Protective circuit for diode switching device

Abstract: An electrical circuit supplying a load from a voltage source includes a switching device and a diode, and is to be protected from recovery current caused by polarity reversal of the diode during the operation of the switching device. The electrical circuit further includes a transformer having an excitation winding sensing the recovery current through the diode immediately after operation of the switching device, and a sink winding coupled to the excitation winding for inducing in the sink winding a reverse current corresponding to the current in the excitation winding. A unidirectional conducting device directs at least a portion of the reverse current from the sink winding back to the voltage source.

Description: The present invention relates to circuits for protecting systems which include diode switching devices against the effects of diode reverse recovery currents which occur upon the switching of a diode. One of the serious problems involved in electrical circuits including switching devices and diodes, such as power supplies, inverters, motor drivers, and the like, is the problem of reverse recovery current resulting when the diode is switched off, which causes the current through the diode to be momentarily reversed. Thus, when a diode that was forwardly biased is switched from forward conduction to reverse, the diode behaves as a short circuit during the first few nanoseconds or microseconds until all the stored charge in the diode is recovered. This causes an extremely high magnitude of current, called reverse recovery current, to flow through the diode and the switching device during this recovery period. This recovery current places a considerable stress on the diode and the switching device, and also wastes a considerable quantity of energy in the form of heat. This recovery current also causes energy accumulated in effective inductors and capacitors of the circuit to be radiated as electrical noise. One known solution for this problem of diode recovery is to include an inductor in series with the electrical switch. While this solution protects the electrical switch, it does not solve the problem of wastage of energy. In addition, the inductor generates high-voltage spikes, and therefore it is common to include a zener diode to absorb the excess voltage, but this also does not solve the problem of wastage of energy. The common solution is to use an ultrafastacting diode, but such diodes are very expensive, if available at all, for particular applications producing a relatively high forward voltage drop. The problem is even more severe when using MOSFET's (metal oxide semi-conductor field effect transistor), particularly in bridge configurations. Thus, if the integral Drain/Source is allowed to conduct, the whole device is limited upon reapplying the dv/dt. In order to stay at a safe level of dv/dt, it is necessary to add a large serial inductance and large parallel capacitors. These components cause an additional waste of power. Another solution is to prevent conduction in the diode in the MOSFET by inserting a serial diode, to block backward conduction, and bypassing the MOSFET diode combination by an additional diode, parallel to the combination. However, these solutions are expensive and significantly increase the circuit losses. JP-A-55-150776 also relates to an electrical circuit including a switching device and a diode and having means for minimizing power loss resulting from the momentary reversal of the diode current. In that circuit, however, the power loss to be eliminated is that resulting from the parasitic capacitance of the diode (D 10 ) produced upon operation of the switching device (S 1 ); and to eliminate this power loss, there is introduced inductors (L 15 , L 16 ) and a diode (D 16 ) to transfer the energy generated by the parasitic capacitance of diode D 10 to the load. An object of the present invention is to provide an electrical circuit of the foregoing type, i.e., including a switching device and a diode, with improved means for minimizing the above effects resulting from reverse recovery current caused by momentary reversal of the diode current. According to the present invention, there is provided an electrical circuit including a switching device and a diode, and means reducing the effects of reverse recovery current caused by momentary reversal of the diode current during the operation of the switching device, having the features recited in claim 1. The transformer may sense the recovery current directly, or indirectly, e.g., by reflection. Also, the unidirectional conducting device preferably has a voltage drop larger than that of the protected diode. The invention may be implemented in many forms. For example, the unidirectional conducting device may be an electronic switch, a diode, or a plurality of diodes connected in series. The latter is particularly advantageous, since it is possible to manufacture small ultrafast diodes having high voltage drops which have no influence on the particular circuit. Moreover, the current density in the plurality of diodes is extremely high, and therefore the charge which is accumulated during forward conduction is reduced. The invention is also particularly advantageous when applied in MOSFET circuits, where the integral diodes normally exhibit a relatively high minority charge, and therefore cause long recovery time and high losses. The turns ratio of the transformer determines the fraction of the current which flows away from the voltage source during the recovery process, and therefore which produces the power losses. Accordingly, the turns ratio should be kept as high as possible within practical limits. In this respect, a high turns ratio is difficult to achieve without increasing unwanted serial induction; diodes conducting during short periods tend to develop a forward voltage drop from several volts to several tenths of volts. Further features and advantages of the invention will be apparent from the description below. The invention is herein described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein: Fig. 1 is a circuit diagram illustrating a known basic switching diode circuit causing the problem of recovery current as described earlier; and Figs. 2-17 illustrate various circuits in accordance with the present invention which may be used for solving or reducing this problem. Reference is first made to Fig. 1 which illustrates the basic switching diode circuit. Thus, when a diode D1 that was forward biased is switched off, the diode behaves as a short circuit for a short period of time (known as the recovery time) until all the stored charge is recovered. This generates a reverse current (IR) which, together with the load current (IL), is applied to the switching device (S1). Accordingly, this recovery current produces a momentary over-current and over-voltage which places considerable stress on the diode D1, may be destructive of the switch (S1), and also wastes a considerable amount of energy in the form of heat. Figs. 2-17 illustrate different circuits which may be used according to the invention to recycle most of the recovered charge back to the diode. Thus, only a small fraction of the recovery current flows through the active switch, thereby solving or reducing the above problems. Fig. 2 illustrates a basic configuration for solving or reducing the above problem. Thus, the protective circuit identified by block PC in Fig. 1 includes a transformer T 1 having an excitation winding N E in series with the protected diode D 1 so as to sense the recovery current through the diode imniediately after closing of the switching device S 1 . Transformer T 1 also includes a sink winding N S inductively coupled to the excitation winding N E for inducing in the sink winding a reverse current proportional to the current in the excitation winding. The protective circuit 1 illustrated in Fig. 2 further includes a unidirectional conductive device in the form of a switch S 2 in series with the sink winding N S and connecting it across the protected diode D 1 . Switch S 2 , if not controlled, has a voltage drop larger than that of the protected diode D 1 and is therefore effective to direct at least a portion of the reverse recovery current from the sink winding N S to the protected diode. The reverse current IR 1 which momentarily flows through the excitation winding N E of transformer T 1 induces a much larger current IR 2 through the sink winding N S , and switch S 2 . Therefore, the inverse current IR 1 which flows from the voltage source V to switch S 1 is significantly smaller than the total diode recovery current which is the sum of IR 1 and IR 2 . The part of the recovered charge which flows in the reverse direction through the diode from the voltage source V is thus significantly reduced, and so is the power loss. Fig. 3 illustrates the same circuit as Fig. 2, and therefore the corresponding parts are identically numbered, except that an inductor L 1 is included in series with the excitation winding N E and the switching device S 1 to further reduce the current stress on the switching device. Fig. 4 illustrates a variation wherein the inductor L 1 is added in series with the sink winding N S of the transformer T 1 , instead of in series with the excitation winding N E . Fig. 4 illustrates the further variation wherein the unidirectional conducting device is in the form of a pair of diodes D 2 , D 3 , providing the above-described advantages when using a diode pair for the unidirectional conducting device. In addition, the excitation winding N E is connected to the switch S 1 in order not to interrupt the commutation action of diode D 1 . Fig. 5 illustrates a circuit wherein a capacitor C 1 is connected across the protected diode D 1 to limit the rate of voltage rise across the protected diode. Fig. 6 illustrates an electrical circuit including a clamping diode D 4 connected across the excitation winding N E and the switching device S 1 to protect the protected diode D 1 from voltage transients. Fig. 7 illustrates an electrical circuit wherein a zener diode D 5 is connected across the switching device S 1 , to limit the voltage rise on the switching device S 1 . Fig. 8 illustrates an electrical circuit wherein the transformer T 1 includes a second sink winding N 2s coupled to a second unidirectional conducting device D 7 , which latter circuit further aids in utilizing the energy stored in the transformer. Fig. 9 illustrates an electrical circuit wherein the sink winding N S of the transformer T 1 is connected to direct at least a portion of the recovery current back to the diode D 1 via the excitation winding N E of the transformer. Fig. 10 illustrates an electrical circuit corresponding to that of Fig. 4 but embodied in a buck converter, wherein the switching device S 1 is a MOSFET, and the output of the protected diode is supplied to the load via a coil and capacitor. Fig. 11 illustrates an electrical circuit similar to that of Fig. 10, but embodied in a boost converter type. Fig. 12 illustrates an electrical circuit in which two diodes D 1a , D 1b are to be protected, each being protected by a sink winding N sa , N sb coupled to the excitation winding N E in series with the switching device S 1 . Fig. 13 illustrates an electrical circuit including two MOSFET's, S 1a , S 1b , each protected by a protective circuit corresponding to that illustrated in Fig. 4. In the circuit of Fig. 13, when one MOSFET acts as the switching device, the other acts as the diode to be protected. Fig. 14 illustrates an electrical circuit including four MOSFET's S 1a , S 1b , S 1c , S 1d , arranged in a bridge configuration, including a single transformer T 1 and a single unidirectional conducting device D 9 . Thus, when two MOSFET's act as switching devices, the other two act as diodes to be protected. The single transformer T 1 includes a single excitation winding N E and a single sink winding N S effective, with unidirectional conducting device D 9 to protect all four MOSFET's. Fig. 15 illustrates an electrical circuit wherein the sink winding N S is connected to the excitation N E at a point on the ladder remote from its connection to the protected diode D 1 . unidirectional device is shown as a diode D 8 but could be a plurality of diodes in series or an electronic switch. Fig. 16 illustrates a circuit in which the transformer is split into two transformers T 1a , T 1b , in order to obtain higher turns ratios. Fig. 17 illustrates an electrical circuit having two (or more) input circuits, each including an excitation coil T E . While the invention has been described with respect to a large number of preferred embodiments, it will be appreciated that these are shown merely for purposes of example, and that many variations, modifications and applications of the invention as defined in the appended claims may be made. Where technical features mentioned in any claim are followed by reference signs, those reference signs have been included for the sole purpose of increasing the intelligibility of the claims and accordingly, such reference signs do not have any limiting effect on the scope of each element identified by way of example by such reference signs.

Claims: An electrical circuit supplying a load from a voltage source (V+), and including a switching device (S1), a diode (D1), and means reducing the effects of reverse recovery current (IR) caused by momentary reversal of the diode current during the operation of said switching device (S1), comprising: a transformer (T1) having an excitation winding (NE) sensing said reverse recovery current (IR) through said diode (D1) immediately after the operation of said switching device (S1), a sink winding (NS) inductively coupled to said excitation winding (NE) for inducing in said sink winding (NS) a current (IR2) proportional to the current (IR1) in said excitation winding (NE); and a unidirectional conducting device (S2; D2, D3; D6; D8) connecting said sink winding (NS) to said diode (D1), characterized in that said sink winding (NS) is connected to direct the current (IR2) induced by the flow of said reverse recovery current via said unidirectional conducting device (S2; D2, D3; D6; D8) through said diode (D1), and in that said sink winding (NS) includes a number of turns many times less than said excitation winding (NE) such that a large proportion of said recovery current (IR) flows via said sink winding (NS) and said unidirectional conducting device (S2; D2, D3; D6; D8) through said diode (D1), and only a small proportion of said recovery current (IR) flows via said excitation winding (NE) through said switching device (S1) . The electrical circuit according to claim 1, wherein said unidirectional conducting device is an electronic switch (S2). The electrical circuit according to claim 1, wherein said unidirectional conducting device is a further diode (D2, D3; D6; D8) The electrical circuit according to any one of claims 1-3, further including a capacitor (C1) connected across said diode (D1) to limit the rate of voltage rise thereacross. The electrical circuit according to any one of claims 1-3, wherein said transformer (T1) includes a second sink winding (N2S) coupled to a further unidirectional conducting device (D7), the latter circuit further aiding in recovering back to the voltage source energy stored in said transformer (T1). The electrical circuit according to any one of Claims 1-3, wherein said transformer (T1) is split into two transformer sections (T1a, T1b), one feeding the other, in order to obtain a higher turns ratio.

Inventors: RUBIN DANIEL, RUBIN, DANIEL
Applicants: SYSTEL DEV & IND LTD, SYSTEL DEVELOPMENT & INDUSTRIES LTD.
Application year: 1990
Main classification: H03K17
IPC codes: H02M1, H02M3, H03K17