right the reason why this happens is because you want to encourage people to go here to earn more money right so so it's not like the government makes any money from the poor people independently of how it how high it taxes them but it is a basically an incentive structure to make them move over to the somewhat more productive population because here it's assumed kinda that even the lowest skilled ones can move over a bit if you just tax them enough at the low brackets right so um this this is what i find to be