three subjects with pi , a clinically healthy implant , and a periodontally diseased tooth were selected .
they had not received systemic antibiotics , anti - inflammatory drugs , or oral anti - microbial agents within the last 3 months .
the investigation was approved by the ethics committee of the tokyo medical and dental university , and a written informed consent was obtained from all subjects .
the following clinical parameters were assessed at six sites per tooth and at six sites per implant ( mesiobuccal , buccal , distobuccal , mesiolingual , lingual , and distolingual ) : ( 1 ) probing depth ( pd ) , ( 2 ) bleeding on probing ( bop ) , ( 3 ) suppuration ( sup ) , and ( 4 ) gingival index ( gi ) ( 27 ) .
intra - oral periapical radiographs ( insight dental films , eastman kodak company , sp , japan ) were obtained using the parallel technique .
radiographs were analyzed for peri - implant bone loss by the same examiner using the smooth components and threads of the implants as reference points . based on clinical and radiographic data , a diseased implant , a clinically healthy implant , and a periodontally diseased tooth
diseased implants ( implants with pi ) showed pd5 mm with bop and/or sup and concomitant radiographic bone loss ( bone loss more than three threads up to half of the implant length ) .
healthy implants ( h ) showed pd<4 mm without bop and sup , and radiographic bone loss .
subgingival plaque samples were obtained from the deepest pockets at the implants with / without pi .
in addition , samples from the deepest pockets of the periodontally diseased tooth , not adjacent to the implant were collected .
two weeks before sampling , we performed periodontal examination for all of the residual teeth and implants .
pd , bop , and sup were measured at six points per tooth as pre - examination and together with radiographic evaluation , sampling sites were decided .
after 30 s , all paper points were removed and placed in a sterile tube with 1 ml of sterile distilled water .
samples were mixed for 1 min using a vortex mixer . after removing the paper point ,
the resulting pellet was resuspended in 150 l of lysis buffer from a bacterial dna extraction kit ( mora - extract , amr inc . ,
samples were then incubated for 10 min at 90c and total bacterial genomic dna was isolated using the mora - extract kit .
total bacterial dna was eluted with 200 l of te buffer ( amr inc . ) and was stored at 20c .
16s rrna gene clone library analysis was performed as described previously ( 28 , 29 ) .
briefly , the primers used for pcr amplification of the 16s rrna gene were 27f ( 5-agagtttgatcmtggctcag-3 ) and 1492r ( 5-tacggytaccttgttacgactt-3 ) .
pcr reaction mixture ( 100 l ) containing 10 l of extracted dna , 2.5 u of takara ex taq ( takara bio inc . , otsu , japan ) , 10 l of 10 ex taq buffer , 8 l of dntp mixture ( 0.2 mm each ) , and 50 pmol of each primer .
pcr amplification was performed using a veriti 200 pcr thermal cycler ( applied biosystems , foster city , ca , usa ) with the following program ; 95c for 3 min , followed by 15 cycles of 95c for 30 s , 50c for 30 s , 72c for 1.5 min and a final extension period of 72c for 10 min .
pcr products were purified using a qiaquick pcr purification kit ( qiagen , valencia , ca , usa ) .
purified amplicons were ligated into plasmid vector pcr2.1 and then transformed into one shot invaf competent cells using the original ta cloning kit ( invitrogen , san diego , ca , usa ) . plasmid dnas were prepared using the templiphi dna amplification kit ( ge healthcare , buckinghamshire , uk ) from randomly selected recombinants and used as templates for sequencing .
sequencing was conducted using the 27f and 520r primers , a bigdye terminator cycle sequencing kit ( applied biosystems ) , and a 3130xl genetic analyzer ( applied biosystems ) .
all sequences were checked for possible chimeric artifacts by the chimera check program of the ribosomal database project - ii ( rdp - ii ) and compared to similar sequences of the reference organisms by blast search ( 30 ) .
a 16s rrna gene sequence similarity of 98% was used as the cut - off for positive identification of taxa ( operational taxonomic unit 
less than 98% identity in the 16s rrna gene sequence was the criterion used to identify bacteria at the species level .
the sequences were aligned with the clustal x 2.0.12 program ( 31 ) and corrected by manual inspection .
nucleotide substitution rates ( k 
 nuc values ) were calculated ( 32 ) after gaps and unknown bases were eliminated .
the phylogenetic tree was constructed by the neighbor - joining method ( 33 ) . bootstrap resampling analysis
sequences for novel phylotypes were deposited in the ddbj database under accession numbers ab538407 to ab538428 .
distance matrices were calculated using the dnadist program within the phylip software package version 3.69 .
three subjects with pi , a clinically healthy implant , and a periodontally diseased tooth were selected .
they had not received systemic antibiotics , anti - inflammatory drugs , or oral anti - microbial agents within the last 3 months .
the investigation was approved by the ethics committee of the tokyo medical and dental university , and a written informed consent was obtained from all subjects .
the following clinical parameters were assessed at six sites per tooth and at six sites per implant ( mesiobuccal , buccal , distobuccal , mesiolingual , lingual , and distolingual ) : ( 1 ) probing depth ( pd ) , ( 2 ) bleeding on probing ( bop ) , ( 3 ) suppuration ( sup ) , and ( 4 ) gingival index ( gi ) ( 27 ) .
intra - oral periapical radiographs ( insight dental films , eastman kodak company , sp , japan ) were obtained using the parallel technique .
radiographs were analyzed for peri - implant bone loss by the same examiner using the smooth components and threads of the implants as reference points . based on clinical and radiographic data , a diseased implant , a clinically healthy implant , and a periodontally diseased tooth
diseased implants ( implants with pi ) showed pd5 mm with bop and/or sup and concomitant radiographic bone loss ( bone loss more than three threads up to half of the implant length ) .
healthy implants ( h ) showed pd<4 mm without bop and sup , and radiographic bone loss .
subgingival plaque samples were obtained from the deepest pockets at the implants with / without pi . in addition , samples from the deepest pockets of the periodontally diseased tooth , not adjacent to the implant were collected .
two weeks before sampling , we performed periodontal examination for all of the residual teeth and implants .
pd , bop , and sup were measured at six points per tooth as pre - examination and together with radiographic evaluation , sampling sites were decided .
after 30 s , all paper points were removed and placed in a sterile tube with 1 ml of sterile distilled water .
samples were mixed for 1 min using a vortex mixer . after removing the paper point ,
the resulting pellet was resuspended in 150 l of lysis buffer from a bacterial dna extraction kit ( mora - extract , amr inc . ,
samples were then incubated for 10 min at 90c and total bacterial genomic dna was isolated using the mora - extract kit .
total bacterial dna was eluted with 200 l of te buffer ( amr inc . ) and was stored at 20c .
16s rrna gene clone library analysis was performed as described previously ( 28 , 29 ) .
briefly , the primers used for pcr amplification of the 16s rrna gene were 27f ( 5-agagtttgatcmtggctcag-3 ) and 1492r ( 5-tacggytaccttgttacgactt-3 ) .
pcr reaction mixture ( 100 l ) containing 10 l of extracted dna , 2.5 u of takara ex taq ( takara bio inc . ,
otsu , japan ) , 10 l of 10 ex taq buffer , 8 l of dntp mixture ( 0.2 mm each ) , and 50 pmol of each primer .
pcr amplification was performed using a veriti 200 pcr thermal cycler ( applied biosystems , foster city , ca , usa ) with the following program ; 95c for 3 min , followed by 15 cycles of 95c for 30 s , 50c for 30 s , 72c for 1.5 min and a final extension period of 72c for 10 min .
pcr products were purified using a qiaquick pcr purification kit ( qiagen , valencia , ca , usa ) .
purified amplicons were ligated into plasmid vector pcr2.1 and then transformed into one shot invaf competent cells using the original ta cloning kit ( invitrogen , san diego , ca , usa ) . plasmid dnas were prepared using the templiphi dna amplification kit ( ge healthcare , buckinghamshire , uk ) from randomly selected recombinants and used as templates for sequencing .
sequencing was conducted using the 27f and 520r primers , a bigdye terminator cycle sequencing kit ( applied biosystems ) , and a 3130xl genetic analyzer ( applied biosystems ) .
all sequences were checked for possible chimeric artifacts by the chimera check program of the ribosomal database project - ii ( rdp - ii ) and compared to similar sequences of the reference organisms by blast search ( 30 ) .
a 16s rrna gene sequence similarity of 98% was used as the cut - off for positive identification of taxa ( operational taxonomic unit  otu ) .
less than 98% identity in the 16s rrna gene sequence was the criterion used to identify bacteria at the species level .
the sequences were aligned with the clustal x 2.0.12 program ( 31 ) and corrected by manual inspection .
nucleotide substitution rates ( k 
 nuc values ) were calculated ( 32 ) after gaps and unknown bases were eliminated .
the phylogenetic tree was constructed by the neighbor - joining method ( 33 ) . bootstrap resampling analysis
. sequences for novel phylotypes were deposited in the ddbj database under accession numbers ab538407 to ab538428 .
distance matrices were calculated using the dnadist program within the phylip software package version 3.69 .
clinical data of subjects and sites selected for bacterial sampling are summarized in tables 1 and 2 , respectively .
a total of nine sites ( three pi , three periodontitis , and three healthy implants ) were selected and collected for subgingival plaque samples .
one sample ( periodontally healthy implant ) was missed in the process of sample preparation , so eight samples were analyzed .
a total of 335 sequences from eight samples were subjected to sequence analysis , which revealed 112 species ; 51 ( 46% ) were uncultivated phylotypes , of which 22 were novel .
the total numbers of bacterial species identified at the sites of pi , periodontitis , and periodontally healthy implants were 77 , 57 , and 12 , respectively .
each clone was classified into several clusters corresponding to phylum - level classification ( table 3 , fig .
1 ) . microbiota of pi primarily included gram - negative species and the composition was more diverse than that for healthy implants or periodontitis .
also parvimonas micra , peptostreptococcus stomatis , pseudoramibacter alactolyticus , and solobacterium moorei were only observed at pi sites .
fusobacterium nucleatum was identified at all of the pi sites and granulicatella adiacens was identified at two thirds of pi sites ; these two species were also detected at periodontitis sites but not at healthy implants .
most of the bacterial species found in the healthy implants were also detected in the pi and periodontitis sites .
phylogenetic tree of bacterial species and phylotypes detected in peri - implantitis ( pi ) , periodontitis ( p ) , and healthy implants ( h ) .
right columns 1pi , 2pi , 3pi , 1p , 2p , 3p , 2h , and 3h represent subject , sample , and the numbers of bacterial species identified at each site ( see text ) .
boxes used to indicate abundance levels , based on total number of clones assayed : not detected ( blank box ) , 15% ( black ) , 610% ( yellow ) , 1120% ( green ) , 2140% ( orange ) , and 40% ( red ) .
clinical data of the subjects clinical information of sampling sites bacterial phyla and genera detected in this study when the diversity and richness of the resident bacterial species were compared between pi and periodontitis , higher values for the shannon index and richness were observed at pi sites ( table 4 ) , thus suggesting that the bacterial community at pi sites were more diverse when compared to periodontitis .
comparison of diversity and richness of sequenced clones between peri - implantitis and periodontitis 
					  shannon index and richness are estimated based on 2% differences in nucleic acid sequence alignments .
values given in parentheses are 95% confidence intervals , as calculated by the mothur program .
in the present study , we identified the bacteria that compose biofilm at sites with pi .
it is believed that the source of infecting bacteria on implants is mainly plaque from residual teeth or saliva , and that microbiota around the implants tend to be similar to that of residual teeth ( 3638 ) .
the periodontal status of remaining teeth would thus determine the bacterial composition at pi sites ( 37 , 38 ) .
sites with pi tend to show a more complex microbiota when compared to periodontitis / healthy implant sites and gram - negative anaerobic bacteria are particularly common at such sites .
the presence of periodontopathic bacteria is generally considered to be a risk factor for pi , and indeed , many studies have reported the high prevalence of bacteria , such as p. gingivalis and a. actinomycetemcomitans in pi lesions ( 1520 ) .
in contrast , several researchers have argued that pi and/or implant failure does not always harbor periodontopathic bacteria ( 3941 ) .
f. nucleatum is reported to be a pathogen involved in periodontitis and was found at all pi sites in the present study .
however , we were unable to confirm the high prevalence of other periodontopathic bacteria in peri - implant / periodontal lesions .
it should be emphasized that the sample size was limited and our results do not rule out an association between 
although numerous species reside in peri - implant lesions when compared to periodontitis sites , potentially important bacteria may have been overlooked as disease pathogens . to our knowledge , this is the first study using the 16s rrna gene clone library technique to analyze the microbiota in pi , to confirm that the biofilm of pi is composed of a greater variety of bacterial species when compared to periodontitis .
bacteria isolated only in pi , such as p. micra , p. stomatis , and p. alactolyticus , have been reported to be present in periodontal and/or endodontal lesions ( 42 , 43 ) .
because most of these bacteria are difficult to grow in culture , they have not yet been characterized by their bacterial properties .
also the chloroflexi , tenericutes , and synergistetes phyla were only detected at pi sites .
we considered that the discrepancy of the results was mainly derived from the bacterial sampling method ; they used pooled plaque samples taken by curette from four periodontal pockets . since the number of subjects attended in the studies was small ( vartoukian ; 10 , ours ; 3 ) , further studies are necessary for clarifying the role of the phylum synergistetes in peri - implant diseases , moreover for other bacteria .
differences in bacterial diversity between pi and periodontitis lesions may be explained by the characteristics of surfaces to which the bacteria adhere
. surface roughness and free energy ( wettability ) are thought to have a significant impact on biofilm formation ( 45 ) and the higher levels of free energy on the implant surfaces are likely to affect biofilm components . in conclusion
, pi biofilms showed a more complex microbiota when compared to periodontitis and periodontally healthy implants , and were mainly composed of gram - negative anaerobic bacteria .
previously established periodontopathic bacteria showed low prevalence and several bacteria were identified as candidate of pathogens in pi , although it is unclear whether the importance of these species is higher when compared to established periodontopathic bacteria .
there is no conflict of interest in the present study for any of the authors .
 backgroundperi - implantitis ( pi ) is an inflammatory disease which leads to the destruction of soft and hard tissues around osseointegrated implants . 
 the subgingival microbiota appears to be responsible for peri - implant lesions and although the complexity of the microbiota has been reported in pi , the microbiota responsible for pi has not been identified.objectivethe purpose of this study was to identify the microbiota in subjects who have pi , clinically healthy implants , and periodontitis - affected teeth using 16s rrna gene clone library analysis to clarify the microbial differences.designthree subjects participated in this study . 
 the conditions around the teeth and implants were evaluated based on clinical and radiographic examinations and diseased implants , clinically healthy implants , and periodontally diseased teeth were selected . 
 subgingival plaque samples were taken from the deepest pockets using sterile paper points . 
 prevalence and identity of bacteria was analyzed using a 16s rrna gene clone library technique.resultsa total of 112 different species were identified from 335 clones sequenced . among the 112 species , 51 ( 46% ) were uncultivated phylotypes , of which 22 were novel phylotypes . 
 the numbers of bacterial species identified at the sites of pi , periodontitis , and periodontally healthy implants were 77 , 57 , and 12 , respectively . 
 microbiota in pi mainly included gram - negative species and the composition was more diverse when compared to that of the healthy implant and periodontitis . 
 the phyla chloroflexi , tenericutes , and synergistetes were only detected at pi sites , as were parvimonas micra , peptostreptococcus stomatis , pseudoramibacter alactolyticus , and solobacterium moorei . 
 low levels of periodontopathic bacteria , such as porphyromonas gingivalis and aggregatibacter actinomycetemcomitans , were seen in peri - implant lesions.conclusionsthe biofilm in pi showed a more complex microbiota when compared to periodontitis and periodontally healthy teeth , and it was mainly composed of gram - negative anaerobic bacteria . 
 common periodontopathic bacteria showed low prevalence , and several bacteria were identified as candidate pathogens in pi . 