb corporation , energy transfer partners l.p. , ensco plc , the hartford financial services group , inc. , kinder morgan energy partners , l.p . ( included through november 26 , 2014 when it was acquired by kinder morgan inc. ) , noble corporation , spectra energy corp , transocean ltd . and the travelers companies , inc . dividend information we have paid quarterly cash dividends on loews common stock in each year since 1967 . regular dividends of $ 0.0625 per share of loews common stock were paid in each calendar quarter of 2015 and 2014. .

Previous questions in this conversation: what is the net change in loews common stock from 2013 to 2014?
Previous answers: -15.64
Question: what is the percent change?
Answer: -0.1239
equipment and energy .

1	2013	2012	2011
2	sales	$ 451.1	$ 420.1	$ 400.6
3	operating income	65.5	44.6	62.8

2013 vs . 2012 sales of $ 451.1 increased primarily from higher lng project activity . operating income of $ 65.5 increased from the higher lng project activity . the sales backlog for the equipment business at 30 september 2013 was $ 402 , compared to $ 450 at 30 september 2012 . it is expected that approximately $ 250 of the backlog will be completed during 2014 . 2012 vs . 2011 sales of $ 420.1 increased 5% ( 5 % ) , or $ 19.5 , reflecting higher air separation unit ( asu ) activity . operating income of $ 44.6 decreased 29% ( 29 % ) , or $ 18.2 , reflecting lower lng project activity . the sales backlog for the equipment business at 30 september 2012 was $ 450 , compared to $ 334 at 30 september 2011 . other operating income ( loss ) primarily includes other expense and income that cannot be directly associated with the business segments , including foreign exchange gains and losses . also included are lifo inventory valuation adjustments , as the business segments use fifo , and the lifo pool valuation adjustments are not allocated to the business segments . other also included stranded costs resulting from discontinued operations , as these costs were not reallocated to the businesses in 2012 . 2013 vs . 2012 other operating loss was $ 4.7 , compared to $ 6.6 in the prior year . the current year includes an unfavorable lifo adjustment versus the prior year of $ 11 . the prior year loss included stranded costs from discontinued operations of $ 10 . 2012 vs . 2011 other operating loss was $ 6.6 , compared to $ 39.3 in the prior year , primarily due to a reduction in stranded costs , a decrease in the lifo adjustment as a result of decreases in inventory values , and favorable foreign exchange , partially offset by gains on asset sales in the prior year. .

Question: in 2013, what was the ratio of sales to operating income?
Answer: 6.88702
equipment and energy .

1	2013	2012	2011
2	sales	$ 451.1	$ 420.1	$ 400.6
3	operating income	65.5	44.6	62.8

2013 vs . 2012 sales of $ 451.1 increased primarily from higher lng project activity . operating income of $ 65.5 increased from the higher lng project activity . the sales backlog for the equipment business at 30 september 2013 was $ 402 , compared to $ 450 at 30 september 2012 . it is expected that approximately $ 250 of the backlog will be completed during 2014 . 2012 vs . 2011 sales of $ 420.1 increased 5% ( 5 % ) , or $ 19.5 , reflecting higher air separation unit ( asu ) activity . operating income of $ 44.6 decreased 29% ( 29 % ) , or $ 18.2 , reflecting lower lng project activity . the sales backlog for the equipment business at 30 september 2012 was $ 450 , compared to $ 334 at 30 september 2011 . other operating income ( loss ) primarily includes other expense and income that cannot be directly associated with the business segments , including foreign exchange gains and losses . also included are lifo inventory valuation adjustments , as the business segments use fifo , and the lifo pool valuation adjustments are not allocated to the business segments . other also included stranded costs resulting from discontinued operations , as these costs were not reallocated to the businesses in 2012 . 2013 vs . 2012 other operating loss was $ 4.7 , compared to $ 6.6 in the prior year . the current year includes an unfavorable lifo adjustment versus the prior year of $ 11 . the prior year loss included stranded costs from discontinued operations of $ 10 . 2012 vs . 2011 other operating loss was $ 6.6 , compared to $ 39.3 in the prior year , primarily due to a reduction in stranded costs , a decrease in the lifo adjustment as a result of decreases in inventory values , and favorable foreign exchange , partially offset by gains on asset sales in the prior year. .

Previous questions in this conversation: in 2013, what was the ratio of sales to operating income?
Previous answers: 6.88702
Question: and in 2012?
Answer: 9.41928