GHSA-q96j-3fmm-7fv4: LXD: Importing a crafted backup leads to project restriction bypass
SummaryLXD instance backup import validates project restrictions against `backup/index.yaml` embedded in the tar archive, but creates the actual instance from `backup/container/backup.yaml` extracted to the storage volume. Because these are separate, independently attacker-controlled files within the same tar archive, an attacker with instance-creation rights in a restricted project can craft a backup where `index.yaml` contains clean configuration (passing all restriction checks) while `backup.yaml` contains `security.privileged=true`, `raw.lxc` host filesystem mounts, and restricted device types. The instance is created from the unchecked `backup.yaml`, bypassing all project restriction enforcement.DetailsLXD projects support a `restricted=true` mode that enforces security boundaries on what instances within the project can do. These restrictions include blocking `security.privileged=true` containers, `raw.lxc` / `raw.apparmor` overrides, and device passthrough (GPU, USB, PCI, unix-char). These restrictions are intended to prevent container escape vectors regardless of user privilege level within the project.The backup import path has two distinct configuration sources within a single tar archive:`backup/index.yaml` - A quick-access metadata file read by `backup.GetInfo()` at `backup/backup_info.go:68`. This is the config checked against project restrictions.`backup/container/backup.yaml` - The full instance configuration extracted to the storage volume and used for actual instance creation at `api_internal.go:784`.The vulnerability exists because:`AllowInstanceCreation()` at `instances_post.go:885` validates project restrictions using only `bInfo.Config` from `index.yaml`.The tar contents (including `backup/container/backup.yaml`) are extracted to the storage volume at `generic_vfs.go:952` via `unpackVolume()`.`UpdateInstanceConfig()` at `backup_config_utils.go:236` reads `backup.yaml` from storage but only syncs `Name`, `Project`, pool info, and volume UUIDs - it does not overwrite `Instance.Config` or `Instance.Devices`.`internalImportFromBackup()` at `api_internal.go:784` reads `backup.yaml` from the storage mount path (not `index.yaml`) to build the instance database record.`instance.CreateInternal()` at `api_internal.go:946` creates the instance using the config from `backup.yaml`. `CreateInternal` calls `ValidConfig` which validates config key **format** only, not project restriction compliance.Proof of ConceptEnvironment setup (server admin)These steps are performed by the LXD server administrator to set up the
restricted project and grant access to the user. This represents the normal
multi-tenant configuration that the exploit targets.After this setup, the attacker can create normal unprivileged instances in
`restricted-project` but should not be able to create privileged containers,
use `raw.lxc`, or attach GPU/USB/unix-char devices. The exploit bypasses
all of these restrictions.Steps**1. Create an instance backup archive locally**The attacker constructs the entire backup archive locally. No access to any
LXD server is needed for this step.**2. Connect to the target LXD server and import the backup**Connect to the target LXD server and confirm restricted access:**3. Escalate to full LXD admin**Start the container and use the LXD Unix socket, which was bind-mounted
from the host via `raw.lxc`. Local connections over the Unix socket are
trusted as full admin with unrestricted access across all projects.ImpactThe exploit allows full host compromise from within a restricted project.
The requirement is that the user has `can_view_instances`, `can_create_instances` and `can_operate_instances` on the project -- standard permissions for any tenant expected to manage instances.Possible remediationAdd a second `AllowInstanceCreation` (or `checkInstanceRestrictions`) call after `backup.yaml` is read from storage and before `CreateInternal` is called. In `api_internal.go`, between the `ParseConfigYamlFile` call (line 784) and the `CreateInternal` call (line 946):Patches| LXD Series  | Interim release |
| ------------- | ------------- |
| 6 | https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/lxd-6-7-interim-snap-release-6-7-d814d89/79251/1  |
| 5.21 | https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/lxd-5-21-4-lts-interim-snap-release-5-21-4-aee7e08/79249/1  |
| 5.0 | https://discourse.ubuntu.com/t/lxd-5-0-6-lts-interim-snap-release-5-0-6-7fc3b36/79248/1 |
CVSS v3.1: 9.1