TITLE: Effect of additive calcium administration on FGF23 levels in patients with mild chronic kidney disease treated with calcitriol: a randomized, open-labeled clinical trial

  ABSTRACT.BACKGROUND:
The purpose of the present study was to determine the effect of additional calcium carbonate treatment on fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF23) levels in patients treated with calcitriol.

ABSTRACT.METHODS:
In this randomized, open-labeled, and parallel-group study, a total of 30 patients with early chronic kidney disease (CKD) and vitamin D deficiency were randomly assigned to two groups and received interventions for 8 weeks: 1) a combination of calcium carbonate and calcitriol group; and 2) calcitriol only group. The primary outcome was the difference in percentage change of serum FGF23 levels from baseline between the two groups. Secondary end points included the changes in serum levels of calcium, phosphate, parathyroid hormone (PTH), and 25-hydroxyvitamin D3 (25(OH)D) from baseline.

ABSTRACT.RESULTS:
Serum FGF23 levels were more elevated in the combination group than in the calcitriol-alone group. However, both mean change and percentage change in the serum FGF23 levels during the 8-week period were not significantly different between the two groups. Serum calcium level was increased significantly only in the combination treatment group. There was no significant difference in percentage change of serum calcium levels between the two groups. In addition, changes in serum levels of phosphate, 25(OH)D, or PTH were not significantly different between the two groups. In correlation analysis, changes in serum FGF23 levels were positively correlated with changes in serum calcium and phosphate levels, but not with changes in 25(OH)D or PTH levels. No serious adverse events were observed, however, there was one case of mild gastrointestinal discomfort.

ABSTRACT.CONCLUSION:
This study revealed that additional calcium carbonate treatment significantly increased serum FGF23 levels in patients treated with calcitriol, with their synergistic effect in promoting intestinal calcium absorption. This suggests that serum FGF23 levels should be monitored regularly, especially in those who use combination of vitamin D and calcium carbonate from the early stages of CKD.

BODY.BACKGROUND:
Vitamin D deficiency is highly prevalent in patients with chronic kidney disease (CKD), and it can be exacerbated in renal failure.1 It has been known that vitamin D deficiency itself affects calcium, phosphorus, and bone metabolism, referred to as chronic kidney disease–mineral and bone disorder (CKD-MBD).2 In addition, vitamin D deficiency leads to increased parathyroid hormone (PTH) secretion, high bone turnover, and cardiovascular risks.3–5 In this regard, vitamin D supplementation is recommended for early CKD patients to delay the progression of CKD-MBD by maintaining adequate vitamin D levels.6 In these patients, monitoring of vitamin D and PTH levels is required to assess the efficacy of vitamin D treatment and identify the progression of CKD-MBD. However, since PTH changes at 3–6 months after vitamin D treatment,6 serum PTH level would not be a direct indicator of vitamin D efficacy. In addition, the change in the PTH level is small at the initial stage of CKD, so the progress of CKD-MBD cannot be evaluated only by PTH level. Thus, a new parameter is needed to evaluate and predict CKD-MBD in patients with slightly reduced renal function.7  Recent studies have indicated that fibroblast growth factor 23 (FGF23) plays a role in the regulation of mineral and bone metabolism from initial stage of CKD.5,8,9 Elevation in serum levels of FGF23 and increased calcium and phosphorus levels are frequently observed in patients with active vitamin D treatment (eg, 1,25-dihydroxyvitamin D3 [1,25(OH)2D]; calcitriol).5 Therefore, a change in FGF23 levels might be considered as an early indicator of MBD in CKD patients treated with vitamin D analog.9 High FGF23 is associated with atrial fibrillation, incidence of osteomalacia, faster disease progression in CKD,10 and increased mortality.11,12 Several previous studies have demonstrated that various factors including dietary calcium and phosphate intake, vitamin D production, and PTH levels can increase the change in serum FGF23 levels. Administration of vitamin D analogs has been shown to stimulate FGF23 synthesis directly13 and increase systemic phosphorus level indirectly.14–16 In addition, a high calcium diet led to increased serum calcium and FGF23 levels.17 High serum phosphate levels can also stimulate the expression and secretion of FGF23, which can induce excessive renal phosphate wasting.18 Thus, nephrologists have tried to regulate FGF23 through phosphate restriction and suppression of PTH levels using phosphate binders.7,19–21 As a result, lanthanum has appeared to be effective for lowering FGF23 levels and phosphate levels in patients with early stage of CKD and in those who are undergoing hemodialysis.19 Several studies have documented that sevelamer treatment decreases urinary excretion of phosphate and plasma FGF23 levels.20,21 Although non-calcium-containing phosphate binders have been consistently shown to be able to lower FGF23 levels, there is no consistent result for calcium-containing phosphate binders. Some studies have shown a significant increase in serum levels of FGF23 after treatment with calcium acetate as a phosphate binder compared to treatment with sevelamer or lanthanum,7,22 but a significant change in FGF23 has not been observed in another study.20 In other studies aiming to compare between calcium carbonate and lanthanum, calcium-containing agent has shown no significant effect on FGF23 levels, unlike lanthanum carbonate.23,24 This is probably because complex mechanisms are involved in the regulation of mineral homeostasis. In addition, most of these studies have been performed in moderately progressed CKD patients, making it difficult to determine the effect of calcium on FGF23 level in early stage of CKD.  We hypothesized that elemental calcium would have a remarkable increase on serum FGF23 levels when it is treated in combination with calcitriol as vitamin D analog. Especially, it is currently unclear how FGF23 and PTH change as biomarkers of MBD in early CKD patients who are administered calcium and calcitriol together. Therefore, the aim of this study was to determine the effect of additional calcium treatment on change in serum FGF23 levels of patients receiving calcitriol.

BODY.METHODS.STUDY DESIGN AND PATIENTS:
This study was designed as a randomized, parallel-group, open-labeled, and single-center trial. Adults of age 18–70 years with CKD stage 3 (defined as estimated glomerular filtration rate [GFR] of 30–60 mL/min/1.73m3) were recruited from the Nephrology Department of a tertiary academic hospital in Korea. Exclusion criteria included known allergy to calcium carbonate; administration of calcium-containing phosphate binders within 3 months prior to study entry; history of hypercalcemia (corrected serum calcium >10.5 mg/dL), hypophosphatemia (serum phosphate <2.5 mg/dL), and very low PTH level (intact PTH [iPTH] <5 pg/mL for adynamic bone disease) within 3 months prior to study entry; patients with bone pathologies or diseases requiring treatment unrelated to CKD-MBD; administration of concurrent medication, including steroids, bisphosphonates, other agents containing calcium, magnesium, and aluminum; comorbid diseases such as osteoporosis, congenital mineral metabolism abnormality, or history of surgeries that might affect mineral bone metabolism or alter bone status; patients diagnosed with rapidly progressive glomerulonephritis or in need of renal replacement therapy; patients with obstructive bowel diseases; and patients with <2 years of life expectancy.  The institutional review board of the Seoul National University Hospital approved the current study, and the study protocol was registered at ClinicalTrials.gov (NCT01748396). This study was conducted in accordance with the ethical standards of the Declaration of Helsinki. Written informed consent was obtained from all patients.

BODY.METHODS.STUDY INTERVENTION:
Participants were randomly assigned to preserve allocation concealment (in a 1:1 ratio) by computer-generated randomization sequence. One group received calcium carbonate (Cicibon® Tab; Huons Co., Ltd., Seoul, Korea) at 500 mg three times daily with meal for 8 weeks and the other group received no such medication. All patients were treated with calcitriol (Bonky® Soft Cap; Yuyu Pharma Inc., Seoul, Korea) at 0.25 μg daily. Dosages were kept uniform throughout the study duration.

BODY.METHODS.DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS:
Blood samples were collected at study entry and at study completion to analyze serum levels of creatinine, calcium, phosphorus, albumin, iPTH, 25-hydroxyvitamin D3 (25(OH)D), and FGF23. PTH level was measured using an immunoradiometric assay, and FGF23 level was measured with a MILLIPLEXMAP enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (MilliporeSigma, Billerica, MA, USA). The level of 25(OH)D was measured via radioimmunoassay. Blood samples taken to measure FGF23 and 25(OH)D levels were frozen at <−70°C until analysis. Serum calcium levels were corrected for serum albumin levels.  The primary end point was the percentage change in serum FGF23 levels from baseline during 8 weeks. Secondary end points included percentage change differences in mineral parameters, including serum levels of calcium, phosphate, PTH, and 25(OH)D between the two groups. Safety assessment consisted of occurrences of adverse events and laboratory abnormalities such as hypercalcemia and/or hypophosphatemia during the study period. In addition, compliance of patient was assessed by pill count when drug bottles were returned after 8 weeks.

BODY.METHODS.SAMPLE SIZE AND STATISTICAL ANALYSIS:
Based on CONSORT guideline and a previous study,7 sample size was calculated using 80% power and two-sided type I error of 0.05, considering dropout rate of 20%. In all, 30 patients (15 per group) were required for analysis. Demographic characteristics and biochemical parameters were described as mean ± SD or median (interquartile range [IQR]) according to their distribution. Mean differences between the two groups at baseline and at the end of the study were analyzed using independent t-test or Mann–Whitney U test for continuous variables and χ2 test for categorical variables as appropriate. Percentage changes from baseline within groups were analyzed using the same statistical techniques. Spearman's correlation for non-parametric data and Pearson's correlation for parametric data were used to analyze relationships between percentage changes in FGF23 levels and changes in serum levels of calcium and PTH. All tests were two sided, and statistical significance was considered when P-value was <0.05. All statistical analyses were performed using SPSS version 24.0 (IBM Corporation, Armonk, NY, USA).

BODY.RESULTS.PATIENT CHARACTERISTICS:
Participants were recruited and followed up during the period from August to November 2012. In all, 30 patients were randomly assigned to receive either calcium carbonate or no medication for 8 weeks (Figure 1). During the study period, four patients from the calcium treatment group (withdrawal of consent, n=3; protocol violation, n=1) and one patient from the other group (protocol violation, n=1) dropped out from the study. The remaining patients were included for analysis. Baseline characteristics of these patients enrolled in the current study are summarized in Table 1. Almost all patients were vitamin D deficient (25(OH)D level <30 ng/mL). Mean serum calcium and phosphorus levels of the two groups were within the normal range (calcium normal range, 8.5–10.5 mg/dL; phosphorus normal range, 2.7–4.6 mg/dL). Median serum FGF23 level in these patients was at 24.5 pg/mL (IQR, 23.2–30.3 pg/mL), and median PTH level was at 27.5 pg/mL (IQR, 21.3–41.0 pg/mL; normal range, <70 pg/mL). Both groups were similar in demographic and biochemical parameters. There were no significant differences in baseline characteristics between the two groups. At the end of study, both groups demonstrated relatively high compliance rates (data not shown).

BODY.RESULTS.CHANGES IN CKD-MBD PARAMETERS.CHANGES IN SERUM FGF23 LEVELS:
The percentage change in the serum FGF23 level showed a trend to increase more in the combination group (calcium carbonate and calcitriol) than that in the calcitriol-alone group, although the difference was not statistically significant (with and without calcium carbonate: ΔFGF23 [%] =68.9%±58.8% and 35.1%±39.1%, respectively, P=0.097; Table 2). After 8 weeks of treatment, mean serum FGF23 levels were increased significantly from baseline in both groups (with and without calcium carbonate: ΔFGF23=18.8±16.8 pg/mL and 9.7±10.0 pg/mL, respectively, both P<0.01; Figure 2A).

BODY.RESULTS.CHANGES IN CKD-MBD PARAMETERS.CHANGES IN SERUM CALCIUM AND PHOSPHATE LEVELS:
Serum calcium levels were increased significantly from baseline in the treatment group with a combination of calcium and calcitriol (baseline and 8 weeks: Ca =9.3±0.2 mg/dL and 9.6±0.2 mg/dL, respectively, P=0.003). However, the calcitriol treatment-alone group showed no significant difference in serum calcium levels (baseline and 8 weeks: Ca =9.6±0.5 mg/dL and 9.6±0.5 mg/dL, respectively, P=0.77; Figure 2B). Percentage change in the serum calcium level from baseline did not show significant difference between the two groups (with and without calcium carbonate: ΔCa (%) =2.6%±2.2% and 0.5%±4.6%, respectively, P=0.075; Table 2). Both percentage changes and mean changes in serum phosphorus levels from baseline to 8 weeks in both groups were not statistically significant (Table 2 and Figure 2C, respectively).

BODY.RESULTS.CHANGES IN CKD-MBD PARAMETERS.CHANGES IN OTHER CKD-MBD PARAMETERS:
There was no statistically significant reduction between serum PTH levels at 0 and 8 weeks after combination treatment, but their levels were slightly increased in the calcitriol treatment-alone group (with and without calcium carbonate: ΔiPTH (%) =−1.3%±89.8% and 20.4%±82.1%, respectively; Table 2 and Figure 2D). During the study period, concentrations of 25(OH)D were not significantly changed in either group (with and without calcium carbonate: Δ25(OH)D =1.5%±13.2% and −5.4%±11.0%, respectively; Table 2).

BODY.RESULTS.CORRELATION ANALYSIS FOR CHANGES IN FGF23 LEVELS:
Before intervention, serum FGF23 levels were not correlated with any demographic or clinical parameters. During the study period, significant positive correlations were found between percentage changes in serum FGF23 levels and percentage changes in serum calcium levels in the combination treatment group but not in calcitriol treatment-alone group (combination and calcitriol: Spearman's correlation coefficient =0.63 and 0.18, P=0.038 and 0.55, respectively; Figure 3). However, percentage change in the serum PTH level was not significantly correlated with percentage change in the serum FGF23 level in either treatment group (combination and calcitriol: Pearson's correlation coefficient =−0.59 and −0.13, P=0.059 and 0.66, respectively; Figure 3).

BODY.RESULTS.SAFETY:
We did not observe laboratory abnormalities such as hypercalcemia or hypophosphatemia throughout the study duration. For adverse events, only one case of mild gastrointestinal discomfort was reported in the calcitriol-alone group. There were no serious adverse events.

BODY.DISCUSSION:
We performed a randomized trial to estimate the impact of additional calcium treatment on serum FGF23 levels in CKD-MBD patients receiving combination treatment of calcium carbonate and calcitriol. During the study period, the calcium and calcitriol combination treatment group showed a significant increase in both serum FGF23 level and calcium level, compared to the calcitriol treatment-alone group. These results suggest that additional calcium carbonate might result in upregulation of serum FGF23 levels by acting as a calcium supplement rather than as a phosphorus binder.  Several reasons might explain why FGF23 level was elevated when calcium and vitamin D were used together in CKD patients. First, activated vitamin D can regulate FGF23 expression and potentially regulate PTH. In both animal and human studies, administration of calcitriol has increased serum FGF23 levels due to a direct or indirect action of vitamin D on FGF23. For example, calcitriol acts directly on a vitamin D response element (VDRE) located upstream of the FGF23 promoter,25,26 resulting in the production of FGF23.27 In addition, calcitriol promotes the synthesis of epithelial calcium channels28,29 and activates the plasma membrane calcium pumps.30,31 It can also induce the formation of calcium-binding proteins.32 These mechanisms can induce calcium absorption from the gastrointestinal tract, which might continuously stimulate FGF23 release.5 Burnett-Bowie et al33 and Alvarez et al34 have reported that FGF23 levels are significantly increased after 12 weeks of ergocalciferol or cholecalciferol treatment at 50,000 international units (IUs) in contrast with placebo carried out in patients with relatively normal kidney functions. Wesseling-Perry et al35 have also demonstrated that FGF23 levels are increased after treatment with either calcitriol or doxercalciferol using various amounts of vitamin D supplementation. These results suggest that the absorbed amount of vitamin D can influence the concentration of FGF23, regardless of renal function of patients. However, we did not observe the significant elevation in FGF23 levels in calcitriol-alone group. This was probably due to difference in absorbed amounts of vitamin D. In fact, amounts of vitamin D analogs in the studies by Burnett-Bowie et al33 and Alvarez et al34 were very high when they were converted to the equivalent doses of calcitriol.  Second, administration of calcium may itself induce a rise in circulating FGF23, independent of vitamin D. Vervloet et al36 have reported that serum FGF23 levels are increased during high dietary calcium intake, whereas levels of both PTH and 1,25(OH)2D are decreased. Kobayashi et al37 have reported that calcium supplementation can significantly increase FGF23 mRNA abundance independent of vitamin D concentration using vitamin-D-receptor null mice. These studies suggest that serum calcium has positive and significant correlation with FGF23 level. Similarly, serum FGF23 levels are decreased at hypocalcemic status despite high PTH and 1,25(OH)2D levels.38 However, as noted earlier, FGF23 was not significantly increased in studies using calcium acetate. This was probably due to low amount of elemental calcium in calcium acetate. Calcium acetate contains less elemental calcium than calcium carbonate (25% versus 40%, respectively),6 although it has superior phosphate-binding capacity than calcium carbonate.39 Thus, contents of calcium in calcium carbonate might have outbalanced the effect of phosphorous binding, resulting in more increase in serum FGF23 levels.  Finally, in our study, the significant increase in serum FGF23 levels following combination use of calcitriol and calcium carbonate might reflect that vitamin D could facilitate calcium absorption. As described earlier, when calcitriol is combined with calcium, calcium uptake in the gastrointestinal tract is promoted, leading to elevated calcium levels in the blood. These results were also observed in our study, in which serum calcium level was significantly elevated after 8 weeks in the combination treatment group. The stimulatory effect of calcium was further enhanced by vitamin D analog. This consequently suggests that the risk of adverse effects might be higher due to elevated FGF23 levels.  Meanwhile, despite these changes in calcium and FGF23 levels, no significant change in serum levels of phosphorus or PTH was observed in our study. Previous study has shown that vitamin D could suppress PTH directly in the parathyroid gland.40 However, in our study, only the combination treatment group lowered serum PTH levels from baseline compared to the calcitriol-alone group, although not statistically significant. It seems that the combination of vitamin D and calcium suppresses PTH directly or indirectly by increasing calcium concentration. Serum phosphorus concentration was not significantly changed in either group during the study period. These results indicate that effects of vitamin D analog on FGF23 are not likely to be mediated by changes in serum phosphorus or PTH level. Rather, they might be mediated directly by serum calcium levels in early CKD patients. Since calcium acts directly on calcium-sensing receptor of parathyroid glands to inhibit the secretion of PTH,41 elevated calcium might inhibit PTH secretion. Therefore, it is more important to monitor serum FGF23 levels and serum levels of phosphorus, vitamin D, or PTH status in the patients under vitamin D and calcium treatments.  To the best our knowledge, this is a well-done study that identifies the stimulatory effect of additional calcium on changes in serum FGF23 levels. In addition, our correlation analysis suggests that change in serum calcium level is a potential biomarker for prediction of increased FGF23 in patients treated with vitamin D analogs and/or calcium-based phosphate binders. This new insight can be applied to clinical practice for predicting the risk of cardiovascular diseases related to high FGF23 levels. Nevertheless, our study had some limitations. We could not identify the involvement of FGF23 levels in bone metabolism change, a direct marker of CKD-MBD. This might be due to the relatively small number of patients used in this study with a relative short period of monitoring for the formation and degradation of bone. Although assumptions made in calculating sample size estimations were performed based on a previous study, the small number of patients might have limited us in achieving results of greater power. In addition, as mentioned earlier, because we used a relatively small dose of calcitriol, the absorbed amount of vitamin D might be low. Thus, larger randomized controlled trials of vitamin D analogs at various doses are needed in the future to achieve improved results. Further studies are warranted to determine the long-term clinical impact of combination treatment on serum levels of FGF23 associated with cardiovascular disease morbidity and mortality.

BODY.CONCLUSION:
Additional calcium carbonate to calcitriol treatment showed greater effects on changes in serum FGF23 levels than calcitriol alone. This might be due to synergistic effect between calcium carbonate and calcitriol by increasing intestinal calcium absorption. Our results suggest that it is important to regularly monitor serum calcium and FGF23 levels in patients having risk of increased calcium absorption due to combination treatment with calcium carbonate and calcitriol, even if their serum phosphorus levels are within normal range.

Question: Compared to calcitriol only group what was the result of a combination of calcium carbonate and calcitriol group  on serum calcium level?
Evidence: After 8 weeks of treatment, mean serum FGF23 levels were increased significantly from baseline in both groups (with and without calcium carbonate: ΔFGF23=18.8±16.8 pg/mL and 9.7±10.0 pg/mL, respectively, both P<0.01; Figure 2A).
Answer: no significant difference