Abstract:
To provide for security and robustness in distribution of high value video content such as UHD video, a white list is provided that does not grant default access to content like a revocation listing does, but rather forces a software update on potentially compromised devices to bring them back into copy protection compliance, eliminating, e.g., the use of certain outputs that have been compromised. Prior to outputting content, a source device determines whether the receiving device is on a white list, whether the output is still valid, whether the version number of the receiving device is still valid, and that the receiving device does not have insecure outputs on which it could re-output content.

Description:
TECHNICAL FIELD 
       [0001]    The application relates generally to distributed white lists for content security renewability. 
       BACKGROUND 
       [0002]    An example computer ecosystem, or digital ecosystem, which is an adaptive and distributed socio-technical system that is characterized by its sustainability, self-organization, and scalability, that is pertinent to present principles s a network in which ultra-high definition (UHD) video such as so-called “4K” or “8K” video is distributed to client devices for secure playback on client devices, while providing for security against unauthorized copying and dissemination of the UHD video. Revocation messages can be used with the security system. As an example, the Digital Transmission Copy Protection (DTCP) protocol uses revocation messages that are called “System Renewability Messages” (SRMs). 
         [0003]    As understood herein, one problem with current link protection is that it is challenging to correct a problem downstream from a source device once a breach is identified. For example, at least one earlier version of the High-bandwidth Digital Content Protection (HDCP) content protection protocol, which protects content transmitted over High Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI) links, has been compromised. The present application understands that a gateway device may receive compressed content protected by Conditional Access (CA) or Digital Rights Management (DRM) from a Pay-TV provider. The gateway device descrambles the content using CA or DRM. The gateway device then can re-transmit the compressed content over the home network using DTCP-IP to another device, e.g. a game console. The other device, e.g., a game console, can then decompress and output the content over HDCP. However, a hacker could create a fake HDMI sink device impersonating a TV using, e.g. a personal computer, with fake HDCP credentials. In this scenario, the decoding device, e.g., the game console, is not aware that it is attached to a fake TV. The content may be output over HDMI protected by the hacked version of HDCP, in which case the content could be captured and piratically delivered out to the Internet. When delivering content from the gateway device to the decoding device using DTCP-IP, it has not been possible to exclude the hacked version of HDCP from downstream distribution. 
         [0004]    In the case of HDCP, the key generation algorithm was reverse engineered by hackers allowing the generation of an unlimited number of bogus HDCP devices. However, a bad implementation can also expose keys and, thus, content. The problem can be so pervasive that a realistic revocation of potentially thousands (maybe millions) of devices is just not practical. Content providers and service operators trying to bring a premium service into the home are left with unappealing options. They can continue to deliver content and risk a loss of control over content, or forgo the service all together and endure the resulting loss of revenue. 
       SUMMARY 
       [0005]    In an embodiment, a white list is distributed in the home network. The white list brings a different type of control over the protection and distribution of content in the home than a revocation list. The white list can be used at just the gateway and it can also be distributed from the gateway to sinks, to foster content security with distributed devices that may obtain content from the sink. 
         [0006]    Accordingly, in one aspect a device for a computerized content gateway includes at least one computer memory that is not a transitory signal and that includes instructions executable by at least one processor to receive a white list of sink devices authorized to receive at least some content from the gateway. Entries on the white list pertain to respective devices, with at least some entries being associated with a respective device identification (ID). The instructions are executable to receive a request to send content from the gateway to a sink configured to play video content; compare a device ID associated with the sink and received by the gateway in a digital certificate against at least a portion of the list of devices, and based on the device ID associated with the sink received in the certificate matching a device ID on the list, provide the content to the sink. The instructions are executable to, based at least in part on the device ID received in the certificate not matching a device ID on the list, not provide the content to the sink. 
         [0007]    In some examples, the instructions are executable to provide the list to the sink such that requests by tertiary devices to the sink for content is controlled at least in part by the sink using the list. In some examples, the list is version-controlled and the instructions are executable to share a most recent version of the list between at least the gateway and sink. In some examples, the instructions are executable to verify a version and authenticity of the list using a public key of a common root of trust certificate authority. In some examples, the public key of the common root of trust certificate authority is held by both the sink and the tertiary device. In some examples, the device ID that is compared with the white list is accessed from a digital certificate used by the sink during link protection between the gateway and the sink. In some examples, the link protection is Digital Transmission Copy Protection (DTCP), High Bandwidth Digital Copy Protection (HDCP), or Digital Rights Management (DRM). 
         [0008]    In another aspect, a method includes, at a computerized gateway, receiving a white list of devices authorized to receive at least some content from the gateway. Entries on the list pertain to respective devices, and at least some entries are associated with a respective device identification (ID) and at least one expected criterion. The method includes receiving a request to send content from the gateway to a sink configured to play video content, and comparing a device ID and at least one device attribute of the sink received from the sink by the gateway in a digital certificate against at least a portion of the list of devices. Based at least in part on the device ID and device attribute received from the sink matching a device ID and associated expected criterion on the list, the method includes providing the content to the sink. On the other hand, based at least in part on the device ID and/or the at least one device attribute received from the sink not matching a device ID on the list and/or the respective expected criteria on the list, the method includes not providing the content to the sink. 
         [0009]    In some examples, the method includes providing the list to the sink such that requests by tertiary devices to the sink for content is controlled at least in part by the sink using the list. In some examples, the method includes, based on the device attributes received from the sink not matching expected criteria on the list, sending a message to the sink to output an OSD to the user. 
         [0010]    The example expected criterion may include one or more of the following: software version number, time to last software update, minimum version of HDCP protocol, minimum version of DRM protocol, minimum version of DTCP protocol, inclusion of a secure execution environment, inclusion of storage capability, minimum level of robustness, and minimum level of hardware robustness, manufacturer, model number, maximum number of downstream connected devices. For example, if a device&#39;s software version number sent as a device attribute from the sink device does not match a minimum level of software versioning, an OSD can be shown to the user prompting an update the software of that device. 
         [0011]    The example device attribute may include one or more of the following: software version number, time to last software update, version of HDCP protocol, HDCP device ID, version of DRM protocol, DRM device ID, version of DTCP protocol, DTCP device ID, inclusion of a secure execution environment, storage capability, level of robustness, level of hardware robustness manufacturer, model number, device serial number, number of downstream connected devices, connection status to the Internet, decoding capability, screen resolution, screen size. 
         [0012]    In some examples, the method includes verifying, using the sink device, a device ID from a digital certificate by proving that the sink device has a private key corresponding to a public key in the digital certificate. In some examples, the method includes delivering, from the sink device, sink device attributes to the gateway using a tamper proof protocol that involves public and private keys. In some examples, the method includes providing the list to the sink such that requests by tertiary devices to the sink for content is controlled at least in pan by the sink using the list. The list can be version-controlled and the method can include sharing a most recent version of the list between at least the gateway and sink. In some examples, the method includes verifying a version and authenticity of the list using a public key of a common root of trust certificate authority. 
         [0013]    In another aspect, a device for a computerized sink includes at least one computer memory that is not a transitory signal and that includes instructions executable by at least one processor to receive, from a gateway, a white list of devices authorized to receive at least some content received through the gateway. Entries on the white list pertain to respective devices, with at least some entries being associated with a respective device identification (ID). The instructions are executable to receive a request to send content from the sink to a tertiary configured to process video content, compare a device ID associated with the tertiary device and received by the sink in a digital certificate against at least a portion of the list of devices, and based on the device ID associated with the tertiary device received in the certificate matching a device ID on the list, provide the content to the tertiary device. The instructions are further executable to, based at least in part on the device ID received in the certificate not matching a device ID on the list, not provide the content to the tertiary device. 
         [0014]    The details of the present application, both as to its structure and operation, can best be understood in reference to the accompanying drawings, in which like reference numerals refer to like parts, and in which: 
     
    
     
       BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS 
         [0015]      FIG. 1  is a block diagram of an example system including an example in accordance with present principles; 
           [0016]      FIG. 2  is a block diagram of another system that can use the components of  FIG. 1 ; 
           [0017]      FIG. 3  is a schematic diagram of an authentication message according to one embodiment; 
           [0018]      FIG. 4  is a schematic diagram of a gateway and a sink showing DTCP revocation lists and message flow, in concert with  FIG. 5 , which illustrates an example authentication process; 
           [0019]      FIG. 6  is a schematic diagram of an example double handshake authentication process; and 
           [0020]      FIGS. 7 and 8  are flow charts of example logic. 
       
    
    
     DETAILED DESCRIPTION 
       [0021]    This disclosure relates generally to computer ecosystems including aspects of consumer electronics (CE) device mesh networks. A system herein may include server and client components, connected over a network such that data may be exchanged between the client and server components. The client components may include one or more computing devices including portable televisions (e.g. smart TVs, Internet-enabled TVs), portable computers such as laptops and tablet computers, and other mobile devices including smart phones and additional examples discussed below. These client devices may operate with a variety of operating environments. For example, some of the client computers may employ, as examples, operating systems from Microsoft, or a Unix operating system, or operating systems produced by Apple Computer or Google. These operating environments may be used to execute one or more browsing programs, such as a browser made by Microsoft or Google or Mozilla or other browser program that can access web applications hosted by the Internet servers discussed below. 
         [0022]    Servers and/or gateways may include one or more processors executing instructions that configure the servers to receive and transmit data over a network such as the Internet. Or, a client and server can be connected over a local intranet or a virtual private network. A server or controller may be instantiated by a game console such as a Sony Playstation (trademarked), a personal computer, etc. 
         [0023]    Information may be exchanged over a network between the clients and servers. To this end and for security, servers and/or clients can include firewalls, load balancers, temporary storages, and proxies, and other network infrastructure for reliability and security. One or more servers may form an apparatus that implement methods of providing a secure community such as an online social website to network members. 
         [0024]    As used herein, instructions refer to computer-implemented steps for processing information in the system. Instructions can be implemented in software, firmware or hardware and include any type of programmed step undertaken by components of the system. 
         [0025]    A processor may be any conventional general purpose single- or multi-chip processor that can execute logic by means of various lines such as address lines, data lines, and control lines and registers and shift registers. 
         [0026]    Software modules described by way of the flow charts and user interfaces herein can include various sub-routines, procedures, etc. Without limiting the disclosure, logic stated to be executed by a particular module can be redistributed to other software modules and/or combined together in a single module and/or made available in a shareable library. 
         [0027]    Present principles described herein can be implemented as hardware, software, firmware, or combinations thereof; hence, illustrative components, blocks, modules, circuits, and steps are set forth in terms of their functionality. 
         [0028]    Further to what has been alluded to above, logical blocks, modules, and circuits described below can be implemented or performed with a general purpose processor, a digital signal processor (DSP), a field programmable gate array (FPGA) or other programmable logic device such as an application specific integrated circuit (ASIC), discrete gate or transistor logic, discrete hardware components, or any combination thereof designed to perform the functions described herein. A processor can be implemented by a controller or state machine or a combination of computing devices. 
         [0029]    The functions and methods described below, when implemented in software, can be written in an appropriate language such as but not limited to C# or C++, and can be stored on or transmitted through a computer-readable storage medium such as a random access memory (RAM), read-only memory (ROM), electrically erasable programmable read-only memory (EEPROM), compact disk read-only memory (CD-ROM) or other optical disk storage such as digital versatile disc (DVD), magnetic disk storage or other magnetic storage devices including removable thumb drives, etc. A connection may establish a computer-readable medium. Such connections can include, as examples, hard-wired cables including fiber optics and coaxial wires and digital subscriber line (DSL) and twisted pair wires. Such connections may include wireless communication connections including infrared and radio. 
         [0030]    Components included in one embodiment can be used in other embodiments in any appropriate combination. For example, any of the various components described herein and/or depicted in the Figures may be combined, interchanged or excluded from other embodiments. 
         [0031]    “A system having at least one of A, B, and C” (likewise “a system having at least one of A, B, or C” and “a system having at least one of A, B, C”) includes systems that have A alone, B alone, C alone, A and B together, A and C together, B and C together, and/or A, B, and C together, etc. 
         [0032]    Now specifically referring to  FIG. 1 , an example ecosystem  10  is shown, which may include one or more of the example devices mentioned above and described further below in accordance with present principles. The first of the example devices included in the system  10  is a consumer electronics (CE) device configured as an example primary display device, and in the embodiment shown is an audio video display device (AVDD)  12  such as but not limited to an Internet-enabled TV with a TV tuner (equivalently, set top box controlling a TV). However, the AVDD  12  alternatively may be an appliance or household item, e.g. computerized Internet enabled refrigerator, washer, or dryer. The AVDD  12  alternatively may also be a computerized Internet enabled (“smart”) telephone, a tablet computer, a notebook computer, a wearable computerized device such as e.g. computerized Internet-enabled watch, a computerized Internet-enabled bracelet, other computerized Internet-enabled devices, a computerized Internet-enabled music player, computerized Internet-enabled head phones, a computerized Internet-enabled implantable device such as an implantable skin device, etc. Regardless, it is to be understood that the AVDD  12  is configured to undertake present principles (e.g. communicate with other CE devices to undertake present principles, execute the logic described herein, and perform any other functions and/or operations described herein). 
         [0033]    Accordingly, to undertake such principles the AVDD  12  can be established by some or all of the components shown in  FIG. 1 . For example, the AVDD  12  can include one or more displays  14  that may be implemented by a high definition or ultra-high definition “4K” or higher flat screen and that may be touch-enabled fbr receiving user input signals via touches on the display. The AVDD  12  may include one or more speakers  16  for outputting audio in accordance with present principles, and at least one additional input device  18  such as e.g. an audio receiver/microphone for e.g. entering audible commands to the AVDD  12  to control the AVDD  12 . The example AVDD  12  may also include one or more network interfaces  20  for communication over at least one network  22  such as the Internet, an WAN, an LAN, etc. under control of one or more processors  24 . Thus, the interface  20  may be, without limitation, a Wi-Fi transceiver, which is an example of a wireless computer network interface, such as but not limited to a mesh network transceiver. It is to be understood that the processor  24  controls the AVDD  12  to undertake present principles, including the other elements of the AVDD  12  described herein such as e.g. controlling the display  14  to present images thereon and receiving input therefrom. Furthermore, note the network interface  20  may be, e.g., a wired or wireless modem or router, or other appropriate interface such as, e.g., a wireless telephony transceiver, or Wi-Fi transceiver as mentioned above, etc. 
         [0034]    In addition to the foregoing, the AVDD  12  may also include one or more input ports  26  such as, e.g., a high definition multimedia interface (HDMI) port or a USB port to physically connect (e.g. using a wired connection) to another CE device and/or a headphone port to connect headphones to the AVDD  12  for presentation of audio from the AVDD  12  to a user through the headphones. For example, the input port  26  may be connected via wire or wirelessly to a cable or satellite source  26   a  of audio video content. Thus, the source  26   a  may be, e.g., a separate or integrated set top box, or a satellite receiver. Or, the source  26   a  may be a game console or disk player containing content that might be regarded by a user as a favorite for channel assignation purposes described further below. 
         [0035]    The AVDD  12  may further include one or more tangible computer readable storage medium  28  such as disk-based or solid state storage, in some cases embodied in the chassis of the AVDD as standalone devices or as a personal video recording device (PVR) or video disk player either internal or external to the chassis of the AVDD for playing back AV programs. Also in some embodiments, the AVDD  12  can include a position or location receiver such as but not limited to a cellphone receiver, GPS receiver and/or altimeter  30  that is configured to e.g. receive geographic position information from at least one satellite or cellphone tower and provide the information to the processor  24  and/or determine an altitude at which the AVDD  12  is disposed in conjunction with the processor  24 . However, it is to be understood that that another suitable position receiver other than a cellphone receiver, GPS receiver and/or altimeter may be used in accordance with present principles to e.g. determine the location of the AVDD  12  in e.g. all three dimensions. 
         [0036]    Continuing the description of the AVDD  12 , in some embodiments the AVDD  12  may include one or more cameras  32  that may be, e.g., a thermal imaging camera, a digital camera such as a webcam, and/or a camera integrated into the AVDD  12  and controllable by the processor  24  to gather pictures/images and/or video in accordance with present principles. Also included on the AVDD  12  may be a Bluetooth transceiver  34  and other Near Field Communication (NFC) element  36  for communication with other devices using Bluetooth and/or NFC technology, respectively. An example NFC element can be a radio frequency identification (RFID) element. 
         [0037]    Further still, the AVDD  12  may include one or more auxiliary sensors  37  (e.g., a motion sensor such as an accelerometer, gyroscope, cyclometer, or a magnetic sensor, an infrared (IR) sensor, an optical sensor, a speed and/or cadence sensor, a gesture sensor (e.g. for sensing gesture command), etc.) providing input to the processor  24 . The AVDD  12  may include an over-the-air TV broadcast port  38  for receiving OTH TV broadcasts providing input to the processor  24 . In addition to the foregoing, it is noted that the AVDD  12  may also include an infrared (IR) transmitter and/or IR receiver and/or IR transceiver  42  such as an IR data association (IRDA) device. A battery (not shown) may be provided for powering the AVDD  12 . 
         [0038]    Still referring to  FIG. 1 , in addition to the AVDD  12 , the system  10  may include one or more other CE device types. In one example, a first CE device  44  may be used to control the display via commands sent through the below-described server while a second CE device  46  may include similar components as the first CE device  44  and hence will not be discussed in detail. In the example shown, only two CE devices  44 ,  46  are shown, it being understood that fewer or greater devices may be used. 
         [0039]    In the example shown, to illustrate present principles all three devices  12 ,  44 ,  46  are assumed to be members of an entertainment network in, e.g., a home, or at least to be present in proximity to each other in a location such as a house. However, for present principles are not limited to a particular location, illustrated by dashed lines  48 , unless explicitly claimed otherwise. 
         [0040]    The example non-limiting first CE device  44  may be established by any one of the above-mentioned devices, for example, a portable wireless laptop computer or notebook computer, and accordingly may have one or more of the components described below. The second CE device  46  without limitation may be established by a video disk player such as a Blu-ray player, a game console, and the like. The first CE device  44  may be a remote control (RC) for, e.g., issuing AV play and pause commands to the AVDD  12 , or it may be a more sophisticated device such as a tablet computer, a game console, a personal computer, a wireless telephone, etc. 
         [0041]    Accordingly, the first CE device  44  may include one or more displays  50  that may be touch-enabled for receiving user input signals via touches on the display. The first CE device  44  may include one or more speakers  52  for outputting audio in accordance with present principles, and at least one additional input device  54  such as e.g. an audio receiver/microphone for e.g. entering audible commands to the first CE device  44  to control the device  44 . The example first CE device  44  may also include one or more network interfaces  56  for communication over the network  22  under control of one or more CE device processors  58 . Thus, the interface  56  may be, without limitation, a Wi-Fi transceiver, which is an example of a wireless computer network interface, including mesh network interfaces. It is to be understood that the processor  58  controls the first CE device  44  to undertake present principles, including the other elements of the first CE device  44  described herein such as e.g. controlling the display  50  to present images thereon and receiving input therefrom. Furthermore, note the network interface  56  may be, e.g., a wired or wireless modem or router, or other appropriate interface such as, e.g., a wireless telephony transceiver, or Wi-Fi transceiver as mentioned above, etc. 
         [0042]    In addition to the foregoing, the first CE device  44  may also include one or more input ports  60  such as, e.g., a HDMI port or a USB port to physically connect (e.g. using a wired connection) to another CE device and/or a headphone port to connect headphones to the first CE device  44  for presentation of audio from the first CE device  44  to a user through the headphones. The first CE device  44  may further include one or more tangible computer readable storage medium  62  such as disk-based or solid state storage. Also in some embodiments, the first CE device  44  can include a position or location receiver such as but not limited to a cellphone and/or GPS receiver and/or altimeter  64  that is configured to e.g. receive geographic position information from at least one satellite and/or cell tower, using triangulation, and provide the information to the CE device processor  58  and/or determine an altitude at which the first CE device  44  is disposed in conjunction with the CE device processor  58 . However, it is to be understood that that another suitable position receiver other than a cellphone and/or GPS receiver and/or altimeter may be used in accordance with present principles to e.g. determine the location of the first CE device  44  in e.g. all three dimensions. 
         [0043]    Continuing the description of the first CE device  44 , in some embodiments the first CE device  44  may include one or more cameras  66  that may be, e.g., a thermal imaging camera, a digital camera such as a webcam, and/or a camera integrated into the first CE device  44  and controllable by the CE device processor  58  to gather pictures/images and/or video in accordance with present principles. Also included on the first CE device  44  may be a Bluetooth transceiver  68  and other Near Field Communication (NFC) element  70  for communication with other devices using Bluetooth and/or NFC technology, respectively. An example NFC element can be a radio frequency identification (RFID) element. 
         [0044]    Further still, the first CE device  44  may include one or more auxiliary sensors  72  (e.g., a motion sensor such as an accelerometer, gyroscope, cyclometer, or a magnetic sensor, an infrared (IR) sensor, an optical sensor, a speed and/or cadence sensor, a gesture sensor (e.g. for sensing gesture command), etc.) providing input to the CE device processor  58 . The first CE device  44  may include still other sensors such as e.g. one or more climate sensors  74  (e.g. barometers, humidity sensors, wind sensors, light sensors, temperature sensors, etc.) and/or one or more biometric sensors  76  providing input to the CE device processor  58 . In addition to the foregoing, it is noted that in some embodiments the first CE device  44  may also include an infrared (IR) transmitter and/or IR receiver and/or IR transceiver  42  such as an IR data association (IRDA) device. A battery (not shown) may be provided for powering the first CE device  44 . The CE device  44  may communicate with the AVDD  12  through any of the above-described communication modes and related components. 
         [0045]    The second CE device  46  may include some or all of the components shown for the CE device  44 . 
         [0046]    Now in reference to the afore-mentioned at least one server  80 , it includes at least one server processor  82 , at least one tangible computer readable storage medium  84  such as disk-based or solid state storage, and at least one network interface  86  that, under control of the server processor  82 , allows for communication with the other devices of  FIG. 1  over the network  22 , and indeed may facilitate communication between servers and client devices in accordance with present principles. Note that the network interface  86  may be, e.g., a wired or wireless modem or router, Wi-Fi transceiver, or other appropriate interface such as, e.g., a wireless telephony transceiver. 
         [0047]    Accordingly, in some embodiments the server  80  may be an Internet server, and may include and perform “cloud” functions such that the devices of the system  10  may access a “cloud” environment via the server  80  in example embodiments. Or, the server  80  may be implemented by a game console or other computer in the same room as the other devices shown in  FIG. 1  or nearby. 
         [0048]    Now referring to  FIG. 2 , an AVDD)  200  that may incorporate some or all of the components of the AVDD  12  in  FIG. 1  is connected to at least one gateway for receiving content, e.g., UHD content such as 4K or 8K content, from the gateway. In the example shown, the AVDD  200  is connected to first and second satellite gateways  202 ,  204 , each of which may be configured as a satellite TV set top box for receiving satellite TV signals from respective satellite systems  206 ,  208  of respective satellite TV providers. 
         [0049]    In addition or in lieu of satellite gateways, the AVDD  200  may receive content from one or more cable IV set top box-type gateways  210 ,  212 , each of which receives content from a respective cable head end  214 ,  216 . 
         [0050]    Yet again, instead of set-top box like gateways, the AVDD  200  may receive content from a cloud-based gateway  220 . The cloud-based gateway  220  may reside in a network interface device that is local to the AVDD  200  (e.g., a modem of the AVDD  200 ) or it may reside in a remote internet server that sends Internet-sourced content to the AVDD  200 . In any case, the AVDD  200  may receive multimedia content such as UHD content from the Internet through the cloud-based gateway  220 . The gateways are computerized and thus may include appropriate components of any of the CE devices shown in  FIG. 1 . 
         [0051]    In some embodiments, only a single set top box-type gateway may be provided using, e.g., the present assignee&#39;s remote viewing user interface (RVU) technology. 
         [0052]    Tertiary devices may be connected, e.g., via Ethernet or universal serial bus (USB) or WiFi or other wired or wireless protocol to the AVDD  200  in a home network (that may be a mesh-type network) to receive content from the AVDD  200  according to principles herein. In the non-limiting example shown, a second TV  222  is connected to the AVDD  200  to receive content therefrom, as is a video game console  224 . Additional devices may be connected to one or more tertiary devices to expand the network. The tertiary devices may include appropriate components of any of the CE devices shown in  FIG. 1 . 
         [0053]    In an initial basic example, the AVDD  200  or one of the gateways shown in  FIG. 2  may receive user input to play UHD content. Typically, the user will have to possess a subscription to such content, as such content is typically considered to be high value. In any case, the gateway tunes to the selected UHD program, establishing, in this illustrative embodiment, a digital transmission content protocol (DTCP) connection with the AVDD  200 , if not already established. Both the AVDD  200  and gateway possess DTCP certificates which are checked by the opposite component (AVDD checks gateway certificate, gateway checks AVDD certificate) for revocation. Assuming neither certificate has been revoked, the gateway sends the content to the AVDD, which acts as a sink for the content, playing the content. 
         [0054]    In some embodiments, per protocol the AVDD  200  is programmed to not retransmit or record the content, and no high definition multimedia interface (HDMI) output may be permitted from the AVDD  200 . There may be no means provided to externally access compressed or decoded content from the AVDD  200 , and any Ethernet or USB interfaces may be disabled programmatically for audio-video content output from the AVDD  200  (although other outputs may be provided for). 
         [0055]    However, in other embodiments discussed herein, the AVDD  200  is permitted to send content to tertiary devices. As understood herein, however, it is possible that other devices to which the AVDD  200  may send content may not comply with content protection robustness requirements, leading to unauthorized dissemination of value content. As also understood herein, this problem is only partially addressed by DTCP, in part because the digital transmission licensing administrator (DTLA) certificate used in DTCP authentication does not contain the identity of the manufacturer of a device or model number information. Accordingly, as understood herein simply using the existing DTLA certificate cannot provide for the implementation of a “white list” of approved devices to manage content distribution downstream of an approved sink. 
         [0056]    With the above in mind, present principles provide for sending device attributes and/or device ID in a secure fashion for authentication purposes. In an example, the digital living network alliance (DLNA) commercial video profile (CVP)-2 authentication mechanism as modified herein may be used to implement a bit indicating compliance with relevant robustness standards, with the data payload being secured by a private encryption key of the device seeking authentication. Note that present principles may apply to the AVDD  200  seeking authentication with upstream components such as a gateway, and/or to tertiary devices seeking authentication to obtain content from a sink. Thus, for example, in  FIGS. 3-6  the client seeking authentication can be the sink, which can be the AVDD  200 , and the authenticating server can be the gateway  202 ; or, the client seeking authentication can be one of the tertiary devices  222 ,  224  and the component granting authentication may be the AVDD  200  acting alone or in concert with the gateway upstream. 
         [0057]    Among the device attributes that may be used are software version number (e.g., the version number of the HDCP software the device currently employs), time to last software update, version of HDCP protocol, HDCP device ID, version of digital rights management (DRM) protocol, DRM device ID, version of DTCP protocol, DTCP device ID, inclusion of a secure execution environment, storage capability, level of robustness, level of hardware robustness manufacturer, model number, device serial number, number of downstream connected devices, connection status to the Internet, decoding capability, screen resolution, screen size. Authentication may be triggered by a hypertext transfer protocol secure (https) link to an authentication server, and the authentication requirement may be conveyed in a “protocolInfo” message. 
         [0058]      FIG. 3  provides an illustration in which an added field  300  is added to a transport layer security (TLS) message  302  that supplements or that carries, for instance, a DTCP certificate. An opaque random byte  304  and random nonce  306  can be provided and encrypted using the private key of a device in a public key/private key encryption scheme. According to present principles, the field  300  may include an unsigned character string of, e.g., 16 bytes, which may be identical to one sent in a Universal plug-n-Play (UPnP) message and which may be a universally unique identifier (UUID) that uniquely identifies the device seeking authentication. The character string may be generated by a DTCP compliant sender that sends a dtcp_authentication message and used by a server (such as a gateway in  FIG. 2 ) to uniquely identify the requesting device regardless of the type of DTCP certificate also being used. The UUID in the field  300  may indicate manufacturer, model number, and device ID of the device. The TLS message  302  may also include one or more DTCP certificates  308 . 
         [0059]      FIGS. 4 and 5  are shown together to illustrate use of the data in  FIG. 3 . As illustrated in the non-limiting example of  FIG. 4 , a gateway  400  communicates via Ethernet or Wi-Fi with a sink  402 . Each component may access a respective data structure  404 ,  406  of DTCP revocation lists, listing DTCP certificates that have been revoked. Also exchanged between the gateway  400  and sink  402 , as indicated at  408 , is the message  302  of  FIG. 3 . As also shown in  FIG. 4 , the gateway  400  may access a white list data structure  410 , which is a list of individual devices authorized to receive content. Each entry in the white list  410  may include device manufacturer, model number, and device ID. 
         [0060]    At  500  in  FIG. 5 , the message  302  is indicated as being sent from the sink to the gateway. At  502  the gateway accesses the white list  410  to determine, based on the field  300  in  FIG. 3 , whether the sink is on the white list. If it is, the sink passes a first check; otherwise, the sink is not accorded access to the requested content. 
         [0061]    The gateway can also determine, at  504 , whether the sink&#39;s DTCP certificate received in the DTCP authentication protocol is the same as the certificate received in the TLS message  302 . If both tests (at  502  and  504 ) pass, the gateway determines that the sink is authorized to receive content. If either test fails, the sink may not be accorded access to the content. 
         [0062]    The above process is shown in greater detail in  FIG. 6 . In  FIG. 6 , “UI Client”, “DTCP Lib”, and “AuthClient” are local software routines executed by the client device seeking authentication, e.g., the sink or a tertiary device connected to the sink, while “AuthServer” is a routine executed by the component granting access, e.g., the gateway. 
         [0063]    At  600  a user, through a user interface (UI) presented on the client, may select content for play, which initiates an authentication request. At  602  the client and server may announce to each other their mutual support for the TLS supplemental data messaging extension described above by exchanging messages to that effect. 
         [0064]    At  604 , the server can send a supplemental data message that can be DTCP-signed and that may include a random number (noncel), the server&#39;s DTCP Certificate (which can be assumed to be present, but which is optional), the server&#39;s public key, which may be sent by way of sending the server&#39;s so-called X.509 Certificate, which may be self-signed if the DTCP certificate used). 
         [0065]    At  606  the client confirms (validates) the server&#39;s signature using the public key of the server&#39;s DTCP Certificate. In this way, the client knows it is communicating with a bona fide server. Also, if desired at  608  the server sends to the client a TLS message including the DTCP certificate, session key exchange (SKE) field, a certificate request (CR), and a server hello done (SHD) indication. 
         [0066]    At  610  it is merely indicated that if the client fails to authenticate the server, an error message to that effect may be presented on a display of the client. At  612  it is indicated that a determination has made that the server&#39;s DTCP verification has successfully passed. 
         [0067]    At  614  the client sends to the server a supplemental data message that is signed by the DTCP signature of the client. The supplemental data message includes the original random number (noncel) sent at  604 , the client&#39;s DTCP certificate (with the conformance bit set and/or Make/Model # of the field  300  in  FIG. 3 ), the device manufacturer TD, device model number, and other data as desired. At  615  the server verifies, using the data sent at  614 , that the client DTCP certificate is not revoked, the client DTCP certificate contains the “conformance bit” (and Manufacturer/Model number if used), and that the manufacturer/model number is in the white list. The signature validates the public key of the client&#39;s DTCP certificate. As mentioned above, the DTCP certificate used with authentication is also the same one used for link protection. To prevent a man-in-the-middle attack, a TLS tunnel is established between the client and server at  616  and then the above-described sequence repeats inside the TLS tunnel at  618 - 629  (using a different nonce, i.e., using “nonce 2” instead of “nonce 1”), with authentication success being indicated on the client at  630 . 
         [0068]    Further aspects are shown in  FIGS. 7 and 8 . Commencing at block  700  in  FIG. 7 , the gateway provides the above-described white list of approved devices to the sink. At block  702  the sink receives a request from a tertiary device for content. The request may contain a manufacturer ID, model number, and device ID, as well as one or more device attributes. At decision diamond  704 , using the manufacturer ID in combination with the model number and/or device ID, the sink accesses the white list to determine whether the tertiary device is on the list. If it is not, the logic may proceed to  FIG. 8 . 
         [0069]    However, if the tertiary device is on the white list, the logic may move to decision diamond  706  to determine whether one or more device attributes received at block  702  matches one or more respective expected criterion of the device as indicated by the entry for that device in the white list or other associated data structure. In one implementation, when multiple device attributes are used, all must match with respective expected criteria for a positive test result to be returned and access to content on the sink provided to the tertiary device at block  708 . In another implementation, when multiple device attributes are used, fewer than all must match with respective expected criteria for a positive test result to be returned and access to content on the sink provided to the tertiary device at block  708 . 
         [0070]    Without limitation the expected criterion may be selected to be one or more of the following: software version number (e.g., HDCP version being used by the tertiary device), time to last software update, minimum version of HDCP protocol, minimum version of DRM protocol, minimum version of DTCP protocol, inclusion of a secure execution environment, inclusion of storage capability, minimum level of robustness, and minimum level of hardware robustness, manufacturer, model number, maximum number of downstream connected devices. 
         [0071]    In the event that at decision diamond  706  a device attribute does not match a relevant expected criterion associated with the device, the logic may move to block  710 . At block  710  the sink may command the tertiary device to present a UI on the tertiary device prompting a user to take appropriate action. For example, if the device attribute is a software version of HDCP (e.g., HDCP 1.0) that does not match an expected HDCP version for the device as indicated in the white list (e.g., HDCP 2.2), the prompt may be to upgrade the software, and consequently, the HDCP version, of the tertiary device. Or, at block  710  the sink may cause the updated software version to be automatically pushed to the tertiary device. Note that the logic of  FIGS. 7 and 8  may be employed by the gateway to validate the sink, with the gateway playing the role of “sink” in  FIGS. 7 and 8  and the sink playing the role of “tertiary device” in  FIGS. 7 and 8 . 
         [0072]    In an example implementation of  FIG. 8 , an algorithm is presented for dynamically updating the white list such that the mesh network of  FIG. 2  self-heals by adding appropriately vetted devices to the white list. Commencing at decision diamond  800 , the sink determines whether the tertiary device is from a trusted source. e.g., whether the tertiary device is made by a manufacturer known to be trusted. This determination may be made based on comparing the manufacturer ID or other information received at block  702  in  FIG. 7  against a list of trusted sources. If the device is not from a trusted source, the logic may end at state  802 , but if the device is from a trusted source, the logic may flow to block  804  to gather information from the device, e.g., its device ID, model number, and device attributes. 
         [0073]    Proceeding to block  806 , the sink adds the device information gathered at block  804  as a new entry to the white list. At block  808  the white list is pushed upstream, in the example shown, to the gateway, which in turn may push the updated white list to the Internet for dissemination to other gateways. At block  810  updated white list versions may be received at the sink from upstream, i.e., from the gateway, as received by the gateway from white list sources upstream of the gateway. 
         [0074]    In the event that a tertiary device such as a game console supports both HDCP 1.0 for legacy TV and new HDCP 2.0 for new TVs, the distributed white list can cause to be disabled or otherwise turned off HDCP 1.0 forever in the game console, or for just certain content. In any case, the device that has the newest or latest white list distributes the white list to other devices. 
         [0075]    The above methods may be implemented as software instructions executed by a processor, suitably configured application specific integrated circuits (ASIC) or field programmable gate array (FPGA) modules, or any other convenient manner as would be appreciated by those skilled in those art. Where employed, the software instructions may be embodied in a non-transitory device such as a CD Rom or Flash drive. The software code instructions may alternatively be embodied in a transitory arrangement such as a radio or optical signal, or via a download over the internet. 
         [0076]    It will be appreciated that whilst present principals have been described with reference to some example embodiments, these are not intended to be limiting, and that various alternative arrangements may be used to implement the subject matter claimed herein.