Patient case: 36-year-old female with Brugada syndrome; genetic feature: SCN5A

Clinical trial: Eastbourne Syncope Assessment Study II

Summary: Syncope (commonly called collapses or blackouts) is defined as loss of consciousness which is transient, self limiting and usually leads to falling.
  While the causes of syncope encompass a wide variety of factors, those due to heart rhythm abnormalities are acknowledged to be significantly more serious compared with other causes.
  The main aim of the study is to see if it is possible to find the cause of a patient's syncope faster using a device called an implantable loop recorder (ILR), which is implanted under the skin, versus conventional management. The device is slightly larger than a 50 pence coin and records the rhythm of the heart continuously.
  Although ILRs are being used widely today, we want to use a new model that is able to relay information to the doctor via wireless technology and internet.
  We also want to use ILRs earlier in diagnosing syncope, thereby avoiding unnecessary and lengthy hospital admissions and lowering cost.
  Primary aim: To see how soon the ILR detects abnormal heart rhythms or normal ones (in study subjects who faint/ suffer syncope).
  Secondary aims are:
  1. To see how soon treatment is started once the abnormal rhythm is detected by the ILR.
  2. To see which group (patients with ILRs or those receiving conventional tests) receives treatment sooner.
  3. To see which group has less subsequent collapses i.e has benefited from appropriate treatment sooner.
  4. To assess the cost effectiveness of using the implantable loop recorder more as a diagnostic tool for syncope versus conventional management (it should save many hospital admissions).

Detailed description: The original EaSyAS study (1998) evaluated the use of implantable loop recorders (ILRs) in the diagnosis and management of syncope.This demonstrated a significant increase in successful diagnosis following use of implantable loop recorders. Here there were 442 syncope admissions to Eastbourne in 2001. Diagnostic rate was 42%. In addition, time to diagnosis was quicker and therefore so was introduction of therapy. This resulted in significant increase in time to recurrent syncopal episodes and improved general wellbeing in an unselected population with syncope of an unknown cause.
  The "Post-EaSyAS" study evaluated extended (2.5 years) follow up of these patients. The "Tis-EaSyAS" study evaluated 3 different tilt protocols with long term ILR follow up describing the positive predictive value of tilt testing in unexplained syncope.
  The EaSyAS II study elaborates further the above by using the ILR to avoid hospital admission and optimise the use of a falls/syncope clinic, potentially improving cost effective diagnosis and management of syncope.
  ILRs will be implanted without patient admission and with follow up in a syncope/falls assessment clinic, compared to optimal protocol driven current management.
  The ILR used has capabilities to record and transmit heart rhythm abnormalities to a wireless receiver which will then relay the information to the clinician via the internet. It is hoped that this will shorten diagnosis times and speed up commencement of treatment for patients, and will avoid expensive tests and more expensive hospital admissions.

Eligibility: Inclusion Criteria:
  -  Age > = 16 yrs
  -  Acute syncope presentation to MAU or A+E
  -  2 or more unexplained syncopes within the past 24 months including index episode
  -  Normal baseline ECG
  -  Absence of co - existing pathology requiring admission
  Exclusion Criteria:
  -  Suspected or known heart disease
  -  ECG abnormalities suspected of arrhythmic syncope listed in Table 1
  -  Syncope occurring during exercise
  -  Syncope causing severe injury
  -  Family history of sudden death
  -  Sudden onset palpitations prior to syncope
  Table 1: ECG Abnormalities:
  -  Bifascicular block (defined as LBBB or RBBB combined with left anterior or left posterior fascicular block)
  -  Other intraventricular abnormalities (QRS duration >= 0.12s)
  -  Mobitz 1 second degree AV block (Wenckebach)
  -  Asymptomatic sinus bradycardia (<50 bpm), SA node or sinus pause >= 3s in the absence of negatively chronotropic medications
  -  Pre-excited QRS with short PR interval (WPW)
  -  Significantly Prolonged QT interval
  -  RBBB pattern with ST elevation in V1 - V3 (Brugada Syndrome)
  -  Negative T waves with ST segment elevation in right precordial leads suggestive of arrythmogenic right ventricular dysplasia
  -  Significant Q waves (>= 0.02s) suggestive of MI

Relevance to patient case: not relevant