System for intensity-variable printing

Abstract: A method of printing an image onto a substrate includes the steps of determining a difference in intended color intensity between a first pixel and a second pixel; adjusting the intended color intensity of the second pixel based on the determined difference; and depositing a colorant onto the substrate at the first pixel and at the second pixel at the adjusted intended intensity, so as to enhance the appearance of the image on the substrate. The disclosed invention has particular utility in enhancing the appearance of fine images such as one pixel wide, vertical and diagonal lines in a printing system which utilizes printhead heating elements that are larger in the vertical direction than in the horizontal direction.

Description: This invention relates to a system for enhancing the visual appearance of a fine image, such as a thin line, during printing. More specifically, the invention relates to improving the appearance of such an image in an intensity-variable type printing system utilizing pixels which are larger along a first axis than along a second axis. Intensity-variable printing is, for the purposes of this document, defined as any type of printing in which colorant may be deposited on a base unit area, or pixel, in more than one intensity or degree of dilution. Diffusion printing, which is defined as including both common dye-diffusion and sublimation dye printing techniques, is one type of intensity-variable printing. Other intensity-variable printing techniques may include continuous ink jet printing, variable spot-sized phase change ink jet printing, variable dot electrophotography, variable dot thermal transfer printing, laser-induced dye diffusion transfer processes, dry silver technology and photographic printing, as well as others. Dye diffusion printing involves the transfer of a dye colorant from a carrier, such as a polymer ribbon, onto a specialized substrate surface, such as a polyester sheet or a coated sheet of ordinary paper, in a controlled manner to generate an image. A thermal transfer print engine having an array of electrically actuatable heating elements is typically positioned so that the ribbon is juxtaposed between the print head elements and the substrate. The amount or intensity of dye deposited at a single location or pixel on the substrate can be varied by adjusting the electrical input to the print head elements. When one or more of the print head elements is heated, the dye/carrier structure is heated to a temperature sufficient to cause migration of a commensurate amount of dye to the substrate. By using a ribbon or ribbons having the three primary or subtractive colors, or those colors plus black, highly subtle colorant gradations may be achieved on the substrate. Images of near photo quality have been produced using dye diffusion technology. One characteristic of print heads that are used in sublimation dye printing, diffusion dye printing or the like is that the height of each printhead heating element is larger than its width. In other words, each print head heating element is rectangular, rather than square. For example, the pixel shape on Sharp Electronics Model JX561 print head is a rectangle having a height to width ratio of approximately 2 to 1. This hardware characteristic creates some problems during printing. For example, as may be seen in FIGURE 1, vertical single-pixel lines are noticeably thinner than horizontal single-pixel lines. To compensate for the height of the rectangular heating elements, a portion of the two vertically adjacent pixels is overlapped as shown in FIGURE 1. The dotted line shows the bottom of the rectangular heating element. The overlapping corrects some of the distortion. For example, 3 pixels-by-3-pixels square is achieved by the partial vertical overlap without further correction. A space between horizontal heating elements does not cause any visible break in the printed horizontal line. Diffused dye from the adjacent heating elements diffuses and closes the gap on the substrate. However, this correction does not help single-pixel lines. Diagonal single-pixel lines are also affected by such a printhead and tend to appear jagged and inconsistent. Consequently, small point size text tends to lose definition due to the rectangular-shaped printhead elements. Furthermore, there are thermal issues that make it difficult for the printer to securely deposit a single pixel which is isolated from the next horizontal pixel. When only one printhead element is heated, rapid dissipation of heat from that element to adjacent structure on the printhead and to the carrier ribbon sometimes causes insufficient heating of the ribbon to induce the intended amount of colorant deposition. Since the print head elements are arranged as a horizontal linear array horizontally isolated pixels will not be protected against such heat loss effects, even when the desired image requires a vertically adjacent pixel to be printed upon. Accordingly, it is an object of the invention to provide a system which is adapted to compensate for the visual distortions of a fine image, such as one-pixel-wide lines, small size text and isolated single pixels, which is printed in a preferred embodiment by a printhead having rectangular heating elements. It is an object of one aspect of the invention to provide an enhanced visual appearance of the fine images so that they will appear as wide as the longest edge of the, preferably rectangular, heating elements. It is another object of the invention to prevent poor printing quality which might otherwise result from rapid dissipating of heat from the heating elements when horizontally isolated pixels are being printed. It is yet another object of the invention to limit such enhancement, so that the enhancement does not result in unwanted distortion of the image. According to the present invention there is provided an intensity variable printing system for printing an image on to a substrate, comprising: means for determining a difference in color intensity between a first pixel and a second pixel; means for adjusting said color intensity of said second pixel based upon said difference; and means for depositing a colorant on to the first and second pixels on the substrate according to said adjusted color intensity, thereby enhancing the appearance of the image on the substrate and wherein the shape of the deposited colorant is larger along a first axis than a second axis. Advantages and features of novelty which characterize the invention are pointed out with particularity in the claims annexed hereto and forming a part hereof. However, for a better understanding of the invention, its advantages, and the objects obtained by its use, reference should be made to the drawings which form a further part hereof, and to the accompanying descriptive matter, in which there is illustrated and described a preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 1 is a diagram illustrating a visual distortion of lines printed by a prior art printhead with rectangular heating elements. FIGURE 2A is a diagram of a letter "E" printed by the same prior art rectangular heating elements. FIGURE 2B is a diagram of a letter "E" printed by prior art square heating elements and has the same number of pixels as FIGURE 2A. FIGURE 3 illustrates an enhancement of the vertical and diagonal lines shown in FIGURE 1, according to a preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 4 illustrates an enhancement on the letter "E" shown in FIGURE 2A according to a preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 5A is a diagram of horizontally isolated pixels that are apart by more than one pixel. FIGURE 5B illustrates an enhancement over the horizontally isolated pixels as shown in FIGURE 5A according to a preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 6 is a diagram of horizontally isolated pixels that are apart by only one pixel, and this pattern of pixels is not enhanced by a preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 7 shows a window which contains four pixels under examination for an enhancement according to one embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 8 is a flow chart depicting detailed processes of enhancing a fine image. FIGURE 9A illustrates an existing three-pixel-wide vertical line whose outer columns of the pixel have a lighter color intensity. FIGURE 9B shows an enhancement of the three-pixel-wide vertical line shown in FIGURE 9A by providing a more desirable contrast in color intensity between the surrounding and center columns of pixels. FIGURE 10 is a schematic depiction of a thermal mass transfer printing system according to one embodiment of the invention. Referring now to the drawings, wherein like reference numerals designate corresponding structure throughout the views, and referring in particular to FIGURE 1, one horizontal line, one vertical line and one diagonal line are depicted as printed by the printhead that has rectangular heating elements. Such heating elements are activated to melt dye such as diffusion dye or sublimation dye to deposit the dye on the surface of a substrate. For the purpose of this document, the pixel is an abstract concept which refers to the extent of an area where dye is deposited by one heating element. Any image is constructed by printing combinations of single pixels, and each pixel has an identical rectangular shape with a substantially 2 to 1 ratio between the height and the width. Because of this ratio, the single-pixel-wide vertical line in FIG. 1 appears thinner than a single-pixel-wide horizontal line. A single-pixel-wide diagonal line also appears inconsistent due to the rectangular pixel. These visual distortions are not limited to the above-described graphical primitives, but are also manifested in more complex graphics such as small size font. The legend on the side shows that the original line has the color intensity value of 15, while the background has zero. Referring now to FIGURE 2A, a letter "E" looks more unproportional than a normal counterpart, FIGURE 2B. Although the letter "E" in FIGURE 2A has the same number of pixels as FIGURE 2B, the letter "E" in FIGURE 2A appears to have thicker horizontal live segments than the vertical line segment. The letter "E" as shown in FIGURE 2B, however, will lose its proportion when it is printed by a printhead with non-square heating elements. It is an object of the invention to solve the above described problems in intensity-variable printing systems. The legend on the side shows that the original line has the color intensity value of 15, while the background has zero. By using intensity-variable printing technology, it is possible to create a different shade of color by varying the amount of deposited dye on the substrate surface. conceptually speaking, to make the single-pixel vertical line appear as wide as the single-pixel horizonal line, an additional lighter color single-pixel line is juxtaposed next to one or more, and preferably both, sides of the single-pixel vertical line. Referring to FIGURE 3, the lines shown in FIGURE 1 are compensated by the juxtaposed lines. The compensated vertical line in FIGURE 3 is three pixels wide. An additional single-pixel-width line is juxtaposed on each side of the original single-pixel vertical line to enhance the width. The color intensity of the juxtaposed line is approximately half that of the original single-pixel vertical line. The legend on the side shows that the original line has the color intensity value of 15, while the background has zero. The compensating line has the color intensity value of 7.5. However, since the new vertical line is now three pixels wide, the distortion caused by the 1:2 ratio rectangular pixels seems overcompensated, as may be seen in FIGURE 3. However, the enhanced vertical line in the actual print appears as wide as a single-pixel-wide horizontal line, and each row in the enhanced vertical line now appears substantially square rather than rectangular, because of the lighter shade of the compensating adjacent pixels. Accordingly, a human will perceive the enhanced vertical line as being somewhat narrower than it actually is. Still referring to FIGURE 3, the diagonal line is also compensated for, according to a preferred embodiment of the invention. One pixel on each side of the pixels in the original single-pixel-wide diagonal line is added to enhance the width the appearance of the line. These juxtaposed pixels have approximately half the intensity of the original diagonal line. As for the vertical line, the enhanced diagonal line in the actual print appears as wide as a single-pixel-wide horizontal line, and each row now appears substantially square rather than rectangular. Referring now to FIGURE 4, the same enhancement is applied to the letter "E," as depicted in FIGURE 2A. Some pixels have been added along some portions of the vertical line in FIGURE 4. The intensity of these additional pixels is approximately half of that of the original pixels. The legend on the side shows that the original line has the color intensity value of 15, while the background has zero. The compensating line has the color intensity value of 7.5. Although the enhanced character has not changed its overall height, it has gained a better proportion between the vertical and horizontal lines. As a result, the enhanced character appears aesthetically more acceptable. Such effect is more readily appreciated in some characters or numbers that have a sharp contrast between the vertical and horizontal line components. On the other hand, other characters such as "_" (underscore) and " - " (hyphen) are not affected by the preferred embodiment of the invention. Referring now to FIGURES 5A and 5B, similarly horizontally isolated single pixels as shown in FIGURE 5A are enhanced by the above-described preferred embodiment of the invention. FIGURE 5B shows the enhanced horizontally isolated single pixels. The legend on the side shows that the original pixels have the color intensity value of 15, while the background has zero. The compensating pixels have the color intensity value of 7.5. These horizontally isolated single pixels are not visually distorted as much as the vertical single-pixel line. Because there is no comparison such as the case between the vertical and horizontal line, there is less need for correcting the appearance of the horizontally isolated single pixels. However, as discussed above, it is difficult for some printers to accurately deposit dye over a horizontally isolated single pixel area on the substrate due to heat dissipation from the single activated heat element. Thus, because of the thermal issue of the print head, the enhancement of the horizontally single pixel is also preferred. On the other hand, a certain pattern such as shown in FIGURE 6 should not be altered by the preferred embodiment of the invention so as not to destroy the original pattern. Accordingly, it is important that the enhancement should be somewhat limited so that it is applied only to the single-pixel-wide vertical and diagonal lines as well as certain horizontally isolated single pixels. For example, since these lines or patterns can be a part of some alpha-numeric characters or other symbols, an overenhancement may make these characters and symbols unrecognizable. Thus, the preferred embodiment of the invention enhances horizontally isolated single pixels only if they are separated by more than one pixel apart. To accomplish the above described enhancement, according to one preferred embodiment of the invention, four horizontally contiguous pixels are examined at a time as shown in FIGURE 7. Prior to printing, the values of the four pixels corresponding to the upper left corner of a substrate are loaded into a one-dimensional array called Window, which is designated by w[0] through w[3]. When these pixel values are examined and processed, Window is shifted by one pixel as shown by the dotted line in FIGURE 7. When all the pixels in the same row are processed, Window is moved down to the next row and the process continues. This is repeated until all the pixels on the raster data array are considered. Referring now to FIGURE 8, the process of enhancement is further described in detail. After the four-bit (which in binary numbering can represent values of 0-15) data of the intensity level for each of the four horizontally contiguous pixels is loaded from the raster data array into Window, three conditions are tested. These tests include: 1) whether a difference in the pixel intensity value between the second and first pixels (w[1]-w[0]) is more than 8, 2) whether a difference in the pixel intensity value between the second and third pixels (w[1]-w[2]) is more than 8, and 3) whether a difference in the pixel intensity value between the second and fourth pixels (w[1]-w[3]) is more than 8. When all of the three conditions are satisfied, the first pixel intensity value is adjusted to an average of the first and second pixel intensity values as shown in w[0] := (w[0] + w[1])/2. Similarly, the third pixel intensity value is adjusted to an average of the second and third pixel intensity values as shown in w[2] := (w[2] + w[1])/2. On the other hand, if any of the three conditions is not met, no pixel intensity value is adjusted. Then the content of the Window array, w is stored back into the raster data array, and the Window frame is moved to the right by one pixel or the beginning of the next row upon finishing the last four pixels on the row. Until all the pixel values in the raster data array are examined, the above described process is repeated. Still referring to FIGURE 8, the process may affect any pixel which is adjacent to a pixel having a pixel intensity value of 9 or greater, provided that the above described conditions are met. Accordingly, a single-pixel-wide vertical line with its pixel intensity value over 8 with a zero intensity background is enhanced to have 50% intensity pixels on both sides of the original line. The above-described enhancement is not limited to single-pixel-wide lines. For example, a vertical 3-pixel-wide line as shown in FIGURE 9A may be also enhanced to one shown in FIGURE 9B. FIGURE 9A diagrammatically shows a 3-pixel-wide vertical line having the center pixel intensity of 15 and the adjacent pixel intensity of 1 with the background of zero intensity. Since the difference in the pixel intensity is more than 8 between these columns of pixels and the second column right to the center column of pixels has 0 intensity, all the three conditions described in reference to FIGURE 8 are satisfied. Thus, the adjacent columns of the pixels will have the intensity level of 8 as shown in FIGURE 9B after the enhancement. The enhancement of this kind is not necessarily spatial as discussed in reference to FIGURES 1-6, but intensity-related. Because of more desirable contrast of 50% intensity in FIGURE 9B, the vertical line substantially improves its appearance so that its width is more likely perceived as that of the horizontal line. A similar type of enhancement can be applied to a situation where the difference in color intensity between a single-pixel line and the non-zero color intensity background is more than eight. FIGURE 10 depicts an intensity-variable printing system 10 according to a preferred embodiment of the invention, which is preferably a diffusion-type printing system. System 10, designed to print an image on a substrate 12, includes a printhead element 16, which is responsive to commands from a printer controller 18. Printhead 16, according to the preferred embodiment of the invention, includes a linear array of heating elements 20, each of which may be heated in response to a command from the printer controller 18 by electrical resistance. Each heating element is intended to be aligned with discrete unit areas or pixels on the substrate 12. A printer ribbon 24 is interposed between heating elements 20 and the substrate 12. Printer ribbon 24 includes a carrier layer, and a colorant layer containing a dye or colorant that is designed to migrate to the substrate upon application of heat from one or more of the heating elements 20. For dye-diffusion printing, the ribbon 24 contacts the substrate 12, and the colorant migrates into the substrate on a molecular level. For sublimation dye printing, there is no contact between the ribbon and the paper, and heat from the heating elements causes the colorant to sublimate, or phase from solid to gas, adjacent to the substrate, causing absorption in to the substrate 12. The surface of substrate 12 must be chemically compatible with the dye of colorant for printing to be successful, as is well known to those having ordinary skill in this technology. System 10 is preferably a color printing system, and ribbon 24 preferably includes different portions, each having colorant impregnated thereon, which correspond to the three primary or subtractive colors. Optionally, a black portion may also be included. More than one ribbon 24 may also be used to accomplish transfer of the different colorants to the substrate, if desired. A support roller 22 or equivalent surface is provided to support substrate 12 in parallel spaced relationship with respect to heating elements 20. By selectively controlling the heating elements 20 on printhead 16, printer controller 18 is constructed to control the placement of an image onto the substrate 12, as will be described in greater detail below. Preferably, printhead 16 is obtainable from Sharp Electronics Corporation as Model No. JX561. Preferably, ribbon 24 is the printer ribbon which is obtainable from Sharp Electronics under Model No. A4JX61R3T, which is a three color ribbon having a cyan component, a magenta component, and a yellow component. Alternative ribbon models may include Sharp Electronics Model No. A4JX61R4T, which is a four color ribbon having a cyan component, a magenta component, a yellow component, and a black component. A black ribbon, which may be used alone or in conjunction with the three or four color ribbons, is obtainable from Sharp Electronics under Model No. A4JX61RBT. It is understood, however, that even though numerous characteristics and advantages of the present invention have been set forth in the foregoing description, together with details of the structure and function of the invention, the disclosure is illustrative only, and changes may be made in detail, especially in matters of shape, size and arrangement of parts within the principles of the invention to the full extent indicated by the broad general meaning of the terms in which the appended claims are expressed.

Claims: An intensity variable printing system (10) for printing an image on to a substrate (12), comprising: means (18) for determining a difference in color intensity between a first pixel and a second pixel; means (16, 18) for adjusting said color intensity of said second pixel based upon said difference; and means (16, 18, 20) for depositing a colorant on to the first and second pixels on the substrate according to said adjusted color intensity, thereby enhancing the appearance of the image on the substrate, and wherein the shape of the deposited colorant is larger along a first axis than a second axis. A system as claimed in Claim 1 wherein said first and second pixels are adjacent. A system as claimed in Claim 2 wherein said first and second pixels are horizontally adjacent. A system as claimed in any preceding claim wherein said first and second pixels are near an edge of the image. A system as claimed in any preceding claim wherein each of said pixels is monochromatic or each of said pixels further comprises a plurality of colors. A system as claimed in any preceding claim, wherein the print head element (16) includes a heating element (20) which selectively deposits a colorant onto said substrate (12) in response to print commands. A system as claimed in any preceding claim comprising a rectangular print head element (16). A system as claimed in Claim 6 or Claim 7 wherein said pixels are adjacent in the direction in which the shorter edge of the rectangular print head elements (16) extend. A system as claimed in any preceding claim wherein said determination on color intensity includes a comparison between immediately adjacent pixels. A system as claimed in Claim 9, wherein said determination on color intensity includes a further comparison between said first pixel and said second pixel which is at least two pixels away from said first pixel.

Inventors: CLARK JEFFERY J, CROSBY BRIAN G, LEWENDAL BO, THORNTON GREGORY P, CLARK, JEFFERY J., CROSBY, BRIAN G., LEWENDAL, BO, THORNTON, GREGORY P.
Applicants: TEKTRONIX INC, TEKTRONIX, INC.
Application year: 1993
Main classification: H04N1
IPC codes: B41J2, B41M5, H04N1