Melting glass with oxidation control and lowered emissions

Abstract: Premature dissociation of fining agent is avoided in a glass melting operation while controlling the final redox state of the product glass by initiating the melting process under relatively oxidizing conditions and subsequently altering the redox conditions to make the glass more reducing. A glass that is more reduced than usual can thereby be produced without sacrificing the ability to adequately fine the glass. For a given redox level, less fining agent need be used, thereby lowering emissions from the melting operation, because dissociation of the fining agent is delayed until a later stage of the process where the redox conditions are changed.

Description: This invention involves the interrelationship between the redox condition of melting glass and the solubility of certain compounds in the melt. More specifically, this invention deals with controlling this interrelationship so as to reduce emissions from the glass melting operation, to assure adequate fining of the glass, or to produce certain colored glasses. Commercial production of glass conventionally involves feeding raw glass batch materials into an opening at one end of an elongated melting furnace while withdrawing melted glass through an opening at the opposite end of the furnace. When exposed to the high temperature conditions within the melting furnace, the raw materials undergo chemical reactions and dissolution which normally take place within the first portion of a continuous glass melting furnace. The remainder of the furnace is devoted to "fining" (or "refining") and conditioning the glass melt. The process of fining is the removal of gaseous products of reaction or other entrained gases from the melt by providing conditions which cause the gases to be driven from the molten glass. High temperature is one of the conditions that enhances fining, and for that reason the heat sources in a melting furnace are often arranged to provide the peak temperature downstream from the initial melting zone. Failure of the glass to be adequately fined can result in the undesirable presence of bubbles or "seeds" in the product glass. Glass makers conventionally include in the mixture of batch materials being fed to a melting furnace at least one compound that is intended to serve as a fining aid or agent. A fining agent is characterized by its tendency to dissociate at relatively high temperatures, whereby it dissociates and forms substantial volumes of gas into which undesired species of gas diffuse and thereby more readily escape from the melt. Compounds of sulfur constitute the most common refining agents, particularly sodium sulfate (salt cake) and calcium sulfate (gypsum). Other sulfates, as well as sulfides and sulfites have also been suggested as fining agents. Injecting SO₂ gas directly into the melting glass is proposed in US-A-3,375,095 (Poole). Regardless of the form in which the sulfur is introduced into the melt, most of the sulfur is converted to sulfate, sometimes expressed equivalently as SO₃ concentration, in which form a portion remains dissolved in the glass and the remainder dissociates, forming SO₂ and O₂. Carbonaceous material, usually powdered coal, is sometimes included in the batch mixture so as to increase the amount of sulfur that dissociates from the melting glass with the intention of enhancing the fining effect. Ideally, the fining agent would dissociate when it is desired to begin the fining process, i. e., after the initial melting of the batch materials, as the melt enters the zone of peak temperature. Unfortunately, fining agents often begin dissociating as soon as they are exposed to the heat of the furnace and the reducing conditions produced by the presence of reducing agents such as carbon that are included in the batch mixtures. As a result, there is premature dissociation of the refining agent before the glass enters the fining zone. In order to provide sufficient fining agent for the downstream fining process, it has then been necessary to include excess fining agent in the batch mixture to compensate for the losses in the early melting stages. As a result, considerably more of products of the dissociation of the fining agent enter the exhaust gas stream from the furnace than is required for the fining process itself. The emissions from most fining agents are considered to be environmentally detrimental, and costly exhaust gas treatment is often required to avoid excessive discharge of these emissions to the atmosphere. Accordingly, it would be desirable to reduce the amount of refining agent required. One approach to reducing the amounts of fining agent used is disclosed in US-A-4,138,235 (Turner), but further reductions would be desirable. Some colored glasses require that the reduction/oxidation ("redox") state of the melt be controlled so as to be relatively reducing so that certain multivalent colorant ions are induced to be present in the glass in their lower valence state. Iron is frequently used as a colorant in glass, and it is known that melting the glass under reducing conditions enhances the amount of the iron that is in the ferrous state rather than the ferric state, with the result that the glass is more absorbing in the infrared range of the spectrum. This is very desirable for glass that is intended to reduce the heat gain into enclosures such as buildings or automobiles. One prior art attempt to increase the infrared absorption of glass by increasing the amount of ferrous iron entailed including larger total amounts of iron in the glass. This approach is limited by the difficulty of melting glass with large amounts of iron due to lowered heat transfer. Using a moderate amount of iron and attempting to drive more of it to the ferrous state by providing a reducing environment in the melter by including a reducing agent (such as powdered coal or other carbon source) in the batch materials or by firing the furnace with an excess of fuel has also been less than successful because of inadequate fining. Production of relatively reduced glass by introduction of reductant with the batch mixture can lead to premature dissociation of the fining agents so that amounts remain at the fining zone, with the consequence that fining may be inadequate. Specialized melting and fining means as disclosed in US-A-4,792,536 (Pecoraro and Shelestak) can avoid these problems, but it would be desirable to be able to produce reduced glasses with the large capacity of conventional glass melting furnaces presently available. US-A-2,330,324 (Adams) discloses a process of first bubbling carbon monoxide (a reducing agent) through a pot of glass and then bubbling oxygen, the combined effect of which is said to improve fining of the glass and to produce clear glass. That patent also describes the former practice of throwing carbonaceous objects such as potatoes or blocks of wood into a glass melt to temporarily increase the local fining action. Such an erratic technique is not considered suitable for a large scale, continuous glass melting operation. US-A-2,387,222 (Wright) discloses bubbling gas into molten glass in a melting and fining furnace for the purpose of controlling the circulation of glass in the furnace. It is disclosed that the gas may be oxidizing, reducing, or neutral. The purpose for using a reducing gas is stated to be "to retain certain colorants." There is no disclosure of which colorants are contemplated nor of an explanation as to how a colorant would be retained by making the glass more reducing. US-A-2,254,079 (McAlpine) proposes assisting the fining process by bubbling gases through molten glass in a fining zone of reduced depth. Carbon monoxide is one of the gases suggested as being usable in this process, although a troublesome brown coloration is described as requiring subsequent treatment with oxygen. From US-A-4,792,536 a method of making a transparent infrared absorbing glass is known, by employing a moderate amount of iron in the glass composition and controlling reducing conditions to maintain a relatively large portion of the iron in the ferrous state. It is the object of the present invention to provide a process for making glass wherein the emissions from the glass melting operation are reduced. This object is attained by a method of making glass by initiating the melting of glass batch materials containing a source of multivalent ions and a fining agent in an upstream zone, complete melting the batch materials in a downstream zone, fining the molten glass and forming a glass product, characterized by (i) maintaining redox conditions oxidizing as measured by the ratio of ferrous iron to total iron or equivalently in terms of other multivalent species being present during the substantial liquefaction of the batch material in the upsteam zone, (ii) in the upstream zone avoiding undue premature dissociation of the fining agent to provide the presence of sufficient fining agent in the molten glass during fining to provide adequate fining, (iii) thereafter altering the redox conditions of the liquefied glass in the downstream zone to be more reducing as measured by an increase in the ratio of ferrous iron to total iron or equivalently in terms of the other multivalent species of at least 20 percent compared to the ratio in the upstream zone to reduce solubility of the fining agent in the melt to induce dissociation of the fining agent to aid in fining of the molten glass and thereby controlling the final valence state of the multivalent ions in the glass product by inducing a greater portion of the multivalent ion to be present in the lower valence state. In accordance with the present invention, the necessity of having to choose between having reducing conditions or providing adequate fining is avoided. Melting of glass is initiated under conditions that are sufficiently oxidizing to yield adequate solubility of sulfate in the melt. Subsequently, redox conditions are altered to a reducing condition during the completion of the melting process. One consequence of the shift toward a reducing condition is that solubility of sulfate in the melt is decreased, causing dissociation of the sulfate that is in excess of the solubility limit. By effecting this redox change in the vicinity of the fining zone, the fining is assisted by the additional gaseous release of the excess sulfur compounds. As a result, the fining can be more effective for a given amount of sulfur fining agent, or a given level of fining performance can be achieved with less sulfur refining agent in the batch mixture. In the latter case, the batch mixture need be provided with little or no sulfur in excess of the solubility limit of the melt in the early melting stages, the gaseous release in the subsequent fining zone being provided substantially by the redox change. As a result, dissociation of sulfate in excess of the solubility limit is substantially lessened at the initial melting stage so that emissions are decreased, but at the same time adequate fining action is assured. The magnitude of the redox change will vary, depending upon the particular melting conditions, the particular glass composition, and the redox state desired in the final glass for the multivalent ions. The operative step of increasing the redox ratio in the present invention is at least a twenty percent increase or more as measured by the ratio of iron in the ferrous state (expressed as FeO) to total iron (expressed as Fe₂O₃). It should be understood that iron oxide need not actually be present and that the redox state can be measured equivalently in terms of other multivalent species. Eliminating some of the dissolved sulfate from the glass by changing the redox conditions in the melting furnace also has advantages for subsequent steps of the glass making process. In the manufacture of flat glass by the float process, the melted and fined molten glass is directed onto a pool of molten tin in a float forming chamber and is shaped into a thin, flat ribbon of glass as it passes along the pool of tin. Sulfur introduced into the float forming chamber from the molten glass has the undesirable effect of reacting with the tin to form tin sulfide, which volatilizes and condenses on the roof of the chamber, and various products of this condensation may subsequently drip onto the glass ribbon, thereby causing defects in the glass. By lowering the amount of sulfur present in the glass, formation of tin sulfide in the float forming chamber may be lessened and the drip problem alleviated. Shifting redox conditions within the melting and fining process also has advantages for making glass colored with a multivalent ion such as iron. Instead of providing the batch mixture with a reducing agent to induce formation of the lower valence state of the colorant ions, the batch may be initially melted under relatively oxidizing conditions that provide greater solubility of sulfur-containing fining agents. Then the desired lower valence state can be induced by changing the redox conditions downstream from the initial melting stage. Accordingly, infra-red absorbing glass having a high proportion of iron in the ferrous state can be melted and adequately fined in a conventional tank-type melting furnace. Selenium is another colorant whose solubility in molten glass is known to increase as the redox condition is more oxidizing. But some uses of selenium as a colorant require it to be reduced, which entails low solubility. Selenium is very volatile at glass melting temperatures and is relatively costly. Therefore, improved retention of selenium in the glass by means of the redox variation technique of the present invention can be very useful. The oxidizing condition maintained during the initial melting stage of the present invention may be provided by appropriate selection of the batch mixture (e.g., substantial absence of reducing agents). The subsequent shift to reducing conditions is carried out by substantially continuously introducing reductant into the melt at a location within or preferably slightly upstream from the fining zone. In most cases the beginning of the fining zone is the region of maximum glass temperature, or "spring zone." The reductant may be injected in the form of a gas, such as a fuel gas, or it may be produced electrolytically within the melt. THE DRAWINGS Fig. 1 is a vertical cross-section through a typical cross-fired, end-fed, glass melting furnace showing circulation flow patterns of the molten glass and the locations of electrodes in accordance with one embodiment of the invention. Fig. 2 is a plan view of the lower portion of the furnace of Figure 1 showing an example of an arrangement of electrodes in accordance with the invention. A typical glass melting furnace to which the present invention relates may be characterized by an inlet end at which raw glass batch materials are deposited onto a pool of molten glass held in the furnace and a generally opposite outlet end from which a product stream of molten glass is withdrawn from the pool. A specific embodiment of the invention is described herein in the context of a common type of glass melting furnace in which the primary source of heat for melting is a plurality of flames extending transversely above the molten glass pool from ports in the side walls. It should be understood that other configurations of glass melting furnace are also commonly used and may also benefit from the present invention. Referring to Figure 1, the typical glass melting furnace depicted includes a refractory basin bottom wall 10, basin inlet end wall 11, an arched roof 12, a suspended back wall 13, and a plurality of side firing ports 14. The number of ports may vary; typical flat glass furnaces usually have five to eight ports on each side. The basin of the furnace contains a pool of melting glass 15. Side basin walls 16 are shown in Figure 2. Batch materials are fed onto the pool 15 through an inlet opening 17 and form a layer or batch cover 18 that melts as it progresses into the furnace. Molten glass passes from the furnace through an outlet opening 19 at an exit end of the furnace partly defined by an exit end wall 20. The circulation currents in the pool of molten glass 15 are shown in Figure 1. The presence of relatively cold batch material at the inlet end of the furnace and the shielding of the pool of glass from the overhead flames by the layer of batch 18 cause downward convection currents in the inlet region of the pool. The hottest region in the molten glass tends to be located downstream from the end of the batch layer 18, typically opposite the last or next-to-last port 14. The high temperatures in this region 23 known as the "spring zone" or "hot spot" generate rising convection currents in the pool. The combination of the rising and descending convection currents produces a circulation cell in the region upstream from the spring zone 23 which, as viewed in Figure 1, moves in a generally counter-clockwise direction, with flow in the upper portion moving in an upstream direction (i.e., toward the inlet 17) and with flow in the bottom portion moving in the downstream direction. Downstream from the spring zone a circulation cell rotating in the opposite direction may be present. One technique for carrying out the redox change within the melting furnace in accordance with the present invention is to inject a reducing gas into the melt. A plurality of bubbler tubes 21 which may, for example, extend through the bottom 10 of the furnace may be provided for this purpose. The bubblers 21 are shown in a straight row extending substantially across the width of the furnace in the drawings, but it should be understood that more than one row may be used and that a linear arrangement is not necessary. The number and spacing of the bubblers 21 is dependent upon the degree to which the injected reducing gas is to be dispersed in the melt. The need to introduce the gas in a dispersed manner depends upon the extent to which the normal operation of the furnace homogenizes the melt. If strong convection currents are maintained in the furnace, only a few widely spaced bubblers may be necessary. Otherwise, a larger number of bubblers is needed so that regions of reduced and unreduced glass do not persist in the furnace downstream from the spring zone 23. Theoretically, the number of bubblers would preferably be as large as possible, but is limited by the inconvenience and cost of installation. The reducing gases used with the present invention are preferably carbon-containing substances, most conveniently hydrocarbon fuels such as methane or propane. Carbon monoxide could also be used. It should be understood that the description of the reducing agent as being a gas refers to its state at furnace operating conditions and that it need not be gaseous at standard conditions. Thus, liquid substances such as fuel oil may also be used. Theoretically, the reductant could even be a solid such as coal if a suitable mechanism is provided for introducing it below the surface of the molten glass. The reducing gas is injected into the molten glass as opposed to the space above the molten glass so that a substantial, localized redox change is effected. It should be understood that creation of bubbles of reducing gas in the molten glass is not necessary. In fact, it may be preferred to diffuse the reducing gases as much as possible. Thus, an alternative mode of introducing the reducing gas into the melt is to pass the gas through a porous refractory member submerged in the melt or forming part of the furnace bottom. Another alternative to injecting reducing gas into the molten glass is to change the redox conditions electrolytically. For this embodiment of the present invention the elements 21 and 22 in the drawings represent electrodes connected to a source of direct current. The electrodes 21 are cathodes and the electrodes 22 are anodes. Sacrificial iron electrodes are preferred for this purpose. At the cathode, sodium ions in the glass are reduced to elemental sodium which in turn gives rise to the following or equivalent reactions: 2 Na° + Fe₂O₃ ---> 2FeO + Na₂O 2 Na° + SO₃ ----> SO₂ + Na₂O At the anode oxygen bubbles will be generated, which is beneficial for maintaining the desired oxidizing conditions at the initial melting stage. Therefore, the anodes 22 are preferably located upstream from the cathodes 21 and may be located under the batch layer 18, although their particular location and number are not critical for the purposes of the present invention. A single anode would suffice, but it is preferred to provide a plurality of anodes in the approximate location shown in the drawings so as to oxidize the bottom layer of glass at the inlet end, as disclosed in US-A-4 919 698, for the sake of avoiding nickel sulfide stones. The preferred location for the cathodes 21 is immediately upstream from the spring zone 23 so that changing the redox condition toward a more reducing condition lowers the solubility limit of the sulfate in the glass so that more sulfate is available for dissociation at the spring zone. The peak temperature attained at the spring zone also reduces the solubility limit of the sulfate in the glass, so the combined effect of raising the temperature at the spring zone and altering the redox condition assures a vigorous gas release and adequate fining. The following example is set forth to illustrate a particular application of the present invention. The usual solubility limit for soda-lime-silica flat glass from one commercial source is 0.22% of sulfate, which is the amount that appears in the product glass. To provide sufficient dissociation for refining, the prior art approach required the glass to include 0.27% SO₃ as it entered the fining zone. In other words, dissociation of 0.05% SO₃ yields adequate refining. Expressed another way, it is typical for approximately 25 percent of the sulfate dissolved in the glass to be subsequently lost from the glass in order to effect adequate fining. But to provide that much sulfate at the fining zone, a considerable surplus of sulfate needs to be provided in the batch materials due to losses of sulfate during the initial melting stage. Therefore, batch mixtures have typically been formulated to include enough sulfur source to theoretically yield 0.5% SO₃ in the glass. The resulting emissions attributable to volatilization of the excess sulfates in the prior art approach can be reduced by employing control over solubility in accordance with the present invention rather than providing a surplus of sulfate. In the typical case described above, the ratio of iron in the ferrous state (expressed as FeO) to total iron (expressed as Fe₂O₃) of the glass would be approximately 0.25. If the glass is initially melted under similar conditions except with less sulfate, and the redox conditions are subsequently changed to increase the ratio of ferrous to total iron to an amount substantially higher than 0.25, the solubility of the sulfate in the glass can be lowered so that the same 0.05% of SO₃ is dissociated in the fining zone. For example, it has been calculated that raising the ferrous to total iron ratio to 0.55 would yield an adequate amount of sulfate dissociation from a glass initially formulated to contain only 0.15% SO₃ after initial melting. The benefits of the present invention may be attained with substantially smaller changes in the redox conditions, and an appreciable effect may be expected with a redox change of about twenty percent measured as the increase in the ratio of ferrous to total iron. In the conventional manufacture of soda-lime-silica flat glass, the ferrous to total iron ratio would not normally exceed 0.30. Therefore, another expression of the incremental change in the redox conditions in the present invention is that the ferrous to total iron ratio is raised to a level of 0.35 or more in a downstream region from a level less than that in the initial zone of the melting process. Ratios of 0.4 or more and even 0.5 or more are contemplated, and can yield glasses having advantageously high proportions of their iron contents in the ferrous state. Sustained, continuous, commercial production of glass with such high ferrous to total iron ratios is very difficult or impossible by conventional means.

Claims: A method of making glass by initiating the melting of glass batch materials containing a source of multivalent ions and a fining agent in an upstream zone, complete melting the batch materials in a downstream zone, fining the molten glass and forming a glass product, characterized by (i) maintaining redox conditions oxidizing as measured by the ratio of ferrous iron to total iron or equivalently in terms of other multivalent species being present during the substantial liquefaction of the batch material in the upsteam zone, (ii) in the upstream zone avoiding undue premature dissociation of the fining agent to provide the presence of sufficient fining agent in the molten glass during fining to provide adequate fining, (iii) thereafter altering the redox conditions of the liquefied glass in the downstream zone to be more reducing as measured by an increase in the ratio of ferrous iron to total iron or equivalently in terms of the other multivalent species of at least 20 percent compared to the ratio in the upstream zone to reduce solubility of the fining agent in the melt to induce dissociation of the fining agent to aid in fining of the molten glass and thereby controlling the final valence state of the multivalent ions in the glass product by inducing a greater portion of the multivalent ion to be present in the lower valence state. The method of claim 1 characterized by altering the redox conditions prior the molten glass entering a region of peak temperature. The method of claim 1 characterized in that the liquefaction takes place in an upstream zone of a melting furnace and a reducing agent is introduced in the vicinity of a downstream fining zone of said melting furnace. The method of claim 1 characterized by introducing the reducing agent into the melt in a gaseous state. The method of claim 1 characterized by altering the redox conditions by electrolysis. The method of any of claims 1 to 5 characterized in that the multivalent ions comprise iron as colorant. The method of claims 3 and 6 characterized in that the initial ferrous to total iron content of the glass in the upstream zone is less than 0.35 and the reducing agent is introduced in the downstream zone in quantities increasing the ratio to at least 0.35. The method of claims 1 and 6 characterized in that the alteration of the redox conditions increases the ferrous to total iron content in the final glass composition to at least 0.4. The method of claim 8 characterized in that the alteration of the redox conditions increases the ferrous to total iron content in the final glass composition to at least 0.5. The method of any of claims 1 or 6 characterized in that the multivalent ions comprise selenium as colorant. The method of any of claims 1 to 10 characterized in that the batch materials being melted include a sulfate source serving as the principal fining agent. The method of claim 11 characterized in that the batch materials include sand and the sulfate source is included in an amount of at least 5 parts by weight, expressed as sodium sulfate, for each 1000 parts by weight of sand. The method of claim 11 characterized by maintaining the ratio of ferrous iron to total iron of no more than 0.3 during the melting of batch materials in the upstream zone and the glass batch materials include sulfur compounds in an amount to provide a sulfur content of the glass measured as SO₃ being not greater than 0.20 percent by weight. The method of claim 11 characterized by a sulfur content of the glass measured as SO₃ after melting and fining being not greater than 0.15 percent by weight. The method of claims 1, 3, and 11 characterized by increasing the temperature of the melt after the reducing agent is introduced, wherein the temperature increase and the alteration of the redox conditions resulting in reduced solubility of sulfur species in the melt, such that at least 0,05 percent SO₃ dissociates and is lost from the melt at the downstream zone. The method of claim 15 characterized in that the temperature increase and the alteration of redox conditions resulting in reduced solubility of sulfur species in the melt, such that at least 25 percent at the sulfate dissolved in the melt entering the downstream zone dissociates and is lost from the melt at the downstream zone. The method of claim 1 characterized by melting the glass batch materials in a tank type of furnace and feeding the batch materials onto a pool of molten glass (15) held in the furnace at an inlet end (17) and withdrawing molten glass (15) at a longitudinally spaced outlet end (19) and maintaining a region of rising molten glass currents in a spring zone (23) at an intermediate region between the inlet and outlet ends (17,19) and introducing the reducing agent in a bottom current of molten glass flowing toward the spring zone (23) between the inlet end (17) and the spring zone (23). The method of claim 17 characterized by introducing the reducing agent at a plurality of locations near the bottom (10) of the furnace.

Inventors: HARRELL WILLIAM CURTIS, KNAVISH LEONARD ARTHUR, HARRELL, WILLIAM CURTIS, KNAVISH, LEONARD ARTHUR
Applicants: PPG INDUSTRIES INC, PPG INDUSTRIES, INC.
Application year: 1991
Main classification: C03B5
IPC codes: C03B5, C03C1