simply gradient descent on the parameters of the energy function so in a sense there are four things right there are these three inputs and then there are the parameters of the energy function if we're given any three of those four we can gradient descent on the rest and that's going to be the basis so the X here is going to be the so-called state and the state in this paper is going to be images of entities the entities sorry is not going to be images but the entities are these little circles that you're going to see and