Abstract:
The physical properties of heat-cured coatings of saturated epoxy resins are significantly improved by the addition of heat stabilizers (antioxidant) and/or actinic stabilizers.

Description:
BACKGROUND OF THE INVENTION 
     Conventional epoxy resins, such as the glycidyl ethers prepared by reacting a dihydric phenol such as 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl)propane (BPA) with epichlorohydrin in the presence of alkaline medium, when heat-cured with urea-formaldehyde resins, melamine-formaldehyde resins, and the like produce coatings which exhibit good gloss and color. On the other hand, when the saturated epoxy resins derived therefrom are cured with urea-formaldehyde, melamine-formaldehyde resins, anhydrides, etc., the resulting coatings generally exhibit considerable discoloration on overbake. It has now been found that the color and gloss of these cured saturated epoxy resin coatings can be significantly improved by the addition of heat and/or actinic stabilizers. 
     SUMMARY OF THE INVENTION 
     The present invention provides a curable composition, which when cured exhibits improved gloss and color, which comprises (1) a saturated epoxy ether of a polyhydric phenol, (2) an epoxy curing agent and (3) at least one heat stabilizer (antioxidant) or actinic stabilizer. 
     DESCRIPTION OF PREFERRED EMBODIMENT 
     The present invention is directed to the preparation of cured saturated epoxy resin compositions exhibiting excellent gloss and color retention. 
     Saturated Epoxy Resins 
     The epoxy compounds useful in the present compositions include those compounds derived from polyhydric phenols and having at least one vicinal epoxy group wherein the carbon-to-carbon bonds within the six-membered ring are saturated. Such epoxy resins may be obtained by at least two well-known techniques, i.e., by the hydrogenation of glycidyl polyethers of polyhydric phenols or (2) by the reaction of hydrogenated polyhydric phenols with epichlohydrin in the presence of a suitable catalyst such as Lewis acids, i.e., boron trihalides and complexes thereof, and subsequent dehydrochlorination in an alkaline medium. The method of preparation forms no part of the present invention and the resulting saturated epoxy resins derived by either method are suitable in the present compositions. 
     Briefly, the first method comprises the hydrogenation of glycidyl polyethers of polyhydric phenols with hydrogen in the presence of a catalyst consisting of rhodium and/or ruthenium supported on an inert carrier at a temperature below about 50° C. This method is thoroughly disclosed and described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,336,241, issued Aug. 15, 1967. 
     The hydrogenated epoxy compounds prepared by the process disclosed in U.S. Pat. No. 3,336,241 are suitable for use in the present compositions. Accordingly, the relevant disclosure of U.S. Pat. No. 3,336,241 is incorporated herein by reference. 
     The second method comprises the condensation of a hydrogenated polyphenol with an epihalohydrin, such as epichlorohydrin, in the presence of a suitable catalyst such as BF 3 , followed by dehydrohalogenation in the presence of caustic. When the phenol is Bisphenol A, the resulting saturated epoxy compound is sometimes referred to as &#34;diepoxidized hydrogenated bisphenol A&#34;, or more properly as the diglycidyl ether of 2,2-bis(4-cyclohexanol) propane. 
     In any event, the term &#34;saturated epoxy resin&#34;, as used herein shall be deemed to mean the glycidyl ethers of polyhydric phenols wherein the aromatic ring structure of the phenols have been or are saturated. 
     An idealized structural formala representating the preferred saturated epoxy compounds is as follows: ##STR1## wherein n has a value so that the average molecular weight of the saturated polyepoxide is from about 350 to about 3000. 
     Preferred saturated epoxy resins are the hydrogenated resins prepared by the process described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,336,241. More preferred are the hydrogenated glycidyl ethers of 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl) propane, sometimes called the diglycidyl ethers of 2,2-bis(4-cyclohexanol) propane. 
     Epoxy Curing Agents 
     In general, all conventional epoxy curing agents that are employed in the heat-curing of epoxy resins are suitable for use in the present compositions. 
     The use of amines as curing agents in baked, or high temperature-curing of epoxy resins, is somewhat limited; however, for some applications some amines, polyamines, etc., such as the polyamides containing carboxyl groups may be employed. 
     Most suitable curing agents include the polycarboxylic acids and polycarboxylic acid anhydrides. Examples of polycarboxylic acids include the di-, tri- and higher carboxylic acids such as oxalic acid, phthalic acid, terephthalic acid, succinic acid, alkyl and aklenyl-substituted succinic acids, tartaric acid, polymerized fatty acids and the like. Examples of suitable polycarboxylic acid anhydrides include, among others, pyromellitic anhydride, phthalic anhydride, succinic acid anhydride, and maleic acid anhydride. Other suitable catalysts include boron trihalide and complexes of boron trihalide with amines, ethers, phenols and the like; Friedel-Crafts metal salts, such as aluminum chloride, zinc chloride, and other salts, such as zinc fluoborate, magnesium perchlorate and zinc fluorosilicate; inorganic acids and partial esters as phosphoric acid and partial esters thereof including n-butyl orthophosphite, diethyl orthophosphate and hexaethyltetraphosphate and the like. 
     Preferred curing agents include the so-called amino resins or amino-plasts containing --NH 2  groups derived from urea and melamine. Suitable amino-containing resins are prepared by reacting urea or melamine with formaldehyde under well-known conditions to form a reaction monomer first and then, by condensation polymerization, a large number of varying types of polymeric intermediates are formed. The preparation of urea-formaldehyde and melamine-formaldehyde resins is well-known in the art and forms no part of the present invention. Their use in crosslinking epoxy resins mostly through methylol groups is also well-known. Accordingly, a large number of aminoplast and phenoplast resins, i.e., urea-formaldehyde and melamine-formaldehyde resins, are commercially available under such trade designations as Plaskon, Beetle, Cymel, Fiberite, Resimene, Curacron and Beckamine, among many others. 
     Other suitable curing agents include the hydroxyl- and/or carboxyl-functional acrylic resins such as those marketed under the trade designation Acryloid® Resins. 
     Stabilizers 
     Suitable stabilizers useful in the present compositions include the so-called &#34;heat&#34; stabilizers or antioxidants (Group I) and &#34;actinic&#34; stabilizers (Group II). 
     Representative antioxidants of the &#34;heat&#34; category (Group I) include the sterically hindered phenols, sulfides and amines as well as the dialkyl esters of beta thiodipropionic acid. 
     The preparation of suitable antioxidants and thermal stabilizers of Group II are described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,285,855, 3,330,859 and 3,441,575. 
     One suitable &#34;heat&#34; stabilizer of Group I is a stabilizer of the general formula: ##STR2## wherein R and R&#39; are the same or different alkoxy groups containing from 12 to 24 carbon atoms, R&#34; is hydrogen or an alkyl having 1 to 6 carbon atoms and n is an integer having a value 0, 1, 2 or 3. 
     Still other heat stabilizers (antioxidant) include the dialkyl esters of beta thiodipropionic acid wherein the alkyl group contains from 12 to 30 carbon atoms, as in preferably dilauryl thiodipropionate (DLTP) or distearyl thiodipropionate (DSTP). 
     Suitable stabilizers (ultra-violet absorbers) of Group II include compounds of the general formula: ##STR3## 
     Other suitable stabilizers include the 2-(2-hydroxy-3,5-dialkylphenyl) chlorobenzotriazole, having the general formula: ##STR4## wherein the chlorine atom is attached to either the 4, 5, 6 or 7 carbon atom of the benzotriazole moiety. In the above Formulae (a) and (b) R&#39; represents a tertiary alkyl radical of from 3 to 8 carbon atoms and more particularly a tertiary butyl radical. The preferred position for the chlorine atom is on the 5 carbon atom. Preferred chlorobenzotriazoles are those described in U.S. Pat. Nos. 3,004,896 and 3,189,615 and marketed under the trade designation of Tinuvin® 327 and Tinuvin® 326 such as 2-(3,5-di-tert-butylphenyl-2&#39;-hydroxy-)-5-chlorobenzotriazole and 2-(3-tert-butyl-2&#39;-hydroxy-5-methylphenyl)-5-chlorobenzotriazole, repectively. 
     The formulation of heat-curable or &#34;baked&#34; coatings is well-known. Simply, the resin or resins are usually dispersed with one or more additives such as pigments, fillers, thixotropic agent, flow control agents, and the like, by suitable techniques such as by roller mill. When the roller mill grind dispersion has the proper particle size range, i.e., from about 20 microns to about 5 microns, the resin/pigment dispersion is mixed with one or more curing agents such as the aminoplast resins, solvent and, optionally, a curing catalyst such as para-toluene-sulfonic acid (PTSA), phosphoric acid or cyclohexane sulfamic acid. The resulting enamel is then applied to the substrate by any suitable means such as dipping, spraying, rolling, brushing, or doctor blade. The coating is then baked for from about 5 minutes to about 20 minutes at a temperature from about 350° C to about 400° C. In the present compositions, the stabilizers are preferably added to the resin and pigments to prepare the roller mill dispersion. 
     In general, the stabilizers are employed in amounts from about 0.01 to about 5.0 phr (parts per one hundred parts by weight of saturated epoxy resin). 
     The amount of pigment employed is usually in amount to produce a pigment to binder weight ratio in the final enamel of from about 25:75 to about 75:25, with about 40:60 to 60:40 being preferred. A pigment to binder (resin plus curing agent) ratio of 50:50 is very suitable. A catalyst such as p-toluenesulfonic acid (PTSA) in 50% isopropyl alcohol (IPA) may be employed in amounts from about 0.1 to about 5.0 phr. 
     In general, a curing amount of curing agent is employed, i.e., a stoichiometric amount, although up to 25% excess of either epoxy resin or curing agent (aminoplast) may be employed under such circumstances. 
     Suitable solvents include ketones, such as acetone, methyl ethyl ketone and methyl isobutyl ketone; alcohols, such as methanol, ethanol, isopropanol, and the like; glycols, glycol ethers and glycol esters; hydrocarbons such as benzene, toluene, xylene, mineral spirits, naphthas, and the like. The solvent component may be a mixture. 
    
    
     The following examples illustrate the preparation of the present epoxy compositions and are for the purpose of illustration only and are in no way intended to limit the invention to the particular compositions illustrated. Modifications within the spirit and scope of the present invention will become apparent to those skilled in the coatings art. Parts and percentages are by weight unless otherwise noted. 
     The following compounds, resins, curing agents, etc., used in the illustrative embodiments are as follows: 
     1. Saturated Epoxy Resin A (Resin A): a diglycidyl ether of hydrogenated 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl) propane, i.e., the diglycidyl ether of 2,2-bis(4-cyclohexanol) propane. 
     2. Saturated Epoxy Resin B (Resin B): Epon® Resin 828 was hydrogenated over a rhodium catalyst by the process described in U.S. Pat. No. 3,336,241. 
     3. Beckamine 21-511: a urea-formaldehyde resin marketed by Reichold Chemical Company supplied at 60%w solids and having a K-M Gardner-Holdt viscosity at 25° C. 
     4. Cymel 370: a melamine-formaldehyde resin marketed by American Cyanamid supplied at 88%w solids and having a Z 2  -Z 4  Gardner-Holds viscosity at 25° C. 
     5. Resimene X-745: a melamine-formaldehyde resin marketed by Monsanto supplied at 98%w solids (min.) and having a W-Z Gardner-Holdt viscosity at 25° C. 
     6. Resimene X-918: a urea-formaldehyde resin marketed by Monsanto supplied at 70%w solids and having a Y-Z 2  Gardner-Holdt viscosity at 25° C. 
     7. Acryloid Resin AT-50: an acrylic/melamine-formaldehyde resin marketed by Rohm and Haas Company supplied at 50%w solids and having a viscosity of 625-1755 cps at 25° C. 
     8. Irganox 1010: tetrakis [methylene 3-(3&#39;,5&#39;-di-tert-butyl-4&#39;-hydroxyphenyl) propionate] methane. 
     9. Irganox 1035: thiodiethylene bis-(3,5-di-tert-butyl-4-hydroxy) hydrocinnamate. 
     10. Irganox 1076: octadecyl 3-(3&#39;,5&#39;-di-tert-butyl-4&#39;-hydroxyphenyl) propionate. 
     Epon® Resin 828 is a diglycidyl ether of 2,2-bis(4-hydroxyphenyl) propane having an average molecular weight of about 380. 
     Illustrative Embodiment I 
     This example illustrates the effect of catalyst (PTSA) and stabilizer concentration on the cure and initial gloss of a Resin A/urea-formaldehyde baking enamel. 
     Baking enamels were prepared using Resin A and Beckamine 21-511 is a weight ratio of 60:40 wherein varying amounts of a catalyst (PTSA) and various stabilizers (antioxidants) were used. The enamel contained TiO 2  pigment to produce a pigment: binder ratio of 50:50. The enamel was applied in organic solvent (Cellosolve® acetate and xylene) to steel panels and baked at 400° F for 10 minutes. The results of these experiments are tabulated in Table I. The control is Resin A without stabilizer. The Yellowness Index was determined by ASTM: E313-67 and the Gloss was determined by ASTM: D523-67, Reapproved 1972, at a 60° angle. The &#34;MEK Rub&#34; test is a test of degree of cure and is a simple test whereby the number of double rubs of a cheesecloth saturated with methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) needed to soften the film is noted. The greater number of rubs indicates a higher degree of cure. The data clearly indicates that at this cure cycle, a catalyst is desirable. 
     
                                           TABLE I__________________________________________________________________________EFFECT OF CATALYST AND ANTIOXIDANT CONCENTRATION ON CUREAND INITIAL GLOSS OF RESIN A/BECKAMINE 21-511Antioxidant        Irganox 1010                         Irganox 1010                                    Irganox 1076Concentration   Control    0.5%       1.0%       0.5%% w     Yellowness Yellowness Yellowness YellownessCalalyst.sup.a)   Index      Index      Index      IndexConcentration   Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEKphr     %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs__________________________________________________________________________0.25%   +0.89   5  -1.71   5  -1.26   7  -2.38 14   72         68         70         710.50%   -0.10   99 -1.22   8  -1.46   9  -0.86 12   58         79         78         741.0%    +1.75 &gt;100 -2.10 &gt;100 -1.82 &gt;100 -2.06 &gt;100   53         72         73         66Antioxidant        Irganox 1076                         Irganox 1035                                     Irganox 1035Concentration      1.0%       0.5%       1.0%% w                Yellowness Yellowness YellownessCatalyst           Index      Index      IndexConcentration      Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEKphr                %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs__________________________________________________________________________0.25%              -0.57   9  -1.81   29 -1.83   9              79         70         730.50%              -1.31   13 -1.29   10 -1.10   10              72         78         721.0%               -1.97 &gt;100 -2.40 &gt;100 -1.60 &gt;100              68         74         70__________________________________________________________________________ .sup.a) p-Toluenesulfonic acid added as a 50% soln in IPA 
    
     
                                           TABLE II__________________________________________________________________________EFFECT OFF CATALYST AND ANTIOXIDANT CONCENTRATION ON CUREAND INITIAL GLOSS OF RESIN B/BECKAMINE 21-511Antioxidant        Irganox 1010                         Irganox 1010                                    Irganox 1076Concentration   Control    0.5%       1.0%       0.5%% w     yellowness Yellowness Yellowness YellownessCatalyst.sup.a)   Index      Index      Index      IndexConcentration   Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEKphr     %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs__________________________________________________________________________0.25%   +2.37   2  +0.28   2  -0.23   2  +0.03   2   83         85         84         830.50%   +0.53   10 -1.53   13 -1.79   6  -1.53   10   64         76         63         691.0%    +0.24 &gt;100 -2.39 &gt;100 -2.85 &gt;100 -1.71 &gt;100   66         72         70         73Antioxidant        Irganox 1076                         Irganox 1035                                    Irganox 1035Concentration      1.0%       0.5%       1.0%% w                Yellowness Yellowness YellownessCatalyst.sup.a)    Index      Index      IndexConcentration      Gloss MEK  Gloss MEK  Gloss MEKphr                %     Rubs %     Rubs %     Rubs__________________________________________________________________________0.25%              -0.48   3  -0.29   4  +0.13  3              81         83         860.50%              -1.54   12 -2.30   7  -2.15 10              77         64         641.0%               -2.34 &gt;100 -2.44 &gt;100 -1.40 26              70         73         72__________________________________________________________________________ .sup.a) p-Toluenesulfonic acid added as a 50% soln in IPA. 
    
     
                                           TABLE III__________________________________________________________________________SUMMARY OF FLORIDA EXPOSURE DATA ON RESIN A BAKING ENAMELS                     RatioResin                     ResinSystem Resin/Curing Agent  Curing                           Catalyst/No.   Resin   Curing Agent                     Agent phr__________________________________________________________________________1     Resin C Beckamine 21-511                     60/40 PTSA/12     Resin C Beckamine 21-511                     60/40 PTSA/13     Resin C Cymel 370   60/40 PTSA/24     Resin C Cymel 370   60/40 PTSA/25     Resin C Resimene X-745                     60/40 PTSA/46     Resin C Resimene X-745                     60/40 PTSA/47     Resin C Resimene X-918                     60/40 PTSA/28     Resin C Resimene X-9l8                     60/40 PTSA/2 Duraplex9      ND-78  Uformite MX-61                     65/36 --10    Soya Alkyd         --          --    --11    AT-50   --          --    -- EPON Resin12     1007   Beckamine 21-511                     70/30 -- EPON Resin13     828    Beckamine 21-511                     50/40 PTSA/1 EPON Resin14     828    Cymel 370   60/40 PTSA/2 EPON Resin15     828    AT-50       35/65 --Bake        Florida ExposureResinSchedule       60 Deg. Gloss, %   Yellowness (N)SystemTemp    Time       Months             MonthsNo.   ° F    Min.         0  3  6  9 12 15 18 21 0    21 ΔN__________________________________________________________________________1    400 10 73  72 73 66 64 -- -- -- -0.20                                     -- --2    400 10 75  73 77 66 68 -- -- -- +0.47                                     -- --3    400 10 85  77 88 74 81 61 47 41 +1.39                                     -- +1.93.sup.1)4    400 10 85  78 89 75 81 57 43 39 +1.35                                     -- +4.53.sup.1)5    400 10 88  81 86 73 76 51 27 -- -0.64                                     -- +5.14.sup.1)6    400 10 87  84 87 72 77 49 22 -- -1.37                                     -- +5.49.sup.1)7    400 10 81  77 77 67 70 26 -- -- -0.78                                     -- +12.40.sup.2)8    400 10 81  80 77 67 69 37 -- -- +0.69                                     -- +9.13.sup.2)9    300 30 89  49 19 29 31 14 -- -- -1.34                                     -- +2.71.sup.1)10   --  -- 88  74 51 48 49 28 -- -- +2.33                                     -- -0.06.sup.2)11   300 30 85  78 94 80 85 54 13 -- -0.97                                     -- +1.73.sup.1)12   400 10 94  64 23 27 32 16 -- -- +1.21                                     -- +3.22.sup.2)13   400 10 93  75 69 22 19  8 -- -- -0.60                                     -- +20.00.sup.2)14   400 10 &gt;100           95 58 21 10  5 -- -- +1.37                                     -- +6.87.sup.2)15   300 30 84  89 88 51 48 32 14 -- +0.49                                     -- +8.46.sup.1)__________________________________________________________________________ .sup.1) ΔN after 18 months .sup.2) ΔN after 15 months 
    
     Illustrative Embodiment II 
     The procedures of Illustrative Embodiment I were essentially repeated wherein Resin B is substituted for Resin A. The results are tabulated in Table II. The control example is Resin B without stabilizer. 
     Illustrative Embodiment III 
     This example illustrates weatherability of the present baked coating compositions. 
     A dispersion containing 62.5% by weight TiO 2  and 37.5% by weight of Resin C (Resin A plus 0.5% by weight Irganox 1035) was prepared on a roller mill, hereinafter referred to as &#34;Roller Mill Grind&#34;. 
     This Roller Mill Grind was then formulated into baking enamels as follows: 
     
         ______________________________________A.  Enamel A             %wt     Solids (% NV)______________________________________    Roller Mill Grind    59.1    Cymel 370 (88%)      16.8    Cellosolve Acetate/Xylene (50/50)                    22.6    p-Toluenesulfonic Acid (50% IPA)                    1.5                    100.0   73.9B.  Enamel B    Roller Mill Grind    59.6    Beckamine 21-511 (60%)                    24.8    Cellosolve Acetate/Xylene (50/50)                    14.9    p-Toluenesulfonic Acid (50% IPA)                    0.7                    100.0   74.5C.  Enamel C    Roller Mill Grind    58.3    Resimene X-745 (98%) 14.6    Cellosolve Acetate/Xylene (50/50)                    24.2    p-Toluenesulfonic Acid (50% IPA)                    2.9                    100.0   72.9D.  Enamel D    Roller Mill Grind    60    Resimene X-9l8 (70%) 21.4    Cellosolve Acetate/Xylene (50/50)                    17.1    p-Toluenesulfonic Acid (50% IPA)                    1.5                    100.0   75%______________________________________ 
    
     The resulting enamels were applied by doctor blade (1.0 mil coatings) to cold rolled steel panels and cured at 400° F for 10 minutes. The cured coated panels were then exposed to the weather in Florida. The results of selected representative test panels are tabulated in Table III. For comparison a number of control samples are also tabulated wherein various other resin systems were employed. 
     Illustrative Embodiment IV 
     The procedures of Embodiment III were essentially repeated wherein an antioxidant (Irganox 1035) is used alone and in combination with a UV-stabilizer (Tinuvin 327) in Resin A. For comparison, films of a commerical resin system were also used (ACRYLOID AT-50). The weathering results are tabulated in Table IV. 
     
                                           TABLE IV__________________________________________________________________________EFFECT OF STABILIZERS ON THE WEATHERINGOF RESIN A/CYMEL 370 BAKED ENAMELS        RatioResin System     Stabilizer System  Curing        Curing            Catalyst (PTSA)                     Anti- UV.sub.1Resin  Agent Agent            phr      Oxidant                           Stabilizer__________________________________________________________________________Resin A  Cymel 370        60/40            2        Irganox.sup.a)                           --                     1035Resin A  Cymel 370        60/40            2        Irganox.sup.a)                           Tinuvin 327.sup.a)                     1035ACRYLOID  --    --  --       --    --AT-50__________________________________________________________________________        FLORIDA EXPOSUREResin System 60° Gloss, % Retention  Curing        MonthsResin  Agent 3   6    9   12   15  18__________________________________________________________________________Resin A  Cymel 370        91  104  88   95  69  53Resin A  Cymel 370        94  105  91  102  84  68ACRYLOID  --    95  111  94  101  68  20AT-50__________________________________________________________________________ .sup.a) 0.5% by weight based on Resin A 
    
     Illustrative Embodiment V 
     This embodiment illlustrates the effect of selected antioxidants on weight loss. 
     A drop of Resin A (above-defined) was placed in a weighed aluminum cup and methyl ethyl ketone (MEK) was added to dispense the resin. The MEK solvent was then evaporated at room temperature to form a film of from about 0.2 to 0.3 mils thickness. The cup was then placed in an oven at 400° F for 10 minutes. The weight loss was then determined and reported as percent non-volatiles. 
     This procedure was repeated using Resin B. Then 1% by weight of selected antioxidants were added to the resin and the procedure essentially repeated. The results are tabulated in Table V. In all instances, except when Ionol® was used, the weight loss was reduced when antioxidant was used. Since Ionol is somewhat volatile, it is predictable that some weight loss would be experienced; however, the gloss and weatherability is improved when Ionol is used. 
     Illustrative Embodiment VI 
     Related results were obtained when Plastinox 1729, a white phenolic, sulfur-containing polyolefin antioxidant (American Cyanamide Co.) having a melting point; soluble in acetone, ethanol, methyl ethyl ketone and tetrahydrofuran; but insoluble in water, is incorporated in the saturated epoxy resins. 
     
                                           TABLE V__________________________________________________________________________EFFECT OF SELECTED ANTIOXIDANTS ON WEIGHT LOSSOF SATURATED EPOXY RESINS       Irganox             Irganox                   Irganox    Poly-       HITEC.sup.e) Control       1010  1035  1076  Ionol.sup.b)                              gard.sup.c)                                   DLTDP.sup.d)                                          E653Resin %, NV.sup.a)       %NV   %NV   %NV   %NV  %NV  %NV    %NV__________________________________________________________________________Resin A 70    79    87    82    66   83   71     76Resin B 86    92    91    94    79   92   91     84__________________________________________________________________________ .sup.a) Percent Non-volatiles .sup.b) 2,6-di-tert-butyl-p-cresol .sup.c) Trinonyl phenylphosphate (Uniroyal) .sup.d) Zinc dialkyl dithiophosphate (Edwin Cooper, Inc.)