Abstract:
An automated process (and system) for facilitating the creation of a frame based knowledge tree for use with a configuration system is provided. In accordance with a preferred embodiment, a database induction module interacts with a user interface and a vendor provided database containing product information in the form of database files. The user sets induction preferences via a graphical user interface, and the induction module accesses product information from the client database files and automatically generates a frame based product knowledge tree in light of the user&#39;s preferences, where the frame based product knowledge tree is intended for use with a configuration system for configuring certain desired products, services, or other assemblages.

Description:
REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS  
       [0001]     This application is related to U.S. patent application Ser. No. 09/684,907, filed Oct. 10, 2000, which is hereby incorporated by reference in its entirety. 
     
    
     BACKGROUND  
       [0002]     The growing trend of mass customization in the manufacturing community has accentuated the importance of configuration systems. Configuration systems facilitate the configuration of desired products, services, or other assemblages that require users to gather and assimilate disparate knowledge of makes, models, types, features, options, limitations, manufacturing constraints, etc. of a desired product/service (or group of the same) to be configured. In the manufacturing sector, for example, a configuration system can reconcile the complexities involved with configuring customizable products that conform to certain known manufacturing constraints. Through the use of configuration systems, a user can identify any potential manufacturing problems prior to the expenditure of funds.  
         [0003]     Typically, configuration is facilitated through interaction by a user, via a user interface, with an inference engine that performs, for example, frame-based inferences to discern product knowledge stored in a knowledge base. The creation of the knowledge base containing the disparate product knowledge involves acquiring the product knowledge from numerous sources and encoding that knowledge using graphical user interface (GUI) tools.  
         [0004]     Such GUI tools allow the user (typically, a knowledge engineer) to model the product knowledge in a tree like structure where each node of the tree is known as a frame. The attributes that describe and specialize the frame are represented using slots. The node at each level in a tree inherits properties from its parent node(s) and allows the user to override, extend or specialize these properties at the current level. The level in a tree at which certain attributes are placed depends on the generality of those attributes. For example, attributes that are common to a number of configurable items are placed closer to the top of the tree. Attributes that specialize a configurable item are placed at the lower levels of the tree. This process of creating a frame based knowledge tree is called the product knowledge design process and is implemented by knowledge engineers.  
         [0005]     Typically, the process of creating a frame based knowledge tree includes the creation of product information files by acquiring the product knowledge from various product experts. These experts can include pricing experts, manufacturing process experts, product specification experts, customer service experts, etc. The process of amassing the disparate product knowledge, organizing that knowledge in some predetermined hierarchical system, and creating a frame based knowledge tree is very time consuming, cost intensive and requires the coordination of several individuals.  
       SUMMARY  
       [0006]     A method for and apparatus for facilitating the creation of a frame based knowledge tree for use with a configuration system is provided. In accordance with a preferred embodiment, a database induction module interacts with a user interface and a customer-provided product database containing product information. The user sets induction preferences via the GUI, and the induction module accesses product information from the client database files and automatically generates a frame based knowledge tree in light of the user&#39;s preferences. 
     
    
     BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS  
       [0007]      FIG. 1  is a block diagram illustrating a database induction system in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention;  
         [0008]      FIG. 2  is a screen shot of an exemplary graphical user interface used in the  FIG. 1  database induction system in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention;  
         [0009]      FIG. 3  is an exemplary illustration of a flowchart depicting an operational flow of the  FIG. 1  database induction system in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention;  
         [0010]      FIG. 4  is an exemplary illustration of a frame tree of domain knowledge specifications in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention;  
         [0011]      FIG. 5  is an exemplary illustration of a frame tree constructed based on responses to SQL queries run during generation of a frame based knowledge tree in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention; and  
         [0012]      FIG. 6  is an exemplary illustration of a frame based knowledge tree constructed in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. 
     
    
     DETAILED DESCRIPTION  
       [0013]     Preferred embodiments and applications of the invention will be described herein. Other embodiments may be realized and structural or logical changes may be made to the embodiments without departing from the spirit or scope of the invention. Although certain embodiments disclosed herein have been particularly described as applied to a knowledge base for specific exemplary products (e.g., plumbing supplies), it should be readily apparent that the invention may be embodied to create a knowledge base for any number of products, services or the like.  
         [0014]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention, a database induction process for creating a frame based knowledge tree is implemented using a processor-based system that may be supported in a stand-alone, networked, mainframe, or client-server architecture. A single (or multiple) program memory module is provided for storing one or more computer programs used to perform the functionality described herein.  
         [0015]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment, one or more user interfaces are provided as part of (or in conjunction with) the database induction process to permit users to interact with one or more vendor databases and also with an induction module. Individual ones of a plurality of client devices (e.g., network/stand-alone computers, personal digital assistants (PDAs), WebTV (or other Internet-only) terminals, set-top boxes, cellular/PCS phones, screenphones, pagers, kiosks, or other known (wired or wireless) communication devices, etc.) may similarly be used to execute one or more computer programs (e.g., universal Internet browser programs, dedicated interface programs, etc.) to allow users to interface with the vendor databases and the induction module.  
         [0016]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment, a user (e.g., knowledge engineer, etc.) of the database induction process interacts with the system to create a frame based knowledge tree. The interaction with the system is preferably through a series of questions provided by the system with input answers provided by the user. The system may, however, support a variety of other methods of interaction (e.g., command driven, menu driven, script, etc.)  
         [0017]      FIG. 1  illustrates in block diagram form, a database induction system (and preferred apparatus for performing a process) in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. The system preferably contains a user interface  100  for enabling the user to interact with an induction module  120 , in accordance with induction settings  115  specified by the user, and also for interacting with a database access module  125  enabling the system to access a client database  105 . In accordance with a preferred embodiment, the induction settings are also stored in memory (not shown) by the interface  100  as saved induction settings  110  for future use.  
         [0018]     The database access module  125  interacts with the vendor database  105  to receive the disparate product knowledge that is to be inducted in the generated knowledge tree. The induction module  120  is preferably coupled to the product knowledge output module  130 , where the generated knowledge tree is configured as product knowledge files for use, for example, with a product configuration system.  
         [0019]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment, the vendor of the product(s) to be configured provides the user (e.g., the knowledge engineer) with at least one database table representing specific information about the product(s) (e.g., plumbing supplies). Below, four such database tables (TABLES 1-4) are described; however, the first table (TABLE 1) contains the data that is essential to the construction of the knowledge tree. Further, the vendor need not actively provide the database table(s) to the user, but, rather, the vendor need only make the underlying data for the table(s) available to the user via the client database  105 .  
         [0020]     With reference to TABLE 1, a data table is depicted as containing product catalog data (e.g., product specifications) for a given category of product where each column represents a different attribute (e.g., diameter, length, material, finish, etc.) for the category of product (e.g., pipes), and where each row in the table describes up to four different attribute values such that each row describes a different product. If a certain product attribute is not applicable for a certain product, the attribute value is left blank. While TABLE 1 depicts product data for three different products, it should be readily understood that many more rows and/or columns may be used to describe as many different product attributes and attribute values as are necessary for a given product category. Further, in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention, the user may update such data tables representing a vendor&#39;s single product line and/or multiple product lines.  
                                 TABLE 1                           Data Table            Product   Product               Attribute 1   Attribute 2   Product Attribute 3   Product Attribute 4               Attribute Value 1   Attribute   Attribute Value 13   Attribute Value 14           Value 12       Attribute Value 2   Attribute   Attribute Value 23   Attribute Value 24           Value 22       Attribute Value 3   Attribute   Attribute Value 33   Attribute Value 34           Value 32                  
 
         [0021]     With reference to TABLE 2, a frame table is depicted as maintaining items of similar type made by multiple vendors or multiple product lines from the same vendor. This table can be generated by the user to force all vendors of a particular product category (e.g., pipes, valves, etc.) to have the same top-level attributes (e.g., diameter, material, length, finish, etc.) for their respective products. The frame table can also be generated by the vendors who each have multiple product lines and want all the product lines to have common top level attributes (e.g., where such products are standardized in the given industry).  
                                 TABLE 2                           Frame Table            UNIQUE ID   Product Category 1   Product Category 2   Table Name               1   Category 1   Category 12   Product-table-1       2   Category 2   Category 22   Product-table-2       3   Category 3   Category 32   Product-table-3                  
 
         [0022]     Each row of the frame table, for example, is assigned a unique identification and is associated with a different product category and also with a different product data table (e.g., such as TABLE 1) containing a unique set of product attributes and values for the associated product category. The columns labeled Product Category 1 and Product Category 2 can represent the same category of product as supplied by two different vendors or different categories by the same vendor. The two product categories of row 1, for example, although supplied by two different vendors, may have common attributes as listed on Product-table-1. Of course, the frame table may have as many rows and/or columns as are necessary for a given application. Further, in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention, the user may update the frame table product lines (e.g., as vendors change).  
         [0023]     With reference to TABLE 3, a question repository table is depicted. The question repository table contains a list of questions generally asked in a particular industry to describe a certain product in a given product category. The underlying data for the question repository table is supplied by the vendor since the vendor is most familiar with the specific questions a customer will ask in order to arrive at a specific product. In addition, the vendor may choose to add or delete questions as required to describe their product differently. Each row contains a separate question, where the Question ID column contains the unique value by which the question is identified. Further, the Question Title, Question Description and Question Prompt headings are self-explanatory and respectively describe those other attributes of a particular question.  
         [0024]      FIG. 2  illustrates a typical screen shot of a user interface  100  implemented with a graphical user interface (GUI). The questions addressing product attributes to be included on the knowledge tree, which are stored by the question repository table, appear in display portions  200  of the GUI in order to prompt the knowledge engineer during interactive knowledge tree construction, as will be described more fully below.  
                                     TABLE 3                           Question Repository Table            UNIQUE       Question   Question           ID   Question ID   Title   Description   Question Prompt               1   CATEGORY   Category   This column   Please select your                   contains the   category                   question                   category                    
         [0025]     With reference to TABLE 4, a question linking table is depicted as containing references to the frame table (TABLE 2), the question repository table (TABLE 3), and the product data table (TABLE 1). The underlying data for this table, as with TABLES 1-3, is preferably provided by the vendor in order to facilitate the creation of the frame based knowledge tree; however, this table is not necessary to practice this illustrated embodiment of the invention. In fact, the only table necessary for practicing the illustrated embodiment of the invention is TABLE 1, the product data table. TABLES 2-4 facilitate the process of automatic knowledge tree construction but are not absolutely necessary to do so. Further, with regard to the product data table, the product data need not be presented in a single database table in order to practice this illustrated embodiment of the invention, but rather, the product data may be in the form of a plurality of database tables made accessible by the vendor, or in a plurality of tables that follow a relational schema.  
                                 TABLE 4                           Question Linking Table                    Question-table-   Column-       UNIQUE ID   Frame-table-id   unique id   name/Column-id               1   1   1   Product Attribute 1                  
 
         [0026]     Referring back to  FIG. 1 , the induction module  120  receives the product information from the vendor&#39;s database  105 , including the information depicted above at TABLES 1-4, via database access module  125 . In one embodiment, an interactive (i.e., manual) knowledge tree construction may be utilized, where the user interface  100  prompts the user with a series of questions requiring the user to select from a list of product attributes, the answers to which determine the order, and manner in which the attributes are added to the frame based knowledge tree. In another embodiment, automatic construction (described below) may be utilized, where the process of knowledge tree construction is automatic based on user specified generalization and optimization criteria.  
         [0027]     Referring again to  FIG. 2 , an exemplary screen shot of a GUI is depicted in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. The user may set his preferences, including generalization and optimization criteria, via the  FIG. 2  GUI. One example of a user preference may be the number of rows in a compound slot. The user is presented with a series of screens for completing the optimization process. In the series of screens, the user reviews the database tables present in the vendor&#39;s database and selects those database tables required for the database induction process (e.g., TABLES 1-4) of the product(s) of interest.  
         [0028]     Once the system has identified the necessary database tables for interactive construction, the user is presented with a list of product attributes (e.g., diameter, material, length, finish, etc.). For more simple projects, a knowledgeable user can interactively construct the knowledge tree based on the product attributes by selecting them in the order with which they are to be added to the knowledge tree. For more complex projects, the user may let the system construct the knowledge tree automatically based on the product data table(s) or can do a combination of both. For example, with reference to  FIG. 2 , the user may specify at portion  205  a threshold number of rows in a compound slot based on which the induction module  120  shifts from interactive to automatic knowledge tree construction.  
         [0029]     For interactively constructing the tree, the user selects the attributes from an attribute list displayed in the user interface at display portions  200 ,  201 . Each attribute selected by the user serves to further split the knowledge tree into separate nodes, where each node may be further split into additional nodes. The following SQL query may be used to display the attribute list at display portions  200 ,  205 :  
         [0030]     “SELECT QUESTIONID FROM QUESTION_REPOSITORY-TABLE WHERE FRAME-TABLE.PKTABLENAME=USER_DEFINED_TABLE AND QUESTION_LINKING_TABLE.FRAME-TABLE-ID=FRAME_TABLE.UNIQUE_ID AND QUESTION_LINKING_TABLE.UNIQUE_ID=QUESTION_REPOSITORYTABLE.UNIQUE_ID.” 
         [0031]     It should be readily apparent that the SQL query is generic and may be tailored to a specific application and for specific database names.  
         [0032]     For each attribute selected by the user, the induction module  120  queries the vendor database tables for unique values associated with that attribute. For example, where the attribute is color, unique values may be blue, red and green. In another example, where the attribute is shape, the unique values may be circle, square, rectangle, etc. The unique value dataset for each attribute forms the branches of the resultant knowledge tree (e.g., as depicted at  FIG. 6  below).  
         [0033]     Preferably, in the case of automatic frame tree construction, the induction module  120  (as opposed to the user in the interactive construction) determines the order in which the attributes appear in the knowledge tree. For determining the order, the induction module  120  uses the following generalization and optimization heuristics: 1) domain knowledge; and 2) count of distinct attribute values.  
         [0034]     The domain knowledge heuristic is premised on the fact that for a given product or product type, any number of vendors within a given domain will have the same attributes for the same type of product. For example, where the product type is pipes, it is known in the art of plumbing supplies that many vendors will have identified a given pipe at least by diameter and material. In this example, diameter and material are used to split the tree twice. Therefore, at least the first two nodes of the knowledge tree may be pre-specified based on the domain knowledge.  FIG. 4  depicts a default frame tree construction for a domain knowledge specification. In this example, there are two nodes  400 ,  405  (feature frame  1 , feature frame  2 ) where each node is an attribute of the product. Each attribute further respectively includes a plurality of unique values  410 ,  415 . Of course, the domain knowledge approach may be used to pre-specify any number of attributes common to a given type of product. The construction of any additional nodes on the knowledge tree beyond the domain knowledge specification may be carried out, for example, by the induction module  120 .  
         [0035]     The count of distinct attribute values option allows the user to specify the number of distinct values used for determining the level at which the attribute appears in the knowledge tree. For example, the user may specify that any attribute having greater than five unique values should be located near the top of the knowledge tree, or, conversely, perhaps such an attribute should be included near the bottom of the knowledge tree. Further, the user has the ability to combine domain knowledge with count of distinct attribute values. If the user selects this option, whenever a conflict exists between the two, the domain knowledge takes precedence over count of distinct attribute values. A (user-changeable) default value is set for the count of distinct attribute values. The following SQL query may be used to determine the count of distinct values:  
         [0036]     “SELECT COLUMN_NAME FROM ATTRIBUTE TABLE GROUP BY COLUMN_NAME.” 
         [0037]     Still referring to automatic knowledge tree construction, based on the user specified criteria, the induction module  120  parses through the vendor&#39;s database tables to induct the attributes that fall under each of the frame nodes. As described above, the induction module  120  uses the above-described generalization and optimization heuristics to determine which of the attributes need to be inducted at or near the top of the tree and which attributes fall towards the bottom.  
         [0038]      FIG. 3  illustrates a method or process in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. The process may be performed by any of a variety of apparatuses or systems. For convenience, the process will be described as being performed by the database induction system illustrated in  FIG. 1 , in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. The process begins at segment  300  and at segment  305 , the induction module  120  determines whether there are any attributes to induct from the vendor&#39;s database tables. If there are none, the process ends at segment  315 . However, if the induction module  120  determines there are attributes to induct (e.g., the database tables have not yet been exhausted of attributes), then at segment  310 , the induction module  120  determines whether the user has specified any splitting attributes, such as, for example, in connection with interactive frame tree construction. If the user has specified splitting attributes, then the module  120  queries the vendor&#39;s database tables for unique values associated with that new node at segment  340 . At segment  345 , for each unique value found in the database tables, the module  120  creates a new child node and the process returns to segment  305 .  
         [0039]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment, the knowledge tree may be made up of several nodes where each node is represented by a frame. Each frame contains a set of attributes that specializes the frame. Each frame may also have any number (e.g., 0, 1, 2, 3, etc.) of child frames. The attributes for each frame are called “slots.” There are three different types of slots.  
         [0040]     A first type of slot is known as a “single slot.” A single slot contains a single attribute and one or more values (e.g., diameter, and ½ inch, ¾ inch, 1 inch). This value(s)-attribute pair specializes the frame.  
         [0041]     A second type of slot is a “compound slot.” A compound slot is used to specialize a frame with attributes that depend on each other. The compound slot contains two or more dependent attributes and combinations of values of these attributes that would define a valid configuration.  
         [0042]     A third type of slot is a “conditional slot.” A conditional slot is used to decide which of several frame sub-trees to include in the configuration. The conditional slots are designed based on the value of the conditional attribute.  
         [0043]     If at segment  310 , it is determined that there are no user-specified attributes to be added, then at segment  320 , the induction module  120  queries the vendor&#39;s database tables for all remaining attributes to be inducted. The induction module  120  then determines, at segment  325 , whether the number of attributes remaining is less than a pre-specified threshold number. If the number is less than the threshold, then a compound slot is created at segment  335 , and the process returns to segment  305 .  
         [0044]     If it is determined at segment  325  that the number of attributes remaining is not less than the pre-specified threshold number, then the induction module  120  conducts automatic splitting based on the generalization and optimization heuristics described above (i.e., domain knowledge, count of distinct attribute values, or a combination of both). The induction module  120  then queries the vendor&#39;s database tables for unique values at segment  340  and creates a new node for each such unique value at segment  345 .  
         [0045]     An exemplary implementation of a database induction process in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention is explained in greater detail below in connection with TABLES 1A-4A, and also in connection with  FIGS. 5 and 6 . TABLES 1A-4A respectively depict a product data table, a frame table, a question repository table, and a question linking table, each containing exemplary vendor data.  
         [0046]     TABLE 1A is an exemplary product data table that contains specific product data for eight different products. Each row defines a separate product. Each of the eight products have features that fall under the same three attributes. In this example, the first attribute is color, the second attribute is size and the third attribute is shape. For example, the first product listed is red, is small and is in the shape of a circle. The second product listed is blue, is small and is in the shape of a square, and so on.  
                             TABLE 1A                           Product Data Table            Product-Attribute1   Product-Attribute2   Product-Attribute3               Red   Small   Circle       Blue   Small   Square       Green   Small   Rectangle       Red   Medium   Circle       Blue   Medium   Rectangle       Red   Large   Circle       Blue   Large   Rectangle       Green   Large   Square                  
 
         [0047]     TABLE 2A is a frame table, which as described above, maintains items of similar type made by multiple vendors or multiple categories by the same vendor. In this example, however, only one such vendor is listed where the product data table is identified as being Product-table-1 (i.e., TABLE 1A).  
                             TABLE 2A                           Frame Table            Unique ID   Product-Category1   Table Name               1   Widgets1   Product-table-1                  
 
         [0048]     TABLE 3A depicts a question repository table as containing all of the questions that are generally asked in a particular industry to describe a certain product. In this example, three such questions are asked, one addressing a different attribute of the product (i.e., Color, Size and Shape).  
                                     TABLE 3A                           Question Repository Table            Unique   Question       Question           ID   ID   Question Title   Description   Question Prompt               1   COLOR   Color   Contains Color   Please select your                       color       2   SIZE   Size   Contains Size   Please select your                       size       3   SHAPE   Shape   Contains Shape   Please select your                       shape                  
 
         [0049]     TABLE 4A depicts an exemplary question linking table as containing references to the frame table (TABLE 2A), the question repository table (TABLE 3A), and the product data table (TABLE 1A). TABLE 4A also contains a column that refers to the specific Attribute of the product data table that is associated with each respective question.  
                                 TABLE 4A                           Question Linking Table            Unique ID   Frame-table-id   Question-table-id   Column-name/Column-id               1   1   1   Product-Attribute1       2   1   2   Product-Attribute2       3   1   3   Product-Attribute3                  
 
         [0050]     In accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention, the induction module  120  parses through the vendor&#39;s database tables and identifies the set of SQL queries that require responses in order for the frame based knowledge tree to be constructed. With reference to  FIG. 5 , an exemplary frame tree is depicted. The frame tree is made up of SQL queries that need to be run in order to organize the data from the vendor&#39;s database tables into an automatically constructed product knowledge tree (e.g., such as is depicted below at  FIG. 6 ).  
         [0051]     Referring back to the exemplary product data table (TABLE 1A), one attribute of the product is color, where there are three unique values for that attribute (i.e., Blue, Green and Red). Nodes  500 ,  505  and  510  exemplify the respective responses to the SQL queries regarding the product color.  
         [0052]     Referring back to TABLE 1A, a second attribute of the product is size, where there are three unique values for that attribute (i.e., Large, Medium and Small). Child nodes of node  500  are depicted as nodes  515 ,  520  and  525 , where each of these nodes address the question of the product&#39;s size. Each of nodes  515 ,  520  and  525  inherit all attributes of the parent node  500 .  
         [0053]     Referring back to TABLE 1A, a third attribute of the product is shape, where there is only one possible unique value for shape where the color is blue and the size is small; that shape is square. A child node of node  525  is depicted as node  530 , where this node addresses the question of product shape. Node  530  inherits all attributes from parent nodes  525  and  500 ; therefore, node  530  already addresses the attributes of color and size.  
         [0054]     Referring now to  FIG. 6 , an exemplary frame based knowledge tree is depicted in accordance with a preferred embodiment of the invention. Once all relevant attributes from the vendor&#39;s database tables (e.g., TABLES 1A-4A) have been inducted by the induction module  102  (of  FIG. 1 ) either interactively or automatically, the  FIG. 6  knowledge tree is the end result. The particular construction of the knowledge tree can change from that depicted in  FIG. 6  based on the specific preferences entered by the user (e.g., at the  FIG. 2  GUI), including whether the user selects interactive construction or automatic construction; and for automatic construction, whether the user selects the domain knowledge or the distinct attribute values count heuristic approach.  
         [0055]     As depicted in  FIG. 6 , and with reference to TABLE 1A, the products are identified according to three distinct attributes; color, size and shape, where each of these attributes is respectively represented by nodes of the knowledge tree. For example, the color attribute contains three distinct values; blue, red and green, where each value is represented by a separate node  600 ,  610 ,  620 . Slots  605 ,  615  and  625  are respectively associated with nodes  600 ,  610  and  620  and define the unique value of the associated node.  
         [0056]     In the case of the interactive creation of the knowledge tree, the user&#39;s response to the prompt regarding the color attribute, that appears at screen  200  of the  FIG. 2  GUI, splits the knowledge tree into three different frames  600 ,  610  and  620 , off of the root frame. In the case of automatic creation of the knowledge tree, the induction module  102  identifies the three different values for the color attribute and automatically splits the knowledge tree without further input from the user.  
         [0057]     Still referring to  FIG. 6 , there are three child nodes  630 ,  640 ,  650  of node  600 . Each of the nodes  630 ,  640 ,  650  inherits all attributes of the parent node  600 . Accordingly, in this example, each of nodes  630 ,  640 ,  650  has the attribute color blue. The nodes respectively contain additional attributes to size, where node  630  contains attributes blue and large, and where node  640  contains attributes blue and medium, and where node  650  contains attributes blue and small. Further, slots  635 ,  645  and  655  respectively define the values of the attributes of nodes  630 ,  640  and  650 .  
         [0058]     Still further, node  650  contains one child node  660  which inherits all attributes of its parent nodes  650 ,  600 . Accordingly, in this example, node  660  has the attribute color blue and the attribute size small and the attribute shape square. Slot  665  defines the value of node  660 . The same process is followed to complete the construction of frame  600  as well as for the other two frames  610 ,  620 .  
         [0059]     Once the  FIG. 6  knowledge tree is constructed, the product knowledge output module  130  converts the frame based knowledge tree to product knowledge files for use with a configuration system, as is known in the art.  
         [0060]     The modules described herein (e.g.,  120 ,  125 ,  130 ) particularly those illustrated or inherent in the instant disclosure, may be one or more hardware, software, or hybrid components residing in (or distributed among) one or more local or remote computer systems. Although the modules are shown or described as physically separated components, it should be readily apparent that the modules may be combined or further separated into a variety of different components, sharing different resources (including processing units, memory, clock devices, software routines, etc.) as required for the particular implementation of the embodiments disclosed herein. Indeed, even a single general purpose computer executing a computer program stored on an article of manufacture (e.g., recording medium) to produce the functionality and any other memory devices referred to herein may be utilized to implement the illustrated embodiments. User interface devices may be any device used to input and/or output information. The user interface device may be implemented as a GUI containing a display or the like (such as, e.g.,  FIG. 2 ), or may be a link to other user input/output devices known in the art. Discrete functionality of the system may be separated (logically or physically) to more efficiently operate the system.  
         [0061]     In addition, memory units described herein may be any one or more known storage devices (e.g., Random Access Memory (RAM), Read Only Memory (ROM), hard disk drive (HDD), floppy drive, zip drive, compact disk-ROM, DVD, bubble memory, etc.), and may also be one or more memory devices embedded within a processor, or shared with one or more of the other components. The computer programs or algorithms described herein may easily be configured as one or more hardware modules, and the hardware modules shown may easily be configured as one or more software modules without departing from the invention. Accordingly, the invention is not limited by the foregoing description, drawings, or specific examples enumerated herein.