comments on the extent to which we think that they are similar which is that they're not particularly similar to the nips final copy just just for completeness however so I reacted to exactly these changes and then you did not comment it's not sure that you commented or reacted to these confrontations yeah so there are comments which you did not address and I think still think I would prefer to use my tutorial to teach about generative adversarial networks if people want to read about particularly memorization and