generate this data they only had 2,000 labeled examples so a purely supervised discriminatory system really couldn't get that far and they actually were basically not performing much better than random and so what Roy was able to show is that well if you exploit tons more additional data which was available of like training on small short stories and then you use this model to score the endings so it just produces a single scalar which is like the ratio of the probabilities is sinky my trick that we talked about before but commuted for a