would turn up and I got along with him very well he's a great thing yes I know about it he was very eclectic very very fluid in his thinking yes he he wasn't he wasn't dogmatic at all and he was just very interesting to is very interesting to learn from him and he would always take the students ideas seriously and always have something interesting to say about them he was never dismissive so that was the one for philosopher who I really appreciated then I got fed up with philosophy because it wasn't telling me what I